Culture and Arts Infrastructure: Discussion (Resumed)
Community and voluntary arts representatives described a shortage of affordable, accessible spaces, especially in rural areas, alongside fragile funding, insurance and staffing pressures. They called for targeted capital and ongoing programme support, stronger State capacity to guide projects, and practical help for grassroots groups; witnesses also urged a national approach to youth arts and support for artists’ housing and livelihoods. Proposals included protecting at-risk venues, reusing vacant buildings, planning for cultural space and improving access to nightlife venues. The hearing will inform the committee’s planned report and policy recommendations; no formal decision was made.
I warmly welcome Senators, witnesses and visitors to the second public hearing of the Seanad Public Consultation Committee on the topic of culture and arts infrastructure. These public meetings are the next part of a process which began in February this year with a public call for written submissions. Submissions were received from individuals, interest groups and organisations across Ireland. After reviewing the submissions, the committee divided them into four core themes: artists and practitioners; community and voluntary groups; interesting models; and local authorities and State bodies. This meeting is an engagement under the second theme of community and voluntary groups. The committee had its first meeting with artists and practitioners on 22 September and the other themes will be discussed at our next two meetings in October. Unfortunately, Senators Craughwell, Keoghan, O'Loughlin and Ahearn had to send their apologies. On behalf of the committee, I sincerely thank those who sent in submissions and engaged on the topic to date. All submissions have been considered by the committee members and will contribute to the committee's final report.
On behalf of the committee, I welcome the following witnesses to the Seanad Chamber: Mr. Max May, chief executive of Creative Lives; Ms Siobhán Burke, visual development manager, West Cork Music; Mr. Eamonn Ceannt, cultural project adviser and founding chair of the Museum of Literature Ireland; Mr. Ollie Breslin, youth theatre organiser, and Ms Niamh O’Shea, co-ordinator, Cumas Ceantar Uíbh Ráthach; and Mr. Sunil Sharpe, spokesperson, Give us the Night. The witnesses are all most welcome to today's meeting and I thank them for their engagement with the committee in its consideration of this important topic. Each organisation will be given a maximum of five minutes, although I understand one or two of you may go over the five minutes and that is okay. We will then have a general question and answer session.
Before I call the witnesses, I must draw their attention to the matter of privilege. The evidence of witnesses physically present is protected by absolute privilege pursuant to the Constitution and statute. This means they have an absolute defence against any defamation action in legal proceedings for anything they say when giving evidence to the committee. However, they are expected not abuse this privilege and it is my duty as Chair to ensure it is not abused. Witnesses should note that only evidence connected with the subject matter of the meeting should be given. All witnesses and members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable, or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an unidentifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks and they must do so. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
Before I call the witnesses, I thank Senator Black for coming up with the idea for this committee and I invite her to make an opening statement.
Comment on this
I warmly welcome the witnesses and thank them all for being here. I am so happy they have been able to join us. I will outline what we are doing here today. The Cathaoirleach has already mentioned it but the whole idea is to have four public sessions with advocates, organisers, practitioners and innovators across the arts and cultural landscape. It is so important that we engage directly with those on the front line of cultural provision to hear about the vital work they do. When we have completed these four sessions we are hoping to produce a report informed by the witnesses containing policy proposals and suggestions to respond to the needs and challenges outlined by our discussion. We will then present that to the Government and I will be the rapporteur of that report.
Last week, we had a really constructive and informative session and we will definitely have the same today. I mentioned last week, and some of the witnesses might know, that my background is in music and I have been surrounded by it my entire life. Many of the submissions today, which I look forward to hearing, will speak about how the arts are so important, especially for community building, particularly in rural Ireland and in under-served communities. I totally recognise this. I spoke last week about how vital the arts are in sustaining a resilient social fabric and bringing people together. With music I have seen this first hand on so many occasions and I am still amazed at the force it has to connect us all. It blows my mind. It brings us all into the present moment and makes us all feel human in this very trying world in which we are living. However, that force is utterly dependent on having physical spaces where those experiences can be shared. Those moments simply cannot happen if there are no rooms for them to happen in, and that is why we are here today.
It is obviously not only music but all disciplines of the arts and culture that require this space. Unfortunately, arts communities of all types are facing immense challenges in accessing the infrastructure and creating the spaces where we can feel that connection and where it is vital that cultural communities flourish. Arts and culture need space not just to thrive but also to survive, and those arts communities need to have a reliable access to space. Without that security, as we heard last week and will undoubtedly hear today, cultural organisations and practitioners are terribly inhibited by precarity in what they can achieve and they cannot plan long term. They cannot build for the future and cannot grow sustainably.
I spoke last week about how technology and social media is changing how we socialise. The phones in our hands make it easier, now more than ever, to conduct our entire social life and consume culture from our living room without even having to meet someone face to face or go to a cultural venue. The tech companies which run platforms on those phones are battling for the same attention that cultural organisers and producers like the witnesses are. That is an important context to the challenges that arts and cultural organisations face and their struggles. They really need more support than ever. The State has to recognise this and match that recognition with meaningful investment and initiative. While increased in-person cultural activity will not solve all of our problems, there is still a profound power in bringing people together in a space to share a cultural experience. In the increasingly lonely and isolated society in which we all live, it is just so important.
By engaging directly with the witnesses, whose life's work is dedicated to cultural provision, as well as with the State bodies responsible for supporting and facilitating that cultural activity, I really hope this committee can produce some meaningful policy proposals, informed by our witnesses and by the lived experiences of those on the ground, that could begin to address the desperate situation so many arts communities find themselves in regarding accessing cultural infrastructure. I am really looking forward to hearing all their submissions today.
I warmly thank them for coming in. I know some of them have travelled. Unfortunately, Thursday afternoon is a very busy time here in Leinster House but I am delighted that we have other Members of the Oireachtas here. I look forward to hearing everyone's submissions. I thank them very much. I also thank the staff and the secretariat who are doing phenomenal work in this area on this report.
Comment on this
Gabhaim buíochas leis an Seanadóir. I now move to our first witness, Mr. Max May of Creative Lives.
Comment on this
I thank the Chairperson and members if the committee very much for this invitation to speak. I am the chief executive of Creative Lives. Creative Lives is Ireland's and the UK's voice for grassroots creativity with over 35 years of experience in community-led culture. Creative Lives supports, connects and champions local creative groups so people and places can thrive. We do this on a local, regional and national level through advocacy, development support and profile-raising in partnership with communities, policymakers and strategic partners. This includes capacity building via resources, guidance and training, direct work in priority communities, including Edenderry, awards, broadcast partnerships, research and campaigning.
We want to see grassroots creativity recognised and valued as a vital part of community life across Ireland and the UK. We champion the evidence-based role local creative groups play in connecting communities and shaping places, improving people’s health and well-being, supporting civic action and local democracy and developing people’s skills and opportunities.
We estimate there are approximately 4,500 local creative groups across Ireland, bringing together around 540,000 participants every month. These groups include everything from traditional music circles to Bollywood dance troupes, digital creativity to lacemaking and everything in between. We see first-hand through our Creative Places Edenderry programme, now in its sixth year, how significant this contribution is but these groups are under threat and improving the infrastructure to support these groups is crucial for their survival.
Every year, we conducted the Creative Lives monitor, a survey of grassroots creative groups across Ireland and the UK. This measures their capacity, resilience and connections and identifies key strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats. This year, over 500 groups contributed and, collectively, they support over 1 million people. This year’s monitor demonstrates that local creative groups are in high demand, have significant social impact and are characterised by resilience and determination. However, a fast-changing world and systemic challenges result in burnout, financial volatility and disconnection. The headline findings are: groups are financially fragile, with a cost-of-living crisis increasing outgoings and reducing income; there is a huge demand for creative activity but the activity itself is not equally spread, with certain groups underserved; an ageing population means ageing leadership and urgent challenges about who will take on the mantle; the struggle to access appropriate, affordable and accessible venues continues to hinder groups and those they support; and groups are isolated from and struggle to establish meaningful connections with local authorities and other civic infrastructure, reducing their impact.
Further analysis of the Ireland-specific responses reveal a rollercoaster of optimism, participation and struggle - the most disparate experience across the nations. Some 94% of groups are optimistic about their future versus 67% on average. Participation is 8% higher too. At the same time, however, 50% report that they are struggling versus 45% across the nations.
When surveyed, Irish creative groups identified three key practical priorities. The first is light-touch funding - more funding opportunities with processes that are proportionate to their value and that enable sustainability as well as project delivery. The second is practical support to develop and increase their impact. Groups need support in areas such as constituting, insurance, safeguarding and fundraising. Affordable insurance is a major barrier and bureaucratic challenge. The third is to protect and support community spaces. Venues are closing, becoming unaffordable and are not accessible. People worry that their venues are changing without community consultation. The vital role of community spaces must be safeguarded.
Creative Lives believes these practical priorities would be best addressed through a structural response centred on increased investment and stronger integration. Increased investment from local, regional and national sources is key to ensuring grassroots creativity keeps enriching lives and connecting communities across Ireland. Existing vehicles, including local authority arts offices, the Arts Council of Ireland and Creative Ireland do vital work. This can be extended and complemented through additional grassroots-focused support. Local creative groups should also be increasingly funded by health, social and skills investment.
Grassroots creativity also needs to be better understood, recognised and championed by public bodies and better integrated into public policy. This will ensure that it is supported to increase and articulate its impact. This requires better connectivity between groups and more traditional institutions and infrastructure to create supportive and mutually beneficial partnerships. Everyone in Ireland deserves a place to create, connect and thrive. Without both practical and structural measures, the rich tapestry of Irish grassroots creativity risks being lost, depriving individuals, communities and the nation. I thank members very much.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach and committee members for the invitation to address this meeting. I am venue development manager for West Cork Music. I am joined by Mr. Eamonn Ceannt, founding chair of Museum of Literature Ireland and cultural project adviser to West Cork Music.
We welcome members' interest in how to develop sustainable, community-led culture and arts infrastructure, and we offer insights based on our experience of carving out space for the arts in rural Ireland for over 30 years. Our world-renowned festivals for chamber music, literature and traditional music are staged in every conceivable setting from Bantry House and St. Brendan’s church to hotel function rooms, classrooms, island pubs and even our town’s courthouse, when it is not in session. Like arts organisations in many peripheral areas, however, West Cork Music is forced to improvise spaces for the arts again and again. We install and dismantle mobile staging, seating, lighting, hearing loops and sound rigs regularly and expensively in spaces where facilities and accessibility are variable and sometimes poor. We are deeply grateful to our hosts and we create genuine magic for our artists and audiences but this resource-intensive approach is not a long-term solution that supports vibrant spaces for and universal access to the arts in rural Ireland. Moreover, without a home and hub for the arts, talented teams like ours expend efforts on logistics and negotiating availability and cost that would be better spent on year-round programming, education, cultivating talent and encouraging arts participation.
The committee rightly identifies the closure of arts spaces, music venues and cultural hubs as a cause of national concern. In rural Ireland, however, the problem is not the loss of spaces that once existed. It is the absence of any baseline provision in the first instance. Bantry is the second-largest town in the west Cork municipal district, with an extensive coastal and inland catchment, but by the Arts Council’s standard measure, that is, an hour’s travel, our local audiences are out of reach of a major performing arts facility and our festivals and concerts only address that gap for around 30 days each year.
Without permanent arts infrastructure, rural programming decisions are constrained by what borrowed and temporary spaces can accommodate rather than by what communities need and artists can offer. In places like west Cork, basic performing arts infrastructure is simply not in place. It is unclear where at national level responsibility for addressing such deficits lies. There is no equivalent to the national cultural institutions investment programme, for example. Meanwhile, piecemeal interventions and investments will not meaningfully rebalance the regional distribution of arts facilities. We suggest that the committee may consider the transformative and regenerative potential of new build and large-scale projects in areas the last wave of major arts infrastructure funding did not reach.
Our own plans for a multifunctional accessible arts venue and education hub on a brownfield site in the heart of our heritage town have been advanced with local investment and support, as no State investment has yet been sought by us.
Ireland has a rich network of arts organisations, like ours, rooted in our communities and with excellent track records, ready to develop and sustain new community-led arts infrastructure. Activating them will require four steps. First, community-based arts organisations require a dedicated funding stream if they are to proceed with capital projects. Criteria need to encompass new-build projects as well as regenerative projects where necessary. Second, grassroots groups require help to access the professional services needed to activate capital projects, and to manage the related skills, leadership, and operational transitions. Third, funders will need to be flexible and communicate with each other to accommodate arts organisations as they transition to venue-based models. Fourth, funding will be required in the longer term to help sustain year-round programming with non-commercial components, particularly in peripheral areas.
More generally, we suggest that arts festivals should be recognised as a form of cultural infrastructure in their own right. Permanent arts spaces in Ireland have often emerged from these roots, and so arts festivals should be properly valued, nurtured, and protected. We are confident that the measures we have described would allow grassroots arts organisations like ours to create and sustain spaces for the arts in underserved areas, and to move from occasional programming to year-round activity. Targeted investment of this kind would also help unlock the full, cross-cutting benefits that equitable arts infrastructure can deliver across community well-being, social inclusion, and rural regeneration.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach very much for this opportunity. I wish to talk about youth arts. It is an area that I have worked in for a number of years now and I feel it is very important. It is 25% of our population. Unfortunately, it falls between two big stools, which are youth work and the arts world. Neither of which has totally embraced youth arts. It is in a very strange position. I am not talking just about infrastructure; I am talking about policy and a lot of areas that need to be addressed. I would like if an all-party group could look at this and try to progress it. As I said, I have worked in this area for 40 years now. It is crazy that I am leaving this area while at the same nothing has really progressed as regards to the structure and all that kind of stuff.
I wish to tell members a little bit about my life first. I had no interest in the arts when I was growing up. I did not see the arts as being important. In those days, music, reading books and going to the cinema were not part of the arts. I am talking about performing arts. I was off travelling for a number of years. I came back to Waterford, and I wanted to do something interesting to contribute to Waterford in some way. There was an advertisement for a community arts project being run by the Waterford arts for all project. I went along but I had no interest. I ended up being offered a place in this new theatre company which eventually became called Ciotóg. It changed my life. I have been involved in the arts ever since.
Regarding Ciotóg, the training we received was in-service, mainly through an inspirational leader called Ted O’Regan but other people came in. We did all sorts of theatre, including theatre and education and community theatre. We did all sorts of things. We did festivals, straight plays and all that kind of stuff. After about three years, the funding ran out and we all went back on the dole and went off to do other things. As part of my voluntary work, I helped to establish a youth theatre in Waterford. It was a voluntary thing. It was voluntary for about ten years or so. It then started to develop. It was originally called Waterford Youth Drama. This organisation developed organically. It eventually became a professional arts organisation. It went from a youth drama group into working in all sorts of areas in the arts, including dance, film, music, creative writing, circus and visual art, so the name changed to Waterford Youth Arts.
While all this was going on in Waterford - and I will come back to Waterford - I saw interesting things happening nationally. I saw some great youth theatres created and evaporated for different reasons. There is no policy in relation to youth arts. It is very haphazard. There is no long-term development or planning. It depends on where one lives. If one lives in a city where there is an arts officer who is interested, then happy days. If one is in an area where an arts officer is not interested, then forget about it. It depends on whether one's parents are interested in the arts as regards what involvement one has because there is an economic side to this. I have seen youth theatres disappear over night because a leader got sick, a leader emigrated, or a building got taken from them because it was turned into something much more lucrative. It has been very haphazard. It is not just youth theatre. It is youth film, dance, creative writing and all these different and very niche areas. However, they are very important because, as I said, they change the lives of young people. They changed my life, and they change young people's lives.
It should not be a case of it being dependent on where one lives. It should be a universal right for young people to get access to the arts, which are safe and exciting.
On the other hand, while I have seen all this nationally, I have also seen in Waterford the organisation develop from a very small Mickey Mouse-type organisation into now what would be seen as quite an innovative national organisation. It has its own voluntary board of directors. It now has a turnover of nearly €200,000 a year. It hires professional artists who have skills and an interest in working with young people. In a sense, it is like the first step for young people into the industry. They dip their toes and if they like it, they stay. We now have ex-members in all counties in Ireland in the professional arts world. Waterford Youth Arts works mostly with young people from ten years old to 19 years old. We also work with younger ones as well. The whole idea is that everything is subsidised, so it is very much accessible. Money never comes into it.
The model that we created happened organically but it could be replicated throughout the country. It is a very interesting model because it involves three main agencies. It involves the local council that gives the premises. It is the former military barracks premise in Waterford. It also gives a bit of money towards some of the projects. We have the Arts Council that funds our arts programmes. We have the ETB which funds two key workers. Those workers are youth arts workers. That is funded through the UBU programme. That model could be replicated throughout the country. It has been done. It is there. It is a model that people can look at and replicate. We originally got ideas from Scotland, Limerick and other places. We stole ideas wherever there were good ideas.
It means that there is an organisation that is there. It has a programme every year that young people can go into, learn and start their journey into the arts world. It is a very exciting area. I would like to see the Arts Council embrace it fully.
The problem is that there are a number of agencies, including Creative Ireland, the arts offices and a whole plethora of other agencies, which means a whole plethora of administration. Hence, we need two key workers.
On a more general point about the arts, not just youth arts, I agree with many of the speakers so far. For example, there are some very good spaces in Waterford but the problem is that often people only have so many hours per week they can work. Full-time workers or people on CE schemes only have so many hours. The arts organisations need to also embrace volunteers, although that has an implication. It means they need to have an insurance policy and have someone who is dedicated to the volunteers, as well as training and that kind of thing. Arts buildings should be used 16 hours a day but that has an impact on paint, on cleaning and on all the practical things. As I said, it needs to be a combination of paid people, people on CE schemes and volunteers.
The arts offices around the country should be told to spend their money in line with the population percentages. In other words, why is 25% of arts officers' funding not going towards youth arts? I would like to see that happen but it does not happen. It is taxpayers' money. I think taxpayers would be very happy to see their children and grandchildren getting access to the arts.
Comment on this
I am grateful for the invitation to attend. I am a co-ordinator for Cumas Ceantar Uíbh Ráthaigh. It is a Creative Places programme funded by the Arts Council in south Kerry. I am also the founder of Cur le Chéile community festival, which runs for three days in our locality, with 50 events.
I would like to speak about rural arts infrastructure from the perspective of someone working directly with the arts, creatives and communities on the ground. In rural Ireland, we have an abundance of creative talent but we simply do not have the spaces or infrastructure to support it. In some areas, it is not a question of finding a suitable venue. It is a question of whether a venue exists at all. For example, Hometree has a Dinnseanchas project whose members visited us but the venue literally blew away in a storm. In Cahirsiveen, one of our main towns in south Kerry, at present the only room available to rent for activities is a carpeted room in the back of the library. For the Cahirsiveen Music and Arts Festival, artists exhibit their work in the derelict penal church, in the windows of shops and along the church railings because there are no other suitable exhibition spaces.
While this demonstrates the resourcefulness of local artists and organisers, it also highlights the very real shortage of arts infrastructure in our area. We need accessible exhibition spaces, larger venues for performances and rehearsals, and flexible spaces where artists and communities can come together to create. Through my work at Cumas Ceantar, I have had three separate large groups approach me looking for artist-led shared studio spaces. They are not simply looking for somewhere to work alone. They want affordable, multifunctional spaces where they can connect with their peers, share skills, collaborate, run workshops and develop their artistic practice.
This brings me to another enormous challenge facing artists in rural Ireland, that of housing. In communities like ours, where tourism and holiday accommodation are such a significant part of the local economy, finding affordable, long-term housing can be extremely difficult. If we want artists to remain in rural communities, they need affordable places to live. They need to be properly paid for their time, skills and expertise. Goodwill and voluntary effort are enormously valuable but they cannot be the foundation on which the arts sector survives. At Cumas Ceantar, we are fortunate to have a programme that recognises, listens to and supports our local artists and creatives. The message we are hearing is clear: they need physical spaces in which to work and grow.
I would also like to highlight the wider community value of having access to creative spaces. In my own little village of Caherdaniel, we are extremely grateful to have a community hall but it is always booked out for ping-pong and every other activity - the list goes on. We have been searching for years for land or an additional building that we can rent, purchase or develop as a community hub. This year, our Cur le Chéile festival brought over 60 people together to create a street theatre performance. Artists, local creatives, school children, families and people of all ages worked side by side. One of our participants was a 76-year-old local farmer who had the most wonderful time taking part.
To me, this is the beauty of socially engaged art. It brings people together who might not otherwise have the opportunity to work alongside one another. However, creating something like this requires space. We need somewhere to make costumes, build props, develop performances and leave work in progress safely between workshops. We need somewhere to store these creations afterwards, so they can be reused and developed for future community projects. At present, much of this depends on borrowed spaces, people’s homes and the goodwill of individuals. That generosity is something to celebrate but it cannot be our long-term solution. That is why investment in rural arts infrastructure is not simply about providing buildings for artists. It is about creating places where artists can develop their professional practice, where communities can come together and where creativity can flourish throughout the year.
We need to explore how existing and underused buildings can be brought back into use alongside investment in accessible and affordable artist-led studios, exhibition and performance venues and flexible community spaces. We need to ensure that these spaces are sustainable, with support for ongoing running costs and for artists and facilitators to bring them to life. Programmes such as Cumas Ceantar are helping to build creative networks, recognise local talent and support communities to develop their ideas. However, when artists and communities are saying they need physical spaces, we need the infrastructure to respond to that need.
I would like to finish with the idea of a meitheal. In south Kerry, we know the value of people coming together, sharing their skills and supporting one another to achieve something that would be difficult to accomplish alone. That is exactly what I see happening through the arts. However, even the strongest meitheal needs somewhere to gather, somewhere to create and somewhere to grow. We have the artists. We have the creativity. We have the communities that are willing to come together and make things happen. What we need now are the spaces, the investment and the support to allow that creativity to thrive. If we want artists to remain in rural Ireland, they need somewhere to live, somewhere to earn a living and somewhere to create. If we want our rural communities to thrive, we must recognise that the arts are not an optional extra. The arts breathe life into rural communities. They create connection, confidence and a sense of belonging. They give people opportunities to come together that simply would not exist otherwise. They are an essential part of what keeps our communities connected, vibrant and alive.
Comment on this
I thank the Chair and the committee for the invitation. Our group, Give Us The Night, is a community organisation representing DJs, promoters, collectives, artists, venues and others involved in Irish nightlife. Our aim is to modernise and improve nighttime culture in Ireland and access to it, which, depending on where you live, is becoming tougher to do. Our roots are in nightclubs, many of which were the discos, ballrooms and dance halls of years gone by. In 2000, Ireland had 522 nightclubs, with 100 of those in Dublin. By 2025, that overall number had dropped to 83, with 23 remaining in Dublin. Depending on how rigorous we want to be in defining a nightclub, Dublin’s number could now be about 15.
In 2025, we measured 123 collectives and promoters putting on specialist dance events within Dublin’s late-night scene. In a city where the costs of doing business and maintaining a sustainable presence as a venue are increasingly difficult, only a small proportion of these organisers will get their hands on a suitable space, or even regular dates. Organisers need room to grow and, in time, even become venue operators themselves, something we see far less of today as spaces become harder to find.
There are many factors in the downturn of nightclubs, not least the painfully out-of-date licensing legislation that recognises and primarily favours public houses and very little else. With one of the most restrictive licensing regimes in Europe hampering the ability of dance venues to easily open after the public houses, this has unfairly shaped social options at night and the culture of dancing in Ireland.
Dance venues are not the only spaces we are losing. There are also the cinemas, pubs, theatres, artist studios, rehearsal rooms, leisure centres, swimming pools, boxing gyms, post offices and even the corner shop - the list goes on.
Communities are losing places to gather and socialise, especially at a low affordable cost. Planning and zoning systems should explicitly recognise and encourage a wider range of cultural uses, taking into consideration daytime, nighttime and multi-purpose spaces. As it stands, mixed-use developments conceptually suggest a diverse range of uses, yet in practice do not necessarily deliver this, with so much activity focused on the 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. working day. We also believe that demolishing licensed venues like pubs and other former cultural venues to create housing is, in almost all cases, a long-term mistake. More should be done to retain these spaces as cultural hubs of some form, with accommodation attached if necessary.
Local authorities should be obliged to publish an annual inventory of their land and property, identifying opportunities for cultural and artistic use. A recommended minimum quota of cultural space that each citizen should have local access to, as is known with green space, should be calculated. This would be very useful to informing policy on 15-minute cities too. We should also create an at-risk register of arts, cultural and entertainment spaces in danger of closure. Where appropriate these spaces could be eligible for associated State funding and protection. An expansive protected-use cultural venues register should also be established, with greater powers to protect cultural spaces and venues of significance that are at risk due to redevelopment. A mechanism like this would potentially have saved venues like the Complex in Dublin this year. Without it Ministers have less apparent power to make interventions in such cases.
Ireland should also adopt an equivalent of the UK's asset of community value status. This could apply to important local cultural infrastructure such as post offices, community centres, churches, music venues, sporting facilities and other buildings, businesses or spaces of significant community interest as identified by local community members and formally designated by the local authority. In this case a community could gain a preferential right and have a period to bid on a property before it goes on the open market. A community asset transfer should also be explored as a smoother mechanism to hand over public buildings into community operation.
The use of vacant property should be improved through greater collaboration between Departments, State agencies like the LDA and OPW, property management companies and real estate agents. We should introduce a better meanwhile-use system for the temporary use of buildings for culture, with a fast-track system from local authorities that provides the necessary agility to get the quickest and longest use from vacant properties. This could include periodic cultural use of vacant State-owned buildings.
A stand-alone State-supported body to purchase, manage and provide affordable access to cultural space could be established, in effect, the LDA but for culture. This could also be an initiative for the Taoiseach's Dublin city task force to oversee. There is a question about the future role of the Arts Council to carry out such work too.
We should also develop artists' quarters, including live-work units in urban and rural areas where affordable rented accommodation and workspaces for artists can co-exist in specified locations. Studio-above-the-shop initiatives could be piloted in city and town centres too, particularly within derelict and vacant spaces.
Large-scale development should also contribute directly to cultural infrastructure. A 5% community arts and culture infrastructure requirement should be applied to large-scale developments outside of the Dublin City Council area, with greater flexibility explored for smaller developments too. Developers must also fit out arts and cultural infrastructure for use, rather than simply providing a shell that could take years to be used, if at all.
Specific arts and culture funding strands should also be developed and improved within the towns and cities regeneration investment fund and rural regeneration and development fund. We welcome the investment through schemes such as the town and village renewal scheme and town centre first which are bringing vacant and derelict buildings back into use. However, we have yet to see examples of this investment resulting in later night use specifically for dancing or the creation of a dedicated dance space. These buildings offer an opportunity to restore cultural and social infrastructure that many communities have lost, with good potential for public-private partnerships between local authorities and venue operators.
Culture needs to be treated as essential infrastructure. If the State is determined to move cultural activity out of the areas where it has traditionally thrived, then it must also start to seek out new locations or ways to embed that activity. It is understandable that the current agenda now is all about housing but it is also important to prioritise how people live as well as where they live.
There is obviously a wider conversation about the costs involved in running these spaces. For now, however, we need to know how determined our Government is to rectify these situations. Despite lots of talk since the pandemic, delivery on effective policy for arts and cultural infrastructure has been thin on the ground. Cross-departmental co-operation, which is crucial to push forward meaningful change, is slim. We believe this stems from a lack of political ambition at Cabinet level which has been markedly less creative in this Government term than it was in the last.
Comment on this
I thank all the witnesses for their interesting opening speeches. We will now have general questions and answers from the members.
Comment on this
I might just ask individual questions if that is okay.
Comment on this
My first question is for Mr. May. I thank him for highlighting the thousands of volunteer-led creative groups that face an existential crisis because of the lack of suitable, affordable venues and the increasing costs of insurance in particular. Based on the submissions here today, the lack of support that the arts get is quite shocking. Mr. May's opening statement referred to practical supports and protections regarding insurance and the safeguarding of existing community spaces. I ask him to elaborate on those proposals and how they might work. I also ask him to speak a bit about the work that Creative Lives has done in Edenderry and Cork.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator for that question. It is really important to start by reflecting on the quite broad definition of infrastructure. The submissions today indicate the definite need for more built environment infrastructure across Ireland to support all types of arts to thrive but in particular community arts. However, for us at Creative Lives, infrastructure is broader than that. It is about the type of support that people can access in terms of information, advice and guidance, networking and connectivity. There is no point having a brilliant beautiful cultural centre if no one can travel to it or if people do not understand that it offers the type of opportunities that they can get involved in.
When we talk about the practical support around things like constituting, understanding, safeguarding requirements and navigating the bureaucratic challenges that exist, we are thinking about the advice and guidance that organisations like Creative Lives and Create, the socially engaged arts organisation, can offer to people. One of the themes that comes back again and again from our local creative groups is that they might be offered a grant but the hoops they have to jump through to draw that down are so significant that our volunteer-led organisations cannot manage. They will turn a grant down because they are volunteers. By the time they have done all the hard work to increase their insurances and write new policies, it becomes unviable. While we have to protect taxpayer money, we have to think about the proportionality of funding requirements. That is one thing I think from a structural point of view we could decrease slightly.
We need to ensure that we invest in the organisations that support our organisations rather than just investing in direct delivery.
I thank the Senator for giving me the opportunity to reflect on our work in Edenderry and Cork. Edenderry is a really interesting example. We have been delivering a creative places programme there for six years now. When the programme first started the people in the community were desperate for a dedicated arts venue. Interestingly, six years on, we have found lots of different ways to deliver arts across the community in lots of unique spaces that are not cultural organisations, for example, the Brazilian church and the community centre as part of the library. What I really appreciate about today's discussion is that we have to recognise there is a balance needed in all these things. We need arts-specific venues and we need community venues that can host the arts; it is not one or the other.
In Edenderry for six years, we have been finding very exciting ways of putting that on, including a festival in a van and things like that. What is most important for me about our work in Edenderry is that while we have a project worker on the ground, it is entirely led by the community.
There is a community steering group and there is monthly community consultation. Our worker, Phoebe, led one last night, heard from people who said there were four different poetry opportunities coming up and asked how they could badge that as a poetry season for Edenderry, for example. Therefore, the ambition in the community is there and it needs to be led by the community, supported by trained workers.
Finally, a reflection on our work in Cork, we had a partnership with Red FM which was all about celebrating the stories of local creativity because, unfortunately, what we are seeing more and more is that people think that creative pursuits are perhaps for our children or something we might do in a care home. What about the 60 to 70 years in between? We deserve to live full, rich creative lives. What we have is a partnership model, which we used to have with Red FM, where every week there would be a showcase of something brilliant and creative happening in Cork just to get into the ears and imagination of people living all across the region and, hopefully, inspiring them to do something themselves.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. May for that. It was very informative. I will come to Ms Burke and Mr. Ceannt. Their submission identified a lack of baseline provision as a key issue and mentioned how the Arts Council standard measure of reach, which is one hour, means that Bantry and many other parts of west Cork and Kerry are unserved. I think the same was, more or less, said there. Can they say a little more about their plans for a multifunctional arts venue on the brownfield site, for example, and how they have been able to secure investment? What are the challenges that they faced in doing so? I think that is really important.
The Minister has just announced an arts capital investment scheme of €6 million. Last week, witnesses here suggested this would have very little impact. The witnesses might talk about this when I come to them. It was said it would have little impact and needed to match the scale of the sports capital schemes, which I think is €250 million. It is right that it gets that but the comparison of €6 million and €250 million, between sports and arts, does not weight up for me. Have the witnesses any views on this? I will touch on that question with the others later.
Will Ms Burke and Mr. Ceannt speak on how they have been able to secure investment and what challenges they faced when it came to the venue on brownfield site? Then they might say something about the comparison of €250 million and €6 million for the arts.
Comment on this
It has been so interesting to hear people reflecting different challenges that we share and also the different phases our organisations have gone through over the years. In some ways we have been doing a version of what Mr. May has been doing in Edenderry for 31 years, thanks to the visionary leadership of Francis Humphrys, who established West Cork Music beginning with concerts in the library in Bantry House, now stretching out across west Cork, and building out a programme that tries to press out across the year. That work is so important. We are so proud of the work our team does, of the artists we bring together, of the people from our community who we help to show case to and of how we show to local, domestic and international audiences. It is absolutely fantastic.
Our current project is to try to establish a year-round arts venue with a world-class acoustic in the heart of Bantry because we are going beyond the ambition of that very welcome scheme to thinking on a larger scale. Audiences in peripheral areas deserve access to infrastructure that offers them artistic experiences at the level they would find if they were living in an urban area. I have learned more about acoustics from people who buttonhole me to tell me what is wrong with the acoustic in one of our venues or what is not quite right about the others because there is a huge appetite for and knowledge of the arts in rural Ireland and people who want to be able to listen to music in incredible spaces that support that experience to the maximum, whether that is by making sure they have access to a hearing loop when they are in the room or whether there is turning space for a wheelchair in that venue. We did concerts in St. Brendan's church in Bantry, which is wonderful - it has a lovely acoustic - but we had musicians in December saying their fingers were too cold when they were playing the violin. There were people coming out of that concert saying, “I saw her in Carnegie Hall as well”. Obviously, Carnegie Hall will have a slightly more suitable setting there but why can we not have venues that support world-class performances and world-class visitor experiences in rural Ireland.
For example, we run masterclasses where young people from Cork School of Music get to learn from world-class musicians. When they talk to me afterwards and I ask them where they came from, they say they have come from Bandon and Ballincollig. I mention the Meliora Quartet and the Olympia Quartet. These are young musicians so excited to have that opportunity but I have yet to meet somebody who says they are from Durrus, Castletownbere or Adrigole because getting to the spaces where they can learn, rehearse or see performances that inspire them is currently not possible.
All of the kinds of work people are doing with festivals and community groups, we have done. We are now looking to move to create those really incredible spaces. There is so much social impact we can produce. Encouraging people's creativity throughout their lives is a priority. In the summer, at the literary festival and the chamber music festival, young kids and young adults wandered up to venues and asked, “What's going on in there? Can I have a look?” You bring them in and show them the quartet or invite them to meet the writer. They might ask, “Is that a writer? Do they write those books? Do they make a lot of money from it? What's that like?” They meet the writer, you invite them back and you see them the next day. However, we cannot invite them back the week after or the month after or really hook them in to the opportunities to be inspired to start creating for themselves. That is a very long-winded answer that spins between somebody you meet outside an event to trying to match the ambition of really world-class spaces.
What we need is something sustainable and high quality that allows us to have all these things - the pop-up stuff that still happens in Sherkin community hall and in wonderful spaces that are fully accessible. Mr. Ceannt might want to come in on the process of how a group like ours works through selecting a site and progressing.
Comment on this
On the Senator’s comments on the difference between the sports grant of €250 million and what is being given to culture, we have an unbelievable dearth of facilities in this country. I come from the education sector. I was a vice president in UCD and was responsible for putting the campus together. We got grants under the sports grants programme, which is extraordinary when you think about it because a university has an awful lot of access to funding. I would have put in a lot of the campus infrastructure that you would see in Belfield now.
After I stepped away from UCD, I put together the Museum of Literature Ireland, MoLI, in St. Stephen’s Green. Out of that has come a process of advising a number of cultural institutions, including West Cork Music, Irish National Opera, which presented here, Na Píobairí Uilleann, which is doing a €20 million development in Henrietta Street and other cultural institutions. What is glaringly obvious is the lack of funding for arts infrastructure. It is absolutely shocking. It is appalling and it is a disgrace.
I moved from the education sector to the cultural sector and I would like to praise the capital programme people in the Department of education - their discipline, knowledge and capacity is unmatched. I have worked with them in the Department of education and in the Higher Education Authority. I worked with the Royal Irish Academy of Music on its development where we interacted with the Department of education.
At the moment, we do not have the capacity in the Department of arts and culture to replicate what is done in the Department of education. They are very positive to work with but, within the Department, I do not believe we have the capacity to support the kind of infrastructural development that is needed to match what we have in the education space.
That is the first place I would look. I would look within the Department of culture to see whether it can be supported to develop the capacity to deliver the infrastructure we need around the country. That is the first point.
The second point I want to make really only became obvious as an issue looking at the situation of West Cork Music. The Royal Irish Academy of Music, for instance, is clearly linked into the Department of education, while Na Píobairí Uilleann is linked into Dublin City Council. The infrastructure guidelines have been developed over recent years. We previously had the public spending code and cost-benefit analysis assessments. The infrastructure guidelines, as they developed over the years, are superb. They provide great guidelines as to how people should approach putting in infrastructure. I am really coming from the perspective of pretty expensive infrastructure, not the community infrastructure that might be needed around the country but, rather, the infrastructure to support theatres and other venues. The infrastructure guidelines provide the basis for approaching the Government for the funding that is needed by sponsoring organisations.
However, there is a gap in the cultural sector, which is not so obvious as in the education sector. The approving authority is not clearly specified. In the case of education, one goes to the Department or the Higher Education Authority, HEA. In the cultural space, what is the approving authority? Where do people go for guidance and support? West Cork Music has gone to Cork County Council. Within the Department of culture, we need the emergence of an approving authority that has the understanding and the capacity to deal with capital projects. It is not the Arts Council, which is more programme based. It needs to come from the Department itself. At the moment, well meaning and all as the officials are, they do not have the expertise and capacity to deal with the multiplicity of capital projects for which we need to raise funding.
Currently, the funding is appalling. There is €250 million for sports funding, together with all the other access to funding for sports but culture gets so little. I work pretty much full-time as a sculptor at this stage. I have seen what the situation is for visual artists and for the music community. The funding does not come anywhere near what is needed and, moreover, it is spread out over all the different areas, as we have heard today. Even just in the one area I know something about, which is infrastructure, the funding is appalling. By contrast, we see the kinds of cultural facilities there are in every town and city across Europe. I am advising Music for Galway at the moment. All of its venues are substandard. In a city that is synonymous with music, there is not a single properly resourced facility. The organisation is using churches, a convention centre and so on. It is a disgrace to see it.
If I had to pick a couple of specific actions to take, I would say, first, the Department of culture must be properly resourced, like the Department of education is, with the expertise to handle the capital infrastructure that is needed. In addition, there must be greater clarity as to where arts and cultural organisations can turn in order to understand and implement the infrastructure guidelines, which are fundamental to delivering some of these projects.
Comment on this
West Cork Music is an incredibly privileged organisation. We are strategically funded by the Arts Council, which supports us to the fullest extent. We have had fantastic support from the arts office in Cork County Council. We managed to raise €1 million to get us to this stage with our project. That is partly supported by the demographic of our festivals. Our festival supporters are in a position to offer us philanthropy, for which we are very grateful. We have also had fantastic support from local businesses. The Bantry community fund granted us €75,000, which is a huge commitment from our local community. It demonstrates a groundswell of support.
However, West Cork Music, as an organisation, is almost at the evolutionary limit of the model of using informal spaces. We started 30 years ago by borrowing one space. We now have 22 spaces on our website, each with its own set of accessibility information. We have taken that model on through 30 years. We are supported to the fullest extent by all of the organisations that are in a position to offer us support. We also get some support from Fáilte Ireland, for example, which is very welcome. It recently helped us to make our website accessible, which was incredibly important. We have paid staff.
Yet, we are stuck at this point of asking where can we go to progress a capital project for which we have demonstrated the need, built the audiences and got the artist networks ready to go. If we get a building up and running and we are in it, it is not a start-up. Any of the spaces that can be used, we are in them and we get things going. If we are in that position, then there is an issue with capital funding for the arts.
Comment on this
Ireland probably is one of the most famous countries in the world for our culture. In that context, the lack of funding and supports for our arts and culture is very wrong.
My first question is for Mr. Breslin. I totally agree with him that spaces need to be accessible when the public needs them, not just during regular working hours, and they also need to be financially accessible, including to youth and emerging artists. Will he talk about how he came to work with Waterford City and County Council, in particular, and the ETB, and how he was able to secure his council-owned space? That is really important and it could be one of the avenues we really need to explore much more. Will he also say a little about whether the private market is offering any opportunities to him in terms of providing the type of accessible space he needs?
Comment on this
In relation to the private sector, youth arts is a really exciting area. I think if there was a deal done with some of the large multinational companies that are involved in the creative industries, whereby there was some sort of system for writing off tax in respect of investment, it could lead to a very interesting partnership between the Government and the private sector to develop the sector. That could be really interesting. I am talking about a hands-off approach in the sense of kick-starting projects.
The arts is now an industry. When I started off, I remember my mother kept asking me when I was going to get a real job. Any time we went to talk to people about the arts, everybody wanted us to do things for nothing. That was the kind of mentality at the time. The attitude was that we were doing this because we loved it. We kept saying, "No, we do not do things for nothing". We want artists to get paid because if they are not paid, they will go to London, Berlin or wherever and we will not have them in Waterford.
We kept telling community organisations and local organisations that this is a job. We said that if these people stay in Waterford, we will have filmmakers, musicians, artists and costume people in our local community. We have those people now because they are making a living there. Making a living is really important and, now, people can do it. The film industry in Ireland is a very interesting example. It is really short of people and those people are having to be brought into Ireland all the time for shoots. We are not keeping up with the training.
The first steps into the industry are really important. If young people dip their toes in and find they would not mind working in the creative industries, then it is happy days and Ireland will have a reputation as we go forward. However, if we do not grab that opportunity, we will lose it. Young people are heading off to Australia by the bucket load because they do not see a future here. It is not just about the arts structures. It is also about housing and all the other things that give people hope.
I will give the Senator a couple of examples. The basic income for the arts, BIA, scheme, to me, was a disaster. People went on the scheme for three years. There were 2,000 artists put on it as a survey or experiment to see whether it worked.
We also had 1,000 people who did not get a penny but who were in the control group. They were on it for three years - 3,000 people, including the control group - and at the end of it the Minister scrapped it. All those people are back on the dole and whatever they are on and they have to start all over again, blah, blah, blah. Now he is taking another 2,000 people on. That is ludicrous. We had an experiment that worked and had positive results, and now we are removing them and starting all over again, taking another 2,000 people on - madness.
I do not begrudge the sports people getting €250 million. We all love sports in Ireland but we are so proud of our artists, actors, writers, movies and musicians. The list could go on and on. We feel proud when somebody is standing up getting an award or achieving something. We love if an actor does well but it has to start at grass roots. It has to start at the bottom. You do not get people up there without it happening down here.
I would like the Minister to embrace the arts and not just see them as a problem. There is huge potential. After 40 years, I am still really excited about it. This area is only starting. We could do so much more. We can see the number of interesting people out there. If the Minister does not have good advisers, there are plenty of them out there who would be willing to get involved and throw their tuppence ha'penny in to help him put forward some new ideas and plans. That is what I would like to see happen.
Comment on this
That is really good. I appreciate that. I thank Mr. Breslin.
I will come to Ms O'Shea. I know the Iveragh Peninsula very well and I love it. I love west Cork as well. I love Cork and I love Waterford and Wexford - and Dublin, of course, where I am from.
Ms O'Shea highlighted the shortage of flexible and welcoming multi-use community hubs where people can create, rehearse, learn and connect. Will she say a bit about how that building blew away? It is so typical of the arts. They are in little hubs or prefabs.
She mentioned the derelict penal church used for the Cahersiveen Music and Arts Festival and she said that highlights the shortage of arts infrastructure in her area.
Comment on this
It was actually a beautiful venue. No matter what happened, I would say they would still use that again.
Comment on this
What key supports are needed to bring those types of spaces back into use? What supports does her organisation need to meet the demand for artist-led studio spaces? There is kind of two questions there. Will Ms O'Shea say a little bit about the penal church and what supports are needed to bring those spaces back into use?
Comment on this
Cahersiveen is one of the larger towns in our area. From where I live, it is about 33 km. It is where our main supermarket is. The demographic of where we live is rural. There are mountains to climb over. Since it is one of our larger towns, there is no space in Cahersiveen. It is a room at the back of a library that is carpeted. If you are painting or doing ink work, that is the room you have. When it came to that festival, they wanted to hold all these art events and exhibitions but there is no space. There is a community centre being redone but they have not factored in the arts. It will not have a gallery or other space for arts. It was not planned for.
Sorry, what was the second question?
Comment on this
The first one was the church and then what supports does Ms O'Shea's organisation need to meet the demand for artist-led studio spaces. The other thing is how the building blew away.
Comment on this
With Cumas Ceantar, I have been in the job two years. It is here three years. We have had many clinics. We do creative networking once a month, when about 60 people turn up from Valentia Island or wherever, connecting, and we meet the artists. There is no space. A lot of places are holiday accommodation. Either the land is too expensive or there just is not anywhere for us to use, or the space is given to something else that is also vital to the community. Arts goes to the bottom and that is usually where the problem lies.
In each of the little towns, community centres run maybe 50 different things at any given stage. If you are doing art, you have to prepare your workshop, make sure it is clean and tidy and then bring all your things back out. We need designated spaces. It is vital. I have seen in our communities where we gave ciste beag funding. It is usually between €200 and €2,000. They work in the communities and it has enriched the lives of everybody. That is what the arts do. It is worth more than gold.
Comment on this
It is. I thank Ms O'Shea. I thank Mr. Sharpe and his organisation for all the work they do. He spoke about the difficulties that young organisers who are starting out have in getting their hands on spaces. What implications will these difficulties have in the future? He has been on the nighttime economy task force in the Department of culture for the past six years and is also on the strategic policy committee for arts and culture in Dublin City Council. Can he cite any good examples of the use of publicly-owned buildings for arts and culture? Will he outline the challenges he has faced in the course of all his work?
Comment on this
I will start with the last part. In terms of good examples, I would like to be able to give more. We were at an advisory group meeting the other day and the arts officer gave us a list of infrastructure that has been delivered, is in the process of being delivered or is in planning. It painted a more positive outlook of where Dublin is going than the conversations that have been happening for the past decade.
Things have been slow. The apparatus in place to deal with this has been the 5% rule that I mentioned, where you are hoping developers will be able to build this infrastructure. That has been difficult. Not all developers have signed up to that or have wanted to sign up to it. Some of what is delivered is not ready to be used, so there are a lot of empty spaces lying there not doing anything. I would name particular places but there is probably no point.
FLUX on Chatham Row is a good example. I remember an old SPC meeting some time ago. We had noticed there was a sale. Let us not call it a fire sale but definitely Dublin City Council was selling stuff off and probably wanted to do it fast. The old school of music on Chatham Row that DIT was also using was up for sale. As far as we were concerned, that space was in use for music, so let us leave it that way. It was being used to educate people. From my own inquiries when going past the building at one point, I found out there was a small performance space as well that had been used for dance classes and was now being used as a pop-up space for different types of events. Another group went in and then, eventually, it went out to tender. The group that went in had a background in BLOCK T and they created the FLUX creative studio and space there. They have done incredible work. Dublin City Council should shout more about that.
The community asset transfer I mentioned earlier looks similar to that, where we would pass it on to a community, bring them in, get them to run it, see how it goes and maybe offer them a long-term licence. That is definitely a success story we see in Dublin right now. I hope it will be there for a considerable time.
In Ireland, we like a good pilot - more pilots than Aer Lingus. We always have to test something, and then it sort of stays in limbo.
Quite often, we have to see what they are doing internationally. We know what people are doing internationally. We just know what we need to do politically in terms of decision-making to just do it, to pass that on and to tell local authorities, or to work more closely with them, to make this stuff happen.
Over the past number of years, I have found that some of the wins that are starting to emerge are good but there are not enough of them. I wonder whether some are catching the number of communities that they could. In terms of going into a space, you need to be able to experiment and try and fail sometimes. The way it is set up with the 5% system is a project will only be prioritised based on track record and balance sheet. I worry a lot about the younger communities coming through.
We could talk about nightlife as well. In the old days, the trailblazers coming through who were opening venues were in their twenties, sometimes in their early twenties. In fact, I think Paddy Dunning was in his teens when he was opening venues in Temple Bar. We do not really see that breed of venue owner, space operator or space maker coming through anymore, which is worrying. Something that was covered earlier, which Mr. Breslin spoke about, is that there have been surveys recently on how many young people want to leave Ireland. A lot of those are young creatives. I have spoken about this before. We cannot underestimate the number of local community leaders who get frustrated with Ireland and just want to go. If they are the leaders, the people whom people will follow to open these spaces and be part of those communities, are not there anymore, that is a problem.
What was the Senator's first question?
Comment on this
The first question was about getting the hands on the spaces. What implications or difficulties will there be?
Comment on this
I will go back to the question on the nighttime economy task force. Was that just a general question about how it has been going so far? It was. Part of my answer is in what I read out earlier. It is just the co-operation between Departments. I do not mind saying that as soon as Leo Varadkar stepped down, everything changed - almost within like a matter of days. It felt to us like some civil servants behind the scenes said, "Hang on for a second. Maybe we do not need to really pursue this as much as we previously did because the person that was telling us to do it is now gone." That is how that felt. There is co-operation between some Departments. In fact, the culture Department is doing incredible work but it does not have enough assistance sometimes. Some of the bigger stakeholders in terms of the Departments include the Department of housing, the Department of Finance, the Department public expenditure and the Department of enterprise. In terms of where the Department of enterprise comes into this conversation regarding the nighttime economy, culture and the arts, it often feels like the Departments of culture and enterprise are not really talking enough together.
The €6 million scheme was mentioned earlier. I need to read over it properly. I still have not seen it but I think it is particularly for not-for-profit organisations. There are three different strands there. There is nothing wrong with an organisation or an operator making profit. If it does not make a profit, it is not going to last. We need to like invite everyone to come together to provide infrastructure. Who knows? If people do a good job, they might not need as much State funding going forward. Some people are happier to just get on with it and do not need State funding and would like to just be left alone but that is when regulations and costs also become a problem.
Comment on this
I thank all of our witnesses sincerely for not only taking the time to put forward such detailed submissions to give their perspective but for their clear recommendations arising from today. I will be taking them back to the Labour Party. We can raise them in this Chamber, as will my colleagues in the Dáil, and when we are lobbying the Ministers. It is really informative. It is a space that am learning about. I am the spokesperson for Labour Party on further and higher education as well. Therefore, I can see the ties in there. Education was mentioned as part of it.
I am the eldest of five girls. Three of them have left the country. They did not see a future in Ireland. When we are talking about that, a lot of families are affected by it. My youngest sister is an artist. She just qualified and finished her degree in MTU in Cork. She is a mixed media artist. I am thinking about her and her future prospects in this country. When we talk about spaces in particular and infrastructure, it hits home.
I am based in Cork city but I am from the county. We have seen a hollowing out of a lot of rural areas over recent years in terms of spaces in general. A lot of the witnesses mentioned that, particularly in terms of the need for art spaces. There is a perception out there that artists struggle. It is accepted that they should struggle or that some form of a struggle is part of it. That absolutely should not be the case. Artists should be supported every step of the way in the work they do in the venues and they should have the venues that are required.
I will make some general points and I have some questions for everybody if they want to come back and add anything. If we did not have the arts and an emphasis on the arts in Ireland, it would be a very dull place to live. The work that the artists are doing is so important. I take the points in terms of transport and accessibility of venues. It is not merely just having the venue but people have to be able to get to the venue. That is important. Some interesting recommendations were made in terms of the county and city councils having to list all of the available buildings and land that they have and that there should be potentially a requirement in terms of building in regard to allocated space for the arts. These are certainly things that should be put in place. I refer to the funding discrepancies in different areas and Departments and the fact the arts is underfunded. None of us in this Chamber could dispute that this is the case.
Even in Cork city, we have been promised an event centre for over ten years, which would host artistic performances. That has not been delivered on. There are big infrastructure projects that have not been delivered on. When people see that it does not inspire a lot of confidence in terms of providing further spaces.
Cork will be a new city library. Libraries were mentioned, as was the need to be more imaginative about how we think about libraries and that they should be more multifunctional in terms of having an evening space and a daytime space. I was at Culture Night in Cork last week and it was just incredible to see the different spaces of the library being used for different things, different exhibitions, poetry and song. It is amazing when we see these spaces used to their full potential - even spaces that would have been closed normally. The English Market in Cork, for example, was open. One could see the potential if such spaces were open in the evenings, even venues which do not serve alcoholic, giving people other options. It is about building community as well as education spaces for artists to perform in. It is also about the local economies in terms of driving tourism and spending where people are able to go out and to have a social life. All those different benefits are interconnected as part of this.
I had a couple of specific questions. I want to mention the importance of the arts in terms of the Irish language and Gaeltacht areas. We hear a lot of lip service being paid to the language in these Houses but not a lot of goals are being met. We do have to connect the arts to that.
Mr. Sharpe mentioned London and San Francisco as recommendations in his submission in terms of the funding models there. Will he expand on that? Others are welcome to come in as part of that. Are there other countries they think are doing this well or are there examples that they might have seen that Ireland should be looking to as examples? I might come back around to all of the witnesses individually.
Mr. Breslin mentioned that he has been working in this area for 40 years.
I know that a lot of the witnesses have been working in this area for a number of years. What differences have they seen since they started off in their careers? Have they seen any marked differences in recent years? Are we really losing space? Have they seen any improvements in terms of what they are hearing from the Government? Are they hopeful, which is the key question?
I know all of the witnesses have dealt with funding applications and politicians as part of their jobs. What have their experiences been when they have dealt with public representatives? Have they been positive overall? What challenges have they found there? How do they think we could do better to support them as public representatives in our local communities? Are their particular things they would like to see their local politicians doing more of to support the work they are doing and the calls they are making?
I will give the witnesses a chance to come back in, and if they want to add in anything else that they did not get to cover today that would be great.
Comment on this
I will start with the Senator's first point, which was about models in other countries Ireland could perhaps learn from. One thing I was really keen to reference was the cultural and creative sector guarantee facility which is part of Creative Europe. It is a programme that Ireland could be participating in at the moment but we were thinking about whether there might be a national-level version of that.
The cultural and creative sector guarantee facility is a loan that is backed by the State, so organisations of all sizes could access these different loans. Some of them might be part grant or part loan and then a repayable finance model could be set up that would be more affordable for people. We find that people are now very risk averse. We are living in a very volatile financial climate, so it is unlikely that people are going to take out loans unless there is some form of additional support.
In terms of other countries that we work in, I would like to reflect a little bit on Wales where they have a new government. Plaid Cymru is in power for the first time, and it is making culture central to its movements forward. In particular, it is thinking about culture as a mechanism for preventative health, so it is incredibly important that we have all had the opportunity today to reflect on capital investment, and there is some welcome capital investment that has just been announced, but it is really important to think about revenue funding as well. If we have these brilliant buildings but no money for the people to run them and deliver this amazing community impact, then they will be empty shells. The Welsh Government is thinking proactively about how the Arts Council of Wales and Public Health Wales work together for some revenue support.
In terms of changes in the last decade, there has obviously been really rapid growth in arts funding in Ireland and that is very positive. The changes that we hear about from our local creative groups, which are almost entirely volunteer run, relate to the access around buildings being very constraining and buildings closing but also bureaucracy and administration just taking the love out of everything. Ireland, like the UK, has a rapidly ageing population, systems are changing and demands are increasing, if someone is in their 70s, how long can they keep filling in grant applications that will give €1,000 for six months and then filling out another one for €1,000? It is just not sustainable. That is how things have changed for the worst for our groups in the last decade.
In terms of political engagement, this committee is an incredibly welcome opportunity, and I am sure that all my colleagues would share that view. There is a challenge to be negotiated in how long things take to deliver versus the arts sector's understanding of that, and it is a piece of navigation for perhaps our organisations to offer support with by saying that things on the ground might be really hard but it takes a long time and political will to change things. The most compelling thing we can do is pair brilliant data with compelling stories. If we can be sharing those things with the committee, I think that is incredibly positive.
Comment on this
I will go in the reverse order to say that one of the things that has been really great about project is that we have had really sincere cross-party support at the local level. It has been practical and engaged, and we really appreciate that. Quite honestly, that is driven by an interest in the arts but also by an understanding of the cross-cutting benefits that a project like ours will deliver in terms of rural regeneration and health. For example, our brilliant literary festival director, Eimear O'Herlihy, collaborates very actively with Arts for Health West Cork. We run programmes that are connected with it. We run events that showcase the local LGBTQI youth and give them opportunities to stand out in their community, be creative, be recognised and be appreciated. That is so important. We take our concerts into care homes and do all of this work that is just incredible. They recognise that.
In terms of where we are, if great venues are added to places like Cahersiveen and Bantry, then that supports a year-round visitor economy too. Our festivals are run over 23 days a year. We had a survey of those 23 days of festivals conducted independently and reviewed by Cork University Business School. It said that over those 23 days in 2025, our festivals generated an economic impact of €7.67 million and over €10 investment for every €1 of State investment that came into us. It is a no-brainer to invest in arts infrastructure.
We do a lot of work with the Bantry Dementia Alliance's inclusive town initiative. We could be doing so much more if we are not also asking, "Did you bring the key back for that? Can you take those chairs over there? We do not have access to that today because this is going on".
The challenges over the past couple of years are do with rising costs, things like a hotel or venue switching ownership or what we do when there are changes in strategy. We do not have a lot of control and that makes our model, hard won as it has been and as robust as we have made it, vulnerable because we are constantly having to engage with all these other partners and that just turns us inward when are a very outward facing organisation. It also means that we are less able to run events that would produce the kind of benefits that Mr. May has really eloquently talked about today.
For example, we run an initiative for Colaiste Pobail Bheanntrai where a quartet comes in and plays for them. Last year, the students, who were 15 and 16 years of age, heard four pieces. We asked them what their favourite thing was, and they said Shostakovich. They just thought Shostakovich was amazing. We had a Shostakovich weekend a couple of weeks later and we had some of our regular chamber music people saying, "Shostakovich is too much for me, I shall not be going to that". If we show the arts to people when they are too young to have any kind of a judgment attached to it, they can attach themselves to anything. They could take up any interest and follow it but we do not hold those events for the schools in Skibbereen and Castletownbere because we do not have the sustainable, regularly available space to use.
The challenges are real, and they are the things we have to deal with, but the benefits, if we take some of those challenges away by making us more secure, are tangible. They are tangible to our local politicians and that has helped drive their support.
Our architects and our brilliant design team have been looking at venues across the country. They have visited lots of these small venues in small towns in Nordic countries and Wales. They are incredible, and we are just looking to have that kind of infrastructure.
If we think about the Irish theatre tradition, it was not a venue-based activity. In the 20th century, it moved into that. It did not kill off things like West Cork Fit-up Theatre Festival but it created a stable base. If we look at the wealth of talent that has come through Irish theatre since then, in terms of writing, acting and so on, we maybe need to think about in that kind of way. There are so many stereotypes around the arts and thinking that it is somehow separate. Politicians maybe need to be a little bit more confident about thinking about, talking about and defending the arts as something that is part of society in a really powerful and transformative way.
Comment on this
I will make two comments. When you look at society outside of work, there is education, arts and culture, and sport. Arts and culture is without doubt the poor relation. It is so far behind that a committee such as this needs to put the paucity of funding at the very top of its agenda. Everything else is moving deckchairs around the Titanic. The arts need increased funding. Venues have to be put into place. I have heard the comments and they are all very valid. Venues will not produce results in and of themselves, but they will at least encourage and stimulate results. I am not a critic of the Department of arts and culture but it needs to be more fully resourced to try to provide for this society what education has so phenomenally provided over the years. I am a big fan of the Department of education when I look at what it has achieved across the country, although there are areas that need to be better resourced. That model should be brought into the Department of arts and culture to provide those facilities.
One scheme I would like to mention as extremely good is the per cent for arts scheme for visual artists. It is a small scheme but if it implemented, and we must ensure it is implemented, it could achieve an awful lot with the small amount of money that is already within the budgets of the existing institutions. That should be spread out to private developers money, too.
Comment on this
In respect of models in Europe or around the world, unfortunately, young people are not taken seriously in other countries either. We have had exchanges over the years with groups in Scandinavia, the UK, France, Germany, Italy and elsewhere. They have other problems, bigger problems and all the rest. We could be a pioneer. We could pioneer something in Ireland which the rest of Europe could copy. I would like that.
On some general points, I worked for many years with Waterford Youth Arts. It is ridiculous that it has to apply every year. It has to apply again to the Arts Council and for education and training board, ETB, funding. It is a very safe organisation that does its job very well. It is very well organised and supervised by a strong board. Why can it not have three-year funding? That is a simple thing. Why could three-year funding not be normal? It has to do the same thing every year, which is to apply again.
The kind of development I am talking about in communities, small villages and towns, bigger towns and cities needs to be led by the Arts Council. When you are at the bottom level, the local council level, unfortunately, every council around the table is fighting for its own little corner. The councils want a bit of action for whatever village they are from. It means you can never do anything substantial. They will all get a slice of the pie and the pie becomes very small. That is how it works. I am talking about new ideas and developments. They need to come from a national agency. The Arts Council is the obvious one but it does not have the resources. It would require a new set-up. It is a no-brainer. We should spend taxpayers' money well.
Waterford County Council is great at trying to rejuvenate by restoring buildings that have been derelict for years and all that kind of stuff. It has bought an awful lot of property. I have asked councillors and officials about a simple proposal. Could we not have some artists in residence? Could they not have accommodation? I am told they could not because they have to be on the waiting list. It is all about the waiting list. When it comes to the council, it is all about the waiting list. That is completely understandable. In Waterford's cultural quarter, why not have a few artists in residence who live there? It could be for a certain number of years. There could be flexibility but there is none at the moment. That is not just a matter for Waterford County Council. It is a national suggestion. We need more of that kind of creative thinking around this kind of stuff.
Comment on this
I agree with what all of my colleagues have said. I have been living in south Kerry for about 33 years. When I moved there first from Cork, it was the most booming spot in the universe. As the years have gone by, things closed. There is now a community centre. There is no shop, only a pub and a church. No money has been put back into it at any stage, not for the dance halls, music or art. Money needs to go back in to keep these places alive and keep our communities going. It is important.
Comment on this
I will address what has been said. What was said about San Francisco and London was contained in a document we published online. I reference the need for a stand-alone, supportive State body to purchase, manage and provide affordable access to space. I am thinking of something like the Creative Land Trust in London, which I believe is funded by the Mayor of London. There is also the likes of the Community Arts Stabilization Trust, CAST, in San Francisco, which is a successful model to look at. People and the Government would probably agree with that in theory but then say that we have buildings and ask whether we can do something with them instead. It is then handed over and it is expected that the Office of Public Works, OPW, will step up and do something. It is like a father or granddad saying, "Here, you can use my old football boots." You have to think about cleaning them up and wonder whether they will still be in good condition. It is a little like that when it comes to trying to get your hands on heritage buildings. They have to be treated in a particular way and there is a lot of hesitancy to put these spaces into use.
Mr. Ceannt mentioned the Department of education. I have often seen infrastructure in the shape of unused old schools and educational facilities that could be used on a temporary basis. I used to play at a club in Amsterdam. It is still in use. It is called De School. It was an old school. It was purchased by somebody, as far as I know, or it may have been on a long-term lease from the city. I think a guy purchased it. We should be able to access these kinds of places.
The other thing with venues and spaces is that we must bear in mind that not every space needs to be forever. Sometimes the experience of a particular community at a particular time in its journey is that it gets everything it needs, going forward. There can be a finite approach to how we use these spaces.
I will try to bounce to a couple of other issues. Mr. Breslin mentioned offsetting tax. I do not want to be heavily promoting everything that Charlie Haughey did but he did ring a few of his pals at a certain point and tell them there were spaces available for them to do something with and that the Government would write off some tax to get Temple Bar going. It often feels to me that when we talk about the regeneration of spaces - and this is where leadership is important - it is not enough to say it will be lovely that we will have a certain number of apartments and offices, as if that is interesting to most people, as well as a slick hospitality offering. We have to do better than that. We need to reuse buildings.
To reiterate and acknowledge what everyone here is saying, we need to have more serious conversations. I want to know that the Cabinet is going to start talking about these matters.
There is now a little bit of controversy over the sports stuff and we saw the thing recently between the two main parties. It is in the news a little bit more, so I imagine it has to get discussed at the Cabinet table. How much time is given at the Cabinet table to infrastructure and the kind of stuff we are talking about? Ultimately, it will take leadership but, unfortunately, the culture Minister and Department is seen as a junior part of the Cabinet. There is teamwork there and we need a few people speaking to each other who can, hopefully, make a democratic decision on some of this stuff within the Cabinet.
I think I got everything in and mentioned tax breaks as well. There is probably a lot of other stuff I would like to bring up but that is pretty much it.
Comment on this
I am afraid our time is up. We were meant to finish at 4.30 p.m.
Comment on this
Yes, but our time slot is 2.30 p.m. until 4.30 p.m. and that was the agreement earlier on today.
Comment on this
I thank everyone for coming in. Many travelled long distances. We learned a lot from the discussion here today. Both the rapporteur and the committee will be formulating a report based on the views and findings. The witnesses will be contacted again and sent a copy of the report when the time comes. I thank everyone and remind them there are refreshments in the coffee dock for witnesses and members.