Special Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General.
Contributions 180–354 of 354. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. The area of criminal law, I am sure, protects Garda information from other sources. It is not in our provenance. However, the Director of Corporate Enforcement will have greater powers and need not necessarily instigate section 19 investigations and will have Garda——
Comment on this
Yes, but at present an authorised officer cannot draw upon Garda information where his fact-finding mission is concerned.
Comment on this
No, absolutely not. It is very limited as to sources of information.
Comment on this
We have given this a great deal of time. This is very unsatisfactory. What is the purpose of this if it will take years with nothing achieved? There is a general perception that, in this State, white collar wrongdoing is not pursued with the diligence shown in other jurisdictions, including Northern Ireland. There are never prosecutions for wrongdoing. I thought it was a good thing when the initiative was taken but I have lost faith because it is taking so long. There is no tangible progress and that is how I see it. Is this good use of public money?
Comment on this
I must almost apologise that I will deal with more mundane matters. I concur with the Chairman's final remarks except where he stated that there have not been any prosecutions. Until now, there have not been any investigations and we are at least going the correct route. It is to be hoped that, when due process is complete, prosecutions will ensue should any wrongdoing be found to have happened. Until the past few years, no investigations took place.
The Comptroller and Auditor General mentioned in his opening remarks that the buoyant economy has affected many of the original Estimates. For example, expenditure on the INTERREG II programme and Union initiatives was at least a third lower than the Estimate. What was the reason for that? I have a few questions related to that material.
Comment on this
Yes. On the other issue, in the Faxhill Homes case, 29 summonses have been issued and a case is being heard in the Naas District Court, so there are prosecutions.
Comment on this
It is hard and I accept the rightful impatience of people to see progress in these areas. We need to be impatient. This is I2, is that right?
Comment on this
As Members know, INTERREG II involves a number of measures - economic development, tourism and technical assistance - and it is a North-South programme. We have had underspends in this because it was a very slow programme to get up and going. We had long delays in draw-downs and I remember discussing this last year as well when there was a much lower level of expenditure. We found that it is taking a while for projects to come in and those are only the projects for approval. Projects have to have certified delivery also. I am told it is moving forward very well at this stage. The guidelines and requirements are very strict. They are EU guidelines, as Members will know, and there can be delays for tax clearance and planning. My note says there was only £0.99 million last year, in 1998, and expenditure went up to £1.8 million in the year in question, 1999. Recent approvals are drawing down a lot quicker at this stage. Our experience is that a lot is happening and we are quite sure - the section has advised me that by the end of 2001 the full amount will be drawn down. This series of measures seemed to have a very long start period.
Comment on this
I can fully understand. We would be the people insisting on the tax clearance and so on with community groups but I felt that an extra initiative might be taken on this because of the North-South dimension and that it was more or less established in a blaze of glory, with the need for co-operation being stressed. Did we give any attention to assisting people with this other than what we would offer with normal schemes?
Comment on this
The county enterprise boards would be very aware of it and they would have tried to promote it as best they could. In addition, 54% of it has been paid down so far and we are told that the full INTERREG amount will be paid by the end of 2001.
Comment on this
On the community employment schemes generally, we have had a lot of controversy, some of us believe they should not be phased out pro rata to the unemployment figures. I felt we got a bit of a sop in the social employment programme but there was no expenditure on that. We were assured of approximately 700 special positions being created nationally for those who might not be able to cope or engage in normal full-time employment. However, there was no expenditure on that social employment programme. Why was that?
Comment on this
The social employment programme was not launched, effectively, until September 2000, so there were delays in launching the activities. The programme did not start until September 2000 and we hoped that up to 2,500 jobs would be created by end 2003 in the social economy but it is an area we have to learn a lot about. There are complex definition issues and the term has been used widely with limited precision at an early stage. The reason we did not spend is that basically the Tánaiste did not launch the programme until last year. That is why there was no spend in 1999. We are hopeful and expenditure is growing. The new chief executive of FÁS says there is a strong and vibrant demand for this. There is now a system in place which should lead to growth.
As unemployment falls dramatically, that does not mean we can close down all our schemes to support those who find it difficult to get into full-time employment, those whose local economies are so poor or those whose resource skills are low. We have to have measures to help people when they leave the jobs initiative or community employment. We need strong systems to support them in their move from unemployment and supported training to employment. It seems there would be some continuing future need for certain forms of sheltered employment. I do not like to categorise social economy as such but there is a panoply of schemes needed and some of those will be sheltered employment or systems of support while in employment, such as some of our schemes with the disabled.
Comment on this
This programme was created because there were complaints from those of us involved with people in the communities and there was an obvious need there. The Hamilton Ross report adopted a simple formula of cutting by 40% if there was 40% more unemployed. That was not the answer. This was given as a kind of half way house but continuity was the key word we tried to build into it - when the other programmes finished someone would be capable and ready to implement the scheme. If people are to be out of the activity for two years or more, however, we are going right back to where we were ten or 15 years ago.
Comment on this
I accept that. There were some changes with the jobs initiative and there was relaxation of the exit demands trying to achieve what the Deputy is suggesting. The Deputy is right and there is no point in pouring money into a person and leaving them at home for a couple of years because there is a waste of the investment in them. We must also be realistic about the ultimate impact we expect to have on some people. The ESRI did a report on some of the training and employment schemes recently and it was very strong on the CE schemes having a limited training impact, with limited numbers getting into full-time employment. There are problems there but sometimes the social outcome of some of the schemes is to support the community or an individual and not always to get an outcome where they are regarded as totally independent. That does not always occur and does not invalidate the need to give some support——
Comment on this
I ask the Secretary General to delegate someone to keep an eye on this because I am aware that FÁS would want to - I would not say wash its hands of - concentrate on what it sees as its original job of training apprentices and so on, but it cannot do so because it is understaffed and does not have resources to do so. There is a danger it will walk away from the needy in society.
Regarding health and safety, I know Mr. Haran will not know the everyday workings of the Health and Safety Authority, which has a new role in certain areas. One is the policing of the Seveso 2 EU safety directive. That was previously a general matter for the Department up to perhaps two years ago. Implementation of that directive concerns me and the public. I have been trying to ascertain the areas, sites, processes and plants affected by this. I have been looking for an area map of the places affected and it appears that until such time as someone seeks planning permission for an area, nobody can be told what establishments or areas are affected by the directive. The Secretary General may know it is causing havoc in Passage West in Cork, a town designated for renewal three years ago but which has now been told it can do almost nothing because of this directive, which is being implemented by the HSA. Is there a map available to me, other public representatives or industrialists of the affected zones?
Comment on this
On the specific question I do not know if there is a map available. I will have to come back to the Deputy on that. On the general issue, there is a serious problem in Passage West with the IFI plant. As I understand it, the HSA is asked as part of the planning process for a view under the Seveso 2 directive. The HSA would say it is ultimately up to the planners to say yea or nay. They feel they have to give technical advice as to the extent of risk involved. I am not technically competent to question their technical advice. The relevant plant has been very good and I do not think it has ever had a problem. However, their advice to the planners is inhibiting development of the Haulbowline site.
Comment on this
I have tabled parliamentary questions on this issue but everyone seems evasive. Initially I felt that people did not know what was happening, particularly as regards section 12 which was changed under the second directive. People have assured me that the Health and Safety Authority had only an advisory role.
Comment on this
However, no planner will go against the Health and Safety Authority's advice and take a chance of being before a tribunal in ten years' time. The HSA has a much more important role than an advisory role. It is defining what and where developments can take place. I am concerned about this because Cork in particular has a difficulty if this is implemented as it seems to be in that we have chemical and related developments. There would be a significant detrimental effect if there is no public discussion on the implementation of this directive. There has been no such discussion other than questions we tried to put to the Minister.
I do not know if it is possible to issue anything on this matter. Can the committee receive a note? I would like to start a process of public dialogue on this issue rather than being pushed from planners to the Health and Safety Authority to Ministers and so on, and everyone stating that it concerns an EU directive. We need to know what we are implementing and why we are implementing it. For example, was the decision regarding the distance in kilometres an arbitrary decision, was it taken by the HSA, does the same apply in the UK and so on? I would like to receive a note on these issues. It is important that we know what we are at.
Comment on this
As regards the prompt payment report and interest levied, those at fault seem to be bodies down the line such as health and education bodies and so on, rather than central agencies. Is it a charge on their budgets or is it a central Government charge?
Comment on this
They are being negligent as it were. They are wasting taxpayers' money if they do not implement the 45-day stipulation.
Comment on this
That is correct. It is a penalty and the intention is that it should be fiscally stimulated. In other words, to pay on time. The direction from which we come at this is to protect small suppliers. That was our goal. When dealing with a very large company, such as the State, small companies would not want to say that if they were not paid on time they would not come back. It is best to place the onus and responsibility on the State or the large purchaser so they pay these companies automatically.
The penalty interest is an incentive to us all. We have also made mistakes. It would be wrong for me at central level to say it is all to do with health bodies.
Comment on this
I do not know if we have dealt with the issue of the intention of going to the private sector. Is that an EU objective or directive?
Comment on this
It is an EU directive which we support. It is a very good idea. It will come into operation in the autumn of 2002 and will stipulate a period of 30 days rather than 45 days. It will be a fairly onerous responsibility of which we are very supportive. We were also one of the initiators of the minimal level which is to avoid the situation where people have to write cheques for 10p or £1.
Comment on this
When this was first mooted a couple of years ago, the point put to the Secretary General of the Department of Finance by county and city managers and their agency was whether it would also apply to the Department of Finance. Does the Department have to pay health boards, local authorities and so on under the regulation?
Comment on this
The Bula inquiry concerned section 14 which was ultimately about the ownership of certain companies. Transactions took place and it was a question of who was involved in those transactions. I am sure we published the——
Comment on this
That is correct. It was referred to the DPP. It was published on 22 July 1998 with section 14.
Comment on this
Yes. Two people came in during the serious dispute which closed the airport.
Comment on this
What has the State gained as a result of that expenditure? The Labour Relations Commission could arguably have——
Comment on this
The nature of some disputes - the protagonists and what is happening - means one has to look to other solutions. At the time it was not felt the machinery of the court would have been effective in resolving the dispute and opening the airport. Two people were brought in and a dispute gave rise to court cases which added to the costs.
Comment on this
A major part of the cumulative cost of the personal injuries tribunal arose in 1999. How was that incurred? Is there any sign of that tribunal being established?
Comment on this
There is. The personal injuries tribunal has produced a report. The report was largely finished last year but there were delays with finalising one particular aspect. We expect it to go to Government within the next two to three weeks. We are late in publishing the report and reaching a conclusion but we are very bullish about the conclusion we might get from it. Some very good people were working on it. We are looking at alternative means of addressing the determination of injuries so we might try to de-litigate this area to a large extent. The costs in Ireland are much higher than in other jurisdictions. We are bringing a fairly robust proposal to Government.
Comment on this
If the Government was to approve it, how soon could the personal injuries tribunal be up and running?
Comment on this
It will not be this year anyway as it would be impossible to get the legislation through the Dáil. We would probably set up a pilot activity in a tight area and try to move from that towards 2002.
Comment on this
Yes, but the issue was the relationship between the schemes and a social economy programme. The social economy programme had not started in 1999 and we were letting people go from the range of CE and jobs initiative schemes, who were going to nothing. One of my responses was that people on jobs initiative schemes were allowed to continue until we had an array of supports available. So there were——
Comment on this
That is a humane facility but it lacks clarity. It is difficult to give answers to people who say their programme was extended for four or five months - they do not know for how long. They seem to have an undertaking from the Minister that in no event will they regress to the unemployment queue, yet they do not know.
I was speaking to people in a child care facility before Christmas. One has to be able to plan such a business, yet the manager did not know whether she would have job initiative people who are allowing her to provide the service. It is a little unsatisfactory although I understand the humanity behind it.
Comment on this
A new range of additional supports are being developed and a social partnership process is under way. However, that is tangential. It is important but it is not the driver. It is not satisfactory that people are concerned about their future. We have not devised a full range of supports in this area and I do not defend the fact that some people are unsure what their future will hold. We have managed to keep people on the jobs initiative and, ultimately, we are trying to secure their migration into the open labour market. However, we have not sufficiently developed high level supports to assist them in their transition from the jobs initiative to the open labour market. The open labour market may not, however, be the end goal for certain groups of people. I remain loathe to write people off or categorise them as being unable to achieve that goal. It would be dangerous to do that.
The new supports may be in the form of mechanisms which would support people in continuing employment. It is accepted that such mechanisms should be available to people with a physical disability whom we assist in obtaining and retaining employment in the open economy but the same thought processes do not seem to operate in regard to people with other forms of disability or inability.
Comment on this
It is unsatisfactory that the people concerned feel that the Minister, the Government, the Department or FÁS are trying to reduce numbers by issuing letters outlining their remaining time in the perceived hope that they will exit into other employment. Perhaps the social economy programme could take on some of these people. What is preventing a successful outcome to the discussions between the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment and the Department of Education and Science in regard to the latter Department taking responsibility for the myriad of CE participants who work as caretakers, classroom assistants, part-time secretaries etc.? I thought the idea was that the Department of Education and Science would take on that responsibility.
Comment on this
Discussions have been held on this issue over a period of time. If I might respond to an earlier point, it is still necessary to push some of the jobs initiative and community employment scheme participants into the open economy. I would be dishonest if I said people can stay on as long as they wish. People are individually assessed and encouraged into the open economy.
The delays in agreeing a mechanism in regard to the CE participants with the Department of Education and Science are occurring at an administrative rather than a political level. The Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment has some concerns that in moving a group of people from one categorisation to another, their needs will not be sufficiently protected. We are anxious to find a transition which will adequately address the needs of CE participants who currently hold jobs in schools into an environment in which education is properly driven by the school's needs and educational requirements. We want to devise a transition which will not offend the Department of Finance. My Department, the Department of Education and Science and FÁS are working hard to devise a set of proposals to deal with that migration. Ultimately, it is not desirable for the education system to be augmented in this back-door fashion through community employment. We must regularise support structures in this area.
Comment on this
Am I tempting you into a policy area by asking whether we will have clarity on this matter by the start of the next academic year in autumn?
Comment on this
I hope to have clarity by then. Any solution must take account of educational needs and the individual requirements of employees in this area so that the transition would be a clean one.
Comment on this
Can prospective sponsors obtain details from the Department in regard to the social economy programme? If I believe my enterprise has a social economy potential - I could be peeling potatoes for the local hotel - can I contact the Department to obtain clarity on that?
Comment on this
My understanding is that FÁS has put in place a good structure to support social economy work for which there is a high degree of demand. The social economy could form part of people's transition from community employment into the open economy. This could happen in regard to schools. We must be open to different ideas as we plan the migration.
Comment on this
The uptake for the North-South trade and business development body was negligible in 1999. What is the current situation?
Comment on this
Inter-trade Ireland is up and running and has appointed its chief executive, Mr. Liam Nelis, who is recruiting additional staff. Due to a hiccup which occurred, many of the staff members were on secondment and that was not a very good way for the new entity to do its work. I attended a seminar about a week and a half ago with all the agencies North and South to agree co-ordination mechanisms.
The board of Inter-trade Ireland, chaired by Mr. Martin Naughten, is very able and hungry in driving this project forward. The political system strongly supports its efforts. Inter-trade Ireland is currently recruiting full-time executives.
Comment on this
It is based in Newry as per the agreement. As far as I understand it, the board has obtained a permanent premises there. The challenge for Inter-trade Ireland will be to find areas in which it can add true additional value and that it why it arranged a seminar to bring together agencies from the North and South and the two Departments. It wanted to identify areas in which it could have a meaningful impact without stepping on the toes of the plethora of other entities in this field. I can elaborate on the body's activities if the Chairman so wishes.
Comment on this
I have never quite understood what the Díon committee does. Will Mr. Haran clarify that?
Comment on this
We support, via a committee operating out of London, a range of bodies in the UK which supports the Irish diaspora. A member of the Department's staff, who is the labour attaché in London, acts as the chairperson of the Díon committee which provides grants to a number of organisations. I have a list of the organisations involved and will be happy to forward it to the committee.
Comment on this
My point is that we are currently scouring the world for labour. A huge number of Irish people living in London remitted money to their families here when it was badly needed but are now living in appalling conditions, sometimes in poor health as a result of the heavy physical work in which they were engaged. It seems we are not doing a great deal to address the situation in which they find themselves. We are trying to attract workers from Newfoundland, Beijing and Johannesburg but we do not seem to be particularly interested in people to whom we have a moral responsibility. Does the Programme for Prosperity and Fairness contain a commitment to establish a commission to examine this matter?
Comment on this
A commission operates under the auspices of the Department of Foreign Affairs. I agree that when many Irish people went to the UK in the past they were not a burden on the social welfare system. We are trying to support these people through many NGOs in the UK. These organisations deal with other immigrant bodies as well as the Irish.
Comment on this
My impression is that we are contributing a pittance - it is just scratching the surface.
Comment on this
This year we contributed £2 million. Three years ago, we contributed approximately £600,000. That is the political response from the Minister and from Ireland by way of saying that we must accept our responsibility to these people and increase the support.
Comment on this
Many of these people went to the UK in the 1950s and are now retired. When they return to Ireland to visit their relatives or friends - many of them have few relatives or friends left - they do not have free travel, to which they would otherwise be entitled. Can something be done in relation to giving them free travel as if they lived in the country?
Comment on this
I hope the committee will examine these important issues relating to rights and responsibilities.
Comment on this
On appropriations-in-aid, 40% of credit unions paid their fees when submitting their annual returns, despite a campaign by the Irish League of Credit Unions against payment of fees. What is this about?
Comment on this
There was a change in the registration charge of credit unions. The Irish League of Credit Unions tried to encourage its members not to pay, but 40% of them paid. It has since agreed with the registrar that they should pay, and everyone is now paying fees.
Comment on this
On the returns to the Office of the Director of Consumer Affairs under the Consumer Credit Act - I have an interest in this matter since I introduced the Act - the garage owners at the time claimed it would be the end of civilisation as we know it if they had to pay a very modest fee. It seems garage owners have not gone out of business. Are they paying their fees to the director as required under the Act?
Comment on this
It is a point of detail. I would like to know the answer because the Society for the Motor Industry at the time made stout representations that it would put——
Comment on this
I am sure after the past couple of good years, stouter representations will be made.
Comment on this
I would like to know if the director is getting her money. On the income from IDA Ireland property, are we still disposing of property?
Comment on this
Two things are occurring. We are disposing of buildings and selling them to clients and others. At the same time, we are acquiring landbanks to develop the brown side of the business. We are building up landbanks in strategic areas and depending on the private sector to build the buildings. I recall that £35 million worth of property was put into IDA Ireland driven landbanks by the private sector in the past year. The view is that the landbank is the way to go and that we should encourage the private sector to get involved.
Comment on this
I know there is an answer to this question, but I am a little confused as to how the allocations to IDA Ireland always have an outturn that is so precisely in line with the allocation. Where do we catch up with the actual accrual accounting?
Comment on this
We do not have accrual accounting in relation to these areas because it is a grant system. IDA Ireland may have it within its books. While the outturn is accurate, the Deputy will notice that the Estimate was wrong. This led to a supplementary for IDA Ireland in the year in question. Collectively, we got the figures wrong when the Estimate was being drawn up.
Comment on this
It is on an invoice basis - it must have delivered on certain projects. We know what its potential liability is but whether it is real depends on its delivery on the approval. If it does not start up activity or employ people, it does not draw down. We cannot govern whether it will draw down but we usually have a fairly good estimate of the quantum. However, there were delays in the year in question so a Supplementary Estimate had to be introduced to reduce its overall allocation.
Comment on this
To get back to the more mundane question of FÁS, while it may be regarded as mundane here, it is not mundane to those people in rural constituencies like mine who derive an income from it. On the question of the open labour market versus community employment, I am very unhappy with the way in which community employment schemes are currently structured. It seems they are being phased out, particularly when one considers the three year rule whereby someone over the age of 35 who works three years on a FÁS scheme is no longer eligible. What material grants are being provided to community employment schemes? Again I emphasise the importance of the overall FÁS community employment schemes both to local communities and participants.
Comment on this
I do not have the data on what the quantum currently is of the additional money provided for materials, which makes a difference to sponsors. This relates to paint and so on for clubs, schools, playing pitches, providing posters and so on. On the wider policy issue, CE was introduced originally because of the dreadful unemployment figures and so on. This was an unemployment project, dealt with through sponsors. Over time and because of its use, it went from being an unemployment scheme to a service provider scheme and an important part of the infrastructure, particularly for communities with endemic unemployment rates which were impoverished by years of underdevelopment. It was an important part of the resources of the local community.
The social economy should play a role in addressing some of these issues but other areas of expenditure will also have to play a role in ensuring our overall level of provision in communities reflects the needs of these communities. We are providing training in this area to ensure community employment remains a labour market intervention and that other interventions such as the social economy and a change in the education support structures also take place in parallel. I accept there are discontinuities that affect communities where one is ending and the other has not begun adequately, which can cause a strain on communities. I could not come before this committee and say we are maintaining a whole lot of these schemes for labour market reasons. Given that the ambit of some of these schemes goes beyond the labour market, we must be specific in this regard and support them.
Comment on this
If one takes areas such as the west and north-west, they do not have the same employment levels which prevail in Dublin and other parts of the country. The structure is failing to provide the support it should be giving to rural communities because most of the programme is focused on areas of high employment such as Dublin and the criteria applied to areas of high employment are also being applied to areas where unemployment is four or five times the national average and where the FÁS community employment schemes and other schemes have been beneficial to the local community and participants.
Comment on this
I accept that. In an attempt to ensure that it was not Dublin or urban centred, in the adjustments which were made particular consideration was given to island communities because they do not meet some of the criteria and have special challenges. They were excluded from the restructuring. However, other rural communities were not. It is a matter of striking the right balance between schemes which are designed to help individuals return to mainstream employment and schemes which are useful in helping communities to grow and which improve their welfare. Leader and county enterprise boards also have a role to play in this regard, as do EI and IDA Ireland. I recognise that the closure of community employment schemes causes problems because communities become dependent on them and are used to them. We have to find a way of working through that and putting in place other support structures to help rural communities, especially where the population density is such that it is difficult to secure support structures.
Comment on this
There is a section of the population in rural areas who, because of a number of factors, including socio-economic factors, cannot migrate to Dublin. The community employment schemes were extremely important for these people and their communities.
Comment on this
I accept that there are places where they are important, but we have to find measures which will help those communities out of full dependency and also help them to grow. There are wonderful communities where the community enterprise centres helped to develop sustainable economic activity. Industrial policy should not have to depend on these people coming to Dublin for a job. The emphasis of industrial policy has to be the opposite, it must encourage people to go out and bring economic activity to other areas.
Comment on this
I want to follow up on the point made by Deputy Gildea and the Secretary General's comment. He said that communities have got used to community employment schemes as they provide job opportunities etc. During the past year I have argued that while an audit was carried out on the numbers employed, etc., no audit was done on the work carried out under the schemes. I am not referring only to the school-related work, to which Deputy Rabbitte referred, but to the maintenance of sports pitches and a range of community-related activities which the local authorities will not touch. We are all involved in local authorities and we know they will not go anywhere near this work. No audit has been done of the great benefits of these schemes and I am concerned at the official line, "We have tried to rehabilitate people and have provided outlets for them." Villages and urban areas which were semi-derelict have been turned around by these workers. These schemes are critical not just in providing posts or generating cash but also in doing beneficial work. I do not think you attempted to measure this aspect when this argument was going on.
Comment on this
They provide a very valuable service and communities have become dependent on them because they have re-energised them. They provided sports facilities and gave a new vibrancy to communities by encouraging community spirit and the development of entrepreneurship and a different attitude. This is why measures such as social economy and others are so important. The emphasis is not necessarily on the recruitment of an individual as a labour market measure, rather it is on providing society with a new form of economy, which can be sports, providing care for the elderly or needy and providing meals for disabled people. These are very valuable measures and I accept that we have not done an audit on them. Community employment was measured as a labour market intervention. However, it clearly has value as a wider service in providing intervention.
Comment on this
Do you have any intention of doing this audit which should be done? The mechanism used seemed to be very crude. You took on a firm of consultants and economists who did number crunching and came up with a simple solution - while there were 200,000 a few years ago there are now 40,000 and the figures should be reduced pro rata. Do you have plans to carry out a social audit, which is critically important?
Comment on this
We plan to do the mainstreaming of the provision. This is the way we have to go so that communities are not dependent on an employment scheme. Communities are rightfully dependent on sports support structures, educational support structures and health care support structures, and CE was one of the ways of providing these in the past. It has a role to play in the future but because of its size and the rate at which it escalated it started doing many things which should now be delivered by new systems. I accept the value of what it has done in communities and would not try to underestimate it.
Comment on this
I want to ask about your internal audit arrangements. To follow up on the point being discussed, there are labour shortages at every level of the economy and in most regions for high, medium and lower level jobs. Yet last month 135,000 people were paid unemployment benefit. This point has been troubling the committee for some time. Why is this mismatch continuing? There are labour shortages everywhere, yet 135,000 people are still being paid unemployment benefit. Do you have anything new to say to the committee on this point?
Comment on this
I am afraid I do not have anything new to add. The labour shortages are growing and unemployment rates are collapsing. The ILO labour force unemployment rate and live register figures are falling rapidly. There is still a huge gap between them but it has narrowed slightly - I think it is 84,000, down from 100,000 a fewyears ago. There is still a big gap between the entitlement to a social welfare payment andthe labour force estimate of unemployment. The labour force estimate of unemployment reflects very much our understanding of the labour market. It has a long-term unemployment rate of 1.4%——
Comment on this
It certainly reflects my experience. Is this not a colossal rip-off? Are many of the people receiving unemployment benefit also working? Is there any other explanation?
Comment on this
I imagine a big reduction must be occurring in the black economy element because it is becoming easier and more beneficial to be in paid employment as it gives more money. There are new tax structures in place to encourage paid employment. The tax burden on paid employment is also coming down for both the employer and the employee. I do not have data - I am not auditing the social welfare aspect. The Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs is pursuing the investigation you initiated in Galway——
Comment on this
——and this should throw some light on the matter.
Comment on this
I cannot see any other explanation but that people are working and drawing unemployment benefit and they are getting away with it. Of the figure of 135,000, maybe 30,000 are part-time employed and receiving partial payments. I ask you and the Department to be vigorous in protecting the public finances. We do not wish to have another public inquiry showing that your Department or others did not do their job. Mr. Jack Lynch, when Taoiseach, said that if the unemployment figure went above 100,000 a Government should resign. We are now talking about full employment, yet we are still paying 135,000 people. The DIRT issue, in terms of money foregone to the Exchequer, is minimal compared to the potential loss of revenue here.
Comment on this
Our employment action plan plays a role in helping to reduce that figure. The thresholds have been reduced to get at people crossing it at nine months rather than the year to date.
Comment on this
We will have a more detailed debate on that soon. Will you tell me about the internal audit arrangements within your Department?
Comment on this
There are six people employed in our internal audit unit. We have two sets of responsibilities, standard internal audit of the departmental Vote and internal audit activities relating to EU funding and the cascade arrangements which exist there. We also have an internal audit committee. I was a member of that committee up to the end of last year. Best practice has suggested that the Secretary General should not be a member of such a committee because it reports to him. It is now chaired by my colleague, the head of corporate services. An external accountant from the Department of Agriculture, Food and Rural Development is a member of the internal audit committee which meets on a regular basis.
Comment on this
There is a head of internal audits post. We also have an internal auditor.
Comment on this
Ultimately, he reports to the head of internal audits, the internal audit group then reports to me and the management board on a regular basis. For example an audit needs assessment is currently under way. The internal auditor came to the management board and presented proposals regarding this assessment. The management board will adjudicate on that. I also make adjudications with the management board.
Comment on this
Yes. I do not know of any place he cannot go - perhaps he cannot go to the inspector's office because he reports to him.
Comment on this
He is an assistant principal. The head of internal audits is a PO higher scale. I make a distinction because the EU internal audit officer also reports to the PO higher scale. He is a consultant accountant, it is a technical grade.
Comment on this
Tell me about health and safety. What are the statistics regarding health and safety injuries?
Comment on this
I will get the figures. I think the death statistics have risen, everything is relative. Related to the overall population of employment the figure is decreasing but the absolute figures have increased in the past year. The fatalities investigated were 78 in 1995 and 48 in 1997 and they were up to 69 in 1999.
Comment on this
Apart from the fact that more people are working, is there a slackening off in safety standards?
Comment on this
It is very difficult to identify why it is happening. There is a great deal going on in the construction industry. There is a partnership arrangement to try to encourage employers, unions and the health and safety people to work together to effect a significant improvement in that area. The number of farm accidents remains very high. Beyond that there are isolated incidents. This year's budget has provided a significant allocation for increased staffing.
Comment on this
How many accidents have taken place each year for the past five years in the construction industry?
Comment on this
The figure for last year is 18 fatalities. I do not have with me figures for previous years. There were over 1,000 reported injuries. The statistics in the agriculture industry are the highest, with 23 fatalities last year. It is a serious problem.
Comment on this
Does a programme exist between your Department and the Department of Agriculture, Food and Rural Development focused on farm safety?
Comment on this
A task force has worked on this area and has produced guidelines for it. The HSA has attended the ploughing championships and has worked with the representative bodies, Teagasc, the ESB etc. to raise awareness in this area. There has been a great deal of activity in the area. It is a very difficult area and it has been a persistent problem.
Comment on this
The committee, regrettably, is only interested in the costs ultimately to the Exchequer. That is our function. We must draw this to the attention of our colleagues on the agriculture committee.
Is there any new approach to the problem as expressed by Deputy Gildea about high unemployment in some rural constituencies remote from Dublin? I see that the Estimate for IDA Ireland was reduced in the Supplementary Estimates. Am I reading that correctly?
Comment on this
That is a lag type of Estimate. Commitments were made two years previous to that. It is a poor reflection of activity.
Comment on this
Is there any attempt to use that money in places such as west Donegal and west Mayo?
Comment on this
Yes, there is. IDA Ireland and Enterprise Ireland have new regional strategies. We use differential financial packages depending upon where the project is located. The BMW region will attract much higher grant aid than a non-BMW region. The aim of IDA Ireland is to have 50% of all announcements for new greenfield investment in a BMW area by 2002. It achieved that last year. Enterprise Ireland is giving differential grants - I did not bring the figures with me. It wants to move 150 companies from Dublin to the regions. A lot of effort is being made in this area. Improved infrastructure plays an important role in this area. We do not deliver the infrastructure but we are drivers of it.
Comment on this
I know that, but on that point, I was appalled when I read that the national development plan would include a map of the island of Ireland, and the road structures proposed were one to Belfast, one to Galway, one to Limerick, one to Cork, one to Waterford and the south-east and nothing to the north-west. There is nothing for Sligo, Donegal or Monaghan. How can those regions develop if good infrastructural connections do not exist?
Comment on this
I cannot speak in detail about the national development plan but I can say that the inhibitors to development in the north-west include the road structure and the transmission and distribution infrastructure. Such factors inhibit the types of company located in the north-west. These new economy projects are very dependent upon robust energy infrastructure. The educational infrastructure must also be robust. They will be the key drivers. We will do things with our differential grants to promote the areas but ultimately the areas must promote themselves by having high quality infrastructure.
Comment on this
One look at that map of Ireland in the national development plan shows the north-west is completely ignored. There is no proposed road except the one to Belfast. There is a huge gap. I have, for years, identified the north-west as an area which should receive major structural development, yet it is omitted from the national development plan. Deputy Gildea has rightly raised the question of high unemployment in the north-west.
Comment on this
I accept that good infrastructure is required. IDA Ireland has scored recently in this area following the task force problems in Donegal. Letterkenny has a great resource of software people. That is a palpable resource and we are trying to tap it. Inishowen has very serious problems.
Comment on this
If industry needs to communicate through airports and to markets it needs roads, rail and infrastructure. The north-west does not have these facilities. This is the case from Mayo to Donegal.
Comment on this
There is unemployment and labour shortages but there are no infrastructural proposals whatsoever.
Comment on this
I am not sure there are no infrastructural proposals but I know there are real challenges there.
Comment on this
The National Roads Authority has come in here and there is a major gap. Perhaps Mr. Haran would take this up with the Department of the Environment and Local Government and let us have a note on his reflections within two months. Is that agreed? Are there any other questions?
Comment on this
I wish to revert to the health and safety issue. Did I hear Mr. Haran say there has been a 33% increase in inspectors?
Comment on this
I will get the figure. I was involved in the negotiations about it but I do not remember the extra number.
Comment on this
It will be up to the health and safety board which is a tripartite board to direct, with the executive, the deployment of the resource.
Comment on this
Part of my previous experience was as a safety officer in Irish Steel, which was what turned my hair white. Normally a bad employer is at fault but the farm fatalities appear to suggest that is not the case because obviously they would have their own interest in this matter. What I am trying to get at is whether the finance is being targeted in the right way. The National Industrial Safety Organisation is doing fantastic work but it is a voluntary body. It is that body that has made the real impact rather than the statutory body. The funding is being targeted at inspectors, but should it be targeted at education? I appreciate there is a need for both, but is the mix right?
Comment on this
I hope the mix is right. A lot more energy is being put into awareness raising campaigns such as the partnership campaigns, FÁS training and health and safety modules to assist the educational side. Clearly we learn a great deal from the farming community but these people are under great stress and strain. It is dangerous to categorise any one grouping. Safety has to be a total partnership activity. We know from some of the multinationals which have set up some huge projects here that one gets health and safety down to an extraordinarily robust fashion. The Intel construction plant was the best in the globe from a health and safety point of view because it put systems in place, with workers and employers working together to ensure people do not get hurt.
Comment on this
I accept that point. Are we heading in the right direction? The Irish refining plant is a classic example as there has not been an accident there in 14 years. If one occurred there it would obviously be damaging but it has taken the precautions to avoid that and it has done so through education.
Comment on this
Is our national money going in the right direction? In my experience, 90% of the accidents on which I took reports and of which I oversaw the results arose from over-enthusiasm by workers. They were trying to do the right thing and to do it speedily. It was not due to negligence as such even though the company might be found negligent later but it would probably come down to a lack of training or education. If we are funding 33% of the budget, some of it must go towards education rather than merely towards increasing the number of inspectors. We seem to get caught up in the public debate, the number of inspectors available and so on.
Comment on this
That is a fair comment. There are 25 additional inspectors. I am informed that 52% of the increase is for the non-pay area. The Health and Safety Authority believes strongly in public awareness activities. Sometimes it is difficult to do a cost-benefit analysis because one does not always see the benefits of public awareness, apart from indirectly. I totally agree with the Deputy's analysis that these things can be done if the education is provided, but there is a role also for inspection to protect employees where an employer is not as active as he should be in encouraging this partnership.
Comment on this
When the parliamentary question is asked or the debate is taking place in the House the important issue seems to be the number of inspectors. That is the end of the matter for most politicians. I am anxious that Mr. Haran's Department would say what cannot be audited as well, emphasising training, results and benefits. That is important.
Comment on this
This is a time of great joy in your Department given the state of the economy and the state of employment. Is there any assessment of where we may be at risk? Have we too many eggs in any one basket? Are we trying to spread that risk to ensure there is not a sudden shock to the system whereby there is a collapse in one sector?
Comment on this
I think the Chairman is right. There are a number of risks about which one has to be careful. The type of risks that can be avoided are in indigenous and overseas companies, and there may be an imbalance in terms of particular markets. Enterprise Ireland has done a lot of good work in trying to develop indigenous industry. That will give us much protection against certain downturns. It has to try to find different marketplaces, particularly the euro marketplace. We have had much success but we are still very exposed to the UK market and with the movement into the euro we are quite exposed to asymmetric shocks from a currency point of view. On the portfolio balance, we have to concentrate on the sectors. We are strong in health care and in ICT. It is good to be strong in an industry that is so pervasive and growing so well. A counteraction to that is that we are strong in health care and pharmaceuticals and in the financial services industry which give a certain amount of protection against the ICT collapse and any problems that might occur in that area.
It will be a while before we will be able to measure our success, but it is constantly growing on the value chain. It is easy to say our success is moving up the value chain but we have to try to concentrate on as many of our businesses, those in existence and those which will come into existence, to ensure the value they add is high so that they are less exposed to the average wage cost. In the long-term Ireland cannot compete against low wages so we have to constantly grow to ensure it is the brainpower of our society that is being exploited and used for added value. That is what the whole Science Foundation Ireland investment is about, trying to grow the quality and quantum of research occurring in our society. That is a ten year horizon. That is when we will start to get the real benefits. It is an early investment today for a deferred and delayed response but it is critically important that in every product line we are in we go up the value chain so that we are more robust. If there are hiccups of a global nature of course we have to suffer but we have to try to organise it as best we can. It is a free market so we cannot determine all the outcomes. We seek to secure as great a balance in it so that individual shocks will not hurt us more than other people.
The euro is an important element and I hope our euro market exposure will be a critical part of that. An example of this is that 40% of the new jobs in IDA Ireland assisted companies were in wage levels above £25,000, which is one of the indicators of how far we are going up the value chain. We would not pay that money if we were not going up the value chain. There are also more high productivity companies. We have to keep on working on this and trying to secure those outcomes. The rhetoric is easy.
Comment on this
What do you think about wages and the criticism from the European Commission? An editorial in the Financial Times on that issue stated that we would have to face the inevitability of an increase in wages.
Comment on this
I juxtapose the Financial Times with the European Commission. They almost say the opposite. The Financial Times states that Ireland is bad because wages are not increasing and the Commission states that inflation and potentially wage inflation is too high so we should not have an inflationary budget. They are contradictory arguments. Basically, the Financial Times is saying that we should go away from social partnership processes, let wage increases rip through the economy and have what it would call a self-correcting inflation response. That is what its analysis would suggest.
The Union is applying certain analyses to us which may not be appropriate for an economy like ours. We have a very open economy. In the 1980s we tried to expand fiscally. We pumped money into the economy to make it grow, we discovered that pumping money into it does not make it grow because it is dissipated. It goes out of the economy immediately through imports and exports so it does not affect domestic inflation the same way as a fiscal stimulus would affect a very closed large economy. In a certain sense, we feel that maybe it is misapplying analyses for large countries with lower dependence on trading to an open economy like ours that is fiscally healthy.
Comment on this
Our job is to protect the public finances and to ensure that we are taking steps now to protect it down the road. I would like to hear about training and retraining. You spoke about embarking on programmes that will have benefits in ten years. Is FÁS looking ahead to training needs in three, four and five years and is it adjusting accordingly now?
Comment on this
There are a number of activities. The national training fund legislation was passed by the House at the end of last year. In the fund we are moving away from the old sectoral committees and establishing new structures to try to address this issue. We have a skills awareness group that is chaired by Danny O'Hare which tries to anticipate the skills requirements in our industry. It concentrated in the original report on the higher end of the business. It is also doing a report on the construction industry. It hopes to use that type of device, which brings together the two Departments with Forfás and FÁS as our two agencies and the HEA, to try to identify what will be the skills requirements of the future and what systems we have to support them.
Second, there is something on which we still have not adequately developed a policy but which we are thinking about, the lifelong learning aspect of training. I hope we will get it right with regard to the mix of degrees and skills we are developing. One thing we feel confident about is that we will need new systems to help grow skills on an ongoing basis. We are trying to think about it but we have not settled on anything in particular. We have the skills nets process as well, involving trade unions and employers in the active management of training within certain areas. However, I do not feel we have yet cracked adequately the lifelong learning challenge which will be important for continuous economic development.
Comment on this
We could discuss this for some time. There are no further questions so I propose that the committee note both the accounts and the special report on prompt payments and that the meeting adjourn until next Thursday at 11 a.m. Is that agreed? Agreed. At that meeting we expect to have the vocational education committees from County Wicklow, including Bray.
The witnesses withdrew.