Vote 26 - Department of Education and Skills (Supplementary)
Contributions 146–300 of 300. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Not now but the Tánaiste can come back to us.
Comment on this
It will be of interest to all members. Perhaps the Tánaiste's officials could give it to the clerk and then it can be circulated to members. We want an up-to-date report on the smart school, smart technology plan.
Comment on this
On each of the targets, there is an executive summary and there are targets which I think were agreed by the Minister of the day. What is the position on each of those?
Comment on this
I understand that two thirds of it has been achieved.
Comment on this
The reasons are as I have outlined. The number of people going into apprenticeships has been reduced, savings have been achieved in the procurement of training programmes and there have been price savings on training allowances.
Comment on this
I understand that 700 FÁS apprentices cannot get qualifications because they have lost their jobs or cannot get training anywhere else.
Comment on this
We introduced the redundant apprenticeship scheme. The ESB, the Air Corps and some of the large organisations have been in a position to participate in that programme to help apprentices complete their education. We also introduced the rotation scheme. If an employer had a student who was going into the academic side, we would pay that employer to take on a person who was coming out of the academic side and help him or her go through the programme. We have the apprenticeship scheme for redundant apprentices, the rotation apprenticeship scheme and some public sector people have agreed to take on a number of these apprentices to complete their apprenticeship.
Comment on this
That is not enough. Redundant apprentices are in an extremely difficult position. While I bow to the Tánaiste's wisdom, they inform me that if they go into the Air Corps module, notwithstanding its excellence, they are still not working on full-scale commercial aircraft. While they may technically qualify on apprenticeship, they will not be able to work on commercial aircraft because they have not finished their training on them. The question that has been put to me is whether the Department would consider liaising with Ryanair and Aer Lingus with a view to placing more apprentices there than at present. The case has been put to me that while the Air Corps system may be adequate, it will not get them employment.
Comment on this
I will have get some information from the Air Corps on this.
Comment on this
I go back about 20 years to the debacle in the Air Corps where it was training pilots and technicians and it could not keep them because they were all going into the private sector.
Comment on this
They were suitably qualified at that stage. I will have to go back to FÁS. Anyone in the private sector can come forward and provide training opportunities for these apprentices.
Comment on this
We had very good discussions with the Minister for Defence, Deputy Tony Killeen. We had to work through the process and ensure we had the right people with FÁS and his Department. I will revert back to the Deputy. I can only assume the qualification will be of the requisite standard to pass the examinations.
Comment on this
That point is given. The problem is that it does not get them employment because it is not commercial aircraft training per se. I am not taking from the Air Corps. I welcome and support everything it does. When apprentices visit my office they tell me this course will not help them get a job and that they will never be able to work on commercial aircraft.
Comment on this
Does the Tánaiste accept that 7,000 apprentices cannot complete their courses, or is the figure higher?
Comment on this
It is fewer than 7,000 at this stage on foot of the two new initiatives introduced.
Comment on this
We have also been able to assist whereby a number of employers abroad have taken on apprentices. I have been working with the Construction Industry Federation and we have asked contractors who have been able to get contracts abroad if they would take on young people who were prepared to work abroad on contracts. We have some success, albeit limited, but at least some success with a number of those companies. We are actively engaged with people in the marketplace, especially with contacts we had many years ago, seeking to ensure apprentices will be able to complete their apprenticeships. The number is fewer than 7,000.
Comment on this
It is important the Tánaiste would have it because I have been told the official figure is 7,000 but the actual figure could be as high as 10,000.
Comment on this
We have moved many of the apprentices through the system over the last while.
Comment on this
I know that, but these people are not getting training. Their previous experience in some cases is not recognised.
Comment on this
The harsh reality is that a huge number of people are in that programme and currently there are no jobs in that sector on the basis that 110,000 people in the construction sector have lost their jobs.
Comment on this
Many people in the industry are reluctant to take on anyone. That is why we brought in the rotation scheme on the basis that we would pay. We pay the employer-----
Comment on this
-----to take on these people. We are changing the new methodologies of traineeship of apprentices because on foot of union agreements, some apprentices get paid more than some people who have long-term experience. We are tied into the REAs and EROs in the case of apprenticeships. That is difficult for employers because they cannot afford to pay them. FÁS, on my behalf together with some officials in the Department, is working with the unions to examine whether a different mechanism can be found which would ensure an apprentice would be paid more than a married man with three children with 20 years' experience. In that way we could get more apprentices through the process. The way it is structured is ridiculous and does not work.
Many employers have come forward and have been more than helpful in facilitating us to get these young people educated and to enable them to complete their apprenticeships. They may need to convert their qualification later but they need their qualification at present even though it is difficult for them to get employment. We are actively examining new methodologies to try to get these young people through the system. The institutes of technology have been very helpful, as the Deputy will be aware, and have taken people into their institutes to enable them to complete their education. In that way we will be able to move people on.
We are reviewing the entire apprenticeship programme. I do not want there to be any loss in terms of the reputation or quality of the programme as it is excellent. We are one of the very few in the world that have such an intense and long programme. We are examining a new model and FÁS will come up with a new and better model of traineeship-apprenticeship that will be structured in such a way that participants will not spend as long in the apprenticeship model. While some participants spend six years in the apprenticeship model, all participants spend a minimum of four years in it.
Comment on this
The number of types of apprenticeships that people can pursue also needs to be increased.
Comment on this
We are changing that whole scenario.
Comment on this
There are a very limited number of apprenticeships. I would like the Tánaiste, through her officials, to revert-----
Comment on this
We will get the number and pass it on to the clerk to the committee.
Comment on this
One of the issues the Tánaiste brought to my attention was that in the past some employers took on apprentices but did not register them until they had been working with them for, say, six months. People who may have a very short time left technically to finish their apprenticeships find that their pre-apprenticeship work-----
Comment on this
-----for which they were paid an apprentice wage and on which they worked as part of their apprenticeship is not taken into account and they cannot complete their apprenticeship because they cannot get that 30 weeks' work experience somewhere else. I am referring only to people who have been employed as apprentices in a transparent manner and who would have worked on the job. Will the Tánaiste examine the position of those people?
Comment on this
We could only examine this on an individual basis-----
Comment on this
-----if it involved someone in particular. One must register with FÁS-----
Comment on this
-----in order that one can be supervised by FÁS.
Comment on this
If there is an individual case, we can-----
Comment on this
I refer only to cases where the people were trained and worked and it was transparent and accepted that they did that work. If they have done that work and were paid as such-----
Comment on this
FÁS tries to be as flexible as possible but it also gets criticised for being flexible.
Comment on this
If there is a particular case, it could be considered on an individual basis and we would definitely ask the head of the apprenticeships to contact the Deputy directly if the Deputy has the name of the person concerned.
Comment on this
Sure. FÁS has had an underspend of funding. I understand the future skills task force - the Tánaiste can correct me if I am wrong on this - identified that approximately 180,000 people need to be up-skilled from level 3 up.
Comment on this
Given the current economic climate and the great number of people unemployed, it is amazing that FÁS is not spending enough money on those courses. Why is more money not being spent on up-skilling people? Is there a roadblock to doing that?
Comment on this
The harsh reality is that we had to change the emphasis in FÁS from training in employment to training the unemployed. Skillnets has done the same. In some cases it has worked very well and in others it has not worked as well. The synergy between unemployed people and employed people working together has worked out very well and people who were unemployed have obtained employment from the programme. We had to change. We had to take a 360 degree turn away from training people in employment. Under the national skills strategy we have achieved a considerable amount and the percentage of those in the labour force with higher education qualifications has increased from 33% to 39%. The target is 48%. We still have a way to go to reach that target. On levels 4 and 5, the percentage has remained at 40% and the target is 45%, and at levels 1 to 3 the target is the other way around. We want it to fall from 27%, which is level we are at, to 21%, so our target is a 7% reduction. In other words, we want to take people out of the system.
Although there has been progress, there is a challenge because the focus has been on training those who are unemployed. A number of small pilot projects have worked well whereby we have had people in existing employment and, through training programmes, we have been able to keep them in work instead of them having to be laid off work for two days. That has helped build their capacity.
I will give the Deputy a good example in this respect. A company in Shannon was going to have to lay off a considerable number of employees. We worked with FÁS on a pilot project to train these people on the two days they were going to be laid off and they reconfigured the work among themselves to ensure everyone would keep his or her other job. This year they had to increase their employment. Training in employment is important and up-skilling is very important. We have not discontinued the programme but we have had to convert our resources to focus on those who are unemployed. I hope that when we get through this difficulty we will refocus back. That would be part of the parameters of FÁS under the national skills strategy and the implementation of the plan. We will work to achieve the target of 48% for those at levels 6 to 10 in the labour force, a target of 45% for those at levels 4 to 5 and a target of a 7% reduction for those at the other levels.
Comment on this
There is underspend of €21 million in FÁS this year yet a vast cohort of people need to be up-skilled.
Comment on this
As the Deputy will be aware, when I appointed a new board and a new chief executive, I told them I wanted to cut any unwarranted expenditure and they have increased savings hugely for the Department. Huge savings have been made on the basis of getting good value for money and also in dealing with the issue of apprenticeships. We have had to convert matters, and rightly so. When this crisis hit in 2008, we had to ensure people stayed close to the labour market and we had to keep people motivated. There was a good deal of criticism of there being short courses as against long courses, and I can appreciate there being such criticism. When I was in the former Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation, the Secretary General had a different perspective to me but we had to do this. We had to get people motivated and to connect with the labour force.
Although we continue to have those short courses, the emphasis now is on more medium to long-term courses, new conversion-type courses and different types of courses. PLC colleges and FÁS are running beauty therapy courses but one is enough to do that. FÁS's new strategy is to work with the further education sector to streamline who does what. Nobody should be a hostage to fortune on this. That work is ongoing in the Department so that one will go to one place if one wants to be a hairdresser or a beauty therapist and to another if one wants to do the ECDL. One should go to wherever the competencies are. That will provide even more savings because we will streamline things.
Comment on this
A fine, a tax or whatever one wants to call it is being imposed under the four year plan. If one wants to go to a PLC college, one will have to pay €200 to do a course whereas if one goes to FÁS, one will not have to pay it.
Comment on this
This is where the work is ongoing.
Comment on this
From talking to people involved in PLC colleges, a significant number who go to them are unemployed, are trying to up-skill and to get back into the workforce. They do not have that money.
Comment on this
People who are entitled to a grant will get one for the PLC college.
Comment on this
No, they will not. We will pay the fee.
Comment on this
The Department will pay the fee by way of the grant.
Comment on this
It will apply to people who are not eligible for the grant. Those in receipt of the back to education allowance will not have to pay the fee either. It is exactly the same as the higher level grant.
Comment on this
Does the Minister see a new role for vocational education and training - in other words, a new synergy between VECs and FÁS and new line up there?
Comment on this
Yes. I have that lined up. We have two or three people on the board with expertise in this area. They have come from the VEC sector. We are streamlining the situation because it is ridiculous.
One of the criticisms we all face as Deputies is that people do not know where to go. We will now have one place. If one wants to do a certain course, one will go to a particular place. We will not differentiate. There is excellence in both sectors and they have both been very flexible in dealing with the needs of the economy but we will streamline the situation in such a way that we will not have a doubling and trebling of course provision in the same parish not to mention the same town.
Comment on this
One of the criticisms of FÁS by the OECD was that there was not adequate contact with the long-term unemployed - in other words, that contact should increase the longer one is unemployed.
Comment on this
That is happening. The European model of labour activation measures is different from ours. The OECD gave a number of directions when I was in the former Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment on new ways in which labour activation measures should take place. One of the criticisms was that there was a disincentive for some people who found themselves unemployed to go on courses or to get work.
That is why under the new model in the Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2010, on which Deputy O'Dowd might have spoken, we are changing the interaction between the State and client. This is to be client-focused. We will have a service delivery model where one will establish an entitlement to jobseeker's benefit or whatever but interaction will take place at that time in regard to one's career path. One will be supported to go into training, a job or whatever. The criticism was that people were left languishing for three or four months before the national employment action plan went through. There was no interaction.
Under this new legislation the Minister for Social Protection will be in a position to create a better synergy. That is the model used in France, Germany and in the United Kingdom. When I was in the former Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment, we looked at how that model could be adopted in Ireland.
We are now asking the client how we can help him or her to get a job or be trained. We are saying that in the meantime, he or she has an entitlement. The psyche must change from what one is entitled to followed three months later by what one will do. When there is that greater interaction, there is less fraud. There have been situations where people who did not have an entitlement disappeared. That must take place more quickly and is why the national employment action plan has changed from six months to three months to even less.
That is where we will target people, in particular those under 35 years of age. Different types of people are coming in who never knew where the Department of Social Protection was. They have a different need from those who might be accustomed to part-time working or whatever. That is very much the strength of the new model, which is the right way to go. There has been an appreciation in the House that it is the right thing to do. FÁS will provide the training. There will also be private colleges, third level institutes and further education.
Comment on this
Could we have a copy of the savings or the headings in FÁS where the €21 million has not been spent? I would not have a problem if the Minister sent it to the committee secretariat.
Comment on this
The savings are on the apprenticeship programme - €5 million-----
Comment on this
-----services to business - €2 million, integration supports - €2.7 million, employment schemes - €3 million and training for employment - €15 million.
Comment on this
I will get a copy for the Deputy.
Comment on this
I do not understand how €5 million was saved on apprenticeships. It does not make sense.
Comment on this
It does. It is a demand-led programme.
Comment on this
This is the beginning and not the end. The demand has gone down from 2009 and there has been a shortfall of approximately 7%. In other words, we put in an allocation for the apprenticeships last year but the demand has gone down more than we anticipated and the saving is €5 million as a consequence. The number of people going into an apprenticeship programme has gone down.
Comment on this
Yes, but that is not this money. This money is for people going into apprenticeships.
Comment on this
The number of people who came into the first phase is down by 7% on the 2009 figure which was down considerably on the previous year.
Comment on this
Where are they? They are nowhere. They are still in apprenticeships. They are still on FÁS's book.
Comment on this
It has nothing to do with the €5 million. That is an expenditure issue. Their issue is an employment one.
Comment on this
Their issue is they cannot get a job and, in some cases, their training is inadequate.
Comment on this
The Deputy does not seem to understand what I am saying.
Comment on this
When I did the Estimate last year, I allocated a certain amount of money for those who will go into apprenticeships. Due to the economic climate, there has been a reduction in the number of people expected to take up apprenticeships, which is equal to €5 million. That is from where the savings is coming. The second saving of €2 million is coming from the competency development programme which I am winding down. That was a matter of real controversy in the House for some time. That programme will be closed, so that money will be saved.
I refer to integration supports. That is mainly on the basis of the local employment service and the employment schemes. There have been some savings on activities in regard to the job initiative scheme which has been closed for many years. We are working through it and as people leave, there is a consequential saving. In addition, we reduced the allowance and this has also been factored into the saving.
The position with regard to training for employment is broadly in line with the forecast we made. Savings were made on a number of programmes, particularly the specific skills programme, mainly as a result of reductions in training allowances, travel and subsistence costs, start-up costs and contract fees. The costs have decreased considerably and to an even greater extent than was the case at this time last year. We made our decisions at that stage on the basis of what we would have expected and would already have seen in 2009. There is a €10 million saving on training for employment activity. This relates mainly to training in community training centres.
The market has changed to a major extent and it continues to become more competitive. Consequently, we are obtaining greater value for money through FÁS. The reduction in the allowances is working through the system and is giving rise to savings. Another factor is that fewer people are entering the apprenticeship programme. It is in these areas that savings have been made in FÁS expenditure.
The Deputy inquired about redundant apprentices. I will obtain the figures in that regard and forward them to him. This is a very difficult time for FÁS but we are actively engaged in trying to obtain positions for the apprentices to whom the Deputy refers so that they might complete their training programmes. We will continue our work in this regard.
Comment on this
I acknowledge the facts which have been provided to the Tánaiste. I will not labour the point but there is something wrong when €5 million relating to apprenticeship training remains unspent and 7,000 apprentices cannot complete their training. The Tánaiste appears to be stating that money allocated under one subheading cannot be spent under another.
Comment on this
Let us be clear, the Tánaiste stated that the €5 million which remains unspent relates to the point of intake.
Comment on this
Yes, the €5 million saving is for first-----
Comment on this
I could transfer that money into the redundant apprentices scheme but there are not any employers to whom I can pay it.
Comment on this
As already stated, we are actively engaged in the marketplace in the context of trying to-----
Comment on this
I have been in contact with someone who employs large numbers of apprentices throughout the country and who stated that the rules must be changed.
Comment on this
I am referring to the rules relating to apprentices. The individual with whom I was in contact spoke about a new way of considering how 7,000 people-----
Comment on this
The Tánaiste should allow me to conclude. The key point is that 7,000 people are in limbo and that there is €5 million available which could have been allocated in respect of them. I am of the view that this matter is not being tackled in an adequate fashion. This is a serious problem and it is unacceptable that the money to which I refer has not been spent on trying to resolve it.
Comment on this
I have explained the position five times and I do not intend to explain it again.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste will have to provide an explanation to the 7,000 apprentices who are in limbo at present.
Comment on this
If the Deputy ever has the honour to sit on this side of the table, he will then know the score. The position is that I allocated a certain amount of money to FÁS last year in respect of new apprentices. Some 7% fewer apprentices actually entered the system in the intervening period. It was as a result of this that the saving was made.
The position with regard to the apprenticeship and rotation schemes is that adequate funding is available through FÁS's budget - and under the new scheme - to pay employers who provide apprentices who have not yet completed their training programmes with the opportunity to do so. The issue that arises is that there is a lack of employment opportunities - even on the schemes currently in place - for the apprentices in question. All of the members of the various FÁS teams and I are actively engaged in the marketplace in an attempt to obtain as many places as possible to allow these redundant apprentices to complete their training programmes. Our efforts in this regard are focused in both the private and public sectors. I met representatives of the County and City Managers Association to see if it could be of assistance. I also made inquiries with a number of contacts we have in certain countries throughout the world.
Another aspect of this matter is the fact that training must be authenticated by FÁS and assessed as being deliverable. An expense arises in this regard but I am prepared to pay that money in order that the people in question can complete their training. The rules, etc., relating to a new traineeship scheme are being negotiated with the unions at present. The person to whom the Deputy referred is probably of the view, and rightly so, that being tied into to EROs and JLCs acts as a deterrent for a number of employers in the context of taking on apprentices. We are working with the unions to change the system.
FÁS's level of interaction with employers is superb when it comes to the apprenticeship schemes. We have listened to what the employers are saying and we are trying to change the system. However, I am obliged to get the unions on boards in order to facilitate this. That is proving quite difficult but it is the correct thing to do. The review of the various schemes is taking place under the national recovery plan and is being co-ordinated by the Minister of State, Deputy Calleary. If we can change the system, it will provide employers with a better incentive to take on apprentices. There is a financial issue that arises. Under the new service programmes we are going to deliver through FÁS, we are going to provide a new traineeship programme which will prove to be excellent. This programme will gain a great reputation and will involve apprentices spending fewer years in training and there will also be fewer stages to be completed. That is the current position.
We are working with employers in the public and private sectors to progress matters. We are pushing hard with the public sector. The Deputy will appreciate that if Louth County Council let a certain number of people go and proceeded to bring others onto schemes, the unions would be up in arms and an issue relating to displacement would arise. At teaching level and in the context of apprenticeships, I am trying to stress that these are difficult times, that we are operating in a new environment and that we should allow the apprentices in question to complete their training in order that they will have an opportunity to obtain employment. When they obtain their certification, they will be in a position to use it as a pathway to the next stage. We will continue to be extremely active in this regard because it is the right thing to do.
Comment on this
Would it be possible to provide greater subsidies to employers in order that they might provide opportunities for the 7,000 apprentices who cannot complete their training? Could we increase amount paid to employers to make it more attractive for them to either retain or take on apprentices? If the subsidy was increased, the cost to employers would be reduced. They could pay apprentices the same wages as now but the Department could subsidise the remainder. As I understand it, such apprentices have no future at all.
Comment on this
I do not believe any Deputy or Senator should state that young people have no future. That is neither fair not right.
Comment on this
The people in question are excellent individuals and-----
Comment on this
I am asking the Tánaiste a question. She should not try to attribute to me words which I did not utter. Regardless of whether she likes it - I certainly do not like it - 7,000 people have no future as apprentices because they cannot obtain employment to complete their training. That is what I said. If the problem is that employers cannot pay the rate which applies in respect of third or fourth-year apprentices, will the Tánaiste not provide a subsidy so that employers can pay wages at a reduced rate? This would allow the 7,000 apprentices to complete their training and have some hope for the future. These individuals will have no future if they cannot obtain their qualifications.
Comment on this
We have discussed this matter for a considerable period.
Comment on this
We have until 1.30 p.m. to put questions to the Tánaiste. I apologise if we have been dealing with this matter for a considerable period but I am of the view that it is worth discussing.
Comment on this
With respect, the Deputy does not appear to understand anything I am saying. I do not disagree with him in respect of the necessity of ensuring that people complete their education. That is I have been active in the marketplace - in conjunction with FÁS - in respect of progressing the rotation scheme and providing other supports. The harsh reality is that employers do not exist.
Comment on this
How can one have a situation where 110,000 lost their jobs in the construction sector and expect them to be taken on? That does not make sense. We are financially supporting employers to complete the projects. It is difficult because many of the people on the rotation scheme have their own apprentices and may not be able to keep them on. They may have to let them go and this is difficult for employers. We are working with the private and public sectors to allow these people to complete their education. We have travelled abroad to the UK and Germany, in particular, where we had apprentices many years ago and we have an authentic way in which we can ensure these people are qualified.
When they do their apprenticeship, not only does the academic work have to be supervised, the practical work has also to be adjudicated on. We are doing this with the practical work but we do not want a scenario such as that raised by the Deputy where some unfortunate person who was not registered on time or who was not supervised cannot secure the requisite number of weeks for authentic certification. We do not want that to happen. We are working closely with employers on this. There has been no restriction whatsoever on FÁS's budget in this regard.
I will raise the Air Corps issued referred to by the Deputy. Its apprenticeships should have the same-----
Comment on this
That is something we could look at. We are working with employers and we asked others in the airline industry whether they would take on some of these people in order that they could finish their qualifications. That is part of the work we are currently involved in. I asked local authorities, although it is difficult for them as well because there are issues with displacement, to see whether there is any way these apprentices can complete their projects. The ESB came forward with a considerable number of places for redundant apprentices and we are working towards that. A number of other private people are out on a daily basis on my behalf and the Deputy's behalf working to allow that happen. This is not a financial issue. There is no capacity in the economy to help these people complete their projects. A great deal of pressure was put on me to allow these young people to go to Australia to finish their apprenticeships, although I am favourably disposed if they would like to do that. One of the issues that has arisen is the qualification and certification in Australia is totally different from ours and it will take time to work through this.
When I was on a trade mission to Canada, I met a number of people, particularly in western Canada, who were anxious to take on apprentices, particularly in the gas industry. It is difficult, unfortunately, because we do not have the same qualification rigour as the Canadians but we are working to see if there are opportunities, even if means only ten or 20 people can go to Canada to get that experience. We are, therefore, actively trying to work through the system.
Comment on this
I wish to clarify that members are not obliged to continue asking questions until 1.30 p.m.
Comment on this
I want to avoid repetition. We need to have questions on the Estimate before we conclude.
Comment on this
A total of 4,000 apprentices who were made redundant are in these programmes and 7,000 are not. We have successfully established opportunities for 4,000 apprentices and that is important for them. We will not lose sight of the others who need to be supported.
Comment on this
That is the stark reality. It would be helpful if the Minister provided us with an analysis at our next meeting of the progress outlining the categories, the issues arising and the strategies that could help these people. The Minister said some employers cannot take on apprentices in their fourth year because they cannot afford their pay but they can take on someone on a lower income who does not have the same skills. They would prefer to have the fourth year guy but they cannot afford him. Can the Minister consider strategies for this cohort, which would result in the Department giving increased payments to the employers?
Comment on this
The payments are expensive as it is.
Comment on this
I acknowledge that but how will these people finish otherwise? Some of them have cars and so on and they incur expense travelling to a job. Some are married and have families.
Comment on this
The Department pays the employers €250 a week.
Comment on this
I do not deny that but there is a problem and if it helps an employer to take on Johnny Murphy and he finishes his apprenticeship, it would be worth it. I would be happy if the Minister examined this issue.
Comment on this
We are considering every idea. We have had a number of discussions at this and other committees about how to address this. Nobody has an answer to everything and that is why we are examining new initiatives. Over the past two years, 4,000 people have been placed in programmes. We are considering as many options as we can and we will continue to do that because we want to ensure all these people complete their programmes in order that at least they will have their certification, which is a necessity to get a job. We have an over supply issue until all the programmes are worked through. We have an over-supply of apprentices and a lack of opportunities.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Dowd said he would be happy if the Minister examined the issue and she said will not lose sight of this as an issue.
Comment on this
I accept that but I would like her to come back to the committee with a deeper analysis from FÁS, including the comments of programme managers and an outline of the issues and how they can be dealt with.
Comment on this
A committee in FÁS is working on this and interacting with my officials on the new apprenticeship and training programmes.
Comment on this
I welcome that and I would welcome a detailed analysis by those at principal officer level of the issues and what can be done to address them.
Comment on this
Everybody accepts it is an important issue and considerable time has been devoted to it. Are there questions on the Supplementary Estimate?
Comment on this
There are many issues relating to FÁS and FETAC about which I would like to ask the Minister but I will put them to her next week. I appreciate she may not necessarily be briefed on all of them. The reply to the parliamentary question I tabled about FÁS, FETAC and their relationship did not indicate that she knew. I will wait until next week.