2000 Annual Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General and Appropriation Accounts: ›
Vote 10 - Office of Public Works (Resumed).
Contributions 343–511 of 511. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
Yes but to cut to the chase, you accept you made a mistake on the dormancy issue from the point of view of perception. The perception of it is unfortunate, but the reality is you have stated elsewhere you will not resign. You do not believe you have done anything wrong on that issue. It would appear that PricewaterhouseCoopers backs you on that. It does not believe it to be wrong.
Comment on this
No. It participated at every stage of the process subsequently.
Comment on this
It did not say this was wrong, we should have rectified it. We are dealing with a problem of perception of the word "dormancy," as the Chairman rightly said, by the ordinary person in the street who does not understand finance or corporate or company structure or company law. Is that not the reason for all the calumny that has been visited on you? I say "calumny" lightly.
Comment on this
I agree with what you and the Chairman say. There is a perception, but it is based on accounts in the media that were not based on full information.
Comment on this
If I could say something that is important in terms of some of what has been said. It is my judgment and it has never been put to an assessment panel - again there has been a certain innuendo in this direction - but you will recall that in saying Rohcon replaced MDC from the Netherlands the standard that our legal advisers put to us and the assessment panel was if Rohcon had presented at the outset, would it have gone through the stages and the answer of the assessment panel was "Yes, it would." It is my view that if Rohcon and Dublin Waterworld, being the people from or living in Tralee who are now there, had presented at the outset, they would have gone through the tender without involving Waterworld (UK) Limited.
Comment on this
To put the dormancy issue to bed once and for all - I hope that is not an unfortunate pun - is it the case that the other three consortia which pre-qualified in this contest also had shelf companies established? I do not know if you checked this. They may also have had dormant shelf companies which, if they had won the tender, would have been an issue.
Comment on this
As I have said, one of the consortia had a company being the operating company and it was such a company. It is in the statement.
Comment on this
You said you would deliver this project at a cost of £350 million. You stated at the height of the controversy over this project that you would stake your reputation on that figure. Do you mind if we ask on behalf of taxpayers that you not only pledge your reputation but also the fees in the contract? Is there a relationship between the cost at which your company through the executive services delivers this project and the final project cost and the fees you would earn from this project?
Comment on this
It might be useful to clarify this. I do not earn fees in relation to the executive services contract. I am not part of the executive services team. I was appointed by the Government to be the executive chairperson of Campus and Stadium Ireland Development Limited for which I receive a reasonable but small amount of money.
Comment on this
Are you confident that would be reflected if it is delivered on that figure? If it goes over it, would there be a requisite level of penalty or whatever? One of the issues, like others that have confronted us here today, is that of perception. Unfortunately, the perception is that this project is a rolling one, the figure is indeterminate and keeps rising. From the point of view of the taxpayer, there needs to be some contractual or other reassurance that if it goes over the figure of £350 million, if there is a roll-over that is not explicable, it would be reflected in the fees paid and there would be a suitable penalty imposed on the people who are tasked to deliver the project. You are one of them because you are committed to the figure of £350 million.
Comment on this
I will make three points on that. As I have stated, and as the table shows, the HPR company had a figure in its analysis under cost No. 2 in the table of £350 million which is not significantly higher than ours. It states in the report that ours is a viable estimate. What I believe strongly is that in the event that the Government at a point approved the go-ahead for the project and gave a budget to Campus and Stadium Ireland of £350 million or €445 million I would be fully satisfied that all the facilities could be put in place for that amount of money on a fully acceptable basis. That is where I am coming from. I am saying that when you look at the figures for the different facilities and compare them with the experience of similar facilities worldwide there is a sound basis for the figure of £350 million being the sum, as the table shows, for the different facilities.
Comment on this
Is the contract designed to punish an overrun of that figure? That is the key point from a taxpayer's point of view.
Comment on this
The third point - this is important from the committee's point of view - is the executive team, the lead company, Magahy and Company, made a proposal on a voluntary basis to which Margaret Hayes referred at an earlier stage that the 1.8% contract would not be pursued, that what would be put in place was a contract that would specify what were called charge out rates by the number of people involved and the amount of time that they would put into the project, in other words, a different contract, but fully transparent in terms of some of the criticisms that have been made.
Comment on this
It was made some months ago. It has been considered by the finance and audit committee of CSID. As Margaret Hayes said, it now falls to be finalised by the board. Clearly, there is no problem from the side of the executive services team because it proposed it voluntarily. It is complicated by the fact that the executive services team made a second proposal which is that it would work for a number of months in this period to, let us say, the end of May this year for 75% of the costs, in other words, to take account of the position in which we now find ourselves that the project is not going ahead. The board will consider in the next short while and reach a definitive conclusion on both propositions and will then put them to the Department for agreement.
Comment on this
Did that renegotiation come as a result of your initiative or that of Margaret Hayes and the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation?
Comment on this
Neither. It came at the initiative of the executive services team lead company. It is concerned at some of what is being said in the media that somehow there is a large and wrong amount of money being paid. It felt that it was very important that there should be something that was clear, transparent and readily understood by anyone looking at it.
As regards the figure of 1.8% - this relates to what was said earlier - percentage amounts are not unknown in projects. Architects and so on can be paid on a percentage basis. It may well be that people would say this is not equivalent, but it is not unknown. There could be a significant advantage in a 1.8% contract for a particular amount of time. In other words, the figure of 1.8% applied in a situation where the executive services team had to guarantee that it would provide these services irrespective of the length of time of the project. The predication was that it would take five years, but if it took ten years, it would still have to provide all the services for those ten years for 1.8%. That has never been referred to. It may be that if people had considered it, they would still have concerns. There were circumstances in which if there was a time overrun, one of the issues on which HPR is very strong, the figure of 1.8% would still apply, in other words, you have to have a certain number of people who cost a certain amount of money on an annual basis. If you have to provide this for ten rather than five years, you could end up making a significant loss in certain circumstances relative to the figure of 1.8%. I accept that in putting the proposal the lead company of the executive services team believed that it was preferable on all counts that what would be in place was a contract that would specify these charge out amounts for particular individuals, clearly identifiable, for particular amounts of time they would put into the project.
Comment on this
I have an unavoidable commitment. I do not want to leave the meeting, but I cannot avoid it now. How do you intend to proceed and for how long? I have been a member of this committee since 1989 with a break during the rainbow Government and there was a time when we proceeded by way of question. We did so for many years. I have to say about my constituency colleague and dear friend, Deputy Lenihan, that I sincerely hope he is successful in the general election because if he had to go to the bar to make a living, he would be in very great difficulty.
Comment on this
We will leave the constituency to them. Could we have a direction on what we are doing as regards time?
Comment on this
That would have been an appropriate place to be. We have not put anything to bed. We are still asking questions. The only issue we have put to bed is that nobody on this committee challenges Mr. Teahon's honesty. We have not put dormancy or competence or contracts to bed. Could we have a copy of the contract before we renew, Chairman?
Comment on this
In fairness, I should ask the executive services team. I would have thought what would be useful would be not just the contract that exists but the contract that will be put in place very shortly.
Comment on this
The Deputy asked me what way I intended to proceed. I was allowing Mr. Teahon to tease out questions. We are meeting in a vacuum. When this meeting was originally scheduled we anticipated that the Attorney General's report would be with the Cabinet and we would have access to it and could proceed with our discussions accordingly. On the basis of what the Tánaiste indicated in the Dáil this morning, the report will be available tomorrow. I hope it will be accessible to the committee in the morning. It is my intention to resume this session tomorrow at 12 o'clock. In teasing out the parameter questions about the executive services and the accounts for Campus and Stadium Ireland Development Limited we will get down to the issues raised within Mr. Teahon's opening statement and the Attorney General's report. We will be able to conclude accordingly. I do not see us finalising the debate this evening. I ask the Secretary Generals of the Departments to be on standby for a meeting tomorrow at 12 o'clock. If we do not have the report, we will suspend and indicate the time at which we will meet in the afternoon. I am anxious to have the issue finalised by the committee tomorrow evening rather than return to the topic next week. I know I had the agreement of members to my original suggestion at the beginning of the meeting.
Comment on this
I do not intend to proceed much longer. I will allow members to ask opening questions. We will return to it tomorrow. Mr. Teahon's statement and the Attorney General's report will help us to put the pieces of the jigsaw together better.
Comment on this
Chairman, before you close on that subject you should be aware that the Attorney General has issued a draft of his report to the principals referred to in the report and given them until noon tomorrow to give comments and views. I doubt, therefore, if he will be in a position to finalise his report and have it available to the committee tomorrow morning, certainly not in time to facilitate consideration of it tomorrow afternoon.
Comment on this
I suggest you consult the Office of the Attorney General. I do not know when exactly they intend to finalise, but the principals have been given until noon tomorrow. I presume, therefore, he does not intend finalising until he receives those comments and has considered them.
Comment on this
In the light of the Tánaiste's remark today that it will be published tomorrow and Ms Hayes's remarks now, is it awkward for colleagues who are not Dublin based to meet at 5 p.m. tomorrow?
Comment on this
It is fairly certain from what Ms Hayes has said that we will not have had an opportunity to see the report by 12 noon tomorrow.
Comment on this
It is unrealistic to expect to have it by 3 p.m. If they have been given until 12 noon to respond, the best we can hope for is somewhere in the region of 4 p.m. or 5 p.m.
Comment on this
We will set the time provisionally for 4 p.m. tomorrow in anticipation that we will have the report. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
In view of what the Chairman said I will reserve further comment. I agree with Mr. Teahon when he said that if it had not been for the fact that he made a mistake, we might not be here. That clears up that element of it and I am glad it has been put on the record. There is much disquiet because of it, as has been stated. The dormant company was not raised by Members of the Oireachtas but by the media. The first I knew of it was when I read it in the national press. It was very difficult for the general public to understand how a dormant company - as far as they were concerned it meant a non-existing company - could get a contract of this magnitude. Are you satisfied that the companies which have given the guarantee within the consortium are capable of completing the project on time and will do so within the funding allocated?
Comment on this
Let me give the background. The Government instructed my Department to carry out an independent cost overview of the projected cost of the stadium and gave us a certain set of criteria. We established a steering group which oversaw a public procurement process where we advertised internationally for consultants, received a number of bids and——
Comment on this
In my judgment, it got it wrong because it did not understand the sunken bowl concept put forward by our project managers. The fact that it is an independent company does not mean it cannot get something wrong. I am fully satisfied and have gone into the matter in a significant way. It is not a simple idea. Normally, a sunken bowl means you have a pitch at a lower level than normal ground level. What our people are suggesting is, not that you would sink the pitch down, but rather that having the pitch at ground level you would then build up the outside. That is where communication between our project managers and HPR went astray. It refers in that context to sliding out the pitch which is one of the things stadia do internationally. If you have sunk the pitch and want to slide it out, you must excavate a large amount. By building up the outside and having the bowl in that sense you can slide out the pitch at ground level. When it looked at the issue of sliding out the pitch and said we had a real problem I was satisfied it did not understand what our project managers were talking about.
Comment on this
Why should the cost of relocating the laboratories not be taken into account? Is that not a real cost of the project? If you have to relocate very expensive buildings, as was said earlier, why should that not be taken as a cost?
Comment on this
I will address that question and perhaps Barry Murphy will add to it. All I said was that HPR in its report said it should not be taken into account.
Comment on this
Why should it not be taken into account because it will be part of the cost if it ever gets out of the limbo in which the Comptroller and Auditor General has put it? I accept Mr. Teahon's regret that he did not clearly say to the panel and to the Department of the Taoiseach that the company had been found to be dormant. From my judgment of Mr. Teahon and from the very well presented report here today, he is a man who chooses his words carefully. He is good with words. I know Mr. Teahon has admitted the error but it does not ring true to me from the presentation made today. Deputy Rabbitte is well capable of dealing with this himself tomorrow but when Mr. Teahon was referring to innuendo he said "and some other people involved". Being a very sensitive person, for a while I thought he was looking at me. We had better be very careful about using the word "innuendo". I do not think anyone on this committee has made any such suggestions. In case the press or anybody else would get the impression that Mr. Teahon was talking about me because I was the person addressing the question at the time or any other member of the committee, it should be made clear that I have said nothing that would indicate that it was me, when Mr. Teahon spoke about some others involved in adverse comments as well.
Comment on this
If I believed any other Deputy in the committee had made such a statement I would have referred to it. I am making it clear that I was not referring to any other Deputy. We should be honest with each other. People here know that there were two programmes on national radio and television where these statements were made in what was not in any sense an acceptable form. Both of them suggested that people from Tralee and from Kerry could not be expected to run significant aquatic centres. That is completely wrong.
Comment on this
People in the constituency raise the issue of the "Bertie bowl". They do not realise that there is an arena, a multi-purpose hall, outdoor pitches, tennis centre, golf academy, etc. It is very important that all of what I hope, will be provided is made clear to the public.
Comment on this
I accept that perhaps we have not been able to communicate as strongly as I would have liked. I have attempted to do it on every occasion I have been interviewed. I genuinely believe that the campus we can put in place is what Ireland deserves as a country and what our sports people want. When it is put in place, as I trust it will be, it will be a world class campus that will compare with anything in the world. That is the standard that as Irish people we should seek to attain. We should not be prepared to say that somehow if it is people from Tralee it cannot be world class. As a country we should set out to achieve world class facilities and I believe we can do so.
Comment on this
I am glad to hear Mr. Teahon use that phrase because one of the parties has adopted that as their slogan. It wants health care and various other issues to be of the highest possible standard, and that is only right. I received two pages of correspondence signed by a number of sporting organisations. How many of the national sporting organisations support the concept of the stadium?
Comment on this
All the relevant organisations. Donagh Morgan tells me 45 in total.
Comment on this
I was saying 37. That is important. There was some "argy-bargy" between constituency colleagues but we need to get real. This project is intensely political. For different reasons members have taken sides for or against this concept. I hope after May, it may all change. People will have different views across the House but our job is slightly different here.
Comment on this
The Deputy will know soon enough. He might not know now but he will know then. Whatever our views on the complex, our job is to examine the value for money and financial aspects of it. It is critical to spell that out. If we took a stand and tried to either justify the building of it or knock it we would not be doing justice to our role. People have made a judgment, particularly in regard to the aquatic centre, based very much on one-sided arguments. I welcome Mr. Teahon's contribution. Others have said they accept his credentials and record. I am glad he held up his hands and said mea culpa from the outset. To a lay person it was a major error not to notify people of this and I am glad he explained it. PricewaterhouseCoopers carried out 13 company searches. Is it standard practice when awarding a contract to do a company search?
Comment on this
It would have happened anyway. Nothing was concealed. You were not hiding a shelf company. People were being carried away in talking about islands and where you have all this money. Can the consortium deliver on the project? I heard a journalist on one of the radio programmes, say that believe it or not, the expertise on swimming happened to be in Tralee. As an Irish person I found that very hard to take. It shows an inferiority complex on the part of those making the comments.
Comment on this
All I would add is that we had an international expert, Kit Campbell, from Scotland who is an international expert on this front to advise the assessment panel. It was his judgment that the people from Tralee came highly respected in the field.
Comment on this
Have you any idea of the percentage cost of the sunken bowl? Is it £10 million, £20 million or £40 million?
Comment on this
It could be as high as £100 million. It is very significant. In effect most of these stadia operate on rings or layers. By building up the first layer one could save as much as £100 million. Because of the way in which we are doing it, it may be that they did not include as much as £100 million but some figures that I have seen suggest that it could be that high. If one looks at the table, it could explain the difference between the two figures.
Comment on this
That is the kind of information both we and the public need. We have not had that until now. We can get involved on the technical aspects and be side-tracked by Waterworld UK and so on. I would be concerned that the project would fall for the wrong reasons. I have been a member of this committee on and off since 1987 and I have seldom seen people of your standing from any Department come here and say they will put their career and record on the line and stand over this figure and deliver. I take it you will stand over the figure you have given. With that in mind, why is there such great disparity between the figures? The first HPR figure is near your own, the second one you explain is because of the sunken bowl but where did the figure of €1 billion that is usually thrown about by the Opposition come from? Such a figure frightens the public.
Comment on this
In fairness to HPR, consultants in their situation tend to err on the side of covering themselves and put in a higher figure. One of the ironies is that, in a different situation, when HPR put in a higher figure I can say this is good, because if I believe it can be delivered for £350 million and HPR put in a figure of £550 million and if the Government gives £550 million, then I have a very easy task. I am not suggesting that delivering it for £350 million at 2001 prices is easy. It is not. It will be very difficult. We will have to be very focused on delivering value for money. In the same way when the three original aquatic centre bids came in, the range between the lowest and highest was £20 million. We were not talking about one figure being £50 million and the next being £52 million and next being £54 million. We were talking about a range of £20 million. I believe it will be delivered on budget. If the committee sees fit to accept the invitation I offered, it could see for itself. It is significantly advanced now and will be a great national aquatic centre and wonderful for the Special Olympics.
Comment on this
People are confused. On 25 August the initial examinations were assessed by CSID and Office of Public Works personnel. At that stage they were all working together. It would now appear that the Department of the Taoiseach, the Office of Public Works and your organisation are working separately. At what point were personnel from the Office of Public Works no longer involved? Together with you they carried out the initial assessment of the eight consortia.
Comment on this
I was reading from your report which is why I took that aspect, but perhaps Mr. Murphy——
Comment on this
We decided to assume the role of adviser to the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation in February-March because of our inability to reach agreement with CSID on a working arrangement.
Comment on this
In any large project that we do for an external client we have an agreement on what are our range of activities and responsibilities. In January 2001 we started a process during the down phase, if you like, when the aquatic centre had gone for planning permission and before we entered into the larger phase of the stadium. We raised the question then - we had always known it was a question to be raised - of the kind of agreement there would be between Office of Public Works and CSID. The agreement we wanted was the same type of agreement that we had used in many other cases. It was not anything new or different but we failed to come to an agreement with CSID on a division of work.
Comment on this
I was very disappointed we were not able to reach such an agreement. I very much value the contribution Sean Benton made, and I have said this publicly before so I am just repeating what I said previously. It was invaluable. He is now a member of the board of CSID. This was considered at a meeting that Barry Murphy and I attended with Margaret Hayes and which was chaired by the Minister for Finance. The outcome of that meeting was that we in CSID should take on project managers by open tender which is how DL/PKS came on board and that Office of Public Works should act as technical advisers to the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation. That is the reality. I was disappointed, and I want this to be known, that we could not come to an agreement between ourselves and Office of Public Works because I valued very much the work that had been done up to then by Office of Public Works as project managers.
Comment on this
This building will stand as a monument to Sean Benton and his colleagues and the Office of Public Works, Mr. Murphy and others. The sunken pitch is——
Comment on this
Mr. Teahon has a marvellous reputation for getting things done and was involved in the North and elsewhere. It is unfortunate that this has cropped up. He likes to get things done and I do not believe he would have much patience with people who want to go the slow slogging way. Was it because of the anxiety to get things done that Office of Public Works found it hard to keep up to the pace?
Comment on this
I will praise you again if you give me half a chance. Mr. Teahon, the phrase "cutting corners" has been used. There are systems laid down and we are here to ensure they are adhered to. Was there any conflict surrounding the approach to getting the job done? You had a very specific and one of the tightest targets ever set to have this project gone to tender six days after the announcement. You sent a notice of contract to Europe. That is unheard of. It is unprecedented. I am trying to find out the genesis of the split between the Office of Public Works and your organisation.
Comment on this
We would not have got where we did in December in terms of getting this project to planning permission stage were it not for the work of Sean Benton and his colleagues in Office of Public Works. There is no suggestion other than at all times they worked in the fullest possible way with us. I am disappointed that it was not possible to reach agreement in taking it forward in that way. To this day I do not fully understand why that was not the case. It was not that it came from our side, in other words that we were saying that in terms of corporate governance we must have an arrangement that makes sense in terms of the company. I believe Barry Murphy, his colleagues and the Minister, Deputy Cullen, who was involved in that meeting made the judgment given their experience of how they dealt with projects, that they did not believe they could be part of such an arrangement. As I said, I was very disappointed. The judgment in the end was not made by me or by Barry Murphy. It was made ultimately by the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy.
Comment on this
There were some comments made when I raised the question of division and so on. If Mr. Teahon cannot understand why there was division and why they did not proceed together surely I am entitled to question that. I have put on the record over and over again my praise of Office of Public Works, the new era of Office of Public Works. I am asking why they did not proceed together and Mr. Teahon, as one of the senior witnesses, says he does not understand why they did not do so. We will find out the reasons there were difficulties. He made a fair comment earlier that if he had mentioned it was a dormant company he would not be here. I want to know why we have difficulties and where we are at and if I offend somebody in asking those questions, so be it. We are offended every day of the week and no one has any sympathy for us or protests in any way.
Comment on this
I acknowledge that Deputy Dennehy has always been very fair to the Office of Public Works but I thought that slagging off the Office of Public Works at a particular point was something that had been put to bed. It was not a question of one meeting. We had many weeks of discussions and documentation between ourselves and CSID and still could not come to an agreement. We have come to an agreement with every other company or client with whom we have done business but not with this client. When Deputies read the papers they will see the reasons.
Comment on this
I am asking for that too, Mr. Murphy. We will be here tomorrow and when the meeting finishes I will have a four hour drive to Cork but I will remain to hear the evidence. I would prefer to hear it now from you. We are here to get information. I am not slagging you off. I believe people must have a slow methodical approach at times.
Comment on this
I do not mind you using the words "slow" and "steady". All I tell you is that over the past ten years we have stopped being slow but we are steady and we offer compliance with all the EU and Government regulations and so on. We are in no way slow. We would have brought this project to the same pitch ourselves and at the same speed. There would be no problem with that. We would like to bring the stadium project forward in the same way. If you are asking me for a reason for not coming to an agreement, we were being asked to take responsibility for the project at a particular stage where we would not have had an input into the ingredients that made up that project so we simply could not be accountable for the end product. Not being in charge of ourselves at the key phases was something we could not allow happen to us.
Comment on this
It is important to bear in mind that there was another side to this discussion. As early as January when we were gearing up to take over responsibility for the project I identified a need for access to technical support for the Department. We were a Department that did not have a track record in managing projects of this scale and I was most anxious to build up the back up support. I spoke to the Department of Finance independently of any discussions ongoing between Office of Public Works and CSID and said I would either have to go out to the market and recruit expert advice, architectural, quantity surveying, engineering and so on to assist us in monitoring and overseeing this project or take on board the advice and client arrangement with someone such as Office of Public Works. What was Paddy's loss was my Department's and our Minister's gain and we have received a very efficient, independent and professional service from Office of Public Works. It was not just a question of the situation between Office of Public Works and CSID. The Minister for Finance had also to decide what was the best way of providing technical support to the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation, just to put the entire subject in context.
Comment on this
The contract specifies that the operator will be in place subject to satisfactory performance for a 30 year period.
Comment on this
Some commentators have said that is a long time. I do not know whether it is long or short in this type of operation.
Comment on this
It would not be unusual to have a 30 year lease for a facility of this kind where you wanted operation into the future.
Comment on this
I have no difficulty with Kerry men. I admire them. Some of my best friends are Kerry men. My brother-in-law is a Kerry man and we have managed to co-exist for several years. I have always admired their prowess both on and off the field.
Comment on this
I have never known Kerry men to be sensitive. What worries me is that I appear to be chided in some of the remarks made by Mr. Teahon. I know him to be a highly respected public servant with an excellent track record but I would not like anyone, Kerry man or other, to feel they could soften us up before the match starts with a couple of public warnings to the effect that in some way someone associated with the committee had made allegations that were wide of the mark. This committee will do its job at all times, regardless of what it is, within the parameters laid down.
I am concerned about a few matters. Mr. Teahon's loss was the Department's gain but I still do not know exactly why it was not possible for the great minds to meet on what is a laudable project. I have no hesitation in saying the stadium project is laudable and the accommodation of the Special Olympics is a highly laudable project. In the scheme of things, we have to make decisions and choices. Other people made that decision. I do not think it appropriate we should be told by anybody before the committee the merit or otherwise of the project. That is not our function. I will set down a few parameters before we start. For instance, it would be great if we did not have hospital waiting lists and we should aspire to that but we do not do so. It would be great if we did not have housing lists. We should aspire to that too but we do not. In the scheme of things we balance one against the other and do the best we can. We set our priorities. When we are asked to examine something that is contentious for one reason or another, people outside this room ask questions. The Comptroller and Auditor General asked questions about the procedures being pursued. The Office of Public Works in its innermost heart has had some little concerns and did not come to an arrangement in the usual fashion. The Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation had some concerns and was not happy. If all these people have shown some degree of unease or unrest, it is quite legitimate for this committee to ask whatever questions are necessary, including hard questions.
On the Order of Business this morning the Tánaiste said: "We now know that on four different occasions the Government was not given the information at the time it requested appropriate information and that is my concern". That was not a newspaper but a senior Cabinet Minister. The Tánaiste also said: "The Chairman of CSID has already said he did not inform his board nor did he inform anyone else". I will deal with that later. That is not a wild allegation made by a newspaper editor looking for a good headline. That is the Tánaiste speaking. She also said in reply to another question:
It is no secret that I have had concerns about this matter for quite some time. That is why we had HPR evaluate this project. The HPR report reaches some serious conclusions which we should all take on board.
In reply to questions from Deputies Noonan and Quinn, leaders of their respective parties, the Tánaiste said:
My concerns relate to the fact that appropriate processes and procedures were not in place for the expenditure of huge sums of public money. This was a 30 year contract awarded to a company which had no trading record, which was a requirement. When the Government made decisions in this matter it did not have the full information that the Government was entitled to.
We should set the scene against a different background from the one we have had so far. Those queries raised by the most senior Government Minister after the Taoiseach require to be addressed by all bodies concerned without any hesitation. We need to know the answers sooner rather than later. It is not sufficient to say someone on a radio or television programme made allegations or innuendo. We can only go on what we have before us. What I quoted is taken from the blacks of the transcript of this morning's Order of Business. Perhaps Mr. Teahon might comment on that.
Comment on this
I do not believe it would be appropriate for me to enter into some form of debate with the Tánaiste through the committee. I attempted in what I said here to explain the situation as far as I am concerned. I have no problem in accepting, and I did accept, that if I had explained the position fully to the board, the Department and the panel, many if not all of the concerns that have arisen could have been avoided. In that sense when the Tánaiste said I had not told the Department of the Taoiseach at the time, and through it the Government, I fully accept that. I believe, as I have said today, that we did not contract with Waterworld UK. We contracted with a consortium that includes Rohcon Limited, Dublin Waterworld Ltd. and Waterworld UK. I have equally said today that in my judgment if we had been faced at the outset with a consortium that included Rohcon Ltd. and Dublin Waterworld Ltd. being the company that it is with the shareholders as they are, we would have let them through all the different stages of the competition.
I fully appreciate that the Tánaiste has concerns and that Deputies here will have concerns. What I was trying to do today was respond to those. To a significant extent I would categorise those concerns. You suggested there is a perception that we contracted with a shelf dormant company. I do not believe that is accurate. We did not contract with a shelf dormant company on its own. We contracted with a very significant construction company, Rohcon, and in the same consortium a company that an international expert, Kit Campbell, from Scotland said - he was not saying they were the best in the world - by comparison with the other companies was the best operators available to us. He said it had a very significant reputation in its field. I believe it does. I am not sure if that responds to the concerns that Deputy Durkan expressed at the Tánaiste's words.
Comment on this
It does not. I am still concerned. Page 9 of Mr. Teahon's statement says:
Meanwhile CSID commissioned PricewaterhouseCoopers to carry out a detailed review of the many different companies involved in all of the bidding consortia.
I will come back to the procedure and operation of a site in a project of that size.
These searches were commenced on 22 November 2000 and inquired into 13 different companies altogether. They were carried out in advance of entering a contract with whomsoever would emerge as the preferred bidder. . . . .
That was a good safe procedure. They would check them out beforehand and test their viability and standing.
The issue that was notified to us by PricewaterhouseCoopers on 18 December was that Waterworld UK was a dormant company.
That was said by PricewaterhouseCoopers, not a newspaper, as a result of instructions received to assess the viability of the companies before the board.
In my judgment what one looks for in such cases is adequate evidence of the bona fides, capabilities and financial strength of the people involved in the company.
The next step was to find out who were the principals in the company, what they were and how they stood up. PricewaterhouseCoopers were concerned about it and brought it to the attention of the principals of CSID.
I did not explicitly bring the word "dormant" to the assessment panel's attention because I regarded the issue that I would have to deal with was that of financial standing. The panel's brief was to determine the quality of the bids rather than their financial standing. I did, however, tell the panel - and I believe this is what was important - that there was a funding issue with this bid which would have to be dealt with.
It would appear that the Tánaiste's concern is she was not in possession of all the information that would be required of a Minister. Many Members will be conversant with the brief that is normally sent to Cabinet. A brief is sent to Cabinet by the sponsoring Minister or Ministers, as the case may be, and it is supposed to contain all the information setting out the pros and cons and carries with it the remarks of other Departments. That is how the system works. I have had the privilege of sitting at such meetings a few times.
Mr. Teahon said: "I did not explicitly bring the word "dormant" to the assessment panel's attention", yet the word "dormant" was used presumably by PricewaterhouseCoopers in its report. Why was it not brought to the attention of the panel? Surely it was a major item which could set the project at nought were something to go wrong. Mr. Teahon qualified the procedure by saying that was a financing issue that would have to be dealt with. I appreciate the need for speed and efficiency but this is a big project. With any big project there is a requirement to ensure that as well as speed there is consistency and safety. Is that not correct?
Comment on this
No. That is why on 19 December we sent a letter to the Waterworld UK consortium saying how we believed they should deal with the issue. There was no delay in addressing the consequence of dormancy.
Comment on this
Suppose they could not deal with the issue. You had no way of knowing they could not deal with it at that time.
Comment on this
Correct, and we said to them that we were not confirming them as the preferred bidder unless they satisfied us of this. We also wrote on the same day to the other two bidders and asked them to keep their bids open. That was a clear indication that there was a possibility that the person who may be becoming the preferred bidder may not be able to deliver. If, in effect what had happened was we went through the process and the consortium - I come back to the point that it is the consortium that has to deliver on financial standing in the end - had not been able to deliver we would not have confirmed it as the preferred bidder.
Comment on this
Did you consider, in view of your long experience as a senior civil servant, that in the proposals sent to Cabinet for Government approval at that critical stage all queries had been dealt with to your satisfaction?
Comment on this
I was satisfied that I had put in place a process that would lead to those being dealt with. I am absolutely satisfied. Looking back on it, I remain satisfied of that. Other than what I have said, in the event that I could replay my life, I would tell fully the panel, the board and the Department of the Taoiseach all that I was putting in place, I would not change one other single thing about what I did.
Comment on this
As an experienced senior civil servant I have no doubt you took into account the PricewaterhouseCoopers' reservations and comments. Given the magnitude of the project did you contact the Department of the Taoiseach and alert it to the fact that there was a difficulty that could present at a later stage and that it has been identified by PricewaterhouseCoopers? Did you look for instructions?
Comment on this
I did not do any of those things. My statement says that. I made it clear that I did not tell the Department of the Taoiseach what I was doing. That is on page 12 of the statement.
Comment on this
Are you aware of the seriousness of sending a submission to Cabinet, having regard to the financial implications of a project of this size, in the knowledge that the necessary requirements had not been complied with and you were presuming to hope that at some stage they would be complied with? The project having gone to Cabinet for Government approval, the single most important step in any such project, did you not regard it as a serious matter that, given the information you had at your disposal based on the PricewaterhouseCoopers' report, you did not think it worthwhile to telephone the Department of the Taoiseach and say there is a problem, we are informed we are dealing with a dormant company and will have to defer or take certain action. Did you not do that?
Comment on this
No. I put in place a process as in the letter. In the event that the consortium in question was not able to satisfy the requirements I was satisfied I could have gone to the next bidder.
Comment on this
Did you anticipate the embarrassment of a Minister bringing such a project before Cabinet in the event of anything going wrong?
Comment on this
Did you anticipate that the Minister would be embarrassed if it should happen that everything did not stand up because the project was a multi-million pound one? As an experienced senior civil servant you would not have considered it embarrassing in the event the project blew up, given the information you had at your disposal and that the Government was about to give its approval and there could be a liability for public money at some later stage?
Comment on this
The issue of liability for public money did not arise then or now. What arose, as I said in my statement and I regret the embarrassment as well, was I did not explain the position fully to the Department of the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
Did you explain the position at all to the Department of the Taoiseach in the wake of the PricewaterhouseCoopers' report?
Comment on this
So you knowingly withheld information you had on the project from the Department of the Taoiseach. I am surprised at that.
Comment on this
No, I am not saying that. In fairness I do not recollect what I did or did not say. For example, when this issue first arose in The Irish Times I did not recollect what I had said at the assessment panel. I became aware of what I said at the assessment panel from a note that PricewaterhouseCoopers brought to my attention. So I was not aware. When this issue broke, I was, the same as other people, concerned about it, more immediately because I was the executive chairperson. I did not recollect what I had said at the assessment panel.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach was handed the package to bring to Cabinet for approval. He was the promoting Minister at Cabinet. Can you explain, as a good and reliable senior public and civil servant, how you withheld information from the most senior Cabinet Minister, the most senior Member of the Executive, given the importance of the project to the country as stated by you and as the Taoiseach has often indicated? Are you saying you did not tell him there was a probable financial difficulty with one of the companies concerned and let him walk into the Cabinet meeting oblivious of the true position?
Comment on this
I am saying very clearly that I did not knowingly withhold information. I am saying clearly here today that I did not explain the position fully and I regret not having done so.
Comment on this
I find it very difficult to understand. There are a number of senior civil servants in this chamber at present all of whom know the consequences of failing to bring to the attention of their Minister, the Taoiseach or Tánaiste, reservations that they, their Department or any other agency might have. There must have been some reason for this. Did you believe PricewaterhouseCoopers' report was not sufficiently well based? Did you discuss the report with the Office of Pubic Works or the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation prior to going to Cabinet, two offices that would have an ongoing interest in the subject matter?
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, Sean Benton who is here today was a member of the assessment panel and heard what I said. I am not saying he had any responsibility but you asked me a question.
Comment on this
I am sorry to interrupt, Chairman, but I must intervene here. The information was withheld from us too. It is a fact to say that Sean Benton was on the assessment panel. It does not follow that he had the information. He did not have the information. I object to the insinuation that is being made.
Comment on this
He could not have because he said already that the assessment panel was not told. He apologised for not giving the assessment panel the information.
Comment on this
Chairman, let me follow on with my questions. I thank Deputy Lenihan for his assistance and will call upon him in due course. I mentioned two Departments and asked to what extent you conferred with them as they might have a possible involvement, responsibility or custody of a similar project either at that or some other stage down the road.
To what extent did you alert either Department about the existence of difficulties as pointed out by PricewaterhouseCoopers?
Comment on this
I accept what Barry Murphy has said. I am not trying to say Sean Benton had the PricewaterhouseCoopers information. He did not.
Comment on this
He did not. There was another document that was produced by Kit Campbell who made a presentation at the meeting. Sean Benton did not have that either. I am making that very clear.
Comment on this
How many documents were there that could have been useful and material to the making of a decision in support or otherwise by three Departments, the Department of the Taoiseach, the Department of Finance and the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation?
Comment on this
I believe, Deputy, that you have to make a distinction between the use that would have been made of documents and people being aware of them.
Comment on this
Please, if you ask a question you should allow me to finish the reply. I believe that the action that was put in place on foot of the information in these documents was the correct action.
Comment on this
I hate to labour this but it is our job to get answers. If the information is presented to us in a particular fashion we do our best but if we cannot get answers that are reasonably plausible we must ask more questions. You are aware of the reservations expressed by PricewaterhouseCoopers. You were aware that the Taoiseach, the most senior Government executive, was going to Cabinet with a proposal which required approval and you were aware there were two other Departments that could perhaps have an involvement and you said to them, "I am sorry I did not indicate there was a financial problem". There was another report produced by Mr. Campbell. That information was not available to him and his information was not available to the other Departments
Comment on this
He did. Chairman, I do not believe we will finish this tonight. In a major project such as this - you mentioned, Mr. Teahon, that it was a consortium made up of a number of individual companies that would have to carry it - there are companies that specialise in co-ordinating activities on a project, on a building site, through the whole financial evaluation, the management of the site and all aspects of the work from start to finish. They claim to be experts in that area. They also claim to be able to reduce the overall costs by ensuring people do not cut corners or endanger the project and that good value for money is given. Was any consideration given to the employment of such a concern on a project of this size?
Comment on this
Yes, the company we had employed as project managers, Davis Langdon/PKS, is providing project management to CSID in relation to the contract being carried out by the consortium.
Comment on this
I do not want to make any specific comment on the issue under discussion, though I cannot but say I was not in a tizzy about that matter. My concerns were those I outlined at the outset. On the basis of the earlier discussion there seems to be general agreement that the corporate governance framework for the company needs to be strengthened or developed. That was signalled as far back as the middle of last year when the heads of a Bill to set up the company on a statutory footing were put forward and considered.
I made an adverse comment about the nature of the executive services contract. Through my office, I expressed those reservations as far back as last May. I am happy to hear the executive chairman say these matters are being looked at. I was informed last June that they were being revised. I note that they have not been revised yet but I am gratified to hear that they are being revised in two respects, on the percentage of the total development cost and that there is some quid pro quo for the scaling down of the activity of executive services in this period of limbo, though I will try to avoid religious metaphors.
The last point is one worth revisiting. As regards the memo that went to Government on 11 July 2000 setting out the basis for a maximum cost of £30 million to the Exchequer for the provision of this very desirable facility, I spoke earlier about the reliability of information on which Government can make decisions. In this case the information given to Government on which to base this decision envisaged an income stream from the operation of the facility of a lower range of £472,000 a year to an upper range of £2,129,000 a year. I think I heard the executive chairman mention a realisable figure, the current best realisable figure, of £100,000 a year. I said on many occasions in this forum that when a Government makes a decision it should be in possession of the best possible information in order to make a judgment. We are talking about priorities in spending and so on. That is worth considering, with hindsight of course. We are not talking about huge increases in inflation as is often the case when talking about an increase in cost to the Exchequer. Here we are talking about an estimate produced by experts which was so far wide of the mark that it means we are talking about a capital contribution of probably £50 million as against a maximum of £30 million. When the dust settles on all this maybe we can revisit that as a general point and one that is applicable not only in the context of the aquatic and leisure centre but across the board.
Comment on this
I wish to make a comment and will return to this at the next meeting.
Comment on this
One of the reasons - I will produce the figures at the next meeting if you wish me to come back - for the difference between the £30 million and £48.4 million is there is provision for a very significant amount by way of public policy requirement of what, in effect, are free hours in terms of the operator. I cannot remember the figure at present but it is very significant. It is millions of pounds. You have to make the judgment and the simplest way is for me to bring back the different figures and say they operate a surplus of £100,000, these are the number of hours the operator has to provide free by comparison with the PricewaterhouseCoopers assessment which was that the operator would charge for all the hours. I do not think it bridges the gap between £100,000 and £400,000, but it goes some way toward doing so.
Comment on this
In the note to Cabinet there would have been observations from other Departments. There should have been observations from the Office of Public Works but there were not because it had no involvement as it could not reach an agreement on the operation of the project.
Comment on this
Sorry, Deputy. We are talking about two different situations.
Comment on this
The Office of Public Works was involved at the time the Comptroller and Auditor General is speaking about. This was the initial decision.
Comment on this
We have been discussing this for more than four hours. I thank the Secretaries General of the Departments, Mr. Teahon and their staff. I understand the Attorney General, as Margaret Hayes has stated, will be finalising his report and hopes to have it by lunchtime tomorrow. It will then be delivered to the Government secretariat. We are depending on the Government secretariat to make the report available to members of the committee. We will recommence this session at 4 p.m. tomorrow. Hopefully we will have the report of the Attorney General at that stage and will be able to finalise this issue. Thank you.
The witnesses withdrew.