Chapter 37 - SKILL Programme (Resumed)
Contributions 241–486 of 486. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I am just saying from the Department's point of view and in terms of the procurement, that would not have been an issue for the Department. What I said, and I said it at the first hearing, was that I accepted the Comptroller and Auditor General's finding that the manner in which the annual grant was sanctioned was not sufficiently clear and that, combined with other things, led to a failure in governance.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Magee wish to comment?
Comment on this
In response to the Deputy, this investigation is work in progress. It is not complete.
Regarding the SKILL programme, we have the audit report. We have the report by Mr. Turlough O'Sullivan commissioned by the Health Service Executive, HSE, but a very important piece to complete this is the outcome of the SIPTU internal investigation to ensure we have full transparency around the use to which the moneys that went into the SIPTU local authority levy fund were put. Therefore, in terms of HSE staff we are not in a position to conclude a definitive position.
Regarding the partnership forum, in the interest of the work of the committee that report was completed last week. We will conduct our own investigation into the outcome of that report but I am also cautious and conscious that until we have transparency and access to the administration records of the SIPTU fund we have an incomplete picture. I reserve judgment on all of these issues from an audit point of view until that complete picture is available, and we will then make decisions, following due process, about what should follow.
I share with the Deputy the view that these are damaging issues for the reputation of the HSE and for the service. It is regrettable because there is no argument that the intent and the value of investing in the training and development of the support staff in the health system is critical and needs to continue, and there must be confidence around the way we execute and discharge that.
Comment on this
Moving on to the issue of foreign travel, which appears to be a common theme running through the various reports, there was extensive foreign travel involved and various study visits. The United States of America appears to be a favoured destination. I note the director of the Health Services National Partnership Forum, HSNPF, Mr. Walsh, was involved in various trips including a trip to New York around St. Patrick's Day 2004 and 2005 and that a total of 33 people went on a study trip to New York. Was that appropriate or necessary? Looking through the foreign travel reports and itinerary, much of it reads like the RTE series, "No Frontiers". Was it necessary for this many people to go on these trips?
Comment on this
On that issue, the internal audit report, as the CO said, was finished just last week and therefore we need to investigate that trip about which the Deputy is talking. That relates to the Health Service National Partnership Forum.
Comment on this
We have outlined several trips in the past sitting around SKILL, which is 16 in total, but that one we have identified in the internal audit. One of them is the one to which the Deputy refers. That is work in progress from our end.
Comment on this
To refer back to the unofficial SIPTU accounts into which in excess of €4 million was paid, will Mr. Scanlan indicate if we are any clearer at this stage as to the rationale for the original decision or who made the original decision to begin the process of approving funding being released into this account? Are we any clearer on the origin of that at this stage?
Comment on this
Other than what I have already said to the committee and provided in the report, that is the best clarity I can bring to it. If one looks at it in terms of order of magnitude of how much money went in, probably the most important sanction was the November 2004 sanction the Chairman has referenced because from then on we were talking about €0.25 million, or five years. The vast bulk of it, therefore, went in from then on, although the account, as we now know, goes back many years. As we are starting to discover, and I explained this on the last day, if one looks at the sanctions, if memory serves me only one or two refer even to SIPTU, never mind the account. The vast bulk of it went in from then and the letter of sanction I mentioned in my opening statement said there were two purposes: joint management-union partnership and, I believe, training and development.
Comment on this
How did that work its way into Mr. Scanlan's budget in 1998 when this started? I appreciate Mr. Scanlan was not in his current position at that time but how did it come about that money would be released into an unofficial SIPTU account as far back as then? From the extent of the evidence and the information available to Mr. Scanlan, how was that position arrived at?
Comment on this
It would not have been known at that stage that it was getting into an unofficial SIPTU account but that being said, pre the HSE, all of the funding for the health services came in from the Dáil into the Department of Health Vote. The vast bulk of it was allocated at the start of the year to the individual health boards, the Eastern Regional Health Authority and the other voluntary hospitals who got separate letters of determination pre the Eastern Regional Health Authority.
There tended to be, as I understand it, what was called held-back funding for a variety of sources and over the course of the year that money would be allocated by different divisions in the Department. I am subject to correction because this is just my best knowledge of it but money might be held for disability services, for example, and during the course of the year the unit dealing with disability would then tell the finance unit how to distribute that among the different health boards.
In the space we are operating in here, my understanding is that this money would have been held back in what would be called the external HR-IR part of the Department. In any given year, quite significant sums of money could be distributed during the course of the year on foot of pay awards made during the year. That would have been a very regular occurrence in the way the system was funded. One would not fund the system in advance of getting details of the calculation of the pay costs.
I was trying to give the committee a sense of the amount of money in one year, as mentioned in our report, and the number of agencies to which it went. I have given the committee the very detailed letters of determination. One then finds this appears perhaps once in every year and as I said, I am not 100% certain but I found two of those in 1998, one in 1999 and I had previously given the committee details of one in 2000 and one in 2001. They are individual sanctions in the middle of all of that funding.
Comment on this
On the reference in the Turlough O'Sullivan report to the fact that it was widely known within the health system that funding from the Department was available through SIPTU to fund foreign travel by officials, as well as union officials and others, was that the general view within the Department? Was there acceptance that it was known within the Department that funding was available and was being expended in this way to facilitate travel?
Comment on this
I do not know. Sitting here I cannot describe the general sense of knowledge within the Department. Turlough O'Sullivan has said it. As I said earlier, I would have signed off on the individual claims to travel and I would have known that what was being sought from the Department was subsistence. I would not have known the exact nature of the funding into this account. I certainly would not have known that it was an unofficial SIPTU account.
Deputy Jim O'Keeffe took the Chair.
Comment on this
What work is outstanding on this area? As Mr. Magee said, the SIPTU report is awaited. What further work needs to be done by the Department, the HSE or the Department of Finance for Mr. Scanlan to conclude his consideration of the issues involved?
Comment on this
I probably should have said to the committee that I, too, met SIPTU at its request and I got a letter late yesterday evening indicating that it is proceeding with its investigation. That is my main interest. I am concerned at the way in which the perception prevails - at least until the SIPTU material comes out - that the vast majority of the annual grant, never mind the SKILL programme, was spent on foreign visits. I would like to see that material. There was a series of recommendations in the Comptroller and Auditor General's report, one of which, the recommendation on travel guidelines, was mentioned earlier. It seems there are other recommendations in the Comptroller and Auditor General's report that we need to examine in terms of learning lessons from this and applying them elsewhere.
Comment on this
There are three key areas and, having received the partnership report, one of those areas is to conduct an investigation into the outcome of that report. We also have to complete our investigation into the SKILL programme. Both those areas depend on the input of the conclusion of the SIPTU investigation. The third area is a value for money review of the SKILL training programme, the current phase of which runs up to the end of April. Therefore, a value for money process is under way to determine how we move forward the skill and development of the support staff in the health system into the future and what structures we need to put in place to underpin that. That is the work.
Comment on this
From the point of view of the Department of Finance, what are the lessons learned and what work needs to be completed?
Comment on this
As other witnesses have said, we need to finish our fact-finding elements in regard to the SIPTU report but the internal audit report, which we have received, has a number of recommendations and the Accounting Officer intends to proceed with implementing those immediately. The recommendations of the Comptroller and Auditor General and of the Committee of Public Accounts will inform the future response to the issues raised. I will conclude on that note.
Comment on this
I have a few questions. Do all the witnesses understand the perception we on the committee have that in regard to these matters there is something rotten in the state of Denmark? There is unexplained expenditure of public moneys. Do they accept that is where we are at still in regard to these transactions?
Comment on this
Absolutely. The absence of the rest of the information is perhaps understandably causing that perception.
Comment on this
A vital piece of the jigsaw, that of the SIPTU report, is outstanding. Have we any idea when that report will be available to enable us to get a comprehensive picture of the position?
Comment on this
I recently met the trustee subcommittee, the head of finance administration, the financial adviser and the general secretary of SIPTU who are working on this. They have a number of investigation elements under way. I understand it will be the new year before they expect to complete their report. They may want to interface with our internal audit staff to have access to the insight from our internal audit function as to how this fund operated and we understand that process will be set up. I understand the report will be completed in the new year but we do not have a date for that.
Comment on this
Now that the witnesses are aware of the multitude of questions arising on these matters, is it possible to get from the Department or the HSE a comprehensive analysis of what happened, from where the money came, what was done with it and whether the taxpayer got a reasonable return on that expenditure? Would such a report highlight who was responsible for incurring expenditure or its authorisation where it was inappropriately authorised? Will this committee get such a comprehensive analysis and, if so, from whom?
Comment on this
At the first meeting of the Committee of Public Accounts on this matter on 7 October, the HSE and I, as Accounting Officer, committed to come back to the committee today on the four investigations we have reported on and which were submitted to the committee last Friday. When we see the complete picture arising on completion of the SIPTU investigation, we will try to piece together the totality of this issue from point of view of the SKILL programme and that of a partnership forum and bring forward a synthesis of that based on the various individual reports that have emerged.
Comment on this
In terms of SIPTU, I reiterate that I also met SIPTU at its request on 10 November. The individuals I met were as anxious as I believe this committee is to get to the bottom of what was going on and to finish their investigation. They were very conscious of the damage to reputation in this respect. I met them at their request. I provided whatever documentation I could to them and said I would be happy to do anything more that I could to help them bring that to a conclusion.
On the Acting Chairman's second question, I would be happy to commit with Mr. Magee, as per his suggestion, that when we have all the facts we would bring forward a single joint assessment of the totality of the position.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Scanlan understand the continuing public disquiet about this? We are merely representing the public here. That disquiet has not been assuaged or allayed to any great degree during the course of the proceedings to date or up to today?
Comment on this
Mr. Magee may have a view on this but my short answer is that I do. This vacuum of the lack of completeness of information is very unfortunate and certainly it does not help. It may not be popular to say this but that continuing disquiet is also damaging the reputation of some individual civil servants in the Department who have put in very long days and very hard work. Because of the lack of the total picture, which the Acting Chairman has sought, the Department, the HSE and the SKILL programme are being damaged. The total picture is needed. There are obviously flaws but I agree with the Acting Chairman's point that there is disquiet about this.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Magee want to add a further comment before I call Deputy Rabbitte?
Deputy Bernard Allen resumed the Chair.
Comment on this
What is Mr. Scanlan's perception at the end of 2010 of the impact of these programmes on the industrial relations climate? Pretty much everybody has said that the fundamental purpose of these programmes was to improve the industrial relations climate and so on. Has that been achieved?
Comment on this
That is a big and a difficult question. When I was in the Department of Finance, I was involved in industrial relations in the health services at the time of the nurses' dispute at the end of negotiations on the PCW. In putting all this together, I cannot help but remember endless nights spent down in the LRC where my first encounter was an actual strike by paramedics, followed by a threatened strike by radiographers, laboratory technicians, a threatened strike by non-nursing staff and craft workers. On and on it went. There is a public view on this and I want to be careful not to get into policy issues but, having been involved in the discussions in Croke Park and the preceding ones in Government Buildings, there was, at a personal or relationship level, an attitude that we would not necessarily agree but we could work together. In the case of the health sector, I believe the programme of change that we got from the Croke Park agreement was not something we would have achieved previously. However, that is, in all honesty, probably as much a function of the times as the relationships.
Comment on this
In terms of trying to measure the value of the investment of public money and our current position with regard to the need for change, flexibility, the end of demarcation and plant lying idle for a large part of the week, although some of the caricatures are unfair it is the case that one cannot get a blood test after 3.30 p.m. or the consultants will not come in or if one is not operated on by noon on Thursday the operation will not take place until Monday morning. Investment would be very desirable if it helped change that. What prospect of significant change is on the horizon in that area?
Comment on this
I will give a couple of examples of actual change at a much smaller level and then return to the Deputy's question. Mr. Attley mentioned this previously with regard to upskilling the support staff, but that was part of upskilling nurses and so forth. Consider what has happened with nursing. Nurses can now issue prescriptions, order X-rays and they are starting to do IV cannulations. One is seeing change. What one is also seeing, and Mr. Attley is better able to describe this than me, is the health care assistants stepping up to do work which nurses did previously. This is part of the answer to the Deputy's question. Despite having trained up some health care assistants to do that work, we still had an industrial relations issue about them being allowed to do it. It went all the way to the National Implementation Body as recently as 2005, so the partnership is not a panacea.
In terms of moving forward, I keep returning to the fact that the issue of partnership, industrial relations and change is a very big question. It is a personal view but it I believe it will work best where there is, in a sense, an absolute need to do it or a crisis, where there is no other option. At the same time, one has developed relationships that might help one get over to that stage.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Magee have a view on it?
Comment on this
It is a difficult question. The HSE is completing its service plan for 2011 and will submit it to the Minister tomorrow. That plan is obviously funded on the basis of a significant funding reduction over 2010 of 6.6% net. It is higher at a gross level. Our success in protecting and continuing to provide the same level of services across the system as we did in 2010 with significantly less funding will be predicated on significant co-operation and engagement from our staff and from the representative staff associations. I would be hopeful that it is possible. All the soundings I have indicate that people recognise the challenges in our economy and in our system, and I am optimistic that there will be good engagement on the process of change from the representative unions across both the clinical and non-clinical areas. It is a very tough challenge. However, I am not aware of what the consequences of this will be within SIPTU, for example, and within the relationships between SIPTU and the HSE. We will have to work through the completion of this process to ensure we emerge from it with a stronger industrial relations process.
The governance issues that come to the fore here raise issues about linking accountability and governance, and confusing stakeholder involvement with governance and accountability. We must have greater clarity for all parties to ensure we do not confuse stakeholder engagement with governance and accountability within a public system. That is something we are already debating with the unions in the context of the partnership process and how it functions. If there is a huge learning from it, that is one that has emerged.
Comment on this
Before I call Deputy O'Brien, I have a question about the procurement issues in the IA report on SKILL procurement. With regard to the findings, a contract with a value of €60 million was not formally signed until February 2007. It was stated to the internal audit by SKILL management that negotiation on the contract contents was sought by the contractor's legal advisers and the HSE's legal advisers. Could somebody outline how the contracts were signed by unauthorised persons?
Comment on this
I will take that question. The contracts were approved by the HSE's board, as is appropriate. Under the HSE's national financial regulations we have set thresholds. Those thresholds state that contracts for in excess of €10 million must be approved by the HSE's board and signed by an appropriate officer. The main contract was with the City of Dublin Vocational Education Committee, known as the SKILLVEC. That contract has ultimately cost the HSE €15.7 million. When it was initially tendered, it was said that it was going to be €60 million. The contract was properly approved in December 2005 by the HSE board. It was then signed by Alan Smith who was general manager, who did not have the limit of authority to sign that contract. It was also signed by Mr. Attley as chairman of the steering group. As the audit report identifies, Mr. Attley was not an executive of the HSE. Therefore, the contract was properly approved by the board but it was incorrectly signed by unauthorised officials and Mr. Attley.
Comment on this
The audit looked at the award of the contract in detail. We found that there was significant confusion within the SKILL team in terms of the procurement issue. There are different processes in procurement which one can adopt - open procedure, restricted procedure and so forth. We found that there was confusion and the tender specifications were very vague and broad. When internal audit sought all the documentation relating to the tenders it was not there, which is quite inappropriate from a control perspective. As internal auditors we certainly were not satisfied with that.
We found that the SKILL people could not give us a definite number as to how many people might have tendered and tender valuation reports were not there at the time of audit. The Chairman will have noted from the report that on finalisation of the audit it was brought to our attention that the documentation had been located in storage in a voluntary hospital. Again, from an audit perspective, we were quite unhappy with that in terms of record retention. The HSE has a record retention policy and it is up to officials to identify where records are held at various stages. Overall, we found the control environment surrounding the procurement was not as strong as we would have liked or as the HSE's procurement regulations require.
Comment on this
Mr. Magee, what actions were taken by the HSE when these deficiencies were brought to the attention of senior management?
Comment on this
As I said in my statement, we have carried out a comprehensive review of compliance with, and adherence to, both travel procurement and payment arrangements across our system. We have also centralised control, from within SKILL and within partnership, of the accounting and administrative and executive functions.
We are confident that these breaches will not recur because of what we have put in place.
Comment on this
I apologise for the slight delay in getting here, but I have been watching the contributions on the monitor. I will not try to go back over old ground because a number of my colleagues have covered that. It is not just a question of perception, but also of control and the lack thereof. Since the establishment of the Health Services National Partnership Forum, how many internal audits have been carried out by the HSE's internal audit?
Comment on this
I will answer that question. The Health Services National Partnership Forum had its own internal audit function. It procured an internal auditor and several internal audit reports would have been completed, I believe on a quarterly basis, by that internal auditor.
Comment on this
Yes, absolutely. This person was procured externally by the HSNPF.
Comment on this
When one looks back at the details, particularly since 2004, procedures seem to have changed with regard to the fact that receipts were not required, and various things like that. How was the internal auditor procured by the HSNPF? Was there a proper competition for that? Were they directly appointed?
Comment on this
The Comptroller and Auditor General raised that point in one of the management letters going back over the years. There were issues around the procurement, as raised in the Comptroller and Auditor General's management letter. The person was procured on a one-year basis, which was subsequently extended by another year.
Comment on this
I can find that out for the Deputy now.
Comment on this
It was a company. I believe it was a sole trader called Accountancy and Business Solutions. The internal auditor's name was Hugh Quigley.
Comment on this
I think it was Accountancy and Business Solutions.
Comment on this
The Comptroller and Auditor General's management letter on the 2004 annual financial statements flagged that particular issue, which was that it did not comply with the procurement rules. Two tenders were received, one before the closing date, and opened at different times. The last tender was awarded the contract, so issues were flagged by the Comptroller and Auditor General.
Comment on this
That was flagged by the Comptroller and Auditor General in 2004. When were these internal auditors appointed by the HSNPF?
Comment on this
I believe that was in 2004. The tender was for one year.
Comment on this
So the Comptroller and Auditor General flagged the issue in 2004, which was within the time of the contract. Therefore, he flagged the issue at the time that the contract was not properly put out for procurement or through a proper competition process, is that right?
Comment on this
I believe he is still there, until the HSE internal audit comes in.
Comment on this
We must recall that the Accounting Officer for this body is the chief executive of the agency as well. The HSE is responsible. In 2004, the Comptroller and Auditor General clearly flagged the issue that an internal auditor - I am not making any inference with regard to this man or his company, or anything like that - was not properly procured, without any competition. We are now at the end of 2010. When did the HSE's internal audit start?
Comment on this
Up until the start of 2010, the HSE - and I would hold the HSE accountable for this because it is responsible - has done nothing about that.
Comment on this
As identified in the internal audit report, there was significant confusion in the HSNPF.
Comment on this
I am confused as well. I am trying to get to the bottom of it because I do not understand it.
Comment on this
It is clearly seen from the minutes that the HSNPF was unclear as to what its legal entity was and how it was set up. There was also some debate in the HSNPF as to the relationship with the HSE. We have identified that that is completely unacceptable. Essentially, it-----
Comment on this
I do not mean to cut across Dr. Smith, but I do not want to lose the point. Effectively, the HSNPF was not sure what its relationship was with the HSE, and what the roles within both bodies were. Was that confusion ever fed up the line so that someone would simply clarify that point?
Comment on this
No, it was not fed up the line. That is why we are here today as part of the partnership audit itself. There was ambiguity around it. Trade union officials and HSE officials were sitting on this partnership forum. By and large, they were an organisational forum in their own right, but the legitimacy of their being there and taking this quasi-legal status was obviously wrong.
Comment on this
-----they did not see fit to ask any questions that might have clarified the situation for them. How do we know that there was that element of uncertainty? Is it flagged in the minutes of their board meetings?
Comment on this
Some of the minutes of board meetings going back as far as 2006 highlight this.
Comment on this
It is incredible and simply beggars belief. Getting back to the point therefore, the appointment of the internal auditor is crucially important. Just last week, this committee published a report on procurement in the public sector, because it is an issue we see across all bodies. To be fair, there are areas where it works well and others where it does not, so we are not inclined to be overly critical of it. I really do not understand it, however. Can somebody explain how, in the first year that this person was appointed, the Comptroller and Auditor General flagged this matter in 2004? Do we have a copy of the management note which the comptroller sent to the HSE? I presume the Comptroller and Auditor General sent that to the HSE.
Comment on this
Not until 2005. Obviously, the HSE did not come into being until 2005.
Comment on this
Who is the responsible person, or liaison person, in the HSE for oversight of the HSNPF?
Comment on this
The creation of the HSNPF had a quorum of employers on it. Obviously, it had the HSE, and other sections 38 and 39 disability employers on it. The person responsible for the HSNPF, or the link into the HSE, was the HR director or HR team at that stage.
Comment on this
The HSE was established in 2005, so it knew about it in 2005. The HSE's HR director knew that there was a major issue there - that the internal auditor was appointed without procedures being followed. That was clearly stated by the Comptroller and Auditor General. Do we have a copy of that management note anywhere?
Comment on this
I can read the reply which we got on 7 December 2005 from Mr. Larry Walsh, director. He said that at the time of appointment of the internal auditor, a formal procurement policy was not in place. On the advice of the Comptroller and Auditor General a tendering process was initiated. Three firms were asked to submit tenders to the outline specification, so clearly he specified what he wanted. Two firms responded to the tender, while the third advised that they would not tender for the position. In order to have a broader choice of options, a further three firms were asked to tender, of which one responded, while the others did not make any contact. In all, six firms were invited to tender and three responded. Copies of the three tenders are held on file. Two tenderers responded by email, with one following up with a hard copy. The criteria used were quality of service being offered, compliance with the request for proposals and costs. Of the two firms which were competitive on cost, the selected firm was deemed to offer the best value. He finished by stating that a formal policy has now been adopted which is compliant with the Health Service Executive procurement policy, and he attached a copy. There was this broad rectification of the position.
Comment on this
Was that rectified in 2005? Is Mr. Buckley happy that it was properly put out to competition in 2005?
Comment on this
I will have to check that and get back to the Deputy.
Comment on this
I believe the contract was for one year and then it was subsequently renewed for another year. To the best of my knowledge, one of the issues was that it had continued to roll on.
Comment on this
I do not mean to dwell on this point. I will move on in a minute, but it is an important point. It was put out to tender in 2005. The firm that held the role of internal auditor retained that position for a year, which would have brought it up to 2006. Were any contracts after that signed then or was the contract simply rolled over right the way through?
Comment on this
I believe the contract has rolled over, but I would need to double-check that.
Comment on this
That is something we might check. What was the total cost of that contract to the HSNPF?
Comment on this
The cost, from 2005 to 2009, was €85,734.
Comment on this
Yes. From what I can gather, there appears to be a quarterly internal audit report.
Comment on this
On the HSE's internal audit report earlier this year, the HSE - even though the chief executive of the HSE is effectively the Accounting Officer for this body - internal auditor never carried out an audit up until when?
Comment on this
As part of our audit planning process, we ask management to have input into the plan to identify various areas. Having carried out the audit - we have seen the element of confusion - there certainly was a belief within HSNPF that it was separate to the HSE. It is completely unacceptable, but that is exactly what we have identified in the audit.
Comment on this
Did the HSE understand that the HSNPF was separate to it? Was it understood within the HSE that the chief executive of the HSE is the Accounting Officer of this body?
Comment on this
I do not believe it was understood at the time, going back to 2005. It was an amalgamation of employers, trade unions and other bodies which came together under the HSNPF. It was created under a partnership agreement in 2000. It established its own office, its own constitution, its own rules, and its own bank accounts. Until we got the internal audit in to look at this, it was an organisation very much at a satellite away from the HSE but the bottom line is that we were accountable for it.
Comment on this
Does the HSE understand why I, and probably many others, find that completely unacceptable? It is the HSE and, ironically, we are talking about a partnership forum that could not partner with its own senior body, and where the HSE and the HSNPF were not sure where they stood. There were hundreds and thousands of people going on partnership training courses and yet the two organisations were not even talking to each other. Perhaps Mr. Magee can throw some light on this. I just do not understand this.
Comment on this
In my opening statement on 7 October and my statement on partnership, there is a common theme. Deputy O'Brien is correct. The HSE had accounting responsibility for the operation of the SKILL programme and the operation of the partnership programme from 2005 when it was set up. There is no ambiguity about that. Nonetheless, as I made the qualitative comment, confusion existed around governance because of the separateness and the engagement of stakeholders. That governance arrangement, which involved the staff side and the management side, was kind of physically separated in terms of office and administration, and separate bank accounts.
Comment on this
The partnership forum embraced employers outside of the HSE statutory hospital or operating entity group. It included voluntary organisations and, as the HR director stated, some voluntary organisations that are grant-aided by it. It was a broader group. Nonetheless, accounting responsibility resided with HSE, but it allowed a governance arrangement to take place which created an artificial construct that it was a separate organisation, had separate audit and had separate bank accounts. That is at the core of the problem.
Comment on this
It is. In fairness, that is a reasonable explanation for what happened. I am not disputing that. Neither do I want to take away from much good work which I am certain has been done in the organisation over the time.
Comment on this
What Mr. McGrath has clarified for me is that the HR director of the HSE sat on the board of the HSNPF where confusion reigned on whether it was a separate body, whether it was accountable to the HSE and on its Accounting Officer. If that is covered in the minutes of board meetings dating back to 2005 or 2006,-----
Comment on this
-----I do not understand why it would take until earlier in 2010, when the HSE sent in its internal auditors, to figure out that the HSE was responsible for this. Was there no communication? Did no reports go to the HSE at a senior level on what this organisation did? Did the HSE know what it did?
Comment on this
The organisation of the HSE knew. There were service managers at a very senior level on the forum and there were previous HR directors, or service managers, as co-chair of this, and the funding came from the HSE into the HSNPF.
Comment on this
Because it seemed to be a different organisational forum at a satellite away from the HSE, it continued on in this blissful ignorance that it was a separate organisation with separate bank accounts and operated at a tangent away.
Comment on this
The HSE also carried on in blissful ignorance that the HSNPF was separate to the HSE.
Comment on this
I am not saying Mr. McGrath personally did, but the HSE as an organisation did. What is the total funding to date that the HSE has passed on to this organisation?
Comment on this
The Department of Health and Children would have been responsible up until 2004 and funding would have come from the Department. From 2005 onwards, the HSE would have been responsible. From 1999 to 2009, in total, grants of €39 million, APPM funding of €1.355 million,-----
Comment on this
Action Plan for People Management. Some miscellaneous income would have been earned, giving a total income of €41.155 million.
Comment on this
Including the period of the Department of Health and Children prior to the establishment of the HSE - to call a spade a spade - the parent body, be it the Department or the HSE, gave this organisation €41 million and did not send an internal auditor into this organisation, established since 1999, until the start of this year. The HSE was happy to give the money out, but without the understanding that the HSE was the Accounting Officer, and the HSE had the HR director of the HSE and senior HSE staff sitting on its board.
Comment on this
Tell us about the role of the trustees and their reservations about what was happening. First, who were they?
Comment on this
We had various trustees over the years. I will give a little background as to the role the trustees played. In the rules and constitution of the HSNPF which the HSNPF itself set up, there is a provision for trustees. The role of the latter relates to cheque payments, etc. There are four trustees at all times, two from the management side and two from the union side. Again, over the years there have been various trustees. If it would be of assistance, I will provide a list of the current trustees. They are: Mr. David Hughes from the Irish Nursing and Midwifery Organisation, INMO, who has been a trustee from 2000 to the present and a signatory from 2003 to the present; Ms Nora Mason, a HSE assistant national director of HR, who has been a trustee from 2000 to the present; and Mr. Sé O'Connor, also a HSE assistant national director of HR, who has been a trustee from 2009 to the present. There is currently a vacancy for the fourth position. As already stated, there have been other trustees over the years but there are always two from the management side and two from the union side.
Comment on this
Did the trustees ever express reservations on matters of governance? If so, what happened?
Comment on this
They did do so. The minutes indicate that the reservations about governance seemed to materialise in 2009, which was after the director's retirement. The director was the chief operating officer.
Comment on this
Yes, Mr. Larry Walsh. The latter retired on 3 March 2009. As already stated, the director was the chief operating officer and had responsibility for all the administration and activities of the HSNPF. The trustees expressed concern after Mr. Walsh's retirement, when there was no director in place, to the effect that they appeared to be taking on the role of executive responsibility. In one instance - this is apparent from reviewing the minutes - one of the trustees asked how he could stand over the cheque payments. He was not casting any doubts on the staff or anything of that nature but he was concerned, in light of the governance arrangements, with regard to how the trustees were to know that the information they were receiving was proper, etc. That concern was expressed after the director's retirement.
Comment on this
It would be fair to say that the HSNPF carried out quarterly internal audits. In that context, there did not appear to be any question of anything wrong being done. I will not mention it again but I cannot fathom how senior people in both organisations could not understand the relationship that one had with the other. That is the fundamental point. The HSE sent its internal auditors in earlier in the year. The executive is now clear with regard to who reports to it and Mr. Magee is aware of the areas in respect of which he is Accounting Officer. However, are there any autonomous or semi-autonomous bodies which come within the HSE's remit in respect of which any confusion exists?
Comment on this
No, not that I am aware of. The SKILL programme and this particular organisation were the two that were-----
Comment on this
I have no desire to belabour the point, particularly as we have engaged in a great deal of discussion on this matter. However, one must consider the amount of money invested in the SKILL programme. How much money did the Department and the HSE put into this programme?
Comment on this
In the core SKILL programme, some €48 million or €49 million was invested. However, that was not the grant.
Comment on this
No. Essentially, with the exception of €2.75 million, all of the money came from the HSE. The SKILL programme was established at the end of 2004 and only really took off in 2005.
Comment on this
It is just a question of when the changeover-----
Comment on this
Some €2.75 million was sanctioned by us in 2004. Thereafter, I think €13 million per year was spent on the programme.
Comment on this
So the Department invested €2.75 million in 2004. What has been the level of investment by the HSE since then?
Comment on this
So over €14.5 million has been spent on the programme each year. What drives me and others mad in respect of this matter is that the success of the programme was not properly evaluated. Deputy Shortall referred to this matter earlier. The committee has not yet disposed of chapter 40 of the Comptroller and Auditor General's report, which relates to the Dublin ambulance service and in respect of which the HSE has responsibility. In excess of €14.5 million has been spent on the SKILL programme on an annual basis for a number of years. In the Swords area, which I represent, the HSE will not sanction expenditure of €600,000 and is seeking to remove one of the ambulances that operates there. Some 4,500 calls are dealt with by the ambulance service in the area each year. It is this type of issue which gives rise to concern among communities. I am not seeking to denigrate the work those in the HSE are doing. However, when matters such as that which we are discussing arise, it is front line services which suffer.
In trying to explain the value of the SKILL programme, our guests are fighting a losing battle. Some €14.5 million is being spent on this programme, whereas the ambulance service in Swords can be run for €600,000. In addition, if some of the money spent on the SKILL programme were diverted, the three ambulances that have been removed from service in County Offaly could be restored.
Comment on this
I apologise. That makes it even worse and that is what gives rise to people's frustration. I fully accept that the HSE has carried out its internal audit. We have had many meetings with the representatives from the Department of Health and Children and the HSE at which it has been stated that procedures will be changed going forward. I am confident that this will happen. However, we must consider the procurement issues that arise on a continual basis and the fact that the role of the chief executive of the HSE as its Accounting Officer was not understood from its establishment in 2005 up until this year. The latter is incredible.
I am not stating that all of the €41 million in question has been wasted. However, we must ask how many front-line services were adversely affected as a result of €14.5 million spent each year on the SKILL programme. The committee received correspondence this week in respect of the Dublin ambulance service. As already stated, it is not possible to obtain €600,000 to run an ambulance service which responds to 4,500 calls each year. How do our guests square the circle in that regard?
Comment on this
In respect of the SKILL programme, we have a value-for-money audit. Most of the resources apart from the €2.75 million to which the Secretary General referred was invested in training development, both through funding of backfilling and through the training development programmes. Those programmes have been very successful but we still need to evaluate whether we are obtaining the best value for our spend on training.
Comment on this
Did the HSE carry out spot checks in respect of the results relating to the training programmes? What sort of success rates have been achieved and have the programmes being properly evaluated?
Comment on this
Sporadic spot checks have been carried out since 2004. Mr. Attley referred to Pearn Kandola carrying out a value-for-money analysis in respect of one or two programmes which operated within hospital settings. Organisationally, a full value-for-money audit in respect of the entire SKILL programme since its inception in 2005 is under way. This analysis is being carried out on foot of one of the recommendations in the report. The work in this regard is ongoing.
Comment on this
Much of the funding went to partnership projects and developments across the entire health system. The real issue that arises relates to the moneys spent on foreign trips, the value-for-money dimension relating thereto, the process within which such trips were either approved or authorised and the controls that applied. That key issue has undermined both the SKILL programme and many partnership projects funded throughout the health system. The governance issues, the confusion around accountability and the fact that these entities operate as satellites separate from the mainstream HSE accounting control led to the difficulties that emerged in our audit.
Comment on this
Mr. Magee is correct but I would like him to square the circle. I have mentioned an example of the reduction in front-line services in my area. This was raised previously and we have not disposed of that chapter of the report yet. How does an Oireachtas Member or a Government, no matter its composition, explain that we can have such a spend on this programme but the HSE wants to take an ambulance out of Swords or, for example, three out of County Offaly to reduce front-line services?
Comment on this
We have taken a number of actions to close down the accounts and the separate funding of these programmes. I agree with the Deputy that we are looking at a challenging environment next year, given our funding situation. The obligation is on me, as Accounting Officer and chief executive officer, and my management team to ensure we use the scarce resources we have to best effect through the system.
Comment on this
I appreciate the answers being given by the Department and the HSE but I am trying to get to the bottom of a number of issues. I hope serious lessons have been learned. I do not get to talk to Mr. Magee very often. The HSE's service plan will be submitted tomorrow. Priority must be given to front-line services and we must examine whether these programmes are valuable. Mr. Magee mentioned resources are scarcer than last year but this a fundamental issue. The reason I raise this is these issues make it difficult when the public looks in on what we are doing. We are trying to protect public services and people wonder why this the SKILL programme is important and an ambulance in Swords is not.
The governance of all bodies overseeing such programmes and not only this body where senior HSE directors sit on the board is an issue. I expected directors to have reported back to the executive. When the HR director of the executive is on a board, an annual statement, at the very least, should be submitted to outline what is happening. There is confusion. The body is not sure whether the HSE is controlling it or vice versa. One hopes that will be clarified now for all organisations connected to the executive.
Comment on this
Regarding the responses we received regarding procurement, how did Mr. Attley sign a contract he was unauthorised to sign? What is his explanation for that?
Comment on this
This is the first time I have heard that I had not been authorised to sign it. I have just checked the minute. The procedure was the board approved it. The general manager went to the board and got approval for it. He came to the next SKILL meeting to say that the board had approved it and then he asked me to sign it. I asked him why me and he said he and I were the appropriate persons to sign after the board had approved it.
Comment on this
I am finding out now it was totally wrong. Has Mr. Smith said anything?
Comment on this
No, we have not been able to discuss this with Mr. Smith.
Comment on this
I did not have an opportunity to address questions to the HSE earlier. I am beginning to think we need a map to direct us around the different bodies, funds and so on. I accept there has been a flurry of activity recently on the part of the HSE but this should not mask the fact that it was accountable for the SKILL programme, which was allocated €47 million, and for the partnership forum, which was allocated €41 million. It beggars belief that both organisations could have existed within the HSE for so long while spending so much money without anyone at senior management level doing anything to ensure there was adequate corporate governance or proper accountability. How could have that arisen? How could there have been that level of spend without accountability?
Comment on this
As I said in my two opening statements, a breakdown in governance and in the accountability processes within the HSE occurred. The only way it can be explained is there was confusion around governance in these joint management-union entities both within SKILL and within partnership. I do not think there should have been confusion. The accounting responsibility of the HSE was there from 2005. They were staff of the HSE and they were employed by the HSE. They were paid and the funds came through the HSE. The general point I made is the governance and accountability roles got confused with stakeholder engagement and involvement and that is at the heart of the problem.
Comment on this
That is fine for some organisations but with regard to the SKILL programme, this issue was fundamental to the skills and qualifications of HSE staff. Why is a value for money report only being done on that now?
Comment on this
It certainly came out of the internal audit report that we would do a full value for money audit on the whole SKILL programme.
Comment on this
Did no one from the HSE ask, going back to 2005, whether value for money was being achieved in spending the money on training?
Comment on this
Not within the HSE but we had HSE officials on the steering group of SKILL. Periodically, value for money audits were done within the programme itself but no one corporately within the senior management team, from what I can gather, looked for a value for money audit on the total spend on SKILL.
Comment on this
The position has changed somewhat from the previous meeting we had on this on 7 October where the impression was very much given by the HSE that this was predominantly a union problem. That was the impression that was sought to be given in regard to some of these issues. It now transpires, however, that there were fundamental branches of accountability within the executive in respect of both programmes going back many years. I accept fully that Mr. McGrath has only been around since 2008 and Mr. Magee was not around. I refer to the report produced by Mr. Turlough O'Sullivan on foreign travel. Did this travel relate only to the levy fund?
Comment on this
That foreign travel relates only to what we found from the SKILL programme and the partnership.
Comment on this
Has the Department examined foreign travel under the partnership forum?
Comment on this
No, that is a work in progress. As the Deputy will be aware, we got the internal audit report last week. We have to conduct our own investigations regarding that now.
Comment on this
Has the Department commissioned anyone to examine the larger spends over which there are many question marks relating to the SKILL programme and the partnership forum?
Comment on this
We have commissioned Ernst & Young to do a full value for money audit on the overall programme since its inception in 2005 and that was a recommendation in the internal audit report. We have started that process and they are currently doing their work.
Comment on this
The level of incompetence and lack of accountability in the HSE going back to its foundation in 2005 is mind boggling. These two programmes were running and nobody asked any questions about them.
Comment on this
On the point about accountability, in my opening statement at the committee meeting on 7 December, I said that even though there was a lack of clarity surrounding the governance of the SKILL programme, given its origins, nonetheless and notwithstanding that, the HSE had accounting responsibility for the disbursement of the funding grant for 2005 and that it should have sought clarity from the Department of Health and Children on the issue and satisfied itself about adequate controls, validation and value for money. There is no argument from me nor from the HSE about our accounting responsibility for the operation and we did not apportion that accounting responsibility to any other body.
Comment on this
I wish to explore two aspects, the first being foreign travel by HSE staff. We know from the O'Sullivan report on the foreign travel associated with the SKILL programme that 12 HSE staff participated in various trips at a cost of €26,000. I will put the same question to Mr. Magee as I put to the two Departments. Does he accept it was completely inappropriate that HSE staff should have been participating in foreign trips funded through an account controlled by two trade union officials?
Comment on this
Is Mr. Magee taking any disciplinary action against those 12 staff?
Comment on this
The HSE has two reports, the audit report and the Turlough O'Sullivan report and we await the outcome of the conclusion of the SIPTU investigation before drawing conclusions with regard to the involvement of HSE personnel.
Comment on this
Has the HSE reissued guidelines to staff with regard to foreign travel?
Comment on this
Are these new or existing guidelines?
Comment on this
In the original statement it was a case of adherence to guidelines rather than the inadequacy of our controls but we have reissued the approval arrangements for foreign travel in particular and for expenses. It was a breach of existing regulations in some cases, not the absence of those.
Comment on this
Again the question must be asked, given it was general knowledge that this carry-on was taking place, how come nobody in the HSE did anything about it. I presume Mr. McGrath was aware of it.
Comment on this
We did do something about it. When I came into office I asked internal audit to do an audit-----
Comment on this
Eventually. It took a bit of time. I do not know how long Dr. Smith has been in her position.
Comment on this
I have been with the ERHA, Eastern Regional Health Authority, since 2000 and I certainly did not know about foreign travel being funded through an outside account.
Comment on this
Did Dr. Smith know many HSE officials were going off on trips?
Comment on this
Mr. O'Sullivan's report states it was general knowledge within the health sector that this was going on. It is difficult to accept there was not an awareness at senior management level. One would have to ask why nothing was done about it.
My other question is to do with this famous partnership forum. I ask Mr. McGrath to tell the committee the purpose of this forum and what it does.
Comment on this
The forum was set out as a result of a partnership agreement in 1999 or 2000. Its purpose was to foster partnership at local level among the trade unions affiliated to the Irish Congress of Trade Unions and the wider scope of employers and trade unions not affiliated to congress. It was composed of the HSE, the Department and other voluntary organisations and representatives of the employers and the wider staff. The purpose of the forum was to ensure ongoing collaboration when required on particular projects. One of these projects was referred to in the audit report as being the action plan for people management, a plan to implement a people management structure and programmes within the organisation.
Comment on this
That was a total of €1.3 million.
Comment on this
We are talking about a figure of €41 million spent by the partnership forum. What on earth did it spend that money on?
Comment on this
I will answer that question. Reviewing the annual financial statements, €40.857 million approximately was spent in the period from 1999 to 2009. A significant amount of that sum was spent on grants to partnership committees and various grants to partnership projects.
Comment on this
What does that mean? I do not understand what is meant by partnership committees and partnership projects.
Comment on this
It was a national partnership forum but partnership facilitators were in place within each location such as a hospital or a primary care area or at regional level. These facilitators mirrored what was happening at national level and had a whole suite of different projects and activities at local level as well as national level.
Comment on this
I still fail to understand what Mr. McGrath means by the phrase, "a whole suite of activities".
Comment on this
They are listed in an appendix to the audit report. For example, the development and implementation of a health promotion strategy for St. James's Hospital staff. This would have been proposed by St. James's Hospital partnership committee and it would be regarded by the HSE as a very good project to undertake. A business case would have been submitted and funding sought from the partnership national committee through the local partnership facilitator. The funding would have been given to finance that project. We had a whole suite of different projects and over the course of the ten years the funding referred to by Dr. Smith was used in that way.
Comment on this
How many staff were involved in this organisation?
Comment on this
In total, just 22 or 23 staff. The majority are facilitators in the regions.
Comment on this
I believe this body no longer exists.
Comment on this
The individuals are still there. We have closed their bank account and we have mainstreamed all their financial records and they are now reporting into the human resources directorate, which means they are reporting to me.
Comment on this
Yes, the staff remain. They are HSE staff on the HSE payroll. We will seek to deploy them into the areas in which they currently operate.
Comment on this
Were the 22 staff always HSE staff?
Comment on this
Therefore their pay does not come out of the €41 million.
Comment on this
I believe it does; it includes €10 million for salaries.
Comment on this
They are now back within the fold and working in the normal way.
Comment on this
Who sanctioned the standing down of the forum? Was sanction required from the Department?
Comment on this
These individuals are HSE staff. We engaged with the forum regarding the bank accounts and the activities of the forum. This has been an ongoing engagement over several months. We have sought to make best use of the skills of these staff.
Comment on this
How much was in the account when the HSE closed it?
Comment on this
In total the deposit account held €1.3 million and the current account held €33,000 and a partnership account held €127,000. This is a total of just below €1.5 million and that account has been closed.
Comment on this
These are three different accounts which were in operation. There is a whole other day's examination in this about who had control of the accounts and how much of that money went on foreign travel. That is entirely separate to the other issues about foreign travel. What is known about the level of money diverted from this partnership fund to use for foreign travel?
Comment on this
I will answer that question. The first point to emphasise is that the travel was reflected in the books of the partnership forum. The audit identified a total of 21 trips but of those trips we had previously identified five trips related to the SKILL programme which had been funded through the SIPTU national health and local authority level fund. Essentially, 16 trips were fully funded through the partnership forum. A list of those trips is included as an appendix to the audit report. I will read out details of some of those trips as an assistance to the committee. I can tell the Deputy, in response to her question, that the total cost of the 16 trips was €146,680. I have the analysis here. We have identified that between 2001 and 2009, there were three trips to London, two trips to Stockholm, one trip to Moscow, two trips to Belgium, one trip to Barcelona, one trip to Lyon, one trip to Paris, two trips to Scotland, one trip to Boston and two trips to New York. They are in addition to the trips we identified as having been funded through SIPTU's national health and local authority levy fund.
Comment on this
It keeps going on and on. I was surprised that Mr. O'Sullivan was asked to compile this report. This is essentially about the excesses of partnership over the past decade. Mr. O'Sullivan was the public face of IBEC, which was one of the main partners. I thought it was a strange choice of person to look at this area. What was the reason for that choice?
Comment on this
We felt he was an appropriate person to investigate it because he was familiar with partnership.
Comment on this
Was that not the problem? The problem was the way partnership operated. I refer to the lack of accountability, the jollies and the taxis everywhere. That was the problem. They were the excesses of partnership. Mr. McGrath brought in one of the key players in partnership to examine the matter.
Comment on this
It was someone who was outside the public sector. A number of people could have been facilitated to do this role. It was decided that Mr. O'Sullivan was the person.
Comment on this
Did Mr. McGrath not think he was conflicted given that this was about partnership and how partnership operated in practice?
Comment on this
I thought it was a strange choice. We need to take stock and decide where we are going with this.
Comment on this
We do. What has happened to the official from the Department of Finance that was involved? Is he still with the Department or has he retired?
Comment on this
I do not really know what he is doing now.
Comment on this
Does the Department have any guidelines on people who retire, for example to provide that they should not get involved in any work with Departments or Government-funded agencies?
Comment on this
There are limited guidelines for very senior people. I do not believe there are guidelines that would cover his situation. I can check that. I do not believe there were guidelines that would have prevented him from working in particular areas. The only qualification is that he may have retired under the incentivised scheme for early retirement, to which specific conditions about re-engagement with the public sector are attached. I can confirm the details of that and revert to the committee.
Comment on this
That would be appreciated. Unfortunately, we must finish now. I understand the SIPTU report was discussed when I was absent for a few moments. It was suggested that the absence of the report has created difficulties for the Comptroller and Auditor General. I find it frustrating and annoying that the business of the committee is being held up by the absence of the SIPTU report. Mr. Scanlan and Mr. Magee told us in their evidence that they cannot arrive at their conclusions in the absence of the report. To put it bluntly, two individuals who have questions to answer are holding up the SIPTU report. They commissioned a report of their own. I would like to know who is paying for it. They are holding up the finalisation of the SIPTU report. We were not given the courtesy of a telephone call from SIPTU to say the report was not coming to us until we made a call last evening to find out where it was.
The committee cannot tolerate its business undertaken on behalf of the taxpayer being held up by the absence of the SIPTU report. I ask the representatives of the HSE, which has direct responsibility in this regard, to demand that the report be furnished to the committee before the end of the year. We need to consider it and the HSE needs to consider it before we meet again at this forum in January. The lifespan of this committee is limited. We want to come to a conclusion on this whole area before an election is called and we go out of business. Maybe that is what some people are hoping for. We want to get the SIPTU report in time for our next meeting, which is scheduled for the second or third week of January. The games have to stop. I believe people are using a report that was commissioned by themselves, and perhaps is being paid for with taxpayers' money again, to hold up our proceedings. It has to stop. The HSE has direct responsibility. I am saying it. We have to get on with it.
Comment on this
As the committee intends to resume its consideration of this matter at a future stage, I will not make any comment at this stage.
Comment on this
I thank everybody for their attendance. We will resume our discussion on this area in January. As this is the committee's last meeting before Christmas, I wish everybody the season's greetings. I thank the members of the committee. I thank Mr. Buckley and his staff for their help during the year. I thank our own staff, of course.
The witnesses withdrew.