We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Special Committee Public Charitable Hospitals (Temporary Provisions) Bill, 1929

Election of Chairman

Bill Public Charitable Hospitals (Temporary Provisions) Bill, 1929
Enacted

No. 55 of 1929 ›

Prof. James Craig Deputy Sir James Craig Independent

I propose that Deputy Doyle take the Chair.

Comment on this

Our first business is to decide whether or not representatives of the Press should be admitted to the proceedings of the Committee.

Comment on this

I propose that they be not admitted.

Comment on this

Our next business is to fix a date up to which amendments, if any, to the Bill will be received, and further, to fix a date for the meeting of the Committee at which these amendments will be considered.

Comment on this
Prof. James Craig Deputy Sir J. Craig Independent

Amendments could be received from to-day. I should like to point out, however, that this Bill may have been drawn up by a layman, for all I know to the contrary. I know nothing about the draftsmanship of the Bill at all. It was handed to me by Sir Joseph Glynn. I take it that the Bill, with the amendments we make, will go to the draftsman. I should like that the Bill, as amended by us, should be put in proper shape by the Parliamentary Draftsman.

Comment on this

I think we have not reached that stage yet.

Comment on this

The Second Reading of the Bill has been carried. Therefore, I think we are entitled to any assistance the office can supply in the way of expert knowledge.

Comment on this
Prof. James Craig Deputy Sir J. Craig Independent

Do you not agree that the Bill, plus our amendments, should go to the draftsman to be put into proper shape?

Comment on this

I do not think that the draftsman would undertake to draft amendments.

Comment on this
Prof. James Craig Deputy Sir J. Craig Independent

No, but when they are agreed to they should be sent to him with the Bill.

Comment on this

I am sure they will be put in proper form after they are agreed to.

Comment on this
Prof. James Craig Deputy Sir J. Craig Independent

That is what I have in mind.

Comment on this

You suggest that before the Report Stage the Bill, with amendments, should go to the draftsman?

Comment on this
Prof. James Craig Deputy Sir J. Craig Independent

We will discuss amendments and, if we agree upon them, I suggest that they should go with the Bill to the draftsman, so that it will be presented to the House in proper form.

Comment on this

When we reach that stage, the Secretary will be able to tell us, from inquiry, what assistance we can obtain.

Comment on this
Prof. James Craig Deputy Sir J. Craig Independent

The Minister for Justice may desire to tighten up some provisions of the Bill as far as his office is concerned. Will he send his amendments through the members of the Government Party?

Comment on this

I do not know that he will.

Comment on this
Prof. James Craig Deputy Sir J. Craig Independent

I think we should ask him whether he desires to put in any amendments or not. It would be better that we should have the Minister's amendments before us.

Comment on this

The Minister will get the same information about the Committee being in session as anybody else.

Comment on this

I think the Chairman might see the Minister, inform him of the arrangements, and apprise him as to the last day on which amendments will be received.

Comment on this

I will do that.

Comment on this

Could we arrange, provisionally, a date up to which to receive amendments but not fix that date as the final date?

Comment on this

We can fix a date and ask members to send in amendments before that date, but amendments can be received at any time by the unanimous wish of the Committee. It would be well, however, that as many amendments as possible should be sent in before the suggested date, so that there will be sufficient business to go on with.

It was agreed to request members to furnish any amendments they desired to bring forward before noon on Monday, 3rd March.

The next business is to fix the date of the next meeting.

Comment on this

I propose that the next meeting of the Committee be held on Thursday next at 10.30 a.m.

Comment on this

Thursday morning next will not suit me. Would it not be possible to hold the meeting during the sitting of the Dáil?

Comment on this

I understand that there is objection to the holding of Committee meetings during sittings of the Dáil. The proceedings would have to be interrupted, in any event, to enable members to take part in the divisions.

Comment on this

Thursday morning does not suit me, but I will make an endeavour to attend if it suits the majority of the members.

Comment on this

Wednesday morning would be inconvenient to country members, as it would mean travelling on Tuesday.

Motion by Deputy Dr. O'Dowd put and agreed to.

Next meeting to be held at 10.30 a.m. on Thursday, 6th March.

The Committee adjourned at 11 a.m.

Comment on this