Cork Institute of Technology: Financial Statements 2013
Contributions 425–645 of 645. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
I may have to revert to Ms Sheridan on another matter.
In regard to CIT, Deputy McDonald referred to correspondence from a number of unnamed sources in which questions are raised in respect of the college. One such question relates to the cleaning staff. I recently tabled a parliamentary question on this matter and was told that matter has been resolved. Is that correct?
Comment on this
It was raised in September-October 2014 by the two unions representing the cleaning staff. We then engaged with the unions. Those negotiations are finalised and, at the request of the unions, payment will be made early in 2016.
Comment on this
Another question relates to health and safety funds. In 2014, €1 million in funding for health and safety works was made available. I presume schools could apply for that funding to the Department of Education and Skills. Is that correct?
Comment on this
CIT made €1 million available from its reserves for health and safety works.
Comment on this
One of the major projects was the installation of up-to-date gas lines in workshops and laboratories to meet current standards and some fire safety works.
Comment on this
Is it true that in March 2015 the HSE inspector informed CIT that some of the areas for storing chemicals and so on were no longer to be used as work stations and that flammable chemicals had been left sitting next to explosive chemicals in a store unit? These are the issues that have been raised with the committee. Given that CIT made €1 million available, it would appear from the photographs provided that there is a loose arrangement in place in respect of these matters.
Comment on this
There are two matters arising, including the overall storage and disposal of chemicals. The matter regarding the work station relates to a specific laboratory and the standard operating procedures there for chemical storage, use and disposal. When the matter was raised, we commissioned an internal review of the system of ordering, use, storage and disposal of chemicals. We have acted on that review.
Comment on this
Has the issue raised by the Health and Safety Authority, HSA, in its letter to CIT of 27 November 2014 - which refers to a situation where an employer has knowingly created and allowed a situation to continue where employees are exposed to health and safety and fire hazards and waste from both the biology and chemistry laboratories, as well as a corridor, are allowed to build up within the store area close to the employee's work station - been dealt with?
Comment on this
Yes, to the best of my knowledge. My colleague has informed me that the HSA is satisfied with the approach we have taken.
Comment on this
The correspondence received by the committee, dated 20 September 2015, questions that. It states that €50,000 was allocated but a lot more was needed. We will forward this letter to Dr. Murphy for a more comprehensive response.
I wish to raise the issue of the members of staff employed by CIT who took the college to the Labour Relations Commission, LRC. According to a complaint sent to this committee, a ruling was given but the institute has not yet acted on it. I raise this issue because of correspondence received by this committee.
Comment on this
What the Chairman describes leaves me at a loss because it is quite a general statement. Various issues are taken to the Labour Relations Commission or the Workplace Relations Commission, WRC, as it is now called. The only issue that I can think of concerned timetabling at CIT which is being dealt with.
Comment on this
Based on the question regarding recommendations received from the LRC, no there is not.
Comment on this
The other issue I want to raise relates to this redacted report. I accept what Dr. Murphy said in his opening statement regarding personal details. Who set out the detail of how that report was to be prepared? Who set out the criteria for that report?
Comment on this
The audit committee commissioned that report. It set out, with the assistance of independent legal advisers, Arthur Cox, the details of what was required in the report. The terms of reference were set out by the audit committee.
Comment on this
As I understand it from the redacted document we have, certain allegations were made about individuals. Is that correct? Were those individuals interviewed? I ask Dr. Murphy to talk us through how the report was prepared.
Comment on this
It would depend on the nature of the allegation. KPMG adopted a phased approach. It was asked to do certain things in the first phase and then, depending on the outcome of that, the option was there to proceed to additional phases, if necessary. The audit committee did this in an effort to retain control over the cost of the exercise. There were a number of allegations pertaining to interview processes. We made the specific interview files and selection board reports available, as well as any documentation that would have gone to the governing body. We also provided the minutes of governing body meetings where appointments would have been made. It is my understanding that on the basis of that information, KPMG was satisfied that the allegations were unfounded.
Comment on this
It was far from desktop, I can assure-----
Comment on this
I know that KPMG met a number of individuals who would have been responsible overall for particular areas and that it spent time with those individuals going through the various allegations in their areas of responsibility.
Comment on this
It did not go beyond that. It just spoke, for example, to the head of a section and dealt with the queries that way. Is that correct?
Comment on this
It would then have conducted its own sampling, for example, in the area of expenses.
Comment on this
It was €9,000 to be exact. In terms of the overall cost of €65,000 for the reports, it was-----
Comment on this
Correct me if I am wrong but was there not a complaint in the whistleblower's document regarding O'Flynn Exhams Solicitors?
Comment on this
Following a tendering process, O'Flynn Exhams Solicitors were the institute's legal advisers. They were also the subject of one of the anonymous allegations.
Comment on this
No. The audit committee asked O'Flynn Exhams Solicitors for its advice and operating on that advice and the committee then proceeded, with the authority of the governing body, to seek independent legal advice.
Comment on this
There was an allegation made against O'Flynn Exhams Solicitors. No one is pointing the finger here, by the way. It is the process that I am interested in. The institute then asked O'Flynn Exhams-----
Comment on this
The audit committee asked O'Flynn Exhams Solicitors if they thought it was okay for the institute to employ them as part of the investigation.
Comment on this
They were not party to the investigation.
Comment on this
They provided legal advice to the audit committee, and based on that advice, the audit committee proceeded to seek independent legal advice.
Comment on this
I wish to move on to oversight on the part of the Department of Education and Skills. Did the institute have much communication with the Department or the HEA as it worked through the different allegations?
Comment on this
We gave regular updates to the Department, the HEA and the Comptroller and Auditor General on the process. The governing body was also briefed regularly by the chair of the audit committee as to the progress of the investigations. We supplied full copies of the report to the Department, the HEA and the Comptroller and Auditor General.
Comment on this
An answer to a parliamentary question on 8 December pointed out that four employees of the institute received redundancy or severance packages.
Comment on this
In terms of the health and safety issue, does the institute have a health and safety officer?
Comment on this
My next question is for Ms Sheridan. Does the institute partner with private companies in terms of research? Does it collaborate with the private sector in any way? Is that part of what the institute does?
Comment on this
I should answer that because I was formerly vice president of research for the institute. We have had more than 210 partnerships in the past five years with companies which were funded in various ways. Some were funded jointly with Enterprise Ireland, others were funded privately by the companies themselves and some were funded through Science Foundation Ireland, SFI. There are a number of different ways in which we can partner with companies and develop research for them.
Comment on this
It depends on the funding mechanism. We charge them at cost plus a 30% overhead.
Comment on this
We charge the full cost for the staff and materials, plus a 30% overhead.
Comment on this
I am trying to determine how tied in the institute is with the companies in the context of success. If those companies are successful on the back of the assistance of the institute, is there any windfall accruing to the institute?
Comment on this
It very much depends. There are national guidelines in this regard but it really depends on where the intellectual property originated and the percentage of investment the company put into the particular project. Another factor is the ability of the institute to leverage any additional funding from the work. There is a scale involved. The most important point, however, is that we are part of a national programme, the technology transfer programme, for which guidelines are given nationally. We apply those national guidelines.
Comment on this
I read recently about the great success of a local company, FeedHenry, which was supported by Waterford Institute of Technology.
Comment on this
Yes, I was one of the founders of that company and the originator of its IP as an academic researcher.
Comment on this
FeedHenry was a campus company. The standard is that with such companies, the institute receives 15% of the equity if it transfers the IP to the company. That is before external investment, which will see the equity decrease, depending on the-----
Comment on this
Yes, it was established by me and several members of the TSG research group. It was based on our IP.
Comment on this
Does that mean Professor Donnelly and his colleagues actually started up the business?
Comment on this
We started up the campus company, which is standard practice in universities and institutes of technology.
Comment on this
I was never a director of the company.
Comment on this
I was one of the originators of the company. We have a history of building jobs in the region based on start-ups. In fact, we have built more than 600 jobs on that basis.
Comment on this
No, they come from the IP that is generated by the research, which is carried out to Science Foundation Ireland or Enterprise Ireland standards. There are very clear rules in terms of who has ownership of the IP and who can start a campus company. In general, they are started by staff involved in research, whether in the universities or in the institutes of technology.
Comment on this
Yes, but one must take into account that there had been two rounds of EU investment. The institute's equity in the company at that stage was 4% or thereabouts. As such, we would have got some 4% of the moneys.
Comment on this
That was something of a windfall. Did that money go back into general investment in the college?
Comment on this
I have a question for Mr. Ó Foghlú on an issue that has been raised on a number of occasions in the Dáil in recent days, namely, the proposal to establish an education ombudsman. Deputy Jim Daly raised it on the Order of Business this week. Since then, we found out that the Education (Admission to Schools) Bill 2015, which is the vehicle under which the proposal was made, probably will not be taken before the election. What is the Department's view on having an education ombudsman? Is there a general feeling about what Deputy Daly is proposing? All Deputies have encountered cases similar to those to which the Deputy referred, touching on issues of accountability versus unaccountability. Is there a view forming in the Department in this regard?
Comment on this
I must be careful not to comment on policy, but I will try to answer Deputy Deasy's question.
Comment on this
Deputy Jim Daly came to see me on more than one occasion to talk through his emerging concept and ask us where policy development was at in this regard. We had that discussion a couple of months ago. As it stands, we already have an Ombudsman for Children. Deputy Daly's proposal, as far as I understand it, is made up of two parts. The first is that he sees an ombudsman for education being active in giving policy advice. The second function he envisages is not so much an ombudsman function as an appeals board function to allow for the making of determining decisions, which ombudsmen typically do not do. We talked through those concepts with the Deputy, as I said.
The Government is advancing the Education (Admission to Schools) Bill 2015 but, as the Minister indicated earlier this week, it is highly unlikely that it will be passed before the end of the current Oireachtas term. In the admissions area, we wish to put in place enhanced regulation both in terms of the time applications are made to schools, which would provide clarity for everybody, and in respect of what might or might not be included in enrolment policy. That, in essence, is what is involved in the legislation. The Minister has signalled her view that there is a need to review the Equal Status Act provisions around denominational education. The Bill has been published but not discussed in the Houses, so it is technically on First Stage. The Minister has indicated that it was her intention to introduce amendments to provide for a parents' and students' charter, which, together with the new arrangements around enrolment, should remove enrolment to a significant extent from any necessary appeals mechanisms.
We would like to advance those initiatives and analyse their impact without putting a straight appeals mechanism in place which would have a determining say in schools' enrolment policies. That is the issue we are focusing on in our emerging discussion with Deputy Daly. We hope the Education (Admission to Schools) Bill will be taken in the next Oireachtas, in which case there will be further opportunities to consider the concept Deputy Daly has proposed.
Comment on this
I take it from what Mr. Ó Foghlú is saying that, in a different way, the Department is putting together a type of appeals structure or mechanism.
Comment on this
In a different way, we are seeking to have these sorts of issues addressed in the first instance via the cultural aspect, with a view to ensuring schools are more responsive and transparent in their communities, with an opportunity also for appeals mechanisms. To be fair to Deputy Jim Daly, he said in his discussions with us that he would prefer to advance his own concept while that is happening. I do not think I am breaching any confidences in saying that, because the Deputy is very open to discussion.
Comment on this
Mr. Ó Foghlú is effectively saying the Department is looking at adopting the Deputy's concept at least partially.
Comment on this
I have a question for the delegates from Cork Institute of Technology. Does the college have any staff who retired and then came back to work for it?
Comment on this
Up to this academic year, we did not. However, in the context of industrial action by the Teachers Union of Ireland, under which it basically instructed its members to engage in no overtime whatsoever, there have been a number of cases in which, because of the specialised nature of the expertise being sought and the difficulty of operating at short notice - TUI does not issue such instructions until the beginning of the academic year - we have had occasion to look to retired staff. A note I have in front of me says that four lecturers who were retired have been brought back on a part-time basis, which means they are paid an hourly rate and are limited to a maximum of four hours per week. We have applied to the Higher Education Authority for permission to do this. It is not an ideal situation but relates specifically to areas where the required specialisation was not in ready supply and the academic semester had commenced. In the context of ensuring the delivery of the service to students, that was the decision we took.
Comment on this
There has been considerable interaction and preparation for today, but conservatively at this stage the internal cost must be pushing towards €40,000.
Comment on this
They involved people's time in ensuring there were copies of documentation, and the committee requested extensive documentation in recent days. Somebody must collate this and send it off. Even if it is electronic, it still must be collated, sent off and reviewed. A number of people are engaged in this.
Comment on this
I have a number of questions I want clarified having read the report. Was there a settlement to someone for €500,000?
Comment on this
A characteristic of some of these allegations is they are so vague we sometimes guess what is the basis of them. The National Maritime College of Ireland is part of CIT. It is one of the third level public private partnerships. It was built to provide training and education for the merchant marine and Naval Service.
Comment on this
The Navy has the use of the college, and it can train its own people there. If naval officers are registered students of the college, they are a cost to the college.
Comment on this
No, they are higher education students. If they are registered with us on courses and degrees, they are, obviously, higher education students.
Comment on this
Apart from that, is there any other cost to the college for this particular training or that project?
Comment on this
Under the PPP contract there are pass-through costs, which are mainly the utility costs which come to the college.
Comment on this
The Department pays a regular contribution cost.
Comment on this
No, the Department pays the required PPP repayment, which is the repayment to the company which built and maintains it, and CIT makes the other payments to which Dr Murphy has referred.
Comment on this
That could be the gross value. To put matters in perspective, we have approximately 14,000 fixed assets and describing them as fixed in some cases is a bit of a misnomer. They are anything but, which is part of the reason it is difficult to ensure. As the Comptroller and Auditor General notes, having looked at the audit committee reports, it is a regular feature of his review with regard to ensuring we control our assets and keep track of them. There are certain assets we do not track, such as plastic chairs, of which most higher educational institutions have a considerable number. If we were to say a plastic chair is €30 and we have several thousand of them, it looks like a large amount of money.
Comment on this
We think where this may have arisen is that following an internal audit review in 2013, we changed the way we manage our fixed asset audits. Previously we did it through the summer, and criticism was expressed that there was not enough time to complete the audits, so quite often one year ran into the next. In 2014, we implemented a new system whereby we have continual rolling audits in each department. We also centrally carry out an audit, but this is limited to items which are more than €5,000 in value bought since 1 January 2008. I believe where the allegation came from was the gap between these two. There is a certain element of central audit which we do not undertake. We have devolved it to the academic and functional departments.
Comment on this
The figure came out of the KPMG report and it is the value of the assets not subject to central audit. We have continual rolling audits. We also have an external audit. We engage another company to do spot checks on these assets.
Comment on this
No, the assets are not missing, they are just not counted in a central audit. They are counted in the continual rolling audit.
Comment on this
Great. With regard to the Munster university, has anybody set out the cost for Waterford, Carlow, Tralee and Cork? Is there a forecast of the total cost relative to each? Does Mr. Boland have any idea of this question?
Comment on this
We will see if we can get a precise figure, but each of the stage 2 and stage 3 plans presented with regard to DIT and Munster set out an estimate of what the costs are likely to be. I estimate the figure is in the order of €30 million or €35 million if my memory serves me.
Comment on this
From memory, it is €7 million. It is €6.7 million. The Dublin consortium was rather more expensive.
Comment on this
We have not yet received a plan from Waterford so we do not have a figure for it.
Comment on this
I was thinking of Dublin. The figure for Dublin is €9.5 million. I beg the Chairman's pardon, I grossly overstated it. It is €9.5 million plus €6.7 million.
Comment on this
Author Cox gave independent legal advice specifically for the KPMG report.
Comment on this
The legal adviser to the institute following competitive tender is O'Flynn Exhams.
Comment on this
We do. We examined our expenditure on various advice and we thought it more prudent and cost efficient to have an internal legal officer.
Comment on this
We appointed the individual in 2013 and the salary is grade 8 in the public service.
Comment on this
Does the college have an internal arrangement for PR or does it rely completely on external firms?
Comment on this
As with most institutions, we have an internal marketing office and a minor element of this is PR. It is with regard to marketing the production of materials such as CAO prospectuses.
Comment on this
The PR element is supplied by a company.
Given that the MTU involves two, we have actually tendered for and retained a company in terms of the whole technological university.
Comment on this
Two different firms. Our PR firm is Kearney Melia Communications. Unfortunately, the second partner in the firm died quite recently. In terms of the technological university, we have conducted, in agreement with IT Tralee, another competitive tender and appointed Communications Clinic.
Comment on this
Let me refer to one last issue, which sticks out when one examines all the figures and accounts, namely, the paintings. Are paintings of each president commissioned?
Comment on this
Yes, and of the former chairman of the governing body. We have a tradition. There are paintings of all my predecessors in the council room. This is quite a normal tradition in several higher education institutions.
Comment on this
The cost of the specific paintings was €10,000 each.
Comment on this
There were reports in the newspaper about a recent painting. I presume that if the cost was €10,000, the reports were grossly exaggerated.
Comment on this
I cannot help the Chairman there. I am not sure what he is referring to.
Comment on this
Is the Chairman referring to the internal audit contract?
Comment on this
That is tendered for on a sectoral basis, such that all the 13 institutions-----
Comment on this
Roughly in the order of €38,000 per year.
Comment on this
When the audits are being conducted, is there a different person responsible for each unit, or is the same person looking at the figures all the time?
Comment on this
The audit plan in each institution would be set out and approved by the governing body.
Comment on this
My sense is that the same team comes. I believe it is the Deloitte office based in Limerick that deals with each of the institutions of technology, bar one, DIT.
Comment on this
In fact, its contract has now concluded, as the committee will be aware. Following tendering, there is a new group.
Comment on this
For the benefit of the Chair, we have asked the institutions to share the findings of audits as a learning mechanism.
Comment on this
If any issues emerge, of course we would-----
Comment on this
I am talking about having a deliberate arrangement whereby the audits that are conducted across the sector would be made available to both the HEA and Department in terms of general analysis.
Comment on this
I know they are not but, in a new arrangement or contract, could they be such that Mr. Boland and the Department could get a better overview of what is happening?
Comment on this
One could compare what Dr. Murphy is spending on legal and PR services with what Ms Sheridan is spending.
Comment on this
We do a financial trends analysis of the sector that considers some of those factors.
Comment on this
We could certainly consider it. I would have to think about what it would mean in terms of effort and value on each side. On the face of it, it sounds like a good idea.
Comment on this
If it were Dunnes Stores, for example, every unit would be reporting to a single administrative section. Otherwise, how would one know what is going on all over the place? Not knowing is the problem. With respect, the HEA does not know what is going on all over the place. It has a general view on it but it should be borne in mind that the specific amounts of money being used, in light of the numbers of complaints or allegations we have received, is significant. Both the Department and HEA should be carrying out a more in-depth analysis of where the money is going and how it is being spent. That analysis is a good management tool. Does Mr. Gallagher agree?
Comment on this
No, Mr. Gallagher may answer. Surely when the institutes are being amalgamated, and in light of future developments beyond amalgamation, it is good to have the analysis.
Comment on this
It is worth clarifying the purpose of internal auditing vis-à-vis external auditing. There is a rather good system in the institutes that is centrally managed. A number of projects are undertaken centrally and the results of those are shared with the sector. The results of all the projects that are undertaken at a local level are disseminated also.
With regard to the HEA, we do report through our governance statements, and the results of those internal audits, if they are material, will be included there. Also, in terms of external audits and the review of the financial accounts, the HEA does quite a bit of drilling down and analysis. That is extremely useful and the results are disseminated to the sector. It is useful for me to consider other colleges and ask whether their figures are out of kilter by comparison with ours.
Comment on this
I want to bring to the attention of Mr. Ó Foghlú a matter concerning the audit of the VECs. There is further correspondence on this that arrived only today but it will be sent to Mr. Ó Foghlú. He might give us his view on it. Separate from that, I have had a discussion with someone involved and have to say that the manner in which he is being treated seems extremely unfair. Consequent to his desire to improve things and bring forward suggestions, he is being penalised and sidelined in relation to the audit. This type of practice was raised by Deputy McDonald earlier in respect of the Central Bank. While the individual to whom I am referring is not a whistleblower, he is very concerned about the job. In light of this, it is extremely important that whoever is responsible send out a clear message that what is occurring will not be tolerated and that someone bringing forward positive suggestions for improvements should, at least, have those suggestions examined and be treated in a way one would expect. Very deep concern has been expressed to me over this. It is a matter I will raise again. I wish to bring it to the attention of Mr. Ó Foghlú today.
Comment on this
The culture the Chairman referred to is exactly the sort of culture we are seeking to bring about. I refer to a culture of transparency within institutions so issues can be raised and addressed. Obviously, the internal audit work and so on should be appropriately managed, and concerns should be listened to appropriately.
Comment on this
When someone reports a matter such as the one raised to the likes of me, where should he go thereafter?
Comment on this
It depends where that person is situated.
In the first instance, they should report to the chief executive officer of the education and training board, ETB, and its internal audit committee.
Comment on this
What if that was not possible to do because of the internal workings of the different organisations?
Comment on this
That is why we have the protections code to enable that to be possible.
Comment on this
Of course they can raise it with me. However, I would raise it with the chief executive officer of the ETB.
Comment on this
Would Mr. Ó Foghlú also ensure the appropriate protection is given to the employee in question?
Comment on this
Yes. The legal protection is in place, the provisions for which have been enacted by the Oireachtas. What we are seeking in that-----
Comment on this
The value of that has to be tested. The experience to date is that anyone who has tried it has had a very negative outcome. They are still reeling from the manner in which they were treated and the fact that they expected more. I am not talking about the Department of Education and Skills in this instance. However, when someone has raised concerns and feels excluded in this way, I find it shocking. It should be dealt with. I am going to meet the individuals concerned and, if necessary, I will come directly to Mr. Ó Foghlú. This needs to be rooted out of any organisation which has had that experience.
I thank the witnesses for attending. The committee will not dispose of the 2014 financial statements of Cork Institute of Technology and 2013 financial statements of Waterford Institute of Technology until we decide what to do with them.