We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

2018 Financial Statements of the Charities Regulatory Authority

Contributions 1–217 of 667. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

We are meeting representatives of the Charities Regulatory Authority, CRA, regarding its financial statements for 2018. We are joined by Ms Helen Martin, chief executive officer; Mr. Niall Scanlon, finance manager; and Mr. Eamon O'Halloran, head of registration and projects. We are also joined by Ms Ciara Bates, principal officer, and Mr. Kevin Power, assistant principal officer in the Department of Rural and Community Development. It is interesting that this is the first time the authority has appeared before the Committee of Public Accounts. It is also Ms Martin's first appearance before the committee, having been appointed to her current role last summer. We wish her well.

I remind members, witnesses and the people in the Gallery that all mobile phones must be turned off or put into airplane mode, as merely putting them into silent mode does not prevent interference with the recording system.

By virtue of section 17(2)(l) of the Defamation Act 2009, witnesses are protected by absolute privilege in respect of their evidence to the committee. If they are directed by it to cease giving evidence on a particular matter and they continue to so do, they are entitled thereafter only to qualified privilege in respect of their evidence. They are directed that only evidence connected with the subject matter of these proceedings is to be given. They are asked to respect the parliamentary practice to the effect that, where possible, they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable.

Members are reminded that under Standing Order 186, the committee shall refrain from inquiring into the merits of a policy or policies of the Government or a Minister of the Government, or the merits of the objectives of such policies.

While we expect witnesses to answer questions asked by the committee clearly and with candour, they can, and should, expect to be treated fairly and with respect and consideration at all times in accordance with the witness protocol. I ask the Comptroller and Auditor General to make his opening statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

The Charities Regulatory Authority was formally established in 2014 under the Charities Act 2009. It is responsible for the regulation and protection of charitable trusts and organisations. It has been granted a wide range of powers and duties, including the power to conduct investigations into the affairs of charities. Under the provisions of the Act, the authority holds funds in trust on behalf of charities that wish to participate in a common investment fund controlled by the authority. Separately, it holds the funds of charities in a charity funds account. My audit of the authority covers two sets of financial statements: the financial statements for the normal operations of the authority and the financial statements for the charity funds account. The common investment fund is separately accounted for and is audited by a commercial firm of auditors. The financial statements of the common investment fund are not presented to the Oireachtas.

The 2018 financial statements of the authority recorded total income of €3.96 million, all of which is Oireachtas grant funding. Its expenditure in that year was €3.7 million, which included staff costs of €2.1 million and other administration costs of €1.5 million. The authority reported an operating surplus for the year of €47,000, after appropriation of €236,000 for capital purposes. A clear audit opinion was given on the 2018 financial statements. Certain charity funds have been lodged for safekeeping with the authority or its predecessor, the Commissioners for Charitable Donations and Bequests, and are being held pending clarification of their proper use. These funds are held by the authority in a separate charity funds account. The authority uses the same account, as required, to receive and transmit funds between charities and the common investment fund. The balance on the charity funds account at the close of 2018 was €1.38 million. Most of the balance related to funds of charities being held for safekeeping. Receipts into the fund account during 2018 amounted to just over €2 million, mainly comprising dividends from the investment fund and proceeds of investment units realised at the direction of participating charities. The charity funds account payments in 2018 mainly represented distribution of the receipts to the charities concerned. A clear audit opinion was given on the 2018 financial statements of this account.

Comment on this

I thank the Comptroller and Auditor General. I ask Ms Martin to make her opening statement.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

I thank the Chairman and the members of the Committee of Public Accounts for inviting me here today to address the committee on the 2018 financial statements of the Charities Regulatory Authority. I am joined by Mr. Eamon O’Halloran, who is the authority's head of registration and projects; and Mr. Niall Scanlon, who was recently appointed as the authority's professional accountant and finance manager. The committee will be aware that the CRA, or Charities Regulator as it is known, was established as an independent authority on a statutory basis in October 2014 in accordance with the Charities Act 2009. The board of the authority has 12 members and the authority has 37.5 full-time equivalent members of staff.

The Charities Regulator is funded by the Exchequer through a subhead of Vote 42 of the Department of Rural and Community Development. In 2018, our budget was €4.4 million and our total spend was just over €4 million. Pay accounted for approximately €2.1 million of our overall spend and non-pay expenditure amounted to approximately €1.9 million. Monthly financial reports are used by senior management, by the finance, audit, risk and governance committee and by the board to monitor performance against key strategic priorities, objectives and yearly business plan targets. We have a number of statutory functions, such as maintaining a register of charities, ensuring charity trustees comply with the 2009 Act, carrying out inquiries and investigations into the affairs of charities and issuing guidance and other codes to assist charity trustees. We deal with applications by charities under the Charities Acts, 1961 and 1973, for services and assistance such as authorising cy-près schemes and sales of charity lands. When it was established, the Charities Regulator took over responsibility for administering a common investment fund scheme for charities, established under the Charities Act 1961. The current value of this fund is approximately €39.7 million.

Our first statement of strategy supported the establishment of the Charities Regulator and guided us through our formative years from 2016 to 2018. Over this period, significant time was dedicated to establishing organisational structures, processes and procedures to ensure compliance with the code of practice for the governance of State bodies. During the period of our first statement of strategy, we developed an online public register of charities and established a contact centre for charity trustees and other members of the public to call or email us with any queries they may have. Other key milestones during that period included the publication of a suite of practical and informative guidance materials to assist charity trustees, including guidelines on fundraising from the public, the development of a concerns unit and an online concerns process, the completion of a number of statutory investigations under the 2009 Act, the implementation of a new digital platform to support our regulatory and organisational activities, the launch of an enhanced website and a quarterly e-magazine to keep those involved in the sector updated on key developments, the formulation of a draft scheme for a charities (amendment) Bill along with associated draft accounting and reporting regulations and the launch of the charities governance code.

In 2019, we published our second statement of strategy, for 2019 to 2021, which aims to move us closer to realising our vision of a vibrant trusted charity sector that is valued for the public benefit it provides. Strengthening public trust and confidence in charities is one of four strategic priorities under our second statement of strategy.

A key objective in this regard is to enhance further the public register of charities, which is a searchable online facility.

Charities are independent organisations run by charity trustees. They play a vital role in our society and provide public benefit in diverse ways to communities in Ireland and across the world. It is, therefore, essential that charities are transparent and accountable to volunteers, beneficiaries, employees, funders, donors and the wider public. The register is intended as a point of reference for members of the public to learn more about individual charities. There are currently 10,370 registered charities in Ireland and 65,904 charity trustees listed on the register. According to research published by the Charities Regulator in 2018, the majority of charities on the register are small volunteer-led charities with income of less than €50,000. However, there is no doubt that registered charities make a significant contribution to our economy and society more generally, with income of €14.5 billion, approximately 189,000 people employed in the sector and more than 300,000 volunteers.

Other general functions of the Charities Regulator include the promotion of compliance by charity trustees with their legal duties and ensuring the accountability of charities to donors, beneficiaries and the public. In this regard, we work closely with charities, charity representative groups and other experts and stakeholders to ensure that the guidance materials that we publish are of practical assistance to those volunteering and working in the sector. Examples include the guidelines on fundraising from the public, guidance for charity trustees, internal financial control guidelines for charities and, more recently, a governance code toolkit comprising templates and other guidance materials to underpin the charities governance code. Promoting compliance with the charities governance code and working with charities to support them in its implementation will remain a key focus for the Charities Regulator for the period of our current strategy.

Our statutory remit also includes monitoring compliance by charitable organisations with charity law and carrying out investigations. We actively monitor compliance with key regulatory requirements, such as the requirement for charities to submit annual reports. Compliance rates in regard to this obligation have increased significantly over the past three years, with the overall compliance rate for annual reports due in regard to 2017 reaching 98%.

We also carry out inquiries as part of our concerns process. In 2018, we received in excess of 686 concerns, which was an increase of 29% on the previous year. Of the concerns received in respect of registered charities, over 50% related to internal financial controls and transparency and other governance issues. We closed 722 concerns during 2018.

Other compliance activities in 2018 included 48 statutory directions to provide information or produce books, documents and other records for the purposes of our inquiries. In addition, we published two inspectors’ reports into the affairs of two registered charities, GLEN and Solas–Galway Picture Palace, and we imposed intermediate sanctions on one registered charity.

Developing our compliance and enforcement function further is a key objective in terms of meeting our strategic priorities of providing proportionate risk-based regulation and protection, and promoting compliance within the sector. Supported by our new IT platform, along with a number of important legislative amendments, which the Minister for Rural and Community Development is progressing through the charities (amendment) Bill, we hope to enhance our proactive monitoring capabilities further, using data to identify and anticipate risks to facilitate targeted and proportionate regulatory interventions and engagement with charities. The charities (amendment) Bill is key in this regard as it will create a level playing field for all charities, including those that are companies, and will facilitate increased levels of transparency and greater accountability in regard to the finances of charities.

Since our establishment in 2014, the Charities Regulator has made significant progress in meeting its statutory mandate. Through the hard work and commitment of the authority, its staff and those working in the charities sector, we have a strong foundation on which to build and deliver on our second statement of strategy. We remain committed to working with all our stakeholders to fulfil our mission to regulate the charity sector in the public interest so as to ensure compliance with the law and support best practice in the governance, management and administration of charities. I am happy to respond to any questions members of the committee might have.

Comment on this

Thank you. Today, we have two sessions and we will have one lead speaker for each session, one this morning and one this afternoon, if that is agreeable. The lead speaker this morning is Deputy Kelly.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in and for their opening statement. I wish them the best of luck in their important work. Given the number of charities, and there are those that come under two lists, that is, those that are registered and those that are not, and given the number of full-time staff in the Charities Regulator is 37.5 whole-time equivalents, does it have enough capacity to do this work? It is a relatively new organisation and has had to develop and get structures in place. While I believe this is a positive thing, and I do not say that regularly, it seems a small number of staff for the work it does, given there are 10,370 registered charities.

The Charities Regulator has had a turnover of senior staff lately. That usually sets off alarm bells here. Ms Martin might explain, so we can clear that up, why the three senior people left.

How often does the Charities Regulator liaise with the Office of the Director of Corporate Enforcement, the Revenue Commissioners, the Garda fraud squad, the Data Protection Commissioner and the Companies Registration Office? Will Ms Martin give us a flavour of that in regard to meetings and interactions, what they are about and how often they take place, sharing data, investigations and so on?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

With regard to the number of staff, we do not have enough staff and the complement should be about 53. However, as the Deputy rightly pointed out, we have achieved an enormous amount, although that has been on the back of the real commitment of staff and focusing our resources on where we think we can have the greatest impact. That would be in terms of supporting charities but also, at the same time, since 2016, building up our concerns unit. In future, when we have more staff, we will look to move into the area of more proactive monitoring, and I will come back to that later as there are certain things we require in that regard.

We have managed to get staff over the past year, having lost some staff. We have a new in-house finance manager, which we did not have before as we previously used a consultant. I wanted to bring that role in-house so that person would be reporting to me, as CEO. We have also got our head of communications and stakeholder engagement, which is another key position we have filled since June of this year. In addition, we have a number of positions that are obviously key and which we absolutely need to fill, such as the corporate affairs manager, and we also need more legal resources. On the legal resources, it is a very challenging marketplace out there but we are using the different avenues available to us and working with the Department on that in regard to seeking expressions of interest for secondment of people from within the civil and public service and drawing down from past panels that are available to us. That is very much the focus at the moment. Another key position was filled in recent weeks when Thomas Mulholland joined us as our head of compliance and enforcement.

Comment on this

Why the turnover?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

The turnover was due to promotions that were available to others within the Civil Service. As the Deputy knows, the CEO moved on to become CEO of the Mental Health Commission. Our head of compliance and enforcement moved on. At the time, his role was graded as assistant principal and we sought to have that regraded, but unfortunately he had moved on to a promotion opportunity within the HSE. Our head of communications and stakeholder engagement had been with us on a two-year contract and, as a result, had wanted to move on, and he moved back into the charities sector. They were the main losses that we had.

Comment on this

Can I have an answer to my second question?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

This was in regard to our interactions with other agencies. The main agency we interact with is Revenue, with which members of our registration team would interact. The Deputy might be aware from our briefing material that 6,500 of the charities on our register are there because they were deemed registered at the date the register was established.

The deeming was related to the fact that on that date, they held a charitable tax exemption so, effectively, they came on to the register. We have over 3,500 others which are what we call section 39 bodies. They are the charities that registered with us. As a result of the fact that we have a huge number of section 40 bodies, the ones that are deemed registered, we would deal with Revenue a lot. Where a section 40 charity that has been deemed registered loses its charitable tax exemption through the operation of the Act, it automatically comes off the register. We have no input into that decision. Once a charity loses its tax exemption, it comes off the register and must try to re-register. That is why we interact regularly with Revenue.

In addition, we would be in contact with the Companies Registration Office regarding our IT platform and the fact that we would draw down certain materials from its website regarding the accounts of those charities that are companies. Our compliance and enforcement team would be in contact with staff from the Office of the Director of Corporate Enforcement where particular issues arise, for example, if we were dealing with a company that was not keeping proper books of account. Unfortunately, under our Act at the moment, we would not be able to proceed against such a company for breach of the Charities Act because it is a company and is carved out. That is something we are looking to address under the charities (amendment) Bill because we believe all charities should be equally regulated by the Charities Regulator. It means that in those situations, we have to contact the ODCE because, obviously, it is an offence not to keep proper books of account under the Companies Act. We are reliant on the ODCE to take action in that regard. Similarly, we would have almost daily contact with An Garda Síochána.

Comment on this

Regarding donations and donors, we know that quite a number of people leave bequests to charities. What kind of powers does the Charities Regulator use to ensure that the money being left in wills to various different charities does what it says on the tin, namely, goes to the right area and relevant charity and is spent in the way the person, persons or organisations intended it to be spent? Have there ever been instances where anyone in the legal profession has had to be investigated for ignoring or not following instructions 100% regarding the leaving of money to these organisations? What procedures has the Charities Regulator used to follow up in such scenarios? Does it ever carry out random checks in respect of these sort of donations to make sure the money is being spent appropriately to ensure public confidence? I see that the section on donations in its guidelines for charitable organisations states that where donations are made for a specific purpose, the donor's request is honoured. Can Ms Martin give us confidence that this happens?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Our role with regard to donations and bequests is under the older Charities Acts. As part of that, there is a requirement, which is the subject of a Law Society direction, that when a charitable donation is made, a receipt must filed with us. The solicitor and executor must confirm with the Charities Regulator that the money or the bequest has gone to the relevant person or charity it was meant to go to. We work with the Probate Office on that. We would receive what are known as PAS 3 forms, which are the forms that are filled out by solicitors and executors regarding charitable bequests and donations. We have a team that would go through those. It follows up with solicitors and executors to see if they have receipts or something they can submit regarding the particular bequest or donation.

Comment on this

Does that happen all the time?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

It would. One of the issues we have had, and this is an area where resources come into play, is that-----

Comment on this

The reason I asked the question is that I cannot imagine how the Charities Regulator could go through them all.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

In the past, they were done by paper so we received huge volumes of paper from the Probate Office, which proved very difficult to get through given the volume.

Comment on this

Has the Charities Regulator had any cases involving funds that were not administered in the appropriate way or used for the purpose for which they were not intended?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

I will have to get back to the Deputy about that because I am not aware of any. It has not been raised with me.

Comment on this

As the Charities Regulator, if there was a case, Ms Martin would probably remember it.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

I am not aware of a case but I would like to check it.

Comment on this

I started with a question about resources because it is a genuine issue. I am not saying anything against the Charities Regulator as this is purely a resource issue but surely Ms Martin cannot say hand on heart that she knows that in every scenario where a charity receives a donation, it is spent in the manner it was intended to be spent.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Did the Deputy mean that the charity spent the money in the way it was intended? My apologies - I misunderstood the question. This is one of the problems we have in terms of the-----

Comment on this

Ms Martin cannot say that, therefore. We are here to help the Charities Regulator in this scenario. From a resource point of view, the committee does periodic reports and if members believe the Charities Regulator needs more resources, we will say that plainly. It involves a statement that as Charities Regulator, and this is not Ms Martin's fault, she cannot hand on heart say that the Charities Regulator has the capacity or resources to assure the public that funds left in wills to charitable organisations are used for the purposes for which they were intended.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

That is true. We are reliant on concerns being raised.

Comment on this

That is a fairly significant statement. We are dealing with large amounts of money here. I could not see how the Charities Regulator could have the capacity to do that.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

When specific concerns are raised with us, that is the point at which we would look into it and then see if there are any issues with it. It would be reactive in nature.

Comment on this

Is it fair to say that the Charities Act, which dates from 2009, needs to be updated? What would be the top three aspects that need to be updated?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

The first thing involves levelling the playing field between unincorporated charities and companies. If we take out schools, around 60% of the charities on the register of charities are companies. We do not have sufficient powers with regard to those charities when it comes to required regulatory action.

Comment on this

What powers does the Charities Regulator need?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

The powers we have under the Act are sufficient. It is just that we need them to apply equally to companies. That is the main change we need.

Comment on this

It is a case of bringing those powers across to companies as well.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Yes. They are carved out at the moment.

Comment on this

That is another point we should take on board.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

It is one of the main measures included in the general scheme of the charities (amendment) Bill. Another major issue concerns the regulations for accounting and reporting. They are dependent on us having this change made with regard to companies. We cannot introduce regulations to require a level of transparency with regard to finances that would only apply to unincorporated charities and would not, therefore, apply to 60% of the charities on our register. We have to wait until this amendment comes into force before we can introduce the regulations that, for example, would introduce something like the charities statement of recommended practice or SORP. This is a statement of recommended practice for charities that would require charities with a certain level of income to give far greater detail in their financial statements that is currently the case.

Comment on this

Again, the committee is here to help the Charities Regulator on this issue. I agree with Ms Martin 100%.

I looked at the percentages showing where donations went under headings such as education, religion, benefit to the community, poverty and economic hardship. I then looked at the funds being left to various organisations under each category. I was very taken by the low figure for higher education. I would have expected it to be much higher.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

I have been looking at that since we were talking before the meeting. I think the figures are on page 33 of the annual report. The figure for third level institutions is €2,964 million so it is almost €3 billion. I would imagine that this is the total income of the third level institutions.

Comment on this

Let us get some clarity on this because the figure has been bouncing around the place.

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

It relates to the study we conducted on the charity sector in 2018. It breaks down the income by type. The figure for education and training is €2.9 billion.

Comment on this

Over what period of time?

Comment on this

What document is Mr. O'Halloran referring to?

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

This is from the charities study produced by Indecon in 2018.

Comment on this

What period of time is that?

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

It was the annual period for 2017.

Comment on this

The figure for that year was €2.9 billion.

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

It is the total income in that sector. Generally, it would probably come from the State but that is the total income.

Comment on this

How do we break down how much was left or given in a charitable way by various individuals, philanthropists and organisations?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

More recently, we introduced a requirement for charities to indicate their sources of income in their annual reports.

We are currently working on the business analysis side of our IT system to enable us to publish those types of figures. We should be able to-----

Comment on this

Let us take a step back, if Ms Martin does not mind. We have a figure for total income in 2017. Do we know what amount and percentage of that was from charitable donations?

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

That figure is based on the 2017 financial returns, which do not capture as much information as do the returns for this year and 2018.

Comment on this

Why is that?

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

We increased the information capture to enable us to get a breakdown of the sources. That is something we were not previously capturing or publishing. It allows us to do a breakdown of the sources of income, whether from the State or elsewhere.

Comment on this

I want to dig into this issue because it is one of my main concerns. We have been around the houses in this committee on numerous occasions with issues relating to the third level sector. We did a specific report on it, in fact, and there is a whole quagmire of issues relating to how third level funding operates in respect of third party organisations, etc. We hear a lot about philanthropists funding various third level organisations. We know that Ireland Funds and various other organisations are providing funding to third level. We have had debates where representatives of colleges and universities have come in and said they are putting a sign over a building in Cork, for example, stating that the funding came from private funds they generated themselves, whether through donations or other income. That is complete and utter garbage because the taxpayer has to provide funding in the first place before those bodies are able to access other sources of income.

If the witnesses do not have the information I am seeking, we will need to come back to it another day. I will not stop pursuing the matter because I have a deep nervousness about how these funds are being given to third level colleges, what the Charities Regulator is and is not aware of in this regard, and for what purposes the colleges are using the funds. Are they charitable donations or are they being given for research? Are they being given to the various alumni associations that have been set up to assist in the funding of third level institutions? We have a figure for 2017 but we cannot break it down. Where are we at in regard to 2018?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Education bodies are excluded from the provisions with regard to accounting and finance. Even if we had the regulations we are talking about, we would not have that level of transparency with regard to their accounts because, like companies, they have been carved out.

Comment on this

They are outside of the process?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

They are outside of it. However, on the basis that they are audited by the Comptroller and Auditor General, it is not something we would have pursued.

Comment on this

Looking at the round picture, significant amounts are being given by organisations to third level colleges, universities, etc. From a process point of view, in terms of how that funding is spent, is it true that the Charities Regulator is very limited in terms of how it can analyse whether those moneys have been used appropriately, including, in many cases, for charitable purposes?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We are limited in that regard. However, because the Department of Education and Skills is involved and the Comptroller and Auditor General is overseeing them, our focus tends to be-----

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

I wish to note, as we have discussed here previously, that the universities and a number of institutes of technology have foundations, and I do not audit those foundations.

Comment on this

That is my point.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

The carve-out that happens relates to the financial statements of the university itself, which is provided for in the Universities Act. Similarly, for institutes of technology, the accounting basis is set out in the Institutes of Technology Act. There is a question as to whether a foundation which is operating with a charity is excluded or included within any directions the Charities Regulator would give.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

A foundation is not considered to be an education body for the purposes of our Act. It would be considered in the same way as any charity.

Comment on this

This is a huge issue and we have gone around the houses on it. I thank Mr. McCarthy for the information he provided. I am glad we teased the matter out this morning because there seems to be a big hole here in terms of accountability. We spent years, on and off, dealing with issues relating to the third level sector. Indeed, we did a whole programme on it. Will Ms Martin confirm that funds that are brought through a foundation for charitable purposes do not come within the remit of the Charities Regulator?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

They do come within our remit.

Comment on this

However, the foundations do not.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

They do, because they are registered charities.

Comment on this

We have the 2017 figure. How much went through each foundation in that year?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

That is something we can come back to the Deputy on because we now have the ability to pull that information out from the annual returns.

Comment on this

Does Ms Martin have any figures to hand today?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

I do not.

Comment on this

Can she indicate whether the sum in question is significant?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

I will have to come back the committee on that because I do not want to give an incorrect figure. We will be able to get that breakdown based on the sources of funding.

Comment on this

Can it be done retrospectively or just for 2018 or 2017?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We can do it for 2018.

Comment on this

Ms Martin indicated that her organisation is now grabbing more information than it used to do.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We will be able to grab the information from the 2018 annual report.

Comment on this

We need to get a holistic picture of where funds are going. Universities are audited by the Comptroller and Auditor General and we now know of other sources of income. These foundations are outside the remit of the Comptroller and Auditor General but do come under the Charities Regulator. The funding goes through these foundations and comes out the other end, so we should be able to create a whole and transparent picture of what is going through all the third level colleges. When Ms Martin can provide us with that information, we will have a clearer view of where all that funding is going, how it is being spent and how it is being matched with taxpayers' money. I hope Ms Martin can provide us with as much information as possible, including totals and percentages across all third level colleges, in tabular form, and a commentary on each foundation or other organisation that is in place. All of that would be useful.

Has the Charities Regulator considered running a public awareness campaign in regard to its work? As a public representative, people often tell me that they do not donate to charities other than those which are local to them because they are confident of their bona fides. I am concerned that a lot of charities are being painted in the wrong way. There have been issues with the sector in the past, which I will not detail today. There are one or two organisations that stand out at a national level because they are so large and well known, such as the Irish Cancer Society. Some charities, however, are being damaged by association with what went on in the past, and potential funds are not coming to them because of this. Could the Charities Regulator devise some type of campaign to engage and inform people? It will be challenging because of the range of charities in operation, but it would be helpful. We have discovered in the past that where people were collecting on street corners for certain charitable organisations, a large percentage of the funds raised were given to the collectors and only a small percentage to the charities themselves.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

The Deputy has hit upon one of our main strategic priorities. Specifically, priority No. 4 in our current statement of strategy is all about the need to ensure there is public awareness of what the Charities Regulator does and how the sector is regulated. There is a focus on increasing standards of governance across the sector and working with charities to highlight how they can make the most of being a registered charity. We are currently in the middle of a Meet the Regulator roadshow.

One of the key messages we are trying to get across to charities and registered charities is that not every not-for-profit is a registered charity and that charities should be utilising their registered charity number to let people know they are regulated. We are working very closely with the charities. I believe there is a piece of work there and we will be focusing on that.

Comment on this

I would encourage that for many different reasons.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Kelly. The next speaker is Deputy Cullinane.

Comment on this

First, I welcome Ms Martin and her team, and I offer them best wishes in their work. I am aware that Ms Martin is bedding down the organisation. I have gone through the opening statement and the corporate plan and have done some research on some of the work done by the Charities Regulator. In her opening statement, Ms Martin referred to a number of "statements of strategy". Initially, for the period of 2016 to 2018 the regulator was bedding down organisational structures, looking at processes and procedures in order to ensure compliance with the code of practice for the governance of State bodies. The next part of the strategy for 2019 to 2021 will be, in Ms Martin's terms, to move "closer to realising our vision of a vibrant trusted charity sector [and] ... strengthening public trust and confidence in charities". On that second piece of the strategy from 2019 to 2021, will Ms Martin clarify what the Charities Regulator will be looking at specifically?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

When we talk about trust and confidence one of the main areas, and our main tool at the moment, is the register. The work is about ensuring the register has as much information as possible relating to charities in order that members of the public can check out the individual charity in which they might be interested and can see what the charity is about. Hopefully, the public can also take some confidence that the sector is regulated.

We are also working with the charities on the charities' governance code. This is a huge part of our strategic priorities over the next two years in particular when we will work with the charities on that. This is about getting the charities to engage with the tool that is available to them, which is the charities' governance code, and to increase standards of best practice in governance. We would hope to see that reflected in levels of trust and confidence.

We will be monitoring and doing our own research to establish a baseline early next year for what are the levels of trust and confidence. The members may be aware that in 2012 it was at the highest rate, which was 74%, but it had fallen quite considerably over the last years. In 2017 the level of trust and confidence was at 46%. I want to ensure that we establish a baseline and then look at that in subsequent years. In that way we can see if we can work out the impact of the work we are doing and see how it has assisted the charity sector.

On the other side, which is the compliance and enforcement piece, charities themselves will agree that they want to see the Charities Regulator holding charities to account when things are not being done correctly. This is a key focus over the coming years also, and especially on the resources side. New resources we get in over the next year certainly will be going into the compliance and enforcement area. I have said before that one of the big things is that we would have access to the accounts of all charities and that they would be presented in a very particular way that is specific to charities. This would give certain disclosures to charities with regard to what is suitable for them.

Comment on this

How many registered charities are there?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

There are just over 10,000 registered charities.

Comment on this

I imagine that each of those charities would have to carry out their own external audit. Is that the case?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Most charities would but there are some large charities that, effectively, are State bodies.

Comment on this

If one was to exclude those.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Excluding those, most charities would be required to carry out their own audit.

Comment on this

With reporting, is there any obligation on an auditor if it found a difficulty to report that to the regulator or is there a responsibility on the charity to report that? My questions will focus more on reporting and who does the reporting and how is it acted upon. Consider an example of charity A, where the auditor finds there have been lapses in financial controls or finds some other problem or challenge. Obviously, that would then be included in the audited report. Does the Charities Regulator get a copy of those audited reports?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

No. That is part of the accounting and reporting regulation I was referring to. They do not just deal with the standard of the accounts that are presented and the format. They also deal with the area of auditing and something that is peculiar to our Act, which is examination-----

Comment on this

Why does the Regulator not get a copy of the audited report? The Comptroller and Auditor General does an audit of a Department or an organisation that comes under his remit. He does the audit, reports and there is an audited opinion. If an issue arises, it is there for everybody to see. In this situation, if one has a charity that has to carry out an audit - which they have to do - there may be a report or there has to be a report as a consequence of that, and it may well flag a problem. If the Charities Regulator, however, does not see that audit report how does it know there is a problem?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We have access to the financial statements of companies through the Companies Registration Office, so whatever they-----

Comment on this

That is different to an audit report.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We do not have that at the moment. We do not have the access to that.

Comment on this

Why is that? Is it just not under the regulator's remit?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

It is, but the regulations that would be required to bring in the standards around that have yet to be made. We are waiting on the amendments to the Acts in order that companies can be included in that also.

Comment on this

I will give Ms Martin one example, because this worries me. Console was a real controversy. All of us accept that the vast majority of charities do an excellent job where there are no difficulties and they provide an excellent service. There are some, however, whether they were outliers or not, that had very serious challenges. Console's problems were only highlighted when the HSE's internal audit looked more deeply at what was happening. Flags had been raised, missed and not acted upon over a long period. When they were acted upon it was the internal audit that established what was happening. If the regulator does not have access to internal audit reports of organisations that could be flagging up some problems, then I am worried that the regulator is not across what might be happening in some charities in the way it should be.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

I will outline what we are able to do. Where a concern is raised with us, for whatever reason, about a charity we can go in on that basis. Our inspectors can ask to see the reports and the audited-----

Comment on this

The regulator would be dependent on somebody making it aware of the concern-----

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Exactly.

Comment on this

-----as opposed to the regulator getting a copy of the internal audit report as a matter of routine, which should be the case, and seeing for itself if there are problems. If they are flagged up, then there is even more reason for the regulator to have them. They would be in plain sight and the regulator could see them; it would not need any work done by the regulator.

I want to get on to the concerns process. Ms Martin has said there is an online concerns process and a concerns unit. It strikes me that this is based more on individuals, such as whistleblowers or service users who would perhaps highlight concerns, but this is different to actual processes where people go in to do audits and examine the financial controls that might be in place in organisations. Earlier, I asked about an internal or external auditor who sees a problem. Is he or she obliged to report this to the regulator or not, or is the organisation obliged to report this to the regulator? If a problem has been flagged by the auditor to the organisation, is it then obliged to inform the regulator of the problem? Does this happen or are they obliged to do that?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

If there was a suspicion of theft or fraud it would absolutely have to be notified.

Comment on this

I am not talking about theft or fraud. I am talking about lapses in governance or lapses in financial controls.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

No, there is no requirement for that to be notified to us.

Comment on this

Is that not one of the problems? If one considers the history of the Console issue, it went on for so long and people were trying to figure out how did it happen for so long. It was because people were asleep at the wheel and it was not being examined in the way it should have been: credit card expenditure was off the chart; duplicate accounts were different for the same time period; and directors were also employees. There were huge issues that were all missed but which were eventually found to be the case. I am struggling to understand, as this happened. There are other examples we could go into and while I do not want to spend time talking about the bad examples - as there are so many good examples of charities - we do know there was very bad practice. This has an impact on the people who gave the money to those charities. If the regulator is not across this, if there is no obligation on the auditor to inform the regulator that there is a difficulty, if there is no obligation on the organisation or charity itself to inform the regulator and if the regulator is not seeing the audited accounts, then I am concerned that we do not have the oversight we should have around financial governance and governance generally in charities. When are we going to get to a point when this will be the case?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We share that concern. This is the difference between being reactive in our compliance work and being proactive in monitoring. To have proactive monitoring, there are several elements and we have geared ourselves up for it with the new IT systems, in order we can have a system to interrogate the information we get.

First, we need amendments to the Charities Act to enable us to introduce regulations on accounting and reporting. Once those are in place, there would be a proportionate requirement for certain standards of reporting and auditing for certain sized charities. There would be a somewhat different standard for the slightly smaller charities and then the really small ones that have an income of under €25,000-----

Comment on this

I get that but let us stick with Console for a second. Those concerns and that scandal emerged in 2018 as a consequence of internal HSE controls and complaints that were made. Did the HSE at any time inform the regulator that there were difficulties?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

It was back in 2016. At the time, we did not even have our enforcement powers. Part 4 was not commenced, it was commenced as a result of Console-----

Comment on this

Was that not the start of the process in 2016? The Committee on Public Accounts dealt with this in 2018. During the period between 2016 and 2018, did the HSE contact the Charities Regulator at any point to say there were major problems? When the committee looked at that report, it categorised all the problems by severity as yellow or red. I think the Comptroller and Auditor General will agree that it was quite severe at all levels.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

I think so, yes.

Comment on this

It actually said that it raised systemic problems for the HSE. What I am trying to establish is whether, throughout that process, the HSE ever contacted the regulator to say here is a copy of its internal audit and this is what it shows up. Did it suggest that such information would be of value to the regulator when it looks at what is happening and how it could put in place best practice and learn from the dreadful mistakes that happened in Console? Did the HSE make any formal contact with the regulator during the period from 2016 to 2018?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

I do not believe that it did so in 2016 but I will have to get back to the Deputy on the matter as it would have been before my time with the Charities Regulator.

Comment on this

What about 2017 or 2018? At any point?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

During that time, it would have been under investigation by the Office of the Director of Corporate Enforcement, ODCE, so we would not have been involved in that process at all.

Comment on this

Is it the case that if at any point there is a criminal investigation into an organisation, the regulator's oversight stops?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

It would do if we had concerns that were in any way relevant to the criminal investigation because we would leave it with An Garda Síochána.

Comment on this

I will get to the concerns unit. How many complaints were made? Ms Martin gave us figures from 2018 where there were 686 concerns. What would these concerns have centred on? Where would they have come from generally? Would it have been from staff within the organisations, or service users or members of the public?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

All of those.

Comment on this

Or statutory bodies? Where would they come from?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

The main sources of concerns would be from people who were working in charities and members of the public. We also have internally generated sources, that is, situations where another regulator might contact us with a concern about a charity and we might start looking into it at that point but that would be in a minority of cases. The cases tend to come in from the public.

Comment on this

Of the concerns raised, how many times did any State body, be it the HSE or any other body, raise a concern with the regulator through formal processes? That is separate from people who work in the organisation or members of the public.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

I do not have that information to hand as I do not think we capture it specifically.

Comment on this

Surely the regulator has a breakdown of the 686 concerns.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We do and they are split into people working in charities, the public, charity trustees and other. We do not have a category for those that were generated by other regulators.

Comment on this

That is the point. Surely there is an obligation. Take the HSE for example. Some of these are section 39 organisations which have service level agreements to provide certain services. Separately from that, if a charity was not such an organisation, it would be a charity that would be audited independently and an external audit would have to be done. There is, however, an element of an audit for the moneys paid by the State to these organisations. Given we have had problems with some of the section 39 organisations - I will not go through them all but I believe there was a difficulty in Harold's Cross and elsewhere - I would be surprised if at no point has the HSE or any other body approached the regulator to say it is coming across these problems and here is how those organisations were able to evade responsibility and accountability. Going back to what Ms Martin said earlier, 2019 to 2021 is supposed to be about strengthening public trust and confidence in charities and looking at ways in which the charity sector can provide the trust that people need. Part of that would be that the regulator learns lessons. Whatever about any mistakes that are made, if we are not learning lessons there is a problem. How is it the case that through all these scandals, and I gave two examples, that Ms Martin cannot tell me today she is clear that none of the organisations, whether the HSE or otherwise, has at any point alerted the regulator to any of the problems? It is no good for Ms Martin to read about any of this in the newspaper or hearing it on the news. What good is that to her organisation?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We would be alert. I took the question to relate to Console. There would be other issues where, if they relate to charities, we would have contact from the likes of the HSE, Revenue or something like that.

Comment on this

I am looking for a breakdown of that. Will Ms Martin write to the committee to outline a full breakdown of the source of the 686 concerns raised in 2018 and the State bodies involved? There is a lot of work to be done.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Yes.

Comment on this

I wish to make one final point on university foundations. There seems to be an issue. While we get the accounts from universities, the Comptroller and Auditor General audits the money that comes from the voted expenditure but not the money that comes into the foundation accounts.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

For clarity, when money comes from the foundation into the third level institution, at that point we would be-----

Comment on this

It can follow the money. When money that is in the account and not transferred over, the Comptroller and Auditor General cannot.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

No, we do not. We were encouraging consolidation of foundations but most of the universities now attach a copy of the foundation financial statements -----

Comment on this

Which is good.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

Which is good.

Comment on this

Are they not charitable foundations?

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

They are charitable foundations. That is the point we were discussing.

Comment on this

Are they outside of the regulator's remit?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

No, they are within our remit, it is the universities themselves that are partly outside our remit.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

From memory, for the record, there is one exception, which is Trinity, which fully consolidates its foundation activity with its financial statements. It would be outside of the Charities Regulator because it is within my scope.

Comment on this

Thank you. The next speaker is Deputy Connolly.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Martin for all the documentation. I am glad that the Comptroller and Auditor General mentioned Trinity. It decided to consolidate its accounts in the past few years; it is a new step and is an example to other universities.

Ms Martin has an extremely important job. The figures she gave in her opening statement are extraordinary, with over 10,000 charities, almost 66,000 trustees and €14.5 billion, not to mention almost 190,000 volunteers. It is an extremely important area on every level, both on an economic level and on a psychological level for the work being carried out, and there is also what volunteers get out of it.

I will follow on from the last Deputy's concerns. In her opening statement, Ms Martin noted "In 2018, we received ... 686 concerns, which was an increase of 29% on the previous year." If we have learned anything in recent years, it is how difficult it is for someone to complain. It is not in the interest of someone living here to complain, they suffer as a consequence. That is why the processes and procedures need to be robust. The breakdown of the figures as to where the concerns are coming from is key to help the regulator, as an organisation, to deal in a more proactive way.

We should be relying on whistleblowers and individuals to come forward as a tiny piece of the jigsaw. The regulator is the vital piece in this and the Act is from 2009. It is no reflection on the witnesses but it was years before the regulator became operational. We are still waiting on amending legislation, and that is our fault. Within this, what risk assessment has the organisation carried out to identify the areas that are suffering or exposed because the regulator does not have a full staff complement?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

On the compliance side, we have a resourced team and it is dealing with a large number of concerns. I would not put other resources into the concerns team as it exists; I would put them in the proactive monitoring piece. We will have people in the area working with the systems to see what other information we might have while waiting for the accounting and reporting regulations to come in.

Comment on this

What risks have been identified? What infrastructure and staff are needed?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

The risks overall are in the area of corporate affairs.

Comment on this

My question is not of a personal nature at all. Ms Martin is doing a great job and it is brilliant on paper. She identified the necessary full complement but the organisation does not have it. What are the risks associated with no having the full complement of staff? What is the organisation ignoring and what could it do if it had the staff?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We could do more proactive monitoring. We could get out there and see-----

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

-----what information was available from multiple sources and how to drill into it to see if there are risk factors and flags associated with what we are seeing in the financial statements of charities, for example. We have access to some statements of some companies that are charities. If we had more staff, it is an area where we could do more. Currently, we are very focused on concerns and the reactive piece when people come to us.

Comment on this

That is when somebody has the courage to come forward and contact the regulator.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Yes.

Comment on this

It takes courage to come forward.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Yes. We work closely with people who come forward and it is possible to make concerns known anonymously. That poses an obvious difficulty if we need to follow up.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We cannot do it. Every concern we get, whether it is anonymous or not, is examined.

Comment on this

Is there much effort and energy involved with trying to identify what are serious concerns and what might not be serious concerns?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

There is a whole risk process that is applied to each individual concern.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

It goes from low to medium to high and zero tolerance.

Comment on this

There is a system in place.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

There is a process in place and the minute a concern comes in, a team member will take it through a risk assessment. That is how we prioritise the work.

Comment on this

Would the regulator be able to focus on the foundations if it had more staff? Has it occurred to the witness that the foundations coming under the regulator's remit might be examined?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We tend to focus on concerns when they are raised. If we had more resources to look at different accounts, we could look at different sectors. I am not sure the foundations would necessarily be an area where we would have honed our efforts.

Comment on this

That is of concern to me. As previous speakers indicated, we come across things by chance when somebody is courageous enough to make a complaint and so on. We stumbled on the issue with foundations when we looked at the accounts of third level institutions. We saw how foundations did not come under anybody's remit, really, but they would now come under the regulator's remit. I think of the Galway case. Although I could be corrected, there was a substantial figure of €64 million-----

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

It was €56 million at one point. It certainly decreased.

Comment on this

That was €56 million in a foundation account that was not open for public scrutiny. Would that be of interest to the regulator?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

It would, of course. We have powers available to us. As I said, we tend to use them on the basis of concerns currently, so it is when there is a specific issue as opposed to proactively going out to pick particular sectors.

Comment on this

It is an area that needs to be examined proactively.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Absolutely. That is the plan with the additional resources we get.

Comment on this

With regard to the statutory powers, the regulator asks various organisations to give information but does not use those statutory powers in the first instance. How many times did it have to use statutory powers in 2018?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We used statutory powers 48 times to acquire information.

Comment on this

That is because organisations did not co-operate.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Exactly. We use them if they are not co-operating and also if we are not assured by what is provided. The figure for 2018 was quite high because we did some proactive monitoring in seeking information. This was to establish on the register whether trustee details were being kept up to date.

Comment on this

Will Ms Martin put those 48 occasions in context? How should I interpret the figure of how many times the regulator had to exercise its statutory powers in 2018?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

It is really about not getting information from charities when we have sought it.

Comment on this

What would have been the total number of cases? Were there hundreds where the office did not have to use its statutory powers?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

There would have been hundreds as we had 686 concerns, with 56% of those applying to registered charities. In most cases, charities will voluntarily engage with us and we would not have to use our statutory powers.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Absolutely.

Comment on this

With regard to compliance, organisations must submit an annual report, which is very basic information.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Yes.

Comment on this

Will that change under amending legislation?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Yes. We will look for more information.

Comment on this

I notice in the detailed report supplied to the committee that there is a high rate of return of the annual reports but they are late. There is a significant problem with late returns.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Yes. We are getting better. The big effort was to get organisations to return them.

Comment on this

What are the figures for this? What are the penalties?

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

This year to date, 75% have been returned on time. Last year, 70% were returned on time. We normally allow a further nine months after filing and at that point the figure is usually in the high 90s in percentage terms.

Comment on this

The report indicates that a significant number of charities continue to file their annual reports late despite the fact that under a section of the Bill, they are required to file on time. What are the percentages?

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

For 2018, 70% were filed on time and 30% were late. We can break that down.

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

This year to date, 75% have been returned on time. In 2016, 42% of reports were filed on time.

Comment on this

Very good. There has been a great improvement.

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

Yes.

Comment on this

It is an offence to file them late.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Yes.

Comment on this

Has it gone that far with any organisation?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

No.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Not yet.

Comment on this

That is fine. I have a couple of quick questions on the accounts. Prepayments come up in many accounts. It is note No. 9. What do those prepayments refer to?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

This concerns our information technology, IT, system and its maintenance and support.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

It is the IT system.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We pay in advance for maintenance and support and it goes to the next year, as far as I know.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Scanlon

The vast majority of the prepayment figure of €410,000 relates to ERS digital platform support, a new platform incorporated by the regulator. Of that €410,000, €286,000 related to the support.

Comment on this

That €286,000 is paid to an IT company in advance.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Scanlon

Yes. There is also a payment to Aramark for rental for quarter one of the following year. That accounted for €82,000.

Comment on this

Will the witnesses give a note on how that breaks down? Is the rental payment for equipment or premises?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Scanlon

It is for premises. The invoice would be received in December requesting rent for the first quarter of the following year.

Comment on this

Perhaps we can get a breakdown of that. The rent is €310,773 per year on a ten-year lease.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Scanlon

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Scanlon

The rent is paid quarterly in advance.

Comment on this

That is okay. I can understand the rent for the premises and the organisation is also paying in advance for IT support.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Scanlon

IT support was paid in advance that year. That has been rectified and we noted that this would not be the case going forward. We would not be engaging in such extensive support contracts with such a vast prepayment.

Comment on this

Accordingly, there was a significant risk there. The regulator was paying in advance for a service that it had not got.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Scanlon

Many IT support contracts operate in that way where an advance payment is requested. This was noted. It will not occur again that we have such a vast prepayment in terms of IT support.

Comment on this