We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Chapter 37 - SKILL Programme (Resumed)

Contributions 1–240 of 486. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I welcome everyone to the meeting. Today, we are considering chapter 37, SKILL programme (resumed).

Before commencing, I advise witnesses that they are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the evidence they are to give this committee. If they are directed by the committee to cease giving evidence regarding a particular matter and they continue to so do, they are entitled thereafter only to qualified privilege in respect of their evidence. They are directed that only evidence connected with the subject matter of these proceedings is to be given and they are asked to respect the parliamentary practice to the effect that, where possible, they should not criticise nor make charges against a Member of either House, a person outside the Houses, nor an official by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. Members are reminded of the provisions within Standing Order 158 that the committee shall refrain from inquiring into the merits of a policy or policies of the Government or a Minister of the Government or the merits of the objectives of such policies.

I welcome Mr. Michael Scanlan, Secretary General of the Department of Health and Children, and ask him to introduce his officials.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

I thank the Chairman. I am accompanied by my finance officer, Mr. David Smith, and my personnel officer, Mr. Barry Murphy.

Comment on this

I welcome Mr. Cathal Magee, chief executive of the Health Service Executive, and ask him to introduce his officials.

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Magee

I thank the Chairman. I am accompanied by Dr. Geraldine Smith, internal audit division, Mr. Seán McGrath, national director for human resources, and Mr. Liam Woods, national director for finance.

Comment on this

I welcome Mr. William Attley, former chairman of the SKILL project steering group. I also welcome the officials from the Department of Finance and ask them to introduce themselves.

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

My name is David Moloney and I am accompanied by Mr. Tom Heffernan and Ms Oonagh Buckley, as well as by Ms Louise McGirr and Mr. Rory O'Rua from the Department's internal audit unit.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I wish to raise an issue arising from a meeting of the committee on 18 November, at which an accusation was made against the banks by Mr. McDonagh of the National Asset Management Agency who stated that misleading information was given to that agency by the banking system. Initially, this matter was taken up by my colleague and my annoyance regarding this issue arises because he has misled my committee colleagues. Moreover, one colleague has been greatly shown up in taking up the issue. I make the point that the making of allegations of this nature to this committee by public or Civil Service officials is extremely serious. This is an extremely important committee that was established in the early years of the State. I seek to have the aforementioned official brought before the committee to explain himself. He should be disciplined for misleading members because there is too much of this going on in society at present and members, as politicians, suffer a lot of this. However, there must be an even playing field and there must be much greater transparency and accountability.

NAMA is a newly established organisation and I note this committee has encountered difficulties when seeking other information from it from the outset. While I understand progress may have been made in this regard, the aforementioned official must be brought before the committee at the earliest opportunity to apologise. If an apology is not forthcoming he should be disciplined.

Comment on this

There were two issues related to his evidence. The committee discussed it in private session a few moments ago and agreed to recall Mr. McDonagh on 30 January for two reasons. First, he is reported - I use the word "reported" - to be backtracking on his evidence given to this committee some weeks ago in response to Deputy Michael McGrath. The second reason is his failure to provide to this committee information we sought regarding salary scales within NAMA. We wrote to him last Friday as a result of a decision made by this committee. We received no response but I asked the secretariat to contact him again this morning to inform him that unless the committee received a response regarding information pertaining to salary scales, he would be recalled before it. We now have an indication from him that information will be supplied to the committee over the next number of days. That said, the committee has agreed that it should give him an opportunity to clarify the evidence he gave to it in recent weeks regarding the banks misleading NAMA.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I think the Chairman is going soft on him and that this is very serious.

Comment on this

We will find out what the man has to say.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

It is very serious that this kind of thing is happening in our society at present. A Sunday newspaper has reported that NAMA has told the fraud squad there is no evidence that banks misled it.

Comment on this

Right.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

This official, who holds a senior position in a new agency, can make those statements before the committee and mislead this organisation. I sympathise with my colleague, Deputy Michael McGrath, a decent first-time Member of the Dáil, for being set up.

Comment on this

While we cannot be led by what appears in newspapers, that said, clarification is needed. The man will be given that opportunity to clarify the position.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

The Chairman is being simplistic.

Comment on this

I am not. I am giving the man his opportunity to appear before the committee in January to clarify his position.

I invite Mr. Buckley to introduce the day's business. The full text of chapter 37 can be found in the annual report of the Comptroller and Auditor General or on the website of the Comptroller and Auditor General at www.audgen.gov.ie.

Comment on this
Mr. John Buckley

I will be brief because this is a resumed session. Chapter 37 outlined concerns pertaining to the administration of the SKILL programme. It also outlined the fact that further payments had been made into the SIPTU national health and local authority levy fund account under the action plan for people management. The latter payments were made by the Health Services National Partnership Forum. This forum is a non-statutory consultative group comprised of representatives of management and unions, as well as being a steering committee for workplace partnership. Since the last meeting, the HSE's internal audit function has finalised reports on the payments from the Health Services National Partnership Forum, as well as reports on procurement and backfilling grants related to the SKILL programme. The Department of Finance has finalised an internal audit on travel and related matters and the report commissioned by the Accounting Officer of the HSE on the circumstances surrounding travel by HSE staff related to SKILL also now is available. I have nothing further to add to my report or to my opening remarks at the session of 7 October 2010.

Comment on this

Thank you, Mr. Buckley.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

I wish to update the committee regarding a number of issues that arose at the meeting of 7 October 2010. I first wish to deal with the issue of the appropriateness of foreign travel. The report, which was prepared by my personnel officer and provided to the committee, showed that officials of the Department participated in ten overseas study visits and that the total cost of subsistence paid by the Department in respect of these visits was €6,290. I explained at the meeting of 7 October that the officials who participated in the study visits did so with the prior approval of their line managers, that the visits were relevant to the problems being addressed within the Irish health service at the time and that the joint management-union composition of the delegations reflected the policy at the time of developing and supporting a partnership approach to organisational change.

I recently have received a copy of the report prepared for the HSE by Mr. Turlough O'Sullivan and while the Department has not had an opportunity to consider the report fully, I note that Mr. O'Sullivan interviewed various HSE staff who participated in the study visits and concluded, from the evidence provided to him by those individuals, that "the study visits seem to have been comprehensive and worthwhile". I also stated at the meeting of 7 October that the conference rate of subsistence was paid in respect of these trips. The Department of Finance has since confirmed that while the general instructions to Departments do not specifically provide for a situation in which a third party pays accommodation costs, the conference rate was the only realistic alternative in this instance. This confirms the view expressed by the Department's personnel officer in his report that payment of the conference race was reasonable and justified in the circumstances.

On the issue of the funding of the foreign travel, which arose at a meeting of 7 October, one question put to me was how these visits, no matter how worthwhile they were, could have been funded from moneys provided for front line supervisor training or SKILL or both. According to the first HSE internal audit report of SKILL, it was internal audit's view that the annual grant paid into the national health and local authority levy fund account had been used to fund these foreign trips. However, the Comptroller and Auditor General's report stated that, while the visits to the UK had been funded from the SKILL programme, other foreign visits were not SKILL programme visits but were partnership visits and were funded from partnership moneys.

My best understanding of the factual situation is that the trips were organised by a SIPTU official and certain costs, generally flights and accommodation, were met from the national health and local authority levy fund account; that a number of different payments were being made into this account over the years, including the annual grant sanctioned by the Department, payments from the Health Services National Partnership Forum, HSNPF, and payments from the Local Authority National Partnership Advisory Group, LANPAG; and that one of the stated purposes from 2005 onwards of the annual grant sanctioned by the Department was the development of management-union partnerships of best practice. Accordingly, while it seems clear that the visits were ultimately funded by the Exchequer, I am unable at this stage in advance of the report which SIPTU is preparing to say how much of the annual grant sanctioned by the Department was used to fund these study visits.

Regarding the annual grant, this week I provided the committee at its request with a formal report on the background to the decision to sanction the relevant funding along with statements from individual members of staff who sanctioned the payments. As indicated in that report, it appears that payments dating back as far as 1998 may potentially be relevant. Two payments of £50,000 and £25,000 were sanctioned that year for a partnership project relating to non-nursing staff and a training and partnership initiative relating to the new hospital at Tallaght. The latter payment of £25,000 was allocated on a one-off basis to the Midland Health Board, MHB, to be made available to SIPTU and channelled through the Office for Health Management. The same sum of £25,000 was provided again in 1999 and I have previously provided the committee with copies of various sanctions from 2000 onwards.

It has not been possible to establish for certain the precise origin, nature and purpose of the payments or why they were paid into the national health and local authority levy fund account. However, the annual grant seems to have increased and evolved over time and the stated purpose of the annual payment of €250,000 sanctioned in December 2004 was to maintain support for SIPTU's human resource-personnel development schemes and the development of management-union partnerships of best practice.

Over the years, there appear to have been two common themes, namely, to support the development of a partnership approach to change and to support the provision of appropriate training for support staff. These goals are entirely understandable and appropriate, especially when viewed against the background of the highly adversarial industrial relations climate that existed within the health service and the considerable investment made in the training and career progression of nurses, allied health professionals and non-consultant hospital doctors. The overall aim of all these initiatives was to improve services to patients by enhancing the skills of the health service workforce and building a less adversarial and more collaborative approach to change.

In sanctioning the successive payments over the years, officials would have been familiar with this overall background context and aware that similar funding had been sanctioned previously. They would also have been cognisant of the Minister's ongoing support for these partnership and training programmes and the Government's overall policy objectives in respect of national, sectoral and workplace partnership. From 2005 onwards, the annual grants were noted in the HSE's published annual financial statements.

I have recently received a copy of the HSE's internal audit report on the HSNPF, but the Department has not had an opportunity to consider it properly. The report raises a number of different issues. On the issue of payments into the national health and local authority levy fund account, I note the findings that a total of nearly €925,000 was paid into the account under the Action Plan for People Management, APPM, initiative and that the bulk of this - three payments totalling €700,000 - was paid in 2007 and 2008 following an unexplained change to the process governing the funding. The Department was no longer involved in the APPM assessment process at that stage. I also note that some of the funding was disbursed to other unions and that in excess of €250,000 has been refunded to the HSE by other unions to date.

The development of a partnership approach to managing change within the health service and the investment in training initiatives for support staff both had a clear policy rationale and the full support of the Department. The purpose and nature of the overseas study visits were appropriate and worthwhile. There was no breach of official travel policy and the subsistence expenses paid were reasonable and appropriate in the circumstances. I am satisfied there was no impropriety or irregularity involved on the part of individual officials of the Department in respect of the sanctions that issued from the Department or the study visits. However, the manner in which the funding was sanctioned and administered resulted in, first, the absence of appropriate governance and financial accountability for Exchequer funding and, second, the study visits by Department officials being organised primarily by a SIPTU official and the costs of those visits being funded in part from the national health and local authority levy fund account and in part by the Department. I thank members for their attention.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Scanlan. May we publish his statement?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Magee

I thank the Chairman and members of the committee for their invitation to attend this meeting. At our last meeting on 7 October, I committed to revert to the committee on a number of follow-up audit reports on SKILL and the HSNPF. The four reports are the report by Mr. Turlough O'Sullivan into overseas travel by HSE staff, the audit of the procurement processes as they pertain to the SKILL programme, the audit of the SKILL programme in terms of the backfill funding, contributions and activity data and the audit of the HSNPF. I will comment briefly on each report.

In July 2010, the HSE commissioned Mr. Turlough O'Sullivan to investigate all foreign travel undertaken by HSE staff and paid for out of the SIPTU national health and local authority levy fund. As part of his investigation, Mr. O'Sullivan conducted a series of face-to-face interviews with 11 of the 12 HSE officials who partook of foreign travel. One official, Mr. Alan Smith, the former general manager of SKILL who retired in May 2009, declined requests to attend an interview with Mr. O'Sullivan. The HSE sent two registered letters and made numerous telephone calls to Mr. Smith. His lack of co-operation with the investigation is not acceptable for a former public servant who was centrally involved in the management of the SKILL programme. We are advised that Mr. Smith is not a compellable witness in any non-statutory HSE investigation. However, we will continue to press him to secure his assistance with this investigation.

We note Mr. O'Sullivan's report and, at this stage, it is difficult to draw conclusions or arrive at a complete assessment of the actions of HSE personnel until we have full access to all relevant records and information. SIPTU is currently completing its own internal investigation into the SIPTU national health and local authority levy fund and we have been advised that its investigation will not be complete until the new year. I have met the SIPTU trustees sub-committee, its head of finance and administration, the financial adviser to the investigation and the general secretary. They re-emphasised to us that SIPTU had no knowledge of the bank account and that it was not an authorised bank account of the union and was outside the union's financial structure.

The audit report on procurement reports that there was a lack of adherence to HSE procurement policy, which is based on national and EU procurement rules, and that there was evidence of confusion in carrying out the procurement and contracting process. The audit found inadequate documentary evidence was available to the auditors in respect of various stages of the procurement process. The recommendations of this audit report will be implemented in full.

On backfill funding and activity data, the third audit report deals with the core activity of the programme, namely, the expenditure on backfilling and activity data. This report raises audit issues regarding the cost and volume of training versus the original targets for up-skilling. It also raises issues in respect of the use of training facilities. This model will require further review. The recommendations of this audit report will be implemented in full.

The audit of the SKILL programme has raised a number of concerns. Regarding governance and accountability, the HSE has taken the steps required to ensure comprehensive compliance with its regulations on payments, travel and procurement arising out of our internal audits and the report of the Comptroller and Auditor General. In this regard, the SKILL programme accounts have been closed and all of the SKILL accounting functions have been centralised and amalgamated into the main financial systems within the HSE. The operation of the SKILL programme has been relocated to the corporate head office and the staff has been mainstreamed into the HR directorate function.

We are currently implementing a full value for money review in line with the recommendations of the SKILL audit. The results will inform our decision making with regard to the future of the SKILL programme when the current phase is completed at the end of April. We are awaiting the outcome of the SIPTU investigation in order to complete our own investigations.

The Health Services National Partnership Forum, HSNPF, was established on foot of the national agreement on social partnership in 2000. It was funded by the Department of Health and Children until 2005 and thereafter through the HSE Vote. The HSE internal audit report identified significant failures in governance arrangements in the operation of the HSNPF. The HSE internal audit report charts the evolution of the HSNPF since 2000, the role and function of the trustees, the activity of the forum and, significantly, the standing of the forum. The audit report highlights the lack of clarity and confusion regarding the status of the HSNPF going back to at least 2003 and indicates that the HSNPF sought to create an organisational form and operating entity that was an artificial construct with no statutory basis.

Many of the governance issues and control weaknesses that emerged in the audit report arise from the nature of the operating model existing as it did as a satellite entity outside the mainstream management control system. Breaches of governance noted in the report include the executive role discharged by the joint chairs; the payment authorisation procedures; and the provisions in place to control the signing of cheques.

The action plan for people management, APPM, is a programme run by the HSNPF and whose purpose is to facilitate the improvement of human resource management in the health service. According to the audit report, the HSNPF was provided with funding amounting to €1.355 million under the heading APPM in the period from 2003 to 2008 of which trade unions received €1,080,000. According to the report, the HSNPF developed guidelines to manage this fund. The internal audit report noted that changes were made to how this fund was controlled and governed. This resulted in three lump sum payments totalling €700,000 being made to the SIPTU national health and local authority levy fund in 2007 and 2008. These undocumented changes in governance represent a breakdown in financial control and a lack of compliance with its own arrangements that were deemed to be in place.

In a review of payments to the SIPTU national health and local authority levy fund from the HSNPF, our internal audit report identified that in total, the SIPTU national health and local authority levy fund received €924,963 from the APPM fund. These payments were paid to one account and SIPTU corporate has re-emphasised to us that it had no knowledge of this bank account and it was not an authorised bank account of the union.

A portion of the €700,000 lump sum payments made to the SIPTU national health and local authority levy fund was paid to other unions. Following contact from the HSE internal auditors, four unions confirmed they had received moneys from the SIPTU national health and local authority levy fund but had not yet spent these funds. These four unions further agreed to repay to the HSE moneys received. A total of €275,283 has now been refunded by these four unions. In addition to the APPM fund, the HSE internal audit ascertained that a further €26,201 in cost reimbursements was paid by the HSNPF to the SIPTU national health and local authority levy fund.

The HSE internal audit examined payments made using the HSNPF credit card issued to the forum director in the period from 2003 to 2009. The total expenditure during this period was €84,516. Much of this expenditure related to payments for travel, hotels and restaurants. Of concern to the auditors is the fact that the credit card statements were self-certified and were not authorised by either a joint chair or a trustee. The audit report provides a detailed explanation in a letter from the director of the HSNPF on this issue. The absence of proper authorisation and control highlights the overall lack of clarity on governance.

There were 21 foreign trips undertaken by forum members, staff and other persons as indicated by documentation on file at the HSNPF. Five of these trips were previously identified in the HSE's internal audit report on the SKILL programme. The internal audit identified that in some instances a large number of people went on these trips. The total costs identified in the accounts of the HSNPF, which include payments made by the corporate credit card and subsistence claims, amount to €146,680. Unlike the SKILL foreign trips, the 16 trips in this instance were all arranged by the HSNPF and were properly reflected in its administrative records.

Arising from this internal audit the HSE has closed down the separate bank accounts of the HSNPF and subsumed all accounts payable functions into the mainstream HSE financial control systems. This report was completed last week, and based on its findings we now intend to further investigate all matters arising from the audit and the SIPTU investigation into the national health and local authority levy fund.

It is clear from all of the audit reports before the committee that there was a systemic failure to adhere to the financial, travel and procurement regulations of the HSE relating to the operation of both the SKILL programme and the HSE national partnership programme. The HSE has now subsumed both programmes within the HR directorate of the HSE, ensuring that appropriate HSE governance and accountability oversight is now in place. The HSE has also taken the appropriate steps required to ensure comprehensive compliance with its regulations on payments, travel and procurement and to address in full the recommendations of the internal audit reports and the reports of the Comptroller and Auditor General to ensure these failures do not recur.

Comment on this

May we publish Mr. Magee's statement?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Magee

Yes.

Comment on this

Before I invite Deputy Shortall to pose questions I wish to make some comments. Today, we are examining this issue with the backdrop of chapter 37 of the report of the Comptroller and Auditor General. For the record, we also have document No. 3.8 received on 8 December from Geraldine Tallon at the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government and which we dealt with previously. Ms Tallon is not present today but we expect to recall her because a number of issues arise from her report which we need to clarify. The report, which we received on 9 December, suggested that while €789,000 was paid into the SIPTU national health and local authority levy fund account, invoices are available to cover only €589,919. Along with this report we have document No. 3.1, a report from Ray Mitchell to which Mr. Magee referred; document No. 3.2, a report by Turlough O'Sullivan; document No. 3.3., a review of the involvement in the HSE SKILL project of the Department of Finance; and a document from the Department of Health and Children.

I want to refer to two other issues, one of which was mentioned earlier and concerns the role, or the lack of co-operation, of Mr. Alan Smith. There is on record a letter from him to the committee dated 9 December which, quite honestly, the committee classified as meaningless. However, if Mr. Smith wishes to exercise his right to come before the committee he can do so, or we may consider compelling him to appear before the committee.

Up to last evening, we were still awaiting the report from SIPTU and we have a bit of a vacuum today. We were expecting a report from SIPTU and until last evening we had heard nothing whatsoever from it on the long-awaited and promised report. In response to a telephone call from Mr. McHenry to SIPTU, a letter arrived from the general secretary outlining the position in which the union found itself. The letter has been published and is available for public scrutiny.

I find it impossible to understand how SIPTU's own investigation could be held up by an exercise undertaken by two individuals, one of whom is a paid official of SIPTU and the other a volunteer. These individuals commissioned a report by Grant Thornton but that report is not yet available to SIPTU, which for its own reasons feels unable to provide the committee with a report. Is this a stalling exercise and who is paying for the Grant Thornton report given that it was not authorised by SIPTU? One would think at this stage that SIPTU would have exercised its rights over the individuals concerned. We are in an unacceptable situation in that we do not have a report from SIPTU with the result that we will not be able to complete our deliberations today and will have to revisit the issue in January.

As I noted earlier, we are examining a number of reports and the committee has had to deal with reports which we only received in the past week. I find it very unsatisfactory that, even though the reports were available to the Department of Health and Children, Mr. Scanlan noted in his opening address that he had no time to consider them in detail. We expected him to have prepared for this meeting by giving the reports his priority consideration so that he could comment on them in detail if requested to do so.

The findings of the internal audit reports from the HSE and the Department of Finance, which are to be considered today, show our public and certain trade union officials in a poor light. They also cast a shadow over partnership. I am of the view that major changes will have to be introduced to the way we manage our affairs. The position of senior officials, especially in the HSE, have been compromised at a time when they will have to manage the difficult industrial relations environment that arises from the cutbacks to funding.

I take issue with much of Mr. Scanlan's opening statement. The Department of Health and Children was instrumental in agreeing a system of payments to a trade union official which was seen by his officials and staff in the HSE as a fund to facilitate overseas travel. The Department failed to put oversight in place in respect of these funds. We have to determine the exact circumstances which resulted in just over €4 million being paid into an unofficial account. I know of no other established democracy in the world where this could happen. Some of what we have read in respect of the partnership forum reminds me of what went on in FÁS in terms of overseas trips, credit card bills for pubs and restaurants, poor procurement practices and, above all, poor corporate governance. We also received two further reports on the SKILL programme which questioned its efficiency and effectiveness. Again, we see poor procurement and outsourcing of services that should have been provided in-house. The State deserves better from the senior officials who were involved in SKILL and the partnership forum.

In regard to the report by Mr. O'Sullivan, I welcome the insight he has provided on issues such as foreign travel but his investigation should have gone deeper into the issue of travel. I contrast his findings on the benefits of travel to places like Savannah with the document by the Department of Finance which made a nonsense of the idea that people were required to travel to Florida and elsewhere to partake in a programme which is extensively available in Ireland. What I find most disquieting is the failure of senior public officials to co-operate with the investigation. I mentioned Mr. Smith. The Department of Finance is entitled to feel let down by the actions of one of its officials. I would go as far as to say that a number of senior public servants have done the State a disservice by their actions. Alas, a number of them have retired, including some on enhanced pensions.

The internal audit function of the HSE uncovered many issues that must now be addressed. These issues present a huge challenge to Mr. Magee as he begins his tenure as chief executive. How did State funds end up in an unofficial account? How did senior officials not know that it was wrong to go on foreign trips and junkets paid for by a trade union with which they would have to negotiate in the future? We cannot let our examination of today's affairs go by without addressing the SIPTU report, when we get it, and the report from the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government, which we received recently.

I have outlined my view of what we have read and heard thus far. It is now up to us to get to grips with the contents of the reports we have before us. Deputy Shortall will start the proceedings.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses. What started out as a consideration of chapter 37 of last year's report from the Comptroller and Auditor General is developing into a much bigger investigation. Having spent several hours over recent days trying to follow the various reports and voluminous correspondence and paperwork, it is difficult to avoid the conclusion that we are looking into a quagmire. Several different entities, including the health sector national partnership forum, the action plan for people management fund, the SIPTU national health and local authority levy fund, the SKILL programme and LANPAG, are involved in one way or another. All these entities are interrelated and huge amounts of public moneys were sloshing around between them. I have come to the conclusion that significant issues of accountability arise for the Departments of Finance and Health and Children and the HSE. The lack of public accountability for vast amounts of public money, involving at least €100 million and possibly much more, is shocking.

Issues clearly arise in respect of certain individuals, including two union officials, possibly one or more unions and those involved in the steering group for the SKILL programme. We will have to consider how we can address the issues that arise in respect of the individuals in question but I am concerned about what we are learning in regard to the lack of oversight by the two Departments and the HSE. Serious questions arise in regard to accountability and the audit function for large amounts of public money.

What has Mr. Scanlan learned since our last meeting? He will recall that when I asked him about moneys provided for various partnership related activities, he had difficulty in determining the origin of the decisions and allocations. In spite of the fact that the witness spoke to a number of people within the Department who had signed the cheques and so on with regard to those allocations, it is strange that nobody within the Department seemed to know why these significant sums of money were being paid into very strange entities. Has anything been discovered since the meeting of 7 October about why those allocations were made?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

To clarify, when I said the Department had not had the opportunity to study the reports fully, I meant that the Department and I had received a series of these reports recently and not everybody has had a chance to go through them and the records. I have read all of the reports and I am happy to speak today about each of them to the best of my knowledge. I have come prepared to do this but I make the point that in many cases these are internal audit reports and as I understand it they may or may not have gone through whatever the normal process is within the HSE.

With regard to Deputy Shortall's question, what I have found since is reflected in the report I sent to the committee. I accept the point made that if we consider the totality of funding, it is what the Deputy mentioned in €100 million, consisting of approximately €60 million on SKILL and €39 million or €40 million on partnership. I am not trying to belittle the amounts but the figure for the annual grant is only a part of that. I need to say that in fairness to the people concerned.

The best I could find is set out in the report. It is impossible to find a single common thread running through this but I found payments dating to 1998. The point I am trying to make is that there was a failure of governance, which I indicated the last day. If asked about the Department's role in this I accepted the Comptroller and Auditor General's finding that the manner in which the Department sanctioned this annual payment was partly if not largely to blame for the failure of governance around that payment. On the other hand I have tried in the report to explain that this was happening against a background of two factors; one was the policy of trying to develop partnership, which was only in its infancy in 1998 and 1999, and the other was the policy of trying to provide training and upskilling for a variety-----

Comment on this

With all due respect, I asked Mr. Scanlan about the specific allocations made into a fund controlled by two union officials. I asked if he discovered anything further on why those payments were made or how they were initiated.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

What I am trying to say is that to the best of my knowledge-----

Comment on this

Nobody is arguing about the other moneys. We are concerned about the €4 million.

Comment on this

The witness does not need to tell us about the background.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

That is what I am talking about too.

Comment on this

No, I am not asking about the background. I know the industrial relations background that existed. I am asking if Mr. Scanlan has established how those payments came to be made from the Department.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

What I am discussing only concerns the fund. It is not about the €100 million. The general background had two threads, one of which was partnership and one which was upskilling. Considering the descriptions used in the letters of sanction, both threads appear. Like the committee, in the absence of the SIPTU report I am not in a position to say how much of that money was spent on foreign visits. The committee asked about that point the last day.

All I am saying is that if, for argument's sake, 10% was spent on foreign travel, the issue is put in one context; if 90% was spent on foreign travel it may be put in another context. I do not know how much was spent on travel. To be fair to the Deputy, I cannot find any indication about why it was decided to make the payment into a SIPTU account as opposed to putting it into some other structure. All I can say is that I have managed as best I can to find a rationale for the payment but I have not found a reason for why the money was paid into the account. I should not say it was a SIPTU account, but a health and local authority levy account fund.

Comment on this

Irrespective of how it was spent, there are clear issues regarding the decision to allocate money into a fund controlled by two individuals.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

I agree.

Comment on this

No satisfactory explanation has been provided to us for that. In Turlough O'Sullivan's report, commissioned by the HSE, he indicates that it was clear there was political support for these allocations. We know this from a letter issued by the Minister for Health and Children in 2004, Deputy Micheál Martin, who wrote to a Mr. Matt Merrigan, assuring him funding would be continuing. We know at that stage the Minister was aware of the allocation and supportive of it continuing. These allocations were made going back to 1998 so there must have been political support. Various officials have been involved in signing off those allocations but officials would not have been in a position to make them unless there was ministerial support. Does the witness agree?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

I saw what Mr. O'Sullivan stated in his report. What I have done throughout this process is make available to the committee all the documents I could find. After the last meeting here and in advance of my report I sent copies of various documents to the committee, which included the letter to which the Deputy refers. There was also an e-mail in 2003. They are the only documents I have found which identify that the Minister was aware of something.

Comment on this

Does the witness accept it would have been highly unlikely that any official in the Department would have initiated an unorthodox allocation like this without ministerial approval, or that in subsequent years further officials would have made allocations? That would not have happened unless political support existed.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

I am trying to be fair and honest. I am inclined to say "Yes", to a point. As the Deputy has indicated, officials would have felt or wanted to feel that ministerial support existed for what went on. In fairness, I can find nothing on file to say that specific ministerial approval or authority was sought for particular payments. At the same time, the relevant Ministers over the years would have been very much involved in the development of the partnership and the action plan for people management in the health service by the Minister at the time. I am sure, for example, the first payment I have been able to find relates to the Tallaght hospital. Ministers would have been involved in the industrial relations in that respect but I can find nothing more on file.

Comment on this

Mr. O'Sullivan's report also referenced the fact that it was widely known within the health system that funding from the Department was available through SIPTU to fund foreign travel by officials as well as union officials and others. Would Mr. Scanlan concur with that view?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

I believe I would. In one of the statements which the committee asked me to provide from officers who sanctioned the payments, I was struck by reading that one of the officers correctly made the point that there was nothing hidden about the payments. They were known and issued in formal letters of determination. They were mentioned in some of the annual accounts published each year.

Comment on this

So it was known generally with the Department of Health and Children, the HSE and the Department of Finance, to a certain extent, that public money was available for foreign travel.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

I would broadly concur with what Mr. O'Sullivan has stated. I do not know any more details about that.

Comment on this

It is now established that several officials from the Department of Health and Children participated in junkets and questionable trips abroad funded by union officials. What is Mr. Scanlan's view of that practice and its appropriateness?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

Somebody recently told me that a junket is a trip in which one does not participate. The Deputy has indicated that these are questionable trips abroad but all I can do is repeat what I said in my opening statement. Mr. Turlough O'Sullivan seems to concur with the idea that the purpose of the trips - their joint management-union nature - does not seem to be untoward. Mr. O'Sullivan uses the word "unusual." However, what is untoward is the way in which they were funded, which is what I was trying to explain in my opening statement - the fact that they were being funded by Exchequer money that was essentially in the account to which Deputy Shortall refers - and that the trips were organised by a number of officials who, as I understand it, selected or invited the people to go on them. They were being part-funded from that account and part-funded, in the case of the Department officials, by the Department itself, and in the case of health board or HSE officials, by the HSE. That was unusual and untoward, and that is where there is a lack of accountability and transparency.

Comment on this

What is Mr. Scanlan's view on the appropriateness of officials from his Department going on foreign trips which are funded by an account controlled by union officials?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

I do not think it is appropriate.

Comment on this

Why was it allowed to continue?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

I do not know, other than that the individual trips were seen as worthwhile at the time.

Comment on this

Sorry; I am not asking for Mr. Scanlan's view on the worthiness or otherwise of the trips. I am asking his view on the appropriateness of officials from a Department going on foreign trips organised and funded by two union officials. Mr. Scanlan said he did not believe that was appropriate, and I am asking him why it was allowed to continue over so many years.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

I do not know.

Comment on this

For how many of those years was Mr. Scanlan Secretary General of the Department?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

From 2005 up to and including 2009. I signed off and approved some of those trips.

Comment on this

Did it ever occur to Mr. Scanlan that this may not have been appropriate - that there were conflicts involved?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

To be honest, the answer is "No." This goes back to the Deputy's earlier question as to whether I generally concurred with what Mr. O'Sullivan said about the state of knowledge in the system. I was not aware at that point of precisely how the health and local authority fund was set up, existed or was funded. What is questionable or inappropriate is how the fund was set up and funded, not the fact that there was a conflict because management and union people were going on trips together.

Comment on this

With all due respect, it is extraordinary that Mr. Scanlan's Department made an annual - sometimes more than annual - allocation to a fund without knowing why those allocations were being made, although he was aware that moneys from that fund, which was controlled by two union officials, were then used to pay for trips abroad for officials from his Department. Did no alarm bells ring throughout that period?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

To be clear about the facts, from 2005 onwards the Department did not make annual allocations, as I explained the last day. We issued the sanction in 2004. One of the questions the Deputy asked me was why it did not come to my notice in 2005, 2006, 2007 or 2008.

Comment on this

Was Mr. Scanlan not aware that the money had been routed through the HSE since 2005?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

No. The Deputy asked me this before. I accept the Department has, at a corporate level, responsibility for what happened before, but that would not have come to my personal attention because, by the time I arrived, the funding stream was in place in the HSE. The Deputy asked me whether I had a general awareness of the fact that such visits had taken place - yes, I had signed off on some of them - and was I aware that they were being organised by a SIPTU official - yes - but I was not familiar with the details of how the visits were being funded or how the account was being financed.

Comment on this

Did Mr. Scanlan never ask any questions about that?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

No.

Comment on this

That is not correct. The Department did know, because in 2004, when the HSE was not even there, it made arrangements to put it on a firmer footing. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

Yes.

Comment on this

Through what agency?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

Through the HSE.

Comment on this

The HSE from 2005.

Comment on this

From 2005 it was the HSE. What about 2004?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

The sanction that issued at the end of 2004 referred to the payments that would start to flow from 2005.

Comment on this

Was Mr. Scanlan aware of it?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

The Deputy asked me about when I arrived at the Department of Health and Children. I have said before that the Department was, in a corporate way, aware of it; the sanctions had issued. I am just making the point that from 2005 onwards the payments did not go through the Department - they were not being sanctioned annually by the Department. That was the only point I was making.

Comment on this

Was Mr. Scanlan aware of the continuation of the fund?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

As a Department, yes.

Comment on this

The allocations had been made for seven years by his Department, and the Minister for Health and Children had given an undertaking that they would continue-----

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

Yes. As a Department-----

Comment on this

-----albeit through the HSE. Over an extended period of 12 or 13 years, these allocations were being made, and various officials in the Department were enjoying the foreign trips. Did it not occur to Mr. Scanlan at any stage to say that this was not really appropriate?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

As a Department we were aware of this, yes. And no, it did not occur to me.

Comment on this

All right, but as an individual senior official, was Mr. Scanlan aware of this practice?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

No.

Comment on this

I asked Mr. Scanlan that earlier. Mr. O'Sullivan said there was a general awareness of the existence of the fund, which was receiving public money and was controlled by two SIPTU officials for the purpose of funding foreign travel, and it was being used on a regular basis by officials from various Departments and State agencies.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

I need to distinguish whether the Deputy is asking me personally or corporately. At a personal level, I was not familiar with the fact that a sanction issued at the end of 2004 which covered the period from 2005 onwards. That is at a personal level, not a corporate level. Thereafter, this would not have featured within the Department's Vote. At a personal level, I signed off and approved the trips. I had a level of awareness that these trips were being organised by SIPTU, as I understood it - not by a SIPTU official - and that they were being part-funded by some SIPTU fund. I had a general awareness that the fund was in some way part of a partnership initiative. I was not familiar with all the details that we are now starting to uncover.

Comment on this

I understand that is what Mr. Scanlan is saying. He is stating here today that it was not appropriate for officials to go on such trips, and I am asking him whether it occurred to him at any stage to ask questions about this. Twelve or 13 years later he is saying it is not appropriate, but throughout those years did it occur to him to ask what was going on or think that it may not have been right?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

What I am saying is based on having taken out all the files and looked at all the papers. If the Deputy was to ask me - as she is, in a sense - whether it would be appropriate, by today's standards, to set up a system under which Exchequer funding went into a union account which was run in the way it was, and was, in turn, used to fund trips, I would say "No." That was not my state of knowledge at the time when I signed off three, four or five - I cannot quite remember - applications for foreign study visits.

Comment on this

Most people would think that by any standards, not just today's standards, it was not appropriate. It is extraordinary that it was allowed to continue for so many years. I want to direct that question to Mr. Moloney, with regard to Mr. Dowling from his Department.

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

There was an official of our Department who was involved in many of these study trips.

Comment on this

It was Mr. Dowling?

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

Yes.

Comment on this

How many of the trips did he go on?

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

The total number of trips, we now understand, is 16.

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

When we were before the committee the last day, the number given was slightly different, but more information has become available since then. The internal audit report that we have given to the committee sets out in more detail information from other sources. It still does not, as has been mentioned several times, include information on the SIPTU investigation, and therefore the information on trips is still incomplete.

Comment on this

Mr. Dowling went on at least 16 trips?

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

We have identified 16 that we believe he was on.

Comment on this

I ask Mr. Moloney the same question I asked Mr. Scanlan. What is his view on the appropriateness of a senior official from his Department participating in foreign trips funded through a strange route - an account controlled by two SIPTU officials?

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

In those terms, we would think, as the Secretary General of the Department of Health and Children said, that it was not appropriate. What we are trying to determine in our internal report is to what extent we knew that was the means of funding for those trips. As to a point of clarification on the comment by Turlough O'Sullivan about the general state of knowledge, I cannot speak for the state of knowledge of the person who was on the trips but my understanding is that at no stage did the supervisors know, or were of the view, that this money was coming from SIPTU and/or SIPTU officials. The assumption was different, namely, that it was a HSE-funded trip. Therefore, I am not aware-----

Comment on this

Who made that assumption?

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

My understanding is that the supervisors of the official on the trips were not aware the funding related to SIPTU and/or SIPTU officials. In terms of the internal audit and what we know from supervisors, we have no information that suggests management in the Department knew it was being funded by SIPTU or by SIPTU officials.

Comment on this

Not even an official from FÁS went on 16 trips during such a period. It is extraordinary that a senior official from Mr. Moloney's Department went abroad at least 16 times. Surely that drew some attention within the Department.

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

Yes, Deputy, that is correct. Information gathered in terms of the internal audit points out that in 2008, which would have been after eight trips, if memory serves me, a question was raised by the supervisor about the appropriateness and value for money of the trips. The table within the internal audit report points out that travel claims had been made to the Department of Finance in respect of those eight trips and subsequently travel claims were not made against the Department of Finance. We understand from the internal audit report that the subsequent trips were paid for or reimbursed by SIPTU. We do not have information on that.

Comment on this

Did nobody ask the reason this person was going on so many trips and who was paying for them?

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

It would appear from the internal audit report that subsequent trips were not necessarily taken on work time but at a time when the officer would not necessarily have been-----

Comment on this

However, it was still known he was going on the trips.

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

In terms of the internal audit report in respect of four of the trips, we do not have even now, any records on file to show he was on those trips.

Comment on this

Nonetheless it was known within the Department that he was going on trips.

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

Of the eight trips for which there was a travel claim and which were authorised by supervisors-----

Comment on this

I am talking about the other trips.

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

In terms of the following eight trips-----

Comment on this

Did he claim subsistence from the Department for the first eight trips?

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

Yes, for those trips.

Comment on this

Who paid for the flight tickets and the hotels?

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

They were not claimed for and my understanding is there was an assumption the HSE paid.

Comment on this

This is crazy. Did no alarm bells ring when an official went off on eight trips and claimed travel and subsistence from the Department yet nobody knew who was paying for the flights and the hotels? He went on a further eight trips for which he made no claim. Did nobody ask questions about why this was going on and whether it was appropriate?

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

Questions were asked about the eight trips we knew about and for which claims were made, which were authorised in 2008 by his supervisors.

Comment on this

Did anybody ask who paid for the hotels and flights?

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

I am not aware of any specific questions of that nature.

Comment on this
Ms Oonagh Buckley

Perhaps I can help. From my memory of the files, on at least two occasions the official advised the supervisors the cost would be met from within health funds but did not specify the routing of those funds. There was no knowledge by supervisors within the Department of Finance of the involvement of SIPTU in any element of paying for that. He indicated the cost of the flights and hotels were being met from within health funds and it was on that basis that his supervisors approved the additional costs of subsistence and the other minor claims involved.

Comment on this

When somebody goes on 16 trips in that space of time - for goodness sake-----

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

I absolutely accept there is a weakness-----

Comment on this

What did the delegates think was going on?

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

We did not know about all the trips but I accept there is a weakness in the control environment, in particular around the rules in place in regard to trips that are paid for by third parties. The travel guidelines in the Department did not directly address situations where no claim was being made against the Department. The internal audit report points out that weakness. The report has been accepted by the Accounting Officer and will be implemented and we will move to correct that control weakness.

Comment on this

There are issues about the inappropriateness of union officials organising trips for senior civil servants. Another issue is the overall question of whether it is appropriate for public money to be used to treat people, senior civil servants or anybody else, to trips. This was the case with FÁS where the Minister, a number of politicians and different hangers on were treated to trips abroad with public money. What are the guidelines now in regard to that practice?

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

The internal audit report has pointed out the weakness in that the travel guidelines do not incorporate-----

Comment on this

I am not asking about the internal audit report but about what the Department of Finance is doing, having as it does responsibility for ensuring proper procedures are followed in these matters.

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

On foot of the internal audit report we want to roll out new procedures in regard to travel paid for by third parties.

Comment on this

Only now is this being done.

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

On foot of the evidence that has been brought forward.

Comment on this

What about the evidence that came out in regard to FÁS?

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

As I recall, some amendments to the travel policy were initiated on foot of the FÁS recommendations from the committee.

Comment on this

Can Mr. Moloney tell us what changes took place?

Comment on this
Mr. David Moloney

I can find that out for the Deputy. I am not directly responsible for the travel policy but my recollection is that there were some changes.

Comment on this

I would have thought that coming here today, delegates would have been aware of the travel policy and what changes, if any, have taken place, given that the issue under discussion was well-flagged.

On the SKILL programme, I believe Mr. Attley was chairman of the steering group which oversaw the SKILL programme.

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

Yes, that is correct.

Comment on this

How long was he in that position?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

From about 2005 until 2009.

Comment on this

Mr. Attley was not at our last meeting when we discussed the findings of the Comptroller and Auditor General in regard to the poor oversight of that programme. Many questions were raised in respect of poor corporate governance in regard to the allocation of money, procurement, the oversight of staff, the allocations made to the SIPTU fund, and so on. Does Mr. Attley wish to make a statement at the outset in response to the findings of the Comptroller and Auditor General?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

I already submitted a letter to the committee setting out my response to the report by the Comptroller and Auditor General. I draw the attention of the Deputy to the Comptroller and Auditor General's conclusion at the end of the report which made the point very strongly that we had carried out our role and function diligently. I make that point at the beginning. The role of the steering group was not one of an executive authority and it was clearly set out in our terms of reference that it was not so. We had a specific role and function which we fulfilled and which did not include any question of corporate governance in respect of the management of staff or the financial allocations made by those staff. That was absolutely clear-----

Comment on this

What was the role of the steering group?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

It is set out very clearly. It was to develop the programmes, roll them out and ensure that they met FETAC accreditation. That was the basic role of the steering group. It had no other role or function and it fulfilled this role in an exemplary fashion. It was the first time in the history of the Irish health service that a systematic training programme had been put in place for 30,000 people. It was a blank sheet. The job the steering group had was to fill out that blank sheet, make sure the training programmes put in place met FETAC accreditation and were rolled out and implemented in the health services. The job of the steering group was to fill out that blank sheet, ensure the training programmes put in place met FETAC accreditation and that they were rolled out and implemented in the health services. As the Deputy will see from our terms of reference, which I submitted to the committee, we were specifically excluded from having any executive function. We had no control over the staff or the finances; that was a matter to be put in place by the HSE. I am not privy to all the information, some of which I am hearing for the first time today in these reports, but I understand from reading newspapers and the reports of the committee that the HSE has indicated this is the case and that it had total responsibility for this area.

Comment on this

During the period between 2004 and 2009 some €47 million was allocated to the SKILL programme. Did Mr. Attley have any concerns about the governance at SKILL?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

No, we did not have any concerns. We had a project team based in the old employers' organisation and there was a reporting line for staff through it. We were informed continually that all the things we were doing and all the financial transactions carried out were being done through the HSE internal financial operation and that these were subject to the Comptroller and Auditor General. I inquired about this matter as recently as 2008. There is a minute, which I could not find in my papers, to this effect. It indicates that the general manager, who was at assistant director level, indicated to us that the bimonthly report of all financial matters was sent continually to HSE corporate and was subject to the Comptroller and Auditor General. I asked whether the Comptroller and Auditor General raised any questions about this and I was told "No". To answer the Deputy's question, we raised questions occasionally about whether what was supposed to be done was done. Other than that, we did not have a role.

Comment on this

Can Mr. Attley explain to us how he raised the questions about whether the things that were supposed to be done were done?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

We received a monthly report of the spend - the money spent on training. On several occasions when we reached that section of the agenda I asked whether the procedure was in place, namely, the bimonthly report of HSE corporate. I was told "Yes". When the audit was under way I would ask questions such as, "Has there been any feedback from the Comptroller and Auditor General about these reports?" and I was told "No".

Comment on this

To whom did Mr. Attley ask these questions?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

The general manager.

Comment on this

Was that Mr. Smith?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

Yes.

Comment on this

I refer to the overall programme. Mr. Attley had responsibility for ensuring that the programme delivered what it was supposed to deliver. Some €47 million was allocated during those years to provide upskilling for 32,000 staff in the health services. How many of those staff were trained?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

Yesterday, I rang to find out because I anticipated the question was likely to be asked. I was informed that when the cohort in the programme at the moment comes out in the middle or towards the end of next year, some 9,000 staff will be trained. These staff are being trained to the highest level. Let us remember that 30,000 people are in place, one third of whom are early school leavers. The remainder would probably have little-----

Comment on this

One third of the staff in the health services are early school leavers?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

Yes, because of the historical nature of recruitment. Many of these people have remained with the service all their lives. They came from school or were early school leavers and entered the health services 20, 30 or 40 years ago. They were asked to return to an education system from which they had been absent for 20 or 30 years. The remaining two thirds would have reasonable levels of education but never up to the leaving certificate. Of the 9,000 that will come out of this programme, the majority will have a FETAC level 5 award, the equivalent of an honours leaving certificate award. That is the nature of the achievement.

As part of the process, I insisted that we should go to the hospitals to hold the meetings. We heard from these people and their management about the effect of the training on a regular basis. In every case, the staff and the management of the hospitals believed it was a fantastic programme and that it had made a significant difference to people's attitude and absenteeism. More important, of the 30,000 who entered the programme, some spent up to two years of their lives working in the health service and doing this programme. Then they went back to take on extra work and responsibility. In the six years I was involved in the programme I met hundreds of these people. I attended their graduations where they had come with their families and were dressed in gowns and caps. It was a day of pride for them. Not once during the entire time did anyone raise the question of seeking extra remuneration for this. These are the best people in the public service and they perform in the best interests and traditions of the public service, not the kind of public service in the media daily.

Comment on this

The theory is fine.

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

It is not a theory, it is a practice.

Comment on this

I am saying the theory is fine. Is there data to support it? What evaluation has been done?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

There was continual evaluation of the programmes. Outside consultants carried out an evaluation. Pearn Kandola was in. I am not saying it was an absolutely superb programme or that it was adopted overall in the health service. There was resistance to the programme by certain management and hospitals within the HSE and there was a lack of leadership in small areas with regard to ensuring the people who were trained and who went back were allowed to take on the fold and functions. That is the situation and reports exist to show it. The real issue is that in each instance where we spoke to management apostles, we asked whether the programme had an impact on the care of the patient in the hospital. On every occasion we got a positive result. In addition, programmes were audited and a range of consultancies were brought in to examine these programmes.

Comment on this

The theory is fine, but we are unsure whether that happened in practice. It would be interesting to see data to support those claims. One audit finding from the Comptroller and Auditor General's report with regard to external training costs related to a sample of 25 module delivery sheets which were cross-checked against the related database. Some 72% of the sample did not reconcile with the attendance figures on the database. The finding further suggests that this raises concerns regarding the accuracy of the database and the output figures reported. That was one of several concerns raised by the Comptroller and Auditor General.

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

I see.

Comment on this

That is why I am saying that the theory is fine with regard to funding to upskill people with low skill levels and qualifications but there is no doubt there were serious problems with the manner in which the programme operated. There were serious deficiencies in the level of oversight. Does Mr. Attley accept this was the case?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

I do not know what the Deputy means by oversight. The people overseeing the programme were SKILLVEC. It oversaw the programme. The project group consisted of three people. That is all the project group had in addition to the steering group.

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

Every one of the outside or outsourced training projects went to State companies. The VEC carried out the training. If there was a deficiency, as the Comptroller and Auditor General has suggested, it should have been picked up by the SKILLVEC people. They were supplying-----

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

Let me answer the question.

Comment on this

You were the steering group overseeing the spending of €47 million on training. There was a clear responsibility on the steering group to ensure the money was being spent properly.

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

Yes, on the face of it. The information that comes back to us from the VECs is the information we get and we never got that information.

Comment on this

The implication, then, is that you are taking the word of other outside organisations that everything is all right.

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

No, consultants went in and looked at it. It may have come from a consultancy report many years ago. When that was brought to our attention we made efforts to correct it. I am not 100% sure but from memory I think it came out of a report by one of our own consultants looking directly at the activity of the VEC.

Comment on this

We could spend the whole meeting on the SKILL programme and the difficulties that have been identified with it by the Comptroller and Auditor General.

An allocation was made from the SKILL programme to the SIPTU levy fund. Why was that made?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

The Deputy asked that question of Mr. Scanlan. Why is she asking me?

Comment on this

I am asking about an allocation that was made of €1.5 million by the programme to the SIPTU fund. Why was that allocation made?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

On no occasion in the six years I was chairman, and I only missed one meeting, was any report made to the SKILL programme steering group that there was any allocation of the funds made available to SKILL sent to anyone other than those contracted: the VEC, UCD and the Centre for Nursing Training. We never had a report or discussion on that.

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

No.

Comment on this

You were aware people on the steering group, as well as officials employed by the SKILL programme, were participating in regular trips abroad.

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

No.

Comment on this

You were not aware?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

I am retired for 13 years in April. I would come in to a meeting and meet the general manager before it. I would ask what issues would arise and would deal with the issues on the agenda.

Comment on this

Are you saying to me that you were not aware that members of the steering group and employees of the SKILL programme were going on foreign trips on a regular basis?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

The first time I was aware of the fact they were going on foreign trips, and I am talking about the SKILL programme, not the SIPTU fund, specifically HSE SKILL training - the only area of which I have knowledge, I want to be very clear about that - was when I read it in the papers.

Comment on this

Correct me if I am wrong, was an allocation made from the SKILL programme to the fund?

Comment on this

It was paid by HSE.

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

It was paid by the HSE, not by us.

Comment on this

But you were not aware of that money going into the fund?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

I said at the outset we were specifically excluded under our terms of reference from the financial operation. It would be put in place by the HSE, controlled by it and we were continually told that if we had a minor discussion about finance, it was the job of the HSE. The position within the HSE is that it does not have the right to delegate to anyone control for its vote. We were told that on a number of occasions.

Comment on this

Just on that, my reading of it is that it was "top sliced", where the money was taken by the Department of Health and Children before your allocation was made.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

Yes, Chairman, that is absolutely correct.

Comment on this

How many of the steering group went on foreign trips?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

I only know from what I hear this morning and from what I read in the newspapers how many went.

Comment on this

You were not involved in any of the trips yourself?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

Not with the HSE, no. I only had control of the steering group under the terms of reference we were given. We operated fully within them and each time we sought to go outside of them, we were told we had to step back in. I missed one meeting and at it two people from the staff wanted to do a course. The steering group approved their application and when it went into the HSE, we were told bluntly that we did not have the authority to spend money like that, that we had no authority to spend money on anything other than the training programme as specified within our terms of reference.

Comment on this

I welcome our guests here this morning. From reading the files and listening to the testimony given in response to Deputy Shortall's questions, what went on is mind-boggling. Having read the files, the only conclusion I can draw is that part of the price of industrial peace was that funding would be provided by the taxpayer for jollies for many of those involved in the partnership process, particularly in the health sector.

Looking at the concluding remarks by both Mr. Scanlan and Mr. Magee, Mr. Scanlan referred to the absence of appropriate governance and financial accountability for Exchequer funding and Mr. Magee refers to a systemic failure to adhere to the financial, travel and procurement regulations of the HSE relating to both the operation of the SKILL programme and the HSE national partnership programme. Those are fairly devastating conclusions. Have there been consequences for individuals involved in all of this?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

In the case of the Department, the failure at the first hearing was not to define and explain the purpose and expected outputs of the annual grant. After that, and it was acknowledged at the first meeting here, it was entirely normal practice for those grants to be allocated to individual health boards or health agencies and for them to put in place arrangements around the detailed administrative financial governance. It was acknowledged here that the inquiries the committee is conducting demonstrate there was failure there also.

Comment on this

We are well aware there were failures but I asked about individuals involved who clearly failed in their public duty. Have there been disciplinary consequences for those involved?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

I also made it clear in my opening statement that while there was a failure to clarify the purpose and outputs of the grants, I did not believe there was any impropriety or irregularity on the part of the individual officials who, over successive years, had sanctioned these one-off payments.

Comment on this

Is that the limit of a person's responsibility, that there would not be any impropriety? Surely responsibility extends far beyond that to ensure there is proper governance and proper procedures are used in the disbursement of public money. Clearly that was not the case in this situation. You are speaking in generalities. We refer to systemic failure and failure of governance, but behind governance and systems are people and there appear to be no consequences. Many of the front line workers in the health service will despair when they hear this evidence and look at the reports in the media about foreign travel and it appears there are no consequences for anyone.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

There are two important issues here. In terms of the individuals who issued the sanctions, I do not believe what they did would warrant disciplinary action. That is why I used the phrase "impropriety or irregularity", I do not think the issue arises. Was it best practice in terms of issuing sanctions? No it was not. As I also explained in the report I sent to the committee, in any given year this was only one of a myriad of such sanctions that went out. The second question, which is the most important, is what damage this is doing to the SKILL programme itself? Several Deputies asked this question on the last occasion. To protect the integrity of that programme it is important to distinguish between the two parts, as Mr. Attley has done. Out of the total sum of money, the annual payment from 2005 to 2009 was €1.25 million, an unknown proportion of that was spent on foreign travel, whereas the vast bulk of it was spent on training and upskilling the staff. It is important that be recognised - that is not to understate the failures about the annual grant. It would be a shame for it to undermine the success or the value of the SKILL programme. The Chairman correctly said it was top-----

Comment on this

Much of the money was spent on back-filling posts - we do not really know what happened.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

That is an entirely different issue. My understanding on that - the Chairman may want to ask the HSE - is that because these were front line staff who were being sent off on training courses they had to be replaced and Mr. Attley may know this better than me. I am merely saying that the foreign travel element was a proportion of a total of €1.25 million from the period 2005 onwards out of a much larger sum of money that was spent essentially on buying training courses and covering the cost of staff who went on those courses.

Comment on this

Deputy McGrath asked a question about consequences. Did any of the people who sanctioned those trips go on the trips?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

The last time I appeared before the committee I gave the names of all those who issued the sanctions and all those who were on the trips.

Comment on this

Did some of the people who sanctioned the money go on the trips?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

Yes, to my knowledge.

Comment on this

Will the Secretary General name them, please?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

I will have to do the collation here.

Comment on this

While the Secretary General does that I ask Mr. Attley to continue.

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

I will reply to Deputy Shortall in a moment but on the issue of back-filling. As the Secretary General of the Department said, that was a matter of great contention for us. Once the money went away from the actual training into back-filling it reduced our ability to put the numbers through. It was quite clear, particularly in the health care area, that these were essential services provided by these people. It was made clear to us by the various hospitals and all those participating that they could not be released without people being taken on. Therefore they needed to do back-filling. There was a long discussion over many months as to the level of back funding. At the end of the day, the employers and the unions discussed with the hospitals an appropriate back-filling allowance. The allowance that came to us was an appropriate allowance which would allow them fill the positions vacated by those who went out.

On the question of foreign trips, I said that on no occasion in the six years did the steering group approve a trip. I did not go on it. The staff may have gone, as I said. So that there is no confusion-----

Comment on this

Is is true that members of the steering group went as well?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

Members of the steering group went to where?

Comment on this

Did they participate in some of the trips?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

Yes. This is the point I want to clarify for the Deputy. The steering group comprised a representative of the Department of Finance, a representative of the HSE, and a representative of the unions. It was their programme and they were the driving force behind it. Obviously they were in day to day discussions with the HSE and the steering group. I suspect the trip arose out of those discussions. Any proposal suggesting trips to the United Kingdom or anywhere else in respect of SKILLS was never brought to the attention of the steering group.

Comment on this

Mr. Attley was obviously aware of the fund.

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

Which fund?

Comment on this

The SIPTU national health and local authority levy fund.

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

No. I said to the Deputy before-----

Comment on this

Was Mr. Attley not aware of the fund?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

I do not know how many times I have say this to the Deputy.

Comment on this

I did not ask Mr. Attley that question before.

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

The Deputy did.

Comment on this

I did not ask whether Mr. Attley was aware of the existence of the fund.

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

I said in the course of my reply, how could I be aware of the fund because-----

Comment on this

Everybody else seemed to be aware of it.

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

Everybody else on a day to day basis is dealing with the health services. That is their job. This is not my job.

Comment on this

Was Mr. Attley not aware that two SIPTU officials controlled this secret fund?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

No, until such time as it became available in the media through the internal audit.

Comment on this

Did Mr. Attley not know it existed before then?

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

No.

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

It is not strange.

Comment on this

It is strange that everybody else knew that.

Comment on this

The witness is saying he was not aware of it so we have to-----

Comment on this
Mr. William Attley

The second issue was on foreign travel. I was approached in, I think, 1997 by Mr. Merrigan who said that a Department of Health and Children delegation was going to Boston for a conference. It had a request from those organising it asking if it could find somebody involved in the social partnership process to come and talk about the social partnership aspect. He asked if I would participate. I inquired how it was being funded and he told me it was being funded by the Department as Department officials were going, it would be a three day event and an economy class ticket would pay for the hotel, but one had to pay for one's own food and such like. I participated in that conference. That was a Department of Health and Children approved trip and I was asked as an appendage to go and speak about social partnership. I did not want to have any confusion about that.

I reiterate that never in the six years did the steering group approve foreign travel, or have an application before it for foreign travel or was it aware of the foreign travel.

Comment on this

Getting back to Deputy McGrath. Perhaps Mr. Scanlan would respond to the question I put to him.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

Yes, Chairman. As far as I can establish there were four officials who at various times over the period issued sanctions and at various differing times had been on trips. Mr. Tony Morris who was on a visit in 2004 was involved in sanctioning the payment I found most recently in 1998. He issued a sanction in 1998 and would have been on a visit in 2004. Mr. Frank Ahern, whose name came up before, signed a sanction in 2002, and according to the Department's records was on a visit in 2005, and Mr. Denis O'Sullivan issued a-----

Comment on this

Say that again. He went on a number of trips subsequently after retiring.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

Yes. I agree with the Chairman. In terms of the ten visits made while he was in the Department's employment-----

Comment on this

The point I am making is that he made more than one visit.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

Yes, the Chairman is right. Mr. Denis O'Sullivan who signed a sanction letter in 2004, to the best of my knowledge, was on two visits - one to Indianapolis in 2004 and one to New York in 2006. Mr. Bernard Carey, who signed the sanction in November 2004 - which we talked about before and which that related to 2005 onwards - was on five of the visits.

Comment on this

The essential point - this is a theme we revisit week after week - is the lack of any consequences of failure. We have an accepted failure of appropriate governance, a failure of financial accountability, a failure to comply with financial travel and procurement regulations. If that were to happen in the private sector I do not need to tell Mr. Scanlan what would happen - heads would roll. It seems - and this has been acknowledged - there have been no consequences for any individuals involved because essentially they did not break any law. There was no impropriety involved but that is not good enough. This was public money which was involved. My question will extend to the issue of the €4 million that went into the unofficial SIPTU account. The front line workers who work very hard for reasonable pay will despair when they hear that. If there are no consequences of failure, what is the incentive for people in the public service and in the health service to do their job properly?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

I have answered the question the Deputy asked me about consequences.

Comment on this

Yes. Both Mr. Magee, whom I have sympathy for because he is new to the job, and Mr. Scanlan have accepted a failure of governance, a failure of financial accountability and a failure to adhere to the financial travel and procurement regulations. What happens as a result of that?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

To be clear, I did not say there was a failure to adhere to the travel regulations.

Comment on this