We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

HSE Report on Foster Home in Waterford Community Care Area: Discussion

Contributions 195–398 of 792. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.

Mr. Tony O'Brien

Yes.

Comment on this

-----by whoever wrote that particular-----

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

It is very clear that because the information was not accurate, it had the effect of misleading the committee.

Comment on this

Who wrote the note?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

It came from our parliamentary affairs department. It would have come through my office up from the chief officer.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Healy take responsibility for that?

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

Could I just say-----

Comment on this

No, Mr. Healy-----

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

Of course I take-----

Comment on this

"Yes" or "No".

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

I think the information we have set out-----

Comment on this

Does Mr. Healy take responsibility for the inaccuracies that were presented to us?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

Ultimately, as the national director, of course, yes.

Comment on this

"Yes" is the answer.

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

Can I-----

Comment on this

Can I ask a further question? Mr. Healy is taking responsibility for an inaccurate and misleading note that was rushed to the Committee of Public Accounts to counter an article that had been published in the Irish Examiner. Is that correct? Mr. Healy never checked his facts.

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

I need to-----

Comment on this

All he needed to do was to ask the two people who were alleged to have spoken and to have given the apology whether they had done so. They have said not only that they did not give an apology, but also that they were not asked to give an apology.

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

With respect, I have spoken to these individuals. I went to see them specifically in order to prepare for this encounter today. The individuals concerned confirmed that when asked if an apology had been given - they were asked that in the context of responding to this issue - they said "Yes". They also confirmed that they were not saying they had given an official apology. In the course of expressing their remorse, the word "sorry" was used. When they were asked had they apologised, they confirmed yes. The person asking the question did not ask them whether they had given personal expressions of remorse. That person was asking them whether they had given an official apology. There was a request for an apology to be included in the overall process, but that was not picked up. In my view, having spoken to all concerned, this was an honest mistake. That mistake influenced what happened at the meetings and in the telephone call. It carried through to the information that was provided to the committee, which was incorrect, and to that extent it misled the committee. The question is whether anyone set out to mislead the committee. Having spoken to all of those involved, I do not believe they did.

Comment on this

I refer to the note we received from the Waterford Intellectual Disability Association. It states that:

The two HSE representatives to whom the HSE have attributed the apologies to our client and to her mother have both confirmed to us that they were never asked to apologise, that they did not apologise, and they told the HSE chief officer that no apologies were given, yet the HSE continued to issue repeated statements containing fabricated information about meetings that did not happen, apologies that were never covered, never offered, and conversations that never took place.

Is Mr. O'Brien saying that is an untruth?

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

No. What I am saying is that those are not the words of the two individuals concerned. One of the people who was party to those conversations, Ms Aileen Colley, is sitting to my right, and I will ask her to respond to the Deputy's question.

Comment on this
Ms Aileen Colley

In response to that, when we go back to the intent, the intent was very much on 7, 8, 9 and 10 December to issue an apology to all 47 people. In the discussions, teleconferences, preparations and communications it was always the intent to actually send a letter to all of the people and their families. Over the course of that time, with the local people involved - a local HSE team - it was decided that the best way of communicating to Grace and her mother would involve more personalised communication. In the translation between the letter right through to the actual meeting that vital apology got lost.

Comment on this

I will stop Ms Colley at that. Everybody was getting an apology, and the HSE was going to give a special apology to Grace and her birth mother. How could it end up that no apology at all took place, if the HSE was going to give a special apology?

Comment on this
Ms Aileen Colley

I guess that is exactly the point of how-----

Comment on this

How could it be that the two people who were supposed to give the apology deny that they were ever to do so? Are they telling lies?

Comment on this
Ms Aileen Colley

The sequence of events shows that the apology was always one of the key themes for the interactions that happened in December. When one then brings that forward to January, and the people in question were asked if they had given the apology, their first response was that they did apologise. On the back of that, the information was supplied from the local team through to the national office and the Committee of Public Accounts. It was subsequent to that that we actually discovered what happened, through my direct interactions with the two people concerned, and they clarified for me that when they had said they had given an apology it was actually a personal statement of sympathy and remorse. On finding out - that was after the Committee of Public Accounts-----

Comment on this

I really cannot buy that. If this was supposed to be a special apology, how could it be a watered-down statement of remorse?

Comment on this
Ms Aileen Colley

That is where the miscommunication happened.

Comment on this

That is not miscommunication. How does one miscommunicate a special apology with a watered-down version?

Comment on this
Ms Aileen Colley

I think, as the director general states, there was a two and a half hour meeting between the other two individuals, myself and himself where we put the evidence before all of us to in order to go through the sequence of events. It very much confirmed that the intent was always there and it is with much regret that the apology did not take place when it should have, as was described in the Committee of Public Accounts documents.

Comment on this

I know it is, but a document was rushed to the Committee of Public Accounts for our meeting of the 21st to say categorically that what was in the Irish Examiner was inaccurate, false and untrue without the facts having been checked.

Comment on this
Ms Aileen Colley

The facts were checked, and as I said it was the interpretation of what an apology was and what context that was given-----

Comment on this

It is very hard for those of us on this side of the table to buy that. This was an important case.

We have had a few inquiries into it. We have the Resilience and the Conal Devine reports and a review from the Minister. We have evidence highlighting that not only was an apology not given but the Committee of Public Accounts, which was considering this issue in depth, was informed categorically that it had all been done correctly. Nobody checked the facts. There is no good in telling me there was a misunderstanding. There was a significant misleading response to the Committee of Public Accounts. One cannot come to a conclusion other than it was deliberate.

Comment on this
Ms Aileen Colley

It has been stated elsewhere that the two people directly involved are recent recruits to that service, as I am. Why would we wish to mislead?

Comment on this

If this apology was so important, why was it left to two people who were new to the service and not allocated to somebody with a high level of responsibility and accountability?

Comment on this
Ms Aileen Colley

The reason is that although these two people were new to the service, they were not new to this position or to a higher level of responsibility. They had a relationship with the organisation and one of the parties had at least met Grace before. It was in the context of how we could do the best thing in terms of the person involved and taking due regard of trying to lessen any distress that some of these decisions were made

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

Having spoken to them, my view is that if they had not tried to do a tailored response and if they had not tried to do the right thing, this particular issue would never have arisen. They were moving from a standardised letter with an apology in it, which I do not think was a sufficient apology but nonetheless included an apology and which would have satisfied the expectations that were reflected in the document that was sent to the committee on 10 December 2015. The timetabling around this was influenced by the decision of the Freedom of Information Commissioner, the expiration of the appeal period and the timing of the meeting. There was a strong desire on the part of the social care division to get that part of the report that was approved to be released into the public domain to the committee by that date. A significant level of effort had been made to ensure the individuals involved and their families - there were 47 families, 44 of whom could be contacted - were made aware in advance of release that it could lead to some parts of this information coming into the public domain. The social care division made a decision that an apology should be included in that letter. It was in the case of 43. The decision was made locally in the case of the person to whom we are referring to as Grace that this should be done in a different way. That in essence is where it went wrong.

Comment on this

I will not pursue this point further other than to say it smacks of either fabrication or incompetence of a very high order. I wish to put a question in respect of Ann who was in this home during the period from 2011 to 2013.

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

She was there in different ways for a period much longer than that. The original contact started 23 years ago.

Comment on this

I understand the HSE sought legal advice relating to Ann in 2012, despite the fact there were serious problems of abuse from 1995 and the HSE took no action. The HSE tried to persuade the family not to send Ann into the abusive care. Why did it not close it down and put a stop to it? It took the HSE another three years from the time of the legal advice to send a letter which was, as Mr. O'Brien stated in his remarks, "demanding the foster family cease all care activity". Then and only then was Ann's family written to formally to request that they cease the placement. Surely that is gross incompetence.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

Certainly this is one of the issues that is addressed in the reports. It goes back to my earlier conservation with the Deputy that we talk about the "foster home" and the "foster mother" although they had ceased to be that in the 1990s. This is dealt with in the Devine report in a very clear and comprehensive way.

It had ceased to be a foster home and this person had ceased to be a foster mother. That is clear, but we talk about the individual as the foster mother.

What happened was that when this situation arose in respect of Grace, the Devine report was carried out, which examined all of the issues around that. It focused particularly on Grace - that is why it was constituted - but in the course of the work, the investigation team identified four other cases of significance. Ann was not identified as part of that. There were concerns of a serious nature in respect of that, and they were followed up. The issue in-----

Comment on this

I know that, but it is the way they were followed up that leaves a lot to be desired.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

The issue is in respect of this particular placement of Ann. She was residing at home. She was not placed in this foster home. She was never in care; she was never in the care of the State. She was living at home with her family.

Comment on this

That is Ann, but what about the foster home? Why did the HSE not close it down earlier? It was telling the family not to send her there but it was doing nothing about the home itself.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

Because it was not a recognised foster home.

Comment on this

On that question, can the Department of Health tell me whether it intervened at any stage, in the context of the continuation of services at that foster home, asking that it be reconsidered and that they continue to use the foster home. Is that true or false?

Comment on this
Ms Frances Spillane

To the best of my knowledge, that is false. We did get representations in the mid-1990s asking the Minister to intervene to allow the home to continue, but the reply that issued indicated very clearly that this was a matter for the South Eastern Health Board.

Comment on this

Does Ms Spillane have correspondence from her Department that was sent?

Comment on this
Ms Frances Spillane

Yes, we do.

Comment on this

Can we have copies of that correspondence?

Comment on this
Ms Frances Spillane

Yes.

Comment on this

-----because we have correspondence that offers information to the contrary.

Can Mr. Healy tell me when he first heard of the foster home?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

When the protected disclosures were-----

Comment on this

When was that?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

At the end of 2009.

Comment on this

Mr. Healy knew nothing about it up to then.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

I knew nothing about it.

Comment on this

What did he do when he heard about it?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

How we became aware of it was through protected disclosures. That was already being addressed through the authorised officer and an investigation was being initiated, so when I heard about it I contacted the local head manager. I was the regional director at the time and there was-----

Comment on this

By "regional director," does Mr. Healy mean he was the regional director of the South Eastern Health Board?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

No. I was responsible for the south from Wexford to Kerry, and so I was responsible for that area at a regional level. Each particular local area had its own area manager, management team and so on, but once an issue of protected disclosure arose it was brought to my attention. I was responsible for the totality of that area, a million people-----

Comment on this

Do not try to minimise it.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

I am not at all. The scale of it is the important-----

Comment on this

It is, but Mr. Healy had a job to do.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

Absolutely, and so when I heard about that-----

Comment on this

Do not minimise it. Mr. Healy did this the last day he appeared before the committee, and I would prefer it if he stuck to the facts.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

Absolutely.

Comment on this

The fact is that Mr. Healy heard about it in 2009.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

Yes, and so I-----

Comment on this

When did he hear about it again after that?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

What happened at that point was that I asked for a report in respect of the issue but, given the protected disclosures at that time, they had looked at it nationally and it was agreed that there would be a commissioned report, which was undertaken and commenced in March 2010. At that stage, additional protected disclosures had been received and the terms of reference were adjusted to take account of the totality of those.

Comment on this

Did Mr. Healy have a report in 2010?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

No. The investigation regarding Grace commenced in March 2010.

Comment on this

Did Mr. Healy familiarise himself with the issues that had come to light in 2009?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

The issue that was identified at the time-----

Comment on this

No - Mr. Healy familiarised himself with the issue-----

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

Yes. I was advised-----

Comment on this

-----and the action he took was to-----

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

The establishment of this investigation.

Comment on this

Which investigation?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

The investigation of the Devine report.

Comment on this

The Devine report was finished and handed over to the HSE in 2012.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

No. I was the regional director. It was commissioned by the area manager who had responsibility for that area. It was returned to her in March 2012.

Comment on this

Was this issue raised at a conference, generally speaking?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

It was raised much later when I was the national director of disability. In more recent times, it was raised in December 2014.

Comment on this

It was raised in November 2014.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

It could have been November but I think it was December.

Comment on this

It was 17 November. Mr. Healy and Mr. O'Brien heard this at a conference. What I am asking now is, did it not ring alarm bells for them that in 2014 they were still being asked about something that happened in this home many many years ago that was just horrific? Is that right?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

At that point in time-----

Comment on this

I just want to ask the question. Did Mr. Healy hear it at that conference?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

The question that was asked at the conference was why we were not publishing the reports and-----

Comment on this

Yes, but arising from the question Mr. Healy would have known that the issue was not being dealt with it. It had not come back to his attention or that of the HSE and this was five years down the road.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

It had come back to my attention at that stage.

Comment on this

So Mr. Healy knew about it. Is there such a position as national director for quality and patient safety?

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

There was until early 2015 when that post was divided into two different categories.

Comment on this

Is Mr. O'Brien aware that the individual in the position of national director for quality and patient safety was notified about a lot of the issues that we are talking about today?

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

I am not, but I am aware that this was referenced I think in a radio interview that the Chairman may have given earlier this morning.

Comment on this

Yes, but Mr. O'Brien should have known about it beforehand. This is his organisation. Is he aware of the fact that the individual holding that most senior office within the HSE did not see fit even to acknowledge the letter?

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

Only from the Chairman's radio interview. I have not had an opportunity to speak to him or to find out any of the detail.

Comment on this

Therefore, what kind of investigations were the HSE conducting that it did not even find that piece of correspondence?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

May I respond to that question?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

In regard to what was done when I first became aware of the issue, I became aware of it in 2009. The area manager oversaw an investigation report by Devine, which came in 2012. Subsequent to that, a look-back exercise was undertaken and that is the Resilience report. What we have done is that we have taken the individual, specific situation that was identified in 2009, all the recommendations on that and an action plan was identified to implement those. We also undertook a look-back to see, and that was the purpose of the Resilience report, and anyone who had any contact in relation to that home has had a look-back. That was the purpose of the communication that Deputy Costello talked about; we were setting out the interviews that would happen. There were 47 people, and 35 people were interviewed, including Ann's mother. They were engaged with, initially, by the Garda Síochána. The agreement in relation to the look-back exercise was that there was full engagement with An Garda Síochána, a protocol was put in place - it was called a contact protocol - and the Garda would meet people individually first and go through all of that. When they were cleared, the project team undertaking this met with them. Professional staff met with them, both with-----

Comment on this

Where is Mr. Healy going with this answer?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

I am setting out what actually happened. The Resilience report was concluded in 2015. It was in the context of those reports being undertaken that the question was asked at the national summit in relation to whether the reports were going to be published. Subsequent to that, I wrote to the individual who asked the question at the summit, advised him of the legal situation that we were precluded, as has been outlined here before, but arranged for that individual to be met and the matter discussed with him if he so wished.

Comment on this

That sounds great. This person, namely, the national director of quality and patient safety, was written to on 24 November 2014 and the detail of the issues was outlined.

It was intimated that should the director be interested in hearing about the experience of the people in question as whistleblowers, the director should contact them. However, there was no reply; nothing; zilch.

I have a last question before calling Deputy McDonald. The HSE had a group of three people within the South Eastern Health Board who made the decision to leave Grace in that care. I believe that is what Mr. O'Brien said.

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

I did.

Comment on this

Is there a minute available regarding that decision? While I understand I cannot get it today, is there a note that informs Mr. O'Brien why that group of three saw fit to leave Grace where she was and ignore her rights?

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

This is covered in the Devine report. As part of that report, all three individuals consented to being interviewed and were interviewed by the reviewers who produced the report, so the answer is yes, there is very substantial information relating to that event.

Comment on this

Can you say that substantial information stands up their decision to leave Grace there?

Comment on this

Can Mr. O'Brien tell us the basis for that decision?

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

I feel if I were to do that, I would be straying into the effective publication of the report. As I said earlier, I am happy to tell the committee, to the best of my ability, the types of things it covers-----

Comment on this

Are you satisfied they made the right decision?

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

Based on reading the-----

Comment on this

A simple "yes" or "no" will do, Mr. O'Brien.

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

No, I must be more careful than that, unfortunately, because I have certain functions regarding this which I will later have to discharge. Based on reading the Devine report, and subject to the individuals having an opportunity to respond to it, I have very serious questions in my mind about that decision.

Comment on this

Before Deputy McDonald contributes, I would like an answer to my question about Ann. Mr. O'Brien said that various engagements were made with the family to persuade them to cease contact with Ann's foster family from 2011 to 2013, but that it took the HSE until 2013 to demand that the foster family cease all care activity, and that immediately after the letter was written to Ann's family to request that they cease contact with the foster family, they did so. Once the HSE made the decision and closed the care facility, Ann's family immediately went along with that decision. Given its awareness of the situation, why did the HSE not close that care facility, which it knew to be a site of abuse, instead of simply trying to dissuade the family from having any contact with the foster family? Surely there is gross negligence on the HSE's part in this matter.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

The important thing to say is that this was not a care facility at that point.

Comment on this

It was a care facility. It could be described as a care facility. Mr. O'Brien, in his remarks, described it as a care facility.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

It was a foster home for a time and was funded as such. What we are saying, and this is one of the challenging areas that is addressed in the reports, is that in the Resilience report - I must be careful about going through the detail of it - this family were met-----

Comment on this

Will Mr. Healy please answer the simple question? Why did the HSE not order that facility to cease operating as a care facility in 2011? Why did it wait until 2013 to decide to terminate it as a care facility if it was trying to persuade people not to go there in 2011?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

The issue is-----

Comment on this

Just give me a straight answer.

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

Having examined this issue, it is clear to me that the HSE lacks the necessary formal authority to direct a private citizen, in this case the parents, to desist from this arrangement that they had made privately with this other person who is the operator of the former foster home. Efforts were made-----

Comment on this

Mr. O'Brien is not answering the question.

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

I am trying to.

Comment on this

The question is based purely on Mr. O'Brien's own remarks to us this morning. In October 2013, the HSE formally demanded the foster home to cease all care activity.

Now Mr. O'Brien is saying that the HSE did not have the authority then-----

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

Yes.

Comment on this

-----but it did so later, in 2013. The HSE had the same authority in 2011 as in 2013. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

Yes, that is correct. And if-----

Comment on this

So why did it not take action in 2011?

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

Can I tell you? The emphasis of the actions during that period was on persuasion, because when push comes to shove, the HSE does not have the legal authority to stop that parent entering into this arrangement in respect of Ann.

Comment on this

If I treated little dogs, Mr. O'Brien, they way those people were treated, I would be arrested.

Comment on this

That is the most evasive answer I have ever heard.

Comment on this

This is very important. Mr. O'Brien said the HSE did not have the authority. But during these various engagements, did its representatives tell the family about the nature of the concerns with regard to potential sex abuse?

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

Arrangements were made for those discussions to take place between the family and An Garda Síochána, and they were involved throughout this period too.

Comment on this

In these various engagements, did the HSE inform the family about the tenor or the substance of the concerns?

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

My understanding is that An Garda Síochána provided that information to the family.

Comment on this

The HSE did not, in other words.

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

That is my understanding. Yes.

Comment on this

This is the key thing. Mr. O'Brien says that the HSE had all these engagements with the family, but it never really told them what it was all about and what the concerns were.

Comment on this

And the end result was that that person was open to abuse for all those years.

Comment on this

I will take up that line of questioning, but first, I ask Mr. O'Brien to set out for the committee the term over which this home was a foster home, the financial arrangement between the State and the foster home, and the moneys that were handed over.

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

I will ask Mr. Healy to give that information.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

Our understanding from the reports is that the home was a foster home up to 1995. There were boarding-out arrangements in that period, prior to 1996, and the home would have been paid the foster allowance at that time. Once the foster children were aged 18, the home ceased to receive the allowances. The arrangement ceased in 1995, according to the best information that the investigation team could find. When Grace reached the age of 18, no more foster payments or boarding-out payments were made from that time. Grace, as an intellectually disabled individual, would have received what was, I think, DPMA at that time. Subsequent to that-----

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

The disabled person's maintenance allowance. It is now known as the disability allowance.

Comment on this

What happened to her disability allowance? Did it go to the home?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

Yes, it went to the home.

Comment on this

Once she turned 18.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

I believe that is the case.

Comment on this

Would that payment have been made directly from the State to the foster parents?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

The records are poor in relation to the payments. The investigating team sought to establish detail around that and they were able to find records for two years, as I understand it, but the details were missing. However, DPMA would have been paid. At that time in the 1990s, it would not have been unusual. It was paid for the individual but the family would have been in charge of it.

Comment on this

What happened after that? That was the state of play until-----

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

That was the case until she was taken into care, I would say. She would have been entitled in her own right to payments-----

Comment on this

I am aware of that.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

-----of disability allowance, and I am assuming that DPMA may have been converted to disability allowance and that that would have continued.

Comment on this

So, whether directly or through an intermediary, those payments were made in respect of Grace to the home, which - whatever its official status was - was no longer a foster home. In other words, there was a funding stream from the State directly into this place.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

Yes, exactly, and-----

Comment on this

Was that the case also in respect of Ann?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

No. Ann was residing at home with her family. I am not privy at the minute to the details of the individual payments she was receiving, or the status of those payments. She is residing now full-time-----

Comment on this

No, no, no. Please, let us keep it to the point.

Let us talk about Ann specifically. What State moneys went to this home for her care? I understand she was residing at home and was in this place at weekends. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

No money would have gone from the State to this facility in respect of Ann, as far as we are aware.

Comment on this

Is Mr. Healy saying she stayed in this place in a part-time capacity and no money changed hands, that she stayed there free gratis?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

If any money changed hands, it was from her mother. This was a private arrangement. That is what is meant by a private arrangement. If the mother made an arrangement with this woman to look after Ann on a weekend visit or whatever, that was the arrangement. There was no State money.

Comment on this

Let us just roll the tape back and talk a little about Ann. The witnesses have told us in their opening statement that Ann was born in 1980. We are told contact with the foster family commenced when she was 12 years old, which would have been 1992.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

Correct.

Comment on this

As it happens, that is the same year in which the South Eastern Health Board was made aware of concerns around this particular foster home. The dates tally. When Mr. Healy says contact with the foster family began at that point, was it a part-time arrangement even then, when Ann was 12?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

Yes, the records from the look-back in this regard are-----

Comment on this

Will Mr. Healy give me a "Yes" or "No" answer? Was it a part-time arrangement?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

It would appear to have been a part-time arrangement.

Comment on this

In respect of that part-time arrangement, presumably moneys were handed over for Ann's weekend stays?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

We are not privy to that. We do not have that information. We are not clear on it and there is no detailed information.

Comment on this

Why is Mr. Healy not clear? He has told us it was a foster home officially until 1995.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

We do not have any records in regard to that.

Comment on this

Why does the HSE have no records in regard to it?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

They were not available at the time. One of the issues the Devine report identified was poor record-keeping. It is a reflection, I suppose, of child care services and fostering services at that time that the extent of the records that would be kept today were not kept then.

Comment on this

Mr. Healy is telling us this child was placed, albeit on a part-time basis, at the age of 12, in what was still officially a foster home in the very year concerns about that place were brought to the attention of the authorities. He is also telling us he does not know and cannot tell us what the financial arrangement was and what, if any, State money or subsidies were paid to this place in respect of Ann, and we are talking about her in particular? Is all of that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

The subsequent sentence in my statement indicates that all of her arrangements were conducted privately.

Comment on this

I will come to that, if Mr. O'Brien does not mind.

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

It is absolutely germane.

Comment on this

I will come to it. I just want to put the pieces of this together.

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

It was entirely private.

Comment on this

That is what we have established so far. The child was placed in 1992 at 12 years of age on a part-time basis. The delegates from the HSE have no idea and cannot tell the committee what, if any, moneys were paid in respect of that child to what was still a foster home.

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

That is because they were not paid by the State.

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

They would not have been paid by the State.

Comment on this

However, Mr. O'Brien cannot tell me that because he does not have records.

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

What I can tell the Deputy, because the Resilience report tells me this, and I quote from my statement, "All her arrangements were conducted privately by her family."

Comment on this

I will come to that in a moment.

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

It is part of the answer to the Deputy's question.

Comment on this

I ask the questions and Mr. O'Brien answers them.

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

If I can, I will.

Comment on this

In 1998, Ann would have turned 18. We need to figure this out and the delegates must be clear on it. Once Ann reached the age of majority, what was the status of the then health board in terms of its duty of care and what was the status of her family? I am raising this very particularly because the delegates are going to very great lengths to emphasise these were private arrangements. It is actually very reminiscent of the Magdalen laundries, this private arrangement carry-on. The initial statement looks to me kind of dishonourable in that it wishes to hang the culpability for all of this around the neck of Ann's family, that they were negligent in not intervening and not bringing this situation to an end.

That is the impression I have from the statement and from Mr. O'Brien's comments so far.

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

Those are the Deputy's words and not mine.

Comment on this

I am responding to Mr. O'Brien's words, and I am looking at them in black and white in front of me. At the point at which Ann turned 18 she became an adult, albeit a very vulnerable one. The health board was aware that there were issues with the foster home, which was then not a foster home. Why is it that Mr. O'Brien insists it was for her family to intervene and ensure her safety? Will he answer this for me?

Comment on this
Mr. Tony O'Brien

I will ask Mr. Healy to answer it for the Deputy.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

From the interviews that were held with her family, and from the investigation and the records that are there, what is clear is the following. Ann was attending a special school and living at home, and when she came to graduate she had an assessment, as might happen, and moved part-time into a voluntary service, living at home part-time. This was not unusual at the time, not only in the south east but elsewhere. She was moving into adult-type services. The family had developed a good relationship with this mother - with this woman - and they maintained that relationship for 18 years. They were wedded to it and they felt very strongly about it. That comes across from those who undertook interviews and so on. The issue here is that in 1992 - or in 1998, as she became an adult - that was the level of development of the service at the time. In 2011, as the Garda was investigating matters, it contacted the local service, and there was engagement by An Garda Síochána and health service personnel over a period. Ann had moved into a five-day service at this stage, and to remove the requirement with regard to weekends, or anything of that nature, a seven-day service was offered.

Comment on this

Hold on a second. All of that is in the documentation.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

I do not think all of it is.

Comment on this

I hope Mr. Healy is not deliberately missing my essential point, because his contention is that it fell to the family to make the call in respect of Ann's removal, albeit on a part-time basis, from this home. I am challenging Mr. Healy on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

If I could say, Deputy-----

Comment on this

I am challenging Mr. Healy on that because I actually do not accept it.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

I do not think that is the totality of what we are saying. I think it is one of the challenges. Having looked at the matter and seen the reports, I can say it is one of the issues that was a challenge. Absolutely, there was-----

Comment on this