We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Vote 34 - Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment

Contributions 1–219 of 674. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Before commencing, I advise witnesses that they are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the evidence they are to give this committee. If they are directed by the committee to cease giving evidence regarding a particular matter and they continue to so do, they are entitled thereafter only to qualified privilege in respect of their evidence. They are directed that only evidence connected with the subject matter of these proceedings is to be given and they are asked to respect the parliamentary practice to the effect that, where possible, they should not criticise nor make charges against a Member of either House, a person outside the Houses, or an official by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. Members are reminded of the provisions within Standing Order 158 that the committee shall also refrain from inquiring into the merits of a policy or policies of the Government or a Minister of the Government or the merits of the objectives of such policies.

I welcome Mr. Seán Gorman, Secretary General of the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation, and invite him to introduce his officials.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Thank you, Chairman. With me is Mr. Dermot Curran, assistant secretary at the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation with responsibility for employment rights and industrial relations, Mr. Páraig Hennessy, finance officer, Ms Catherine Carroll, our accountant in the finance unit and Mr. Dermot Mulligan, formerly a member of our Department, who is now with the Department of Education and Skills.

Comment on this
Áine Stapleton

I am from the Department of Finance, and with me is my colleague, Ms Gráinne McGuckin.

Comment on this

The witnesses are all welcome. I invite Mr. John Buckley to introduce today's business. The full text of chapters 29 and 30 can be found in the annual report of the Comptroller and Auditor General or on the website of the Comptroller and Auditor General at www.audgen.gov.ie.

Comment on this
Mr. John Buckley

The Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation made payments of €1.5 billion in 2009 and the bulk of its spend occurred in two main areas, enterprise development, including science and technology in which it spent €730 million and labour force development on which it spent €687 million.

The Department also administered the National Training Fund, which has made payments of €366 million in 2009. The resources of the fund are used to train people who are either in employment or seeking employment.

Chapter 29 of the 2009 report deals with payments by Skillnets Limited, which is a company entirely funded from the National Training Fund. Skillnets was allocated €16.6 million from the fund in 2009, a reduction from the €26 million budget in 2008. The funding allocated to Skillnets is applied in supporting industry-specific training under a training networks programme. The network concept involves funding enterprises which come together and collaborate to address their common training needs jointly. The enterprises participating in the networks provide contributions towards the cost of training provision. In 2009, these contributions were of the order of €8 million.

Under the 2008-09 programme, 123 networks were initially approved for funding, but this had been reduced to 103 networks by the end of 2009. More than 40,000 participants were trained in 2009. Skillnets supports 62 networks in the latest 2010-11 programme. The Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation had overall responsibility for the oversight of Skillnets at the time of my report and had three ministerial representatives on its board.

Chapter 29 deals with the control and monitoring of expenditure under the programme. It also outlines how Skillnets dealt with allegations of irregularities by a training provider who delivered services to the networks. The subsequent investigation by Skillnets found that 24 networks had made payments to the provider in 2008-09. No evidence was found of irregularities in the payments made by ten of the networks. However, there was evidence of such irregularities in 12 cases and investigations were continuing in two further cases.

In the 12 networks where irregularities were found, the training provider had been paid to deliver 24 courses. The investigation made findings in respect of the 24 courses. Although eight of the courses paid for had not been delivered, nevertheless there were trainee profile sheets, evaluation forms and signed attendance sheets on file for the trainees who allegedly attended those courses. A further eight courses had been delivered to companies that were not members of the relevant network. A further eight courses were delivered to network members, but in four of these cases there was insufficient evidence that all of the trainees who had been claimed for had attended the training. In three of the eight courses delivered to network members, the training provider collected the matching income directly from member companies.

The total amount of Skillnets grant expenditure found to be ineligible was approximately €200,000. However, since a proportion of grant funding to the networks concerned had been retained, the bulk of the ineligible grant funding could be offset. The net loss of public funds is estimated to be of the order of €50,000.

I understand that the training provider in question recently ceased trading. A tighter monitoring regime might have mitigated the risk. Skillnets aimed to visit each of the training networks once during each two-year cycle to check the administrative and financial controls. This suggests there would have been approximately 50 visits each year in 2008 and 2009. In practice, there were 16 visits in 2008 and just two in 2009. According to Skillnets, the reductions in its funding and its efforts to manage the consequent downsizing had resulted in an increased administrative workload which impacted on its ability to carry out inspection visits to networks.

The lack of direct contact by Skillnets with the member companies of networks and with trainees and the absence of spot-checking on individual courses or events run by networks made it difficult to confirm that training took place. The training provider was allowed by training networks to take too active a role in the delivery and financial management of courses. This made it difficult to identify whether courses that were paid for actually took place or were provided for the benefit of the network members. There also needed to be more separation of the functions of training procurement and provision.

Overall, the experience points up the need to ensure that, in cases where the Department uses third parties to deliver programmes, there is an adequate control and inspection process in place sufficient to guarantee that expenditure is regular and that public moneys are safeguarded and applied for the purpose intended.

Turning briefly to chapter 30, this deals with redundancy and insolvency payments administered by the Department but paid out of the Social Insurance Fund. Payments in 2009 in respect of redundancy amounted to €336 million. A further €20 million was paid in respect of other employment entitlements in cases of insolvency. The report notes that administration of the payments was in accordance with the parameters of the scheme and, by year end, employers owed the State €144 million in instances where the State needed to step in to meet their obligations to pay statutory redundancy entitlements and other employment entitlements unpaid where employers became insolvent. As would be expected in the current environment, the recovery of these amounts has been low. One of the functions of the Department is to ensure that redundancies are genuine. The audit noted that the level of subsequent rehiring of workers made redundant was relatively low, with straight rehires accounting for 1.6% of payments and blocks of employees moving to related enterprises accounting for 1% of payments. Some 2.6% of payments were to persons who moved onto occupational pensions. Some further information on redundancies by sector is set out in chapter 13, which deals with revenue, but the 2009 report also contains some information on the sectoral breakdown of redundancies.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Buckley. I invite Mr. Gorman to make his opening statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

My comments relate primarily to the contents of chapters 29 and 30 of the report of the Comptroller and Auditor General and to Vote 34 of the appropriation accounts, which in 2009 covered the operations of the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment, now reconfigured as the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation. With regard to the overall Vote for the Department, total gross expenditure in 2009 came to €1.5 billion, including €18 million in carry-over capital allocations from 2008. Comparative figures for 2008 were gross expenditure of €1.5 billion and €23 million in carry-over capital.

I am happy to note that the Comptroller and Auditor General's report on the Department for the year is generally positive. In spite of a particularly difficult global environment, there are a number of positive achievements to record on the basis of the supports provided to enterprise through the Department's Vote. For example, IDA Ireland approved 125 investment projects, Enterprise Ireland supported 73 new high potential start-ups, county enterprise boards exceeded their targets by supporting more than 1,000 enterprises, more than 700 indigenous enterprises undertook research development or innovation projects and IDA Ireland secured 62 research development and innovation projects.

I would like to address the two specific issues raised by the Comptroller and Auditor General's report, namely, redundancy and insolvency payments and the National Training Fund - Skillnets. There was a threefold increase in the number of redundancy and insolvency claims lodged between 2007 and 2009, placing a major administrative demand on the Department to deliver employees' statutory entitlements within acceptable timelines. The Comptroller and Auditor General's audit focused on redundancy payment administration and reviewed departmental controls to manage the payment systems. On this point I am pleased to note that, despite the considerable pressures on my Department to process redundancy payment claims as expeditiously as possible, the audit concluded that the control systems governing payments were satisfactory and that all cases reviewed for eligibility under the legislation were found to have an entitlement to payment.

On the issue of debt management, the Comptroller and Auditor General's report concluded that all debt was found to be listed for recovery and that the Department would need to apply focused risk management to all components of the debt and to guard against the premature write-off of amounts owing. I can assure the committee that my Department, through the efforts of the recoveries unit which I re-established in April 2008, continues to make every effort to recover moneys owing to the fund. To this end, I am exploring with the Revenue Commissioners, given the significantly greater resources and powers available to that office, the possibilities of Revenue also acting to seek to recover debts due to the Minister arising from payments made under the redundancy and insolvency payment schemes.

In terms of write-offs, I assure the committee that my Department does not engage in the premature write-off of debts outstanding as evidenced by the fact that, of the amount of €4.1 million written off in the year to date, €3.5 million related to debts dating back to 2004 and earlier. Of the total amount of €8.7 million written off in bad debts in 2009, some 83% or €7.1 million related to debts arising in 2004 and earlier.

At this point, the Department is engaged only in debt write-off in cases where the official liquidation or receivership process is complete and a final statement of accounts has been provided. As the committee will be aware, the Government has decided that with effect from 1 January 2011 full responsibility for this activity will transfer to the Department of Social Protection.

Chapter 29 of the Comptroller and Auditor General's report deals with Skillnets and the National Training Fund, NTF. Skillnets is an enterprise led limited company funded under the NTF to support development of workplace upskilling and promote training of those employed in the private sector. This funding model involves supporting networks of companies who come together to identify and meet their common training needs. While Skillnets now operates under the Department of Education and Skills, in 2009 it was run under the aegis of my Department. The financial allocation for the Skillnets training networks programme in 2009 was €16.6 million. A total of 103 networks were funded under this provision and 41,610 persons were trained over 193,757 training days, of which 93,020 days were provided to those with low basic skills. In the past five years to date Skillnets is estimated to have trained more than 200,000 persons, including almost 5,000 unemployed persons for the first time this year in an innovative element of the unemployment activation agenda.

Skillnets Limited currently employs 21 staff to administer, support, control and monitor its national training programme. Each of its networks is assigned a programme support manager who guides and advises on the implementation of training plans and Skillnets requirements, procedures and protocols. Skillnets Limited also conducts at least one monitoring visit over the normal two year programme period. Resource constraints in 2009 arising from budgetary adjustments meant these vital visits dramatically declined that year.

The Comptroller and Auditor General's report identifies two cases where allegations of malpractice were reported to the Department. The first had already been identified by Skillnets Limited and was being dealt with since September 2008. The Department sought a response from Skillnets Limited in February 2009 to anonymous allegations made that month and a further detailed report was sought in April 2009 and subsequently received in August 2009. The second allegation arose from an anonymous phone call in February 2010 which Skillnets Limited immediately brought to the attention of the Department before putting in train a thorough investigation which culminated in an external auditor's report being issued to the Department in June 2010.

In both these cases, my Department ensured that Skillnets took immediate action to ensure potential losses of public money were identified and minimised, and that training participants were not adversely affected. All appropriate bodies, including the Garda authorities, were duly notified of the allegations by Skillnets Limited and thorough investigations were conducted. These investigations uncovered a number of breaches of procedures which were addressed by Skillnets and culminated in the conclusions and recommendations set out in chapter 29 of the Comptroller and Auditor General's report. The fact that the allegations had foundation is of concern to the Department. We have pursued these concerns with the CEO of Skillnets, who has responded appropriately.

Key to the measures that have been put in train is the greater emphasis being placed by Skillnets Limited on the oversight of the relationship between networks and their training providers. In this context, more intensive spot checks and compliance visits are being undertaken, including sample checks by Skillnets Limited personnel of network companies and trainees. Greater emphasis has also been placed on network managers attending training events. We will continue to closely monitor these actions in consultation with Skillnets Limited. In addition Skillnets Limited is enhancing its control regime by: providing clear written instructions to each network of its responsibilities; allocating unique identifiers to training providers and conducting quarterly reviews of payments to providers; recording matching income and reconciling income for each course; reviewing procurement in each network; and confirming that only one bank account is operated and that independent accountants obtain standard bank confirmations. Moreover, in December 2009, even before the training provider allegations, my Department had agreed on the following new measures for Skillnets in 2010: a consolidation and streamlining of the number of networks funded with a cap of 70 networks in total, compared to the 123 networks funded under the 2008-09 programme; a revised public-private funding ratio for networks of 50:50; a capping of management costs of networks at 25% of total expenditure, that is, solely from private funding sources; and the capping of retention payments to networks at 10% of total grant paid and at the level of €1 million in total across the programme.

Skillnets has tendered for an external evaluation of all network activity under the 2010 programme, something that was previously procured by networks themselves. The results of this evaluation will be considered by Skillnets and the Department in due course with a view to informing any further improvements in programme operations. The maximum exposure of public funding arising from the activities of the training provider highlighted in the Comptroller and Auditor General's report is estimated by Skillnets to be just under €54,000. Skillnets is taking all appropriate steps to minimise this figure and recover any outstanding funding. It has also conducted a review of this training provider's earlier activity between 2005 and 2007 and is satisfied that there was no improper conduct or loss of public funding during that period. Moreover, it has instituted a wider ranging review and quality assurance of other significant training providers under the programme from 2008 to the present. The sampling results available to date provide positive assurance on all the training tested during that period.

The matters arising in the external evaluation, the ongoing work of Skilllnets Limited and the Comptroller and Auditor General's Report will all be taken into account by the Department of Education and Skills in the context of future funding for Skillnets.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Gorman. May we publish his statement?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

I thank Mr. Gorman and the other officials for attending this meeting. The first issue I wish to raise is chapter 30. As of 31 December 2009, €144 million was due to the Department in redundancy and insolvency payments. How much has since been collected and what is the current figure?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Our latest and best estimate of the total amount recovered out of the aforementioned €144 million is €24 million. These are problem cases from the outset.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

I know that.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

The State only steps in to help employees where a company has failed or is unable to meet its statutory redundancy obligations. From the outset, we are dealing with an employer that does not have the financial capacity to meet these obligations or, in some cases, has chosen not to meet them.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

What is the balance due?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

The current outstanding figure is €183 million.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

It increased from approximately €100 million at the beginning of 2009 to €144 at the end of that year.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Of the outstanding figure, 39% accumulated in 2009 on the back of the financial difficulties companies were experiencing.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

The additional €40 million this year was obviously incurred in 2010. There is a large backlog in processing applications because of the volume received. Is Mr. Gorman able to estimate what level of debt will be in the fund when the applications notified or made to the Department are processed? We all know that it can take months to process applications and issue payments. When is it expected to clear the backlog?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Our worst position in terms of the backlog was a nine month waiting period. We have reduced the waiting period to six months and we hope to improve it further. Two factors are at play in improving processing times. The level of demand is dropping, that is, the volume of redundancies is decreasing. However, the number of claims for processing increased from 35,000 in 2008 to 50,000 in 2009. Over the past 11 months, we have reduced that backlog by 15,000 claims from a high of just over 43,000, and I expect to reduce this to 25,000 by the end of the year. We have doubled the number of staff in this area to do that. We prioritised whatever funding we had from our overtime allocation in this area, and we have also used the call centre at the National Employment Rights Authority to take pressure off the people whom we would prefer to be engaged in processing rather than explaining and answering calls. That has been a significant help. The current time is six months and we hope to continue to reduce this. Thankfully, the volume of demand is falling.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

That means somebody being made redundant this month - that is, November - whose employer does not pay redundancy may receive his or her redundancy payment by next May.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes, as things stand today.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

That is a very long time.

I am concerned about one item which I was going to come to later on, but I will deal with it now. During the year in question, there was an application for €13 million from the European Social Fund, and it was expected that this would be received. However, the application was not submitted by the Department and the funding was not received. We are talking about people who have been made redundant. Trying to find overtime to pay people increases the pressure on the overtime budget. If the Department had collected the €13 million it was due from the EU, it might have had some funds to give people their redundancy payments much more quickly than in six or nine months. Can Mr. Gorman see the connection between the shortage of money in the Department and the failure to claim money it should have claimed and received?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

If I was waiting for my cheque and the Department said it could not pay overtime, but I knew the Department was short by €13 million which had not been applied for from Europe, I would be very frustrated. As Accounting Officer, how does Mr. Gorman square this?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

That €13 million, which arises out of the FÁS problems, is not money I can automatically transfer over. It belongs in an entirely separate space.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Has the Department received that money since?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

No; that claim has been deferred. We expect to get the money but it is not-----

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Next year?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Next year some time, yes.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

It was in the 2009 Estimates approved by the Dáil, but it did not come through, and it is not coming through this year. Is it in the Estimate for next year? It is in the published Estimates for 2011.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

It would be under the Department of Education and Skills vote now because it has moved.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Yes, but it is still expected.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Just to clarify, I do not have an automatic entitlement to move that money around. It is governed by Department of Finance sanction. It is in a different space. The area of salaries, staff numbers and overtime is - understandably - tightly controlled at the moment.

Comment on this

Can Mr. Gorman tell us why he did not claim the money? Why has he deferred the claim?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

When FÁS put together the draft claim for this money, our auditors and the EU were concerned about the accounting methods used to calculate expenditure for contractor training for the unemployed. The formula was designed to convert the initial estimated costs to actual payments at the end of the contract period. When FÁS examined its claim on a case-by-case basis, it found a difference. It was only €165,000 in terms of the conversion. However, in view of the time available, putting in that claim in the knowledge that the €165,000 would have to be sorted out could have jeopardised the full €13.6 million. Therefore, the decision was taken to defer the lodgment of the claim. It is not lost. Putting in the claim while that issue remained unresolved could have jeopardised it, so a prudent call was made not to risk the €13.6 million.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

I do not want to dwell on the issue of FÁS; we can discuss that another day.

I wish to ask about the sum of €144 million - now about €183 million - that is due to the Department in redundancy and insolvency payments. Approximately €39 million of this represents money that was due prior to 2004. Realistically, if money that was due nearly a decade ago could not be collected even during the boom times, are we codding ourselves thinking we will collect it? Mr. Gorman might say it has not been written off, but how much of the money from prior to 2004 does he actually expect to collect in cash? His chances of collecting it now must be close to zero. I know the money is technically due, but why is it still being shown as an asset of the State in the Department? We are dealing with public accounts based on Estimates produced by various Departments which include what I would call fictional debts of almost €40 million, yet this is supposed to add up to represent national assets, on which the State finances are based. There is not a chance in hell of that being collected. How much of that €39 million does Mr. Gorman expect the Department to receive in cash over the next two or three years?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

The Comptroller and Auditor General acknowledged in his opening statement that it is a challenge to recover that debt, and the older the debt, the more difficult it is. I cannot give an estimate. Some of the money is locked into protracted receivership and liquidation processes. We have been slow to write off debt lest an opportunity arise.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

It seems to be an attitude similar to that of the banks - there is money out there that we have been owed for eight or nine years but we are slow to write it off because we are pretending it is a good debt. That was one of the reasons we had a banking crisis - because people were reluctant to accept that some of the figures on their books would never be collected. Now a Department is saying that it operates on the same principle. Two years after the bank crisis it still has such figures on its books. I realise some of it was written off last year, but I am still looking at €40 million, although the Department would be doing well if it received €4 million of this.

Comment on this

Mr. Buckley might wish to comment on this.

Comment on this
Mr. John Buckley

The way the accounting works is that this money is already fully charged to the accounts at the point at which it is paid. Therefore, it is not an asset that is being carried. It is actually a memorandum figure that is being pursued. In the way it is recorded here, it is off the books. It is an amount of money that has been fully charged and absorbed in the State accounts.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

I did not see that in the chapter I am reading. If Mr. Buckley is saying this figure of €39 million is off the books, that is fine, but it is written here in black and white in front of us. That is an important distinction. We had a debate and then we were told the money was not really due, or it was due but was off the books. It is a funny way of doing things. One can understand why the public is becoming mightily confused. We are becoming confused on this side of the table.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

We are trying to strike a balance in terms of walking away from money that is owed. We are being very careful. It can happen that companies that continue to trade but are in difficulty at a point in time actually get themselves out of it, and we can obtain money from them by pursuing them down the line.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

I accept the Department will get some.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

There are opportunities to recover the money. In addition, when the receivership or liquidation processes come to a conclusion, we get a certain amount - sometimes none, sometimes a small percentage. If there is any prospect at all of getting the money, we will keep chasing it. Maybe it is time to see whether there is some we should write off. We have been writing off the certainties; if there is no prospect of collecting the money, they are gone.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

I will move on from this, because we have made our points. Can Mr. Gorman break down the figure of €39 million, which is based on amounts paid out in various years up to 2004, and give us the amount year by year? If Mr. Gorman has this information he can circulate it, and if not I ask him to send it to us. Does some of it go back to the 1970s?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Therefore, included in the figures are moneys that have been owed to the State for 30 years, since which time we have had booms and recessions.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes, and we are still getting some of it in, believe it or not.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Mr. Gorman might give us the year-by-year figures.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Maybe when the tribunals are finished, something might fall out of the bottom of one of them, which would be good.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

I do not have the figures but I will obtain them.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

I did not expect Mr. Gorman to have them here. He can supply them to us.

Mr. Gorman said the Department had been sending out letters each quarter. Many of these companies, which go back to the 1970s, the 1980s, the 1990s and the early part of this century, no longer exist - we all accept that. However, many letters must be returned in the post using the "return to sender" facility. Is there a mechanism for dealing with this outcome when the building in question is no longer there? What does the Department do with such letters? Mr. Gorman has made the point that letters are sent once every quarter. What happens to the ones that are returned?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

They are referred to the write-off committee for assessment.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

An Post is one of the significant actors in supplying information on whether something should be written off.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

In regard to write-offs, the report states the largest write-off in the year in question was €1.9 million. What was the name and address of the company involved? I accept the money will not be collected, but we would like to know whose debt we are writing off.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

I do not have the name of the company involved.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Does any of Mr. Gorman's colleagues know it? From a business rather than an administration point of view, I would have thought the chief executive of an organisation which had written off a debt of €1.9 million for one client would know the name of the company involved when attending this committee.

Comment on this

Will the Department supply the information, please?

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Mr. Gorman might inform the committee of the name before the end of the meeting because that figure jumps out from the report.

I will move to the Vote for the Department concerning which I have noted some comments and Mr. Gorman might help me by providing some information. I will begin on page 448 of the accounts. I note the payments made by the Department to Enterprise Ireland, namely, a grant to meet administration and general expenses of €93 million and grants to industry totalling €111 million. These are ball-park figures which give the impression, although I am sure it cannot be the case, that half of the money given to Enterprise Ireland for business development is used to meet its own administration costs. That cannot be correct. Is that description accurate? It looks extraordinary.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

No, it is in addition to the amount to cover classic wage and pension contributions, rent, rates, insurance-----

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

To meet administration costs.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

It funds the advice given to client companies and covers promotional activities, trade fairs, outward missions with companies and inward missions with buyers. It also covers market research-----

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Am I reading this correctly? Are we agreed that of the €204 million given by the State to Enterprise Ireland, only about half worked its way to Enterprise Ireland client companies by way of grants? No county enterprise board would be allowed to operate in that way. Mr. Gorman cannot mean to say only half of the money awarded to the organisation by the Exchequer goes to companies.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

No. Of the outturn figure of €93 million in 2009, the outturn figure for pay would have been €64 million, while €28 million would have gone towards supporting companies and meeting other overheads, in addition to the direct grants to actual companies, as shown in the next subhead, D2.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

If that sum was paid to companies, that is grand, but why is it not shown?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

There is a distinction made between current expenditure and supports and capital supports to companies.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Will Mr. Gorman explain what he means by that?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Capital supports to companies means fixed asset support, seeking venture capital, feasibility studies, employment grants and consultancy grants, but the cost of running overseas trade missions and advice is largely-----

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Promotional.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

They are promotional rather than capital costs and, as such, are dealt with in subhead D1.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

I reiterate that I find it unacceptable that a State grant agency given €204 million in a particular year was able to pass on just over 50% in indirect grants to organisations and companies and that almost 50% went on salaries, administration and promotional costs. While I accept promotions are essential, does Mr. Gorman understand my basic point?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

The sum of €111 million is paid out from subhead D2.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

I mentioned that figure. Just over 50% of the figure of €204 million - €111 million - is paid out by way of direct grants.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

No. The pay element is €64 million.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

That is contained in the figure of €93 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes. However, it is important to understand the supports companies receive are not provided only from that subhead. From subhead D2, capital supports, €111 million is provided.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

That is the figure to which I keep referring. I shall start at the beginning. It is very simple. In the year in question the Department gave Enterprise Ireland €204 million, consisting of sums of €93 million which Mr. Gorman stated was used to cover salaries, administration, rental, rates, promotional and trade missions costs, and €111 million to client companies by way of grants. My point is that no organisation should be allowed to use almost 50% of its money in that way. If a county enterprise board had such proportions, Mr. Gorman would close it down on the spot. Most are confined to spending 15% of their budget on administration and promotional costs, with most of the money going directly to companies. Does Mr. Gorman understand my basic point?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

I accept the basic point being made.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

I find the proportions to be all wrong.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

A significant amount of what Enterprise Ireland does with companies does not only involve direct financial transfers; people sit down with them to do business plans with them, assess their grant applications, give them market information and work with them on the ground both here and in overseas offices. It does not involve just light administration.

Comment on this

Deputy Fleming is asking a simple question. Can Mr. Gorman give us a breakdown of the figures in subhead D1?

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

The Secretary General might send us a breakdown of the figures in the two subheads. I would not be happy with such proportions. No county enterprise board or partnership company would be allowed to keep 45% of its budget, passing on only 55%.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

The figures in subhead D1 break down into €64.5 million for pay and €28.4 million for non-pay items.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Mr. Gorman can send the information to the committee.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

In recent years-----

Comment on this

Can Mr. Gorman break down the €28.4 million figure even further?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes, I can. Some €9.6 million went on rent, rates, service charges and insurance. Staff travelling expenses amounted to €4.5 million because of the network of overseas offices and travelling with companies and trade missions. There is an extensive requirement to travel both internally and overseas with companies. Professional fees for accountancy and other advices amounted to €2.6 million. Other staff overhead costs came to €2.8 million, for which I do not have a breakdown. Communication and IT costs were €2.6 million. Light, heating and cleaning costs amounted to €1.4 million. Postage, printing, stationery, repairs, maintenance and leasing costs came €1.2 million. Market and client development costs arising directly from the non-pay element came to €946,000, while miscellaneous other operating expenses amounted to €1.6 million.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Chairman, perhaps we should bring in representatives of Enterprise Ireland to discuss its world programme. Mr. Gorman has provided figures, but now I see the figures for 2008 are alarming. In that year Enterprise Ireland received a grant to meet administration costs and other expenses of €100 million but paid out only €60 million in grants to industry and to meet capital expenditure. Almost two thirds of the €160 million given in 2008 to Enterprise Ireland remained within the organisation building, while just over one third was paid out by way of grants. This is crazy stuff. The 2009 figures are utterly unacceptable and the 2008 figures are bizarre; two thirds of the money went on the organisation and one third went on grants.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Enterprise Ireland has been reducing its staff numbers in recent years.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

I wish to move on from Enterprise Ireland.

Comment on this

This is a standard question which we put to each Accounting Officer. We did the same last week. Have you satisfied yourself in a meaningful way that all the expenditure with regard to foreign travel, entertainment and so on has been in compliance with Department of Finance guidelines? What is the nature of your confirmation?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

All the new guidelines introduced by the Department of Finance have been communicated to the agencies. We have issued an office notice internally to our staff, offices and agencies that builds on the Department of Finance guidelines and requires compliance. In his annual report and accounts the chairman of each agency must certify compliance with these guidelines. The guidelines require prudence in the class of air travel used and the types of hotel used. The emphasis is on economy and moving away from first and business class. We pursue this through the annual statement we receive from the chairman.

Comment on this

Does the Department take the statement as read and accurate?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes, we take the statement as read and accurate. It is a formal certification.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Will Mr. Gorman provide information on subheads C1 and C2? We have discussed Enterprise Ireland. In one year, two thirds of its money was spent on the organisation and one third went on grants. Let us move to subheads C1, C2 and C3. They refer to the IDA. In 2009, the IDA received €42 million for its activities but it paid out €68 million in grants. From a total budget of €100 million for the IDA, two thirds of its money went to client companies and one third did not, whereas the figures are in the opposite proportion in Enterprise Ireland. Is there any chance of our having another FÁS here? Mr. Gorman may say they are different organisations and we know as much. However, on the face of it, I cannot understand how of the money the IDA receives from the Department two thirds goes in grants whereas with Enterprise Ireland between one third and one half goes on grants. Is the organisation doing its job? It might be very efficient at procedures and the administration might be good but is it doing its basic job?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

I believe it is. In addition to the direct moneys administered by Enterprise Ireland in subheads D1 and D2, it plays a major role in subhead F, the science, research and development area. It has spent €134 million in 2009 specifically on administering in that area and assisting companies. All the administration for that is charged to the same subhead D1. As the Deputy will see, the proportions begin to change.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Yes. Let us look through the accounts. I will list several organisations and I call on Mr. Gorman to send on this information. It is listed in the accounts and I will not ask Mr. Gorman about them individually. It will be on the record and Mr. Gorman has the list before him. The list is the IDA, Enterprise Ireland, Forfás, Shannon Free Airport Development Company, FÁS, the Labour Relations Commission, the Competition Authority, the National Consumer Agency, the Companies Registration Office, the Registrar of Friendly Societies, the Health and Safety Authority, the National Employment Rights Authority, NERA, the Labour Court and possibly some others. Is it possible for Mr. Gorman to prepare a document for each of these listing the top five salaries in each organisation, any other remuneration entitlements by way of pension, or the value of their pension funds if they are private, any expense allowances for the top five people, how many company cars there are in each of these 14 organisations, whether credit cards are held by the top five people, the credit limit in each case and the throughput for each credit card for the year? Mr. Gorman will understand why we ask the questions. Given the level of money going through those organisations, it is the quickest way of cutting to the chase. As Accounting Officer, Mr. Gorman will be able to get the information. The Department probably has staff on the board of each of these organisations.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes, we have.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Will Mr. Gorman sent that information to us? It will be useful information. Is that feasible?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes, that is feasible.

Comment on this

The committee has received a complaint from a member of the public about one of the agencies, the Health and Safety Authority, regarding the level of expenditure on travel and subsistence. The file is being made available to you. We seek from you information on the nature of monitoring by your Department of that agency and whether it is in compliance with the Department of Finance guidelines post-February 2009 and before February 2009. As you know, the guidelines changed arising from the FÁS report we made. We seek information on the nature of reporting between you, as Accounting Officer, and the Chairman of the board of that authority and the nature of certification by that board. What do you do as Accounting Officer of the Department to ensure there is full compliance? Do you go beyond the assurances received?

Last week, we heard from the Department of Community, Equality and Gaeltacht Affairs that assurances were given and accepted at face value regarding Údarás Na Gaeltachta. The file will be made available to you. We request a detailed examination of the file. Records were released under freedom of information legislation to a member of the public and made available to us and we will use this exercise as a test run along with the information Deputy Fleming has sought.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Will Mr. Gorman tell us the benefit of another figure in the accounts and then subsequently give us a more detailed note? Some €13.5 million is paid out each year for the European Space Agency. Will Mr. Gorman talk to us about what value Ireland gets from that and give a general overview? Will Mr. Gorman send a detailed note to the committee subsequently?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Membership of the European Space Agency gives opportunities for research institutions, universities and companies to participate in space research programmes run by the European Space Agency. It gives opportunities for Irish companies to win business from the European Space Agency. During 2008, we carried out a review of the return for the investment. That was the last time we looked at it formally. Irish contractors involved with the European Space Agency on the back of our membership generated a total turnover of €136 million of which €20 million was directly related to the space programmes. Those companies supported employment of approximately 1,000 people. The businesses involved are highly research and development intensive. Typically, they would invest 40% of their turnover in research and development. We expect that more and more opportunities will become available through membership of the space agency. I can provide a good deal more detail of the actual companies who participate and the precise benefits they gain. The €14 million generates at least €20 million in direct return.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

It would be helpful for the committee to receive a note on that. The Department paid €1.2 million in grants for trade union education and advisory services. Will Mr. Gorman take us through the details of the €1.2 million?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

This is a long-standing subvention which the State pays to the Irish Congress of Trade Unions. It dates back to 1975. Essentially, it supports investment by the trade union movement generally in training and education of trade union people, officials and administrators.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Is it for shop stewards or full-time staff?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

It is not confined to shop stewards, it may include full-time staff as well. The thinking has been that it helps to equip the unions to do their work more professionally. The underlying rationale is that it contributes to industrial relations and the professionalism with which industrial relations can be and are conducted. We have a rule that no intervention should be higher than 80% of the expenditure being incurred on the particular training activity. The averages that have been coming in for the State's intervention were 52% in 2007, 44% in 2008 and we estimate that intervention rate for this year will be about 39%, although we do not have final figures.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

There is a detailed breakdown of where the €1.2 million was spent.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

There are annual audited accounts.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Is that in the Department?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Can the committee get a copy of that?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes.

Comment on this

Is anything going to this famous SIPTU account?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

No, that is a separate arrangement. The Department of Health and Children oversaw that.

Comment on this

There is nothing from the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Our money goes to ICTU, which in turn funds trade unions but I am aware SIPTU gets some money from ICTU as part of this fund.

Comment on this

The Department does fund individual unions directly then.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

No, not directly.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Another thing that caught my eye is the figure on page 458 for extra receipts payable to the Exchequer. I have the revised Estimates for Public Expenditure that were discussed at the relevant Oireachtas committee and approved by the Dáil. It shows a figure under this heading for FÁS sale of assets; €22 million was expected to be received. When we look at the accounts at the end of the audit, there is a note that states the estimate for the FÁS sale of assets is €22,000 and was incorrectly represented in the 2009 revised Estimates for Public Services as €22 million. I do not understand how an organisation can ask for its Estimates to include a figure of €22 million in respect of extra receipts payable to the Exchequer and then a year later when the accounts come in we are told it was a typing error.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

That is what it was in the final printing of the Estimates volume.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

The Estimates that went through the Dáil and were voted upon contained that error. What date did that happen?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Probably late autumn or early winter 2009.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

When that was discovered, was the Minister asked to correct the Dáil record for a wrong Estimate approved by the Dáil caused by a typing error? The Estimate was passed based on the receipt of the €22 million being part of the equation for that year. What happened to correct the Dáil record?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

We did not go back to the Dáil, we brought it to the attention of the Department of Finance on the basis that the Book of Estimates is produced there.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Exasperation is setting in with me. We now see the Estimate for the Department included a figure of €22 million. Someone realised there was a typing error. The Department did not even get the €22,000 as it transpired. The Department was then aware that the Estimates for the finance of State, which we had discussed, were incorrect. I thought there was a standard procedure where a Minister knows incorrect information has been given to the Dáil, it is corrected at the first available opportunity. I thought that was how a democracy worked; when a figure of €22 million is a typing error and we make decisions based on it. Was the Minister asked to correct the record? It is not good enough to say it was a typing error 18 month later. The Department might accept it was a typing error but the Department of Finance expected that €22 million at some stage.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

No, it did not.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

The relevance of the Dáil is important here so I would like to know about the record. This is the Committee of Public Accounts and it is the first we have seen of this. If it was €22,000 I would not say anything but it is €22 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

We brought it to the attention of the Department of Finance and produced a revised Estimates volume. We did not take it any further. The Department of Finance worked on the €22,000 figure, there was never an expectation of €22 million.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

The figure the Dáil was given and that was laid in the Oireachtas Library, that was on the public record, is €22 million. We are being told that what is presented to the Dáil and what the Dáil votes through is not important. This is a cavalier attitude to the Dáil, saying the Department was aware of the mistake but did nothing because the Dáil would not notice it. Am I making a mountain out of a molehill when I say the Dáil should be given accurate information?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

No, the Deputy is correct. It is not cavalier, it was a typing error, the figure was always to be €22,000, and we brought it to the attention of the Department of Finance, which produced the volume. Perhaps we should have gone further.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

I accept the €22 million was not due and the Department knew that. What did the Department of Finance make of this?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

What does the Deputy mean?

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

That the revised Estimate put through the Dáil on behalf of the Government included a typing error of €22 million for a receipt the Members of the Dáil believed to be part of the figures making up the revised Estimates for 2009.

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

I am not sure there is a procedure for the Minister to go back into the Dáil in such circumstances. It was a mistake and it was not accounted for in our numbers. We formally apologise for the typing error in the revised Estimate. I do not take a view on the actions of the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation on foot of the typing error.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

I understand what happened. The mistake was caught at official level and the Departments were aware of it. It is as if, however, the Dáil was not relevant to the process when passing an Estimate. One of the few functions of a parliament is to pass the estimates of expenditure. I would ask the Secretaries General to reconsider that where there are errors we were misled. I voted on it on the basis of this €22 million being received and no one told me until today that was not the case. Perhaps the Department of Finance thinks it runs the country and once the officials know about something, it does not matter about the Dáil and the Government.

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

On behalf of the Department, we apologise.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

It might sound a small point but this carry on is making little of the Dáil.

Comment on this

Does the Department of Finance not have guidelines to deal with an issue like this, where the Dáil must be informed?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

In terms of the financial procedures, I am not aware of any procedure in place but, certainly, we can check and get back to the committee.

Comment on this

Will the officials check?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

Absolutely.

Comment on this

We have to suspend, there is a vote.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Are we not paired?

Comment on this

Deputy Fleming and I are paired but there was no other Fianna Fáil pair.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Perhaps the Chairman has some questions he would like to ask. I would prefer if we did not have to adjourn. Perhaps the Comptroller and Auditor General has an observation to make on the Dáil voting figures through on the basis of what is presented to it and officialdom being happy if those figures are not accurate? Should there be a mechanism to correct such occurrences?

Comment on this
Mr. John Buckley

We must look at what is encompassed in the Vote and the Estimates. The Vote and the Estimates deal with the subheads and the appropriations-in-aid. Appropriations-in-aid are one particular type of receipt, they are receipts that can be estimated. As well as getting appropriations-in-aid, Departments get windfall receipts from other sources and these are called Exchequer extra receipts. If we look at the start of the annual report, there is a full list of those, and some Departments manage to estimate them and put in a provisional figure, as happened here. Others put in zeroes because they cannot estimate the figure. The definition of Exchequer extra receipts is, to use quaint language from Gladstone's time, receipts which are not germane to the Vote. In other words, they are not particularly relevant to the accounting of the Vote and are usually windfall receipts. If one wants to look at it in terms of lessons to be learned we may need to look a bit wider.

When we are dealing with a range of receipts which are not estimable and come from left field perhaps none of them should be estimated and they should just appear when they turn up, or alternatively some effort should be made to estimate them all. One needs to look at it in the round. From the point of view of formal adoption by the Dáil, the Estimate that is voted only refers formally to the sub-heads and to the appropriations-in-aid. The Appropriation Act that comes at the end of the year ultimately confirms that the Estimate only refers to those two elements. The other elements are more or less pieces of additional information which are included.

I take the Deputy's point that when they are included for information purposes they should be accurate and perhaps there should be some way of-----

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

It was an observation. I accept what Mr. Buckley is saying. There are other items of expenditure in this heading, such as IDA grants and refunds. That is fine and they might come in. One can overestimate or underestimate, which nobody argues with. An event might come sooner or later than planned. However, this was not an overestimate or an underestimate, rather, it was an error known at official level. The figures printed in the Dáil record were not accurate. I recommend that we have a procedure whereby when known errors come to light they are corrected at the first available opportunity. I understood that was the normal procedure.

Comment on this

While we are waiting for some of the members to return, Mr. Gorman might tell the committee about the Aer Lingus redundancy scheme where approximately 715 staff were made redundant and some were re-employed at reduced rates. He might take us through the Department's attitude to that scheme and the current status of the redundancy package.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

On the current status of the claim by Aer Lingus for a rebate, a decision has not been taken on its eligibility.

Comment on this

The rebate would be-----

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

There would be a 60% rebate to the company of the cost of making statutory redundancy payments.

Comment on this

Is there a cost in that?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

It is approximately €5 million. Since the redundancies occurred we have engaged in a long protracted discussion and correspondence with Aer Lingus about the circumstances.

Comment on this

To set the scene, how long ago did the redundancies happen?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

In 2008-09.

Comment on this

A scheme which occurred in 2008 is still being considered.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

The legal aspects of it are under consideration. The most recent correspondence from Aer Lingus is from October.

Comment on this

Has a payment been made?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

We have not made a decision or formal payment on the claim. There were 11 individual cases for which payments were made in error; they were put in the wrong processing batch. They are not a problem in terms of what decision is made. We have an ongoing account with Aer Lingus for the normal churn of redundancies and we can offset those in the event that a decision was made that the redundancies were not eligible.

Eligibility is a matter of the Act and the law. The circumstances have been parsed and analysed in great detail. At the time the company and trade unions were negotiating the redundancy package clarification was sought from us in advance as to whether the redundancies in the circumstances which applied, whereby some people would be rehired with different job specifications on different terms would qualify for redundancy, were eligible. We were not in a position to give a definitive commitment in advance that those redundancies would qualify for a rebate.

We were precise in what we said to the company at that time We told it that until the full facts were known after the event we would not be in a position to make a final call on it. We said based on the preliminary information which was available to us at the time, while we were not making a definitive legal interpretation and it was not legally binding, the redundancies may qualify under the Redundancy Payments Act. We told it in writing that this could not be taken in any way to be a commitment by the Department or its deciding officers, nor would it preclude any other wider considerations of its eligibility.

We have been through this protracted process and are at the final stage. I have referred the latest information to our legal advisor for a final piece of advice before we refer it to the Minister for a decision.

Comment on this

Can the Secretary General tell us what elements of the claims have been paid to the workers who were rehired?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

We have paid none. The company would have paid the redundancy settlement terms to the workers. Where eligible redundancies are in play Aer Lingus or any other company would normally be entitled to a 60% rebate for the statutory element of those redundancies. We paid the company no moneys on that basis.

Comment on this

Was there a precedent for a scheme like this?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Not directly. That is why it is taking so long to make sure it ticks all the legal boxes. It is a matter of compliance with the law and will be significant, in terms of the precedent value it will have.

Comment on this

What was the scale of discussions the Department had with the Revenue Commissioners regarding the payments? What is the view of the Revenue Commissioners?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Normally the Revenue Commissioners would regard redundancy payments as eligible where we do but it is separate from us and makes its own determinations------

Comment on this

I know that. What interaction was there?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

We have had some discussions with it and it said it will always retain its independence and make its own decisions, having regard to Revenue legislation and tax law. It has not pronounced on the Aer Lingus case yet, to my knowledge.

Comment on this

With regard to the Dublin Airport Authority and the transfer of staff to the new terminal, has the Department received any communication from it about a similar scheme?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

We have 350 claims on the back of that change and they are in the queue for processing. We have not made a decision.

Comment on this

The Secretary General said that the Department is taking legal advice. When does he expect to have it? Has he received any legal advice so far?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Very much so. We received legal advice when we gave an indication on the possibility that Aer Lingus may be eligible and we were not making a determination. That position was taken on the back of legal advice and a referral to the Government at the time.

Comment on this

It is two years down the line and the Department still has not made a decision. What is the average time for it to adjudicate on a redundancy scheme?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

It is normally six months.

Comment on this

Aside from the DAA, are other cases outstanding?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

I am not aware of any of that nature. There are many straightforward cases. Each case is considered on its own merits and the circumstances of its claims within the context of the statutory provision.

Comment on this

What is the interaction between the Department and the Department of Finance? What is its attitude?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

We have not gone to the Department of Finance on this matter. We have dealt with it internally with our legal advisors and the Office of the Attorney General. The decision is one for the Minister to make.

Comment on this

Earlier Deputy Fleming asked a number of questions on Skillnets. Is there a common denominator between the board of Skillnets and FÁS? Will the Accounting Officer name those on the board of Skillnets and indicate if any of those served on FÁS at the time of the problems in regard to training?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

I have the list of Skillnets board members: Mr. Domhnall MacDomhnaill, retired from IBEC, chairman; Mr. Sexton Cahill, IBEC, retired; Ms Mairead Divilly, Small Firms Association; Mr. Seán Heading, TEEU; Mr. Terry Hobdell, ministerial nominee, Irish Fencing and Railing Limited; Mr. George Hennessy, CIF; Ms Nuala Keher, Lionra, a regional educational group; Mr. Brendan McGinty, IBEC; Mr. John McDermott, an official of our own Department, appointed directly by the Minister; Mr. Henry Murdock, a former FÁS official-----

Comment on this
Mr. Dermot Mulligan

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

-----retired from FÁS; Mr. Peter Rigney, ICTU; Mr. Niall Saul, IBEC, who was chair of the internal audit committee in FÁS; and Mr. Ian Talbot, Chambers Ireland, IBEC.

Comment on this

I have one other question regarding IDA Ireland and Enterprise Ireland. What is the average cost of a new job being created by each organisation?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

About €10,000 is my recollection. I will have it updated in light of the events of the past couple of years. I do not have a bang up-to-date figure. Given what has been happening in the economy that figure could have changed.

Comment on this

We may have to adjourn for a few minutes.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

No.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy a few questions?

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Is the Office of Director of Corporate Enforcement in your Department?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Given that I do not see it listed, where does it appear?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

It is at subhead A9.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

I did not see him or his office listed anywhere. That can be included in the list of organisations I mentioned earlier. On the issue of decentralisation, I understand the Department was to decentralise to Carlow.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

What costs have been incurred? Have staff moved? Are premises rented? What happened?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

We have 100 people in Carlow who are-----

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Separate from the NERA people.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

No, including NERA.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Is NERA a separate agency or is it part of the Department?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

NERA is an office of the Department.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

What does that mean?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

It means that it is essentially part of the Department-----

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Right.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

-----but will become a State agency in its own right.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Is it mainly NERA that has moved?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

It is a statutory office, not a Stage agency.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

We might get the Comptroller and Auditor General to give us a memo on the difference between a statutory office and a State agency.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

The staff will still be civil servants. That is the essential difference.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Right.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

We provide the staff to NERA.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Under the employment subsidy scheme there was an estimate for €20 million and €18 million was paid out. I understand that scheme was highly oversubscribed. I have only heard of the poor unfortunate companies that did not get into the scheme. Tell me about that scheme. If there was such a high demand, how is it that the Department did not spend the money? What has happened since the year end in this year to date? It appeared to be a very good employment subsidy scheme. It is where we should be at in the economy, trying to keep people in work. It is geared towards export companies to make them competitive. Where is that scheme? Has the EU an issue with it in terms of subsidising companies or in terms of competition issues?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

There is no issue with the EU. In fact the EU has facilitated that scheme under a flexibility which it introduced under a temporary arrangement for State aids.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Can there be an extension to the scheme? Is there a next phase?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

The EU is considering an extension into next year.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Have you requested that?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

No, it is being done. It was not a request from us. It is a general-----

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

EU look.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

The EU is taking a general look at that facility. It is not just an Irish facility, it is generally available.

Comment on this