We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE of PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

2000 Annual Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General and Appropriation Accounts: ›

Vote 10 - Office of Public Works (Resumed).

Contributions 527–791 of 791. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

So, you had three executive service contracts ongoing at this stage?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

Correct.

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

The term "executive services" appears in the advertisement that was put into the newspaper - "a team to provide executive services". It presumably was not created by Ms Magahy. Mr. Teahon could probably tell the Chairman where it came from.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Just for the sake of information, executive services is actually enshrined in the relevant European procedures. I think someone used the word "unique". There is nothing unique about executive services. It is a well used idea at European level. In other words, if you want to recruit a number of people as a team you use executive services. Case law exists to do so. I agree with the Comptroller and Auditor General that judgments have to be made from time to time as to whether to use more normal employment contracts. Certainly, at European level, the idea of executive services is used and is well understood.

Comment on this

I am just commenting on the Comptroller and Auditor General's original statement where he said he thought it was novel and indicated that this was the first time he encountered this category of executive services in the composition of an audit he was reviewing. That is the point I am making and you have not denied that.

Comment on this

Can we have a definition of "executive services" and how are they used in this country? Does anybody know how many companies provide executive services here?

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

I never referred to it as unique and I know Mr. Teahon did not. I spoke about it being novel. Companies, particularly the big five accounting firms, provide some executive services like providing pay roll services and some provide narrow administrative services. IT services can also be contracted out. What I said was that this was the first time I came across it in a public sector context. It may well be prevalent in the private sector or elsewhere in Europe and I have no reason to disbelieve Mr. Teahon on that. I want to make it clear that I am not against the concept per se and there was no implied criticism in what I said.

Comment on this

That is not the issue. The issue was whether such services are eligible to be advertised in the European journals and open to competition from that arena. We have already sought and received legal advice on that issue but it was not entirely clear. For instance, when awarding a contract of this nature, is it in order here to exclude advertising in the European journals? Is that the presumption on the basis of the legal advice given to CSID?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I can answer that, Chairman. There is no lack of clarity in terms of what the legal advice was or what issues arise. In the directive, there is a series of categories identified. The legal advice is very clear that if the significant majority of the services are in a particular category there is no requirement to advertise. That is basically the position.

Comment on this

Right. Can I move quickly to a few simple questions on correspondence although I do not want to go over ground Deputy Rabbitte has covered? The first letter to Mr. Paddy Teahon, of 18 October 2000 mentions three items.

Comment on this

Publish.

Comment on this

It says the relevant fee shall be 1.8%, "on the basis set down in our fee proposal to include project procurement programme, advices etc. . . . but not including specialist project management and other specialist services which can be provided by agreement as a direct expense or which are required to be procured separately in accordance with EU public procurement law as outlined in your letter". I know from replies to earlier questions that the subject matter of some aspects of the contract may have to be advertised through EU procurement procedures. However, it seems odd that a major contract in relation to the operation of the proposal is going to a particular firm. I have no criticism of the firm but I am interested in the procedure. My concern is that having got to that position they then have to advertise in Europe in accordance with European law and directives.

Deputy Rabbitte also covered the letter of 7 May 2001 very effectively.

Comment on this

Publish.

Comment on this

In the first paragraph the letter states that "in the light of media speculation the signed executive services contracted for 1.8% of the development was to be carried out on the Abbotstown site. It does not cover external infrastructure, relocation of land values of any kind. The fee was negotiated on the basis of and in the absence of knowing the full extent . . . " etc. It continues into the following paragraph.

In the last paragraph it states:

Given that CSID is now recruiting for project managers to deliver the technical side of the project we would like to propose that our fee, which is 1.8%, to include 0.5% for technicians, will reduce to 1.75%. The proposed cap of the Magahy & Company fee is therefore €9.652 million, ie 1.75% of €550 million.

The Comptroller and Auditor General and others referred to the movement of costs and the total value of the contract as time goes by and there has been speculation about that. In the project so far reference was made to the land and the relocation but that is excluded from the project costs so that the total project costs at this stage are the actual provision of facilities on the land at Abbotstown. What was the cost of the land to CSID?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

There has been no cost to CSID. The land has not yet transferred to it but is still owned by the Minister for Agriculture, Food and Rural Development.

Comment on this

Does the Minister still own the property at Abbotstown?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Yes. He has transferred such interest in order for the pool to be built.

Comment on this

I am not satisfied with answers I got previously on this matter. Is this normal procedure? On the Order of Business, the Tánaiste referred to the cost of the Abbotstown project as €775 million for the works on the site, excluding the cost of the site. Given the dangers of pursuing with a multi-million project of this nature if all legal transactions in relation to transfer of lands have not been undergone, surely somebody has thought about the possibility of transferring the land in an up-front and realistic way. Has no valuation been put on this property which I presume has increased considerably in value since the first post was driven into the ground?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

There was never an intention to transfer the land from public ownership. Nobody said "We are going to transfer the land to the private sector". That was never the intention. In that sense, if we had valued the land we would, I think, at this stage have three different valuations for it. We would have a basic cost before the sports campus development got under way. People in the PricewaterhouseCoopers feasibility study raised the issue of some of the land being sold, effectively to the private sector, to fund part of the cost of the development. There is a figure in the PricewaterhouseCoopers study which could be extended to the entire cost and multiplied by the proportion that they suggested should be used for other purposes. That figure is there. The value of the land would depend then critically upon whether you were prepared to put housing on the land or not. In other words——

Comment on this

Once the first post is put in the ground, it becomes potentially housing land in any event.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

It does not. In fact, under the Fingal development plan, you would not be allowed to have housing on it. As I recall it, the issue actually came up in the Dáil at one stage and a number of Deputies said there should be a specific provision that it would not be used for housing.

Comment on this

Can you give some indication as to how the Department of Agriculture, Food and Rural Development will be compensated for its loss of 500 acres of land, the relocation of its facilities to another site in another area and how that is deemed to be excluded from the overall proposal? This has come up repeatedly. I would like an answer once and for all.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

There is a Government decision that says that the land will be transferred to the authority that will be established under legislation as Campus and Stadium Ireland - the company. In other words, there is a piece of draft legislation which has been approved by the Government which provides that the land will be transferred to the authority. At a point in time the land will be transferred to the authority. It will be in public ownership and it will remain in public ownership.

Comment on this

Yes, but that still does not answer my question. The question is that facilities must be transferred from one area to another area necessitating fairly considerable expense and also recompense to a Government Department. A Government Department still owns the property concerned; this is not the private sector. CSID is building a structure on the property still owned by the Department of Agriculture, Food and Rural Development. No transfer has been made to anybody yet and there is a process now in hand to relocate the facilities which were previously provided at Abbotstown in another location, necessitating fairly considerable expense.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Yes. In fairness, given that the HPR report is widely quoted, it says that the costs of relocation should not be considered as part of the cost of the project. Therefore, I would think, HPR might be used to argue that one should not take account of this relocation cost.

Comment on this

Why not?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I am only saying if people want to have HPR, it says that you should not take account of the relocation costs in the cost of the project.

Comment on this

I did not quote HPR at all. I was not using HPR criteria at all. I was using the simple query that the taxpayer raises from time to time. I want to go to the third last page in the same document and look at the daily rates.

Comment on this

It is commercial information which Ms Magahy has.

Comment on this

I am looking at the executive services team and there is a set of fees. I presume, Chairman, that I cannot quote the fees.

Comment on this

You may, providing that you do not identify the company.

Comment on this

I do not intend to identify the company. The highest amount is £2,000 per day. That is not too bad. There is a range of fees from £184 to £2,000 and there are particular fees set out in respect of particular services. One of the advices referred to considerably in evidence comes from a firm of advisers who would be fairly reliable and who would be on a very high fee rate. I wonder why at all times its advice was not strictly adhered to? It refers to the shelf company. It strikes me as odd that a highly qualified firm of advisers on a justifiably very high fee give advice and the advice is not necessarily taken on board.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

With respect, Deputy, the advice was followed. The business advice, the financial advice and the legal advice were followed and they participated in the drafting of the letter which went to the consortium on 19 December.

Comment on this

The Attorney General does not seem to agree.

Comment on this

Does Ms Magahy wish to contribute? I see her nodding her head.

Comment on this

On page 30 of his report, he says that requirements specified - this is the whole area to which I referred - in the advertisement for tenders were for financial and economic standing, etc. Persons tendering were required to demonstrate that they had financial and economic standing and that technical knowledge and ability to design, build, finance, operate and maintain the aquatic and leisure centre. Participants had to show a track record for similar projects. Participants were required to provide financial and other documentation as set out in Council Directive 93/37/EC. I do not think that the Attorney General was in agreement and fully accepts that the procedures were followed as he would have wished. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I do not know the answer to that question. The only answer I can give - I am not sure what it has to do with the earlier point - but the only answer——

Comment on this

It does not necessarily have to. It will all emerge in due course.

Comment on this

I ask the Deputy to make his point.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

The one point I would make, and which some people miss, is that the participant in this case is a consortium. When we talk about participants, we are talking about consortia; we are not talking about individual members of consortia even though when it came to the issue of the individual members, we in CSID followed a procedure which led to our making a judgment that all the elements in the consortium were in fact able to show a track record of the kind suggested.

Comment on this

There is something peculiar. At the bottom of that page——

Comment on this

In fairness, Deputy, many of those points are coming up.

Comment on this

I assure you that question was not answered before.

Comment on this

In fairness, the issue of the dormant company was dealt with exhaustively before.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

The Attorney General has made the argument that, in relation to some comments, he draws a distinction between opinion and fact. It seems to me that the statement being referred to is not a fact but an opinion.

Comment on this

His opinion, with which you disagree.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I neither agree nor disagree.

Comment on this

Right.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I am simply saying it is an opinion which we have no way of clarifying at this stage.

Comment on this

One second, Chairman. Let us leave the circuitous route. Let us cut out the nonsense and talk straight from here on. The reality is this: it is his opinion. Whether you like it or not, that is his opinion and it stands. Whether you like it or not, he is the legal adviser to the Government. That is a fact of life. It does not matter——

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

The words the Deputy is using are not fair. It is not fair to say, "whether you like it or not."

Comment on this

That is true. I ask the Deputy to rephrase it.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I made no issue about whether it was fair or not. I made a statement——

Comment on this

Just a second, Chairman. A moment ago Mr. Teahon attempted to dismiss——

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I am sorry, I did not attempt to dismiss it.

Comment on this

He said it was an opinion.

Comment on this

I call the Deputy to order. Will you come to the point, please?

Comment on this

If you let me continue, I will come to the point. I have not spoken all day but have been sitting here patiently.

Comment on this

I know, and I am giving you plenty of latitude. I do not want us to go over old ground again.

Comment on this

I am not going over old ground. I just want an answer to the question.

Comment on this

I have given you 30 minutes on this, in case you do not think I am giving you latitude.

Comment on this

I am not finished.

Comment on this

All right, 18 then.

Comment on this

I can come back to it another day if you wish.

Comment on this

No, if you come to the point, I will be happy.

Comment on this

My problem is that I asked a simple question, which was then referred to as an opinion. It may well be an opinion but it is one that has been put before us. It is on that basis I am asking the question. I presume that the opinion is not being dismissed and that I can continue on that basis. Is that correct?

Comment on this

Yes, but I think Mr. Teahon has made his point.

Comment on this

He can make the point all right, but——

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

If the Deputy wishes, I will make a statement of fact. As a statement of fact, Waterworld (UK) Limited never attempted to suggest that it was a leading water park operator with approximately 20 years of experience. That is a statement of fact.

Comment on this

It is.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

It is. It never suggested that.

Comment on this

Could you repeat that?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Waterworld (UK) Limited never attempted to suggest that the company was a leading water park operator with approximately 20 years of experience.

Comment on this

The opinion was clearly created in the minds of those in CSID——

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

No.

Comment on this

——that it had considerable experience in that area.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

That is a different issue. I am simply reading the words of the paragraph to which the Deputy refers.

Comment on this

It is stated there that from these assertions it is clear that an attempt was made to foster in the minds of those in CSID the impression, during the early stages of the process, that Waterworld (UK) Limited was a leading water park operator with approximately 20 years of experience. Do you not accept that?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I do not. It is not factually correct. Waterworld (UK) Limited, at all stages, suggested that it was associated with companies in the USA that were, in fact, leading water park operators with approximately 20 years of experience.

Comment on this

All right. I did not intend to spend so much time on that issue and digressed. I may need to return to it again. I want to ask Mr. McCarthy a couple of questions but before doing so will ask Mr. Teahon one last question. Mr. Teahon disagreed strongly with Mr. Barry Murphy at an earlier stage of today's proceedings in relation to an issue raised by Deputy McCormack.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I disagreed on the basis of what happened at a meeting chaired by the Minister for Finance on a particular day which was referred to in the file.

Comment on this

Obviously, Mr. Murphy and Mr. Teahon hold opposing views. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

The only point I will make is that my views on that day are in the context of the earlier papers in the file which you have.

Comment on this

When did Mr. McCarthy first become aware of the kind of public concerns currently being expressed in the outside world in relation to the tendering process and the initial stages of the project, before the full details relating to the project were made available to him? When were they first made available to him, for example?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

Just to clarify matters, Chairman, is this in relation to the aquatic centre?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

The first set of concerns were made known by the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation in relation to the form of contract submitted by CSID for approval towards the middle of 2001, as I recall. That is the first suggestion that came to my notice of concerns about the form of contract. I was aware of subsequent discussions between the Department and CSID.

Comment on this

Did you obtain all the information required for your Department? How did it come to you? For example, did you read about it in the newspapers first or was a folder delivered to you with the information that would normally be available to you?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

The issues involved were matters for the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation. Clearly, it was the lead Department at that stage.

Comment on this

Did they know about it before you got involved, before you were familiar with the project?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

They had. These issues came to my notice in an informal sense because it was expected that the form of contract would come to Government for ultimate approval before it was signed. I was aware from some point in the middle of 2001 that there were some concerns about the form of contract on the part of the lead Department, namely the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation.

Comment on this

Were you aware of the concerns expressed by the Office of Public Works and the Department?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

Yes.

Comment on this

Did you bring them to the attention of the Government, the Minister or the Taoiseach or all three?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

The concerns were primarily matters for the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation and its Minister, who was, as I understood, aware of them. It was for him to bring the matter to the Government at the appropriate time.

Comment on this

I refer to the Office of Public Works document, page 42, headed Monday, 5 February 2001. It states:

Arrangements for a meeting between Seán Benton and Paddy Teahon to discuss the contract sent to Campus Ireland on 2 February, 2001, were made for Wednesday, 7 February, 2001. With Seán Benton I met the Minister at 5.30 p.m. and briefed him on the above. I expressed complete incredulity about the versions of conflicts of interest now being proffered by Paddy Teahon. The Minister suggested that the three of us should meet Paddy Teahon.

Reference was made to that meeting in the earlier exchanges. That is a true version of what happened, I presume.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

If the Deputy is looking at me, that is a note made by Mr. Barry Murphy. I take strong exception to the sentence, "I expressed complete incredulity about the versions of conflicts of interest now being proffered by Paddy Teahon." I am amazed that anybody could write a sentence such as this.

Comment on this

It appears, however, that he did have some concerns. Would that be correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Concerns are one thing; complete incredulity, in my view, is a completely different matter.

Comment on this

Perhaps Mr. Murphy would like to elaborate on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

The point of the note is that I was told one thing on one day and another contrary thing on another day, with something added. At that point, I did not know what I was being told. To say that I was incredulous is a reasonable summation of how I felt. It is a contemporary, diary record of what was happening. It is reasonable to say that was what we expressed on that day.

Comment on this

Is it possible to publish the legal advice? I notice on page 59 of the Office of Public Works document the concerns expressed by the Office of Public Works about the emerging project.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

These papers are becoming available under freedom of information legislation today. However, the legal opinions are not being made available.

Comment on this

Where does that leave us?

Comment on this

We discussed issues like this the last day and we subsequently deleted the companies mentioned. I do not think that we referred to this legal advice at the time. It would be dangerous to publish it because there are companies mentioned in it and there may be conflicts of interest, etc. Perhaps the Deputy could make a general point.

Comment on this

The opinion would be that the appointment of the Office of Public Works was made at this stage in a somewhat informal manner.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I do not follow the Deputy.

Comment on this

The appointment of the Office of Public Works as project manager was made in a somewhat informal manner on foot of statements made by the Taoiseach and one or two letters between the Department of the Taoiseach and the Office of Public Works. The net point with regard to this appointment is that the exact role of the Office of Public Works is unclear and the exact scope of its duties has not been clarified. The point I am making is that genuine concern was expressed by the Office of Public Works previously. I suggest that the legal advice underlines that.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I accept that.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Without naming the company, I would like to read one sentence of legal advice provided to the Office of Public Works, not to CSID. About half way down page 60, it states that: "Based on the information available it would be our view that it would be difficult to exclude. . . " - two companies are mentioned - ". . . from the competition on the basis of Mr. Teahon's statement." That was one of the concerns raised.

Comment on this

Yes, I also noted that. The question of the conflict of interest has been referred to on a couple of occasions. I refer to page 68 in the same document. Perhaps Mr. Teahon would comment on, for instance, section 9 on significant developments which says that in the view of the Office of Public Works, this would be sufficient to remove some companies from consideration, if Office of Public Works procedures were applied.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

That is difficult to understand in the light of the sentence in the legal advice that the Office of Public Works received. That legal advice said that, on the basis of the statements, the companies could not be excluded. I cannot understand why that statement was made.

Comment on this

All right. On page 69 concerning matters of trust——

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

The difference in this case is something that we spoke about on day one and day two and that is the gap between what is strictly legal and what is best practice. We have moved to ensure that, in future, if there is any legal doubt about this from our point of view, we will close it. If there was contact with any firm by any member of staff or anyone involved during a bidding process, they would be eliminated straight away.

Comment on this

Would that be in accordance with the Office of Public Works's best practice?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Yes.

Comment on this

For safety reasons.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Absolutely.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

There was no contact with the company in question.

Comment on this

That information came out later. Is that still accepted by the Office of Public Works?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Is what accepted?

Comment on this

Mr. Teahon has indicated that there was no conflict of interest in the first instance.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

The Office of Public Works would reserve comment on that. There are two different versions of events.

Comment on this

Mr. Teahon has just said that it emerged that there was no conflict of interest. The situation stands and the Office of Public Works reserves judgment on that at this stage. I have a number of other questions but I realise that I cannot ask them all at this stage. I will come back to them again.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

A fuss was made earlier about the contract which was apparently signed by two people on 18 August 2000. I have been involved in such contracts between the commercial sector and the public sector. It seems to be pro forma and there is nothing unusual about it. Deputy Rabbitte made a point earlier that Ms Magahy's company seemed to pop up all the time. Is it correct that Ms Magahy is involved full-time as a self-employed person pitching for public sector contracts? Is that her background?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

Yes.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Ms Magahy is employed in Digital Hub, Temple Street, the Mater and Campus and Stadium Ireland and she was previously involved as an employee in a public sector project called Temple Bar Properties. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

Yes.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

So all her working life has been spent, albeit as a private rather than a public service person, in a public sector setting. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

That is correct.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

She has no other background. I am not suggesting that we are in the business of making background checks on people but Ms Magahy has worked entirely in the public setting.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

I have.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

She has never worked in a private company other than her own private company for the purpose of providing services of one kind or another, or project management services. Would Ms Magahy be one of a few people in Ireland with that kind of background? When Mr. Teahon said earlier that there were foreign versus domestic people who tendered for the contract which Ms Magahy's company won in a tender process - obviously that did not involve price but it did involve the type of service being offered - how many of the bidders——

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Seven, that we created in the decision-making——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Seven companies, including Ms Magahy's, were shortlisted.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Yes.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Have the names of the unsuccessful companies been published?

Comment on this

I am not sure it is relevant to publish that. What is more relevant is whether Ms Magahy's company was the best, as it was according to the assessment team. However, we cannot presume that the other six were deficient in relation to a job like this.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Mr. Teahon said, and I took note of it, that it would be borne out that Ms Magahy's company was still the best value.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I was making the point——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

When Mr. Teahon made the assessment, did it turn out that, despite the fact that price was not the issue, her figures were lower than those of the other six?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

In so far as you could make any judgment at that stage, given that you were not able to ask questions about the suggested outline fees, the ones that came in from the overseas companies were higher, in general, than the ones that came in from the Irish ones. I was only making the point that in terms of value for money there might be——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

The Irish companies were better value than the overseas ones.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

If you were judging both people and the fee proposed by the outside companies - which we might now argue is the correct procedure - there is no reason to suggest that those fees would have led to a different decision, even if you had been making both. During a hard negotiation, who can say to what extent companies will adjust their fees when they know they are in the running? That is the way companies will proceed. They will suggest a fee and after you tell them they are in the running, you ask them to give you the bottom line in terms of the fee. I do not know how much leeway the overseas companies had, but on the face of it there was no reason to believe they were proposing a lower fee than the one we negotiated.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

The effect of what Mr. Teahon is saying is that from an evaluation of the foreign versus the domestic, the fees suggested by the foreign companies were clearly on a par or in the same range.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

They were above in most cases.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

There were three domestic players, including Ms Magahy's company.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

There were four.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

There were four versus three. Of the four domestically incorporated companies, where did Mr. Teahon rate Ms Magahy's company in terms of the criteria he used to evaluate her versus the——

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

My recollection was that it was in the middle.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

It was in the middle of the range.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Yes.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

That is important because there was a hint in Deputy Rabbitte's question that there was a grace and favour process, whereas Mr. Teahon points out that there was a tendered process.

Comment on this

Deputy Rabbitte was in agreement.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I meant that his question might have the implication, but of course the Deputy would not imply that.

Comment on this

In fairness to Deputy Rabbitte, he was trying to probe questions at the time.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I accept that.

I am very keen that the issue of the conflict of interest in the role of chief executive is resolved. It was suggested that the chief executive role on this project become full-time because of the implications and I will be asking that the committee endorses that suggestion when it comes to make its recommendations. Given the level of heat that this issue has generated, it is crazy that there is not a full-time chief executive in charge of this project. I hope that comment is not lost on Mr. Murphy.

Can Mr. Benton's role going forward be clarified? I am still unclear as to what it is and I am frustrated by that. Mr. Benton was appointed by the Government to be the chief executive of this company.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

That is not so. The Government asked the Office of Public Works to facilitate the company in procuring the services of an interim chief executive. The company chose Seán Benton as its interim chief executive——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Exactly, that is very good.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

——and we were happy to facilitate that.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

That is excellent and the least we would expect for a large public project. His reporting relationship, as chief executive, is not to Mr. Murphy, I presume, given that the company is properly incorporated, but to its chairman and board.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Yes, of course it is to the board of the company.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

He will not be reporting to Mr. Murphy in future.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

As we speak now, no. He is a chief executive with responsibilities to the board of the company.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Perhaps Mr. Haugh has a view on this. Going forward, Mr. Benton will be reporting as chief executive to the board and its chairman and the next reporting line beyond that will be to the sponsoring Department, which is Ms Hayes's Department. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

This is not unusual.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I am not suggesting it is.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

The Office of Public Works has many, many clients which are independent companies or independent State bodies. The National Gallery, for instance, is an independent State body and we do work for it. We have a similar relationship in this case. We act as agents for the board and we are under its direction.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Does the Office of Public Works lend personnel to become chief executives of the National Gallery? That is not my perception.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

No, but we provide it with a full team. We have formulae agreements with it. Commissioner Benton was, for instance, the head of the gallery's extension project, reporting directly to the National Gallery's board.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

That is right. That is what I mean. I am not suggesting there is anything unusual in this; I am trying to clarify the lines of reporting. Does the Office of Public Works charge for Mr. Benton's services? What is the relationship?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

No, it is a Government project.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Given that this project is important, it is an honour to be asked to facilitate the board by providing a suitable person to run this company.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

The Government has asked us to facilitate the board and we are pleased to do that.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

There will be normal reporting lines to the board and, upwards, to the Department.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Absolutely.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

There has been a conflict between Mr. Murphy and Mr. Teahon at this committee over the last few weeks regarding who is in charge of this project and this committee needs to be clear about who that is and to know if they are working on it full-time. Given all the paper and political heat generated by this issue, it is imperative that Mr. Benton is not sent out to Abbotstown without clear riding instructions, to use racing parlance. He needs to know who he is reporting to and I want that clarified now. Will he be reporting to Mr. Murphy as well as to Ms Margaret Hayes? Is there an understanding that he will report to Mr. Murphy from time to time about progress on the project?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

The Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation is in charge and CSID reports to him through the Secretary General of his Department. Seán Benton is interim chief executive for that company and his reporting relationship is that he carries out the instructions of the company's board. The company board is instructed by the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation - through his Department - for whose policies Government approval is sought, where necessary.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Some of the coverage seems to indicate that the Office of Public Works was going to run the project. That is what I was trying to clarify. In fact, it will be a person on loan to the company from the Office of Public Works.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Seán Benton is bringing his experience and knowledge as a commissioner of public works to the board.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Absolutely. Conflicts of interest have been mentioned and I do not suggest that there is one here. I hope there is not one between the various roles, which is why I asked those questions.

In relation to this project, the Office of Public Works is currently employed as an adviser to the Government. In effect, it is an adviser to the Minister. A groundbreaking meeting was referred to earlier at which the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy, decided that the Office of Public Works would not provide the project management in this case, despite Mr. Teahon's desire that it would be part of the set up. As a result, the Office of Public Works became adviser to the Minister and his Department, in effect becoming a monitor of the company's performance. In light of the reporting relationship, is Mr. Murphy happy that there cannot be any conflict of interest between Mr. Benton's commissionership role in the Office of Public Works and his role as chief executive? This is very important because if he is not working full-time in the role of chief executive of CSID, even on an interim basis, on the Campus Stadium Ireland project and the delivery of the aquatic centre and he has other duties to perform in an Office of Public Works context, he would be open, in some people's minds, to the accusation - I do not believe this to be the case with him as a person and I am trying to remove him, as a person, from this - that there is a conflict of interest. This is why I raise the issue of it being desirable from a public point of view to have a full-time chief executive not just from the monitoring point of view, but also from the governance point of view.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I think we have been over this ground. I dislike the phrase "conflict of interest" because it does not arise here.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

A crossing of the lines of reporting.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Yes, I accept that.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Whether it is a conflict of interest is another matter.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

No, the conflict of interest is a very particular thing.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

There is no corporate governance.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

The point here is——

Comment on this
John Dennehy Deputy Dennehy Fianna Fáil

"Incompatibility" was the word used earlier and it is what I asked about.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Yes, and I fully accept that word. However, the Government's decision on this requires the Office of Public Works to facilitate the CSID board and it will have our full facilitation.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Therefore, the preference is, I hope, for a full-time chief executive. Ms Magahy, you stated that all three of the criteria laid down for you had been achieved. Can I assume from this that the second item you mentioned, the planning application for the full-scale enlarged Campus Stadium Ireland project, is now ready for the planning stage? In other words, if, for instance, after the election, the Government was to give you or the board the go ahead to proceed to build a full-scale project of this kind, a planning application could be lodged the next day with Fingal County Council outlining what exactly has been proposed.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

Not exactly the next day. There would be about a month's work to do to bring it to completion.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

To finesse it. You mean finessing a full-scale planning application.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

Correct.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Does this include the EIS?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

The environmental impact statement is, by and large, finished. There is some tweaking of the documentation by the architectural team which needs to be done in order to finesse it. It is, however, by and large ready as a planning scheme.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

The sports facilities, the price outline, the planning preparation - was the other one the aquatic centre?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

Yes.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

When you said the aquatic centre was achieved, I was a little surprised. Do you mean it is on its way to being achieved? What target was set for you?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

May I——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I am not taking——

Comment on this

The whole project would be ruined if it was not under way at this stage.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

There were doubts expressed that it might not be.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

The pool will be finished on 9 December. It is on time and on budget.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

It is on time and on budget as far as you are concerned.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

Yes.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

The other issue that really struck me——

Comment on this
Pat Rabbitte Deputy Rabbitte Labour Party

Was it upside down?

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

——was your comment during a somewhat heated discussion between yourself and Deputy Durkan about the Attorney General's insistence that this company had, during the early stages of the bidding process, tried to foster in the minds of CSID the impression that Waterworld UK was itself a leading water park operator with approximately 20 years experience. We are all aware from our private sector and job application days that we enhance our CVs from time to time - even very famous people do it from time to time.

Comment on this

Is that how the Deputy got in here?

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Mr. Teahon, you say that at no point did the consortium behind Waterworld UK inform you that it had been operating because it is self-evident that the company is a special purpose vehicle that would hardly be involved in operating. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

If you go to Annex F of the Attorney General's report, the second paragraph of the letter spells it out. It makes a distinction, which I think is a very important distinction. It says in relation to operators:

WaterWorld UK Ltd

The UK company of one of the world's leading Waterpark operators. . . .

In fairness to the Chairman, he and I have been through this two or three times.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Yes, this is the website issue which I remember - "with specialist waterpark experience".

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

"The UK company of one of the world's leading Waterpark operators". The people who had 20 years——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

The people who are investors or consortia in that company are——

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

——experience were and are the people in the US.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Therefore, they mean the people rather than the body corporate. Is that where the misunderstanding lies?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

No, I think it is clear that the companies in the US were the companies which had approximately 20 years experience and they were the companies about which we spent a good deal of time deciding whether they could give us an acceptable parent company guarantee for Waterworld UK. Therefore, there was no issue that this possibility existed. In the event, it did not work out and when the alternative proposal was put to us about the people who had the experience in Tralee, we proceeded to assess that experience. In fairness to Waterworld UK, it never tried to pass itself off as the company which had 20 years experience. It said, as in the letter, that it was the UK company of one of the world's leading water park operators. I think that is an important distinction.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Did you believe, as the Attorney General seems to be suggesting, that it was almost actively fostering this impression, perhaps by saying to board members that the company has been 20 years in the business as opposed to——

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I genuinely do not because, in fairness to Waterworld UK, it was trying to convince us that the fact that it was the UK company of the US companies was of significance for us. In my view that was fair as it was the UK company. They did have common directors and the US company went through a significant period in which it said it would provide a parent company guarantee.

Comment on this

I ask the Deputy not to read out the figures.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I have them.

Comment on this

You equalled Deputy Rabbitte with 39 minutes each so I was very fair to both of you.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this
John Dennehy Deputy Dennehy Fianna Fáil

I can see you are about to wrap this meeting up, Chairman. I have one question in the light of what Ms Magahy said about the timing. I think Mr. Teahon also made this clear the other day. We had a headline in at least one of the newspapers about the Special Olympics. May I presume that there is no doubt about finishing on target and that we will be prepared for them?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

Yes, we will.

Comment on this
John Dennehy Deputy Dennehy Fianna Fáil

The message seemed to have gone out that the whole thing might implode. You are quite happy this will not be the case.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

It will be ready.

Comment on this
John Dennehy Deputy Dennehy Fianna Fáil

Mr. Teahon, I believe, was adamant that it would be ready, but then we read a couple of days later that there might be problems.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

There was a statement from the board of CSID the other day after Con Haugh and Seán Benton were appointed that they were satisfied it would be ready for the Special Olympics.

Comment on this
John Dennehy Deputy Dennehy Fianna Fáil

This is critical and we will have to look through everything we have said. It is important because the Special Olympics were the catalyst for the timing and many of the other things in hand. It is critically important that we release people from any pressure because people were starting to ask us questions about this. I want to have this made clear.

Comment on this

On that point, Mr. Murphy, you may have heard an assertion made on "Morning Ireland" by a representative of Dublin Waterworld to the effect that the work of the Office of Public Works was too slow. Now that you are involved in this project in a hands on manner, will you also give the necessary assurance that everything will be on time?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I think my reply to Deputy Dennehy on a number of occasions has been "steady, but not slow".

Comment on this

I refer again to the point raised by Deputy Conor Lenihan. I noticed the comment made by the Attorney General on the CSID response. I presume it is in order to refer to that. It is at the end of the Attorney General's report. He makes the reference to not commenting on compliance with the EU procedures. He then says:

The comments on the adequacy of the pre-qualification and assessment process in my report stand. No adequate consideration was given to the financial standing or capacity, actual or potential, of the proposed operator company at any time prior to the decision by the Government to accept Waterworld as the preferred bidder.

When I referred to that earlier, coming from a different angle, sufficient relevance was not given to the importance placed by the Attorney General on his views on that subject. One should note paragraphs (a) to (g) in this respect.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

If one reads paragraph (b), it looks as if one is talking about the same thing when referring to the proposed operator company and, then, Waterworld as the preferred bidder. In fact, they are different. The proposed operator company at that time was Waterworld (UK) Limited and Waterworld, as the preferred bidder, was the consortium. There is an important distinction.

Comment on this

What was the Attorney General commenting on there? Was he not commenting on the possible perception in the open market of the procedures followed and the ability of various people to compete in the open market for State-funded projects instigated by the State and his knowledge of the need to adhere to certain procedures?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I do not know, but if he believes that the proposed operator company and Waterworld, as the preferred bidder are one and the same thing, he is wrong.

Comment on this

No, he does not say that at all. He merely says exactly what I quoted. He emphasises "at any time prior to the decision by the Government to accept Waterworld as the preferred bidder". My interpretation, which is subject to clarification, is that the Attorney General is saying a considerable doubt was created by the methodology used at that particular time, given the information that was available to CSID and, eventually, to Government, which had to make a decision.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Let me make a different point. If the sentence had read "No adequate consideration was given to the financial standing or capacity, actual and potential, of Waterworld as the preferred bidder.", that statement would have been incorrect.

Comment on this

The Attorney General did not say that.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I accept that the words are different.

Comment on this

He did not say that at all. I presume he deliberately put on paper what he was thinking. We should always bear in mind in this committee that we have seen, over the years, numerous instances where certain procedures were not followed and where we had to visit the scenes afterwards with much annoyance, trauma and hurt. The Attorney General is saying that there are certain procedures that need to be put in place, operated and adhered to at all times. He is not saying he is satisfied that that was the case. What does Mr. Teahon think?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I believe that adequate consideration was given to the financial standing or capacity in accepting Waterworld as the preferred bidder. That was the issue. It was an issue of accepting a consortium as a preferred bidder.

Comment on this

I do not want to quote again what was said in the House, but does Mr. Teahon understand that the Attorney General seems to have difficulties with the explanation? This is obvious and hence the comments made at the end of the report. Apparently, the Tánaiste has had some considerable difficulty as well. She indicated this in the House. She said in the House that if certain information was available, different decisions might have been made. Given the point I made earlier on the duty of this committee and the fact that we have visited so many difficult scenes over the years, does Mr. Teahon feel, in light of his own knowledge of the way the system works in respect of procurement, etc, and the need to observe checks and balances, that the Tánaiste is justified in her remarks?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I have said before that I am not setting myself up as agreeing or disagreeing with the Tánaiste. I am simply saying that I had the information that I had. If I had to decide all over again, I would reach the same decision based on that information and I believe it would be a valid decision. I recognise that the Tánaiste is making a valid point, which is that the Government should have had the opportunity to make the decision on the basis of the same information.

Comment on this

All the information.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Exactly. I accepted in my statement that I had not made that information available. In my judgment, if all the information had been available, the Government would have reached the same decision that was made.

Comment on this

That is not what she said. She said that, if all the information had been made available that is now available, a different decision might have been made.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I accept that the Government should have had that opportunity. I should have made more information available and the Government should have had the opportunity - and rightfully so - to make the decision in the light of all the information. If it had had all the information, I honestly believe it would have reached the same decision that was made.

Comment on this

Would the Attorney General have advised the Government to do so in view of his comments and advice and given his role in Government?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I believe he would have done so because, if one reads the Government memorandum, Annex D, it is clear that the Attorney General raised doubts in the context of the Government making the decision. The additional information, essentially stating that it was a once dormant company, is not significant in respect of the issues the Attorney General raised at that time. In fairness, the Tánaiste's views are set down there too.

Comment on this

How does Mr. Teahon arrive at the conclusion that the additional information is "not significant"? Given that the Attorney General, the Tánaiste and, for all I know, half the Cabinet expressed concerns, it would appear that there is considerable room for concern based on the points they raised in reply to questions.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Yes, but the points made are not significantly different from those made by the Attorney General and the Tánaiste in the context of the Government making a decision on that memorandum.

Comment on this

Why not?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

The memorandum raises issues in respect of Waterworld (UK) Limited.

Comment on this

We will not agree on that anyway.

Comment on this

I do not think there will be a meeting of minds on the issue.

Comment on this

My point stands. The Attorney General apparently had serious concerns, as had the Tánaiste. Apparently Mr. Teahon does not share those concerns. Only time will tell who is correct.

Comment on this

In fairness to Mr. Teahon, his interpretation of 20 years is different from what the Comptroller and Auditor General said in his report. We have already covered this ground and I am anxious to conclude the meeting. It would be remiss of me not to ask Ms Magahy a final question. Reference was made at several junctures to the documentation we got regarding Mr. Teahon's consultancy project. Has Mr. Teahon's company offered consultancy advice to either of your other two projects?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

No, nor on Sports Campus Ireland.

Comment on this

The budgeted price was £48 million. That was the lowest tender for the aquatic centre project.

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

Yes.

Comment on this

Are you totally confident that it will come in on budget?

Comment on this
Ms Magahy

There is no reason to believe otherwise at this point in time.

Comment on this

I thank those who attended the meeting. The committee will now meet in private session to consider what further steps, if any, we will take on the matters under consideration.

The witnesses withdrew.

The committee went into private session at5.52 p.m. and adjourned at 6.05 p.m.

Comment on this