2000 Annual Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General and Appropriation Accounts: ›
Vote 10 - Office of Public Works (Resumed).
Contributions 260–526 of 791. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
I had no hand, act or part in that. What I read out was, "to assist Government in determining final Exchequer allocations for Stadium and Sports Campus Ireland and the sensitivity of such allocations to the variations in the scale of each element of the project". Then it goes on to say that the consultants will, etc.
Comment on this
It is a masterpiece anyway - that is all I wanted to record, not to suggest that Mr. Teahon wrote it. He can be very happy that his successors in the State service are——
Comment on this
The drafting involved a team of Ministers, led by my own Minister, Deputy McDaid.
Comment on this
Chairman, I have a couple of disjointed questions to ask. Can I ask Ms Magahy about the Attorney General's report, on page 19, where he records her as saying that the contracting entity has no substance? What did she mean by that?
Comment on this
Sorry, I just want to get it out, if I may. I believe it refers to the PricewaterhouseCoopers memo, which is——
Comment on this
The full sentence reads:
This meeting between Laura Magahy, Aidan Walsh and Kevin Kelly is detailed in a PwC memo which goes on to indicate that Laura Magahy commented on the situation whereby they were now faced with a "contracting entity that has no substance."
Comment on this
I believe that refers to the memo that is published in full——
Comment on this
——in Annex J of the Attorney's report. I was basically looking for clarification as to what the next step should be now that the preferred bidder had been selected and what the appropriate steps would be. The memo goes on to state that Kevin Kelly, who is from McCann Fitzgerald solicitors:
. . . commented that it would be normal to enter into contractual arrangements with a special purpose vehicle set up for the purposes of this particular contract and that these would be backed [up] by necessary parent company guarantees and an adequate amount of equity in the company. This needed to be resolved with the consortium members.
Comment on this
I was concerned to see that whatever contracting entity we had chosen would have the required backing.
Comment on this
What Ms Magahy said was that we are now faced with a "contracting entity that has no substance". Was that her view?
Comment on this
I do not actually recall saying that. I take it that I was concerned, after the meeting of the assessment panel, to make sure that the right contracting structures were put in place and that we had adequate backing.
Comment on this
I do not recall the exact circumstances of the day. I am not avoiding the question.
Comment on this
Was it your view that you were now faced with a contracting entity that had no substance?
Comment on this
No, it was not. One of the parties of the consortium had shown up in Pricewaterhouse's search as saying that it was dormant but certainly the consortium was not a contracting entity with no substance.
Comment on this
But these paragraphs in the Attorney General's report seem to be set against a background of having found that the successful contractor or bidder had no financial capacity and it seems to be recording Ms Magahy in a PwC memo as concluding in these discussions that it was an "entity that has no substance".
Comment on this
That is certainly not the case. First of all, CSID had not contracted with anybody at that stage.
Comment on this
The intention was to contract with the selected preferred bidder, subject to their assuring CSID that they had the requisite financial backing. The job of that meeting after the assessment was to make sure that whatever required financial backing that had to be demonstrated would be put in place and could be put in place.
Comment on this
All right. Did you think that the entity with which you were about to contract did have substance?
Comment on this
No. I am asking what you thought, Ms Magahy. You are the one who is recorded in the PwC memo. As I understand it, the Attorney General is doing no more than recording it from the PwC memo - presumably a contemporaneous note. Was it your view that it had no substance?
Comment on this
To be quite frank, until I saw the memo I had no memory of it at all because things were moving very quickly at that time. What I do know is that we wrote, on foot of that meeting, to the consortium to make sure they had the required financial and levels of guarantees that we——
Comment on this
But would it not be a terrible shock to be confronted with? If it is as presented in the Attorney General's report and in the contemporaneous record made by PwC, it would be a terrible shock to discover that one was contracting with an entity that had no substance.
Comment on this
I am sorry to repeat myself, but it was not an entity that had no substance so it was not my view.
Comment on this
You see it was not an entity that had no substance because it was a consortium. My concern was to make sure that the consortium with which we contracted would have the required financial backing and that CSID should not enter into any contract with anybody that did not have the required kind of backing. That meeting went on to draft a letter, as between Pricewaterhouse and Kevin Kelly of McCann Fitzgerald. . . to write to the consortium members asking them to set out their relevant financial backing to show us that they had it.
Comment on this
I know all that. If you want to take the opportunity to comment on it once more, Ms Magahy, that is fine. I understand that would have been very prudent indeed. All I am saying is that the Attorney General has concluded, from a PwC memo - presumably contemporaneous of the meetings - that you reached that conclusion. Are you saying to the committee that you did not reach that conclusion?
Comment on this
I am saying that I have no memory of saying those words. It does not even sound like the way I talk to be quite frank.
Comment on this
And what do you think now, with the benefit of hindsight? If you had said it, would you have been correct?
Comment on this
I do not think it is really. What happened was that the preferred bidder was selected. It was the best bid by a long shot. What needed to happen after the meeting was that whatever contracting——
Comment on this
We have heard Mr. Teahon make a very stout defence of the bidder that was selected, etc. I was not asking you about that, I was merely asking you about an apparent direct quote attributed to you.
Comment on this
Chairman, would it be possible to place on screen the contract of 18 August for executive services?
Comment on this
Deputy, lest you are moving away from it, can I make a very clear statement? If Laura Magahy had said that the contracting entity had no substance, she would have been wrong because the contracting entity was the consortium. If you look at the consortium, Ascon Rohcon clearly had substance. What was at issue - to the extent that it was at issue - was the substance of the company that was Waterworld UK.
Comment on this
I hear what you are saying, Mr. Teahon, but you will note I was asking Ms Magahy. I hear your view on it. Is it possible to put up the first page of the contract of 18 August 2000, Chairman?
Comment on this
The first page. Mr. Teahon, I am puzzled by one small aspect of this. This is a letter from you to Ms Magahy of 18 August, is that correct?
Comment on this
The thing that puzzles me is why it ended up as a joint effort? If we look at page five, Chairman, why did a document that started out as a letter from Mr. Teahon end up as——
Comment on this
Because the advice we received from our legal advisers was that to form a contract it had to be a letter from me to Ms Magahy which Ms Magahy accepted. That was the form of the contract that evolved. We were told "The way to do it is for Ms Magahy to accept the contract".
Comment on this
Is it not a bit odd that you started out writing a letter to Ms Magahy - it is addressed "Dear Ms Magahy" - on what was a hugely significant matter which she ended up signing as well?
Comment on this
Perhaps it would have been clearer if Ms Magahy had said "I accept the terms of the offer you have made to me", but other than that——
Comment on this
Would that not be normal practice? She did that on 18 October 2000. Would it not be normal practice for her to receive the letter and reply to it?
Comment on this
Why should it metamorphose into contract in this fashion? Who is the person who witnessed the letter?
Comment on this
It is Eve-Anne Cullinan, who is a director in my company.
Comment on this
This was dated 18 August. It seems not then to have been dispatched to your office and it seems to have been retained in the offices of CSID. Is that the case?
Comment on this
It is a duplicate letter, Deputy. It was a letter that was signed in duplicate.
Comment on this
When Mr. Teahon wrote to you on Sports Campus Ireland paper, was the letter dispatched to your office at Lombard Street West or did you meet at one or other of your offices to sign it with this fellow director of yours as the guarantor, with the company seal?
Comment on this
And I do not recollect either. You will notice, I had not noticed this until then, but it is dated a different day. In other words, the letter is dated the 18th but the accepting signature is dated the 21st.
Comment on this
That is my point. I wonder if it was posted, retained in your office or did you go on 21 August to Ms Magahy's office to convert what was a letter into a contract and sign it, witnessed by this fellow director of Ms Magahy? You cannot recall that, Mr. Teahon?
Comment on this
With the benefit of hindsight, it would be better if there were, as you suggest, a letter from Ms Magahy saying "I accept what you have put to me". However, in terms of substance I do not think it makes any difference. I am not sure if you are making a particular point relative to the substance of what took place.
Comment on this
One of points I am making is that which appears so much in the public press. Ms Magahy, are you in a position to provide any insight into the secret whereby you seem to land more than your fair share of contracts, on the face of it, where Mr. Teahon happens to be the chairman or the presiding person?
Comment on this
Are you suggesting I did not get contracts on merit?
Comment on this
I am just asking if you can give any insight. The same system, as I understand it, is applicable in the MediaLab contract. Does the percentage basis apply there?
Comment on this
No, it does not apply there. If you would like to know the process, we applied . . . we responded to a publicly advertised contract, we put a proposal to the company, Sports Campus Ireland, and we negotiated a contract. I do not see that Mr. Teahon's presence is relevant to us landing two contracts.
Comment on this
You must be as conscious as I am, Ms Magahy, that there has been much comment in the public media about the fact that, whether it is Temple Bar, the stadium or the media hub, the same personalities are involved in what must be a competitive arena, with weighty applicants from the homeland of the Financial Times applying. Do you wish to comment on that?
Comment on this
Only to say that we won all contracts on merit and that I was not part of the panel that assessed our applications, and that I resent any implications that we landed contracts as a result of knowing Mr. Teahon. I have no further comment to make.
Comment on this
I was not the only person that made the decisions involved. I believe that the people who made them were highly reputable. I also believe that there is a kind of implication that because Laura Magahy and I happen to know each other through our work together, even if her company was the best, that, to avoid what the people to whom Deputy Rabbitte refers might be suggesting, she should not have been awarded the contract. That would have been totally and completely wrong.
Comment on this
What is the point of Mr. Teahon's stressing that the percentage never applied? As the Comptroller and Auditor General commented, the flat rate is based on the percentage and, presumably, when Mr. Teahon entered into the contract for a percentage, the intention was that a percentage would apply.
Comment on this
I was not making a virtue of it, but making the point, in relation to people, who now believe that Laura Magahy was being paid 1.8% of £1 billion, that this was not so. It was never my intention and I have always stressed that £350 million, €444 million, was the figure that would apply. I also said that——
Comment on this
Actually, it says that the estimate of €444 million is a reasonable one, contrary to speculation in the media.
Comment on this
It also says that to deliver the project would be approximately twice the advised cost, which Mr. Teahon challenges.
Will Ms Magahy clarify the following? Was the percentage contract, which was entered into, to the consortium and were its elements paid on a charge-out basis of an hourly, daily or weekly rate? The figures we have show that they were paid a flat rate.
Comment on this
It is not clear from this document which contains the daily charge-out rates. Was the intention of the contract that the 1.8% would apply to each of the elements of the consortium, or was Ms Magahy, as the lead player, to pay out to the consortium's elements on an agreed weekly, daily or hourly charge of rates?
Comment on this
The agreed fee is split between the five parties that form our team and is a commercial arrangement between the team members.
Comment on this
Yes. I stress again - and also in reference to the Deputy's former question - that this contract was awarded to a consortium of reputable firms with track records in all of their areas relevant to performing their tasks which they have performed exceptionally well. PricewaterhouseCoopers, McHugh planning consultants, SIAS transport consultants, WHPR, Seamus Monahan & Partners and our own company are all part the consortium. We have delivered the three things that we were expected to deliver in one and a half years.
Comment on this
I made no adverse comment on any element of the consortium. Did Ms Magahy agree with each of these reputable companies a charge-out basis for their services?
Comment on this
We agreed between ourselves a commercial arrangement as to how we would organise our business.
Comment on this
Let me express it this way. If Mr. Teahon is wrong and High Point Rendell is right, and the cost of the project doubles, would the fees to the other elements of the consortia also double?
Comment on this
No, nor would mine because we had proposed in June 2001 that a capped fee would be agreed for the services. The percentage, therefore, no longer applied to ourselves or to the rest of the team.
Comment on this
I understand that, but that is not the contract before us on the screen, which is on the basis that a percentage would apply.
Comment on this
Ms Magahy cannot see what is on the screen as we felt that the information was commercially sensitive regarding the different companies involved. However, I am sure that she understands that the Deputy is referring to the daily charge-out rates.
Comment on this
If the original contract applied and if the project was larger and if more resources were required to be put in as a result of the larger project——
Comment on this
Then the 1.8% would have applied to the rest of the project, which is why, in fairness, we proposed a capped fee approach to allow for more transparency and to make sure that there was not the perception that we would benefit - as was suggested in the press - from deliberately making the project more expensive.
Comment on this
I take it that Mr. Finlay is Wilson Hartnell, another element of the consortium. If the original contract had applied and the cost was twice for the same size project, would Wilson Hartnell's fees have increased proportionately, or was the 1.8% a block payment to the consortium to be paid out by Ms Magahy? I would like an answer to that.
Comment on this
Mr. Finlay may be called before the committee but Ms Magahy may volunteer an answer if she wishes.
Comment on this
If more services had been required, then the fee would have gone up proportionately.
Comment on this
It is being paid at the commercial rate and is an arrangement between the consortium partners. There is a team of six——
Comment on this
There are two corollaries to the percentage. If the cost went down, the percentage would also go down, and if——
Comment on this
As of today, anybody's guess is as good as mine as to whether this project will see the light of day——
Comment on this
There are many reasons why things happen or do not happen. The other point is that if a project took twice as long, that is ten years instead of five, the same rate would apply and we would have people working for those ten years. That is the counter argument and that is why in the construction development business very often percentage rates are used, because projects can take twice as long. It is a cost benefit to the client on a percentage basis.
Comment on this
I do not know these other companies well, but can Ms Magahy tell us from her experience, if it is normal to pay a public relations company on a percentage basis.
Comment on this
I am not saying that it would be normal to put any particular people on a percentage basis. The contract that we negotiated was on a percentage basis and the team involved are members of an entire team and, furthermore, as I said already, we proposed that the contract be capped and that it would take place on a charge-out time basis.
Comment on this
I did so for several reasons. First, because the project seemed to have grown larger and there was public comment regarding the fact that it was larger than originally envisaged.
Comment on this
I am sorry. Ms Magahy is present to have a full opportunity to answer questions in her own time and to take as long as she wishes. However, she should not continue to refer to the project getting larger. It is still 80,000 seats or whatever. It may be getting more expensive, but it is not getting larger.
Comment on this
The project that we were hired to carry out was Sports Campus Ireland, not Stadium Ireland.
Comment on this
To answer Deputy Rabbitte, Ms Magahy said in the first part of her reply that in light of recent media speculation about the executive services fee she would be grateful, etc. She then suggested a new scale of fees. However, she attributed this to recent media speculation.
Comment on this
That is what I was saying, Chairman, but you interrupted me.
Comment on this
May I, with respect, tell the Deputy why the project became larger? When the Comptroller explained how the £100,000 came about, the figure to which it applied was the figure for the stadium and the pool. When the stage to which Ms Magahy is referring came about, we had a campus which had a stadium and an indoor arena. I am sure she will explain this. As a matter of fact, the figure which would have applied at that time was the total cost to which I keep referring - the £350 million cost to the Exchequer - which is about £550 million. One would have gone from a figure of £330 million to £550 million in that interim period.
Comment on this
Chairman, you anticipated what I was asking about. I was unaware that this had anything to do with larger or smaller. I thought this was about perception. I thought that Ms Magahy was responding to media criticism and that is what we, indirectly, understood from her. She is now saying that she came forward with this proposal because the project was getting larger.
Comment on this
I started to say that there were three reasons, but the Deputy cut across me. The first reason was genuinely because the project had become larger. I will go through that issue first.
We started with a greenfield site at Abbotstown around which the line is drawn. Our brief on being appointed was to develop Sports Campus Ireland. At that point a feasibility study had been carried out for the stadium and a wider campus had been mooted, but was not clearly defined or costed.
The other project discussed or agreed at Government was that the aquatic and leisure centre should be undertaken. In discussions and consultations with the board and a range of others, the definition of the campus, and what it could be for the sporting and non-sporting public, translated more into what appears on page two. That is a much more developed idea of what Sports Campus Ireland would be. It would include a stadium, an arena, the multi-purpose hall, the velodrome, outdoor pitches, the aquatic and leisure centre - one can see how small the pool is in relation to the overall project even though it is enormous in its own right - a tennis centre and a range of activities which the local community——
Comment on this
In consultation with the board and the chief executive, the project was developed further to turn into this vision.
Comment on this
So the original instructions were somewhat unclear and the project evolved as the board began to focus on it.
Comment on this
That is correct. What had been costed originally at about £330 million was now looking more like £550 million gross. However, it was also envisaged that commercial income would come in and that is why we get back to the net cost of £350 million. We negotiated a percentage in good faith about which there was media comment and we did not wish to be seen to be enlarging the project so that our fees would increase. That seemed to be the kind of implication being made. We were not interested in that as we were interested in delivering public sector projects which have a wider public benefit. In that interest, and in the interest of greater transparency regarding the fee - the Comptroller and Auditor General commented that this was a percentage-based fee and that to get greater transparency——
Comment on this
I discussed it with Mr. Teahon in January and I wrote to the board putting the proposal on 7 May 2001.
Comment on this
Did anyone in the Taoiseach's office, in the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation, the Office of Public Works or any State Department make that suggestion to Ms Magahy?
Comment on this
The only person to do so initially was the Comptroller. The Tánaiste remarked on it at a meeting with Government in March. Mr. Teahon said at that meeting that the fee was being discussed as a capped fee.
Comment on this
My understanding is that there was concern in the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation at the stage at which it took over the project. Is that correct?
Comment on this
We asked for a copy of the contract which we did not have on 26 January. Mr. Teahon forwarded it to us on 2 February. At a meeting with Ms Magahy on 8 March, having looked at the contract I asked her to provide a full schedule of the current level of resources provided under the contract and what the future planned executive services resource commitment was going to be. On 21 June I received the direct response to that request which was described as a revised fee proposal being presented to the board of CSID for discussion on 28 June 2001.
Comment on this
I suggested that we needed to know what exactly we were getting under this contract. We needed to know what resources were being offered for the fee being charged so we could establish the value for money we were getting.
Comment on this
On 21 June. I understood - and I think this is what happened - it was put down for discussion at the board meeting on 28 June.
Comment on this
What happened in the intervening six months since Ms Magahy mentioned this to Mr. Teahon in January? Was there toing and froing?
Comment on this
I was volunteering to do the proposal and I needed to discuss it with different consortia members. I wrote to the board on 7 May. I believe it went to the finance and audit committee on 13 June and I met Ms Hayes on 27 June.
Comment on this
What is the practical effect of the proposal and how should the committee assess it? Other than the fact that one is a flat fee and the other is a percentage, does it have much meaning? How was the figure of £100,000 per month settled on?
Comment on this
It was a percentage of what was then a £330 million project.
Comment on this
So we have altered the perception, but not the cost. It is important that we are clear on that.
Comment on this
The 1.8% at the time we are speaking about would have been applied to £550 million and not £330 million. Arguably, there should have been a higher figure had we maintained the same approach. In other words, £100,000 was 1.8% of £330 million. If we had followed through in the approach, it should have been increased from three to five.
Comment on this
The £100,000 is based on the £350 million project? As a successful business woman, and with a watertight contract in her pocket, why would Ms Magahy volunteer to take £100,000 on a project which had now increased to £550,000?
Comment on this
What I put was a resources chart which showed on charge-out rates how the resources might increase if the board wanted them to increase. I did this in the interests of transparency. I do not do public projects for the money. I am interested in procuring and managing public projects. It is not simply about the money. I did not want the perception to be that it was in my interest to increase the project such that I should get a larger fee. It is as simple as that. I am aware that in this day and age people are cynical but actually it is that simple.
Comment on this
Just to clarify for Deputy Rabbitte, we are not talking about a situation where, under the June 2001 proposal, the cost per month would have continued at £100,000. In fact, it was envisaged that it would increase to £150,000 for the remainder of 2001 and to £175,000 per month from 2002 to 2005 on the allocation of resources on the basis that the final project cost would be £550 million. That was how I came up with the cap of £9.625 million, which I roughly translated as €12 million. Perhaps that will clarify the matter for the Deputy.
Comment on this
It was a complete proposal which was open to be negotiated. If the board did not want the level of resources or if it wanted to change resources or take a different approach that was fine. I was proposing a transparent and open system which was open to the board if it did not want the percentage basis, and that stands.
Comment on this
Is it correct that the board accepted it, even though the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation had reservations about the charge-out rates?
Comment on this
According to the minutes here, the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation had reservations about the call-out rates.
Comment on this
When this matter was tabled at the board meeting in June, I raised the issue of the call-out charges being quite high. That was basically it.
Comment on this
Looking through the fee proposals that came to the board, I felt they were quite high in a number of categories. I raised that issue at the board meeting.
Comment on this
Had you previously received such a breakdown? Is that the first time a detailed document came to the board itemising the actual tasks for which the charge-out was being applied?
Comment on this
I cannot say for definite but I think so. I was on the board since February 2001.
Comment on this
To go back to the change in the structure, Mr. Benton's appointment and considering the earlier comments about the possible conflict of interest or the incompatibility between being adviser to the Minister and a member of the board CSID and so on, are there any difficulties now about that or are they all washed aside? Will a new format be used or how will the difficulties that existed be reconciled?
Comment on this
I am not absolutely sure to what conflict of interest the Deputy is referring. We raised a question at one stage about having a member of the Office of Public Works on the board of CSID and the conflict that might arise. However, that was resolved and I see no problem now.
Comment on this
If the Chairman wishes, I can dip into it. It was also raised in the Minister of State, Deputy Cullen's letter. These are now all gone by the board.
Comment on this
I was concerned about that matter because I did not want us to dig a second hole for ourselves given that we are coming out of one. However, it appears we have been able to reconcile matters that I thought were not reconcilable.
Can I ask Ms Magahy to bring those of us who do not have back-up into the picture? Approximately how many people were involved in the executive team? I know it would vary.
Comment on this
It would vary depending on what was going on at the time.
Comment on this
I appreciate that. Were there approximately eight or ten people involved or were they getting massive money?
Comment on this
No, they were not getting massive money. They were all salaried.
Comment on this
On the one hand, we are just getting an executive team and, on the other, a financial figure. Therefore, it is impossible to break it down. I have not got all the data, but approximately how many professionals were operating from the six consortia?
Comment on this
I am not avoiding the question, but it varied depending on the amount of work being done at a particular time. We had to focus on delivering the three different job elements we had to do. Depending on whether we were heavily involved in, say, the environmental impact side of things, there would have been a whole lot of people involved from the environmental side. If we were putting together the outline bid documentation, there would have been much heavier involvement over a long period from, say, PricewaterhouseCoopers. It really depended on what the particular jobs were at a particular moment in time.
Comment on this
Would Ms Magahy accept that to give the members an idea of whether it was value for money we would need some kind of figure? I appreciate there is a call-out rate given but I would not be in a position to say what an architect or someone else should be paid. I would not have the figures Mr. Haugh might have. Is it possible to put hours on these or to get the number of personnel and give a picture of the numbers involved?
Comment on this
As I said, there were two bases. The first was that we negotiated the percentage basis which was against providing the particular service, which service we provided. The second on the charge-out rates is done. You can see the level of charge-out rates which actually fall within quite a reasonable estimate as between different people. They would be on a par with other professional services.
Comment on this
At some stage, Ms Magahy might give us an approximate idea of how many bodies were involved over a few quarterly stages - not their exact jobs but the number of people involved. We seem to be getting ourselves into a knot in regard to the legal fees and so on. People are getting astronomical amounts of money for doing work. I accept we have already advised the Department of Finance. However, we must review the green book and so on. However, we need to know whether we are in favour of a fixed fee or a percentage rate which was the old system by which architects and so on were paid. We would need some comment on that issue.
I do not have many questions. However, I have an observation in regard to the number of people who were potentially disqualified through conflict of interest, including legal firms and so on. When will it be possible to do business in this city without the conflict of interest question eliminating everyone? We seem to have gone down through the pile. Will it come to the point when only the Office of Public Works will be in a position to say it has no conflict of interest, it is clean and wholesome? I am not being smart or cynical, I am just asking the question because it appears that even the slightest contact with companies is sufficient to prohibit one from carrying out work. I appreciate Mr. Murphy has commented throughout his statements on potential conflicts of interest. I am asking the question in a wide sense. Will only State bodies or the Office of Public Works be able to do business in these instances?
Comment on this
We actually manage without conflicts of interest. It simply means the awarding authority in the Office of Public Works's case has an extremely strict ethical code. We have an extremely strict ethical code and it is based on a Department of Finance circular on ethics. That is aimed at ensuring that no one on my staff has contact with firms outside, or receives favours from them or gets paid or anything like that. I am glad you say you are neither being smart nor cynical, because I personally regard this as being extremely serious and we make a really tremendous effort to ensure that, as far as the Office of Public Works staff are concerned, these conflicts do not arise. We have an extremely strict code on this, which I have circulated to the committee in the past.
Comment on this
I will rephrase that because Mr. Murphy may have picked me up incorrectly there. As you know I continually praise your organisation and the great work it does. You are above reproach, obviously. I am concerned about the private sector. I am concerned about the State getting projects done and how we are going to work. Are we going to get to a point where the only people we can do business with is the Office of Public Works? I am concerned about this because we are in a very small place. As we have become more affluent in the past couple of years, huge money is going around. There are very big projects and very big contracts and I am concerned that we are getting into a bit of quagmire. For obvious reasons I am not suggesting the Office of Public Works would have a problem. Will everyone else be eliminated from doing, managing and dealing with certain issues and will this lead us into difficulty in public private partnership projects and issues of that nature? That is what I am concerned about for the future.
Comment on this
Public projects will certainly not be limited to the Office of Public Works. The ethics code which the Department of Finance has circulated affects all public bodies, all semi-State bodies and so on. Provided that code is observed, there is no doubt that there will be a core of bodies, any one of which will be able to take on public sector contracts. That is the issue, simply that the public bodies would follow what is a reasonable code of ethics in dealing with contracting bodies.
Comment on this
To spell this out more and following Deputy Rabbitte's question, we have seen with various accountancy firms and other companies that, while they are the best in the field or something else, the same people seem to crop up. I wonder if we need to look at this and to know what the difficulties are. Why are the same people in front? Are they simply better? I am concerned that we might make the pool smaller and eliminate certain people, groups or companies because they happen to have worked with somebody five, ten or whatever number of years ago. This is a very small country, particularly when one works in a specific discipline, let it be accountancy, architecture or whatever.
In reading the report I noticed once or twice the suggestion that Mr. Teahon had employed or worked with someone in the past and these companies were being eliminated. As a member of this group I am concerned that we might prevent very good Irish companies from doing business here, because there would be no suggestion of a conflict of interest in a company which came from abroad; apparently we would just take them on. I am concerned that we would make the pool smaller and then, in turn, leave all of the cake for a very small number of people. That is not your concern, Mr. Murphy. That is for us to look at.
I said earlier today that this was very much a locally based issue. It is not, obviously. Campus Ireland is very important but this is first time we have got a clear layout of what is involved and I think people will be surprised at its scale. A fair point has been made about the size of the pool as against the rest of the project. It is fairly massive. If we have done nothing else we have brought this to light and some of us are beginning to realise exactly what we are talking about.
Comment on this
Before I hand over to Deputy Durkan I just want to ask Ms Magahy a question. Ms Magahy, you are synonymous with the Temple Bar development. For what period of time were you involved with that development?
Comment on this
When I started off initially I was financial and cultural director.
Comment on this
I assume Mr. Teahon was seconded from the Department at that stage. Is that correct, or was he within the Taoiseach's office?
Comment on this
You became managing director. So, you remained as managing director for what length of time?
Comment on this
So, obviously, the expertise you got in your position of art director etcetera served you in good stead to become managing director of that project.
Comment on this
Yes. Now, when you actually became director of that project who were you answerable to? Was it direct to the Taoiseach's Department?
Comment on this
No, I was answerable to the board in the first instance and to the Department of the Environment.
Comment on this
Where did the executive services idea flow from? You were an employee at that stage. In other words, you were getting a fixed salary. The big contract you got after that would have been Campus Stadium Ireland, would that be right? I think Mr. Finlay is giving you a bit of advice there.
Comment on this
When you finished up with that company you were paid a salary. Your first big contract as a company was Campus Stadium Ireland. Is that not correct?
Comment on this
Well, I had actually been doing some work prior to that for another development, which was the Mater Hospital and Temple Street Children's Hospital.
Comment on this
Well, in fact, I was doing it in a consultancy capacity for the sisters.
Comment on this
We have since been awarded an executive services contract.
Comment on this
I mean, I thought I was here to discuss Campus Stadium Ireland.
Comment on this
It is fine, actually. I am just wondering where the title of executive services came from, first day.
Comment on this
If one were tendering for a contract, it would appear to me there would be very little difference between consultancy services and executive services.
Comment on this
Well as I say, I responded to advertisements in the——
Comment on this
Okay. And that was your next involvement. Obviously, in the suite of service you provided your Temple Bar experience counted a lot in selecting you. Would I be right in that?
Comment on this
I would presume so. It was a huge development. We had 30 design teams, it was a whole mix of direct construction work, public private work, joint venture work, all the range of construction but also very much a mixed development in terms of different types of uses and public realm. It was a large scale public sector project.