We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad Public Consultation Committee

Culture and Arts Infrastructure: Discussion (Resumed)

Summary

Witnesses highlighted the shortage of affordable, secure arts spaces and the fragility of organisations relying on short leases, volunteer labour and ad hoc funding. They presented community-led models using vacant buildings and shared spaces, while stressing that successful reuse needs long-term tenure and support for operating costs as well as capital investment. They called for a national audit and strategy, coordinated public-sector action, standard meanwhile-use agreements, sustainable funding and legal structures suited to cooperatives and community land trusts. The Complex also urged urgent action to secure a permanent home after its lease expired.

Maria Byrne An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I warmly welcome Senators, witnesses and visitors to the third public hearing of the Seanad Public Consultation Committee on the topic of culture and arts infrastructure. These public meetings are the next part of a process which began in February this year with a public call for written submissions. Submissions were received from individuals, interest groups and organisations across Ireland. After reviewing the submissions, the committee divided them into four core themes: artists and practitioners; community and voluntary groups; interesting models; and local authorities and State bodies. This meeting is an engagement under the third theme of interesting models.

The committee had its first meeting with artists and practitioners on 22 September and with community and volunteer groups on 1 October and the final meeting with local authorities and State bodies will be held next Thursday, 15 October. On behalf of the committee, I sincerely thank those who sent in submissions and engaged on the topic to date. All submissions have been considered by the committee members and will contribute to the committee's final report.

On behalf of the committee, I welcome the following witnesses to the Seanad Chamber: Micheál Keating, programming director of Féile na Gréine; Siobhán Geoghegan, director of Common Ground; Seosamh Ó Cathail, secretary of the NCF Cultural Cooperative; Damien McGlynn from Create; cofounder of Ample Space, Darren O’Connor; and Vanessa Fielding, artistic director of The Complex. I wish to acknowledge Mr. Chris Cullen from Flux Studios. Mr. Cullen is unfortunately unable to attend today but his opening statement has been circulated to the committee.

I must also pass on apologies from Senator Frances Black, who is the rapporteur on this topic, as well as Senator Pat Casey. I understand Senator Higgins will join us later. I welcome Senator Cathal Byrne; the Leader of the Seanad, Senator Ahearn; and Senators Fitzpatrick, Comyn and Duffy.

Before I call the witnesses, I must draw their attention to the matter of privilege. The evidence of witnesses physically present is protected by absolute privilege pursuant to the Constitution and statute. This means they have an absolute defence against any defamation action in legal proceedings for anything they say when giving evidence to the committee. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege and it is my duty as Chair to ensure it is not abused. Witnesses should note that only evidence connected with the subject matter of the meeting should be given. All witnesses and members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable, or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an unidentifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks and they must do so. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

We will now go to Mr. Mícheál Keating of Féile na Gréine.

Comment on this
Mr. Mícheál Keating

I am an artist, musician and freelance arts worker who has been working in Limerick city for the bones of a decade. I am here today as a director of Féile na Gréine, an artist-run festival that celebrates independent Irish music in spaces across Limerick city. I am also director of a newly established artist workspace on Nicholas Street. Féile na Gréine is run by a team of 24 volunteers and our meetings usually take place either in someone’s home, in a pub or in a public park, as these are the only spaces available.

This sums up the biggest challenge for the arts in Limerick today: space, which is crucial to developing and presenting work. If you are a musician who plays a loud instrument, you will have to rent a rehearsal room at €30 per hour, and rising venue rental costs are making it difficult to bring new music to audiences. If you are an artist looking to secure a studio space, you will rely on a stroke of luck or a sound landlord who is keen to support artists. In reality, these opportunities are few and far between and are usually stop-gap solutions.

Limerick has a lot going for it artistically: a strong third level presence with Limerick School of Art and Design, TUS and UL and fantastic arts organisations like Ormston House, EVA international and LCGA. It is a compact city with a lower cost of living than Dublin, an ideal place to build artistic community. Yet the lack of affordable workspace and the precarity of tenancies make the city a hostile place for artists, and many graduates end up leaving. This is a key gap in our arts infrastructure in Limerick, and I have no doubt it resonates nationally.

The arts capital investment fund is welcome news, though these supports are out of reach for emerging organisations that do not have secure long-term tenancies. This leaves a whole tier of the arts unable to grow or become sustainable. Féile na Gréine has an eight-year track record in the cultural life of Limerick, and this year's edition brought over 2,000 people together to experience new Irish music, yet Féile na Gréine grows only through minuscule increments of programme funding each year and is still largely held together by the team's countless hours of volunteer work. This barrier between emerging groups and the capital fund further emphasises the dire need for space. To support artists and organisations across career stages and art forms, we need a mixed approach to space provision, one that incentivises meanwhile use of space in buildings, encourages long-term leases and, most importantly, creates more permanent spaces.

First, we should incentivise landlords to lease disused spaces to artist groups for peppercorn rent - for example, by waiving rates. There are so many vacant spaces across Limerick. They may not all be up to code for living in but they are perfectly feasible as workspaces. Artists are really adaptable, and buildings should be too. Artists who work also bring activity to the city after the shops close, boost the twilight economy and improve safety.

Second, giving empty offices to the arts would tackle vacancy and give essential space to those already at work in the city. The new Opera Square development has Revenue marked as the anchor tenant, but since Covid it may not need the whole space, so there is a risk of even more office vacancy. In a case like this, the per cent for art scheme could be used to strengthen infrastructure. Why not put that per cent towards the creation of a small permanent arts space in a single floor of a new building? Sarsfield House, the publicly owned building that Revenue will vacate, would also be an ideal home for a permanent mixed-use arts space. Security and permanency are vital to create livelihoods in jobs and to allow the arts to flourish. We got a glimpse of this with the success of the basic income pilot scheme. I was a recipient of the scheme and I likely would not be sitting here if not for the stability it gave me. National and local governments need to work together and use existing buildings to address the gaps in infrastructure. This will allow Limerick to retain its artists, to give emerging groups like Féile na Gréine the chance to mature and to create a strong and healthy arts ecology that generates wide-ranging and lasting benefits for the country.

I thank the committee for inviting me to speak on behalf of Féile na Gréine and I look forward to hearing the other speakers.

Comment on this
Maria Byrne An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Go raibh maith agat, Mr. Keating. Thank you for your presentation. Everybody will have five minutes, but if somebody goes a couple of seconds over, that is okay too. Then we will have a general question-and-answer session with the members.

We now move on to Ms Siobhán Geoghegan. You are very welcome.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Geoghegan

I thank Senator Frances Black for the original invitation. Our original submission outlines how we began, our local demographic context and examples of our projects, programmes and funding profile. We employ one full-time and one part-time staff member and are a registered charity.

Since 1999 we have been working as a locally based arts organisation in the complex and constantly changing inner-city areas of Inchicore, Rialto and Bluebell. We are an example of how a local model contributes to a local, citywide and national arts ecology. We engage the twin methodologies of arts practice and community development, and our work takes place in partnership with artists, community development projects and community youth projects across flats complexes, community centres, after-schools and schools. For over 27 years we have invited artists and communities of place and interest to make art together in a range of programmes and residencies. The artworks and practices that emerge often explore issues of spatial and social justice, including class and power, all central to the reality of community life in Ireland. All require time and investment in order to establish equitable relationships and build quality and affordable infrastructure. These combine to create strong arts and cultural practices and progress shared ideas.

In 1999, with the Rialto Development Association, which owns and manages St. Andrew's Community Centre, we collaborated on the planning and construction of Studio 468 in the centre. Since it opened in 2003, over 45 artists have been based there and in the community. In 2016 we approached Dublin Cemeteries Trust, formerly Glasnevin Trust, to consider us as the cultural tenant of The Lodge at Goldenbridge Cemetery, in Inchicore, which had been vacant for eight years. We moved in in 2019. Both spaces are rich resources for artists and community and are an outcome of positive working partnerships.

Why Studio 468? It was a response to local arts and cultural work across the area. We could also see in the late nineties that artists were leaving Dublin as it was unaffordable. We decided not to charge a fee for the studio space. Instead, we invited artists and community groups to respond to an open thematic call. Studio 468 and The Lodge are high-quality workspaces bringing artists and communities together, building skills exchanges and creating diverse artworks. We also allocate a larger amount of our modest public funding to artists, projects and residencies of between €4,000 and €20,000 per annum. It is well documented that the arts sector is precarious and demanding. Many artists engaged in multiple projects are often forced to accept the poor practice of reduced fees, small bursaries or project awards that consistently undermine their role and contribution. Our annual funders are the Arts Council and Dublin City Council. The Arts Council holds back 10% of our annual arts grant fund until it is expended. We receive the balance four months later. With community partners we seek other funding streams for arts programmes with children, young people, schools and older people. This funding is ad hoc and limits programmes to a six-month or one-year basis, which radically limits the scope of what we want to offer and is not supportive of the complex landscape in which we work. These unsustainable practices are combined with the impact of austerity measures in 2008 that severely cut public funding for us, the arts and the community and youth sectors. Many have not returned to their original funding or staffing allocations.

Dublin 8 is in continuous redevelopment. The slow regeneration of flat complexes, extensive hotel and student accommodation, high rents, build to rent, and the new children's hospital all bring new challenges to the area. As the community and neighbourhoods adjust to this massive transformation, our experience is that the locally based arts and cultural resources are crucial in encouraging community connectedness and sustainability. In recent years, Dublin City Council and the Arts Council have encouraged the arts sector to enter into lease agreements with the corporate sector. The reality is that the corporate sector is profit led and those relationships are fundamentally unequal. In the past two years we have seen poorly funded groups from the community, youth and arts sectors enter into contracts with corporate property developers, leaving them vulnerable with the prospect of no operational base in the future. Examples include Richmond Road, The Complex and the Liberties Community Project. Across the EU and the UK, we have also witnessed the corporate sector leading poor-quality public art processes and commissioning, censorship and art-washing. At its core this also excludes communities. Ireland needs more equitable models. We are based beside the former St. Michael's Estate flats complex in Inchicore, which was previously vacant and is now under construction as a key cost-rental site called An Droichead Órga. Our local community role also includes being a member of the Inchicore resilience group, a key community safety initiative as part of Dublin south-central's Building Community Resilience project, and Inchicore Community Regeneration Forum, where we advocate for a dynamic public arts programme, a new community centre and library, and other arts spaces like the F2 in the former Fatima Mansions.

We are also involved in local community events for Hallowe'en and community and family fun days. The Lodge gives us security of tenure and autonomy. Our open-door policy means we operate as an accessible public arts and community venue through residencies, arts activities and many community meetings.

We will activate and celebrate our archive MARKING 25 in 2027 to celebrate 25 years with the wider community and the public. Common Ground has worked hard to be an autonomous and independent arts-in-community model. Studio 468 and the Lodge act as inclusive, diverse community and arts spaces, hosting multiple arts practices that challenge and diversify the Irish canon.

Comment on this
Mr. Seosamh Ó Cathail

A Cathaoirleach, a dhaoine uaisile agus an coiste, tá mé fíorbhuíoch a bheith anseo inniu. Gabhaim buíochas leis an Leas-Chathaoirleach agus na Seanadóirí uilig. My name is Seosamh Ó Cathail and I am here on behalf of the NCF, a cultural co-operative in Ballina, County Mayo.

Before moving home to Mayo, I lived in Germany for a decade. While there, I spent time in and took some space in a number of artist-run venues in Berlin. I will give a few names in order that they can be cross-referenced, namely Zuhause and Artistania on Neckarstraße in Neukölln in Berlin, an old brewery, and one that has now closed called Antje Øklesund on the famous or infamous Rigaer Straße. Berlin is full of co-operative spaces like this where art and nightlife cross over. They are small, member-led, self-organised collectives that are inexpensive to run, democratically governed and embedded in their Kiez, which is an urban village or village within the city. In other words, the local neighbourhood and people. For the uninitiated, as I was when I first moved over there, they were very strange, exciting and different from the nightlife we had here.

When I came back to Ireland, I became aware of the initiative called Give Us the Night and the report of the night-time economy task force. I read that report, and all of those things inspired me to try to do something like that in Ballina. I felt Ballina was a suitable location for a venture like this. Very simply, our model is, we began in 2023 as an unincorporated association of local people from the DIY scene there, returning people like me and immigrant artists located in north Mayo and west Sligo. We started with a website, email address and bank account. We put out a newsletter and started to run some events. We now have around 300 members, 40 of whom are active volunteers. They are split into groups of interest which naturally form themselves. They are very autonomous within the co-operative. We have our space, No. 5 Pearse Street, which is on the main street in Ballina. It is a beautiful building. It is a vacant council-owned building that we brought back into use. The council gives it to us on a €100-a-year licence. Our running costs are really low, and that is on purpose. We try to run a tight ship to give us the most artistic freedom possible, so those costs are only €2,000 a year. We can manage to run the space on that. Our reuse-led approach aligns with various policies, such as the town centre first policy - a Government one - and also the EU's new European Bauhaus project. The way we run things naturally lends itself to the mentality of reuse and sustainability anyway because we run things so cheaply.

The NCF is one of a number of groups participating in the Mayo sustainability fund, which is a pilot administered by Community Foundation Ireland. We are self-funded, as I mentioned, through member fees and small donations. We take small, ad hoc grants, mostly from the council. We are very grateful to the council. At the moment, we run a few events a week, depending on the time of year. The rest of the time, the members use the space however they want. It is a shared space. Our ambition is to expand our footprint - it is a big building - and provide permanent studio space for members. There is also an enclosed backyard that has fallen into dereliction. We would like to make that into a green space in order to have outside and inside event spaces. In other words, a full multi-purpose arts and cultural centre.

To realise our vision, we had to execute a few workarounds. Because no single Irish legal entity is suitable for our model, when we were first set up, we adopted the international co-operative alliance principles. Those seven principles align with our values. It is not really feasible to be a co-operative as a legal entity, and most people here would realise why that would be. It involves prohibitive expense in terms of not being audit exempt and exempt from other compliance expenses. We simply did not want to take that burden onto ourselves. We became a company limited by guarantee, CLG, when we had to in order to get the licence from the council and that caused a bit of tension within the group. We have to have a board of directors and that had not been expected initially when we were formed.

Referring back to the night-time economy task force, we had hoped that the Sale of Alcohol Bill would be passed. That was a big worry initially before we set up the group buy in the end we went bring your own bottle, BYOB. This is practical and it has worked great. We escaped the financial burden of being licensed, our members like it and the people who come to our space are happy to simply bring their own alcohol if they want to drink. We are talking about night-time events, so that is an important consideration.

To return to the German example to compare, a collective like ours in Germany would typically be an eingetragener Verein, eV, and you can look it up. It is all of the things I have talked about bundled into one legal entity. It is democratic by default. No capital is required upfront. It is very inexpensive to establish, it gets charitable recognition fairly routinely - unlike here, where in order to become a charity there is another administrative and compliance burden - and alcohol can be served at association events. Sometimes you need to apply for a licence, but it is a fait accompli and there is no major burden in that regard.

What could ameliorate the current situation from our point of view? First, enacting the Co-operative Societies Bill would be a help. I mentioned that being a CLG and having a board of directors is not a good fit for our organisation. It is fine and we manage, but it would be helpful if there was a co-operative, legal entity that was audit exempt, for example. That is one of the provisions in the Bill, if I am not mistaken.

Second, one of the issues we had when starting up was the amount of toing and froing with the council. There is no system or standard framework for licensing buildings, so we had to have a negotiation about what a licence was. Some of the councillors and other people in the council do not understand that we do not have a lease, which causes tension.

Third, proactively advertise vacant State properties for temporary cultural reuse. Ballina has a 25% vacancy rate for commercial buildings at present. Some of them are absolutely beautiful. It would be wonderful if they were brought back into use.

Fourth, would be having an umbrella body, like the European Network of Cultural Centres. The latter is basically an umbrella body for co-operatives like us. It would be great to have something like that in Ireland to help people who are starting up and to say, "These are the steps, one, two, three and four. This is how you do it. We will talk to the council and allay their fears. "

Finally, we could revisit the Sale of Alcohol Bill. Even though I said that this is was not a big blocker for us, it would be nice. We are no threat to established drink vendors. The people who come to our night-time events are people who usually stay at home; they do not go out. They are people who fall outside the bounds of the normal nightlife.

Our impact has been modest but noteworthy. The maximum attendance at our events is 50. We are not a big group but we provide a different kind of social space in the town, with no judgment and no pressure to conform. Any kind of event can be run. The feedback we get from people who come to events is that they feel excluded from the current nightlife but have now found a place they can come to at night and meet like-minded people, and that helps them in general.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien McGlynn

Dia dhaoibh, Senators. My name is Damien McGlynn and I represent Create, the national development agency for collaborative arts, enabling artists and communities across Ireland to create exceptional art together. That is our slogan. I thank the committee for the invitation and opportunity to address the room today as part of its consideration of cultural infrastructure and, in particular, interesting models from elsewhere.

The availability of appropriate cultural infrastructure is fundamental to the strength and sustainability of the arts. Artists and cultural organisations need places in which to create, rehearse, exhibit, perform, meet collaborators and develop their work. Communities also need spaces where people can participate in cultural life, encounter different perspectives and build connections with one another. In Ireland, many of these spaces are increasingly difficult to establish, maintain and access. The cost of property, energy, insurance and construction has placed considerable pressure on cultural organisations. At the same time, cultural spaces are vulnerable to redevelopment, short-term leases and changes in the property market. As others have recently told other joint Oireachtas committees, much of the space available to artists is either unaffordable or unsuitable, while the continuing loss of performance and working spaces is a serious constraint on the sector. The issue before us is, therefore, not only how to build more cultural buildings but also how we manage, maintain, fund and protect cultural infrastructure over the long term.

There are useful examples across Europe. One model is the repurposing of vacant or underused buildings for cultural and community use.

The network Trans Europe Halles has documented the contribution of cultural centres operating in former factories, schools, warehouses and other heritage buildings. Its current common spaces initiative treats these centres not simply as venues but also as community-rooted spaces that can contribute to civic participation, environmental sustainability and local regeneration. The model is based on collaboration, shared knowledge, participatory governance and the development of cultural spaces as vital assets for the common good. This is relevant to Ireland because public bodies hold buildings that may not be suitable for housing but could be suitable for studios, rehearsal rooms, workshops, galleries or performance. Local authority or State ownership combined with long-term leases and appropriate community or co-operative management could offer greater security than relying solely on the private property market.

A related example is the EUREKA project, which brought together universities, cultural practitioners, policymakers and local communities to address real urban challenges in four European cities. Through urban living labs, residents and other stakeholders, we are involved in examining spaces, testing ideas and shaping proposals. The important lesson is that cultural infrastructure should be designed with communities rather than simply delivered to them. This approach could be applied in Irish towns and cities and adapted to rural areas, where the challenge may be one of dispersed populations and limited existing facilities.

There are also useful lessons in the way cultural infrastructure is financed. The European Union has developed financial instruments intended to help cultural and creative organisations to access loans, recognising that these organisations often have limited collateral and irregular incomes. A comparable national loan guarantee or patient finance scheme could help organisations acquire, refurbish or adapt buildings without placing the entire burden on annual grant funding.

The evidence from European recovery plans in the past few years also suggests that investment must be balanced. A number of countries directed funding towards cultural buildings, energy efficiency, regional development, digitisation and culture-led regeneration. However, the analysis provided by Culture Action Europe cautions that investment can favour large institutions and heritage projects while leaving independent organisations, microenterprises and grassroots spaces behind. Infrastructure policy must therefore support both major national institutions and the smaller spaces that sustain local cultural ecosystems.

I suggest that Ireland consider four practical measures. First would be a national audit of vacant and underused public buildings with potential cultural use. Second would be a dedicated multi-annual fund for the acquisition, adaptation and operation of cultural spaces. Third would be planning and development mechanisms that secure space for arts and culture in significant regeneration and mixed-use projects. Fourth would be a national financial instrument to provide guarantees or low-cost loans to cultural organisations.

Cultural infrastructure should be planned across Departments and levels of administration. It involves culture, housing, planning, local government, climate action, enterprise and regional development. The objective should be a long-term national strategy that recognises cultural spaces as essential civic infrastructure. Ireland does not need to copy any one international model. We can learn from approaches that combine public commitment, community participation, secure tenure and sustainable financing, and adapt them to our own circumstances. I look forward to our discussion.

Comment on this
Mr. Darren O'Connor

I thank the committee for the opportunity to contribute to the public consultation concerning culture and arts infrastructure in Ireland. I will share practice experience on behalf of myself and my colleague Ailbhe Cunningham. Our practice, Ample Space, carries out architecture and spatial research in Cork city. Since 2020, we have co-ordinated Test Site, a collaborative art, architecture and ecology meanwhile-use project funded through an Arts Council project award, activating a vacant local authority-owned site in Cork city centre. The project will conclude its first cycle of meanwhile use later this year. Working through Test Site and through our wider engagement with urban communities has shown us the acute difficulties facing community-organised cultural infrastructure. Insurance, bureaucracy, access to land and buildings and an overemphasis on capital funding at the expense of personnel can make otherwise viable projects difficult to establish and sustain.

These experiences led to my colleague Ailbhe's involvement in the formation of Cork Community Land Trust CLG. Community land trusts are democratic, non-profit models through which communities can steward land and assets permanently for local benefit. Incorporated in January 2025, Cork Community Land Trust aims to provide a structure through which communities can steward affordable, sustainable homes and social, cultural and ecological spaces in perpetuity.

In April of this year, we co-delivered the Cois Baile seminar, focused on creative placemaking and community-led housing and the practical implementation of community land trusts in Ireland. More than 100 organisations were represented. A clear mandate emerged for a strategic organisation supporting housing, arts, culture and community organisations to pursue community-led approaches to land and asset management. We therefore ask the committee to advocate for the establishment of a resourced strategic support organisation. At present, individual organisations are expected to navigate insurance, finance, property management, governance, legal agreements and asset stewardship themselves. A properly resourced bridging organisation could provide shared expertise, reduce duplication and ensure that the financial risk of financing projects in arrears is not transferred disproportionately onto arts and cultural organisations.

We also ask the committee to advocate for a long-term rolling fund for community-led arts infrastructure. Such a fund must recognise that infrastructure is not simply land and buildings. Personnel, management, governance, insurance, maintenance and development are essential to keeping arts and cultural infrastructure viable. Funding decisions should therefore reflect the lived experience and actual operating costs of arts organisations.

Meanwhile use also requires a more responsive framework. These projects often operate in short windows of opportunity, while individually negotiated agreements can take months. Standardised, off-the-shelf or meanwhile-use leases could establish clear protections for landowners and arts and cultural organisations while allowing projects to proceed at the pace required. Ireland has made some progress. The Affordable Housing Act 2021 recognises community land trusts, CLTs, and other community-led organisations in the housing context. However, their potential extends well beyond housing. A research paper by Johanna Wiedermann of the Housing Agency comparing CLT development across Scotland, England and Wales highlights the gap in national policy and legislative infrastructure in Ireland. Reform of the co-operatives Bill is similarly important, and we hope that recent progress will lead to its prompt enactment. Recognition alone is insufficient, however. These models require the financial, legislative and organisational infrastructure to become viable.

There is also a fundamental question about how we value cultural infrastructure. Arts organisations are repeatedly told that the land or buildings they activate are required for speculative development. We believe Ireland needs mechanisms that recognise and protect the social, cultural and community value created by these assets alongside their financial value. The Community Wealth Building (Scotland) Act 2026 offers one example of how this principle might be developed.

We need to address the invisible infrastructure currently sustaining the arts and cultural sector, namely volunteerism. Organisations are increasingly expected to meet complex requirements around governance, insurance, health and safety, and welfare through voluntary capacity. These responsibilities have grown, while the resources and structures supporting them have not. While increased investment may be questioned on financial grounds, we argue that the current level of reliance on volunteerism is no longer socially viable. We urge the committee to advocate for investment in the structures that allow communities to become long-term stewards of cultural infrastructure: strategic support, sustainable funding, practical meanwhile-use mechanisms and policies that recognise social and cultural value alongside financial value. We understand infrastructure not simply as buildings but as people, organisations, relationships, land and systems that allow culture to take root and remain in place.

Comment on this
Ms Vanessa Fielding

I thank the committee for inviting the Complex to contribute and, in particular, Senator Mary Fitzpatrick, who has championed our quest for a permanent home for the past number of years, and Senator Frances Black for her continued pursuit of this issue. The Complex was constructed on an alternative model in that it was based on a series of privately or commercially owned buildings, not owned by the State, while retaining its non-profit status. It is not the only example of this model, but it is probably the one that has done it on the largest scale in the capital, but maybe nationwide. This model came about because we, as a collective of mixed artists, had an urgency to make our work in an alternative space to those available to independent artists - a space that enabled immersive work of all arts mediums and was not end-on, with fixed seats at one end and a stage at the other.

We had occupied and renovated several buildings on a temporary basis in the nineties for individual theatre productions, which is my practice. This was time consuming and expensive and ultimately, like others who work in immersive presentation, we elected to concentrate our resources in creating one space for all our work, including pre-production.

In 1996, the first of many applications were made to the Government and council for support to buy property, to partner with developers or purely for fit-out funding but none of them progressed meaningfully. I would like to note that is possibly before some of the committee members were born. Three major opportunities were passed up – The Academy, the old fish market and Ellis Court - and several smaller ones. They were very large feasibility studies that were done that went absolutely nowhere. Then, as now, there was a culture of inertia, even disinterest, towards arts space provision and there was no State process for such investment, so it came down to a matter for individual decision-makers who may have been risk averse. The Complex decided to go it alone and while it did receive small amounts of support, it has navigated a hard road for 18 years.

The Complex was, and could be again, a centre for the making and presentation of multidisciplinary arts, that is, theatre, dance, music, opera, circus, film, arts events and filming. Led by artists, it has earned a national and international reputation for the high quality of its innovative programming, its deconstructed theatre productions, its versatility to alternative stagings, its cutting-edge visual arts commissions, its support of emerging artists and its declared interest in the social relevance of work. There is no venue like it in the country and its loss is felt very strongly by the arts community nationwide. It had been in operation in five venues in Dublin 7, serving audiences of all ages, but in particular it excelled at attracting those that other arts venues find difficult to reach, such as the under-35s, local inner-city residents, those from low socio-economic backgrounds, ethnic minorities and from the disabled, neurodivergent and LGBTQI communities. We were not all things to all people, but we operated with integrity and courage, making our own work and curating programmes that encouraged emerging artists and crossing forms, including the creative evolution of electronic music. Partnerships were in place with Dublin International Film Festival, Screen Ireland, Dublin fringe and theatre festivals, aemi and many regular programme partners. A three-year commercial sponsorship deal with Diageo supported two large event bars.

The Complex was open 24 hours every day and events ran as programmed, some until 1.30 in the morning, thereby contributing to the late-night economy, while populating and making secure an otherwise volatile area of the north-west inner city. In 2025, it hosted 187 events, some for a week or more, and it attracted 41,000 paying visitors and approximately 4,000 others for studio visits, commissions, recces, scoping and design. The Complex is a registered charity, governed by a board of eight directors. It is strategically funded by the Arts Council, is a revenue client of the arts office of Dublin City Council and receives regular funding from Dublin City Council, Creative Ireland and the Department of culture. Its most recent venue on Arran Street East, just off Capel Street, comprised three large interconnecting warehouses with a footprint of 18,500 sq. ft. It accommodated 18 artist studios housing 28 artists, mostly visual, a contemporary art gallery, The Cooler, a 60-seat music space for rehearsals, recordings, workshops and performances, let to resident artists The Improvised Music Company, from whom the committee has already heard, and The Depot, a 350-capacity flexible warehouse performance space.

Its business model pivoted on stable monthly income, made up of rents from the studios, subsidised in part by the Arts Council, income from venue hire and services, grants, which were at 22%, to support commissions and the visual arts programme, sponsorship, ticket sales, merchandise and bar sales. Rates for venue hire were tailored to the size and scope of each event, with sporadic commercial hires part-supporting the non-profit end of the programme. In the last three years, its annual turnover has been just shy of €1 million.

In January 2026, The Complex’s lease on Arran Street expired. A proposal had been made to the Government and council in 2024, supported by a financial assessment by Forvis Mazars and a feasibility study by masters students in Technological University Dublin, TUD, to buy into a new development on the site. The Complex would own the bottom two floors of a mixed development for its cultural use, and the Government would have a lien on that part of the property. A significant amount of match funding was raised, some €5.5 million, and the Department of culture, Department of public expenditure, the Department of Finance and Dublin City Council were open to co-supporting it but no one Department would, or could, take the lead as it was not a building of national heritage importance. Dublin City Council was not interested in taking the lead, having recently resolved the transfer of Smock Alley.

A large-scale public campaign arose, and artists and the public expressed their outrage that such a resource could be lost through lack of leadership. It takes such a long time to build a reputation, relationships with a diversity of artists, production companies, clients, film crews and audiences. A petition of over 17,000 signatures was presented to the Dáil by a rally of over 1,000 people, an assembly of speakers collected to voice their views, from the council’s arts officer to Senator Fitzpatrick, and many senior representatives from the arts community, which was filmed and sent to the Dáil. Finally, a marathon three-day music event called Groundswell, involving 45 well-known bands, played to large crowds to raise awareness, but there was no movement, just inertia.

The resolution to providing arts infrastructure needs all the relevant sectors to engage formally together and become part of a resolution-focused network. Traditionally, heritage buildings owned by the Office of Public Works, OPW, have been allocated to national institutions. There is nowhere to go for the independent sector or a collective of artists like The Complex seeking to be building-based. We would like to recommend to the committee that space for arts is pursued through the commercial and private property market as well as through State-owned property portfolios. This would increase the choice and location of space for arts use. It could be by means of partnerships, which are incentivised through the planning process by the local authority,and supported financially with adequate resources to provide interventions such as single purchase or co-purchase agreements and significant rent subsidies or rent guarantees, all administered via a formal process. This formal process would be by means of a panel for submissions, like the Taoiseach’s task force, made up of representatives from all relevant parties such as Department of public expenditure, including the OPW, the Department of Finance, the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage, Dublin City Council, including planning, arts, acquisitions, the Arts Council, and led by the Department of culture. This would ensure engagement and a unified response. We also recommend that initiatives from artist collectives are considered, like The Complex, in addition to per capita provision for arts spaces.

The Complex has until the end of the year to source a destination. Its preference is to stay in the north inner city, especially the west side which is acutely underprovided with arts infrastructure. Our partnership remains intact with the Improvised Music Company and many of our former programme partners and clients. We are two strategically funded organisations, reducing risk and bringing a wealth of experience to guarantee a high-quality operation with a ready-made regular following, including minority audiences. One option is to tender for the meanwhile use of the GPO and hope it prolongs the life of The Complex until the Government has put in place a proper mechanism for investment in arts space for independent artists. This would be a popular choice with the public. It would restore lost vital arts infrastructure, redeem the Government and it would have the backing of the Arts Council which wishes to augment provision for the independent arts sector.

Comment on this
Maria Byrne An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Before we move to the questions and answers session, I acknowledge our colleague, Deputy Noel McCarthy from Cork, and his guests. I met some of them earlier with the Deputy. I hope they enjoy their visit to Leinster House. I also welcome Senator Higgins, who has joined us on behalf of Senator Black.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for being here and giving their presentations. They were very enlightening. I come from Clonmel, and we have some really good events on every year like the busking festival and the Clonmel Junction Arts Festival.

There is also Clonmel Applefest, and South Tipperary Arts Centre does a lot of work. There are many people who are very passionate about the arts in my area. We have tried to build up an awareness of and passion for the arts in Clonmel, which has been quite successful. I see, when the witnesses talk about Limerick and other places, that they are doing that right across the country, which is so important.

Senator Fitzpatrick and I were in Osaka last year for the Expo. Ireland was represented at it. The focus was predominantly on Irish culture, arts and music. This attracts an audience from Asia. There are benefits on the back of that in terms of people coming to Ireland and increased tourism. It is good for the economy and everything else. When we go abroad, we are always so proud of our culture. Our culture is based on the arts, musicians and poets, but that can only continue if work is done on the ground in towns across the country. I thank the witnesses for that.

Reference was made to Germany. I was in Berlin recently. It is amazing what an open-space culture can do to create vibrancy around a city. I saw a little bit of it and it was very appealing. I can see why the witnesses think it could be done in places such as Ballina. It just creates something different that people would visit.

Ms Fielding spoke about the excellent work Senator Fitzpatrick is doing for her. Sometimes I feel that, certainly within the arts but in other sectors as well, people need to find a local representative who understands what they are talking about, what they actually want to deliver and the vision they have. In places like Limerick and Ballina, have the witnesses had local representatives who have said they get it and can offer help and support? Sometimes it is a battle to get funding or support from a local authority. Often, it is a representative from the area, whether a councillor or national representative, who says he or she wants to work with and help those concerned. Have the witnesses sought that and do they see the benefit of it?

Comment on this
Mr. Mícheál Keating

Yes. In the past year, I was evicted from an artists’ workspace that I was sharing with a bunch of other artists. I contacted local councillor, Maria Donoghue, who is also an architect. She is quite passionate about the arts but also about the use of space in the city. I had quite a good interaction with her in that she put me in contact with a community group that happened to have a floor of a building available on the island in Limerick. I am now renting that space with a bunch of other artists and the community group is happy to have arts-focused, community-focused people in the building using it. That is my experience.

Comment on this
Mr. Seosamh Ó Cathail

Yes, I can answer. Senator Mark Duffy was an Independent councillor in the town at the time and I approached him. He seemed like a progressive young guy and he introduced us to the decision-maker in the council. I do not want to get into a side discussion, but obviously the council has all the cards. What we were really looking for was an introduction to the person who could say "Yes". Senator Duffy did that for us at the time and that was crucial.

I have listened to all the contributions and everyone keeps talking about space. The physical space is so important for the buy-in. People can try everything else, but without the space it is so tough. Councils have the space. For us, that is exactly how it worked. Councillor Duffy, who was an Independent at the time, introduced us to one of the property managers in the municipal council. We had a tough conversation. There was not much understanding of what we were trying to do, but over time the council took a chance on us. You would have to ask it but it gave us another licence, so I guess it is happy. It worked out.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien McGlynn

Maybe we are slightly different in that we are a national organisation, but we fund and support projects all over the country. We see the same issues everywhere. We obviously have our own base here in Temple Bar in the city and deal with our own issues there.

Helpful or amenable local councillors are great, and we have had a few of those who have been very supportive of us in Dublin City Council. We have seen it elsewhere as well. Again, it comes back to how disjointed the policies or funding structures are. A person can have a very supportive councillor and the arts office supporting him or her, but they will tend to say they can do only so much and that they are stuck because of some national policy or the lack of funding coming down from the State. Many people are supportive and recognise the issues, but they feel that their ability to do something about them is limited. Everybody is saying it is not really their role but that of somebody else. We get stuck in this cycle of being told there is a block somewhere. The problem is that there are multiple blocks in multiple locations.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Geoghegan

Our model is very different because we were established through European Regional Development Fund, ERDF, funding, following research by a local partnership company. That research was really trying to capture the growth and plethora of arts and cultural initiatives that happened around the south-west inner city in the late 1990s. Our original funding came from the ERDF. Even though we did not approach councillors ourselves when looking for a secure base, we did approach Dublin City Council's assistant city manager at the time, who has a big reputation. Some people in this room might remember him. His name was Brendan Kenny. He was the key person who negotiated on our behalf, or brokered our meeting with the Glasnevin Trust. We approached executives within the city council and we work with many executive staff in the city council in different spaces, positively and negatively at times.

Our model was around that whole idea of trying to find a space and a place. As Mr. Keating referred to earlier, we pay a peppercorn rent. We could not afford to pay €15,000 to €20,000 a year in the south-west inner city of Dublin for an arts and cultural space that would house artists and the community. It would be impossible. We did find ourselves in a situation where we were paying a very high rent and we ended up just giving notice on that. We ended up in a Dublin City Council space, the old Goldenbridge convent. A former nun's cell was our base for a good number of years. The difficulties around those spaces are that they do not have 24-hour access. Trying to facilitate the needs of an arts organisation, the artists it works with or the local groups it works with can create restrictions in the relationships. Trying to open the spaces up and to open up the idea of what we need, what the community needs and what the artist needs is a big negotiation.

It is kind of funny, in one way, that we ended up talking to an organisation whose business is the burial of the dead and that it was able to give us a tenancy in the building. The whole process around that involved regenerating the building because it was vacant and derelict. We managed to secure some funding from the Department of arts towards the rebuild of that building. That was the exchange between us and Glasnevin Trust. The building is a small sexton's house, like a domestic house, but it has a huge impact on the area, which is a really positive thing.

Similarly, with studio 468 at St. Andrew's, that space was a response to a lot of arts and cultural work that happened in the area. The Irish Museum of Modern Art, IMMA, had just opened in the 1990s. Rialto Youth Project was doing a lot of community and youth work with Wet Paint. There were these really strong grassroots practices that had been established in the area. What Common Ground was really trying to do was harness that energy and that connection between local people, children, young people and artists. That is why we were established.

We started with £18,000 and now we are on €130,000 from the Arts Council every year. It is a small amount of money. Even though the examples here involve small amounts of money, we need more investment. We need more structures and commitment, because it is tough being in a community, it is tough being an artist, and it is tough trying to keep an organisation above water.

The models that are represented here really describe a vibrancy and energy that needs to be harnessed.

Comment on this
Ms Vanessa Fielding

We too had incredible support from Brendan Kenny back in the day. However, it is important that it is not person-led or personality-led or, with all due respect, led by somebody who champions an arts organisation. I have spent at least 18 years with politicians and councillors and there is only so far you can go without a national policy, a national fairness and somewhere to go so it is not actually down to an individual's choice. It should be a fair, transparent process that enables artists and is not at the whim of somebody when they choose to pick it up or not. That is critical. If we do not get that, we will not get progress. Equally, that panel needs to be funded and have a resource so we are not just hearing the woes of artists for years and years. To be fair, the impulse that made me start The Complex was that I had been in so many talks that were circular and had gone nowhere, so I decided to do it myself and try to be an example of somebody breaking through and actually doing it. I have defied all the odds all the way, through financial crashes, ups and downs.

We are better than that. We are so proud of our culture here and we are so good at it. We should be investing in it. It is really stark that sports got a capital investment of €250 million and arts got €6 million. That is really just enough to change the bins, nationally. It is ridiculous. We can go on saying it. When one is as old as I am and has been doing it long enough, it is really frustrating because you are dealing with individual decision-makers. My guidance would be against that.

Comment on this
Mr. Darren O'Connor

I will speak specifically to TEST SITE. TEST SITE took over a vacant piece of land in Cork city that was owned by Cork City Council. Through that process we did not engage with public representatives. It was entirely through the council's staff in the property department, arts department and planning department. That was not an easy process either. It took quite a long time. The project started by initially asking permission to put up a poster and then we were asked why we were asking permission to do that. It was those types of smaller conversations that allowed us to build up a relationship and trust with the council and its staff. Equally, the project started during the Covid pandemic when there was a much greater push for outdoor spaces and venues. While the council staff had been very good in supporting the project, there have not been as many projects since we came out of the pandemic.

It takes a really long time to build up these relationships and, as Ms Fielding was saying, it should not take a champion to do it. Often, through restructuring or movement, someone who was favourable to one sort of thing can move to another council and the years of relationships we spent building all of a sudden mean nothing.

Comment on this

I thank each of the witnesses for their submissions, for their statements today and, more importantly, for their dedication, bravery, tenacity, passion and inventiveness. They are all very well versed in making a silk purse out of a sow's ear, and they do an incredible job with what they have. I am the Fianna Fáil Seanad spokesperson for the arts. I am so excited to hear about the witnesses' models but at the same time I know about the hurdles and challenges they face. Being from a town like Drogheda, I know how hard it can be sometimes to reach out to the regions.

However, I feel quite lucky that we have a night-time economy officer, which makes a huge difference. I have seen great use and repurposing of spaces, etc. We also just received €7.5 million in THRIVE funding which was then matched by the local authority for an arts and culture hub. That will make such a vast difference, it is unbelievable. It is a derelict vacant property called Westgate House. It will be home to several of our wonderful cultural groups and have a new performance space, etc. This is the model we need to see on a national basis. What frustrates me, and I am certain it frustrates others as well, is when you see the vacant and derelict buildings being filled with far too many vape shops, nail bars and so on. I would love to see arts and culture being nurtured in those types of spaces, along with shops selling artisan products, jewellers, etc. This is what we need to see on our streets rather than more shops selling these disposable, unhealthy and dangerous products.

I was in Limerick for my first ever night out there on Sunday night to see the incredible use of King John's Castle. Of course, it does help when you have the likes of the Ryder Cup coming to town, with very deep pockets. It is the legacy when we have events like that which I would love to see. Drogheda hosted the Fleadh Cheoil na hÉireann in 2018 and 2019. There was a big plan to have a legacy following that and then the pandemic hit and we have never got back to where we should be. That is what we need to work on. If something comes to a town, city or village, before it even gets there we must start building on the legacy.

I would love to see how we can help the witnesses through policy making. I have seen beautiful spaces being used inventively in my home area and across the country, such as empty buildings. In practical terms, how do we convince local authorities and landlords, in particular, to take a gamble and a chance on the likes of culture and arts? Sometimes it seems that the quick fix is available for them. It is quick money. I would like to know about the practical steps.

It was mentioned that lots of money goes into sports. Yes, it does go into sports. At the same time, we have to welcome the fact that there has been the first arts capital grant, which we have long fought for. The figure of €6 million might sound like a drop in the ocean, but if it is coming, we need to make the most of it and show that it should be recurring and that it should be built on. What are the practical things I can help with? I can lobby individually with Louth County Council, and I have done so and we have got great things, but this needs to be a policy across the 31 local authorities. What can we do to help? We can begin with Mr. Keating.

Comment on this
Mr. Mícheál Keating

I am not sure exactly how to address that. In terms of interacting with local councils, we have a brilliant arts office in Limerick but its remit often seems limited and there seems to be poor communication and transparency across council departments. The accountability for these things can fall through the cracks. As Ms Fielding was saying, there does need to be overarching policy nationally so that the arts and culture are valued inherently beyond their fast economic impacts because we know the impact of the arts is broader and can be invisible and hidden. There needs to be integration between the national and local governments to help support the arts and arts infrastructure. There also needs to be better communication between local government departments. The roads department is important for the arts if, for example, a festival is trying to run events in public spaces. The property department is obviously very important as well. It can be a whole process to try to approach these individual departments and can take a very long time to get an answer. There is no idea of how these things work in the council and it seems like there is a very entrenched attitude or an established way that one cannot break into, especially for somebody like me and my peers who are emerging arts organisers and emerging practitioners. It can seem like there is no way in sometimes. The arts office might say it sees somebody doing brilliant work and that it wants to support them as much as possible, but its hands are tied because an email may go to another council department and there will be no response. These kinds of silly things happen. That is my perspective on it.

Comment on this

It sounds like we almost need to bypass the arts office at times. When it comes to infrastructure, we may need to be dealing with a different department. If a housing development is at the planning stage, I would certainly like to see that it must contain a cultural centre such as a hall or some sort of dedicated space, whether it is local authority housing or a private development. That is a practical solution whereby we could target a particular department.

Comment on this
Mr. Micheál Keating

For sure. I mentioned the per cent for art scheme. That is always thought of as a way of erecting a public sculpture or something like that, but perhaps this could be used for infrastructure. Maybe that is poorly understood by developers or whoever is around these decisions. It could be worth looking at.

Comment on this

I would love to hear about any practical solutions that we can actually see happening.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Geoghegan

I do not know if this is practical; it might be more of a critique. In planning, we have section 48. When the Government and Dublin City Council or any local authority rely on cultural space being secured through the planning system, we are then relying on commercial entities which are controlling what that cultural activity is. Who controls art and cultural activity? Whose tastes, priorities or ideas about cultural work are shaping it? Who decides what artists and community organisations go in and who is allowed to access it? We have hundreds of examples of this in Dublin 8 at the moment. We have the Staycity which was the original Tivoli Theatre, a huge community resource. There used to be pantomimes there, and a nightclub. Now it is a cultural space but we cannot really get into it. Criteria are applied to some of those spaces, if a cultural or arts organisation wants to apply. We have been working with artists who are really interrogating this issue of who gets to make culture in the local area, or who gets to access those spaces. Staycity has this control over the space. The criteria applied for any application include "values alignment" and "leadership and delivery confidence", assessed on the basis of a presentation. These kind of criteria fly in the face of what art, community development, youth development and all of those things are. The purpose of art sometimes is to critique what is going on in the world. How can artists and organisations remain independent and autonomous within that process? It is a really difficult thing at the moment. It is a real hurdle for how we look at that planning. For Common Ground, being autonomous in our space has been really powerful for us as an organisation. However, when artists are going into other spaces, they are being censored. In some spaces, organisations are being censored and asked not to critique certain things.

Comment on this

Is Ms Geoghegan finding that more in commercial settings or in local authority settings?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Geoghegan

Particularly in commercial settings. As Ms Fielding would say on this whole idea of what policy is, it is a very ad hoc system and it is very much at the mercy of what commercial entities define as tasteful, appropriate and something their clients or their community would like. We have seen that with Newmarket Square as well. We have had almost a cleansing of that square for the tourism market. These are real problems we are finding in the south-west inner city at the moment. We and other partners have real concerns. There has to be something that challenges these commercial entities, to really think about how to open up opportunity rather than close it down and control it. Do we want a really vibrant city or do we want a homogenous city? We are at a critical breaking point around that at the moment. This can apply to all parts of Ireland. Once we start redeveloping, regenerating and thinking this is the way to go, who is it for? That is a big question. Who gets access? How do we work together to make it much more dynamic, inclusive and interesting? Some of those models are cooling the temperature, not allowing growth or dynamic practice, and not allowing artists or communities to thrive. It is a really big challenge within the planning system in how local authorities and the Government start thinking about that differently. If we bring people together who can advocate for that, and bring other experiences to the table to challenge it, that would be really interesting to see.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien McGlynn

I have a couple of things to add. There was a reference to the €7.5 million going into this arts and cultural hub. I am thinking that is great, let us cut the ribbon, but what is going to happen in ten or 20 years' time? There are a lot of these developments. As they progress, we get the Arts Council and local authority looking at each other and wondering who is going to manage and sustain this new wonderful facility. It just seems to happen time and time again that we will invest in new or refurbished spaces but we are not thinking about how they are going to be resourced. When I talk to people in the Arts Council, they are really frustrated. They feel there are new things being thrown at them and they are being told they need to keep them going now. They do not have the additional resources to do that. We know that everybody is stretched.

On commercialisation, we are based in Temple Bar. We can look at that as a case study of a cultural quarter that was developed in our capital city. There were posters and bunting up recently celebrating its 35th anniversary. That is obviously because the EU is in town, so there are EU flags everywhere and "Europe's budget" is on the bunting - a very exciting thing to celebrate. It is recognising that 35 years ago, there was this partnership, there was investment and there was a vision. They use that word a lot in what has been put out around the area. However, looking at Temple Bar now, does anybody think it is a successful cultural quarter? Is it thriving in the way that we thought it would be? I do not think so. It is thriving economically because of the commercial entities, the pubs that are making a fortune off tourists. I remember ten or 15 years ago when McDonald's first applied to move in to Temple Bar Square, into what was Frankie's Italian restaurant. People warned that once it moved in, that would spell the end what was already a precarious cultural quarter. The economic arguments and the market are dictating what is successful in that area. While there are still cultural organisations and venues there, those spaces have not been maintained. A lot of them are extremely dilapidated. Smock Alley was mentioned. There are serious issues there because it has not been looked after. So 35 years later we are putting up the bunting and saying it is great, but in those intervening years the investment really was not there. That is just one example of how this issue comes up time and time again.

There was discussion of provision within planning. We had the 5% rule that Dublin City Council brought in. I remember going to The Complex two years or so ago, when they did a big workshop on how this was going to work. There were massive questions about who was going to fund, operate and manage these spaces, even if a developer provides the 5% for community and cultural use. People from Germany were invited to present at that event, who stood up and showed us amazing things that had happened in Germany, but then said that could not happen here because we do not have the legislative infrastructure to do it. The very last moment in that event was when we went around the tables, hearing from everybody. The last table was a group of developers who just said it was never going to work and they were not going to do it - mic drop. That was the end. When the new coalition Government came in, one of the first things it did was try to veto that provision within Dublin City Council.

The provision is still there in the city strategy or plan. It is a difficult thing to implement but it still has all the same problems. It is well intentioned but it is not really thinking about how it is going to work long term.

Comment on this
Ms Vanessa Fielding

There are some really good ideas about how to progress relationship partnerships but they need to be homogenised into some kind of whole. People working in the sector have excellent ideas, but there is a discrepancy in what an arts organisation can pay. In other words, I will use us as an example. Unlike Ms Geoghegan, we had a big rent. We paid €120,000 a year and it increased to, I believe, €144,000 in the end. We thought that, with a slightly larger capacity and if we bought into this new development, we might be able to make €200,000 a year, which is enormous for an organisation that works in the arts but was a third of what the developer required. The response from the council was one of maybe we could do a guarantee and underwrite the other part of the rent for a period, but obviously the stretch was so great that we would never have made it. Then there was a whole series of suggested levies that could benefit the developer in different ways. I am saying this by way of example to show that there are people trying to create a way forward, but it needs to go into a statutory body.

I congratulate Senators on getting €6 million, if they fought hard for it. We are all very happy with that, but it is just far too small. The funding needs to be increased to €250 million, even if that sum would still be too small. We also need to have people in leadership who are interested in the arts and understand how to value it. It is not just how much rent we can pay.

Comment on this
Mr. Seosamh Ó Cathail

The non-Dublin context is very different. I am sorry if this is a big mental switchback and, possibly, a bit of a boring detailed point. I have outlined some points, including in my written submission, and will not recapitulate them. The term "meanwhile use" is one people will hear a lot and is written in all of the published documentation. I am open to correction, and we have a great relationship with Mayo County Council, which is as progressive as it can be, but I do not think it has any framework for dealing with "meanwhile use". It means we are in a negotiation where people really do not understand what either is talking about too much. We had to invent a legal instrument for this. A licence was drawn up by, I guess, the solicitors engaged by the county council and, as far as I know, there was no precedent. I am pretty sure that there was not because when we came to renew our licence, there were some questions. Many of the decision makers in the council were under the assumption that we had a lease, which they obviously did not like because if we had a lease, then they wondered whether it was permanent and would it be problematic to move us if the county council wanted the place for something else. I do not understand how it would work, but even something basic like a framework would allow councils to understand what it means when groups come to them. A council would then have a precedent or policy that it could fall back on to understand what steps to go through to give a group like ours "meanwhile use" of a building it owns, and even vet us or whatever one wants to call it. There is a big trust involved. It has worked out for us but I can understand how councils would have concerns. We had no relationship and Mayo County Council did not know who I was before I showed up and was introduced. The council is giving us a building and a lot of things can happen around that.

I will make another small point about "meanwhile use". As we have a licence and not a lease, it would be very hard for us to get capital funding. We do not to, given that we have a different philosophy, but if we did, we might as well forget about it. We could not do it because the first thing that we would be asked would be whether we had a lease. A "meanwhile use" is a fantastic concept but it is very nebulous in terms of how all of the various stakeholders, or whatever people want to call them, understand how a building can be brought back into use.

Obviously, this concept will not work for Dublin because of completely different numbers, but the committee might be able to help people in Drogheda, Ballina and other regional towns. I know Ballina, and there is loads of demand for space there. The council has loads of space, but there is no framework to deliver it in a way that is fast or comfortable for all of the parties. We had a licence and thought we were a great success, but when we went to renew it, the person who had introduced it had moved - someone else made this point, although I cannot remember who - and we met a completely new contact who did not know who we were. The official did not know we had a licence, what a licence was, etc. I do not know how practical stuff like that can be progressed, but that is practical feedback I can give the committee based on what is admittedly a much shorter experience than that of the other people who have given their testimonies today.

Comment on this
Mr. Darren O'Connor

We have outlined several elements in our statement and submission. Enacting the reformed co-operatives Bill would give another structure to community groups. Speaking about the bridging organisation, a lot of the work that we do is community-organised cultural space. Those communities should not have to become experts in property law or health and safety. Obviously, there are degrees to which they need to be educated, but this knowledge can be held in a different institution that can allow these groups to operate to a realistic standard. Equally, the Community Wealth Building (Scotland) Act mandates that the wealth that is being brought in through commercial development is maintained locally. That is an option from the commercial side. Community land trusts are mentioned within the Affordable Housing Act 2021 but it is only listed as something that local authorities can work with in the delivery of affordable housing. There is no legal definition of a community land trust within Irish law. There are many ways in which community land trusts can receive lands, for example, philanthropic donations or bequests, but they often require initial capital sums in order to make their first purchases. It is not that this money needs to be a payout. It can be a revolving fund that gets paid back in and then the next CLT can use the same money to make its initial purchase. A lot of bridging needs to happen.

Comment on this
Maria Byrne An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I am conscious that we have approximately half an hour left and two speakers. Senator Fitzpatrick has indicated next. I suggest that the Senators have 15 minutes each.

Comment on this

That will be more than enough time. I thank all of the witnesses for coming in today and, more importantly, for all of the great work that they have done for many years. I am a Dub and the arts enrich the city. The experiences outlined are funnily familiar. I served as a member of Dublin City Council and I know exactly what Ms Geoghegan talked about when she mentioned Brendan Kenny. Mr. Ó Cathail mentioned how an agreement could be reached with one official but then that official would move on. Many people have had that feeling after having a great agreement with Brendan Kenny. He is a man who could make decisions, think outside the box and be creative, and always with good intent.

However, the situation is just not working. I am not a member of this committee. I am substituting today for Fiona O'Loughlin who, unfortunately, is unable to attend, but I am delighted to attend. Twenty years ago, I met Ms Fielding on Benburb Street. This city has changed. I grew up in Stoneybatter with a white homogenous Irish population. It was a village - there was no Tesco, Lidl or anything like that. Our city and world may have changed but the capacity of humans to escape normality in day-to-day life is through art.

It is a huge escape not just for the artist but for everybody else who gets to appreciate their art and creativity. Its value is enormous for humanity and for our society and country.

I would like to see the committee make strong recommendations at a policy level. Ms Fielding called out the numbers from the budget. They say it all. They really do because if you follow the money, you can see where the emphasis and the priority are. It is not to say that we do not support sport and other cultural activities but we need a rebalancing. This committee needs to make strong recommendations for a significant rebalancing with respect to funding. It also needs to make strong recommendations around policy direction from a high level. We have been truly around the houses, and I am not just talking about this House, Government Buildings and City Hall. It is circular. The witnesses have had it in Limerick and Mayo. This is happening all around the country. I do not think any of us minds doing due diligence and being responsible. It is public property held in trust by local authorities but there has to be a point at which officials are encouraged to be braver and to make a decision. The only way they will be brave enough to do that is if it is the policy objective, so it has to be a strong policy objective.

Ms Fielding is right about the meanwhile use. Dublin City Council gives licences for crèches and all sorts of facilities in the city but the meanwhile use is not properly legally defined. It is more of a policy statement and that needs to be corrected. The GPO is going to be made available. It will be advertised and there will be expressions of interest. That is great and I think there could be three to five years of meanwhile use there. It is not just the facade that you see at the front; it is an enormous space. It is important that that meanwhile use happens promptly. The OPW has the property now and I think this committee has an opportunity to put the pressure on to encourage an energy around that process and prove that what is probably the most iconic building in the country is not going to be vacant and is going to be animated and occupied. Culture and art need to go in there. This committee can play a strong role in dealing with that.

All of the other issues are valid and really well articulated in these opening statements, and the statements the committee has received from the other witnesses, on sustainable financing. There are a lot of good intentions, such as the 5% in the city development plan. Each local authority has a county or city development plan and they are now going to be ten-year plans. They are moving from, historically, being shorter or around five years. They are good but if the direction does not come from the Department and the Minister, we are not going to start to see anything like the catch-up that is needed. I do not think we can afford to lose any more spaces. We really cannot. The loss of The Complex in Dublin city is enormous. I am not talking about locally; I am talking in a cultural and artistic sense. That is a cost to the value of the city. We do not want to be some homogenous, bland repeat. We need our arts to be right at the heart of the city.

I thank the Leas-Chathaoirleach for allowing me to participate today and I encourage the committee to make strong strategic and operational recommendations that will lead us, recognising the deficit we have, in a policy direction that local authorities and Government Departments can adopt. That can then enable people who are creative in nature and bursting with talent and a desire to share that in their communities to just go and do it. That is it.

Comment on this
Maria Byrne An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Would anybody like to contribute on Senator Fitzpatrick's comments?

Comment on this
Ms Vanessa Fielding

I am delighted to hear Senator Fitzpatrick mention meanwhile use. I would suggest that, a lot of times, meanwhile use is considered impractical because buildings that local authorities, the Government or the OPW own are maybe considered not fit for purpose. They require investment but also project management. I know because I have done it a lot. It is perfectly possible to divert that to the artist themselves. There is a statutory requirement to reach a certain level of compliance. It is not that anyone is going to try to do it on the cheap or on the sly and not really achieve it because of the certification you have to get to be able to open. We are perfectly able to do that, probably at a lower cost and speedier. It is one of the bigger hurdles in making meanwhile use accessible.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Geoghegan

There is an irony in Mr. Kenny introducing us to Glasnevin because the city council could not give us a space. There is also another irony at play at the moment in Inchicore where we are getting a new community hub and library but there is an empty library sitting on Emmet Road. I think it is the Carnegie library, which is a beautiful old library. It is sitting there and has not been used for at least six or seven years. It could have been used but the city council wants rent. It wants €15,000, which is too much money. There are lots of spaces. I refer to that model Mr. Ó Cathail was talking about in Ballina where the local county council has this space and enters into an arrangement. We could not even get to that here in Dublin with the city council because it wants you to pay a huge amount of rent.

The same is happening at the moment with the Goldenbridge Integrated Complex, which is the former Goldenbridge Convent. There are so many rooms there. I know an artists' collective in the area that would love to get their hands on that building. I am encouraging them to try and get their hands on that building. They cannot maintain and run that building. It is an old convent but it belongs to the city council. It was handed over to the city council. The only way you can shift that is if you have some kind of policy that drives that and says city and county councils that have these empty buildings need to do something with them because they are just going to fall into disrepair. It would create a more dynamic neighbourhood, county or town. It is not okay for a city or county council to hoard empty buildings. That needs to shift and change because there are plenty out there who want to use those spaces.

Comment on this
Mr. Mícheál Keating

I mentioned meanwhile use in my opening statement. It is really important that the tools are there for councils but also for landlords. In Limerick, Limerick City and County Council does not own all the vacant buildings. There are a lot of landlords who have no incentive to accommodate artists who are actively looking for spaces. We need a template that could easily make meanwhile use doable and practical and protect artists, because it is very hard to create work and do projects if you could be turfed out at short notice.

We had a programme in Limerick before I was active. It was in 2014. It was called Creative Limerick. There was a kind of peppercorn rent situation where there were a lot of buildings used for meanwhile use and doing fantastic things. However, speaking to people who were active at the time, they did not know if they were still going to be there in a few months.

It is very important that the security of the tenancy be clear cut for our artists and arts organisations so that they know where they stand. If artists are to be used to redevelop an area of the city and the developer wants to send the building on for commercial reasons when the area and building are in better use, then artists need to be able to move somewhere else rather than just left without a space. "Meanwhile use" is great, but it only caters for a very small portion of what we need for art spaces. There need to be long-term leases and some way of incentivising them. There also need to be permanent spaces. Council-owned buildings may be the ones to look for in that regard.

Those are my two cents on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien McGlynn

Thinking about the budget and investment, I am neither a politician nor a tax expert - I do not ever want to be either - but watching the press conference with the Minister for arts yesterday, there was a lot of defence along the lines of this being what he had been given and how he had to work within it. We all understand that, but there are comparisons with other sectors. It is not just the current funding from the Exchequer that is given to agencies like the Arts Council. There are other tax mechanisms that incentivise things, including capital. I do not understand those things but I like to read a blog by a consultant called Dan O'Brien who is much better on the economics of these things and has broken them down quite well. I recommend looking at that or speaking to him about this at some stage because he seems to get into the nitty-gritty of it.

There are other mechanisms out there. We cannot keep accepting this argument that there is not enough to go around, that we have to give X to health and education, and things like that. As Ms Geoghegan said at the beginning, we are still dealing with the fallout of the cuts that happened in 2008, 2009 and 2010 across not just the arts, but also community, youth, education, etc. We are now seeing those impacts socially, and all we are doing at present is continuing to bed in problems for the future because we are not backing the infrastructure.

The Minister kept using the good news story of the basic income yesterday in the press conference. We are all fairly united in thinking the basic income is a good thing. It is helping to alleviate the drastic levels of poverty and precarity that came through in the Department's own research among artists so that they can live with more dignity. However, if we are not investing in the infrastructure - as Mr. O'Connor said, it is about people and organisations, not just buildings - then we are not setting them up to have viable, long-term careers as artists because there will be no supports, opportunities or spaces. We are helping them with an income supplement for three years, then they are off it for three years and then back on it again. That is how it is currently being proposed, so there is a huge gap there. We are saying we are supporting artists but are they really artists if-----

Comment on this

If they cannot practise.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien McGlynn

-----the opportunities and the things that they need are not there? There is something about getting into that "everybody needs their slice of the pie" idea. For me, it is not a failure of policy; it becomes a failure of humanity if we do not see why we should be strategically investing in this for the future.

Comment on this

When Mr. McGlynn was speaking, it struck me that this was something I had mentioned before. The changes to the capital gains tax were €186 million. I have seen almost no evidence of why that has come in, yet we have seen piles of evidence over decades, and painstakingly so, of the social, cultural and economic benefits of investment of any and every kind in the arts. The case-making is huge, but then you have these very big decisions. It is not just the arts versus health. There is also the arts versus capital gains tax waivers.

It was mentioned that the infrastructure was about organisations and space. That is part of it and is what makes it viable. In the performing arts, which are probably an area I have been involved in, having multiple venues artists could go to around the country was what made it viable. Someone could have a tour and be in seven different venues over two months. We do not do Broadway-style runs in Ireland. These are the kinds of thing that give the person who is rightly being supported in their income and artistic practice the spaces for exchange and action, which is part of all this.

It is an interesting matter. In a previous chapter of my life, I was part of an arts collective in New York for a long time. During my time, it was the Flux Factory. It has connection to FLUX Studios on Chatham Row, which is a very interesting model of what happens when you have a proper space. We were in two different spaces during my time. Now, it is considered a cultural institution because it is 30 years old, but we were in an old factory in my time. Then, we converted an office building. After my time, there was a hard year where everyone was just on a bus. This was finally followed by acquiring and moving into a permanent space. It is very important to acquire a permanent space. You can see it in those who have described The Lodge when they were able to be there. When you have a space where you can breathe, think or invest in a dance floor, for example, or a proper hanging space for art with working lights, you can make something that works.

I was also struck by Create and Common Ground in particular on the "who is it for" piece, through which we get meaningful community connection. If art is part of what we want for our communities, and we want that cultural connection and participation, it is important that they not see that artists in a building might be turfed out at any point. Instead, people should be able to grow up seeing these cultural spaces where the community's ideas come to fruition. I would be interested in talking about how important space is, not just for the artists and art, but for making that kind of meaningful community connection to culture.

I want to talk about some of the very specific things mentioned regarding anchoring this. I was glad to see some push-back on the dangerous and excessive reliance on the private partnership and the control that can have. It is an insecurity in terms of how long an artist gets to be there under the lease. It is an insecurity in terms of what they can say or do.

The 5% rule is an exciting one and would be good to see happen. It is interesting to see the developer push-back on it. However, while this should be happening, we also should not depend on building things and just sticking the arts in or finding empty spaces and then putting in the arts. "Meanwhile use" is great for public buildings and using spaces, but the witnesses might talk about how the arts need to be built into our development plans. When a new development is being proposed, what does it do for the arts and cultural practice in this area? It should not just be about giving a percentage. I would be interested in the planning for the arts piece.

As to the importance of using public buildings, I like the public "meanwhile use" option instead of the private temporary use because at least there can be an ongoing conversation about building in the journey from a "meanwhile use" to a permanent space and home for something that serves the community.

The witnesses also mentioned community wealth building and the co-operative societies Bill. That legislation is coming through. What should we be doing to ensure that the Bill serves arts organisations in a meaningful way and that it works for them?

The community land trust legislation was mentioned as an instrument that was not used properly for the arts. How could we specifically strengthen that in legislation? I would like to see those proposals.

That is enough for now.

I am interested in development planning, in planning for the arts and in the meanwhile use of public buildings as a route through to an long-term arrangement. It may or may not be in that meanwhile location. During the meanwhile period, it becomes a conversation. I have also asked about what can be done with regard to the community trust legislation and the co-operative societies Bill. I also ask the witnesses to comment on the importance of anchoring for the community.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán Geoghegan

From Common Ground's point of view, when we started we had no building. We thought we were good because we did not have to have a building and could work in different spaces in the community. When the recession hit, it was a different reality. We had the Studio 468 model because of practices that had happened in the Rialto and Inchicore area. That was a very particular time in the nineties and there was a very different funding framework at that time. It allowed that activism and the growth of arts and cultural work in communities to be solidified in the community centre in St. Andrew's. We were able to win funds to make a capital contribution to the building of that space. We remained outside and managed that space, but we were still an independent organisation. We shared the space with the youth project when we started. When the recession hit, I and the board realised that we needed somewhere and that is why we pursued The Lodge beside Goldenbridge.

That model could almost be seen as an organisation of artists going into a building on a very vulnerable site in a complex area - Senator Higgins knows the area. We are in a building in a neighbourhood with a lot of difficulties, but we persevered and stayed there, and we are still there. We still work with local groups to make sure we have a presence and we work with them. This year, we cooked 300 burgers on a family fun day. We do other things in order to be seen and visible in communities as an organisation. We work with others so that we can make other things happen, such as at Halloween. We are able to ask people to engage and meet artists who are coming from Australia next week to create a community space. We are constantly trying to diversify and build on how people can engage locally. That does not happen overnight. It takes years and months of planning.

Those are the things that we know. That has been our experience. It may be very different for other organisations. I have a fear around the term "meanwhile use" because we were in meanwhile use spaces. Everything was meanwhile until we found something. I think of how meanwhile became a big thing during the recession, like Granby Park and other temporary spaces which were built on the back of artists' free labour. I do not think that is okay. We need to examine how we do other things that allow for the use of empty spaces. There are empty shops and developments around the country. There are ghost estates and places that have been left vacant for years.

I am very fearful about the development of the site beside where we are currently located. Some 568 units are going in and there is a new cost rental model. I am concerned that there will be a lot of commercial units in the development because the terms for those units have not yet been written. We are going into a space and asking who can apply for those spaces. Can social enterprises apply for those units? That has not yet been agreed. Local authorities holding back on how and which organisations can access those spaces is unsettling.

Comment on this
Maria Byrne An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I am sorry to interrupt, but I am conscious that I have to get everyone else in. We are running out of time. I ask everyone to be brief. I am sorry. We are against the clock.

Comment on this
Mr. Darren O'Connor

I echo some of the points on meanwhile use. We have run Test Site for six years and it is now ending. People think it is very sad, but it was always meant to be a temporary thing and that is why meanwhile use works for us. The issue is when arts organisations are shown meanwhile use as their only option. It is one option.

As we said, it is very difficult to invest when one does not have guaranteed tenure. Community land trusts offer a way forward that is beside meanwhile use. It is different option. Community land trusts operate on the basis of removing the land from the for-profit market. Land is held in trust and structures can then be leased. This offers organisations the opportunity to move from short-term caretaker leases to 99-year leases which means organisations can invest in things like dancefloors, soundproofing and other things one cannot do when one is always moving from space to space.

Artists in Ireland are experiencing more than one crisis. It is not just a lack of infrastructure but also a lack of housing. Community land trusts offer the opportunity to co-locate housing and work or performance spaces. They can even be used to subsidise each other. There are examples of this. There is an art space trust in Berkeley in California. Such spaces allow for artists to have a say in how assets are managed. Community land trusts operate on a tripartite governance system. The users make up a third, civil society makes up a third and local authorities or public bodies make up the last third. This not only allows for the artists' needs to be heard and met for today, but also ensures that the needs of artists in the future are safeguarded rather than only addressing immediate needs. Community land trusts offer an opportunity to move out of a cyclical meanwhile use. Temporary projects have existed and should exist. The arts are being shoved into them, with an attitude of doing something for now. Other options for longer term use are needed.

Comment on this
Maria Byrne An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Great. Thank you.

Comment on this
Ms Vanessa Fielding

The Complex was in a series of meanwhile use buildings and there was no trajectory or somebody to talk to about converting buildings to a permanent space. Everybody was pushed from pillar to post. The Department of culture said it did not do acquisitions because it was not mandated to so do. The Arts Council was not mandated to do it. Who does that work?

I would have said we grew over 18 years to the point where we were ready for a permanent home. We could not be less of a risk. We were everything an organisation could possibly be. We employed a lot of people and engaged with the community, which is another conversation for which we do not have time. The organisation was everything one would want, yet there was nobody to talk to. The State eventually decided it could not invest in the project because it did not know how to. There are examples from the UK like the Creative Land Trust. It has buy-in from government, through its arts council and lottery. We do not have that mechanism and cannot do that. That kind of thing could not exist here because we are missing that bit. I am sure there are mechanisms and people can think of ideas for how to get around that. It seems to be a problem which could be addressed in what we have all said is a new policy.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien McGlynn

I want to recognise that all community infrastructure is cultural infrastructure. Ms Geoghegan has spoken about that in her context. We support work all over the country. Artists working with communities are often looking for space to gather. We have had a decades-long erosion of community third spaces where people can gather. Those spaces do not exist. In a press conference yesterday, when he was talking about the culture card idea, the Minister said that if we want to get kids off phones we have to offer them something else. It seemed that the solution was very much on the audience side, but there are three parts to that.

You have to support the artists, the audience and the infrastructure. The infrastructure we are talking about today feels like it is lacking. There is a huge number of issues why certain young people may not be able to access culture - not just a €100 voucher - that have not been addressed. There may be something in that. The point was made about how we get this more strategic. I refer to the Dublin City Council development plan. It will say all these great things in the plan about meanwhile use and all that, but we still lost The Complex, D-Light Studios, Ormond Art Studios and Broadstone Studios. Everything is disappearing and they are not being replaced.

Comment on this
Maria Byrne An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I am sorry to interrupt Mr. McGlynn, but I want to see if Mr. Ó Cathail or Mr. Keating want to give a final statement. They have indicated that they do not. I thank the witnesses for coming in and for their contributions. I reiterate and pass on Senator Black's apologies. She is the rapporteur for the report. Many Senators sit on the committee, but she will be reading all the responses.

Comment on this

I know we ran out of time, but there was a question about the co-operative Bill and the specific suggestions on that. Two or three people mentioned it. That legislation will be coming through very soon. If people have any supplementary points in relation to that, they should pass them on and they might be reflected in the report specifically on the co-operative Bill. I know the NCF Collective looked at those different structures and models. I know we have not had time to hear back from them on that.

Comment on this
Maria Byrne An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We will be formulating a report. Witnesses will be informed and sent a copy of the report. We will be in touch with the witnesses again. Their submissions and oral answers will be considered when the report is being formulated. We are in the third meeting of a four-meeting process. I thank the witnesses again for their contributions and for taking the time to come from across the country and from Dublin to be here. We will be looking at everything.

Comment on this