HSE Report on Foster Home in Waterford Community Care Area: Discussion
Contributions 399–594 of 792. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
I am sorry, Mr. Healy, but I am going to stop you right there. Not alone does Mr. O'Brien's initial statement emphasise the private nature of the arrangement in respect of Ann, but it goes on to reiterate that the family had confirmed that they had no concerns regarding the foster family or the level of care. Mr. Healy has already told Deputy Deasy that in his engagement with the family he was not fully frank about the concerns, perhaps, that had arisen, and the possibility of horrific sexual abuse-----
Comment on this
To be clear on that, if I could, what happened was that at this point in time in the local services, as has emerged now from the investigations in the context of the commencement of the Conal Devine investigation, the Garda, having been contacted by Conal Devine as chairman, initiated its own investigations-----
Comment on this
Do you know what I think you are doing, Mr. Healy? I think - if you do not mind - you are spoofing me.
Comment on this
Let me tell you: I think you are spoofing. You are trying to bring us on a merry dance in respect of detail in reports that we cannot even see.
Here is my proposition for the HSE and its predecessor organisation. I am putting it to it that it was its legal responsibility to ensure the safety of Ann. It carried that responsibility irrespective of the views of the family or the relationship between the family and the foster providers. What Mr. Healy is attempting to do is say the onus lay with Ann's family. I believe that is wrong. He is doing that deliberately to cover his tracks.
Comment on this
With whom did and does legal responsibility and onus rest in respect of the care and safety when a person with a severe intellectual disability who requires the care of the State turns 18? Where does it rest, Mr. O'Brien?
Comment on this
I would like Mr. O'Brien to answer, please.
Comment on this
With whom does the responsibility rest?
Comment on this
In relation to children's services, there is a clear responsibility in the Child Care Act, which provides statutory capacity to act in situations like this. There is no such provision for adult services. It is referenced in the recommendations of the Devine report and so on. The national safeguarding policy is a really strong effort to try to bring about for adults an appropriate safeguarding policy that had not existed before. The Devine report is not the first report but it was an important report that made that recommendation. That is the effort in having a national policy like that, to bring-----
Comment on this
As I see it, the onus and legal responsibility rested with the HSE. That is my understanding. I refer the delegates to the letter of apology. It is signed by Ms Colley. One of the matters for which there is an apology is an absence of the necessary protocols and arrangements to support the placement in foster families of vulnerable children and adults with a disability. The HSE concedes, correctly, that that is its job. The attempts in respect of Ann, based on the controversy that has arisen over her ongoing placement and the discovery made, to make the family culpable are really unfair. They are dishonourable and inaccurate. I would like the delegation to correct the record.
Comment on this
It is important to say we are not saying that.
Comment on this
Mr. O'Brien said it in his opening statement.
Comment on this
What I was articulating in the response, including in relation to Ann's case, and what is in the statement references what actually happened. I am trying to articulate, without the published report, what the circumstances were at the time and the thinking on what was being pursued locally. That is what I am trying to do. I am not making a judgment on it but just articulating a position that is actually from the records and what we are able to identify as having happened. Of course, the commission will examine that and see whether that is appropriate.
Comment on this
May I make a brief point? Mr. Healy knew there was a risk to the girl and did not tell the family about the sex abuse allegations because somebody had initiated a report. It is morally disgraceful. That is the issue. That is at the centre of all this.
Comment on this
May I respond to that specifically? What appears to be the case and what we could see is that there was consultation between the team locally and the Garda on what could be said - that is why I mentioned the Devine report - in the context of both a Garda investigation and the Devine report. The team was advised that it should talk about serious concerns of care, which is what it did, and vouch for children in the home, or words to that effect. I am not giving the exact wording but paraphrasing. In the context of investigations at the time, associated with the Devine report and, more important, the Garda, those concerned consulted regarding what was to be done, and that is what they did. The gardaí advised them to get the family to speak to the Garda.
I know it is referenced in the report that they spoke to An Garda Síochána. Later, at the end of 2011 when a seven day placement was offered, the family made a choice. Having advised the local health service team and having discussed the matter with the gardaí the family was satisfied to continue with arrangements as they were.
Comment on this
Therein lies the difficulty. Please, there is no need for any further expansive narrative because here we go again; the onus was left on the family to make the call. That is a derogation of your duty. Irrespective of what the family thought, there was a responsibility on the State and on the authorities to protect this woman. She is a woman at this stage. She entered the care arrangement at the age of 12 in the year when the concerns were first brought to the attention of the authorities but she was left there. The explanation offered by the witness - let us not put any blas on it - is that she was left there because that was the decision of her family. That simply does not stack up.
I am also alarmed at the fact - not least because the witnesses are before this committee - that they are not in a position to give us chapter and verse on precisely what amount of State money found its way into this particular institution. This is information that should be made available to the committee. It is information that ought to be in the public domain. We have a scenario where State moneys are, at least in part, funding this place yet the HSE's oversight duties and so on - as were conceded in the letter of apology - were simply not fulfilled, not least in the case of Ann.
Comment on this
Would Mr. O'Brien accept that it was not the responsibility of Ann's family to intervene in this matter and that ultimately the HSE and Mr. O'Brien's predecessor had the authority and the obligation to do that?
Comment on this
The letter from which Deputy McDonald is quoting, signed by Ms Aileen Colley - and the committee cannot see this because the name has been redacted for obvious reasons - is a specific letter relating to Grace who is not being cared for in-----
Comment on this
In respect of Ann the Deputy will see the letter that I issued yesterday is attached to the submission. It is the final attachment to the opening statement. It is a one-page letter.
Comment on this
Yes. What is Mr. O'Brien's point? Is it his contention that in Ann's case there was not an absence of necessary protocols and arrangements to support her placement?
Comment on this
No, my contention is merely to ensure the Deputy is aware that the letter from which she quotes was a specific letter in relation to Grace. Just to be-----
Comment on this
Can we clarify that what Mr. O'Brien has conceded here he concedes in respect of all the persons concerned, including Ann?
Comment on this
There are distinctions and I know this is not a pleasant distinction. I am advised legally that for an adult who is essentially under the care of a parent - albeit that they are substantially being provided with care residentially or for most of the time - the HSE does not have the capacity to direct the ending of that arrangement. Ultimately, over a period of time, starting persuasively but ultimately probably with some degree of bluffing, that arrangement was brought to an end. However, it is not at all clear that the HSE has the legal capacity to direct-----
Comment on this
Has Mr. O'Brien legal advice to that effect?
Comment on this
Yes. Not here with me but I can get it for the committee.
Comment on this
I would like to see that and I would query that very strongly.
Comment on this
It turns on the difference between powers that exist in relation to child care in its broader sense and the powers that do not exist for care beyond that age.
Comment on this
There is also a distinction in respect of the family concerned, and this is where the HSE has laid the emphasis, regarding a minor and regarding a person reaching the age of 18 and over.
In that balance, it is very clear that Mr. O'Brien has tried to pass off Ann's case as being a flaw, a fault or a bad decision of her family. That is wrong and Mr. O'Brien is wrong to have presented it in that fashion.
Comment on this
I have not reached any judgment, but let us be clear. If I came in here and gave the committee information in relation to Ann and the reason she continued beyond 2009 to 2013 without describing the role and involvement of the family, I would be misleading the committee. I have not sought to characterise the family's actions in any way.
Comment on this
I think it is very clear from Mr. O'Brien's statement that he has laid the-----
Comment on this
We will have to agree to differ on that point.
Comment on this
We will agree to disagree but Mr. O'Brien's opening statement is on the public record. Others can, therefore, adjudicate on the matter.
Comment on this
It is on the public record and it does not contain any of the sentiments or accusations that the Deputy is ascribing to it.
Comment on this
How many formal apologies does the HSE issue in any given year?
Comment on this
It would be difficult for me to tell the Deputy that number because apologies exist at many different levels. It could be issued in relation to a cancelled appointment in a hospital where there would be an apology issued. There are------
Comment on this
Would that have the status-----
Comment on this
Mr. O'Brien, I think you know what Deputy McDonald means and to answer her with that remark is not treating the issue seriously.
Comment on this
They are formal apologies. If the question is how many-----
Comment on this
If I am being asked how many apologies I issue, I could get that answer.
Comment on this
Deputy McDonald has asked a question and Mr. O'Brien is about to take Mr. Healy's lead and go on with the nonsense.
Comment on this
The HSE will issue many thousands of official apologies every year. They range in severity and what they relate to, but they are all official apologies.
Comment on this
How would Mr. O'Brien rate this particular official apology?
Comment on this
No, the one that was due to Grace, on a scale of one to ten, with one being an apology for a cancelled appointment. By the way, people generally do not get an apology for a cancelled appointment. They usually get a note telling them that the procedure has been cancelled.
Comment on this
The apology in that instance would arise where a complaint is made. In relation to this apology, it is clearly a high-scale apology.
Comment on this
A high-scale apology. How many of those are made in any given year?
Comment on this
I would say very, very, very few. I would say it is rare. Does Mr. O'Brien agree with me?
Comment on this
In the scale of the number of interactions the HSE has, yes.
Comment on this
Who decides that a high-level official apology is due?
Comment on this
In this instance, Mr. Healy made the decision.
Comment on this
Mr. Healy made the decision that a high-level apology was due. Mr. O'Brien has given a kind of a garbled account, as I heard it, in respect of teleconferences, conversations and so on discussing the need for this high-level official apology and how it might be made.
Comment on this
To be honest, work on it commenced on 4 March 2015. There were meetings at which this was discussed.
Comment on this
Work commenced on 4 March 2015.
Comment on this
There were ten interactions in all before the final piece of the jigsaw, if I can put it that way, concluding the matter happened in the last few days. This was referred to and is referenced here. However, there was a significant amount of preparatory work because the apology was part of the publication of this and all that went with it. There was, therefore, a significant amount of work. In fairness, some of that work was undertaken by the current chief officer's predecessor who was acting in the role and was actually doubling up in the role at the time. There was a significant amount of work in preparing for that and getting all of that done.
Comment on this
Mr. Healy conceives of this high-level official apology, which are very rare, on 4 March 2015. There are ten interactions in respect of it and some activity towards the tail end of the process in December. The apology is not made, yet a report is given to this committee that an apology was made. The committee then receives the correspondence referred to earlier from the Waterford Intellectual Disability Association, WIDA, which, I have to say, has proved to be a very honest broker in the midst of all of this. It informs us that the two HSE representatives whom Mr. Healy has cited confirmed to the association that they were never asked to apologise, that they did not apologise and that they told the HSE chief officer that no apology was given.
That is in stark contradiction of what the witnesses have told us here. There are two issues. The first, which is perhaps testimony to the HSE's ineptitude, is that all of this work happens, from March, with all of these interactions, yet there is a miscommunication, according to the officials themselves. My God - that is some shambles, is it not? A high-level apology on an issue like this - these apologies are as rare as hen's teeth - that is some shambolic carry-on from the HSE.
Comment on this
Or - this is even more serious - if we are to take the word of Waterford Intellectual Disability Association, there was not in fact a miscommunication; there was no communication. There was no apology expected, according to this correspondence, and none was given, and furthermore, the HSE was informed of that fact. The truth is somewhere, perhaps, in between those two positions.
Comment on this
We said already that we got it wrong. It is to our lasting regret that with the one individual to whom we intended to give a personalised apology, we got it wrong. That is absolutely correct.
Comment on this
Mr. O'Brien said that, having reviewed the situation with those staff involved, "I am satisfied that it was the intention to offer a full and frank apology." Did he raise this particular piece of correspondence with the staff?
Comment on this
Yes. We had it in front of us for the purposes of the discussion.
Comment on this
I will take the Deputy through it step by step, if I may. First of all, I asked about the circumstances in which they were giving the apology and the nature of the request to them to give the apology. There is e-mail correspondence relating to ensuring that an apology was included, but there is a degree of ambiguity about that correspondence such that it could be interpreted as referring to either the letter or the conversation.
Comment on this
I ask Ms Colley how was it so ambiguous.
Comment on this
Can I finish the sequence - would that be all right? Otherwise, I will lose my train of thought. When arranging to have the meeting, they did not signal that an apology was to be given because they did not understand that they were being asked to give an apology. That is one point in the letter. I subsequently asked them how was it that the organisation we are referring to here was able to say that these conversations took place and so on, and each of the individuals received a telephone call in which they were asked, "Were you asked to give an apology? Did you give an apology? Have you told them you did not give an apology?". They confirmed that those conversations had occurred, but that was consistent with the fact that they had not understood - or had not been effectively communicated with, whichever way we care to put it - that an apology was to form part of that meeting. They arranged and went to the meeting without having in mind the giving of an apology. They left the meeting with the individual concerned, and when I met them on Friday I asked how could it then be that when this issue was queried there was confirmation that an apology had been given. In the case of one of the people involved, the exact way it was put to me was, "When I was asked had I apologised, I said I had." I asked why the person had said this, and he said, "Because the person I was talking to became upset and I told her how sorry I was about everything." When he was asked whether he had apologised, he answered it in the context of what he had said, which was not the same as the context in which he was being asked the question. At the outset, there was a miscommunication about whether an apology was to be given in that meeting, and everything else followed from that. It is not necessary to conclude that any of these parties are lying. What the WIDA letter says is correct. That information was given to them by the two individuals. There is no question-----
Comment on this
Okay. They said that they were not asked to apologise and that they did not apologise and, furthermore, that they told the HSE chief officer that no apologies were given.
Comment on this
By the time that letter was written, that had been confirmed, which is why, on the 25th of this month, two days before the date of that letter, Ms Aileen Colley, as chief officer, met with the organisation, conveyed to them on that date the letters the Deputy has, which we discussed a little earlier, and arranged with them to meet with Grace at a later date. That meeting occurred, if I am correct, last Thursday.
Comment on this
Can Ms Colley explain to us how her e-mail was so ambiguous?
Comment on this
My e-mail set out the themes that were to be conveyed via the letter, around the themes of ensuring an apology was given but there were other themes in there as well. So the themes-----
Comment on this
Did the e-mail say an apology is to be given-----
Comment on this
------or an apology will be given?
Comment on this
Because, as I said earlier, we set out with the agreement that there would be 47 letters and in the course of conversation with the local team-----
Comment on this
I heard that it would be verbal.
Comment on this
Are staff - I am struggling to find a word - that absolutely incompetent that one has to take them through things like that with baby steps? I am at a loss to understand how the ambiguity arose. Ms Colley has told me it was not in a letter and it was going to be done verbally. That is hardly an earth shattering concept to take on board for somebody that the HSE has entrusted, by the way, to deal with a very traumatic and sensitive situation, a really bad situation. For that to get miscommunicated or misunderstood is beyond the understanding of just about anybody else outside, perhaps, of the HSE. To be frank, I am worried that we are getting the truth from the Waterford Intellectual Disability Association and we are getting a kind of massaging of things from the HSE. That is what my instincts are telling me, from what we have heard from Ms Colley.
Comment on this
If I can respond to that, I would say that everybody did set out with the best of intentions to do the right thing. We very much regret and have consulted, reviewed and shown evidence to the director general that there was no mal intent, that there was nothing sinister around this misinterpretation.
Comment on this
I shall ask my final question. The whistleblowers have been fairly damning in their description of the HSE. They feel that they were ignored, set aside, undermined and their professional credibility called into question. That was their experience of dealing with you. How does Mr. O'Brien respond to that?
Comment on this
I have an arrangement to sit down with the representatives of WIDA in which I can discuss all of these things.
In relation to this specific issue, as I say, having spoken to the staff, I do not believe there was any malice. The alternative explanation is kind of fanciful, that there would be some attempt to pretend to have given an apology in the-----
Comment on this
Do not bring us down an alleyway.
Comment on this
Mr. O'Brien, that is nonsensical.
Comment on this
No. It is legitimate because I have had to make a judgment about what happened and I am reflecting to you my judgment. One of my considerations is what is the alternative explanation, that there was some-----
Comment on this
Tell me what the explanation for this is. What is the explanation for the whistleblowers, whose names are on record-----
Comment on this
-----a social worker and a director of services from WIDA, to say, that in six years of dealing with the HSE and, indeed, the Department of Health, they were discredited------
Comment on this
They use phrases like "damaging their professional reputation". They described themselves as outraged and insulted.
Comment on this
They say that statements released by the HSE referred to meetings with their agency that did not take place and so on. Is Mr. O'Brien familiar with this piece of correspondence?
Comment on this
I am sure Mr. O'Brien is not suggesting that there is any other or ulterior motive on their part than assisting their clients-----
Comment on this
This, to their way of thinking, is the true and accurate reflection of their interactions with the HSE, and it does not read well.
Comment on this
I have not questioned what they have said, at all, in our discussions today but I do have an appointment to meet with them at a later point.
What I was about to say was that the alternative explanation to this not being a mistake is that, somehow or other, it was believed that it could be pretended that an apology was given in the presence of the two people who have written that letter and somehow it would not be noticed. I do not think it is a credible theory of someone setting out to mislead.
Comment on this
Does Mr. O'Brien think the whistleblowers are due an apology from the HSE and the Department?
Comment on this
I will be talking to them later on and----
Comment on this
What is Mr. O'Brien's position as he is talking to us now?
Comment on this
It is clear that the whistleblowers have done a significant service through their protected disclosure in 2009, which has led to the Devine and the Resilience Ireland reports, led to the removal of Grace from the setting that she was in and ultimately led to the removal of Ann. I am absolutely certain that they have done significant service. They have raised issues in that letter. I look forward to discussing them with them. I am not going to tokenistically----
Comment on this
When is Mr. O'Brien meeting them?
Comment on this
I am going to keep that confidential other than to say that it is soon and it is by mutual agreement, but----
Comment on this
Finally, as you thought about an apology from March to December, to what extent was----
Comment on this
I was not thinking about it from March, to be honest, no.
Comment on this
Your colleague Mr. Healy was. Is that correct?
Comment on this
I am talking about "you" as an entity, corporately.
Comment on this
In that period, to what extent did litigation or potential litigation loom large in your assessment?
Comment on this
In my own assessment, I think that the issue of litigation is not relevant. Based on my reading of the reports, where harm has occurred and if anyone wishes to litigate on the basis of that, there is no effective defence that can be offered. As the Deputy knows, the HSE does not manage the process of litigation when persons take lawsuits against the HSE. While that is managed by a separate agency, as I see it there is no conceivable defence. Therefore, the issue of litigation is not one that needs to be taken significantly into account in deciding what we do or do not do.
Comment on this
So it would not be a possible explanation for the miscommunication-----
Comment on this
-----or the lack of apology that was supposed to be given?
Comment on this
No, I do not believe so. There is no corporate interest in seeking to defend this whatsoever.
Comment on this
Mr. O'Brien, you and the members have been here since 12 o'clock. I am suggesting that we take a break for half an hour. Before we suspend, I want to put two things on record for this part of the meeting. In 2009, the HSE was told about the risk to Ann and was asked to take the necessary and reasonable steps to protect her. That is a fact. She was still there in 2013. In respect of Grace, if my calculation is right from information that I have received, the foster mother would have been paid up to €70,000 in disability allowance. The HSE knew that Grace was at risk of financial abuse in 2007 and did nothing. In 2009, when she was taken into care, she had no belongings, no documents and no money. If that did not ring bells in an organisation, I just do not know what would. Those two statements are factual. Maybe we will address them later on.
Comment on this
I thank the Health Service Executive, HSE, representatives, Mr. O'Brien and his team, for attending. To start with Mr. O'Brien's last comment to Deputy McDonald, essentially is he putting his hands up and saying, "We are guilty" if he says there will be no legal issues arising from this matter?
Comment on this
To be absolutely clear, I have come here in an attempt to explain but not to defend so in regard to any civil claims or civil actions that might arise from what I have described as very significant failures, the HSE will not be seeking to defend such actions. The only caveat I put on that is that the HSE itself does not manage its legal defences. It is managed, by statute, by the State Claims Agency but we will be very clear that in our view there is not an adequate defence that can be put forward, so we will not be seeking to defend.
Comment on this
Does that arise just with the two individuals we have discussed at much length or does it arise with others as well?
Comment on this
If anybody else has a stateable claim in regard to their time in this foster home, then it arises in respect of them as well.
Comment on this
How does Mr. O'Brien see the HSE handling this? Would that just be handed over to the State claims body?
Comment on this
At the very moment that anyone initiates legal proceedings they stand in the name of the HSE but by virtue of the statutory orders that exist, we pass all of that on to the State Claims Agency and it then manages the claims, as it would in respect of any civil liability that might arise for any of the HSE services. However, it is my very clear view that there is no potential defence available and, therefore, the HSE will not seek to defend them. That is the reason I was quite happy today to write to all 47 - and the members have a copy of the letter - with an unambiguous apology because I do not see any basis for any other course of action. As I say, I have not come here to defend, merely to explain.
Comment on this
So it would be up to them to contact the HSE to-----
Comment on this
I have also given every individual Ms Aileen Colley's contact details for any issue they wish to raise, which could be about current care needs or additional needs that arise as a result of the focus that is on this right now, which can have a particular impact on individuals. If they wish to pursue a claim, that can be discussed as well.
Comment on this
So, it could lead to a legal situation if they were not satisfied by the machinery offered.
Comment on this
Yes, but I am certain that in terms of the current supports there would be no issue about providing supports. A range of additional supports are in place for people affected by this. If they wish to claim in a civil way on the basis that a liability arises owing to the negligence of either the South-Eastern Health Board or the HSE since its establishment then clearly they need to formally make that claim but we will not be seeking to defend if it relates to this foster home.
Comment on this
I have looked at the timeline of the events. During 1992-1993 there were a lot of allegations made about abuse, which led to an internal investigation by a Pat Donaghy. Arising from that, some time later - perhaps about two years afterwards - placements in that foster home were stopped, with the exception of the woman called Grace. Presumably the report by Pat Donaghy raised very serious concerns. How was it that probably the most vulnerable person was left in the home when everybody else was removed? I accept that is before Mr. O'Brien's time but does he have any sense of understanding of why that happened?
Comment on this
Again, this is spelled out in very fine detail in the Devine report. What I will attempt to do is give a general characterisation rather than get into the fine detail, which would take me into difficult territory from the point of view that we have already discussed.
There were decisions at two levels - in other words, two separate sets of decisions at two separate levels - around not allowing Grace to continue but then there was a decision made at a third level which effectively countermanded those other decisions.
Comment on this
That was all within the then South-Eastern Health Board.
Comment on this
Yes, the South-Eastern Health Board continued to exist until 31 December 2004, at which point the HSE came into being. Everything before that time in the scope of what we are talking about was within the ambit of the South-Eastern Health Board.
Comment on this
Are the people who made those decisions retired at this stage or out of the service or are some of them still there?
Comment on this
The persons who made the key decision, namely, the one that allowed Grace to remain, are all retired. There may be other persons who did not make that decision but who were involved in some way - perhaps, they were the people who wanted to remove her - who could still be in public service but I do not have that detail with me. I do not believe they would have a case to answer in that instance.
Comment on this
Moving on, can the witnesses tell me about the Waterford Intellectual Disability Association and its relationship with the HSE and with people with intellectual disabilities?
Comment on this
I can give the Deputy an overall view on the local issues. As set out in our report, the Waterford Intellectual Disability Association is a voluntary group that emerged locally. It provides residential and day care services. It is a medium-sized organisation and, therefore, it is funded by the HSE. We have set out in the note today the funding provided over the past number of years. What we were seeking to do was, I suppose, to indicate that since 2009, since the downturn commenced, all services in health have been affected to some degree. I think there has been a general attempt to minimise the impact on disability services but they have had an impact. That is reflected here. What we are trying to indicate is that while the Waterford Intellectual Disability Association has been impacted on average with the medium and larger sized organisations they have been treated fairly from a funding point of view. In the final year, 2015, as can be seen there was an 18% increase. I think that reflects some of the additional supports that they are providing but also-----
Comment on this
So, they would be involved in the care of people with intellectual disabilities directly.
Comment on this
It is important to acknowledge here that we fully take account of points that have been made. The chief officer, Ms Aileen Colley, met WIDA recently in dealing with the issue of the apology, but also in general, and we are considering that as an opportunity to begin to build the type of trust and relationship with them that will move us collectively from where we are to where we need to go. I certainly want to say here publicly that we want to do that, and the chief officer is fully committed to-----
Comment on this
Would Mr. Healy regard WIDA as a reputable organisation?
Comment on this
Has he ever had any reason to believe otherwise?
Comment on this
No. I do not deal with the organisation on a day-to-day basis - I have never managed it; that would be done locally - but absolutely, it is a very good, reputable, voluntary organisation providing services for people with intellectual disabilities locally.
Comment on this
Obviously, a whistleblower came from within the organisation. When did he or she approach the HSE with concerns about Grace and perhaps Ann as well?
Comment on this
What we now know, having gone through the report and so on, is that they had been in contact for a period-----
Comment on this
Well over a year, if not longer, specifically pursuing and engaging with people locally. The important thing is that the whistleblower felt that he or she was not being listened to and, notwithstanding his or her involvement in assisting Grace's removal, submitted protected disclosures at the end of 2009 and, together with another whistleblower-----
Comment on this
It was from within the HSE. They were the individuals who first submitted the protected disclosures which gave rise to the commissioning of the Conal Devine report-----
Comment on this
When Mr. Healy says they were the first, does he mean they were from WIDA-----
Comment on this
I am conscious that we do not normally identify from where specific whistleblowers come; we talk about it as the voluntary organisation in the area. They identified the protected disclosures which gave rise to the Conal Devine report. Those protected disclosures were the initial basis of the terms of reference of the report. Subsequently-----
Comment on this
Regarding the cases of Grace and Ann, there were three whistleblowers, or people who provided protected disclosures.
Comment on this
The Conal Devine report and all of the information relating to it concerned Grace. It was initiated, and those involved had been ready to start their work when a further protected disclosure was received and the terms of reference were amended to take account of that, so the totality of the protected disclosures that were received at that time were incorporated into the terms of reference of the report.
Comment on this
There is something I find very difficult about this. Probably unlike anyone else in this room, I have actually taught non-verbal children, and the non-verbal children whom I taught did not have intellectual disabilities but they were still incredibly vulnerable because they could not speak. I am absolutely hit in the stomach by the fact that a really vulnerable woman was left in that sort of situation for 12 or 13 years after everybody else had been removed. I find it impossible to get my head around that. Arising from that, can I ask about the whistleblowers? I am closely related to a whistleblower who suffered quite a lot after whistleblowing in a totally different area of life. I am looking at the end of the letter signed by Claire Looney and Fiona O'Neill from WIDA.
It states:
However, we remain concerned that the HSE's treatment of us as whistleblowers is as despicable now as it was six years ago. The HSE's actions over the last week are the latest in a series of attempts to silence us. We are no longer willing to accept this treatment as we feel we need to send a signal to the HSE and to other people who might wish to speak up for vulnerable people being failed by our health services who cannot speak for themselves.
I will tie in with that the interview on "Claire Byrne Live" last night, in which Claire Byrne talked to a whistleblower. The whistleblower's voice was disguised and her face was not shown on the TV. Why would whistleblowers in and around the HSE be afraid to show their faces, such as in the case of the woman last night? Why did Claire Looney and Fiona O'Neill write that last paragraph in their letter?
Comment on this
As I said to Deputy McDonald earlier, I have arranged to meet with the authors of the letter to discuss their concerns. As I see it, WIDA has been, is and will continue to be a very important service provider. As I said earlier, they gave significant service through the period before, during and since the time of the protected disclosure. It is important that we rebuild that relationship.
I did not see the programme last night. One of the reasons for the disguising may well have been to protect the identity of their client, I understand that may be the case.
Comment on this
That is not the impression I got.
Comment on this
However, in the period since 2009 and certainly since I became director general of the HSE, through the appointment of Leigh Gath and my own response to what happened in Áras Attracta, I have made it very clear that I welcome people within our wider services standing up and blowing the whistle, making protected disclosures, or whatever terminology we like to use. The fact that they are writing that at this point is of significant concern. That is the primary reason I intend to meet with them, in order to ensure that any damage to that relationship can be rebuilt.
Comment on this
It strikes me that this has a wider implication. It seems to me that for whatever reason, there was real fear in the case of these whistleblowers that there would be very negative consequences. That leads me to consider that if that kind of atmosphere is widespread in the HSE, it is a discouragement to staff who do a good job and want to do a good job - and I am sure the vast majority of people who work in the HSE fit into that category - to spill the beans if something wrong is happening. This has a corrupting effect on an organisation. What is the HSE going to do to try to address that issue? One of the things that we should have learned over the last number of years is that the best way to protect an organisation is to root out those who cause damage from within; whether that be the Catholic Church, the HSE, or dare I say it, a particular political party. There is a real need to do that and to support the people who throw light on problems. I accept that the witness cannot straight away accept upfront what a whistleblower says and that their allegations must be checked out. It strikes me that is what happened in the early 1990s in this particular case, but it was not fully followed through on. It was followed through where most people were concerned, but not in the most unfortunate case of Grace. What plan has the HSE in place to encourage people to throw light on things that are happening which should not be happening?
Comment on this
In particular, in order that being identified should not be a barrier to making a disclosure, I have appointed Ms Leigh Gath as a confidential recipient who can receive disclosure at arm's length from the HSE, pursue the matter and never have to disclose the source of her information. One of the issues with the creation of the HSE is that it was set up without any description of what its culture ought to be. In our 2015-2017 corporate plan, which was approved by the Minister, we have committed ourselves, over the course of that time, to enabling four words to be the hallmarks of that culture, recognising that culture does not change instantaneously but is a long-term play. Those four words, which appear on the top of the letterhead I use to write out to people, are care, compassion, trust and learning. They are not intended as a description of the "as is" but as a description as to where we need to get to. As the person with responsibility for leading the HSE, that is a message I pursue vigorously every time I am engaged in any meeting with staff, town hall meetings and so on, as do other members of the management team and management of community health care organisations and hospital groups. We have to create a different understanding of the nature of the relationship that is required between the public health service, whatever its legal name may be, and society and the people who use or are dependent on those services.
We recognise that, right now, some people may be deterred from making protected disclosures. There is the formal protected disclosure route, which is effectively the route that was used in this case. However, there is also the confidential recipient in the form of Leigh Gath, and a number of issues have been satisfactorily dealt with in the intervening period since December 2014 when she took up that role. Many issues have been raised that had to be pursued and brought to appropriate conclusion where Ms Gath was able to act as a strong advocate in this regard.
Comment on this
Does Mr. O'Brien agree the whistleblowers in this case seem to be patriots in the best sense of that word and in a way we often do not use it in Ireland, which is to mean standing up for what is best in one's community? In the early 1990s, whistleblowers seem to have made their mark, but it just was not fully carried through. It would have saved this State huge amounts of money if people had listened to whistleblowers in these matters. If we count the investigation in the early 1990s, the two most recent investigations and the examination that is now taking place of what has been done already, we are talking about four investigations. How much has all of that cost the HSE and, by extension, the State?
Comment on this
I am not sure about the one in the 1990s but I understand the two reports, Devine and Resilience, have a combined cost attached to them in the order of €225,000. I do not know what the costs are for the senior counsel review that is currently being carried out or what the costs will be for the commission of investigation or inquiry.
Comment on this
Does the figure Mr. O'Brien gave include legal costs?
Comment on this
No, that is the direct cost of the two reports.
Comment on this
I understand we previously gave the committee a note in regard to that but I do not have it with me today. The clerk has indicated we did provide such a note.
Comment on this
There is another cost in terms of the huge amount of officials' time that has been spent on this. It would be far better for the efforts of the HSE to be directed more towards what its function should be, which is looking after people's health in the broadest sense of that word. It is a great pity.
Before concluding, I take this opportunity, particularly as I am not seeking re-election, to thank the Chairman for his chairmanship over these past years. It has been an honour to serve on this committee. To describe any issues that come up here as high points would be incorrect because we are usually looking at the dirty linen of how things are done in this country. However, it was a particular honour for me, because of my close connections with the organisation in question, to be here when representatives of the Central Remedial Clinic came before the committee.
I was in the rather invidious situation of having to tell somebody who appointed me to a job that he should give back some of the money he got. I thank the Chairman.
Comment on this
I think the Chairman knows the answer to that.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for their time. A lot of what I would like to have said has already been said, so I will not go over a lot of it. Initially when this came up for the Committee on Public Accounts, I thought it was not the appropriate place for this type of situation but when one looks at it, the whistleblower was so desperate to get anything done this is the path the person had to come down. To me, it is mind-blowing - absolutely mind-blowing - the amount of to-ing and fro-ing that has been done by the HSE about an apology. The whole thing about this was a cover-up and a protection of the HSE rather than protecting the people the HSE is actually paid to protect. I think the amount of time that has been wasted - HSE staff, time and money - about an apology, when all that time and money could have been invested in clients, is outrageous.
With this in mind, it is no wonder the health service struggles like it does if this is the type of carry-on that goes on in it. I think it must be very difficult for parents and families of the service users, and I am going to call them victims in this case, that they have to go through this and that they were so helpless that they could not help and protect their loved ones. They depended on the HSE to do that and it was not done. I would like to ask about the people who worked in these services. Where are they now? Were they fired? Were they ever held accountable for what happened? They should have been held accountable. In most jobs in this day and age, and for the past while, one goes through an appraisal on a regular basis. Did these staff ever have an appraisal? As politicians we have appraisals every five years, and if one does not do one's job properly one loses one's job. These people should be held accountable.
There are a few things by which I am really bothered. In the case of Ann, Mr. O'Brien said in his opening statement that in October 2013 the HSE formally demanded that the service stop being used. Why was that not done before this? Why did the HSE wait until 2013 to formally demand that this would happen? If it could do it why did it not do it before? Why did it wait? Mr. O'Brien spoke about the €225,000 in combined reports, in the two reports, rather. That money, I would suggest, would probably have provided a person-centred individual service for a client with an intellectual disability for a year at least, for at least two or three clients for one year, and this money was wasted on reports and other things.
I will ask all of my questions and the witnesses can come back in, because I am so annoyed that if I stop now I might forget. In the HSE's report to the Committee on Public Accounts in December 2015, one of the things on page 6 was the 47 clients and the way the HSE broke them down. It stated three could not be traced. That is unbelievable, that there are three clients of the HSE who cannot be traced and nobody knows where they are. Are they missing? I ask the witnesses to tell me about that, please. I would like to know how much money was spent. Deputy McDonald might have asked this question, and the HSE cannot tell how much money was spent, which to me is ridiculous. It loses clients and it does not know how much is being spent on the service.
Mr. Healy spoke about the downturn in the economy and said it had an effect on the disability services. I have to say to him that no amount of money could provide or can pay for this. This is not about money. This is about a properly run health service. It is about a properly run system. Mr. O'Brien said the HSE does not have legal authority to end an arrangement like the one in this case. It may not have a legal authority, but it certainly has a moral authority. If it knew there was something going on I think the HSE had a moral obligation to look after that person. If I worked there and if I had a child, I would not want it to be in a situation like that. I am so annoyed now that I am going to forget something.
Mr. Healy said Ann was assessed when she graduated at 18. Presumably, the assessment was by a psychologist. What kind of assessment was that and what was its purpose? Was it educational? At what stage was Ann at that time? Did alarm bells not ring for the psychologist when Ann was assessed at 18? If either of the delegates could answer those questions for me, I would appreciate it.
Comment on this
I will start with the last question, on Ann. As was normal around that time, she was assessed at 17.5 years. The assessment was carried out by the local Brothers of Charity service. It involved psychiatry and psychology. It was an assessment as to what was the best placement and so on. She graduated, attending a voluntary provider after that and so on. In relation to-----
Comment on this
Were any alarm bells raised by the assessment?
Comment on this
No. That is one of the relevant points. Among the 47 that we set out, Ann's family is one of the 18 families that identified that they had a good experience. One of the challenges that arose regarding this matter was that, in their view, they actually had a good experience of working with the mother, and that had influenced them in how they dealt with the matter. There were no issues of any kind. I mentioned in the previous contribution that Ann was never in care and there were never child protection issues or anything of that nature. She went for the assessment simply because she was at the age where she was graduating, having been in a special school. I refer to day-to-day services.
I shall refer to the issue at the time in 2009 after Grace was moved out of the facility to a voluntary provider. I was trying to articulate that, for a period, the Devine report did not identify any particular case, or did not identify Ann’s case. The investigation was going on. Clearly, from the report, there was information locally to the effect that she was attending the location in question, and that is when engagement with the family took place and so on. I think what happened then was that a senior manager in the area was reviewing the Devine report implementation and assessing it and, in that context, raised the issue of taking more decisive action in relation to Ann. At that point, the Devine report had been concluded and the Garda investigation was still going on. It was at that point that the foster mother was written to and instructed not to take placements any more, and the family was also written to.
Of course, in the consideration of this, one of the issues concerns how one deals with circumstances where the family of a vulnerable adult feels that individual is being looked after satisfactorily and that there is no concern, yet there may be other concerns and one must consider how to deal with that. Certainly, from 2013 onwards, the lady was in five-day residential care and then seven-day residential care. She still visits her mother. She comes out of residential care every second weekend and visits her mother. We have been advised, right up to the current time, that the mother indicates that she does not place Ann in that home anymore. She does visit.
Comment on this
Progressing well. We mentioned in the director general’s opening statement that, following on a broadcast earlier in the year, a question arose. The voluntary provider she was with, reflecting on this set of circumstances being aired at the time, looked back on the situation in the past and felt particular matters might be looked at. It submitted them to the HSE and to HIQA.
We have carried out an investigation of that to be sure there was not anything, and as of today that report has just concluded. We have not fully assessed it yet but the indication to us, as outlined in the director general's statement, is that there was nothing untoward in that. The extra mile was gone to carry out an investigation and so on, just to be complete in all of that. That covers the position up to date regarding Ann, and she is progressing very well at the service she is in now.
With regard to the funding side of it, as I mentioned, when one goes back on the records, one can see it was a feature of the child care services. There are two years of records. We were not able to identify the others. However, clearly the family were being provided with the equivalent of foster care allowance up to the time that it stopped in 1995. From that time on the State was providing support to the individual through what was DPMA and is now the disability allowance, and that continued. That is the situation regarding the finances.
Comment on this
Where does Mr. Healy think the three missing clients are?
Comment on this
I forgot to deal with that; apologies. It is not that there is anybody missing. We wanted it to be totally complete, and the job given to Resilience Ireland was to identify any individual who had had any contact whatever with the foster home concerned. There were a number of people whose records are on file, but they may have been very limited records, and those individuals were not traceable. They may have had contact through An Garda Síochána or the HSE. They are just references on the file; they were identified and put in as part of the investigation, but we have not been able to trace them. For completeness, and to ensure everyone was recorded who had been involved in any way with this foster home, in fairness to the investigators, they identified all of that. They provided all of that information to An Garda Síochána and, between the Garda and themselves, it was not possible to trace them. However, if anybody had any further information-----
Comment on this
It is hard to believe that somebody who is vulnerable and needs a service would not be traceable. It is not that big a country.
Comment on this
The investigators went through every single file. It is not that there is a person lost; it is just that there is a record that is very indeterminate-----
Comment on this
It is not that the records are not right. There is a record that someone was placed in the home. The investigators identified that to ensure that nobody who had had any contact with the home would be left out or not referenced when the events were investigated and when talking to An Garda Síochána.
Comment on this
With regard to the cost of the reports, there is no doubt it is a substantial sum of money. However, the value of the reports is in the material they provide for the current ongoing Garda investigation, the value of which we have not yet seen. I would not agree at this point that the money has been wasted. Obviously, I have had the opportunity to read the reports, which the committee members have not. They are comprehensive reports and they provide a solid basis for the Garda investigation that is currently ongoing.
Comment on this
If everybody was doing their job right and fulfilling their moral obligation, there would not be a need for reports and that money would not have been wasted. It is wasted.
Comment on this
It is wasted in that sense but, given the protected disclosure that was made in 2009, I believe the person who commissioned those reports was doing the right thing. The reports are available to the Garda and to the commission of investigation or inquiry, whatever the correct term is, when it is established. The reports have a value, but clearly, if different decisions had been made way back in the 1990s, then this direction of travel would not have been necessary. There is no doubt the Deputy is right in that respect.
Comment on this
I asked whether staff ever do appraisals. Has anybody been held accountable for this?
Comment on this
At this point, as I explained earlier, nobody has been held accountable. That process depends upon the availability of the Conal Devine report and, to a lesser extent, the Resilience report. If I were to move forward at this stage I would actually compromise the ability either of An Garda Síochána to correctly and appropriately complete its investigation or of the HSE to pursue any disciplinary issues.
I know this is a really difficult point and many people find it hard to accept but if I were to publish those reports at this point, in my view, I would completely undermine the ability of An Garda Síochána to successfully complete its investigation and I would certainly undermine the ability of the HSE to take any disciplinary actions.
Comment on this
Are any of those people still working in the HSE or have they been moved on? Are they still working with children or adults who are vulnerable? Have we learned nothing from the past?