Health (Family Planning) Bill, 1978: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–129 of 267. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 47 of 1978 ›
This is the most controversial section of the Bill and is probably the most confusing, misleading and impractical proposition for many reasons. There are a number of important words used in this section for which there is no clear explanation and for which, in the process of their explication later in the law courts, the Law Library must be jubilant at the prospects of the fortunes to be made in the interpretations of this section. I will have to do my best to make whatever definitions and clarifications I can in the hope that the Minister may then tell me where I am wrong or, if I am right, in order that we shall have on the record some kind of undertaking that at least this House saw the defects in the Bill, reminded the Minister of them and possibly that this Minister may decide that he may amend this section.
The Minister makes a number of statements. He claims that the best people to implement this Bill will be members of the medical profession. He also claims that this Bill is brought in in answer to the Supreme Court decision about the McGee case. Then he is particularly vague and indecisive on the issue of to whom it is to be permitted that contraceptives shall be made available on the prescription or authorisation of the general practitioner: must these people be married and, if they are, what do we do about the complicated position, which the Minister concedes exists, in relation to the law of marriage in this country?
The Minister is reported on Radio Éireann as saying that the person who is to get the contraceptives is the individual who "in the opinion of the general practitioner formed at the time of giving the prescription or authorisation, sought the contraceptive for the purpose, bona fide, of family planning or for adequate medical reasons and in appropriate circumstances”. He then attempted to establish—at column 320, Volume 313 of the Official Report—that the Health (Family Planning) Bill, 1978, follows the Supreme Court decision which involves a fundamental change in the law relating to the availability of contraceptives.
Comment on this
This section deals with the control, sale and supply of contraceptives. The Deputy seems to be going into matters which were appropriate to the Second Reading.
Comment on this
With respect, Sir, subsection (2), says:
... that the person named in it is a person who, in the opinion of the practitioner formed at the time of the giving of the prescription or authorisation, sought the contraceptive for the purpose, bona fide, of family planning or for adequate medical reasons and in appropriate circumstances.
That is the part of the section with which I am concerned: the Minister's decision to establish that a person who will authorise or prescribe a contraceptive must be a medical practitioner. He is giving the impression that medical practitioners have accepted this as desirable and he has sought to give the impression that his decision to establish this practice is in accordance with the ruling in the McGee case in the Supreme Court. I want to refute all these points in some detail because I believe they are very categorical misstatements of fact.
We should further establish that as things are at present there is no law in force in this State which prohibits the distribution or manufacture of contraceptives for use inside or outside marriage. This statement was made in the Supreme Court and this decision to change the law in a very fundamental way is, I believe, contrary to the provisions of the Constitution. It is very strange—and I am very concerned about this—that any couple, but certainly a married couple, should not have imposed on them a legal responsibility to go to a medical practitioner to establish that they are seeking contraceptives, bona fide, for family planning purposes.
This is an extraordinarily insensitive proposal that the privacy of the individual's marriage should have to suffer this intrusion of somebody outside the marriage in order to make this essentially very personal, very private and very sensitive decision. Quite frequently, through my life as a socialist, I have been attacked on the broad principles that my socialist beliefs inevitably imply that the State will intervene in the lives of the people in a very direct way and will lay down rigid laws and rigid restrictions to order their lives. One of my most consistent opponents in this broad conflict of ideologies has been the Minister, yet, if ever 1984 was epitomised in a piece of legislation surely it is implicit in section 4 of this Bill, and, in particular, in this subsection, that Big Brother should make decisions on behalf of a married couple or a couple who intend either to have a family or not have a family—to make decisions about the extremely personal, intimate details of their married life. When the Minister says that this particular proposal in this Bill stems from the ruling in the McGee case, I think he is——
Comment on this
The Deputy is now dealing with the broad principles, the fundamentals of the Bill on Committee Stage. The section is confined, irrespective of its reference to the subsection. It only deals with control of supply and sale.
Comment on this
I am dealing, in some detail, with the right of the Minister to introduce this clause into the Bill. I dealt with the principle of the Bill on Second Stage; I completely accede that point. It was quite impossible for us to deal on Second Stage in the required detail on this proposal. I said it was quite wrong for the Minister to bring in this proposal on Second Stage; I am now attempting to enlarge on the general principle which I attempted to establish at that time and to back my case——
Comment on this
The Deputy could make a speech on every subsection of the Bill if he uses the same strategy.
Comment on this
It is impossible to refute, or contradict, or reject a statement without making an argument for it. That is what Committee Stage is about. The Minister has said to me, "Deputy Browne does not agree with the Bill. This is unfortunate, but this is what it is going to be." I am explaining now why I do not agree. He is quite right to reject my simple statement that I do not agree with the Minister's Bill. He would say, "Why not?" and I am attempting to say why I do not agree with this matter in detail here on Committee Stage.
Comment on this
The Chair agrees that the Deputy may have referred to principles in the Bill in order to discuss the section, but not in a detailed Second Reading speech. The section in question deals only with the logistics of the Bill and with the manner in which it may be operated—mainly in relation to sale and supply.
Comment on this
I am dealing precisely with the logistics. The Minister made it clear on an earlier Stage that he would ask the doctors to implement the provisions of the Bill for him. He said in his Second Reading speech that the doctors are the best people to implement this Bill for him, and particularly this section of the Bill but he is wrong to give the impression that the medical association believe that they should implement, particularly, the section dealing with the non-medical type of contraceptive. They have repeatedly said that the legislation on contraception is social and political and not medical. They went on to say that the doctors should not be the only route by which non-medical contraceptives should be supplied. The Minister says, "I have consulted various people", and he keeps on consulting people until he gets the opinion that he wants and then he says, "The doctors told me this, therefore I must do what they say". The doctors have said they do not want to be solely responsible for the distribution of non-medical contraceptives. When they give him advice that he does not want, the Minister persists in attempting to impose this responsibility on them.
I have already made the point that there are less than 20 doctors trained in family planning in the country. The doctors welcome the suggestion that the medical profession should supervise the agents which may affect the health of those people who want the medical type of contraceptives, the IUD, the cap, the pill, and so on, and that is perfectly reasonable. These should obviously be restricted to supervision by the medical profession. The Minister, however, inexplicably refused to divide the medical from the non-medical type of contraceptive, so we have the situation where it is true that one type of contraceptive should be made available by general practitioners, but it is highly absurd that contraceptives such as the condom and spermacide should be restricted for prescription to members of the medical profession. These are articles which are available in barbers shops, chemists' shops, slot machines, anywhere and everywhere, as a result of newspaper advertisements, and through the post quite indiscriminately in most other countries. There is no case whatever for the Minister's decision to restrict the sale, or the prescription, of contraceptives to the members of the medical profession.
In fact is has been generally agreed that doctors are almost the last people who should be asked to deal with the question of non-medical planning or contraception. At the European symposium in Istanbul it was laid down that doctors are not needed for non-medical types of contraception. The report says that the medical profession, especially obstetricians, have been the greatest obstacle to the development of family planning services all over the world. A notable example is our own Dr. Arthur Barry, an obstetrician with obviously a vested interest—as all members of the profession have—in the baby business, who made a completely hysterical assault on the suggestion that there should be an extension of the availability of artificial contraceptives. He went on with the usual charges that this must lead to abortion and so on. So that if the Minister is serious in trying to extend the scope of his family planning services then he is certainly not going to do that by restricting the administration of the service to members of the medical profession. The doctors do not wish to be the instruments by which family planning contraceptives, particularly the non-medical type of contraceptives, are made available. Many of them are hostile to the extension of contraceptives for various reasons, sometimes simply ideological reasons, sometimes committed conviction and moral beliefs and sometimes the factor of simply ordinary common or garden interests in the very extensive and very valuable business of having babies.
If the Minister attempts to interpose the medical practitioner he is carrying out a direct assault on the very principle decided on in the McGee case in which it was decided that the individual has natural and human rights over which the State has no authority and the family is the natural, primary and fundamental unit of society which has rights which the State cannot control. So that the Minister is acting in direct conflict with this rather than introducing a provision which is going to implement the Supreme Court's decision in the McGee case. In another section of Mr. Justice Walsh's ruling he said:
It is a matter exclusively for the husband and wife to decide how many children they wish to have and it would be quite outside the competence of the State to dictate or prescribe the number of children they should have.
Comment on this
The Deputy is going back to the principles of the Bill again. This was appropriate to the Second Reading which was debated and passed in this House. The Deputy may not go back on it.
Comment on this
The Deputy asked me that very specific question at another stage in this debate and I gave him the answer to it.
Comment on this
The Minister may have given me an answer but he did not give me a satisfactory answer. This is why I am contesting section 4 of the Bill.
Comment on this
I did not indicate that it was satisfactory. I could not have indicated that it was satisfactory because that is what my whole conflict is with the Minister.
On the question of bona fide family planning, I went to some trouble to find out what a family is and according to the Oxford English Dictionary a family is:
1. Members of a household, parents, children, servants, etc. (happy -, animals of different kinds in one cage); set of parents & children, or of relations, living together or not...
2. All decendants of common ancestor, house, lineage, ...; race, group of people from common stock.
3. Brotherhood of persons or nations...
4. Group of objects distinguished by common features.
5. Group of allied genera, ...
and at the end—
—planning, birth control;
But in the definition of family, marriage is not referred to at all, so therefore it is important that we try to establish that the Minister cannot restrict the principle of family to what he said in his speech, that it must be a married couple. I would be glad if he would deal with this matter again because at one stage he quite satisfied me at any rate——
Comment on this
Yes. The provision is that the registered medical practitioner may, for the purposes of this Act, give a prescription for a contraceptive to a person if he is satisfied that the person is seeking the contraceptive, bona fide, for family planning purposes. I am trying to find out what the Minister means by family planning.
Comment on this
The Chair is attempting to protect the Minister. He knows quite well that we are entitled to debate this in detail here.
Comment on this
I will not withdraw it. The Chair knows quite well that we are meant to debate this in detail on Committee Stage.
Comment on this
The Deputy should withdraw the allegation that the Chair is protecting the Minister. The Chair is enforcing the Standing Orders which apply in the case of a Committee Stage debate which relates only to the section and not to the principles which have already been discussed and decided. Whether the Deputy thinks they were adequately discussed is another matter, but the broad principles of the Bill have been debated and voted on.
Comment on this
May I just intervene for a moment? Deputy Browne was present in this House when all these matters were dealt with in detail by me. Every possible question was answered. I have a record of the Dáil debate here in front of me and I will give the Deputy the reference if he wants it. It is Wednesday, 9 May, column 281 onwards. We went into all these matters and I gave my view and my approach as explicitly as I possibly could.
Comment on this
If the Minister cares to look at his own remarks at column 175 they are a direct contradiction and that is the cause of Deputy Browne's upset——
Comment on this
The Chair will not allow the general framework of the Bill to be discussed again. It is not in accordance with the well-established principles and order in this House as laid down in Standing Orders. The imputation that the Chair is protecting anyone should be withdrawn.
Comment on this
I withdraw it. Our problem with this Bill is the equivocation of the Minister on a number of occasions. We had a good instance of it last night where we had an amendment No. 17 and a further amendment No. 17a One was quite different from the other. We were satisfied with one and then the Minister produced another.
Comment on this
I have already made my point. One amendment was introduced amending another amendment and that is what I meant by equivocation. There has also been equivocation on the question of the meaning of the word "family", whether it means a married couple, a stable couple or otherwise. Our laws are confused for the same reasons that we cannot make up our minds to provide for the dissolution of marriage in a divorce. We have this strange anomaly of annulment by the Catholic Church and the absence of civil law. The Minister—perhaps he would enlighten me on this for the last time when he is making his own contribution—has to admit that he cannot impose on doctors the responsibility of trying to decide who under our laws is married and who is not. We have the couple who got an annulment from the Catholic Church and are living apart, the couple who have a foreign divorce and are living apart, the couple who have had an annulment and are remarried and the couple who are divorced. Divorce and annulment are not recognised by our laws. There can be seven or eight permutations of legal or illegal marriages in our country. For that reason all the Minister can do is leave the whole question of contraception widely open in the terms of the Oxford English dictionary, that is, practically any couple living together, married or unmarried, divorced or following an annulment, can be considered suitable for being permitted a prescription for contraceptives.
I do not see how the Minister can ask any doctor to decide bona fide on the kind of person who should have further children or have no children as the case may be. This is something which must be clarified. In my whole approach to the Bill I have tried to slow myself down to the rate of the caterpillar progress of social advances in society in order to come to terms with the kind of debate that must be carried on in this House. I am not attempting to make any problems in doing so.
If I was a doctor in general practice and a person came along to me, I do not see how I could say to him or her: "I think you are bone fide planning a family” or “I do not think you are bona fide planning a family”. On what grounds could a doctor say this and why should he say it? Why should a third Irishman or woman intervene between two others when it comes to having their family? The Minister said at one stage—this is why it is so important that I deal with this matter—that bona fide family planning meant that contraceptives would be allowed only to married people.
Comment on this
I have it written down that the Minister said that. I do not have the references but I will find the precise reference and get it for the Minister. Accepting that the Minister has not said it, this is a considerable advance.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows exactly what I said. We thrashed it out on 9 May by way of question and answer.
Comment on this
At column 175 on 9 May the Minister said it was restricted solely to married persons. This is the cause of the entire problem in the debate for the last half hour.
Comment on this
I would not try to deliberately mislead the House. What I asked the Minister about was whether married people could decide to have no children. That I felt was an advance in so far as he said "Yes", that he could not intervene in those circumstances. It was an advance that we would not compel people who did not want to have children to have them. With regard to bone fide family planning, that meant that contraceptives would be allowed only to married people. Now we have it on the Minister's assurance that this is not so.
Comment on this
On a question of fact, I refer the Deputy to column 282 of the Official Report of 9 May, Volume 314, where it states:
Mr. Haughey: I will give you my definition of family planning. I use the word "family" because a married couple seems to bring us into some complicated legal situations. There could be people who are a family and who strictly in the terms of our law are not so regarded. Can the Deputy accept that?
Comment on this
No. I find it very confusing; our law is so confusing. I have made that point already. The computations of marriage in our law are so confusing that I am afraid the Minister cannot equivocate at all.
Comment on this
I made it clear that I do not use "marriage" because of the confused situation in regard to the law on marriage. That is why I use the word "family".
Comment on this
I want to make it clear to the Minister that there is no definition of the word "family" other than the definition I gave.
Comment on this
I have indicated that in this legislation I am adopting the constitutional concept of the family.
Comment on this
Yes, but there is no definition of what the family is. All sorts of wonderful things are said about it, but very few of them are implemented. There is no definition of the family other than the one I gave. The Minister can say what he likes, but when he moves away from the position of the marriage—and I am glad he has done that—that means a couple living together, a stable couple. Of course that is an absurd word. What is a stable couple? We are now in the position where we are accepting that the family is——
Comment on this
The Deputy is incorrigible. I know full well that if I used the word "married" in this legislation the Deputy would rant and rave about it and say it is a confused concept.
Comment on this
Because I move away from that and use the word "family", which is the whole basis of our constitutional approach to this matter—and the McGee court decision was derived from the family articles in the Constitution—and because I am keeping in line with that basic constitutional position the Deputy cannot accept it.
Comment on this
The Chair would remind the Minister and the Deputy that we are not dealing with the principles of the Bill. We are dealing with a section which is an integral part of the Bill.
Comment on this
Nobody wants to make progress more than I do. You should know that. That is what I have been trying to do for many, many years.
Comment on this
I know. That is quite a different thing. I am not misleading the House when I define a family as members of a household, parents and children. I am a doctor and I may be asked to prescribe contraceptives. I have been in the past, and I may be in the future. I will look at the Bill and I will find that what I have to do is be satisfied that the person is seeking the contraceptives bona fide for family planning purposes. As if I did not know already, I will look up the dictionary and I will find that a family consists of parents, children and perhaps servants. There is no question of marriage. It could be parents, children and relations living with them.
Remember that there are such things as polyandry, polygamy and monogamy. The status of marriage in our society is crazy because successive Governments have left it the way it is. The Minister has had to desert the marriage position and go into the family position. Whatever he may say about all the wonderful things which are said about the family in the Constitution —and at this stage I have studied the Constitution in greater detail than I ever did before and I have more admiration for it now than I used to have—there is no doubt in the world that there is no definition of the family in the Constitution.
Comment on this
I am just making the statement that there is no definition of the family in the Constitution.
Comment on this
If the Constitution does not suffer because of that lack of a definition, I do not think this Bill suffers either.
Comment on this
Five minutes ago the Minister gave a solemn undertaking that he would not intervene again.
Comment on this
I am concerned with the dilemma of a doctor. We are attempting to solve the problem of a doctor facing the line in this Bill which says he must satisfy himself that the person is seeking the contraceptive bona fide for family planning purposes or for adequate medical reasons. Despite all the marvellous things said in the Constitution, about the family being the basis of society and so on, there is no definition of the family in the Constitution. The Minister has given me no definition of the family.
Comment on this
I have given the Deputy a definition of family planning ad nauseam. That is the important thing.
Comment on this
Yes, planning a family. I ask: what is a family? I made it quite clear that a family is a group of people living together, men, women and children, dozens of them, or two or three of them. This is a considerable advance. No wonder the medical profession are very puzzled as to why they should have to intervene in this very private and personal decision between two people. It is a completely personal whim how the doctor decides. It is an extraordinary, absurd and inexplicable intervention by another individual in such a private and personal decision. It must occur to the doctor to ask: "Why on earth should I be asked to make a decision between a man and a woman as to whether they should or should not have a family?" This provision must make us the laughing stock of Europe.
The Minister mentioned the McGee case concerning this lady's right to have no children and to have the contraceptives of her choice, but even that does not hold up. The Minister tried to establish that because of the McGee case, a married lady and her husband, the provisions here can be extrapolated in some sort of reverse direction. The Supreme Court decision was that this married couple must have contraceptives but even that does not hold up because in a dissenting judgment on this question in the Supreme Court, Mr. Fitzgerald said it is well to realise that the plaintiff's claim here is as a citizen and not as a married person and that if any portion of section 17 of the 1935 Act is declared unconstitutional—and of course it was—the benefit to be derived from such a decision is equally to be enjoyed by every other citizen married of not.
The Minister's whole case is in shreds. He is asking for a Supreme Court action to be taken the day this Bill becomes law. That is why it seems so extraordinary to me that the Minister should make the claim in his Second Reading speech, and subsequently, that he is in fact implementing decisions arising out of the McGee case. He is not. This is a crazy provision. It is completely unworkable. Maybe that is what the Minister has in mind. It is so totally unworkable and impracticable that perhaps I am wasting my time. It will go under the carpet and nobody will take any notice of it. Maybe that is so.
At the same time if law-abiding citizens want to get permission to buy contraceptives presumably they must consult a lawyer in order to ascertain the position legally, in order to ascertain what variation of Irish marriage is permissible so as to give one the right to decide whether to have a child. Even more important is the position of the doctor. He would be in a very vulnerable position and would possibly face a High Court action if he presumed to tell two people who were planning not to have children that in his opinion they should have children. The whole situation is absurd.
Comment on this
We know that what the Deputy wants is the simple solution of making contraceptives available by way of slot machines but the House would not accept that.
Comment on this
The Chair must intervene here because we are having a tremendous amount of repetition, must of it from Deputy Browne. We must make progress on the section before the House. It is not in order to continue to repeat the argument.
Comment on this
The Chair must be fair and admit that I have not repeated the argument. I have been very careful not to do so.
Comment on this
The Chair has been hearing the same argument repeatedly. I heard it on the last occasion and again this morning.
Comment on this
Has the Chair heard the argument I put forward a few moments ago—that the right given to Mrs. McGee in the McGee case must be given also to every other woman?
Comment on this
That was not repetition. We have established much this morning. For instance, we have established that the Minister is making it possible for a doctor to make contraceptives available to anyone who asks for them and that while there may be defence in law such defence would not be upheld in terms of the Constitution in the case of any doctor denying people, whether married or unmarried, the right to have as many or as few children as they wished. The Minister attempted to establish that "family" meant marriage but later in his dealings with the medical association he said that the law relating to marriage is not clear and that, consequently, he did not wish to put medical people in the position of having to decipher the law in this regard.
Comment on this
The Deputy is endeavouring to mislead the House as to what is the constitutional position.
Comment on this
If there is no new matter to be put before the House the Chair will have to put the section, because repetition is totally out of order.
Comment on this
Before there is any attempt to guillotine the section, I should hope to have the opportunity of speaking on it.
Comment on this
There is no wish on the part of the Chair to guillotine the section but it is the responsibility of the Chair to ensure that legislation is not obstructed and to ensure also that there is not repetition. Deputy Boland will have the opportunity of speaking but Deputy Browne may continue if he has anything new to add to the section as amended.
Comment on this
This has been a most useful morning. We have established the very important principle that a couple need not be married in order to be able to avail of the means of planning a family. I have made the case before that arising out of at least one interesting survey carried out by Dr. Bowman of the Department of Psychology at TCD, just less than 50 per cent of those visiting family planning clinics are not married. We should have regard also to the ICTU recommendation that there should not be any restriction in this legislation in relation to marriage. I cannot forsee any possibility of this section being upheld.
We have dealt with the position of the doctor but the position of the chemist is particularly invidious because he is to be put in the position that if he gives advice or information to his customers as to the use of contraceptives, and it would be reasonable for a chemist to do that since he offers advice in respect of any drug or anything else he sells, he will be acting unlawfully as a family planning clinic.
Comment on this
I tabled a specific amendment on that point and that amendment has been dealt with by the House.
Comment on this
My main point is, then, that it is completely outrageous that we adults here should legislate for the establishment of the principle that one citizen has the right to enter the bedroom of another pair of citizens and make decisions for them regarding the size of their family. In addition we know now that the phrase "family planning" is totally meaningless and cannot be established in the sense in which the Minister attempted first to establish it. We have established that family planning refers to people living together, that marriage does not enter into the question. Regardless of whether the Minister or any other Member of the House may like to hear this, the situation as a result of this Bill will be that anybody who wants contraceptives will be able to get them on the prescription of a doctor but at unnecessary expense. In other words, the Bill is unworkable.
Comment on this
Before Deputy Boland intervenes, it might be useful for me to demonstrate the manner in which Deputy Browne is approaching this legislation. He has just said that the position of a pharmacist is to be very difficult but the Deputy knows that amendment No. 13 which was passed by the House applies directly to the situation of the pharmacist and will result in his being exorerated specifically from the sort of difficulty to which the Deputy referred. If we are to continue to cover the same ground all Deputy Browne will succeed in doing will be to delay the Bill and, therefore, to delay the initiation of a family planning service. There is one very brief point about the constitutional position. It is my view, and I think constitutional lawyers would uphold this view, that the majority decision in the McGee case contained the following point but I might point out that it was the minority decision to which Deputy Browne referred——
Comment on this
The majority decision is the one that matters and in that decision the point was made that a husband and wife have the correlative right to agree not to have children. There is no argument about that. Towards the end of that majority decision Mr. Justice Walsh said that he wished to emphasise that he had not given any consideration to the question of the constitutionality or otherwise of laws which would withhold or restrict the availability of contraceptives for use outside marriage and that nothing in the judgment was intended to offer any opinion on that matter.
Comment on this
It is my view that the majority decision was based on the Article in the Constitution relating to the family and that, therefore, any question of the availability of contraceptives to single people was not involved. I am reasonably certain from my knowledge of these things that the Supreme Court did not and would not upset this Bill because it does not make artificial contraceptives available to single people as of right. The Supreme Court have never said that there is any such constitutional right and I do not believe they ever would say that there is any such constitutional right.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister would be good enough to read out the first quotation from the majority Supreme Court ruling that he gave to us.
Comment on this
It is the same as I told Deputy Browne here last day: "In my view the husband and wife have a current right to agree to have no children."
Comment on this
"The sexual right of husband and wife is an area of particular privacy." They also said that.
Comment on this
That is why I said on Second Stage that I did not believe that the courts would look in a benign fashion on this Bill and that is why this Bill and this entire discussion have been a waste of time of the House and have been misleading the public. In section 4 of this Bill the Minister now purports to join a third party, the doctor, into that right which the majority decision that the Minister has read twice into the record of the House gave to the husband and wife. The Minister is now removing from the husband and the wife that absolute right which the Supreme Court in the majority decision stated was theirs and he is giving instead that decision to a third person, a doctor. He is giving it specifically in section 4, not on the basis of the doctor's medical knowledge, abaility or training. In section 4 (2) he says:
A registered medical practitioner may, ... give a prescription or authorisation for a contraceptive to a person if he is satisfied that the person is seeking the contraceptive, bona fide, for family planning or for adequate medical reasons....
If the Minister had not chosen to put in the last phrase it might be argued that "family planning purposes" came within the ambit of the doctor's medical training. However, the Minister in his own legislation is at pains to make it clear that family planning purposes are not necessary medical reasons at all. It appears clear that this Bill will end up in the courts on foot of this section and the joining of the doctor with the couple who had their right confirmed by the Supreme Court in the McGee case judgment to decide how to order their sexual affairs in private without interference from anybody else or without their interfering with anybody else. That right appears to be eroded and attacked in section 4. If the courts take the same line as they took previously they cannot accept sections 4 as being constitutional now because of the joining in of the doctor, and indeed in some degree of the chemist, into that decision-making approach. For that reason we are to a large extent wasting the time of the House unnecessarily on a Bill that will not stand up.
The last time I warned the Minister that we were wasting the time of the House on a Bill that was unworkable he did not accept that. That Bill, which was for the control of the advertising and sponsorship of tobacco products, has never been implemented because the Minister subsequently found that what I said was right. That Bill has never come into effect and this Bill will not come into effect either.
Comment on this
The Tobacco Products (Control of Advertising, Sponsorship and Sales Promotion) Act is in effect.
Comment on this
I am not suggesting in any facetious way that this Bill is going to fall. I am making the suggestion on the basis of a fairly careful study that I and other people have done of the legal effects and implications of the Bill and I am pointing out that the last time I made such a prediction I was proved right. The regulations have not been made.
Comment on this
We will have to get some other opportunity to discuss that Bill.
Comment on this
I said it would be unworkable, not unconstitutional.
Other parts of section 4 raise serious doubts. Section 4 (1) (b) sets out the fact that a chemist, his servant or agent may supply contraceptives to a person on foot of a prescription or authorisation, but apparently the situation is now to be that the chemist may supply to the named person who has to go to the doctor to have a prescription made out to him in his name for contraceptives. The spouse of the person to whom the prescription has been issued apparently would not be empowered to go to the chemist's shop with the prescription or authorisation. Similarly the husband of a woman would not be allowed to go to the chemist's shop to have the prescription or authorisation dispensed. Does that not seem a rather unfair, unnecessary restriction? The Minister might care to explain why he is insisting that only the person to whom the contraceptive prescription is issued must attend personally at the chemist's shop to have the prescription filled. It does not seem reasonable. There is the even more ridiculous position that the pharmacist apparently will find that while he is selling contraceptives to other people on foot of these scripts he will be obliged to obtain a script from a doctor in order to supply himself with contraceptives. Otherwise if a chemist were to sell contraceptives to himself he would be clearly in breach of the provisions of section 4.
I referred last night at some length to the use of the phrase "bona fide” and the difficulty it had created. I asked the Minister to explain why he had used the phrase “bona fide” in the legislation. He suggested, perhaps a little facetiously, that it was because of his classical education. My reason for inquiring is that in recent legislation on the Landlord and Tenant Amendment Bill, 1979, which was an amendment of the 1930 Act, the phrase “bona fide” was dropped. When the Minister of State at the Department of Foreign Affairs, Deputy D. Andrews, who handled that Bill in the Seanad, was questioned as to why “bona fide” was no longer being used his explanation was that it is just a piece of superfluous jargon which lawyers are inclined to use. I think he would agree that it is not necessary in the context and is purely a drafting matter. The phrase “bona fide” is a cliche. Why use the words? Why not use the words “with the best of intentions”? The Minister of State went on to say that it was about time we started to use printable and understandable English. When the matter was raised again in the Seanad on 2 May by way of amendment the Minister of State said, as reported in the Official Report of the Seanad, column 15, Volume 92:
The language is there, but it is out-of-date language. It has not been updated and consequently is meaningless to anybody who would wish to understand it, except lawyers....
We have an obligation to make Acts meaningful not only to the people who practise the law but the people who actually use the law in defence of their interests.
It is also a well-known matter of social justice that people in the capacity of private citizens are entitled to go to the courts without, dare I say it, the services of a solicitor or a barrister.
Consequently, to ensure that fundamental concept of social justice we have an obligation to make Bills in this House, which eventually become Acts, as meaningful as possible. I have no reason to change my views in relation to the use of the words "bona fide”.
If the Minister handling the Landlord and Tenant Bill, which is a very complicated piece of legislation, should speak as strongly as that against the use of the words "bona fide” because it is not clearly understood by the general public, why has this Minister chosen to use the words “bona fide” in a section where the unfortunate doctor and the person visiting him will both be obliged to interpret for themselves what “bona fide” means? If the Landlord and Tenant Act, which is normally interpreted by lawyers, has the words “bona fide” excluded from it because the Minister believed it to be a cliché in lawyers' jargon, why are we including those words in a Bill which is to determine the decisions to be made by doctors for their patients? I tried to raise that matter last night but I am afraid the Minister did not deal with it to my satisfaction. The main objection to section 4 is that it places a very unfair obligation on the doctor to decide which people should or should not have contraceptives made available to them.
Comment on this
For the benefit of Deputy Browne, or anybody else, it is the doctor who will decide what bona fide family planning purposes are, not having regard to his medical experience, because the Minister in subsection (2) set family planning purposes aside from adequate medical reasons.
Comment on this
Somebody else could be the family milkman, but that does not mean that he is any better qualified.
Comment on this
I am being absolutely serious. Apparently the association representing doctors did not see that it was appropriate that they should be asked to take on the business of being the moral arbiters or to take on a quasi-judicial role. Subsection (2) states that once the doctor issues the script and states on it that it is for the purposes of this Act, it shall be conclusively presumed that the person sought the contraceptive for bona fide purposes. Not only has the doctor to take on a moral role as an arbiter but he has to take on a quasi-judicial role as well and yet he is being asked to interpret words like “bona fide” which the Minister of State, Deputy David Andrews, a lawyer, felt should be excluded from other legislation because of the difficulty of interpretation.
The doctor is also being asked to define "family", a word which the House was not prepared to define. I have the same reservations as Deputy Browne in relation to the Minister's definition of "family". I would be satisfied with the definition given by the Minister on Wednesday, 9 May at column 282 of the Official Report except that earlier on the same day the Minister gave a completely different definition. I invited the Minister on two occasions to state that his later statement was appropriate rather than the earlier statement.
Comment on this
The earlier statement at column 175 of the report of the same date said:
I am convinced that there is a considerable majority of people in favour of making artifical contraceptives available to married persons. That is solely what we are legislating for in this Bill.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows that that was a slip of the tongue and that I meant to say "family" there. My approach has been consistent throughout the Bill. I have explained repeatedly that I did not use "married" because of the difficulties involved.
Comment on this
I accept that now. As the Bill goes on, that is the way the courts would interpret it. The Minister would have saved a lot of time this morning if he had said that.
Comment on this
In cross talk across the House the Deputy cannot blame me for using the word "married" on one occasion, when I meant "family".
Comment on this
At last we have clarified it and I accept the Minister's explanation. I would like the Minister to deal with some of the other points I raised especially in relation to his belief that this section would stand the test of the courts.
Comment on this
I have no doubt about that. The drafting of legislation is a skilled art. Neither Ministers nor their civil servants are involved in it but a skilled body of men called parliamentary draftsmen whose specific skill is used to devise legislation for us to draft.
Comment on this
Are these the same draftsmen who drafted amendment No. 17 so badly that the Minister had to amend it before it went through the House?
Comment on this
In these matters parliamentarians are entirely in the hands of the draftsmen. The phrase "bona fide family planning” is the phrase adopted for the purposes of this legislation by the draftsmen. I am quite satisfied that it achieves its purpose. It means genuine or valid and in neither legal terminology nor in common parlance is there a phrase which means more to the ordinary person than “bona fide”. I am not claiming any pride of authorship nor am I defending it except to say that it is the phrase which in the draftsman's skilled opinion he has deemed appropriate for this legislation.
I read the report of the majority decision of the Supreme Court again and again and right through that decision the sentiment, the direction keeps reappearing that married couples—here I am using the word "married" because that is the phrase that the Supreme Court used—have the constitutional right to artificial contraceptives. From that simple statement this legislation has evolved. I am convinced that the trend of the majority decision of the Supreme Court is that the availability of artificial contraceptives be confined to a husband and wife relationship or to married couples. The Supreme Court went to the trouble of specifically stating that they were not extending this right of availability to single persons. It is very significant that the Supreme Court did that. If the Supreme Court were leaving the thing completely open and were only deciding the issue in so far as a family, married couples, or a husband and wife were concerned it would have stopped at that. The Supreme Court did not stop at that. In the majority decision they went on to specifically indicate that they were not prepared to extend this constitutional right of availability to single persons.
We are all fallible. We can only do our best. However, I am reasonably convinced and advised that what we are proposing in this Bill is not alone in accordance with the decision of the Supreme Court but also in accordance with the spirit of the decision of the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court majority decision is based upon and evolves from the family Articles of the Constitution and therefore we, as parliamentarians, are obliged by the Supreme Court decision to make artificial contraceptives available to families for family planning purposes. I have sought in this legislation with all the advice and all the parliamentary drafting skill of the draftsmen to give effect to that and on that basis the Bill will stand up. If it does not we will have to try to legislate again. At least we have made a reasonable effort to legislate for what is a difficult complicated sensitive area.
I do not know that I can add any more to this argument. We have been over the ground again and again, we have taken every word and examined it minutely, we have discussed it and considered its implications. I maintain that if we accept that there is a constitutional obligation on Parliament to make artificial contraceptives easily available, reasonably accessible—that is all that is involved—to married couples, then everything else in this Bill follows in logical sequence. I do not have to say this to Deputy Boland but I have to say it to Deputy Browne. If you accept, on the one hand, that you have a constitutional obligation to make them reasonably available to married couples for family planning purposes, husband and wife relationship, and at the same time you do not want to make them completely and limitlessly available to the general public, then some mechanism and some arrangements such as are outlined in this Bill are the only logical alternative. I maintain that the arrangements I am outlining in this Bill to try to fit inside those two parameters are as good as you can devise.
Comment on this
I want to take up the point the Minister made in his last few words, which is the kernel of the matter. I know we have got to keep to section 4, but there are many points of view. Yesterday, when I asked Deputy Boland a certain question it was not with the intention that he attributed to me, but to bring out the broad spectrum. My view of the situation might not be very far away from Deputy Flanagan's in fundamentals but we have to follow the line of the Minister for two very coercive reasons, which apply particularly to section 4.
We have, as the Minister said, a choice of a free for all. The McGee case has resulted in the administrative necessity of bringing in control. The alternative is commercial exploitation, serious problems of public health and morality and the protection of young people. These are the consequences resulting from the administrative impact of the McGee case, which left everything wide open. It is on that fact that I believe Deputy Flanagan and I take different views in relation to this section. I take the Minister's view very strongly because I believe that this control must be brought in urgently before the situation deteriorates completely.
The second fact was discussed on Second Stage. It may arise on Fifth Stage but it would not be proper to discuss it now. I must mention it as a background. Section 3 is a necessary ingredient in this Bill because the McGee judgment was given. The absence of section 3 would substantiate Deputy Boland's argument about constitutionality. I do not believe that the Deputy would ask me to go into the constitutional argument with him. The Minister has answered it and there is no need for me to answer it again. With regard to constitutionality the Bill would not stand up without section 3. I am no more enamoured with some of the implications of the situation than Deputy Flanagan is but the choice is: "Will you sit back and do nothing and let the flood gates widen and have all the consequences?". It would be out of order to go into those details now.
Comment on this
I will be very brief on this. In all the arguments, constitutional and others, there has been little advertence to what I regard as the fundamental reasons why the doctor is the appropriate agent. I have already given them in detail. Whether contraceptive methods are drugs, intrauterine devices, surgery or even diaphragm, these are all matters for close medical supervision. It would be very difficult under any of those headings to supply any other answer than the one in section 4. They all have serious implications within the doctors' ambit. I believe, in tying it to the medical profession and the pharmaceutical profession, that the arguments I made on an earlier Stage in regard to that still hold and this is the basic reason why it is logical to adopt the mechanism the Minister is using.
The last point is one that has been insinuated into the argument on this section, that is, putting the onus on the doctor. Is it not just relying on the doctor as a responsible member of the community to use his judgment since it is so closely associated with his skill and with his profession? Where else can one go? There is an implication in the criticisms that have been made of referring this matter to the medical profession that the medical profession are not a group of responsible people who will particularly look to the human factors. I would like to make this point to Deputy Browne, who is a doctor. Are not the doctors the most likely people to be humanly and understandably sympathetic to their patients?
There has been sufficient time given to debate on this section without going into further detail. I wanted to say something, particularly to a Deputy like Deputy O.J. Flanagan, whose fundamental views and attitudes I would share more nearly than perhaps I do a lot of other views expressed in this House. Furthermore—and this relates somewhat to what happened here yesterday—there are many arguable and divergent views held and there are very substantial groups holding very different views in this community. We must take that as a fact also. My personal view is that we have got to do something; we cannot sit back negligently and let everything go by default. In all the circumstances the Minister's Bill, as he has justly claimed himself in his last remarks, is about the best solution to this very difficult problem facing our community with its diverse thinking and this House representing it. In all these circumstances, then, I urge that we take a reasonable view of the realities following the McGee case. Endeavouring to take that view I personally, as well as being a member of the party supporting the Minister, I feel that his solution is the best and that we should pass section 4.
Comment on this
Deputy Dr. Browne. Unless there are some new points to be raised at this stage the Chair must put the section. We cannot go on hour after hour repeating the arguments made and making Second Stage speeches.
Comment on this
I will deal only with the points referred to by the Minister in relation to the Constitution, but I think he gave the impression in some way that I was misleading the House in my references to the Constitution, the majority decision, and particularly Mr. Justice Walshe's magnificent and very moving defence of citizens' rights in our society. This is what genuinely amazes me about this provision for the introduction of the doctor in the decision-making process between married people for married people—of course, that is what is intended here—but even between any two mature people, any mature couple taking a decision about having children, whether they should have contraceptives or plan their family.
The general point made by the Minister is correct, of course, but he did not deal with it, I felt, completely frankly. Mr. Justice Walshe was dealing with the case put to him, that is the McGee case. That was a married lady looking for the right to use contraceptives. He came down categorically on her right as a married person. He did not deal with the rights of an individual, of a person as a citizen, because that is a separate question arising out of the rights of the individual under our Constitution. While it is true to say that Mr. Fitzgerald dissented in his judgment from the majority decision, in the course of his dissent, he made the statement to which I have referred already and which I have read into the record of the House. It is well to realise that the plantiff's claim here is as a citizen and that if any portion of section 17 of the 1935 Act is declared unconstitutional the benefits to be derived from such a decision are equally to be enjoyed by every other citizen be they married or not. That statement was not concerned with the McGee decision. It was the interpretation of the right of an individual under the Constitution. That is quite unequivocal and, it seems to me, unanswerable. It establishes beyond doubt that this section cannot be applied.
What is surprising—if the Minister has gone to the trouble of reading Mr. Justice Walshe's decision—is how on earth he could bring in a Bill of this kind in which he is insisting that an individual shall intervene in the decision-making when eloquent paragraph after eloquent paragraph makes the position quite clear, according to Mr. Justice Walshe. Incidentally he dealt also—something which might interest the other Deputies here who are insisting on the implementation of Catholic social teaching on the question of natural family planning methods—with the question of the pluralist nature of our society.
Comment on this
The Chair must intervene again. Deputy Browne is now making a Second Stage speech. We must adhere to the section before the House. If there are no new points to be made on it, I must put the section. That is the duty of the Chair. I cannot allow the debate to continue this way much longer. There is no reason why the Chair should permit repetition after repetition and Second Stage speeches. The Chair has a responsibility to the House.
Comment on this
I appreciate the Chair's dilemma but the position is that the Minister has referred to the majority decision.