We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters ›

International Agreements

Summary

Ireland will seek an ambitious, time-bound mandate for a legally binding CCW instrument on lethal autonomous weapons, including prohibitions and regulations and meaningful human control. Higgins urged Ireland to pursue alternative processes if consensus fails and to align its international stance with EU and national policy; Richmond said all options would be considered.

The Minister of State, Deputy Richmond, will be aware I have previously brought forward legislation in respect of lethal autonomous weapons. I want to begin by recognising the constructive engagement I have had with the disarmament unit in the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade in respect of that legislation and the ongoing process. The intention of the legislation was to support a stronger mandate as we go into those negotiations. We are at a crucial point in terms of a horrific new form of warfare involving lethal autonomous weapons. Machines are setting targets and carrying out actions, including killings, sometimes without any meaningful human control.

This is urgent in two ways. First, these weapons are already being tested and used. We are seeing them in Ukraine and Gaza, and we are seeing them marketed, celebrated and developed with investment going towards their further development. It is a huge danger that is already happening right now.

Second, there is urgency because the mandate of the group of governmental experts is about to expire. They have been tasked with looking at conventional weapons and treaties. A crucial meeting is happening next week at which the decision will be made whether to proceed with a protocol to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons. I am interested in seeing what position Ireland is taking. We want the mandate that comes out of next week not to be a mandate to continue talking about this but one to discuss and develop a binding protocol. It will still be opt-in, of course. That is the nature of these things, but a binding protocol should be negotiated and the timeline for the negotiations should be one year because of the urgency and the speed involved. We know there are those who would like to put this on the long finger while continuing to actively develop and use these weapons.

It is also crucial we have the phrase "meaningful human control". I know there is discussion of "human control and judgment" as a potential alternative but that language is crucial. I am also worried there is a loophole in the definition. There is the exclusion of what is sometimes called "fire and forget", that is, situations where a human may set the target or targets but then the autonomous action is taken by the machine in terms of the actual execution. Machines like this do not recognise a white flag or surrender. That is not consistent with the Geneva Convention or international humanitarian law. That is a real concern that I want to highlight. There were some good aspects to the definition. It includes components as well as the finished product but in the "fire and forget" space we could end up with a loophole which would diminish the effectiveness of this.

I am concerned about things like autonomous target identification mechanisms, which fall slightly outside the remit currently. Where both the identification of targets and the execution and killing sit within the machine area without meaningful human control on either of those sides of it, that could end up falling outside the remit of what we are talking about.

I know Ireland has had a constructive position. I want to know more about it and to encourage Ireland to take a robust position. If we are not seeing what we need to see coming from this process, might Ireland be willing, as it has been in the past, to take leadership on other processes, whether an independent treaty, as in the case of the Convention on Cluster Munitions, or a UN process or discussion? There are articles within the convention on conventional weapons which can be used to trigger a further discussion.

While it is done by consensus, a majority can be employed to demand that there would be a General Assembly debate before resuming discussions. There are a few options there.

My apologies, I went a little bit over time.

Comment on this
Neale Richmond Minister of State at the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade Fine Gael

I am grateful to Senator Higgins for raising this important issue.

The control of autonomous weapon systems is one of the most pressing issues facing the modern arms control agenda. Ireland has been at the forefront of states seeking to address it. The development and deployment of such systems raise serious ethical, moral and legal questions and the possibility of contravening international humanitarian and human rights law. For the seventh review conference of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, CCW, at the United Nations in Geneva next week, high-contracting parties to the convention will be asked to endorse the set of elements of an instrument on lethal autonomous weapons systems without prejudice to its nature. This set of elements gained consensus agreement last September from the group of governmental experts on lethal autonomous weapons systems, otherwise known as LAWS. I apologise in advance, as I will be using that acronym throughout my remarks.

It is important to be clear about what systems we are discussing, particularly now that there is agreement on a working characterisation or definition. LAWS are a specific set of autonomous weapons systems that are capable of identifying, selecting and engaging targets without human intervention. This means that they have the capability to be fully autonomous. Ireland's strong and long-standing view is that meaningful human control over such systems is required for compliance with international humanitarian law. That is what we fought for in negotiations through the group of governmental experts. We welcome the consensus agreement by the group in September on the characterisation of LAWS, the need for control and human judgment over them, and some measures on how to effect the required control.

It is now necessary to build on that agreement through a negotiation mandate for an instrument to govern LAWS. Ireland helped to shape the European Council conclusions for the CCW review conference, which called for an ambitious negotiation mandate. For Ireland, any mandate should provide an opportunity to ensure that measures that have been discussed over the past 13 years but did not make it into the agreed set of elements can be included in any future instrument or instruments. Among a broad range of measures, this includes adequate legal reviews, robust testing and evaluation requirements to ensure predictability, traceability and explainability of digital systems under a human chain of command and control and the mitigation of bias from such systems, including automation bias and algorithmic bias.

As the Senator will be aware, Ireland is among a group of states seeking a negotiation mandate to agree a legally binding instrument that will govern LAWS. In our view, this should be a sixth protocol to the CCW and should include a combination of prohibitions and regulations on their development and use. Any negotiation mandate should be time-bound and fit to address the urgency of the issue. That is why we and like-minded partners have sought a one-year mandate with a sufficient number of meetings to address outstanding legal and technical issues. In short, Ireland will seek a progressive outcome at next week's CCW review conference on LAWS and will continue to support international efforts to mitigate the risks associated with the use of AI systems in the military domain.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State. It is an appropriate building on Ireland's history in the area of disarmament, from the work on nuclear non-proliferation through to our key role in negotiating the convention on cluster munitions. I have no doubt that Ireland will go in with a strong and progressive agenda on these issues. While Ireland is also very good at seeking consensus, I would urge that in the event that a binding instrument with an appropriately short timeline does not emerge from this process, Ireland should be willing to work with like-minded countries to develop parallel processes, such as a separate convention, if necessary, in order to ensure that action is taken on these appalling weapons. Sadly, investment is regulating the pace.

I ask that Ireland would bring the expertise that it brought to the disarmament negotiations and regulatory negotiations into a more robust response within the European Union. As we know, AI weaponry is not included in any of the EU instruments in respect of AI regulations. It is either a national or a global competence. There is a huge lacuna there at time when we are seeing massive investment in militarisation. I am very concerned that this investment is happening in a period when there is a lacuna in terms of regulation. I have to flag that I am concerned about our own industrial development Bill, which is removing the requirement for Enterprise Ireland to engage with the Government on military investment. These are areas for consistency, with a very strong position, which I am very proud that Ireland is bringing into those UN negotiations. We need to carry that back into our EU and national policies in these areas.

Comment on this

It is Ireland's view that this is an urgent issue. States need to seize the opportunity of this review conference and meet the needs of the moment. We recognise that the CCW operates by consensus and the challenge in achieving an outcome in the current international security environment. However, in our pursuit of an instrument through the CCW, Ireland will consider all options and mechanisms available under the convention. The Senator will understand that I will not prejudge any discussions at this time, but her point is well made and taken on board by the Government.

It important to add that while LAWS will be a key focus of the review conference, they are part of a wider range of issues in relation to the use of AI in the military domain. Ireland supports other relevant and complementary initiatives, such as the UN dialogues and the summits on responsible artificial intelligence in the military domain. These initiatives incorporate discussions on AI decision support systems and bias, which are key concerns. Ireland is funding research on a addressing bias in military AI through the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute.

Without getting into another round of debate on the related issues that Senator Higgins added, I would like to point out that this is increasingly becoming the most threatening part of how humanitarians work in the world. I spent quite a bit of time at the United Nations this year working with like-minded ministers in relation to drone attacks and AI-powered attacks on humanitarian aid workers, particularly in Sudan. This is an area of real consequence, with the last two years being the deadliest in history to be a humanitarian worker. Part of that is due to not only autonomous weaponry, but the inability to control whose hands those weapons find themselves in and what happens thereafter.

I hope that we can continue to work together on this.

Comment on this