We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE of PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

2000 Annual Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General and Appropriation Accounts: ›

Vote 10 - Office of Public Works (Resumed).

Contributions 226–443 of 443. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Mr. Murphy

On a point of clarification, I would hope that an assessment panel recommendation normally would be well made but the assessment panel normally only deals with certain elements. In other words, the decision on the overall matter, in this case, would be for the chief executive and it would take into account more than just the recommendation of the assessment panel.

Comment on this

Deputy I will allow you one final short question.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

The final question relates to Annex I, Annex J and Annex K in the Attorney General's report, which are principally memos from an Aidan Walsh, who, I presume, is employed by PricewaterhouseCoopers. This includes statements to the effect that Laura Magahy of Magahy and Company raised issues about the lack of clarity in what was being proposed by Waterworld. It also says that this Mr. Walsh highlighted to an Una Carmody the view that the Waterworld and Dial proposals were very thin on the operating side as they did not have P & L and cash flow projections for the length of the concession contract and they did not say how they would finance the operating part of the business. They also point out inter alia that Waterworld UK Limited is a £2 company which has not commenced trading according to its latest annual return. Has Mr. Teahon any problem with that memo from Mr. Walsh, particularly his view that the Waterworld submission was thin on the operating side? We have heard Mr. Teahon's concerns about the financial standing of this consortium but it seems Mr. Walsh of PricewaterhouseCoopers was calling into question the Waterworld and Dial proposals on the operating side which I assume to mean either what they were proposing in operating terms to manage this facility or the personnel involved. I am not clear what he is referring to and Mr. Teahon may have a better view on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I would have to say that is one sentence that I do not identify with for two reasons. First, the advice to the assessment panel on the operating issue if we look at the previous paragraph on the third sentence reads "The operating proposals were being reviewed by Kit Campbell". Kit Campbell has expert knowledge in relation to the aquatic centres and if I were making a judgment as I was as a member of the assessment panel on the operating proposals I would have been influenced virtually entirely by the Kit Campbell review. This review was clear minded because the judgment he made was a relative assessment of three proposals. In other words, we had operating proposals from each of the three consortia and Kit Campbell was clear that, by a significant margin, the operating proposals from the Waterworld consortium were significantly the best. I am not sure what Aidan Walsh means by saying the Waterworld proposals were thin on the operating side because, in my opinion, the judgment the assessment panel would rightly rely on was that of Kit Campbell.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

For the chairman's own information, I refer to page 2 of the PricewaterhouseCoopers memo from Aidan Walsh in annex 1. It refers to a Keith Neilson from the Office of Public Works who also reviewed the proposals from an operating perspective and concluded that the Waterworld proposal was the most developed and robust. I am trying to find out if the Office of Public Works was involved at some level of review or assessment of the case.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

To clarify that matter "operating in this situation" refers to the maintenance of the plant. Keith Milson, who is mentioned here, has nothing to do with operating swimming pools or anything like it - he is a mechanical and electrical engineer in the Office of Public Works and the thing has been mis-stated here. The term "operating" in this context means physically operating.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

I ask Mr. Teahon to focus on the critical week of 15 December to 22 December 2000. The Attorney General has set out a road map on page 6. The closing date for the bids was 15 December. On 18 December the board had the PricewaterhouseCoopers due diligence report. On 19 December the consortium was selected as preferred bidder status. On 19 December the Cabinet agreed. On 21 December the board had the completed PWC report and 22 December was set as the date for the planning applications to be lodged.

Mr. Teahon had a very busy week in that period. I am not saying that sarcastically but I do not know how he packed that much into the week. Since the Special Olympics are not until 2003, why was it necessary to impose the 22 December deadline for planning because that seems to be the cause of virtually everything that has happened.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

We have - and it may be useful to produce it which I am happy to do - a time path backwards from the date on which the pool will be required for the Special Olympics. There were people who said that even getting it in for planning permission for 22 December might miss the Special Olympics but we were satisfied that once it was in and, allowing for all eventualities in terms of objections which did not materialise that was the date we needed to hit.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

The project was granted panning permission in March. It put Mr. Teahon into a situation. He had the preliminary PWC conclusions before he went to Cabinet——

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Yes.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

——and yet he allowed the Cabinet make the decision to contract the consortium that was not what it represented itself to be which we now know from the Attorney General's report. Its financial capacity was much less than anything else that had been represented and its international reputation in terms of running the water park industry was not what it appeared. Mr. Teahon had time to say "steady up" and refer to the preliminary report indicating these difficulties but instead he let the Cabinet go ahead.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

In fairness to myself, I would have to say that one piece which is missing from this chronology is the letter we sent out on the afternoon of 19 December. There was not just a letter on 21 December which is referred to here.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

To whom?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

To the consortium. The letters that went out on 21 December were letters to each of the three consortia. There was a letter to the consortium on 19 December and there was a reply from the consortium on 20 December.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

What did the letter of 19 December say?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

It set down the conditions which are spelt out, as I recall, more fully in the letter of 21 December.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Mr. Teahon was in charge of a very prestigious project and was he not alarmed when he saw the preliminary PWC conclusions? Presumably he took the representation of Waterworld UK on its own terms. This company S&P turns out not to be substantial and then NGBS as represented as the company which had the expertise in running the water leisure industry. Alarm bells must have gone off in his head when he saw it.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

We are into words here I would think in terms of alarm. I identified that there is an issue. How does one deal with that issue? What the Deputy said is that we allowed the Government to contract. I did not see the situation as being one in which there would be a contract irrespective. I saw that there was an issue in regard to the economic and financial standing of this consortium but it was one that could be relatively readily dealt with. Admittedly, in the fullness of time, it was not dealt with on the basis I would have foreseen on that day or the following day, because the answer that came back on 20 December was that a parent company, or parent company type guarantee would be provided by NGBS International. As far as we were concerned on 20 and 21 December, we were dealing with a consortium that could be adequately dealt with on economic and financial standing.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Remind me when you left the Department.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

When did I cease being secretary general?

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Early May 2000.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Therefore, in your capacity as executive chairman, did you function initially out of the Department of the Taoiseach?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I was involved from the feasibility study, the first thing that happened.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

When did you physically relocate to Blanchardstown?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

June or July.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

It was that early?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

In other words, we did not have the building at the very earliest stage.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

The Attorney General refers to the memo being faxed from the offices of CSID. Did you, Mr. McCarthy, or anyone in your Department, make substantial changes to that memo?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

No, Chairman.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Are you telling us that someone who is no longer a civil servant, who is a business man, was writing memos for the Taoiseach?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

Chairman, the position was that the material for submission to the Government was submitted by CSID in the format of a memorandum and, presumably, that reflected the past experience of the people involved as to what would be required. That material was incorporated then into what was substantively a memorandum for the Government.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

I suggest. Mr. McCarthy, that means the same thing. The real drafter of the memorandum is Mr. Teahon, not you or any assistant secretary in your Department.

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

It was drafted as you suggest, Deputy, and then submitted by the Department to the Taoiseach as a memorandum which he might then bring to the Government.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Were you on hand Mr. Teahon to answer questions if the Cabinet raised questions about it?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Yes.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

You were physically present in the Cabinet room?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Yes.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Can we go to the Attorney General's riposte to the response of CSID? I am referring to the two pages before annex x headed "Comment by Attorney General on CSID Response". Your feeling was that what was revealed by either PricewaterhouseCoopers's preliminary or complete reports could be put right. The Attorney General refuses to give an opinion on whether the award was in accordance with EU procurement procedures. We do not want to dwell unnecessarily on this for the same reasons he gives, but is it not safe to presume that the reason he does not want to give an opinion is that it might accord with the opinion that legal advisers gave you and that we have been given?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I have no information on that question.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

However, the Attorney General would be reasonably expected to concur, if he does concur? If he agreed that EU procurement procedures were complied with he ought to have stated that here.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

That is a question for the Attorney General to answer.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

He then makes the point that the comments on the adequacy of the pre-qualification and assessment process in his report stand. They are very critical. He summarises that no adequate consideration was given to the financial standing or capacity, actual or potential, of the proposed operator company at any time prior to the decision by the Government to accept Waterworld as the preferred bidder. That is a very serious matter, Mr Teahon, is it not?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

In fairness, it is not the material point. Financial standing or capacity, at the expression of interest stage, relate to the consortium, not to the operator company. That was the basis on which the judgment at the expression of interest stage was made.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

The construction work commenced without any concluded agreement on the financial backing required for the operator. The Attorney General is saying that work commenced anyway, the limited financial guarantees eventually negotiated with Dublin Waterworld Limited would largely self-extinguish after five years and were far removed from joint and several consortium liability in the DBFOM contract originally envisaged.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

The concluded agreement to which the Attorney General is referring is known as the project agreement or contract, which was signed in February of this year. He is correct in saying that it concluded the construction work prior to that. That project agreement was put to Government for approval. The financial guarantees negotiated apply over the five year period. I am not clear what the Attorney General means when he says they are far removed from joint and several consortium liability in the DBFOM contract originally envisaged. The issue of whether it should be joint and several liability arose and the legal advice we had was that we did not have to insist on it. The Department considered that legal advice and said to us that we should have joint and several liability and, in fact, there is joint and several liability of——

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

From memory, the Attorney General referred to it in the report as a measure of joint and several liability. Is that not right?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

He may well do but it is joint and several liability which involves Rohcon.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Right. Have you accepted point d about the failure to notify the board and Government?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I would take issue with the use of the words "grave doubts". There was an issue that had to be dealt with but I did not have any grave doubts that it could be. I did not believe this was likely to give us the wrong result. I saw that, with the proper pursuit, it would give us the right result.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

You will be glad to hear, Mr. Teahon, that Denis O'Brien is not alone in admiring your confidence in correcting problems. I respect that view and I believe you held it but, nonetheless, the Attorney General is saying that there were grave doubts about the financial capacity and status of this group to do the business. That seems to me to go the heart of what you were contracting to do. What other conceivable deficiencies could there be greater than track record and financial?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Leaving aside the communication issue and just dealing with the issue that arose, the question was whether it was reasonable to conclude on the basis of the information we had that it would be possible for the consortium - we were still talking about the consortium - to satisfy us in the context of signing a contract that it had the economic and financial standing required, in my judgment - and I remain of that view - it was reasonable to conclude that would be the case.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

The consortium was a moving statue.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

No, to the extent that it was moving it had ceased to move at that time.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

It had stabilised, had it?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Yes, and the point needs to be made, because I think it has been missed in some comments, that at the time of the detailed bid, the judgment that Kit Campbell, who was the expert on the issue, had made was in relation to the capacity of the two people from Tralee who were going to run the——

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Yes, but somewhere in that report, Kit Campbell made the point that he could not find any information on NBGS.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

My comment is purely in relation to the observation and capacity.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Mr. Teahon is talking about after NBGS fell out.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

No, at the point that Waterworld UK, prior to Dublin Waterworld, in the context of the detailed bid, said it would put in place a company and Messrs Ruttledge and Bohan would be the key people. The judgment that Kit Campbell made was essentially a judgment in relation to his understanding of their capacity. So that piece did not change subsequently.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Does Mr. Murphy think it is normal to assign interest to essentially a third party - it only had a 5% residual stake? Can it be assigned to a third party like that?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Generally speaking, no. It is not an impossibility, but let us consider the kind of contract we operate that is closest to this one, that is a design build finance. The assignment has to be done with the agreement of certain parties and most importantly the funding agency. It always comes back to money somewhere. If the bankers who are involved are not prepared to have an assignment, then the thing will fail.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Could I just make one point? The issue I am referring to is not a question of assigning anything. The issue was that Waterworld UK said, in submitting its final bid, that it would put, if you like, a management in place. I think that was the word that Kit Campbell used. He said the management of the centre would be carried out by Messrs Ruttledge and Bohan. It is not a question of assigning. Assigning is a separate issue, which ultimately went to John Moriarty.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Going back to the earlier misunderstanding between us about the Kerry connection, yesterday I met a man on the street who wanted to know why the three Kerry men did not set up a company called Kerry Waterworld Limited and apply for this themselves?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

As I read what happened, S&P was the firm of architects for the Aquadome in Tralee. It was aware of Messrs Ruttledge and Bohan from that connection. I would assume that what happened was that they approached them and said that Waterworld UK would have to put a management in place and asked if they were interested. Then there was contact with Waterworld UK and, in the context of the detailed bid, Waterworld UK said it would put this company in place.

I also refer back to what I said in the earlier meeting. It is my judgment - it is a personal judgment, because it was never considered by the assessment panel - that if Dublin Waterworld, regardless of any involvement by Waterworld UK Limited, which now was only 5% anyway, had presented itself originally, it would have been the preferred bidder.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

According to the report of the Attorney General: "The claims made for the experience and success of Waterworld UK Limited appear to be unfounded and unchecked. The response questions the basis for my conclusion that an attempt was made to foster in the mind of CSID the impression that the company was itself a leading water park operator with approximately 20 years experience. That claim was made on behalf of the consortium by MDC in its initial letter on 23 August as pointed out at page 28 of the report".

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Although I share it on some level, people had more of a problem than I had with this attempt to foster in the mind the impression that the company was a leading park operator. I had a problem with it in two senses. When we came to making the detailed bid assessment, we were not in any sense primarily making a judgment on the two people Palmer and Currie that came from Waterworld UK Limited. We were not making that judgment, we were primarily making a judgment - or Kit Campbell was giving us advice in the making of a judgment - on the competence of Messrs Ruttledge and Bohan to run an aquatic centre. That was primarily the judgment, as I would see it.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

However, Waterworld UK was the lead company, was it not? Surely some kind of assessment of its background and credentials would have been prudent.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

No, no, they were not. At the expression of interest stage the lead company was MDC, the Dutch company. That was why I stressed at an earlier stage today that we were making a judgment in relation to a consortium and MDC was the lead in the consortium and was a company of very significant financial resource.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Who did not proceed.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Who did not proceed. It was replaced by Rohcon, which would not have been quite as financially strong but is very financially strong.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

The next point in the Attorney General's report is that Waterworld UK represented itself as having a close relationship with Schlitterbahn and NBGS. The report says that appears tenuous.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Again I am not clear why he says that because the reality was that when we sent the letter to the consortium in December, the answer we got back was that it would put in place a parent company type guarantee from NBGS. There are issues in relation to whether parent company is the right phrase to use in relation to NBGS and Waterworld UK, but the reality was that for quite a number of weeks - and that included contact with NBGS - we believed that a parent company guarantee would be put in place. That is why I do not quite understand what he means when he uses the remark "appears tenuous".

Comment on this

The next question will have to be your final one, Deputy.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

How about a final answer?

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

As Deputy Durkan remarked, there are many additional matters that need to be questioned. Accepting that guillotine, can I ask Mr. Teahon if he has any understanding of the difficulty on this side of the table in someone like me understanding why a respected former most senior civil servant would take the apparent risks that are highlighted in the Attorney General's report in terms of pressing ahead, however admirable showing such urgency might be, unless he had some kind of political cover? He must have told someone about this. Somebody with Mr. Teahon's training would never have proceeded in this fashion without political cover.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I will come back again to the issue. I feel, quite genuinely, that the issue of a dormant company has been significantly exaggerated in recent times. One would think——

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Before Mr. Teahon answers, it is not, in fairness, just a question of dormancy. It is a question of lack of financial capacity, lack of track record in the water park industry, pieces of the jigsaw falling out and having to be replaced on the basis of Mr. Teahon's ingenuity and then, having got in replacements, of having alternative finance put in place by Allied Irish Bank and so on. To focus on dormancy alone does not convey the breadth of the criticisms in the report of the Attorney General. I find it very difficult to understand that somebody with a track record like Mr. Teahon's and a history of complying with Cabinet procedures in accordance with the Government handbook issued to all Ministers - which were clearly breached in this instance - would take such action without sanction. I do not believe Mr. Teahon would do so.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

If the Deputy is asking, by implication, whether I discussed this matter with the Taoiseach in a detailed way, the answer is "No".

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Thank you, Mr. Teahon.

Comment on this

Before I hand over to Deputy Batt O'Keeffe, I have a question in relation to the assessment of the final bids. Were the final bids all submitted on 15 December?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Yes.

Comment on this

This was a €63 million project for the largest ever aquatic centre, on which a massive amount of information was furnished to CSID on 15 December and the contract was provisionally announced on 19 December. We can assume that, over that weekend and on Monday 19th, all of that documentation was furnished to the assessment panel who must have spent the entire weekend going through the material. Who was on that assessment panel?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

The membership is listed in the document.

Comment on this

How many members were on the panel?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Six or seven, I believe.

Comment on this

Six or seven. Were they people with experience in relation to construction?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Well, the membership is there. You know who the members are, Chairman.

Comment on this

In relation to the board of directors, I am asking what construction experience there was. There was massive documentation involved, containing a variety of information on a massive project.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I refer to page 80. The answer to your question, Chairman, is that, between the members of the panel and the advisers referred to, there was significant construction experience.

Comment on this

Were you satisfied that the evaluation of the final bids for this major project could be done over a weekend?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

If I may refer back, this matter was discussed in answer to Deputy Rabbitte's questions at the last meeting and I believe Mr. Barry Murphy pointed out that, in fact, there had been significant discussions with all three consortia in the run in to December 15. It was not a situation where the information provided on that date came as a complete surprise. We had had discussions with the three consortia over a number of weeks before that and, therefore, the information had already been discussed, in different ways, with the consortia. Accordingly, what we were doing between December 15 and 19 was to ensure the information was in accordance with our expectation of what it would be and the advisers were making recommendations in relation to the different elements of design, build, finance, operate and maintain- - sorry, in relation to design, build, operate and maintain, not finance.

Comment on this

S&P Architects have been referred to several times. There is a description of a UK company as one of the world's leading water park operators, with about 20 years experience of operating and managing some of the most popular and successful resorts.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Where is that description?

Comment on this

I will find it in a moment. I took note of it earlier on.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

S&P are the architects, they are not operators.

Comment on this

Yes, but they described UK Waterworld as one of the world's leading water park operators, with approximately 20 years experience of operating and managing some of the most popular and successful resorts.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I am not clear what point is being made.

Comment on this

I am suggesting it would not appear to have been a very honest response from S&P Architects, on the basis that UK Waterworld did not have 20 years operating experience, having been in operation only since 1997. I do not regard S&P Architects as having been very honest in their comment.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I do not know which area of the report the Chairman is referring to.

Comment on this

It is on page 30.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Without looking at the particular remark, with regard to the operational issue - I come back to this point again - when we came to the detailed bid, what we were looking at and what Kit Campbell made his judgment on, in the context of operation, was the proposal by the consortium that there would be, in effect, a local management company to run the aquatic centre and that the two key people in it were Messrs. Ruttledge and Bohan. That was the judgment——

Comment on this

I am not disputing that at all. I am just referring to the comment of S&P Architects in relation to UK Waterworld having a track record over 20 years, whereas we now know it had no track record whatsoever. That is my point.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

In fairness to them - and this is just on the basis of a quick reading - the statement was that "the UK company of one of the world's leading water park. . . . .". As I understand it, "one of the world's leading water park operators" was the combination of NBGS and Schlitterbahn. On that basis, one could speak of two companies which had 20 years experience of operating and managing. The problem to which the Chairman may be rightly referring is that, in the event, this apparent company guarantee from NBGS did not come to pass. However, in fairness to S&P and what they meant by the comment, I believe they were saying that Waterworld UK is the UK company of the other people who, I think, would accurately be described as water park operators with approximately 20 years experience.

Comment on this

On the basis of what is written here, one could probably dispute that, but perhaps we will not develop that argument.

Comment on this
Batt O'Keeffe Deputy B. O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I will be very brief, Chairman. Mr. Teahon, having been in the public service for so many years and having aspired to the highest level, is it not reasonable to expect that all the experience of the public service and the cautious approach to contracts would have been reflected in your subsequent involvement in the private sector? Looking back on what has transpired, are there many issues on which you would now say you would have acted differently and would not have left yourself open to a charge that what you were involved in was a design and build project with very little effective obligation? Was it a situation where the Department of Finance code should be applied but was not applied and that the normal approval of terms of major contracts should have been adhered to, as appeared on page 42? What would be your approach if you had your time over again? Would you consider that your general alacrity, the short time frame available to you and the absolute necessity of getting on with the job may have destined that you would depart from some of your Civil Service training?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

My honest answer is that, in my view, if all the information now available was available at the time decisions were being taken, the decisions would have been exactly the same. As I said when I made the statement to the committee on the first day, I accept without reservation that my communication on the matter was inadequate and I have accepted that I made a misjudgment in not giving fuller reports and information. However, if asked whether I believe looking back on it that we have a company, Rohcon Limited, that will construct a really great aquatic centre, I would answer "Yes". If I am asked if I believe we have a company that will operate the centre really well, the answer will be "Yes".

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Last week Mr. Teahon stated "No, I will not resign because there is absolutely no reason for my resignation". Does he feel let down today at having been, effectively, removed as chairman of the group and having his role as chief executive taken from him? Does he feel that his integrity has been impugned or does he feel that, given the shortcomings in the Attorney General's report, the Government had no option but to ask him to vacate those positions, while indicating it believed Mr. Teahon to be very much above board by keeping him on as a director of the company?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

There had been a conversation with me many months ago relating to the division of roles between chair and chief executive and, in the light of my experience, it is my strong belief that those roles should not be combined. I had no problem with that. When the board came to make its recommendation to the Minister on 8 March it said that there should be a full-time chief executive and I was part of the board in making that recommendation. On that occasion, I made it clear to the board that I would not wish to be a full-time chief executive. I could not see myself having the time to carry out that role. As I said earlier, the Government asked Dermot McCarthy to contact me today to put the Government's subsequently issued proposal as a statement to me. He asked me for a response and I agreed it in the interests of the project. The Government clearly felt that in the interests of the project this should happen and I agreed. I did not say this to Dermot, but I very much welcome and appreciate what the Government said about me in the statement as regards my integrity.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Full planning permission was applied for on 22 December and granted on 28 March, which indicates that the decision to grant was made about 28 February, within two months of the application being made. That is how I read it from the Comptroller and Auditor General's report and if that is the case, I compliment Fingal County Council for working so well. You would not get permission for a bungalow in County Galway in two months, never mind a project like this. Is it the case that the decision to grant was taken about 24 or 25 February?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

That is correct.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

The Cabinet decision was made on 19 December. Given public notice and everything else that has to be done during a planning application, was it anticipated that the Cabinet would give the go-ahead to the project? How was an application ready to be lodged within two days of the Cabinet decision to go ahead? Was it not prejudging the matter to have that ready?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

We had identified 22 December as the final date in the time path I mentioned earlier. Therefore, when the decision was made on 19 December, we wrote to S&P Architects and asked it to agree that its design could be used, which it did. The planning application was made by CSID with the agreement of the architect.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

CSID could not have been ready to lodge a planning application. There is no way one would have a planning application of that magnitude ready to lodge within two days of a decision being taken, given the need to provide a paper public notice with the planning application on it.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I am sorry, but that is not the case. I am happy to provide the specifics.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

What is not the case?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

What the Deputy said is not the case because we did it.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

It was done because there was a clear understanding from somebody that the project was going to get the go-ahead. Otherwise it could not have been done in two days. Quite obviously it was ready before the Cabinet decision on 19 December. It is quite obvious to me anyway. It must have been quite clear to somebody in advance, be it CSID, Mr. Teahon or whoever was dealing with this matter, that the go-ahead was going to be given by Cabinet on 19 December.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I do not agree with the Deputy. If he is suggesting that we somehow made a judgment before the nineteenth as to who would be the successful bidder, he is wrong as that is not the case.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

I am talking about the planning aspect of the matter. I am not saying a judgment was made. CSID would have to have been very confident that the project was going to get the go-ahead to have its planning application ready to go in on 22 December. That is obvious.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

It was clear to us that the planning application had to be in on 22 December. In the event that the Government had not taken its decision on 19 December, we would not have submitted a planning application.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

On 18 December the preliminary report was received by CSID. Was it not thought necessary in presenting the brief to the Taoiseach, who was the Minister pursuing this project at Cabinet, to alert him to the information in that report?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

As I have said in answer to Deputy Rabbitte, the answer to that is "No".

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Pardon?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

"No" is the answer to that. I have already answered that question for Deputy Rabbitte.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Mr. Teahon has, but he said a few things to Deputy Rabbitte that I would like to come back to. He said he did not discuss the report with the Taoiseach in any detail. Did he discuss it with him at all?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

The answer I gave was to Deputy Rabbitte, who said he found it very hard to believe. I said, "If you are asking me the question, did I discuss this in any detail with the Taoiseach, the answer is "No".

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Did Mr. Teahon discuss this with the Taoiseach at all? That is the question I am asking.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I did not discuss that we had received a report from PricewaterhouseCoopers which said there was an issue in relation to the economic and financial standing of the project.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

What kind of discussion did Mr. Teahon have with the Taoiseach before this? Did I hear that Mr. Teahon was at the Cabinet meeting on the matter?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Yes, I was.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

I do not know much about Cabinet meetings and I do not want to breach the confidentiality of them. Did things not arise at Cabinet? If Mr. Teahon cannot answer the question I will understand. I am sure everybody did not just give the nod to the project, saying "That is grand. The Taoiseach has presented the report and we will all accept it. We are all for it." Did questions not arise which obliged Mr. Teahon, who was attending in an advisory capacity, to clarify matters? Did questions not arise that might have obliged Mr. Teahon, who was there in an advisory capacity, to be called on to give clarification on matters? Did questions not arise in respect of which he felt it was necessary to give the information which, apparently, he withheld from the Taoiseach?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

With respect, Chairman, I do not think Mr. Teahon or any of us is in a position to answer the question.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Okay, I accept that. The Tánaiste in her statements yesterday expressed her concern. She differs with Mr. Teahon. He said he believes that if all the information was available, the decision would have been the same. The Tánaiste does not believe that according to her statement yesterday. She was very careful in the way she chose her words. She says that full information was not made available to the Cabinet. She did not say full information was not available to the Taoiseach. I do not know why she chose that form of words. She said that if full information had been available to the Cabinet, there might have been a different decision. Does that not indicate that it might not have got the go-ahead if that information was available to the Cabinet?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

The Tánaiste is obviously entitled to say what she said. I looked at the information and asked if the same decision would have been reached if all the information was available. My answer is that it would have been.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

So Mr. Teahon and the Tánaiste disagree on that matter.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

The Deputy should not put words into my mouth.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Mr. Teahon is telling me the opposite of what she said yesterday.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

No, I do not believe I am. She is saying it might have been a different answer. I am saying that, having considered the issue, I do not believe it would. That is not disagreeing.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Mr. Teahon and I will disagree on whether that is disagreeing. On page ten, it says the outline bid in respect of the consortium, which now includes Rohcon made it clear that Waterworld (UK) Limited was closely linked with NBGS International, a US company with many years of design, manufacturing and consulting in the waterpark industry. Why is the Attorney General referring to that in his report?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I do not honestly know.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

It also says "In addition, details were provided on the associate company Schlitterbahn, which is owned by NBGS and their waterpark operation." Why is that being referred to by the Attorney General?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I think the heading is "Chronology". As I see it, the Attorney General is describing a chronology and that statement is part of the chronology.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

On page 12, it says:

On 7 March 2002, the Executive Chairman informed his Board that he did not believe it necessary to inform them or the Assessment Panel at that time of the information received about the status of Waterworld (UK), or of his judgment in this regard.

Why did Mr. Teahon believe that at that time?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I believed so because I believed I was acting on the basis of delegated authority.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

On page four, the Attorney General says:

Failure to alert those politically accountable to the true situation seems to seriously call into question the existence of a proper relationship between the executive and the board and between the board and its State shareholders.

Does Mr. Teahon accept that?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I have already answered that question earlier. I said I believed that the material around that sentence should have referred to the fact that I was operating on the basis of delegated authority.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Mr. Teahon seemed to stress a few times today that he did nothing wrong. That is his view. Why did the Government stand him down today from the position of chairperson and chief executive? Am I, the Government or Mr. Teahon missing something?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

When I say I did nothing wrong, I am referring to all the actions which I took to have a company construct what I believe to be a really good aquatic centre and have an operating company that will run it well. I recognised - it is in my statement to the committee - that my communication on the matter was inadequate. I have accepted that I made a misjudgment in not giving fuller reports and information. The decision the Government took was its own, not mine.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

There seems to be some misunderstanding outside this body about the functions of this committee. I was listening to somebody on the radio this morning who was expressing that he would regret very much if any actions delayed the project. None of us is trying to delay the project in any way - the project is going ahead. Our duty and function on the Committee of Public Accounts is to ensure that there is value for money. As distasteful as that is, sometimes we have to ask hard questions. For anybody outside to be given the impression that this committee would wish to hold up the project or in any way delay it is false. That is not our function at all. Our function and duty is to ensure that we query cases where public money - £63 million - is involved and where that money could be put at risk by decisions taken.

Let us return to the issue of planning. When the planning application was lodged on 22 December to Fingal County Council, were there prior discussions with the council about the project or with the planners in Fingal County Council? Were there preliminary discussions with the planning authority before the planning application was lodged?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Yes, there were.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Was there any time, during the initial two months in which a decision was made, in which further information was sought or where any clarifications of matters concerning the planning application were dealt with in conjunction with Fingal County Council?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I believe there was, yes.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

In the normal course of events, when further information is sought, it usually takes two months to deal with an application from the time that a reply is submitted in respect of further information. However, in this case, that did not happen because it is quite obvious that the decision to grant planning permission was issued within two months of the date of the planning being lodged. Why would that be so?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I will have to check that and will be happy to do so.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Okay.

Comment on this
John Dennehy Deputy Dennehy Fianna Fáil

I agree with Deputy McCormack. Our role is to ensure value for money at all times. Things can get confusing when trying to ascertain if we are getting value for money. This issue has become particularly confusing, probably because, at one session last week, we were kicking footballs around Croke Park and around the new pitch and things like that.

Consider the dormant company and its involvement in this matter. The dormant company is referred to by Mr. McDowell as a shelf company and I am wondering if it is the same thing. I am not an accountant but, for the purpose of clarification, how does Mr. Teahon define a dormant company?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

As I understand it, a dormant company is one which has not traded. A shelf company would generally be a company which has just been formed and is transformed, for the purposes of making a bid, into another company.

Comment on this
John Dennehy Deputy Dennehy Fianna Fáil

I mentioned the other day how well Mr. Teahon had done in driving the project along. The planning permission was granted in March but, given the level of objections generally, did he fear any objections to the project?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

We included the possibility of an objection in the time path that I described earlier.

Comment on this
John Dennehy Deputy Dennehy Fianna Fáil

I return to the question of dormant companies because I feel that is the key point. There is comment that the entire board seems to have discussed this question at some point and the difficulties arising from it. When the board received its letter of comfort from Anglo-Irish Bank on 7 February, did Mr. Teahon see it covering any financial contingencies or difficulties that might arise?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Yes. At the end of December and through January we believed that the consortium would provide a parent company guarantee from MBGS. However, MBGS indicated it was not prepared to give such parent company guarantee. There was then a proposal, not from us but I believe Kieran Ruttledge, that we should accept this Anglo-Irish Bank letter. We checked with our financial and legal advisers and on that basis accepted it.

Comment on this
John Dennehy Deputy Dennehy Fianna Fáil

We are out of chronological order because this is the way this report is written. I refer to 18 December and a quote from page 17 of the report:

The information revealed that Waterworld UK was a dormant company and that the lack of material information on the enterprise had resulted in searches to determine if the directors of the company held directorships in other companies.

The business report showed that Mr. Roger Currie held directorships in Waterworld UK and Royson Limited and that Keith Palmer had a directorship in Waterworld UK. Was that information available to everybody else at that stage or just to Mr. Teahon?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

In terms of the board - just to myself.

Comment on this
John Dennehy Deputy Dennehy Fianna Fáil

The business report indicates on page 18 that "It is inadvisable to proceed with unsecured dealings without prior referral to the parent company". Would the £3 million letter of comfort guarantee have covered that aspect of that in the context of that advice?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

The letter of comfort was not a parent company guarantee - it flowed from legal advice that a third party guarantee could apply and, in that sense, it was a third party rather than parent company guarantee.

Comment on this
John Dennehy Deputy Dennehy Fianna Fáil

The purpose of that is to lock away any liability the State might have if a company folded. There are suggestions that money might have been lost in this and that we might have chosen the wrong people, and page 19 states "Paddy Teahon commented during the course of the meeting that the Waterworld proposal was not the best funded and that there were issues to be resolved, particularly in this area, with them." Who would Mr. Teahon have been stating that to?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

To the assessment panel at the detailed bid stage.

Comment on this
John Dennehy Deputy Dennehy Fianna Fáil

Were there three or five?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

They are at the end of page 18.

Comment on this
John Dennehy Deputy Dennehy Fianna Fáil

The advisers are Keith Milson, Una Carmody, Kit Campbell and Seán Boyle——

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

No, the panel is described first as myself, Laura Magahy, David O'Connor, Seán Benton, Seán Treacy and Pat Duffy.

Comment on this
John Dennehy Deputy Dennehy Fianna Fáil

In the comment at that meeting he was signalling to them that they were not the best funded. That could be interpreted in a number of ways. I am amazed that nobody seems to know anything and can go through life in this manner. I will refer back to the Attorney General being incorrect about who was involved.

Mr. Teahon signalled that Waterworld UK was not the best funded and that there were issues to be resolved, particularly in this area, and if I was a director or an assessor I would be asking what was wrong without waiting for Mr. Teahon to point it out.

The report further states that Mr. Teahon said that Waterworld appeared favourable but that the board would revert to the other bidders to keep their bids open. This was presumably a strategy in order to keep Waterworld on board without shutting the door. I assume SB is Seán Benton who is quoted as saying that they would lose interest. In other words, if they were knocked out at the first stage they were not going to stay with it. Paddy Teahon is recorded as having "nervousness or slight concern about the Waterworld-Rohcon backing and their ability to have deep pockets". I presume that refers to their coming up with enough cash although it is an unusual term.

There is a suggestion that nobody was really aware of anything other than Mr. Teahon and I am concerned if that is the case, but can I take it that Mr. Teahon was, at this point, signalling concern about the Waterworld-Rohcon grouping financially?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

This point has caused us some concern too. We wrote to the Attorney General on the matter when he was preparing his report. It is not included in his report but he refers to it and I suspect the omission of the letter itself is simply an omission on his part. The key part to this letter is that Seán Benton told Mr. Teahon that he had no record or recollection of Mr. Teahon making the comments that have been referred to by Deputy Dennehy and that Mr. Teahon himself had acknowledged he had no recollection of making these comments. Seán Benton checked out the position with the other Office of Public Works officials who were present at the meeting of the assessment panel - Kevin Connolly, Kieran McGahen and Keith Milson - none of whom has any recollection of the comments being made. Further, CSID's own report of the assessment panel meeting contains no reference to a contribution of this nature by Mr. Teahon. Finally, we pointed out to the Attorney General that it is a matter of particular significance that the PWC note does not record that anybody from PWC raised concerns at the assessment panel meeting about Waterworld UK.

Comment on this
John Dennehy Deputy Dennehy Fianna Fáil

There is a memo compiled by Aidan Walsh which stated that, so he must have got it wrong as well.

I expressed grave concerns about trying to speed read 480 pages of text. There is nobody in the country who can do it in time. If I am now being told that there are regular mistakes and misquotes by the Attorney General, we are really in trouble. Not alone must I speed read 480 pages in half an hour this evening, but I must also anticipate the mistakes and errors. I make the point, which I made last week, that I am not happy with the way we are proceeding. Perhaps someone will mark the errors as we proceed because it is only when we ask questions we find——

Comment on this

We will be adjourning at 7 p.m.

Comment on this
John Dennehy Deputy Dennehy Fianna Fáil

This is a critical issue.

Comment on this

I know, but we will be resuming at 11.30 a.m. tomorrow and members will have another chance to assess the documentation before then.

Comment on this
John Dennehy Deputy Dennehy Fianna Fáil

In the context of value for money and some suggestions that have been made, it is stated on page 32:

It is important to emphasise that this analysis is not suggesting that the decision of the Assessment Panel to select Rohcon/Waterworld in preference to the other two bidders who submitted detailed bids was unreasonable. For reasons concerned with price and design, the preferred bid was obviously clearly ahead of the other contenders.

I also worry about value for money and we may have had an incorrect message but we now know that the bid in question was the best of the three.

There is another philosophical argument developing between Departments about the merits of design, build, finance, operate and maintain contracts. One Department might wish that others did not have all this but it seems to be a trend and I am concerned about it. I am concerned about what we might call internal departmental dynamics - if we were talking about politics it would be called internal dynamics - but it seems to be inherent in the debate. I am also worried about our picking up the wrong messages. If there are other corrections or revisits, I would appreciate if Mr. Murphy had prepared them in time for the next meeting so that I do not raise things, presuming that our Attorney General is correct, only to find out that he is wrong. I do not want to get into an argument with Mr. Murphy or to appear to be contradicting or obstructing him.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I have no problem whatsoever with that and we will have it done prior to tomorrow's session.

Comment on this
John Dennehy Deputy Dennehy Fianna Fáil

The important thing is that guarantees were put in place for the future of the State and to cover ourselves financially when the weakness was found. We will need to decide whether these eventual guarantees were adequate. The weakness, a dormant company - I nearly called it a shelf company - got all the headlines. The other two companies, who were major players as the first only accounted for 5%, have never been mentioned in the media. Would the guarantees received have covered any potential loss? Should we have gone for a design, build, finance, operate and maintain contract? The decision was made. It has been criticised; other people might not have made the same decision. However, it was made, probably with the target date of the Special Olympics in mind. I like to see people being innovative when trying to get things done for the State and I agree with that approach if it is done correctly with guarantees in place. Guarantees were sought and, as far as I can see, they were provided.

I know the Chairman is concerned about time but on page 24 it is stated that "critical issues which remain to be resolved" were referred to again in a letter dated 2 March. My point is that this was not something that was hidden until recently. The Comptroller and Auditor General referred to a number of concerns he had and they were covered earlier on. There were concerns about the performance bond and about financing and guarantees. The £5 available would not have gone far, even though it was sterling. It appears that these concerns were dealt with. If they were not, I would like to hear about it but the points I would have raised appear to have been covered. It is important to get across the message that the assessment committee and its members were unbiased, professional and knowledgeable and that they selected what they saw as the cheapest bid - the one which involved not only the lowest cost but also the least potential for leaving us open to further costs down the line. The essential message is that the process was carried out honestly and fairly.

Public perception has been mentioned. I am afraid people may misinterpret the situation and infer that there was some hokey-pokey. I have no problem with returning later to discuss the philosophy of integrated schemes including funding, organisation and management. We should be using these schemes a lot more and we will do so. Some people may have concerns and we can discuss them, but we should be cutting the State's exposure to financial outlay. I take the AG's point that once the strategy was set out in this case the tendering procedure became a straitjacket. They were tied to it as soon it went into the EU Journal.

I have a letter from the board of CSID to the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation and I hope that what is stated is accurate. I think it is dated March but the print is unclear. The letter states that the board is satisfied, having considered the position and on the basis of advice from its legal advisers, that these issues do not impact on the integrity and validity of the award of the contract and is satisfied that EU procurement procedures were properly implemented and applied in carrying through the process. Was this letter indicative of unanimous support?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Yes, it was.

Comment on this
John Dennehy Deputy Dennehy Fianna Fáil

It has been suggested, Chairman, by at least two questioners that there may have been a difficulty with the EU procurement procedures. The board states unanimously that its members were satisfied that the EU procedures were properly implemented and applied. We need to make this very clear.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

What Deputy Dennehy mentioned has been suggested by the Attorney General, not by us.

Comment on this

It was only suggested by us prior to our obtaining the information which has now emerged.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

One annex in this document is of huge significance and I suspect that the Attorney General may have included it by accident rather than by design. Perhaps we require more time to investigate the issue. Annex D included in the AG's report happens to be the exact memorandum brought by the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation, Deputy McDaid, to the Cabinet on 18 December 2001. I understand these memorandums are normally confidential and restricted in their content and in their release. In the penultimate paragraph it is stated that:

While acknowledging the concerns of the Tánaiste, the Minister remains convinced, taking the advice of the AG's Office into account, that the option of concluding the present contract represents the least risk among the options now open to the State and is also the only way in which appropriate swimming facilities can be put in place in time for the Special Olympics Summer Games in 2003.

This is an actual Cabinet memorandum which Mr. McCarthy signed and notified to the Minister's office, indicating that the Cabinet had signed off on it. This acknowledges that in fact the Tánaiste's concerns, and indeed many of the concerns we have been discussing for the last few days, were aired openly by the Cabinet in its discussions of the memorandum formulated on 18 December by the Minister. In effect, all of the concerns have been addressed and acknowledged and could vindicate——

Comment on this

On a point of order, is the Chairman running the same questioning order as he has been until now? I assumed I was to be ahead of Deputy Lenihan.

Comment on this

Deputy Lenihan may make one final point.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

It underlines that if the information had been released initially——

Comment on this

Deputy Lenihan——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

The Cabinet clearly discussed and clarified all of the issues, including dormancy, and decided to proceed with the decision.

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

I should clarify two points. First, as a matter of procedure, any comments by the chairman of the Office of Public Works regarding factual inaccuracies in the Attorney General's report should be directed first and foremost to the Attorney General, as matter of courtesy. Second, the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation's memorandum was dated December 2001 and was not considered by the Cabinet until January 2002, and the issue of dormancy was not addressed because the Minister was not aware of the issue at the time.

Comment on this

It would be unfair to the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation to imply that was the case.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

It ought to be made patently clear that we are not talking about December 2000 but about December 2001.

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

The concerns are set out elsewhere in the memorandum to which that comment refers.

Comment on this

I merely wanted to request some clarification on one point regarding the Cabinet meeting that took place in December 2000, at which the presentation was made by the retired Secretary General of the Department in regard to the whole project. I presume it is common practice for consortia of this nature to make proposals directly to Cabinet.

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

First, the proposal emanated from the Taoiseach. In so far as Mr. Teahon was in attendance, it was to facilitate discussion of the Taoiseach's proposal.

Comment on this

But Mr. McCarthy was the Secretary General of that Department. Would he not have been in as good a position as anybody to examine the issues prior to the presentation to Cabinet? Would this responsibility not fall within the remit of the Department itself, as opposed to coming from outside consultancies?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

I shall make my second point regarding Mr. Durkan's original question. It is not common, but it is equally not unusual, for non-officials or members of Government to attend Cabinet meetings to facilitate the discussion of certain issues. Regarding the circumstances of 19 December, I was not in fact the Secretary General of the Department at the time. Nonetheless, in the particular circumstances, where the material was being submitted to the Government at short notice as a matter of urgency, I presume the Taoiseach considered it appropriate to facilitate consideration of the matter by the Government and that Mr. Teahon would be available for the meeting.

Comment on this

My apologies, Mr. McCarthy was not Secretary General at the time. His colleague was Secretary General at the time, and Mr. McCarthy mentioned that he had assessed the proposal. I presume the Taoiseach himself did not conduct the assessment or draft the note prepared for Cabinet discussion. Somebody else must have drawn up some kind of documentation and I am asking who that was.

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

Briefing material was provided from within the Department, as well as the text of the——

Comment on this

From whence within the Department?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

The material that was provided was based upon that material which had also been supplied directly by CSID.

Comment on this

So it was a circular exercise. CSID was actually supplying the briefing material, the basic information on the assessment and appraisal of the proposed contractors and so on, and at the same time it was acting as judge and jury of the entire process. Mr. McCarthy, is that not true?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

What happened was that the outcome of the assessment was reported by CSID, but there had been a clear recommendation in favour of one of the three consortia, which had attained the highest marks under all the relevant assessment criteria and the lowest cost implication. On that basis, it was recommended that CSID should be authorised to conclude heads of agreement with the particular bidder, and that proposition was put to Government on that basis for approval.

Comment on this

I presume the Attorney General was consulted at some stage in the matter. I am not sure whether I am entitled to know whether he attended Cabinet meetings at the time, but I am sure that somebody will make this inquiry and that it is pertinent to this discussion. My understanding is that at the time the proposal went to Cabinet there were certain reservations about some aspects of it, or the status of some of the companies involved, and that the proposal could only proceed with the recommendation that it be subject to certain conditions being fulfilled. Will Mr. McCarthy say if this is correct?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

The approval that was sought from the Government was to authorise CSID to conclude heads of agreement with the preferred bidder. As part of that decision, as is clear from the documentation, there was also a decision taken that some agreement would be reached with the preferred bidder regarding the capital contribution to be made and the value of the free swimming hours, which have already been mentioned to the committee. These elements, together with the fact that the recommendation was in respect of heads of agreement, had a degree of conditionality implicit in them. In other words, the heads of agreement would proceed if those conditions were met, and contracts would be signed at a later stage on the assumption that all the other technical requirements of moving from heads of agreement to contract status——

Comment on this

That can only be done on the basis of the information presented to Cabinet at the time the decision of approval was made, not on the basis of further investigations that could take place or further developments that could have taken place with regard to the merging or changing of ownership of various companies. The only decision that could have been taken at that stage was on the basis of the information actually submitted to Cabinet on the day, and I assume the Attorney General was present at such a discussion.

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

In reply to an earlier question, I indicated that had that information the Deputy mentioned about the queries raised on the financial standing of some of the companies been known, it would have been regarded as a relevant matter to bring to the attention of the Government.

Comment on this

By whom?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

By the Department and presumably by the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

I will refrain from asking further questions: there will be an opportunity to take the matter up again.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

In the interests of clarity on Mr. McCarthy's point about what is usual or unusual at Cabinet meetings, would he not agree that it is exceptional for a non-civil servant to present at Cabinet?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

Non-civil servants do not generally present at Cabinet. They may make a presentation, but items are always presented to Government by a sponsoring Minister. In so far as officials or non-officials are in attendance, it is to facilitate the Government's consideration of the proposition from the sponsoring Minister.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

I accept that entirely. My point is that it is extremely unusual, for a non-civil servant to be in the Cabinet room at all. From my own memory, I never saw it. I saw civil servants from various Departments brought in to make submissions, but I never saw a non-civil servant in the Cabinet room.

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

It is by no means common, but it has happened on a number of occasions in my time as Secretary General to the Government.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

In recognition of the late hour, I am not going to rehearse old arguments. One of the issues some Deputies raised was the role of the Committee in this matter, and that is for the Committee itself to determine, but I suggest it is very much in line with my own role, to ensure that proper procedures are in place for the spending of public moneys and that due regard is had for the achievement of value for money for taxpayers. These are my sole concerns in this matter.

On the first day of these hearings I referred to corporate governance, and it seems to me that some of what has happened here was down to what could be regarded as, and is now accepted as, an inadequate corporate governance framework. There was a corporate governance framework in place, but the adequacy of that framework must be called into question. There is a tacit recognition of this in the arrangements put in place by the Government today.

In terms of value for money, the issue here is whether the company should have gone with a design/build option and then gone for an operations/maintenance agreement, and separate those, or else have gone with what was chosen by the company, the design/build/operate and maintain option. I appreciate that given the tight timeframe within which the company was expected to deliver this project, it was very difficult to go with what I believe would have been the most economic option, a design/build and then operations/maintenance agreement. The position regarding value for money is not quite as bleak as I might have indicated in the earlier meetings because I have received information and documentation from various sources in the last few days which suggest that the State is at least getting something from this operational arrangement and lease. It is getting a share of any profits from this arrangement over the 30 years.

There are 1,300 free swimming hours each year for our elite swimmers and the national squad, and the monetary value of this has been quantified at £13 million. That is a maximum figure and I can certainly explain this view in detail tomorrow. It certainly would not be worth that sum to the operator. To be worth that to the Exchequer, it would have to be assumed that the Government of the day would be prepared to give about £450,000 per annum to Swim Ireland to make these arrangements. If you make that assumption, you then have to ask if Swim Ireland would have to pay £350 per hour for off-peak hours for what is less than exclusive use of a facility. However, while this sounds a little begrudging, and there is certainly value in this provision, it has to be entered into the equation.

Arising out of the discussion today was the danger of any potential liability on the State as a result of the way these particular arrangements were implemented. It is better to stay silent on that but also to recognise it as a potential cost. That is all it would be wise to say on that matter. Hopefully, this will not arise, and on the basis of legal advice it will not. However, legal advice is a very moveable feast depending upon who is looking for it.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Teahon in particular for his patience over the last few days. I know it has not been easy for him. At least the committee has provided a mechanism for him to put forward his side of the issue, which he did persuasively, and we respect that.

The witnesses withdraw.

Comment on this