We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters ›

Alcohol Sales

Summary

Senator Linda Nelson Murray called for a review of on-demand alcohol delivery and safeguards such as age checks, volume limits and delivery restrictions, citing risks to people with alcohol dependence and their families. The Government said the concerns would inform future licensing-law reform, though the work is not yet on the legislative programme and existing alcohol-sale rules apply to online purchases.

I thank the Minister of State for being here. We all get many emails and calls about different things every day. We try to help people as much as we can. Sometimes, an email can really resonate. I will quote part of one that did so. It deals with the delivery of alcohol from delivery apps and supermarkets:

Dear Linda,

I am writing to you to ask for your support on a campaign on protecting vulnerable people on home delivery of alcohol in Ireland. My concern stems from the experience of a close female friend of mine in her mid-30s who suffers from chronic alcoholism. She spends much of her time at home and is able to order alcoholic drinks online, which are delivered directly to her front door by delivery services. She wouldn't be easily able to obtain access to alcohol without these delivery services. As someone who cares about her, I find it deeply troubling that a person struggling with such a serious addiction can obtain alcohol so easily, without having to even leave her home. The convenience of these services can make it easier to continue drinking and harder to break the cycle of addiction. What I find particularly concerning is just how easy this process has become. A person can order two bottles of vodka on a smartphone and have them delivered to their door with much the same ease as ordering two cartons of milk with a grocery delivery. The products are obviously very different but the convenience and simplicity of obtaining them are almost identical. For someone who is not struggling with alcohol dependence this may seem like nothing more than a convenient service, but for someone suffering from chronic alcoholism that same convenience can have devastating consequences. There may be no need to leave the house, no meaningful interruption to the drinking cycle and very little to prevent another order from being placed. I believe this raises a serious question for public policy. Should obtaining alcohol be quite so effortless when we know that alcohol dependence can destroy lives?

I think it is a fair and legitimate question from my constituent. We have spent years developing policies to reduce alcohol-related harm, protect young people and encourage responsible consumption. However, the growth of instant delivery creates a right new challenge. Alcohol is no longer something that necessarily requires a journey to a shop, pub or off-licence. It can be ordered on a phone and delivered to someone's sitting room within minutes. I genuinely had not thought about this until this man contacted me. Apart from Christmas when getting my groceries I might include a couple of bottles of wine, I have never had alcohol delivered to the house. It has implications for people experiencing dependency or those trying to maintain recovery; young people and children living in households where alcohol is being ordered; domestic violence and family welfare; people who are already intoxicated and can continue drinking without leaving home; and vulnerable people who may be particularly affected by targeted online promotions.

I am asking that we support a review of the public health implications of on-demand alcohol delivery, particularly for people experiencing alcohol dependence. Should we be considering legislation prohibiting third-party platforms - we all know who they are - facilitating the home delivery of alcohol? Should we examine whether any prohibition should extend to other commercial home delivery services, including direct delivery by off-licences and supermarkets, to ensure a consistent approach? I am proposing that we have proper age verification to be asked for at the point of sale and also on the physical delivery and I am also calling for a cap on the total volume allowed per customer per night. In Australia, they offer a two-hour safety pause between order and delivery, as that can release the temptation if you have to wait two hours to get it; a limit on the hours during which alcohol can be delivered; mandatory responsible service of alcohol training for delivery drivers; and, most importantly, the ability to opt-out of alcohol delivery marketing.

In April of this year, the Minister said that updating licensing laws was a Government commitment. Where are we on that, because there is an important distinction between having legislation and ensuring that it works in practice?

Comment on this

I sincerely thank Senator Nelson Murray for raising this pertinent issue, not only from a legislative point of view, but from a human one as well. This is something that will cross all of our inboxes at various stages. There is a very painful human dimension, possibly not for the person directly at the centre of it, but definitely their family and loved ones.

On behalf of the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, I thank the Senator for raising the matter. There is widespread interest in this topic from members of the public, representatives from the industry and members of the Government. Neither the 2022 sale of alcohol Bill nor the 2024 intoxicating liquor Bill progressed in the lifetime of the previous Government. The programme for Government commits to updating the licensing laws. The autumn legislative programme, published on 16 September, sets out the 32 Bills that have been prioritised for publication and a further 32 Bills prioritised for drafting in the current Dáil session. Other legislative works, including work on updating the licensing laws, will be taken forward in subsequent iterations of the legislative programme to be determined by Government in due course. In that regard, the points raised by the Senator in respect of regulations around alcohol delivery in the interests of public health have been shared with relevant officials in the Department and will be considered as part of this work.

However, it is important to note that under existing legislation, where alcohol is purchased online, the same restrictions on the sale and supply of intoxicating liquor apply as do to on-site purchases. Under section 17(3) of the Intoxicating Liquor Act 2003, it is an offence for a licensee with intent to evade the conditions of the licence to take the intoxicating liquor from the licensed premised for the purpose of it being sold on the account or for the benefit or profit of the licensee or to permit any other person to do so. The penalty on conviction is a fine of up to €1,500 for a first offence and up to €2,000 for a second or subsequent offence.

Any proposals for reform will need to be informed by engagement with relevant stakeholders and Departments, such as the Department of Health. The Department of justice is committed to ensuring that any changes to alcohol licensing would be evidence based, balanced and capable of supporting a modern licensing system while maintaining appropriate protections for communities and consumers.

I might use the time available to make the clear point that we might be at a very early part of this discussion. Indeed, when we move forward, we may look back and say that the Senator was the person who really started this discussion. That is the opportunity that lies before us and across these Houses, to look at the legislative timetables there across Government but also how this can fit into the promised review, as stated by the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan. Indeed, in anything that we can do to move that along, I would be more than happy to be at the Senator's disposal.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State. I really appreciate his comments. It is definitely something that I am going to continue working on, so the Minister of State will hear a lot more of me talking about this. As I said, this matter has resonated with me. It is not just something that I am bringing up today and I am not going to talk about again.

It is all very well having some laws there, but they do not particularly apply to these apps and whatever. It is something that we need to work on. We have to ask ourselves whether the convenience of alcohol delivery is now moving ahead of our responsibility to protect public health. I am not suggesting that we prohibit people from purchasing alcohol legally. However, I believe we need to look seriously at how easily alcohol can now be ordered through an app and delivered directly to someone's home. We would not allow somebody who is visibly intoxicated to continue being serviced in a pub or restaurant - we are quite good at that now. Why should the same principle not apply when alcohol is being delivered to their front door?

Other countries are beginning to recognise that the rules governing alcohol sales must keep pace with technology and it is all about how fast technology is moving at present. Ireland needs to examine those safeguards now rather than waiting until we see the consequences.

Comment on this

There is widespread interest in this topic. Although the updating of the licensing laws has not been included in the autumn legislative programme, the relevant officials in the Department of justice have taken note of the issue around the availability of alcohol on third-party delivery platforms. As with any area of retail activity involving the sale of alcohol, it is important that appropriate safeguards be in place and that existing legal requirements be fully observed.

The issues raised by the Senator touch on matters relating to enforcement, public safety and responsible consumption, all of which must be carefully considered. While the Department cannot pre-empt the outcome of any future policy development, the Senator can be assured that these considerations will form part of the broader examination of licensing law reform as this work progresses and the Government is extremely grateful for her raising it today.

Comment on this