Vote 34 - Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment
Contributions 220–447 of 674. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
One of the requirements is that companies must retain employees for a certain period.
Comment on this
One of the difficulties Enterprise Ireland is finding is that companies, because of the difficulties in the economy, are not in a position to comply with the terms and, therefore, are actually-----
Comment on this
Yes, in the circumstances that prevailed at the time of the application, subsequently find they cannot live with them.
Comment on this
Does the Department pay them at the end of the year when they promise to hold on to the people or does it give the money and seek to recoup if they let people go?
Comment on this
Towards the autumn or early winter of last year.
Comment on this
There were 1,632 approvals under the second call. The total number of jobs the second call was supporting was 14,902.
Comment on this
Going back to the Aer Lingus issue, would it be unfair to say this seems to be a bogus redundancy scheme operated by Aer Lingus and that the taxpayer should not have to pay for a scheme which is basically changing the terms and conditions of employees and staff and if it wants to do that it should do so through its own resources?
Comment on this
The scheme is designed to help companies retain people. It is aimed at helping companies through a difficult period to retain staff rather than make them redundant with the resultant calls on the State for either redundancy rebates or social welfare. The intention is to avoid redundancy, not, if I understand the Chairman's question-----
Comment on this
Sorry, the Chairman asked about the Aer Lingus situation. My apologies, I was interpreting it in the context of-----
Comment on this
That is the decision that has to be made, whether that arrangement qualifies under the legislation.
Comment on this
It is certainly an instrument that is being used to rationalise and change terms and conditions but I cannot make a call on it until I have the final legal position and a ministerial decision.
Comment on this
My last question - I hope I am not stealing any of Deputy Enright's questions - is on the McCarthy report. It states that there should be a rationalisation of services supporting the developing agencies and that in some cases the promotional work being done by these agencies should be amalgamated. What progress has been made on that?
Comment on this
In regard to the mainstream agencies - Enterprise Ireland and IDA Ireland - we have not restructured the organisations in terms of doing away with one or the other. What we have put in place is a much closer level of co-operation between the two agencies on the ground in dealing with companies. In terms of the county enterprise boards which are also part of that enterprise support structure, the Minister has announced his intention to bring proposals soon to the Government to restructure and refine the basis on which those enterprise boards are structured and to look at streamlining the number. Given that he has not been to the Government with it I do not have a decision on it. That is the publicly announced position of the Minister.
Comment on this
I apologise in advance if I repeat points that were raised previously while I had to leave for a vote that was called in the Dáil. If I may return to Vote 34 and the failure to submit the European Social Fund claim, Mr. Gorman has explained the reason for that to the Chairman and Deputy Fleming. What was the effect of not submitting that money? What has not happened as a result of not having that funding of in excess of €14 million?
Comment on this
It has not affected the direct delivery of programmes or services but the effect it has had is that the receipt of that money to the benefit of the Exchequer has been delayed. That has been the direct impact of it.
Comment on this
Therefore, everything that was planned, for which such funding should have been used, has gone ahead.
Comment on this
It has gone ahead. It is a retrospective claim.
Comment on this
On the FÁS training budget, I refer to the labour force development subheads, can Mr. Gorman explain the rationale behind the reduction in the funding for the FÁS training integrated supports at this time when the numbers requiring those services has increased? Had the funding been reduced five, six or seven years ago, I could have understood why that happened but it was reduced in this climate. Was it related to a lack of satisfaction with the delivery of those supports or was there another reason? Was it simply a cutting exercise?
Comment on this
A decision was taken by the Minister that there was to be an important shift in emphasis reflecting the unemployment problem, that more resources were to be devoted to training of the unemployed. In terms of the levels of voted moneys that were being made, we leaned more heavily on the National Training Fund for additional funds for that area of training but the most significant shift was to bring the unemployed more into focus and to reduce the focus on those at work.
Comment on this
Under subhead C2 - the grants to industry - with which Deputy Fleming has dealt with in different detail, there was a significant drop in the grants to industry from the IDA in the period from 2008 to 2009. Are we supporting fewer companies as a result of that?
Comment on this
The moneys which go to the IDA for the purposes of these grants reflect two dynamics - historic demand and obligations due to companies that have already made investments, and moneys that are being made available to allow for new investments and new commitments to companies. The level of funding determination each year is both a factor of pipeline demand and headroom for new business. The figure reflects the market as it prevailed. No companies that were offering and ripe for assistance from the IDA have been turned away and no project has been refused, denied or not assisted. During 2009 it won 125 new investments and new companies investing in Ireland during 2009 were up 11% on 2008. Some 49% of investments in companies are in the research space and more than 4,500 jobs were created during that year in IDA companies with exports increasing to the value of €110 billion. Therefore, we have always been very careful, as had the Minister, to ensure that the IDA would be resourced to both meet obligations and avail of new business opportunities.
Comment on this
There have been less opportunities. That is the bottom line.
Comment on this
Yes. There are fewer projects in the pipeline for 2009 and, I presume, for 2010 than there was 2008.
Comment on this
There is a very strong pipeline of companies with which the IDA is negotiating. I cannot give the names and the details but it a very strong pipeline and the IDA is very encouraged. Investors are continuing to come here and existing multinationals are continuing to expand and invest in new areas.
We always have attrition which, unfortunately, is a natural part of the business. The year 2009 was very difficult because global foreign direct investment decreased overall by 30% and the scale of investments being made by companies was also smaller. We did not see, even globally, 1,000 or 2,000 job size investments that we might have seen in the past.
Comment on this
Moving on to Skillnets - I will deal with the overall problem and the investigation into it later - was the rationale for the reduction in the funding for Skillnets the same reason Mr. Gorman gave for FÁS, that the Department was concentrating on the unemployed? If Mr. Gorman is going to answer "Yes" to that, which he seems to be indicating by nodding his head, many industries need support. The FÁS budget for the previous area I dealt with was cut to concentrate on the unemployed and the same has happened in the case of the budget for Skillnets. The parallel in that respect is are we giving business less support and, as result, are more people likely to become unemployed?
Comment on this
The reality is it is a difficult call that must be made in the context of the wider Estimates choices that are made by the Government and the Minister. There is not as much money to go around as there was - we all know that. The focus has been to shift more into the unemployment space and it has meant that while we have asked Skillnets to do some training of the unemployed as a new initiative side by side with people who are at work to give them that interaction and experience, we have had to reduce the budget for Skillnets. It is still getting €16.5 million, which is substantial, but there is a very clear change in Government emphasis from training those at work to training people who are unemployed because of the pressures that exist.
Comment on this
When an evaluation is done and a decision like this is made, and I appreciate it is more of a political decision - I will deal with the evaluation of Skillnets in general later - what is done to ensure the balance is right and that jobs are not being lost as a result of a reduction in support in those two areas, Skillnets and the FÁS budget to which I referred?
Comment on this
It is a judgment call that is made. People who are at work have the opportunity of their companies' training them. The more educated one is, the more training one tends to get and the better one tends to do. The policy choice was very stark for the Government, when it was dealing with so many people who were outside the labour market altogether. For it the choice was straightforward and that was the decision we were given. Therefore, we proceeded on that basis.
Comment on this
The number of networks fell from 103 to 63 in the period from 2009 to 2010. That were 40 fewer but the funding amount between the two years only reduced by €100,000. How were 40 networks lost and only a saving of €100,000 made?
Comment on this
There was a considerable rationalisation and merging of networks behind those figures. There was not only a net reduction in overall levels of participation but an administrative merging of networks.
Comment on this
In terms of people and training places, what was the difference?
Comment on this
I can give the Deputy the figures in terms of training days or trainees.
Comment on this
The figures for trainees would be better.
Comment on this
In 2008, there were 57,863 trainees, in 2009, there were 41,610 and the number estimated for this year is 46,000. I believe we will get a small extra throughput this year.
Comment on this
We lost 16,000 trainees as a result of the reduction.
Comment on this
Then the Department managed to increase the number a little with a saving in funding of €100,000.
Comment on this
What kind of cost-benefit analysis was done on the outcomes of Skillnets by the Department? Of the 130,000 or more people trained in the past three years, does Mr. Gorman know how many of them are still in employment? Has the training they received been successful in that sense? Of the companies in the networks that participated in Skillnets in the past three years, how many of them have ceased trading, or are they all still trading?
Deputy Edward O'Keeffe took the Chair.
Comment on this
I do not have the number of people who are still at work and I do not have a list of those companies that were assisted which are still receiving training. Since 1999 when Skillnets was set up, more than 50,000 enterprises were supported as well as 300 networks and 240,000 employees. Some 59% of all of the training days delivered were on courses that received national framework of qualifications certification, so that has a value.
Some 95% of the companies supported were SMEs. In a survey of 6,000 companies in 2009 conducted by Skillnets but of which the Department got the benefit, 88% were of the view that the cost efficiency of the training provided was lower than they might have expected to otherwise pay, so that was positive; 93% would recommend becoming a member of a training network to other companies; 86% stated it allowed them avail of training they would not have had available to them otherwise; and 83% felt the training was better suited to their needs than other options available largely because of the flexibility and the fact that it was enterprise that was driving the nature of the training rather than a "We have a course, can you put someone on it?" type of approach.
The Skillnets model was also looked at by Forfás in the context of the work of the expert group on skill needs and has been regarded by it as a very positive, relevant and useful instrument. In addition, the EU considers the Skillnets model to be a very good, useful model and frequently arranges study visits to Ireland from other member states to see how Skillnets works and the value it delivers.
Very recently, as I stated, we have now asked Skillnets to include an element of unemployed persons to work and be trained side-by-side with persons in work because of the value that can add to an unemployed person.
Deputy Bernard Allen resumed the Chair.
Comment on this
I accept those are fairly good recommendations on how the programme is working, but does the Department propose to carry out any more detailed examination to see if it is genuinely assisting persons remaining in and upskilling within employment?
Comment on this
We do. We are reviewing and revisiting the mandate for Skillnets which expires on 31 December 2010. In the context of a decision having been made to renew that mandate, and in light of the findings of the Comptroller and Auditor General's report and the difficulties that have arisen, we are taking a very close look at Skillnets - its objectives, the board structure and, generally, its continued relevance beyond mere governance issues. It will be done by the Department of Education and Skills.
Comment on this
A few years ago Skillnets aimed to carry out monitoring, or what it called finance visits, to each network within a two-year cycle. Some 103 networks existed in 2009, but in the 2008-09 period, it only carried out a total of 16. In its comments to the Comptroller and Auditor General, Skillnets blamed the funding reduction on its inability to carry out those reviews. The funding reduction was obviously very significant - over €10 million between 2008 and 2009 - but Skillnets still only carried out 16 reviews in 2008. Before it ever suffered a funding reduction, Skillnets was nowhere near meeting its target of carrying out the reviews. Is the Department concerned by that?
Comment on this
Yes, we are. Skillnets has accepted that is not acceptable. When it talks about the impact of the funding reduction, it is not so much that it was left without the capacity to do these visits, in terms of losing staff or losing resources in that way. Its budget had been adjusted downwards a few times during that period and much reshaping and reprioritisation had to be done, and it had put this forward as the main reason for the failure to maintain a high level of compliance visits. Skillnets has now undertaken, as one part of the response to this latest report and to exhortations from ourselves, that it will do one visit per network each year and will be undertaking 62 visits this year as part of that.
Comment on this
Does the Department attribute Skillnets failure to do what it should have been doing all along, or what it had aimed to do, to the difficulties we have discovered later with Empower? Would that have been able to happen if Skillnets had carried out the visits?
Comment on this
It is a hard one to be absolutely definitive about, but certainly visits would have helped. The Empower situation was complicated, and there was a referral to the Garda fraud squad. As I understand it, that investigation is still under way. Certainly, more compliance visits would have been desirable. I do not know whether or not they would have totally prevented it, but it certainly would have helped.
Comment on this
Is there not a failure within the organisation in the sense that in the companies it visited in the 2008-09 period, Skillnets identified control weaknesses, particularly in the procurement procedures? What happened when Skillnets identified them? What was done about it? Did it not make Skillnets realise that it really needed to up its game in terms of getting out to the other networks if the small few it had investigated showed up these problems?
Comment on this
What Skillnets has done as a result of its own work, its own visits and, indeed, the reporting of these two cases, is tighten up its own procedures, which includes the compliance visits. It has tidied up and strengthened the wording of the funding agreements and the general conditions which it applies to the networks who are participating. It is also providing for additional monitoring of the expenditure and the actual income of the networks themselves. It is providing for unannounced visits by Skillnets staff to the actual training events themselves. It is tidying up the arrangements as regards bank accounts and it has put in place a new system to track matching income to specific training events. It has been moving along, but on these two cases, in one there was no financial loss and in the other there is a financial loss of approximately €53,000---
Comment on this
It is still unclear to me. That is a great many matters Skillnets stated it needs to change. Where was the fault-line in that Skillnets was not doing all of that up until it discovered these problems? Beside the budgetary excuse or reason Skillnets used, why was it not done? There has been no consequence for anybody in the organisation for the fact that it was not carried out. It was Skillnets's own aim. It was clear that it was something that was to be done. I assume it was the responsibility of someone or some group within the organisation to ensure it was done.
Comment on this
Skillnets has accepted that it should have been done as part of its oversight. It has accepted that in its response to the Comptroller and Auditor General.
Comment on this
Has Skillnets identified the failures within the organisation that stopped it happening so that it was not done?
Comment on this
Yes, through a combination of updating the framework agreements, greater inspections, greater clarity around procurement rules at the level of the networks, and taking evaluation roles away from the networks themselves and bringing them into the centre of Skillnets. It has taken on board significant changes as a result.
Comment on this
Has the Department encompassed all that Mr. Gorman told us there in a service level agreement with the organisation?
Comment on this
There is what is called a funding agreement in place with Skillnets which we have updated.
Comment on this
Skillnets has introduced these changes on foot of the contracts and arrangements-----
Comment on this
That is not the question. Is there a service level agreement between the Department and Skillnets?
Comment on this
There is, yes. That is now part of this review that we are doing in light of this and in the light of its mandate expiring on 31 December.
Comment on this
Perhaps I am slow, but I do not understand what Mr. Gorman is saying. Is the Department about to do it, has it done it or is there one in place?
Comment on this
We have one in place and we are updating it now - the Department of Education and Skills will update it - in the light of these experiences and the learning that has taken place.
Comment on this
Yes, that is the one. With that goes an actual service level agreement. The Mandate is the high-level piece.
Comment on this
I refer Mr. Gorman to the last paragraph of his opening statement. The first case that was identified by Skillnets, which I had not seen - it is probably my own fault - in the briefing document, was being dealt with since September 2008. Did this arise as a result of the 16 visits carried out in 2008? How did this case come to light? I am aware that the second case, from February 2009, arose as a result of an anonymous allegation.
Comment on this
The first case also arose on foot of such an allegation.
Comment on this
In respect of the first case, Skillnets had already identified that there was a matter which would require examination. It was already involved in investigations prior to the anonymous allegation being received.
Comment on this
Was that as a result of one of the 16 visits which were made that year? If not, how did the matter come to light?
Comment on this
I am not sure how Skillnets identified the fact that there might be something amiss.
Comment on this
It was the result of a visit and some contact with Skillnets.
Comment on this
Whether it was as a result of one of the 16 structured visits or a special visit, I do not know.
Comment on this
What I am trying to establish is the importance of the visits.
Comment on this
The Deputy is referring to the routine checks.
Comment on this
Yes, and whether such visits are able to bring matters such as those under discussion to light. Were any of the networks using Empower Training to deliver the course covered in the visits carried out in 2008 and 2009?
Comment on this
To my knowledge, yes. I do not have the full list but I can obtain it for the committee.
Comment on this
Surely any problems which existed should have been identified during these visits and it should not have taken an anonymous telephone call to lead to those problems been investigated and matters being referred to the Garda fraud squad.
Comment on this
I would have to check which networks in the client base of Empower Training were visited. A sophisticated manipulation of data and information was involved so what was going on was difficult to detect.
Comment on this
Yes. However, people are often obliged to deal with complicated and difficult matters.
Comment on this
Compliance visits would have been of assistance.
Comment on this
I am trying to ascertain whether such visits took place. Is Mr. Gorman in a position to obtain the relevant information in this regard because it would make a major difference?
Comment on this
I will try to discover which participants in the network were visited prior to the detection.
Comment on this
Yes, prior to the anonymous allegation which gave rise to the investigation.
Comment on this
Why is Mr. Gorman not in receipt of the information requested by Deputy Enright?
Comment on this
Surely Mr. Gorman has seen it.
Comment on this
I do not have the list of those that were visited.
Comment on this
Did the Department not examine the list when the complaint was received and it was realised a problem existed?
Comment on this
We examined the problems with the issue. However, we dealt with the issue of compliance visits at the level that they were not taking place on the scale and frequency which should have applied.
Comment on this
Is that the only way in which the Department dealt with the matter?
Comment on this
That is a fairly relaxed approach. In respect of the 24 courses that were investigated, it emerged that eight were not delivered and that a further eight were delivered to companies which were not members of the relevant network. Were those companies members of other networks? If not, how were the courses delivered to them?
Comment on this
I do not know if they were members of other networks. However, they were not eligible because they were not members of the network in respect of which funding was being provided for Empower to provide training.
Comment on this
Mr. Gorman said it was a fairly complicated scenario. How was that the case? Either the companies were members of the network or they were not. Surely the position is black and white and problems should have been identified when claims were submitted. I do not see where the complication arises in ascertaining whether a company is a member of a network.
Comment on this
The claims were being submitted but they were not based on fact. There were no records to show that the levels of attendance matched what was claimed.
Comment on this
Before we deal with attendances, I wish to resolve this matter in respect of companies which were not members of the network. If a claim was submitted in respect of a company that was not a member, the fact that it was not a member should have emerged when the company's name was checked against the list of members.
Comment on this
The contractual relationship is between Skillnets and the network. It is the latter's responsibility to deal with the training providers and the companies that are part of the network. Claims are submitted by the networks to Skillnets. Compliance visits may very well have highlighted the matter under discussion. However, these were not happening at that level.
Comment on this
So it was a very relaxed arrangement.
Comment on this
It would have been a very loose arrangement.
Comment on this
Yes, there would have been a lack of checking at network level.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Gorman know if the companies in question were members of other networks?
Comment on this
Can he check the position in that regard?
Comment on this
With regard to the second instance, it is stated that in four cases there was insufficient evidence that all trainees claimed for attended. There are three levels - four if one includes the Department - in operation here, namely, Skillnets, the networks and Empower Training. It is clear that there was a real problem with the networks because they were not checking what was going on.
Comment on this
Has that problem been addressed in order that there will not be a recurrence of the type of behaviour under discussion?
Comment on this
It has been addressed by Skillnets. In some instances, ticks rather than signatures were provided. This did not really prove-----
Comment on this
So a tick was placed after a person's name on the roll.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Gorman of the view that there was a level of collusion between Empower Training and particular networks in this regard or was the system just too loose?
Comment on this
No. The evidence - from the audit which Skillnets carried out and the information we have been able to garner - suggests there was no element of collusion between the networks and Empower Training. There was a lack of oversight.
Comment on this
Mr. Gorman referred to courses being needs-led rather than provider-led. The information provided and some of the comments that have been made would seem to indicate that the courses were, in many instances, provider-led rather than being informed by the needs of the relevant industry. What is Mr. Gorman's opinion on that matter, particularly in the context of Empower Training?
Comment on this
In the first instance, the model provides for a demand-led approach whereby companies or sectors come together with proposals in respect of training. I am aware that the company in question was extremely active in selling its wares to and indicating what it could do for other companies. It also encouraged such companies to use the Skillnets model as a way of effectively generating business here.
Comment on this
FÁS is also carrying out an audit in respect of Empower Training. Is there a timescale for the completion of this audit?
Comment on this
I am informed that it should be completed in the coming weeks.
Comment on this
On 18 February last - prior to my becoming a member - the committee met representatives from FÁS. While the cost to the taxpayer has been extremely different, the problems which arose in respect of Skillnets - infrequent monitoring, a failure to record outputs and the absence of an impartial evaluation of the objectives - are exactly the same as those which arose in the case of FÁS. I am concerned with regard to whether the solutions which have been put forward will actually work. It seems that this matter has been left to Skillnets and it has been stated that the latter recognises that there is a problem. I do not know whether those who are in place at Skillnets can introduce the changes required in order to rectify that problem. We would certainly be obliged to ask questions in that regard.
Comment on this
There is also the fact that FÁS is due to issue the results of its audit in a few weeks. Officials from FÁS are due to come before the committee in two weeks. It would be extremely helpful if the audit in question could be completed before that date rather than it again being stated at our meeting two weeks hence that the audit is still in train. Perhaps Mr. Gorman could ensure that the audit will be completed and copies of it presented to the committee before the meeting to which I refer.
Comment on this
I will discuss that matter with FÁS. The audit in question is part of the latter's internal audit process. I will raise the matter with the director general of FÁS.
Comment on this
We established earlier that €13 million in EU co-funding has been obtained and that questions arise in respect of a small element of this. What is the total amount of co-funding the Department receives from the European Union? Are there any other cases where European Union funding has been withheld on foot of audit concerns?
Comment on this
Yes, there have been a number of instances where we have encountered difficulties in respect of European funding. We have the €13.6 million claim that we are referring to, which is deferred. It has not been refused but deferred. For the period 2000-06 in the employment and human resources development operational programme, we have submitted a claim to the Commission for €407 million for FÁS. I cannot say what we will get for that.
The final claim, which is already gone to the Commission for that period, internally has an unqualified audit opinion from the national ESF auditing authority, which is the best rating we can get and, therefore, we are not anticipating any loss to the Exchequer. There were earlier cases where we lost money under an earlier round. We took a case to the European Court of Justice where we believed that the Commission was wrong in its interpretation of some of the rules regarding particularly how we converted at that time from ECUs to punts. We lost the case and the Commission eventually withheld €15.6 million. This was in the 1994-99 round of ESF funding. The Commission contested our claim. It accepted there was no fraud, everything was done in terms of delivery of training, etc., but because of the methodology used by the Department in converting punts to ECUs, we lost €15.6 million overall in that claim. That was the previous round.
There was a €12.75 million employment community initiative case where an audit established overpayments to Ireland, which again, was contested and we had to concede the bulk of that money to the Commission.
Comment on this
It was the 1994-99 round and it was the same point on which we had challenged in the court, which was the audit trail and the basis of conversion.
Comment on this
There was a different programme known as INTERREG. There was a maritime case where €1 million was withheld under the maritime community initiative in the 1994-99 period and we managed in the context of the outcome of that to reduce the hit to €652,000. There have been significant losses of funds to the Commission going back to the 1994-99 round. We believe we will get €13.6 million but it is delayed.
Comment on this
I welcome Mr. Gorman and his colleagues. How much have we lost in EU funding for various reasons?
Comment on this
A sum of €15.6 million in the court case. There was €12.75 million withheld under an employment community initiative case.
Comment on this
That is more than €28 million.
Comment on this
Then there was approximately €600,000 in the INTERREG maritime case.
Comment on this
That is €29 million. How did the system work between 2000 and 2006? Mr. Gorman said the Department has a claim in for €407 million.
Comment on this
The system works on the basis that the EU funds are provided on a retrospective basis. Claims go in periodically. A final claim goes in at the end of the period for any moneys outstanding under the programme and that has to be accompanied by a certificate from what is known as the ESF financial control unit, which is an audit unit now located in the Department of Education and Skills. They have to certify for the Commission - they act as agents for the Commission - that the claim is robust and that there are no issues.
Comment on this
Is €407 million the total claim under ESF funding for that round?
Comment on this
It is the total allocation of ESF funding for that round.
Comment on this
Is it normal that the Department would claim back over a ten-year period? The round started in 2000. Have we received any of the €407 million yet?
Comment on this
There are two rounds: 1994-97 and 2000-06. We would have received instalments of the €407 million over the years. We are now looking for full and final settlement of the moneys due to Ireland.
Comment on this
How much has the Department received?
Comment on this
So Mr. Gorman does not know how much the EU owes the State.
Comment on this
I do not know what the net figure is off the top of my head. I will have to check that.
Comment on this
This is going back four years.
Comment on this
That is not unusual. The way the funding rounds work is that they have a funding round period for a number of years.
Comment on this
However, Mr. Gorman cannot tell us how much the Commission owes us for a programme that finished in 2006.
Comment on this
Is that the total amount for all ESF funding programmes during that round?
Comment on this
No, that is for the human resources development operational programme. Other ESF moneys could be due.
Comment on this
I do not have that. I am dealing with the FÁS-related programme but I can get the full profile.
Comment on this
Are other ESF moneys due to the Department for training?
Comment on this
No. I will give the Chairman a profile of the full breakdown.
Comment on this
I refer to the issue of partnership funds which was mentioned earlier. Mr. Gorman said that the Department had not contributed to the funds we have discussed previously but it had contributed money to the ICTU. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Yes, the budget line in the Estimate goes to the ICTU and it disburses it then.
Comment on this
What is the purpose of that allocation?
Comment on this
The purpose is to provide for the training, education and development of primarily trade union officials and administrators in the trade union movement.
Comment on this
How much is that on an annual basis?
Comment on this
Just over €1 million. The maximum intervention rate the State pays is 80% of the cost of the training and development incurred by the ICTU and its constituent parts. Earlier I said that the average intervention rate on that in recent times has been significantly less than 80%. It was 52% one year, approximately 30% last year and we reckon it will be 39% this year.
Comment on this
I do not follow what Mr. Gorman is saying. Will he explain it?
Comment on this
We do not pay their full costs. The money is made available as a contribution towards the cost of training but there is a set ceiling of 80% and we have been coming in significantly below that.
Comment on this
What are the arrangements for the oversight of that money?
Comment on this
Audited accounts are provided to the Department. Claims are submitted quarterly in arrears and full audited accounts are submitted by the ICTU to the Department to confirm those figures.
Comment on this
Has the Department any concerns about that?
Comment on this
No, we have no concerns. This is a very long-standing arrangement. It goes back 40 years at least.
Comment on this
I refer to the Skillnets company. Was it set up in 1999?
Comment on this
Is it correct that total funding since it was set up is €114 million?
Comment on this
It would appear that between 1999 and 2006 this fund increased twenty-seven fold which is faster than the FÁS CDP fund grew and we all know the issues relating to that. This seems to be CDP mark II in many ways, as far as I can see. How many agencies with responsibility for providing training to people who were in employment were in the Department at the time the decision was taken to set up Skillnets?
Comment on this
At the time FÁS would have been the main agency providing training. Enterprise Ireland would have provided some assistance to companies as part of their management development for management training. IDA would have done a small amount with some of its client companies. Skillnets came on board in 1999.
Comment on this
Would Shannon Development have done the training?
Comment on this
It would have largely funded its resources from its property portfolio.
Comment on this
It would have done training with employees.
Comment on this
It would have assisted some companies but very few.
Comment on this
What about the county enterprise boards?
Comment on this
They would do it with micro-enterprises which have fewer than ten employees.
Comment on this
There were other EU funded initiatives.
Comment on this
Yes, there were. FÁS was a major beneficiary of some of the other EU funding initiatives.
Comment on this
At the time the decision was taken to set up Skillnets six or seven other agencies in the Department had responsibility for training people in employment. Why was it decided to set up a new quango?
Comment on this
Can the Secretary General explain the thinking behind that? It is hard to understand.
Comment on this
The policy decision was taken but the context for it was a 1997 White Paper on human resource development which recommended doing a pilot programme of this nature. In 2000 there was a renewed commitment from the social partners in the context of Partnership 2000 to continue this type of approach. It was a policy decision. Part of the consideration was that this would be very much enterprise driven and because of the nature of the networks and the participation by companies it would provide a relevant, close to business and market type training.
Comment on this
It is very difficult to understand from the outside why a new agency was required given that ample provision seems to have been made through FÁS and all the other agencies to provide training. Why was a new agency needed?
Comment on this
The thinking was to try a more enterprise-led approach using the Skillnets network which involved the participation of companies.
Comment on this
Would it be true to say Skillnets was a creature of IBEC?
Comment on this
No, it had IBEC representation on its board. IBEC would have pushed for and encouraged this type of support to be made available for training for people in enterprises. There is no question about that. The decision was taken to do this. I do not know if I would call it a creature of IBEC. ICTU and other interests were also represented on the board.
Comment on this
We will come to that in a moment. I am trying to understand why on earth a new agency was set up. Given that a decision was taken somewhere to set it up, why was it set up as a limited liability company rather than a State agency?
Comment on this
The thinking at the time was to try to reduce the complexities of having to legislate for new State bodies. It was seen as an efficient way of getting money to the companies quickly and it could be done without the need to introduce new primary legislation. The source of the funding is the National Training Fund which the Minister, with the approval of the Minister for Finance, has authority to allocate to training initiatives. At the time it was seen as a useful and efficient way of moving into an enterprise-led training space.
Comment on this
Did that mean it was not subject to the normal scrutiny to which State agencies are subject?
Comment on this
The National Training Fund is subject to scrutiny by the Comptroller and Auditor General. In that sense it was not placed outside the scrutiny obligation.
Comment on this
Presumably it was, as a limited liability company.