We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Select Committee on Housing, Planning and Local Government

Residential Tenancies (Amendment) (No. 2) Bill 2018: Committee Stage

Contributions 395–596 of 596. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Residential Tenancies (Amendment) (No. 2) Bill 2018
Enacted

No. 140 of 2018 ›

Many of us argued for this in amendments when the legislation was originally introduced in 2016. I am delighted that, three years on, the Minister is catching up with the Opposition.

Comment on this

I will take that.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 18 is in the name of Deputy Boyd Barrett.

Comment on this

I do not think substantial refurbishments justify higher rents because rents are completely out of control at the moment and we should not allow any other mechanisms for rents to be raised over and above where they are. I do not think that doing things to an apartment or other property that need to be done should justify massive rent increases. Rents are not set at affordable levels and the Government is doing nothing to set them at affordable levels. Other amendments of mine will deal with other aspects of the problem but we should not provide any mechanism for landlords to put up rents that are already excessive, extortionate and unaffordable.

Comment on this

A number of amendments are linked but we are opposing them because we have our own amendments to bring forward. If a landlord did a substantial refurbishment to their property they were able to cite that as grounds for getting outside the RPZ provisions. People were concerned that this was being used for renovations and as an excuse to get people out so that they could jack up the rent and the RTB issued guidance to landlords so that landlords would know how not to break the law or breach rights. This Bill brings forward a definition of substantial refurbishment and we are bringing forward an amendment to further improve the definition and make sure it is watertight. We do not want to allow our rental stock to fall into disrepair over a number of years by giving no incentive for a landlord to invest in a property. We do not want to stop people from improving their properties, such as by providing extra bedrooms to accommodate more people, by ensuring they will not get their money back for the investment they have made. If a landlord spends €30,000, €40,000 or €50,000 to convert a garage into an additional room, maybe a play room, a TV room or a bedroom, but the tenancy agreement states they can only increase rent by 4% in an RPZ, they should be able to step outside the RPZ provisions because they should certainly be able to charge extra rent for another person in the property. We want to avoid unintended consequences that prevent or dissuade landlords from investing in their properties so that we keep stock up as time goes by.

Comment on this

I get the thinking behind extensions from two to three bedrooms with a genuine and significant expansion of the space but, as I understand the Minister's proposal, modifications to more than 50% of the floor space would be covered.

Comment on this

Substantial change is defined as works that consist of a permanent extension that increases the floor area by 25% or where three of four things happen, which are raising the BER by two points; adding an extra room; making a change in the internal layout of the home; or an adaptation to allow for disability access. If landlords do that they can put in an application to the RTB, signed off by a registered professional such as an architect or surveyor as to the extent of the work, and they can then increase the rent by more than 4%. The work would necessitate a person vacating a property so it is something significant.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister for the clarification and it does improve matters so I will consider it again between now and Report Stage. If a property is at the lower end of the BER ratings, a jump by two points would not be very difficult and the box could be ticked relatively easily. It is different at the top levels.

Comment on this

We have an amendment later which will propose that, to be deemed significant, there should be two criteria for BER improvements. One should be that it goes to the top two categories and the other is that it should jump three points. That is a tighter way of doing it and will ensure it will genuinely make a difference, rather than simply ticking a box.

I can see potential for messing in regard to the internal layout. I believe they are doing this across the road from me at the moment. I do not think there will be any substantial change to the size of the apartments in question but I am certain they are going to ask to go beyond the RPZ limits. I would be highly surprised, however, if anything dramatic has changed but they might manage to get through these tests.

Comment on this

We are talking about a permanent change internally. In addition, they would not be able to get around building control standards for the minimum size of a room, for example, by putting a wall between two bunk beds or something like that.

Comment on this

In respect of the Minister's amendments I am, in principle, in favour of a statutory definition of substantial refurbishments. That was always our position and, while I liked the version in the original Bill on account of it being so restrictive, we have to deal with the amendments in front of us.

I have a couple of technical questions. The criteria for an extension are straightforward and they seem sensible. The creation of an extra room has to be within existing building regulations but one could imagine a person subdividing one room into two and, so long as the two rooms met the regulations for adequate room size, the work constituting substantial refurbishment, even though the financial cost of subdividing a room into two would not be very significant. How can the Minister satisfy the committee that the provision cannot be abused?

I share Deputy Boyd Barrett's concern about the building energy rating, BER. Anything that incentivises and pushes landlords to raise BERs is important. It is a minimal cost to improve from the lowest grades. If something is already at a high grade, going up a point or two might not necessarily cost a significant sum. I like the principle of finding a mechanism but I am not sure what the Minister has is adequate. I do not have a better option for him but it is something that he could look at between now and Report Stage.

This gets tricky when it relates to changes in internal layout. What kind of guidance will be given to the RTB or to the local authority to make it clear what kinds of changes would fall within this proposal? Likewise with adaptation works, it is a very general proposition. If there are substantial renovation works to assist disability adaptability, that is really good but it could include a relatively minimal level of change, such as ramps and rails, which would raise a question.

All of these works we are talking about already enable landlords to write off the capital costs against their tax liabilities, albeit at 12.5% over a year. I am not proposing this but I know that Deputy Casey had a good discussion with the Minister at a previous meeting about a financial threshold. Working a financial threshold into legislation is very clumsy and I am not proposing that but I think for any of us to justify a threshold to excuse somebody from the rent pressure zones, it has to be over and above the ordinary renovations one would expect landlords to be doing, which they can write off against their tax liability anyway.

I am not opposed in principle to what the Minister is proposing but there is a lot of convincing to be done that what is currently in front of us is tight enough not to open up another area of abuse. This will be more tricky to abuse than the current scheme but the questions I am asking are genuine in intent.

Comment on this

I also have concerns about the BER because of the lack of a high minimum grade. That allows scope for abuse. It is very easy to fluctuate by two grades. What measures has the Minister developed to ensure changing grades are monitored correctly and certified? Will certification be overseen by the RTB alongside the SEAI? I will discuss it later since amendment No. 28 addresses it but I ask the Minister to give further consideration to that.

Comment on this

Where a landlord seeks to invoke this exemption, the rent will not be treated as a small thing. A number of different documents will have to be lodged to prove the landlord has done it. I understand the concerns about whether a landlord might address just the BER or the layout. A combination of three of the four factors I laid out would have to be accomplished, or a 25% extension to the floor space. I understand the point about the BER jumping by two points. What if a landlord was doing something significant that was not disability adaptation, but changed the layout, added an extra room and went up by a BER grade, but could not go up by three points because it might take the property beyond A1 or maybe to A1, which might not be seen as necessary and the landlord might not want to incur the costs? If it were just two points on the BER scale, if it is coming from a low BER, simple insulation in the attic might address that and I would be concerned about it.

The RTB issued guidance about what it would consider to be a change of layout, renovation and such. I will refer to that briefly. When we talk about a change of layout or structural alteration, those include attic conversion, garage conversion, the change of a ground floor bedroom to improve the layout of a property and so on. We are not talking about changing tiles on the floors but about the movement of walls to create rooms. An example I gave earlier is turning a garage into living space, whether a bedroom, a playroom, a living room or even a kitchen. That is significant work. We talked about some of the investments that might be made to improve the BER. Attic insulation is not very expensive but cavity wall or dry lining can be, as can external wall insulation. Maybe the boiler, the pipework, the radiators or the cylinder are being replaced or maybe one is doing the windows and doors. Those types of investment are expensive but we are not asking for them to be done on their own. They have to meet three of the four criteria or a 25% extension. They then have to have surveyors and architects sign off and give documentation to the RTB which will then adjudicate and state that the clause has been invoked in the right way.

We think it is a vast improvement on not having a definition. We came with a definition because the committee looked for a definition. In the conversations we have had at the committee about the previous definition, some of the problems we and others saw in the definition were highlighted, and we have now come with what we think is a more robust definition.

Comment on this

I take the point that it is an improvement and the Minister is genuinely trying to put in safeguards. It may merit a little more thought and consideration of the detail on all sides. We have to look at certain test cases. One could go into that apartment block across the road from me to see what that company has put in for. It would be interesting to see. I am certain that what it is doing is to try to have a higher than 4% rent increase. Judging from what I can see from the outside, there definitely will not be an increase in space. We shall see whether that passes muster. What we propose is a little tighter.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 19 is in the name of the Minister. I think the majority of this has been discussed.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 17, 19 and 23 to 25, inclusive, all relate to the same issue.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Boyd Barrett want to discuss amendment No. 24?

Comment on this

It is on the same lines. I will consider what the Minister has said and we will possibly come back to it.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Boyd Barrett wish to discuss No. 26?

Comment on this

Amendment No. 27 is in the name of Deputy Jan O'Sullivan, who is not present, and it falls. Amendment No. 28 is in the name of Deputy Catherine Martin.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 28 seeks to improve how the Bill addresses BER by requiring it to be improved by at least three grades, bringing the dwelling to a minimum of a C1 rating. I am aware of what the Minister is proposing in amendment No. 25. Requiring a minimum of two grades would not involve extensive change and a landlord could fluke an increase like that with very little change. BER can even improve on its own since grading was different 12 years ago due to the intensity of fossil fuels in our energy system. I ask the Minister to give it further consideration and strengthen it. I think it is open to abuse. I know amendment No. 25 is tied in with others. I hope to get this right and am looking for this to be increased by at least three grades, to bring the dwelling to a minimum of a C1 rating.

Comment on this

On the issue of a minimum of a C1 rating, some buildings will never reach it because of their age. I am informed that the Custom House is such a building and that one could never get it up to a C1 rating. I am reluctant to tie it to a specific grade but we can look at whether we can have a requirement of three points if it is at a certain grade, or of two points if it is at another grade, and to have a gradient to it rather than a jump of two points each time. I will look at that between now and Report Stage.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 29 is in the name of Deputy Boyd Barrett.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 30 is in the name of Deputy Darragh O'Brien.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 30 is on the same matter that we were trying to introduce and which we spoke about in private session, namely, capping it on the basis of a financial contribution. That option is still there, and while I know the Minister said it could not work, the home incentive scheme has worked quite well, where a list of permitted enabling works is given and a financial minimum that can be spent is put on it. Some of these works can be carried out without affecting the tenant, especially when it comes to the building energy rating, BER. Many of us have lived in our homes when we have had major renovation works carried out and there was no issue. By adding the financial limit to it, along with listing the works that are permitted, it simplifies it a bit. We seem to get very technical in everything we are doing instead of saying that we can increase the energy efficiency, improve disability access, improve wiring and so on, but it must have a certain minimum value. That was the general opinion I felt at the time, and while the Minister said it was not operational, the home incentive scheme has worked very well in the sense that every contractor who is doing it has to be tax compliant and they have to go through the processing, log it online, and away they go. It is an option that we have put on the table and it could and should still be considered, although the Minister has other evidence from what I have.

Comment on this

It was a very good idea and we did consider it when it was raised in the previous session. The home incentive scheme is a bit different because it is a person's home, so perhaps there is a different incentive base working there.

Comment on this

I am just talking about the principle, I am not talking about-----

Comment on this

I know, and we had a lengthy discussion about a rules-based or principles-based approach to these matters. Here we are very much falling down on the rules because a principles-based approach was too open to interpretation. Where we came down with regard to the money issue was that it was more of a problem around verification, the potential to defraud, and that type of approach to it rather than the way we are going with it. We did not progress it any further, therefore. We looked at it but we came down in favour of our amendment.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 31 is in the name of Deputy Boyd Barrett.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 31 provides that if the landlord fails to comply with the regulations of the Act, he or she will be guilty of an offence and liable to a class A fine or a maximum of two years' imprisonment, or on conviction on indictment, a fine not exceeding €50,000 or imprisonment for a maximum of five years. That is basically getting tough with the landlords if they-----

Comment on this

Hang them by the neck until they are dead.

Comment on this

-----break the law or mess around. They will know it is a serious business.

Comment on this

Stocks outside Leinster House?

Comment on this

Our approach with this is that we have the stronger class A penalty applying under the new section 148S if someone obstructs the work of a Residential Tenancies Board, RTB, authorised officer in carrying out an investigation, but for the new section 19 offences, a class B offence is the approach that has been taken. That gives the potential for imprisonment for a term not exceeding six months or a fine up to €4,000 or both. If, after the summary conviction, the offence continues, a further offence is committed under the Residential Tenancies Acts on each day that such action or inaction continues. The class E fine applies then for each of the further offences. We believed that was proportional in using class A in the new section on obstruction of an RTB authorised officer's investigation and class B where an offence was committed under the new section 19 offences.

Comment on this

Let me just clarify this. Does this mean imprisonment in certain circumstances or not?

Comment on this

Yes, and potentially a fine as well if it is a class B offence, so they will do time.

Comment on this

Leaving joking about stocks aside, some of the cases we have had have been of horrific abuses by landlords and we do need severe penalties for the real rogues.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 32 is in the name of the Minister.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 32 is to change section 20 of the principal Act to extend for a further period, from 4 December 2019 to 31 December 2021, the restriction of rent reviews to occurring at most once every two years before reverting back to a yearly restriction. Essentially, because we are lengthening out rent pressure zones, RPZs, to 2021, outside of an RPZ the rent can only be reviewed every two years, and that continues to 2021 in line with the extension of RPZs.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 33 is in the name of the Minister.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 33 brings the 4% rent increase ceiling to an end on the same date as the end of the RPZs, namely, 2021.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 34 is in the name of the Minister.

Comment on this

Did we discuss amendment No. 15?

Comment on this

It is out of order.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 34 amends section 24B of the 2004 Act to provide that deeming Cork city, Dublin city, Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown, Fingal and South Dublin as RPZs expires on 31 December 2021.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 35 is in the name of the Minister.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 35 inserts a new section 24BA into the 2004 Act to provide that the administrative area of Cork City Council, which was deemed a rent pressure zone on 24 December 2016, includes the area transferring from Cork County Council to the city council on 31 May 2019. The Chairman will know that we increased the boundary for Cork, and it is just to make sure that Cork city, as it will be deemed from the end of May 2019, will all be covered under one RPZ.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 39 is in the name of Deputy Boyd Barrett.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 39 extends notice periods from 90 days to 180 days. I have pretty much made the case for this earlier so I will not repeat the argument, but particularly in the current circumstances and generally as well, we need to give people more time because being forced to leave one's home is a big deal, it often puts people in great difficulty, and they should be given the maximum amount of time possible to find alternative accommodation.

Comment on this

I cannot accept this amendment because it would essentially give six months' advance notice before a rent review, which is not necessary.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 17:

In page 6, to delete line 7 and substitute the following:

“(b) in subsection (5), by—

(i) the substitution of the following paragraph for paragraph (a):

“(a) to the rent first set under the tenancy of a dwelling, provided that no tenancy in respect of that dwelling subsisted during the period of 2 years immediately preceding the date on which the tenancy concerned commenced”,

and

(ii) the substitution, in subparagraph (ii) of paragraph (b), of “greater than” for “different to”,”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 18:

In page 6, to delete lines 8 to 37, and in page 7, to delete lines 1 to 6 and substitute the following:

“(c) by deleting subsection 5(b).”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 19:

In page 6, to delete lines 12 to 15 and substitute the following:

“(a) the works carried out to the dwelling concerned—

(i) consist of a permanent extension to the dwelling that increases the floor area (within the meaning of Article 6 of the Building Regulations 1997 (S.I. No. 497 of 1997)) of the dwelling by an amount equal to not less than 25 per cent of the floor area (within such meaning) of the dwelling as it stood immediately before the commencement of those works, or”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 20:

In page 6, to delete line 16 and substitute “(ii) result in any 3 or more of the following:”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 21:

In page 6, line 17, to delete “is” and substitute “being”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 22:

In page 6, line 18, to delete “is” and substitute “being”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 23:

In page 6, to delete line 21 and substitute the following:

“(III) a permanent increase in the number of rooms in the dwelling, or”.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 24 cannot be moved.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 25:

In page 6, to delete lines 22 to 26 and substitute the following:

“(IV) in the case of a dwelling to which the European Union (Energy Performance of Buildings) Regulations 2012 (S.I. No. 243 of 2012) apply, the BER (within the meaning of those Regulations) being improved by not less than 2 building energy ratings,”.

Comment on this

As amendment No. 25 has been agreed to, amendments Nos. 26 to 29, inclusive, cannot be moved.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 30 has been discussed with amendment No. 16. Does Deputy O'Brien wish to move the amendment?

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 31:

In page 7, line 19, after “offence” to insert the following:

"and liable—

(i) on summary conviction, to a class A fine or imprisonment for a term not exceeding 2 years or both, or (ii) on conviction on indictment, to a fine not exceeding €50,000 or imprisonment for a term not exceeding 5 years or both".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 32:

In page 7, between lines 30 and 31, to insert the following:

"Amendment of section 20 of Act of 2004

4. Section 20 of the Act of 2004 is amended—

(a) in subsection (5), by the substitution of “1 January 2022 and from that day” for “the day immediately before the fourth anniversary of the day on which section 25 of the Residential Tenancies (Amendment) Act 2015 came into operation and, on and from the first-mentioned day”, and

(b) in subsection (6), by the substitution of “31 December 2021” for “the day immediately before the fourth anniversary of the day on which that section came into operation".".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 33:

In page 7, between lines 30 and 31, to insert the following:

“Amendment of section 24A of Act of 2004

5. (1) Section 24A of the Act of 2004 is amended—

(a) in subsection (4), by the substitution of the following paragraph for paragraph(b):

“(b) the average rent (determined by reference to the information specified in paragraph (a)) in the area in respect of the 3 months to which the most recent Rent Index quarterly report applies is—

(i) in the case of the county of Kildare, the county of Meath, the county of Wicklow or a local electoral area in any one of those counties, above the average rent in the State (other than the Dublin Area) specified in that report, or

(ii) in the case of any—

(I) other county or local electoral area, or

(II) any city, city and county or local electoral area situated in such city or city and county,

above the average rent in the State (other than the Greater Dublin Area) specified in that report.”,

and

(b) in subsection (10), by the insertion of the following definitions:

“ ‘Dublin Area’ means—

(a) the city of Dublin, and

(b) the counties of South Dublin, Fingal and Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown;

‘Greater Dublin Area’ means—

(a) the Dublin Area, and

(b) the counties of Kildare, Wicklow and Meath;”.

(2) Notwithstanding subsection (5) of section 24A of the Act of 2004 or any order made thereunder, the period specified in any such order to be the period during which an area shall stand prescribed as a rent pressure zone shall expire on 31 December 2021.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 34:

In page 7, between lines 30 and 31, to insert the following:

"Amendment of section 24B of Act of 2004

6. Section 24B of the Act of 2004 is amended by the substitution of “during the period commencing on the relevant date and ending on 31 December 2021” for “from the relevant date for a period of 3 years".".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 35:

In page 7, between lines 30 and 31, to insert the following:

"Amendment of section 24 of Act of 2004

7. The Act of 2004 is amended by the insertion of the following section:

"Relevant area within meaning of Local Government Act 2019 deemed to be rent pressure zone

24BA. (1) For the purposes of section 24B, the administrative area of Cork City Council shall include the relevant area and, accordingly, the reference in that section to relevant date shall, in so far as that section applies to the relevant area, be construed as a reference to the transfer day.

(2) In this section—

'Act of 2019’ means the Local Government Act 2019;

‘relevant area’ has the meaning assigned to it by the Act of 2019; and

‘transfer day’ has the meaning assigned to it by the Act of 2019.".".

Comment on this

Did we discuss amendment No. 33, which deals with the new qualifying criteria for rent pressure zones?

Comment on this

It was discussed with amendment No. 16.

Comment on this

As I said, it deals with the new qualifying criteria. We are taking Dublin out of the picture. There will be two new qualifying criteria. The first is the greater Dublin area, excluding Dublin, plus the rest of the country to qualify in the greater Dublin area, and the second is the rest of the country, excluding the greater Dublin area, to qualify outside of the greater Dublin area.

Comment on this

Based on the analysis of the new qualifying criteria for everywhere outside of Dublin, which I presume the Minister or the RTB has done, what would be their impact or is it too early to say?

Comment on this

It is too early to say. I have seen data from the RTB and we also ran the numbers. For a while now, the committee has been calling for a review of the qualifying criteria. I have been engaged with the RTB on various pieces of work in that regard. Each scenario threw up different results. I wanted to come up with a change that was simple and would not confuse people such that both the landlord and tenant would know their rights. This is the one we chose. I do not have information with me on the likelihood of new areas qualifying but once Dublin is taken out of the equation, given how far ahead rent in the capital is, other areas start to come into RPZ designation quite quickly. I do not have information on the numbers or the areas to hand. I would not like to speculate on them.

Comment on this

I presume that once the legislation is enacted, the RTB would relatively quickly make recommendations and publish the new areas to be included.

Comment on this

The RTB has completed its quarter 4 rents index for 2018, on the back of which there were two new designations. If we get this legislation into law at the beginning of May, at some point in June the RTB will do the quarter 1 index for 2019 using the new criteria.

Comment on this

The existing rent pressure zones are based on local electoral areas. We have had some boundary changes, Cork being the most obvious. Where a boundary has changed but the RPZ designation was made under the earlier LEA boundary, does that have an impact? I accept the Minister might not be able to answer that question now. It is an issue that came up recently in conversation with my Cork colleagues. If he is not aware of the issue, perhaps he would have his officials examine it.

Comment on this

In regard to Cork and the city boundary change, two areas in the county were already covered by an RPZ but they have come into the city. It is a moot point because they were covered before and they are covered now.

Comment on this

There is another-----

Comment on this

Is there another recent change?

Comment on this

Yes. I do not have the detail with me but I will forward it to the Minister. Apparently, part of one LEA is currently in a rent pressure zone but it will no longer be in that LEA.

Comment on this

I bet it will be soon.

Comment on this

That could be the solution.

Comment on this

I know there are two areas in Cork that were covered and will still be covered. If there is a third area, perhaps the Deputy will forward me the details and I will have a look at them. Ballincollig and Carrigaline are the two areas that were already designated RPZs and will continue to be, even though they move in terms of the boundary for the city.

Comment on this

I will do that.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 33 has been agreed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 39:

In page 7, between lines 30 and 31, to insert the following:

"Amendment of section 22 of Act of 2004 - to extend the notice period for new rents to 180 days

4. Section 22 of the Act of 2004 is amended in subsection (2) by substituting "180 days" for "90 days".".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 40:

In page 7, between lines 33 and 34, to insert the following:

“Amendment of Table to section 34 of Act of 2004

5. (1) Section 34 of the Act of 2004 is amended, in paragraph (a), by—

(a) the deletion in subparagraph (i), of "and",

(b) the substitution of the following subparagraph for subparagraph (ii):

"(ii) the notice of termination cites as the reason for the termination the ground or grounds concerned and contains or is accompanied—

(I) in the case of paragraph 2, 5 or 6 of that Table, by the statement referred to in that paragraph, and

(II) in the case of paragraph 3 or 4 of that Table, by the statutory declaration referred to in that paragraph, and",

and

(c) the insertion of the following subparagraph:

"(iii) in the case of a notice of termination that cites as the reason for the termination the ground specified in paragraph 5, the notice of termination contains or is accompanied by a certificate in writing of a registered professional (within the meaning of the Building Control Act 2007) stating that—

(I) the proposed refurbishment or renovation works would pose a risk to the health or safety of the occupants of the dwelling concerned and should not proceed while the dwelling is occupied, and

(II) such a risk is likely to exist for such period as is specified in the certificate which shall not be less than 3 weeks,”.

(2) The Table to section 34 of the Act of 2004 is amended—

(a) in paragraph 3, by the substitution of "9 months" for "3 months",

(b) in clause (i) of subparagraph (b) of paragraph 4, by the substitution of "12 months" for "6 months",

(c) in subparagraph (b) of paragraph 5, by the substitution of the following clause for clause (i):

"(i) the dwelling becomes available for reletting by reason of the completion of the works of refurbishment or renovation, and",

and

(d) in clause (i) of subparagraph (b) of paragraph 6, by the substitution of "12 months” for "6 months".".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 41:

41. In page 7, between lines 33 and 34, to insert the following:

"Amendment of section 35 of Act of 2004

6. Section 35 of the Act of 2004 is amended—

(a) in subsection (5), by—

(i) the substitution of “paragraph (aa) of subsection (8) and paragraph 4(b), 5(b) and 6(b) of the Table” for “paragraph 4(b), 5(b) and 6(b) of the Table”, and

(ii) the insertion of “statutory declaration or” before “statement concerned”,

(b) in subsection (6), by the substitution of “paragraph (aa) of subsection (8), or paragraph 4(b), 5(b) or 6(b) of the Table,” for “paragraph 4(b), 5(b) or 6(b) of the Table",

(c) in subsection (8), by—

(i) the deletion, in paragraph (a), of “and”, and

(ii) the insertion of the following paragraph:

“(aa) a declaration that the landlord, by virtue of the notice, is required to offer to the tenant a tenancy of the dwelling if the following conditions are satisfied:

(i) the contact details requirement is complied with;

(ii) the landlord does not enter into an enforceable agreement of the type referred to in paragraph 3 of the Table within the period specified in that paragraph commencing—

(I) on the expiration of the period of notice required to be given under subparagraph (i) of paragraph (a) of section 34, or

(II) in circumstances where a dispute in relation to the validity of the notice is referred to the Board under Part 6 for resolution, on the final determination of that dispute;

and

(iii) the tenancy to which the notice relates has not otherwise been validly terminated by virtue of the citation in the notice of the ground specified in paragraph 1, 2 or 6 of the Table.",

and

(d) the insertion of the following subsection:

“(11) Where, in respect of a tenancy, a landlord serves on a tenant a notice of termination that cites, as a reason for the termination, a ground specified in the Table, the landlord shall—

(a) subject to paragraph (b), give a copy of the notice of termination to the Board not later than 3 months before the expiration of the period of notice given by the notice of termination, or

(b) in the case of a period of notice specified in the notice of termination of less than 3 months, give a copy of the notice of termination to the Board at the same time as he or she serves the notice on the tenant.".".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 43:

In page 7, between lines 33 and 34, to insert the following:

"Amendment of section 34 of Act of 2004

5. The Act of 2004 is amended by the deletion of paragraphs 3 and 5 of the Table to section 34.".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 49:

In page 7, between lines 33 and 34, to insert the following:

“Amendment of section 34 of Act of 2004 - to require landlords terminating a tenancy on the ground of needing the dwelling for occupation by the landlord or by a member of the landlord’s family to pay compensation to the tenant

5. (1) The Act of 2004 is amended in paragraph 4 of the Table to section 34 by the insertion after “his or her family” of “and has paid the tenant an amount equivalent to six months’ rent in respect of the tenancy as compensation for the termination of the tenancy”.

(2) The Act of 2004 is amended in paragraph 4 of the Table to section 34 by the insertion of the following subparagraph after subparagraph (b):

“(c) and that the landlord is obliged to pay the tenant an amount equivalent to six months’ rent in respect of the tenancy as compensation for the termination of the tenancy.".

(3) The Act of 2004 is amended by the deletion of paragraph 5 of the Table to section 34.".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 50:

In page 7, between lines 33 and 34, to insert the following:

"Amendment of section 34 of Act 2004

5. Section 34 of the Act of 2004 is amended by the deletion of paragraph 3 of the Table to that section.".

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put

Tá 2
·
Níl 5
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 51:

In page 7, between lines 33 and 34, to insert the following:

"Amendment of section 34 of Act 2004

5. Section 34 of the Act of 2004 is amended in paragraph 4 of the Table to that section by the deletion of "or for occupation by a member of his or her family and the notice of termination (the "notice") contains or is accompanied by a statutory declaration" and the substitution of "and the notice of termination (the "notice") contains or is accompanied, in writing, by a statement".".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 52:

In page 8, between lines 24 and 25, to insert the following:

"Amendment of section 56 of Act of 2004

7. Section 56 of the Act of 2004 is amended—

(a) in paragraph (c) of subsection (1), by the substitution of the following subparagraph for subparagraph (i):

"(i) in case the ground cited is that specified in paragraph 3 of that

Table—

(I) an enforceable agreement of the type referred to in that paragraph is not entered into within the period specified therein,

(II) the notice of termination is not accompanied by the statutory declaration referred to in section 35, or

(III) the offer referred to in paragraph (aa) of subsection (8) of section 35 is not made in circumstances where the conditions specified in the said paragraph (aa) are satisfied,",

and

(b) in subparagraph (c) of the Table to subsection (6), by the substitution of the following clause for clause (i):

"(i) in case the ground cited is that specified in paragraph 3 of that Table—

(I) an enforceable agreement of the type referred to in that paragraph is not entered into within the period of 9 months after the tenant ceases to occupy the dwelling following the final determination of the dispute in relation to the validity of the notice of termination, or

(II) an enforceable agreement of the type referred to in that paragraph is not entered into within that period and the conditions specified in paragraph (aa) of subsection (8) of section 35 are not satisfied,".".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 53:

In page 8, between lines 24 and 25, to insert the following:

"Amendment of Chapter 3 of Part 5 of Act of 2004

8. Chapter 3 of Part 5 of the Act of 2004 is amended by the insertion of the following section:

"Duration of tenancy for purposes of this Chapter

64B. (1) For the purposes of this Chapter, a Part 4 tenancy and any further Part 4 tenancy entered into following the expiration of—

(a) the said Part 4 tenancy, or

(b) a further Part 4 tenancy,

shall be treated as one tenancy, and references in this Chapter to duration of tenancy shall be construed accordingly.

(2) This section is without prejudice to subsection (2) of section 61.".".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 54:

In page 8, to delete lines 27 to 37, and in page 9, to delete lines 1 to 32.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 55:

In page 8, line 31, to delete "on a tenant" and substitute "or a tenant".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 56:

In page 9, line 4, after "landlord" to insert "or tenant, as may be appropriate,".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 57:

In page 9, line 8, after "landlord" to insert "or tenant, as may be appropriate,".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 58:

In page 9, line 10, to delete "on the tenant".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 59:

In page 9, line 28, after "landlord" to insert "or tenant, as the case may be,".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 60:

In page 9, line 30, after "landlord" to insert "or tenant, as the case may be,".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 61:

In page 9, between lines 31 and 32, to insert the following:

"(c) by the insertion of the following subsection:

"(2B) Where this section applies, the period of notice to be given in respect of a tenancy referred to in subsection (1A) of section 3 by the landlord or tenant and specified in the notice of termination shall be not less than 28 days.",".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 62:

In page 9, to delete lines 35 to 43 and in page 10, to delete lines 1 to 3 and substitute the following:

"

Duration of Tenancy (1) | Notice Period (2)

Less than 6 months | 28 days

Not less than 6 months but less than one year | 90 days

Not less than one year but less than 3 years | 120 days

Not less than 3 years but less than 7 years | 180 days

Not less than 7 years but less than 8 years | 196 days

Not less than 8 years | 224 days

Comment on this

As amendment No. 62 has been agreed, amendments Nos. 63 to 65, inclusive, cannot be moved.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 66:

In page 10, between lines 16 and 17, to insert the following:

"Amendment of section 67 of the Act of 2004

8. Subsection 67(2)(b) of the Act of 2004 is amended in subsection (2) by after "tenancy", deleting "." and substituting "and," and inserting a new subsection (3) as follows:

"(3) the failure to pay mentioned in subsection (2)(b)(ii) was not due to an inability to pay.".".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 67:

In page 10, between lines 16 and 17, to insert the following:

"Amendment of section 67 of the Act of 2004

8. Section 67(2)(b)(ii) of the Act of 2004 is amended by deleting “an amount of rent due" and substituting "rent for at least three consecutive months".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 68:

In page 10, between lines 19 and 20, to insert the following:

“Amendment of section 78 of Act of 2004

9. Section 78 of the Act of 2004 is amended, in subsection (1), by the substitution of the following paragraph for paragraph (f):

“(f) an allegation that the landlord has sought to—

(i) terminate a tenancy (other than a tenancy referred to in subsection (1A) of section 3) other than in accordance with Part 4, or

(ii) terminate a tenancy referred to in subsection (1A) of section 3 other than in accordance with Part 5,”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 73:

In page 11, to delete lines 2 to 5 and substitute the following:

“(b) in subsection (2), by—

(i) the substitution of “paragraph (a) of subsection (1)” for “this section”,

(ii) the insertion, in paragraph (a), of “(other than a tenancy to which paragraph (aa) applies)” after “in the case of a tenancy”,

(iii) the insertion of the following paragraph:

“(aa) in the case of a tenancy to which subsection (1A) of section 3 applies that commences during the period of 3 months from the commencement of section 3 of the Residential Tenancies (Amendment) Act 2019, not later than 4 months from the commencement of the tenancy, and”,

(c) in subsection (2A), by the substitution of “paragraph (a) of subsection (1)” for “this section” in each place that it occurs,”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 75:

In page 11, line 19, to delete “paragraph (a)” and substitute “paragraph (a), (aa)”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 76:

In page 11, line 30, to delete “paragraph (a)” and substitute “paragraph (a), (aa)”.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 77 is out of order.

Comment on this

I will look at amendment No. 77 again for Report Stage. I will enter into discussions with the Ceann Comhairle's office.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 77, 86 to 135, inclusive, and Nos. 137 to 144, inclusive, are just including tenants.

Comment on this

The Deputies cannot mention anything on that but they can raise it on Report Stage.

Comment on this

The amendments are out of order. I can rework them and retable them on Report Stage. I will do that with some of them.

Comment on this

The subject matter of this-----

Comment on this

Only if the Deputy discusses the subject matter. He just says what the title is and then he has discussed it.

Comment on this

Which amendment?

Comment on this

Amendment No. 77.

Comment on this

If we have discussed it, he can bring it back on Report Stage. If we have not, he cannot.

Comment on this

It is out of order. He is not allowed to discuss it. Once it is out of order, if he just mentions it-----

Comment on this

We need to find another way to discuss it.

Comment on this

Basically the overall point of the section is the rent transparency register. The Ceann Comhairle's office has made a decision that this would in some way add a charge to the Exchequer. I reject that. Rent transparency important. We want a rent register. In private session we discussed at length how we might be able to do this. Most members were in agreement that it would be a help. Certain GDPR issues were raised and the Attorney General raised some concerns. I was surprised it was ruled out of order on the basis that it would involve a potential charge on the Exchequer.

Comment on this

We cannot get into this.

Comment on this

I do not accept that aspect of it and that is fair enough. On Report Stage, I will return to the issue of a rent transparency register. We have discussed the issue of deposit protection, which is different. We will get on to that because it is important. The Minister was broadly supportive of it. The issue was getting down to specific houses. If it was 14 Main Street in Rush, people would know how much that is. We were talking about a transparency register based on area. I remain to be convinced on that. I will retable amendments on that. Even if it was a question of getting a report 12 months following the passage of the Bill, we cannot just give up on rent transparency. It is important to ensure fairness within it. It is good for tenants and landlords. Much of these data are recorded by the RTB. I will work on an amendment to table on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I wish to update the committee on the matter. We have discussed it on a number of occasions. I was hoping to get down to the individual property level. We have gone back and forth to the Attorney General on this. The advice is that we cannot go to the individual property level. While we were investigating what amendment we could introduce to do it at a local area level, we think we have identified a separate Act where we might be able to get at this for a local electoral district area level. We are working to see if we can do that. It might not require an amendment on Report Stage at all. We will get a chance to discuss it then in more detail.

Comment on this

I will table an amendment which I hope will not be seen to have a potential charge on the Exchequer.

Comment on this

If the Deputy tables an amendment on the lines of his amendment on the deposit protection scheme, it would give us an opportunity to discuss it and perhaps even amend that depending on what work we get done in the meantime.

Comment on this

Great. We will do that.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 78:

In page 12, to delete lines 7 to 10 and substitute the following:

“(b) in subparagraph (i) of paragraph (e) of subsection (4), by—

(i) the insertion of the following clause—

“(IA) the obligation on the landlord to pay fees to the Board on an application to register a tenancy at its commencement and annually during the tenancy,”,

(ii) the substitution of the following clause for clause (II):

“(II) security of tenure under Part 4 (other than in the case of a tenancy referred to in subsection (1A) of section 3),”, and

(iii) the substitution of the following clauses for clause (III):

“(III) the termination of tenancies (other than tenancies referred to in subsection (1A) of section 3) under Part 4, and

(IV) the termination of tenancies under Part 5,”.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 79:

In page 12, to delete lines 22 to 35, and in page 13, to delete lines 1 to 26 and substitute the following:

“ 15. (1) Section 137 of the Act of 2004 is amended—

(a) by the substitution of the following subsection for subsection (1):

“(1) (a) Subject to subsections (2) and (6) and section 137A, the fee to accompany an application under section 134 shall—

(i) in the case of an application (other than an application referred to in paragraph (b)) made during the period of 12 months after the commencement of section 15 of the Residential Tenancies (Amendment) Act 2019, be €40, and

(ii) in the case of an application (other than an application referred to in paragraph (b)) made after that period—

(I) be €40, or

(II) where an amount stands declared for the time being under subsection (1) of section 138 for the purposes of this paragraph, be a fee of that amount.

(b) Subject to subsections (2) and (6) and section 137A, the fee to accompany an application under section 134 shall—

(i) in the case of an application in respect of a tenancy to which subsection (1A) of section 3 applies made during the period of 12 months after the commencement of section 3 of the Residential Tenancies (Amendment) Act 2019, be €40, or

(ii) in the case of an application in respect of a tenancy to which subsection (1A) of section 3 applies made after that period –

(I) be €40, or

(II) where an amount stands declared for the time being under subsection (1) of section 138 for the purposes of this paragraph, be a fee of that amount.”,

(b) in subsection (2), by the substitution of “that a fee referred to in subsection (1)” for “for a fee specified in this section to”,

(c) by the substitution of the following subsection for subsection (4):

“(4) (a) The amount of the single fee referred to in subsection (2) shall—

(i) if the applications (other than an application referred to in paragraph (b)) concerned are made during the period of 12 months after the commencement of section 15 of the Residential Tenancies (Amendment) Act 2019, be €170, or

(ii) if the applications (other than an application referred to in paragraph (b)) concerned are made after that period—

(I) be €170, or

(II) where an amount stands declared for the time being under subsection (1) of section 138 for the purposes of this paragraph, be a fee of that amount.

(b) The amount of the single fee referred to in subsection (2) shall—

(i) if the applications concerned are in respect of a tenancy to which subsection (1A) of section 3 applies made during the period of 12 months after the commencement of section 3 of the Residential Tenancies (Amendment) Act 2019, be €170, or

(ii) if the applications concerned are in respect of a tenancy to which subsection (1A) of section 3 applies made after that period—

(I) be €170, or

(II) where an amount stands declared for the time being under subsection (1) of section 138 for the purposes of this paragraph, be a fee of that amount.”,”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 80:

In page 13, to delete lines 29 to 40, and in page 14, to delete lines 1 to 5 and substitute the following:

“(e) by the substitution of the following subsection for subsection (6):

(6) If an application under subsection (1) of section 134 is made after the expiration of the period specified in subsection (2) or subsection (2B), as may be appropriate, the fee required to accompany that application shall be of such amount as is equal to the aggregate of—

(a) the fee that would have been payable had the application been made before the expiration of that period, and

(b) €10 in respect of each month or part of a month falling after such expiration.”.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 81:

In page 14, between lines 5 and 6, to insert the following:

“(2) The amendment of section 137 of the Act of 2004 effected by this section shall not apply in relation to an application under subsection (1) of section 134 made after the commencement of this section that was required to be made at any time before such commencement.".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 82:

In page 14, between lines 5 and 6, to insert the following:

“Amendment of section 137A of Act of 2004

16. (1) Section 137A of the Act of 2004 is amended—

(a) by the substitution of the following subsection for subsection (1):

“(1) Subject to subsections (2) and (6), the fee that is required to accompany an application referred to in subsection (2A) of section 134 shall—

(a) in the case of an application made during the period of 12 months after the commencement of section 16 of the Residential Tenancies (Amendment) Act 2019, be €20, or

(b) in the case of an application made after that period—

(i) be €20, or

(ii) where an amount stands declared for the time being under subsection (1) of section 138 for the purposes of this paragraph, be a fee of that amount.”,

(b) in subsection (2), by the substitution of “that a fee referred to in subsection (1)” for “for a fee specified in this section to”,

(c) by the substitution of the following subsection for subsection (4):

“(4) The amount of the single fee referred to in subsection (2) shall—

(a) if the applications concerned are made during the period of 12 months after the commencement of section 16 of the Residential Tenancies (Amendment) Act 2019, be €85, or

(b) if the applications concerned are made after that period—

(i) be €85, or

(ii) where an amount stands declared for the time being under subsection (1) of section 138 for the purposes of this paragraph, be a fee of that amount.”,

(d) in subsection (5), by the substitution of “subsection (2A) or (2B), as may be appropriate, of section 134” for “paragraph (a), (b) or (c) of section 134(2A)”, and

(e) by the substitution of the following subsection for subsection (6):

“(6) If an application referred to in subsection (2A) of section 134 is made after the expiration of the period specified in that subsection, the fee required to accompany that application shall be of such amount as is equal to the aggregate of —

(a) the fee that would have been payable had the application been made before the expiration of that period, and

(b) €5 in respect of each month or part of a month falling after such expiration.”.

(2) The amendment of section 137A of the Act of 2004 effected by this section shall not apply in relation to an application to which subsection (2A) of section 134 applies made after the commencement of this section that was required to be made at any time before such commencement.”.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put

Tá 4
·
Níl 2
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Amendment No. 83 has been ruled out of order.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 84, 85, 136, 145, 146, 150 and 175 are related and may be discussed together. Amendment No. 85 is consequential to amendment No. 84.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 84:

In page 19, between lines 38 and 39, to insert the following:

"(17) An application under subsection (7) shall be made to a judge of the District Court for the time being assigned to the District Court District within which the person in respect of whom the application is made resides or carries on any profession, trade or business.

(18) An application for a warrant under subsection (13) shall be made to a judge of the District Court for the time being assigned to the District Court District within which the premises in respect of which the application is made is situated.".

I will try to cover them all in one intervention at the beginning and then we can get into the detail. Government amendment No. 84 technically amends the new section 148S of the Act, which is being inserted by section 18 of the Bill. This is a technical amendment to legally provide territorial jurisdiction to the District Court for the purposes of making court orders to generally enforce compliance with the requirements of an authorised officer under the new RTB sanctioning regime. Government Amendment No. 85 is a consequential technical amendment.

The Government cannot support amendment No. 136, which proposes to delete the new section 148Z, which provides for a right to appeal a RTB sanction decision in the Circuit Court and that a RTB sanction decision must be confirmed by the Circuit Court, either on appeal under section 148AA or on foot of direct application, on notice to the landlord, for confirmation by the RTB under section 148AB. The new section 148Z is a central legal requirement to enable the empowerment of the RTB to operate its new administrative sanction regime. I accept that where court involvement is necessary, the courts process will add to the length of the overall sanctioning process but I am following the advices of the Attorney General on this important legal point. It is important to point out that a decision to impose a sanction is not a given. A decision maker can decide not to sanction and court involvement is not then required. I do wish to stress that on the ground, court involvement need not delay redress for the tenant. The decision on the nature of a sanction to be handed down takes into account the actions of a landlord after the RTB issues an investigation notice.

For example, under section 148AD in determining the nature of the sanction, the Circuit Court or decision-maker may have regard to, for example, whether the landlord acknowledges the improper conduct, the extent of any failure by the landlord to co-operate with the investigation, any steps taken by the landlord to remediate any loss suffered or costs incurred, the duration of the improper conduct, the recurrence, if any, of the improper conduct, the continuation of the improper conduct after the landlord has been notified of the investigation, the extent and timeliness of any steps to end the improper conduct, any steps taken to remedy the consequences of such conduct, and whether similar improper conduct occurred previously. There is good scope at the earliest juncture for a landlord to acknowledge and stop the improper conduct and remedy the matter to hand. The incentive is there to limit the sanction to be imposed.

I also wish to highlight that proceedings need not go all the way to confirmation by the court. Landlords have a number of opportunities during the process. For example, section 148W(3) provides that, where a landlord acknowledges improper conduct, the decision-maker shall on receipt of such acknowledgement determine what sanction, if any, is to be imposed. This provision applies to both tenant complaint initiated and RTB own volition investigations. Section 148X(4)(a) provides that the decision-maker may, if he or she is satisfied that improper conduct has occurred, impose a sanction on a landlord. This is an enabling provision. It does not follow that the decision-maker must impose a sanction, even if improper conduct has occurred. The decision-maker must continue the sanctioning process only if he or she wants to impose a sanction. Separately, 148X(4)(c) provides for complaints to be dismissed or for no further action to be taken if the decision-maker is satisfied that no improper conduct has taken place. Section 148X(5) provides that where an acknowledgement by a landlord is received under 148W(3) as referenced above, the decision-maker may decide to impose a sanction on the landlord as he or she thinks fit in the circumstances of the case. This implies that the decision-maker is not obliged to impose a sanction. Under 148Z(2), the decision to impose a sanction requires a Circuit Court confirmation. The Bill does not provide for court confirmation, however, if the decision is to impose no sanction. Circuit Court confirmation is legally required to publish the detail of any sanction and to give effect to any sanction.

I will also be moving amendment No. 145 to provide technically territorial jurisdiction to the Circuit Court for the purposes of an appeal by a landlord under section 148AA(1) of a sanction imposed.

The Government cannot support amendment No. 146, which proposes the deletion of the new section 148AB requiring the RTB to apply to the Circuit Court to confirm its sanctioning decision.

I will also be moving amendment No. 150, which concerns the granting of territorial jurisdiction to the Circuit Court to deal with applications made by the RTB under section 148AB(1) and related matters. Again, this is a legal necessity for the operation of the new RTB administrative sanctioning regime.

Section 168 of Act of 2004 will be amended by amendment No. 175, which inserts a new paragraph (da) into subsection (2) of that section 168. Subsection (2) of section 168 lists the categories of person to whom a section 168 indemnification can be applied by the RTB. Amendment No. 175 includes authorised officers and a decision-maker appointed for the purposes of the new RTB sanctioning regime in the list of indemnified persons.

All of the amendments speak to the new sanctioning regime, how it is to be applied, the role of the Circuit Court in that regime, and the different points in time at which the process can come to an end. The decision-maker may decide that there is nothing to put forward because there was no breach or because the reason the sanction was imposed either has been remediated or compensation has been made to the aggrieved party or both.

Comment on this

At the informal briefing two issues arose. There were concerns that the timeline of the new process, at its very longest, could be excessively long. The Minister said he would look at it to see if there was some way of shortening it. In terms of the amendments tabled here, is it the view of the Minister that those amendments assist us in any way or provide for those concerns? There was also a concern around the new role of the decision-maker and whether it would lengthen the time required to make a decision. A suggestion made by a number of members was that decisions on sanctions below a certain amount could be made by the chief executive rather than the decision-maker, or that the decision-maker could make sanctions of a higher order.

Amendment No. 136, which I tabled, contains a drafting error. I must have had some help from Deputy Darragh O'Brien on that one. I did not intend to remove the right to appeal to the court, rather I wanted to remove the court confirmation. I will withdraw the amendment, but I will return the amendment at a later stage on the matter of the court confirmation. I still hold the view I held at our previous discussion, which is that court confirmation adds a cost and unnecessary delay. The right to appeal to the court is sufficient, and we will return to that matter on Report Stage.

Comment on this

We discussed this at length previously. The confirmation of the court cannot be removed if the ultimate outcome is going to be a sanction and the publication of the sanction. Where there is no compliance or acceptance by the landlord, for example, where he or she has acted offside in some way and does not accept that he or she has acted poorly and wants to take it all the way, it has to go to court. We looked at this matter with the Attorney General, and it has to stand. It has to be there at the end of the process if we want to impose the sanction and publish the details. However, there is an official sanction, which involves going all the way through the process before sanctioning, but the voluntary acceptance of a type of sanction is also possible and can happen at a much earlier date. When we discussed this previously, it was not clear if, once this investigation had begun, the only way to come to a conclusion that satisfied all parties was to go through the entire process and end up in court. There are three or four instances in which the process will end based on different outcomes from the investigation. Mediation is now available in the first 60 days as a possible outcome as part of this regime. Both parties can be brought together and a solution can be reached which both are happy with. Another potential ending is if the complaint is not valid, meaning that one would not have to go to the court. Landlords were worried that they would have to go all the way to court to confirm that a complaint was not valid, but that is not the case. The landlord, under section 148 and the different subsections I set out, can acknowledge that he or she is in the wrong. In that case there is no official sanction but there will be some sort of remedy if it is done within the first 40 to 66 or 70 days.

If the aggrieved party, for example, the landlord, decides that he or she wants to go further, there is then the possibility of an oral hearing with the investigation report having been given by the authorised officer to the aggrieved party. A decision might be made then that there has been no improper conduct and that there will be no sanction. Alternatively, there could still be a settlement if the parties wanted to take that route and such a solution was acceptable to all parties. Once we go beyond that point, resolution could potentially take some time. That is a long way of answering the Deputy's question. We have found ways in which participants can step out of this process at an early stage. However, if someone refuses to accept that he or she has a liability and one wants to pursue a formal sanction and publication, we will have to go through the Circuit Court confirmation process.

Comment on this

The shorter processes might involve something like a landlord who is in breach of the rent pressure zones legislation. If he or she owns up to that and accepts the sanction, he or she can do that. It is within his or her gift. The RTB pointed out to us that the real value for it of the new investigative and sanction powers is that if someone is breaching the rent pressure zone legislation, it will be able to move on it very quickly, take the case and win it. If the landlord drags the process out to the end, its concern is that, given the timelines provided in the original Bill, that process would be significantly longer than the standard process for a comparable adjudication and fine. The RTB expressed concern about that. Is it fair to say that, in a case where a landlord is unwilling to accept fault, there is a likelihood that the RTB's concern is a valid one and that some of those cases may take longer than would ordinarily be the case under the current regime?

I am still not completely clear about the court confirmation aspect. The RTB, in its determinations today, can make sanctions and publish those determinations, including the details of landlords.

The sanctions can be very high. For example, in the case of third-party antisocial behaviour complaints, they are in the tens of thousands of euro. When we last spoke, the Minister said what is different about this process is that the RTB is doing the investigation, and that is the reason for the sanction. If we look at the determination process of third-party complaints for antisocial behaviour, the adjudicator is doing an investigation and then making a recommendation to the board. I accept the two parties get to present and dispute the facts, and all of that. Obviously, I do not have the benefit of the Attorney General's advice but, essentially, I do not see how the process of this investigation and sanction regime is substantively different from existing adjudications, fines and publications in a way that would warrant this to have a court confirmation where those other determinations and very significant financial fines and publication of details do not warrant court confirmation. I am not trying to be awkward. I am genuinely not clear on this.

Comment on this

To be clear, I met the RTB specifically on this issue and we went through it. If we were to take a worst-case scenario on timelines, where it would be necessary to go through the full court confirmation process to level a sanction on someone who was not accepting a liability, then some of those fears of the RTB may be realised in terms of the length of time. Following that meeting, I went back to the Attorney General and the legal advices to see how we could come at this in a better way so there is not that fear of those lengthy time periods. What is an improvement in terms of the understanding is there are points at which a person can step out for things like mediation or where a person accepts improper conduct, but it has to be accepted.

As it was explained to me, the reason the threshold seems to be high, in terms of having to get Circuit Court confirmation, is because of a combination of the powers that have been granted, whereby the RTB can investigate and can initiate an investigation itself and the sanctioning, which can potentially total €30,000, is higher than what is awarded in other examples under the existing process. That combination of factors warrants the involvement of the Circuit Court and we have not been able to get around that. What we would hope is that given the clarity we have provided in law in this Bill, the excuses a landlord might be able to give such as "I did not know" and so on, fall away because so many things are being tightened or better defined in this legislation. We also think that, given the power the RTB will have to deal with this and the amount of money that can be levelled, this will be a deterrent and that landlords will be, if not coerced, then induced to admit liability because it can be so clearly proven by an investigating officer because of the legislation but also because we have these officers coming in on foot of the legislation. It remains the case that where a landlord is in breach and the RTB has chosen to pursue, the Circuit Court has to be there.

Comment on this

This is only for landlords stepping out of line.

Comment on this

It is related to section 19 offences, which deal with rent increases that are not compliant with the rent restrictions, knowingly furnishing information to the RTB which is false or misleading or failure to notify the RTB when one is availing of an exemption to the rent pressure zone. Also coming under this are the section 34 notice-to-quit terminations, which we said would also be a sanction because it is improper conduct. I cannot think of an instance in which this could apply to a tenant.

Comment on this

I wanted to clarify that point in respect of section 34. Will potential breaches of all the section 34 notice-to-quit criteria fall under this new investigative power?

Comment on this

I will double check. We have made section 34 relate to improper conduct and that improper conduct then gets captured by this new administrative process.

Comment on this
Vice Chairman

As the Minister has already spoken on amendment No. 145, we will now discuss amendment No. 146 in the name of Deputy Boyd Barrett.

Comment on this
Vice Chairman

No, it is in this grouping.

Comment on this

I have already dealt with this, as it is directly related to what we have been discussing in regard to the RTB having the right of appeal.

Comment on this
Vice Chairman

We need to deal with Deputy Boyd Barrett's amendment No. 146.

Comment on this

I apologise. The amendment proposes the deletion of the Circuit Court provision which we just talked about. I said the legal advice is that the Circuit Court has to be there as the final part of the process in levelling a sanction where a landlord does not accept improper conduct and where that is found to be the case by the courts. In order to sanction and to publish, the court confirmation has to be there.

Comment on this

My amendment seeks to delete that Circuit Court provision.

Comment on this

I will be pressing that amendment.

Comment on this
Vice Chairman

We move to amendment No. 150 in the name of the Minister.

Comment on this

Will amendment No. 146 be pressed?

Comment on this
Vice Chairman

We are only discussing it now.

Comment on this

I wish to move Government amendment No. 150, which relates to what I was just discussing.

Comment on this
Vice Chairman

The next is amendment No. 175.

Comment on this

I will move amendment No. 175.

Comment on this
Vice Chairman

We are just discussing the amendments. Does the Minister want to discuss this amendment?

Comment on this

No, it relates to what we have just been discussing so there is nothing to add. It is about authorised officers and decision makers appointed for the purposes of the sanctioning regime being included in the list of indemnified persons.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 85:

In page 19, line 39, to delete “(17) In” and substitute “(19) In”.

Comment on this
Vice Chairman

Amendments Nos. 86 to 135, inclusive, in the name of Deputy Darragh O'Brien have been ruled out of order.

Comment on this
Vice Chairman

We move to amendment No. 136 in the name of Deputy Ó Broin.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 136:

In page 25, to delete lines 38 to 41, and in page 26, to delete lines 1 to 3.

I will be withdrawing that amendment, due to the drafting error, but reserve the right to reintroduce it on Report Stage.

Comment on this
Vice Chairman

Amendments Nos. 137 to 144, inclusive, have been ruled out of order.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 145:

In page 26, between lines 27 and 28, to insert the following:

“(5) An appeal under subsection (1) shall be brought before a judge of the Circuit Court for the time being assigned to the Circuit in which the appellant resides or carries on any profession, trade or business.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 146:

In page 26, to delete lines 28 to 39.

I wish to press this amendment.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put

Tá 2
·
Níl 4
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Amendments Nos. 147 to 149, inclusive, have been ruled out of order.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 150:

In page 26, after line 39, to insert the following:

"(3) An application under subsection (1) shall be made to a judge of the Circuit Court for the time being assigned to the Circuit in which the landlord to whom the decision concerned applies resides or carries on any profession, trade or business.".

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 151 to 173, inclusive, have been ruled out of order.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 174 has been ruled out of order.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 175:

In page 30, between lines 10 and 11, to insert the following:

"Amendment of section 168 of Act of 2004

21. Section 168 of the Act of 2004 is amended by the insertion, in subsection (2), of the following paragraph:

"(da) an authorised officer or decision maker appointed under section 164A,".".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 176:

In page 30, line 24, to delete "or" where it secondly occurs.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 177:

In page 30, line 27, to delete "subsection."."” and substitute the following:

"subsection,

(c) the citing by a landlord in a notice of termination of a reason for the termination of the tenancy concerned that is, and that he or she knows to be, false or misleading in a material

respect,

(d) the failure by a landlord, who has served a notice of termination that cites the ground specified in paragraph 3 of the Table to section 34 as a reason for the termination of the tenancy concerned, to make an offer referred to in paragraph (aa) of subsection (8) of section 35 in circumstances where the conditions referred to in the said paragraph (aa) are satisfied,

(e) the failure by a landlord, who has served a notice of termination that cites the ground specified in paragraph 4 of the Table to section 34 as a reason for the termination of the tenancy concerned, to make an offer referred to in subparagraph (b) of that paragraph in circumstances where the conditions referred to in that subparagraph are satisfied,

(f) the failure by a landlord, who has served a notice of termination that cites the ground specified in paragraph 5 of the Table to section 34 as a reason for the termination of the tenancy concerned, to make an offer referred to in subparagraph (b) of that paragraph in circumstances where the conditions referred to in that subparagraph are satisfied,

or

(g) the failure by a landlord, who has served a notice of termination that cites the ground specified in paragraph 6 of the Table to section 34 as a reason for the termination of the tenancy concerned, to make an offer referred to in subparagraph (b) of that paragraph in circumstances where the conditions referred to in that subparagraph are satisfied.".".

Comment on this

Amendment No. 178 is out of order.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 179:

In page 30, line 27, to delete “subsection.”.” and substitute the following:

“subsection.

“(c) the seeking by the landlord to falsely rely on paragraph 3 of the Table to section 34 as grounds for termination of a Part 4 tenancy.

(d) the seeking by the landlord to falsely rely on paragraph 4 of the Table to section 34 as grounds for termination of a Part 4 tenancy.”.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 180:

In page 30, line 27, to delete “subsection.”.” and substitute the following:

“subsection.

“(c) the seeking by the landlord to rely on paragraph 5 of the Table to section 34 in respect of a dwelling that does not comply with the requirements of that subsection.”.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 181:

In page 33, after line 4, to insert the following:

“Application of Act of 2004 to certain licences

26. (1) The Act of 2004 shall apply to licences and licence agreements as it applies to tenancies of dwellings referred to in subsection (1A) of section 3 of that Act and tenancy agreements relating to such tenancies, subject to the following, and any other necessary, modifications:

(a) references to tenancy shall be construed as references to licence;

(b) references to tenancy agreement shall be construed as references to licensing agreement;

(c) references to landlord shall be construed as references to licensor;

(d) references to tenant (other than a tenant to whom the definition of “multiple tenants” in subsection (1) of section 48 applies) shall be construed as references to licensee;

(e) references to dwelling shall be construed as references to a residential unit (whether or not self-contained) situated in student accommodation;

(f) references to rent shall be construed as references to payments or charges (howsoever described) payable under a licence agreement by the licensee to the licensor; and

(g) the deletion, in paragraph (a) of subsection (1) of section 12, of the words “and exclusive”.

(2) In this section—

“licence” means a licence—

(a) given by the owner of student accommodation to a student, and

(b) created not earlier than one month after the commencement of this section, permitting the student to enter and reside in a residential unit (whether or not self-contained) within that student accommodation, and “licensor” and “licensee” shall be construed accordingly;

“licence agreement” means an agreement (whether or not in writing) between the owner of student accommodation and a student giving a licence to the student;

“owner” has the meaning assigned to it by section 96 of the Planning and Development Act 2000;

“student” means a person registered as a student with a relevant provider (within the meaning of the Qualifications and Quality Assurance (Education and Training) Act 2012);

“student accommodation” means a building, or part of a building, used for the sole purpose (subject to paragraphs (a), (b) and (c)) of providing residential accommodation to students during academic term times under a licence—

(a) whether or not the building or part of the building concerned is used for any other purpose outside of those times,

(b) whether or not any such students are permitted to reside there outside of those times, and

(c) whether or not any person other than a student resides there, provided that the purpose of the person’s residing there serves the first-mentioned purpose,

but does not include a building or part of a building used for the first-mentioned purpose where the licensor (other than a licensor who is not an individual) also resides in the building or part of the building concerned.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 182:

In page 33, after line 4, to insert the following:

“Amendment of Planning and Development Act 2000

27. The Planning and Development Act 2000 is amended by the insertion of the following section:

“Short term lettings

3A. (1) The use of a house or part of a house situated in a rent pressure zone for short term letting purposes is a material change in use of the house or part thereof, as the case may be.

(2) For the purposes of this section, the Minister may make regulations requiring such persons as are specified in the regulations to provide a planning authority with such information as may be so specified and at such intervals as may be so specified in relation to short term lettings in the administrative area of the planning authority.

(3) A person who contravenes a provision of regulations under this section that is described in the regulations as a penal provision shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable, on summary conviction, to a class A fine.

(4) This section shall not operate to abrogate or amend the law with regard to—

(a) lettings (including short term lettings) outside a rent pressure zone,

or

(b) lettings (other than short term lettings) in a rent pressure zone.

(5) In this section—

‘rent pressure zone’ means—

(a) any area standing prescribed for the time being under section 24A of the Residential Tenancies Act 2004, or

(b) an administrative area deemed to be a rent pressure zone under section 24B of that Act;

‘short term letting’ means the letting of a house or part of a house for any period not exceeding 14 days, and includes a licence that permits a licensee under the licence to enter and reside in the house or part thereof for any such period.”.”.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 183 has been discussed already.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 183:

In page 33, after line 4, to insert the following:

“26. The Minister has within 12 months of the commencement of this Act to issue a report on the establishment of a National Rent Deposit Scheme.”.

We discussed this earlier. I will withdraw it and re-table it on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Can I clarify what it was on?

Comment on this

Amendment No. 183 is on the national rent deposit scheme and we did also discuss the rent level, in respect of the rent transparency piece that we will table as a Report Stage amendment, similar to amendment No. 183, so that at least we can discuss it.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 184 is out of order.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 185:

In page 33, after line 4, to insert the following:

“PART 4

MISCELLANEOUS

Amendment of sections 27, 28(1), 28(3) and 50(3) of Act of 2004 - to extend Part 4 protections to all tenancies over two months in duration

26. (a) Section 27 of the Act of 2004 is amended by the substitution of “continuous period of 2 months” for “continuous period of 6 months”.

(b) Section 28(1) of the Act of 2004 is amended by the substitution of “continuous period of 2 months” for “continuous period of 6 months”.

(c) Section 28(3) of the Act of 2004 is amended by the substitution of “expiry of the period of 2 months” for “expiry of the period of 6 months”.

(d) Section 50(3) of the Act of 2004 is amended by the substitution of—

(i) “continuous period of 2 months” for “continuous period of 6 months”, and

(ii) “expiry of that period of 2 months” for “expiry of that period of 6 months”.”.

This amendment provides that Part 4 tenancies should begin after a continuous period of two months, rather than one of six months.

Comment on this

The Government cannot accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 186:

In page 33, after line 4, to insert the following:

“PART 4

MISCELLANEOUS

Amendment of sections 28, 34, 55, 56, 57, Chapters 4 and 5 of Act of 2004 - to make Part 4 tenancies indefinite

26. (a) Section 28(2)(a) of the Act of 2004 is amended by the substitution of “for an indefinite period from” for “for the period of 6 years from”.

(b) Section 34(b) of the Act of 2004 is hereby repealed.

(c) Chapter 4 of the Act of 2004 is hereby repealed.

(d) Chapter 5 of the Act of 2004 is hereby repealed.

(e) Section 55(1) is amended by the deletion of “or a further Part 4 tenancy”.

(f) Section 55 is amended by the substitution of the following for subsection (2):

“(2) A termination under section 34 on one or more of the grounds specified in paragraphs 2 to 6 of the Table to that section of a Part 4 tenancy or a further Part 4 tenancy shall not be regarded as a termination of that tenancy for the purposes of section 17(1)(a) of the Landlord and Tenant (Amendment) Act 1980.”.

(g) Section 56(1)(a) is amended by the deletion of “, or under a further Part 4 tenancy,”.

(h) Section 57(b) is amended by the deletion of “or further Part 4 tenancy”.”.

This amendment aims to make Part 4 tenancies indefinite, something we discussed earlier in respect of other amendments. The Government has said it wants to go on this road but cannot do it now. We do not accept that; we think Part 4 tenancies should be indefinite to give security to tenants.

Comment on this

I support the intent but not the amendment, unfortunately.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 187:

In page 33, after line 4, to insert the following:

“PART 4

MISCELLANEOUS

“Amendment of section 34 and 56 of Act of 2004 - to abolish sale of a property as a ground for terminating a tenancy

26. (a) The Act of 2004 is amended by the deletion of paragraph 3 of the Table to section 34.

(b) Paragraph 4(b)(ii) of the Table to section 34 is amended by the substitution of “the ground specified in paragraph 1, 2 or 6 of this Table” for “the ground specified in paragraph 1, 2, 3 or 6 of this Table”.

(c) Section 56(c)(i) is hereby repealed.

(d) The Act of 2004 is amended by the deletion of subparagraph (c)(i) of the Table to section 56.”.

This amendment is to abolish sale of property as a ground for terminating a tenancy. It is a critical issue, which we will be marching to vindicate on 18 May. We hope there will be tens of thousands of people out marching for this demand. This is a critical measure to give security to tenants which is sadly lacking.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put

Tá 2
·
Níl 4
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 188:

In page 5, line 11, after “Board;" to insert the following:

“to provide that the letting of a house or part thereof for any period not exceeding 14 days in a rent pressure zone is a material change in the use of the house or part and for that purpose to amend the Planning and Development Act 2000;”.

Comment on this

One of my amendments was ruled out of order. It would affect the Title because it would be a substantial provision in the Bill. There is a big problem with new tenancies and the setting of their rents which neither current nor proposed legislation deals with. For a brand new tenancy the rent can be set at any level at all. We can see that rents are being set at extortionate levels. There was a place in the docks where they were talking about charging €3,300 a month. Something has to be done about that.

I am not sure why my amendment was ruled out of order but I will check with the Bills Office. I am not challenging that decision but the proposal was that the RTB should set rents for new tenancies, that affordability should be a factor in setting them, and that the Minister should provide guidelines as to how that might be done in consultation with this committee. One of the reasons RPZs are not limiting rents to the extent that the Minister or we might want is that new tenancies are being created all the time. The more building there is, the more will be created and landlords are totally free to set rents at whatever level they like. Something has to be done about that but nothing is being done about it.

Comment on this

The amendment being ruled out of order has nothing to do with me or the Department. It is not true to say that landlords are free to set the rent at any level they like. They have to set them at market rates and have to be able to provide evidence of that. We can perhaps come back to this on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister and the officials, for attending today's meeting. I thank the members of the committee for sticking with us throughout the day. I thank the secretariat who put in enormous work prior to today's meeting which sometimes goes unnoticed.

Comment on this

I thank the Chairman and the officials from the Department.

Comment on this