We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE of PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

2000 Annual Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General and Appropriation Accounts: ›

Vote 10 - Office of Public Works (Resumed).

Contributions 1–173 of 511. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

This meeting will consider Campus and Stadium Ireland Development Ltd. financial statement for the period 10 December 1999 to 31 December 2000 and 2000 Annual Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General Appropriation Accounts, Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation - Vote 35, Department of the Taoiseach - Vote 3, Office of Public Works - Vote 10 (Resumed). Please note that at its private meeting on 12 March 2002 the committee decided that its examination of these Votes today would be confined to administrative and operational control aspects associated with Campus and Stadium Ireland Development Ltd. We have received correspondence from Ms Margaret Hayes, Secretary General, Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation, which is noted, as is further correspondence from the Department.

Members' and witnesses' attention is drawn to the fact that as and from 2 August 1998 section 10 of the Committees of the Houses of the Oireachtas (Compellability, Privileges and Immunities of Witnesses) Act, 1997 grants certain rights to persons who are identified in the course of the committee's proceedings. Notwithstanding this provision in legislation I remind Members of the long standing parliamentary practice that Members should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the House, or an official, either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. Members are reminded of the provisions of Standing Order 149 that the committee shall also refrain from inquiring into the merits of a policy or policies of the Government or a Minister of the Government or the merits of the objectives of such policies. Members should note that the committee is concerned with the accounts specifically listed for examination and administrative and operational control aspects in relation to same which are within the knowledge and competence of the witnesses being examined.

Mr. Teahon, will you introduce your officials please?

Comment on this
Mr. P. Teahon

Thank you, Chairman. I am the executive chairperson of Campus and Stadium Ireland Development Ltd and with me is Donagh Morgan, Company Secretary of Campus and Stadium Ireland Development Ltd.

Comment on this

Thank you. Ms Margaret Hayes, Secretary General of the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation, will you introduce your officials please?

Comment on this
Ms M. Hayes

Good afternoon, Chairman. I am accompanied by Ms Eugenie Deegan and Ms Kathleen Stack, principal officers in the Department.

Comment on this

Thank you. Mr. Dermot McCarthy, Secretary General of the Department of the Taoiseach, will you introduce your officials please?

Comment on this
Mr. D. McCarthy

I am accompanied by Mr. Peter Ryan, assistant secretary, and Mr. Martin Fraser, principal officer, from the Department.

Comment on this

Thank you very much. Mr. Barry Murphy, Chairman of the Office of Public Works, will you introduce your officials please?

Comment on this
Mr. B. Murphy

I am accompanied by Commissioner Sean Benton who is present in that role.

Comment on this

Thank you very much. I ask Mr. Purcell to introduce the accounts.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

Thank you, Chairman. Last April I received a request from the Secretary General of the Department of Finance to audit the annual accounts of Campus and Stadium Ireland Development Ltd. I agreed to audit the company's accounts on a voluntary basis pending the enactment of legislation to put the company and its operations on a statutory footing. The audit, which was completed in June 2001, covered a period from the date it commenced operations on 10 December 1999 to the end of the year 2000. Almost £2 million was allocated from the Department of the Taoiseach's Vote to meet the costs of the company in the initial period. The committee will see from the accounts that something around £560,000 of that went to fitting out the offices which were rented in Blanchardstown, £400,000 went to pay for executive services for the last four months of the year 2000 and £313,000 or so went on consultants' fees. They were the main items of expenditure. The rest are detailed on page 11 of the accounts before you.

Before finalising my audit report on the accounts I formally queried a number of matters with the executive chairman - corporate governance arrangements, tendering for executive services, fee levels for executive services, credit card expenses and the tax status of the company. I can expand on the specific issues during the course of the examination if the committee so wishes. The main activities of the company during the period of the accounts were developing an architectural and environmental scheme for the Abbotstown site, devising the structure of a competition for the provision of the various facilities on the site and latterly organising a competition for the provision of an aquatic and leisure centre.

As the committee will be aware, the main project is in limbo consequent on a decision to suspend development following publication of the report of consultants appointed by the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation to review the cost of providing the proposed stadium and other facilities on the Abbotstown site. This decision did not affect the construction of the aquatic and leisure centre. In July 2000 the Government agreed to the development of such a centre on the site on the basis of a design, build, finance, operate and maintain agreement and provided for a capital grant of up to £30 million towards its cost. However, when the bids came in and were assessed it became clear that the Exchequer would have to fully meet the capital costs of the centre. This was computed at £48.4 million, a figure which had appeared in the report of the management consultants for the overall project. The fact that the bids reflected a far higher cost to the Exchequer than had been envisaged raises doubts about the reliability of the information underpinning the July 2000 decision of the Government. The consortium that had scored highest in the bid competition under the design and maintenance elements of the proposals was also the lowest in terms of price by virtue of the fact that the operator would make a £0.5 million contribution upon the granting of the 30 year lease.

What ultimately emerged was far from the classic public private partnership arrangement originally envisaged. In effect, the Exchequer is putting in at least £48.4 million while the private sector's financial input is limited to £0.5 million. Moreover, the transfer of risk to the private sector which is normally a feature of these partnership arrangements was almost non-existent. There are a number of issues surrounding the arrangements for the aquatic and leisure centre that have come into the public domain in recent weeks which the committee may wish to explore but the fundamental concerns that arose out of my audit and subsequently are: (1) the appropriateness of the corporate governance framework of the company; (2) the nature of the executive services contract and (3) the circumstances in which a project that was supposed to cost the State a maximum of £30 million in July 2000 increased five months later to a minimum contribution of £48 million or so.

I am willing to expand on any of those points if the Chairman wishes.

Comment on this

We will refer to you for clarification at various stages. I understand Ms Margaret Hayes, Mr. Dermot McCarthy and Mr. Barry Murphy do not have opening statements but Mr. Teahon has one. However, I would like to leave that until later as some aspects that might arise in the questioning by members might be relevant to other Departments. We have a copy of your statement, Mr. Teahon, and will return to it later.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

In his report the Comptroller and Auditor General referred to concerns with corporate governance. What were his concerns in relation to both the corporate governance of this structure and the nature of the executive services contract? Perhaps, if Mr. Teahon has views on that he will respond as well.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

In the matter of corporate governance I specifically sought to be informed of the arrangements made by the board to assess and address any business and operational risks associated with its operations and ensure controls and monitoring systems appropriate to its construction and project management operations were in place, the arrangements to assess and address the risks associated with the arrangements for the supply of executive services by an independent company and the arrangements to put a system of governance in place which specifies the reserved functions of the board and implements controls which govern the actions of the various organs of the company.

These are not unusual and I would have looked for reassurance on these matters before I completed my audit report on the company. They are very much in line with the guidelines being promulgated by the Department of Finance on corporate governance for companies in the State sector. As I understand it, these will be mandatory shortly for all State bodies in the commercial sector and a little later in the year for non-commercial State organisations.

It would have been a general concern, particularly where the roles of chairman and chief executive officer were held by one person and where the services were being provided by an executive company. There is nothing necessarily wrong with either of these, the joint holding of the role of chief executive officer and that of chairman of the board and services being provided by an outside executive company, but they add to the risk of having a proper corporate governance framework in place and specific actions have to be taken to ensure the principles of good corporate governance are met. That was my concern.

Comment on this

What is the overall value of the executive services contract?

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

The executive services contract was set initially at 1.75% of the total development cost of the project. This was later adjusted to 1.8% of the total development cost to take into account some additional responsibilities that arose out of overseeing the project. As you will see in a note to the accounts towards the end, encompassed in this is a floor fee of £100,000 a month which equates to the £400,000 charged in the accounts for the period ended 31 December 2000, that is, £400,000 for those particular services.

Comment on this

On a five year basis the floor price would be £6 million for executive services.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

If the project went ahead and the arrangement was not terminated and there was a five year timescale envisaged, it would be IR£6 million.

Comment on this

Do you wish to seek clarification, Deputy Doherty?

Comment on this

How does the Comptroller and Auditor General describe the situation where the same individual holds two separate positions and how is corporate governance adequately complied with in that context?

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

It makes it more difficult but not impossible. There are certain other measures that must be put in place in such circumstances to avoid the risk in order that there is the classical governance structure of having an executive reporting to an independent board and the checks and balances inherent in such a structure.

Comment on this

Was an internal or an external auditor appointed?

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

There is an audit committee.

Comment on this

That is a separate matter.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

As far as I am aware, I should have clarified for the committee——

Comment on this

Did you examine that?

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

——when I finished the audit last June I had not come back to this matter except as a means of briefing myself for the purposes of this meeting. I am the external auditor.

Comment on this

You are the external auditor. For the purposes of the audit you undertook and completed in so far as that was done, did you take account of the necessity for an internal auditor?

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

Not specifically. I addressed a series of questions which outlined concerns I had to the executive chairman. Having received his representations in relation to those concerns I was satisfied I could give a clear audit report on the accounts.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

In fairness to Mr. Teahon, it is only right that the last sentence be amplified for the purposes of those reporting the meeting. You may have inadvertently given the impression that there is a question mark over the corporate governance, the structure of the executive services contract and so on. As far as you were concerned from your discussions before signing off on your audit, you were happy that those issues had been addressed following the representations made to you by Mr. Teahon. In fairness to a former senior civil servant of his standing, that point should be made clear. You are happy about those issues now.

Comment on this
Michael Ahern Deputy M. Ahern Fianna Fáil

In a statement made today when dealing with the Estimates for the Department of the Taoiseach there was an insinuation of corruption regarding Campus and Stadium Ireland Development Limited. It is important that the opinion and audit report of the Comptroller and Auditor General are clarified and this matter dealt with.

Comment on this

I do not know who participated in that discussion, but I do not believe any member of this committee made any statement alleging corruption.

Comment on this
Michael Ahern Deputy M. Ahern Fianna Fáil

It was not made by members here.

Comment on this

I would like this committee to focus on the line of questioning. The Comptroller and Auditor General can deal with corporate governance.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

My question relates to the Comptroller and Auditor General's last statement that following the representations made to him by Mr. Teahon he is happy with the state of the accounts, corporate governance, the management services contract and the risk and cost issues that he raised initially as being among his concerns.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

Without being mealy-mouthed about it, happiness is a relative state. I have to be satisfied to a level that will enable me to append an opinion as to whether the accounts show a true and fair view. I am absolutely of the opinion that the accounts show a true and fair view. I was not required, as external auditor at the time, to make a comment on corporate governance. That will be a requirement from a current date, but it was not required at that stage. However, I had certain concerns. Mr. Teahon did reply and I accepted those representations. He stated for instance——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

You used the word "representations". Mr. Teahon made comments clarifying the points you made and you accepted that your concerns about the corporate governance structures were resolved. The word "representations" could——

Comment on this

Let the Comptroller and Auditor General finish his point.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

When a formal audit query is addressed to an individual that person will make whatever reply he or she wants to. In this case, I am auditing this body in a voluntary capacity. The company is merely a company incorporated under the Companies Act. It does not have a statutory basis other than that. There is the intention to put it on a statutory footing. It is in the never never world where we must try to apply public service values to what is in effect a private sector company even though its total income is obtained from the public purse. It is unsatisfactory that it should be so. In view of the imminent introduction of standards for corporate governance in public bodies I felt that I should take those on board in applying what would be seen as best practice to my audit of the company, but it does not necessarily impact on my ability to give a clear audit report on the accounts and I stand over that opinion. I do not make any attestation of the adequacy or otherwise of the corporate governance framework in my audit report. I may have to in the future.

Comment on this

In the context of executive services and your auditing of different accounts, is this the first time you saw a category where there was an expenditure programme for executive services? Mr. Murphy is familiar with Government procurement policies and embodied within those is the different range of services which must go to tender. You must advertise in the European Journal if it goes over a certain amount and in this case the amount for executive services has been exceeded. If we look at procurement policy, consultancy services, advertising and so on are listed and must adhere to EU procurement policy. Mr. Murphy, is this the first time you have encountered the category of executive services and are you happy with that? It would appear that by calling it "executive services" and not "consultancy services" it did not need to be advertised in the European Journal. Will the Comptroller and Auditor General say whether he questioned the "executive services" and if he is happy the proper procurement policies were followed in this case?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I do not like to pass on the question but the Office of Public Works was not involved in the procurement of the executive services contract. That was done through the Department of the Taoiseach at the time. We gave some comments and some would say drafts, but beyond that we had no involvement. It is not open to us to comment on the points you made.

Comment on this

I put the question to Mr. McCarthy, Secretary General of the Department of the Taoiseach, who was responsible for Campus Ireland up to 31 December 2000 and these are the accounts we are reviewing.

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

Chairman, the contract in question followed on a tender process carried out by Campus and Stadium Ireland Limited as the contracting authority. It was the subject of public advertisement nationally and I understand internationally. In the subsequent period, the Department raised with the executive chairperson and the director of the executive services team whether the procurement process was appropriate. We made no payment in respect of that contract until we were satisfied that the contracting authority had operated on the basis of legal advice that in terms of the EU Directive on Services the executive services concept and contract was an exempt category. Legal advice to that effect was produced to us following which payments in respect of the contract were made.

Comment on this

A consultancy service is listed as one which would have to be advertised in the European Journal. What is the difference between consultancy services and executive services? It is a new category.

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

Fundamentally, Chairman, the concept of executive services is the parcelling together of a range of services that might stand separately if they were advertised for separately but which together constitute something more than the sum of their parts. It is a process by which one manages the logistics and the support services in a structure or organisation. In accordance with the legal advice which the Department saw and which was obtained by the contracting authority, the determining question regarding whether an EU procurement obligation arises is the respective value of the elements within the executive services package, as it were. The legal advice which the contracting authority relied on was that, having regard to the quite specific definition in terms of that directive and the EU nomenclature of services, the balance of the value of the contract pointed towards it not being covered by the EU procurement requirements but it was the subject of competitive tendering in the other sense.

Comment on this

That competitive tendering was in the European Journal?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

No, it was not. It was, as I understand it, in other media.

Comment on this

It seems a huge contradiction that if you give a service for a period and it is £1.2 million a year you do not advertise in the European Journal but if you have up to 260,000 ecu for consultancy services you would have to advertise in it.

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

There are two elements to the EU threshold, one is monetary and the other is the nature of the services to be contracted. In terms of executive services, as I understand it, the nature of the relationship between the entity offering the executive services and the contracting party is different from the normal consultancy relationship and it is in that context as in other aspects of service definitions that the legal advice pointed towards it not being covered by the EU procurement but it was subject to the requirements which the Department had made clear applied to CSID, namely competitive tendering as a procurement method.

Comment on this

It would appear that if you advertise an executive service you are precluded from advertising in the European Journal but for consultancy and so on you must advertise if it is over a certain ceiling. Deputy Durkan, do you wish to comment?

Comment on this

I would like the Comptroller and Auditor General to comment.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

There are two issues, the tender competition and the executive services contract. I also asked in the audit query why the services were not advertised in the EU Journal and the legal advice, as has been described by Mr. McCarthy, was given to me stating that it was not necessary because the preponderance of the services fell into administrative type secretarial support. Technically in that sense it did not have to be advertised.

Comment on this

Did you check that independently?

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

No, I did not. There is legal advice and I will not try to interpret EU procurement directives some of which have come before the European Court of Justice. I was happy that there was legal backing for what was done. When we speak about competitive tendering, as I understand it, cost was not a factor. We are talking about presentation, quality and so on. That can be clarified by any of the principals present but it is my understanding from returning to the papers that cost was not one of the assessment criteria. As regards the contract for executive services I had a figure of £400,000 in the accounts. I had no evidence to back up that figure. I had seen as part of the contract that it was 1.8% of the total development cost. That as much as anything else prompted the query on that matter to the executive chairman. He pointed out that the contract as agreed provided for a float but the amount was not mentioned in that contract.

I would also have a general concern which I expressed in relation to another company about this type of contract. Let us say, for instance, that the main development at Abbotstown is in abeyance at present. In such a situation if you were tied down to a fee of £100,000 a month, that might raise doubts for me as to the value for money of that exercise. The nature of the contract on which I needed clarification, and which was given to me by the executive chairman, makes it clear that the proposal of the company was that it had a stipulation that if a positive balance between the annual floor fee level and a percentage base fee remained in year five, this would become payable to it in that year. What I am saying is that if 1.8% amounted to more than £6 million in fees over a five year period, the difference would be paid to the executive services company. If, however, the then development value was £330 million on which the £100,000 per month was based and it was not reached, there would be no claw-back of the fees paid. Let us assume you could build a bare bones stadium for £150 million in Abbotstown and that was the final development value, you would imagine there would be a claw-back to the State of the fees because it would have paid the equivalent of 1.8% on £330 million. In fairness - I am sure the executive chairman will clarify this - he said to me at the time - I quote from the letter dated 12 June 2001:

The finance and audit committee of the board are currently examining a proposal from the executive services company such that a fee in the contract be based on the required level of resources rather than be calculated on a percentage basis. When it is agreed with the executive services company it will be the subject of a revised contract. I will write to you at that time to inform you of the terms of the revised contract as approved by the board.

As I said, I have not revisited this matter since last June, but, to the best of my knowledge, we have not received any indication that a revised contract arrangement is in place. There are people present who can clarify this better than I.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

To recap, we are dealing with the accounts.

Comment on this

Deputy Rabbitte, on a point of clarification.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Was that legal advice from the Office of the Attorney General?

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

It was from the solicitors who serve as the company's solicitors, the legal advisers to the company. The Office of the Attorney General was not involved.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

The legal advice was from the solicitors to the company.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

Yes.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Does the Comptroller and Auditor General know of any contract anywhere in Europe that is similarly structured on a figure of 1.8%, irrespective of what the costs might rise to?

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

I do not. There is some resemblance to the contract in the case of the Digital Hub Company. I said in my annual report last year I concurred with the concern of the Department of Finance in relation to agreeing a contract based on a percentage of an indeterminate amount that could grow. Arguably, the more something goes over budget the more you have to pay. That did not seem to be a very good incentive for any company. Other than that, I am not aware of contracts of this nature. It is quite a novel approach to the delivery of executive services and, in many cases, may be the appropriate way to go. I have seen the delivery of executive services to State bodies for particular aspects of their activity, for example, payroll or internal audit services, that are contracted out to a services company, but this is the first of that type I have come across. I have no doubt it may well be a feature in the private sector. I do not know.

Comment on this

Is the same company involved in the delivery of executive services for Digital Hub and is the same legal interpretation put on them vis-à-vis Digital Hub?

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

The same company is involved. I cannot recall offhand the terms of the contract. I am subject to correction, but recall it was amended following concern expressed by the Department of Finance. I said in my report I shared that concern.

Comment on this

The Comptroller and Auditor General took on board the legal advice available to the company.

Comment on this

Did you see the legal advice?

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

Yes, of course. All documents were made available to my staff and, through them, to me. I saw the legal advice. It is as good as any other legal advice.

Comment on this

It was convincing.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

I am not a lawyer and do not try to evaluate the quality or quantum of legal advice given to clients.

Comment on this

Did you seek to avail of legal advice in the first instance? You sought access to that legal advice.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

I sought an assurance from the executive chairman regarding the reason the services for tender were not published in the EU Journal which, on the face of it, seemed to be a requirement. I then saw the legal advice in conjunction with the reply from the executive chairman and was satisfied to accept it.

Comment on this

Who appointed the legal advisers?

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

The legal advisers were those appointed by the company from day one.

Comment on this

How were they selected?

Comment on this

That is probably a matter for Mr. Teahon.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

They would be selected by a competitive process. Clearly, cost was a factor in that process.

Comment on this

You said in relation to the executive services that it was competitive tendering and that cost was not a factor. I find it hard to reconcile competitive tendering with cost not being a factor. Perhaps I am na13161ve in the circumstances.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Some people are getting excited about executive services versus consultancy. From my experience of the private sector, executive services are provided for people who run a company. Consultants do not run companies, they advise companies on how they might be run.

Comment on this

Nobody is getting excited. All we know is that there are procurement policies in place and what we are trying to establish is if for this new category of executive services one is deviating from normal procurement policies. We want to have clarification of this new category.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

We are dealing with the accounts. Perhaps it would be opportune for Mr. Teahon to respond at this time. He will respond later with an opening statement that addresses the current issue of controversy. Let us be clear that there is no controversy as far as the Comptroller and Auditor General is concerned about the current state of the accounts. The accounts for this organisation are well run, in order and reflect a true and fair view of what has been happening within the company. There is nothing untoward in that regard. However, on certain issues raised by the Comptroller and Auditor General Mr. Teahon may wish to have an opportunity to respond, particularly in relation to corporate governance and the representations that he made in order to improve it, the executive services contract and the increase in cost as regards the changeover in the timeframe of a five month period.

Comment on this

We will leave Mr. Teahon to reflect a little longer. I am sure he remembers the line of questioning. I am anxious to involve other members who may have similar type questions. I do not want to go back over the same issues again. If the Deputy has finished making his point I will call Deputy Bell.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I am addressing the question to Mr. Teahon.

Comment on this

I accept that. Mr. Teahon, you will answer the questions shortly. You remember the questions?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Yes.

Comment on this

I do not want to go back and forth to you all the time. I want other Deputies to ask questions. Mr. Teahon will respond to your questions, Deputy Lenihan.

Comment on this

I am sorry I am late as I was attending another function. It would appear from studying the report of the Comptroller and Auditor General which we had yesterday - to correct something that appeared in one of the national newspapers where it was suggested we did not have it at all - particularly page 9, that the opinion given in the last paragraph indicates quite clearly that as far as he is concerned, and he is the person who reports to the committee and has the expertise to deal with it, everything he examined in regard to the financial structure is in order, in accordance with the Companies Act and with law. What should be the criteria for examining this subject? The Comptroller and Auditor General is telling the committee that he found everything in order and yet we are having a debate on whether money was spent in accordance with the law. Are we questioning what the Comptroller and Auditor General is telling us? His report is quite clear. If his report is correct and accurate, which I accept it is, the only issue that remains to be answered, and it can only be answered by Mr. Teahon, is in the first paragraph and half of the second one on page 12. Will Mr. Teahon tell the committee who advised him? What company advised him? Will he name the people he hired or had as advisers who indicated that this shelf company or dormant company should be awarded the contract? Surely that is the nub of the issue. In his statement on page 12 Mr. Teahon apologises for not referring to the fact that it was a dormant company and he apologises to the Department of the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

Mr. Teahon has not made his opening statement. He will do so later and we will have questions specifically on that.

Comment on this

I want to put that on record.

Comment on this

I accept that.

Comment on this

That is the key question.

Comment on this

I know it is a key question but there are other aspects we want to tease out about the executive services. He will come back to you.

Comment on this

Could I have an answer from the Comptroller and Auditor General? Is my interpretation of his report and in particular the opinion on page 9 correct or is there any reason to doubt that?

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

There is no reason to doubt what I have written in my report. I said I stand over that. However, it has to be seen very much in the narrow context of an auditor's function in relation to a true and fair view of the figures in the account but there are special considerations that apply to State bodies in relation to the proper conduct of public business which had not fully matured at the end of December 2000 which was the date of the account on which I appended my audit report here. It is perhaps a technical point but here I am carrying out an audit on a voluntary basis as an auditor appointed under the Companies Act and not in the same sense as I would carry out an audit of the Department of Taoiseach, for example, where I would have a much more discursive type report that would touch on the kind of issues I elaborated on earlier. It is a fine point and a difficult one to grasp.

Comment on this

Are you happy that Mr. Teahon will respond shortly to your other questions?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Members should bear in mind that we have invited other Departments so they should not be afraid to digress and address specific questions to the Departments of the Taoiseach, Tourism, Sport and Recreation and the Office of Public Works.

Comment on this

I wish to clarify with the Office of Public Works the extent, if any, of direction given, requirements made, questions asked and so on and at what stage?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

During the drafting phase of the executive services contract we were asked for comment, as Departments are, even though we had no direct responsibility. We work in parallel with the various agencies and were then providing a project management service. In that context we were asked for our views on the terms of the executive services contract. We gave those. We had three headings of concern. We were concerned with the overall cost and we made that known.

Comment on this

Was Mr. Murphy aware at the time that there were consultants working alongside and that there would be separate consultants' fees?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

That was not part of our remit. We got the draft contract on a purely informal basis.

Comment on this

In respect of executive services fees only.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

That is correct. It was on a purely informal basis. We commented on cost and the items the Comptroller and Auditor General has mentioned, the exposure of Government and the clarity of the services that were being set down in the contract. Having given our comments, that was it, as far as we were concerned. We were not in at the drafting of the final version of the contract or anything like that. We had no responsibility for it. It went to the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation.

Comment on this

Who asked for your opinion on an informal basis?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Let me be accurate. I would guess, without going back on it, it was the Department of the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

The Department of the Taoiseach asked you for it and you made your recommendations and expressed your concerns.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Yes.

Comment on this

How did the Department of the Taoiseach react to the expressions of concern from the Office of Public Works?

Comment on this

Will you or one of your colleagues respond, Mr. McCarthy?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

In terms of when that would have happened, it probably would have predated the period I referred to earlier when we raised particular issues in relation to the contract. My understanding is that it was at the time that the form of the contract was being prepared which was relatively shortly after the company was established. The comments that undoubtedly were received, as Barry Murphy outlined, were taken on board by CSID rather than the Department.

Comment on this

Who in the Taoiseach's office, obviously for good and valid reasons, sought the opinion of the Office of Public Works?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

I am not in a position to answer that.

Comment on this

Would any of the officials who may pre-date you in the Department be in a position——

Comment on this

Do you know as opposed to not being in a position to answer?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

I do not know.

Comment on this

Do any of the officials with you know?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

I am afraid not.

Comment on this

You are all new to the Department of the Taoiseach.

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

Alas, no.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Office of Public Works will elaborate further on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

It was Mr. Donagh Morgan and it was 6 March 2000.

Comment on this
Mr. Morgan

Just to explain my position. I was the official at the Department of the Taoiseach at the time who was liaising with the Office of Public Works. The Government would have established Campus and Stadium Ireland shortly after its decision in January to go ahead with the Sports Campus Ireland project. I would have worked closely with the Office of Public Works with regard to advice and contract matters or any matters that we are discussing. I would have taken up any concerns with the chairman, Mr. Teahon.

Comment on this

Are you seconded to Campus and Stadium Ireland Development Limited or have you left the Department of the Taoiseach?

Comment on this
Mr. Morgan

I am on secondment.

Comment on this

At what stage was the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation involved in the compilation of the final project? At what stage was advice sought, given or offered by that Department?

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

The Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation took over responsibility for the project with effect from 1 January 2001 when provision for funding for the project was included in our Estimates. We had prior notice that the change of responsibility was taking place but by that time the contracts to which you refer were finalised and were well in place. They had come into place at the end of August or early September. We would not have been consulted on the terms of the contract prior to signature.

Comment on this

Would the Department of Finance have been alerted to the ongoing procedures?

Comment on this

We have a representative from the Department of Finance.

Comment on this
Pól Ó Duibhir

I could not comment directly on that. I am not aware if that is the case.

Comment on this

The reason I am asking is because of the magnitude and scale of the project as then envisaged. I presumed that everyone who might have a possible responsibility at some later stage would be consulted. Is that not normal practice?

Comment on this
Pól Ó Duibhir

It might be in some cases, and I am not saying this case because it is different, but it would not be necessarily in all cases.

Comment on this

Does Mr. McCarthy wish to comment?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

We had a series of discussions with the Department of Finance on accountability, governance and procedure in relation to Campus and Stadium Ireland Development Limited. We then established a project steering group as a formal entity involving the Departments of Finance and Tourism, Sport and Recreation as well as the Office of Public Works and representatives of CSID. That came into place in September 2000 but there had been discussions with the Department of Finance in advance of that, including some about the terms of the executive services contract.

Comment on this

Why does the executive services contract come up again and again? The Taoiseach's office was concerned and referred to the Office of Public Works. That office expressed concerns and the Comptroller and Auditor General has expressed concerns. The Department of Finance must have been restive when the dialogue took place. What was the reason for that continuous roundabout of concern?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

As mentioned by the Comptroller and Auditor General earlier, this was a relatively innovative way of structuring the delivery of services. That evoked a degree of interest. There was also the fact that we were dealing with a relatively new entity. It was established by Government in late January, the membership was approved in February and the first meeting was in March. We were dealing with a relatively new body as well as a new contract. It was inevitable that there would be a focus on procedures in general in the first instance and then on this as a relatively innovative arrangement.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach's office was aware of the consultants' fees and costs associated therewith and also the executive services fees. Not all agencies would have been so informed. Is that correct? Would everyone have been aware that two separate entities were running side by side? You mentioned earlier that the two were greater than their separate entities, or words to that effect.

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

There were contracts for specific services additional to the executive services contract. That is clear. Whether Departments or bodies other than us were aware of them I could not be sure. I suspect there was probably an awareness in the Office of Public Works because of the relatively close involvement at that stage in the development of the project.

Comment on this

The Office of Public Works would have been aware of the existence of two types of consultants' fees, costs and executive services fees as well.

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

I believe so as a by-product of its involvement. We had an agency agreement with the Office of Public Works at that point in relation to certain aspects of the development of——

Comment on this

Did it express concern about the existence of both?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

I am not aware that such concern was expressed. The other contracts, as I recall, were in relation to legal services and some other specific design services.

Comment on this

Mr. Murphy seemed to have indicated some expression of concern earlier and made observations arising from that concern.

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

That was in relation to the scope of the executive services contract rather than other contracts or services not comprehended by it. That was my understanding of the point made.

Comment on this

We will come back to it, Chairman.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

I was at Question Time earlier but I have since had an opportunity to look at Mr. Teahon's statement. Perhaps I should clear the air at this stage.

Comment on this

We will allow him to make his statement shortly. I want to finish these questions. I have no doubt there will be further questions following his statement.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Mr. Teahon draws attention to a question I posed on national radio. I want to make it clear that I intended no innuendo or imputation against Mr. Teahon's honesty or integrity. The question I posed was in the interrogative. In due course I intend to pose it again but not because I make any imputation against Mr. Teahon. I want to clarify that. Mr. Murphy, what were your three concerns?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

The three concerns were as I have described them. They parallel the concerns expressed by the Comptroller and Auditor General. One was the overall cost, one was the exposure of Government to further costs and one was the clarity of the job to be undertaken. It was the third one we were concerned with most as it had implications for the work of the Office of Public Works. We had the project management role and we were working in parallel with executive services in that role. We were ensuring that there was no overlap, duplication or unnecessary State expense at that time. That was our main concern.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

For how long were you working with executive services?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

We worked in parallel with executive services up to February 2001.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Why did you disengage then?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

At that stage the aquatic centre project went for planning permission. It was quite a rush to get it to that point. There was a little bit of quiet on that project and we were about to enter into the next phase which is the larger part, the stadium and other facilities. Our experience leads us to require clarity in the roles of the various people involved in anything of that scale, complexity and speed, otherwise there will be duplication and confusion. At that point we asked - this is not unusual - Campus and Stadium Ireland Development Limited to enter into a formal agreement with us on what services we would provide. We failed to reach agreement on such a contract with Campus and Stadium Ireland Limited.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Because the role that was to be defined for us was not one we could carry out with any kind of final accountability. In other words, the role had to be one we had some control of. For instance, when we do project management we would normally shape the brief. We would assemble the design team and tender documentation and run the competition. We require these elements so that when we get on-site and we have a contract and there is a price on it we can be sure we are managing something that is manageable and can be brought in on time and on budget. We could not get these elements put into the document.

Comment on this

You have a long tradition of project expertise in public works and it is well known. Were you disappointed that the Office was not used for this project?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Yes we were. It is a huge project. It is one we would have liked to do. Part of the Abbotstown project is the removal and reinstatement of the laboratories for the Department of Agriculture, Food and Rural Development, the State Laboratory and so on at Backweston. That is a project worth €200 million. It is very large and sizeable in the context and is the one on which we concentrated. In the past year we have developed our brief, brought it through planning and been out to tender. We will sign the contract within the next week or so. We had that contract to concentrate on. It is not that we were without work.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

We have established you are not redundant, Mr. Murphy.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Thank you.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Who filled your very large shoes when you pulled out?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

It was advertised by Campus and Stadium Ireland Limited. It may well be better able to speak on this but, as I understand it, it was advertised and Davis Langdon/PKS is the firm looking after the project management.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

What did you mean when you said one of your concerns was exposure of Government?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Just as the Comptroller and Auditor General has described it, that the Government could be exposed to a price for executive services that did not match the work done. The example the Comptroller and Auditor General gave was if the project were to come in luckily at half price the fee would still remain the same.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

So you think Mr. McCarthy's description of it as an innovative way of structuring delivery of services is a euphemism.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I am not sure. I am not going to speak for Mr. McCarthy.

Comment on this

Mr. McCarthy can speak for himself.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

What about the overall cost?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

This was the cost of the executive services. I believe I am right in saying the Office of Public Works has not commented on the cost of the overall project.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

If I were to ask you, would you comment?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

No because the High Point Rendel study published recently makes it clear, and we are clear on this too, that the requirement of the project is not yet clear.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

The first concern you expressed was the overall cost of the executive services contract. What was your precise concern in that regard?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Simply that it was large.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Too large, you thought?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

It seemed to be large, yes.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

What do you think now with the benefit of hindsight?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

The executive services contract is not one for which we had responsibility but maybe if I took up Mr. McCarthy's view and said perhaps we should not have been quite as innovative, as he has described it.

Comment on this