We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Vote 34 - Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment

Contributions 448–674 of 674. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Mr. Seán Gorman

It was audited by the Comptroller and Auditor General.

Comment on this

It was not audited by the Comptroller and Auditor General.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

My apologies. It was audited by the National Training Fund.

Comment on this

You said Skillnets was audited by Comptroller and Auditor General. It is not.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Can I correct that? The allocations that we make from the National Training Fund-----

Comment on this

That is not what I asked. I said Skillnets was not subject to the normal scrutiny because it was a limited liability company. Is that the case?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Its accounts would be audited independently by its auditors. Its annual returns are filed with the Companies Registration Office, its financial reporting and annual reports and accounts are sent to us and we have a member on the board.

Comment on this

Who is that person?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

He is now an assistant principal officer in the Department of Education and Skills, Mr. John McDermott.

Comment on this

How long has he been on the board?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

For about three years.

Comment on this

Can Mr. Gorman outline the structure of Skillnets in terms of the personnel infrastructure in place? I understand there were some 130 networks. What support staff were involved in them?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Skillnets had approximately 23 staff overseeing the networks. Skillnets contracted with the networks who in turn bought the training provision directly into the network. The numbers engaged in each of the networks, in terms of oversight, would have varied. I do not have a detailed breakdown of the actual numbers involved. There was a cap on administration. There would have been one manager in each network.

Comment on this

In each of the 130 networks?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes.

Comment on this

What kind of support staff would a manager have had?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

I do not have figures for the support staff.

Comment on this

Why does the Secretary General not have figures for the support staff? It is one of three items under discussion today. He should be in a position to provide details to us on the structure of Skillnets.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

A provision was allowed for administrative support but I do not have details on the staff.

Comment on this

Mr. Gorman does not know anything about the numbers of people employed by Skillnets.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

I know how many were directly employed by Skillnets and the network manager - each network had a manager - but I do not know the numbers employed beyond that.

Comment on this

Mr. Gorman told us there are 23 people overseeing this body and there are 130 managers.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

There would be fewer now; the number has been reduced to about 60.

Comment on this

There were 130 managers.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Gorman have any idea how many other staff there were?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

No, but very few per network. I would not be able to tell the Deputy the numbers now. I can get the figures.

Comment on this

It would be conservative to say that there would be one support staff member with each manager-----

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes, one can assume that.

Comment on this

-----which means that all of the networks comprised 260 staff and 23 oversight people. Some 283 staff were employed in this organisation at a minimum. Is that the case?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

The networks would have employed the managers. There would have been a minimum of one manager per network employed, plus the Skillnets oversight staff.

Comment on this

What is the total staff cost for the organisation?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

It is approximately one fifth of the total overhead for Skillnets. I do not have a cash figure for it.

Comment on this

Is the Secretary General saying that approximately €20 million out of the €114 million has gone on staff? Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

It could have. I will have to check it out as I do not have the staff cost percentages.

Comment on this

Why does the Secretary General not have those details?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

I have focused on the problems of the two companies, in terms of Sales Skillnet and Empower Skillnet, as the major problem or issue here.

Comment on this

My questions are about the organisation, which is the subject of this meeting. My questions are basic questions, such as staff numbers and costs and the Secretary General should be able to provide those details.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

I can give the Deputy the staff numbers, but will have to get the costs for her.

Comment on this

In 2008 and 2009 the costs were €2.6 million and €2.7 million, respectively. Are these the figures Deputy Shortall requires?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

The administration cost of €2.6 million would have included staff, but I do not know exactly how much of that was directly for staff.

Comment on this

It is difficult to continue with this meeting when the witnesses are so ill-prepared. These are basic questions about the Department's oversight of significant amounts of public money and it is impossible to do our business today. This is not the first time this has happened. We have had serious difficulties dealing with the Department throughout the FÁS and Community Development Programme, CDP, sagas, which are still unfinished business. It is highly unsatisfactory that the Secretary General has come to this meeting so ill-prepared despite having had notice of the meeting for some time.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

I have invested significant time in this and apologise for not having the particular information the Deputy requires.

Comment on this

We will have to come back to this again, Chairman.

Comment on this

May I ask the Department of Finance -----

Comment on this

Sorry, Deputy Shortall has not completed her questions.

Comment on this

Can Mr. Gorman tell us what arrangements have been put in place within the Department for the oversight of the €114 million being invested in yet another training scheme?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

First, we have a formal mandate and funding agreement in place with Skillnets. That requires them to put in place standard accounting and financial control systems through which they must account to the Department for all moneys. They report to us regularly on finance and operational targets. At least two progress reports are required annually and quarterly financial reporting on income and expenditure, personal requirements and bank reconciliation statements. We also require them to ensure that procedures are in place with regard to ensuring that moneys are only paid out to beneficiaries based on binding contracts and so on. We also have a member on the board of Skillnets who participates in its oversight and governance.

Comment on this

I want to move on to the make-up of the board of Skillnets, which seems to parallel that of FÁS over the past decade. We are aware that the board has 14 members, seven of whom are IBEC representatives. Others represent the CIF, ISME and so on and there are a few social partner representatives. How is the board appointed and what is its term of office?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

The board is appointed by the Minister on the basis of nominations from the representative organisations and three of the members are appointed directly by the Minister. The members are selected from nominations to the Minister.

Comment on this

Who makes the nominations to the Minister?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

The participating organisations, including IBEC and ICTU.

Comment on this

Basically, the company itself makes the nominations.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes. They submit names to the Minister.

Comment on this

So, three people are also appointed by the Minister.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes, including one official.

Comment on this

Who are those three people?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

The three people appointed by the Minister are: John McDermott, an assistant principal in the Department of Education and Skills, Henry Murdoch, a ministerial nominee and Terry Hobdell a ministerial nominee from a company called Irish Fencing and Railings Limited.

Comment on this

What are the arrangements for remuneration for board members?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

I am sorry, but I do not have details of their remuneration with me.

Comment on this

Can the Secretary General get those details for us please?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

I will.

Comment on this

I have a question with regard to potential conflicts of interest on the board. In the case of the CDP we saw that large amounts of public moneys that were being dispersed were being dispersed to organisations that were closely associated with board members within FÁS. What safeguards has the Department in place, if any, to ensure that board members do not benefit, either personally or through their companies, from decisions relating to spending?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Skillnets has in place a procedure which requires board members who are involved in the determination of eligible applications for assistance to declare in writing in advance any potential conflict of interest for each meeting they attend. This information must be provided in writing to the company secretary. The members of the board of directors are also required, under the arrangements with Skillnets, to declare any direct or indirect interests they might have and the company secretary records all such declarations.

Comment on this

On a related matter -----

Comment on this

Sorry to interrupt, but I have some figures on remuneration to board members. The remuneration ranges from €9,400 for the chairman down to €6,300 for each board member. This information is in the Skillnets Ltd. report and financial statements. A total of €31,500 was paid by way of payments to the directors and out of pocket expenses came to €10,100.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

I apologise for not having that information.

Comment on this

The Chairman certainly has more information than Mr. Gorman.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Our Chairman is very efficient.

Comment on this

I want to ask about a related matter in respect of Chambers Ireland. Recently I submitted a parliamentary question to the Minister for Finance with regard to a sanctioned write-off, by way of legal agreement, of more than half of a sum of €630,000 owed by Chambers Ireland under the EQUAL programme of the European Union. How did that decision come about and how was it that the Minister for Finance wrote off approximately €320,000 owed by Chambers Ireland?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

At the time that issue arose Chambers Ireland was experiencing some financial difficulty. We considered whether we should take it to the courts to pursue those moneys, but the legal advice was we would be unlikely to win the court case. We balanced that advice with the risk of costs being awarded against us if we lost the case and then put a proposal to the Department of Finance that the prudent thing to do was to write off those moneys. We got sanction to do that.

Comment on this

It is hard to understand how the Department could reach the conclusion that was the prudent thing to do. It was €320,000 of public money.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

The legal advice suggested we would be unlikely to win the case, and the legal costs would have been substantial.

Comment on this

Why? Why was the Department unlikely to win or why was that advice given? What was the basis of the advice?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

It was on the basis that the arrangements that were put in place with Chambers Ireland and the Department at the time were insufficiently watertight and could have allowed Chambers Ireland to win the case.

Comment on this

Will Mr. Gorman provide us with a separate note on that issue as I would like to get more detail of it?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

I will.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I apologise for not being here earlier, but I had to attend a function. The county enterprise boards support 1,000 enterprises. They are out of date, being more than 30 years in existence. Has any cost analysis of the county enterprise boards been undertaken? Should they be restructured? Is the Department satisfied with their work to date?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Any decisions to restructure them are a matter for the Minister but he is on record as saying that he is well advanced in a process of examining the county enterprise board structure. He is of the view and the Department is also of the view that they provide a valuable local support to micro-enterprises. The Minister is examining their structure and the sheer number of them to decide if they can be streamlined. He is finalising proposals for consideration by the Government.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

The Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation is the lead Department in the World Trade Organisation negotiations. I note a report issued today by the EU Court of Auditors in Luxembourg about the sugar beet industry. The WTO negotiations were begun in Cancun, Mexico, in 2001. Reading yesterday's report, it seems Ireland was misled by the European Union as a result of the decision of the WTO which at the time was seen by Ireland as being very serious for our sugar beet industry which was a significant employer in four towns and important to growers and industries such as the service industry. This has now been lost. We are informed by the EU Court of Auditors today that it was the wrong decision. Will the Secretary General describe the Department's role? Arising from the WTO decisions, the European Commission took the decision to close an Irish industry because it was not competitive, highly subsidised and was a threat to imports of sugar.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

That matter is being handled by the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food as the lead Department.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I do not wish to argue with the Secretary General. His Department has responsibility for trade matters and this was a trade issue which then went to the Commission. What happened between 2001 and when the decision was taken by the Commission to close the factories? Where does the Department fit in that chronology? It was the lead Department in this case.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

We co-ordinated the attendance at the World Trade Organisation but the lead Department on the sugar beet policy was taken by the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food. I will have to study that report which was issued today and come back to the committee. I am not in a position to comment on the report as I have not read it.

Comment on this
Mr. John Buckley

I refer the Deputy to a section in the annual report of the Comptroller and Auditor General on sugar restructuring on which, presumably, the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food will be in a position to answer further questions upon when it appears before the committee.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

This is a trade issue and the lead Department for trade issues is the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation. The backup information had to come from that Department before it reached the Commission.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

I will study the report and come back to the committee.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Will the Secretary General report back to the committee?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes, I will provide a written report to the Chairman.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

It is a most serious matter that the European Court of Auditors would say that it was provided with the wrong information. Ireland is very closely scrutinised by the European Court of Auditors and by the court officials. We are one of the leading countries for overpayments or underpayments. We do our business very well.

Comment on this

I am inquiring about the name of a company which had defaulted.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Is it in order for me to name the company?

Comment on this

Yes, under absolute privilege.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

The company is Clover Meats Waterford and the amount involved was €1.9 million.

Comment on this

What elements of the McCarthy report have been implemented in the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

The Minister is close to finalising his proposals to Government on the restructuring of the county enterprise boards. We have also taken over responsibility from the Department of Education and Skills for the PRTLI funding as part of streamlining the arrangements for the single point of delivery for science and research and development policy and funding. Apart from structural changes, we have significantly reduced numbers and pay bills as a result of changes, rationalisation and reductions in general. The pay bill in the Department and its agencies has been reduced by more than €6 million, which is €5 million in the Department in 2010 compared with 2009. This is due to rationalisations, restructuring and approximately €2 million as a result of the incentivised scheme for early retirement, ISER. Considerable work continues in an examination of the area of how the enterprise supports are delivered. The McCarthy report made very wide recommendations about consolidating a range of agencies such as Enterprise Ireland, IDA Ireland, Údarás na Gaeltachta and the Irish Film Board. These are being examined and a decision will be made on the basis of whatever policy the Minister decides. One of the recommendations was the rationalisation of Forfás and its absorption into the Department. The Minister has decided this should not happen because he wants to keep Forfás as a separate policy advisory entity with its own board. In his view, this is the best position for Forfás.

The Department is examining the relocation of a number of the industrial relations institutions into a single location, including the Labour Court, the Labour Relations Commission and the rights service. The Minister of State, Deputy Dara Calleary, is leading an exercise on improvements in streamlining shared services and efficiencies by means of co-location of those agencies. Recommendations were made for a merging of the Health and Safety Authority and the National Employment Rights Authority into one inspectorate. We are looking for more co-operation between those agencies. They are two very different types of agency serving very different client bases with requirements for very different types of expertise. Most of the employees in the health and safety area are chemistry graduates and engineers while the staff in NERA who inspect employment rights tend to be general civil servants who are trained specifically for enforcement of the Acts in question. The Competition Authority will be merged with the National Consumer Agency and the enabling Bill will be ready shortly. This was a recommendation of the McCarthy report.

Comment on this

Did the Department acquire staff in the process, for instance, when PRTLI transferred to the Department from the Department of Education and Skills?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

One head of staff. It did not have a big resource.

Comment on this

This agency is now being administered by the Department.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes.

Comment on this

The Registrar of Friendly Societies used to be responsible for regulation of the credit unions. What is the position in respect of that agency?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

This was one of the recommendations of the McCarthy report but the Department had already merged the position of head of the Companies Registration Office, CRO, with the Registrar of Friendly Societies which is an office with two or three people. It is not a big office.

Comment on this

What is its function now?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

It receives reports from the trade unions and such organisations that are not limited companies. Such companies send in their returns to the Registrar of Friendly Societies. Its work parallels the work of the CRO somewhat. The two offices are the responsibility of the same public official in the same building so there is very little value in doing any more merging.

Comment on this

Let me ask Ms Stapleton from the Department of Finance a question. Training is an important issue as significant amounts of money go through various training organisations under the aegis of the Department. We have just had a discussion on Skillnets. Is the Department of Finance satisfied that we are getting value for money? Is it satisfied with the quality of administration of these moneys?

Comment on this
Ms Áine Stapleton

I will not go into detail on Skillnets. The Department looks at certain requirements as part of its general oversight of programmes and schemes of this nature. It examines the delivery mechanisms and outputs of training programmes. I will ask my colleague, Ms McGuckin, to talk about the enterprise area from the perspective of the sectoral policy division.

Comment on this

Before Ms McGuckin comes in, I would like to ask whether the Department is satisfied with the lapses we traced earlier. Is the Department of Finance engaging with the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation on tightening the ship?

Comment on this
Ms Áine Stapleton

Clearly, we are always concerned when such issues come to light. The Department generally puts a framework in place from the perspective of its governance role. The framework sets out the corporate governance requirements of the agency sector, for example, supplemented by guidelines in appropriate areas. We always wish to ensure appropriate arrangements are in place in the parent Department and agencies to ensure there is compliance.

Comment on this

That is a general statement of policy which I am sure the Department of Finance implements. I am asking whether it is satisfied with the manner in which these arrangements are operating in the specific case of the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation.

Comment on this
Ms Áine Stapleton

The Accounting Officer present at the meeting has given us assurances about the steps the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation has taken to communicate with the CEO of the organisation concerned on the mandate and service level agreements in place. We have been assured that new procedures will be put in place to ensure some of the incidents that occurred in this instance will not be repeated.

Comment on this

Is the Department of Finance involved in the oversight or preparation of these procedures?

Comment on this
Ms Áine Stapleton

Regarding direct communication between the Accounting Officer and the CEO of Skillnets, the Department of Finance would not be involved in that individual set of guidelines. Anything done in this area would be within the broader framework of the accounting responsibilities of the State agency and ensure it was operating within the code of practice.

Comment on this

I am not criticising the total training throughput because I appreciate the investment in training and upskilling is very important. The Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation has a very important role to play in that regard. Is the Department of Finance actively concerned about the difficulties we have experienced with FÁS and Skillnets and the matters about which Deputies Enright and Shortall asked? Has it recently been actively involved with what has been highlighted in the general training area?

Comment on this
Ms Áine Stapleton

The Department always takes account of the effectiveness of the corporate governance arrangements in place in organisations engaged in the delivery of training programmes. At a more general level, it also ensures the arrangements are in place to deliver on accountability. That matter is always under review in the Department. We certainly take on board the issues presented today.

Comment on this

Ms Stapleton is still answering with generalities in respect of the ideal framework she would like to see in place. I am asking whether the Department of Finance has been seized of the issue since all of this erupted in the public domain.

Comment on this
Ms Áine Stapleton

When individual instances come to light, the appropriate role of the Department of Finance is to ensure the appropriate framework is in place. We see it as a matter in the first instance for the Accounting Officer, the CEO and the chairman of the board of the agency involved to address operational issues that arise in individual programmes. Of course, these issues would be of concern and feed into the broad policy discussion within the Department.

Comment on this

What did Ms McGuckin wish to say?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

I do not disagree with anything Ms Stapleton has said on the subject.

Comment on this

I did not expect Ms McGuckin to do so. Did she want to add anything?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

Not really, no. Unfortunately or fortunately, we have a role to play and that framework role has been set out. We set the broad policy parameters. Obviously, it is up to the parent Department and the CEO of Skillnets, in this case, to adhere to the policies, procedures and rules in place. It would not be possible, given the plethora of organisations for which we are responsible and which form this Vote alone, for us to go down the road of engaging in oversight on a day-to-day basis. Certainly, the issues that have been raised with regard to Skillnets and FÁS raise concerns for us. We will redouble our efforts to ensure the procedures and policy rules are in place.

Comment on this

They raise concerns for the Department of Finance. I am trying to find out what activities happened between the Departments of Finance and Enterprise, Trade and Innovation when those concerns were raised. Was there direct contact with FÁS? What exactly did the Department of Finance do once-----

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

No.

Comment on this

I accept that the Department cannot oversee everything at a micro level.

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

Yes.

Comment on this

I am trying to find out what the Department did when it erupted in the public domain that there were questions about value for money in terms of the training budget. When it emerged that there was waste and perhaps worse in some cases - questions have been raised today in respect of Skillnets - what proactive measures did the Department take, other than to assure the committee that there was a framework in place and that it was concerned?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

Obviously, if there was a need to look further at the procedures or the framework, we would actually do this. We are aware that issues arose on the travel side, for example. We would have taken action in that area in the context of FÁS. The rules on the procurement side are very clear. There are plenty of guidelines available to organisations. I am satisfied that the procurement rules, as set out by the Department of Finance, are clear and explicit. It is up to the CEO charged with running the organisation-----

Comment on this

They were ignored.

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

I am satisfied-----

Comment on this

Is that not the case?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

Can I finish?

Comment on this

No, I am saying they were ignored by Skillnets. The Department did not police its guidelines.

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

It is not the job of the Department of Finance to police the guidelines on a day-to-day basis. Enough procedures and structures are in place to do this.

Comment on this

They just do not work.

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

I am not taking-----

Comment on this

What is Ms McGuckin saying about oversight of misspending, wasteful spending or worse? Whose task is it? Is it the task of this committee in direct exchanges with the relevant Accounting Officer? Is the Department of Finance stating "once we are satisfied we have a sound framework in place, even if it does not operate, we do not have time to get involved"? Is that what Ms McGuckin is saying to the Chairman?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

I am saying guidelines are in place and the Accounting Officers in the particular Department and its respective agencies are required to adhere to them.

Comment on this

What happens in the event of non-adherence?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

Obviously, the situation arises where the Comptroller and Auditor General raises issues. If there is a need to do so, we can discuss it with the Accounting Officer in the particular Department.

Comment on this

Was that done in this case?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

No, we did not do so formally in this particular case but we would have had discussions informally with the Department.

Comment on this

Is it not reasonable for us to expect it to have been done in this case?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

Perhaps.

Comment on this

I am sure Deputy Rabbitte remembers his time as a Minister. I recall that each year one would have to justify one's budget for the forthcoming year. I visited the Department of Finance and had to go through, line by line, the areas for which I was responsible and I was put through hoops in doing so. While in discussion with the then Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment, did the Department of Finance at any time question closely the operation of Skillnets, FÁS and the training programmes?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

On a day-to-day basis, what we look at, certainly on my side of the house, is the actual allocation. Most of our discussions on Skillnets, if there were any out of a very large vote, would be on decisions they might make on the allocation itself. We do not get involved in the operational policy of Skillnets. That is quite clearly the case.

Comment on this

I have a final question for Mr. Gorman. On Skillnets and the FÁS competency development programmes, Deputy Shortall has expressed dissatisfaction with the information provided today and the committee cannot close on this matter at this meeting. It strikes me that having spent considerable time discussing FÁS, the committee is now spending considerable time discussing Skillnets. That the Department lost control of FÁS was unfortunate but then to lose control of what was taking place in Skillnets indicates either carelessness or poor governance. Is the Department fit for purpose in terms of controlling vast budgets?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

It is not a question of losing control of Skillnets. What is involved here is a small amount of €53,000. There were gaps in how the procedures were followed and implemented and there was a need for them to be improved. We learned that on the basis of this experience. It is not so much a case of losing control but rather a case of tightening in the light of what we have learned. Skillnets has tightened and the Department of Education and Skills is tightening again the agreements we have with Skillnets. The amount of money at issue is relatively small.

Comment on this

While the amount of money may be small, the consequences are serious for those participants in the training programme who suffered because of a lack of certification and so forth.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes, there were big issues there. In the case of Skillnets, however, certification was not an issue. The look-backs that have been taking place are validating and confirming issues of certification.

Comment on this

The Secretary General states there are no questions with certification. What about Waterford?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

That aspect has to be-----

Comment on this

That was a certification issue, was it not? The Secretary General stated there were no questions of certification.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

On the general issue of certification, which is being looked at by Skillnets, I have been assured, as of last night, that there is not a widespread problem of certification.

Comment on this

The company involved was issuing false certificates from the Waterford Institute of Technology. Mr. Gorman stated there were no questions of certification. How many trainees were issued with false certificates?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

I do not have that number.

Comment on this

It is about time we had it. We should invite the chief executive officer of Skillnets before the committee because we are not being given enough information.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Part of the issue is the distance between where we sit and where the delivery on the ground sits. That is the gap.

Comment on this

Perhaps we will bridge that gap by asking the chief executive officer of Skillnets to appear before us because we are not getting the information we seek. This is the second time the committee has expressed concern that Departments are not taking this committee seriously. We had a similar episode with the Department of Finance last week. As has been stated, this meeting has been under way for three hours and we are not getting the information we seek. We have to bridge the gap, as Mr. Gorman says, between his Department and Skillnets by getting the chief executive officer of Skillnets before the committee.

Comment on this

On the question of accountability, how on earth can the Department of Finance oversee this kind of model in which a limited liability company is entirely funded from State resources? What other examples of that model do we have? Is it not quite an unusual model? How can one have adequate oversight of such a company?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

Does the Deputy want me to discuss the delivery model of Skillnets? The delivery model of Skillnets, as has been decided, is obviously a policy matter. On the particular matter of the-----

Comment on this

No, I am asking about the Department's oversight.

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

The oversight role rests, in the first instance, with the line Department. The chief executive officer also has a role. The oversight rests with the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation.

Comment on this

Given that the ultimate oversight role rests in the Department of Finance, are there not real difficulties with having this type of model in which a limited liability company is in receipt of large sums of public money?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

What this has raised is the full total of €54,000. The net loss of €54,000 in this case-----

Comment on this

I am not talking about that. I am talking about the €114 million that has been paid to the company over the past 11 or 12 years. How can one have adequate oversight of a model in which a limited liability company is entirely funded from the public purse? Are there other similar models where limited liability companies are entirely funded from the public purse?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

I am not aware of any such company on my side. In terms of the €114 million, this is a particular type of model which, as far as I know, has worked quite well up to now. The report has thrown up issues and irregularities and a net loss of €54,000.

Comment on this

With all due respects, how does Ms McGuckin know that? How can she pass judgment on the matter?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

The onus is either value for money studies or the Comptroller and Auditor General's oversight. Our response to that depends on the Comptroller and Auditor General's work in that area.

Comment on this

The Comptroller and Auditor General does not audit Skillnets.

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

By extension, if one likes. This is why the matter has come up in the context of the look-back on the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation's Vote.

Comment on this

Again, as the Department with ultimate oversight responsibilities, is there not something very strange about the fact that-----

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

May I stop Deputy Shortall there?

Comment on this

The Member is speaking.

Comment on this

Is there not something very strange about the fact that at the height of the boom, some €27 million per annum was being channelled into a limited liability, essentially private company to provide training for employees who were in employment and that this was done at a time when business generally was doing extraordinarily well and there was no reason it could not fund its own training requirements? It is very strange that such large sums of public money were being channelled into private businesses in such an unusual model and with little or no accountability. Are there concerns in the Department about this model and about the fact that so much public money has been channelled through it over the past 12 years?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

The decision on the delivery model was a policy decision so I will not comment on it. I am not commenting on the delivery.

Comment on this

I am asking Ms McGuckin about the delivery model from an accountability point of view. Does she accept that there are real difficulties in establishing accountability for the spending of public money if such money goes through a private company?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

Not if the procedures, rules and guidelines are being followed and adhered to.

Comment on this

Which rules and guidelines are they?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

There are financial procedures and procurement procedures.

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

With regard to procurement of training, for example, there are procurement procedures that should be adhered to.

Comment on this

Do those guidelines and procedures not apply to public companies and State agencies?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

Under procurement rules, if a body is funded or partly funded from public funds, it is subject to the procurement rules.

Comment on this

Okay. In terms of other aspects of corporate governance, is there not a difficulty in establishing accountability?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

In what sense?

Comment on this

By and large, they are a law unto themselves and are not required to adhere to the normal guidelines that apply to State agencies. Principally, they are not audited by the Comptroller and Auditor General. They arrange their own audit.

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

That is true but, in terms of the accountability model, it is a matter for the parent Department. It has already set out the reporting mechanism to ensure it is satisfied the money is going through properly and that there is accountability.

Comment on this

I accept that but there are major question marks over it. We will deal with that through the Department. It is equally valid to ask the Department of Finance if it has concerns about that model, given what has entered the public domain.

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

Certainly on the basis of what has been thrown up by the Comptroller and Auditor General's report, we would reflect on it.

Comment on this

Has the Department of Finance not done anything about it?

Comment on this
Ms Gráinne McGuckin

Not since the publication of this matter.

Comment on this

I thank Ms McGuckin.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

On that topic, will Mr. Gorman elaborate on the community employment schemes delivered through FÁS and funded by the Department. Are there 400 or 500 community employment schemes?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

There is a budget of approximately €400 million.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

That is fine. We need not get into detail.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

Will Mr. Gorman explain the structure of the local community employment schemes that operate in most parishes and communities? What is the corporate structure? Are the companies limited?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

They are community organisations that FÁS contracts with to provide these services.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

They do not contract with organisations; they contract with a legal entity.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

The point I am making is very simple.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

I do not think they are limited companies.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

They are companies that are subject to independent audit.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

Yes.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

I make this point because an erroneous impression was given in the past five minutes. All FÁS local community employment schemes with which I am familiar are run by local limited companies. Different sponsors come together and elect a board of directors. I and, I am sure, most Deputies attend annual general meetings. The companies are audited independently and will not be approved for participation in the community employment schemes next year until the audited accounts are submitted to and double-checked in the FÁS office. It is a common and successful method of channelling funding for community employment - a lot of it is geared towards training - to limited companies in local communities. Mr. Gorman says €400 million is going through the local schemes. All the problems we have had with FÁS, by and large, have not been at that level. Hundreds of examples exist of successes involving hundreds of millions of euro. I would not want anyone in this committee to suggest that the model for community employment schemes is not very good. Every company is subject to an independent audit. A different interpretation might have been generated on the basis of an earlier conversation.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy referring to community employment schemes?

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

No, the questions were being asked about channelling State funds for training purposes to limited companies. That was the issue. I am saying this is well tried and tested in respect of 400 cases in every FÁS scheme. Somebody was trying to suggest or ask whether the mechanism is flawed.

Comment on this

The difference is that all of the payments are made and set by the Department in that regard. It is not-----

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

No, there are training budgets and procurement. On the local FÁS schemes, there is a certain level of discretion in relation to procurement. Given that the schemes are publicly funded, they must follow the same procurement regulations. All I am saying is that not all is as it looks. The system is good and is working all over the country.

Comment on this

Point taken.

Comment on this

Is the point taken? FÁS monitors and supervises, supposedly in considerable detail, the operation of community employment projects. That is the difference. Skillnets is not monitored by FÁS, nor, it would appear, anybody else.

Comment on this

We shall conclude shortly.

Comment on this

Excluding community employment schemes, are there other private companies operating in the way Skillnets was allowed to operate under FÁS? When Deputy Shortall asked Ms McGuckin whether it was the only one, I got the impression from her answer that it was. Would there not be other companies, at least under the FÁS umbrella?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

FÁS would have contracted with many private training providers to provide training.

Comment on this

With 100% of their income from FÁS?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

It would have been a direct contractual relationship. Here the model is that there is a limited company provided with funding that then contracts with a network to provide the training. The network secures the trainers and the training service. It is not as close as the community employment schemes would be to FÁS.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

It could be close to it.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Gorman

One has Skillnets and the network, and the network procures the training.

Comment on this

I call on Mr. Buckley to make his concluding remarks.

Comment on this
Mr. John Buckley

I shall make two general comments, one on each of the two issues we were considering today, redundancy and Skillnets. With regard to the latter, there are wider important lessons to be learned. Forthcoming budget reductions will probably lead public bodies to resort to more programme delivery through private sector mechanisms and intermediaries. The State may opt to buy rather than make.

The experience in this case and in the case of the CDP programme suggests that there needs to be as much control and monitoring of these arrangements as there would be if the programmes were delivered through State agencies. It needs to be both sufficient and timely to reduce the risk of public funds being wasted. Monitoring, even with private sector intermediaries and such arrangements, must still be of a high or sufficient standard and carried out on a timely basis.

With regard to redundancy, I will pick up on what Deputy Fleming was talking about. We considered the question of what the figures meant and the fact that the moneys listed are in memorandum lists of debts that must be followed and so on. It seems that with the integration of this activity into the Department of Social Protection, there will be access to more information and capacity to run computer sweeps that would match debts with companies that are in expansion mode. Much information comes from the Revenue system to the social welfare system, especially with regard to commencement of employment information. By running the sweeps, one will be able to see those companies that would be a reasonably good mark for repayment purposes and match that against the debt record because one has the employer RSI references and employee references in respect of all this information. Therefore, there would be room for more focused debt-recovery actions in the future. That, in turn, may allow repayment schedules to be agreed with those companies that would be in a position, over time, to start to repay these debts.

Reverting to Skillnets, I want to emphasise that, in the case of bodies that get more than 50% of their funding from the State, I can inspect them in exceptional cases. That opportunity exists should an issue of concern arise. The problem is that something must arise to draw one's attention to a problem before such an inspection. There is a lot to be said for operating bodies that are effectively resource allocators, as is Skillnets as a State agency. It is effectively carrying out a core function of the State in allocating funds to downstream organisations. There is merit in having the full rigour of the code of corporate governance and the State audit conducted in respect of those bodies. However, I do not want to question policy and I accept that this has been set by policy. In the overall framework, the concept that was more or less agreed when the 1993 Act was introduced was that non-commercial State activity would be subject to audit by the Comptroller and Auditor General whereas commercial activity would be the subject of audit by private sector auditors. In this context and if the issue were to be re-examined, it could be useful to try to determine where the boundary lies and whether Skillnets is on one side or the other.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Buckley. Is it agreed to note Vote 34 of the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment?

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

I have no further questions now, but we are awaiting a great deal of information.

Comment on this

I was referring to the Vote and proposing that we not dispose of the chapter on the National Training Fund - Skillnets.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

We are also awaiting a great deal of information on the Vote. I do not dispute anything, but I would like to get the information before signing off.

Comment on this

We will not note Vote 34 or chapter 29. What of chapter 30 on redundancy and insolvency payments?

Comment on this
Sean Fleming Deputy Seán Fleming Fianna Fáil

No, we are still waiting for information on it. Again, I do not dispute anything, but we should get the information before noting the chapter.

Comment on this

That is fair enough. We will keep everything open. I thank the witnesses for attending.

Next week's business is Report No. 76 of the Comptroller and Auditor General on the National Asset Management Agency - acquisition of bank assets.

The witnesses withdrew.

Comment on this