Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters ›
Crime Prevention
Senator Scahill urged reform of the rural policing model, with more visible front-line Gardaí and adequately resourced, accountable community safety partnerships in areas facing recurring incidents. Minister O’Callaghan backed the broader, multi-agency safety strategy and cited rising Garda numbers, but left deployment decisions to the Commissioner and said he would convey the Senator’s concerns.
Dia dhaoibh go léir ar maidin. I congratulate the Minister on the resolution to the criminal legal aid dispute yesterday. Hopefully, it will result in a more efficient system in the future. Well done on that.
I welcome the development of the National Strategy for Improving Community Safety 2026-2030, particularly the commitment it contains to ensuring that people, regardless of where they live, can be safe and feel safe in their communities. However, a strategy is only as good as what it delivers on the ground. On many occasions in this House, I have raised the issue or my concerns about Garda resourcing and the policing model in rural Ireland. We need to examine whether the current model is meeting the needs of our rural towns and communities. Right now, that is not the case. The events of recent days have brought those concerns into even sharper focus.
In my home county last weekend, there were reports of an alleged brawl on the main street of Ballaghaderreen on Saturday morning. This incident has understandably caused great concern. I acknowledge Councillors Micheál Frain and Liam Callaghan and other local representatives who the Minister has met when he visited Roscommon and who have continued to highlight the need for greater Garda visibility and resources in our towns. In Longford, we have seen reports of a shooting incident with renewed calls for additional Garda resources as investigations continue. We have seen further calls for concern regarding Ballinasloe. They are not simply headlines in our local newspapers. These are communities where people live, work, raise their families and run their businesses.
I have engaged with gardaí locally, with Garda management and with public representatives across Roscommon and Galway on these issues. I want to be clear. This is not a criticism of the gardaí working in our communities - far from it. I know the work they do, the pressure they are under and the commitments they have to keep in order to keep people safe. They need to be properly supported.
The strategy rightly talks about prevention, early intervention, collaboration and community involvement. I welcome all of that, but we cannot have efficient community policing if we do not have the gardaí available to deliver it. Gardaí are covering enormous geographical areas. I remind the Minister that I am from the three-county Roscommon, Longford and Mayo division, where gardaí are responding to emergencies, attending court, dealing with investigations and being pulled from one town to another to meet operational demands. We cannot expect gardaí to be everywhere at once. When they are dealing with all of those demands, who is left to provide the visibility and preventative policing that our towns need?
I welcome the Government’s investment in Garda recruitment. I welcome every additional garda who is qualifying out of Templemore. However, we need to ask where those gardaí are being deployed and whether rural communities are seeing the benefit. National recruitment figures mean very little to somebody who rarely sees a garda on their main street. The strategies are also placing considerable emphasis on the local community safety partnerships. That is the right approach and I know from my own engagement that there is a genuine willingness to work together within those partnerships. However, partnership, engagement and consultation must be backed up by resources and action. We cannot simply produce another strategy, establish another structure and expect communities to feel safe unless we are prepared to deliver the services they need.
I am asking for three things as this strategy moves forward to implementation. The first is that we examine how the strategy will address the challenges of rural policing, including the enormous geographical areas covered and the actual availability of gardaí on the ground. The second is that the commitment to community policing is supported by adequate front-line resources, particularly in towns experiencing repeated incidents of violence, intimidation and antisocial behaviour. The third is that our local community safety partnerships have the support, resources and accountability needed to deliver measurable improvements in their communities.
We must ask whether rural communities are receiving the Garda service that meets their needs. If the answer is “No”, how will this new strategy change and when can communities expect to see the difference? People do not simply want another strategy or commitment. They want to see gardaí on the street, they want to feel safe in their communities, and they deserve the policing service to deliver that.
Comment on this
I thank Senator Scahill for raising this very important point. I welcome Senator McAdam to the Upper House. It is a great privilege to be elected to this House.
Senator Scahill’s questions and Commencement matter are opportune because it was last Monday, at St. Andrew’s Resource Centre, that I launched the first national strategy on improving community safety. I appreciate the Senator raising this matter. It is an important strategy. It is also important to point out that the strategy is simply part of ensuring that our communities are safer. As the Senator has identified in his contribution, there are other aspects that are probably not as apparent in the general community safety strategy.
We have our Garda resources, and a high level of resources goes into ensuring that we have adequate numbers of gardaí policing our cities, towns and villages in rural and urban areas. We also have our criminal justice system. The focus of the national strategy for improving community safety is to recognise that not all of the problems in our communities are the responsibility of or can be solved exclusively by gardaí in their efforts to keep people safe. If we look at issues in respect of addiction or other issues that may arise, we need a broader range of supports and services to respond to them. The purpose of the strategy for improving community safety is to give recognition to that and to build on the local community safety partnerships, which are also an integral part of the new system that was enacted by the Oireachtas in the 2024 legislation.
I fully appreciate that Senator Scahill wants to see more gardaí in his constituency and his community. The most important way of ensuring community safety is for gardaí to be in the community, although we recognise that they cannot resolve everything. We are in a good position at present in that we have 14,800 sworn members of An Garda Síochána and around 3,500 staff who are doing tasks that were previously done by gardaí. We will have another attestation in Templemore at the end of December, and I am hoping that we will either get to, or very close to, 15,000. At present, we have the largest ever number of sworn members of the force, but that will get us up to even higher numbers.
The launch of the strategy marks the next chapter in the evolution of community safety in Ireland. It is a key element of the new community safety infrastructure established under the Act. It creates a strong foundation for collaborative action at both national and local levels. The work will be supported by the national community safety steering group, the national office for community safety and the 36 local community safety partnerships. One of the great strengths of this framework is that it has truly been shaped by the people and communities it seeks to serve. The extensive engagement process is evidenced by the fact there were 7,000 responses to a national survey and a large number of local communities responded as well.
As the Senator will know, local communities are experts within their own communities, and their voices must be central to decision-making. Rural communities face a range of difficulties in relation to community safety, ranging from burglary and theft to animal crime and road traffic offences. The Garda is committed to tackling all of these forms of crime. It has had unprecedented success in reducing and preventing burglaries through Operation Thor, which has been a notable success.
Policing is obviously enormously important for rural and community safety. Senator Scahill wants to see more gardaí in his community, which I fully appreciate. Of course, community safety is not just about policing alone. It requires a multi-agency, multisectoral and whole-of-government response. I believe that is what is provided for in the community safety strategy. I hear what the Senator says in respect of the events in Ballaghaderreen and his concerns about Ballinasloe and Longford. I can assure him that when it comes to the allocation of Garda resources, the Commissioner makes the decisions based on where he believes resources should go. I certainly hear what the Senator says regarding the resources he wants to see in his own constituency and I will pass that on.
Comment on this
Before the Senator responds, I acknowledge the presence of our guests in the Visitors Gallery. I hope they have an enjoyable day in Leinster House.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister. I potentially lured him in to make a statement on a strategy when, really and truly, I wanted him to talk about the rural policing model. It is a model that the former Commissioner, Drew Harris, modelled on Police Scotland, which was established in 2013. Subsequently, Police Scotland has been reformed because the Scots found that it was not necessarily doing everything they wanted it to do. The reforms they have emphasised in the new model have been around strengthening local and community policing, improving responsiveness to different community needs, giving greater attention to local accountability and engagement, reviewing how front-line resources are allocated and balancing national specialist capabilities with neighbourhood policing. These are all things that I believe would significantly strengthen rural policing. That is why I believe we need to reform the model to properly reflect rural policing at the moment. That is my simple ask.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator. It is not the first time I have been lured into Seanad Éireann to debate one topic when another topic was raised. They are all interlinked. Community safety is impossible unless we have Garda resources. I hear what the Senator says about the operating model. I have spoken to the Commissioner about this. I am not committed to a model and I am not the expert in the same way that people in here are not the experts when it comes to policing. Gardaí are the experts when it comes to that. I want a system in place that is most efficient for policing in the communities.
One thing I do hear in respect of the operating model is that it will become more effective if we have more resources to ensure that it operates effectively. One of the issues can be that there is only one superintendent in certain areas. I think we need to increase the number of superintendents and chief superintendents. The increasing numbers in An Garda Síochána - we are now at 14,825 serving members and, hopefully, will get approximately another 200 into the force on 21 or 22 December - will create opportunities for more resources to be available in different communities. I know what the Senator wants to see; he wants to see more gardaí in his community. That is what all Senators and Deputies want to see. I will pass that on.
Comment on this
The three-county division is very important as well.