We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Vivion de Valera

Follow

Former member, 1948–1981

Service

Dáil

Estimates, 1980. - Vóta 29

Like Deputy Flanagan, I am limited to 45 minutes because the House so decided. Time has to be apportioned and efficiently used in modern times. I am not to be taken as going the whole way with the Deputy, But I take the opportunity to concur in the point he made. I am glad that…

3 contributions in this debate

Dáil

Personal Explanation by Member.

In the course of his speech here yesterday Deputy Kelly addressed himself to certain Members on the Government side in a way that implied an invitation to them to change their minds. To this I said aloud to colleagues beside me, "Invitation refused". Deputy Kelly appeared not to…

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

Estimates, 1979. - Vote 2: Houses of the Oireachtas.

——as a rubber stamp. It is simply my usual delenda est but do we have to, year after year, go through these motions? Why not change to a more realistic system?

2 contributions in this debate

Dáil

Health (Family Planning) Bill, 1978: Committee Stage (Resumed).

I will be very brief on this. In all the arguments, constitutional and others, there has been little advertence to what I regard as the fundamental reasons why the doctor is the appropriate agent. I have already given them in detail. Whether contraceptive methods are drugs…

5 contributions in this debate

Dáil

Health (Family Planning) Bill, 1978: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Is the Deputy speaking for himself or for the main Opposition party? The views the Deputy has expressed are some fundamental policy views and it would help us to know whether he is speaking for himself or his party. Could the Deputy clarify that?

2 contributions in this debate

Dáil

Health (Family Planning) Bill, 1978: Committee Stage (Resumed). Section 3.

It is a fact that under American law when these things are advertised, particularly in medical journals, a list of these points must be published. These drugs have their uses in legitimate medicine but they are to a large extent regarded as belonging to the dangerous drugs…

10 contributions in this debate

Dáil

Health (Family Planning) Bill, 1978: Committee Stage.

I will not go into the details of the argument, but I shall put the following to the House for consideration. We have a well-established and well-tried system of law—it was in England but it has been altered there—which lays down a code for preventing abuse of abortifacients. I…

2 contributions in this debate

Dáil

Health (Family Planning) Bill, 1978: Committee Stage (Resumed).

One point is almost clear now, that is, the impossibility of defining these things. I agree with Deputy O'Connell. The same substance may give you a number of ambiguous answers if you attempt to interpret it in any rigid legal way, quite apart from the chemical affinities of many…

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

Appropriation Bill, 1977: Second and Subsequent Stages

I do not intend to delay the House with a speech on this Bill but I wish formally to draw the attention of the House, as I have done previously, to the fact that this is probably the most important Bill we pass but it will be disposed of in a matter of minutes at the end of term…

3 contributions in this debate

Dáil

Written Answers. - Grants to State-sponsored Bodies.

asked the Minister for Finance the provisions now governing the making of statutory or other grants from public moneys to State-sponsored bodies since entry to the European Economic Community; and if he will set out the limitations imposed by EEC Regulations on the making of such…

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

Written Answers. - CIE Grants.

asked the Minister for Tourism and Transport if he will specify in detail the new system arising out of EEC Regulations under which grants to Córas Iompair Éireann are paid since the 1st January 1975 as referred to in note (b) to the Estimate for Transport and Power, Vote 42, for…

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

Ministers and Secretaries (Amendment) Bill, 1977: Second Stage (Resumed).

This Bill is significant in more than one way. I should like to point out one very significant fact in this area generally; it is that most development since the war in organisation and administration has come about through the direct action of Government initiating action…

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

Telephone Capital Bill, 1977: Second Stage.

In the course of this debate it is understandable that particular emphasis should be placed on the modern problems of the telephone service experienced in particular by Deputies seeking to have telephones connected or who, in representing their constituents, have particular cases…

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

Nomination of Taoiseach.

Molaim dhuit, a Cheann Comhairle, Seán Ó Loinsigh agus molaim go n-ainmneoidh an Dáil é le dul ós comhair an Uachtaráin le bheith againn mar Thaoiseach agus ceann an Rialtais óir tá sé ceapaithe cheana féin mar Thaoiseach ag muintir na hÉireann.

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

Supplementary Estimates, 1977. - Finance Bill, 1977: Report and Final Stages.

This is one of the traps in this type of legislation. The existing phrase "wholly or mainly" leaves discretion to the Revenue Commissioners or in particular to the inspector who is dealing with the matter. I am not questioning the practice of the words being a general guide to 75…

9 contributions in this debate

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1977: Committee Stage (Resumed).

That is fact and I know it. There are good arguments why Ministers should have cars like that, but if what the Ministers say here is right then the ultimate end of the logic puts him in a peculiar position. On Deputy Haughey's amendment, as he rightly points out, there is a…

7 contributions in this debate

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1977: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Before we adjourned on this amendment I was making a case on the basis of the number of people involved. Obviously, I could make only a rough guess from the figures available. However, I do not think there is a large number of people involved. Having regard to the fact that other…

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1977: Committee Stage.

Yes. I said to the Minister that there are so many involved in the category that all those people are caught. If one listens to the Minister's argument one would think that it is just a handful of people with very big cars paying a very big lump sum each who are involved but that…

19 contributions in this debate

Dáil

Interim Report of Committee of Public Accounts: Motion.

I move: That an Interim Report from the Committee of Public Accounts be laid before the Dáil and that the Report be printed.

1 contribution in this debate

Special Committee National Board for Science and Technology Bill, 1976

SECTION 8.

Surely, the answer to all this is that if you start on that premises it is not 20, 30 or 100 you would want. This board cannot be approached on the basis of representation: it must be approached on what it is like. I completely agree that it should not be academic and that it is…

2 contributions in this debate

Special Committee National Board for Science and Technology Bill, 1976

SECTION 7.

There is a very imperfect precedent on the lines the Minister is thinking. In 1940 or 1941 the Emergency Scientific Research Bureau was set up, and I had a good deal to do with that body myself. It functioned very much in the way the Minister is describing now. It was in a…

3 contributions in this debate

Special Committee National Board for Science and Technology Bill, 1976

SECTION 5.

Here we are up against the problem of the hen and the egg to a certain extent. The Government mechanism is that there is the Government as the decision-making authority. Immediately below is the Department of Finance and then the individual Departments. The Votes for all these…

14 contributions in this debate

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1977: Second Stage (Resumed).

This debate embraces a wide area. In a sense, it is a second debate on the budget. I wish to comment on the Bill from an administrative point of view but, first, I will make the point that, although I shall not be repeating the very valid points made so far in the debate from…

1 contribution in this debate