Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters ›
Pesticide Use
Senator Noonan urged the Education Department to work with other agencies on guidance to end pesticide and herbicide use in school grounds, citing biodiversity and health risks and a survey finding that over half of schools use weedkiller. Minister Moynihan said he would consider the issue across government and praised schools’ biodiversity work, but made no firm commitment to a protocol.
Cuirim fáilte roimh an Aire Stáit. Níl clóis na scoileanna in Éirinn ina spásanna do nimh. Tá na spásanna seo le haghaidh súgartha. Tá muid i measc ghéarchéim na bithéagsúlachta agus, mar sin, tá freagracht orainn go léir oibriú le chéile chun ár ndúlra a athchóiriú.
We are in the depths of a biodiversity crisis. It is incumbent on us all to play our part in restoring nature and it should start with our schools. Our national biodiversity action plan is an all-of-government and all-of-society plan and was adopted by the Government in 2024. It is also a statutory plan; it is no longer a nice-to-have. As Minister of State at the time, I made a commitment to the children and young people of Ireland at the Children and Young People's Assembly on Biodiversity Loss that I would take the 58 calls to action they presented to me and stitch them into our national biodiversity action plan. We ensured all but two of them appeared in that plan and were enshrined in law, which was really transformative.
Call to action No. 50 was to ask us to phase out the use of herbicides and pesticides so here I am trying to honour that promise I made in Killarney a few years ago. It was disappointing to learn from the Irish Schools Sustainability Network, ISSN, on biodiversity in schools that these harmful chemicals are still being used in our school grounds. These are places of education where children and young people should be learning about why these chemicals are so bad for us and so bad for nature. The biodiversity in schools survey found that over half of our schools routinely use Roundup, which is the brand name for glyphosate, the most commonly and most widely used weedkiller in the world, to control weeds around school grounds.
While I appreciate schools are really busy places and the maintenance and upkeep usually fall on the lone caretaker in the school, the use of weedkiller at all in the school environment is wholly unnecessary and wrong. Apart from the immediate risk posed to the whole school community and to the caretaker who may have to handle such chemicals, it invariably will end up in water courses through drains and in rivers and streams, or wastewater treatment plants, many of which do not have the capacity to remove such chemicals.
The national pesticides and drinking water action group reminds us that pesticides are routinely detected in drinking water supplies and that every effort should be made in the community to eliminate their use. They are found to be ubiquitous in our food and traces of glyphosate are even found in breast milk, so eliminating their use in school grounds, public parks and spaces and roadside verges should be our priority. The sight of yellow burned grass and plants - some might call them weeds - in school grounds is not a welcoming one. There are other, natural, means of managing vegetation, some of which could be part of school activities or the green schools programme. Today, the Aire Stáit's colleague, the Minister of State with responsibility for nature, is launching the Our Dúlra Agreement, a schools network-wide agreement towards managing biodiversity in schools. This is what is required, namely, a whole-of-school approach in partnership with local authority biodiversity officers. Indeed, it suggests our schools could do with a network of biodiversity officers all of their own to work with teachers, parents and students. I ask the Minister of State that the Department of Education and Youth work with the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage and the ISSN on biodiversity in schools to develop a protocol that would eliminate the use of herbicides and pesticides in our school grounds. In my gardening days I worked a lot with schools, putting in school gardens, mini woodlands, ponds and orchards, which was really enjoyable work. However, breaking up tarmacadam to put in a garden in a school was really rewarding and the garden became a wonderful educational resource in its own right. We need to do lots more of this around the country and to see our school grounds as contributors to our national nature restoration plan but first, let us stop spring poisoning them.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator for raising the issue. The issue is for the boards of management and the management of the schools and I know they take it desperately seriously. A prepared document will be circulated containing a response to the Senator's queries about the various functions and managing the school grounds for biodiversity. I will pick up on his second last point in terms of the amazing work that is being done in school communities the length and breadth of the country. I often think that when we were going to school - certainly when I was going to school - one of the major issues was litter awareness and now the vast majority of Tidy Towns committees are populated by people of our age group so it certainly sank in. In many of the schools I have had the honour to visit over the past year and a half, the amount of biodiversity work that is going on in schools is quite incredible. Some stand-out schools remain with me. One school in the inner city in Limerick had a dome and one of our Oireachtas colleagues, equipped with the heath advice students are getting now, said that we will live into eternity. We have to compliment the amount of excellent work that is going on at school level on biodiversity, on the natural environment and protecting it, as well as enshrining in the students that love of the environment and of nature as I have seen in some clips over the past day or so of students being taken on biodiversity and nature walks and to biodiversity gardens.
They also grow their own vegetables. I do not think there is a school, certainly in rural Ireland but also in urban Ireland, that does not have a plot allotted to growing its own food to show where food comes from and the respect we have for food.
With regard to ensuring pesticides are eliminated in schools, we have to give credit to the school leadership and particularly the caretakers who manage these facilities in school communities. Recently I was at the CBS in Charleville, to mention one school, and I saw the work done there by somebody who trained as a horticulturalist and then went on to become a teacher. I saw the love he has enshrined in the students. We had also been there more than two years ago when he was taking the students out to plant bare root trees at this time of the year. We have to applaud what is going on at school level and we certainly have to acknowledge it across the system. Of course we need to do more but in the first instance we must thank the teachers, the school leadership and all those instilling in our students a love of nature and biodiversity.
Of course we can look at this. Senator Noonan asked me specifically to work across Departments. All Departments are acutely aware of ensuring we protect our environment and protect biodiversity. We have an opportunity to protect it and to keep what we have. So much has been lost but a lot of it has been protected through an intergenerational love of nature and love of environment. A person who had been in school many years ago spoke about the nature walks they did in the woods and the information they were given by the teachers. The teachers inspired a love of nature in them and she continues to translate this into her own garden. A lot of great work is being done. I will look across government but I assure Senator Noonan that we take this very seriously.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State for his very eloquent and unscripted reply. I absolutely agree wholeheartedly with him that the work going on in schools throughout the country is absolutely exceptional. I note that the scripted speech mentions a protocol for managing school grounds for biodiversity. Biodiversity in Schools discovered that more than half of the schools it surveyed still spray weedkiller in the school grounds. This is a cause for concern. I know how busy it is particularly for caretakers, as if a cistern breaks or a window will not open they are first on call for all of the maintenance on school grounds and this is another headache for them. However, it is important that we have a unified approach to it. I know it is a matter for school boards of management but, more broadly, direction from the Department would be helpful. Some guidance from the Department, coupled with support from the National Parks and Wildlife Service, would help. I appreciate the Minister of State's reply and I agree wholeheartedly with everything he has said.
Comment on this
To confirm, the Department has worked with the National Parks and Wildlife Service to promote biodiversity. In the role I hold as Minister of State with responsibility for special education and inclusion I cannot underestimate the importance of biodiversity and a sensory garden. Some of the best practice we have seen throughout the country is where school communities come together and plant trees and other permanent plants on a piece of their property and over the years, ten or 15 years later, they become so important for those with additional needs. I fully understand the need for it and we have to give enormous credit. Perhaps the protocols are not in place but certainly the goodwill is there, as is the commitment of school communities and caretakers throughout the 4,000 schools in the amount of work they are doing to protect it. There is also the amount of work being done throughout school communities to harvest water. The importance of this is being instilled in the younger generation of people and I have no doubt this will translate into their adult life and into the habits they will develop. I take the points on board. We take it very seriously and I compliment the work being done.