We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Select Sub-Committee on Education and Skills

Technological Universities Bill 2015: Committee Stage

Contributions 1–144 of 284. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Technological Universities Bill 2015
Enacted

No. 121 of 2015 ›

The topic for debate today is Committee Stage of the Technological Universities Bill 2015. The main purpose of the Bill is to provide for the establishment of technological universities which is a new type of higher education institution to be formed through the consolidation and merger of existing institutes of technology. The Bill also provides for the revision of the governance arrangements of the Dublin Institute of Technology and the institutes of technology, under the Dublin Institute of Technology Act 1992 and the Regional and Technological Colleges Act 1992, respectively. The Bill is comprised of 117 sections that are divided into seven Parts together with two Schedules. Members will recall that the joint committee considered the proposed Bill in 2014 as part of its pre-legislative scrutiny procedures. After that committee heard from a range of witnesses it produced a report which included recommendations for consideration by the Minister.

I welcome the Minister for Education and Skills, Deputy Jan O'Sullivan, and officials from her Department to the meeting. I reiterate that members and guests should place their telephones on aeroplane or safe mode or completely switch them off for the duration of the meeting. I propose that if possible, the sub-committee concludes its consideration of Committee Stage during today's meeting. Is that agreed? Agreed. I refer members to the list of grouped amendments for the purpose of debate which has been circulated. We will now commence consideration of the Bill.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 1 to 6, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 1:

In page 9, between lines 27 and 28, to insert the following:

" "academics" means tenured officers of the institute;".

I think the amendments are self-explanatory. They seek to insert definitions.

Comment on this
Jan O'Sullivan Minister for Education and Skills Labour Party

I thank the committee for its pre-legislative scrutiny. Many of the points made at the time have been taken on board in the drafting of the Bill. A number of amendments relate to more general issues rather than to the specific purpose of the Bill and certainly will be considered in the context of other legislation. It is probable that there will not be any other legislation in the lifetime of this Dáil but certainly the Quality and Qualifications Ireland Assurance (Education and Training) Act has to be amended and a higher education reform Bill is planned. They may be appropriate places for some of the points that will be raised during the course of the debate. For the technological universities and the consortia that are interested in becoming technological universities, they need this legislation before they can move to the final stages.

As the Deputy has said, he is seeking to insert new definitions into section 2 while amendment No. 6 would have the effect of deleting the phrase "or appointed" from the definition of "student" as currently set out in the Bill. However, amendments Nos. 1, 2, 4 and 5 would insert definitions for words which are not actually used in the Bill nor in any of the other amendments tabled by the Deputy, and for that reason I believe they are unnecessary. Amendment No. 3 would insert a limited definition for the word "programme", a word which is used in the Bill. However, the term "programme of education and training" is defined in the Bill, by reference to the extensive definition of the term set out in the Qualifications and Quality Assurance (Education and Training) Act 2012. Introducing an additional definition of the word "programme" would, therefore, introduce uncertainty with regard to the correct definition of the term. Amendment No. 6, which would have the effect of deleting "or appointed" from the definition of "student", would unnecessarily limit the scope of that definition. For these reasons, I cannot support the amendments.

Comment on this

I will be pushing the amendments.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy have any further questions or comments?

Comment on this

Does any other Member wish to comment?

Comment on this

Following on from the Minister's general comments, I understand - correct me if I am wrong - the mergers can go ahead but there is no guarantee they will get the status of a technical university following the merger. Therefore, is there a possibility that we could have mergers without status?

Comment on this

The criteria originally announced were that there were various stages that had to be gone through. One of the stages is the merger of the relevant institutes of technology. The stage beyond that is attaining the status of a technological university. It was always very clear in the criteria that the mergers would happen prior to attaining the status of a technological university. As people will have a very good idea of how they are progressing, I do not think that should be a deterrent to the progress of the institutions that want to become technological universities and are progressing well.

Comment on this

There is a danger they could merge and not get technological university status and then the smaller ITs would be subsumed into bigger ones. There is that possibility.

Comment on this

When institutes of technology were invited to consider this proposal, they would have been fully aware of the criteria. I do not think it is appropriate that we would change the criteria at this stage.

Comment on this

One would have to acknowledge that the criteria have caused huge issues particularly among staff.

Comment on this

We will address the issue further when we discuss amendments on issues that are of concern to staff. I do not know how much further the Chairman wants this conversation to continue, as we will come to it later.

Comment on this

There has been an extensive consultation process. I understand the issue. I have received the representations the same as the Deputies from unions representing staff. We will come to all of this later. I am certainly aware of the considerations.

Comment on this

Is Deputy O'Brien pressing his amendment?

Comment on this

The advantage of withdrawing the amendments is that he can table them again.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy withdrawing the amendment?

Comment on this

I will withdraw the six amendments on the understanding that I can table them on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Okay.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 7, 18 to 20, inclusive, 24 and 26 are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:

In page 12, between lines 11 and 12, to insert the following:

" "Trade Union" means registered representative body with a negotiation licence.".

Amendment No. 7 is self-explanatory. Amendment No. 9 seeks to delete-----

Comment on this

Amendment No. 9 is not included in this list. Amendments Nos. 18 to 20, inclusive, are on the list.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 18 to 20-----

Comment on this

Does the Minister wish to comment?

Comment on this

All the amendments are connected with trade unions.

Comment on this

They have to do with trade unions and staff associations. The Bill, in sections 63, 67, 79 and 83, provides that members of staff of bodies dissolved under the Bill shall automatically become members of staff of the relevant merged institute or technological university. In addition, those sections ensure that transferring members of staff shall retain their existing conditions of remuneration, unless those conditions are varied in accordance with a collective agreement "negotiated with a recognised trade union or staff association". This is a standard provision which can be found in a wide range of legislation dealing with the transfer of staff from one body to another, including the Education and Training Boards Act 2013, the Roads Act 2015, the Local Government Reform Act 2014 and the Competition and Consumer Protection Act 2014. Amendments Nos. 7, 18 to 20, inclusive, 24 and 26, tabled by Deputy O'Brien, would have the effect of varying this standard wording and, for that reason, I cannot support them.

Comment on this

In regard to the transfer of staff, I want to ensure that conditions and service will also transfer in terms of pensions and superannuation schemes. I am aware there are a number of superannuation schemes although the Bill refers to a superannuation scheme. I wish to flag that it does not refer to schemes.

Comment on this

The intention is that all of those things would be fully taken on board. As I have said, they have been incorporated in other legislation. That is the system that has worked. I will look at the issue of "scheme" versus "schemes" but I do not think it should cause any material problems.

Comment on this

I will table an amendment on Report Stage listing all the various schemes.

Comment on this

Okay. We will check to ensure the wording is correct.

Comment on this

Are there any other comments or questions on that issue?

Comment on this

I seek clarification on the term "staff association".

Comment on this

We say "recognised trade union or staff association". In most cases there would be recognised trade unions but maybe in a small number of cases they would be described as staff associations. We say that in order to be comprehensive in terms of what is included.

Comment on this

Does the Minister have any particular example of a staff association?

Comment on this

It is the standard terminology that is used in all legislation. There may not be any relevant ones in this case but it is used in general to ensure that we do not leave anybody out.

Comment on this

Could it lead to a staff association-----

Comment on this

Some professional bodies would have associations rather than unions. There may not be any in this case. I can check it before we come to Report Stage to see if there are any specific associations.

Comment on this

Have the trade unions queried that wording?

Comment on this

Unless this is where this is coming from, it may well be. I have received representations from the trade union but I do not recall seeing that as a particular issue but it may well be and it may well have been raised by them.

Comment on this

I have concerns around the inclusion of staff associations.

Comment on this

Again, we can check and see if there are any specifics available on that. Certain trade unions would have negotiating rights that cannot be in any way modified. We are just putting it in because it is a standard term used in legislation to ensure we are being comprehensive. It is not designed in any way to water down the role of trade unions.

Comment on this

Would one of the issues relate to the freedom of association provisions in the Constitution? Would it be to cover those provisions?

Comment on this

We try to be consistent in all legislation when using these terminologies. Sometimes that prevents problems arising later and legislation being challenged. It is entirely designed to be comprehensive and in conjunction with standard procedures for legislation in general.

Comment on this

Are there any other comments or questions on that amendment? How stands amendment No. 7?

Comment on this

I press the amendment.

Comment on this

Are there any questions or comments on the section?

Comment on this

We will be bringing forward an amendment on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Will Deputy O'Brien give us some indication of the amendment?

Comment on this

We will be looking to amend the proposal that the dissolution would be made by the Minister.

Comment on this

We are opposing this section.

Comment on this

Does Deputy O'Brien wish to make any comment on the section?

Comment on this

The section provides, "The Minister shall, by order, appoint a day." This power rests solely with the Minister and we think it should be not just the Minister's call but that it should be done on the recommendation of the governing body or that there should be some mechanism within the institutes themselves to indicate that they are ready for dissolution. This section does not allow for that. I will flag now that the same objection applies to section 10.

Comment on this

Does the Minister wish to make any comment?

Comment on this

The main purpose of the Bill is to provide for the establishment of technological universities, which is a new type of higher education institution, to be formed through the consolidation and merger of existing institutes of technology. Chapter 3 of Part 2 provides a general mechanism for the merging of consortiums of institutes of technology to form new institutions of greater scale. This mechanism includes assessment by an expert panel of their application to merge. In 2014, consortiums in Dublin, made up of DIT and the institutes of technology in Blanchardstown and Tallaght, and in Munster, made up of Cork Institute of Technology and the Institute of Technology, Tralee, were assessed by an international expert panel and found to be on a clear trajectory to meet the very robust performance and quality criteria that had been set down for merging institutes which wished to apply for the new technological university status.

Therefore, these consortiums have already completed the stage of the process set down in Chapter 3 of Part 2 and are working towards a full merger in the near future. For that reason, Chapter 1 provides for the merging of DIT with IT, Blanchardstown and IT, Tallaght while Chapter 2, including sections 10 and 11, provides for the merging of CIT and IT, Tralee, as the next steps of the process on which those institutions have embarked. To be clear, these are not forced mergers, as characterised by some. Each of the consortiums has of its own accord come together to work towards achieving technological university status. The purpose of Chapters 1 and 2 of Part 2, including sections 10 and 11, is simply to ensure that these consortiums are not required to go back to square one and be reassessed by an expert panel. For that reason, the proposal by the Deputy that sections 7 and 10 be deleted from the Bill cannot be supported. Essentially, it is to facilitate the process which is ongoing.

Comment on this

To clarify, it does not appear that there was a submission by Deputy O'Brien to oppose the section. It is not listed here. It is listed for sections 10 and 11.

Comment on this

I understand that but I am just saying that when section 7 is-----

Comment on this

Are you saying-----

Comment on this

I will be putting forward an amendment on Report Stage in respect of section 7 but I will also oppose it today. In relation to sections 10 and 11-----

Comment on this

We will come to those in due course, Deputy, if you do not mind. I am trying to be helpful. Do you intend to table an amendment to the section as opposed to opposing it?

Comment on this

Ideally, I would like to see it deleted but if not, I will table an amendment to provide that the dissolution day would only happen following an application by the governing bodies and-or the president. The application would be accompanied by a statement that the terms of the merger have been agreed with staff trade unions. This would be the basis to the amendment.

Comment on this

The points that I made on section 10 apply similarly to section 7, so when we come to section 10, I have already covered the response. I understand Deputy O'Brien will propose an amendment rather than just oppose the section.

Comment on this

An amendment will more than likely be tabled.

Comment on this

To go back to that point, I know that extensive discussions have taken place but the main trade union, which is the TUI, has concerns. While it is not opposed to the idea of a technological university, there are concerns. One of those concerns is that a merger can go ahead without agreement from the staff trade union. The amendment will be to ensure that those issues are addressed before a merger can go ahead.

Comment on this

We can debate those points on Report Stage. There are no amendments before us right now but it is helpful to know what are the Deputies' concerns.

Comment on this

This section is being opposed by Deputy O'Brien. Does he wish to say anything further on it?

Comment on this

No, we have covered it.

Comment on this

Does the Minister wish to add anything?

Comment on this

I intend to bring forward amendments to sections 10 and 11 on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Brien opposes section 11.

Comment on this

I will bring forward an amendment on Report Stage in respect of the phrase, "Two or more colleges".

Comment on this

Does the Deputy seek a response from the Minister on that at this stage?

Comment on this

No, this is just to indicate an amendment will be tabled on Report Stage in this regard.

Comment on this

I wish to indicate I intend to table an amendment to section 17(2) regarding the applicant colleges and the need to provide that other stakeholders such as, for example, staff may make representations to the Minister.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy seek a response from the Minister at this Stage? Is the Minister in a position to respond to that suggestion?

Comment on this

Again, I suppose "colleges" is an inclusive term although I acknowledge the Deputy's particular concern is for staff. The question that will arise is whether one should name other elements of the college. If one names one element of the group, should one name students or others? That would be my concern, whereas "colleges" is an inclusive term.

Comment on this

I also intend to table an amendment on Report Stage in this regard.

Comment on this

Following on from the previous matter raised in respect of section 13, I wish to indicate I also intend to table an amendment to section 18 to amend "colleges" to "college".

Comment on this

Does the Minister wish to respond?

Comment on this

That will be on Report Stage.

Comment on this

While I am not supposed to be partisan, if there is an amendment from the Opposition that can be taken, it should just be taken. Perhaps there could be some liaising in this regard if the principle is conceded. While it is not my call to make, as someone who has tabled amendments previously, I believe that if an amendment from the Opposition can be taken, it should be taken if there is no disagreement on its substance.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 8:

In page 19, line 32, to delete “, as it sees fit,”.

Section 22 sets out the functions of technological universities established under the Bill, including the provision of programmes of education and training, the making of awards and undertaking high-quality and relevant research. In keeping with the distinctive mission of these institutions to provide high-quality, enterprise-focused higher education for their regions, the purpose of this amendment is to ensure those technological universities engage fully with regional stakeholders in the effective transfer of knowledge arising from research.

Comment on this

I wish to indicate my intention to table an amendment on Report Stage on the functions of a technological university.

Comment on this

I wish to do likewise. I am a member of some of the bodies overseeing the Grangegorman development and the nature of the amendment will be to indicate the extent of the community and the social engagement between the college, that is, the Dublin Institute of Technology, DIT, and the communities. There is a need to consider social communities and cultural activities and as this should be specified, I also intend to table an amendment in this regard. It is a matter the Minister might take on board in the meantime.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 9 and 10 are related and will be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 9:

In page 21, to delete lines 21 and 22 and substitute the following:

“(i) be established following consultation with trade unions representing employees of the technological university, where the matters in dispute relate to staff, or with the Students’ Union where the matters in dispute relate to students,”.

These amendments are self-explanatory. The purpose of amendment No. 9 is to delete lines 21 and 22 and to substitute them with provisions for consultation with the trade unions representing employees where the matters in dispute relate to staff or with the student unions where the matters in dispute relate to students. The purpose of amendment No. 10 is to delete lines 25 and 26 and to substitute them with the phrase "be published in such manner as the technological university considers appropriate jointly agreed by the parties concerned".

Comment on this

This is about keeping the wording similar to other legislation in the sector. Section 22, which sets out the requirement that technological universities establish procedures for the resolution of disputes, largely mirrors the wording of the relevant provisions of the Universities Act 1997, the Regional Technical Colleges Act 1992 and the Dublin Institute of Technology Act 1992. Amendment No. 9 would remove from that section the standard reference to staff associations, as well as trade unions. I acknowledge members already have had some discussion on this and I have indicated that I will get specific information as to whether there are any staff associations that might have relevance to this legislation. I will revert with that information on Report Stage. The amendment also unnecessarily distinguishes between the dispute resolution procedures which would apply to staff and those which would apply to students.

Amendment No. 10, in providing that the method of publication of those procedures must be jointly agreed with "the parties concerned", goes further than is necessary. Institutes of technology and universities currently make those procedures available both in hard copy and electronically. This also would be the case for technological universities and this is why I do not believe it is necessary to have that.

Comment on this

Why does the Minister oppose the procedures being jointly agreed?

Comment on this

I understand it pertains to their publication. In the current situation, they already must be agreed in the colleges and that also would apply in technological universities. My point is it already is catered for and covered.

Comment on this

In section 22(k)(iii), the word "practicable" is a very loose word. When the word "practicable" is used, it provides too much of an out clause, as opposed to the words "must" or "shall". Consequently, I intend to table an amendment in this regard on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 10:

In page 21, to delete lines 25 and 26 and substitute the following:

"(iii) be published in such manner as the technological university considers appropriate jointly agreed by the parties concerned.".

Comment on this

I know the Minister is not going to take on board any of my proposed amendments to the Bill but I hope some of the concerns we are raising today will at least be addressed on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I have taken a note of the indications Deputies O'Brien and O'Sullivan have given of some amendments that they might put forward. We will examine those during the time between now and Report Stage as well as the ones of which we are already aware.

Comment on this

I indicated on Second Stage that unless some amendments are made to the legislation that we could not support it, even though we support the concept of technological universities. As the Bill currently stands, some changes must be made to it.

Comment on this

I understand the Deputy's point and, as I said, I have taken notes on the extra issues that have been raised today.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 11:

In page 22, to delete lines 12 to 17 and substitute the following:

"(2) A member of the academic staff or a student learner of a technological university shall not, subject to the provisions of any enactment or rule of law, be disadvantaged, or subject to less favourable treatment by the technological university, arising from his or her questioning and testing received wisdom, putting forward new ideas or stating controversial or unpopular opinions in his or her teaching, research and any other activities either in or outside the technological university.".

I will not go into the detail of the proposed amendment because the Minister will not be supporting it. It proposes to delete lines 12 to 17 and substitute the text set out.

Comment on this

This amendment is about academic freedom. The principle of academic freedom is a defining characteristic of high quality, higher education and research throughout the world. The Bill rightly ensures that academic freedom shall apply in technological universities in the same manner as it applies in universities. However, it is understood internationally that academic freedom applies to academic staff of higher education institutions and both this Bill and the Universities Act 1997 reflect that understanding.

Amendment No. 11 in extending academic freedom to students would put technological universities in a different position to their peers, both within the State and internationally. That would be a real issue in terms of how we are consistent across the sector. That is my concern there.

Comment on this

What is the disadvantage to it?

Comment on this

The principle of academic freedom is a very cherished one in terms of academics being able to express viewpoints that may be contrary to Government or to the leadership in the particular academic institution and that is really valuable. If one was to change that in any way, we would need to have a conversation across the sector and engage with the entire sector.

Comment on this

We are not proposing to change it but to add a provision that students can also have that same freedom.

Comment on this

If one were to say that for technological universities, one would have to say it for all universities and all institutes of technology.

Comment on this

One would have to amend other legislation as well as this legislation. I do not think that we are in a position to do that in the context of what is relatively narrow legislation in that this is specifically about the establishment of technological universities.

Comment on this

The Deputy is the Minister and she can amend any legislation she wants.

Comment on this

It is a matter that can certainly be discussed. As I said, other Bills are coming down the tracks in regard to this whole sector. This is an example of one of the areas where I said at the outset that some of the proposed amendments relate to the entire sector and that it would not be appropriate to have what they propose apply only to technological universities and not to the other institutes of technology or universities.

Comment on this

I indicate that I intend to bring forward an amendment in this respect on Report Stage. I want to press this amendment but clearly it will not be accepted.

Comment on this

Perhaps the clerk to the committee would clarify the position. If the Deputy presses his amendment, he cannot submit the same amendment on Report Stage.

Comment on this

It would be a different amendment because I would include all the other items of legislation to which the Minister referred.

Comment on this

I do not know about that.

Comment on this

I would like clarification on that point.

Comment on this

We will not be able to get it at this time but it is my understanding-----

Comment on this

The Chairman is saying that if I press this amendment I cannot bring forward an amendment on Report Stage that would be-----

Comment on this

That would be very similar.

Comment on this

-----more extensive with respect to including other legislation.

Comment on this

The Deputy is talking about it being a different amendment. I would not be able to make a ruling on that now. That is something the Deputy will have to follow up later.

Comment on this

If the Chairman cannot make a ruling on it, how-----

Comment on this

If I can intervene, I would certainly be disposed towards accepting that Opposition members could put forward amendments on Report Stage.

Comment on this

There is a ruling about this and to be sure, I would advise the Deputy to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

To be sure, I am willing to withdraw the amendment on the understanding that on Report Stage I will be bringing forward an amendment along these lines but also extending it beyond technological universities.

Comment on this

Once the Deputy withdraws the amendment, there will be no problem with that.

Comment on this

Is that fair enough?

Comment on this

Sure.

Comment on this

To be clear, is the Minister saying that if I wanted to change the text to include students, I would have to apply that change to all of the other items of legislation?

Comment on this

I was making a general point that amendments proposed to this legislation should be applicable across the sector. It would be more appropriate to first have a consultation with the sector and to ensure then that we can amend various other items of legislation. It might be easier to do it in a further piece of legislation rather than try to tag on to this legislation issues that are relevant to other items of legislation. We have not tried to change anything in other parts of that particular sector through this legislation. It is probably an inappropriate place to change general points. That is my view. The Deputy is entitled to have a different view.

Comment on this

I wish to indicate that I will be tabling an amendment because I believe the governing body needs other representation. For example, the trade unions will be anxious about this one. With respect to the communities where the institutes have been located, I know the extent of the relationship they have had with communities. I would like to see that community social environment also represented. Is there not a role for the local authorities to be represented on the governing body? My experience in Dublin is that the local authority does have a significant role to play.

Comment on this

I support what Deputy O'Sullivan said regarding the governing body. I, too, will be bringing forward an amendment on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Does the Minister wish to respond on those points?

Comment on this

I will comment on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 12 is in the name of Deputy O'Brien and involves the deletion of section 25. This is complex but I will try to guide people through it. Amendment No. 12 and the amendments Nos. 1 to 4, inclusive, to amendment No. 12 will be discussed together. Amendments Nos. 1 to 4, inclusive, to amendment No. 12 are proposed by Deputy Clare Daly and Deputy O'Sullivan is substituting for Deputy Clare Daly.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 12:

In page 22, between lines 23 and 24, to insert the following:

“Membership of governing body of technological university

25. (1) A governing body, having not fewer than 11 and not more than 20 members, shall consist of—

(a) the president,

(b) a chairperson (in this section and Schedule 1 referred to as the "chairperson") who shall be an external member, appointed by the governing body,

(c) three members of the academic staff of the technological university, elected by the academic staff of the technological university,

(d) two members of the non-academic staff of the technological university, elected by the non-academic staff of the technological university,

(e) two undergraduate students of the technological university, nominated by the student union in accordance with its own procedures,

(f) one post-graduate student of the technological university, nominated by the student union in accordance with its own procedures, and

(g) ten external members, at least one of whom has expertise in standards and practice in higher education outside the State, nominated by a committee of the governing body comprising the chairperson and 2 other external members of the governing body formed for that purpose including—

(i) two external members nominated, in accordance with its or their own procedures, by the education and training board or boards in whose education and training board area the campuses of the technological university are located,

(ii) two external members of local authorities nominated, in accordance with its or their own procedures, by the local authorities in whose area the campuses of the technological university are located,

(iii) two external members of Seanad Eireann nominated in accordance with its or their own procedures, and

(iv) two external members from trade unions nominated in accordance with its or their own procedures whose members work in the technological university.

(2) (a) The term of office of a member of the governing body, other than the president, shall not exceed 4 years and such a member may not serve more than 2 consecutive terms of office.

(b) A member of the governing body who is a student at the technological university shall hold office for such period, not exceeding one year, as the governing body may determine but may be re-appointed for a further period not exceeding one year.

(3) Before appointing members under subsection (1)(g) the governing body shall agree with An tÚdarás the competencies required of such members relating to areas such as business, enterprise, finance, law, corporate governance, human resources, community organisation or other areas relevant to the functions of the technological university.

(4) (a) The governing body shall, for the purposes of this section, make regulations of a technological university relating to conduct of elections, seeking of nominations for appointment and appointment of members to the governing body.

(b) In making regulations of a technological university under paragraph (a) the technological university shall have regard to the objective that at least 40 per cent of members of the governing body shall be women and at least 40 per cent shall be men.

(5) In this section, “external member” in relation to a technological university means a person who is not—

(a) the president,

(b) a member of the academic council,

(c) a member of staff of the technological university, or

(d) a student of the technological university.".

Given that there are amendments to amendment No. 12, I am willing to withdraw the amendment but I indicate that I will bring forward a new amendment on Report Stage which will include, particularly with respect to subsection 1(g) of the existing legislation in regard to external members of the governing body, that they should be appointed by the Minister for transparency and accountability reasons. I will be incorporating that into a new amendment on Report Stage. I am quite willing to withdraw the amendment at this stage.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy formally withdrawing it?

Comment on this

I formally withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

That will mean the amendments to the amendment will fall, but does Deputy O'Sullivan wish to comment on these?

Comment on this

Yes, we have an interesting amendment included in this group. It is interesting at a time when there are concerns about political appointees, that we are seeking a role for the Minister to make appointments and that these appointees will be accountable to the Minister. This is a concern and I will raise the issue again on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Does the Minister wish to comment further?

Comment on this

The amendments relate to the membership of governing authorities and the various bodies that should be included. The joint committee conducted pre-legislative scrutiny on this Bill and there was significant discussion on the issue of how the governing bodies should be constituted. One of the principles is that they should not be too large so that they can be effective in terms of size. There were Seanad Members on that committee. I have nothing against Seanad Members but I am concerned a number of proposals in these amendments would add to the size of governing authorities.

In regard to the amendment in the name of Deputy O'Sullivan, I understand the intention is to provide that certain members of the governing body would be appointed by the Minister rather than by the governing body. There are differing views on that. One of the purposes of the reform of the governing structures of higher education institutions in the technological sector is to grant governing bodies greater autonomy in the appointment of their members, within the parameters of a competency framework to be agreed by the governing bodies and the HEA. Providing that the Minister, rather than the governing bodies, is responsible for those appointments diminishes that autonomy.

With regard to the second proposed amendment to amendment No. 12, the Bill currently provides that each governing body shall have between one and three academic staff as members. Those members will be elected by the staff themselves. As I said earlier, this proposal could serve to increase the size of the governing body, which runs counter to the policy for governing authorities of higher education students to be smaller and more effective. The suggestion that staff representatives be appointed from each of the institutes of technology involved does not accord with the establishment, through the merger of institutes of technology, of multi-campus technological universities with unified and integrated management and governance structures.

In regard to the point made about members being "recommended" rather than "nominated", this might create uncertainty. Where a person is nominated, it is clear he or she should be appointed. However, where people are recommended, it is unclear whether the governing body is required to appoint them or whether it can reject the recommendation. We could spend a lot of time discussing whether we should have more autonomy for institutions or whether the Minister should have more power, but I hope the Deputy accepts the point I am making in regard to "nominated" rather than "recommended".

In the context of decision-making, we do not want the governing bodies to be too cumbersome. At the same time, we want the competencies to be provided for on them. Anybody with responsibility for an institution as large and as important as this needs the competencies required for good governance. The governing body will also have between one and three academic staff as members. These will be elected by the staff themselves, which is important.

Comment on this

There are concerns about the low number of academics who might be on the governing bodies, although these are the people who are actively engaged in working, teaching and doing research. There is a concern there might only be one academic on the body.

I understand the point the Minister has made regarding a merger and about the creation of a new entity, but for an interim period each of the merged colleges should have a representative on the governing body.

Comment on this

We will come to amendments I have put forward relating to interim arrangements later. One of the reasons there is a merger before full university status is granted is to ensure it is genuinely one institution on day one of becoming a technological university. This is preferable to having two or three separate institutions merging afterwards. The intention is to ensure they become a unified institution.

Comment on this

It will be very difficult to achieve a successful merger if the individual colleges do not have a voice on the governing body.

I wish to indicate, therefore, that I will bring forward an amendment on Report Stage on the need for representation, even for just a period of time.

Comment on this

On that, our committee made a recommendation regarding representation from local authorities. This was a key recommendation of the committee, which was a cross-party committee. I am aware that as Chair, I cannot be partisan, but it was a recommendation of our report. The thinking behind local authority representation previously was the need for democratic accountability. This is part of our second level system where State schools such as ETB schools have such representation. Local authorities represent the community, which provides democratic accountability of the institution for the community. What is the Minister's thinking behind not including such a provision in the legislation?

Comment on this