HSE Report on Foster Home in Waterford Community Care Area: Discussion
Contributions 1–194 of 792. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
I welcome the witnesses. Before we begin, I ask members, witnesses and those in the Gallery to please turn off their mobile phones because they interfere with the sound quality of the transmission of the meeting.
I advise witnesses that they are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the evidence they are to give this committee. If they are directed by the committee to cease giving evidence in respect of a particular matter and they continue to do so, they are entitled thereafter only to a qualified privilege in respect of their evidence. They are directed that only evidence connected with the subject matter of these proceedings is to be given and they are asked to respect the parliamentary practice to the effect that, where possible, they should not criticise nor make charges against a Member of either House, a person outside the House or an official by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. Members are reminded of the provisions of Standing Order No. 163 that the committee should also refrain from inquiring into the merits of a policy or policies of the Government or a Minister of the Government or the merits of the objectives of such policies.
I welcome Mr. Tony O'Brien, Director General, Health Service Executive, and his officials to the meeting. I ask him to introduce his officials.
Comment on this
I thank the Chairman. I am joined by Mr. Pat Healy, who is the National Director of Social Care, and Ms Aileen Colley, who recently took up the post as chief officer for our community health organisation in what we call CHO 5, which covers Wexford, Waterford, Kilkenny and south Tipperary.
Comment on this
I welcome also Ms Frances Spillane and Ms Gráinne Duffy from the Department of Health. I ask Mr. O'Brien to make his opening statement.
Comment on this
I welcome this opportunity to provide further information and to answer questions in respect of the south-east foster home matter. As members are well aware, this involves allegations of abuse and neglect of the most egregious nature. The committee has asked the HSE to provide clarity on two particular matters of concern, which have emerged over the past week, and I am conscious that recent media coverage may have raised other issues that it may also wish me to address.
In addressing the committee today, we will be mindful of the fact that this matter remains subject to a live investigation by An Garda Síochána and we will be careful not to prejudice or impede that process.
The committee asked the Health Service Executive, HSE, to address specifically a number of key issues which I will deal with in turn. Before addressing those issues I wish to place on the record that I met the Minister for Health, Deputy Varadkar, and Minister of State, Deputy Kathleen Lynch, yesterday during which meeting we discussed the recommendation to Government for the establishment of a commission of investigation into this matter. I welcome such a commission as it would provide a statutory mechanism to conclude this drawn-out process and allow the 47 users, their families and other interested parties to get answers to the questions they have been asking for many years now on this deeply concerning and dreadful case and to achieve some level of closure for all concerned.
Turning now to the issues and regarding the apology, the intention in early December 2015 was for the HSE to provide an update and an official apology to the 47 users, including Grace, who had contact over the years with the foster home at the centre of the abuse allegations. Letters, which included official apologies, issued by registered post to 43 families. Three service users were untraceable by the HSE or by An Garda Síochána. On 9 December, a verbal briefing, to include an official apology, was to be given to Grace and her mother the next day, 10 December. While the 43 letters issued as planned, the HSE mishandled issuing the important apology to Grace and her mother. In considering how to communicate to Grace in the most appropriate way, the view was taken that this should be undertaken in person in the first instance rather than by letter. With this change in the mode of communication in the case of Grace, it is now evident that the official HSE apology that was intended to be issued to Grace and to her mother was not made at that time. Unfortunately, the desire to offer a formal HSE apology was lost in the communication to the staff members who were to conduct the meeting in person with Grace. Having personally reviewed the situation with those staff involved, I am satisfied that it was the intention to offer a full and frank apology to Grace. I confirm that the HSE has since apologised officially to Grace and to her mother. This official apology has been made by the chief officer both in person and in writing with the assistance of the professionals now caring for Grace. There is correspondence in this regard appended to the opening statement.
As the director general of the HSE I wrote yesterday to the 44 families to let them know that I am unhappy with the way the HSE mishandled the apology and I also apologised to them for the further distress this mishandling may have caused them or their family member. That letter is also appended in sample form. Furthermore, it is clear from both of the unpublished reports that there were significant failings in the care provided by that foster family and significant failures by the former health board, and subsequently the HSE, to make the situation safe. For this, I offer them and their family member a full, sincere and heartfelt apology.
With regard to the communications to the Committee of Public Accounts, the HSE became aware of concerns being raised in the public domain on 20 January following a report in a national newspaper. The HSE sought reassurance at local level that the apology had in fact been given. As a result of this, a report was provided confirming that an apology had been offered. The report formed the basis of the submission to the committee by the HSE on the morning of 21 January. However, it is the case that the assurance given to the chief officer, which she in turn passed upwards, referred to an individual expression of regret of the senior staff members to Grace and her mother. This expression of regret was then mistakenly taken as confirmation of an official apology on behalf of the HSE. I wish to take this opportunity to offer, in person, an unreserved apology to the Committee of Public Accounts and its members for submitting a document that contained erroneous information at that time. I assure the committee that having met the principals involved, I am satisfied there was no intention to mislead the committee.
Regarding the question of other placements after 2009 when Grace was removed, it is important at this point to assure the committee that based on all the information available to the HSE and having regard to the two investigation reports, the best information currently available is that no new placement was made by the South Eastern Health Board after the primary decision of 1995;
Grace was the only health board placed person to remain with the foster family after 1995; and the South Eastern Health Board, now the HSE, is aware of one other person having contact by living arrangement with the family after 1995. I confirm today that she - Ann, as I will call her - remains in full-time, seven-day residential care with a voluntary provider and takes regular visits home to her mother. I also note for clarity that a different name has been used by Fergus Finlay in the Irish Examiner today. I believe Fiona is the name he has assigned to her. I want to be clear that we are talking about the same person, but this document was written before we knew that Mr. Finlay was using that name, so I have referred to her as Ann.
In April 2015, following a national broadcast, the provider, as full-time carer, contacted the HSE, having reflected on their involvement in recent years, and indicated concerns regarding historical unexplained bruising. Two professionals independent of the case were commissioned by the HSE to examine this matter. The investigation report was provided to the HSE yesterday, and nothing untoward is evident in the findings. The provider has also provided information to HIQA and Tusla, and the HSE remains in contact with those organisations. Within the limited powers it has, the HSE is pursuing references to alleged non-residential contact between Ann and her former foster carers. I can confirm she is in a residential placement and this is her primary source of protection.
From the summary review of the information based on files reviewed by Resilience Ireland, I can now summarise the position in respect of Ann. I am conscious that this will be the subject of further detailed consideration and therefore I emphasise that this is a high-level overview. Ann was born in 1980. She is now aged 35 years and has had a severe intellectual disability since birth. Her contact with the foster family, with whom she lived on a part-time basis, commenced when she was 12 years old. All her arrangements were conducted privately by her family. During June 2011, having been contacted by the Garda Síochána, the HSE team at local level engaged with the family again to confirm that there was a Garda investigation, to advise them of concerns and to invite them to make direct contact with the Garda if they wished. In October 2011, Ann, then 31 years of age, was residing in a five-day week residential placement with a voluntary provider. A seven-day week service was offered with the same provider, but her family confirmed they had no concerns regarding the foster family and wished to continue their part-time contact with the foster mother and had confirmed this to An Garda Síochána. The seven-day week placement was not taken up at that time.
In early 2012, a local HSE team sought legal advice on the case of Ann, which informed them that they could take no further action regarding her placement at that point. From 2011 to 2013, there were various engagements with Ann's family, essentially to persuade them to cease contact with the former foster family. In October 2013, the HSE formally demanded that the foster family cease all care activity which was either current, as in Ann's case, or which they might be minded to engage in towards the future. Later that month, Ann's family was formally written to requesting that they cease the placement, and it ceased shortly thereafter.
Regarding the care needs of those who had any contact with the foster home in question, I confirm to the committee that the service user, who was removed from the foster home in mid-2009, has been fully cared for in full-time residential care by a voluntary service provider since mid-2009. The HSE chief officer and her team in the south east will continue to work collaboratively with the service provider, the service user and advocates to ensure the highest quality of service and support continues to be provided to the service user involved.
An important aspect of the Resilience Ireland report commissioned by the HSE was to look back at all service users who had any contact with the foster home in the south east and to have their care needs reviewed to ensure the necessary supports and services were in place. In the main, the service users were either in residential placement or living at home and availing of day services.
As a result of the review, increased respite was provided where needed to those living at home, and specially tailored supports were provided in some other cases.
Other matters were raised by voluntary providers in correspondence. In relation to equity of funding for providers in the south east, outlined in my handout is the funding relevant to the provider in question, from 2009 to 2015. We have full detail in two categories, totalled, with an indication of the percentage changes from year to year. This includes additional funding in 2015 for a new service regarding named individuals, sleepover costs, school leavers and changing needs.
Between 2008 and 2014, the five largest funded organisations in the State providing intellectual disability services received an average reduction in funding of 12%. Since 2009, the disability sector has been generally protected from any decreases in allocation, except for those due to Government reductions such as pay reductions, the Haddington Road agreement and the Financial Emergency Measures in the Public Interest Act. Based on the percentage increases or decreases of the three main providers in the area from 2009 to 2014, the voluntary provider in question had a 4.9% reduction in funding, while the average nationally was 12%, and in the local area the average reduction was 9% for the major providers. The increases in 2015 reflect the intention to support the provider, particularly in the context of the needs of individuals highlighted in the Resilience review.
It is important to assure committee members, those concerned and the wider public that the HSE did not wait for the publication of reports to take actions to improve the service and management failings identified in child care and disability services and to act on the recommendations of the reports. A comprehensive action plan is in place to address the combined recommendations of the reports. A number of the key recommendations implemented include those related to child care and fostering services in Waterford, for which a full review was undertaken. Recommendations were implemented between 2010 and 2012, with investment in staff and improvements in practice and supervision. Intervention with vulnerable adults is limited in the legislative and policy framework. A key recommendation of the Conal Devine report was the implementation of a HSE safeguarding policy for vulnerable adults. This policy was published in December 2014, with an immediate implementation plan which has progressed through 2015. This included the establishment of professional, resourced safeguarding teams in the nine community health care organisations.
The HSE is establishing a national independent review panel with an independent chair and review team for disability services. Establishment of the panel has been included as a priority in the HSE's national service plan for 2016. It is intended, in the first instance, that the review panel will focus on serious incidents that occur in disability services across the HSE and HSE-funded services. The review panel will be modelled on the Tusla review panel, which reviews cases in which children die or experience serious harm while in the care of the State. In December 2014, I appointed Ms Leigh Gath as an independent confidential recipient to examine concerns and provide help and advice to vulnerable adults, or anyone concerned about a vulnerable adult in a HSE or HSE-funded service.
The HSE received confirmation in writing from An Garda on Friday, 29 January 2016, that its investigation remains ongoing and that clearance is not provided for either of the reports to be published.
Comment on this
On housekeeping matters, I wish to ask the witnesses from the Department of Health what it is they do in the Department. Can they tell us what their positions are?
Comment on this
I am an assistant secretary with responsibility for social care, which involves disability services and services for older people.
Comment on this
I am a principal officer in the disability unit at the Department of Health.
Comment on this
Thank you very much. I presume that committee members will want to ask questions after me, so I will go ahead, and I might speak again afterwards, once everyone else is done.
I thank Mr. O'Brien and his officials for coming in today. In the third line of his opening statement, Mr. O'Brien referred to allegations of abuse and neglect "of the most egregious nature". Thanks to a number of national newspaper reports, the nature of the alleged abuse has been publicised. It is worth repeating that information here today because it has never been articulated or verbalised at this committee. According to those reports, and I know this to be the case from meetings I have had in my own constituency, we are dealing with allegations of rape with implements. These are allegations of horrific sexual abuse. At previous meetings, I alluded to the fact that this was probably the worst example of abuse I had ever come across.
It is worth pointing out what has been publicised and the horrendous nature of what we are talking about here. Mr. O'Brien referred in his opening statement to allegations of abuse and neglect "of the most egregious nature". He admitted in his report to serious poor care failings and has made apologies. Can Mr. O'Brien, to start with, give us a description of the failings he is talking about and the kind of neglect he referred to as taking place over the course of 25 or 30 years? What exactly, in his own mind, is he apologising for? Can we start with that?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. In the two reports, and the Devine report in particular, there is considerable detail which I cannot go into in the specifics because of the nature of those reports. They relate, in essence, to opportunities that might have been taken to deal with the allegations that were known at the time, which, had they been dealt with in a different way, would almost certainly have produced a different outcome. This occurs on a number of occasions in the period essentially back to the mid-1990s. While the allegations are just that - allegations - and are not probative at this stage because of other processes, they are of a sufficient nature that they could have triggered different actions by the persons dealing with the case.
Comment on this
That is not really what I asked. Mr. O'Brien has made statements to this committee in which he referred to failings and neglect. What is he talking about there? I want him to describe the neglect he referred to in writing. What is he apologising for?
Comment on this
I am apologising for the fact that Grace was permitted to remain at risk in that care setting for the length of time she was.
Comment on this
Mr. O'Brien is apologising to 46 or 47 different individuals; it is not just Grace. Why did he feel it necessary to apologise to everyone?
Comment on this
At one point or another, all of those individuals were cared for in that foster home and, as a result of that, they were at risk. It is for actions, or, more particularly, inactions that allowed them to be at risk and exposed to risk of the type we have both made reference to that I am apologising on behalf of the HSE and, in effect, also for the former South-Eastern Health Board.
Comment on this
Who made the decision to leave Grace in the foster home?
Comment on this
That was made by a group of individuals in the South-Eastern Health Board in the middle of the 1990s, but there were further opportunities later.
They are people whose participation in the process is detailed in the Conal Devine report. I have been asked by An Garda Síochána not to publish the report, so I hope the committee understands that I cannot go into line-by-line detail as to what is in the report, because that would effectively be to publish it.
Comment on this
Let us stick with the individuals who made that decision. It is probably a good example. Mr. O'Brien is probably aware of comments that Ministers have made in recent days on individuals who made the mistakes about which we are speaking and who were responsible, in large part, for the neglect, poor care and, potentially, the very serious sexual abuse that occurred or is alleged. To cut to the chase, outside of Garda investigations and commissions of investigation, there are people still in the system, by which I mean the HSE, who have graduated to other organisations dealing with child protection whose work and involvement in this, in some cases, go back to the 1990s. They are still in the system and are still dealing with children and making very serious decisions at a very senior level when it comes to children. What is Mr. O'Brien doing about this? I want him to answer this question, considering he is the director general of the organisation. What is he doing? He must have concerns that if there are people who are responsible for this and for the neglect, as he put it, the poor care and the failings then surely the most basic and obvious step would be to have these people step aside until any investigation is concluded.
The public interest dimension of this now requires, in my opinion, these people to step aside while an investigation is concluded. What is not tolerable by the public at this point is for those people who were responsible for this to continue in their jobs, based on the fact they still have senior positions dealing with child protection in this country. If Mr. O'Brien's organisation does not understand this, it understands nothing. This is really, I think, the kernel of the matter today. Mr. O'Brien should probably have addressed it in his opening statement, and I am surprised he did not. Before he leaves the committee room, he will have to address this and satisfy the members of the committee that the individuals involved and responsible for this will account for themselves. That is critical, necessary and obvious.
Comment on this
In relation to the events of the 1990s, the individuals concerned are no longer in public service. In relation to subsequent events, the Conal Devine report was commissioned specifically to identify-----
Comment on this
Is Mr. O'Brien sure all of them are not in public service? Is he absolutely sure about that?
Comment on this
The three who made the decision to which I referred-----
Comment on this
That is not what Mr. O'Brien said. I am not talking about that specific decision. I am talking about people in the HSE and the health boards who were involved in the foster home and decisions about the foster home. They are still in public service. Is this correct?
Comment on this
No, answer that question. Is that correct?
Comment on this
If I was unclear in my first answer, I need to restate it. I know the Deputy will allow me to do so. I referred in my first answer, when the Deputy asked me for what I was apologising, to a specific decision that was made to leave Grace in the foster home in the 1990s. This was made by a three-person panel, for want of a better word, and those three persons are no longer in the public service to be clear about that.
The Conal Devine report was commissioned specifically to lay out in full unvarnished detail who did what and when, and would be the basis upon which any action in the disciplinary space would be taken. From the outset of its commencement, there was close liaison with An Garda Síochána, and it was always understood and intended that the report would be published and available, whatever action may be necessary.
However, since its conclusion in 2012, it has not been possible to use it for that purpose, and that is why no disciplinary action has been proceeded with on foot of the Conal Devine report.
Comment on this
I am saying it is not sufficient. I am saying this has gone on for 30 years. We talk about the circumstances of Ann, in particular, in 2013 and maybe before then. Considering that we are talking about a current situation and that very serious issues were raised in the early 1990s, Mr. O'Brien's answer is not sufficient. He cannot stand over what he just said with regard to the means of dealing with the people who are potentially responsible for making these mistakes, which are very horrendous and serious. It is just not going to wash any longer. Mr. O'Brien has got to accept that. The public will not allow it to wash. This matter dates back 20 or 30 years. We are talking about something in 2013 that was raised back in the early 1990s. Mr. O'Brien is going to have to come up with something better. I am sorry, but he will have to deal with the issue of those individuals who were responsible for this, who allowed it to continue and who have not been brought to book by his organisation because it would actually become an issue for it in terms of its corporate culture and the fact that the HSE's attitude to everything has become so defensive and litigious. The HSE has become incapable of dealing straightforwardly with problems and, as a result, it has actually become a danger to the very people it is meant to protect in the first place. That is the issue.
I ask Mr. O'Brien again - I am sure other members will ask him as well - what he is doing about the individuals who, from the early 1990s, made these decisions and who are still in the system in some cases. Mr. O'Brien should please not hide behind the Conal Devine report and the Garda investigations any longer. He will have to come up with a better answer with regard to making these people account for themselves. They are within his organisation in some cases.
Comment on this
I know the Deputy believes - he has said this to me before - that we are hiding behind either the Conal Devine report or our inability to publish it. If the committee has any doubt that I am not in a position to publish and proceed, it is able to take its own legal advice. I imagine and am certain it would be advised in the same way that I am advised, that is, that I cannot use that report in any way until I am cleared by An Garda Síochána to publish it. If I were to do so, I would be prejudicing an ongoing criminal investigation, which I do not have the right to do. If one had an unfettered ability to rewrite the law book, one might do things differently. In the case of Áras Attracta, for example, where there are currently prosecutions, the same issue applies.
Comment on this
Hang on a second. What is preventing Mr. O'Brien from picking up the phone and calling the individuals who were in charge at the time and who are still within his organisation? Has he done that?
Comment on this
To bring them into any process, I have to be in a position to give them the evidence that exists in relation to their conduct.
Comment on this
I am not talking about the evidence. I am talking about Mr. O'Brien, as the CEO or director general of the HSE, picking up the phone and asking the individuals what happened. He is not prevented by law from asking them what happened. He is not prevented by law from asking the people around him why, in the first instance, he was not told about the issues associated with Ann being in the home until 2013. If some members of the public were talking to Mr. O'Brien, they would say, "Tony, why don't you pick up the phone and find out what actually happened and who was involved here, and why don't you speak to them about the decisions they made from the 1990s up until 2013?" Has he spoken to them? Has he spoken to the people around them? Has he made any attempt to-----
Comment on this
They have all been interviewed as part of the Conal Devine process and I have not myself spoken to them. It would be neither normal nor appropriate given that I have an appeals function in relation to any disciplinary action that would follow. I would be prejudicing the process.
I do not live in the world that the Deputy and I probably wish I did live in where I could just do what I like. I cannot. I have to follow the process-----
Comment on this
That is the problem and the world is going to have to change. It is not tolerable any longer. It is not acceptable.
Comment on this
With respect, the world that I operate in is one governed by laws that are determined in this place, not where I work. It does not change the fact that I may be equally frustrated but I still have to follow the appropriate pathway within the legal framework that currently exists.
Comment on this
Mr. O'Brien has been in to this committee on quite a few occasions and I am afraid that I have come to the conclusion that he is hiding behind these reports. He is hiding behind the Garda investigation and-----
Comment on this
Deputy Deasy has said that a number of times. I would challenge him to obtain legal advice from the advisers that exist in the Houses of the Oireachtas so that he can know that I am not hiding behind these reports. It is very easy for the Deputy to say that but has he got legal advice that tells me I can do it? I do not think he has.
Comment on this
Perhaps I will change the subject here Chairman. If this is basically going to be the stonewall here today, as has been the case in every meeting with Mr. O'Brien at which this issue has been discussed, we are probably not going to get anywhere. With regard to the reports the invocation of one of the health Acts so the Minister and the junior Minister involved can finally request the reports after all this time is curious. It is curious and problematic for us that, after years and months of being told that "there is no way we can actually get or read these reports", they finally have the reports. All that had to be done was to read an Act and see that the definition of the Acts does allow these reports to be obtained.
Comment on this
Hang on a minute. Mr. O'Brien has got to let me finish. Again, the kernel of this is the public interest dimension. Now Mr. O'Brien has admitted the mistakes and the failings - we know the detail of the allegations involved and we know the people who are still within the system in many cases while some have moved on to other organisations dealing with child protection. The reality is that a previous Garda investigation collapsed. This second Garda investigation may not go anywhere and commissions of investigation take time. People retire or leave the system. The people who are actually charged with making these mistakes remain in situ and have access to files and e-mails and are sitting on potential evidence. That is a big issue. If Mr. O'Brien is so frustrated legally and is saying "Oh my God I cannot do anything ... these people", has he asked anyone whether or not there needs to be a change of course with regard to his powers internally? If it is the case that he is going crazy in not being able to deal with this and not being able to make these people account for themselves, has he just given up and left it at that? Is that effectively the answer to the committee here today?
Comment on this
No it is not. I know the term "stonewalling" has a certain cachet. I am not stonewalling the committee. I am prepared to answer any question I can that does not involve me effectively publishing the two reports that An Garda Síochána has asked me not to. I want to be very clear that this is the only reason they were not published. The reports were accepted when they were submitted; the Conal Devine report in 2012 and the Resilience report in March 2015. The recommendations are being pursued and the intention of the commissioning of the Conal Devine Report - which preceded my own time - and it is written in to the terms of reference, was that it would be for publication. It has been prepared carefully so it can be published but it cannot be published in the face of a Garda objection to its publication.
Comment on this
I have asked Mr. O'Brien this question a couple of times. He stated at our previous meeting that he had not read the reports.
Comment on this
So now he has read the reports. All right. What change prompted Mr. O'Brien to read the reports? When I asked him the question at our previous meeting he stated he had not read the reports. Will he remind the committee of the reasons he felt he could not read the reports? Why has he changed his mind?
Comment on this
It was never the case that I could not read the reports. It was the case that I had not read them, although I was obviously aware of the recommendations and monitoring their implementation. When I was last here and we talked about this, I shared correspondence with the committee concerning the decision of the Information Commissioner and the pending cooling-off period, subject to whether there would be an appeal, etc. In that period, recognising that it was likely that the recommendations would all be in the public domain, I took the opportunity to read the full reports. I re-read them last weekend and I am now very familiar with what they say, but I still cannot tell the Deputy all that they say.
Comment on this
Okay; well, answer this question. Now that he has read the reports, does Mr. O'Brien have any personal concern that the people involved in making these decisions are still involved in child protection?
Comment on this
I am very concerned that I am unable to publish them and unable to-----
Comment on this
I need to give a complete answer, if I may.
Comment on this
Mr. O'Brien is giving me a legalistic answer.
Comment on this
Now that he has read the reports, does Mr. O'Brien have any personal concern that the people involved in making these mistakes - the neglect and poor care that he has described in writing to this committee - are still involved in child protection?
Comment on this
There are a wide number of people whose actions are detailed in the report. It is clear from my reading of the report that there were many instances - missed opportunities - but not all of the people covered were on, shall we say, the downside of that. I am concerned that there is an ongoing delay to enabling us to publish the reports, which would enable each of those involved - each of the persons implicated, as it were - to have an opportunity to answer what it says in the report so that those who have something to account for can account for it and those who are blameless can have their names restored, as it were.
Comment on this
We have gone from abuse and neglect of the most egregious nature to "missed opportunities." That is my problem here. Mr. O'Brien started off in the opening paragraph of his opening statement-----
Comment on this
There were missed opportunities to prevent-----
Comment on this
Will Mr. O'Brien explain what he means by "missed opportunities"?
Comment on this
As has been in the public domain, and answering the Deputy at a general level so as not to open the documents themselves, there were occasions on which there was information available which, had it been treated differently, would have removed Grace from that situation earlier than she was removed, and, on the basis of what is alleged to have happened, she would therefore have been protected from the egregious abuse that is alleged to have occurred.
Comment on this
And these people are still working in the HSE?
Comment on this
There are many people who were involved in different ways in those processes. One of the features of this is the disagreements that occurred at different times as to what should have occurred, and different people were on different sides of those disagreements. Some of those people are still working in either the HSE or Tusla.
Comment on this
One of the reports in the newspapers today quoted one of the whistleblowers as saying that when he visited the foster home in question, there had not been a HSE inspection of that foster home in six years. Can Mr. O'Brien confirm that?
Comment on this
I cannot confirm that detail but I can confirm that the issue of the frequency and appropriateness of visitation, inspection and compliance with the relevant legislation at that time is the subject of the Conal Devine review.
Comment on this
Is that a missed opportunity, as Mr. O'Brien referred to? After everything that happened and the failure of Mr. O'Brien's organisation to visit the individual in question in the foster home, is Mr. O'Brien seriously describing this as "disagreements," "differences of opinion" and "missed opportunities"? Is that really what he is getting at? I would refer to that a bit differently.
I would refer to that as extremely serious and as constituting negligence of extraordinary proportions, not a missed opportunity. It is serious.
Comment on this
I will tell the Deputy why I use the term "missed opportunity". It is exactly the same language that HIQA uses in its reports, and I am borrowing that language for no other reason.
Comment on this
I ask Mr. O'Brien not to use HIQA lingo.
Comment on this
Let us be clear. I have already described the nature of the allegations. We are not in disagreement. I have accepted that up front.
Comment on this
What we are in disagreement about is what to do with the people who were responsible at the time-----
Comment on this
-----who are still working in the system and how Mr. O'Brien is dealing with that.
Comment on this
We may not even be in any disagreement about that.
Comment on this
What we have a difference of view on, I think, is what is within my power to do right now. We have a difference of view on how much of that turns on the ability to publish the Conal Devine report.
Comment on this
Does Mr. O'Brien trust the people around him to give him full and clear information, and does he believe that the people around him have given him the full facts every time he has asked questions with regard to the details of this foster home and everything around it?
Comment on this
When the Deputy says "the people around" me, is he referring to the two people who are accompanying me today?
Comment on this
I refer to the people whom Mr. O'Brien has asked to report to him on this issue.
Comment on this
The honest answer to that question is that I do not always get the answer to the question I am asking first time and, a bit like the Deputy, I often go back with follow-up questions.
Comment on this
I really should try again. Actually, Mr. O'Brien should try again. I asked him a question.
Comment on this
I ask Deputy Deasy to tell me the question again, if that is all right, Chairman.
Comment on this
It is clear from Mr. O'Brien's interview on Sunday that, for him, it was new information-----
Comment on this
That this individual, Ann, had been in the foster home until November 2013. Is that the case?
Comment on this
That information is contained in the Resilience report and, in that sense, it is not new information.
Comment on this
Okay. Let me ask Mr. O'Brien my question again.
Comment on this
I will tell the Deputy why I appeared to hesitate at the end of that interview. I had had a number of discussions with people directly involved in this on Friday arising from the events here on Thursday. I had not expected that particular question and I was a little fuzzy on one or two of the details, so I gave a slightly broader answer so as not to mislead in any way. I then asked the relevant questions and was able within a couple of hours to confirm the detail to RTE, the broadcaster in question, and that was confirmed to other media as well.
Comment on this
I am sure the Deputy has been in that situation.
Comment on this
I will ask the question again so. When Mr. O'Brien has asked questions about this issue in the past couple of years, is he happy that the information he received was accurate? Is he happy that he was not misinformed? Is he happy that the people whom he asked to deal with this gave him the correct answers at all times?
Comment on this
I am certainly happy that every effort has been made to give me the correct information. On occasion I have had the opportunity to question something - is that complete, is that whole, is the sequence of that correct - but on the broad issue of trust, the answer is "Yes." From time to time I do not trust everybody, but on this one, given the existence of the two reports which are clear and unambiguous and the other information that has been provided, I have a good degree of trust.
Comment on this
Finally - for the time being, anyway - on the issue of the apology, Mr. O'Brien mentioned the rebuttal to the Irish Examiner. Frankly, if Daniel McConnell had not written that story in the Irish Examiner, we would not be sitting here talking about this today. With regard to Mr. O'Brien's two-page rebuttal, which was very detailed and very specific with regard to individuals - how they did it, what they said - is he comfortable that he was given the correct information? He stated that it was a misunderstanding; I do not believe that. I think it was dressed up. I believe the two individuals who were meant to give that apology were never instructed to give the apology, and they made it clear to people after the fact that they did not give the apology. With regard to Mr. O'Brien's version of events, which I will not go into, I do not believe it occurred the way it has been characterised. In some ways that is a good thing, because we would not be talking about this and we would not have a commission of investigation if Mr. O'Brien had not gone to the bother of rebutting that story in the two-page letter to the committee.
It was, as it has turned out, not a negative thing. The director general can go ahead.
Comment on this
I set out, in my opening statement, the information that I obtained from meeting the principals involved which included the two individuals - the one who made the phone call to Grace's mother and the other who met Grace. I also saw the correspondence. I should say, at the outset, that I was not happy with the nature of the apology at all in relation to the 44 letters that went out, which is why I have subsequently issued a much more appropriate apology myself and there is a copy of that attached to the opening statement. That is the first thing to say.
In relation to the miscommunication, misunderstanding, mis-interpretation or whatever we care to call it, I have spoken to all of the parties involved, including those two. Having looked at the whites of their eyes and sat down with them for over two and half hours, I am satisfied that there was a miscommunication and that there was no intention to mislead. I cannot imagine why the people involved - the chief officer, for example, has been working in Ireland for about four or five months, having been in Australia for a long time. The two individuals concerned, I cannot imagine why they would wish or have any motivation to concoct a story in relation to this apology given that the three of those, and those to whom they sent that information, but the three of those had no hand, act or part in the previous substantive issues that we are talking about. I do not see any motivation there either to misunderstand or mislead and I accept their bona fides. I agree that the net effect is that an incorrect story was told and this committee was given incorrect information and, again, I apologise for that.
Comment on this
I will ask my last question, Chairman, for the time being. When the Minister of State, Deputy Lynch, and I am not going to get political here, asked for the full information on this foster home and asked if anyone else remained in the home, she was given faulty information.
Comment on this
I do not accept that. When she asked was in early 2014 and in early 2014 there was no one remaining in the foster home.
Comment on this
That is Mr. O'Brien's answer with regard to that matter. Did Mr. O'Brien tell her about Ann at that time or did he say that Grace was the last resident in the foster home?
Comment on this
I have had subsequent conversations with her.
Comment on this
So the Minister of State was not told about Ann. Is that what Mr. O'Brien is saying?
Comment on this
No. I am saying I did not have that conversation.
Comment on this
Mr. O'Brien does not know. So Mr. O'Brien does not know if the Minister of State was given faulty information then. Was she informed about Ann or not?
Comment on this
When I spoke to her on Sunday, just this Sunday gone, we discussed the issue of what information was provided to her and when. Partly because of the issue that we talked about earlier, at the end of that interview I was slightly equivocal because I was unclear of the exact dates. She picked up on that herself. We spoke and she was concerned to know whether, when she was briefed in early 2014, had anyone remained in the home. When I was able to confirm that that was not the case, then she was satisfied.
Comment on this
When the Minister of State asked the question initially, she was not told about Ann.
Comment on this
That I do not know. The Deputy will have to ask her about that.
Comment on this
It is pretty clear that she was not, at this point. It is clear from the Minister of State that she was not.
Comment on this
I have not had that conversation about that. The central point-----
Comment on this
I am looking at Mr. O'Brien's opening statement. He said there were "various engagements" from 2011 through to 2013 concerning Ann, internally and within the system.
Comment on this
All I can say is the central point that we talked about, and I cannot speak to other things, was whether anyone had remained beyond the point to which she had been given an assurance that no one remained there, and that point was in early 2014.
Comment on this
I thank the Chairman. I will come back in later after other members have contributed. The hallmark of this entire issue with Mr. O'Brien's organisation has been when anyone asks a question, in here or at ministerial level, they are given just enough information to suffice with regard to kicking the matter down the road. The hallmark of this matter is that full information has not been given by Mr. O'Brien's organisation at times. The HSE, as the Chairman has said, has been dragged kicking and screaming, in many respects and on many occasions, to give us that information. That is the hallmark of this entire issue and that has been our experience in this committee.
I am afraid that is a big problem for me.
Comment on this
I think our shared frustration stems from the fact we cannot give the Deputy what he wants, which is the two reports. If we were able to do that, many of his concerns would be addressed in that he would have full information. The reports pull no punches. They lay this out in full detail and the issue that creates this difficulty is that we cannot give him those reports.
Comment on this
I will say one last thing to Mr. O'Brien. He should have read those reports a long time ago. He tells us he has read them now, when these allegations date back to the early 1990s and are very serious. For Mr. O'Brien to feel compelled now to read them tells me everything. He should have done it a long time ago and it is inexcusable that he did not considering what we have brought up in this committee, what the concerns have been and their seriousness. That tells us an awful lot.
Comment on this
Thank you, Deputy Deasy. For the information of members, Deputy Costello has indicated, as have Deputies McDonald, Dowds and McFadden. That is the order in which members will contribute. Before I call Deputy Costello, I want to bring the meeting back to the reason we are here. It arises from poor information or misinformation, the work of the whistleblowers and their bravery in coming forward.
I would have thought, Mr. O'Brien, given the content of what has been told to the HSE by the whistleblowers and the extreme nature of the abuse we are speaking about, that you would have availed of the opportunity to be a lot more open in your opening statement. I see the English language being used to strengthen the veil of secrecy around what is going on. It is a pathetic attempt to continue what happened at our previous meeting.
I want to answer the question that Mr. O'Brien asked Deputy Deasy. He might answer it in a different way, having reflected on it. Mr. O'Brien asked him if he understood the legal advice and the legalities of where Mr. O'Brien stood. Let me be clear about this. Mr. O'Brien said that he shares our frustration. He has no idea of the degree of frustration and anger that exists throughout the country, beyond this committee, concerning this issue. As we get nearer to the centre and to the families concerned, and we experience the sadness and watch on their faces the question marks and the fact they have misplaced their trust in Mr. O'Brien's organisation, one cannot even begin to answer them or to understand that sadness. I do not know how the individuals who suffered in this foster home feel.
To answer the question about this legal discussion that Mr. O'Brien had with Deputy Deasy, what about the rights of the 47? What about the breach of their rights? What about the fact their rights were trampled upon, kicked around and ignored by the State and Mr. O'Brien's organisation? What about those rights?
Mr. O'Brien can find all the fancy words in the English dictionary to describe this. It is alleged rape. It is alleged sexual abuse of the most horrific kind. It is physical abuse. It is in the form of evidence where the clients appeared in hospital, battered and bruised. It is in the form of evidence from the whistleblowers as to what happened. Yes, we speak now about Grace and Ann, but there are 47 people affected by this who cannot speak for themselves, who could not speak for themselves at the time and who are intellectually disabled.
Your defence is not of them; your defence is of those who ignored that house to one degree or another, those who failed in their duty of care. That would seem to be your defence. I find that absolutely shocking because of where we are today and because we are here today. I understand the legalities around the publication. However, I want you to understand this - it is not about the members of the Committee of Public Accounts and what we feel. It is about you giving some sort of comfort to these 47 and to all others in care in this State on this day, but I do not get that comfort from your statement. I do not get a sense that the HSE gets it. That is what is coming across in the opening questions from Deputy Deasy and the conversation around those questions.
I will call Deputy Costello next, and I am honestly asking you to please reflect on the state of play within the HSE and on those within the HSE who know exactly what happened because they do know. I wish to remind you that in 1993 the South-Eastern Health Board carried out investigation after investigation because of the Kilkenny incest cases. There was a spotlight on the South-Eastern Health Board for a long time during this period. There was a concentration on the care for the intellectually disabled and those in care. How this home escaped all of that, I do not know. I am not convinced that what was going on was not widely known within the HSE at the time.
I will finish on this. In his opening remarks Mr. O'Brien adverted to those who were referred to this service by the HSE or the health board, as it was then. There were other referrals - from the Brothers of Charity I think - but they stopped those referrals because of suspicions they had in 1990. However, the HSE or the health board continued.
A further aspect is that individuals were taken into that foster home independently of either the HSE or the Brothers of Charity. I would have expected you to avail of the opportunity today to give an overall context to how this house existed at all, to its interaction with the HSE or the health board and the Brothers of Charity and to how they independently took in individuals.
Lastly, I thought you would have dealt with the complaint made by an authority in England. We are told an authority in the United Kingdom made a complaint in respect of the service and concerns certain individuals had. That is the context for today's meeting. Let us not forget the horrific nature of the abuse in this case as you answer questions.
Comment on this
Thank you, Chairman. I thank Mr. O'Brien and his team for coming before the committee today. The matters we are discussing are extremely serious. I do not think we have had an issue of such a horrendous nature before this committee previously. Important issues of accountability and responsibility arise before us today as well as the question of the entire operation and ethos of the HSE. We are discussing a very serious matter.
Mr. O'Brien gave us a briefing and said that the HSE sent us a briefing paper on 10 December. In the opening points in that document the HSE states that no individuals have been placed with the family by the South-Eastern Health Board, the HSE or voluntary service providers since 1995. Is that the situation?
Comment on this
Yes, that is confirmed in both of the reports.
Comment on this
Was the HSE aware of anyone else being placed in a private capacity?
Comment on this
The Resilience report contains the information relating to Ann, which I have included.
Comment on this
We are not necessarily discussing the Resilience report, but the actual situation that pertained since 1995.
Comment on this
The Resilience report, from which I will draw this information-----
Comment on this
I have to rely on a source of information, so I am telling the Deputy what it is.
Comment on this
The HSE had no further information about anyone else going in any other capacity to-----
Comment on this
I am about to give the Deputy the information that he is asking for, but I am citing where I am drawing it from for the sake of clarity, if that is okay. The Resilience report - the second report - was a look-back or tracing exercise and made reference to nine persons known to have been placed there under private arrangements throughout the totality of the period. The last of those was Ann. According to the information in the Resilience report, she was the only one who was there beyond 2009.
Comment on this
Was the HSE aware of anyone else being put there in any capacity? Is that the full story now?
Comment on this
Mr. O'Brien is telling me what the full story is from the Resilience report.
Comment on this
The Resilience report was commissioned specifically to-----
Comment on this
I am aware of the Resilience report and its commissioning, but I will move on.
Comment on this
The aim of the report was to identify the totality of persons who had experienced "care" in that setting. It identified nine who had been placed there privately, that is, not by the South Eastern Health Board, SEHB, or the HSE. The HSE never actually placed anyone there. Placements ceased in 1995.
Comment on this
Did the HSE give us the full story on 10 December? The impression that was clearly given was that no individuals had been placed - to the letter of the law, that was accurate - by the South Eastern Health Board, the HSE or any voluntary service provider, but that was not the full story. Was the HSE aware at the time of a broader story of private placements that whoever wrote this chose not to divulge?
Comment on this
The HSE has had the Resilience report since March 2015 and, therefore, was aware that there had been nine private placements, one of whom was Ann.
Comment on this
Why did the report used to brief the Committee of Public Accounts not contain that extra information? We are discussing vulnerable people in the care of an institution that we were given the impression no one was in after 1995.
Comment on this
No. It was clear that the person we now call Grace was there until 2009. The term "placement" is intended-----
Comment on this
I will ask Mr. Healy to respond, if I may.
Comment on this
That is the distinction that the Deputy mentioned concerning private placements. The focus of the report was on identifying who the health service had placed there. The health service, the South Eastern Health Board, voluntary providers and public providers had-----
Comment on this
This conceals the fact that other people were there. It gives the impression that the only people who were going there were the ones who were coming either from the SEHB, the HSE or the voluntary service providers. Now we know that other people were there. We could not have known it from the information provided by the HSE.
Comment on this
The witnesses cannot just rely on the-----
Comment on this
The significant issue is that, when the State takes a decision or allows a situation where it has responsibility for people with intellectual disability, it places them. That is what happened in the case of Grace. The State was looking after Grace as a child from an early age and placed the child in this location. That is the most significant issue where the State has responsibility for provision. That is what we were communicating.
Comment on this
I am well aware of that, but this briefing-----
Comment on this
If I could make a further point. In Ann's case, we are trying-----
Comment on this
I have not asked Mr. Healy about that case yet. Why was further information not divulged to us about other people who were there subsequently, having been placed in a private capacity and of whom the HSE was aware? It had read the Resilience report, which referred to this matter, but the HSE did not advert to it.
Comment on this
We were discussing the totality of vulnerable people who were in that foster home.
Mr. Healy gives the impression that there was another cohort that was not there at all.
Comment on this
In writing the report, the clear intention was to clarify what the State had done in putting people there. The distinction is that in the case of the private placements, they were not placed there and living there, as Grace was, but rather they were living at home or they were attending residential or day centres and came on a weekend or on a respite visit. That was the reason the emphasis in this report-----
Comment on this
It was not just a question of emphasis, the other was excluded. Let us go on-----
Comment on this
Would Mr. Healy tell Deputy Costello just how many people we are talking about, including independent referrals, referrals from the Brothers of Charity, referrals from the HSE and these other cases he is talking about?
Comment on this
What we sought to do in the report, actually-----
Comment on this
There is, therefore, no number beyond 47 about which we have to be concerned; it is 47.
Comment on this
It is 47 and that was the reason for including 47-----
Comment on this
It is not quite the answer. There is no reference to those other people in the response that came to us initially. They are included in the 47, but they are not included in the information that was divulged to us.
Comment on this
The challenge we had in dealing with this was that on the day we wrote this report we had received an approval to release into the public domain the information cleared by the Information Commissioner - the 12 pages that were allowed, principally the terms of reference and most of the recommendations, which were non-personal in nature. That was what we had. We took the opportunity to include some additional information, which would not raise issues in respect of the Garda investigation or anything like that, which was very significant, to be of assistance to the committee. That is what we sought to do.
Comment on this
For clarification, is it 47 plus nine, or-----
Comment on this
No, it is 47. The nine are in that. The purpose-----
Comment on this
What is misleading, if I may so, is that there is no reference to the nine in the 47.
Comment on this
In the briefing document that was given to us on 10 December, the impression is given that there is nobody else there at all other than the people who were referred by the South-Eastern Health Board, the HSE or the voluntary providers. There is no reference whatsoever to private referrals or other charitable referrals.
Comment on this
Just to say to Deputy Costello, the information we gave here related to the placements. We set out in 1.4 the placements in respect of-----
Comment on this
The information that has been given in relation to 47 should have included the fact that there were people other than those referred by the HSE and the SEHB, because that concealed the fact that there was another channel of referrals, which should have been referred to in all of this. I want to move on-----
Comment on this
Can I clarify, Chair? It actually identifies the totality. What it was setting out was the overall-----
Comment on this
Where does it identify the totality?
Comment on this
It is set out on page 5. There is a table there that sets out the total. What it is seeking to do-----
Comment on this
Page 5 of the report. It sets out the totality and it goes through every single one. In 1.5 on page 6 there is a summary analysis.
Comment on this
It is certainly not there on page 5. I see the table, but it does not show the origins or the referrals.
Comment on this
It was not intended to do that. What it was doing-----
Comment on this
Why is Mr. Healy saying it is doing it, then? It is not doing it.
Comment on this
Can I just explain? If Deputy Costello goes to page 6 of the report, at 1.5, it sets out there that of the 46 users who were identified, 35 families were interviewed and 36 service users. What we were trying to communicate out of the Resilience report, without going into it-----
Comment on this
Forty-seven service users and 46 families. One of the families had two children involved
Comment on this
If Mr. Healy is saying that is clear about the nine families-----
Comment on this
I know what the purpose is. What I am pointing out-----
Comment on this
I do not want to dwell on it much longer. The document Mr. Healy sent to us clearly indicated that no individuals had been placed in this foster home since 1995 and that the totality of those who were there was described by the South Eastern Health Board, the HSE and the voluntary service providers. Now he is giving an apology. Why should he be apologising to these people when he had nothing to do with them being placed in this home and he did not even refer to them in the original document?
Comment on this
Can I explain what we were setting out? We were indicating what was covered by the Resilience report. The Resilience report was-----
Comment on this
That is not what it is. That is what Mr. Healy is saying.
Comment on this
Sorry, I am not going to dwell any longer on it. All I am saying is that the report submitted to the Committee of Public Accounts did not say a word on the outside about being a Resilience report.
Comment on this
The table is an extract, Deputy Costello. What we have done is that we have summarised key pieces of the report that we felt we could put into the public domain.
Comment on this
The point I am making is that misleading information was given to this committee. That is what happened at our last meeting as well. Misleading information was given to us at the previous meeting.
Comment on this
There was a categorical statement that people had gone to the service user and that they had made an apology. The two people who met the service user and the birth mother have declared categorically that they were not asked to make an apology. Is that a fabrication? Who actually wrote the note that came to us on 21 January?
Comment on this
The note described something that did not happen. I refer to the non-apology.
Comment on this
It described in graphic and detailed terms how an apology that never took place was supposed to have taken place and how two people went along to make the apology. We know now that no apology ever took place. Maybe there was some expression of regret, but there was supposed to be an apology, as outlined by Mr. O'Brien today. It never happened. Surely that is misleading.
Comment on this
I have agreed and accepted that the committee was misled. The issue is whether it was deliberate.
Comment on this
That is accepted now. We were misled-----