We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE of PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Special Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General.

Contributions 1–179 of 354. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

We are here to deal with the 1999 Annual Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General and the Appropriation Accounts, Vote 34, Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment. We are also dealing with a special report of the Comptroller and Auditor General on the prompt payment of accounts.

The attention of witnesses is drawn to the fact that as and from 2 August 1998, section 10 of the Committees of the Houses of the Oireachtas (Compellability, Privileges and Immunities of Witnesses) Act, 1997, grants certain rights to persons who are identified in the course of the committee's proceedings. These rights include the right to give evidence, the right to produce or send documents to the committee, the right to appear before the committee either in person or through a representative, the right to make a written and oral submission, the right to request the committee to direct the attendance of witnesses and the production of documents and the right to cross-examine witnesses. For the most part, these rights may be exercised only with the consent of the committee.

I want, first, to welcome Mr. Billy Bell, MLA, Chairman of the Northern Ireland Public Accounts Committee and his colleagues, Ms Sue Ramsey, vice-chairman of the committee, John Dallat, MLA, Séamus Close, MLA, and Donovan McClelland, MLA. I welcome also the Comptroller and Auditor General of Northern Ireland, Mr. John Dowdall, the Clerk of the Committee, Mr. Michael Rickard, and the Deputy Clerk, Mr. Joe Campbell. We are very honoured by your attendance, you are most welcome.

I ask the Comptroller and Auditor General to introduce the Vote and the special report, which we will take together.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

There is no report on the Vote proper. I draw the attention of the committee to the effects of the buoyant economy on the outturn of the Vote. Allocations under several subheads were underspent because of the lack of provision for an expected level of training of unemployed people. Most significantly, there was a saving of £18 million on grants to industry through Enterprise Ireland. It is explained on page 263 that very little expenditure was incurred under the new Community Enterprise Centre Programme owing to the capital nature of the projects involved, which require a certain lead-in time between approval and draw-down of grant. That is all I have to draw the attention of the committee to on the Vote proper.

As suggested, I will introduce my special report. The report before the committee this morning sets out the results of an examination into how public bodies within my audit remit coped with the requirements of the Prompt Payment of Accounts Act, 1997. It also deals with the main issues which had to be addressed in implementing the legislation, together with reporting and auditing considerations. The origins of the Act lie in the volume of complaints from the private sector that public bodies were tardy in making payments on foot of goods and services supplied and that the excessive delays lead to cash flow and other difficulties for suppliers, particularly small businesses. A study was carried out in 1997 which confirmed that there was a significant problem. The Act came into effect at the start of 1998, with the aim of reducing the level of late payments made by public sector purchasers by requiring them to pay their suppliers within a specified time or to pay penalty interest if they did not. Essentially payment to suppliers must be made within the period specified in the contract or, where there is no contract, within 45 days. Clearly special conditions have to apply in cases of disputed invoices, receipt of goods and so on.

The evidence available from my audits, supported by feedback from the organisations representing suppliers, indicates that for the most part public sector bodies paid the vast bulk of their bills on time in 1998 and again in 1999. While this improvement is to be welcomed, it masks a number of problem areas which the examination brought to light. Some organisations have not put systems in place which would enable them to comply with the legislation. Although this criticism applies across the State, semi-State, health and education sectors, it was most prevalent in the vocational education committees where it was the rule rather than the exception. Clearly if there is no system that enables organisations to identify the dates on which invoices are received, they will not be in a position to know whether there is a liability for interest when making payment.

We found that some organisations adopted the practice of not paying small amounts of interest, for administrative efficiency purposes. We are talking about amounts between £1 and £10. While on the face of it this seems like a reasonable approach, it is not in conformity with the Act and legal advice confirmed that this was the position. It appears that amending legislation would be required to give legitimacy to the practice. The matter is likely to be resolved when Irish legislation is amended to give effect to an EU directive on prompt payments which is due to be implemented in Ireland in 2002. The directive allows a threshold of five euros for interest payment purposes. There were other aspects of the legislation where legal assistance on interpretation was needed, principally, how one defines a supplier and whether a foreign supplier should be covered by the Act or whether interdepartmental transactions would be covered by the Act. There was also the possible use of contract periods as a means of circumventing the Act. The Department will need to clarify the position in these areas to organisations where it has not already done so.

The Act provides that organisations should report annually on their payment practices and on the timeliness of payments, either by way of an insertion in its annual report or by way of a report to the Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Employment who in turn is required to present any such report to the Houses of the Oireachtas. The reporting aspect of the arrangements was weak. The information in the reports did not meet what was specified by the Department, many organisations omitted to send in their reports and those that were submitted tended, in general, to be late. The lack of diligence on the reporting side means that suppliers and potential suppliers are not informed about the payment performance of public sector purchasers. The Department could have been more proactive in its monitoring of the reporting arrangements.

While the Act has been instrumental in improving the payment performance of public sector bodies, there is much tidying up to be done before the EU directive comes into force in Ireland in 2002.

Comment on this

I welcome Mr. Paul Haran, Secretary General of the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment. Perhaps Mr. Haran will introduce his colleagues.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

I am accompanied by Ms Pat Lynch from the finance unit, who helped me in the accumulation and assembly of the brief, Michael McKenna, the new head of corporate services in the Department, Ronnie Sheehan, our finance officer, and Paul Cullen, our recently appointed attaché to Brussels who is the expert on the prompt payments legislation.

Comment on this

Mr. Dermot Quigley is from the Department of Finance.

Comment on this
Mr. Quigley

I am accompanied by Mr. Adrian Finneran and Mr. Alan Zambra.

Comment on this

You are welcome. There are also other observers from the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment. They are Mr. Bill Roe, Mr. Gerry Murphy, Mr. Turlough O'Molloy and Ms Catherine Carroll. Mr. Haran, do you wish to start by making a brief statement to the committee?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

I can discuss either the prompt payments or the general report.

Comment on this

I would like you to make your points on the Vote and then discuss the prompt payments, in that order.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

On the Vote, the Comptroller and Auditor General is correct that the buoyant economy has helped on the overall outturn. A lot of effort over the years has gone into addressing the unemployment problem and trying to help people to get back into employment. There have been some individual savings as well on certain subheads, some of them caused by buoyancy, others caused by late or slow draw-downs from particular areas where it is difficult to anticipate the precise outturns that might be required. Supplementary Estimates generally address those but in IDA Ireland we had a supplementary estimate to reduce the overall Vote in that area. Similarly, in Enterprise Ireland there were delays in drawing down certain funds.

On the special report on prompt payments, the Comptroller and Auditor General's report is very useful to us in trying to review our current policy but, more importantly, in helping us to decide how to address the implementation of the EU directive which will extend to the general community the rules, obligations and practices of prompt payment. The Comptroller and Auditor General is right to draw our attention to deficiencies in the reporting structure. However, we feel the way we will address this might require changes in the design of the Act, in sections 12 and 13.

Fundamentally, we feel we should protect small suppliers from large purchasers. The State is a very dominant purchaser in the economy and it has a lot of power. The position for very small companies supplying to the State was one of weakness and it was important to introduce this Act to protect them. The Act has helped to improve the practice of payment in society. There is a 45 day rule in the Act. The EU legislation will reduce this to 30 days, which is similar to the rule in the UK, and it will expand it to all suppliers within the State. For that reason, we will have to consider how best to ensure its practice. We are looking to the review group on auditing and the proposals it has about looking at positive statements of compliance from auditors about practices within organisations.

We feel strongly that the de minimus rule is needed. The Comptroller and Auditor General is right that the Act does not allow for de minimus thresholds at the moment but clearly the de minimus rule, for administrative convenience and efficiency, probably is needed and we would intend to apply that to the Act. Then we need a way of periodically reporting on what payment practice is within our society, not only by the State but in the wider society. That is where the Department is coming from with this Act. In the UK, private sector credit agencies usually provide information about average payments and look at various large purchasers. Maybe we can encourage such an outcome when we move forward. Alternatively, the Department might need to sponsor or fund periodic statements and surveys of payment practice within the various organisations both in the State sector and outside it.

One of the defects of the Act was that it allows reporting on payment practice to be done by one of two means, either through the annual reports of organisations or to be sent into the Department where we batch them and publish them through the Dáil. It is a very ill-focused and ill co-ordinated system of reporting on the practice of payments and clearly we will need a new mechanism. We have written to all the Departments to find out from them which of their agencies use 12.1 or 12.2, in other words, their annual report or other reports as the means of promulgating information. I accept it is not an adequate mechanism so we have to find new mechanisms. We hope to find these in the context of legislation that will be used to implement the EU directive.

With regard to legal interpretation, the Comptroller and Auditor General is right that there have been differences of legal opinion in a number of areas. He has suggested to us that we go to Government to confirm the relationship of transactions between State companies. We have been reluctant to do this because we are getting legal advice which says our interpretation is correct. However, from an effectiveness point of view and to be sure, as it were, we intend to go to Government and seek its approval to confirm the nature of transactions between Departments.

Comment on this

When the person carrying out the audit establishes that there is late payment, what is the sequence of events? What happens and who is held responsible? What is done to put the situation contained in the report right?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

With regard to the mechanisms that are needed, large organisations that do a lot of purchasing need to have automated systems of invoice management and payment. Manual systems are difficult to use to ensure the application of the Act. When an invoice is sent in, it is stamped. The clock starts ticking with the date of the invoice. Take a case where there is no contract that says one can be late or the contract does not have particular provisions to enable the date to be extended. The payment systems should highlight when one goes past 45 days and automatically credit to the supplier, in the cheque or in an additional cheque, a payment for the late interest with a statement showing how the interest payment is calculated. The essence of this is that it should not be the responsibility of the supplier, usually a small business, to seek payment of the late payment and interest. It should be an automatic activity that is triggered.

The Comptroller and Auditor General's office does a special audit, a section 13 audit, to ensure compliance with this. The Department also compiles certain information in a section 12 report which should outline the extent to which late payments are being made and to identify whether late payments are becoming a problem.

The Comptroller and Auditor General has stated that he will give a note in regard to an account where certain thresholds are exceeded as a means of trying to ensure that best practice is promulgated within Departments. Best practice ultimately means that you pay on time and quickly, rather than that you conform with legislation and pay the interest. It would be desirable that we would not have to pay interest.

Comment on this

The Comptroller and Auditor General's report suggested, if I read that section correctly, that there was difficulty in establishing the actual sequence of events regarding the payments. In other words, in many cases the records did not show how late they were or the date of payment. Did Mr. Haran find any difficulty with that?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

We, even in our own Department, had difficulties at a very early stage in the implementation of this in the absence of good automated systems and recording systems. At the heart of this is automation, ensuring when the goods and invoices arrive that one captures the date, that the trigger is started and the system is automated. In the early application of the Act, I know that there were difficulties in certain organisations about the degree to which automation was used and the proper practice in organisations to ensure that they date stamped invoices and that the invoices and the goods arrival were properly captured.

Comment on this

In the report it would appear that there was some difficulty with the interpretation of section 13 of the Act. Will Mr. Haran comment on that? Does he think that it could, for example, require amendment?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

On section 13, the issue is really about the role of the auditors. There is an issue about grouping the section 13 and 12 reports and there is an issue about the views of external accounts regarding their onus of responsibility in determining the efficacy of the practice within the organisation which they are auditing. We are now looking to rectify this through the response to the auditing review group so that we would look towards having the section 13 aspect of it captured within a positive statement by the auditor about the compliance and the directors are happy that they have mechanisms in place to ensure compliance with a variety of statutes, one of which would be that regarding prompt payments.

Comment on this

I know it is not Mr. Haran's responsibility to write legislation, but will he recommend to the committee that that section or sections be amended?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

Yes. We feel that this should be done. We accept the Comptroller and Auditor General's comments also and we accept the committee's recommendation that we need to address this area.

Comment on this

Chairman, we could consider making that recommendation to the relevant Ministers.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

On the Vote, section 13, commissions and inquiries, over the past year or two the Department has been vigorous in relation to certain inquiries, particularly into the 120 alleged Ansbacher account holders, who in the main are prominent businessmen. The cost of these inquiries does not appear to be reflected in that. I would have thought there would have been a much higher cost. In 1996, £36,000 was spent on company law inquiries in general and the Faxhill Homes ones, which I presume relate to the Ben Dunne issue and Deputy Lowry etc., is costed at £135,000. Where is the cost shown for the other substantive inquiries which have arisen out of the public tribunals?

Comment on this

It is on page 268, commissions and inquiries.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I was wondering why it is separated. I am sure the Secretary General would have a view on this and perhaps he would give us a progress report on them because that seems to be a rather low cost for the amount of activity which is involved in these inquiries.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

The Deputy is right. There are differences in the costings of the different types of report and the essential driver of the ultimate cost is whether these reports are, first, under the aegis of the Department or the court.

The section 8 reports under way are those of High Court inspectors. High Court inspectors are external individuals appointed by the court at the application of the Minister but not determined by the Minister. They are court costs and they will ultimately be borne by the Vote of the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform. My Department is very active in the negotiation and the committee previously commented upon the application of the costs in these areas.

The current section 8 inquires would be, first, the National Irish Bank financial services and, second, the Ansbacher report. As the Deputy will be aware, there are judges involved in both of these, augmented by other inspectors of a professional nature.

The section 19 reports are ones which are normally done within the Department, although sometimes these also are contracted out because of resource issues. We have five section 19 reports currently under way and they are being carried out by the authorised officer, Mr. Gerry Ryan, who is a departmental accountant.

Comment on this

On what are those five reports?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

The section 19 reports are: the Celtic Helicopters report which is ongoing, the Guinness & Mahon report which is ongoing——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

About what is that one?

Comment on this

Let us get the list first.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

There is the Hamilton Ross report which is ongoing, the Kenford Securities report and the College Trusts Limited report.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Will Mr. Haran jog our memory regarding those reports?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

The Celtic Helicopters report is separate. The other reports are of financial structures where information came to light arising from the earlier reports such as the Ansbacher report. They are follow-on reports.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Are they tail-off reports?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

Yes. They are reports where information emerged which required investigation.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I hope Mr. Haran does not mind me ticking them off as we go through them. The Celtic Helicopters report is self-explanatory. What is the substantive issue in the Guinness & Mahon report——

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

It would be improper for me to state anything other than that they are reports where information came to mind about activities——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

——and structures and an organisation within the bank or whatever. What about these names such as Hamilton Ross?

Comment on this

What is the background to each of these reports?

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

That is what I am trying to establish, Chairman. What about Hamilton Ross?

Comment on this

The Deputy asked the question and interrupted the reply.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I apologise.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

As the committee will be aware, the Tánaiste initiated certain studies, shortly after coming to office, in the areas of Celtic Helicopters, Garuda, Ansbacher Cayman and Guinness & Mahon. Following from these reports, certain information came to light which prompted her to seek to have section 19 investigations and authorised officers appointed to other legal entities. These investigations have been prompted by the Tánaiste and they are under way at present. It would be prejudicial of me to identify particular aspects of activities in any of these entities.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Mr. Haran can speak generally.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

The Tánaiste felt that there were matters which came to attention which raised issues of concern and required further investigation, which is what a section 19 investigation is. A section 19 investigation is a fact-finding activity.

Comment on this

In which Act is section 19 contained?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

It is section 19 of the Companies Acts, as amended in 1991.

Comment on this

Mr. Haran, you have listed seven inquiries. Will you state the commencement date of each of those seven inquiries, starting with the NIB inquiry?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

Yes. The date of the Celtic Helicopters inquiry was 9 September 1997. Garuda, which has concluded, was also on the same date. That has been concluded and referred to——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

It is not ongoing.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

No. Does the Chairman want the ongoing ones?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

The Guinness & Mahon report commenced on 8 January 1998. The Hamilton Ross Company Limited report commenced on 23 January 1998. If the Chairman wishes to have the section 8 ones included, the National Irish Bank Limited report was commenced on 30 March 1998. As the Chairman knows, that is under the High Court.

Comment on this

On 13 March?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

No, 30 March 1998. The reasons for that would have been announced in the court in the affidavit that was presented to it. The Kenford Securities Limited report commenced on 9 June 1998.

Comment on this

That is a section 8 one as well?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

That is a section 19. National Irish Bank Financial Services was a linked one with National Irish Bank and that commenced on 15 June 1998. That was a section 8 report. That was in the courts. There are two section 19 reports relating to Dunnes Stores which are delayed by court actions. We have been to the High Court twice and the Supreme Court once on them.

Comment on this

I want the commencement dates of all the inquiries and then a progress report. There are two Dunnes Stores inquiries?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

The two Dunnes Stores reports commenced on 22 July 1998. The section 19 report regarding the College of Trustees commenced on 10 March 1999. Its status is that it is still ongoing. The Ansbacher Cayman Limited section 8 report started on 22 September 1999 and that is ongoing.

Comment on this

Are there any others?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

No.

Comment on this

The section 8 NIB report started in March 1999. The section 8 Ansbacher report started in September 1999 while the Celtic Helicopters report started on 9 September 1997. Is that a section 19 inquiry?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

Celtic Helicopters?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

That is a section 19 report.

Comment on this

Under which section is the Guinness & Mahon report which started on 8 January 1998?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

The Guinness & Mahon section 19 report started on 8 January 1998.

Comment on this

Under which section is the Hamilton Ross report which started on 23 January 1998?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

That is under section 19.

Comment on this

The Kenford Securities report under section 19 started on 9 June 1998 while the College Trustees report is under section 19. The Garuda inquiry is completed. What is the position regarding the Ansbacher inquiry?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

The section 8 report into Ansbacher Cayman Limited started on 22 September 1999. The High Court orders took place——

Comment on this

Is that inquiry under section 19?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

That is a section 8 report.

Comment on this

The section 8 report into National Irish Bank Financial Services started on 15 June 1998.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

That is correct.

Comment on this

The two Dunnes Stores inquiries started on 22 July 1998.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

That is correct.

Comment on this

They have been delayed by court action.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

For the convenience of some members who are curious about these companies, I wish to concentrate on the section 19 inquiries because they are germane to this committee. They are ongoing investigations and taxpayers' money was clearly involved. While the Ansbacher Cayman Limited inquiry might be more interesting, it is in the theatre of the courts. Will Mr. Haran remind the committee to what Hamilton Ross, Kenford Securities and College Trustees relate? I appreciate he cannot prejudice the outcome of the inquiries, but will he remind us of their origin?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

The origin of these reports is information that came to light following other investigations that were under way that required investigation. The Tánaiste decided they required investigation.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Was that as a result of information that came into the public domain via the tribunals?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

Not into the public domain. This was as a result of information that came into the Tánaiste's province from other inquiries that were initiated originally from information that might have come out of tribunals. It originally stemmed from that, but some of these investigations were spawned or initiated following from information that came from the other section 19 inquiries that I mentioned, some of which have now concluded.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

The provenance of the Celtic Helicopter and Guinness & Mahon inquiries is clear. What is the position regarding the Hamilton Ross inquiry? Our memories of the names on this side of the House are not too good generally so perhaps Mr. Haran could remind us.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

The names generally would not be in the public domain. They are not household names.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

We have heard of College Trustees in some context in the tribunals. Perhaps my memory is serving me badly, but with what was College Trustees associated? Can Mr. Haran identify parent companies?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

I find it particularly difficult to answer what companies are associated with because——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

These are matters of public record.

Comment on this

The Deputy should allow the Secretary General reply to the questions.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

In so far as the question might mean why we are investigating one particular aspect of it, I would find difficulty. College Trustees is a corporate structure, I believe, involved in banking activity. I do not have details of all these companies with me at the meeting. The Tánaiste has answered many parliamentary questions about these in the House.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

The corporate structure is publicly known.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

That is right.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

We can all go down to the Companies Office and find out those.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

That is right.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Guinness & Mahon is banking while Celtic Helicopters is aviation.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

All these——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Is College Trustees also involved in banking?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

As I understand it, all these are corporate structures used for banking activity.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

All of them?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

All of them, apart from Celtic Helicopters which we know is different.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

The genesis of these is information supplied or arriving on the desk of the Tánaiste and the Department.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

Usually the authorised officer. That is where the information usually comes to us from.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Yes. The section 19 device is, of its nature, fact finding.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

It is fact finding. It is trying to establish whether there is a basis to do other activities. The authorised officer has a lot of power and there are a lot of protections in place as well to prevent the section 19 reports ever being published. There is a balance of rights and responsibilities for the Tánaiste and the Tánaiste's officers. Much information can be gleaned from a section 19 and frequently we will use the section 19 to seek a section 8, which would be a High Court inspectorate and more public domain——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

They are initiated by the Minister in his or her own right.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

A section 19 would be initiated by the Minister.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

This matter will recur for this committee. How do we evaluate the cost? Is there a time duration? How do we evaluate whether the taxpayer is getting value for money in what is essentially an information trawling exercise as the Secretary General described it?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

Fact and information gathering.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Fact finding.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

The type of thing one might consider is, for example, the section 19 report on Faxhill Homes.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

That is completed.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

Yes. That was done by the private sector and that is why the cost for that one is there.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

There was an authorised officer and the cost was £135,000.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

Yes. An external officer was appointed to do that and deal with people.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Is that the famous case of Ben Dunne and the conversion to the home in Tipperary?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

I understand legal activities are taking place at present on some of these issues.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Yes. What was the duration of that outsourcing? It cost £135,000 over how long a period?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

It was created on 22 July and it reported to the Tánaiste on 21 December 1998.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

How many people were involved in the staff of the inquiry?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

I do not have the taxed costs of it. I do not have the breakdown or the working papers of the costings that came in. The cost was £143,000 of which £89,000 was paid in 1999. However, other authorised officers of the company would also have been involved in doing the work. Frequently, there is recourse to legal advice which can be quite expensive.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

That is all included in that?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

That was all included. In our ones, where we get the Attorney General's advice, it is not included as a direct cost.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

That is a section 19?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

Yes. In our own section 19 reports, it is the officer's own time.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Could one expect a cost of £135,000 each for the reports into Kenford Securities Limited, College Trustees, Hamilton Ross, Guinness & Mahon and Celtic Helicopters?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

No.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

In other words, does one multiply the cost by five?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

We are doing these internally so we are achieving a great cost saving by having an authorised officer, an accountant in the Department, augmented by two other accountants. We use the Attorney General's advice and external advice when necessary. Doing section 19 inquiries within the Department is an extremely cost effective mechanism of achieving a section 19 report. The original Ansbacher one that created the section 8 inquiry was done by the same team as was the Geruda investigation.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Was Mr. Haran's expectation that the cost would be halved per individual and it would cost £50,000 or £60,000 each?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

It is very difficult to compare individual supports.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

It is complex.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

Sometimes one has to do a section 19 report on a very small financial structure that is used to carry out a number of transactions. The company structure could be very small and one might only be doing a study to look at a small number of transactions going through it. A study into such a company might be a small activity and relatively inexpensive.

If one had to do one on another corporate structure, say, on Dunnes Stores, that could be an enormously expensive activity from a time point of view. We feel strongly that by doing it within the Department we save a lot of money. Some of these are related companies so by having the one officer do them we are getting very good value for money.

Comment on this

When are we likely to get results? Some of these have been going for three and a half years.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I am concerned about the time element in all five investigations. Is there a timeframe?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

The Tánaiste in Dáil PQs on Tuesday said that she expected to get some of these reports quite soon. I believe she was expecting those on Kenford Securities and Hamilton and Ross soon. I hope later in the year we will get the other three, Celtic Helicopters, College Trustees and Guinness & Mahon. We cannot determine when the sections 8 inquiries which are in the courts will arrive. As the Tánaiste said, in the first half of this year she hopes to get the National Irish Bank ones. As the committee will be aware, we have had a change in one of the inspectors into the Ansbacher Cayman section 8 inquiry and two inspectors added.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Will Mr. Haran itemise, when he has time, the internal savings he claims can be achieved through an internal rather than external investigative process? It would be helpful for comparative purposes.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

It would be very difficult to come down with a hard number on it. It is the cost of an accountant in the public sector. I can give the Deputy costs like that. An external accountant is a multiple of an internal accountant. Similarly, an external barrister is a multiple of AG advice. The Comptroller and Auditor General's accountants are also much cheaper than those of an auditor but it would be a multiple.

Second, the other benefit I am getting is that when we use our accountant like Gerry Ryan and his team we are talking about people who have developed a level of expertise and a familiarity with individual cases which give a lot of savings. However, it creates a huge strain on individuals and it is a long time for people to work on single projects. They have delivered some of the outputs and have concluded some of the cases they have undertaken.

Comment on this

Can the Secretary General assure the committee there is no avoidable delay in these cases? For example, why has the Celtic Helicopters investigation taken three and a half years?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

I cannot go into the detail of the individual cases but I can tell you the types of events that can lead to a delay. I do not know what the current delay is in Celtic Helicopters. In an investigation under section 19, one hits a road block when one finds a new corporate structure being used to carry out a certain transaction. I am only giving a generic example. One finds a corporate structure that was used to carry out a number of transactions. The authorised officer has no right to inquire into that structure and look behind those transactions. What then happens is that one might seek to go to the Minister in charge and say "I have got information that points to certain activities that need to be investigated" and one then creates a new section 19 into that corporate structure. Only when that is completed can one then go on and complete the original one that led to it being opened. One closes that case before one closes the original case that led to it being opened. That can happen.

Comment on this

Are you saying that in some cases those who are the subject of an inquiry can frustrate the law and the inquiry?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

We are usually looking back at an event. People can, to protect themselves against the prying eyes of our officers, create structures that are labyrinthine and require us to go after each one in a serial fashion. As you know, amendments to company law have been promulgated and are being discussed on Committee Stage at the moment creating the Office of Director of Corporate Enforcement where enhanced powers will be in existence maybe to give us a speedier and more streamlined way of dealing with these types of activities.

I would not like to detract from the strong work and the extraordinary amount of fact-finding that has been achieved by the authorised officer who clearly convinced the courts when they appointed the section 8 inspectors into the Ansbacher accounts.

Comment on this

Can you assure the committee that there is no avoidable delay in any of these cases?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

Yes, I can assure the committee.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Mr. Haran cannot expand on the individual cases but he referred to labyrinthine company structures. The purpose of a section 19 investigation is to establish facts——

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

That is right

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

——not breaches of the law in relation to corporate structures that may be labyrinthine and complicated and also structured in such a way as to cumulatively amount to an abuse.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

As well as facts in relation to circumstances suggesting there have been abuses. One might find out that certain things were done in a certain fashion and were clearly wrong. Section 19 gives limited powers to come along with a determination but one may come along with a determination that there is a lot more investigation required because certain transactions or processes occurred which lead one to this conclusion. One convinces a court to appoint a section 8 inspector.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

One can conclude that the common pattern in all investigations - Celtic Helicopters, Guinness & Mahon, Hamilton Ross, Kenford Securities and College Trustees - is not an illegality but a company structure or a cumulative series of overlapping structures that is connected to an abuse.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

I would like to emphasise that the structure can be something that inhibits and elongates the time required to do a section 19 investigation. Section 19 usually looks into whether there is a reason to look towards appointing a section 8. One is not only looking at structures, one is looking at activities undertaken within individual companies. The structures can lead to the need to create further section 19 investigations.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Facts are established to ascertain bona fides or mala fides in the structures and activities of companies.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

If something requires deeper investigation where powers of subpoena are required, cross-examination and, therefore, a High Court inspector is needed to do it.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

How many legal challenges have there been in these five investigations by directors and executives of these companies?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

To the best of my recollection none of these five has been challenged.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

The delay cannot be attributed to legal challenges?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

At times one might get a shake of a bush but that does not amount to a challenge. Sometime one has difficulties when one asks people individual questions. One might not get the response that one requires. We had legal activity in the Cayman Islands in relation to one of them, as the Deputy knows, but that was an isolated set of events where we were in the Caymans.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

In general the delay cannot be attributable to legal challenge, in other words, people seeking to legally defend themselves in a robust manner against the Department's prying eyes.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

The delay in the Dunnes one is the only one where we have been stopped by legal challenge.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Are the executives of the other five companies fully co-operating with the letter and spirit of the law and not using the law to obstruct?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

I do not know the detail of each of these reports and what goes on. We actually gave the authorised officer the responsibility and the authorised officer is given a huge amount of discretion. There is not a huge difference between my supervision of the authorised officer and how we would have supervised the external authorised officer. They have safes and locked rooms and we have a lot of security and protection for them. Their reports are numbered and only go to one or two people. We regard this as a highly sensitive and confidential activity. I do not know the detail of what the authorised officer is doing. To the extent I gave the Chairman assurances about delays, I hope it is understood that I am not supervising the day to day work. I could not and I would not do so.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Given the sensitivity of what is being investigated, the references to safes and locked rooms and the need to know basis of these inquiries, I trust Mr. Haran understands our concern——

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

Of course I do.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

——that, while we know they work pro bono and for the public good, we, and Mr. Haran as Accounting Officer, need to be able to ensure that these authorised officers do not indulge in some type of detective fantasy at the taxpayers’ expense.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

I accept that. As a justification, the Ansbacher Cayman work he did created an extraordinary response. It was a tremendous piece of work and the quality of it convinced the courts that it was proper to proceed and to appoint a section 8. There is a high onus of responsibility to prove to the court that this is reasonable. As the Deputy will know, the court is one of the few bodies to see the report. I do not remember who else will have seen it.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I know Mr. Haran does not supervise the authorised officer's day to day investigations and inquiries which are highly sensitive and confidential, but does he demand a periodic assessment of what the officer does and whether it is worthwhile to continue with it? In a normal office, if a person is appointed to inquire into a problem in the company, he or she is normally given a time limit or a date by which he or she is asked, for example, if the company should go to court.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

We do on the section 19 inquiries. I have had review meetings with the Tánaiste and the authorised officer on a number of occasions and have asked about progress, what can be done to speed them up, whether there was a resource issue and if we could augment resources in certain circumstances.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Some of these investigations can last for three years. How often would Mr. Haran, the Tánaiste and the authorised officer meet to try to speed up matters or allocate additional resources?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

It is not only about speeding up or resources, it is about a number of elements. It would not always be myself and the Tánaiste. Frequently the authorised officer would be reporting privately to the Tánaiste. That is a very useful device. I would meet the authorised officer, who is in my own building, a few times every month.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Would it be specifically about these investigations?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

Yes, and how work is going, what needs to be done, on specific policy issues being investigated which are related to me and whether we would seek a section 8 on a particular case or otherwise. A lot of work and meetings could take place on high policy questions that emerge, such as a section 8 appointment, an application to the court.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Mr. Haran meets the authorised officer three or four times a month. Would the Tánaiste meet him a similar number of times or would it be once or twice?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

I do not monitor their meetings. I know over the past few years the Tánaiste would have met the authorised officer a number of times.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Would it have been about these investigations?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

Yes, and on work in progress.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

What does "a number" mean? Would it be once a month?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

At times it might be more than once a month and sometimes it might be once every few months. It depends on the progress. Frequently it might be at the request of the authorised officer or of the Tánaiste.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Would there be an intention in the long-term to have some form of structured reporting system to evaluate the work of an authorised officer?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

In the longer term we are moving towards the Office of the Director of Corporate Enforcement, which we feel would probably be a better way overall to manage and promote this activity. The Director of Corporate Enforcement will have gardaí attached to the office and we feel it would be a more efficient and effective way in the longer term.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Would it be more appropriate than using an authorised officer?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

Yes. That authorised officer is out of our corporate services area where his job was previously working on tax policy and competitiveness policy. We have not augmented our resources. We have taken someone from the Registry of Friendly Societies as well and someone from the old prices area. We used to do some of the prices investigations. We have tried to augment his resources from there. Sometimes we look for the Attorney General's advice and sometimes we seek external counsel to advise them. It is a very effective and efficient means of carrying out or conducting this type of work.

Comment on this

I disagree with you there. I imagine the public shares our frustration that these investigations take so long and are behind closed doors. Why should they be behind closed doors? There is no accountability under this cloud of confidentiality. That is what Mr. Haran tells us. Why does it take so long? I imagine the public is very frustrated by the lack of progress.

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

I accept the frustration people have about the time it takes to do some of these activities. In parallel I accept that many people would like to know what is being found out. The Oireachtas, as far as I understand it, decided that the nature of the powers the officer has - the powers relate very much to the constitutional advice - are such that the investigation has to be done in a fashion that protects the information found and that it cannot be promulgated. It is a decision of the Oireachtas but, as best I understand it, because of the nature of the rights and responsibilities of the officer and responsibilities of the person whom the officer goes to, such information has to be protected.

Similarly, at a certain stage, the Garda files would also be protected and they are fact-finding. To a certain extent most Garda files are protected. We do not necessarily see what the outputs from Garda investigations are. That is to protect the innocent and the privacy of people being investigated. We have not established that any of these entities that we are investigating are carrying out criminal activity. It is only when one goes to a section 8 and the proper protections under section 8 structures are in place that reports with the facts that we find can be published. The reports are published under the jurisdiction and competence of the courts which is a safeguard for us all.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I am not clear on this. Does this fact-finding section 19 device allow the Department's authorised officer have access to Garda investigation reports?

Comment on this
Mr. Haran

No, I am drawing the parallel with Garda investigation reports.

Comment on this