Health (Family Planning) Bill, 1978: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 130–267 of 267. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 47 of 1978 ›
On a point of order, the Minister dealt with the constitutional argument only because it was put up by Deputies Browne and Boland, and I was asked to deal with it.
Comment on this
I accept that, and I allowed it, but all of this is completely out of order. I must put the section. I will allow Deputy Browne now to make his point and then I will put the section.
Comment on this
I shall make just two very brief references that I think will establish my point: the question of the outrageous nature of this proposal to introduce the doctor as the arbiter in family planning.
Comment on this
All right. Now I shall explain that the Supreme Court is on my side and I cannot see how the Minister could come in here and say that he has the backing of the Supreme Court or majority decision, which he said a few minutes ago, in defence of this. I am reading now from Mr. Justice Walshe's ruling:
It follows that the use of contraceptives by them within that marital privacy is equally guaranteed against such invasion and as such assumes the status of a right so guaranteed by the Constitution.
Mr. Justice Walshe continues:
The sexual life of a husband and wife is of necessity and by its nature an area of particular privacy. If the husband and wife decide to limit their family or to avoid having children by use of contraceptives it is a matter peculiarly within the joint decision of the husband and wife and one into which the State cannot intrude unless its intrusion can be justified by the exigencies of the common good.
And there is no such suggestion.
The one aspect which is very important from the point of view of Deputy de Valera's and Deputy Flanagan's point of view is that we live in a pluralist society from a religious point of view. Therefore Mr. Justice Walshe went on to point out that we have guarantees of religious freedom, freedom of conscience which are not confined to the different denominations of Christian religions but extend to other religious denominations and so on. There is another point which is important in relation to the importance given to natural law.
It is undoubtedly true that among those persons who are subject to a particular moral code no one has a right to be in breach of that moral code. But when this is a code governing private morality and where the breach of it is not one which injures the common good then it is not the State's business to intervene.
Comment on this
The Chair must again point out that all this was debated on Second Stage. It is not relevant to the section before the House. The Chair has to put the section at this stage.
Comment on this
This is the final paragraph:
There is no law in force in the State which prohibits use of contraceptives either in or outside of marriage or the manufacture or distribution of contraceptives within the State.
I accept that the majority decision of the Supreme Court referred to marriage strictly because that was the case put to them. The dissenting decision had nothing to do with the fact, Mr. Fitzgerald went on to say, that if the majority decision was a valid decision—and obviously it is—then it refers to everybody in this State.
Deputy Flanagan rose.
Comment on this
I am not denying you the right to speak as long as you raise a matter relevant to the section and which has not been raised previously.
Comment on this
I will take this opportunity to refer briefly to what has been said by other Deputies. This is the first time I made a contribution on section 4 and it is not my intention to delay the House. The Minister must be extremely anxious to put this Bill through the House and I realise the Chair is anxious that this section be dealt with quickly.
Comment on this
That is not the job of the Chair. If the debate on this section went on for a year the Chair would not have the power to do anything about it. The Chair must ensure that there is no repetition, or that a section is not being deliberately held up.
Comment on this
It is not my intention to repeat anything that has been said already. This section gives a person the right to obtain contraceptives. It says that:
(1) A person shall not sell contraceptives unless—
(a) the sale is in accordance with regulations for the purposes of this subsection relating to the sale of contraceptives,
And the prescription must be given solely for the purpose of family planning. A person who acts contrary to the regulation which is likely to be made under this section shall be guilty of an offence. I would not like to rush this section through without hearing what every Member has to say about it.
Deputy V. de Valera and the Minister referred to the Supreme Court decision on the McGee case which brought about this legislation and particularly this section, which is the principal section of the Bill. If the Supreme Court rule in a special case that a certain husband and wife have, or a wife has a legal right to obtain contraceptives, we are now told that we must change the law because of that decision. If a citizen feels she has a legal right to abortion, as Mrs. McGee felt she had a right to contraceptives, and as a result of the Supreme Court decision in her case we are now changing the law for everybody, we must bear in mind—and this is accepted by Catholics and Protestants—that contraception is morally wrong——
Comment on this
There are Protestants, particularly in Northern Ireland, who express indignation when we say that in order to bring about national unity we must change our laws in relation to contraception. A large proportion of Catholics and Protestants object to the provisions which this section will place on our Statute Book.
The Minister said, and Deputy de Valera agreed with him, that this Bill was introduced as a result of the Supreme Court decision. Does this mean that every time the Supreme Court give a decision on any matter pertaining to the family or the individual, irrespective. of the special or unusual circumstances of the case, legislation will be passed to give everyone the same legal rights as those given in the special case which was brought before the Supreme Court?
When this section is passed the groups which pressured the Minister into bringing in this section will say, "We have won the first part of the race and we will now proceed to pressure for the further opening of the floodgates to make contraceptives available". This Bill was introduced as a result of a Supreme Court decision. In the event of somebody claiming a legal right to abortion in special circumstances and the Supreme Court deciding in her favour, will we reach the stage when we will legalise abortion to meet the decision of the majority of the Supreme Court?
This House has the right to legislate independently of any outside views, and this is where section 4 comes in. If the Supreme Court or any other court has laid it down that the purchase, sale and making available of contraceptives is a legal right, have we not the right to legislate for the good of the majority? Must we put in section 4 of this Bill to please a small pressure group in a complete minority? Must we leave dangers for the majority in order to please the pressure group minority? That is the danger I see in section 4 of this Bill. This is a section giving teeth to the Bill. The valuable time of the House and the Minister is taken up with this section, simply because a small pressure group in a complete minority wishes to have legislation enacted in order to meet its point of view, to the detriment of the majority. I cannot contribute, by any means, to this section, bearing in mind that the whole question of the prescription, purchase, sale and the making available of contraceptives are morally wrong. This is the section which gives the right to do that and I strongly oppose it by every means in my power. No matter how we legislate, we cannot make right what is morally wrong and make available to any section of the public facilities which are morally wrong. No Act of Parliament passed by this House can do that.
Comment on this
The Minister has not dealt with my question. Perhaps Deputy de Valera would care to deal with the question I asked the Minister? How can this section stand against the ruling of the court—let us leave aside any other matter—that married couples are entitled to be allowed——
Comment on this
On a point of order, I want to state that the constitutionality or otherwise of this legislation may not be discussed on Committee Stage.
Comment on this
There is nothing arising on Committee Stage except what is on section 4. We are discussing all the principles of the Bill which were raised on Second Stage. I am sorry, the Chair will have to protest.
Comment on this
Section 4 is the kernel of the Bill. Are we going to be deprived of making points? So far I have spoken only once on this section.
Comment on this
The Chair is not depriving anybody of making points. The Chair is telling the Deputy, and every other Deputy, that all the points being raised have been raised a score of times already. The Chair must point that out.
Comment on this
Have we come to a new stage where the Chair is going to decide to cut Committee Stage short if he has become bored?
Comment on this
The Deputy will resume his seat at this stage. The Chair is not bored. The Chair is prepared to sit and hear the arguments all day. The Chair has a duty to the House to ensure that legislation is put through in a proper fashion, that there is not continual repetition of argument, as we have had already for the last four hours on this section. If the Deputy has any new points to raise, the Chair is prepared to allow him to so so. The Chair has no authority to prevent a discussion lasting as long as it will, or as long as it must, provided it is not repetition. We have had, on this matter, nothing but repetition for hours on end. We cannot have repetition; we cannot have Second Stage speeches and that is what we are having.
Comment on this
I am not making a Second Stage speech. I am making Committee Stage points and I have long enough experience in this and the other House to know the purpose of Committee Stage as well as any other Deputy. I will not be deprived of my rights.
Comment on this
I am not going to be deprived of my rights. When the Minister did not answer my question, I want to know if Deputy de Valera will deal with it. I will not be denied my rights.
Comment on this
I want to ask a question. I did not get an answer; perhaps Deputy de Valera will answer. How can this section be reconciled—this section which joins the doctor with the husband and wife in the decision whether or not the husband and wife should have artificial contraceptives made available to them? How can that be reconciled with the majority ruling in the McGee case? I accept the point made in relation to the importance of section 3 being in compliance with the McGee ruling. How can this section, joining the doctor with a married couple in the decision as to whether or not the married couple should have availability of contraceptives or not, be reconciled with the majority ruling of the McGee case? This is one question.
Comment on this
On the basis, very simply, of the need for control, having regard to all the circumstances which I mentioned before. Now, I do not want——
Comment on this
I have mentioned on a number of occasions that it is my view that the arrangements set out in this Bill are compatible with the constitutional majority decision of the Supreme Court. For Deputy Boland to ask that question is simply being illogical.
Comment on this
The next question I wish to ask is, suppose Deputy de Valera chose to import 100,000 gross of condoms and set up a stall in O'Connell Street to sell them as prophylactics——
Comment on this
——apart from the fact that he might be penalised for not having a street trader's licence—can anybody tell me what law he would be breaking, as the law stands or as the law will stand when this legislation is passed? If Deputy de Valera or any other Deputy chooses to sell them as prophylactics for the prevention of disease, what law would he be breaking?
Comment on this
It is my responsibility, as Minister, to pilot this legislation through the House and to deal with questions arising out of it. It is not any Minister's duty to deal with a hypothetical question which any particular Deputy asks.
Comment on this
The Chair is putting the question.
The question is: "That section 4, as amended, stand part of the Bill."
Deputies: Vótáil.
Comment on this
In the interest of endeavouring to make further progress may I suggest that the House adjourn for ten minutes so as to discuss, and possibly have reconsidered, the ruling of the Leas-Cheann Comhairle?
Comment on this
The Chair has no option but to accept the ruling of the Leas-Cheann Comhairle. A division has been called and I am putting the question. If the Deputy has any protest or complaint he may raise it afterwards.
Comment on this
I must make the point that we had not concluded the Committee Stage discussion on section 4. While I was on my feet and had been interrupted by the Minister the Leas-Cheann Comhairle chose to rise and put the question that section 4 be passed although the Committee Stage debate had not concluded. It raises very serious problems.
Comment on this
It is unusual to have a discussion just as I am about to put the question. The Leas-Cheann Comhairle has taken a decision; the division bells rang and I have come in to take the division and I have no option but to put the question.
Comment on this
I would ask the Chair to consider an adjournment of ten minutes to allow us to consider the matter.
Comment on this
There is no precedent for the action of closing a debate on Committee Stage with someone intervening in the middle of a sentence and the debate going on across the floor of the House. It is that lack of precedent that leads me to ask that there be a ten minute adjournment.
Comment on this
Deputy FitzGerald will appreciate that we cannot have a discussion on this at this time.
Comment on this
If the Deputy wishes to raise the matter afterwards he may. I must put the question.
Comment on this
At this stage in the proceedings of the House it is not in order to have a debate or to make speeches. I am not familiar with what the Deputies are talking about. All I know is that when I was in the Chair earlier section 4 was under discussion and was being discussed for a long time and indeed there was a bit of repetition to which the Leas-Cheann Comhairle possibly took exception.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): The only point I want to make is that there is only one way of putting a question that a section stand part of the Bill and that is if all debate has stopped or as a result of a motion that the question be now put.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): If the Minister wants the question put he must propose that the question be put and that was not done. The only other way it can be done is if the debate has finished.
Comment on this
The question is being put. The vote was called. It must have been challenged in the House; it could not have taken place unless it was challenged.
Comment on this
It was challenged by one Deputy. I am asking that, in order to enable amicable discussion to take place, we adjourn for ten minutes.
Comment on this
There is no precedent for a debate just as the Chair is about to put a question which has been challenged.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
Before the Ceann Comhairle leaves, would it be possible for him to take the Chair for a moment?
The Ceann Comhairle should be in the Chair for the statement I am about to make. I wish to give notice of my intention to move a vote of censure against the Leas-Cheann Comhairle in view of his handling of that vote and of the calling of the vote.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): On a point of order, might I ask for an interpretation for the guidance of the House for the rest of this Bill? I think I am right in thinking that the question can only be put when the debate has concluded on the amendment or on the section and if the Chair thinks, or the Government think, that it has been debated long enough a question must be put that the question be now put. There are only two ways of doing it. The Chair cannot decide himself that he is going to put the question in spite of the House and that is what was done in this case.
Comment on this
Might I direct the Chair's attention to a very serious matter unless Parliament is to be turned into a complete farce? I have been sitting here since 10.30 this morning. I have certain questions to ask on section 4 and I had been waiting for Deputy Boland——
Comment on this
Can we raise section 4 despite the fact that the division has taken place? We were not finished with it when the Leas-Cheann Comhairle decided to dispose of it.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): The Government may have 84 seats here but they do not have 84 seats in the country.
Comment on this
Lest any misstatements get abroad I want to say that I patiently answered every argument put up and every question put to me on section 4 all day yesterday and all day today.
Comment on this
I want to ask the Minister what was in his mind on this section and I do not think we can accept that the parliamentary draftsman is entirely responsible in this case. Section 5 (1) (a) provides that a person shall not import contraceptives into the State unless they are part of his personal luggage accompanying him when he is entering the State and their quantity is not such as to indicate that they are not solely for his own use. Possibly the draftsman may be responsible for some of the tortuous language employed in the paragraph but the Minister must have indicated what his requirement was in this area.
How on earth is the unfortunate customs officer to interpret what is a quantity of contraceptives which would indicate that they are not solely for the traveller's own use? Is the customs officer supposed to determine for himself on the basis of his own knowledge or experience what is an acceptable quantity for a person's own personal use? Does the Minister intend to issue regulations or guidelines giving some indication to the customs officials that quantity X would be deemed to be appropriate for a person's own personal use but quantity Y might not? Would the length of stay of the traveller in the country be taken into account vis-á-vis the amount of contraceptives he may or may not have in his personal luggage? Will the whole thing not be as farcical as the wording of paragraph (a)? Surely the Minister could have found something better, or nothing at all, rather than inserting that paragraph in that form at this time?
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
A recent survey indicted us as being the most hypocritical nation in Europe. They will be able to introduce a new category now of our being the most absurd and ridiculous nation in Europe when it becomes common knowledge amongst visitors to this country the kind of questions they will be asked about their very intimate and private and personal lives. A Frenchman, or a German, or a Dane, or an Englishman, or an American, coming into the country will have to suffer an inquisition by an unfortunate customs man about details of his private and marital relationship arising out of an investigation into the contraceptives he is attempting to bring into the State.
To me a contraceptive is simply an industrial product. A non-medical contraceptive is an industrial product and it is a matter for the IDA, if they so wish, to set up a factory to produce and sell them. Nothing more than that is involved. The Minister has not referred to the question of standards. Contraceptives coming into the State should be dealt with as ordinary industrial products. Tourists, visitors and businessmen coming into the State, and our fellow countrymen coming down from the North of Ireland, will find that this society——
Comment on this
On a point of order, may I draw the attention of the House to the fact that there is not a quorum present?
Comment on this
If the Chair cares to consult Standing Orders he will see that I do not have to ask for one.
Comment on this
May I draw the attention of the Chair to Standing Order No. 64:
If during a sitting of a Committee of the whole Dáil, other than while a private member's Bill is under consideration, a member calls the attention of the Chair to the fact that a quorum is not present, or if on the report of a division such fact shall appear, the division bells shall be rung...
Comment on this
All down the years the precedent of the House has been that a Deputy has asked for a quorum.
Comment on this
The precedent is that Deputies asked for a quorum. That is the way it has always been done. I take it the Deputy is asking for a quorum?
Comment on this
I take it the Chair will comply with Standing Order No. 64.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
I was dealing with the problem of the customs man at the point of entry to the State faced with implementing the provisions of section 5 in respect of visitors. It is well to remember that there are a number of different kinds of contraceptives starting with the pill of varying strengths, and then the IUD, the cap, the condom and the spermacides. Imagine the position of a customs officer faced with one or other or all of the different forms of contraceptives in a visitor's luggage. He has to decide whether the person is bound by this bona fide intention of family planning. He has to decide whether a traveller may bring them in and not use them bona fide and whether he is subject to our law. He has to ask whether he will use those contraceptives for the purposes of family planning. That is one question which obviously arises and which a stranger or a non-Irish person coming here will be asked.
Secondly, there is the Irish man or woman coming in here with one or more of these different devices who presumably as a national is subject to our law. What is the position of the customs officer faced with a multiplicity of these various devices in the bottom of the person's luggage? The customs officer is faced with a citizen and he has to decide what he will do. Does he ask the Irish national for his prescription authorising him to import them and in what amount, or to reimport them if he had them when he was going out and in what amount?
As Deputy Boland asked, how is the customs officer to decide? Taking the simplest device, the condom, what is a reasonable amount for a week's stay, a month's stay, six months' stay, a year's stay or an overnight stay? What is he to tell the foreign visitor who brings in a week's supply and may or may not stay for a fortnight? Must he tell the visitor: "Once you are in here you are subject to Irish law and you will have to go to a doctor for further prescriptions if you require them for contraceptives."? If a woman mislays her contraceptives will she have to accept the strictures of Irish law and go to a medical practitioner in order to be fitted with a new device rather than simply going and saying: "I want No. 5 or No. 6" or whatever it may be, or will she be treated as a foreign visitor and so allowed——
Comment on this
It is not really funny. It is pitiful.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
It is a total negation of the pluralist idea of true republicanism. We are talking of a couple from the Continent who during their stay here find it necessary to renew their supplies of contraceptives but neither he nor she can obtain supplies without going to a chemist and producing a prescription. Is the customs officer to tell him or her that this is the situation here? I am emphasising both him and her since both are involved. Are they to be told on arriving here that in order to obtain contraceptives they must go to a doctor for a prescription for which they must pay and then go to a chemist where they must also pay a fee in order to allow them to carry out this perfectly reasonable practice of indulging in effective family planning as they know it on the Continent?
In subsection (a) there is reference to the situation of contraceptives being part of a visitor's personal luggage but the reference is to "he". What is the position about a woman? Do we recognise that women come into this State from other places and that they may bring contraceptives with them? Are they to be permitted to bring in condoms or other contraceptives or do women exist at all in our male chauvinist muslim-type society? They do not appear to have any rights so far as this section is concerned.
Comment on this
So far as I can see customs officers are to be faced with the problem of attempting to decide whether the contraceptives in an individual's luggage are for the person's own use and whether the amount involved is reasonable. This will put customs officers in a dilemma comparable to the dilemma facing a doctor in terms of section 4 except infinitely more advanced. It is particularly absurd for us to treat contraceptives as if they were some kind of dangerous drug like cocaine, opium, pot or one of these which are alleged to be serious drugs. To treat contraceptives in the same way in regard to the supervision of their importation into the State is absurd. They are completely harmless. They are medicinal, as the Minister has made it clear on a number of occasions. They are most valuable to every society. They are accepted by the World Health Organisation and by EEC bodies involved in the question of family planning. It is obvious that if we leave section 5 in the Bill we are going to create an absurd dilemma which will bring about a laughable situation where Irish people are concerned in Europe. They are going to be subjected to this inquisition by these unhappy young customs officials who will not for the life of them be able to say whether the person they are talking to can say reasonably and truthfully that the number of contraceptives that he has in his baggage is the amount to which he has a right.
Comment on this
The Minister does not necessarily have priority over another speaker who may request first.
Comment on this
The Minister is usually called after a couple of speakers from the Opposition. I will call Deputy O'Connell afterwards.
Comment on this
Before the Deputy follows Deputy Boland and Deputy Browne in making a cod of himself, I tell the House that the position now is that the law at the moment is that anybody may import artificial contraceptives for his or her own use. Persons may not import them for sale, so this legislation does not change the situation that Deputies opposite seem so terribly worried and excited about. If the present situation upsets them, then they are objecting to legislating at all in this area. Apparently Deputy Browne is content to let the present situation continue, but the present situation is exactly as it is in this legislation.
Comment on this
At present as a result of the Supreme Court decision anybody coming into this country is entitled to import artificial contraceptives for his own personal use. He is not entitled to bring them in for sale. Therefore, this provision in section 5 does not change the situation.
It is quite simple to use that reductio ad absurdum argument to put forward a hypothetical proposition in regard to any legislation. Any legislation must be looked at reasonably and sensibly. This is a reasonable proposition. I can visualise clearly the ranting and raving by Deputy Browne and others if there was no provision in this legislation for a traveller coming into this country to bring in artificial contraceptives for his own use. Could you imagine the song and dance we would have about that? Just because I put in a simple, practical provision, Deputy Browne wastes the time of this House endeavouring to use reductio ad absurdum tactics to make it appear ridiculous. Customs officers are trained officials used to dealing with this sort of situation every day of their lives. They will have no difficulty whatever in administering this provision and they will administer it in a reasonable, sensible and mature fashion. It is a sensible, practical proposition. Apart from anything else, this is the situation that has prevailed for the past ten years since the Supreme Court judgment.
Comment on this
First, the Minister says that this has prevailed for the past ten years, but the contraceptives must be in the luggage accompanying the person. This is not the law as it stands, Secondly, this brings us into disrepute and holds us up to world ridicule in that we may now have to have notices displayed prominently at foreign ports to say that tourists coming into Ireland may not bring more into this country than a quantity sufficient for their own personal requirements. Who is to determine their personal requirements? Shall we now measure the sexual prowess of an individual? Shall we measure his virility? Shall we have blood tests of his serum and antigens? Shall the person have in attendance there a doctor or medical consultant to advise him——
Comment on this
It holds us up to public ridicule. Any legislation that we are attempting to pass in this House must be sensible legislation that can be enforced and which should not hold us up as a nation to public ridicule among other nations of the world.
Comment on this
I did not think that the Minister would start interrupting me. I did not intervene in this debate at much length because I feel there are more pressing issues.
Comment on this
This should have been submitted to a Select Committee of the House so that this House can proceed with more important legislation. I am of that opinion and I am sorry to say that, but now that the Bill is here and not before a Select Committee of the House, this section creates a problem because we are now giving customs officers arbitrary power which they do not want.
Comment on this
Not in so far as they deploy it. I would be glad if the Minister would correct me if I am wrong, but as I understand it, at present it is not stated that contraceptives must be part of the personal luggage accompanying a person coming into this country. When we come in with this luggage must they be declared? Must we go with them into the green or the red zone? These questions must be faced by everyone who may bring them into the country. I am not trying to take this jokingly. I am talking seriously about a problem that may confront a customs officer.