2018 Financial Statements of the Charities Regulatory Authority
Contributions 218–440 of 667. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
The Chair might follow up on that.
Comment on this
How many investigations did the regulator carry out in 2018 and 2019?
Comment on this
Last year there were two investigations for which we published inspectors’ reports.
Comment on this
One of them related to the Solas Picture Palace in Galway?
Comment on this
What was the other one?
Comment on this
The Gay and Lesbian Equality Network, GLEN.
Comment on this
What about this year?
Comment on this
This year we have one ongoing investigation.
Comment on this
When will that be completed?
Comment on this
I am hoping that it will have concluded before the end of the year.
Comment on this
Were those the first three investigations carried out by the regulator?
Comment on this
Yes. The first was Ataxia Ireland. Then there was GLEN and Solas in Galway.
Comment on this
Were there any investigations prior to these?
Comment on this
How did the investigation into Solas arise?
Comment on this
Solas would have arisen as a result of an internally generated concern on the basis of media reports.
Comment on this
It would have been on the basis of media reports. It was generated internally based on what had been seen in the media around that charity.
Comment on this
Is it the case that the regulator took that seriously and then followed up with an investigation?
Comment on this
Is the regulator aware that the Department did a post project review recently of that case?
Comment on this
Did the Department contact the regulator on this?
Comment on this
Was there no contact at all?
Comment on this
That is interesting. The Department did a full post project review and set out figures with which I had an issue. We might be coming back to these figures. The regulator did its report and confirmed some donations were not properly accounted for. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Is it the case that no income was recorded after 2007 by the charity when income was generated in the form of donations? That is not clear to me from the Department’s post-project review in any event. Did the regulator confirm in its report that the charity in question raised moneys from donations?
Comment on this
Yes, exactly. The figure in question was approximately €360,000.
Comment on this
Did various entities or people donate that money?
Comment on this
It was from fundraising from the public. It had not been recorded as income in its accounts. Instead, it was reported as a liability.
Comment on this
I might come back to that at the next meeting with the Department. I do not see those donations reflected in the post-project review. In the absence of formal documentation, I will not waste any more time. We have been through this and the regulator is confirming what was in the report, with the exception of the Bord Fáilte advertisement for Galway, which hid the real serious issues.
One of the recommendations in the inspectors' report states, “The Charities Regulatory Authority should review the need for guidance in relation to trustees legal duties”. There was a serious problem with - I will put this as mildly as I can - the trustees’ awareness of their duties and responsibilities. The regulator made a general finding that trustees should be ore aware of their duties and it has a role in that. Another of the recommendations states "the Charities Regulatory Authority should consider furnishing a copy of this report as it deems relevant." Did the regulator send a copy of the report to the Department?
Comment on this
My question refers to the line “should consider furnishing a copy of this report as it deems relevant”. Did the regulator deem it relevant to send it to the Department or the Comptroller and Auditor General?
Comment on this
That actually refers to a particular power that we furnish it if it will not be published.
Comment on this
Whereas if we were publishing it, we would bring it to the people’s attention.
Comment on this
I thank Ms Martin for that clarification. What about the need for guidance for trustees?
Comment on this
The guidance is out there. We had guidance in any event on trustees’ duties published in 2017. In addition to that we have been adding to it. We have internal financial controls, conflicts of interest codes and, most importantly, the governance codes, along with all the materials which underpin that.
Comment on this
Does Ms Martin think there are other cases of Console and Solas out there?
Comment on this
It is hard to say. At the, end of the day-----
Comment on this
Human nature being what it is and trustees doing their best. The mistake was made with the Morris tribunal that we thought those activities were confined to that county. Obviously, this kind of behaviour is not confined to one group of trustees. There are many points to be identified and learned from.
Comment on this
The majority of charity trustees are doing their best every day. We are trying to support them to ensure they have the relevant information available to them and are up to speed on what is required. The Charities Regulator is regulating behaviour but we need engagement by the sector with us. The sector is very much engaging with the charity governance code.
Comment on this
Several times Ms Martin indicated that the regulator’s role is reactive and is more a case of when issues are raised. Thinking back to the Console scandal, there is nothing to say that it could not happen again in light of what Ms Martin said about sufficient powers when it comes to companies, etc. There is nothing to indicate that this could be happening now. Is that a concern?
Comment on this
It would be. That is why we are focused on the next stage of developing the compliance and enforcement team, as well as introducing proactive monitoring. We need certain tools to do that. We need the information to be made available to us. That is why we require the amendments to the Act and the accounting-reporting regulations. To be able to do that proactive monitoring piece would be a massive move for us. Hopefully, we would see flags and particular points in accounts where we would know there is something not right. It would raise a flag and then we could hone in on it ourselves without anyone having to raise a concern with us. We would be able to identify those charities ourselves.
Comment on this
Without those additional powers and amendments to the Act, would it be acceptable for people to perceive the regulator’s role now as just a box-ticking exercise and not as effective as it ought to be?
Comment on this
Absolutely not. We have a whole compliance team which is working on concerns everyday and carrying out inquires. We got over 600 concerns. All of those were looked into. We closed 722 concerns which means they were issues which were looked into by the staff. There is a significant amount of compliance and enforcement work going on. Charities themselves are aware that they are regulated. That would not be the case if this were just purely a box-ticking exercise.
Comment on this
How many of those cases were not resolved? Can Ms Martin give the reasons why they have not?
Comment on this
Of the over 600 which were brought to our attention?
Comment on this
Not necessarily. It takes time and depends on the complexity of the issues. It also depends on how serious the issue was.
Comment on this
Can Ms Martin give us an example of a more serious issue which has not been resolved yet and the reason why?
Comment on this
I cannot give a specific example. The kinds of cases might be where a charity is refusing to engage with us or, for example, if a charity is not keeping proper books of account. It could be a case where the charity’s trustees do not have the skill set to know what they should be doing in that regard.
Comment on this
Other that the trustees not having the skills set, what would be the penalty for not engaging with the regulator?
Comment on this
I suppose it is a range. There was a charity shop, Good and New, which was not keeping proper books of account. We have the ability to impose an intermediate sanction where the contravention is publicised. In some cases, we can remove the charity from the register for a period. An intermediate sanction is used in a situation where there has been a breach and an offence committed under the Act in place of a prosecution. We would see that as being more proportionate, particularly when it comes to charities. We tend not to see charities doing things on purpose. It tends to be an oversight or a case of simply not being informed. We take a proportionate approach to those matters.
Comment on this
How many times has the regulator taken such a proportionate approach?
Comment on this
For intermediate sanctions in 2018, there was one occasion when we had to go that far. I am not sure we record information on the cases in which we do not take statutory actions because we close so many concerns.
We can close them quite easily. We can contact a charity that is not keeping proper books of account, and as soon as it tells us it has engaged a bookkeeper and we are sure it has done so and is progressing, then we will close the concern.
Comment on this
Would the Charities Regulator be concerned about the importance of having continuous oversight?
Comment on this
We will oversee it for a period and we would follow up after a number of months to see whether it was the case and it still has its bookkeeper. We have had situations where an intermediate sanction was imposed. One particular organisation got a bookkeeper and was keeping a proper book of accounts but then it just did not return its annual report on time. That raised a flag for us as to why it was not doing so. When we got in touch with the charity it became apparent that it had lapsed again and was not keeping proper books of account. That particular charity wound up in the end.
Comment on this
Back in June 2017, when the Charities Regulator investigation had secured its first prosecution, it was stated that the regulator was planning to introduce a system in the coming years whereby people could track who was running a charity and exactly how charities were spending donations. Has this been done?
Comment on this
The names of the trustees of every charity are on our registers. Those 66,000 names are there for everybody to see and people can see who is involved. What we do not have is information on the financials. We have a breakdown of sources of funding but we do not have detailed information on our register as of yet.
Comment on this
Is there a reason the regulator does not provide information on how donations are spent? This goes back to June 2017.
Comment on this
It goes back to the amendments we need to be made to the Act and the fact we need the regulations.
Comment on this
The regulator cannot put up the details of how the donations are spent unless those amendments are made.
Comment on this
The charities themselves provide certain details, such as what their activities are, but it will not go to that level of specificity in terms of exactly what they spend donations on.
Comment on this
The regulator cannot compel them at present unless those amendments are passed. Is that correct?
Comment on this
If a concern is raised with us with regard to a particular charity, we can ask for that detailed information but it would be in the context of inquiries and on foot of a concern.
Comment on this
Going back to the Console scandal, does the regulator not see this as something important for it to ensure is there and is available? In 2017, there were discussions about the regulator providing information on who is running a charity and how donations are spent. It provides information on the who but not on the donations. It could provide that information if it chose to do so but it has not done so yet. This is a matter of public concern or public interest. People could see how charities spend their donations. It would also help to ease the suspicion that has arisen because of the Console scandal. If people could see where their donations were being spent they would not have those suspicions about charities. I am surprised the regulator has not done it.
Comment on this
The Deputy is absolutely right and it is crucial. It is one of the reasons that in 2017 we proposed amendments to a courts and civil law (miscellaneous provisions) Bill and we managed to get our amendments included in the Bill. We need further amendments to introduce standardised forms of financial reporting for all charities. If we had those standards, we would have the detail the Deputy is speaking about. Unfortunately, the courts and civil law (miscellaneous provisions) Bill in which our provisions were included did not go anywhere. It has since been carved out into a separate charities (amendment) Bill which we hope will progress shortly.
Comment on this
The documentation and the briefing pack states the advancement of religion is considered to be a reason for having charitable status. The purpose carries the presumption of public benefit. That is a statutory matter but there is nothing there for the advancement of human rights. The church has better rights than Amnesty international. I presume that would be a legislative matter. It could possibly allow a lot of scope for bogus religions or religions that turn profits while not paying tax. It is something that stood out for me. Does Ms Martin have an opinion on this? Does she think it would allow for that scope?
Comment on this
The advancement of religion is a charitable purpose and the Deputy has rightly pointed out that Ireland decided not to have human rights as a charitable purpose. That is absolutely the case. With regard to the advancement of religion, we receive applications from organisations that are religions but even though there is a presumption of public benefit, they go through a rigorous application process in the same way as all other types of charities. I cannot comment on charities that are religious organisations that existed prior to our establishment. They are also on our register but they came onto it along with thousands of other charities because they held a charitable tax exemption. They were entitled to be deemed registered at that time.
Comment on this
I notice that 2,766 schools are registered as charities. Is every registered charity automatically tax exempt?
Comment on this
No. Organisations apply for that separately. To be able to get the charitable tax exemption the organisation must first be registered and have charitable status with the Charities Regulator.
Comment on this
Are all of the 2,700 schools tax-exempt, having registered as a charity?
Comment on this
Schools have almost all of the tax exemptions already by virtue of being a school. DIRT might be the only one to which they are not entitled by virtue of being a school. Many schools may not apply for the charitable tax exemption because they do not need it. Most charities that have charitable status go on to apply for the tax exemption.
Comment on this
I am sure there are public and private schools in the figure of 2,700.
Comment on this
I see Belvedere College is registered as a charity. It does not pay tax on the fees paid by parents. I can only presume this is because it offers a handful of scholarships a year. This type of college is in receipt of huge fees, pays no tax on any of them, is registered with charitable status and is in receipt of a substantial Government subsidy. Is this an area that could be reviewed?
Comment on this
Ultimately, it is an issue of policy. Once an organisation fulfils the charity test, ends up with a charitable tax exemption or was deemed registered back in 2014, it is on the register as a charity. I am not aware of the particular example and whether the school was deemed registered. I think it was deemed registered so it came onto the register automatically. The advancement of education is a charitable purpose under the Act.
Comment on this
I am wondering about the benefit to the public. I presume it is the handful of scholarships each year, but it would be well worth the school's while not to pay any tax and give out a handful of scholarships.
My next question is on bogus charities, which can be prevalent at this time of the year in the lead-up to Christmas. What oversight does the regulator have in this regard? People may be collecting for something that is not registered as a charity. How does the regulator manage this?
Comment on this
More than 44% of the concerns raised with us relate to organisations that are not charities. This is why we speak about the more than 50% that are registered charities. We are reliant on concerns being raised. Either we spot it or somebody comes to us having spotted it. We will immediately try to contact the individuals concerned.
Obviously, it is an offence if it is holding itself out as a charity when it is not a registered charity. When we follow it up, sometimes it transpires that the organisation is simply unaware that it was supposed to be registered. Such cases are passed on to the registration team to enable the organisations in question to engage in the full registration process.
We work with An Garda Síochána on much more difficult areas like the house-to-house collection of clothing bags by bogus charities. When we use the contact details on the plastic bags that are provided to households, we often find that the number rings out and we cannot get through to anybody. We intend to undertake a public awareness campaign in this area. We previously issued a public notice to let the public know specifically about this problem. Ultimately, the public plays a role in this area. When people think they are donating to a charity, we want them to check the register first to make sure it is a registered charity. We have engaged in some publicity in this regard. Next week, we will issue some public notices to alert people to the phenomenon of bogus clothing collections. One of the reasons bogus organisations get involved in this area is that there is money to be made. If people were not donating bags of clothes to these organisations and were instead ensuring they donated to charities only, some of this bogus activity would be curtailed.
Comment on this
Okay. That is a good move. Does the authority keep figures when people notify it about possible bogus charities? Does it keep a record?
Comment on this
Yes. Our concerns team categorises the concerns that come in. One of the specific categories consists of organisations that claim to be registered charities but are not.
Comment on this
Does Ms Martin know the figure offhand?
Comment on this
I do not know the figure offhand, but I can definitely come back to the committee with it. We capture the information in question.
Comment on this
The witnesses are very welcome. It is really important that people feel confident in this incredibly important sector. The work of the witnesses is incredibly important from that point of view. When I went through the list of charities, I noticed that some of them have 19th century names. People know the names of many of the big charities, but there are also local charities like schools that crop up on the list. The number of charities is incredibly large for the size of the country. Perhaps this is a reflection of the fact that the charitable sector in this country is providing services that would normally be public services in some other countries. I refer to charities like Rehab, Enable Ireland and the Irish Heart Foundation. Some of their work is promotional. It is understandable that they would have charitable status. In many other countries, the services being provided by a charity like Enable Ireland would be a matter of public provision. I think there is a gap being filled. Some confidence was lost when attention was focused on the amounts of money being paid to the CEOs of charitable organisations. I assume that does not come under the remit of the Charities Regulator. At a time when the public is being very generous but is seeing very large salaries being paid to CEOs, it is very difficult to retain public confidence in this sector. Is any guidance available in this regard? Some of these companies are very big and need to have good personnel. Is there any guidance on engagement with some of the bigger charities?
Comment on this
I can answer that more generally because it comes under the charities governance code and the whole area of private benefit. When salaries are paid to the people involved in running charities, that is considered to be a private benefit. The Act provides that the private benefit must be reasonable in all the circumstances, must be ancillary and must be necessary to the furthering of the public benefit that the charity entails. We tell charities they must ensure the amounts of money they pay to members of staff should be benchmarked and should be reasonable. They have to be reasonable and necessary. It is obvious that a charity which provides healthcare services in the home will need nurses. We consider that to be a private benefit which is absolutely required and is permissible under the Charities Act. The charity would have to make sure it is benchmarked against what a nurse would be paid elsewhere. That is where we would come across that. People would be asking about that, and that would be our general advice in this area.
I would like to refer to research that has been done on salaries more generally. We might consider a salary of more than €70,000 to be a high salary for these purposes. Research indicates that less than 1% of the workforce in the not-for-profit sector, which obviously is wider than the charitable sector, is paid more than €70,000. The relevant percentage is much higher in other areas. I believe it is 13% in the rest of the economy. There is certainly a perception out there. We often see it when the results of research come back. People want charities to be well run, but at the same time they do not think people in charities should be paid the same as they might be paid elsewhere. Our view is that a nurse who is working in a charity should be paid the same as a nurse who is working in a hospital, if they are doing the same job.
Comment on this
I would not dispute that. The issue that came to public prominence was on the CEO and administration side. Some of the salaries were very large and very generous.
Comment on this
I have been looking at the authority's organisational chart. We have been told that it has 37 staff on its books at the moment, but I can count 43 people on its organisational chart. There are some vacancies as well. The higher up the ladder one goes, the greater the proportion of vacancies. There are vacancies for positions like head of legal affairs, regulatory lawyer and head of corporate affairs. There are no vacancies down at the clerical officer end. That is the point I am making. Where would the additional staff up to the full complement of 53 fit in on the organisational chart?
Comment on this
They would fit in around the area of compliance and enforcement. There are certain areas we need to develop when we are talking about proactive monitoring. They would certainly be going in there. Ultimately, we are looking to resource the whole area of operations, IT and research as well.
Comment on this
I do not see that. It has been set out as a hierarchy in the organisational chart. I am not saying that the organisation is hierarchical. Ms Martin has spoken about teams. I am trying to visualise how the 37 people who have been mentioned fit into these teams. There is an overall administration as well. The administrative staff are probably not part of one of the teams in question. I am trying to visualise how the organisation is run. The top two areas that are named before the chart moves on to the next tier are head of compliance and enforcement, and head of legal affairs. Are all of the areas named there? Will there be an additional stream that will go along with the authority's senior staff, even if they are not employed?
Comment on this
No. These are all of the areas that we will have in the organisation. There is probably some confusion here. At the moment, I am re-examining the organisational structure. I can send the committee the original structure if it would like to see it. The original structure was based on the preferred operating model. Having gained experience over recent years, and having considered where we want to go with our strategy, my view is that we need more senior decision-makers in the organisation. The review has not yet been completed. That is why I do not have the updated organisational chart.
Comment on this
Okay. The authority is funded, or potentially funded, for a complement of 53. Is that right?
Comment on this
We are potentially funded for 53, depending on the grading mix. We could end up with fewer numbers, but with more senior staff.
Comment on this
That is exactly what I am considering at the moment.
Comment on this
Okay. Are they direct employees, or potentially direct employees, as opposed to agency employees? Another organisation that was set up recently had more people in on contract than direct employees. I hope we are talking about direct employees.
Comment on this
Absolutely. We hope they will be direct employees. When we had people in on contract, it did not work. That is one of the reasons we have had this turnover in the senior management teams. One of the members left for that reason.
It is not a way to establish one's team.
Comment on this
Has the position been regraded?
Comment on this
That particular one, head of communications and stakeholder engagement, has not, but it has been filled since we lost that particular employee.
Comment on this
Who has responsibility for regrading?
Comment on this
The regraded position related to the head of compliance and enforcement. That would have been submitted to our Department and then onwards to the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform.
Comment on this
A number of things cropped up in the earlier discussions that I wish to go back over. There are quite a number of small charities where there is an overhead to have an audit, and yet they are very small organisations and there are multiple charities in the same sector. That can be seen in the list of charities and their functions. Is consolidation discouraged, or if a body comes along and meets the criteria, is it automatically granted charitable status?
Comment on this
Yes, once it meets the charity test. We do not seek to control the numbers that are registering. If people apply and meet the charity test, then they will be registered as a charity. We take the view that charities, as was mentioned earlier, are stepping into gaps. Particular individuals who are setting them up can perceive a gap and want to step into that. While on the face of it, it may look like charities are very similar, sometimes when one looks behind them, for example, in the area of animal welfare, it will be found that there are very different philosophies behind those particular charities.
Comment on this
When answering Deputy Kelly, Ms Martin talked about the Probate Office, and that there is this reactive prompt, where somebody brings something to the regulator's attention. Obviously people are asked, when making a will, to think of charities and such things. There may well be people, in some cases, who do not have family members who will follow things up, and these are the ones who will be aware. What would it take to be proactive rather than reactive in that particular sector, because it is likely to be a growing sector?
Comment on this
Once we receive the forms from the Probate Office and the original form will have been lodged, that is what starts our process. We do and we will follow this up with executors. There is a proactive element in that. If we have received a form from the Probate Office and we have not received a receipt from a solicitor, for example, from a charity stating that they have received the money, we will follow that up, so we absolutely do follow that up.
One of the issues we had and that I mentioned earlier is around the whole area of paper and the fact that it was very hard to deal with the masses of paper that we were receiving. We worked with the Probate Office and have put that whole system online now. That will enable us to do that proactive monitoring piece more easily as we will be capturing those data at source from the solicitors or executors who are putting the forms in. That means we can analyse that, and it will also be useful for the Probate Office down the road, when it modernises its systems.
Comment on this
Are the two systems capable of talking to each other?
Comment on this
They are not, at the moment.
Comment on this
They are. It is actually the Probate Office's form, but we have it on our site because we were more advanced in our IT platform. That information is capable of being sent over and received in the Probate Office.
Comment on this
The way our education system is set up probably comes as a big surprise to the vast majority of people. It is publicly funded in terms of the building of schools and the payment of teachers. There is an inadequate amount of money provided to run schools, hence the reason fundraising is required. It is would come as a surprise to people and they would not think that their national school, for example, was a charity. Does the Charities Regulator's office look at comparisons with other countries in terms of what ends up being a charity in this country as opposed to, say, our European counterparts? Is there a remit from that point of view that the Charities Regulator's office will fulfil?
Comment on this
We feed back our comments to the Minister on any areas that we think may require reform or may need to be looked at. We have done that through the charities (amendment) Bill. On the types of purposes that are considered to be charitable, we consider that to be a matter of Government policy.
Comment on this
It is a policy area. On the investment fund, does the Charities Regulator determine the investment policy? How is that determined?
Comment on this
Yes, we do. I will pass over now to Mr. Scanlon on that question.
Comment on this
The common investment fund is managed by Davy Asset Management brokers. The fund is closed to new entrants now. The Charities Regulator administers the fund, whereas the management of the fund lies with Davy Asset Management brokers.
Comment on this
Will Mr. Scanlon take us through how the fund arose?
Comment on this
The fund came about as a result of the 1961 Act. It was set up in the 1980s or 1990s by the then Commissioners of Charitable Bequests and Donations for Ireland. It was set up as a means, particularly for smaller charities, to be able to invest funds and earn a return on those. It was closed, however, by the time we took it over, and before the Charities Regulator came into being. There are no new members in that fund now. We did a review on what we should do with the fund, such as whether we should wind it up, and different options were considered. The preliminary view was that we would maintain it for the moment. We are doing a number of exercises around it. It is quite an old fund and there is a lot of administrative work to be done around it such as data cleansing exercises, anti-money laundering, and making sure we have the right details for people, etc. Once all of that work is done, we will continue with the review and see what the next steps are.
Comment on this
There is €35 million in that fund as of 31 December 2018. Davy Asset Management brokers manage the fund but the Charities Regulator's office is the custodian. Who are the beneficiaries of that fund?
Comment on this
The charities. It is not owned by the Charities Regulator at all. We do not have any right to those funds.
Comment on this
And all of those charities who own that fund are still live charities. Are they all regulated by the Charities Regulator?
Comment on this
There would be ones in there that may not be regulated as they may not be registered. They could be old charitable trusts. That is part of the exercise we are doing in terms of the data that we have available on those.
Comment on this
If they seek a return of their funds, the Charities Regulator would presumably not do that if they were not registered or if there were compliance issues.
Comment on this
If there were compliance issues, to be honest, it is a completely separate statutory scheme. In fact, under the 1961 Act, there was no requirement for registration because it did not exist at the time. It is not something where we can hold back. They are entitled to the dividends out of it. Where we have had situations where we have held back, it has been where we could not contact somebody in the charity. We did not have proper bank details for them, etc.
Comment on this
That would be of concern. I know that, very often, things cannot be done in retrospect. If an organisation is not in the area of compliance, however, that puts the regulator in a very precarious position, I would have thought.
Comment on this
Yes. We are not aware, however, of any body within that fund with which there are compliance issues. Absolutely not.
Comment on this
How many entities are involved with the €35 million?
Comment on this
There are 392 that would receive benefit from the fund. The fund is currently at a value of €39.7 million as of November 2019.
Comment on this
It has gone from €35 million to €39 million, so there is €4 million from the investment because it has been closed.
Comment on this
The value of the fund has gone up due to how Davy Asset Management brokers who have managed and invested it.
Comment on this
My apologies, as I was in the Dáil Chamber and was not here for the witnesses' presentation. If I cover ground that has already been dealt with, the Chairman might stop me, because I do not want to repeat material. From a governance perspective, who appoints people to the Charities Regulator's board?
Comment on this
It is done through the State boards' process, as far as I am aware.
Comment on this
I did not hear that. The mike may be off.
Comment on this
They would be appointed in line with the code of practice for the governance of State bodies, so it would be an open process.
Comment on this
That is public procurement. If the regulator's office has a slot on the board, it advertises, and I or anybody else can apply, and the usual process follows. Are there any prescribed appointees or appointments?
Comment on this
Does the Minister appoint people?
Comment on this
Ultimately, the Minister appoints the members of the board.
Comment on this
The Charities Regulator is the regulatory body for all charities in Ireland. Is that right?
Comment on this
Are there any CEOs of charities on the regulator's board?
Comment on this
Yes, I believe we have one, Rosemary Keogh.
Comment on this
I believe it is the Irish Wheelchair Association.
Comment on this
Is there not a conflict of interest there?
Comment on this
A conflict of interest could arise but I would not say that in the course of its work, being a member of the authority, I would not say it would have a conflict that would stop it from participating.
Comment on this
Was it an appointment with applications where people applied, including Ms Keogh? Is that the case?
Comment on this
I am just trying to think. If it was the banks, would the CEO of AIB be on the regulator staff? Does Ms Martin think that would be good governance? Without prejudice of the person's qualifications, I am talking about optics at the absolute minimum. In terms of best practice in governance across any organisations or any regulated activity, how appropriate is it to have an operator who is the regulated on the board of the regulatory authority?
Comment on this
Ultimately, the appointments are for the Minister. I am not in a position to comment on that.
Comment on this
As the CEO of an organisation, if the recruitment was up to Ms Martin and she sought to recruit the board, would she recruit people who were active from the sector? Does she think that would be good practice?
Comment on this
I can only base it on my own experience of the individuals concerned with whom we have dealt. They bring an excellent perspective in terms of the regulator, particularly in this sector where, in the main, we are talking about very small, mainly volunteer-led, organisations. I welcome the perspective they bring on regulatory activities and their own experience of the charities sector.
Comment on this
I have no doubt that they have specific expertise but it is a clear conflict.
Comment on this
What is the Comptroller and Auditor General's perspective of the regulated being board members of the regulator from a governance perspective?
Comment on this
I think that is moving into a policy space. It is not really for me to make a comment.
Comment on this
Is there company law that governs any of these things?
Comment on this
I would not imagine that company law would be relevant to it.
Comment on this
Is there any law relevant to it that we are aware of? I am sorry to put the Comptroller and Auditor General on the spot, it may not be his area at all. There are also Department representatives before the committee. I would be interested in the Department's thinking on appointing the regulated to be a member of the regulatory authority.
Comment on this
As Ms Martin noted already, appointments to the board go through the Public Appointments Service in line with the code for the appointment of the boards to State bodies, and not-for-profit State bodies. At the same time, we must be cognisant of the skills requirement of every board. The board is responsible for the strategic direction of the Charities Regulatory Authority, CRA, and in terms of that it is how they engage with the charity sector, how they regulate it, and governance. One of the key criteria for being a board member is having knowledge of that sector.
Comment on this
Absolutely. However, if our starting point is to make the fox the head of security for the hen house, it does not give the hens much confidence, that is all.
Comment on this
To bring back perspective and knowledge, one of the key things the Department is looking at in policy in the area - and it has been mentioned many times by the sector itself - is that we did not create an unduly complex regulatory environment or governance burden on the charity sector.
Comment on this
It is hardly complex for the Irish Wheelchair Association because it has a seat at the board.
Comment on this
Again, it is that representation, that knowledge and experience and representing the sector. As Ms Martin mentioned, where a conflict of interest does arise, the person steps away from the board.
Comment on this
Would there be any retired members from various charities that could have been considered instead?
Comment on this
That is great. However, on this occasion the decision was to get someone who was an active CEO of the Irish Wheelchair Association. Again, this is not about the individual at all. I am sure they are more qualified than anyone else in the whole country but that is not the point; the point is that it is poor practice.
Comment on this
There is nothing there to restrict them from applying at the moment.
Comment on this
There is nothing to restrict them from applying but we look to the Department and perhaps, ultimately, the Minister, to apply a bit of common sense that the regulated does not become the regulator while continuing to be regulated. Does anyone agree with me or am I on a different planet?
Comment on this
There are situations, if one looks at other State bodies, where, say, those who would be beneficiaries of a body issuing grants would be members of the body making the determination. It does create a potential conflict of interest. Care must be taken that people are not involved, that they are not briefed on matters in which they might have an interest as an executive or a board member of an entity body.
Comment on this
We are not talking about grants here.
Comment on this
We are talking about oversight and the making of the rules of the game. I must say as a member of the committee, I think that it is shocking governance, without prejudice to the wonderful expertise of the individual we are talking about. As a matter of basic rules, to give people the peace of mind to which they are entitled, the regulated should never, while continuing to be regulated, have a seat on the board of the regulator. I ask the Department to give the committee a formal response as to why this has happened. It would also be useful to know how many people applied for this position and what assessment criteria was used to make the appointment. In terms of ticking boxes of expertise and qualifications, I have no doubt but there is a fundamental flaw in what has occurred here.
It it ironic that Members in the Roscommon area including Deputy Eugene Murphy and Senator Leyden have raised the issue of the Cuisle centre which is a holiday resort for people with disabilities and particularly wheelchair users. That facility is set to close. Say in the case where, for example, the IWA is a fantastic association, and Cuisle is a particularly fantastic part of the national infrastructure for people who are wheelchair users and so on, does the regulator have any competence on issues like that where it can liaise with the charity to ask that it keep such a facility open? Can it ask what are the problems and why such a facility is being closed?
Comment on this
Absolutely not, it is for the charity trustees of every individual charity to make those kinds of decisions. We would have no competency in that.
Comment on this
The regulator has no view and no competence. Would it have come up, with the head of the IWA being on the board, during any discussions? Would it have been mentioned?
Comment on this
Does the regulator examine the finances of the charities that it regulates?
Comment on this
That came up earlier on the information that is currently made available to us by charities. Where a charity is a company we have access to their financial details as they are filed with the companies office. However, charities do not have a requirement to file directly with us at present as we are waiting on amendments to the Act so that we can introduce it across the board.
Comment on this
The IWA would be a section 39 organisation, is that correct?
Comment on this
The Comptroller and Auditor General cannot audit any of these organisations obviously, so they do not have to give him their accounts.
Comment on this
The regulator is waiting for an amendment. The regulator does not have the full suite of powers and tools which a regulator should have, and amendments and additions to legislation are pending, is that the case?
Comment on this
Yes, there is a power in there to get accounts but the problem is it only applies to those charities that are not companies. If we were to introduce it it would only apply to approximately 40% of registered charities. In order to ensure that it is brought in in a fair manner and applies across the board to all charities we are looking for the carve out that is currently there in relation to companies to be removed.
Comment on this
Have there been any concerns about the IWA?
Comment on this
Clearly we have to get the legislation sorted for the regulator so that it can do that. Some charities are limited companies and others are just -----
Comment on this
Some are associations and are unincorporated.
Comment on this
They have no accounting responsibilities except to the Companies Registration Office.
Comment on this
There is an annual report that all charities have to submit to us but that is very basic. It contains very basic information.
Comment on this
The annual report is about activities, whether the charity is solvent and-----
Comment on this
It is about activities, sources of funds and what income is coming in but at a very high level.
Comment on this
To add to that, if their income is over €100,000 per year, they are required by Revenue to carry out an audit each year because they have a tax exemption. That requirement is for the larger cohort who came on to the register by being deemed registered in 2014. Any of them that has a charitable tax exemption is required to have an audit done for anything over €100,000.
Comment on this
Does the Charities Regulator use a public relations, PR, agency? Does it retain the services of a PR firm?
Comment on this
For a large portion of the year we did not have any in-house communications or stakeholder engagement resources available to us so we started using an external PR agency just to assist us with media queries and so on. It is on an as-needed basis.
Comment on this
What kind of money does that cost?
Comment on this
There are daily rates which are commercially sensitive but the full amount cannot exceed €25,000 as per the contract. It is for a period of time.
Comment on this
It could be for the year or could go into next year.
Comment on this
I note that the regulator removed 579 charities from the register of charities. The total annual income for registered charities is €14.5 billion. What are the reasons for delisting charities?
Comment on this
Those charities would have been taken off the register because they were inactive. They would have come off the charities register automatically by virtue of the Revenue Commissioners removing their charitable tax status. We have 6,500 charities on our register at the moment that are deemed registered charities. They are there because at the time that we were established, they held a charitable tax exemption from Revenue. If they happen to lose it, they get automatically removed from the register.
Comment on this
Is it the case that Revenue communicates with the Charities Regulator's office periodically indicating that it has removed charitable tax status from organisation A and then the regulator's office delists that organisation?
Comment on this
Are there any internal processes which the regulator follows under which it might delist independent of Revenue?
Comment on this
There are provisions in the Act through which we are entitled to remove charities from the register.
Comment on this
How many has the regulator removed so far?
Comment on this
How many staff are employed at the moment?
Comment on this
In terms of powers versus staff, does the office have enough staff to execute its current powers, notwithstanding the fact that we have already identified the fact that the regulator does not have enough power?
Comment on this
No, not at the moment; we are seeking to fill a number of vacancies