Criminal Law and Civil Law (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2026: Committee Stage
Committee Stage centred on controversial Government amendments adding Defence Act provisions to the miscellaneous Bill, alongside justice and civil law changes. The Minister for Defence said the new sections would put maritime security powers, aid to the civil power and protection of military installations onto a primary legislative footing, with no change to current practice but clearer statutory authority. Opposition Deputies criticised the use of a mixed-purpose Bill and the rushed process, arguing it bypassed proper scrutiny and seeking clarity on why the aid-to-civil-power powers were being formalised now. The Minister undertook to return with further information, while rejecting a proposal to lay every individual Defence Forces approval before the Dáil, citing existing annual reporting instead.
Contributions 1–147 of 258. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 1 of 2026 ›
I remind members to turn off their mobile phones or to switch them to flight mode. This meeting has been convened to commence the Committee Stage debate on the Criminal Law and Civil Law (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2026. I welcome the Ministers, Deputies Jim O'Callaghan and Helen McEntee, and their officials to the meeting. As the Bill deals with matters for which both Ministers have responsibility, they are both in attendance. To assist in consideration and to provide procedural clarity, the following procedure will be followed. When dealing with sections, as a section does not need to be moved, the relevant Minister can speak to the section, as appropriate. When dealing with amendments, when both Ministers are in attendance at the same time, only the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, as sponsor of the Bill, may move Government amendments. Should an amendment or part of the Bill relate to Deputy McEntee's brief, the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, should move it and then defer to her to speak on the matter.
Should only one Minister be present, that Minister will move and speak to all Government amendments. When the votes are called, in terms of divisions, if both Ministers are present, only the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, will be called upon to vote. If only one Minister is in attendance, that Minister will be called upon to vote. I wish to remind members that it is important to note that in order to participate in a division in committee, members must be physically present.
I believe the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, would like the opportunity to make some brief opening remarks.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for providing time to facilitate the Committee Stage amendment discussion on the Criminal Law and Civil Law (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2026. As the Leas-Chathaoirleach indicated in her opening remarks, the Minister, Deputy McEntee, and I are here. The Minister will deal with the section of amendments contained in group 1. I do not envisage that she will have to spend all of her time here.
I appreciate the engagement of committee members in respect of the Bill. Before we deal with the proposed amendments, I would like to briefly signal a number of other amendments currently at an advanced stage of drafting in the Office of Parliamentary Counsel and that I intend to bring forward on Report Stage.
First is the insertion of a new Part into the Bill providing for an application-based scheme to enable the disregard of historical convictions relating to consensual sexual activity between men. The provisions to be brought forward will clearly set out the offences and scope, the criteria for a disregard, the legal effects of same and the procedures for making, considering and determining applications. Provision will be made for independent assessment of applications and for an applicant to request an independent review where it is proposed to refuse a disregard. Provision will also be made for the revocation of a disregard should this be found necessary in any case. Again, there is provision for an independent review where revocation is proposed.
Second is an amendment to the International Criminal Court Act 2006 to incorporate the 2010, 2017 and 2019 amendments to Article 8 of the Rome Statute on war crimes and to address a drafting issue in the Act to make it clear that Ireland's co-operation obligations with the International Criminal Court cover all offences within the court's jurisdiction, including the crime of aggression and offences against the administration of justice.
Third is an amendment to the to the European Arrest Warrant Act 2003, additional to the amendment being moved today. This further amendment will be made to section 35A of the 2003 Act and will simply ensure that the retrial or appeal mentioned in subsection (2) of that section will take place without undue delay.
Fourth is an amendment to the Social Welfare Consolidation Act 2005 to add the Courts Service as a specified body under Schedule 5 to the Act. This amendment is necessary to enable full effect to be given to section 22 of the 2020 miscellaneous provisions Act, which envisages a personal public service number as a means by which the Courts Service may verify the identity of a person who is transmitting documents to a court by electronic means.
Fifth is an amendment to section 6 of the Bill, which amends section 67 of the Court of Justice Act 1936 to reduce the number of Supreme Court and Court of Appeal judges that sit on the superior rules committee. A further amendment may be necessary to ensure these provisions operate as intended.
Finally, there are some technical amendments to section 95 of the Family Courts Act 2024 and section 27 of the Criminal Justice (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2023. These amendments have been determined as necessary to avoid a lacuna being caused by the commencement of certain provisions of the Family Courts Act 2024, which would result in proceedings under section 28 to 30, inclusive, of the 2023 Act not being subject to the same reporting restrictions as they are at present.
I thank the Leas-Chathaoirleach.
Comment on this
I strongly object to the manner in which the Government has dealt with this Bill. The Minister has treated this committee with utter disrespect throughout this process. We had a pre-legislative scrutiny stage where the committee tried but was ultimately unable to go through each part of the heads of the Bill and the general scheme to try to give each aspect the deliberation it deserved.
I have come from Leaders' Questions, where the Taoiseach said by way of an excuse that the delay in implementing legislation that should have been implemented years ago was because a different committee had to undertake pre-legislative scrutiny. The truth of the matter is that, under the current Government, the pre-legislative scrutiny process is a scam. There is no real consideration, in particular when dealing with a miscellaneous provisions Bill, that covers numerous and completely unrelated topics to such a point that we are not only going across multiple areas of the Minister's Department but also another Department entirely in the first round of amendments. We are even changing the Title of the Bill.
It speaks of rushed legislation and I believe, as has been the case with other Bills from the Minister's Department, there will be unforeseen consequences and problems. Ultimately, the real failure of pre-legislative scrutiny is that, in the areas that the committee had an opportunity to examine, namely, counselling notes, the recommendations of the committee have been completely disregarded. I want to stress in the strongest possible terms that this is an absolute farce. We are dealing with two different Ministers, one in respect of defence matters. This Bill is being brought before the Dáil at the very last minute, primarily, it appears to me, because the Minister for justice inadvertently exposed a lacuna in the Bill when he threatened to use the Defence Forces during fuel protests. It now appears that he had no legal basis to do so. I want to make those points as forcefully as I can.
Comment on this
It is not my intention to show any disrespect to this committee. I have consistently come before the committee and engaged with members. I very much value the process and work that this committee contributes to the criminal justice process and the justice area in general. I have listened to what the committee said in respect of counselling notes. When we come to discuss them, the committee will note that further amendments have been proposed by me on Committee Stage to ensure that I set in place a statutory non-disclosure presumption in respect of counselling notes. That is something the committee wanted me to head in the direction of.
In terms of issues around the Defence Act and matters that the Minister, Deputy McEntee, will deal with, they were issues that came before the Government and were discussed before any fuel protest. No disrespect is intended or given. We are here to do our work.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister. As members are aware, we are at a stage where general discussion is not forthcoming. We will move on with the Bill.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 1, 5 and 37 are related and may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 6, line 4, to delete “Criminal Law and Civil Law” and substitute “Criminal Law, Civil Law and Defence”.
These amendments will be dealt with by the Minister, Deputy McEntee.
Comment on this
I thank the committee and my colleague for the opportunity to speak on this group of amendments, which I brought to the Cabinet on 9 March and have been made public since 11 March. They have been on the website of the Department of Defence since those dates.
Amendments Nos. 1 and 37 amend the Short Title and Long Title, respectively, of the Bill to reflect that the Bill will now include amendments to the Defence Act.
Amendment No. 5 inserts a new Part IIIA into the Defence Act 1954. The purpose of the new Part IIIA, which will consist of three new sections, namely, sections 40A, 40B and 40C, is to include necessary provisions in the Defence Acts to help to protect and defend our territorial seas and international waters and protect the sovereign rights of the State in our exclusive economic zone, to make provision for the long-standing role of the Defence Forces in aid of the civil power, and to enhance the protection of military installations.
The new section 40A deals with maritime security-related matters. The section will ensure that members of the Defence Forces will have enhanced powers to safeguard, protect and defend the security of the State in the maritime domain. The provisions are particularly relevant in today's increasingly volatile geopolitical situation, which, as we know, is resulting in new and evolving threats in the maritime domain. Progressing these amendments is a matter of urgency, as it is a priority for me and the rest of the Government to ensure that the Defence Forces have the powers they need to respond to emerging threats in our waters, in particular from vessels linked to the Russian shadow fleet. In broad terms, the new section 40A of the Defence Act will provide the Defence Forces with stand-alone statutory powers that will include the power to use force that is reasonable, proportionate and necessary in order to safeguard, protect and defend the security of the State and maritime domain. In practical terms, this proposed legislation will allow, for example, the captain of one of our State's naval ships to hail, board, search and redirect those ships suspected of engaging in non-innocent passage in the seas around our island.
The Bill also makes provision for the Chief of Staff to provide guidance on the exercise of these new powers. This guidance will be developed with my consent and, where appropriate, in consultation with the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, insofar as it relates to the application of international law at sea. It is important to note that these legislative proposals do not provide for any prosecutions or arrests or detention of vessels. I am satisfied that the legislation is proportionate and will address the urgent needs of the Defence Forces when carrying out operations at sea. I have asked my Department to undertake a comprehensive review of all maritime security-related legislation envisaged as part of the new national maritime security strategy that I launched at the end of February. I will bring forward further legislation in this space if required.
The proposed new section 40B to be inserted into the Defence Act will make express provision in primary legislation for the long-standing role of the Defence Forces when they assist An Garda Síochána, which is referred to in the Defence Acts as aid to the civil power. The new section sets out the legislative framework under which members of the Defence Forces may be deployed in aid of civil power and clarifies that a member of the Defence Forces so deployed is authorised to use such force as is appropriate or proportionate, necessary and reasonable. This is a necessary provision to clarify the powers of a member of the Defence Forces in any such circumstances.
There are ongoing close liaisons between An Garda Síochána and the Defence Forces on security matters, including aid to the civil power deployment. In any given year there can be a wide range of aid to the civil power operations, including explosive ordnance call-outs, cash in transit escorts, hospital guarding operations, euro cash in transit escorts, Naval Service diving operations, Central Bank security guarding operations and prisoner escorts. There are a lot of different ways in which the Defence Forces are called out. The new section 40B will replace existing provisions in secondary legislation concerning aid to the civil power as set out in the Defence Forces regulations. Existing arrangements for routine deployments in aid to the civil power, for example, explosive ordnance duties whereby requests for assistance are made by An Garda Síochána to the Defence Forces using a C70 form, will broadly continue in line with current practice. There will not be any change to how these forms are applied for or to the process thereafter.
The proposed new section 40C to be inserted into the Defence Act 1954 clarifies the powers that may be exercised by a member of the Defence Forces for the protection of military installations. The section will replace existing provisions in regulations - again, secondary legislation - made under the Defence Act. It is important such powers, as was advised to my Department last year, be set out in primary legislation.
Comment on this
I reiterate that it is entirely inappropriate to deal with the issues these amendments deal with as part of a Bill that covers a wide range of unrelated matters. These amendments are being brought forward outside of the remit of this committee and that of the Department which has been steering the legislation. All of this means that there has been no opportunity for proper Oireachtas scrutiny. The amendments were not part of the provisions we dealt with during pre-legislative scrutiny. We did not have sight of them on Second Stage. Instead, we had minimal debate in which Opposition parties were given something like seven minutes last week to respond to something that had been provided to us in the days prior.
There will be broad political support for provisions that strengthen Defence Forces authority regarding military property and that expand Defence Forces powers in respect of maritime security. We all strongly support the need to protect our maritime territory. We have been very critical of the slow action on the part of successive Governments which have meant that large areas of Irish territorial waters have essentially been unguarded for long periods. We have seen a reduction in our naval services over the past decade or more.
I have a real concern about the new section 40B, as outlined. Will the Minister clarify that this section was included in the memorandum which was brought to Cabinet in March and to which she referred? Was it part of the overall proposal? What inspired it? What led to the consideration that this would be required? It is important that the Minister clearly outline the current legislative basis for aid to the civil power by Defence Forces.
I mentioned the fuel protests. What happened during those protests was both incredibly worrying and antagonistic in nature. It escalated tensions at a time when the Government should have been trying to de-escalate them. The wording the Minister used to justify that is essentially the wording we have in this new section. It states that the Minister "approval for the deployment of a member of the Defence Forces in aid of the civil power ... as agreed with the Minister for Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration." That is exactly what the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, said he was going to invoke and that caused all of the consideration to which I refer to happen.
The Minister, Deputy McEntee, stated that this is currently underpinned by secondary legislation. What is the primary legislation underpinning aid to the civil power? Secondary legislation is a statutory instrument based on regulation. In other words, it is not included in an actual piece of law, but a piece of law has given authority for a Minister to approve such legislation. The Government is expecting to use this committee for a rubber-stamping exercise. Prior to the committee being asked to rubber-stamp this, it is imperative that we get full details as to why this is needed and why it is needed now. What lacuna is this filling? Is it the case that our Defence Forces have been used without there being an underpinning legal basis? If they have had such a basis, why is there a need to change it at this time? Does the underpinning legal basis not cover something the Government wants to cover at some point in the future? Which of the three is it? The Irish public deserves answers to those questions, and we clearly deserve them because there are real concerns about what the Government is trying to pull off here. It has all the hallmarks of a stroke, to be quite honest, and this committee deserves full clarification on the matter.
Comment on this
This is a miscellaneous Bill. It certainly is miscellaneous because it is very wide-ranging. This is not the appropriate way in which to do our business. We are crossing over two totally different areas with this Bill. What is proposed here was not part of the initial legislation. When it comes to defence matters, we are bypassing the committee that should be dealing with this. Our committee should not be dealing with this. In the 20 years I have been here, I do not think I have seen this happen. It is pretty serious. I have seen crossovers in committees, particularly in the context of the relevant line committees that deal with financial issues and all that sort of stuff with the Department of Finance. Here, however, we are talking about defence matters being dealt with by the justice committee. I do not know if that has ever happened before. It is totally inappropriate and avoids proper Oireachtas scrutiny. There are so many questions relating to this that I do not know where to start.
I am 100% with the Minister when it comes to the protection of maritime territory. I am surprised that we have not brought this in previously. The Minister has spoken about this matter, as have I. We all know that there is a huge weakness here. In principle, we will be supportive across the political divide, without a shadow of a doubt. In fact, the Minister will probably be coming back to the Oireachtas with more legislation in the not-too-distant future. I expect that she will have to as this evolves. As the world is changing, we need to ensure that we, as a country, change with it.
Section 40B is probably one of the most intriguing subsets of pieces of legislation I have seen put before a committee in a long time. Either our Defence Forces have been acting without legislative permission and there is no legislation to back up what they have been doing, we are trying to reverse engineer a situation where they can now have permission or there is something we do not know. One of three things is going on here and none of them are good. If there is a lacuna or something we need to know about the Minister should tell us. It might be there was no legislative basis for the operation of Defence Forces in aid of civil power previously – we can all list a range of measures in which the Defence Forces operated this way. I grew up with the Defence Forces outside banks across Ireland transferring money and doing a whole range of other things like helping out with strikes and other issues. Either it was not doing so with legislative basis or something else is going on. Why are we bringing in this legislation? I am not being flippant. Obviously there is the issue of the fuel protests and what the Minister’s colleague, Deputy O’Callaghan, said and, to be fair, what he said and what happened were not exactly the same. However the narrative that came out of what he said was the concerning bit since the execution did not happen. Why are we bringing this in if we already had aid of civil power from our Defence Forces? If we did not, how could they act in the manner in which they did? Is there something we do not know? I do not think it is the latter, to be fair.
Sometimes honesty is the best policy. Sometimes it is best to say, “Legally we have been advised that from a legislative point of view we need to firm up this area.” If that is the case then that is the case. Either there was no basis previously and we need to fill it in, which raises other questions, or there is something we do not know. It looks like we are trying to reverse engineer legislation to ensure everything is covered going forward. We faced similar issues during the fuel crisis. It is intriguing. This was not in the first draft of the Bill and did not arise in any pre-legislative scrutiny. There was nothing. It was nowhere to be seen. I know the Minister cannot necessarily talk in detail about what happened at Cabinet but it would be interesting to know when this was first proposed. Will the Minister clarify to the committee when this was first proposed by her Department to her? We can find out other ways but it would be better if she just told us. We need to put in place the timeline as to how, in a very rushed manner, this was shoehorned in on Committee Stage to a Bill which is so wide in its breadth already and going into a whole different section and not only a whole different Department but doing so on an issue that is so important. It affects the civil liberties of people, potentially, where the Army or Defence Forces can come in and act in a certain way on the basis of a recommendation from the Minister to aid An Garda Síochána under the Minister sitting beside her, the Minister for justice. This is very serious stuff. To have it shoehorned in at the end of a Bill at this Stage creates a huge democratic deficit for anyone watching and it should not happen. I do not think anybody in politics, even on the Minister’s side of the fence, believes this is the right way to do things. They will support it but it is not the right way to do things.
In her reply, the Minister might answer the following. Have we a legislative basis for aid of civil power as of today, 19 May 2026? If we do not, on what basis were our Defence Forces acting previously? That is the first thing. Second, why is there such a hurry and a rapid demand to bring this in now? What has happened or what changed recently? Third, when was this first brought to the Minister’s attention and by what route? Was it through the Minister’s own Department or by another route?
I also have an amendment to amendment No. 5. I am assuming the Minister will accept this amendment. It would be very unusual if she did not considering what I have just said about the democratic deficit and the way this has been shoehorned in at the end of a Bill. My amendment adds a further subsection (6) to the Minister’s amendment to the effect that where the Minister gives a direction, the direction or approval for deployment of the Defence Forces must be laid before the Dáil. That would provide some democratic oversight. I hope that will be accepted.
Comment on this
I thank both Deputies for their questions and points. I will acknowledge at the outset I appreciate this is not the normal route legislation is brought. It does happen and happened in the previous Government I was in. Generally, the reason is time and the need to introduce legislation within a certain timeframe. To be very clear, my reason for asking for this to be included or for this vehicle to be used was to ensure the maritime security legislation was in place for our Presidency and that we respond as quickly as possible to provide our Defence Forces, in particular our Naval Service, with the legislative requirements that they need. They currently operate under customs legislation, An Garda Síochána legislation and environmental legislation so I see it as my job to ensure they have their own consolidated and specified legislation. Importantly, I wanted to make sure this was in place before 1 July and this was the only vehicle that it was possible to do that in. I appreciate that it is not the norm but I did bring this to Cabinet on 9 March, very soon after publishing the maritime security strategy, and made it very clear that I wanted to bring legislation so that we could do this quickly. Obviously it has gone through the process of developing the amendments and going to committee. My Department has worked with me on that and I thank colleagues for the opportunity last week in the Chamber to discuss this and now the opportunity at the committee again.
On the second amendments, this was the first and only opportunity I have at the moment because there is no other legislation through defence to bring forward any other amendments. The first time the need for the aid to civil power and way in which it was used to be put in primary legislation was raised was last year in the Department, before I was Minister. At the moment it is set out and provisions relating to the Defence Forces in regulations made under the Defence Act 1954. There is case law to stand this up. I do not have it here but I can provide it to the House to show it has been tested. The advice last year from the Attorney General was that it would be better to have this on a statutory footing. The amendments we see here do not change how these are going to be deployed. They do not change why they are needed. In the list I have, which I can provide to the committee, the main ways in which they are used are Central Bank patrols, airport security duties, explosive production, security guard, Central Bank security guard, prisoner escorts, explosive ordnance disposal call-outs, explosive escorts, Naval Service diving operations, euro cash-in-transit escorts, hospital guards, VIP visits, search operations, Air Corps, Air Corps repatriation flights and Naval Service. They are the reasons why the civil power is generally used. There are over 3,000 in the years I have here between 2021 and 2024 – I do not have the figures for 2025. The advice was very clear that to put this on a primary legislative footing would be a better thing to do. As Minister for Defence my view was that if I had the opportunity because I do not have legislation before the House to bring this forward and put it on primary legislation that I would do that.
The Deputy mentioned the protests. This was brought forward and worked on well before that. This does not change anything. Most people would realise that even during the recent fuel protests the support the Defence Forces provided was through the use of Bison. These are vehicles used to remove other large vehicles. There was no deployment of actual military personnel. That shows the considered and measured way in which the Defence Forces support An Garda in any of its duties.
The majority, if not all, of the C70 forms that come in on a yearly basis are for all of the reasons that I have outlined. I appreciate that, with the timing, the Deputies are trying to infer that there is something else here, but this was brought to the attention of my predecessor last year and it was brought to my attention early this year because of the fact that I was bringing forward the maritime legislation. I sought and asked if it was possible to bring this at the same time because it simply puts in primary legislation what is already there in secondary legislation. It does not change how they go about their business. It does not change the way in which the Defence Forces can operate. When I am told something would be better on a legislative basis, it is prudent that I as the Minister for Defence would move on that and that I get the support of others. I appreciate that it is not the norm and it is not the way amendments tend to come. Certainly, my primary focus was to make sure the maritime legislation was in situ by the summer and that we had it as quickly as possible. There is an opportunity later on, when the review more broadly of maritime security comes forward, that there will possibly be further amendments giving further legislative powers to the Defence Forces, but because of the timeline I wanted to ensure we brought this forward.
Comment on this
I am not clear on one thing. Actually, I am not clear on a lot of things, to be quite frank about it. The Minister mentioned a number of times the Cabinet memo from 9 March. Did section 40B form part of that memo?
Comment on this
The amendments were not set out but I made clear in what I brought to the Cabinet that I would be bringing forward legislation on aid to civil power and that it would be putting it on a statutory, primary legislative footing, as well as the intention to bring legislation on search and rescue and the maritime security piece.
Comment on this
Okay. I heard very clearly the Minister mention the maritime security aspect-----
Comment on this
It included aid to civil power-----
Comment on this
The Minister included at that point the aid to civil power, and she said that this was before her appointment as Minister-----
Comment on this
That was 9 March this year, but this was well before any inference that it was because of protests. That was 9 March. We know when the protests took place. This was brought well before that because of the advice last year from the Attorney General-----
Comment on this
Yes, so this matter came to the Attorney General. The Attorney General provided advice to the Government. Had that advice been sought?
Comment on this
I can come back to the Deputy on the exact reason as to why, but the advice at the time was that this would be a better legislative footing. My understanding is that there was not any specific reason for-----
Comment on this
Is it that the Minister cannot say why the Attorney General came out of the blue and said that his office had done this piece of work to help the Minister or did the Department seek from the Office of the Attorney General some clarification in respect of aid to civil power?
Comment on this
I can come back to the Deputy, but as is the case with any Department and the Attorney General, there is often an engagement on different pieces of legislation. Issues arise, and as they arise, there is often advice from the Attorney General or there is information sought-----
Comment on this
The question I have asked, and I think Deputy Kelly has asked the same question, is what issues arose. Was it a case that the Attorney General's office said to the Department that this was an issue it needed to be aware of? Was it a case that the Department went to the Attorney General? It speaks to the due diligence that has been done, if nothing else, in terms of this matter. The ultimate question is why is this change being brought now? The Minister is saying that it is being done on the back of the Attorney General's advice provided to her predecessors. I think it is a reasonable question for this committee to ask. What led to the Attorney General's advice? Was there an upcoming legal challenge? Was there a legal decision specifically that led to it? What was it that actually resulted in the Department receiving this piece of legal advice from the State solicitor?
Comment on this
There was no court case that I am aware of. The Deputy will know that often advice is provided by the Attorney General. I can provide more information to the committee but my understanding is that it was not based on-----
Comment on this
The problem is that we are expected to vote on this now.
Comment on this
It was not based on any specific issue. To be quite honest, as the Minister for Defence, if I am advised that it would be better to put something on a primary legislative footing then I am going to take that advice. I think it is good practice by the Attorney General, by Departments and by our legal teams to make sure that, with any legislation, if it is suggested that it could be put on a primary footing, I would do that. There is case law that has stood up what is currently there. It is not to suggest that this is the reason it is being done, but again, the advice was provided. I think it is good practice, certainly as the Minister for Defence, to bring it forward.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not think it is reasonable to ask what led to that advice being sought or given? Yes, the Minister is right that the Attorney General provides different Departments at different stages with legal advice in respect of different matters, much of which is suggesting that there is a legislative necessity to bring forward a new Bill or to amend a current Bill, but this is usually based on something. It is either based on the Attorney General becoming aware of a legal lacuna, sometimes from a legal action and sometimes from a threatened legal action, or it is the Department having sought from the Attorney General's office clarification in respect of legislation it is operating under. It is astounding that the Minister cannot tell us which one it is in this case.
Comment on this
My understanding is that this was in relation to the use of force. This is just to clarify any of the operations that would have been in place here previously, including the ones I have outlined.
Comment on this
In the way that it is outlined, a member of the Defence Forces deployed in aid to civil power may use such force as is reasonable, proportionate and necessary in the performance of his or her duties. It is the case, and I outlined it, even, in the earlier amendment on maritime security, that it should be set out in primary legislation that this clarification is put in place, as in the previous regulations, which I have here and can provide to the committee. It makes no reference to that. I can outline what was in the previous regulations:
(1) The Minister may, at anytime when occasion appears to require, direct that all or so many reservists as he thinks necessary be called out in aid of civil power, in the maintenance or restoration of the public peace.
(2) Whenever direction is given by the Minister under this section, a notice shall be served on every reservist to whom the direction relates requiring him to attend at a time and place specified in such notice, and such reservists shall after that time, for the purposes of the Act, stand called out in aid of the civil power and remain called out in aid of civil power until the prescribed military authority directs his release.
This does not at this stage include the reference to being proportionate, necessary and reasonable in their duties. Over time, this is what has been included in all elements of the legislation. It is also included in the piece on the maritime security, where it refers to and sets out about the Chief of Staff, as soon as is reasonably practicable, regarding the exercise of the power by the Defence Forces pursuant to this section. This is putting on a statutory footing what is the case for other elements of legislation for the Defence Forces.
Comment on this
I am obviously not going to get clarification as to how this originated. The Minister is saying what the basis of the advice was. Essentially, it is to permit the Defence Forces engaged in aid to civil power to use force as reasonable, proportionate and necessary, as it may be.
In terms of protests, the Minister mentioned that aid to the civil power would be known in the general public, as she set out, and the Minister mentioned assisting in cash transit and monitoring explosives manufacturers and such matters. Is it the Minister's view that the legislation that has been in place, the statutory framework, would have allowed, if deemed necessary, and if the Minister for justice asked the Minister for Defence for aid to the civil power, for the Defence Forces to be used in terms of personnel rather than vehicular assistance? Was that the case prior to this? Will that be the case subsequent to this amendment being passed?
Comment on this
In my understanding, the legal underpinning provides for that, yes. What this is doing is putting it very clearly in primary legislation. How that operates is a matter for the Defence Forces to set out. We do not set out here in the primary legislation how that would operate. It is a matter for the Defence Forces to set out how that is deemed as appropriate or reasonable use of force. What I am providing here is a clear legislative basis, on the advice of the Attorney General, where he is saying that primary legislation is the preferred option. I repeat that there is case law to stand up what is currently in regulation via secondary legislation. I think it is good practice as the Minister that, if there is advice there to introduce primary legislation, that is what I would do. I appreciate this is not always the normal channel that is used, but it is important that I do so where this advice is made, and this is the first opportunity I have as Minister to bring this forward.
Comment on this
My final point on this is that the role is different from most other roles that fall under the Defence Forces in that there is considerable autonomy left with the Chief of Staff in respect of operational matters. It is very clear that it is the Minister for Defence who shall give general approval for the deployment of the Defence Forces, as agreed with the Minister for justice. It is very clearly about where the Defence Forces would be used with the approval of, and usually with the instruction of, the Government, as opposed to the position with operational matters. As the Minister has outlined, this would include the deployment of members of the Defence Forces to police protests. Despite this, in dealing with this legislation the Minister can provide us with no clarity as to where exactly this all originated from. I repeat that this is underhand and a really worrying way of dealing with such important legislation.
Comment on this
The Deputy is trying to conflate two things. He is referring to protests that happened a year after anything was suggested here-----
Comment on this
No, to be clear, I am talking about future protests.
Comment on this
In general, that is what the Deputy is referring to.
Comment on this
No, to be absolutely clear, I am talking about future protests.
Comment on this
To be clear, the Deputy is trying to conflate the two.
Comment on this
On the language used, the Defence Forces, unlike An Garda Síochána, for example, are subject at all times to civilian control. The Minister for Defence has ultimate responsibility. In any legislation when it comes to the Defence Forces, it will state “the Minister for Defence”. It is no different here. What the Deputy sees in subsection (2) is that the Minister may, subject to such conditions as he or she may specify, give general approval. As is the case now for all the measures I have outlined, in 99.9% of cases, if not more, the C70 will be used in this manner. Once the provision comes into effect, I will sign what is essentially an approval, which means that in every single instance the Defence Forces or An Garda Síochána will not have to come directly to me. There will be an ability to approve in the way that happens now. One might have an individual request every couple of days. This just references and replicates what is currently the case, but because the Defence Forces are at all times subject to civilian control, there will be a reference to the Minister. However, section 40B(2) will make it very clear that I can give general approval, and that is exactly what I would intend to do.
I do not propose to accept the amendment proposed by the Deputy. The reason I say this is that it provides that a copy of any direction issued under subsection (1) of section 40B, or any approval issued, should be laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. The Deputy can appreciate that in one year there were 3,066, so there is quite a large number. The statistical information I have to hand and that the Deputy is referring to is already laid before the Houses. The data on deployments of members of the Defence Forces in aid to the civil power are provided by my Department annually in a report by it and the Defence Forces. This report is laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. It is appropriate that a report with all of the information be laid before the Houses, as opposed to up to 3,066 individual reports, with some being laid every couple of days, if not daily. There is definitely a report laid before the Houses and I am happy to provide a copy of it to show Deputies exactly how the information is presented.
Comment on this
I will just make a couple of points in response to the Minister's answer to me. To be very clear, my questions were in respect of future protests. I asked whether the existing legislation would have covered protests, but I was referring to future protests. What the Minister is saying is that this legislation does allow the Defence Forces personnel to be used.
The Minister stated correctly that a number of provisions of the Defence Act allow the Minister to give general approval for various actions. Is there any other section relating to the Defence Forces, in terms of aid to the civil power, that includes a provision such as the one that refers to “such class or classes of assistance as may be agreed with the Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration”? Is there any other aspect of the Defence Forces in respect of which a Minister other than the Minister for Defence has a role in giving approval to the Defence Forces for any actions?
Comment on this
I will obtain clarity on this. The Defence Forces cannot deploy themselves overseas, so there would be a reference to that.
Comment on this
To the Minister for Defence, not another?
Comment on this
To me as Minister for Defence, not to another Minister.
Comment on this
We will edge down a small bit further. This all comes down to subsection 40B(3). If I am reading correctly between the lines of all the interaction up to now, the Minister needed to include the subsection so force could be used that is reasonable, proportionate and necessary. This is because it is not written anywhere and has no current legislative base. Is that correct?
Comment on this
It is not specific in the regulation, no.
Comment on this
However, it is the case in other forms of legislation for the Defence Forces.
Comment on this
Can the Minister read out the regulation under which she would be acting today, 19 May, if there were a situation outside where the Defence Forces were needed? On what legislative basis would she be acting?
Comment on this
Let me repeat the question. If we need a measure put in under section 40B(3) – I am summarising the Minister's interaction – and it is not in the regulation or legislation, presumably the country, or the Minister, is operating under the 1954 Act.
Comment on this
Can the Minister read out the part that gives cover to ensure aid to the civil power is covered as of today, before we pass this legislation?
Comment on this
It is spread out. The specific paragraph is not in it but it is spread across the legislation. For example-----
Comment on this
For example, there are references to firing conditions to be observed, revocation, reports, disposition of troops and principles. The references are spread across different areas, but what we are saying, and what the advice to me and the previous Minister states, is that it is for the Defence Forces and the Chief of Staff to set out what constitutes the reasonable use of force and what is proportionate and appropriate, as opposed to setting it out in the legislation here. Again, I can provide a copy of the current regulation. I am satisfied that what is in it ensures actions that have been taken by the Defence Forces through aid to the civil power are covered under law. However, what was proposed to me is what we have here now, namely a proposal to be put into primary legislation. The section the Deputy mentioned reflects something that, in any military operation, would be available. This would be developed by the Defence Forces. Subsection (3) would be developed specifically by the Defence Forces. What we are proposing is to deal with this succinctly in subsection (3) rather than having the set of relevant provisions spread across all the regulations. We can provide the regulations to the Deputy.
Comment on this
Okay, so it is spread across the regulations. Could the Minister give us an example of where she believes this is covered and state where she is reading from?
Comment on this
For example, regarding the disposition of troops, according to section 3(3) the officer commanding the military party-----
Comment on this
Which part is the Minister reading from?
Comment on this
This is from the regulation. I apologise if the Deputy does not have this.
Comment on this
We should not be going through this like this, by the way. This is crazy stuff.
Comment on this
It is the current regulation and it refers to the employment of troops in aid of the civil power in the maintenance or restoration of the public peace.
Comment on this
On what legislation is that regulation based?
Comment on this
This is not in primary legislation but it is made under the Defence Act 1954. It is secondary legislation.
Comment on this
Let me refer to the history of the regulation the Minister is reading from. There is a reason I am asking my question, obviously. There is the legislation of 1954. What is the regulation called?
Comment on this
It is on the employment of troops in aid of the civil power in the maintenance or restoration of the public peace.
Comment on this
That was a regulation built out of the legislation. When was that regulation introduced?
Comment on this
Again, I believe that is another reason it is important for us to update our legislation and why we were advised to put the provision into primary legislation. The regulation was introduced in 1967. It is what has been in place in respect of the C70s in respect of aid to the civil power. Again, as I have said, there is already case law that has stood this up. However, the recommendation is that it be put in primary legislation.
To answer the Deputy's question and give an example, under the heading on the disposition of troops, the officer commanding the military party shall be solely responsible for deciding the action the troops under his command are to take and the degree of force, if any, they are to use in the particular circumstances. It also states that, depending on the situation, the action necessary to restore law and order may vary from mere appearance of troops to the use of all forces at the commanding officer's disposal. However, this is something that is generally set out and provided for by the Defence Forces, through the Chief of Staff. What is set out here allows for that. Section 3 on aid to civil power states that a member of the Defence Forces deployed in aid of the civil power may use such force as is reasonable, proportionate and necessary in the performance of his or her duties. This is the case in any military operation that they take part in, not just in the aid to civil power.
Comment on this
The Minister said earlier that the advice to her was that it was the better thing to do. If we did not do this, would anything change?
Comment on this
What does the Minister mean by "most likely"?
Comment on this
Is the answer "Most likely" or "No"?
Comment on this
No. Nothing would change. It has been made very clear to me that the case law has stood up to what is there. However, the advice is that it would be better to have this in primary legislation. It does not change the way in which this is done. The C70 form that is asked for by the Garda of the Defence Forces, the approval, the way in which the Defence Forces would be deployed, none of that is changing in terms of how it is going to be approached. This is simply putting it on a statutory footing.
Comment on this
Why now? The Minister said it was her predecessor's work. Was this prompted by the Minister's Department or was it prompted by the Attorney General? That is the first question. When was the decision made to change this and put it into a Bill? My third question is, is there a need for this to be done prior to taking up the EU Presidency? Those are my three questions.
Comment on this
In regard to the last question, no.
Comment on this
The advice was obtained last year. I will have to get the date and come back to Deputy Kelly on that in terms of when it was given.
As to why now, as Minister, I see it as my role to bring forward legislation. In the previous Departments I have been in, I brought forward a lot of legislation. A number of Bills are coming down the line in my Department but they are not currently ready at the moment. If there was advice from the Attorney General, I would see it as my role to bring forward legislation. It is for the reason that I had a vehicle-----
Comment on this
It was the Department that prompted this, not the Attorney General.
Comment on this
I will come back to the Deputy to provide absolute clarity. I do not want to give a wrong answer, so I will get absolute clarity.
Comment on this
It is a pretty obvious question for this committee to ask.
Comment on this
Does the Minister want to confer with her colleagues? A Leas-Chathaoirligh, this is a pretty obvious question to ask: was this prompted by the AG or was it prompted by the Department? If it was prompted by the Department as a clean-up exercise, that is one thing. If it was prompted by the AG, that is probably more concerning from a committee point of view because there is probably a legal issue here that the AG is concerned about.
Comment on this
It is often the case that the Attorney General and Departments engage. However, I do not to give an incorrect answer, so I will revert to clarify the exact time.
Comment on this
Again, this is not coming from any specific incident that I am aware of. This has not come from any specific issue.
Comment on this
The Minister can come back to us on it.
Comment on this
Absolutely, and I think it would be better that I do and provide that information.
Comment on this
I have no problem with that, but it would have been expected that the Minister would have the answer to this pretty obvious question, to be fair, a Leas-Chathaoirligh. The Minister will revert with the date and who prompted it.
We are convinced that, if aid to the civil power was necessary today, nothing would be different regardless of whether this legislation was in place. Is that correct? That is 100% correct.
The reports were mentioned. How often are reports on such use laid before the Oireachtas?
Comment on this
Once a year. At the moment, my Department is compiling the 2025 information. That will be laid before the Houses soon. I do not have an exact date but it is generally once a year.
Comment on this
I do not mind not having a date. It might be a suggestion that, given we are putting this into primary legislation and there is a necessity to put it into primary legislation for some reason that we actually do not know, the reports should be laid before the Houses more frequently. In the spirit of co-operation and from a democratic deficit point of view, if I table an amendment on Report Stage requiring reports to be laid every quarter, the Minister might accept it purely because of the amount of these actions and because we as the Oireachtas should scrutinise them more often, especially now that there is a concern about why this provision has needed to be brought in all of a sudden. For the right reasons, if I table that amendment, the Minister might consider it.
The Minister said she needed to do this, and that is fine, but this is not the vehicle for doing it. This is not the legislation for doing it. Nobody on this committee could believe that this was the way we were going to do it. Why did the Minister not consider introducing a Bill herself? This is a piece of legislation on its own. I asked her about the urgency and the EU Presidency but there does not seem to be any reason. Case law seems to cover it. This a tidy-up exercise according to the information in front of us and the discussion we have had. Why did the Minister not introduce a Bill, as small as it might be, if there is not that urgency? To call a spade a spade and to be fair to the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, and given what happened in relation to the fuel protests, the Minister, Deputy McEntee, admitted herself that, while that might not have been the reason, the timing is not great. Why did the Minister, Deputy McEntee, not introduce legislation herself from the Department for Defence in relation to this?
Comment on this
Deputy Kelly has himself said that what we are doing here, and what I am doing here, is responding to a recommendation. It does not change how the C70 is deployed. It does not change how the Defence-----
Comment on this
The Minister told us that. I did not-----
Comment on this
I am saying very clearly that it does not. What I have set out here does not change it. What it does is put it on a primary legislation footing. It does not change any of the ways in which the Defence Forces may be deployed in respect of many of the areas that I have outlined. It does not change the engagement that takes place between An Garda Síochána and the Defence Forces. My view as Minister for Defence was that I would take the opportunity. I appreciate what Deputy Kelly is saying about how this is not the norm and I know it is not, but it has been the case in the past where other Departments have introduced amendments - not larger pieces of legislation, but amendments - through other vehicles that were available to them. My primary intention was to bring forward the maritime security legislation. There is a time sensitivity to that. There is no time sensitivity to this, but for all of the reasons I have outlined, these are two amendments that do not change the practice or the way in which any member may be deployed. They simply change it from secondary to primary legislation. What we have discussed as regards the protests had not yet happened. For me, this was a matter of bringing forward this legislation, doing my job as Minister for Defence and making sure that where there was advice, it was acted on when we could.
Comment on this
The clerk will have taken a note. There are quite a number of questions on which the Minister is to revert. Can we set a short timeline well before Report Stage to make sure we get those? Obviously, I presume that the answers come pretty quickly. Can we get a response by next week on those questions?
Comment on this
There is one main answer really, but the others are to provide the regulation and any of the other elements-----
Comment on this
There were questions about timelines as well.
Comment on this
I believe that is matter for the Department. Maybe-----
Comment on this
Is Deputy Kelly happy that his amendment has been dealt with or would he like to speak to it further?
Comment on this
I do not want to speak to it further. In the spirit of co-operation and in light the democratic deficit that we see here, I will table another amendment, which I hope the Minister will take, on shortening the reporting period, given the scale of what we are talking about here. She might engage with us on that.
Comment on this
I am not a member of the committee and I had no knowledge that the Minister was bringing this forward. I would say that most TDs would have been unaware. Why is this needed? The Minister has not given any clarity on that. Why is it being rushed through? Correct me if I am wrong, but I am deducing that the Minister wants to make this measure primary legislation to give more power to an individual soldier who may not feel confident or want to intervene in, perhaps, protests and strikes.
The Government got a fright from the recent events in this country where people blockaded critical infrastructure, roads and so on. That has the Department of justice or the Department of Defence worried. I am gobsmacked that yet another thing has been added on to this Bill to assist the Garda in aid of the civil power. A lot of people were shocked by the protests and the statement by the Minister for justice about bringing in the Army. I was not shocked because I remember times when the Army was used in strikes. Bin workers had their heads battered on Henry Street. I am old enough to remember that but most people would not. It seems to me now that the Government has got worried that maybe it needs to give more legal backing to the Army intervening against ordinary people. We are not talking about terrorists, foreign actors or anything like that.
I think it will be news to a lot of people that this provision is being brought in now in this Bill along with a million and five other things.
Comment on this
The difficulty with the Minister providing additional information next week is that the Bill will already have passed Committee Stage and these amendments will be included in the legislation. We have no way of knowing that Report Stage will not be guillotined, which is another hallmark of the Bill's parent Department under its current Minister. I could continue for another hour because there are so many questions, but I am conscious that there are Deputies who are not members of this committee who are here to speak to, primarily, the group of amendments containing amendment No. 10 and have taken time off work to be here for that. All of that speaks to this dysfunctional approach.
There is a clear solution. I have not heard any member raise any question or objection in respect of section 40A in the amendment, which is what she has told this committee is the priority and the reason this route was taken in order to have it in place with regard to maritime security. The simple answer is for the Minister to withdraw the aspects relating to sections 40B and 40C and deal with them in the appropriate place, which is the sectoral committee that has responsibility for defence, and in a way that will allow proper pre-legislative scrutiny and passage through the House in an appropriate way. That is the compromise. If we accept as bona fide, as outlined by the Minister, that there was a deficiency in the legislation, which we all accept and appreciate, it was in respect of maritime security. Section 40A deals with that. Sections 40B and 40C, from what the Minister has told this committee, are incidental and clean-up mechanisms that have come about as advice from the Attorney General. I suggest that the Minister remove them from her amendment. It will be passed and the matter of urgency she has outlined will be dealt with, and the issues and concerns that have been raised by members here can be dealt with at a later stage through a more appropriate mechanism.
Comment on this
Obviously, it is not for me to decide how quickly or how this legislation passes, but there are other opportunities to engage on these matters. I have been very clear that I will come back and provide any answers or clarifications to the Deputies.
I want to be clear because there is again an attempt to conflate two things. This is not as a result of anything that has happened in the last month. I could not have been clearer when bringing this to the Cabinet on 9 March that this was being introduced and that it would not in any way change the way in which the Defence Forces worked with An Garda Síochána, as they have done for decades, or the way in which a C70, if sought, would be deployed. What this simply does is take what is currently there in secondary legislation and put it into primary legislation. I am happy to provide any clarifications.
We had an opportunity to debate this in the House last week, we have an opportunity to discuss this here and now and the legislation will progress in the normal manner, but there is no intention here other than to put in primary legislation what is currently in secondary legislation. It does not change the structure of how the process will operate. This is something that has been worked on by my Department since last year and that I flagged on 9 March. Again, the attempt to conflate this with anything that has happened in the last month simply does not ring true and is not borne out by any of the timelines or facts.
Comment on this
This is absolute bonkers. We have a miscellaneous Bill that deals with a wide range of issues that are not getting the scrutiny they deserve. As I said during pre-legislative scrutiny, each aspect could have been dealt with on its own but they have been thrown in together.
For the benefit of the people who are watching, we are tagging something to do with defence onto something that deals with firearms, extradition, probation, counselling notes for sexual assaults, arrest warrants and sex for rent. The Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration has come here today and said that he will bring a whole raft of other amendments to this miscellaneous Bill, including on the issue of historical offences involving gay men, an amendment to the International Criminal Court Act 2006 and an amendment to the European Arrest Warrant Act 2003. This is bonkers. I would not have any confidence that this is the right way of doing things. If people are looking in here, I would say that they are shocked by how this committee is being treated.
No one has mentioned any issues with the maritime defence element. I do not think anybody has a problem with what the Minister for Defence is trying to do there. She should have introduced separate legislation on it instead of tagging the provision onto this Bill, but we are where we are. I do not think that she answered the question on why we needed to tag the provision onto this legislation when there is no rush around this legislation and it does not change anything. A question was asked and I do not know if it was answered, but why did the Minister not introduce her own legislation to deal with the issue that we are talking about? She could have done that and put it forward for pre-legislative scrutiny instead of tagging it onto something that we did not have time to deal with.
Comment on this
I have answered that question. This was a vehicle through which I was able to bring the provision forward. It is not changing any practice of the Garda or Defence Forces. This is changing from secondary legislation to primary legislation what is already in practice. From my point of view, this is an amendment to put a measure on a primary footing. It does not change the actual practice. I have been very clear and can set that out again. I appreciate that we have had an opportunity in the Dáil, and also here now, to discuss this matter as the legislation progressed, but this is a small change compared to what I appreciate is a large-scale miscellaneous Bill. I think I have answered that question quite broadly.
Comment on this
A lot has been said about the numerous pieces of this Bill, which I accept. I always find it interesting that there is an awful lot of discourse about us not passing enough legislation and that the justice committee is not doing enough. Here are the Ministers bringing forward legislation. Granted, we would all like more time to talk about things, but the laws that are being brought forward are to protect our citizens. The Ministers are seeking to place the legislation on a primary footing, particularly the provisions brought forward by the Minister, Deputy McEntee. That is welcome. The Minister has outlined the reasons. We are all agreed that section 40A on the maritime strategy and legislation is welcome, important and time sensitive, in that it needs to be introduced by 1 July prior to Ireland taking over the EU Presidency. It is efficient, then, to include the other matters that need to be tidied up. As the Minister said, they are not going to change anything in the way that the Defence Forces operate in aid to the civil power. However, it does give a degree of security to have it in primary legislation, which I welcome. I fully support the amendments.
Comment on this
Amendment put
Do you agree with this result?
Amendments Nos. 2 and 36 are related and may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:
In page 7, between lines 8 and 9, to insert the following:
“(c) by the insertion of the following section after section 4C:
“Seizure and detention of firearms or ammunition by An Garda Síochána in interest of public safety, security or peace
4D.(1) Where a member of An Garda Síochána who is—
(a) in a public place,
(b) in any other place—
(i) under a power of entry authorised by law, or
(ii) to which he or she was expressly or impliedly invited or permitted to be,
or
(c) carrying out a search authorised by law,
finds or comes into possession of any firearm or ammunition and has reasonable grounds for suspecting that, in connection with the firearm or ammunition, there is a danger to the public safety, security or the peace, he or she may seize and detain said firearm or ammunition for a period not exceeding 14 days.
(2) Where a member of An Garda Síochána has seized and detained a firearm or ammunition in accordance with subsection (1), a member of An Garda Síochána not below the rank of superintendent may, before the expiration of the period specified in subsection (1), if he or she is satisfied that—
(a) there are reasonable grounds for suspecting that the possession, use or carriage of the firearm or ammunition will endanger the public safety, security or the peace, and
(b) there are sufficient grounds, having regard to paragraph (a), to consider revocation under section 5 of the firearm certificate in respect of the firearm or ammunition seized and detained under subsection (1),
authorise the detention of the firearm or ammunition for a further period not exceeding 21 days so that an issuing person may determine whether the firearm certificate should be revoked under section 5.
(3) A person who obstructs or impedes a member of An Garda Síochána in the exercise of his or her powers under subsection (1) shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction to a class A fine or imprisonment for a term not exceeding six months or to both.
(4) This section shall not affect any other power, under any enactment or the common law, to seize or detain a firearm or ammunition.
(5) In this section, ‘enactment’ has the same meaning as it has in the Interpretation Act 2005.”,”.
This amendment proposes to amend section 4 of the Bill, which in itself amends the Firearms Act 1925. I want to put in a new paragraph, section 4D, which will provide a statutory basis for a member of An Garda Síochána to seize and temporarily detain a lawfully held firearm or ammunition where the member of An Garda Síochána has reasonable grounds for suspecting that, in connection with that firearm or ammunition, there is a danger to "the public safety, security or the peace". This is a targeted and proportionate measure to address the legislative gap. The Garda sometimes needs the tools to respond swiftly and effectively to seize a lawfully held weapon when there is an immediate risk to public safety.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister. I am glad he said what he said. I was looking around corners when I saw this pop up because he did not flag it on Second Stage. To be clear, this amendment gives members of the Garda the power to seize a firearm that they come across but that is legally held.
Comment on this
Obviously, the Garda has the power to take firearms and ammunition that are illegally held. In scenarios where gardaí are searching or going about their job and duties, and where they feel there is a reason to take a firearm off somebody legally holding one, this amendment gives them the legislative basis for doing so. There was a lacuna or gap there.
Comment on this
Have there been legal cases in this regard? How was this gap spotted?
Comment on this
No. This is something that has emanated-----
Comment on this
This seems like it is common sense, but how was it spotted?
Comment on this
The Garda recognise that there is a gap in the legislation if they go to a house or an abode and a person is there about whom there could be issues in terms of the mental health of the individual concerned-----
Comment on this
-----and concern about public safety. In that instance, the Garda has no basis upon which to seize a lawfully held weapon. This change will fill that gap. If we look at section 24 of the 1925 Act, and section 5, which provides for a revocation of a firearms certificate, that is a process that has to be gone through. There is nothing in our law, however, to address situations where gardaí are concerned about a person having a lawfully held shotgun. That is a threat to the public and I think it is a gap that needs to be filled.
Comment on this
I will be supporting this amendment. I just wanted to get an explanation of whether this was the reasoning behind the amendment.
Comment on this
I have a technical question. If someone has a legally held firearm and it is obvious to gardaí that the person is suffering from some form of mental health episode or something like that, they can take the firearm. There can be other reasons besides that, including the situation, circumstances, etc. Does this amendment cover both a firearm left in a premises or as part of somebody's property - it covers that obviously - and also disarming somebody?
Comment on this
If we look at subsection (1), it can happen in a public place or any other place. This means that if a garda has a warrant to go onto somebody's property and becomes aware that the person has a lawfully held firearm, it can be seized in that instance. It is not just for the purpose of mental health concerns, which was the example I used. It is for situations where "there is a danger to the public safety, security or the peace". Now, that could be a situation arising where somebody is going through a mental health episode, but there are broader areas than that.
Comment on this
Members of the Garda can disarm somebody, obviously. They can seize and detain a firearm for a period of 14 days. Obviously, if somebody is threatening a member of An Garda Síochána with a firearm, then they are entitled to disarm that person.
Comment on this
That is fine. I am just asking if it extends to everything, because it seems to me to be a pretty obvious amendment. It is kind of strange that we have got this far in life without it, to be honest.
Comment on this
I know, but I will not criticise people. The Garda says it is necessary, and I can understand why it is necessary, as every member of the committee can, I am sure.
Comment on this
I want to put on record that there are a number of amendments that would, under normal circumstances, cause me to have questions for the proposers. Over the next while, we are dealing with amendments from the Minister, Deputy Kelly and Deputy Ward. I am just conscious of the point made earlier that we have people who have gone to great lengths to be here for a particular aspect of the debate. I have sought clarification, which I think is that we cannot jump amendments-----
Comment on this
-----and come back to them, which is unfortunate. I will just say that there are aspects of the amendments we are dealing with that in the normal course of events it would be appropriate for me to ask questions about, but because of the circumstances we have found ourselves in, I do not think that approach is available to us right now.
Comment on this
No. I agree with Deputy Carthy. I would like to speed things up, so I have nothing else to add.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3:
In page 8, between lines 25 and 26, to insert the following:
“Amendment of Judicial Council Act 2019
8. The Judicial Council Act 2019 is amended—
(a) in section 12—
(i) in subsection (1)(a), by the substitution of “or their replacements nominated under subsection (2A) or (3), as the case may be” for “or their replacements nominated under subsection (3)”,
(ii) in subsection (2)(a), by the deletion of “, who shall act as chairperson of the Board”,
(iii) by the insertion of the following subsections after subsection (2):
“(2A) The Chief Justice may, from time to time, nominate in writing a judge (other than a judge who is a member of the Board) of the Supreme Court, Court of Appeal, High Court, Circuit Court or District Court to perform the functions of the Chief Justice as such ex officio member during such period or on such occasion or occasions as are specified in the nomination.
(2B) The Chief Justice shall be the chairperson of the Board and—
(a) shall nominate another member of the Board to act as chairperson during the period or on such occasion or occasions referred to in subsection (2A), and
(b) may, at any other time, nominate another member of the Board to act as chairperson during such period or on such occasion or occasions as are specified in the nomination concerned.”,
and
(iv) in subsection (3)—
(I) by the substitution of “An ex officio member of the Board, other than the Chief Justice, may” for “An ex officio member of the Board may”, and
(II) by the substitution of “of which he or she is President” for “of which he or she is Chief Justice or President, as the case may be,”,
and
(b) in section 44—
(i) in subsection (1)(a), by the substitution of “their replacements nominated under subsection (2A) or (3), as the case may be” for “their replacements nominated under subsection (3)”,
(ii) in subsection (2)(a), by the deletion of “, who shall act as chairperson of the Committee”,
(iii) by the insertion of the following subsections after subsection (2):
“(2A) The Chief Justice may, from time to time, nominate in writing a judge (other than an elected member of the Judicial Conduct Committee) of the Supreme Court, Court of Appeal, High Court, Circuit Court or District Court to perform the functions of the Chief Justice as such ex officio member during such period or on such occasion or occasions as are specified in the nomination and a reference in this Act to the Chief Justice as such ex officio member of the Judicial Conduct Committee shall, during such period or in respect of such occasion or occasions, be taken to be a reference to a judge so nominated.
(2B) The Chief Justice shall be the chairperson of the Judicial Conduct Committee and—
(a) shall nominate another member of the Judicial Conduct Committee who is a judge to act as chairperson of that Committee during the period or on such occasion or occasions referred to in subsection (2A), and
(b) may, at any other time, nominate another member of the Judicial Conduct Committee who is a judge to act as chairperson during such period or on such occasion or occasions as are specified in the nomination concerned.”,
and
(iv) in subsection (3)—
(I) by the substitution of “An ex officio member of the Judicial Conduct Committee, other than the Chief Justice, may” for “An ex officio member of the Judicial Conduct Committee may”, and
(II) by the substitution of “of which he or she is President” for “of which he or she is Chief Justice or President, as the case may be,”.”.
This is a short amendment. It is designed to facilitate the Chief Justice, who has a lot of non-judicial functions. One of them is in respect of his membership of the Judicial Council and the Judicial Conduct Committee. I am proposing this amendment as an efficiency measure to reduce the non-judicial obligations of the Chief Justice and similar obligations on ordinary judges of the Supreme Court, thereby allowing them more time to deal with pressing judicial matters arising for the Chief Justice and the Supreme Court.
This provision will amend sections 12 and 44 of the Judicial Council Act 2019 for the purpose to enable the Chief Justice to nominate a judge of the Supreme Court, Court of Appeal, High Court, Circuit Court or District Court as a replacement for him or her on the board and the Judicial Conduct Committee, rather than just a judge of the Supreme Court as is currently provided for. It does the same in respect of the Judicial Conduct Committee.