We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE of PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

2000 Annual Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General and Appropriation Accounts: ›

Vote 10 - Office of Public Works (Resumed).

Contributions 1–259 of 791. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Witnesses should be aware that they do not enjoy absolute privilege and should be appraised as follows: Members' and witnesses' attention is drawn to the fact that, as and from 2 August 1998, section 10 of the Committees of the Houses of the Oireachtas (Compellability, Privileges and Immunities of Witnesses) Act, 1997, grants certain rights to persons who are identified in the course of the committee's proceedings. Notwithstanding this provision in the legislation, I remind members of the long standing parliamentary practice to the effect that members should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.

Members are also reminded of the provisions within Standing Order 149 which state that the committee should also refrain from inquiring into the merits of a policy or policies of the Government or a Minister of the Government or the merits of the objectives of such policies.

Members should note that the committee is concerned with the accounts specifically listed for examination and the administrative and operational control aspects related to same which are within the knowledge and competence of the witness being examined.

I invite Mr. Teahon to introduce the personnel accompanying him.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I am accompanied by Mr. Donagh Morgan, Ms Laura Magahy and Mr. Fergus Finlay.

Comment on this

Thank you.

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

I am accompanied by Mr. Con Haugh and Ms Eugenie Deegan.

Comment on this

And the Office of Public Works?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I am accompanied by Mr. Kevin Connolly and Mr. William McIntosh.

Comment on this

The Department of Finance?

Comment on this

I am accompanied by Mr. Pól Ó Duibhir.

Comment on this

The Department of the Taoiseach?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

I am accompanied by Mr. Peter Ryan and Mr. Martin Fraser.

Comment on this

The committee is resuming its deliberations on Campus and Stadium Ireland Development Limited, Financial Statement 10 December 1991 to 31 December 2000. Before resuming I invite the Comptroller and Auditor General to contribute.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

At an earlier hearing I described the provision of executive services by way of contracting out as a novel approach to the administration of a large public capital project. There was not necessarily an implied criticism in that statement. There is always a place for innovation and novelty in the delivery of any services but my concern related to the way we went about it in this case. Normally, if one is going to commit up to €12 million of taxpayers' money to a particular approach prudence demands that the approach be costed against alternative forms of service delivery. That did not happen in this case. When you add on the fact that cost was not a factor in the assessment of proposals to provide a service, it is difficult to see how the most economically advantageous solution is being achieved. Moreover, when the contract eventually signed is based on a percentage of an unknown final cost of the project and does not provide for periodic review during the five year course of the contract, it is difficult to come to any other conclusion but that the public purse is not being properly protected. We now have a situation where the company in question which is providing the executive services is being paid €127,000 per month, even though the scale of the work must have been reduced as a result of the main project being in abeyance for a number of months. A number of questions arise. How do we know we have been getting the quantum of executive services which would justify the ongoing payment of €127,000 per month? How do we know the time allocations and the charge out rates were reasonable in the first place? To look forward, how can the contract be renegotiated or even terminated to take account of the new scenario in which an interim chief executive has been appointed? Certainly there has been mention of the possible engagement of a full-time financial director. These are the kinds of issues that have to be addressed satisfactorily if value for money is to be achieved on this front from here on in.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Laura Magahy for attending the meeting. Do you wish to make an opening statement?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

No, Chairman, I am here to take questions from the committee.

Comment on this

Thank you. I proceed to questions and call Deputy Bell.

Comment on this

I wish to address my first question to Mr. Murphy which is a follow-up to the questions I posed at the last two meetings. Why was the Office of Public Works not selected to carry out this contract in its entirety given that it had charge of many very large State projects, the present one being for €200 million on behalf of the Department of Agriculture, Food and Rural Development? From what was said I understood the Office of Public Works was not capable of carrying out this major project. In view of the developments since the last meeting and the fact that the Office of Public Works has been given charge of the project, how did the change of mind come about? Did you suddenly change from a "Mr. Badman" to a "Mr. Goodman" and you are now fully equipped, fully financed and fully capable of doing a project which the Government of the day did not think you were capable of doing some 12 months ago? Are you confident you are capable of completing that project on time and in accordance with the contracts laid down? How do you propose to take over the contacts which have been assigned to other people and other companies? What are the financial implications for taxpayers?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

We were always capable, always fully financed and almost reasonably staffed for it. It was a Government choice to set up CSID and to have executive services, as I understand it. The fact that things have panned out in the way they have and that we may have more control of the project than we had previously comes back to a situation where the Office of Public Works is still capable of carrying out this project, and all the major projects we have, on time and on budget. I cannot offer reasons.

Comment on this

In regard to the second part of that question, what financial implications has this for the taxpayer and what changes is Office of Public Works considering in relation to existing contracts for people already on site and already under contact for the payment of State funds?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

We would be concerned to get value for money. We are subject to the Committee of Public Accounts and to the examinations of the Comptroller and Auditor General in the normal way. It is too early to say what will happen next. Our interim chief executive of the outfit only happened on Thursday of last week and it is far too early for us to say what changes we might yet put into effect.

Comment on this

Apart from what we have read in the national media over the past 48 hours or so, neither this committee nor Dáil Éireann would be aware of the conditions under which this important change was made by the Government - I am sure the reasons will be spelled out eventually - but it would be interesting if Mr. Murphy indicated the conditions under which he has now been appointed as the controlling organisation of this major project.

Comment on this

Mr. Murphy, you might clarify first whether Mr. Benton has been appointed as an interim chief executive and perhaps you would define the role of the board of works in that context. Deputy Bell is on the right track but we want to find out what your role is now.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

There was a decision by Government on Tuesday of last week, if I have that correctly. I do not have the text in front of me and I am not sure if Mr. McCarthy has it but if I recall the wording affecting the Office of Public Works, the Government simply said it would facilitate CSID in employing an interim chief executive officer through the Office of Public Works. Those are the exact words as I remember them.

Comment on this

And you would nominate Mr. Benton?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Yes.

Comment on this

What does Mr. Murphy propose to do about the CSID situation in terms of the contract and the relationship between the Office of Public Works and the consultants, headed by Laura Magahy, whom we have not met previously but who is very welcome? Will he propose to pay off the company headed by Ms Magahy and terminate the contract or continue it under the circumstances in which it was negotiated?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I have a completely open mind on that. I have no view on it yet because it is only a couple of days since we took over the project and we will take account of the terms of the contract and everything that has been said here, so we have a fair amount of examination to do before we even begin to form a view on it.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I want to put a number of points on the record, Chairman. First, the Office of Public Works was involved in the project as project managers right through to the beginning of the year 2001, so it is not true to say that the Office of Public Works was not involved. Second, I want to again put on the record what I said at the last meeting, namely, that at every stage of the Office of Public Works's involvement I, as executive chairman, wanted it to be involved. The decision that was ultimately made centred on whether there was an acceptance that the Office of Public Works people would report to CSID. This arose at a board meeting of Campus and Stadium Ireland Development recently and Seán Benton was very clear that he was now reporting, in so far as the project was concerned, to the board of Campus and Stadium Ireland Development. I just want to put those points on the record for the sake of balance in terms of what was said.

Comment on this

I was not talking about involvement, as Mr. Teahon will remember from the last two meetings. I was talking about control by the Office of Public Works, not its involvement. We all know it has an involvement but I thought, as one member of this committee, that it should have had control. There is a difference between an involvement and having control.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

The point I was making, with respect, is that the control of the project is and continues to be with the board of Campus and Stadium Ireland Development.

Comment on this

Perhaps that can be changed too. What is Ms Hayes's opinion on her Department and the changes that have now been decided? What difference will they make to her, as the major player in the operation?

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

My understanding is that our responsibilities remain exactly the same as they were on transfer of responsibility for this project from the Department of the Taoiseach over a year ago. The main impact of the Government's decision was to separate the role of chief executive and chair, to appoint a new interim chairperson, Mr. Con Haugh, and that the board, on recommendation from Office of Public Works of a nominee, appointed an interim chief executive. The interim nature of these appointments is contingent on final Government decision following consideration of the High Point Rendell review of the future shape, structure and scale of this project and the Government will then put in place permanent arrangements to take this project forward but as Mr. Teahon said, the company remains in place, the board retains its role for the overall control of the project and it has a new chief executive in place, reporting for the interim, and a new chairman.

Comment on this

Would Ms Hayes be happy with the changes that have been made?

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

I will implement Government policy as they state it. I have no reason to be unhappy with it.

Comment on this

Is Ms Hayes opposed to it?

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

No, I am not.

Comment on this

I put my final question to Ms Magahy. What is the situation as far as her company is concerned now that a major change has been made which means, effectively, that the controlling interest will be held by the Office of Public Works? Is Ms Magahy happy with that and what effect will that change have on the contract she had with the company, with which we are not au fait because we have not seen it? Why would it cost the taxpayer €1 million plus if the contract was terminated?

Comment on this

The contract was circulated to the members but if the Deputy does not have a copy, we will issue one to him.

Comment on this

I have not seen it.

Comment on this

We have copies.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

I look forward to working with the Office of Public Works. We had good working relations with the Office of Public Works when it acted as project manager on the project and I look forward to working with Seán Benton as the interim chief executive.

Comment on this

The media created the impression that Ms Magahy would have difficulty working with the Office of Public Works in view of the enormous amount of taxpayers' money involved. Would Ms Magahy like to expand on that so that the media can report what she has to say, as the chief executive?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

I say again that I have no problem whatsoever working with the Office of Public Works. I respect its work. We got on well as colleagues when we were on the job together and I would be more than happy to work to Seán Benton as chief executive.

Comment on this

Before you leave that point, in the context of the Office of Public Works involvement now, to what degree would there be duplication vis-à-vis its role and your role in terms of your executive services?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

Mr. Murphy has said that it is not yet clear what will be the involvement of the Office of Public Works as an organisation going forward. It is clear that Mr. Benton is the interim chief executive, but in regard to how wide the involvement of the Office of Public Works will be, I simply do not know at this point. I have started a discussion with Mr. Benton about our contract and I hope to conclude that by the end of next week.

Comment on this

Mr. Murphy, do you see a duplication of the role of the Office of Public Works and your role or is its role as providing exclusive executive services complementary to what you do? Do you have a view on that?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I do not have a view on it yet. As of now there is no duplication of work. As Laura Magahy has just said, all that has happened so far is that we have supplied an interim chief executive and it will take the coming week for us to work out the practical implications of that in terms of services.

Comment on this

Looking ahead, do you see it as a duplication of some of the services that you, in your new capacity, can provide because your objective is to get involved in the project? In the context of what is being provided now, do you see yourself providing something different?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Again, I am slow to answer that question. I undertake that there will not be duplication of services, but beyond that I cannot give an outline of how the services will be organised. I would prefer to let Commissioner Benton and Laura Magahy work through this.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Some of the replies confuse me. We had better get something right on governance. Let us get this clear, am I right in saying the Office of Public Works is not involved in providing executive services for Campus Stadium Ireland?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

That is what I said. As of this moment we do not provide them, but we have provided the interim chief executive.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

That is correct. He is a Government appointee to the board. I imagine the job of chief executive is full-time. Will he cease his activities as a commissioner? That is the key issue from a personnel management point of view for which you would be responsible.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I am not sure if it is appreciated that Commissioner Benton has had 431 projects with clients of all shapes and sizes and that this is his 432nd. He will remain a commissioner of public works and provide the interim chief executive services. To the extent that the service in this case will require full-time application by him, it will get it, but I cannot assess at this moment how much time will be needed. I do not think it was ever regarded as a full-time job.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

That is precisely the point with which I want to deal. Given that you have made certain criticisms of the way the decision on the awarding of the executive services contract was made, that you would have liked to have been there if circumstances had been slightly different and the human cry about Mr. Teahon's stewardship of the role, from a taxpayer's point of view, do you not think it would be a good idea to have a full-time chief executive seconded from the Office of Public Works working full-time on the project, having regard to its financial implications for the State and the taxpayer?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I do not think I have made any criticism of the executive services. I absolutely have not. On the full-time nature of the job, I hark back to what Margaret Hayes said, that the main project is in a state of suspension until the Government addresses the High Point Rendell report and decides, in a policy way, what is the best way forward. There is that gap in the whole process.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I understand there is a gap in the process. Given that there has been considerable brouhaha about taxpayer's money and interest in regard to the overall stewardship of this strategically and long-term financially important taxpayer's project, is it the intention of the Office of Public Works to supply a full-time chief executive fairly quickly?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

We will provide the full service that is required. As of now, as I have made clear, we have not measured it yet.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Let me put it another way. The Government has appointed somebody to head up and be chief executive of a project which has caused significant controversy in terms of the allocation of and the potential downside risk to taxpayer's money, but we still do not know whether this person will be fully seconded to the project to work directly to the CSID board. Significant issues have arisen regarding the management of the project. It is important to have clarity going forward on the issue.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

The main thing at the present moment is to bring the pool project in on time and budget. That is central thing.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

From my experience of having been in the private sector, I would imagine that even the pool project on its own, costing £876 million - perhaps I am being naive in this respect - would require a full-time chief executive.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

In fact, we have a company working full-time on project management or rather it is being done through CSID.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

That is precisely what I want to get to grips with. Significant criticisms of Ms Magahy's company have been aired in the public media. You are saying that as of now you would be quite comfortable with a part-time chief executive overseeing a project in which Ms Magahy's company is providing the substance of the project management through her executive services team. That seems to indicate confidence in Ms Magahy.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I have not said we are happy to provide a part-time chief executive officer. I said our interim chief executive officer will provide as much of his time, up to 100%, as is required by the project.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I do not want to accuse you of being Sir Humphrey, but we need clarity on whether the interim chief executive officer will work full-time or part-time on the project. There are only two choices. He will either check in for work on the project on a full-time or part-time basis. That is how I define it. That may be putting it simply, but I think it is fairly clear.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

My clear answer to the Deputy is that if it requires this, it will get it.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

What is the situation? Perhaps I am asking the wrong person.

Comment on this

Mr. Murphy just said that if it requires it, he will give it.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I do not know of how many civil servants here I have to ask that question. Will there be a full-time chief executive officer for the project? I do not want to know about an interim chief executive officer or otherwise. Will there be a chief executive assigned full-time to the project? When was Mr. Benton appointed?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

On Thursday last. Can I say——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Is Mr. Benton clear on what his working arrangements will be?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Absolutely.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

What are those working arrangements and does his job specification specify that he should work 100% or part-time on the project?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

He is a commissioner of public works. One of his jobs is as interim chief executive of the company. Whether there will a full-time chief executive in time will depend on the outcome of the Government's review of the High Point Rendell report. As we now stand——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I am still worried about project management issues that arise in the day-to-day running of the project and the stewardship of Ms Magahy's executive services team. Irrespective of whether major projects are being reviewed or analysed, they still need strong executive leadership. Perhaps I am being naive and misunderstanding something, but I would have thought that a project such as this with its financial implications would have required somebody working full-time on it as of now or as of yesterday. Is that the situation?

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

Maybe I can help. The first thing to remember is that the Government has already separated the role of chairman and chief executive. It now has a completely separate chairman and chief executive.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I am aware of that, but that is not the question I am asking.

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

The board has accepted the interim arrangement facilitated by the Office of Public Works. It will be a matter for it to determine the level of input it requires from the chief executive, even on an interim basis.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

If it is okay, I will switch my question to Mr. Haugh, the chairman. We are thankful to you for being here. Do you feel it is appropriate to have a full-time chief executive for the project and that it requires de nova, today or yesterday, a full-time chief executive - I believe Mr. Benton is very good at his job, of which I have experience from my earlier working life - given the controversy there has been about it?

Comment on this
Mr. Haugh

The board met on Thursday last and appointed me as chairman and Mr. Benton as interim chief executive. What is to happen now is that Mr. Benton, as chief executive, has to assess what is the role, the workload etc. of the chief executive. I am heartened by Mr. Murphy's comment that if this requires Mr. Benton to be available on a full-time basis, he will be available. Obviously, the board is anxious that the work which CSID is undertaking is managed in an efficient and effective manner. If Mr. Benton is required on a full-time basis, I am given to understand he will be available.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

As of now, he is not working 100% on the job. He has been in the job one week, but is not 100% involved in it.

Comment on this
Mr. Haugh

He was appointed to the job on Thursday afternoon. Taking into account the Easter break——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

That is fair enough. I agree.

Comment on this
Mr. Haugh

——it is not unreasonable that he might have a few more days——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Great. What time do you envisage us having a decision in relation to whether he will be full-time or part-time? Do you have an estimate of the length of time he will be required?

Comment on this
Mr. Haugh

As I say, the next board meeting is on 18 April so by that time we will be in a position to give a firm judgment on that.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

But you have no instinct, as chairman, as to whether your requirements are full-time or part-time?

Comment on this
Mr. Haugh

Again, I would be loath to make any judgment on that at the moment until such time as we have assessed the implications.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

You have no particular view as to whether it is necessary to have a chief executive officer?

Comment on this
Mr. Haugh

I am not prepared to make any public comment on that at this time.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Ms Magahy, you heard the commentary of the Comptroller and Auditor General in relation to the approach that was taken to the structuring of your contract. It was indicated by Mr. Teahon at the meeting before last that there has been a substantive review of that contract. Have you any information to impart in relation to the current position of the contract for executive services with CSID? Where does that stand now? Has it been agreed or is it still under negotiation?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

As I understand it, it was agreed at the last board meeting that Mr. Benton would be mandated to discuss the proposal that we put to the board on 4 March this year with me as director of executive services.

Comment on this

Can you just clarify if it was 4 March? You mentioned proposals to the board of Campus Stadium Ireland Development agency on 28 June.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

That was June 2001, but, on foot of some correspondence from the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation in February, which basically indicated that the project was being scaled down and was effectively being put on hold, we were asked to consider what level of revised service might be appropriate.

Comment on this

Have we got a copy of the revised proposals of February this year?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

4 March. Yes, I sent it through last week.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

It might be useful to have them.

Comment on this

It would. We have several proposals at this stage and we would like to know what is the up to date one.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Can I clarify that? You have, effectively, three documents. You have the original contract, you have a second proposal which was made voluntarily by Ms Magahy and then you have a third proposal which was one for a lesser contribution based on the fact that, as somebody said already, the main business was not going ahead.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Right. I am clear to that extent. The main contract has been formally agreed. That, as far as your company is concerned, would be considered a legal contract.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

It is a legal contract.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

And binding?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

Yes.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

So the second proposal represents an attempt by you to revise your contract with CSID in the light of public clamour about the 1.8% issue going forward. Is that the case?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

It was on foot of the fact that the project seemed to be larger than was originally envisaged and that there was more certainty about the size of the project. It was in an effort to have more transparency which, I think, Mr. Purcell had indicated he would like and we were perfectly happy to row in with it.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

When was that second proposal?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

The proposal was made in June 2001 by our team.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I am trying to get the chronology right. Was agreement ever finalised on revising that contract?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

No, it was not.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

You are saying, therefore, that although you initiated that in June 2001, you still have not heard any substantive response as to whether that was the way CSID or the Department was going to go in terms of revising your contract?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

I understood that they welcomed and accepted the principle of a capped fee and it was down to discussing then the level or nature of that capped fee.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

So from June to now you are still looking at the nature of the capped fee?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

Correct.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Has there been substantial documentation passing from the State side or the board to you to explain how that happens?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

Not directly with me, backwards and forwards, but I think the HPR report intervened in the meantime and therefore the scale of the project, which was envisaged as being larger, then suddenly got put in the spotlight, if you like, and it was to be debated as to how big or otherwise the project would be. I would understand that is why it was not actually——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Who was negotiating? When you indicated in 2001 your desire to have the contract amended and, presumably, tightened up from the Exchequer point of view, who negotiated with you about either lowering or controlling that fee?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

I put the proposal to the board and the board mandated the finance and audit committee to negotiate.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Who is the principal person who would have had discussions with you about it?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

I would have had discussions with Mr. Teahon.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

As chairman?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

As chairman and chief executive.

Comment on this

I ask the Deputy to conclude with his next question.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Yes. The other issue is the third proposal. How soon do you think this will be resolved? In the next week or two will there be a new contract?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

Yes, I would hope so. I discussed it with Mr. Benton very briefly yesterday and we agreed that what we would try to do is to have the situation resolved by tomorrow week.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

What is being discussed here is a review of your contract, not the termination of the contract.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

Absolutely, yes.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

As you understand it, termination has not been put to you.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

No, it has not.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

It has not been put to you.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

No.

Comment on this

Since the word "termination" has been used, Ms Magahy, in the original contract there is a termination clause. What are the terms of that termination clause, should it be terminated? The termination aspect has been much in the media in recent times.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

I have to check the documentation. I think you have it.

Comment on this

We have, but I prefer you to say it yourself.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

No problem.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Is the termination of contract an issue in the review?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

I am presuming that when the overall discussion about the level and nature of the service is being discussed with Mr. Benton, in the context of the project being on hold, that what we will get, effectively, is a new contract.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

You are saying that the termination fee is, as you would regard it, an academic issue?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

Yes.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

As you see it, it will not arise.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

If we can come to an agreement, which I fully expect we can, then it will not be an issue.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

You do not see it as an issue, in terms of the transparency mentioned earlier, that needed to be resolved as well?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

I do not see it as an issue. Let me be clear. I wanted as much transparency as possible as well. It was not something——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

That was forced upon you.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

We actually volunteered it; we wanted it and we are more keen than anyone to get a resolution to this issue.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

The £1 million figure seems to have attracted a lot of attention. Do you think that is a fair fee, given the amounts you are being paid on a monthly basis?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

I do not know where the £1 million figure came from, to be frank.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

You are saying it is not accurate?

Comment on this

I am publishing the details of the contract. As I said earlier, the £1 million is regularly mentioned in the media. Perhaps Ms Magahy would expand on the terms of the exit contract, if the contract was terminated. It is important that we should know.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

Under clause 10, CSID has the right to terminate the engagement under the agreement by notice in writing to Magahy and Company. Fees will be paid for services rendered during the period of notice in accordance with the fee proposal of 30 June. In the event that CSID were obliged to so terminate the engagement prior to the expiry of five years from the effective date, other than for reasons set out in paragraph 9 and 1.2 of paragraph 11 which follows, then compensation will be payable on the following basis - where at least six months notice is provided, compensation of a sum equivalent to one month's fee per year for each of the unexpired years of the five year period and, where less that six months notice is provided, additional compensation of a sum equivalent to one month's fee per month by which the period of notice actually provided is less than six months. Where a relevant period is part of a year or month, as appropriate, the compensation relative to that part shall be calculated on a pro rata basis. No other compensation, fees, costs, losses, expenses, etc. shall be paid on termination.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

There is some basis for the £1 million. Clearly, at the time the contract was signed, we were envisaging a five year contract. If, let us say, it was terminated and there were four years still to run, that would be £400,000. If no notice was given, £600,000 would be added on to that. That is where the £1 million figure comes from. In the circumstances, it could be up to £1 million.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Does that mean no notice was given and that there were four years of the contract left? In other words, I am talking about a situation where termination occurred in the first year of the contract.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

If termination occurred in the first year and no notice was given, Magahy and Company would be due compensation of approximately £1 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I want to clarify why six months is mentioned. Six months was put in because I judged that in any normal circumstance one would expect a significant period of notice to be given. If one goes into a contract such as this, one assumes that one will be able to give a reasonable period of notice. The normal situation one would consider would be where six months' notice would be provided. The figure of £1 million is generated to give the highest possible number in circumstances which no reasonable person would believe would apply.

Comment on this

What is the lowest possible number in that situation?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Zero.

Comment on this

Do you, Mr. Purcell, have any comment to make?

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

It goes down to zero towards the end of the five years. Ultimately, if one gives six months' notice——

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

The other point which needs to be made is that this contract was signed in a situation where we were talking about an executive services team. We were talking about a team of people who would be brought on board for a period of time. In the normal circumstance, the company which put that contract in place in terms of providing the team would have to have arrangements with a significant number of people. Those people had to have some comfort to get them to come on board. We cannot ask a person to do an important job and then tell them we can let them go without any notice. I am sure the committee would not like to think we took people on board in this project and then dispensed with them at a moment's notice. The reason there is such a provision is that people see themselves as being on board for a five year period.

The project was approved by the Government. It was always clear there was some question mark. I always hoped it was a question mark which would have been relatively insignificant. However, it proved to be more significant. In order to get good people on board on the basis that they would be there for a five year period, we had to provide a termination clause. A termination clause in those circumstances is perfectly reasonable. The type of termination clause provided was that if the contract was terminated, a reasonable judgment would be that the person would have six months' notice. One would hope that such a termination would not arise. The termination clause was reasonable in the circumstances.

Comment on this

The project was envisaged to be for five years. People in any large construction project are employed by the company to do a job. Are you saying it was better value for the taxpayer to have an executive services team, with a projected figure of £9.625 million over the five year period? Was that cheaper than employing skilled people and giving them £100,000 or £150,000?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

If the people were provided with normal employment contracts - the Comptroller and Auditor General used the word "innovative" - and let go in the circumstances now being talked about, it would have been more costly. If all the people were employed on normal employment contracts - in other words, if we told them we would employ them on a five year contract - no one would sign up to a five year normal employment contract. They would then have a five year contract. If, in those circumstances, a person had to be let go, he or she would have to be paid the full cost of that contract. It goes back to something Deputy Bell said at the outset.

The judgment made in relation to having an executive services team rather than normal employment contracts was made on two bases by me. Basis one was that we needed a significant number of good people in place relatively quickly, particularly because the Government had asked for the pool to be put in place for the Special Olympics. That was a clear and short-time deadline. If we wanted to get good people on board on that basis, undoubtedly the fastest way to do it was through an executive services team. We then had to ask if there was any significant downside relative to employing all the people on normal employment contracts in a longer period of time, but for a five year term. One would not get good people on board for shorter than a five year term because everyone knew we were talking about a five year term. In those circumstances, the executive services team which was put in place represented better value for the State than if we had employed people on the basis of normal employment contracts, leaving aside the time issue. Given that we were faced with a deadline, the judgment is significantly reinforced.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Talking about terminating five year contracts makes me nervous in the present climate.

Comment on this
John Dennehy Deputy Dennehy Fianna Fáil

That does not show much confidence.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Mr. Teahon stresses every day he is here that he wanted the Office of Public Works to be involved in the process. What factor decided that the Office of Public Works would not be involved in managing the project from the beginning?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

The papers provided by the Office of Public Works and the meeting chaired by the Minister for Finance answer that question. At a particular moment in time the Minister for Finance said a judgment had to be made by the Office of Public Works relative to the issue which arose on the day. In other words, were the Office of Public Works satisfied that the Office of Public Works people would report to the company and specifically to me as executive chair? Mr. Murphy and the Minister of State at the Department of Finance, Deputy Cullen, decided - I do not have a problem with the decision - that in their judgment they did not want to proceed on that basis. The decision was then made that the Office of Public Works would provide technical services for the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation in connection with the project and we, in Campus Stadium Ireland, would proceed by way of normal tender to recruit a company, which we did, to provide the project management services. That company was then put in place.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I do not want to enter into an argument or dialogue on this issue, but that is not the case. We were prepared to work for CSID, provided we had a formal legal agreement with it. We could not get it and did not work for it.

Comment on this

Did you sign a contract in February 2000?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I did.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I do not want to enter into a dispute with Mr. Barry Murphy, but what he says is untrue. If anyone wants to clarify the situation, they should ask the person who chaired the meeting which reached the agreement.

Comment on this

Who chaired it?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

The Minister for Finance.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

We cannot ask him today. I do not want to enter into a dispute between Mr. Murphy and Mr. Teahon, but want to continue with my questioning. Does the interim appointment of the chief executive allow the Office of Public Works to report to the company? I want to get clarification on that matter. That was not allowed in what was offered in the beginning.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I am not absolutely sure of your question, Deputy. We are facilitating the company and providing and interim chief executive for it. What further services we might provide, or what different arrangements there might be, simply have not been worked out yet. We will work it out over the coming week.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Will the general public know in advance of the expected May election that this will all be worked out?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I am not sure.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

These are the questions we, as members of the Committee of Public Accounts, are being asked by members of the public in our constituencies and elsewhere.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I would hope, Deputy, yes, that we will have some answers by then. I am not sure if I know the date of the May election but whatever the date is, I would hope that we would have some of the answers then.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Yes. I want to get a bit more clarification on this. On 4 March, Ms Magahy, they proposed some new contract arrangements. Has there been any response to that yet? The 4 March is a month ago today.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

Yes. As I said, I met with Mr. Benton last week - or yesterday, I am losing track of time - and we agreed that we would finalise the discussions on that by tomorrow week.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Is this all being arrived at on a voluntary basis, despite the fact that you say you have a legally binding contract the way you are? Why is there a necessity for re-negotiation at this stage?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

Well yes, first of all, the answer is that it is all being done on a voluntary basis. It is being done in the interests of more transparency which was called for by the C&AG, which I welcomed and which Mr. Teahon and the board wanted. We all wanted it so that is why it is being done.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Perhaps, Chairman, your committee could take some credit for arriving at this situation. Could we?

Comment on this

I am sure the fact is that the committee has made the quote sequence very familiar to people.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

To get back again to what the C&AG said at the beginning, I think he used words such as "the public purse was not properly protected in the 1.8% of an unknown cost of the project". How was that 1.8% of the cost of the project arrived at? Who came up with that figure, or how was it arrived at?

Comment on this

Two per cent was suggested, Mr. Teahon, and I think you modified it to 1.8% in some documents we got.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

That is right. In fact, it was modified to 1.75% in a negotiation between Ms Magahy and myself. The percentage arose by reference to the percentage that professional people, who would be paid on a professional basis, would expect to get paid. The fact that the number was also reasonable in a more transparent way is provided for, if you look at the first voluntary proposal from Ms Magahy, which shows that, on the basis of a time input multiplied by a charge-out rate, the figure is not significantly different.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Yes, but is it normal that there would be a percentage of an unknown cost?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Professional people in construction projects, like architects, are always paid on that basis. Everybody believes in their estimate of the cost but the percentage applies to a cost.

Comment on this

Mr. Murphy, is there a scale with regard to contracts you have been involved with, or do you negotiate?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

For the European contracts, part of the criteria is the amount bid so there is an actual bidding process for the fee. But it is not quite so straightforward, as has been said. Our estimating processes are quite refined and I am glad to say that your own committee has only hauled me over the coals once in the last ten years for having a cost overrun on a project. So, our mechanisms for getting a price on which fees are based is well established. Then the fee is paid for specific work done so that at each stage only a portion is paid. I have the exact amounts here. We pay a certain amount of the fee at outline proposal stage, a certain amount more at the scheme design stage, and so on. At construction stage, when we get into that area, where you might have a cost overrun if you had not prepared properly for it, there is only 15% of the overall fee left to be paid. It is a segmented fee, as you go along. There are controls at each point. It is not simply a single fee on an outcome.

Comment on this

Can you tell us whether Mr. Benton, who was originally in the three-member panel who assessed the tenders - I will not use the word "competitive" tender because I think it was a range of services that was offered originally - and awarded the contract to Laura Magahy's company, expressed any reservations to you that there was no financial consideration attached to the actual tenders themselves? As we know, the percentage was negotiated afterwards.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Can I hark back to our meeting, I think it was the last day, where I explained to you that the assessment panel was involved only at looking at a set of written submissions? That was their job. There was no involvement by them in establishing the bona fides of the various bidders, that was a matter for CSID, nor was there any way that the assessment panel could guarantee the extent to which the personnel and companies being offered in the consortium would be the actual personnel and companies that would ultimately take up the particular job.

Comment on this

The question is, with your expertise in the Board of Works, and Mr. Benton being a senior commissioner, did he think it unusual in a bidding process that if people gave a range of services they would provide, there was no financial quantification of those services? I believe there were three applications in the final assessment. There was only an assessment on a range of services, so I do not think it could be used as a competitive tendering process because, to me, tendering has a financial linkage.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I accept that fully, Chairman. All that the assessment panel was asked to look at was, I think, seven tenders, finally. They were not tenders in that sense, they were statements of services that could be provided. The assessment panel only looked at these services, they did not look at the cost of them.

Comment on this

But they did select Laura Magahy's company for the executive services contract, based on the suite of services that were going to be provided.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Yes. What they said was that for the personnel and companies offered, the service being offered through them was one that would meet the technical requirements of an executive services package.

Comment on this

But there was no financial quantification of the other two tenders?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

No, none, nor was any offered.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

As a matter of clarification, Chairman, since I made the statement the last day, I checked and what I said is correct - that we asked if the approach should be the one that was adopted. We were told that under the Department of Finance's so-called "green book" the way in which you should approach these contacts was, in the first instance, to select one preferred team, in this instance, and then to negotiate a fee with that team. It may have changed since then and I agree wholeheartedly with the Comptroller and Auditor General when he said it would make far more sense if you negotiated the team, the people and the fee as part of the process. But I did check and that is what we were informed at the time - that this was the way in which you should go about doing it.

Comment on this

Does the Department of Finance wish to comment?

Comment on this

I am not an expert on procurement but I have the green booklet here. Appendix 2 of this booklet, which is on page 40, sets out Department of Finance circular 24 of 1993. It is dated 3 November 1993. It revises circular 11 of 1987. Circular 11 of 1987 must be read in conjunction with this and it is in appendix 1. They refer to the professional fees for construction contracts. In reading those, you have to have regard to what a consultancy contract is in that context as, I think, was referred to in the legal advice provided by McCann Fitzgerald of which the committee has a copy. It refers to a different part of the green booklet which is chapter 3, page 11 and, particularly, page 12 which talks about the engagement of management and other consultants. When you get into what is covered by procedures, you are into matters of EU law and whether EU directives apply. McCann Fitzgerald provided advice to CSID on that matter and it came to the view that the EU directives do not apply.

In the context of what the actual services were, you have to form an opinion as to whether it falls under the engagement of consultants or circular 11 of 1987 which deals with construction. When you deal with circular 11 of 1987 and if you read paragraph 3.1 of page 11, it refers to particular types of services which include design, architects and quantity surveying types of ones whereas paragraph 3.3 refers to other consultancies. It is quite a confusing picture in terms of what applies in particular instances here.

Certainly, if we are talking about consultancy work, I would regard paragraphs 11 and 12 as applying. In paragraph 12, there are requirements for consultancy engagements, the principal steps to be taken, and I would regard those as applying in those types of consultancies. So, it is quite a complex one and I am not familiar with the detail - I am not a legal expert. I was just trying to be helpful to the committee in explaining that I think it depends on what you look at. If you look at construction and at services in that context, like design, quantity surveying and so on, circular 11 of 1987 applies and if it is at other ones, the relevant part of the green booklet that applies is pages 11 and 12.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Mr. O'Brien, in your view, into which one does executive services fall?

Comment on this

I am not a legal expert and this is where the advice from McCann Fitzgerald is quite important as to where it sees it falling and on which it advises CSID. It concludes that it is not covered by the EU directive. I am not a legal expert and I cannot give an opinion on that.

Comment on this

If the whole principle of executive services is accepted and if services contracts embrace such things as advertising, property management, architecture, engineering, surveying, management consultancy and so on, if the contract is in excess of €166,000 - we are talking about contracts of £1.2 million in 2001 - and if you are not an expert, do you think the Department of Finance should get clarification for the future? Otherwise we might have a situation where the words "executive services" are used rather than "consultancy services" because if you use the words "consultancy services", you would have to advertise in the European Union journal in the 15 member states? You may not be an expert. However, if you have the procurement guidelines, as you have here, you would want to get clarification on that because a company in the future may say it is providing executive services rather than consultancy services because it would cover what it is doing.

Comment on this

One of the lessons arising from the consideration by the committee here will be that we will have to look at the green booklet to give greater clarity in this area. I stress that the responsibility of implementing EU directives, which are legally binding, is on the contracting authority. Your point, Chairman, is well taken. We will have to look at the green booklet to give greater clarity in terms of——

Comment on this

I will ask the Comptroller and Auditor General to make an observation.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

What you said, Chairman, and what the Department of Finance representative said in response was the point I was going to make. The green booklet is totally inadequate for the type of services which have developed over the years since 1994. The negotiated procedure envisaged in the green booklet, public procurement, was one which applied to things like architectural and engineering services. You had, on the other hand, quite brief references to the engagement of consultants. Something which fell in between was in never-never land. That needs to be addressed because we were all in agreement - the executive chairman agreed with me on that - that it was totally inadequate to go into this particular provision of executive services without cost being a factor.

What we are all trying to achieve here is the most economically advantageous tender. The green booklet refers to using various criteria such as price, period for completion, running costs, profitability and technical merit. These are mentioned in it but price is number one. We may have had legal advice to go a particular way but the principles underlying public procurement certainly were not followed in order to gain the most advantageous economic solution.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

To make one point which is, if you like, in addition to that, you made the point the last day, Chairman, and you asked me if, in fact, any people had applied internationally. We advertised this, even though there was no requirement to do so, in the Financial Times. We got three applications of substance which were part of the final assessment. There was a requirement for people to indicate an outline fee. I checked on those and, in fact, they were significantly above in terms of the basic amounts that would apply to the people who came from Ireland. Who knows what would have happened if - I agree with the Comptroller and Auditor General on this - we had had a hard negotiation? On the basis of the information that became available, the people who applied from abroad were quoting higher fees than the people who applied from Ireland.

Comment on this

We will leave that point. We appreciate the fact the Department of Finance is going to look at the whole public procurement policy——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Chairman——

Comment on this

We will come back to questions later.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

This is very important. If the fees of the other bidders were all higher, we need a read-out on that because of the significance being made of the cost of the executive services contract. The other bidders were all higher.

Comment on this

According to Mr. Murphy, who Mr. Benton was——

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

We should reserve drawing any conclusions until we have heard all the evidence.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

But we need the documentation, Chairman.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

I will try to keep my questions short because my last one led to a long discussion. There seems to be a conflict of opinion. Our job concerns value for money and the expenditure of State money. The Comptroller and Auditor General said that the public purse was not properly protected and Mr. Teahon said he got the best value for money. Who is right?

Comment on this

The jury is still out on that. The Comptroller and Auditor General may like to comment on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

I am sorry for hogging the debate, Chairman, but I said that there were three different factors which, for me, would pose a risk to the achievement of value for money. The achievement of value for money can be difficult and the relationship between the procedures you follow and the end result are not always unequivocal. Certainly, there were risks and I outlined three particular steps at which those risks existed.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I will make one final brief point because there now appears to be a big difference of opinion between me and the Comptroller and Auditor General which is not the case. I agree completely with the Comptroller and Auditor General that we would have been in a far better situation if we negotiated the people and the fee as part of the one system. Between us, we are completely agreed on that. I happen to believe that the contract that was negotiated provides value for money. I accept the point the Comptroller and Auditor General makes about risks and I still believe the contract provides value for money.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

I will not press the matter further, although I am still unclear on it. The Comptroller and Auditor General mentioned a figure of €127,000. To what does it refer?

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

It is the flat fee per month being paid to the executive services company.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Is that on top of 1.75%——

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

No. The figure of 1.75% or 1.8% was put into abeyance——

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

This is very important. I am of the view that people believe that, somehow, this figure of 1.8% applied at some point in time. It has never applied. Based on the voluntary proposal made by Ms Magahy, it never will apply. It is important that people out there, who I accept have a legitimate concern, understand that. It never applied and probably never will.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

I am not so concerned with the people out there, but with our duty here. If there is a figure of 1.5%, 1.7% or 1.8% off the total cost, that concerns us.

Comment on this

I accept that.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

The figure of 1.8%, as it applied to the executive services team's fees, £100,000 per month, was based on 1.8% of a particular contract amount - I think £320 million. From that point of view, the figure of 1.8% formed the basis for the flat monthly fee. The original contract envisaged that if the figure of 1.8% was ultimately greater, more would be paid to the executive services team.

Comment on this

The figures are 1.75%, 1.8% and £100,000 per month. Ms Magahy, what services are you providing for €127,000 per month?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

I am delighted to take the opportunity to respond to that question. First, the executive services team has a team approach. It comprises PricewaterhouseCoopers, McHugh Consultants, SIAS Ireland, transport consultants, WHPR and Magahy and Company. For a period of time it also included Seamus Monahan and Partners, project management services. The difference between the figures of 1.8% and 1.75% is that Seamus Monahan and Partners withdrew at a point in time when the Office of Public Works retired from being project managers and when CSID had to advertise for one. Seamus Monahan and Partners decided it would like to apply as project manager, hence it withdrew from our team. That explains the difference.

The figure of £100,000 was based originally on an estimated project cost of £330 million which, as I understand it, arose from the PricewaterhouseCoopers original stadium price estimate, plus the cost of the pool. The cost of the stadium and others was £270 million and the pool, £48.4 million, which arrive at a figure of £330 million. That was the estimated cost of the project at the time.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Does it still exist, despite the fact that the main project will not now go ahead? It will not proceed before the general election because it is political dynamite, in one way. Perhaps that is not the cause of its deferral. Does the fee of €127,000 still exist?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

Perhaps I could explain the service we have been providing for that sum.

Comment on this

Deputy McCormack points out that on 1 January 2001, £100,000 per month was paid to you while on 1 January 2002, £100,000 was paid. It has been known for some time that the overall development has been stalled and you are proceeding with the aquatic stadium. The Deputy is pointing out that the level of service is static and wants to know what you are providing now and the reason you are still getting the same fee each month.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

We were notified of the scaling down in the middle of February. Until that point we were providing the full suite of services and all the people were working on the project. We had three objectives to achieve within a very short space of time. We were appointed just a year and a half ago, in September 2000. The three objectives we were set to achieve were, first, to get the aquatic centre up and running on time, on site and on budget - that has been achieved; second, to bring the overall sports campus Ireland idea up to the point where it was ready to submit for a planning scheme to Fingal County Council - that is what we have here. All the documents are here. It is the work on which we have all been engaged. That is what we were required to do.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

All along there was a serious doubt that the main project would ever proceed.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

May I continue?

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

All right.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

The third thing we were required to do was to bring all the sports facilities, which include the stadium, the arena, the multi-purpose hall, the sports, science and medical centre and the pitches, and the commercial facilities up to the point where we would have some kind of price outline for them. We did this and brought them into the right price by receipt of private sector bids in June last year. We have brought the scheme, as required and requested by the board of Sports Campus Ireland, to that point, including from the point of view of master planning, the demand for and feasibility of the various sports facilities, transportation and infrastructure planning, commercial and community uses, examining the financial feasibility and funding scenarios to deliver the uses within the budget set, programming the whole project to meet the five year delivery expectation, examining the property and getting the planning structure in place and consulting on the details with all the different stakeholders. That was the task we were set. We were not being paid £100,000 per month to do nothing. We had six full teams working on the project.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Despite the fact that there was a doubt about it going ahead for a long period of time.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

With respect, we were not told there was a doubt about the project. As far as we were concerned, the Government had——

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

There was a public debate taking place that created a doubt about the project ever going ahead and there was a debate taking place within the Government which also created doubt about it going ahead.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

As I say, we were working away to try to get this scheme in place, as we had been briefed.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Mr. Murphy said the Office of Public Works was still capable of overseeing the project, although I am not sure in what capacity. How long will this interim arrangement last until that becomes a definite arrangement?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

We do not have a time on it. I am assuming it is whatever length of time it takes for the Government to come to a decision on the future of the project as a whole.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Can you give an assurance that if the Office of Public Works is in an overseeing capacity - I am not sure about Mr. Benton's position - the Swimworld part of the project will be finished on time?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

As we have heard, that project is on time, as I understand it. It is being project managed by PKS, a private sector firm.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Why was there a necessity for interim management of a project that is not going ahead?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I understand the interim chief executive's role is to sort matters out in advance of a Government examination of the High Point Rendell report. I presume that is what will happen.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

Expand on what you mean by "sort matters out".

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Proposals will have to be put to the Cabinet, presumably, through the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation. They will have to be based on the views of the board of CSID. That is the job that has got to be done now, as I understand it.

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

To revisit some of the points Deputy McCormack and Ms Magahy discussed, the project was proceeding as planned from early 2000 right up until May 2001, when the Government decided to have a major cost overview carried out by independent consultants. At the same time the Government allowed the outline bid process for the major project to go the end of that phase of the bidding process, which was due to run to mid June. At the same time the consultants were put in place and CSID was asked to give full co-operation to the consultants to help them carry out their review.

CSID was also given specific Government permission to go ahead with a number of technical and scientific surveys relating to the site which would contribute to the overall planning preparation for the project. That would deal with working out the quality of soil surveys. There was a heritage survey to be carried out; a number of requirements in relation to a planned submission of a planning application at some time in the future. Therefore all those surveys had to be overseen as well by the executive services team.

The High Point Rendell cost overview was published at the end of January with a Government decision, which requested the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation to do the following: to report back to it on the implications of the High Point Rendell recommendations and options, and in particular to evaluate the viability of the existing tendering strategy, which is, as we discussed last week at some length, a design, build, operate, finance and maintain strategy, as a basis for any modifications of the stadium design and operation; to also evaluate the implications for the Exchequer of the options and recommendations identified in High Point Rendell report; and to look at the issues raised in paragraph 1.7 of the report which is about the overall management structure for the project.

The Government stated at the time that it remained convinced that a stadium project at Abbotstown was both desirable and feasible and that the Abbotstown campus can and will be developed into a vital infrastructural asset for the achievement of national aims in the field of sports, recreation and related tourism, and it is against that background that CSID has continued its work. Contemporaneous with all that work that I have outlined, which was ongoing in the latter half of last year at the planning stage, CSID was also completing the detailed contract negotiations on the pool.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

That clarifies a great deal for me but was there somebody talking out of both sides of their mouth? If, in May 2001, there was an independent review ordered by the Government, was there somebody saying, "Continue on with the work, this is only a minor part of the Government that is looking for that and we will get over that obstacle. We will get on, keep going."? Why did somebody at that stage say, "Now let us cease planning, work and expenditure on this project" because at that stage if one was looking for an independent review, it was likely it would have to take into account the opinion of the independent review when it was eventually presented in January 2002? I cannot understand why work continued and expenditure was allowed to continue in the period after the Government set up an independent review to look at the project.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

It is worth recalling the terms of reference, which unfortunately I do not have before me. My recollection of the terms of reference of the High Point Rendell report is that the objective of the review was to assist the Government in deciding on the amount of money that was appropriate to put the entire project in place.

I can read it out now; Mr. Donagh Morgan has just provided it for me. The terms of reference for the overview were "to assist Government in determining final Exchequer allocations for Stadium and Sports Campus Ireland and the sensitivity of such allocations to the variations in the scale of each element of the project". It seems to me that anybody reading those terms of reference, which were approved by the Government, would assume that what was in question was the amount of money one should spend, not whether the project would go ahead or not.

Comment on this
Pádraic McCormack Deputy McCormack Fine Gael

I know I cannot ask about Cabinet confidentiality, but was Mr. Teahon present at that Cabinet meeting when those matters were approved by the Government?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

No, I was not.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Chairman, who drafted those terms of reference?

Comment on this

Who drafted the terms of reference? Was it the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation?

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

I am trying to recall. I think they were——

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

If Mr. Teahon could lay his hand on that paragraph again, it is worth reading.

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

Does the Deputy mean the terms of reference?

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

If the Deputy wishes, I will read it again. If I could clarify one matter, lest that question is hanging in the air, I had no hand, act or part in the drafting of those terms of reference.

Comment on this

We would not dream of thinking that.

Comment on this