We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Cork Institute of Technology: Financial Statements 2013

Contributions 208–424 of 645. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Mr. Seamus McCarthy

I will repeat the point I made earlier. Owing to the way financial reporting is done in the education sector, more of the institutions are coming to the attention of the committee. The HSE has a systemic problem; it is significant in that organisation. With regard to the list in front of the committee members, I have reported previously that there is non-competitive procurement of goods and services in the National College of Art and Design in the order of almost 100%. That is why there is no figure appearing in the document regarding that college. For the other colleges, I refer to the exceptions that have been found. I would not describe the problem as being systemic in the other colleges but it is significant.

Comment on this

That is fair enough. Professor Donnelly, there is a bigger subtext in respect of the current status of Waterford Institute of Technology. With regard to what we have been dealing with in respect of the institute, namely, regularising what seems to have taken place, we are at a point where we must move on, as the Controller and Auditor General is making clear. Financial systems and the health of the institute have been dealt with. Since the Comptroller and Auditor was there in April, he contributed an awful lot to that. We are at the point of moving on but the more significant subtext concerns the status of the merger with the institute in Carlow. That has always been the bigger issue. Could we have a status report on the merger? I understand it is in phase 2 and that it is expected that could be completed early next year.

Comment on this
Professor Willie Donnelly

I am on the record as saying the major challenge for the south east is the university for the south east. I have worked on this for 22 years. As people now know, we started a facilitation process involving ourselves and those concerned in Carlow. That has gone very well and we have a very good relationship with the president in Carlow. We are now at a stage where we can review the next phase in the development, which will be the engagement of the two governing bodies and, following that, the engagement of the executive. I am confident that the process is where it should be at this stage and that we should move forward in the right direction.

Comment on this

As far as timelines are concerned, could we have an update on when Professor Donnelly expects the next phase to be completed, if all goes well?

Comment on this
Professor Willie Donnelly

The next phase is vital. I would prefer not to give a timeline but to say we have to build the proper foundation. Things fell apart before because the foundation was not in place. The consequent recovery phase was pretty difficult for everybody. We do not want to go there again; we want to get it right and have a university of real quality for the region. That is what we are focusing on. It is best to ensure we get everything right and move forward rather than setting some unrealistic date on which everybody is focused rather than the process and the way we engage with one another.

Comment on this

That is understandable. I understand the input of Mr. Ó Foghlú is critical in this. Obviously, his oversight is ongoing. Could he comment on the process?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

Obviously, it is principally a matter for the two institutes but given the Government's priority in this area, we are supporting the engagement of the facilitator we discussed at the last meeting. In fact, the facilitator was chosen in light of her experience of facilitation. We are actually expanding the amount of facilitation to host a number of further meetings to assist in what Professor Donnelly has referred to. We are confident that the two institutes are working well together. The Minister committed additional funding of €2 million for next year to support all the technological institutes in consolidating in respect of applications for technological university status. The HEA is currently going through a process, using additional funding it has made available from within its own overall budget, to have applications from various higher education institutions that are seeking to move towards amalgamation. They are going through that process at present. We are making additional funding available towards supporting this and to help the Minister's assistants in expanding both the loan for the Carriganore sports complex and the timescale for the loan. This is also support for WIT-----

Comment on this

The Department's financial backing for these initiatives is an indication of its support. That is fair enough and clear.

Professor Donnelly's statement on the Chinese market was interesting. I acknowledge it is probably non-compliant; we will not go there. How did the officials get on? I realise the professor’s institute is not the only one that has considered the Chinese market and tried to attract Chinese students. Was the successful? Is the process ongoing?

Comment on this
Professor Willie Donnelly

It is ongoing. We were one of the first to enter that market. We have a good history in China. It is a very good market for us. We have many students from China. It is an important market, not only educationally but also economically. The educational and economic links are connected. It is a market that we prioritised and continue to prioritise and develop.

Comment on this

It is fair to say that both the Chairman and I have spoken about Waterford and Carlow institutes of technology outside these meetings. We have had a good few meetings in the past three or four years. The purpose of today’s meeting was really to draw a line under the issues that have dogged the institute in Waterford in the recent past. Apart from the issue concerning Mr. Byrne, it is fair to say, and there is agreement, that this has been achieved. For the first time, the direction that Waterford Institute of Technology is going financially with IT Carlow is extremely positive.

I wish to clear up a matter that concerns the Controller and Auditor General and audit committees. There was a point in my brief referring to the institute’s audit committee not issuing an annual report to the governing body until September 2014. That is the point I was trying to make.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

There is a requirement in the code that the audit committee should report on its proceedings but it felt it was not in a position to do that and did not submit the report on the year 2012–13 until more than a year later. I believe the date was in September 2014. Obviously, there is reliance in the governance of an institution on the audit committee and, therefore, it is important that internal auditing processes and audit committees be functioning. The college has disclosed that this was a problem in the SIFC. I drew attention to it because it is a significant matter.

Comment on this

I was just seeking clarification.

Comment on this

I thank everybody for their contributions on the institutes around the country. I am very conscious that the HEA manages a fund worth €2.5 billion. There are 170,000 students in higher education and over 17,000 staff. These figures have a bearing on growth in the economy. It is important that there be regional development and a connection with IDA Ireland. Last week, the Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation, Deputy Richard Bruton, made a big announcement in IT, Sligo, on the potential for developing a high-tech company in conjunction with IDA Ireland.

I have no doubt but that, with a fund of €2.5 billion, 170,000 students and 17,000 staff, issues will arise.

With regard to footprints and reconfiguration, a similar debate to that with regard to the institutes of technology in Waterford and Carlow is taking place in Sligo with regard to the institute of technology there, along with Letterkenny IT and GMIT. What are the issues and challenges? How have the numerous protected disclosures been managed? It is hard to imagine there would not be issues given the scale of the funding and the number of staff and students.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Boland

The key outcome the Government and the Irish people should expect for an investment of €2.5 billion is that the higher education sector provides the skills and related competencies needed by the economy, the IDA and society more generally. In the past two years, we have introduced a very specific system for assessing the performance of the sector and the performance of individual institutions against stated national objectives. This strategic dialogue, or performance management, tool is very valuable to ensure the higher education sector delivers what it is supposed to deliver. In addition, we have a robust system of governance and accountability for the higher education sector. There is no dispute among the institutions or anybody else that all of the institutions are accountable to the Government through the HEA and the Department of Education and Skills for every cent they spend, and by and large the system of governance works well.

Deputy McDonald mentioned earlier that procurement is honoured more in the breach than in the observance, and in fairness I take issue with this. Procurement in any one year amounts to approximately €1 billion and, overwhelmingly, it is done properly. This is not in any way to excuse those instances in which it is not done properly, and there is zero tolerance of these types of departure from the norm, although putting it into practice can be somewhat difficult. By and large, there is a strong higher education system delivering what Ireland needs. It is well governed at institutional level and there is a good governance and accountability system in place. I have said before that no system of governance is exempt from human error, and it will happen. The particular job of the HEA is to ensure when it does happen that proper action is taken so it does not happen again.

Comment on this

There are 170,000 students in the system. Foreign direct investment is driven by the huge acclamation of the calibre of the students and graduates that we have. We also have SMEs in the Enterprise Ireland portfolio. Is there much collaboration? Sligo Institute of Technology works very closely with start-up companies through facilitation of low rent for accommodation. I have observed the recognition of the institutes of technology, their partnership with SMEs and their support for foreign direct investment. Is it fair to say much foreign direct investment is based on a very efficient institute facility. Sligo has several thousand students, and companies consider the calibre of the students with IT degrees or qualifications in forensic science. Is this the engine of growth for foreign direct investment? We have a regional development plan, but it is very much focused on the calibre of students. It is important to recognise the role of the HEA with regard to the institutes of technology. Do we have 19 institutes of technology?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Boland

We have 21 institutes of technology and universities and a small number of other institutions.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Boland agree that the institutes of technology are more focused than the universities on industry?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Boland

A key requirement of the higher education system is to liaise closely with the economy, business and enterprise and, increasingly, institutions are doing so. This is without any dilution of the broader mission of education as we all understand it. It is very evident that a significant factor in attracting foreign direct investment to the country is the availability of skilled graduates. The institution in Sligo is a particularly good example of an institution that works very well locally and nationally in identifying skills needs.

Comment on this

Procurement was mentioned. How does the national procurement office work? There can be anomalies and there are always matters that are not correct. Given the amount of €2.5 billion and the number of purchasing managers in each college, is there much involvement with Mr. Quinn's office on procurement issues?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Boland

As I understand it, the purpose of the central procurement office is to centralise all procurement in the public sector in a single function in the interests of efficiency and getting value for money. The higher education system is ready to embrace this. The final i's have not been dotted and the t's have not been crossed, but it is a work in progress.

Comment on this

With regard to the 170,000 students in lifelong learning, the fact that people have gone back to education is very encouraging and it facilitates industry by allowing staff to qualify in institutes. What are the projections for future student intake and the future demands of industry?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Boland

The anticipation is that, even with the current level of participation in higher education, we will have an increase of around 25% in student numbers until approximately 2028 through demographic growth alone. It is very significant amount which consists just of school leavers, by and large. Another major piece to be delivered is upskilling people, both those who did not have an opportunity to go into education earlier and those whose skills are now redundant or need additional honing. This is a very important piece of the higher education system for the future. We already have the Springboard programme, which accommodates approximately 6,000 students and has proven to be very successful in getting unemployed people back to work by giving them more relevant skills. The issue of the relevance of what the higher education institutions are doing for the economy and society keeps coming up. People need high-quality relevant skills.

Comment on this

With regard to lifelong learning and investment by institutes of technology, how big an emphasis is there within the HEA on the capacity of the institutes of technology to deliver online courses for people who may not be able to attend on campus?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Boland

It must be part of the way in which we respond to the huge demand for higher education. The use of technology is a very important factor in the sustainability of the system. I do not ever envisage a situation in which courses can be delivered exclusively online, especially to undergraduate students. The more effective way of dealing with technology in education is through a blended system whereby technology is used. Without wishing to engage in plamás, Sligo is a leader in this particular space.

Comment on this

With regard to Carriganore, a statutory inspector was appointed to investigate issues at Waterford Institute of Technology. It appears the HEA has adhered fully to the recommendations in the report. Is this correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Boland

Yes.

Comment on this

Did the HEA and the Department not allow the institute to borrow the funds to finish the project? Is this correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Boland

It was not a question of not allowing it. It simply could not. It had no power to do so.

Comment on this

Was this due to the financial emergency measures?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Boland

No, it was due to the fact that, under the legislation governing the institutes of technology, an institute may borrow only in accordance with the framework that is agreed between the Higher Education Authority, the Minister for Education and Skills and the Minister for Finance. No such framework is in place.

Comment on this

Will Mr. Ó Foghlú comment on this because it is an important point? If there is an appeal to the Department in such cases, does the Minister have discretion in the matter? We are talking in this instance about a situation where a cost-benefit analysis and due diligence were done but it ended up with contracts having to be cancelled and new ones drawn up. It is important to know what happened because the institute might be blamed for it. In fact, Waterford Institute of Technology did not have the power to borrow the moneys needed. I am asking whether, if those funds were available, the Department could have intervened to provide them?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

If we did intervene and the intervention we made was to start an investigation because we did not have sufficient information about the indebtedness of the company, that is a very serious matter. The investigation was undertaken on our behalf and the Minister then made a call to make a loan facility available, which has not been made available to anybody else, for both the student accommodation and the Carriganore campus.

Comment on this

However, the contracts were cancelled.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

We needed an investigation because there was not sufficient information available.

Comment on this

Surely, in that window of opportunity, there must have been consultation on the cancellation?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

The information flows were so bad that we needed to undertake a statutory investigation.

Comment on this

Was the Department happy with that statutory investigation?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

Yes, it was very effective.

Comment on this

Were no major anomalies found?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

The investigation found many anomalies, which is why the recommendations coming out of it have been very detailed, as Mr. Boland said. We have sought to implement the recommendations relevant to us and, as Professor Donnelly detailed, Waterford Institute of Technology has sought to implement the recommendations it was given. We intend to have a follow-up on the investigation in the new year which will involve sending Mr. Quigley back to double check that implementation has been completed in the institute.

Comment on this

There seems to have been a lack of collaboration and consultation and certain anomalies in regard to the commencement of phases one and two and again prior to the announcement of phase 3.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

The issue was the commencement of phase three without certainty around the funding. Mr. Quigley has some detailed comments on that in his report.

Comment on this

It is important to note that the institute did not have the facility to borrow.

Without wishing to be too parochial, I have a question regarding St. Angela's College in Sligo. It is the only school of home economics in the country and is now part of the institute of technology campus along with the school of nursing. There is an issue there whereby a capital project was approved in 2011 but was subsequently shelved. I am aware that many other projects have since been approved. There is a health and safety aspect involved here in that there is no access for wheelchair users from one facility to the next. What is the status of that project, with particular reference to the accessibility issue?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Boland

I will not be able to give the Deputy chapter and verse today but I can find out for him. I am aware St. Angela's College has made an application for funding for certain works, some of them relating to health and safety issues. The difficulty is that it is not alone in the sector and there is a large number of capital works projects that could be done if funding was available. I am sure the committee understands that funding is very limited. I am aware this particular project is one of those being considered by the HEA.

Comment on this

The point I wish to emphasise is that these works were included in a list of approved projects in 2011. I understand all the other projects on that list have either commenced or been completed and other projects have been undertaken which do not have the same level of priority. The shelf life of the St. Angela's College project dates back to 2009 or 2010. Does the HEA or the Department have the final say in this matter?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Boland

We decide these matters in combination but, ultimately, it is the Department that makes the funding available for all capital projects.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

We have not had extensive higher education capital funding available in recent years and there has not been a wide range of commitments made on capital for new buildings in the sector. In fact, a moratorium was in place, although it was partly lifted in exceptional circumstances. No other project that was paused or stop has been recommenced. In the six-year Government plan for capital spending, there is some €300 million available for higher education, €200 million of which is for public private partnerships, PPPs. In other words, there is very limited funding for projects outside of PPPs. We will be consulting with the HEA on the prioritisation of projects. As I said, we are very challenged on higher education capital funding.

Comment on this

The project in question has a cost of €3.5 million and is intended to address an issue of health and safety. It is unacceptable in the 21st century to have a building that is not accessible to students who use wheelchairs. It does not involve constructing a new building but linking one campus to another. I hope the delegates will do their best to advance it.

Comment on this

I refer to a report issued to the Higher Education Authority on 3 June 2011 from Deloitte in response to a request from Mr. Boland. Is Mr. Boland aware of the report to which I am referring?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Boland

This issue was raised by Deputy McDonald. I am not familiar with the report, as I said earlier, but I accept it was done.

Comment on this

It was done in response to a request from Mr. Boland.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Boland

Yes, that is as I understand it.

Comment on this

However, Mr. Boland is saying he is not familiar with it?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Boland

As I said earlier, I do not recall it. It was done four years ago.

Comment on this

I apologise if I am repeating material that was already covered. The report I am referring to was produced by Deloitte.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Boland

As I understand it, the report was from Waterford Institute of Technology to the HEA and it drew on a report from Deloitte. I am somewhat at a disadvantage here because I do not have the detail of the report in front of me.

Comment on this

If Mr. Boland cannot answer the question, perhaps one of the delegates from Waterford Institute of Technology will be able to. Is it correct that Deloitte was commissioned to produce the report?

Comment on this
Professor Willie Donnelly

The report we produced was a summary of the Deloitte report.

Comment on this

Why was Deloitte chosen to compile the report?

Comment on this
Professor Willie Donnelly

Deloitte was the internal auditor.

Comment on this

Does that in any way give rise to a conflict of interest? Surely Deloitte should have been the last company to be chosen because, presumably, it was getting fees elsewhere from Waterford Institute of Technology?

Comment on this
Professor Willie Donnelly

Yes, but Deloitte also would have had the appropriate information to carry out the review.

Comment on this

Of course, but some other external consultants could have obtained that information.

Comment on this
Professor Willie Donnelly

I really do not know why the decision was made. I was not there at the time.

Comment on this

What fees was Deloitte earning at the time?

Comment on this
Professor Willie Donnelly

There were two reports produced at a total cost of €90,000.

Comment on this

The document I have in front of me is headed "Expenditure Incurred by the Office of the President". It strikes me that Deloitte, because it was not independent, should not have been tasked with producing that report.

Comment on this
Professor Willie Donnelly

I was not there at the time and cannot answer the Deputy's question.

Comment on this

I am interested in Professor Donnelly's view on it. Would he task an internal auditor with making a report on internal matters in which it would already have been involved?

Comment on this
Professor Willie Donnelly

No, possibly not.

Comment on this

I doubt that the witness would. It strikes me as an unusual way to operate. It certainly would not be acceptable now. In the report from Deloitte, despite the fact that perhaps Deloitte was the wrong group to do it, was there any suggestion, with regard to the president's expenditure, that there was any expenditure incurred in the president's office that was for purposes other than those of the institute?

Comment on this
Professor Willie Donnelly

The core issue was the amount of items that went through the president's account. There appeared to be a huge range of items that went through that account. It is the basis of a legal issue at present. We, as an institute, from what I can see from reading the data around it, separated those items into which were items for the institute and which perhaps should have been in another account, items which were for duties carried out as the president under his own account and a smaller number of other items. We did an examination of the expenses which also highlighted expenses that were not necessarily for institute business purposes and others for which it was seen there may have been personal benefit. It was only on these latter categories that the actions initiated by the institute were grounded, that is, the institute sought repayment for those items.

Comment on this

Is that on the back of the Deloitte report?

Comment on this
Professor Willie Donnelly

Yes, it was on the back of the Deloitte report.

Comment on this

Is there a suggestion that any of the expenditure incurred in the president's office was for purposes that were not for the institute?

Comment on this
Professor Willie Donnelly

Yes, there are a number of items.

Comment on this

Could the witness tell us what they are?

Comment on this
Professor Willie Donnelly

No. I am sorry, but it is part of an ongoing discussion with the former president in which we sought clarification. In fairness to the president, we should continue with that ongoing discussion. Just to clarify, out of all of the items a number of items are open to query. There is a request to the president either to clarify or reimburse the institute for those items. That is reasonable.

Comment on this

The report I am reading is WIT making a report to the HEA, in effect, which is a summary of the Deloitte report. I am sure the witness has seen that document.

Comment on this
Professor Willie Donnelly

Yes.

Comment on this

It says that overall controls at the institute were sound, as evidenced by annual Comptroller and Auditor General management letters and internal audit reports. Does the witness agree with that?

Comment on this
Professor Willie Donnelly

That is correct. Also, Mr. Quigley said the same thing.

Comment on this

It goes on to say that at no stage has Deloitte or the governing body suggested that any expenditure incurred in the president's office was for purposes other than those of the institute.

Comment on this
Professor Willie Donnelly

I am not-----

Comment on this

The witness does not agree with that.

Comment on this
Professor Willie Donnelly

What I said was that there are a number of items which were identified as possibly for the benefit of the president. There is a request to repay those items.

Comment on this

This report says the opposite.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

There is a second Deloitte report.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

There were two Deloitte reports and the second one went into more detail and was forwarded to the Committee of Public Accounts on 12 February 2013. There are two Deloitte reports and the action Professor Donnelly is discussing arises from a conflation of the issues in the two reports.

Comment on this

I do not know much about this, which is why I am asking these questions. Is the witness saying the two Deloitte reports are in conflict with each other on that issue?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

In the combination of the two Deloitte reports there are a number of matters, which also were identified in the Comptroller and Auditor General's reports, where there are question marks over the expenditure and WIT has initiated action with the former president about those.

Comment on this

The witness is not quite answering my question. Is he saying the second Deloitte report-----

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

I do not have the two reports. The Deputy has the extract-----

Comment on this

I have the summary here. It is a very important point.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

Yes. WIT took a subsequent overview of all of the expenses. After the two reports it received, it conducted its own analysis and came to its own conclusions building on the two reports. We would have to get the two reports and write back to the Deputy. However, the overall conclusion by WIT, not in Professor Donnelly's time as president, was that having received the two Deloitte reports it completed its own analysis, having regard to the Comptroller and Auditor General's work as well, and has sought reimbursement. It has initiated action in respect of reimbursement, or correspondence between solicitors as it might not be action, to have a dialogue about some of that expenditure being clarified or refunded. That is where the issue stands now.

Comment on this

How much was Deloitte paid for the two reports?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

We do not have the information here but we provided it to the committee previously. We can certainly provide it again.

Comment on this

Does the witness have no idea?

Comment on this

Ms Sheridan can answer the question.

Comment on this
Professor Willie Donnelly

It was €98,000.

Comment on this

It was approximately €100,000 for the two reports.

Comment on this
Professor Willie Donnelly

Yes.

Comment on this

I wish to return to this report, because I have been listening to how it is being described, and the timing of it. I understand that there is correspondence, as Mr. Ó Foghlú said, to clarify certain matters of expenditure. The report here is a report to the HEA requested by the HEA. It was prepared in response to a request from Mr. Boland and it refers to the recent media reports. That appears to be its purpose. The report deals mainly with everything that was in question at Committee of Public Accounts meetings relative to the cost centre referred to as the president's office. It refers to the fact that it implied that €3 million formed part of the expenditure of the office, and says that was misleading. It makes other remarks that would discredit the original report that this was a spend that was way above the norm for an individual in an organisation, the president. This report discredits what was said previously. It says "No" and lays it all out. It states clearly that at no stage did Deloitte or the governing body suggest that any expenditure incurred in the president's office was for a purpose other than the institute's. Either the past statements were incorrect or this statement is incorrect.

I know we have moved on, but our task is to look at the accounts, the audit and the evidence before us and decide how best we can improve circumstances as we proceed. I am a little shocked, Mr. Boland, having looked at this report. Regardless of how long ago it was, and it is easy to dismiss it by saying it was four years ago, it is a topic we are dealing with at this meeting and it is part of the evidence and paperwork around that topic. It deals with the credibility or otherwise of an individual who was employed there. That is very important. It is important that whatever might have been there previously, if the record must be corrected it should be corrected. You should know your business. After all, your organisation is responsible for the oversight of WIT and the others. It is a little odd that you expect us to dismiss it on the basis of, "It is a legal matter", "I cannot remember" or "It is a long time ago", because all of the other bigger figures were remembered.

What is Ms Sheridan's role?

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

I am the financial controller in WIT.

Comment on this

What were Ms Sheridan's other roles there, if she had any?

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

I was the finance manager prior to this.

Comment on this

Was she chairman-----

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

I was the chairman of the DCS for an interim period.

Comment on this

Ms Sheridan was chairman of the companies.

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

Yes.

Comment on this

Ms Sheridan would have more knowledge than most people in this room because she were at the coalface of every one of these projects or management systems.

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

Yes.

Comment on this

What is her view on this? Who in WIT wrote the report for the Higher Education Authority?

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

I do not have it in front of me but I believe it may have been written by the acting president at the time.

Comment on this

Who was the acting president?

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

Mr. McFeely.

Comment on this

Would he have done this all on his own? Would he not have had to refer it to somebody for overview or comment?

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

I cannot answer that question as I was not involved in the writing of the report.

Comment on this

So Ms Sheridan does not know if anyone was involved. Would anyone else from Waterford know?

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

We can go back on our records and try to clarify it.

Comment on this

Ms Sheridan might just tell us who put this together because they were obviously acting on the instructions, or at the request, of Mr. Boland.

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

We will do that.

Comment on this

It is a request to the Waterford Institute of Technology. That is not one person. Given the finer detail in the report, it would appear that the person who wrote it had access to a lot of the finer detail and was willing to comment on it. Given that a meeting came afterwards in Kilkenny, according to Deputy McDonald, and given the outcome as regards the then president's position, this report is significant. I would like to find out who actually penned this report and to whom it was presented. It would be helpful to know if, during the writing of the report or thereafter, it was discussed with Mr. Boland.

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

Okay.

Comment on this

Without going into detail, Mr. Boland met with the president of the time of his own accord. Mr. Boland asked for the meeting and was not told to go and meet him.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Boland

The Chairman is referring to Professor Byrne.

Comment on this

Yes. Mr. Boland just went and met him.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Boland

That is correct.

Comment on this

We take it that the purpose of the meeting was as Mr. Boland outlined in the presentation here on 10 October 2013. Dr. Neavyn was president and now works for the HEA. Is the institute still paying him?

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

He is seconded to the Department of Education and Skills but he is still an employee of WIT.

Comment on this

He is seconded to the Department of Education and Skills but working for the HEA and paid by WIT.

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

Yes. We would be reimbursed for that.

Comment on this

When did the job arise and where is the advertisement for the job?

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

The Chairman would have to talk to the Department about that.

Comment on this

What is the job description?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

In November 2014 a representative of the president contacted the Department and indicated that the president would be interested in moving from his role. Following discussions in March 2015, the governing body of WIT agreed to a request from the Department for the secondment of Dr. Neavyn as an adviser on the development of the technological sector in the HEA. At the last meeting, we discussed the fact that we were working through the payment for that. The HEA has come to an arrangement with WIT regarding the recruitment of Dr. Neavyn and his salary for the period of the secondment so there is no cost on WIT for the secondment. I have the specification of his role here.

Comment on this

Was the institute not obliged to advertise that position?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

No. It was a secondment arrangement.

Comment on this

Therefore, the institute was not obliged to advertise it.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

Because of the nature of the arrangement, no, we did not consider we were obliged to advertise it.

Comment on this

So the institute is deciding for the HEA.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

We agreed it with the HEA.

Comment on this

Dr. Neavyn wrote to the institute.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

A representative contacted us on his behalf.

Comment on this

Who was that?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

I do not have the details of the representative here.

Comment on this

A lot of our guests are very short of information this morning. Now the institute is recruiting for the HEA.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

No. We are finding a solution for the fact that he did not want to continue with the remainder of his contract.

Comment on this

The solution is that, if it is his decision, it is his decision. Is that not right?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

That is one-----

Comment on this

If there was a skillset that was not represented within the HEA, surely the latter would have actively dealt with this to find a professionally-qualified person to fill the vacancy. What obligation is there to give a job to someone who does not want to fulfil his or her contract?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

He indicated he would be interested in moving from the role. We felt that it would be helpful for the development of WIT and it was very important and helpful for him to find a role. The HEA has been seeking additional staff from the Department and it was helpful-----

Comment on this

So there was a letter from the HEA seeking additional staff with the type of qualifications that Mr. Neavyn possesses.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

We have had continuous dialogue with the HEA about developing a refined skillset. We have made arrangements, with the assistance of the HEA, whereby the HEA has seconded in expertise from the technological sector and, as far as I am aware, from the university sector because it does not necessarily have the skill base internally. The higher education strategy sought for it to diversify the skill base it has.

Comment on this

So Mr. Ó Foghlú explained to Mr. Boland that he had this wonderful solution to a skillset which the HEA lacked. Mr. Boland, through the Department, employed Mr. Neavyn but to this day his salary is not being paid by the Department or the HEA.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

The salary will be back paid. We have entered into-----

Comment on this

Why, when it was agreed to terminate the contract and that Mr. Neavyn would go to work with the HEA, was the relevant paperwork not completed to allow the HEA to employ him directly?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

No contract has been terminated.

Comment on this

He is still the president.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

No. He has a secondment and we have not terminated his contract.

Comment on this

He can go back to it.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

He has agreed to the extension for a time, taking him to the end of his contract, and WIT has appointed Professor Donnelly on an acting basis, through an internal process.

Comment on this

I hope it does not unnerve Professor Donnelly that there is the position of the presidency and this other position.

Comment on this

It is like the Pope.

Comment on this

Exactly. When will the payment arrangements regarding Mr Neavyn be finalised?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

There is no difficulty in Dr. Neavyn being paid. The question is the reimbursement of WIT and we will finalise that before the end of the year.

Comment on this

To go back to what Mr. Ó Foghlú said, Mr. Boland, are the others who have been recruited from that sector being paid in the same way?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Boland

We had one arrangement, until the person's retirement, with the Dublin Institute of Technology where we bought out some of the time of one senior member of staff and she was effectively seconded for part of our time. The objective, as the Secretary General has said, is to bring expertise, particularly of a policy kind and in terms of institutional knowledge, into the HEA that we simply would not have normally.

Comment on this

What is the salary level for that position?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Boland

For which position?

Comment on this

Dr. Neavyn's position.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Boland

It is €146,000.

Comment on this

What is Mr. McKenna's position with the institute?

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

Mr. McKenna is on sabbatical at the moment.

He is due to return to lecturing duties in September.

Comment on this

Am I correct that he was not only lecturing?

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

He was also CEO of Diverse Campus Services, DCS, for a number of years.

Comment on this

Has that job been advertised?

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

Yes.

Comment on this

What is the salary in respect of that job?

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

It is not disclosed in the advertisements.

Comment on this

That may be so but perhaps Ms Sheridan will disclose it to the committee.

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

It is in the region of €100,000 per annum.

Comment on this

What was Mr. McKenna's salary?

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

As he was in a lecturing grade, his salary would have been in the region of €90,000 per annum.

Comment on this

He is now on sabbatical.

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

Yes.

Comment on this

For how long?

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

He is due to return in September.

Comment on this

What is the timeframe for the sabbatical?

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

Two years.

Comment on this

What approval was required and sought and what is Mr. McKenna doing while on sabbatical?

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

He is retraining to return to his lecturing position, having held the CEO position at DCS for a number of years.

Comment on this

Would it not have been a consideration to bring him back to complete the project?

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

Is the Chairman speaking about the consolidation project?

Comment on this

No, the WIT Diverse Campus Services project in which he was involved.

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

I understand there were discussions in that regard with Mr. McKenna at the time. Two options were put to him and the option he chose was to return to lecturing.

Comment on this

When were those options put to him?

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

Two years ago, around the time of the Quigley report on the consolidation.

Comment on this

Returning to Carriganore and the current position, we are trying to establish the figures in relation to the completion of that project. Perhaps Mr. Ó Foghlú would confirm again the amount of money allocated by the Department to that project.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

The Department made an overall allocation, by way of loan, of €10 million to WIT for the purchase of Manor Village and the completion of Carriganore.

Comment on this

Did Mr. Ó Foghlú say €10 million?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

Yes, by way of loan. The Manor Village project was estimated to cost €7.5 million but that cost was reduced through negotiations by WIT such that the loan required in respect of the purchase was €7.1 million, which left €2.9 million available to complete phase 3. Following discussions between the Department and WIT, we agreed to provide an additional €2.1 million. I think WIT also has additional funding of €200,000 available to it from another source.

Comment on this

What is the estimated cost of completion of the Manor Village project?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

It cost €7.1 million to purchase.

Comment on this

What is the estimated cost of completion of the Carriganore project?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

It is being funded by us. We had agreed to fund the €2.5 million plus the €400,000, which is €2.9 million in total, and we also agreed to an additional allocation of €2.1 million. There is also other funding available to WIT.

Comment on this

It is costing €7.1 million for completion of the Manor Village project. What is the cost of completion of the Carriganore project?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

Manor Village is part- funded by the Department. WIT also had to fund elements of it from its own resources.

Comment on this

I am clarifying on what the Department's €10 allocation is being spent. That €10 million breaks down into €7.1 million for the Manor Village project and €2.9 million for the Carriganore project.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

We also made an additional €2.1 million available.

Comment on this

Is the €10 million a loan?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

Yes. The total €12.1 million is a loan.

Comment on this

The €2.1 million and €2.9 million will be used to complete the Carriganore project.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Ó Foghlú

Yes, along with other funding which WIT has secured.

Comment on this

Perhaps Ms Sheridan would clarify the position with regard to the other funding.

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Sheridan

It is a sports capital grant of €200,000.

Comment on this