We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters ›

Coroners Service

Summary

The Minister said heads of a Coroners Bill are expected to go to Government in the next two to three months, proposing a centrally funded service, a chief coroner and full-time coroners to improve consistency and reduce delays. He called an eight-year wait unacceptable and offered to examine the Kerry case raised.

I welcome the Minister to the Chamber. I commend him on his recent work as the Minister for justice. I welcome the opportunity to raise this important matter. I seek an update on the long-awaited reform of Ireland's coroner system and the progress being made towards modernising the legislative work governing coroners and inquests. The legislative basis for our Coroner Service remains the Coroners Act 1962, a framework that has now been in place for more than 60 years. While the role and expectations of the service have changed significantly, the law has struggled to keep pace with modern standards of transparency, consistency, family engagement and timely delivery of justice.

This is not a new issue. In 2022, the Government acknowledged that significant reform of the Coroner Service was required and many recommendations from previous reviews remained outstanding. Since then, there has been broad recognition that the system requires legislative and structural change. In 2023, the Department of Justice launched a public consultation on coroner reform seeking the views of bereaved families, coroners, legal practitioners, pathologists and other stakeholders. The concerns raised through that process were both consistent and concerning. In October 2024, the then Minister for Justice, Deputy McEntee, published the consultation findings. Those findings highlighted lengthy delays in investigations and inquests, inconsistencies between coroner districts, poor communication with bereaved families and a clear need for stronger national leadership and oversight. The report also identified the need for improved family liaison services and a modern legislative framework fit for a modern Ireland.

The Government subsequently approved the drafting of the general scheme of a new coroners Bill and signalled proposals, including the establishment of an office of the chief coroner, national standards for service delivery, greater consistency across districts and measures aimed at reducing delays. These commitments are welcome. However, for many families reform remains a promise rather than a reality.

In north Kerry, concerns were recently highlighted by Fine Gael Councillor Aoife Kennelly. Families have reported waiting for more than two, four and eight years for inquests relating to the deaths of loved ones to conclude. For those families, delays of this magnitude prolong grief and deny the closure that the inquest process is intended to provide. Indeed, the coroner's office and mortuary services in Kerry cost €500,000, which is paid directly from the budget of Kerry County Council. That is where that question raised its head. While some interim measures were introduced through the Coroners (Amendment) Act, including additional capacity and greater flexibility in appointments, the fundamental reforms that have been discussed for several years have not been delivered. I therefore ask the Minister to provide a clear update on the status of the proposed coroners Bill, the timeline for its publication and enactment, and the measures being taken to address delays in the meantime. I also ask what steps are being taken to improve engagement with bereaved families and to ensure a more consistent Coroner Service across the State.

The need for reform has been recognised since at least 2022. Consultations have been completed, recommendations have been published and legislation has been promised, yet many bereaved families continue to face unacceptable delays. The question now is not whether reform is needed but when the Government intends to bring the promised legislation before the Oireachtas and deliver the modern, compassionate and efficient Coroner Service that families across this country deserve.

Comment on this
Imelda Goldsboro Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

I welcome to the Gallery the guests of Senator Kennelly. We hope they have a great day in Leinster House.

Comment on this

I thank the Senator for raising this important issue. It is important to note that in carrying out my functions as the Minister for justice, I spend a lot of my time addressing issues that arise in respect of the whole coroner system. I welcome the fact that the Senator has raised it here because it does not get much prominence in the Houses of the Oireachtas. It is an extremely important part of the role played by the State in facilitating families in times of great difficulty.

The Senator was correct to identify that we are dealing with legislation, the Corners Act, which dates from 1962. In most areas of life or administration that we are operating in at present, we have updated legislation that has been there since the 1960s. This is legislation that needs to be updated. I note what the Senator said about what was done by my predecessor in 2022 and the Government approval, in October 2024, to draft the Bill. I will give the Senator an update in that regard presently. Department officials are working on drafting the heads of Bill with the aim of bringing them before Government in the coming months. I have news for the Senator in that regard. We hope that will happen in the next two to three months. It is a matter that I and my Department are keeping an eye on.

The coronial system is a sensitive and important issue. As the Senator knows, coroners are independent office-holders. Their function is to investigate reportable deaths, including sudden and unexplained deaths, in order to establish a cause of death. We are aware of a range of challenges affecting the coronial death investigation system. These include pressures related to the provision of post-mortem examination services by pathologists and workforce capacity issues, as well as competing demands on pathologists in areas of diagnostic and research work.

Other delays can also arise. One of the issues that I will deal with frequently is that if somebody died in circumstances that give rise to criminal prosecutions, the inquest will be delayed until the conclusion of the criminal prosecution or criminal investigation. That can be a matter of concern to families because it can mean that the process is delayed.

At present, we have many part-time coroners around the country. I commend them on the difficult and challenging work they do. Everyone agrees that we need to put in place a statutory scheme that recognises the requirements of the 21st century and ensures that the whole system is professionalised and modernised. That is why the proposed legislation is so important. It intends to establish an independent and centrally funded coronial service with an office of the chief coroner and full-time salaried coroners. The new model will facilitate the introduction of consistent national standards for the conduct of coronial investigations and support the streamlined delivery of coronial services across the State.

The carrying out of inquests is an important function. It is important for families to know how their loved ones died. I have noticed in recent years, and perhaps Senator Kennelly has noticed it too, that inquests are sometimes being directed not just to determine the cause of death but to deal with issues in respect of liability for death. That is a matter we need to be cautious of because although they are referred to as "coroners' courts", they are not courts in the sense of administering justice. They carry out a very specific function, which is to determine the cause of death. The new system that will be put in place under the new statutory scheme will assist in clarifying the primary function of coroners when it comes to fulfilling their functions in inquests.

On many occasions where we have post-mortems and inquests, there may be circumstances where they are not necessary. We all know there are a lot of elderly people dying in nursing homes and, in many instances, post-mortems are being carried out which may not be necessary. These are issues that we will have to look at in the round.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister for his response. It is widely welcomed. When these families came to us, they needed closure. For one family in particular, this has been going over eight years. The system has to be completely overhauled and reviewed. I am delighted that in the next couple of months, legislation will be brought through by the Minister. I look forward to it. I will take the assurance back to the families in Kerry that the Minister is doubling down on this. It is not just a Kerry issue. It is a national issue. I am encouraged by the Minister's response.

I welcome the group in the Gallery. Many of them are from the Minister's neck of the woods in Currow. I welcome them and hope they enjoy their day in Leinster House.

Comment on this

I thank the Senator. I also welcome all the people from Kerry. My father was from Currans in Currow, just outside Farranfore, so I am delighted to see so many Kerry people here.

The Senator mentioned a family that has been waiting for eight years. That is an unacceptable delay.

If the Senator sends me an email or gives me the information, I will look at it. There may be reasons for it. If there are not reasons, it is a matter of concern to me. I look forward to hearing from him on that.

Comment on this