We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

FÁS Annual Report 2009

Contributions 1–176 of 362. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I remind members and witnesses to turn off their mobile telephones. We are looking at FÁS training and employment authority annual report 2009.

Before commencing, I advise witnesses that they are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the evidence they are to give this committee. If they are directed by the committee to cease giving evidence regarding a particular matter and they continue to so do, they are entitled thereafter only to qualified privilege in respect of their evidence. They are directed that only evidence connected with the subject matter of these proceedings is to be given and they are asked to respect the parliamentary practice to the effect that, where possible, they should not criticise nor make charges against a Member of either House, a person outside the Houses, or an official by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. Members are reminded of the provisions within Standing Order 158 that the committee shall also refrain from inquiring into the merits of a policy or policies of the Government or a Minister of the Government or the merits of the objectives of such policies.

I welcome everybody here. Before I call on witnesses to introduce themselves I wish to point out that before the meeting I was informed that Mr. Seán Gorman, accounting officer, Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation has been hospitalised following a car accident this morning and, consequently, cannot be with us. On behalf of the committee I wish Mr. Gorman a speedy recovery.

In today's session which I had hoped would be the last time we would have to deal with legacy issues that arose in FÁS in the period up to 2008, we will deal with the issues that have come to light since our last session. These include the payment for training that does not appear to have been delivered by one company, Empower Training, and issues relating to the purchase and lease of property in Offaly which were covered in the Comptroller and Auditor General's report. We will also examine the FÁS accounts for 2009 and get answers on the issues that face the organisation with the unemployment figures well over 450,000. The organisation faces huge challenges at a time when it is going through a major change. As members will be aware only yesterday the Dáil discussed the Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill which will see the employment aspects of FÁS come under the remit of the Department of Social Protection. We will be looking to see that the controls and oversight that were clearly not in place in previous years are now much in place. I welcome Ms Brigid McManus, Secretary General, Department of Education and Skills and invite her to introduce her officials.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

With the permission of the Chair, there is an issue I wish to raise, arising from the last meeting in public session. A statement was made by the National Asset Management Agency that banks may have tried to cheat the Exchequer out of billions of euro. I would like that statement substantiated. That statement was made here by that agency, which is a new agency, and is now the biggest property development company in the world. That it should make a statement like that without support and back-up is very serious. It will have to defend that statement. It should be brought back here to tell us the story on how it was cheated or how the proposed cheating was going to take place. One cannot defend them. Such an agency cannot make statements of that nature without having support and back-up and try to discredit agencies whether in the private or public sector.

Comment on this

I would point out that it was a colleague of Deputy O'Keeffe, Deputy Michael McGrath, who raised the issue initially. In fairness, Mr. McDonagh was only reacting to comments made by Deputy Michael McGrath. We agreed at last week's meeting, just for the record, since the Deputy raised the issue, that this committee would write to the Financial Regulator whose responsibility it is. We have done so. A copy of the letter is available for members. We have asked the Financial Regulator to investigate that matter.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

That is fine with me but the National Asset Management Agency is answerable to this committee, as the oldest committee in the land since the founding of the State. The Chairman attended a book launch recently in the Euro office at which Mr. Cosgrave presided and made a wonderful speech about the history of this committee and its influence. If we have agencies in the State who behave in that way, and make those outrageous claims, arising from a question from a TD it is a scandal without having back-up and support. The Chairman has written to Mr. Appleby-----

Comment on this

Mr. Elderfield.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

About three years will have elapsed before we hear from him. He is only interested in my job, public life. I raised another issue on the same day.

Comment on this

Sorry, most of this should have been dealt with in the previous session.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

This arose in public session today week.

Comment on this

What is it?

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I asked a question about a payment to an auditing company, Deloitte & Touche - I have the letter here - which got €890,690 for 8,058 hours of work, which is roughly-----

Comment on this

We will-----

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Hold on. We are on about transparency in this economy and never was it more upfront than now. That an agency who appears before the committee does not have this information for the public arena here is just not good enough.

Comment on this

Just a second.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I am listening.

Comment on this

Just a second, the Deputy is aware that just ten minutes ago we dealt with that letter and we decided to note and publish it and put it in the public arena.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

But it is a public question here by me, as the second questioner when Deputy Shortall left.

Comment on this

The letter is now in the public arena as of ten minutes ago.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

That is not good enough. The agency should have those answers the day it appeared before the committee and should not try to protect itself by a board decision. We are talking about procurement.

Comment on this

I would expect the agency would have those answers also but we have got the answer now. It will be up on our website.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

The Chairman is spiting himself by accepting it in that fashion.

Comment on this

I will read it out just to put it on the public record.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Of course.

Comment on this

Dear Mr. Allen,

Further to the Committees query on Thursday, which was considered by the Board.

The fee payable to Deloitte & Touche to perform Internal Audit Services is €890,690 per annum for 8,058 hours of work.

The firm was appointed further to an EU public procurement competition.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I thank the Chairman. I am not satisfied that the Chairman has written to the Financial Regulator because these people should answer this committee and not the Financial Regulator - he has another job. That they should come in here and make that type of statement about institutions they dealt with, that they were trying to cheat them - I want to know who was cheating them and how can they prove to me that they were being cheated. The agency should be at that table answering the question; it will have to be brought back.

Comment on this

We may do that. We agreed as a committee last week that we would write to the Financial Regulator. We have done so. We are awaiting a response. Sorry about the delay, I now invite Ms Brigid McManus to introduce her officials.

Comment on this
Ms Brigid McManus

I am accompanied by Mr. Dermot Mulligan, assistant secretary in the Department dealing with FÁS and skills issues, Mr. Vincent Landers, principal officer dealing with the European Social Fund, among other issues, and Mr. Pádraig Ó Conaill, principal officer dealing with FÁS and skills issues.

Comment on this

I welcome all the officials. Will Mr. O'Toole, director general of FÁS, introduce those accompanying him?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

I am accompanied by Mr. Martin Lynch, assistant director general of employment, community and business services, Mr. Conor Dunne, assistant director general for finance and information technology, and Mr. Con Shanahan, director of finance.

Comment on this

I welcome the FÁS officials. Will Mr. Ellison introduce himself?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Ellison

I am from the sectoral policy division in the Department of Finance dealing with education policy.

Comment on this
Mr. John Buckley

We are examining the 2009 financial statements of FÁS. The accounts should be read in light of the extended disclosures in the accompanying statement on internal financial control. The statement on internal financial control records the progress in implementing the key recommendations contained in the reports of the committee as well as those that arose from reports by my office.

In particular, the statement outlines a number of actions which the board has taken to improve management and governance including the fact that the risk management process has been reactivated; statements are now required from individual mangers on compliance with authorisation and procurement procedures; a committee of board was established to deal with financial matters, including the review of the FÁS annual budget, the review of quarterly accounts as well as the monitoring and review of the adequacy of the system of financial reporting to the board.

FÁS spent more than €1 billion in 2009. This was mainly funded from the Vote of the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation and the National Training Fund. Approximately 80% of the expenditure went on programme costs: €430 million on employment schemes; €266 million on training for employment; and €111 million was spent on training for those in employment which includes apprenticeship costs of €94 million. Overall the expenditure decreased by €47 million from 2008 levels with the largest decline in the area of apprenticeships which saw a reduction of almost €33 million.

Like a number of other organisations with funded pension schemes, assets associated with its funded pension scheme were transferred to the National Pensions Reserve fund at the end of 2009 in accordance with the Financial Measures (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2009. The value of the assets transferred was approximately €365 million and all future pension and retirement benefits of this scheme will be met on "a pay as you go" basis out of the annual Voted moneys. Overall, based on the actuarial assumptions set out in its accounts, FÁS's pension obligations at the end of 2009 were of the order of €832 million in net present value terms.

The chapters in my annual report which include references to FÁS are chapter 21, on decentralisation which is coming before the committee next week, and chapter 29, Skillnets, which the committee considered two weeks ago.

Under the decentralisation programme, it was planned to move approximately 400 people from FÁS's head office to Birr. FÁS was one of a small number of bodies which procured property directly under the programme. It made arrangements for a short-term lease to accommodate 40 staff. One firm, the landlord's building company, was asked to provide quotes for the fit-out of the premises. Taking account of these fit-out costs of approximately €1 million, the annualised costs of the accommodation at this premises are higher than an upper benchmark which was set by a property consultant engaged by my office.

I refer to chapter 29 on Skillnets. The committee will recall that the report outlined instances where training had been paid for but was not done. FÁS was informed by Skillnets earlier this year of allegations that it also had been the subject of malpractice by a training provider and it commissioned an internal audit report to inquire into those facts. A brief on the matter has been tabled by FÁS. The apparent lessons are that where two different delivery channels, utilising the same providers, are used for training services, there is, at a minimum, a risk of overlap or duplication. Given this risk and in order to ensure these programmes are delivered with efficiency and regularity, there would be a need for more co-ordination in future if the CDP and Skillnets programmes are retained in their present shape. The director general of FÁS will be in a postilion to update the committee on these or any other matters that arise.

Comment on this

I call on Ms McManus to make her opening statement.

Comment on this
Ms Brigid McManus

Will I deal with Mr. Gorman's opening statement? The committee requested some information which we supplied. If the Chairman wishes me to-----

Comment on this

Yes. Mr. Gorman is unavoidably absent today because he was involved in a car accident this morning.

Comment on this
Ms Brigid McManus

Mr. Gorman's statement dealt with the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation's perspective in regard to the FÁS 2009 accounts. Obviously, that function has since transferred to our Department.

The year 2009 was a significant one for FÁS in terms of change. Utilising total State funding in 2009 of €1.01 billion, FÁS responded to the significant shift in Ireland's labour market conditions by changing its programmes to focus to a greater extent on the needs of the unemployed. This meant that the agency significantly increased the numbers of unemployed for which it provided job search supports, training and work experience.

As regards job search supports, FÁS and the local employment service increased their capacity under the national employment action plan from 86,000 people in 2008 to 127,000 in 2009. As regards training, provision for the unemployed almost doubled to 120,000 in 2009. This was achieved through changes in the delivery of training courses with innovative formats, such as online blended learning and night courses. As regard work experience, community employment, job initiative and the new work placement programme gave valued work experience to more than 24,000 unemployed.

As regards departmental oversight of FÁS activities, my responsibility is - it was Mr. Gorman's responsibility when he was Accounting Officer - to satisfy myself that the requirements of the code of practice on the governance of State bodies is being implemented and, if reports indicate that problems exist, to ensure that appropriate action is taken as soon as possible. These requirements were met in 2009 and that the chairman of FÁS has met the additional requirements under the code of practice.

I welcome, in particular, the measures taken in response to the Department's request to FÁS to indicate how it will ensure that some of the irregularities which occurred in the past will not recur. These measures include tightening the financial control environment processes and procedures as well as the risk management and internal audit enhancements which are outlined in the statement of internal financial control as set out in the FÁS 2009 report. During 2009 the Department also enhanced its oversight arrangements of FÁS to ensure moneys are spent in accordance with the purposes for which they are allocated and that value for money is achieved.

In line with other public service organisations, we have, in recent years, been increasing our emphasis on outputs, performance indicators and value for money. This emphasis includes the laying of output statements for the Department before the Oireachtas. The oversight of FÁS programmes now includes specific performance indicators in regard to budget and the numbers of profiles of those to be trained.

The year 2009 was also a year of significant change for FÁS in terms of its governance. The principal changes were made under the Labour Services (Amendment) Act 2009 which implemented many of the recommendations of this committee's fourth interim report published in February 2009. Specific to the 2009 Act, changes were made to the structure, size and composition of the board and on foot of this, a new board was announced in January this year. It removed the barrier to a FÁS board director reporting issues to the Minister. It made the FÁS director general clearly accountable to the Oireachtas, including this committee and other committees. It required the disclosure of conflicts of interest by FÁS directors and staff and prohibited their involvement in matters where such a conflict existed and it provided for the protection of whistleblowing FÁS staff members reporting serious wrongdoing in the organisation. Taken together, these changes have significantly strengthened governance and accountability in FÁS. In addition, the new director general of FÁS was appointed in 2009.

Mr. Gorman provided the committee with a note on the European Social Fund as requested at the hearing of 11 November 2010. As regards 2009, the key point is that it was decided to remove all FÁS expenditure from the ESF claim to the European Commission until the issues the Commission raised had been addressed to its satisfaction. The key issue of concern to the Commission related to the inclusion in the FÁS claim of projected rather than actual training costs. There was no allegation of fraud in this case. It is my understanding that the Commission has indicated that once a new IT system is in place, it will address the main Commission concerns. It is expected that the new IT system will be in place early next year. The Department of Education and Skills will then in a position to reintroduce FÁS expenditure in future ESF claims. While no ESF moneys have been lost by Ireland, this course of action has meant that the €45 million that would otherwise have been drawn down in 2009-10 will now be drawn down in 2011. Mr. Gorman also responded to the committee on some internal departmental correspondence submitted to the committee.

I will update the committee, from my own perspective, if you like, on the transfer of departmental responsibility for FÁS as part of the restructuring of departmental responsibilities.

In March of this year the Taoiseach announced the transfer of responsibility for skills and training policy to the Department of Education and Skills and the transfer of responsibility for FÁS employment services and employment programmes to the Department of Social Protection.

This means that the training part of FÁS will be re-mandated as a new training and skills agency under the aegis of the Department of Education and Skills. FÁS employment programmes such as community employment and job initiative and FÁS job search services will transfer to the Department of Social Protection and the relevant FÁS staff will be integrated in to that Department.

The Employment Programmes and Services and Skills Training (Transfer of Departmental Administration and Ministerial Functions) Order of 2010, which came into force on 1 May 2010, provided for the reallocation of responsibility for FÁS as an agency and its related funding from the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation to the Department of Education and Skills. The relevant staff from the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation transferred to the Department of Education and Skills at that time and expenditure since that date is accounted for under my Department's Vote.

The transfer of responsibility for skills and training to the Department of Education and Skills provides an opportunity to co-ordinate the training activities in FÁS with the further education and training activities of VECs, the institutes of technology and other education provision. It should facilitate the creation of synergies in this sector and allow us to eliminate duplication where it exists. Our focus is on restructuring and re-mandating FÁS in its skills and training role. The goal is to create an agency that will provide high quality vocational training so as to deliver a workforce that has the practical skills needed by the economy. The newly mandated and reformed training agency will need to work with the VECs and other actors in order to deliver the Government's agenda in the skills and further education field.

The transfer of functions to the Department of Social Protection required legislation. That Department will, following the commencement of the relevant sections of the Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2010, assume funding and overall responsibility for FÁS employment services and employment programmes. This is now planned to take effect from 1 January 2011. Accordingly, in the 2011 Estimates the Department of Social Protection will have responsibility for the policy and funding of employment programmes and employment services.

The Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill, which has just been published and to which the Chairman referred, provides for the full transfer of FÁS employment services and employment programmes to the Department of Social Protection and this would include the transfer of relevant FÁS staff, property, land as well as certain rights and responsibilities to that Department. This will amend the Labour Services Act 1987. The implementation of this transfer is a significant project and will take a period to implement fully.

In the meantime, a service level agreement will be in place between the Department of Social Protection and FÁS. This will come into force in January 2011. Responsibility for FÁS as a State body and overall governance issues during this implementation period will be the responsibility of the Department of Education and Skills.

Officials from my Department, FÁS and the Department of Social Protection are working closely together to ensure the smooth transition of FÁS employment services and employment programmes to the Department of Social Protection. I would be glad to answer any questions the committee may have.

Comment on this

I thank Ms McManus. Can we publish your statement?

Comment on this
Ms Brigid McManus

Yes.

Comment on this

Would Mr. O'Toole like to make his opening statement?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

As the committee will be aware, 2009, and, indeed, 2010, has been a period of significant change for FÁS. During 2009, the board of FÁS resigned, the interim director general who was in place at the beginning of the year was replaced by a new director general and the organisation grappled with dealing with the necessary scrutiny of its affairs and the emergence of a variety of complex governance and other issues. New legislation covering its governance was passed by the Oireachtas and was implemented in 2010, including the appointment of a new board.

In October 2009, further issues regarding the operation of aspects of the assessment processes on contracted training provision arose which have necessitated further examination. Our policy is to examine all significant matters brought to our attention by public representatives, members of the public, through internal and external audits, and by our own colleagues. While this is time consuming and can appear protracted, it is necessary to ensure that corrective actions are identified, strategic process changes are put in place and, moreover, that we learn from experience. FÁS had also to deal with a significant, continuing increase in demand for its services given the problems being experienced in the wider economy and the need to provide the best possible supports to unemployed people.

In financial terms, the organisation spent €46.832 million less in 2009 than in 2008. This included a reduction of almost €20 million in staff pay and overheads. In keeping with the moratorium on replacing staff who left the organisation, numbers reduced by 217 - a trend which is continuing in 2010. Throughput on our main training programmes, largely for the unemployed, increased significantly. No new contracts were entered into on the competency development programme as the policy and related funding switched to meeting the needs of the unemployed. Significant increases on activity in our employment services offices, together with our community programmes, took place.

These changes have been carried through into 2010. We continue to put in place a programme of improvements to our governance arrangements in line with the recommendations of this committee and the Comptroller and Auditor General. We have also commenced the implementation of a new training standards system together with improved contractual and other arrangements for our external training programmes. The demand for our services has been maintained and we believe that all main targets will be achieved in 2010.

In summary, FÁS has embarked on a programme of significant reform. In this respect the structure of the organisation will be changed profoundly as the transfer of our employment and community services to the Department of Social Protection is implemented in line with the Government decision in this regard. In all aspects of our work we are seeking to maintain current services, improve these services and implement the programme of reforms in line with the resources available to the organisation. The board, executive and staff of the organisation remain committed to providing the best possible service to the public, while embracing a process of continuous improvements to all aspects of our work. In practical terms, we need to, and will, devise new methods of monitoring and overseeing our various programmes as we may not be able to provide the desired level of on-site monitoring in all cases. At all times we will be guided by the requirement to quality assure all of our work to ensure that our participants can have full confidence in the interventions which are put in place for them. Inevitably, some problems will occur, but by confronting these problems, making the necessary corrective actions and learning from experience, we minimise their likelihood in the future.

Finally, we would like to again assure the committee that we take this process of reform very seriously. We believe that as our employment, community, training and other services take on new forms, the positive aspects of the work of FÁS, together with the lessons learned in recent years, will provide a solid foundation for the future.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. O'Toole. Can we publish your statement?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

Yes.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

I thank Mr. O'Toole and Ms McManus for their opening statements. Turning to Mr. O'Toole's opening statement, I was struck by the reduction in staff numbers. There were 217 posts vacated and, due to the moratorium, not filled. FÁS has been able to deliver an enhanced programme, with additional training courses, for which I commend Mr. O'Toole. Can he explain, first, how FÁS has managed to be able provide more training and more courses with fewer staff and, second, on the trend continuing in 2010 which he mentioned, has he an indication of numbers so far this year and what is he doing within the organisation to ensure the reallocation of resources to the relevant training areas?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

What we have been attempting to do is maximise the available resources in the best way possible. In 2009, there were two particular priorities. One was to resource our front-facing employment services to the best of our ability and we re-allocated staff against that goal, in other words, that there were guidance officers and other support to meet as many people as possible. By doing that, we managed to make the extra guidance interventions possible and we also worked with the local employment services to enhance their level of engagements with unemployed people as well, in other words, we put as much effort as we could into front-facing activity to help guidance in that. I think we have met our main targets in that regard, not without strain. It has been a pressure to do that.

On the training side of the house, we have been able to do that by expanding our evening training programme. In the past that would have been largely for people who were employed and paid for the service. We decided to make that service available to unemployed people so we are maximising the use of our training centres at night and trying to do that as efficiently and effectively as possible.

We also expanded our contracted training provision, in other words, using external providers to provide training on a contract basis to us. Therefore, instead of having a largely direct provision providing the courses, we have moved to a mixture of direct provision and indirect provision through contracted training. In addition, we have tried to work somewhat more efficiently and effectively in our processes.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

Mr. O'Toole stated that the trend relating to the reduction in staff numbers is continuing. What is the current position regarding staff numbers?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

It is estimated that a further 100 staff will leave the organisation in 2010.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

So approximately 320 staff will have gone, which is quite a significant development. What was the overall number of staff at the beginning of the year?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

At the beginning of the year, the figure was 2,055. At the start of 2009, there were 2,272 staff. At the close of the current year we will have approximately 1,950 staff.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

So there has been a significant - approximately 10% - decrease in staff numbers. However, as the figures provided by Mr. O'Toole and Ms McManus show, the organisation has still been in a position to deliver enhanced and additional training courses. It is obvious that the staff and management team at FÁS must have displayed a great degree of flexibility in order for this to be achieved. I commend them for that. What has happened also shows that there was spare capacity to some degree. It is good that work is ongoing in respect of that matter.

In the context of the provision of additional training, Mr. O'Toole referred to local employment services. Was he referring to Jobcare and groups of that nature which are funded by FÁS or the Government and which are tasked with providing training?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

There is a network of local employment services which comes largely under the area partnership structure. We have a long-standing arrangement with those who provide these services to the effect that we fund the component of their work which relates to the guidance services they provide to people. This is called the local employment service arrangement. Historically, the aim of this was to provide additional supports to people who required particular levels of care and attention. However, as a result of the increase in that need as a result of the rise in the numbers of those who are unemployed, we have asked those who provide local employment services to expand their contacts through the national employment action programme, which they have done. They will provide a significant increase in capacity in addition to that being provided directly through our office network. To clarify, these are not training interventions, they are guidance services.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

How does FÁS ensure that the guidance services being provided meet its criteria for delivery? Are spot-checks carried out? I am sure the courses provided are accredited. If a new partnership comes into operation in a new area, how does FÁS assess that the body charged with providing guidance services is delivering what is required?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

We have a contractual arrangement with the local employment services under which we specify and agree with them the requirements on an annual basis. The local employment services then report to us on the delivery of those requirements. Separate to this, we carry out surveys of unemployed people who have interfaced with the local employment services and our offices in order to gauge their level of satisfaction with the services being provided to them.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

The main matters with which we have dealt during the past 18 months or so are procurement procedures and the corporate governance of the organisation. In his opening statement Mr. O'Toole referred to the number of significant changes the organisation has been obliged to implement. This has happened at probably the worst time possible in light of the level of strain that has been placed on FÁS in current circumstances.

FÁS's annual report for 2009 makes reference to the action taken to strengthen the financial control environment. That is crucially important. I do not know whether Mr. Dunne or Mr. O'Toole wish to comment on this matter. An important outcome from the committee's investigations into FÁS was a recommendation that the organisation should try to tighten up its financial controls. I have no intention of going over old ground but, as Mr. O'Toole indicated earlier, revised procedures in this regard were approved by the board of FÁS in April 2009. As a result, individual managers are required to complete statements of compliance. The annual report states:

The declaration was to be completed in 2010 in respect of the previous year. The declaration will now be signed every six months commencing in July/August 2010.

There seems to have been a delay in putting this procedure, which is extremely important, in place. Will our guests indicate why that is the case? Are the additional financial controls in place and, if not, when will they be put in place?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

The previous board introduced a procedure whereby staff within the organisation, from the level of assistant manager upwards, would indicate their compliance with procurement procedures. That measure was introduced during the year and staff were briefed in respect of it. The board revisited the matter in December 2009 and the original procedure was revised and adapted. What it was seeking to do was implement a self-declaration process so that where issues arose, they would be declared. The detailed forms, etc., were developed this year. For that reason, instead of introducing a new form, I put in place an alternative measure whereby the directors of each department were asked to provide me with a report on the procurement functions relating to their areas for 2009. I received these reports, in full, from each director and made it available in order that people might assess the position to which we have moved in respect of procurement.

Compliance certificates were introduced in the current year, with a view to their being completed for the six months up to and including June. We have used those forms and they have been submitted to me.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

So the process is up and running.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

It is in place.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

I note that over 350 staff have attended various workshops in that regard.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

Yes.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

That is quite a high number. The committee is due to deal next week with a report on procurement processes across State agencies and Departments. How is the procurement process within FÁS structured at present? I am aware that the financial levels, etc., which previously obtained have been changed on foot of the investigations carried out and the recommendations made by this committee. The self-declaration form also came about on foot of one of the committee's recommendation and I am glad that it has been introduced. Will Mr. O'Toole outline the hierarchy that obtains in respect of procurement? How many procurement officers does FÁS employ, what are their qualifications and, in the context of fulfilling their role, what level of experience do they possess? Many Departments and agencies - not just FÁS - have fallen short in this area because they did not have the right people in the right places. Will Mr. O'Toole outline the position?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

The first task was to ensure basic compliance with the procedures. When I initiated the review, I set out for my colleagues four overriding principles which, in my opinion, needed to guide our procurement process. These are: to operate within the law; to adopt best practice; to serve the needs of the organisation; and to deliver value for money for the taxpayer. We have set these down as our overarching goals in the context of procurement. We have made significant savings - that is the tangible demonstration of the changes - through the expanded use of our framework arrangement and through adhering to seeking best value overall.

I reiterate what I stated previously to the committee, namely, that we need to overhaul our overall financial and procurement procedures. Procedures sometimes break down because people do not understand them or within a wide and dispersed organisation, different interpretations can be applied. One of the tasks I have given to one of my colleagues, who is new to the job since April of this year, is to conduct a review of our procurement practices overall.

We have taken a number of actions which we believe are working well. We have increased our compliance within the current regulations. We have also increased awareness of and the need to obtain value for money. Furthermore, we have tried to espouse an ethos of declaration of issues rather than people being obliged to discover them in another way. What is happening is that, genuinely, my colleagues who are in the field and who are procuring on behalf of the organisation are identifying issues, challenges, interpretations, etc. We are on a good path in developing that. That will be improved further when the new financial policies and procedures embracing procurement are adopted. We have practices that are probably more restrictive than in the public sector generally and I am not sure that is necessarily the right way to go. We are also improving our capacity and capability in strategic procurement through the framework arrangements we are putting in place.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

It sounds like a great deal of progress is being made. Mr. O'Toole mentioned significant savings. Will he quantify them for last year and to date this year?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

I will ask Mr. Dunne to address that. The overall figure decreased by between €10 million and €12 million this year and procurement is a significant driver of that. There are other factors but there are some tangible examples of successes that Mr. Dunne can bring to bear.

Comment on this
Mr. Conor Dunne

I will mention a few procurement savings, mainly based on framework agreements where we have gone out nationwide for contracts. On telephone costs alone, we have saved €135,000 in 2010 compared with 2009; mobile telephones, €48,000; light, heat and power, €604,000; printer consumables, €44,000; cleaning of premises, €500,000; and insurance, €500,000. Other frameworks out at the moment will deliver significant savings, particularly in regard to ICT maintenance, of at least €200,000 per annum. We have gone to tender for frameworks in regard to transport, catering and waste management. Frameworks have also been launched for building consulting services. There will be significant savings there.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

The examples Mr. Dunne has given are not specific to his organisation. They show what can be achieved if there is a focus on procurement. The committee's view is that significant savings and efficiencies can be driven in Departments in the current economic climate. What is the overall figure?

Comment on this
Mr. Conor Dunne

In 2010, purely on framework agreements going out to tender, there is a saving of €2 million compared to 2009. The saving will increase because, for example, on our SAP maintenance, there will be a saving of €475,000 over a four-year period. That just kicked in two months ago.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

What is the percentage saving?

Comment on this
Mr. Conor Dunne

Overall, if we look at the six areas where we have savings, we are on an average of 14% saving on those frameworks.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

That is excellent. I commend Mr. Dunne on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Conor Dunne

The Deputy asked about procurement staff. The procurement office is headed up by a procurement manager who is well qualified and has a master's degree in procurement. The person came from the private sector a number of years ago from the pharmaceutical business.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

Does that person oversee all procurement within the agency?

Comment on this
Mr. Conor Dunne

Yes.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

Then that person can spot check as he or she wishes.

Comment on this
Mr. Conor Dunne

Exactly. We have put additional resources into that office.

Comment on this
Mr. Con Shanahan

With regard to the overhead reduction in 2009 compared with 2008, we have more than a 20% reduction in overheads. Mr. Dunne mentioned a number of key framework agreements that are in place but a series of much smaller agreements were not reported separately. These were reported separately for our board to give an indication but our overhead costs fell from €53 million in 2008 to €41 million and we expect them to fall considerably in 2010.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

We think we are making significant progress but I emphasis there is more to go. The compliance is one aspect and while we have adopted the compliance approached specified by the board, we think getting the culture and ethos right, supported by a mechanism of self-declaration and a better understanding of how value can be achieved, will serve us. I emphasise that because our procedures are there but it is vitally important for any organisation that procedures serve the operation of the business or the service and are not an end in their own right and, for that reason, we are having a comprehensive review of them. We want to achieve the principles I set out - better value for money and effective administration.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

FÁS must be commended on significant savings in procurement. Every Department can make significant savings in procurement. The State spends approximately €15 billion a year on procurement of goods and services and a 10% saving would amount to €1.5 billion. That would also lead to major efficiencies, including a tightening of control weaknesses. Page 35 of the report mentions a number of instances in this regard. I do not want to deal with the issue regarding invoices in 2009 totalling €222,000 paid by FÁS in respect of which there was no evidence of any goods or services being received. That is a matter for the Garda. It has moved on and, therefore, I do not want to dwell on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Con Shanahan

A total of 90% of that has been recovered.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

And the insurance excess makes up the difference. It is a much lower loss.

In the overall scheme of things, it is relatively small but the final paragraph states that following internal audit work, there are invoices totalling €207,000 for which there is no evidence of goods and services being received by the organisation. Will Mr. Shanahan elaborate on that?

Comment on this
Mr. Con Shanahan

Four items make up the figure of €207,000. A sum of €75,000 related to income that internal audit determined should have been collected over a four-year period at our various Opportunities events where small exhibitors participated but, for a variety of reasons, the income was not collected from them. The cumulative value of that over the period was €75,000 and that was never registered as a debt on our books but essentially it is uncollectible as this point in time.

Two other items related to commission that was charged, which our internal audit department has determined was inappropriately charged. One case involves a sum of €19,000 which again relates to the Opportunities events, and the other is €33,000. Both of those have been referred to the Garda and if there is not a successful outcome, we will then have to decide whether to take separate cases.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

Has FÁS paid commission in both instances?

Comment on this
Mr. Con Shanahan

FÁS paid commission to intermediaries in respect of services provided by subcontractors.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

Are these not FÁS employees?

Comment on this
Mr. Con Shanahan

No, this has nothing to do with employees. There were two sums, €19,000 and €33,000, and they are both being investigated by the Garda to see whether the recipients have a case to answer. Depending on the outcome of that, we will have to decide whether or not we pursue that further.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

Do they go back some time?

Comment on this
Mr. Con Shanahan

They go back a number of years.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

Did they happen prior to the new financial procedures being put in place?

Comment on this
Mr. Con Shanahan

Absolutely, 2008 and prior.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

Are they just mentioned in this account because they have not come up before?

Comment on this
Mr. Con Shanahan

Essentially, they are part of the legacy issues we have. The final amount of the four is a sum of €80,000, which is at issue with the community programme in the mid-west region and which involved a supervisor who was employed by a community organisation. We have determined that approximately €80,000 was paid to the community organisation and we are seeking its return. The organisation is engaging with the supervisor to maximise a return that might have been involved there. Again, this is with the Garda and we feel that up to €60,000 may be recovered from the organisation before the project is concluded.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

I refer to page 44 of the notes to the financial statement and the specific skills and job training allocation. There has been a significant increase in this from €41.3 million to €64.4 million. That was mentioned and is understood. Mention was made in Mr. Gorman's statement, which was read by Ms McManus, of the increase in the numbers of people out of work using the agency for retraining and up-skilling. How does the agency assess the success of those courses? The significant investment in these courses is welcome, but how does FÁS assess the success of the trainees and the throughput and are these people successful in the jobs market for the field in which they have been trained? What interaction does FÁS have with the Department of Social Protection in that regard? I am aware a number of changes are coming down the line which may assist in that area, but how does the programme work as things stand?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

What we have been seeking to do is to maximise the number of interventions that are available. We have had to use a variety of methods to do this, some of which have been discussed. We have had a range of shorter courses available as well as the traditional longer ones and a variety of mechanisms which are concerned with making choices available. The rationale behind that is to enable as many people as possible to keep in contact, because most research suggests that the longer somebody is unemployed, the greater the danger of becoming long-term unemployed. Therefore, what we have done in that regard is to try to keep people in contact.

We have a long-standing relationship with the Department of Social Protection which refers people who are unemployed to a FÁS guidance officer. That person will then try to seek a suitable intervention from FÁS or otherwise to try to keep the person in contact, either through ourselves, a training grant or a variety of other mechanisms. We are working progressively to ensure that all of our interventions are appropriately certified by an industry specialist, with something like an ECDL. This is done mainly through FETAC and to some degree through City & Guilds. Therefore, one measure of success is the acquiring of a recognised, certified skill by the individual concerned. We follow up then on their progression to further study, training or into employment.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

Does FÁS keep any records on the number of people who avail of its services and then attain employment?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

We have a certain amount of short-term data. For the first three months or so after they leave us, we try to track what they do. As they move out of the system and leave the live register and become involved for various reasons in what they want, the connection becomes a little more extended. However, we conduct a survey every couple of years to look at the progress people have made. We look at people with whom we have had an intervention and where they are after two years. We check whether they are in employment, still unemployed or whether they have progressed to further training or further skills development. We do that survey approximately every two years.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

While FÁS tracks progress through surveys, does it have any idea of the number of users of its services who over the course of 12 months obtain employment? People come off the live register all the time, but has FÁS particular statistics? Currently, many professionals and skilled people are unemployed and FÁS has had to change to deal with that. It is no longer just about basic training. Has Mr. O'Toole any data in this regard?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

I have no data on that with me, but I would be happy to provide it.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

That would be useful. What is the situation with regard to back to work allowances for people out of work who want to get back into the workforce on a self-employed basis? What assistance is provided to them through FÁS? What are the steps involved with regard to obtaining assistance from FÁS, the Department of Social Protection and any of the enterprise boards in that area? How does somebody go about getting assistance and how often does FÁS come across such people?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

I will ask some of my colleagues to respond to those questions.

Comment on this
Mr. Martin Lynch

The back to work allowance comes under the remit of the Department of Social Protection. We give advice in our offices with regard to its availability and the accessibility of the programme, but we are not directly involved with the participants.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

Is it the case that FÁS just provides advice, but is not involved in the assessment?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin Lynch

Correct.

Comment on this
Mr. Con Shanahan

FÁS is represented on all the local county enterprise desks and would, obviously, be aware of what assistance is being provided to people starting their own businesses. If they participated in training, they would be entitled to a training allowance, which is equivalent to the back to work allowance. If people developing an idea are in training, they will get a training allowance from FÁS. If they are employees, they may get an employment grant from a county enterprise board or from Enterprise Ireland, depending on the size of the company. There is some assistance available. Also, as Mr. Lynch mentioned, the Department of Social Protection provides a back to work allowance. Therefore, there is an allowance, which is broadly equivalent to what they would get on social welfare, which they can retain for a period of up to one year, depending on the circumstances, while they are establishing their business.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Deputy Darragh O’Brien Fianna Fáil

Okay. I thank the witnesses for their responses to my questions, particularly on the cost savings side and the way in which they and the team in FÁS are dealing with the situation in which we find ourselves. FÁS must be commended in particular on the savings it has driven through in the procurement area over the past year or two. I am interested in seeing the figures mentioned and hope they will be forwarded to me, along with the financial control documents mentioned. These show how far FÁS has come. We have moved forward from what has been brought up in this committee on a number of occasions. Procedures have changed and that is good. I commend FÁS on the work it has done in improving its internal controls and on its cost savings.

Comment on this

Mr. O'Toole was not chief executive of FÁS when the legacy issues on today's agenda were occurring. Will he explain to the committee what the shape of FÁS will be when he comes here next year?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

The intention signalled by Government is that the employment community services functions of FÁS, which represent approximately half of the overall budget, will have transferred to the Department of Social Protection. That process will involve a number of stages. The Oireachtas has already enacted one element of this, which enables the Minister for Social Protection, Deputy Éamon Ó Cuív, to take policy and budgetary responsibility of employment and community services. As indicated by the Secretary General, this is likely to take place in January 2011. Therefore, we will have a service level agreement with that Department in respect of the delivery of those services. A further Bill is before the Oireachtas currently and it, if enacted, will enable the formal transfer of the staff of the relevant premises and technologies, etc. This is due to take place in 2011, subject to enactment of the Bill. Therefore, we will have a transition programme which will involve FÁS, the Department of Social Protection and the Department of Education and Skills so that we will have an orderly transition to the new arrangements. The training function will derive its policy direction from the Department of Education and Skills and we will drive that forward. Reference was made to this in some of the opening statements.

Comment on this

The staff of FÁS will have dropped below 2,000 by then. What will the total staff of FÁS be when the transfers referred to take place?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

The numbers will have to be determined in light of the adoption of the recovery plan mentioned yesterday and the allocation of staff for the non-commercial semi-State bodies. I expect the number will be reduced from the current number, but I do not have a figure yet. We expect to work that out with the Department over the coming months.

Comment on this

With regard to the staff who have left FÁS, was that as a result of natural wastage or did FÁS offer a redundancy programme?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

The Government introduced an incentivised early retirement scheme and a career break scheme in 2009 and a number of staff availed of that. Quite a number of staff aged 60 and over also left.

Comment on this

Does the new architecture mean that FÁS will have staff, who will ultimately be the responsibility of the Department of Social Protection, working side by side with staff who will be the responsibility of the Department of Education and Skills?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

No, I do not think there will be anything formal. Subject to the legislation the intention is that the staff of FÁS who currently do those services would be fully integrated into the Department of Social Protection and then that the remaining staff-----

Comment on this

Will there be a distinction in reporting arrangements of the staff in the centres-----

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

There will, yes.

Comment on this

-----as between two different Departments?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

We have now about 17 main training centres and a number of satellite centres, but the bulk of the employment services are actually based in employment services offices - physical buildings around the country. The intention is that those properties would transfer to the Department of Social Protection as well.

Comment on this

Will a substantial number of people leave FÁS to become direct employees of the Department of Social Protection?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

At the time when this was being prepared a number of months ago, it will be something up to 40%.

Comment on this

FÁS has a budget of approximately €1 billion, which is the same as the budget at the time when we had virtually full employment. There is now a growing demand for its services and the budget is still €1 billion. Was it getting too much then or is it getting too little now?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

I have a year's experience of this now. I think the structure of the FÁS budget is not clearly understood and maybe we have not communicated it fully enough. Approximately 60% of our expenditure is payments to participants on the various training and employment programmes. The balance is used for our operating costs, which depending on the measures, is somewhere between 15% and 18%. So the core running costs are between 15% and 18% and the balance of the costs are the payments we make to external providers in the public, the not-for-profit and the private sectors, who engage in a set of interventions, training, programmes for the disabled, etc., on our behalf. So we have three separate blocks of expenditure. Like everybody else we have to manage that expenditure in the different circumstances, so what we are trying to do is operate it as efficiently as we can.

Comment on this

I accept that and I agree with what Deputy O'Brien said about the improvement in procurement. However, I return to the question the taxpayer in the street would like me to ask. It is a bit of a problem to understand why FÁS was getting €1 billion when we had full employment and it is getting €1 billion when we have 500,000 unemployed.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

Obviously, I cannot comment on the €1 billion in the past, but my responsibility is the current expenditure since 2009 and in 2010. What I am trying to emphasise is that very substantial portions of that are non-discretionary to FÁS. So the 60% that goes on participants' payments on schemes - to the supervisors of those schemes and to people on training interventions - is paid on the basis set out by Government. Those payments are analogous to social welfare benefits and we have, literally, no discretion in the matter so we are trying to make it as efficient as possible.

Comment on this

Let us consider the competency development programme. I was not a member of the committee, but I understand the Accounting Officer, Mr. Gorman, told the committee in July that there was no disquiet or concern expressed by senior officials about the value, assessment and effectiveness of this programme. He was asked the question explicitly and said: "No." That apparently was not true. I believe Mr. Mulligan was next in command in the Department at that time. How did the committee manage to get an answer of "No"? We often get a certain amount of obfuscation and claims that life is not perfect etc., but we do not usually get a flat "No" when it is untrue. As Mr. Mulligan was the senior person involved, can he tell us?

Comment on this
Mr. Dermot Mulligan

I think Mr. Gorman's remarks in July were driven by the fact that he had not seen the documentation at the time that it was prepared. So the concerns that had been raised had not been submitted to him and that was the-----

Comment on this

Was it Mr. Mulligan's decision not to submit it to him?

Comment on this
Mr. Dermot Mulligan

It was. The concerns were raised in the context of the issue about how to provide for the implementation of the national skills strategy in the national development plan. There was consideration in the Department on the memorandum for Government in relation to that. The context was that the expert group for future skills needs had been for over a year doing a considerable amount of work on the national skills strategy and it was in the position of finalising its report. In coming to that conclusion that we should have a national skills strategy, that it needed to be funded, the question of its inclusion in the national development plan came up.

Comment on this

While I appreciate that, specific criticisms were made by the senior officer in the Department whose responsibility it was to have oversight of this particular CDP programme. He made very particular fundamental forensic complaints about the merits of the programme to Mr. Mulligan, who was the senior person. Why was it considered unnecessary to act on that? While Mr. Mulligan may have very good reasons for not acting on it, it is extraordinary that this committee would have been told that no concerns were voiced, when they were voiced by somebody at principal officer level.

Comment on this
Mr. Dermot Mulligan

When Seán Gorman made a contribution to the committee in July he said that they were not voiced and that was on the basis of what was available to him at that time, which was that when the documentation was prepared - when the document the Deputy is referring to was prepared - it was not submitted to him. In terms of the points raised in the documentation, there was the concern about the scale of the provision for the implementation of the national skills strategy in the memorandum. What was being considered was €500 million over the period of the national development plan and there were concerns raised about the scale of that. In fact, on consideration the amount that was provided was less than that. That was because in the work that the expert group was doing at the time, two issues arose in terms of the costings. One was that they were based on estimates by the OECD of the cost of implementing this sort of plan and there were concerns about how they would translate in practice in the Irish situation. Second, as was acknowledged in the national skills strategy as published by the expert group, not all of the funding for the implementation of the skills strategy was going to be funded by the State - some was going to be funded by employers and some by individuals. While there was concern about the funding, in fact the funding that went into the national development plan was less. So that was one of the points that was raised.

Comment on this

Can we stick with the CDP aspect? Mr. Hayden, who was the principal officer concerned, is known to me since I worked in the Department - although I have not spoken to him for ten years. The memorandum he sent to Mr. Mulligan on 25 August 2006 was very clear. For example, he recommended that a forensic audit of a sample of the projects should be undertaken. Was that done?

Comment on this
Mr. Dermot Mulligan

Yes. That was a consideration that was acted on. I was the Department's representative on the board of FÁS. I was on the sub-committee of the board that was monitoring the competency development programme. It was called the sub-committee on training for the employed. After that suggestion regarding audits was made, I raised it at the next meeting of the sub-committee, on 13 September 2006. It was agreed at that meeting that a number of strategic alliance projects would be audited by the FÁS internal audit unit. That unit began the audit in October 2006 and it was completed in July 2007. It reviewed eight strategic alliance projects. The audit formed the basis for some of the work that was published in the Comptroller and Auditor General's report on internal control and governance of December 2009.

Comment on this

To put this in context, before Deputy Rabbitte became a member of this committee, we heard evidence to the effect that Mr. Hayden, who was the chairman of the competency development programme review group, resigned in protest at the lack of action and activity by the review group. It was described here on the day evidence was given that it was not the best of career moves for Mr. Hayden to do that, but it was courageous. In response to Deputy Rabbitte, you referred to Mr. Gorman, who is not here to answer, unfortunately, because of an accident this morning. When Deputy Rabbitte said that Mr. Gorman gave a blank denial at the meeting of July, you said he was unaware of the correspondence that went between Mr. Hayden and you. You were sitting next to him on that day. You did not correct the evidence given in any way. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Dermot Mulligan

I was here on the day.

Comment on this

Why did you not inform the committee that the evidence being given by Mr. Gorman was not correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Dermot Mulligan

It was because I did not recollect the correspondence at the time. It related to January 2007, I think. It was done-----

Comment on this

It was 2006.

Comment on this
Mr. Dermot Mulligan

It was 2006, sorry. That was a number of years ago. It was done in the context of the finalising of the memo in relation to the national development plan.

Comment on this

Mr. Hayden was so shocked by what went on here in early July that he again made a move, or he acted, which I suppose was not a very good move career-wise. He is a courageous man. He was so shocked by the evidence given that he wrote to this committee on 23 July, which was 15 days later. That letter is on record. I will quote from it:

At that meeting Seán Gorman .... told the committee that no reservations related to that programme had been expressed by officials of the Department. I had a direct responsibility for the administration of the Competency Development Programme at the time. The attachments below, that detail assessments and recommendations that I made in the period between August 2006 and January 2007, belie the evidence given to the Committee on Public Accounts by Seán Gorman. Accordingly, and to facilitate their fuller assessment and reporting on the hearings held to date on this subject ....

He asked us to bring this document, which has been in the public arena since then, to the attention of the committee. That is the context. Mr. Mulligan sat there on 8 July and allowed Mr. Gorman to mislead this committee.

Comment on this
Mr. Dermot Mulligan

I apologise for that, Chairman. It was based on the fact that I did not recollect the correspondence that has been submitted to the committee. I did not recollect it at the time and I apologise for that.

Comment on this

That is the context for Deputy Rabbitte's line of questioning. I apologise to the Deputy for interrupting him.

Comment on this

I thank the Chairman. Is it not also true that Mr. Hayden was so concerned that he drafted a letter for the Minister, and attached notes to it explaining why he intended to take that step? Was that letter sent?

Comment on this
Mr. Dermot Mulligan

That letter was not submitted to the Minister for signature.

Comment on this

Why was that decision taken?

Comment on this
Mr. Dermot Mulligan

The letter from the Minister to the chairman, as drafted, sought improvements in the information being supplied by FÁS to the Department. The reason it was decided not to submit it to the Minister was that the Department already had a significant amount of information from FÁS on the operation of the competency development programme. A lot of that information was-----

Comment on this

Where did the Department get that information from?

Comment on this
Mr. Dermot Mulligan

A lot of that information was received through the sub-committee of the board on training for the employed. In correspondence that-----

Comment on this

How did it get to the Minister?

Comment on this
Mr. Dermot Mulligan

There was a concern that the Department was not receiving information from FÁS. What I am saying is that up-----

Comment on this

Mr. Mulligan said the letter was not given to the Minister because the Minister already had a lot of information about what was going on in FÁS. Who was giving him the information?

Comment on this
Mr. Dermot Mulligan

If I said that, I misspoke. What I meant to say was that the letter was not sent because the Department already had a lot of information on the competency development programme from FÁS.

Comment on this

Did the Minister have such information?

Comment on this
Mr. Dermot Mulligan

The Minister had information, as provided by the Department. The reason the letter was drafted was-----

Comment on this

Mr. Hayden was the principal officer responsible here.

Comment on this
Mr. Dermot Mulligan

Yes.

Comment on this

When I was Minister of State in the Department in a circumstance like this the principal officer would be entitled to send his report directly to the Minister. Under the 1987 Act, the Minister is entitled to direct FÁS to act. He has wide powers under that Act. Apparently, they have never been invoked. Is that true?

Comment on this
Mr. Dermot Mulligan

The Minister, through his Department, gives directions to FÁS, particularly-----

Comment on this

He does so through his Department. Does Mr. Mulligan accept that the Minister has a role in all of this?

Comment on this
Mr. Dermot Mulligan

Sorry, the key role-----

Comment on this

The paperwork and the evidence on this would tend to show that the officials keep all of this away from the Minister. The Department deals with FÁS, which is not what the 1987 Act envisaged.

Comment on this
Mr. Dermot Mulligan

The Minister would have received reports on any queries that he would have had in regard to the operation of any programme in FÁS.

Comment on this

Of course he would. How was the Minister supposed to query if he did not know? Did the Minister know that the principal officer was as concerned as we now know to be the case?

Comment on this
Mr. Dermot Mulligan

What I would say is that I was not as concerned in regard to the flow of information. We already had a significant amount of information in the period up to January 2007, which was when the letter was drafted. That information increased significantly very shortly afterwards, in February 2007, when FÁS management submitted a detailed report and summary in regard to the projects of the competency development programme. It updated that and other progress reports in the months after that. The strategy was to attempt to utilise the contacts at official level before involving the Minister in correspondence around the issue. That worked.

Comment on this

In light of the budget of €1 billion, and given that FÁS has such an important role, if I were the Minister I would have wanted to have known about this. Is it not the case that expenditure on the CDP programme ramped up from €8 million in 2004 to €45 million in 2008 and that €150 million was spent on the programme over that period alone? Was not also the case that the person in the Department who was responsible for the programme believed there were fundamental questions to be asked about its effectiveness? So concerned was he that he brought the matter to Mr. Mulligan's attention in writing and drafted a letter for the Minister. The Minister, however, was in blissful ignorance of the letter because, I presume, Mr. Mulligan decided it should never reach his desk. Is that not what happened?

Comment on this
Mr. Dermot Mulligan

Before the letter was drafted, senior management in FÁS assured the sub-committee that a detailed and summary report of the strategic alliance projects would be furnished to the next meeting, which was in February. That is what happened. I was assured and convinced that the contacts that we had through the board sub-committee, but also departmental contacts, would give us the information that we needed to supply to the Minister. That is what happened.

Comment on this

What is the position regarding the site purchased for FÁS headquarters in Birr?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

FÁS owns a site in Birr which is in the order of 5.7 acres. It was purchased, I believe, in 2005. The indications that we have had from Government is that there will be a review of decentralisation in 2011. For this reason, we have not proceeded in any way to develop the site. What has to be factored in now is the subsequent decision on the transfer of employment and community services to the Department of Social Protection. That will be a factor that will obviously be considered in light of the review of decentralisation.

Comment on this

In August 2004, the site was valued at €140,000 per acre. Three or four months later, it was purchased by FÁS for twice that figure. How did that happen?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul O’Toole

I will ask my colleague, Mr. Connor Dunne, to take the Deputy through that.

Comment on this
Mr. Conor Dunne

That is correct, however the original advice from our property agent was a desktop review. When the agent went on site in Birr sites in the vicinity were going at up to €300,000 per acre. The agent recommended the payment of €275,000 per acre, which was the commercial value at the time.

Comment on this

A property consultant valued the site initially at €140,000 per acre.

Comment on this
Mr. Conor Dunne

Yes, the consultant did an initial evaluation.

Comment on this

However, when he visited Birr he found the site was worth twice that figure.

Comment on this
Mr. Conor Dunne

That is correct.

Comment on this

Who is this person?

Comment on this
Mr. Conor Dunne

It was one of the big professional firms.

Comment on this

Which of them?

Comment on this
Mr. Conor Dunne

Hamilton Osborne King, HOK.

Comment on this

His knowledge of Birr and of the property market was to value the site at 50% of what he subsequently thought was the value.

Comment on this
Mr. Conor Dunne

From paperwork I have reviewed, he said it was a preliminary initial valuation. It was a desktop view. It was when they went down to Birr and tried to assess sites, they looked at the price for which sites in the vicinity were going and found that two sites nearby were going for more than €300,000 per acre. They came with a recommendation that to get the site would cost between €275,000 and €300,000 per acre.

Comment on this

Does FÁS normally buy land for its own uses in terms of the infrastructure of the organisation?

Comment on this