Culture and Arts Infrastructure: Discussion (Resumed)
Local authorities and the Arts Council described shortages of affordable artist workspaces, community facilities and performance venues, alongside ageing buildings and inadequate operational funding. Witnesses called for a coordinated national strategy, sustained capital investment matched by revenue support, better cross-departmental planning and cultural space integrated into housing and regeneration projects. The Arts Council said it would begin a national infrastructure audit, while highlighting a new €6 million pilot grant scheme and growing cooperation with local authorities. Senator McDowell urged a dedicated Departmental team to lead major projects, citing the loss of Dublin arts venues and the need to restore Rathmines Town Hall’s auditorium.
I thank the witnesses for coming. I know many of them have travelled from down the country and some of them are based in Dublin, as are the Seanadóirí. I welcome Senators, witnesses and visitors to this fourth public hearing of the Seanad Public Consultation Committee on the topic of culture and arts infrastructure. These public meetings are the next part of a process which began in February this year with a public call for written submissions to the committee. Submissions were received from individuals, interest groups and organisations across Ireland. After reviewing the submissions, the committee divided them into four core themes: artists and practitioners; community and voluntary groups; interesting models; and local authorities and State bodies. This meeting is an engagement under the fourth theme of local authorities and State bodies.
The committee previously met with artists and practitioners on 22 September, with community and voluntary groups on 1 October and on those with interesting models on 8 October. On behalf of the committee, I again sincerely thank those who sent in submissions and engaged on the topic to date. All submissions have been considered by the committee members and will contribute to the committee's final report.
On behalf of the committee I welcome our witnesses to the Seanad today. Ms Stephanie O'Callaghan, performing arts director and Ms Sinéad O'Reilly, combined arts director, are representing the Arts Council. Ms Karen Burke is the town regeneration officer at Limerick City and County Council. Ms Nicola Gilcreest, arts officer and Ms Jackie Finney, director of services are joining us from Westmeath County Council.
From Leitrim County Council, we have arts officer Mr. Philip Delamere. Last but not least is Senator Michael McDowell, joined by Mr. Pat Wallace, former director of the National Museum. I thank the witnesses for engaging with the committee in its consideration of this important topic. Each organisation will have a maximum of five minutes, there or thereabouts, for its opening statement. We will then have a general question-and-answer session.
Senator Black is our rapporteur on this subject. She came up with the subject and received the unanimous support of the committee to cover it.
Comment on this
I offer a huge, warm welcome to our witnesses. I am delighted they have all been able to join us. I know some of them have travelled a good distance to be here. There is no doubt the support offered by local authorities and the Arts Council is invaluable to cultural and arts communities. It is vital. Their front-line work provides critical funding and infrastructure and keeps many artistic and cultural endeavours alive. I read all the submissions and they really show the expertise and knowledge the witnesses have in this area. I look forward to hearing them today.
I have probably said this at every one of these Seanad Public Consultation Committee meetings of the last three weeks but, in relation to my experience of the arts, music has been a central part of my life. Since I was a very small child, I have been in rooms where songs have been shared. I am still amazed at the power of music to connect us and to bring us together and into the present. It is food for the soul and makes us feel that human connection. However, its force is utterly dependent on having physical spaces where those experiences can be shared.
It is not only music, and we all know that. The spaces for all practices of art and culture across the board are dwindling, and that is a huge concern. The spaces we have face greater challenges to their continued operation. There are hardly any opportunities for the establishment of new spaces and there is a desperate need among cultural communities for greater provisions and protections. Those moments of cultural connection cannot happen if there are no rooms for them to happen in. Art and culture need space, not just to thrive but to survive. Arts communities need reliable and sustainable access to space. Without that security, as we have heard over the last few weeks, cultural organisations and practitioners are terribly inhibited by precarity in what they can achieve and they cannot plan for the long term, build for the future or grow. That is really worrying.
I have spoken in recent weeks of how important cultural communities are in building a resilient social fabric and how increasingly challenging it is for cultural organisers to bring people together in the age of social media. People are glued, unfortunately, to screens and stuck at home rather than going out to a gig, show or other cultural event. The companies running those platforms are competing for the same attention that cultural organisations and organisers are. This, coupled with limited access to infrastructure, makes the challenges they face all the harder. The Government has to recognise these challenges with meaningful and impactful policy proposals. While increased in-person cultural activity will not solve all our problems, there is a profound power in bringing people together in a space to share a cultural experience in the increasingly lonely and isolated society we live in. It is so important.
I hope the committee can and will produce useful policy proposals informed by the lived experience of those on the ground. I am excited to hear the perspectives of those here today. It will be highly informative for us to hear of their experiences in the provision of supports for cultural communities across the country, not only in our cities but also in rural Ireland. I hope our report, informed by what the witnesses contribute today, can begin to address the desperate situation many arts communities find themselves in regarding accessing cultural infrastructure. I thank the witnesses for coming in today.
Comment on this
Before I call the first witness, I must draw the attention of all witnesses to the matter of privilege. The evidence of witnesses physically present in the Seanad Chamber is protected by absolute privilege, pursuant to the Constitution and statute. This means they have an absolute defence against any defamation action in legal proceedings for anything they say in evidence to the committee. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege and it is my duty as Chair to ensure it is not abused. Witnesses should note that only evidence connected with the subject matter of the meeting should be given.
Witnesses and members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be considered as damaging to the good name of a person or entity. If their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks and must do so. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
I move on to our first witness, Ms O'Callaghan of the Arts Council.
Comment on this
I was going to say my feet are firmly on the ground but they are not, actually. I am too short.
Good afternoon, Cathaoirleach and Senators. I am creative arts director at An Chomhairle Ealaíon. I am joined by my colleague, Ms O’Reilly, combined arts director. I thank the committee for the opportunity to attend. We are delighted this is firmly on the political agenda. The Arts Council is the national Government agency for funding, developing and promoting the arts in Ireland. Our role is to advise, invest and work in partnership with others to cultivate a vibrant arts environment at the heart of Irish society.
I will bring members back to a recent hearing on arts infrastructure at the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Arts, Media, Communications, Culture and Sport, which included many of the people speaking here today. There was consensus in the room on the need for a long-term arts infrastructure strategy. There was, and still is, a shared energy and momentum on the need for this and the need to act.
In April of this year, the Arts Council made a submission to this committee which outlined our evidence and insights regarding this need for strategic planning on arts infrastructure. We highlighted evidence relating to artist workspaces, public-facing arts venues and community and place relevance. The submission set out opportunities for meeting the challenges, including capital investment, needs assessment research and the development of a national arts infrastructure strategy.
We believe there is a rising positive momentum in arts and culture infrastructure, not least evidenced by this hearing and those of the previous weeks. In the past few months, three points illustrate positive progress. On 1 October, the arts infrastructure investment pilot scheme opened, launched by the Minister for Culture, Communications and Sport, Deputy O'Donovan. This €6 million fund will support arts and culture facilities and organisations to purchase equipment and undertake refurbishment works, including climate adaptation, health and safety upgrades and works to provide universal access. It will also support community and voluntary groups. The Minister has been clear that this is a pilot and one he expects to be oversubscribed. We share the Minister's ambition for the expansion of the scheme in years to come. Second, we at the Arts Council have made progress with the Department on shared research relating to arts infrastructure. While we have good research already, we want to ensure we have the necessary up-to-date data to understand what is needed to progress further. Finally, the Arts Council and the County and City Management Association have identified, through our current work to update our framework agreement, an emerging shared priority of arts and culture infrastructure.
I have to emphasise that the momentum is there because of the significant need. The Arts Council is acutely aware of that through our research and insights and, crucially, through our ongoing engagement with the sector. We know, as members do and as was evidenced in the sessions over the past four weeks, that there is a crucial need and the sector is crying out for it. The momentum has been hard earned and we want to see it continue.
We look forward to collaborating with our Department, local authorities, sectoral colleagues and the committee to make progress on this issue. Success here will be critical to the continued development of the arts sector and to ensure a positive impact on audiences, artists, and arts practitioners alike.
Comment on this
I thank Ms O'Callaghan very much. I call Ms Burke on behalf of Limerick City and County Council.
Comment on this
I thank the committee very much for the opportunity to contribute to this discussion on the arts infrastructure and from the national perspective to the local perspective in Limerick.
Limerick City and County Council has demonstrated a commitment to investing in culture through supporting venues and facilities, such as Limerick City Gallery of Art, Limerick Museum, the Belltable, University Concert Hall, rural venues and through some artist studios and artist accommodation initiatives. These investments have established and sustained Limerick as a place where creativity can thrive. Alongside these facilities, it is important to recognise the work of local arts organisations, voluntary groups, community theatres, amateur performance groups and individual artists. Through the arts office and other support mechanisms, the council sustains a broad range of cultural activity at grassroots level. We are grateful for the support provided through the Arts Council and national funding programmes, but it must also be acknowledged that funding remains fragmented, limited in scale and often insufficient to address both capital investment needs and ongoing operational costs. There is a growing gap between policy aspirations and resources available to deliver on them.
The need to develop multi-purpose, flexible space for the arts and cultural sector in Limerick for creation, production and presentation is critical to the viability of the sector. A wide range of spaces are required, but they must be appropriate to the needs of the different creative practitioners and art forms and their varied stages of production, accessibility and sustainability. A particular concern is the shortage of artist workspaces and creative production facilities. This issue is becoming increasingly concerning when we consider the number of graduates emerging from the Limerick School of Art and Design, the Technological University of the Shannon and the University of Limerick.
Limerick City and County Council provides a small number of artist studios in the city at James Street. This illustrates the value for a relatively modest investment in creative production space. Over many years, these studios have supported artists who remain in Limerick, develop professional careers and contribute to the city's cultural reputation. The demand for these spaces consistently exceeds availability. While Limerick city has a small number of established studios, provision across rural Limerick is extremely limited with a small number located in Cappamore. These accommodate writers and performers. Our festivals continue to flourish across rural Limerick, often working from community spaces rather than purpose-built facilities. Newcastle West provides a clear example of both need and opportunity as Limerick's largest county town. The town hosts the annual Éigse Michael Hartnett Literary and Arts Festival and attracts leading writers, poets and artists. It has become a significant cultural event in the region, yet it has no dedicated arts or cultural centre.
It is equally important to address the condition of existing infrastructure. Many cultural facilities are operating in historical or protected buildings. Ageing facilities require significant upgrades regarding accessibility, energy efficiency, digital capacity and environmental performance. We welcome the publication of funding opportunities earlier this year. It is important to think about arts infrastructure quite broadly. Investment should not be confined solely to public-facing venues but also behind-the-scenes infrastructure that allows creative activity to flourish. Given the high operation costs associated with stand-alone cultural venues, there are significant benefits in creating multi-use spaces and combining performance areas, artist studios, rehearsal spaces, community facilities and educational activity under one roof. This approach increases utilisation, strengthens community engagement and improves long-term sustainability.
The recommendations emerging from our submission earlier and outlined today include a co-ordinated national strategy for arts and cultural infrastructure; a dedicated multi-annual capital investment programme for arts that reflects the scale and ambition of the existing investment mechanisms available in other sectors; greater investment in artist studios, creative workspaces and youth arts infrastructure; and dedicated resources for cultural needs assessments. Ideally, consideration should be given to developing a policy around provision of cultural spaces within large housing or community developments, where private developers may be required to deliver a specific floor space for cultural activity.
Arts and cultural infrastructure is not simply about buildings. It is about creating places where people can gather, learn, create, perform, connect and belong. It is about strengthening communities, supporting economic development, nurturing talent and fostering well-being. It is about ensuring our cities, communities, towns and rural communities have the opportunity to thrive culturally. With sustained investment and a coherent national approach, we can build a stronger inclusive cultural landscape.
Comment on this
Good afternoon. I am the director of services for Westmeath County Council. I have responsibility for community development, libraries, arts and the municipal district of Athlone-Moate. I thank the members for the opportunity to address them in my capacity as director of services. I am accompanied by Ms Gilcreest who is the arts officer for County Westmeath.
The submission from Westmeath County Council reflects the local authority perspective on arts infrastructure. It draws on the experience of Westmeath County Council's arts office, on written contributions from artists and arts workers in County Westmeath and on our interactions with communities and local groups across the county. Westmeath County Council is mandated to deliver a diverse range of functions and services, including economic development, community development, physical and social infrastructure, recreation and amenity, planning and environment. The representative structure of the council consists of 20 elected members from the two municipal districts of Mullingar-Kinnegad and Athlone-Moate. The council is assisted in policy development by four strategic policy committees, including the housing, community, recreation and culture strategic policy committee.
Westmeath County Council supports the development of arts and culture through a range of strategic policies, including our spatial planning policies, public art policy, arts development plan, which is in development, support for venues and developmental and financial support for artists and creative industries within the county. Westmeath arts office co-ordinates the investment of public money in the arts on behalf of the council, funding a wide range of activities. The arts office provides support for the professional, voluntary, community and amateur arts sectors. The office also provides guidance and support to communities on the development of arts and culture opportunities in their communities with the aim of improving equality of access and wider public engagement in the arts. Westmeath County Council provides significant financial support to the development of arts and culture in Westmeath through the council’s arts development funding and administration of the Arts Council and Creative Ireland funding to the value of €1.9 million. In 2026, financial support totalling €1.5 million was directed towards existing venues. We are very grateful for the support we have received from our partner agencies.
Westmeath is a county rich in arts, music and culture. The two large urban centres of Athlone and Mullingar, each with populations in excess of 22,000, are home to a number of important cultural venues. These include the Luan Gallery - the municipal art gallery - and the Dean Crowe Theatre in Athlone, the Mullingar Arts Centre, and Áras an Mhuilinn, which is the regional base for Comhaltas Ceoltóirí Éireann in Mullingar. The creative life of the county is widely distributed across the smaller towns and villages, with Tuar Ard Arts and Enterprise Centre in Moate and the outdoor art trail at Dún na Sí. Cultural activities are also supported across the network of library and community spaces in towns and villages throughout the county.
Westmeath County Council's submission outlined the following challenges. There is strong evidence of a growing demand for arts infrastructure such as spaces for production, presentation, studios, creative businesses and participation in arts.
Equally, there is a need for community arts facilities, particularly shared community spaces where artists can collaborate and engage with communities. Creative practitioner workspaces for creation, production and presentation of creative work are required across the varying disciplines. The visual arts infrastructure is limited, particularly in terms of artist workspaces and showcasing visual arts. The Abbey Road Artists' Studios in Athlone provide a valuable support to artists. However, spaces are limited - there are just four studio spaces - and the development of studio spaces for visual artists in other areas of the county is necessary. Dance infrastructure, as in dedicated dance space, is underdeveloped. Good quality spaces for young people to engage in the arts are limited.
The submission highlighted the emerging need for the development of arts festival infrastructure, including spaces for physical production, storage, rehearsal and delivery. The community arts sector in Westmeath is vibrant and growing. However, it is also a sector that remains under-resourced in physical infrastructure, largely relying on temporary, unsuitable or oversubscribed spaces. There is also a clear demand for the development of existing and principal arts venues in the county.
As part of the consultation for this submission, the views expressed by independent artists highlighted the challenge for the independent arts sector to develop the necessary infrastructure. These challenges include high construction and refurbishment costs, scarcity of adaptable buildings and competition with commercial development.
The submission focused on the following policy changes that we believe need to be made to public policy. They are: the development of a sustained, co-ordinated investment in artist spaces, community facilities, visual arts infrastructure and festivals infrastructure; the integration of arts infrastructure into housing and urban development; enhanced support for cross-county and shared island opportunities through joint funding initiatives; investment in digital infrastructure, hybrid production and retrofitting cultural buildings to meet climate and energy targets with targeted supports; the development of cultural hubs in underserved areas and investment in mid-scale venues; capital grants for building improvement works, such as the installation of accessible bathrooms and changing places for public use and energy upgrades; and expanding smaller capital grants for community arts spaces. I previously mentioned the importance of festivals in the county, which has been growing in recent years. Festivals must be considered as essential arts infrastructure and it is important that supports are provided for their development and growth.
Local authorities are key to the provision of support for arts and cultural development, both in terms of our policy support for infrastructure development and in terms of reach within our communities for broader public engagement and access to arts and culture. In Westmeath County Council we stand ready to work with the committee, the Department of Culture, Communications and Sport, and all stakeholders to develop sustainable solutions that ensure artists, creative practitioners and the public in Westmeath have access to arts and cultural spaces into the future.
Comment on this
Gabhaim buíochas le Ms Finney. I will move on to Mr. Delamere from Leitrim County Council.
Comment on this
I thank the Chair and members of the committee for the opportunity to make this presentation on behalf of Leitrim County Council. Leitrim County Council recognises the vital role the arts play in supporting vibrant communities, enhancing quality of life and contributing to social, cultural and economic development. As a local authority, we have invested significantly over many years in our cultural infrastructure. The redevelopment of The Dock in Carrick-on-Shannon in 2005 transformed a former courthouse into one of the most active cultural venues in the north west. We support the Leitrim Sculpture Centre, which provides a wide array of specialist facilities for artists to create work, and we work with the Glens Centre, the Island Theatre and the Corn Mill Theatre to support community engagement with the arts. More recently, we redeveloped a former secondary school in Ballinamore as the Junction, which comprises an arts education facility, a youth centre and an enterprise hub, and we are currently developing a new community and youth arts facility in Carrick-on-Shannon, purchased through the building acquisition measure and redeveloped under the town and village renewal scheme and the PEACEPLUS programme.
Discussions on arts infrastructure can be framed around two distinct but interconnected requirements, namely, spaces in which art is created and spaces in which art is experienced. First, there is an urgent need for affordable and appropriate creative workspaces. Across Ireland, artists are facing increasing difficulties in securing studios, rehearsal spaces and production facilities. Rising property and rental costs have reduced the availability of suitable spaces and have created significant barriers to artistic practice. At the same time, many towns continue to contain vacant and under-utilised buildings. There is considerable potential to bring these properties back into productive use as creative workspaces, which would support artistic development while also contributing to wider policy objectives around town centre regeneration and sustainable development.
Annual arts-specific infrastructure programmes are crucial in this regard, in particular in relation to the upgrading of existing facilities, enhancing access and energy efficiency. However, other Government initiatives, such as the building acquisition measure and the town and village renewal scheme, also provide a valuable opportunity. More explicit recognition and promotion of cultural uses within these schemes would likely encourage greater take-up. It should also be noted that some schemes designed specifically to address the lack of cultural infrastructure often do not reflect the true costs associated with acquiring, adapting and maintaining buildings for arts purposes. More ambitious investment levels and more favourable match-funding requirements would enable these schemes to have a more meaningful impact.
It is also important to recognise that artists have diverse infrastructure needs. The requirements of a sculptor, dancer, musician or a circus performer vary considerably. Future policy must therefore be sufficiently flexible to accommodate a broad range of artistic practices while ensuring accessibility, sustainability and climate resilience.
The second area requiring attention is the provision of high-quality presentation and engagement spaces. Arts centres, theatres and galleries are not just buildings; they are specialist cultural facilities that provide professional expertise, technical resources, curated programmes and carefully planned opportunities for public participation. They connect artists with audiences and ensure that communities are able to engage with high-quality cultural experiences.
A key lesson from our experience is that capital investment, while lacking, is the easy bit. New or refurbished facilities represent an important investment, but they must be matched by sustainable operational funding, which has not kept pace with increasing costs for many years. Staffing, programming, maintenance, technical support and audience development all require ongoing resources, as without adequate revenue funding even the most impressive capital projects will not reach their potential. Separately, it may sometimes be appropriate to consider how facilities developed for other purposes can, through thoughtful design and planning, provide valuable opportunities to make or present work and for community engagement. Similarly, ad hoc and pop-up spaces can be useful for short-term projects and particular types of engagement. These should be supported, but they are not a solution to any of the more critical issues facing cultural infrastructure today.
In conclusion, arts infrastructure should be understood as a long-term public investment in people, places and communities. By supporting creative production and cultural participation, and by providing sustainable revenue funding alongside capital investment, we can ensure that artists are able to create, communities can engage with the arts and the cultural life of the country can continue to flourish.
Comment on this
Gabhaim buíochas le Mr. Delamere. Before I move on to our final speaker, Senator McDowell, I understand he has a video presentation rather than an opening statement. I acknowledge the Senator's guests in the Gallery. They are all very welcome. I welcome, in particular, Councillor Patrick Kinsella. He is very involved in the arts. We all look forward to Senator McDowell's presentation.
Comment on this
Could I add a few words to that?
Comment on this
I thank the committee for inviting me here, as a non-member, to make this presentation. I also welcome a number of guests: Mr. Pat Wallace, former director of the National Museum; Mr. Peter Pearson, one of our foremost architectural historians; members of the Rathmines initiative; and Mr. Tony Reddy, one of our leading urban architects.
Listening to the contributions of the local authorities and Arts Council, I want to put on the record that I am very grateful to the Library and Research Service, in particular Dr. Emily Heery, for this research. Since 2000, that is, in the past 26 years, 32 high-profile cultural buildings have closed in Dublin. That is 32 performance and arts spaces gone, and there has been nothing else in Dublin to compensate for this. There is also the National Concert Hall, which is about to undergo a huge redevelopment and will be closed while that redevelopment takes place.
I have prepared a pack here for everybody, so I do not want to waste anybody's time. The National Concert Hall is required, under the lease from Dublin City Council, to be available to the public. It has built three prefab classrooms on the ground floor of this huge auditorium, which used to hold 2,000 people. That is just gone now, and there are just three classrooms built on the floor. The committee can see the photos which show the damage that has been done.
Unlike other local authorities, Dublin City Council owns this building. The City of Dublin Education and Training Board is a tenant and holds that tenancy on the basis that those facilities be available to the public. Unfortunately, those facilities have been taken out of public use. A conservation plan for the building has been prepared by the Heritage Council. It too is in the pack I have given to committee members. I have exhibited the lease, which deals with this. There is huge local support for this, but it is a matter of pleading with people - I will not say banging heads together - to restore this absolutely magnificent auditorium to its proper role, which it is legally obliged to serve the community.
I thank the committee for the opportunity to bring this yet again into the public domain.
Comment on this
Thank you, Senator. I thank all the witnesses for their opening statements. We will now move to the question-and-answer session. Senator Boyhan was first to indicate.
Comment on this
I confirm that I am not a member of the committee, but I am hugely interested in this area. Clearly, I was not going to miss this opportunity as a Senator in the Houses.
I will start with a few comments, working backwards from the presentation made by my colleague, Senator McDowell. The committee saw today the importance and significance of visuals. It really gets the message across, and I do not think that message could have been communicated any better than through that visual presentations. I am a former member of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown County Council, where we had similar challenges. We prided ourselves as a council on being pretty high up the ranks in terms of arts spaces, etc.
I ask and advise any member of the committee who is interested to pay a visit to the former Blackrock Vocational School, which was a Carnegie Library, as well as the old technical school, the old fire station and the complex of buildings on the main street of Blackrock. Great credit is due to Valerie Mulvin and other architects for the massive restoration done there.
We did overcome the exact difficulties and challenges Senator McDowell was talking about. We had a synergy and a collaboration with the then ETB, successor to the Vocational Education Committee, and with the council owning the primary building, the assembly halls, the theatre, etc. , and then the library. On foot of synergy and with an agreement by the council to surrender the building to an established project team on a nominal lease for 100 or 200 years, we now have a state-of-the-art facility that has a capacity of 1,000 students, lecture rooms, a joint library for both the students and the public, presentation rooms and rooms for historical societies. There is a living example of a project that faced many difficulties, having been in abeyance for 30 years. It is now up and running.
I acknowledge the very significant role of the CCMA and the collaboration with all 31 local authorities on the issue of the arts officers. Having worked closely with some of those involved, I know they drive the agenda. That is one of the great reforms of local government. There is a great synergy between the creative people, artists and writers, including the writers-in-residence, and the suite of measures that arts officers drive. My only real concern is that there are not enough of them. We need more in local authorities and they need more funding. In the last few years, there has been a real energy for creativity, festivals, culture and embracing diversity, and an appreciation of how all of these overlap and enrich our diverse communities and our creative spaces.
Well done to the witnesses for attending. Well done to the Chair and the committee members for really driving this initiative. We do not just live in an economy or a society. It is about the different facets of life. I actually believe that if people are imbued with a love of the arts, culture and creativity, their mindsets are expanded. There are no better people than those present, who lead in this work from the front. I acknowledge, and congratulate them on, this work. I also acknowledge the support of the CCMA and, of course, the parent Departments that support the arts officers’ work.
Comment on this
Would anyone like to reply to Senator Boyhan? Are there any comments? Since his remarks were more comments than questions, I will move on to Senator Black.
Comment on this
I thank all the witnesses for their presentations. They were very informative. Many of the witnesses’ submissions, and submissions we have got from practitioners and cultural organisations, have referred to the need for a co-ordinated national strategy for arts and cultural infrastructure. I am going to ask everybody my question, which is on cultural infrastructure. What do the witnesses think would be useful, and how should such a strategy be developed? Do they believe it requires a dedicated task force in the Department of culture that can bring together stakeholders from multiple Departments and public bodies? That is something that I would be very interested in. It would be very powerful.
Many submissions have discussed expansion of the per cent for art scheme, whereby developers would be obligated to provide cultural space as part of certain developments. I have, a few times, highlighted the inadequacy of the cultural space on the site of the former Tivoli Theatre, which was provided as part of the obligation on the developer in the planning permission to provide a cultural venue. However, the space provided had no toilet facilities and no working electricity. That is very worrying. In fact, that space provided could not be used for a good few years, until I started to follow up on it and ask what was happening with it. It is awful to think that artists could not use that space and that somebody like me was needed to put pressure on the developers to do something with it. How can we ensure that spaces that might be provided through such schemes are of good quality and give cultural organisations and communities the infrastructure and the facilities they need?
Is it okay if I ask questions of individual witnesses?
Comment on this
I have one for Mr. Delamere. His opening statement highlighted The Dock in Carrick-on-Shannon, which I absolutely love. I have performed there a few times, and I know Brendan, who works there, very well. It was a former courthouse that had been vacant and was transformed into a really vibrant cultural venue.
We invited the Courts Service and other public bodies like the OPW, which manage these buildings, to make submissions to the committee to outline how these types of transformations could take place. I am aware that we are discussing something that happened in 2005, but how did the transfer of function take place? It is a great model. I know there are plenty of vacant OPW buildings around. The model is a great way to transform empty buildings into cultural spaces. Does it offer a template for how we can transform vacant publicly owned buildings into cultural venues?
We have been discussing the cultural infrastructure scheme a lot over the past few weeks. The next question is also for Mr. Delamere but if anybody else wants to answer, they may do so. His statement highlighted the building acquisition measure and the town and village renewal scheme, which is the responsibility of the Department of Rural and Community Development, as opportunities for local authorities to establish cultural infrastructure. Will the witnesses speak a little bit about that? Do schemes like this point to the fact that there is a need for cross-departmental collaboration on issues of arts and cultural infrastructure?
My next question is for Mayo County Council. May I ask all my questions first?
Comment on this
I am sorry.
Will Ms O’Callaghan speak a little about the research the Arts Council has done on arts infrastructure? Will she give us some details on the update of the framework agreement the council has with the CCMA and the shared priority of arts and cultural infrastructure?
Will the witnesses from Limerick City and County Council tell us a bit more about the work that has gone into assessing the demand for a dedicated arts centre in Newcastle West? I realise this has been touched on already. What further supports are required?
Will the witnesses from Westmeath County Council tell us a bit more about how festivals should be regarded as essential arts infrastructure and how this could be implemented?
I want to come to Senator Michael McDowell. I commend him and all of the people who were involved. Rathmines Town Hall has a very special place in my heart. I went to St. Louis High School. My children went to school up in Ranelagh. We spent a lot of time during my children's youth going to all the shops around that area. I do not live too far away. It is a wonderful project. I want to get an idea from the Senator as to how far he has come. Obviously, there has been a lot of work, as he has been working on this for five years. He has a great team of people behind him in the Gallery. How close does he think he might be to getting this done? What kind of Government supports is he getting? I appreciate he is saying there is a lot of cross-party support, but what kinds of Government supports is he getting? I will come to Mr. Delamere first, if that is okay.
Comment on this
Just before I call on the witnesses to respond, I acknowledge the presence of members of the House of Commons Environmental Audit Committee in our Distinguished Visitors Gallery: Toby Perkins, the Chair of the committee; Julia Buckley MP; Jonathan Davies MP; Sojan Joseph MP; Adrian Ramsay MP; Martin Rhodes MP; John Whitby MP; the Right Honourable Sammy Wilson MP; Ian Cruse, the committee clerk; and Misha Patel, the committee specialist. They are all very welcome. I hope they enjoy their visit to Leinster House today.
This is a discussion involving members of our Seanad Public Consultation Committee and members of the arts community. Mainly present are representatives from local authorities, discussing arts infrastructure or the lack of it. I say this just to let our visitors know what is happening. They are all very welcome.
Now I will move on to Mr. Delamere to start with the questions.
Comment on this
The building that houses The Dock had ceased being a courthouse many years before the centre was established. Subsequent to the closure of the courthouse, it had been used by the local authority as offices and for other purposes, and then it fell into disuse. At the same time, we recognised there was a great need for cultural infrastructure in Carrick-on-Shannon. There was a great deal of public consultation on the potential, the needs and so on before development. Of course, the building housing The Dock, having been a courthouse, was naturally designed around an auditorium, so it was an easy transition. However, when I say it was an easy transition, it was probably anything but.
It is an historic building that was complex in terms of redeveloping it into a modern arts centre. That needs to be borne in mind. These are beautiful buildings, but they are complex buildings to transform into modern, sustainable facilities. That is why it is really imperative that the ongoing operational costs of these buildings are kept in mind at the capital stage. That would have been funded under what was the access scheme. That was a crucial scheme. A lot of the cultural infrastructure in the country was developed at that time through the access scheme and its successors. However, its infrequency was an issue. It might happen every five to seven years, or whatever. Whenever it came around, you had to have a good plan to go for it, whereas a more regular cultural infrastructure funding scheme would make that process and planning around these things much easier.
The new community and youth arts facility in Carrick-on-Shannon and The Junction in Ballinamore are multidepartmental, multifunder projects, where a number of needs and opportunities coalesce around a project. That requires all the Departments to work together. Like any issue, there is not going to be one single solution. There are a number of interrelated issues and a number of different solutions together are going to address the concerns.
Comment on this
The proposed arts centre in Newcastle West is a project that is in preparation. We have utilised various funding streams to get to the point we are at. In my role as town regeneration officer, I have utilised the building and land acquisition measure, which Mr. Delamere referenced as it relates to Carrick-on-Shannon, to secure some properties in Newcastle West. We have utilised some European funding to prepare and integrate a strategy and extensive consultation and engagement were carried out with artists and practitioners in the space around the needs and the demands. An independent needs analysis was carried out, which confirmed the demand and viability for such a facility. We acquired the properties, and we have secured planning consent to advance that. We are seeking funding through the Department of Rural and Community Development and the Gaeltacht's rural regeneration and development fund for a multifunctional building, because the key piece is the operational piece. Lots of people have referenced that. The multifunctionality of the building for various arts and cultural opportunities will, we hope, sustain that building.
It is about trying to join up the dots, which is often difficult, and focusing on the multifunctionality of the building, and the town regeneration by attracting people back into the town centre and creating a purpose to visit the town centre, focused around arts and culture.
Comment on this
I will take the question on research. We have a number of pieces of research that are building up a strong evidence base for the deficiencies in the existing stock of infrastructure. We are also looking to build up a better sense of the demands. We must also think about the potential that exists. To give an example of some of the information we have, 50% of 122 arts and cultural venues that are publicly facing were built pre-1919, before the establishment of the State. We are looking at a building stock that is very old and decrepit and needs an awful lot of work. That applies to existing stock, but we then have further evidence. For example, 79% of visual arts workspaces are at full capacity, so there is huge pent-up demand at workspace level. That applies to visual art spaces, but we have evidence from sectoral consultation that this is replicated across all sectors. Music, performing arts and other disciplines have been mentioned. We are constantly building up this profile of the demand and need both to create new space and to undertake remedial action with the existing stock. There is real potential for what we want to be as a country, and the infrastructure we want to have for both the arts and creative sector, and for what the public should expect a wealthy country like Ireland to deliver in terms of those spaces.
Something I wanted to mention is that we are about to embark on an infrastructure audit, which will create a really in-depth national profile of the arts spaces that are available throughout the country. That is going to be foundational research to have available to us and to other policymakers across Departments, and with our colleagues in local authorities, to really inform policy decisions and directions into the future. That is work we are going to undertake over the next couple of months. At the previous Oireachtas joint committee, we spoke to our colleagues in the County and City Management Association, CCMA, as well. Our colleagues in local authorities are crucial to this, as are our colleagues in the Department. There is real buy-in for that research we are undertaking. As I say, it will be seminal baseline information that we will embark on gathering in the coming months.
The possible establishment of a task force was mentioned. Whatever it looks like, there is absolute consensus among the parties involved that there is a need for heads to come together and work to solve this issue in a more co-ordinated and strategic way. Great work is happening, but it may be on an individual basis. For future planning and sustainability, that cross-sectoral work really needs to happen. It is the least that we owe to the sector and to the public. That may be a recommendation coming from this committee. It needs to happen, and there is a willingness to make it happen.
Comment on this
I want to pick up on some of the other areas Senator Black mentioned, and also on the comments Senator Boyhan made regarding Dún Laoghaire–Rathdown and the work of local authorities. The Arts Council has a relationship and partnership with local government going back 41 years. That partnership began as an offer and opportunity to collaborate with the local authorities to establish the post of arts officer. That is how embedded that relationship is between the Arts Council and local government, and we have that relationship with individual arts officers and the CCMA now through that framework for collaboration that was mentioned. Through all the years and the schemes, some of which Mr. Delamere mentioned, like the access schemes, the cultural development incentive scheme and the capital schemes the Department has rolled out over the years, local government has shown significant leadership in establishing really important venues that we can name off the top of our heads right around the country. These venues either were newly built over the past 20 years or so, or are repurposed churches, courthouses and a range of historic buildings that have been used in the past. There has been huge imagination and great intention to continue that drive to expand on the capital need.
Regarding the Arts Council agreement with local government, we have a ten-year agreement and framework of collaboration, and we are working on the next iteration. The early indications as we work through that live process are that infrastructure is a shared core priority. The Arts Council does not have a role in capital. It did in the past, but does not currently. However, along with local government, we have a role in supporting venues financially. We know local government investment in the arts is significant collectively on an annual basis. About half of that investment goes into infrastructure.
That is why it is important we work in concert with each other, including our parent Departments.
I will pick up on the per cent for art scheme and we can come back to it in more detail. The per cent for art scheme and the development levy mentioned are two separate instruments. The per cent for art is attached to public capital projects and the development levy is attached to developments with some local authorities, but not all. They are different instruments, but both have a potential role to play in relation to capital and enhancing spaces and activity within them.
Comment on this
I will comment on the funding element. Some of my colleagues referred to how local authorities are adept at maximising funding opportunities for the needs within communities. There are funding measures like the rural regeneration and development fund, the building land acquisition fund, town and village, just transition funding in the midlands counties and more recently community recognition funding. They would all have gone towards community buildings and community spaces, which often cut across arts, culture and community activities. The Luan Gallery in Athlone was developed through EU funding in 2013 with matched funding from what was Athlone Town Council. Local authorities are good at accessing funding from various sources to develop these spaces, but a more co-ordinated approach and fund for infrastructure would be helpful as would a collaborative approach between the Departments. All of those funding streams cut across different Departments. That would be welcome.
On the conversion of buildings and accessing funding, Westmeath County Council is in the process of acquiring an old friary building in Athlone as a community and cultural space with residential and public amenity park space integrated into it. That will probably come from a range of funding sources as well as matched funding from Westmeath County Council. That is the response local authorities have because we know what the needs are within communities. We also know what the opportunities are.
I will talk about festivals in a general sense before Ms Gilcreest contributes. We have seen a growth of festivals in Westmeath in recent years. There is a long history of festivals. The RTÉ All Ireland Drama Festival has been going in Athlone for a number of years. We had Fleadh Cheoil na hÉireann for two years a number of years ago and it was a huge success. More recently, new festivals have been growing, such as the Croílár arts festival in Athlone and the river festival. There are also community festivals happening across the county. The council has a festival and events fund, but it is limited and is supporting small, community events that happen throughout the county. While we give more substantial funding to some of the larger festivals, such as the drama festival, we are limited by our own revenue funding in what we can provide. Often, the challenges and barriers to the voluntary groups running these festivals are about infrastructure, space for storage and to prepare artwork or installations for the particular festival. The festivals are becoming more popular and valuable to communities. They contribute to community life, the local economy and tourism. We have good tourism towns. They also provide work opportunities for artists and creative practitioners. From another point of view, they bring access to arts and culture onto the streets, making it accessible to people, often for free, and bringing it into the town and into our public spaces.
Comment on this
I will add to that and speak of the place-making aspect of the river festival in Athlone or the community arts festival in Castlepollard and others. They are an expression of living culture and we see it as infrastructure. Ms Finney outlined the needs around production, storage and space for things like rehearsal. There is also the ability to share resources. Existing supports are really aimed at programming. There are specific physical space needs that others have outlined like tall spaces for a circus. It should be seen as essential infrastructure because as outdoor art, spectacle and multi-arts, it is happening in a whole town. That is a whole town model. For infrastructure that means a networked approach to using existing spaces, new spaces and the outdoor public realm. That can work for urban and rural. It is about seeing places and spaces as a hub and spoke network that has huge potential alongside programming supports to develop specific sites, towns or villages as a site of production.
It also allows us to develop artists, art forms and places not just in a county but in a region. We have challenges working into the wider areas of tourism and community arts, for example, to create diverse, accessible and inclusive art forms that are visible. We are trying to encourage artists in the region to be able to practise and have sustainable careers instead of buying in objects, props and other things from far away. We want to have local circular economy production. It still comes down to using what we have and enhancing it. For example, in Athlone we could have some storage, rehearsal and outdoor spaces. We could have dedicated and earmarked supports for infrastructure and potentially bring spaces back into use or enhanced use, where it is not one individual space but a network.
Comment on this
To answer Senator Black's question, I believe it is necessary that the Department of culture has a team whose focus is on infrastructure. It is quite clear that to support festivals is one thing, but to support the performing arts is another. When you are talking about infrastructure, somebody has to have the responsibility of providing that. I was interested in Mr. Delamare's description of the dock in Carrick-on-Shannon. I live near there at some times in the month and I was Minister for Justice when it escaped from the Department of Justice as a court into the county council's hands. It lay derelict and difficult to invest in. As Mr. Delamare said, when you create infrastructure you have to work out who is going to pay to maintain this. You can put €5 million or €10 million into some project, but who is going to pay to repair it and all the rest? That is an issue.
To answer the question, I believe that what is necessary is a unit in the Department of culture that would say it will take charge of this, especially for major things. My pet project is an auditorium that used to contain 2,000 people.
That is a huge thing. I am dealing with Dublin City Council, the education and training board, the Department of heritage, which paid for the report that was a big help, when Senator Malcolm Noonan was Minister of State, the Department of education and the Department of further education. That is five different agencies, none of which is going to take the reins and run this project. An agency needs to undertake to do that project. In Dublin city, a major library project is under way on Parnell Square.
However, let us look at what has happened in Dublin. Senator Black will 1,000% know about this. Andrew's Lane Theatre is gone. The City Arts Centre is gone. SFX Hall is gone. Father Mathew hall is gone. These were all city centre performance spaces that are now gone, having been turned into different things. There are aspirations aplenty in the city development plan but nobody is saying who is actually going to take Rathmines Town Hall and put a couple of million into restoring it. While the Minister, Deputy O'Donovan, is very supportive of this, if we had a Minister who would tell Dublin City Council that the money is there and it should go and do this, a lot could be achieved.
To go back to the point made, there really needs to be a unit that adopts particular projects, runs with them and says that the funding will be available, and not that it will have to be grabbed from this fund or that one and must be scraped together from various agencies. Dr. Wallace would like to say a few words.
Comment on this
It is a privilege to be able to say anything here. Apart from supporting Senator McDowell on the town hall in Rathmines, my qualifications are that I was director of the National Museum of Ireland for 24 years, the longest time anyone has spent in that post. I am also the retired director of the Wood Quay archaeological excavations. I am a kind of quasi-Dub, although I am from Limerick.
I will briefly make four points, if I may. The first is that I would ask people to reflect on the bad decision that is the redevelopment plan for Wood Quay. It is a hopeless and immoral decision. People should bear that in mind. It is going to cost €500 million. It does not do the archaeology any good. The archaeology still needs a museum in Dublin. We have an exhibition in the National Museum, but it does not do it adequate justice. On the same subject, the National Museum should be compelled to resume the publication of the Dublin excavations. When I stepped out of office more than a decade ago, the museum stopped publishing these things.
While we have some Westmeath neighbours here, that county is crying out for the needed retention and restoration of the gorgeous mid-19th century railway station in Mullingar. My typist, who lives in Castlepollard, and I meet in Mullingar Station. It is a disgrace to see such an incredible 19th-century piece of architecture being allowed to be run into the ground before our very eyes. Dick Hogan of the Topic and I tried to do something about it but we failed.
Limerick is very interesting. The Minister should be developing a regional museum for the area. It could hold some material from the National Museum and act as a branch to serve that north-Munster region. I might just say to my colleague from Limerick City and County Council that Newcastle West is alive and glowing as a result of the beautiful restoration work that has been done on the medieval buildings where the old cinema was. There is no fear regarding Newcastle West if things are handled properly.
On a final point, my hero in Irish history is Daniel O'Connell. To see him portrayed in that way is a disgrace.
Comment on this
Is Dr. Wallace talking about the statue?
Comment on this
Yes, I am talking about the statue at the entrance to this building. Daniel O'Connell did not look remotely like that.
Comment on this
I am conscious that I have three more Senators to get in so I will ask people to be tighter with their questions and responses.
Comment on this
I will certainly try. I welcome the stakeholders from the local authorities and the Arts Council and my colleague, Senator McDowell, to the Chamber to discuss the Rathmines Town Hall project. While it is easy to focus entirely on the top-line macro figures, we must talk about the structural barriers facing our cultural workers, especially with regard to the accessibility of funding and public visibility. For many emerging practitioners, navigating the dense and complex bureaucracy of State applications is a full-time hurdle in itself. We must ensure that access to infrastructure support is simplified, streamlined and visible to those who need it. In that context, I strongly back the recommendations put forward by Westmeath and Limerick county councils to expand capital grants for shared community arts spaces and facilities.
While small direct grants to individual artists are vital, we must invest heavily in bricks-and-mortar hubs, co-located spaces and shared facilities. We cannot allow our creative sector to operate in isolated silos. Bricks-and-mortar facilities bring artists together, fostering a collaborative community that naturally integrates into the wider public fabric. Furthermore, from a cold financial perspective, investing in shared multiple-use infrastructure delivers major economies of scale as regards maintenance, specialised technical equipment and overheads. Crucially, these shared community hubs solve a major democratic accessibility issue. While established full-time professionals are well aware of the State help that is available, a physical community arts space is a welcoming gateway for the public and opens the door for citizens who work full time in other sectors who want to participate, learn and engage with the arts in their spare time. This transforms arts infrastructure from an elitist administrative exercise into a living, breathing public service.
I have a few questions for the various stakeholders. I will go through them quite quickly. In the submission made by Ms O’Reilly and Ms O'Callaghan of the Arts Council, they note that affordable appropriate workspaces are the second most critical factor affecting artists' lives. How can a future national arts infrastructure strategy actively lower bureaucratic barriers to entry so that independent artists can easily access and locate these spaces?
What has been the experience of the county councils in providing artist residencies? What are the pros and cons? What more can be done to facilitate residencies? How effectively are we at leveraging EU funding streams, such as Creative Europe, to finance regional arts infrastructure and collaborative workspaces? What can the Government do to better assist councils in securing European grants? I have been advocating for EU officers in every local authority for years.
I thank Emily Heery, who provided a very comprehensive report on the culture and arts venues in Dublin this afternoon. I also thank Samantha Long for the information package she provided for us this afternoon on the town hall in Rathmines. I lived in Rathmines for a year of my life and am well aware of the building. I also thank Senator McDowell for providing the visuals today. It is really important to have visuals. Perhaps the committee can look at having more visual presentations in future.
I have a few questions on that. The master plan is fantastic. It covers everything: the phased restoration, the sandstone and the brickwork. It covers absolutely everything. Where does the Gulistan Depot master plan stand in relation to this plan? How is it progressing?
With regard to funding pathways, there is absolutely oodles of funding. The witnesses should not pigeonhole themselves into relying on cultural funding. There is also urban regeneration and development fund funding, local authority funding, national heritage funding, and capital and Department funding. There is loads of funding. Getting funding is not going to be a problem. There is already a body there if someone is being sought to run this. The National Concert Hall could operate this as some sort of subsidiary operation. There is already a body there so things should not be complicated too much. Getting somebody to run this overall could come under that.
Those are my few questions. I was very impressed by each and every one of the witnesses today. I thank them for bringing arts into this Chamber.
Comment on this
I will call Senators Casey and Mullen.
Maybe then we can put everything to the witnesses and get a statement on each of them.
Comment on this
I welcome all of the witnesses and thank them for their presentations. I wish Senator McDowell the very best of luck with his ambitious project. I wish him all the best with all the red tape that he will have to get through before he can even talk about capital funding.
I am trying to create a vision of what a strategy for the future of the arts and culture in Ireland would look like, specifically in terms of infrastructure and the operation of the infrastructure, which is probably more complex. There is a realisation, definitely for me if not for everybody now, that between sports, community and arts there is a significant deficit across the whole country when it comes to all of those facilities, and I do not think we are investing enough time and resources into all of them. We should look at ways to integrate all of those elements into one policy document, specifically when writing county development plans and all the rest.
The infrastructure is the easiest problem to solve in the sense that capital is found and then a building is built, but the biggest problem is operating the building once it has been built, which falls to the experience of local authorities because they manage most of these facilities. While I appreciate it, and support it 100%, the use of historic buildings for arts and culture is fantastic but the cost of doing that and operating for the long term compared with the cost of running a brand new purpose-built building is something that we should analyse in terms of value for money.
In Wicklow, we are lucky to have the purpose-built Mermaid Arts Centre in Bray, the purpose-built Whale Theatre and we have the lovely Courthouse Arts Centre in Tinahely, which is a restored old courthouse. The Department of Justice, Home Affairs and Migration has now said that it held on to Wicklow courthouse for 11 years while it was unopened and it was going to build four courthouses but is no longer planning to do so as it is too expensive. It has asked Wicklow County Council if it would like to take on the courthouse. If I were a director of finance in Wicklow County Council, the last thing I would want is the noose around my neck of trying to return that courthouse to use, because of the costs involved. When assessing what to do with buildings we have to look at the pros and cons of the value of historic buildings. Perhaps at a national level we should take cognisance of the fact that it is not just providing a home for the arts; it is restoring an historic building and bringing it back into society. Such buildings have a greater purpose than just centres for arts and culture.
I served as a member of Wicklow County Council for 12 years. The county council has a development levy contribution scheme of which community facilities form a part and I often wonder how much of that scheme's finances actually goes to infrastructure for the provision of arts and culture. I would say that upon analysis it would be minimal at best. Another point in respect of local authorities is that a lot of it can come down to the personnel within the local authority, the passion they bring to arts and culture, and how much they are willing to fight for arts and culture when the pie is being divvied out.
I come from the small village of Laragh, where we built the very successful Brockagh Resource Centre. It is a multi-purpose venue that does everything, including sports, theatre and a bit of music. There are also the municipal-led facilities, which probably might be more specific to regional and national levels. Has anybody done a viability piece of work on the size of population that supports each type of infrastructure? For example, Bray with a population of 40,000 will support the likes of the Mermaid Arts Centre with a bit of support from Wicklow County Council from an operational point of view. Has an analysis been done on the size of population that supports each type of infrastructure, and where is it viable to have a stand-alone unit or a multi-purpose unit that would bring together sports facilities, arts facilities and meeting facilities in a community? I ask because at a community level there would be a need for people to volunteer to operate and run these facilities. The volunteers do incredible work across this country. I am looking for a strategic vision. What is the strategy? How will we fund the infrastructure? How will we, as a nation, accept that if we want historic buildings we will have to pay for them? How will we operate these facilities on a long-term basis? I would add sports and community facilities into the whole national debate.
Comment on this
I commend my friend and colleague, Senator McDowell, on his excellent work to date and on this excellent proposal in relation to Rathmines Town Hall.
I had the good fortune to be in Birr on Sunday evening when I spent some time in the wonderful Birr Theatre and Arts Centre located on Oxmanstown Mall. A film festival was coming to an end on that occasion. It struck me at the time that the benefit these facilities carry for an area goes far beyond the enjoyment of the arts. These are places where community is built; that was very obvious to me.
Again, I commend Senator McDowell on thinking through this issue in all its aspects. What has gone on is, first, the misreading or misapplication of a lease or, indeed, the unlawful establishment of structures that have frustrated the existing obligation to enable the usage of the facility while not being used by what is now the ETB. Senator McDowell has really pinpointed that this is a waste of an excellent facilities. I fully understand and agree with the point that he made about the need for a dedicated unit where these important projects can be driven forward. Somebody has to take the initiative and responsibility for projects. It is no good having lots of key people thinking this is a great idea but waiting for somebody else to take the lead. I hope this project can progress.
I have two brief questions for Ms Finney, in the context of Westmeath and Athlone, on the plans to develop the friary building. I am very interested in that place because I know that former Franciscan church. Is Ms Finney referring to the Franciscan church and not to a friary building in connection with the church? Am I right that it is proposed to develop a project or a new facility in what was a place of worship?
Comment on this
It is the whole complex, including residential land.
Comment on this
As Ms Finney can well imagine, that is good news from the point of view of people in Athlone and the local area but it comes on the back of a certain sadness at the change. Many people will have very fond memories of visiting, worshipping and being in that space but those are the times that we are in and it is a good thing that there will be movement on the project.
I cannot let this moment go without making the following point, though I do not know if this is the place to say it. Coming and going from Ballinasloe, as I do every week, I lament the state of the St. Brigid's Hospital building in Ballinasloe. I was in Grangegorman recently along with Senator McDowell to see the wonderful use that has been made of the Grangegorman complex, which has been given new life for a great and positive purpose in education. with a beautiful design. There is great credit due to everybody involved in the Grangegorman project. We await people who can dream the dream for other important buildings across the country to take them out of dereliction and give them a new and better future.
Comment on this
I suggest that we start with Ms Finney and work backwards this time in terms of the witnesses replying to the comments or questions by the three Senators.
Comment on this
I will comment on the friary building and my colleague, Ms Gilchreest, will comment on the residencies. I can confirm for Senator Mullen that it is the complex.
With reference to the point made by Senator Casey about the cost of returning historical buildings to use, there are ongoing costs and these are a challenge for local authorities. As somebody mentioned, the directors of finance probably are not overly enamoured with some of these projects. In terms of the friary project, it is with sadness that the Franciscans left the town of Athlone. The Franciscans were well loved there and the community was disappointed to see them go. As part of that, the Franciscans were happy to work on the transfer of the properties to the local authority with a view to them being made available for public use. It is a great legacy for them that these buildings will go to such use. It is the friary building itself. The actual use is not set in stone. It is going through the process but it will involve community access and a cultural venue would be super. Obviously there will be local authority involvement. We are looking towards the community in terms of setting up a structure to run it. That has to be worked through but we have lots of good models of that. There is a great community in Athlone and I am sure all members of the community will get behind the project. Again, it is about accessing various funding sources. There are residential buildings within that complex that will be put to residential use, probably age-friendly, and that will come under the remit of the Department of housing. There are also public gardens and spaces that will be open to the public. It is a nice example of how a complex or building can be used for a variety of purposes and all for the good of the community.
I am familiar with the other two locations that Senator Mullen spoke about. I drove past the Ballinasloe facility recently and it is in a poor state. I am also very familiar with the Birr theatre. Sinéad Ó Reilly and I worked in Offaly County Council previously. I am very familiar with it and I know it well. It is not far away. These facilities are wonderful assets for a community and it is great to see a bit of a change in terms of recognition of some of the smaller towns. In the past there would be only one big centre in the big county town but now there is an understanding that smaller communities should have easy access to spaces for community purpose and for access to arts and culture. Especially in the smaller towns and villages they cut across everything, whether it is amateur drama, dance class for kids or music. They cut across everything and provide an opportunity for work for artists and practitioners. I will ask Ms Gilchreest to come in on the residencies.
Comment on this
On our experience of artist residencies, the main aim of an artist residency is to allow time and space for the artist to develop new work and not necessarily to deliver. This is alongside other artist developments such as bursaries. At the moment we offer a number of artist residencies annually but we send artists to other regions of the country to experience these residencies and come back. The aim is to develop more in the midlands region. In addition, the artists themselves approach the arts office with an interest in developing designated activity companies and social enterprises. For example, a group of artists is looking to develop the old CIÉ goods store at the train station in Mullingar. They are willing to self-start on these projects. They want to run them themselves so they are not entirely reliant on the local authority.
Comment on this
The point was made by Senator Casey that it is one thing to establish something and it is another thing to run it. We all know the classic example of swimming pools. At one stage 20 years ago every local authority wanted swimming pools everywhere. Many realised after a while that they could not run them and there was a major problem. Capital expenditure has to be backed up by appropriate commitment in terms of the use of a building.
What I would say in relation to Rathmines is that this is a heritage building. It is a preserved structure. It cannot be allowed to fall down. It is being used in an improper way at the moment, in my view. The principal of Rathmines College, Anna Morris, a wonderful woman, says she needs the three classrooms and this is her department. When I went to Mr. Shakespeare in Dublin City Council I could see him looking at me with slitty eyes asking whether he really wanted to run a second Mansion House in Rathmines. Therefore, to come to Senator Keogan's question on who will run these places when they get established, in terms of Rathmines as an example, the obvious candidate is the education and training board, whose building it will be for the next half century at least. It can use it not simply for arts but for exam halls, conferring ceremonies or for other educational institutions.
St. Patrick's Cathedral is used for conferring ceremonies in the centre of Dublin. There was a controversy about Nathan Carter in a Catholic church recently. There is an awful lot of space. I fully accept what Senator Mullen says about some people feeling sad that church buildings and church institutions are falling into disuse but they are built and there is a green imperative to use them for something. My point is that if we commit, as Dublin City Council does in its city plan, to developing infrastructure for the arts, and if the Government in its programme for Government says it going to fund it, and if all of these good intentions on paper are put in place, somebody has to have responsibility for it.
The document on Rathmines which Senator Keogan mentioned was procured by the intervention of the then Minister of State, Senator Malcolm Noonan, who came and saw the thing. He said he would not be able to build it or finance it but what he could do is finance the survey, which we see. Everything falls between different boats. I do not blame the city manager, Mr. Shakespeare, for not wanting to have to establish an office in Rathmines. I do not blame the education and training board for wanting three extra classrooms. I do not blame the Minister for asking where to find space in Rathmines for those classrooms, although there is plenty, by the way. The real question is whether somebody is willing to take this project and say it will happen and that they will drive it through. I am only a university Senator.
Michael Tierney built Belfield because he bought all the land and he assembled UCD's campus. Otherwise it would be a shambolic mess somewhere around St. Stephen's Green. Somebody has to take a major project and take the reins and say they will drive it. This is why I go back to Senator Frances Black's point. If we are going to have major projects, and I am not suggesting that they all have to be major because around the country church halls and memorial halls are becoming available and need to be used for community purposes and they cannot all be driven by one department in Dublin. However, if we are going to select major projects, then, as Senator Black suggests, it has to be done in the Department of culture. Somebody has to say it is now a Government priority and that it is going to happen.
Comment on this
Going back to the point on policy, a primary issue that most people have mentioned is that an overall policy is essential at this point. However, there is not a one-size-fits-all. Underneath this, each piece of infrastructure has to have its own individual plan that works for it. Perhaps the reason local authorities have been key or adept at engaging on historic buildings is because we work in close quarters with the heritage office and the arts office as well as with planning. There is close recognition that these pieces of infrastructure have social, cultural and economic impacts and benefits and serve all aspects of a local authority. They are complex pieces of infrastructure but the issues are not insurmountable.
We hold a long-term ambition that The Dock will be a net-zero building. This is quite a challenge but doable, even though it is an historic building and difficult to manage in that regard. However, with new technologies such as solar energy, the use of hydrotreated vegetable oil, HVO, and other avenues like that, we believe we can do that.
With regard to residencies, we do not necessarily see that as an infrastructure piece. Our experience of residencies is around engaging with communities, and the infrastructure changes depending on what it is. For example, our spark programme is about artists being resident in companies and places of enterprise. We have residencies with St. Vincent de Paul, Leitrim Hill Creamery and places like that. We also have a farm walks programme, where artists are resident with farmers in Leitrim and Fermanagh, so the infrastructure changes accordingly.
On the point of EU funding, it is certainly a complex area to engage in, particularly for an individual. Any artist would likely have to work with a local authority or an arts centre to be able to lead on programmes like that. We have led on Creative Europe projects. The Dock and the Leitrim Sculpture Centre have led on international residency programmes for artists that Leitrim artists have benefited from.
Regarding workspaces, Leitrim Sculpture Centre provides artists' accommodation and studios, as well as a wide array of material processes for artists to use. Traditionally, a lot of artists in Leitrim had their studios where they lived, so we have not shared the same challenges as other more urban local authorities. However, now that it is becoming more problematic to find affordable accommodation anywhere, the same issues are facing everybody.
Comment on this
I will pick up on the point about artists' accommodation. Limerick City and County Council provides artists' residential apartments in St. John's Square. It has played an important role in supporting artists and strengthening the creative ecology of Limerick. Initiatives like that show investment in workspace is not just simply about the buildings but about retaining talent, supporting careers and building cultural capacity within Limerick.
As Mr. Delamere alluded to, providing affordable accommodation and balancing that with the cultural creative space is a challenge. There is also the issue of maintaining these buildings and the escalating costs. The buildings I referred to are in a protected structure. Exploring opportunities and utilising funding streams is key, and the European-funded THRIVE programme, which the committee is aware of, is restoring many heritage buildings around the country, so there are opportunities for funding. It is about capitalising on those. The task force could bring them to light to people who need the co-ordination or access to that information.
Comment on this
I will talk a little about the question relating to affordable workspaces for artists. Over half of the Arts Council's funding already goes into supporting a network of 100 organisations, 51 arts centres and 200 festivals throughout the country. They all in turn are creating supports and opportunities for individual artists. We also support dedicated workspace facilities.
In the area of the visual arts, we have a dedicated scheme for workspaces for artists which gives funding of up to €50,000 per annum for collectives as a contribution towards light, heat and those studio space costs. However, I acknowledge that it is focused on visual artists and is not more widely available.
While we can talk about the funding here, and I do not want to disregard its significance, we are increasingly aware that what is contributing to the acute need is the precarity of the model that is there. We want a mixed model that includes meanwhile or temporary spaces, but there is a real shortage at the moment of dedicated workspaces for artists.
We support over 1,000 artists through the scheme we run. We fund nearly 30 workspaces in 16 counties, but according to the most recent research we carried out, 41% of those artists identified that they did not have security of tenure beyond a two-year period. Those are just not the conditions for anyone to work in. They are literally trying to make work while at the forefront of their mind they are thinking how long they will be based there. There are other associated issues, such as storage and the scale of work, that obscure what artists and creatives want to do which is to make work.
For us, funding is an issue, but as we look into the further layers, it is about system change and looking at a better and more stable provision of spaces. We have some interesting and excellent models such as Wandesford Quay. It is one of the models that colleagues have spoken about where local authorities are doing a lot to provide spaces. However, this is in no way reaching the demand necessary and, as a result, creatives are at the whim of the commercial sector as well. Private landlords are great and fulfil a need, but creatives are being both priced and developed out of spaces.
There are interesting international models, such as the Creative Land Trust in London which was established in 2018-2019 as a necessary reaction to the issue around creatives and individuals being priced out. There are also agencies that could work in a way that advocates for those artists. They could have a more amplified role than just providing spaces alone, but we need to look at different models than the one that is here at the moment. We need to look at a blend of different models that meet the various needs. New graduates do not just need affordable spaces, they need cheap ones as well, so a multi-layered approach needs to be taken.
Coming back to an earlier point, a cross-departmental and cross-agency approach is the only way to achieve that. This might also lead into the whole issue of the strategy for infrastructure, which would lean heavily into that and build on the evidence we have. While the Arts Council does not have responsibility for capital funding, we have really been building up our muscle in that area and we have expertise and evidence on this that we are building all the time, not least through our sectoral engagement, so we are able to advise our line Department and others in this regard.
Comment on this
In relation what a strategy would look like, while we might not be able to predict that right now, it should certainly look like it is built on evidence and have a multi-stakeholder approach and a long-term vision that identifies the short-, medium- and long-term needs. In our role as a prescribed body in the Planning and Development Act, one of the things the Arts Council did was make submissions on county and city development plans in 2022-2023. One of the recommendations we had in those submissions was that local authorities look at their own cultural audit as well because that changes over time. One of the members asked if population is a consideration for new arts centres. It is potentially, but there are such a range of models. For example, look at Áras Éanna out on Inis Oírr.
It did not drive that. It was the uniqueness of the place and the opportunity it presented. There are lots of ways of looking at these things, but the evidence, driven by local government as well, is really important. They know their places, their areas and their need very well.
Comment on this
I have a final question. It was mentioned in some of the submissions about the film industry being part of arts and culture. It plays a huge role, specifically in Wicklow. Should we be looking at the ones benefiting from the section 481 tax break that they would be levied in some way to provide a fund for the arts and culture community? They are getting a huge 32% tax break and we are asking to have a levy on them so funds go back into the communities that produce everything they need for their films. It is only being recycled as a potential revenue stream because the industry is getting the big 32% tax break which cost €177 million last year.
Comment on this
As Ms O'Callaghan said, a mixed model approach might be the one to take to examine opportunities like that and what they might look like. To research something like that and see if it was possible might be interesting.
Comment on this
I had forgotten to mention that point.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for their presentations. Their reports and contributions have helped with fact finding and been really informative. I know the rapporteur and committee will formulate a report based on the information the witnesses have brought forward. I thank them all for travelling short and long distances to be here and I wish them all a safe journey home. I thank the rapporteur and my colleagues who are still present: Senators Casey, Keogan, Black and Mullen. I also thank Denise and Mark on my right and the stenographers and sound people in front of me who have made today possible. We will be in touch again once the report is finalised.