SECTION 5.
Contributions 148–294 of 294. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
The Deputy is talking about non-arms length transaction between two companies. Clearly if you take the case where there is a non-arms length transaction to do something the value of this can be assessed. There is no problem there. If it is not to do something, this can also be assessed. If money were being paid for this one could assess what it would have been worth. The only difficulty here is that money did not pass because it is not an arms length transaction. Again this is not a new concept at all in taxation questions or dealings within companies.
Comment on this
The section as drafted is not simply designed to catch the particular transaction the Minister has in mind. It says that a service is rendered and, therefore, tax is payable, in respect of the omission of an act. It does not require consideration to pass. Therefore, under this the Revenue Commissioners are entitled in respect of any omission of any act to determine a tax although no consideration passes. It is the double effect of these two together which creates a clearly intolerable situation. You can make some case for taxing an act when a consideration does not pass, and you can make some case for taxing the omission of an act if a consideration passes——
Comment on this
——but it is when you put the two together that you get absolute nonsense. I do not think anyone can justify giving the Revenue Commissioners power to tax people for not doing something and not being paid for not doing it.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy is oversimplifying it when he says " not being paid ". " Not being paid " is not correct.
Comment on this
But that is not the same thing. There need not be consideration on the face of a transaction, but that is not to say that people do not receive value for the act or the omission. Deputy FitzGerald is talking about where there is no consideration on the face of the transaction. A non-arms length transaction between a parent company and a subsidiary is a very good example. On the face of a transaction between the parent company and the subsidiary there may be no consideration, there may be no money passing, but that is not to say that there is no payment. Of course there is.
Comment on this
There is nothing here to say there must be a payment. This leaves it open to the Revenue Commissioners to tax somebody in a case where they do not do anything and where they are not paid and where no value passes.
Comment on this
They can only do that on a basis of evaluation. If there is a row about how they value it there is a method of appeal. They cannot just put an imaginary figure on something that has no value.
Comment on this
Take the case of a merger of two large companies. Is it suggested that the vending company pays tax on the consideration it receives for selling?
Comment on this
That situation is excluded from liability to tax under section 3, subsection 5 (b) (iii) which reads:
in connection with the transfer of a business or part thereof to another accountable person.
That does not become liable to tax.
Comment on this
Could I go back to the example of a firm performing a service for a subsidiary company for which it does not charge and then the profits and the VAT in its purchasing of goods for the subsidiary company and its selling. Are they enhanced?
Comment on this
And because there is a bigger gap the value added is greater and they pay more tax. Is that correct?
Comment on this
No, when they are both accountable persons they are, in effect, not paying tax. They are just acting as a conduit pipe and passing it on.
Comment on this
Are they not paying tax on the value added? The tax they will be charged will always be less than the tax they will charge.
Comment on this
No, the ultimate result of the VAT is to apply to the consumer tax at the final stage at the rate set out here. There is not a question of the intermediate people actually paying tax. They are collecting tax and passing it on.
Comment on this
No, there can be circumstances in which they would be setting off more than they are liable for and getting a refund. The point that I think Deputy Barry is getting at is that each of them is paying tax as they go along but the fact is that the whole incidence of the taxation is going to be at the rate of 5.26 per cent——
Comment on this
The purpose is that ultimately the consumer will pay tax on the full value added on what he buys.
Comment on this
And this is achieved by taxing all the value added all along the line at appropriate rates. In this instance, the value added of the parent company is enhanced by virtue of the non arms-length nature of the transaction of the subsidiary. They pay additional tax because their value added appears larger than it really is. If you now purport also to tax the subsidiary on the amount of the true value added, which it has not shown, and do not simultaneously reduce the tax on the overstatement of value added by the parent company you are taxing the same value added twice and the consumer will pay more.
Comment on this
One has to consider the whole structure of the VAT. I think Deputy FitzGerald misunderstands it because whatever the rate of tax, whatever the amount of tax paid by an intermediary, it is deducted from a later liability for tax and the actual amount of tax ultimately received by the Revenue Commissioners is the appropriate rate on the finished product at consumer level. Whatever happens in between does not increase the amount of tax available to the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
It does if you impose it twice on the same amount of value added. Either the purpose of dealing wih a non-arms length transaction is to collect more money from a firm which has not fully stated the value added, either you do that and correspondigly reduce the tax payable by the other firm, or you do not correspondingly reduce it. If you correspondingly reduce it, the total amount of tax paid is identical to what you would have had anyway and there is no point in the transaction. If the tax is paid twice, then the consumer pays more. Either the consumer pays more in which case there is some point in the transaction, though it is inequitable, or he does not pay more and there is no point in shifting the burden from the subsidiary to the parent company or vice versa in this transaction. It is not like the income tax or sur tax, where the shifting of the burden from one company to another can affect liability for tax between the two companies. In this instance it does not arise. You are taxing the value added anyway. I do not understand the purpose of this.
Comment on this
The first thing you have to grasp is that it does not matter at the intermediate stages whether a person involved in the chain of transactions is paying a higher or a lower level of tax. It does not matter in the sense that the consumer is eventually going to pay the appropriate rate of tax on the price——
Comment on this
No. It does not matter what happens, in the end the appropriate rate of tax on the consumer price is the amount of tax received by the Revenue Commissioners. Whatever happens in between, that is the ultimate result.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy is missing the point. He is talking about applying VAT twice. If that is true what he is really saying is that the price to the consumer is being increased.
Comment on this
The structure of the tax is such that that cannot happen. Any tax charged in the course of the chain of production and distribution is set off, it does not matter how high or how low it is, along the line so that ultimately the tax payable is the appropriate tax on the consumer price.
Comment on this
The Minister is not taking my point. What is the purpose of fussing about whether it is an arms-length transaction or not, what does it matter whether X per cent of the value is added by the subsidiary or the parent company if, at the end, tax is paid on the full value added anyway?
Comment on this
The first point to be clear on is that it does not matter what happens in the intermediate stages as regards whether the tax charged is high or low. It does not affect the consumer price or the amount of tax.
Comment on this
That is my second point, as to whether one should worry about what happens in between. As between two accountable persons, it does not really make any difference whether the rate of tax is wrong, if they are charged too high, apart from some possible effect on liquidity, because what A pays B gets credit for. If both are accountable there is no problem. But if one is not an accountable person, if he is, say, a final consumer, it is important whether the tax rate is right or whether the amount of consideration on which tax is charged is right. If either is wrong, the Revenue will be out of pocket.
Comment on this
What the discussion comes down to is that in the case of a non-arm's length transaction between an accountable and a non-accountable person, who are in cahoots with each other in some way, in respect of not doing something for which the one rendering the service, who is not doing it, is not paid—it seems to me to be an abstruse case on which to base the whole subsection.
Comment on this
If there was the case of a doctor, if one could think of this, not prescribing a particular drug for his patients—this is certainly an outrageous example but it nevertheless illustrates the point—should that doctor be charged or should he not, if there were some adjustment in that type of case involving a manufacturer of another drug. There is one accountable person and the other is not accountable.
Comment on this
The doctor is not. He could make a payment again to somebody in that way where he could get no deduction but the recipient could be a taxable person and should be liable. That is the kind of end result that this is intended to meet, where on one leg of the transaction there is not accountability and on the other there is.
Comment on this
The fact that the example chosen is one which is somewhat inconceivable in operation does suggest we are wasting a lot of time on an attempt to cover an eventuality which nobody is able to visualise arising. I do not see the point of it in the circumstances. The Minister has attempted to say why it will not do any harm to do this but he has not convinced me that there is any good done as a result of it.
Comment on this
I would be prepared to accept that it is for the purpose of closing loopholes. The only thing about it is whether or not the cure is going to be worse than the disease, whether somebody is going to be adversely affected by leaving the section in as it is rather than somebody getting away with it if the amendment is accepted.
Comment on this
As it stands, it does leave it open to the Revnue Commissioners to levy taxation on things not done and not paid for and this is a principle which we cannot concede. Even if there was a good reason for it, we could not concede it, but no reason is given.
Comment on this
It is not true to say that people can be taxed on something where they do not receive money or money's worth.
Comment on this
Again and again people under the income tax code find this sort of thing happening, where somebody comes along and says that a certain amount has been assessed against them, without any evidence whatever being produced, and then after everybody has gone to a lot of trouble, it is proved that the assessment has been incorrect and entirely without foundation. If it can happen in the case of an ordinary workman earning a minimum of £20 a week, what could happen if the same authority is given in this case? That is what is worrying me about it.
Comment on this
The amount of work and trouble which people could be given by this is enormous and the best example we can get of what it is designed to prevent is that of the doctor not attending his patients.
Comment on this
I do not think that is a fair point to make. It was given to illustrate exactly what was involved, but it is only a debating point to say that it is the best example.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): If I were giving service to a company and they agreed to pay for me and my wife on holiday in the Bahamas for three months and if they bought a house and gave me the use of it, this would be a case in which I could say that no money passed to me but still I would be getting a certain value.
Comment on this
Banks and insurance companies are exempted businesses under this, and accountants are exempt but may elect to be taxable in certain circumstances. One could visualise a transaction between these kinds of people which certainly would be of practical importance under this section and without this section. In those cases value-added tax would not be paid. It seems to me that we have an obligation to ensure, as far as we can that there is equality of treatment and the only way we can do it is by a provision of this nature. I think we have established now—I hope—to everybody's satisfaction that as between accountable persons, this makes no difference. It is only in the case of the transaction between an accountable and a non-accountable person that this becomes of importance. I have mentioned some of the categories of people who are not accountable and I think that should give us cause to realise that there could be cases of some substance which would not become liable to value-added tax but which should on the face of them be liable, if we do not have a provision of this kind.
Comment on this
We still have not had a concrete example. I know that I am bad at understanding things without a concrete example, and talking about banks and accountants is all very well, but I am still not clear as to the kind of transaction likely to occur. Somebody is going to be not paid for not doing something but gets value for not doing it, as between an accountable and a non-accountable person in such a way as to avoid tax. Could we have one concrete example of that happening?
Comment on this
The simple case covered by this subsection where somebody does not do something and is not given a consideration, but who, in the Minister's words, receives value which is not a consideration, he is a non-accountable person while the person making the payment is accountable.
Comment on this
May I point out to the Deputy that in the previous sections which deal with the delivery of goods, rendering service and so on, there is no mention of the word " consideration "?
Comment on this
No. I am suggesting that the use of the word in this particular section is really inconsistent with the whole basis on which the Bill is drafted, for the reasons I have given. I am trying to remember from the dregs of my memory of legal definitions what this concept of consideration means, and my recollection is that it is a very wide definition and there does not have to be consideration on the face of a transaction for a consideration to be there.
Comment on this
That is exactly why the introduction of the word " consideration " would not vitiate the Minister's purpose but to ensure that this will not be used in an objectionable way for taxing people for not doing something they have not been paid for. In the Act of the British Parliament, the words " for a consideration " are included and I do not see why it is suggested that there is this enormous room for evasion and we must tighten it up when the British Revenue are not bothering about it. I am unconvinced of the need for this and we have not yet had one concrete example of the kind of thing that might happen in practice and of where, if we do not have this, somebody would avoid tax. If we could have one concrete example, I would be prepared to consider the matter.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy arguing that we ought to delete the reference to not doing certain acts or suggesting that we should put in the reference to consideration or is he suggesting both, in the light of the discussion we have had?
Comment on this
It seems to me that both of these were necessary. The Minister is making a case for omitting the word " consideration " where there is an action done and he has separately made the case for providing for the case of an omission where there is no question of one. My objection is by the drafting of this the two are put together into the one subsection as the result of which somebody can be taxed for not doing something he is not paid for. I have a particular objection to that.
I can see the Minister has some point on both of his legs but when he tries to erect something standing on the two legs together the thing collapses. Perhaps the answer is to separate this into two separate subsections, one dealing with acts done and the other dealing with omissions. In the case of omissions there should clearly be a consideration as a bare minimum.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy not accept that there could be transactions which do not have a consideration on the face of them but in which in fact there is value received?
Comment on this
May I interrupt the Deputy for a moment as I want to follow up that point. If he accepts that, how can he justify applying what he says to let us say, agreements not to do something. As I understand it what the Deputy was suggesting is that we might separate these two concepts and we might provide in the case where there was an agreement to do a certain act that that would be sufficient just to provide that but in the second subsection where we would deal with an agreement not to do a certain act, to refrain from doing something, in that case we ought to apply the question of consideration.
Comment on this
I am not suggesting that what I am now suggesting is a very satisfactory solution at all but I think, as drafted, it is so unsatisfactory that something is required. I doubt very much whether my approach is the best one. I would like to suggest that the Minister might perhaps have another look at this.
Comment on this
I can certainly undertake to do that but I always feel when I undertake to do that that there may be an implication in it that I am going to come up with something better. If I can I will but I cannot undertake that I will.
Comment on this
There is a point here which occurs to me. Does it make allowances even for what I might deem a gratuitous service or is somebody going to get hold of this and say: " put a value on that whether you pay for it or not."
Comment on this
The particular kind of situation that Deputy Gallagher is thinking of is dealt with in section 10.
Comment on this
Is the Minister suggesting that Deputy Gallagher's objection is met by section 10 or that it is aggravated by it?
Comment on this
No. What I am saying is that the concept which he has just referred to is dealt with in section 10 as to when and in what circumstances that kind of transaction should be taxable, what he referred to as a gratutious performance of services.
Comment on this
I am looking to see if there is a list of these type of things and I would be more inclined to go with the Minister. In fact it is left to the Collector-General, as it were, to decide what they are going to do and this is something I am not in favour of.
Comment on this
Can I take it that the Minister will undertake to have a look at Deputy FitzGerald's point, that he will try to clarify that a little more.
Comment on this
Could he perhaps also informally transmit to us a practical example of what it is that the Revenue Commissioners fear, an example which we can grasp and understand. I have not got that clear and I know it is unfair to ask people on the spot to give examples without time to think. One practical example is worth an hour's discussion.
Comment on this
Could I say in that regard that we do not visualise this section being of any practical importance perhaps for quite a number of years. Some experience on the continent in the EEC shows that it is of practical importance there in different circumstances which will almost certainly apply here in the years to come. This is one of the difficulties we have in producing a practical example in our terms at the moment. Subject to that I would certainly undertake to try to produce some examples that will illustrate this.
I also want to say that while I am certainly prepared to have another look and see if we can produce anything better than this I want to draw attention to the fact that when Deputy FitzGerald analysed the thing for himself he suddenly came up against the difficulties that I am up against when he saw—I take his point—that the two legs separately stand up but when you put them together he reads a great deal more into it. On the other hand, if you take one of the legs away you are left in considerable difficulties.
Comment on this
I accept what the Minister says but a difficulty arises partly from this word " consideration ". The Minister has kept saying that there may not be consideration but the value is given nonetheless. If that concept were introduced in some sense that value was given——
Comment on this
They are the lines on which I am thinking in regard to achieving any improvement. Something on those lines might yield a satisfactory solution.
Comment on this
That would be helpful. Another suggestion I would make is that the EEC directive did seem to be much more specific in its terms. Is there much reason for us going beyond what is in that directive? Could we not tie this down more tightly to the kind of wording that is in the directive? Would the Minister look at it from that point of view?
Comment on this
Yes, although I would remind the Deputy that I read out only item 9 and that particular item referred to discharging an obligation not to practice in whole or in part a professional activity or exercise a right specified in the present list. The present list is fairly extensive but I take the Deputy's point.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2 :
In page 9, to delete subsection (5).
The reason for this is that my difficulty can be met better by an amendment to delete this subsection. The reason for this is that in its present form this could be very onerous in the particular subsection. I am trying to think of an example of this and I am faced with the same difficulty as the Minister faced. We will take somebody installing central heating for example. As far as I can see from this the central heating equipment could carry a rate of 16.37 per cent. The effect of this amendment would be if somebody installing central heating has an installation cost which is less than half of the central heating so that the central heating equipment comes to no more than two-thirds of the total service rendered than the service rendered in installing it will be liable to tax at 16.37 per cent instead of 5.26 per cent. This would seem to me to be an undesirable increase in taxation and it is not the purpose of this Bill to increase taxation. Therefore, as drafted this is much too loose and opens up the possibility of increasing taxation, especially where you have the two tax rates. It may not apply in quite this way as the 30.26 per cent tax rate because the additional tax there is imposed at the wholesale level only. Where something is done, where a service is rendered which involves movable goods liable to 16.37 per cent rate there is a difficulty here. At the very least some redrafting is required to get over this difficulty and possibly the thing should be deleted.
Comment on this
This applies only where there is the same rate for the goods as for the service, and it is designed to produce a formula that is easy to work and will avoid the taxpayers being thrown back on complicated legal decisions. Where there is a different rate applying, then there is provision for an apportionment, and in the case of goods it could be 5.26 or 16.27 per cent.
Comment on this
I do not think that is right. It seems to me that when there are two different kinds of goods at different rates what the Minister says is correct, but where goods are at one rate and installation services at a different rate, the Minister is wrong.
Comment on this
In the case visualised by Deputy FitzGerald, the installation of central heating, normally the position would be that you would get a contract price for the whole job, including goods and services. In that case if the value of the goods exceeded two-thirds of the contract price, this section would apply, and it would apply whatever the rate for the goods would be. Where you have a contract for the supply of goods at different rates—as you know, some at 16.37 per cent and some at 5.26 per cent—there is provision for apportionment of those.
Comment on this
But in the case visualised by Deputy FitzGerald, in the normal way I think that the two-thirds would almost always be exceeded. We have experienced difficulty with turnover tax where there is one rate of tax for the supply of goods and a different rate, usually a lower rate, for the supply of services. There is difficulty when there is a combination of the two, as to how the tax should be applied. There is the option of having an apportionment, with so much of the price applying to the supply of the goods and so much of the price applying to the services, and each of them can be taxed separately; or it can be determined that the whole lot is for the supply of goods or the whole lot is for the supply of a service. At present we find it difficult, particularly in the building trade. If a wardrobe is supplied it is liable to turnover and wholesale tax, whereas if it is built in by the builder is it liable only to the tax applicable to the materials used. The purpose here is to give an easy formula to the ordinary person—and it is the ordinary person who will be making his return and there are two elements, namely, the cost price of the goods that go into the contract and the full contract price. If the cost price of the goods exceeds two-thirds, then the whole lot is taken as a supply of goods and we forget about the service altogether. If it is two-thirds or less, then the whole lot is the supply of the service and it is charged at the proper rate which is normally an effective rate of 3.16 per cent on an installation job.
Comment on this
With respect to the explanation given, it simply confirms my point, that the effect of this is to raise the level of taxation on services involved in the installation of goods to the level at which the goods are chargeable where the goods constitute two-thirds or more of the total cost of the contract. I do not see any reason why we should be raising the taxation of services in that way. No reason has been given for this. It is not suggested that we do not know what the value of the goods is, because you have to know what the value of the goods is for the section to work. If you know what the value of the goods is, why not go on charging for the goods at the tax rate for the goods and for the services at the tax rate for the services?
Comment on this
I agree entirely that it would be more accurate if that could be done but the purpose of it is to avoid apportionments of that type in the great majority of cases, and the two-thirds has been pitched at what the Revenue Commissioners at least think is the kind of figure that will allow the service rate to apply in virtually all these jobs except the very special ones where the service is a minor part of the supply of goods. For instance, I buy a refrigerator and it is part of the contract that the electrician would install the plug and plug it in. The point there is that I should reasonably pay the price applicable to a refrigerator, that it should not be governed by whatever service element is in the cost. If the two thirds does, in fact, bring the great majority of these, where there is a substantial service element, into the lower rate and merely leaves the ones where the service element is relatively small, then it seems to make the tax easier to operate.
Comment on this
I had not read this to mean that where the rate is less than two-thirds the lower service rate applies, and that if, the central heating equipment, taking the example I gave—involves, say, 62 per cent of the cost, the 5.26 per cent rate applies to the whole contract, including the cost of the central heating equipment. Is that the case?
Comment on this
Could I be shown just how that operates here? As worded it gave me the impression that it is only designed to operate one way, to the benefit of the Revenue Commissioners. That is what is bothering me.
Comment on this
If the installation job is the special kind of service that qualifies for the building rate, then under section 10 the effective rate is 3.16 per cent. This is the one to which we referred in the House.
Comment on this
Therefore the position is that where it is a building contract of any kind, including the installation of central heating, the tax rate on the equipment is 3 per cent in the ordinary way?
Comment on this
And anyone who wants to have a big installation job done and does not ensure that the cost of the installation is more than two-thirds should have his head examined.
Comment on this
What you do to avoid the tax is to jack up the service charge sufficiently to get over the two-thirds and then you get the tax rate down.
Comment on this
This figure of two-thirds is designed to ensure that the vast bulk of this kind of transactions will come at the lower rate.
Comment on this
It does appear as if this is one case where the Revenue Commissioners are showing heart and I suggest we should allow the provision to go through without any further discussion.
Comment on this
Both things will be invoiced separately and both will be at different rates of tax no matter what.
Comment on this
This avoids lots of complications for taxpayers as well as for the Revenue Commissioners; they can handle it but it is more difficult for the taxpayer.
Comment on this
I seem to have picked a bad example in the building sphere. May I now launch the attack on another front? Supposing the rendering of a service involves the installation of something which bears the 16.7 per cent rate.
Comment on this
I was going to say television sets but that is the 30.26 per cent rate and does not arise.
Comment on this
If you required some kind of survey before you decided how you would lay out your shop and goods as well and you required these at the same time or from the same person then you have the type of situation where the services are chargeable at 5.26 per cent and the goods at 16.37 per cent. If there was a single price quoted for the service and the supply of the goods the question of proportion would come in. The 3.16 would have no relevance because it would not be a building or an installation job.
Comment on this
In those circumstances, if the cost of the goods was two-thirds or more, then the service would also be charged at the 16.37 per cent rate?
Comment on this
Surely we should confine this case to building and not get involved in other instances?
Comment on this
I have been examining this somewhat more deeply with regard to the tax on new houses. I have a note here. VAT taken as 60 per cent of 5.26 per cent, less VAT already paid on materials consumed in the building of the house. Am I to assume that that is the position or will one accept the published selling price or the actual contract price of the house?
Comment on this
That works out at approximately 3 per cent, which is estimated to be the amount of tax that is borne at present by way of turnover and wholesale tax.
Comment on this
Yes. In the case referred to by Deputy FitzGerald I think it is a question of the balance of advantage because even in the examples given, if the situations were reversed and the cost of the goods were less than two-thirds, then what would normally be charged at the higher rate will be charged at the lower service rate. It is a balance of advantage and we have no doubt that the balance is very much in favour of the taxpayer by doing this and that by trying to get an exact figure in each transaction you are going to create much greater difficulty for the taxpayer than by using this formula.
Comment on this
The relevant section 10 (8) led me to believe that the danger I referred to would only be avoided where there was an installation of movable goods in connection with the delivery of immovable goods, in other words building materials installed in a house, or something like central heating. Is it the case that the same thing will operate even where that does not apply? What I am worried about is, even in the case that has just been mentioned that might operate in one way only, favouring the Revenue Commissioners, that is that if the goods are over two-thirds then the services carry a higher rate, if they are under two-thirds you do not get a similar benefit and the whole transaction is at the lower rate.
Comment on this
If I understand the Deputy correctly it is a question of whatever rate is applied to the transaction applies to either the goods or the services depending on whether it is above or below two-thirds.
Comment on this
That applies whether it is goods installed in a dwelling or not? The only reference at section 10 (8) is to do with installing goods in a building. What provision covers other cases?
Comment on this
This section only says that if it is over two-thirds the higher rate applies to both. It does not say that if it is below two-thirds the lower rate applies to both.
Comment on this
The service would be at the lower rate. If the lower rate is to apply, that is in respect of the services, that can automatically only be the lower rate. This deals with the case where the higher rate can apply. If the higher rate does not apply under this provision, then automatically it is the lower rate which applies.
Comment on this
I am not sure I understand. My understanding, given that I have only been referred to section 10 (8), is that in cases other than the installation of goods in a dwelling, if the goods constitute over two-thirds of the total value then the whole transaction is charged at the higher rate but if they are less than two-thirds then each pays at its appropriate rate and there is no corresponding benefit in the average down to the lower rate in those circumstances. If I am wrong perhaps my attention could be directed to the section which makes me wrong.
Comment on this
It is section 5 (5) (a). It deals with the case where the value of movable goods supplied under an agreement for the rendering of services exceeds two-thirds of the total consideration. It provides that in that case the higher rate will apply but in any case other than that—I take Deputy FitzGerald's point. He wants to know where specifically does it say——
Comment on this
The argument as I understand it is as follows. This applies to an agreement for the rendering of services. If it stopped there and did not go on to talk about the two-thirds and so on under the Third Schedule the appropriate rate for the rendering of services is 5.26.
Comment on this
The rendering of services is defined in 5 (1) as being an act other than the delivery of goods. If the service we are talking about is of installing goods and the cost of the goods is 60 per cent of the total and the cost of the service is 40 per cent you cannot say that part constituted by the value of the goods is the rendering of the service because they are being installed. This has been precluded by the terms of the section 5 (1).
Comment on this
No. It says:
Where the value of movable goods supplied under an agreement for the rendering of services . . .
Comment on this
Section 5 (5) (a), on page 8.
Where the value of movable goods supplied under an agreement for the rendering of services . . . .
That visualises the supply of goods under an agreement for the rendering of services. If it stopped at that point then under Schedule III the appropriate rate would be 5.26 per cent, which is the rate chargeable on services.
Comment on this
How could that be when that part of the service which is constituted by the goods being installed is itself explicitly defined as not being a service by the terms of section 5 (1), which says that the service is an act other than the delivery of goods?