HSE Report on Foster Home in Waterford Community Care Area: Discussion
Contributions 595–792 of 792. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
There are people who are referenced in those reports in many different ways who are currently employed either in the health service or in Tusla, as I said earlier.
Comment on this
They are named in the report or the investigations and they are still working with children?
Comment on this
There are some people who are named in the report who are currently employed by Tusla, yes.
Comment on this
Are they working with children? It is a very specific question and a "Yes" or "No" will be fine
Comment on this
I cannot answer that question. That would have to be answered by Tusla. All I know is that they are employed by Tusla.
Comment on this
So we have not learned anything from the past. The headed paper refers to care, compassion and something else. What was the other thing?
Comment on this
I suggest that those words need to be on more than the headed paper-----
Comment on this
-----because absolutely no care or compassion has come out in this whole story or in Mr. O'Brien's replies or tone with us today. There is absolutely no care or compassion there at all from what I can gather. I thank him for his time but I do not see any care or compassion.
Comment on this
Much of this has been covered already but I will go over one area that was raised by Deputy Deasy. When Mr. O'Brien came into the job, was there any point in him making a telephone call to some of the people that he knew were there just to have a chat and see what was going on? I do not mean from the HSE or corporate side of things but just for himself. Was there not a part of him who said, "I will ring these guys and just find out what was going on at the time"?
Comment on this
No, because I cannot separate myself from my corporate role. If this comes in some cases either to criminal charges or to disciplinary charges, in statute, I have a particular function in relation to that which kicks in at a particular phase and I would have compromised that process.
Comment on this
Mr. O'Brien will meet the whistleblowers who were badly treated, involve himself and try to address their concerns. There is no issue with that meeting going on.
Comment on this
No. I have no role in relation to the disciplinary processes within the Waterford Intellectual Disability Association, not that I am imagining there is any disciplinary process to be pursued. Our relationship is such that I can talk to the whistleblowers without compromising any other functions that I have.
Comment on this
Mr. O'Brien understands why there is such a high degree of scepticism surrounding all of this. At the heart of this, there is a real lack of accountability. At the end of the day, we are discussing the lives of two people whom I have not met and do not know. I am sure this is a very distressing time for their families, as I am sure it has been for many years and not just now. Some of my colleagues know much more about this case than I do. Considering some of what we have heard, I do not want to know any more of the finer details of it. All we are hearing today is that Mr. O'Brien can go and work on certain parts but he cannot go and work on other parts.
I spent four years as a youth worker before I became a Deputy. We were always told that the basic rule in cases where we believed a young person was in danger of self-harm or being hurt was to report the matter up the line straight away, not tomorrow. It is the job of the manager to take action and if he or she does not do it, he or she is then held accountable. I have a feeling the Health Service Executive has a different understanding of the word "accountable" from other organisations because all I am hearing today is that nobody has been held responsible for this yet.
Comment on this
It would be the easiest thing in the world for me to make my life apparently easier by publishing these reports. If I did so, I would be interfering with the Garda inquiry, I would be guaranteeing that no one would ever get convicted and I would be guaranteeing that no one could ever be disciplined. I will not make my life easier in that sense by doing that just because it would be the popular thing to do. Unfortunately, some of us have particular responsibilities that place us in positions where we cannot just follow our instincts. We have to do what the law requires us to do. That is really uncomfortable for all of us.
Comment on this
I do not think it is the populist thing to do. We are not looking to create a hero. We are trying to find the answers to all these questions.
With due respect, we are not talking about something that happened in the past few years. This goes way back.
Comment on this
Yes it does. Let us be clear, this goes back to a point where I certainly have no personal agenda in protecting anybody in any way from anything. What I am not going to do is give them a get out of jail free card by putting something into the public domain that everybody wants to read, that I have read and which is horrendous. If I put it out in public, one thing is sure - nobody will get convicted, nobody will get disciplined. Nobody has yet been disciplined or convicted. However, if I put the reports in the public domain now, I guarantee that nobody will ever be. I must hold the line on that; as uncomfortable as that is, that is my job. I am stepping up to the plate. I am standing here taking this criticism for not having published this, but I will not do it if the consequence is that there will never be any accountability. I do not make any apology whatsoever for taking that position.
Comment on this
There is a very good chance that this will be our last Committee of Public Accounts meeting. The odds of these members being around this table in this number again are probably low. Will Mr. O'Brien tell the committee what the next six to 12 months hold on this story? Will Mr. O'Brien be held accountable for his current actions, not for the actions of the past?
Comment on this
At some point - I do not know whether it will be in three, six or 12 months - the Garda Síochána will clear publication of these reports. They will be published. As I understand it, the Government discussed today - but I do not know the outcome of the discussion - the setting up of the commission of inquiry or investigation that the two Ministers announced yesterday they would be recommending. As a result of exercising their rights under section 40 by end of play today, my office will have provided the Ministers with the copies of the reports we are talking about. They will be as hamstrung about their publication as I am. The report by Mr. Conor Dignam SC will be available, I suspect, by the time of the next meeting of the Committee of Public Accounts. That will inform the proposals that will have to go to the Oireachtas for the establishment of the commission of inquiry. If I get clearance to publish the reports, they will be published. Disciplinary action, hearings and all of the normal process will follow as a result of that, provided I am not prevented from doing so in respect of any individual case by a pending criminal prosecution. There are currently situations to do with things not quite as horrendous as this, but almost as bad, where we are holding off on disciplinary action, having placed people off work on protective leave, while matters are before the courts. That is exactly the course of action that will be pursued once we are in a position to publish these reports. Unfortunately that position does not yet exist. If at any point I have authority to publish the report and I do not do so, then of course I will be accountable for not having done so. I do not yet have that authority.
Comment on this
When it happens and we have the commission of inquiry, it will then fall to Mr. O'Brien to act. Mr. O'Brien referred to the corporate culture that he is trying to build up to; has he been able to fire anybody from the HSE?
Comment on this
Yes, in those cases, it was much less serious than this case.
Comment on this
People will want to see that there is accountability and that those who knew what was going on in this case will be held accountable for it.
Comment on this
I have, unfortunately, had occasion to end the employment of a number of people in circumstances that were far less serious than this. In this instance the only way to get to that point is to follow the course we are on in terms of not publishing these reports until cleared to do so by An Garda Síochána.
Comment on this
In regard to this specific area, is Mr. O'Brien concerned that something similar happened elsewhere in the country?
Comment on this
Given that this happened in the mid-1990s, as the Chairman has pointed out in the very health board where we had the Kilkenny incest case, I would be concerned that if we were to go looking back through time, we would find other issues in other parts of the country.
Comment on this
Does that not raise a great deal of concern? In his opening statement, Mr. O'Brien mentioned a look-back at these cases. Surely this should be done on a country-wide basis, considering the people who are involved are extremely vulnerable. There has been no look-back country-wide.
Comment on this
The aim of the look-back was to find people who were no longer receiving any kind of "care" in this foster setting as part of ensuring that we had a full picture in relation to this issue. We do not have similar reports that we need to pursue in respect of other areas but only a complete fool would sit here and say that there can be no concerns that similar things happened in the past in other parts of the country.
We know that a lot of bad stuff happened in lots of parts of the country in many settings. We have other investigative processes in relation to them but I have no live lines of inquiry right now.
Comment on this
Certainly, it is something we will consider but it is not under active consideration right now.
Comment on this
It is something that is under consideration.
Comment on this
We will probably make the decision in the context of the process the Ministers will be going through in relation to the commission of inquiry.
Comment on this
If Mr. O'Brien considered what the whistleblowers have said up to now, there may be other whistleblowers out there saying to themselves that they will not come forward if those two staff feel this way about it. Let us not forget, we are talking about vulnerable persons.
Comment on this
For the past 15 months, we have had a confidential recipient in place - a very credible person in the form of Ms Leigh Gath - who has been receiving confidential disclosures about issues, let me say, that are not in this ballpark at all, where specific issues have had to be addressed and remedies brought to bear. Her door is open. Her phone number is on the HSE website. If anyone has anything they need to disclose to her then they have my personal invitation to do so, as they have done since I announced her appointment.
Comment on this
Two other members have offered. I would ask them to be brief, if they can, in dealing with their issues.
Comment on this
How long has Ms Spillane been assistant secretary for social care?
Comment on this
I am an assistant secretary for approximately 15 years. I have had responsibility for disability since last November 12 months, and older people since a bit later than that.
Comment on this
We now have a commission of investigation. It has been announced. Why has it come to this?
Comment on this
There has been huge concern voiced by Ministers, and, obviously, within the Department as well, about everything that has gone on here and that was reflected in the decision by the Minister to appoint Mr. Conor Dignam SC to do the review of everything that happened in the south east.
Comment on this
The Minister of State stated last night that the reason they are going ahead with a commission of investigation is that they were not sure of the information that they were being given any longer, there was counter information and gaps in the information that the Department had been given.
Comment on this
Everybody would agree that it has been quite confusing, particularly over the last period. Equally, within the Department, we have a huge amount of correspondence on this issue at this stage. The idea with the Mr. Conor Dignam SC review was that he would effectively quality assure the two reports that had been prepared in the south east. Part of the concern at that time was that we wanted to get information and try to establish the facts relatively quickly. In fact, a detailed submission was given to the Ministers at that time outlining the different options that would be available, including a commission of investigation.
Comment on this
The Chairman was on radio last week and somebody in RTE asked whether the committee has a remit here. The Chairman replied that we did given that we looked at the value-for-money issues surrounding the commissioning of reports, but it was probably a fair question. In reality, when it comes right down to it, the Committee of Public Accounts probably should not be dealing with this; the Department should be. Ms Spillane should have dealt with this. We should not be dealing with this today. There is a theory that if it had been dealt with better in the Department of Health, a commission of investigation probably would not have been announced. That is a reasonable point. The reason Mr. Conor Dignam SC was commissioned to conduct a desktop review was because we raised this in this committee.
When it comes to constituents who came to me, I had to fight for the most basic care for some of those who were involved and who were subjected to the most horrendous rape.
We did that through what we do on a daily basis within this committee. I have to ask Ms Spillane a question. The Department of Health is absolutely pivotal in this with regard to its oversight of an organisation that has failed, and failed miserably. What was the Department doing while we were dealing with this matter? We have had Ms Spillane's boss, the Secretary General, in here. We discussed this and dealt with everything but, frankly, it led to nowhere. Ultimately, it has led to a commission of investigation because the Department of Health did not deal with this matter.
Comment on this
Deputy, we have correspondence on this going back quite some time, in particular from late 2014 when a whistleblower approached the Ministers. We have been doing our best to respond to the concerns. We have kept the Ministers fully briefed. They have met a number of whistleblowers on this issue. It is correct that the Committee of Public Accounts hearings have drawn attention to the issue but certainly the intention in getting the independent review was to try to establish the facts because it is a difficult area when people have not read the reports, Ministers have not seen the two reports. As yet, I have not seen the two reports.
Comment on this
Was Ms Spillane aware of Ann and the fact that she was in that foster home for so long? When did Ms Spillane become aware of that?
Comment on this
There is a reference, because we checked back on our records, to private placements from an early report to the Department from the HSE. In 2014, there is a reference to the fact that there were some private placements. Equally, the Department had checked, with the HSE, last year that there are now no placements with the foster family.
Comment on this
Did Ms Spillane check that out? Did Ms Spillane ask them about that private placement of Ann and the circumstances around it? Did Ms Spillane look into it?
Comment on this
No, we did not. I suppose part of our difficulty here is that the Department gets, as the Deputy would be aware, a very large number of representations - over 7,000 last year.
Comment on this
Let us be clear about something. We are talking about a foster home that was a centre of sexual abuse allegations for 30 years at that point. The witness found out that there was a private placement involved here and did not query them with regard to the circumstances around it.
Comment on this
Sorry, the Deputy's question to me was when did I know about it.
Comment on this
I must admit that it was in the interview on Sunday that I really realised-----
Comment on this
-----but we checked our records to see-----
Comment on this
-----had we been told about it. On checking the records, we found that there was a reference to private placements. I would have to admit that I have not retained all of the detail because we have quite an amount of background papers.
Comment on this
Is Ms Spillane surprised at this? I have to ask that of the Department of Health. Mr. O'Brien has made it clear that, in his opinion, and he has repeated it four or five times now in fairness, he does not have the authority within the HSE to verbalise what he would like to or what he would like to get out there. He is frustrated. The organisation is frustrated. Has the HSE contacted the Department to try to change policy regulation in any respect to make it easier for the HSE to deal with the individuals who still might be working with children? Has Ms Spillane received any representations or calls from the HSE in that regard?
Comment on this
Does the Deputy mean in terms of action to be taken in regard to personnel in the HSE?
Comment on this
Does Ms Spillane have a difficulty being an Assistant Secretary in the Department of Health knowing that there is, potentially, people who have made some horrendous mistakes within the system still working in agencies like Tusla, the child protection agency? Is there any uneasiness within the Department about that?
Comment on this
There are procedures when it is established that some-----
Comment on this
I know that. Mr. O'Brien has said that a number of times.
Comment on this
I suppose, at the moment, I feel we do not have all of the facts. That was the background to setting up the senior counsel review, that he would look at the approach and at the two reports, and that he would advise Ministers on the whole area of whether the reports could be published and, also, what the next steps should be.
In terms of that report now, the area of contributing to the terms of reference for a commission of inquiry or commission of investigation is going to be very important. The Deputy will be aware that it can be quite difficult to come up with correct terms of reference for a commission of investigation. In fact, we approached Mr. Dignam last week to see if he could expedite his review. It is going to be completed now by the end of April. We hope that will be very helpful to us in preparing detailed terms of reference, which of course have to be signed off and approved by the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
As this has unfolded over the last few months and weeks, and particularly in the last week, when Ms Spillane has requested information from the HSE about the specifics, is she happy that she got the full information on every occasion? We are not, obviously. We think the information that has been dispatched to us has been selective. Is Ms Spillane happy that she and her Department have received the full information at every juncture?
Comment on this
Certainly we have received a lot of information from the HSE. We rely completely on the HSE all the time for information on operational matters, so we are constantly in contact with it. For example, we would have been in contact with it for a briefing for Leaders' Questions on this issue. It is very difficult to say categorically that I am absolutely satisfied that we got all of the information. To the extent that we have a very good working relationship with the people in the disability unit in the HSE, they do send us prompt replies to queries all the time.
Comment on this
When Ms Spillane's boss - Mr. Breslin, I think - appeared before the committee the last time, we asked him about the draft recommendations that were sent by the HSE to the Department of Health about the selection of people who are commissioned to do reports. We are told publicly now that a panel will be set up. I asked the clerk about this, and I do not think we ever received confirmation with regard to the finalisation of those recommendations. Can Ms Spillane tell us if that has happened?
Comment on this
The HSE would be in a better position to answer that. This is the independent review panel.
Comment on this
I am not sure offhand what members have received, but the-----
Comment on this
Nothing. The HSE gave us the draft. It was going to the Department and has not seen the light of day yet.
Comment on this
There has been a series of discussions about the implementation of it. Under our statute - the 2013 statute - there are two committees which are independently chaired, an audit committee and a risk committee. We have agreed that the chair of the review panel will be accountable to the risk committee - in other words, not accountable to the executive of the HSE at all. They are currently finalising a person specification for that so that an open competition can follow for the appointment of the individual who will be chair of the panel.
Comment on this
This is a hypothetical question, but I think it is relevant. If Mr. O'Brien discovered, hypothetically, that one of his officials was dangerous - complicit in something terrible - and if he had a really serious personal concern with regard to the safety of the individuals that person was in charge of within his organisation, would he feel the same way he does today? Would he say that there was nothing he could do and that he would have to wait until the reports were published and the Garda investigation had concluded? Would he wait? Would he sit on it and say there was nothing he could do statutorily? If he found that somebody was at serious risk of doing something terrible, what would Mr. O'Brien do?
Comment on this
I would do what we did in the case of Áras Attracta, which was to place a significant number of staff on protective leave in accordance with the safeguarding policy that is in place today, pending an investigation; establish that investigation; and wait for our ability to proceed with disciplinary proceedings before we did so. In the Áras Attracta case that investigation is ongoing, but it cannot be brought to conclusion until the criminal proceedings are concluded.
Comment on this
That is not a hypothetical answer. That is a current answer.
Comment on this
I have one tiny last question. It goes back to Ann and those various engagements. We have now found out that, for the reasons the members of the HSE deputation have stated, even though those engagements were ongoing from 2011 to 2013, the HSE did not inform the family of the sex abuse allegations. What changed? Why did the HSE formally demand in October 2013 when it had not done so previously?
Comment on this
I said two things. A similar question was asked. The team had been engaging locally under the senior manager. The Devine report had been completed and implementation of the report had commenced. There was some legal delay at the beginning but it was progressing at that stage. There was a review by a senior manager of the situation and how things were progressing. At that point, she decided to escalate the position and engage with the family directly. She wrote to the foster family first. She then engaged with the mother and the family. There were conversations and so on and then she wrote to her at the end of the month. By the end of October of that year matters were brought to a conclusion.
It is the challenging predicament of an adult living at home on weekends, as it was at that stage. Every second weekend she was going home to mother and staying seven days a week. How do we ensure it? Up to today, we have confirmation that the mother is clear that she receives her daughter at home and does not place her in this location. She may visit, but she does not place her there. That is the most up-to-date information we have, as of today.
Comment on this
I will be brief. What we have heard today has been extremely disturbing. The members of the HSE deputation have already admitted to mishandling and to erroneous and inaccurate information - indeed, misinformation - being provided. We saw from the case of Ann that there was a gross and grave dereliction of duty in terms of the HSE's responsibility of care. There is prima facie evidence of that, quite clearly.
At this point I am worried that there is no disciplinary procedure in place. The abuse has been known about for a long period and there have been a number of investigations. Now, we have to wait further before we are in a position to take any action, on the basis that any action would prejudice the existing investigations. We come then to the question of the commission of investigation that is about to be set up. That could take another couple of years. We end up in a situation, at this point at 4.30 p.m. before the general election is called, whereby no protections are in place that we are aware of in respect of people in care. The HSE representatives have indicated that they did not know what was happening to some of the people named in the reports who are still working in a care capacity. The HSE is unsure whether they were dealing with vulnerable children either.
This is my point. How many children are still under HSE care? What number are we talking about? Does the HSE deputation have any ideas, between now and when we are going to have some outturn from the various investigations, for putting in place any protocols to protect these people? This is a clear dereliction. There seems to be no line management where anyone is directly responsible despite prima facie evidence.
How can we rest tonight and be sure that all the children in the care of the HSE are protected if it has no internal mechanism for dealing with them, as it appears, and it is going to kick everything to touch until such time as the investigations are complete?
Comment on this
First, children in care are not in the care of the HSE. They are in the care of the Child and Family Agency, known as Tusla. Second-----
Comment on this
Mr. O'Brien told us that some of these people were working with Tusla.
Comment on this
Yes, but we are not Tusla and we do not have jurisdiction over children in care. We provide care to children, but that is a different matter. Mr. Healy will speak to that.
Comment on this
Did Mr. O'Brien not indicate that some of the people named in the reports were working with Tusla?
Comment on this
I have indicated that some of the people who have had some role or other in respect of this issue in the south east are currently in the employ of Tusla. Deputy Costello's question to me was how many children we had in care. We have no children in care because we do not have those functions. Regarding the issue of-----
Comment on this
Not directly in care, but for which the HSE has a caring responsibility.
Comment on this
Mr. Healy will give the Deputy that information in a second, if that is okay. Regarding Ann, it is important that I stress that the legal advice is clear. We do not have a statutory capacity to shut down a private arrangement of the type that existed in respect of the person whom we are calling "Ann". Ultimately-----
Comment on this
No, we have been over all of that. The HSE demanded that the family cease activity.
Comment on this
Then the HSE sent a formal letter to the parents, who immediately accepted what the HSE did, but it had been blaming them in the years prior to that for not listening to it.
Comment on this
I am not blaming anyone. I am saying that the HSE lacks the statutory-----
Comment on this
That is the import of that section.
Comment on this
I do not want to go down that road again, but it is clearly the import of the section that the responsibility rested with the parents and not the HSE. It washed its hands of responsibility. It then took responsibility in October 2013.
Comment on this
Up to that time, the HSE sat on its hands and effectively blamed the parents.
Comment on this
I have not blamed the parents. The Deputy may interpret it as that, but he will not find words of blame in my statement. I do not blame the parents. What I am-----
Comment on this
Any reasonable person reading Mr. O'Brien's statement would come to that conclusion.
Comment on this
What I am attempting to communicate, and I hope reasonably, is that, in law, the HSE lacks the statutory capacity to shut down a private arrangement. What is reflected over a period of time is increasing efforts of persuasion-----
Comment on this
That was not my question. We have been over this ground before. My question is on the people who are still in the HSE's employ and in respect of whom no disciplinary action has been taken. No one has been suspended and, as far as we can gather from today, no action can be taken until such time as the inquiries are complete. This is the message that we are getting.
Comment on this
The HSE's hands are tied and, therefore, vulnerable children will remain vulnerable.
Comment on this
I will make two distinctions. Children in care are the responsibility of Tusla, the child care agency, but there are children for whom we have a responsibility. There was a time when the HSE had statutory authority for children. Obviously, we had to discharge that legislation fully. We are no longer the statutory authority. However, we have a duty of care to children and we must fully comply with children legislation, including the Child Care Act. Everyone working in our services, in particular the disability services-----
Comment on this
I do not want to go on with this, Chairman. We are getting nowhere. There are people in the HSE's employ who have not been disciplined and are potentially still in contact with vulnerable children, yet it has no protocols in place or internal-----
Comment on this
All services that are provided must comply fully with-----
Comment on this
We have been given a description of a dysfunctional organisation. We need to know whether the HSE is putting its own house in order so that, when there is prima facie evidence of vulnerable children being in danger, albeit not necessarily evidence that is raised in court, but involving whistleblowers and so on, it will take action without waiting for an investigation and show clearly that it is protecting the children who have been the subjects of the abuse that has been brought to its attention.
Comment on this
In children services, there are full child care protocols in line with Children First that must be followed.
In respect of adults, we now have, for the first time, a national safeguarding policy for adults. It is the first time in Ireland that this has been implemented. It means there is now a policy both for children and adults. There is a statutorily based one for children; the national safeguarding policy is not statutorily based but it is there and all service providers have been confirmed. That is what the national summits have been about, namely, implementing that. One of the good things that has come out of this very damaging and bad situation is this national policy for safeguarding adults. It was one of the key recommendations of the Devine report and for the first time, that has been implemented. That is a very good thing.
Comment on this
That is in all the community care areas.
Comment on this
Every residential centre has been written to and has to comply with this. There are now newly-appointed safeguarding teams in the nine community health care organisations, with a principal social worker in charge of them. For the first time in Ireland we have the beginnings of a structured engagement on a continual basis with-----
Comment on this
Are all HSE staff conversant with and trained in the open disclosures policy?
Comment on this
They have all been provided with the policy and there has been widespread training. As to whether they are conversant with it, I have to be honest I am not happy with the level of open disclosure. Too many issues reach my desk where there has not been open disclosure since the policy was implemented. I am a strong advocate of the open disclosure policy being put on a statutory basis.
Comment on this
Are all of the witnesses, for instance, trained in open disclosure?
Comment on this
I have not been trained in Ireland. Obviously I have been trained in Australia and since I have been orientated, I have read the documents, but I have not undergone training as such.
Comment on this
Had those who were dealing with the apology to Grace and her family been trained in open disclosure?
Comment on this
We would probably want to check that before giving an answer that might be wrong.
Comment on this
Could Mr. O'Brien do that, please?
Comment on this
Just to clarify a few points before we finish, did Mr. O'Brien say that it was for 23 years that Ann was in-----
Comment on this
Yes. She is now 35 and she was born in 1980. It commenced when she was 12, part time. She was never there full time.
Comment on this
Okay. Mr. O'Brien said the HSE lacks formal authority to intervene with a private citizen, in the case of requesting them to stop using the home.
Comment on this
I understand it, but did Mr. O'Brien ever then contact the Department of Health and explain the type of legislation that might be needed in this regard?
Comment on this
Does the Department of Health consider, having listened to all of this, that there is need for further legislation in this area?
Comment on this
I brought to your attention, Mr. O'Brien, the fact that the HSE was told locally about Ann and that the social workers asked that the necessary steps be taken to protect her. They were that concerned. This was in 2009. She was still there in 2013. Have you details of that?
Comment on this
This is detailed in the Resilience report.
Comment on this
That is a fact, that the HSE was asked to take the necessary steps and obviously did not, because Ann was still there in 2013. The necessary steps to protect her were highlighted.
Comment on this
I can confirm, without hesitation, that concerns were raised at that time.
Comment on this
At the time, because Ann was an adult and not a child, the HSE lacked the statutory capacity to close down that arrangement and, as set out in the opening statement, pursued a process of engagement with-----
Comment on this
I am not sure whether the Department was advised in 2011. The Garda was consulted. That was the key piece at the time. Legal advice was received locally at that time.
Comment on this
The Department was not written to on this matter until 2014.
Comment on this
To go back to Grace, a type 2 arrangement was entered into where her disability allowance would have been paid to the foster home, and for that the foster home would give an undertaking that she would be cared for, the money would be looked after, a special account would be opened and so on. Was that type 2 arrangement entered into by the health board or the HSE at the time?
Comment on this
I am not familiar with the type 2. What I said earlier is that my understanding is that she had a foster allowance, which was-----
Comment on this
The Department of Social Welfare paid the disabled person's maintenance allowance.
Comment on this
I will explain what I am talking to him about here. I presume the arrangement that is entered into could be classed as a legal agreement, or as an almost legal agreement, setting out how that money would be looked after. As I said earlier on, even though that agreement was in place, she entered care in 2009 with no belongings, no money and no documentation. She had nothing. If one adds it up, one will find that approximately €70,000 was paid in benefit to the foster mother. If that arrangement was there for Grace, how many more people was it there for? Regardless of whether it is a health board document or a Department of Social Protection document, there is a document that should have been signed by the foster parents, the foster home or the respite home. Can Mr. Healy find out whether the HSE has those signed documents for the others? Are they held by the Department of Social Protection? It is important to follow that up. Mr. Healy was very quick to give us the figures for two organisations funded by the HSE, but he could not give us the figures for the clients' payments when he was pursued on it. I ask him to pursue that aspect of this issue with the Departments concerned in order that we can get to the end of the payment piece. We have not got to the end of the payment piece here.
Comment on this
Yes. Did the HSE in recent times make a statement saying that the Waterford Intellectual Disability Association stopped it from giving the apology? Could Mr. Healy give me some clarification on that? Was that something that was said or issued in a statement?
Comment on this
No, there was never an inference that we were stopped. First of all-----
Comment on this
We have already apologised for the mistake we made in relation to this.
Comment on this
There was never a suggestion that the organisation stopped us from doing this.
Comment on this
The only interest was in trying to do it personally as opposed to by letter.
Comment on this
I would like to follow up with Mr. O'Brien what Deputy Dowds said about the legal issues here and the possibility of people taking a case against the HSE and so on. Mr. O'Brien said that no legal defence is really being offered by the HSE. Have Mr. O'Brien and his colleagues in the HSE estimated how much the possibility of cases being taken and having to be settled might cost the State? Have they entered into such an examination yet?
Comment on this
That is a discussion we would need to have with the State Claims Agency. The quantification of liabilities is a function performed by that agency.
Comment on this
Okay. I would like to return to the Waterford Intellectual Disability Association and the funding. During the course of the care of Grace, did the association get special funding to take care of Grace, or was that something it had to fund out of its grant from the Department?
Comment on this
I am not sure of the detail of how much funding they got specifically for Grace. I know that she was taken into care. There may have been some additional funding. I am not sure.
Ms Colley may have the details.
Comment on this
I am just not sure of the detail of it. I know that what we have done since with the Resilience report-----
Comment on this
No, no. Go back. Do not wander off on me again. What is happening in regard to the care of Grace is that the organisation or agency had to care for Grace out of its own funds. You presented a column of funding in order to point out to us that it was not penalised in any way for raising issues around the care of intellectually disabled people. I understand that Mr. O'Brien is going to have a discussion with it and I know he will be fair about it. I think when you look at the funding figures that you quoted in your opening statement, and factor in the work that had to be done and the care that had to be given, you will find that its funding actually decreased over the period. I will not argue with you about the figures, but I am going to ask you to examine that table at some stage and be prepared to inform the next Committee of Public Accounts of the position.
I am just finished now. With regard to the three people who made the decision to leave Grace there - we have covered this, but let us clarify it - I understand that you cannot comment at all about that, but that you have all of the information that led them to the decision that they made. Is this correct? You were able to give us the table of the funding and everything else and other parts of the report.
Comment on this
Yes. The table that is currently on the screen is not part of the report; it is something we prepared for the committee today. The information that we are currently allowed to release was contained in the submission of 10 December which had the unfortunate cover note that had the effect of misleading the committee. The report of Conal Devine and Associates has considerable detail, including interviews with the people involved, that describe the processes that led to that decision, but I cannot share that information with the committee at this stage.
Comment on this
In regard to Ann, in one of your comments earlier you spoke about the rights of the foster mother and so on. You outlined those. In all of your discussions here, as I said to you earlier on, there was a failure to outline the rights of the intellectually disabled person. The emphasis on one set of rights as against another is not balanced. That is my view of what you have been saying.
Comment on this
In these settings, where the Committee of Public Accounts is doing what it normally does around accounts and value-for-money audits, the typical thing is that the Accounting Officer - in this case, me - would sit here and put up a robust defence of everything that has been done. I think we can agree that is the normal fare. It is not unnatural, therefore, that the committee might perceive that that is how I see my function here today. I do not see it that way. I am not in any way seeking to defend what happened to any of the individuals who suffered harm or may have suffered harm as a result of failings in regard to this foster care centre. My opening remarks were intended to convey that I believe that this is an egregious situation and that terrible things have happened. In response to questions about the issue of the release of documents and so on, in seeking to explain that I have obviously had to focus on those issues. That should not be to the exclusion of the fact that my rationale is that, ultimately, I need to preserve the potential for justice to be done - justice in the name of all of the citizens who have been disadvantaged as a result of these failings. Sometimes I am put in a position of answering questions about a specific thing which may result in my seeming to be arguing certain things, but that is not the case. The whole purpose of my statement was to be clear. I was very clear, I think, on the radio on Sunday. This is a terrible situation. I have no agenda of seeking to defend what went wrong, but I do have an obligation to create the conditions in which justice can be served. That is it.
Comment on this
The problem is that justice may never be done in this case.
Comment on this
Well, it will be. Whoever is in the House after the election will have to pursue it. I respect the position Mr. O'Brien is taking and, as I said, I encourage him to continue with speed down that road. That brings me to the point made by Deputy McFadden. I was asked a question about our remit on the radio and Deputy Deasy quoted me.
It started with the whole question of costs. It is a €13.5 billion fund of taxpayers' money that is given to the Health Service Executive, HSE, and in purchasing the services such as we are describing here or in the procurement process for that service, it is the duty of this committee to hold the HSE to account in terms of the spending of that taxpayers' money so I hold that we are well within the remit. We have strayed into the care of individuals but that is only because dealing with this and with procurement and governance has led us here. That is why we are here. I am saying that, Deputy McFadden, because there needs to be clarity around this. There are those exotic creatures outside the House who might like to describe our work differently, but I believe we are doing it well within our remit.
Comment on this
We do not know who the Chairman is talking about.
Comment on this
In terms of current issues, and I will finish on this, Tusla is now the child care agency and I would have to say that if I had doubt about any employee I would have who was taking up employment elsewhere, I would be inclined to mark their cards. That is all I will say. It is a reasonable undertaking to assume that the HSE would undertake that in terms of any doubts it had because not to correct it or flag it is allowing for the same errors to be possible for the future, and we must break that culture.
Finally, since this happened, and I spoke to Ms Colley earlier on, I have received numerous phone calls from people who are currently attempting to sort out similar issues with the HSE, or with Tusla now, and some of the stories I have heard, which I am checking out and will present to the HSE or to the confidential recipient as soon as I clarify them, would not make one proud as a political figure that we preside over this type of thing in our State. I am just making that general comment because of what I have heard, but I will check it out.
As an example, in my own constituency, in terms of a particular organisation funded by the HSE, I am disappointed at the level of consultation with the parents of 11 intellectually disabled children who have now found themselves out of their homes, and we speak about the homeless here a lot, and are now being cared for in a hotel where the Health Information and Quality Authority, HIQA, standards do not apply. Regardless of how long or how short they will be there, it is simply not right that this would happen. I will speak to Ms Colley privately about this but I am shocked at the way parents are being treated with regard to that particular issue and the provision of respite for those parents who need it. The resolution there is not being found in the way Mr. O'Brien has described it today in terms of finding the resolution, dealing with it, and the most vulnerable people being catered for.
I thank the witnesses for coming today. I know it has been a long meeting but I appreciate their attendance and, at times, their frankness in terms of the replies they gave.
Comment on this
If I may make a point based on a point the Chairman just made, I am sure Ms Spillane is aware that the Director of Public Prosecutions, DPP, has looked at this. There were five files. He did not proceed. Obviously, she is also aware that many of the people involved in this are non-verbal and the likelihood of them testifying was always very slim, and that one of the alleged perpetrators is dead. The issue, and it was raised by the whistleblower on television last night, is that the Department has professional sanctions for, say, care workers but when it comes to a certain level within the health services, there are very few sanctions.
One of the concerns is that the Acts cover the period from 2006 onwards, such that if it was the case that reckless endangerment or professional negligence was involved, the Acts would not cover the period prior to that. Is Ms Spillane concerned that in the area of foster care, when it comes to the management and administration of it, the regulation is not sufficient to provide the kinds of protection that vulnerable children need in this country? Surely, one of the lessons we have got to learn from this is that people can make decisions, frankly, not care, go about their business and that there be no accountability. Is it, after all of this, a concern within the Department that that has occurred in the way it has and are there plans to change that?
Comment on this
As has been mentioned earlier, the Department of Health no longer has responsibility for child protection: it is with the Department of Children and Youth Affairs and Tusla. There have been foster care regulations since 1996, as far as I know, as part of the modernisation of our child protection services and the investment that has been made over the years, including the setting up of a separate child care agency. I would have to check out the point the Deputy made about fitness to practise and whether the legislation applies to the period before the legislation was commenced. I would also have to confer with colleagues in the Department of Children and Youth Affairs in regard to revisions of the foster care regulations. As I worked in that area at one time I do know that it includes a lot of safeguards like visits by social workers to the homes on a regular basis.
Comment on this
That did not happen in this case, as Ms Spillane knows.
Comment on this
No, but the new regulations provide for rigorous vetting of families. We have a very high proportion of our children in care in foster care which is regarded, in terms of the quality of care for children, as being preferable to having them in residential centres.
Comment on this
I again thank the witnesses for attending. This part of the meeting is concluded.
In conclusion of the Committee of Public Accounts for this Dáil term, I thank all those witnesses that appeared before us. I also thank the secretariat, back-up services and all members of the committee, including those currently serving and those who have been members during the course of the past five years. It has been an experience where, like today, we have often had to drag the facts and, in this case, the terrible abuse, out from behind closed doors that are well guarded and place them before the public in the hope that the various Departments that are responsible in this State take account of what has been done and take the appropriate action to ensure that the likes of what we have just heard and, indeed, what we have heard in the last five years does not happen again.
Regrettably, in terms of the Committee of Public Accounts' work, when one hears the description "inquiry into accounts of a State body" it immediately rings alarm bells. In the particular case that we heard today the bells rang true. We saw how it is often the insiders that carry out the reports and sometimes, in fact a lot of the time, that is not satisfactory.
To the whistleblowers that have come before us or that have contacted the committee, I want to put on record that I believe they have been very brave individuals. We were cautioned a lot about receiving evidence from Sergeant Maurice McCabe and look at the service that he did for the State. I think that the whistleblowers in this case are to be commended. Every effort should be made to protect the organisations that support the social workers and that ensure that the whistleblowers in turn are supported and protected.
One other issue that has crossed our desk is that often the last spin of the dice is when an agency of the State refers the issue in hand to the Garda and then the investigation is brushed into a cul-de-sac and does not go any further. That is something that is, perhaps, done to buy time or, perhaps, to create an escape for those involved.
This is something the Minister for Justice and Equality and the Garda should talk about to determine whether legislation is required to deal with the kind of instrument that might provide people with the get out of jail card they are seeking.
Reading the whistleblower legislation, one could be sucked in by it but it has been proven it now needs to be strengthened. More often than not, the whistleblower ends up as the person in the iron mask, silenced, in an office with no work. We have examples of this across various areas. The failed culture that allows this to happen needs to be rooted out. If it is not, this will continue.
I sat on this committee previously and have had the honour of chairing it for the past five years and I hope that, as we face into an election, those who are elected will have the bravery and courage to take on the job the electorate gives them and ensure, through legislation and their work on the committees of this House, they bring justice to those who deserve it, strike out to make a difference and bring about the reforms so necessary to ensure this State functions better. The divide that is emerging between the State and its people must be closed and we must have better representation.
This committee has done a fine job over the past five years and I commend committee members and staff on the work they have undertaken. I should also thank the members of the media. We will adjourn now and someone else will take up the baton after the election. Thank you.