SECTION 11.
Contributions 187–371 of 371. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Of course the 16.37 is the combination of the existing wholesale tax at 11.11 per cent and the turnover tax at 5.20 per cent.
Comment on this
The Deputy is talking about the application of that rate to the retail trade instead of the wholesale trade. I was not talking about a fortuitous 16.37. I was talking about the fact that it is to be applied at the retail stage, if one is to have a value-added tax at all. The amount that arises is £3.7 million. The amount that will be refunded happens fortuitously to work out at approximately the same figure.
Comment on this
So what happens is that by adding together the two actual rates that are now current you get a figure which, applied at the retail stage, amounts to £3.7 million, which happens to be the amount you are handing back and it happens to produce a nil effect so far as the economy is concerned and there is no change in the tax level.
Comment on this
That is not true. Let the Deputy try to work out how you will produce this effect if you start from scratch.
Comment on this
I am summarising what the Minister's argument appears to be. The point is it is no good telling us it would be a terrible tragedy for people if they did not recover the tax but, at the same time, whatever amount he recovers, the same amount is taken back by increasing the taxation, admittedly on other articles. The Minister cannot now turn around and do what he previously tried to do, equate the two. He cannot now turn around and say to me that they are different people. I said that to him but he would not accept it before. I do not think that is an argument. What is this definition of luxury items? Can we not say that luxury items are all those items which we choose to tax at a rate beyond the standard basic rate of tax? What definition is there in the EEC Directive or what limitations are there in it?
Comment on this
The Deputy is getting away from the point. I understood he was suggesting that the 16.37 rate should be operated on the basis of trapping it, as is done on the higher rate.
Comment on this
What I would suggest, if I got that far, and I thought the thing was going to work, would be to suggest that you have something like a 5 per cent tax at the retail level and a tax of, say, for the sake of argument, 20 per cent on all goods that currently have applied to them the 16 and 30 per cent limits and trap them. Now you can adjust the 20 per cent up or down to ensure there is no net increase in the burden of taxation. What objection, I wonder, would there be to such a procedure? I am throwing this out as a figure. I think it is not far away from the figure that you would want to give that result. The effect of that suggestion would be—I do not want to anticipate here but just to indicate the way my mind is working—if combined, with a complete exemption of food, a derating of food. One would, on such a system, get the same amount of tax as at present with a single rate of tax at retail level, no taxation on food and no significant change, I think, in the burden of taxation on different groups of the community.
Comment on this
Could we concentrate on the point the Deputy raised, which was that the 16.37—or, for argument's sake, call it a 20 per cent rate, abolishing the two higher rates—that the 20 per cent rate would be trapped and only 5 per cent or 5.26 per cent would be charged thereafter at retail level. I suggest that, for the moment, we should concentrate on what would be the effect of that. To do this would involve the cascade effect. It would involve double taxation. It would involve it on a very wide range of commodities and, after all, what we are proposing to do is on the luxury range; it is relatively quite a small segment of the economy. To do it on the rest——
Comment on this
Not on the rest. It is done on 5 per cent at the moment and this proposal would involve doing it on 20 per cent of all sales. At the moment, roughly speaking, 5 per cent of all sales will bear the 30 per cent rate and something like 16½ per cent will bear the 16 per cent rate. I think, therefore, what my proposal would involve would be extending this cascade effect from just under 5 per cent to 20 per cent. I am not disagreeing with the Minister. I am merely being precise.
Comment on this
The effect, therefore, would be that, as regards 20 per cent of all sales, there would be this double taxation effect.
Comment on this
Which we have at the moment on 100 per cent sales and the Minister proposes to retain it on 5 per cent and I propose to retain it on 95 per cent but limit it on 80 per cent of sales.
Comment on this
It seems to me it would be quite objectionable from the point of view of traders who would benefit far less on the value-added tax than they will benefit under the Bill as it stands. Furthermore, I am advised that the EEC would certainly object to this because, in effect, what you are doing is abolishing the value-added tax.
Comment on this
I was under the impression that we had put down amendments and we were discussing those amendments here. We have been discussing in the last half hour something for which there is no amendment before the Committee.
Comment on this
It is my amendment No. 7. We are discussing the effect of eliminating the 16.7 per cent rate and this raises questions as to how money would be raised to replace it and I want to explore this and sort out the feasibility of eliminating this rate and combining it with——
Comment on this
Personally, any more than anybody else here, I do not want to be here indefinitely. We want to get the best value we can and we had the right to put down specific amendments and we have put those amendments down. It would be very unfair to everybody, including ourselves, if we continued to debate amendments which are not down on our Order Paper. I can see no reference at all to this 20 per cent that Deputy FitzGerald has been talking about for the last half hour.
Comment on this
I have put down an amendment and the Minister has raised objections to that amendment. In seeking to meet these objections and to find how, on Report Stage, I could frame an amendment to meet these objections, I have to explore this with the Minister.
Comment on this
I suggest this is new procedure. Perhaps it is in order, but I should like a ruling on it. I have never come across this procedure before.
Comment on this
I have not ever worked on a Committee Stage before without having had the problem of finding an amendment of mine in some way defective and requiring to be modified on Report Stage and in the process of establishing how that needs to be done, one explores with the Minister the Minister's objections to one's amendment and that procedure has been operated in regard to every Bill in which I have been involved so far in either the Seanad or the Dáil.
Comment on this
I do not think that is the way it works. In fact the discussion in the Dáil will take the form that, if a person wants to put down an amendment on Report, he must mention it in the Committee Stage on the section and, if it is defeated on the Committee Stage, it cannot, of course, be raised on the Report Stage, so the Deputy's point is not correct.
Comment on this
The point is I cannot frame an amendment on Report Stage unless I understand the Minister's objections to my amendment on the Committee Stage so that I can meet them on the Report Stage. I can imagine no better or more constructive use of the Committee Stage of a Bill.
Comment on this
May I suggest that we have made a mistake in including amendment No. 7 with 8, 14, 16, 19——
Comment on this
We may have made a mistake but, if so, it is in including amendment No. 8 and the others with amendment No. 7, and not the other way around.
Comment on this
This question was raised earlier and the reason why these were taken together was because they all deal with rates of tax and No. 7 overlaps all the others mentioned. That is why they are all being taken together. I take it Deputy FitzGerald is in order in that he has an amendment down there to section 11—Amendment 12 (a) "to delete 16.37 per cent and insert 13 per cent"—and I presume it is on that he is trying to elicit some information.
Comment on this
No. We are not discussing 12 (a). With respect to you, Sir, I would suggest that if it is in order for Deputy FitzGerald—and if he is entitled to do it I have no objection—to suggest an alternative amendment which we may consider for the Report Stage of this Bill, then every time an amendment of mine comes up and is turned down by the Minister, I am entitled to as many alternatives to that amendment as I can think of, and I can ask what will happen that when it comes in on Report Stage, and we can be here until Christmas twelve months and make no further progress. I am not trying to be awkward about this or to shoot down Deputy FitzGerald but I just want to suggest that we are not dealing with amendments in a constructive way. I am as anxious as Deputy FitzGerald or anybody else to have a good Bill coming out, but I do not think that simply talking round and round, and according as something comes into our heads, trotting it out here, will bring us to a conclusion.
Comment on this
It is not done normally. I have never seen it done and I think I have probably as much experience of Committee Stages of Bills as anybody around this table. I have already stated what is the normal approach: you put down an amendment; if it is defeated you cannot put it down on Report Stage. If you want to put down an amendment on Report Stage or on Committee Stage, you must mention it at some previous Stage of the Bill, and then you have the right to put it down.
Comment on this
With respect, Deputy O‘ Donovan 's formulation of procedure suffers from one defect: he never mentioned discussing an amendment. That is what we are doing. Between putting it down and having it defeated, in between those two points, there is discussion. That discussion is designed to elicit objections to the amendment, so that you can either decide to withdraw it, to let it stand despite the objections, or reformulate it for Report Stage. What I am trying to do is to discover the Minister's objections and to discover if those objections are of such a character that they can be met by reformulating an amendment on Report Stage. I have always operated in that way, constructively, on any Bill in which I have been involved. I cannot imagine how else you could ever get to Report Stage.
Comment on this
If somebody can point out to me where there is any reference to a 20 per cent tax on this——
Comment on this
Deputy FitzGerald has been discussing the merits of a 20 per cent tax with the Minister for the last half hour.
Comment on this
We are discussing the consequence of eliminating the 16.37 per cent on amendment No. 7.
Comment on this
I am aware of what is being discussed. I have a number of amendments which I should like to get an opportunity of discussing, but I cannot do it if Deputy FitzGerald wants to discuss the ones he considers he might put down on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I would suggest that, by and large, the members of the Committee would wish the discussion on these amendments to be reasonably flexible and not too rigid. I do not think Deputy Tully would object to that.
Comment on this
I think that, in effect, what Deputy Tully is objecting to is the fact that Deputy FitzGerald's argument for what he is doing is reasonable enough but that it is being carried too far, so far that, as he said himself, if the stage is reached that every member of the Committee on the discussion of an amendment can say: "Well, what about this and what about that?"—things that are not down at all in the amendment—in order to formulate amendments he might want to put forward on Report Stage, this is going to carry the discussion far beyond the limits of normal flexibility. As I understand Deputy Tully's submission, that is what he is saying, and personally I would agree with him.
Comment on this
The Deputy who wants to do this should do it at home in his study. He should take the matter away with him and think it over.
Comment on this
If we could get away from talking about me we might make more progress. I am not down as an amendment anyway.
Comment on this
Could we take cognisance of what has been said on all sides and get on with the work of discussing the rates of tax? Amendments Nos. 8, 9, 11 and 12 form an alternative proposal to No. 7; Nos. 10, 14, 16, 17 and 62 are consequential on amendment No. 8. Nos. 13 and 18 are consequential on No. 11; No. 19 is consequential on No. 12 and No. 12 (a) is an alternative to No. 12. These are all being discussed, and the reason there is so much latitude is that these are the backbone of the whole matter.
Comment on this
I have a list here which reads: 7 to 14, inclusive, 16, 17, 18, 19 and 62. Is that correct?
Comment on this
I am trying to discuss amendment No. 7, and I would be happy to go on discussing No. 7, if I may be permitted to do so.
Comment on this
I am sorry about that. I did not think about the (a)'s. I thought it was a straightforward numbering.
Comment on this
As I understand it, we agreed that the main substance of what was involved in these amendments came to two major divisions: one was the question of rounding the rates and the other was the question of abolishing existing rates and doing much more than just rounding. As I understand it, we have completed our discussion on the rounding and are now discussing the question of substituting new rates as distinct from rounded rates.
Comment on this
Which could be broken down further into the question of modifying existing rates, on the one hand, like changing 16.37 and inserting 13, which is not rounding but making a change, or, alternatively, trying to eliminate one of these rates to leave one rate at retail level. There are perhaps two arms in the discussion and we could be discussing either of them. I simply want to ask one further question of the Minister, which is distinctly relevant to all we are talking about, that is, the nature of the EEC objections. How fundamental are they?
Comment on this
As I understand it, Deputy FitzGerald is now asking about the EEC objections to the question of trapping at this 16.37 per cent rate. The discussion of the past few minutes was to the effect of expressing a consensus that that discussion was not relevant. Am I right or wrong?
Comment on this
I am not clear on this, but there is no amendment down which suggests the trapping of the tax at the 16.37 or equivalent rate. As I see it, this is a completely new suggestion, which is not before us, and I think we have to have a ruling on whether this is in order or not.
Comment on this
We are dealing with amendment No. 7 which has the effect of eliminating the 16.37 per cent rate. The Minister has made certain objections to this and I am trying to establish the nature and extent of these objections. They include financial objections of a legitimate character, because this would deprive him of revenue. That raises the question of whether there is any way in which that objection can be met. What I want to know is, to try to meet the Minister's objection on the revenue side is it possible to do this by a method which would achieve the objective of this amendment of having one rate at the retail level while maintaining the Minister's revenue. The one way of doing that would apparently come up against an objection on the EEC side.
Comment on this
We have suggested that amendment No. 7 does not suggest that. It does not suggest the trapping——
Comment on this
The Minister has taken exception to my amendment and he has given us various reasons for not accepting it. In dealing with those reasons I have to try to find out if there is any way of meeting his objections. One way of meeting his objections apparently comes up against an obstacle and I want to find out how serious that obstacle is before I decide whether I can meet this objection.
Comment on this
I submit, Mr. Chairman, that we shall get nowhere if we allow this to go on. Deputy O'Donovan was right in saying that when Deputy FitzGerald or any other member of the Committee comes up against an objection of this kind and he wants to think about how he can formulate an amendment for the Report Stage he ought to do that at home.
Comment on this
How can I? The Minister has told us here, and it apparently was in order because nobody took any exception to the Minister telling us, that the EEC will not permit goods beyond a certain range to be treated as luxury goods. That is the effect of what he said. Deputy Tully and Deputy O'Donovan did not think that was an irrelevant statement at all.
Comment on this
He did not proceed to discuss it for a half hour afterwards and explain things which are not in the Bill.
Comment on this
I detected, I thought, a certain note of uncertainty on the part of the Minister in making this point.
Comment on this
I want to explore precisely what are the EEC regulations involved. If the Minister, in objecting to an amendment, makes a point now or in the future that there is an EEC objection to it surely the Opposition are entitled to ask what is that objection and where is it set down, so that we can see it.
Comment on this
I think that is an unfair submission because what Deputy FitzGerald is talking about is an EEC objection to a point which he raised in the course of discussion, not an objection to the amendment before us. If we pursue the question of what is the EEC objection to this we can go on forever discussing something that is not before us.
Comment on this
In all fairness, I did say earlier that I thought we all wanted to have a certain amount of flexibility. I think this flexibility would allow me, in responding to an argument, to make a particular point like that without developing it. If I start developing it I think that is going beyond the flexibility we want. If we cannot operate on that basis we will have to operate on a rigid basis with no flexibility at all and I think everybody would find that quite unsatisfactory.
Comment on this
I submit that a procedure under which the Minister can make a point but if he is challenged or asked to explain it further he can then say: "That goes beyond what is permitted" is one which you could not operate in a Parliament.
Comment on this
Very well, Mr. Chairman. In future I will undertake to make no point at all except on the matters before us and if Deputy FitzGerald puts forward submissions which do not appear to relate to them I will not answer them and I do not want to be taken then as being unable to answer them.
Comment on this
I see the Minister's point of view but if there is a little flexibility I think we will get on better provided it does not go too far.
Comment on this
There has been a good deal of latitude and flexibility. I thought that was desirable. Maybe I regretted it, there was so much repetition, but it was technical argument and I was quite prepared to listen to that. I was anxious that everybody here would be satisfied in the end that he had accomplished something. I think that of all the people here Deputy FitzGerald has the least reason to complain about the way things are being conducted because he has said many things that stretched the latitude of the debate. I do not want to handicap him in any way and I would be sorry if the Minister felt that he had to act as he has suggested. Therefore, I think we should keep to the rates of tax. When a person puts down an amendment after all the onus is on him to prove that his amendment is better than anything the Minister has come up with rather than the Minister having to defend not only his own case but the case the other member puts to him as well. If we kept to that we might get somewhere.
Comment on this
I must defend Deputy FitzGerald to a certain extent. We are on this Committee trying to come up with a good Bill. There are a number of alternative ways. I think Deputy FitzGerald made a valid point. I personally could see nothing wrong with it.
Comment on this
Would Deputy Collins agree there is nothing in the amendment about trapping arrangements?
Comment on this
Because Deputy FitzGerald said: "Why can you not do in relation to the lower rate what you do with the higher rate?" I could have said: "I will not answer that because it is not relevant" but I tried to explain why that was so. Deputy FitzGerald then wanted to question the reasons I gave. If we pursue that line we will go on forever discussing something that is not before us.
Comment on this
I am dealing with my amendment No. 7 and subsection (2) of that amendment, as I understand it, deals with the question of trapping. Does it not?
Comment on this
I think Deputy FitzGerald will agree that he has no proposal in amendment No. 7 to trap the tax at the 16.37 rate.
Comment on this
Am I right in thinking that the question of trapping is raised by subsection (2) of my amendment?
Comment on this
The second part of the Deputy's amendment proposes that it be substituted by a 5.25 per cent rate. It is as simple as that.
Comment on this
Subsection (2) talks about goods in the Fourth Schedule. I thought it involved the question of trapping.
Comment on this
Your discussion was about trapping in relation to goods which are not in the Fourth Schedule.
Comment on this
The Minister has made up his mind that he does not propose to give way on this and we have made up our minds that we propose to force this as far as we can. Repeating over and over again the one point is not making progress and I cannot think of any more arguments I can make. Those who have not contributed may have something to say but I cannot see anything further I can add.
Comment on this
Before the Chairman puts the question are we satisfied that we have discussed all facets? When the question is put on any amendment that finishes the debate on it. We cannot come back and deal with the second portion which Deputy FitzGerald has referred to. If we take a vote that concludes the amendment.
Comment on this
Perhaps I might again refer to the insignificance of the matter on which the Minister and his advisors are laying so much insistence, the difference between 5 per cent and 5.26 per cent. This is obliterated almost completely by the inflation we have at present. Nobody can tell me that the inflation is a myth. I do not mind what statistics say about it.
Comment on this
I should like to put the case to the Committee that this inflation shows no signs of abatement. It is a natural phenomenon nowadays in Western countries and therefore the Revenue Commissioners are concerning themselves about something which is—I do not want to use the word "myth" but, in this respect, it is almost a myth.
Comment on this
It is of no arithmetical relevance. I understand the argument put forward by the Minister and his advisers that, in fact, what we are putting forward in these amendments is not nerely as effective for the purpose of simplifying the matter as the amendments would appear to suggest. I have already suggested that the person who reads the Bill and tries to operate it, or the person who gets the advisory memorandum issued by the Revenue Commissioners will not find it all that easy. The Revenue Commissioners issue advisory memoranda and they cannot take these figures out of them; they have to put in this 11.11 and 16.37, and all the rest of it. I think the rounding-down could be done relatively easily. For example, there has been a good deal of talk about the 16 per cent rate being rounded-down to 13 per cent and the 11.11 rounded-down to 10 per cent. I can see no reason why the 16 per cent rate, if the Minister and his advisers do not want to lose revenue, should not be rounded-down to 15 per cent. That would give us the even figure again and we would be working in fives—5, 10, 15 up to 30.
This seems to me to be a much more rational approach. I am talking about right reason now. I am not talking about arithmetic at all. I am talking about reason and not about the arithmetic of the thing because the arithmetic is of no significance. I will admit—I did as much work as anybody else on figures—they are significant in certain circumstances; but I cannot for the life of me see what the relevance of these exact, precise figures is to this matter. I think the Minister and his advisers are really afraid of a shadow. It is not an absolute shadow, but it is as near as can be to a shadow——
Comment on this
——and I can see no reason for this. Even if it be the reality, as the Minister's advisers say, that these even rates are no better than the uneven rates, from the point of view of the working of them by the people concerned they will look better. The Minister said earlier on that what people think does tend to become the reality. I am afraid it does. We none of us want to deprive the Minister of any revenue necessary for his purposes, but this is a serious aspect of this Bill. In fact it is the kernel of the whole problem in it. All these other amendments deal with closing gaps and that kind of thing. What the rates are to be is the centrepiece of the Bill. The Minister should think again about the reasons which seem good and sufficient to him and his advisers to justify having these peculiar rates in the Bill. Arithmetic never worries me unduly—it never did—but I fail to see why in a statute this kind of thing should be done. We have had no coercive argument in favour of doing it. If we had an absolute set to the value of money, money being absolutely level with the table we are sitting before, I could well understand the Minister might say: "If I lose a few million it will make a big difference to me". But we have operated on the figures given to us, comparing this year with last year, without any change in rates and the wholesale tax is up from less than £30 million to £35½ million and the turnover tax is up from £50 million to £53½ million.
There is nothing in the difference between these various figures: the clean straightforward figures, working in fives and the complex figures we have in this Bill, there is nothing approaching these figures created by inflation. I think I understand why the Minister seeks to do this; he wants to scoop up the benefit of the inflation because he realises his costs will go up pro rata with the inflation and he does not want to lose even a marginal bit of revenue on the other change. When new taxation like this comes into operation there are big changes, changes not even the Minister and his advisers or the rest of us can see, and if the Minister and his advisers cannot, in fact, know what the reality will be, then I would like to put forward the point of view—it is a point of view held by many people—that this new tax system will close a lot of loopholes for evasion. So far there has been no discussion at all on that, but it is generally accepted that there are a lot of loopholes for evasion.
It was suggested to me yesterday, and again this morning—I was not myself aware of this—that there is, in fact, a good deal of evasion at present and, when this system comes into operation, evasion will not be so easy of accomplishment by those who want to evade the tax. If that is so, then the Minister will get a great deal more possibly than would be covered by this relatively small change. I have said all I want to say.
Comment on this
When I hear Deputy Dr. O'Donovan talk about reason, I think the Minister has been most reasonable in this matter. When the Minister introduces such peculiar and difficult figures, I am convinced that he would prefer to have adopted simpler and easier ways to calculate figures, but he is seeking to ensure that the revenue from this value-added tax will be at least equal to those taxes he is abolishing—the turnover and the wholesale taxes—and he is not just trying to be difficult. I believe neither he nor the Revenue Commissioners thought up peculiarly difficult computations to impose them on the trade. They agree they are difficult but, nonetheless, underlying all this is the fact this will at least produce the same amount of revenue as was produced heretofore. Buoyancy and inflation, as has been argued, are possibilities, but we must deal with realities rather than possibilities. The very complexity of the Bill indicates to me that the Minister went into this in great depth. I do not think he is refusing to look at arguments designed to improve the Bill where he thinks it can be improved. I believe he will examine the points raised here in this discussion which might give him a new insight into the Bill or a new view of it. It is true there is some evasion of tax, but I think it is very, very small indeed. In that respect I am perfectly satisfied with the Bill as it stands relying on the fact that the Minister and his officials are not being unreasonable but, rather, being most reasonable to ensure that the return of revenue and not buoyancy or inflation will be manna, if you like, from heaven.
There are one or two matters troubling me to some degree and I hope I will be pardoned for raising them if they have been covered on a previous section. I wish to refer to houses. It is not unusual for a house to be finished and not to be sold for about four months, so that many builders will probably find themselves with finished houses in stock amounting to nearly one-third of their annual turnover. In addition to that, there will be a number of houses in the course of construction together with building materials on the site. Up to 31st October they will have paid whatever taxes are now applicable to the goods they buy. I am assuming that under this Bill a tax of three-point something will be applicable but that builders will not be able to recover any tax from these stocks which will be going into these houses. That is the first point. Secondly, I want to talk about secondhand houses. This comes under the heading of immovable goods in the Bill. The first man, I know, will pay tax but, as regards the second man, will he or will he not? In regard to movable goods, for instance, cars and television sets, which do change hands and on which there is a heavy tax, the original purchaser of the goods will pay a tax. What tax is applicable to the second purchaser, or is credit given in respect of the first, to the old owner who paid the full tax on it? Or is the second buyer the beneficiary of a gift in regard to tax or would it be a case of double taxation, that there would be tax on the first sale and also on the second?
Comment on this
Could I say in regard to what Deputy O'Donovan said that I did not intend any discourtesy whatever to him. I think I have tried to the best of my ability to answer the argument he made and I do not think I would add anything by saying it again. In regard to Deputy Gallagher's query about houses on the appointed day, it is dealt with in section 34 and again, in the interests of good order, I do not intend to deal with it now. We shall deal with it when we come to it. In regard to the question of secondhand houses, in the normal way they will not be subject to the tax. Liability would arise only if they had been purchased originally by a registered person who had got credit for the tax. That is the only way in which they would pay.
Comment on this
No, I should like to press that. I do not know what is the procedure in regard to a division.
Comment on this
Standing Order No. 72 reads:
The doors of the Committee room shall be locked while a Division is being taken in a Select or Special Committee. Divisions shall be taken by the Clerk to the Committee calling the names of the members. In the event of there being an equality of votes the question shall be decided in the negative.
Comment on this
I am not clear on this because this is a Special Committee. This is not the House, and do the same rules operate?
Comment on this
The advice available to me—and it is not authoritative on the Dáil procedure—is that an amendment withdrawn here could be moved on Report Stage.
Comment on this
My own opinion is that an amendment can be pressed here and can again be introduced.
Comment on this
My ruling is that it could be introduced in the Dáil whether it is withdrawn or defeated here.
Comment on this
I am not questioning your ruling, Mr. Chairman, but is there any danger that your ruling would be overruled by the Ceann Comhairle?
Comment on this
When the Chairman has made such a ruling and it has been accepted by all the Members of the Committee I could not visualise the Ceann Comhairle overruling that.
Comment on this
I cannot see him do it. I move amendment No. 8:
In subsection (1) (a), page 14, line 43, to delete "5.26 per cent." and substitute "5 per cent.".
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 9:
In subsection (1) (b), page 14, line 48, to delete "11.11 per cent." and substitute "10 per cent.".
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 11:
In subsection (1) (c), page 14, line 58, to delete "30.26 per cent." and substitute "30 per cent".
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 12:
In subsection (1) (e), page 15, line 8, to delete "16.37 per cent" and substitute "10 per cent".
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 12a:
In page 15, subsection (1) (e), line 8, to delete "16.37 per cent." and insert "13 per cent".
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
Even if we all agree to dispose of the others now. Can we not do that to avoid confusion?
Comment on this
I am sorry but, whether we agree or not, we have not got the power to do it now. We must discuss No. 15 and then we will take the others but they will not be discussed because they have been dealt with.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:
In page 15, subsection (3), line 25, to delete "Subject to" and insert "Notwithstanding".
I had difficulty in understanding what is involved in this subsection and in the relationship between it and section 5 (5) and 10 (8) (c). It seemed to me it might be better to express the subsection in terms that the provisions of the sub-section would apply "notwithstanding" section 5 (5) and 10 (8) (c) rather than that they should be "subject to" them. It seemed to me at one stage a better way of dealing with the matter but I am not at all clear in my mind about this. I put the amendment down more with a view to having the Minister clarify the issue than because of any firm conviction.
Comment on this
The effect of Deputy FitzGerald's amendment would be to directly negative the intention in the subsection. The effect of putting in "notwithstanding" instead of "subject to" would be the direct opposite. The phrase "Subject to" indicates that, if the other provisions in section 5 (5) and 10 (8) (c) are more appropriate, then they should prevail over this provision. The effect of Deputy FitzGerald's amendment would be to indicate that this subjection of section 11 would prevail no matter what the circumstances. What we desire to achieve here is that what I might call "the two-thirds rule" should operate in the circumstances which are specified in sections 5 (5) and 10 (8) (c), that is, that where goods of a value in excess of two-thirds of the total package are supplied in the provision of a service or a building, the provisions specified in section 5 (5) and 10 (8) (c) should operate. This subsection is designed to deal with other types of practice where the consideration is not referable to individual constituents.
Comment on this
On the section, I was somewhat puzzled and amused by our earlier procedure, especially on my being ruled out of order for raising a matter that seemed to me to be directly relevant; we then proceeded to discuss a matter which we had finished discussing at 3 o'clock and we had two fairly long speeches, one of them by a Deputy who had objected to my irrelevance on the subject of the rounding-off rates, which we had finished at 3 o'clock, so I am becoming very puzzled about our procedure here.
Comment on this
It is very difficult for the Chairman to differentiate between preludes and legitimate comments. The Deputy is referring now to Deputy O'Donovan's remarks about rounding-off.
Comment on this
May I make the point that it has been suggested, as a way of tidying up matters, that one portion of an amendment should be left over; that would not be relevant at all. In fact, if Deputy FitzGerald so desired, he could have gone back over the whole lot as long as there was an amendment before the Committee.
Comment on this
Actually I was talking about something that was on while others were talking about something that was not on at all.
Comment on this
Might I say I think I am entitled to reply to that remark and I will reply in the minimum number of words. I did what I did at the invitation of the Minister. He asked that the debate be tidied up. The Minister clearly asked was everything finished now in relation to these amendments and I then made my remarks and the record will show whether I am right or wrong.
Comment on this
In the interests of bringing the Committee to a conclusion perhaps Deputy FitzGerald now, Mr. Chairman, would make whatever remarks he has to make.
Comment on this
I will move from my "prelude" now to my first "movement". I want to advert to subsection (2) of section 11. As I understand it, it relates to this question of the Fourth Schedule and what to do with goods in the Fourth Schedule. It deals with the question of the tax being caught at the manufacturing and wholesale stage and provides that the retailer should collect only 5.26 per cent despite the fact on the earlier value of the goods the tax rate is 30.26 per cent. I endeavoured to argue that, in my amendment containing exactly the same provision, I was entitled to deal with the question of the goods being caught and I would like to put to the Minister what limitations are there on the extension of the list of goods in the Fourth Schedule? I understood the Minister to say that there were some EEC objections and, I would like him now to refer me to the Directive in question which inhibits him in the range of goods and which, in his view, would make it difficult or impossible legally for us to extend the range of goods referred to in the Fourth Schedule and dealt with, therefore, under subsection (2) of this section.
Comment on this
I suggest, with all due deference, that if I were to reply to that question I would be out of order. It might be in order on the Schedule, but it is not in order on the subsection.
Comment on this
This is the subsection which provides that the tax will be caught at the earlier stage and that at the retail stage only 5.26 per cent shall be applied. It, therefore, is the subsection of the relevant section which operates this mechanism, a mechanism which it limits to certain goods, a list of which are set out in the Fourth Schedule. I am concerned with the operation of the subsection and the question to what goods it can apply. It is suggested it can apply only to a limited range of goods. The reason has been given for this and I should like to hear the Minister develop his reason.
Comment on this
I suggest, Mr. Chairman, that if this kind of question is relevant at all it can only be relevant when we come to the section dealing with ministerial orders which will enable the Minister to extend the range of goods in the Fourth Schedule. At the moment what we are dealing with here are the goods specified in the Fourth Schedule and what Deputy FitzGerald is talking about is a possible extension of these.
Comment on this
We are dealing with the provision which makes possible the catching of goods at the earlier stage and makes it possible not to apply the full tax rate at the later stage, but to apply a lower tax rate, and the lower tax rate is the 5.26 per cent rate. I am concerned about how, in fact, sub-section (2) of section 11 applies and what limitations there are in EEC legislation to the application of this subsection.
Comment on this
Then I am afraid Deputy Tully is on the wrong side, even on the basis that Deputy FitzGerald is trying to put the case which relates to section 12 and not to section 11, but I still submit that, when we are talking about the goods specified in the Fourth Schedule, it is not in order to ask what provisions there are in the EEC which would relate to the extension of the Fourth Schedule and that, I understand, is what Deputy FitzGerald is asking.
Comment on this
But this is the sub-section which lays down that where goods are of a certain kind and certain things happen to them that the tax rate paid by a person other than the manufacturer shall be 5.26 per cent and not 30.26 per cent. Now that is in the mechanism which is prima facie an unusual mechanism and the question arises as to what limitations there are on the application of this mechanism. I understood the Minister to suggest earlier on that there is some limitation on the application of this mechanism which affects the working of this sub-section and I want to know what these limitations are.
Comment on this
If I may rephrase it, Mr. Chairman, would the Minister say if there is any limitation which will affect what is included in the Fourth Schedule?
Comment on this
So, in fact, no other goods other than those included in the Fourth Schedule are in order.
Comment on this
What I should like to know is can this subsection apply to a wide range of goods and is there any limitation on the application of this subsection? The Minister has listed some goods in the Fourth Schedule. He might have listed more or less. I am not concerned with the Fourth Schedule. I am concerned to know whether this subsection can be applied to the whole range of goods or what limitations apply to the operations of this subsection. The Fourth Schedule is just a red herring.
Comment on this
The Deputy is just making a debating point. He knows as well as I do that this subsection relates to the goods listed in the Fourth Schedule. It is no good trying to tell us that the Fourth Schedule is not relevant. Of course it is relevant. The whole thing is based on that. The real difficulty here is, thinking back over our procedure heretofore, that I have a sense of guilt in that I feel I have contributed to some extent to the fact that we were wandering further from the purposes we had in mind and which most members of the Committee would wish; and the reason is, I think, that I have tended to try to answer points put forward. I could point out to Deputy FitzGerald, as I did briefly elaborate on the fact, that it is on section 12 that what he is talking about arises, but we will then start discussing section 12 and I do not want that to happen because we would be out of order. Even if it is raised on section 12, however, I would still submit, Mr. Chairman, that what Deputy FitzGerald's question relates to is the power of the Minister, by order, to amend the list of goods in the Fourth Schedule. When we come to that it may be that you will rule that it is in order to answer this question, but I submit we are not in order on this section.
Comment on this
I am not concerned with the powers of the Minister at all. I am concerned with the subsection that provides that a certain procedure shall operate and I want to know what limitations are there to the operation of that subsection.
Comment on this
There are no limitations in this section or in this Bill other than those which appear on the face of the Bill.
Comment on this
The Minister is, perhaps, catching me on wording. What EEC limitations are there in the application of this subsection?
Comment on this
Can the Minister reconcile that with his earlier answer? What the Minister says is not assisting the discussion very much.
Comment on this
I should think that in the long run Deputy FitzGerald and other members of the Committee will see that it is assisting the discussion. It is designed to help the discussion.
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?