FÁS Annual Report 2009
Contributions 177–362 of 362. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
FÁS, in the past, would have bought land for training centres, etc.
Comment on this
Does the State not have the expertise to advise on and procure this type of purchase?
Comment on this
FÁS has its own facilities. It has a management department with a professional staff. In relation to the acquisition of property, staff went to an outside professional. It should also be noted that the guidelines on the decentralisation programme issued by the OPW at the time were that the range per acre in the environs of a small town was between €100,000 and €500,000.
Comment on this
Would it not have been more customary to commission the OPW to conduct this business?
Comment on this
That would not normally be the case in FÁS. FÁS gets a special mention in the Comptroller and Auditor General's report because it had the expertise in-house. For example, the Department of Social Protection would use the OPW and FÁS would use its own internal department. It has that skills set internally.
Comment on this
Does Mr Dunne think that expertise was evident in this purchase?
Comment on this
There is a difference between facilities management and the acquisition of property. Normally, facilities management would be expertise in design and construction costs but not necessarily in site values. That would always be done by a professional auctioneer outside the organisation.
Comment on this
The position is that we have a landlocked site of 5.5 acres in Birr for which we paid €1.5 million.
Comment on this
It is not landlocked. Planning permission for the access road into the site has been secured.
Comment on this
Will planning permission make the site un-landlocked, as it were?
Comment on this
Where I am from, planning permission does not build access to a site but gives one permission to build it.
Comment on this
As far as I am aware, there is access available to the site.
Comment on this
Who handled this matter for FÁS internally?
Comment on this
A number of people would have been involved in that transaction.
Comment on this
Does anyone know why FÁS was to end up in Birr in the first place?
Comment on this
Are the documents that went to the board available? Did the board know when it approved this purchase that our friend in HOK was sitting at his desk in Dublin pontificating about prices in Birr about which he clearly knew very little?
Comment on this
It is documented in the board's papers that the initial valuation was €140,000 per acre. It was also documented in the board's papers that due to the further investigative work, the value had risen to €300,000 per acre.
Comment on this
The board was content about that.
Comment on this
The board agreed the purchase of the site at €275,000 per acre.
Comment on this
I have the figure here somewhere. It was the normal percentage rate.
Comment on this
It was normal for those days. I do not have the figure at the moment but I will find it shortly.
Comment on this
As far as I know, the vendor was the Respond housing agency, a charitable organisation.
Comment on this
I believe it is a charitable organisation owned by a development company.
Comment on this
Is that right? Is it a different organisation from the Respond I am accustomed to dealing with?
Comment on this
As far as I am aware, Respond is a charitable housing agency. We bought the site from it.
Comment on this
Perhaps Mr. Dunne will look at the paternity of the agency sometime. Was the Department consulted at the time about this venture and did it give its approval?
Comment on this
The site acquisition was approved by both the Department and the Department of Finance.
Comment on this
At the price of €300,000 per acre.
Comment on this
Were both Departments advised that this was the board recommendation and did they both approve it?
Comment on this
What will be done with the site now?
Comment on this
Does FÁS have a Friesian or Aberdeen angus herd?
Comment on this
No. This is down to the whole decentralisation decision. We were held up by the Labour Court decision in transferring staff. That certainly put a hold on the development of the Birr site.
Comment on this
I accept Mr. Dunne is not responsible for the decision on decentralisation. What is the connection between this and the premises FÁS leases there?
Comment on this
My understanding is that the intention of leasing the premises was to have an advance office in the Birr office technology park.
Comment on this
Was it a separate decision or was it in anticipation of the decentralisation process?
Comment on this
The purpose of it was in anticipation of decentralisation in order to get staff down there early.
Comment on this
Did HOK come to our rescue again or did FÁS do the job itself?
Comment on this
My understanding is that a lease was agreed at €99,000 per annum. A local property agent was used. A fit-out was required which FÁS undertook using a contractor that was on-site. A cost plan was done first and the quote was within the cost plan.
Comment on this
What was the cost of the fit-out?
Comment on this
Including furniture, it was just more than €1 million.
Comment on this
How many people was it intended to accommodate?
Comment on this
At present there are 17 staff. We also operate a jobs club out of the building and there is an employment services office clinic in the building as well.
Comment on this
What will happen to the site and the 17 staff if it is confirmed in 2011 that decentralisation will not go ahead?
Comment on this
The 17 staff are quite happy to stay there. The office is working well.
Comment on this
There is a jobs club in the building and we are using it for an ESO clinic as well. I understand we have other uses for it also. For example, the VEC is interested in taking some space in it. The idea is to get utilisation out of it.
Comment on this
What is the view in FÁS about the job that was done in leasing the office in terms of the cost? I understand that it is 77% above benchmark if one takes it over the range of the lease and the investment to refit it.
Comment on this
That is a conclusion in the Comptroller and Auditor General's report. Within his report the other 12 leases that are mentioned in table 114 on page 295 were all greater than the benchmark for a small town area by 72%. I conclude that we are no better or no worse than those responsible for the other 12 decentralised properties.
Comment on this
Yes, I suppose Mr. Dunne is correct.
Comment on this
The cost of the fit-out per square metre was below the cost of the Bruce Shaw QS fit-out at the time.
Comment on this
Why was it considered necessary to make the move at all? If a site was purchased for a new headquarters and planning permission had been sought to build a road to it, why was it necessary to move people at all to Birr until the new office was built?
Comment on this
It is my understanding that at the time FÁS was trying to fast-track its decentralisation programme. Getting 40 people down there was considered to be a way of getting it kick-started.
Comment on this
While I was not involved with FÁS at the time, in terms of the Department and some of the agencies that were due to decentralise the decentralisation implementation group and the overall Department of Finance approach was to encourage or insist, depending on the range that was managed, people to set up advance offices in order to try to get some people decentralised and encourage further people to volunteer for decentralisation. The general policy environment was that where possible, if people were prepared to decentralise, one should lease interim offices. It depended on how quickly one felt one was going to be building. The circumstances varied. For example, in our case a couple of our bodies, which were much smaller in scale than FÁS, leased interim office space-----
Comment on this
Could we conclude that it was part of the madness of the time?
Comment on this
There was a policy decision to decentralise on which I will not comment. In terms of implementation there certainly was a difficulty when there were delays in getting headquarters. People had moved to Departments or agencies who were recruited on the basis that they would be decentralised but they were often commuting up to Dublin. For example, in the case of our own Department we decentralised a group of people to Athlone but with the Mullingar decentralisation what we have done to accommodate the people who were due to decentralise is to arrange an alternative destination such as Tullamore, for example, that might suit them instead. There probably was a decision which perhaps varied in Departments to send an advance party, which worked well in some Departments or agencies.
Comment on this
Are the 17 FÁS staff resident in Birr?
Comment on this
Are the circumstances that caused FÁS to put a proposal to the board to build a new headquarters a comment on the inadequacy of the present accommodation?
Comment on this
Is the decision to build a new headquarters a comment on the inadequacy of the present accommodation?
Comment on this
If I understand it correctly, the decision to build a new headquarters flowed from the decision on decentralisation. Our current headquarters in Baggot Street is under consideration, as the organisation is now divided. We have a lease on it, the major part of which expires in 2013. Therefore, as the decision on decentralisation has been taken and as the decision on the splitting of the organisation comes through a decision will be required on our current headquarters.
Comment on this
Is there any co-ordination within the service on that kind of situation? There is much fall-out from the decentralisation programme, as announced, being stopped. There is the new economic environment. There is the fact that there are probably other agencies such as FÁS where the lease is due to expire in the next two or three years. Is there any overall co-ordination to try to make savings in that situation?
Comment on this
There is an overall requirement for FÁS to identify any surplus property that it has and to declare it to the Department of Finance, which we have done. In the light of the changes, subject to the enactment by the Oireachtas, a programme board has been established with the Department of Social Protection, the Department of Education and Skills and FÁS at Secretary General level and my level, director general, to co-ordinate the overall programme of transition. Within that we will be bringing to the table for the Department of Social Protection a number of properties and employment services offices. We have already begun a liaison with its property function to ensure that we are handling in an orderly fashion anything to do with property which will become the preserve of the Department of Social Protection. We are doing it on a case-by-case basis. A project team will be put together to examine the property.
In addition, internally within the organisation the board has commissioned a report. My colleague, Mr. Dunne, has reported to the board on our overall property portfolio. Many of those premises are leased. We own a certain range of properties. We are exiting properties that are not needed as we go. In 2009 we exited something like 16 properties. We are absolutely clear on the need to manage resources as effectively as possible, to co-ordinate those arrangements with the Department of Social Protection in particular at the moment and to exit property that is not needed in as orderly and fast a fashion as we can.
Comment on this
FÁS is a very important organisation. It is more important now than ever given the circumstances in which we find ourselves. Is Mr. O'Toole's work constrained in any way by the fact that he is now located in Dublin and might be likely to stay in Dublin?
Comment on this
I am able to undertake my duties from Dublin. It is a requirement that in the event of decentralisation to Birr I will be obliged to transfer there.
Comment on this
Did Mr. Dunne find the HOK figure?
Comment on this
We will provide that information to the Deputy.
Comment on this
The information we got in response to Deputy Rabbitte's questions is stretching credibility quite a bit. There were very strange happenings in Offaly and Laois. I mentioned Mount Lucas on the last occasion. Let us focus on Birr for the moment. There was a landlocked site and we were told by Mr. Dunne there is planning permission for access. Do we own the property over which the access road will be built?
Comment on this
My understanding is that we have a legally binding agreement stipulating we have access to the site.
Comment on this
Let us consider the premises refurbished for €1 million. It was to deal with 40 people although 400 were to be decentralised. Mr. Dunne mentioned the company that carried out the refurbishment. Would I be correct in saying it was owned by the landlord of the offices?
Comment on this
That is correct. The builder was on site. As I stated, a cost plan was drawn up by our own independent QS. The project did not go out to tender and was a type of rent-design-build – if one could call it that. The cost was about €1,200 per square metre whereas the Bruce Shaw index of construction costs showed much higher costs at the time.
Comment on this
Was it a temporary arrangement pending the development of the site on which €1.5 million was spent?
Comment on this
There is a five-year break clause in the lease.
Comment on this
I would imagine that, by the time one received planning permission, built the premises and moved in the staff, five years would be reasonable time.
Comment on this
Was the leasing of the premises approved by the board of FÁS? Deputy Rabbitte asked that.
Comment on this
On the last occasion, we spoke about Mount Lucas. Since then the manager in that part of the world took the committee to task for daring to ask questions about Mount Lucas. I described it as a white elephant at the time. Mr. O'Toole said in evidence that it was under-utilised. He said:
The site has considerable potential to provide a very valuable training resource not simply for FÁS, but in an overall context. We are trying to ensure we can get to that point.
Comment on this
There was, at the time I gave that evidence, very low utilisation of the site. It was designed specifically for construction-related training on scaffolding, plant equipment and cranes. It was being under-utilised in regard to that purpose. We had a facility in the location and wanted to get some use out of it. We acknowledge it was under-utilised. What we have done in the meantime is change the course structure. The VEC is using part of the premises. We have introduced a couple of evening training courses and we intend to expand in this area in the short term. The number of people going through the facility this year will have increased to just under 180.
We have also tackled our cost base in regard to the facility. We have cut out and reduced costs where possible. I have asked the team, which will report to me, about a further plan for the long-term use of the facility. The team has looked at a number of ideas in relation to this. It is looking at the feasibility of long-term use. Given that the facility exists, we aim to have maximum utilisation.
Comment on this
There are 33 acres. On the last day we met, we heard evidence that there are three staff working there.
Comment on this
There are two full-time staff and there are instructors coming in the evenings. The VEC tuition staff arrive during the day.
Comment on this
I do not have the specific details but typically there would be 15 to 20 people on courses. I know of the numbers on the evening courses. This is not an ideal situation as the facility is not being used to the extent originally envisaged. We would like to increase utilisation of the facility. I acknowledge all the points in this regard. Having been given the centre, we are trying to the best of our ability, in very different and difficult circumstances, to ensure there is some utilisation.
Comment on this
Deputy Rabbitte spoke about the madness that took place in respect of the acquisition of property. It was more than madness in that there has been a lot of sharp practice. Many strange things have happened around Tullamore and Birr in regard to FÁS. Has Mr. O'Toole carried out a review of all the papers and files relating to Mount Lucas, Birr and Tullamore? Can he look me in the eye and say all the procedures followed in regard to the three land deals were in accordance with all the proper procurement guidelines and other guidelines that applied at the time?
Comment on this
I can say to the Chairman that the necessary approvals, at the correct level, were given for the purchases and development of Mount Lucas, the site at Birr and the temporary facility that was put in place. The executives at the time put forward their case to the board and the board gave the approvals. The paperwork supports that. I am not in a position to make a broader comment on that.
Comment on this
The Department gave approval in respect of Birr. I am not sure about the departmental engagement in respect of Mount Lucas. I can verify it but do not have the information at the moment.
Comment on this
This ties in to other questions by Deputy Rabbitte about Mr. Hayden's correspondence to this committee, and about attachments to his correspondence to this committee. He spoke about an uneasy and poor relationship between the Department and FÁS. He said FÁS was acting almost autonomously of the Department although FÁS's annual funding, amounting to over €1 billion each year, was coming from the Department. He was basically saying the organisation was a law unto itself and used its political muscle and contacts to bypass the Department.
Comment on this
Obviously I cannot speak to that time. What I can say is that we work very closely with the Department of Education and Skills. At the beginning of this year we received a communication from the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation, which was then our lead Department, setting out its expectations in terms of the budget we were being allocated. It was requested that we report thereon to the Department regularly. We would have contact at all levels with executives. I am sure we have differences of opinion from time to time but we certainly will and do see the officials in the Department, and the Minister, as being very important stakeholders. We seek to work on those relationships and our practices in the appropriate fashion. I know from the board and from the interaction of the new board, that the board is very clear on that point.
Comment on this
Can Mr. O'Toole name the people within FÁS who were directly responsible for the three land deals in the Birr-Tullamore area?
Comment on this
Overall responsibility would have been with the director general. He would have-----
Comment on this
Mr. Molloy. He would have had overall responsibility. I am sure there were various colleagues involved. I can get their names if the Chairman wishes.
Comment on this
We should obtain them for the record. I do not believe in a tooth fairy, nor do I believe this was an act of madness, at a time when there was almost a gold-rush for land. We need to come to grips exactly with what was happening. The questions raised by Deputy Rabbitte are valid and we need more information, to say the least.
Comment on this
Did Hamilton Osborne King, or HOK as it is known, advise FÁS on the other two land deals, as well as the deal in Birr, County Offaly?
Comment on this
Ganly Walters advised FÁS on the leased offices in Birr. A peppercorn rent of €10,000 per annum is paid to Bord na Móna. Naturally, there was a huge capital expenditure on that site for the facility. I am not aware which property adviser was used, if there was any, for Mount Lucas.
Comment on this
It is in the Comptroller and Auditor General's report that HOK gave an initial valuation of the site. It came back, having done further work, stating the value was €300,000 per acre and it explained two sites adjacent, or nearby, had gone for that amount of money. This was in writing from HOK. It recommended the €275,000 per acre price.
Comment on this
I assumed it was a percentage because that was normally the standard at the time.
Comment on this
In fairness to Deputy D'Arcy, will someone from the delegations telephone the office to find out the fee? We would like to have it for the context of today's proceedings.
Comment on this
A 2% fee on a €1.5 million deal would come in at over €30,000 whereas it would be half that for the lesser amount. If the land price increased, did the percentage for HOK decrease? If it did not, why not?
Were relocation costs paid to the 17 staff who relocated to Birr?
Comment on this
Not to my knowledge. I do not think there were relocation costs. I apologise to the Deputy but neither I, nor Mr. Dunne, was in the agency at the time.
Comment on this
We will provide the Deputy with any information he requests.
Comment on this
My concern is if the office in Birr does not remain open, these 17 staff will have to be relocated at further cost.
Comment on this
We will provide the Deputy with that information.
Comment on this
Generally, to my knowledge there were no relocation costs paid under the decentralisation programme.
Comment on this
That is one little bit of good news.
What oversights are in place to ensure courses provided by FÁS through training organisations are well run and the awarding of certificates is appropriate?
Comment on this
I referred to it in my opening statement. We have carried out a review of our training standards and the efficacy of contracting arrangements with external providers. It is clear we need to make significant improvements in this regard. There is an imperative need to improve the arrangements already in place. Having reviewed their status, we introduced a set of new measures in September and will transition to them over the next several months to strengthen the overall monitoring and control of contracted training courses that we run.
Comment on this
For those unemployed, they will be either referred by the Department of Social Protection or, of their own volition, they will meet a guidance officer in our employment services offices. They will establish the skills they already have and those they may wish to acquire. Interventions will be proposed and suggested to them. Depending on the extent of their interest, they will then be placed on a waiting list to be assigned to the appropriate course.
This applies to both people on the direct training courses and on contracted courses. We start with a guidance intervention and work through to the actual contractor.
Comment on this
That is the practice. We have had to rapidly increase the level of interventions. We have managed to do this. We changed our model rapidly with much more choices and possibilities with short courses, evening courses and a small grant provision if we cannot fit them into our direct provision, for example. We are coping with this large expansion reasonably well.
However, I admit there is still work to be done to ensure the effectiveness of course provision and that follow-ups and assessment are done to best practice.
Comment on this
There is no any-course-will-do approach. We want a much closer relationship between an enterprise need, a labour market need and the skills potential of the individual. While we are responding well to the challenge we are facing, there is further work to be done to make that as tight as possible. We are attempting to help people keep some form of contact through a training intervention, with which we are succeeding.
There has to be a closer relationship, however, between the skills we are helping the person get and the opportunities in the marketplace. We are learning this very much as we go. The closer one can get the skills the person is acquiring to the need of an enterprise, the better the chance that person has of getting a job.
Large numbers of jobseekers with fewer job opportunities are encouraging a range of shorter interventions in which people are acquiring skills they did not have. Digital competency is required for many jobs. FÁS provides a large number of people with basic computing skills or the ECDL. Of itself, it adds to their skills competencies. Within the challenges of the marketplace, they probably need more to get a job, however. This is what we are trying to refine and get better at.
Comment on this
I know of two chartered accountants offered a standard FETAC level 5 accountancy course by FÁS. What is Mr. O'Toole's view on this?
Comment on this
Offering a qualified accountant an opportunity to do an accounting technician module would not suit his or her needs. We are not able to get a perfect match in all cases. We have to supply what we can and tailor it as closely as possible to the needs and the potential of the individual. Given the vast numbers we are dealing with, we are not going to get it right every time.
Comment on this
I do not mean to be rude but having two chartered accountants on a course they could have taught is just continuing the waste. The course could have been offered to two other people who could have improved their skill sets. Instead, it appears to be a training organisation filling its courses to ensure it gets paid.
Comment on this
If we have a mismatch like that, it must be addressed. However, we have quite a number of people professionally qualified in a variety of disciplines but who may not have picked up a particular skill. I am not going to stand over a situation that is, in effect, to offer an accountant to do an accountancy course again.
However, many people will step back from their own level and fill in a skills gap. An example could be an architect who had perhaps never done computer aided design, CAD, and would very much welcome doing it. That could be level 5 or 6 at FETAC level, but it is still a valuable component skill for the individual involved. It is not about the stepping back to do something different that fills in a gap, but rather tailoring the course intervention to the need of the individual as best one can.
Comment on this
Yes, and there are many examples of that. However, when that example was given to me in the last month, I could only despair having hoped that FÁS would not allow that type of mismatch to happen because there is no filter. Take it from me, training organisations are not filtering clients to shove them in the direction of the correct course to improve their skill sets, as Mr. O'Toole has just said, with, say, a professionally qualified architect who has all the artistic merits but perhaps none of the auto-CAD abilities. I believe this is something that he and his organisation needs to focus on, in particular.
I want to explore another point. With regard to those who have practically completed a FÁS module but might have one portion left to do, has there been any focus within the organisation on people with small portions of the course to complete to get the necessary certification?
Comment on this
The most marked example of what the Deputy is describing applies to apprenticeships, which are both time and standards based and require at least four years spread over seven phases. Three of those phases are off-the-job training through FÁS and the institutes of technology, largely, and four of the phases are on the job. We are finding, with the recession, that the availability of the work experience portion is becoming problematic for apprentices in particular, but also for others. We have a range of interventions in place to try to help the situation. As the economy geared up in the earlier part of this decade, so did the number of apprentices. We peaked in 2006-07 with an intake of 8,000 and many of those are filtering their way through the system, but a significant number are struggling to find the work experience necessary to complete their apprenticeships.
We have, in agreement with the Department, put in place a number of interventions to help the situation, we are getting through it but it is a significant challenge. We shall be bringing forward further proposals in respect of 2011 that will enable in some way, either through the public sector or through helping private companies that can provide the relevant work experience, to get those people over the line. However, it is a significant issue.
Comment on this
At the moment we have a redundant apprentice placements scheme. An employer who might not otherwise be able to take on an apprentice, and who is qualified to do this in line with a set of criteria will be given a subvention to the cost of employing the apprentice for the unexpired period of his or her on-the-job work.
Comment on this
In 2010 it is between €6 million and €7 million, from memory.
Comment on this
We have not got any, as yet. That will be subject to the budget process but we will be hoping for something similar.
Comment on this
What sort of time schedule is FÁS looking at to clear the backlog in terms of those who are awaiting places?
Comment on this
The last figure I have is to the effect that the overall apprenticeship numbers are of the order of 17,000. Of that approximately 10,000 were in employment or training courses on or off the job, which leaves 7,000. Of that number approximately 3,000-----
Comment on this
To recap, there are 17,000 apprentices, 10,000 of whom are working their way towards the final position.
Comment on this
Yes, they are either employed or in training.
Comment on this
They are working their way, however, to a place where there is an existing backlog. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Not quite. If they are employed, we can facilitate their normal passage through apprenticeship. For example, this year about 4,000 apprentices will get their certification. That figure will be a combination of the mainly employed and some unemployed. I am trying to narrow down the core of the issue for the Deputy, and I apologise if I am being convoluted.
Comment on this
I am sorry if I am not grasping it, but I am wondering whether the people with one module left are being given priority so that FÁS does not start another batch of 17,000 until the people stuck in limbo, and doing nothing while awaiting the final step towards certification, have been dealt with. They will have other options, then, following certification, whether they choose to emigrate or not. At least they will have the choice, but as long as they are stuck in this limbo, they have no choice.
Comment on this
I understand the Deputy. We are prioritising that and enabling people who are unemployed and missing out on their level 5 experience to do their level 6 off-the-job training ahead of the time, so that they are not in limbo when matters pick up sufficiently for them to complete the level 5. The idea is to obviate the chances of their being stuck again because they cannot get their level 6. We have a range of measures and are very concerned that FÁS is doing its level best to ensure those apprentices get the craft exposure they need. We will qualify approximately 4,000 this year. The problem will peak between 2010-12, and the backlog of the big numbers will have worked through at that stage when we will be back to normal conditions, we hope.
Comment on this
Mr. O'Toole is saying, in effect, that the people stuck in this limbo will be there for another two years.
Comment on this
Yes, I believe it will take another two years to work through the bulk of these people.
Comment on this
Has FÁS thought about any further opportunities for apprentices who need to be matched up with people who can give them their final work experience, outside its own structures, so that if people can make a match fruitful to both parties, an apprentice will get certified, while his or her employer gets a certain amount of additional labour that might be helpful to the particular business?
Comment on this
We have, and that relates to the subvention we are giving to employers who meet the criteria, and can give an apprentice what he or she needs to get over the line. We are also working with colleagues in the public sector who may have appropriately qualified crafts people who are able to provide the necessary craft supervision. It is vitally important as we get through this issue as imaginatively as we can, that the ultimate qualification stands up. It is very important not to lose sight of that so that we are as flexible as possible without compromising the standard. That is the balance we are trying to achieve.
Comment on this
Nobody is talking about compromising the standard, but even with the subvention FÁS is still talking about 2011-12 being difficult years. Is that not correct?
Comment on this
I just believe that FÁS needs to think outside the box somewhat further.
Chairman, I believe it is crucial that we get these men - they are nearly all men in the construction sector - certified so that they may expand their options. I should like to think that FÁS will prioritise that. It is certainly a priority for me, given the number of young men, mainly, who are stuck in this limbo. It is an appalling place to be. They cannot travel or emigrate, they are stuck here in that rut and I should like to think that FÁS will prioritise that, along with the Department, and that if there are areas within the private sector which can help, that it will consider that.
Comment on this
I fully accept the Deputy's point. The commitment and passion of my colleagues to deal with these problems is profound. They know these people very well, having worked with them over the four year period of their apprenticeship. They have the same concerns as we all do, that we must not leave people stuck in limbo. I assure the Deputy that we will give this our best shot in as imaginative a manner as possible, without compromising the standard because ultimately that is the goal we must achieve. We have had some successes such as the decision of the ESB to take on 250 people in this position. We have also worked with the Air Corps, who have taken a number of people and we have placed a number of people overseas in conjunction with an EU programme. We are chipping away at the problem as best we can. We are being as flexible as we can. FÁS takes to heart the Deputy's comments because we also believe that. I know that our board, which overviews this issue, is equally concerned.
Comment on this
I have the information on the fee charged by Hamilton Osborne King for the valuation of the property at Birr. It was a flat fee of €12,100.
Comment on this
On that point, I do not accept that simply because a person was doing a valuation exercise from Dublin would give a different valuation when he or she visited Tullamore. That company operated nationwide. In my view, that explanation does not hold water.
I wish to return to Empower training agency issue. I am mindful of the ongoing Garda investigation but on 11 November 2010, the committee heard evidence that the company had received payments of nearly €320,000 of public funding to deliver programmes. It was stated that FÁS was using its internal audit to investigate Empower training, which had been conducting courses on its behalf. One of the points raised was the question of 20 trainee name matches. I ask Mr. O'Toole whether it is possible that Empower training was claiming on the double from FÁS and Skillnets. Has FÁS drawn any conclusions in this regard?
Comment on this
We have drawn a conclusion that of four programme we did with Empower training, there appears to be an overlap of some of those people with people who were on a Skillnets course as well. On that basis, my colleagues in internal audit have come to the opinion that payments to the value of €92,500 to that company were inappropriate and should be returned. We have bills outstanding to the firm of €50,000, which we will offset, leaving a balance of just over €41,000 that we must recoup.
Comment on this
As for the relationship between FÁS and Skillnets, have the lines of communication to eliminate this sort of stuff been strengthened?
Comment on this
In fairness to FÁS, Skillnets referred the matter to us and this triggered the investigation we undertook. Since then, the internal audit function has been in constant contact with Skillnets and the chief executive of Skillnets and I spoke last week. We have sought to ascertain how we can ensure that our own controls are appropriate, through PPS number matching, as one can check numbers in this regard. We largely operate in separate spheres of activity but one of the conclusions we take from this and to which the Comptroller and Auditor General alluded earlier, was that we should ensure that if there is duplication of course, we should minimise the possibility of any potential fraud that may arise.
Comment on this
There have been three reports from the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General on FÁS in the past year or two. There has been a substantial report by the committee itself. From our audit this year, in my opinion there has been a reasonable response to the recommendations in the existing reports. We need to ensure that all the responses, including sign-offs and extended assurance, moving away from boilerplate statements of internal financial control to more explicit assurance as has been done this year, be maintained and that the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General validates this is happening. There is work for both the organisation and ourselves going forward.
I will not repeat the remarks on the possibility of duplication of services, when there is delivery through two different mechanisms on what is essentially the same type of service, that is training to people in employment. Clearly that must be addressed, both at the design and audit stages, that is, at both the front-end and back-end of the design of these types of operations.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Buckley. As I noted earlier, it is unfortunate that Mr. Gorman was not present to answer some of the questions that fell to Mr. Mulligan to answer. We will consider whether we should invite Mr. Gorman to appear before the committee as soon as he is fit to deal with the issues raised by Mr. Hayden's correspondence to the committee, which I mentioned earlier, as well as the contents of Mr. Gorman's letter dated 23 November 2010, that the committee received on the same day and which we agreed to publish today. We will decide when and how Mr. Gorman can come before us.
I stated at the outset we were looking at the legacy issues facing the present FÁS team. Having listened to the evidence, I believe that a far tighter ship is being operated at all levels in the Department and the organisation and that what happened in the past could not as easily happen now.
Having said that, there is a responsibility to review the situation in the Tullamore-Birr land deals and property rental and acquisitions and to ensure that all procedures were followed. Mr. O'Toole has given an assurance that FÁS will do that.
Comment on this
We will do that and we have provided already to the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General details requested by his office on the matters, particularly in relation to the acquisition of lands and the temporary premises in Birr. We have co-operated fully with his office and supplied the information he has sought in respect of that. I thank the Chairman for acknowledging that.
We have made significant progress on a number of fronts, but as I mentioned in my opening statement, we are acutely conscious we have more to do in ensuring the service we provide meets the highest standard. We do not attest that the job is finished but we are attempting to move forward to the best of our ability.
Comment on this
In respect of Mr. Mulligan's evidence, he had a responsibility to be more familiar with his brief on the CDP programme. Arising from the evidence given by Mr. Gorman on that day, which has since proven to be incorrect, there was a responsibility to keep the committee informed of the real position that existed. I believe this constitutes another example of how this committee at times is not being taken seriously in its role to protect the interests of the public purse. We were let down by the fact that it took a third party who looked at evidence given here to inform members that this evidence was not entirely correct. Human nature being what it is, I understand that but this committee must also protect its role and its members believe it should be provided with the full truth and all the facts at all times when they put questions. That is all I wish to say.
That said, is it agreed to note the FÁS Training and Employment Authority Annual Report 2009? Agreed. Next week, the committee will consider Vote 10 - Office of Public Works, chapter 20, the National Convention Centre, and chapter 21, decentralisation.