We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

2018 Financial Statements of the Charities Regulatory Authority

Contributions 441–667 of 667. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Does the office employ agency staff?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

No.

Comment on this

Before we move on, I want to take up an earlier point about the board of directors. I ask Ms Martin to go through the membership of the current board, indicating when each member was appointed and the mechanism under which the appointment was made. We will start with the chairman, Mr. Patrick Hopkins.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

I will have to come back to the committee with the dates of appointment because I do not have that information here.

Comment on this

I have the regulator's report here, which lists appointment dates for some members but there are gaps. The information is provided for some but not for others. I ask Ms. Martin to tell us what she can about each member and any missing details can be provided later.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

The members of the board are Mr. Patrick Hopkins, chairman.

Comment on this

When was he appointed?

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

He was appointed in 2014 originally.

Comment on this

He was reappointed on 16 October 2018, according to the annual report. Was he reappointed through the Public Appointments Service, PAS? Who makes the appointments? Is it the Minister?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Yes, it is the Minister.

Comment on this

Then I should be asking the Department to go through the members of the board of the Charities Regulator. The Minister makes the appointments and the regulator's office is at the receiving end. It is the Department that deals with ministerial appointees. Mr. Patrick Hopkins was reappointed on 16 October 2018 as chairman. Did that go through the PAS?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Power

The reappointment did not. There is provision for reappointment by the Minister without going through the PAS.

Comment on this

Let us go down through the list of directors.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Power

First on the list is Mr. David Brady. He was appointed in 2014 and reappointed in October 2017.

Comment on this

Was that done through the PAS? I am only interested in the current term.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Power

The reappointments were made by the Minister directly and did not go through the PAS.

Comment on this

Mr. Brady was not reappointed through the PAS.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Power

Next is Mr. Ercus Stewart was first appointed in 2018 through the PAS.

Comment on this

That appointment was done through the PAS.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Power

Yes. Next is Mr. Fergus Finlay. He was appointed in 2014 and reappointed in 2018. He was reappointed directly by the Minister.

Comment on this

Mr. Fergus Finlay was reappointed by the Minister.

Comment on this

Just to clarify, he was reappointed directly by the Minister. There was no application process-----

Comment on this

Not the second time around.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Power

There is provision for the reappointment of members for a second term.

Comment on this

There is provision for the reappointment of serving members.

Comment on this

When was he reappointed?

Comment on this

In 2018.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Power

Next on the list is Mr. Graham Richards, who was reappointed in 2018 by the Minister. Ms Katie Cadden was originally appointed in 2014 and was reappointed in 2018 by the Minister. Ms Máire McMahon was appointed in 2018 through the PAS. Mr. Martin Sisk was appointed in 2019 through the PAS.

Comment on this

He is not on the list in the annual report. His appointment must have been very recent.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Power

He was appointed this year so he may not be listed in the annual report.

Comment on this

When was he appointed?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Power

He was appointed on 1 March 2019.

Comment on this

What is the name again?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Power

Mr. Martin Sisk.

Comment on this

How was he appointed?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Power

Through the PAS.

Comment on this

Fine.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Power

Next is Ms Niamh Cahill who was appointed in 2018 through the PAS. Ms Patricia Cronin was originally appointed in 2014 and was reappointed in 2017 by the Minister. Ms Rosemary Keogh was appointed this year through the PAS. Mr. Tom Costello was originally appointed in 2014 and reappointed by the Minister in 2017.

Comment on this

Is Mr. David Brady gone?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Power

No, he was reappointed by the Minister in 2017.

Comment on this

Essentially, those who were appointed for the first time in 2018 and 2019 went through the PAS.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Power

Yes, that is true.

Comment on this

A number of the board members who were there previously have been reappointed directly by the Minister and did not go through the PAS.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Power

The Minister has the power to reappoint for one term.

Comment on this

Mr. Sisk and Ms Keogh were appointed this year.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Power

They were appointed in March of this year.

Comment on this

They were appointed since the publication of the report.

Comment on this

How long is the term? Is it four years?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Power

It is a five-year term.

Comment on this

I just wanted to check because when a name was mentioned a while ago, I looked through the report and could not find it. That is why I wanted to check the membership. Deputy O'Connell has some questions.

Comment on this

In terms of the €39.7 million fund that is being managed, Ms. Martin said that there are 392 players in the mix. Some of them are not regulated because their involvement predates registration. Is that correct? There are entities in the mix, whose money is in that fund, that are not registered charities. Did I understand that correctly?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

That is correct.

Comment on this

What proportion of the money or the groups are we talking about? Is half of it held by unregistered entities? Does the regulator have a breakdown on that? I would find it quite shocking if such a large amount of money was just sitting somewhere but if only a small amount of it relates to unregulated entities, I would not be so worried. It is important to know whose money is in that fund.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We can get back to the Deputy on that.

Comment on this

Does anybody here know the answer? Mr. Scanlon seems to be up to speed on this Davy fund. Does he have any knowledge of the breakdown of the money involved?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Scanlon

No, I do not but I can certainly request that information from Davy.

Comment on this

Specifically what I would like to know regarding the fund of almost €40 million, which seems to be performing quite well, is how many of the 392 companies involved are not registered. What proportion of that fund is in the custody of unregistered charities?

Is there information on how long the money has been there? Is it historic money that has not been touched? Are unregistered charities still putting money into the fund? Is there any activity?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Scanlon

There have been no new entrants to the fund.

Comment on this

Is it closed?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Scanlon

The fund was closed previous to the Charities Regulator having it under its remit. Charities can withdraw their capital from the fund but there are no new entrants, with no new capital being invested into the fund.

Comment on this

They are being paid dividends.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Scanlon

They are paid dividends twice a year.

Comment on this

Unregistered entities are getting dividends. Maybe this is beyond the scope of this committee. When this fund is marketed, is it marketed as a positive, ethical, philanthropic thing which people invest in for different reasons?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Scanlon

The investment policy rests with Davy Asset Management. I would have to revert to Davy for information.

Comment on this

I imagine that people who give money to charities would expect that the money is not being invested in something that is unethical. I am not saying that it is, but one would expect there to be oversight.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Scanlon

In 2017, the regulator informed Davy Asset Management that it should cease making tobacco-related investments.

Comment on this

That is the sort of thing I am asking about. It would seem bizarre to me if, for example, the Irish Cancer Society had money in that fund which was being invested in vaping, cigarettes, cannabis production or such.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Scanlon

The regulator instructed Davy Asset Management to cease making tobacco-related investments and also to have responsible investment policy.

Comment on this

Does the Charities Regulator have a document or parameters in which it is prepared to work regarding responsible investment policy? What other red line issues are there? Did Davy say there was no problem or did it say it would invest in what it wanted to? Is it obliged to listen to the regulator when it directs the investment.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

My understanding is that it is not obligated but in that case it did so and it interacted with us.

Comment on this

If a private company is managing a fund, who decides to write that letter? Who decides, for example, to focus on tobacco? Investment funds support many nasty things. Who decided that was the nastiest thing to put in the letter?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

It was brought to our attention that there were potentially investments in this area. We wanted to clarify that there absolutely should not be.

Comment on this

When that was highlighted to the regulator, did it look any further into other things that might not be so pleasant to invest in or did it leave it at the tobacco?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

I am not aware of what we did at the time but we can come back to the Deputy about that.

Comment on this

I imagine it is important that investments are sustainable for the climate and environment. It seems incomplete to not invest in tobacco but then to not invest in any other thing.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We can come back to the Deputy about that.

Comment on this

We spoke about standardised forms of reporting. Deputy Catherine Murphy might have mentioned it. The witnesses referred to less than 1% of people in the charitable sector being paid more than €70,000. That compares to the private sector, where 13% are paid more than €70,000. The witnesses used a nurse as an example. I do not think that anybody would expect that a nurse who is working for a cancer charity would be on less money than a nurse in a hospital. The concern is the pay of the people at the top. I do not think it really answers our questions to say that less than 1% are on more than €70,000. Could we look at that 1% and get the list of people and the jobs that the 1% accounts for?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We would not have that information. It is based on research done on the wider not-for-profit sector by Benefacts. We would not have the detail of individual CEOs.

Comment on this

If a charity is paying its CEO €500,000 and its nurse is paid the same as a hospital nurse, whose business is it to look into the salaries of the top brass?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

That will come back through the statement of recommended practice, SORP, accounting for charities, which has requirements related to levels of pay. Some detail will be provided regarding that but that is dependent on that amendment and those regulations being made.

Comment on this

Does Ms Martin feel that is essential?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Absolutely essential.

Comment on this

Ms Martin referred to recommendations. Would this only happen if people felt like giving the regulator the figures or does the regulator want it to be statutory?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

That would be the standard and the regulations would state that people have to comply with the standard. The mandatory aspect would come through the statutory instrument.

Comment on this

Would the regulator cap the pay?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

It is not for the Charities Regulator to determine rates of pay.

Comment on this

If I set up a charity and want to pay my CEO €500,000 while I do not pay anybody else any money while they are working for the charity, is that still possible? Who will weed out that practice?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

As part of the application process, a charity will indicate how many employees it will have. It will not yet have started its activities. If there is a very small charity which is talking about taking on 20 people and is not really talking about many other activities, that would flag for us that there may not be public benefit.

Comment on this

Once the flag is raised, what does the regulator do?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We will query it with the charity and see if there is a public benefit. If there is no public benefit associated with the charity and it is all about private benefit and what it will pay to individuals, it will not be registered because it will not meet the charity test, which requires a public benefit.

Comment on this

If it meets the charity test and the people still pay themselves a lot, there is very little that the regulator can do.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

If a concern is raised with us or we become aware of it for any reason, we will always interact. We can interact with the charity, because at the same time it has to be-----

Comment on this

What can the regulator do?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We can appoint inspectors if we are concerned about how the charity funds are being spent.

Comment on this

If the person feels that he or she is worth €500,000, the Charities Regulator can do nothing.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We can appoint inspectors and that can be made public.

Comment on this

What do the inspectors do?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

They look into the affairs of the charity. If it is spending a disproportionate amount on administration and CEOs-----

Comment on this

What can the regulator do?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

That will be called out in the inspector's report and potentially published.

Comment on this

What is the punishment? An inspector comes in and the person is called out, but that person is still going home with €500,000. How does one fix it? I think Ms Martin is saying that the Charities Regulator cannot fix it.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

There is nothing specific in legislation regarding salaries.

Comment on this

What is the role of the Charities Regulator with unregistered charities, where people are purporting to be a charity but they are not registered? If I put up a website and say that I am going to do a run with Deputy Fleming for charity, then we pocket the money, having advertised myself as a charity, what can the regulator do in that case even though I am not registered? What is the regulator's role in such a case?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

It would ultimately prosecute a person for doing that because one has to be registered to be able to present as a charity.

Comment on this

There is a case of a company, Gianna Care, that advertises itself on its website as a charitable organisation. There was a complaint about it six months ago or longer. It describes itself as providing crisis pregnancy care. It has the Gianna Care walk for hope, love and support, and so on. It is not a registered charity. A complaint was made to the Charities Regulator and was brought to my attention.

It is still holding itself as a charity and soliciting donations from the public. It had more than €76,000 in bank accounts since the end of 2018. The name is Gianna Care. Is Ms Martin familiar with the group?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

I am not familiar with it but if there is a concern with us and it is ongoing, I am not in a position to comment because it could prejudice the outcome, particularly when we are speaking about potential-----

Comment on this

Without Ms Martin commenting, it seems clear from the evidence I have been given that this charity is working completely outside the rules. It is not registered but it is active and collecting money. It has cash on hand. It is flouting some of the recent legislative changes in this country, which is a serious problem. The Charities Regulator was contacted some months ago about it. I cannot understand the delay in stopping it. It is still active and live. It is still collecting money. How long would Ms Martin expect an investigation such as this to take? It is a little complicated if a fund has been in existence since the 1960s, 1970s and 1980s but surely it is the job of the Charities Regulator to sort out a group that is not registered but marketing itself online as a charity today.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Absolutely, and this is why we inquire into every concern that comes to us. Other than that, unfortunately, I cannot comment on a particular case.

Comment on this

Ms Martin cannot comment on it. Does the Charities Regulator have parameters or rules from point of complaint to point of processing to point of response? Does it work within timelines or does it take as long as it takes?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

It takes as long as it takes, unfortunately, in some cases because it is not possible. We issue acknowledgements within a certain period but with regard to the investigation itself, we have a risk rating process that we apply to all concerns we receive. Something like a charity that claims to be a charity when it is not would be a high risk.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Any organisation that claims to be a registered charity when it is not is something that would be considered a high risk. That is something that would be rated-----

Comment on this

What other criteria are in the risk rating? Surely a charity that purports to offer counselling services to vulnerable women would ramp up the risk rating, would it not?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Yes, that is another area. If we thought there was potential harm to beneficiaries, it is something that would be high risk.

Comment on this

Very high risk, I would imagine. That would be the highest risk. There would be an assumption that a charity would be out for the good of people and operating within best practice. There is no question that there is a charity that purports to offer professional care to people under a charitable heading when it is not a charity. This is extremely serious.

What role does the Charities Regulator have in highlighting risks to the public? What comes to mind is the financial regulator advertisement from many years ago. What does the Charities Regulator do to highlight to the public that they could be giving money to dodgy things? What is the role of the Charities Regulator in advertising public awareness?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We have done work on public awareness with regard to registered charities and urging the public to check the register before they give to any organisation that they think is a charity. Earlier, I mentioned that we have a campaign due out next week on clothing collection, with regard to making sure people check the register to ensure the entity is a registered charity. This is something we regularly do. We try to come at it from different angles depending on the number of concerns, which are very high with regard to clothing collections. It is something on which we focused because we could see a particular risk there. Certainly, public awareness around these issues and people checking the register is one of our key focuses.

Comment on this

At the end of the day, people walking down the street at Christmas who have a bucket shoved in front of them will not go onto the phone to check the register. They will just throw the money in the bucket and keep going.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

That is what we are trying to change. We are trying to get the public to be more proactive themselves about managing who they give money to. It is about telling people there is a facility available for them if they want to check and that they should be aware there are organisations that are registered and other organisations that are not registered.

Comment on this

Mr. O'Halloran mentioned that an audit must be done if there is more than €100,000. Is that profitability or turnover?

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

Turnover. Prior to the establishment of the Charities Regulator, the original system was that there had to be a tax exemption. One of the requirements to maintain that status is that if income is in excess of €100,000, an audit will be carried out.

Comment on this

With regard to the board, similar to Deputy MacSharry, I am uncomfortable with the fact that somebody on the board of a charitable organisation also sits on the board of the regulator. I was not aware of this until this meeting and I do not believe it is in any way appropriate. Is there any other example where the regulated are on the board of the regulator? It is concerning if it is a widespread practice.

Comment on this

I presume people from the tourism industry are on the board of Bord Fáilte.

Comment on this

That is different. This is regulation.

Comment on this

Okay.

Comment on this

It is totally different.

Comment on this

Grand.

Comment on this

We have had many groups here but this is a regulator. It is a statutory role. I believe that even a family member or spouse on the board would be inappropriate. We need expertise on boards and retired people and people to come from other places but if somebody is actively sitting on the board of a charity and actively sitting on the board of the regulator that is supposed to be regulating the charity, that is just wrong and not acceptable.

Comment on this

How is the advancement of religion quantified? Who can tick that box? Does Scientology have charitable status? Does that religion have charitable status in Ireland?

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

It is not a registered charity. With regard to process, where a body applies to us on top of its constitution, we look for a document that sets out its principles, tenets and faith to understand what it does in terms of worship, for example, where it holds worship. We look for a lot more information from an organisation that sets itself out for the advancement of religion than we do in some other areas where the charitable purpose might be quite clear. This is something we are aware of and we focus on the registration side where risks might occur.

Comment on this

In terms of religious entities getting charitable status in recent years, how many more religions are in the mix now as opposed to a few years ago? Is the Charities Regulator constantly getting applications or is it just every so often? How significant is this new religion stuff?

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

If we look at where there has been proportional growth, it has not been in the advancement of religion, although we do have quite a number of new ones. Many of them come from new communities, who might be of a Baptist religion, for example. Other areas where we see growth are animal welfare charities and environmental charities and this reflects what is happening in society. That is where we see growth. There are people in new church organisations that may not be involved in the traditional Catholic or Church of Ireland churches. This will occur. The register will always reflect what is happening in society. Whatever is happening in society will be reflected in the types of new applications we see.

Comment on this

There is a push now to grab the world market and there is a lot of money to be made out of climate issues by some companies. How does the Charities Regulator assess what is on the right or wrong side? Whose skill set is that? It is a bit like the religion issue. It is subjective. If a company purports to be the greenest of them all, who assesses this? What is the level of expertise? High level people would be needed to be able to work out whether a charity would help to save the environment or whether it is just making a few euro.

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

The first principle is that they must be not-for-profit organisations. The entity being established is going to ensure that all the moneys-----

Comment on this

This is the problem; we do not have governance over how much people are paid. We can all make no profit if we pay ourselves enough, as I have said here before. If the regulator does not have any remit in determining a standard for what people are paid, it is very easy for people to not make a profit if they pay themselves enough.

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

I can give the Deputy some more information on this matter afterwards but new entities - new charities - tend to have much lower incomes. They really do not pay much in salaries. As they establish themselves, it takes most new organisations some time before they earn that type of-----

Comment on this

Before they have the money to feather their own nests.

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

Before they are in a position to generate that kind of income. We request such organisations to prepare a business plan and a breakdown of their income. We look at the proposed salaries and question them quite aggressively to see if they are appropriate. We seek to ensure that, even at the point at which charities are registered, the private benefit is reasonable in all circumstances, ancillary and necessary. We do that as part of our test.

Comment on this

May I ask a tiny question on this point? Does the regulator look at the benefits in addition to the salaries?

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

We look at everything contained in the form. The organisations will set out those benefits. We might not go into the detail of any other benefits they may offer. They will set out a plan of what they intend to offer but they may not have started trading and so may not have any income at that point.

Comment on this

It is probably more of an issue for existing bodies.

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

The other thing is that, once they are registered, they are regulated in respect of their ongoing requirements. As part of the annual report, they are also required to tell us what proportion of their annual expenditure is used for salaries. All charities are required to do that.

Comment on this

Does the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission, CCPC, have any role in this area? Does the Charities Regulator interface with it? Let us take for example an Irish private hospital that provides counselling services. It pays its taxes and is not a charity, just a private hospital. The company I mentioned, which provides bogus counselling, is pulling people away from this legitimately-run hospital and may be tax-exempt. Does the regulator have any role in that as there may be an uneven playing field, without mentioning the quality of service? I refer to people trying to get ahead of the game by getting charitable status and tax exemptions, thereby disadvantaging a legitimate company operating without charitable status. Does the regulator interface with the CCPC in such circumstances?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

No, not in that regard.

Comment on this

Is there such an interface in respect of anything? Does the regulator have any dealings with the commission?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

To date, we have not needed to.

Comment on this

I have a few questions. One of the documents we have been given provides a list of purposes that are of benefit to the community, broken down by category. These include the advancement of community welfare and many other categories. The area of human rights is mentioned. Is that allowed as a category?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

It is not considered a charitable purpose.

Comment on this

Promoting human rights is not a charitable purpose, although promoting animal welfare is.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

That is the case under the Act.

Comment on this

It is excluded.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

It is not included as a charitable purpose.

Comment on this

Okay. Are the main sporting organisations charities?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

No.

Comment on this

Are they excluded?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

They are excluded bodies under the Act.

Comment on this

They are excluded bodies. That is fine. I just want to get the background. Local Tidy Towns committees do work for the benefit of the community, youth and so on. Are they eligible?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

They can be, yes.

Comment on this

Are many Tidy Towns groups or other community groups eligible?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Some have registered as charities, yes.

Comment on this

Continuing to tease out this question, can the local community centre register as a charity in order to benefit from tax relief on its income?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

In some cases, yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

Many community centres are registered.

Comment on this

Many community centres can register, as can Tidy Towns groups.

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

Yes, and some Tidy Towns groups have registered.

Comment on this

The reason I ask is that I saw a picture of someone from a Tidy Towns committee in the book the regulator provided. I thought the group must be registered if it is featured in the book. That is fine. That kind of information could be important to local communities. They should know about the financial benefit in respect of tax. Will the representatives give me a flavour of community groups that have registered? The environment and animal welfare were mentioned.

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

There is a broad range. Some State-funded childcare providers are eligible. I refer to those that are not for profit and which are funded through some of the schemes for-----

Comment on this

Mr. O'Halloran is referring to something like the childcare centre in Tralee.

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

Yes. Other eligible bodies include organisations involved in education at every level from primary to secondary and on to various types of formal education. That includes a very wide range of bodies. With regard to local communities, we have already discussed animal welfare. Many of the other eligible groups are involved in health promotion. These include groups that provide transport to the local hospital for people who have cancer and groups who fundraise for particular issues. These issues may include an emerging need related to a particular disease or condition. That is another example.

Comment on this

Does a group have to be a registered charity for a set period before it can avail of tax relief?

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

Revenue has some conditions. An organisation can apply as soon as it has the status but there may be a waiting period in respect of one of the schemes. There are different schemes but I believe there is a two-year waiting period for the scheme regarding donation relief.

Comment on this

We will make a note of that. Representatives of Revenue will be here next week or the following week. We will specifically ask them about that. The Charities Regulator does not deal with that side of things. I gather that most schools are registered in order to avail of tax relief. Do they need charitable status to avail of tax relief on an extension or new facilities in the school for which funds are raised?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Schools have a charitable purpose in that they advance education. That is why there are included; that is one of the listed charitable purposes.

Comment on this

Churches are also included.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

Yes, on the basis that they advance religion.

Comment on this

I am just asking so that people will know because I did not know that some of these local voluntary groups could register as charities, although sporting organisations are specifically excluded.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

There is actually a separate tax regime for sporting bodies.

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

Also eligible are groups that work with young people, elderly people or those who are need of care. Many small local youth groups are eligible for charitable status.

Comment on this

It may have already been said but why were those 579 bodies removed from the register?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

These groups were removed from the register automatically as result of losing their charitable tax status.

Comment on this

Why does that happen?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

It is provided for under the Charities Act 2009.

Comment on this

Why would a group lose its tax status? We will ask the Revenue but Ms Martin must also know.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

There are many different reasons. Revenue is probably best placed to answer but I believe it is usually because they are no longer active.

Comment on this

It is because the group is no longer active. We will ask Revenue whether there is a sunset clause involved when it comes before the committee next week. We will make a note of that. The first of the organisations with which the Charities Regulator has a lot of interaction that Ms Martin mentioned was Revenue. The regulator has quite a lot of dealings with it because of the financial side of things. That is why I thought Ms Martin might know about this. We will ask the Revenue representatives when they are in.

I have a few questions on the Charities Regulator's accounts. To follow up on what Deputy O'Connell said, we have heard about the investment policy the NTMA set with respect to tobacco and, a year or two earlier, the armaments industry. It has a clear policy. I believe the Courts Service has a lot of funds invested on behalf of wards of court and it also has a policy not to invest in those areas. Will the witnesses clarify the regulator's policy with regard to investing in those areas? Who manages the fund?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Scanlon

Davy.

Comment on this

Davy can invest in funds that do not include companies involved in those industries. I ask the witnesses to provide the committee with a note. If those areas are not already excluded, I ask the regulator to follow the example of the other leading State agencies that have already implemented policies on this matter. It does not have to be legal, in that it can be an investment choice. If the regulator does not already have such a policy, it might-----

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

To clarify, we do have the details of our investment policy to hand. As for the ethical piece, we will get back to the Chair on that.

Comment on this

It can be sent to us in writing.

Comment on this

Mr. O'Halloran mentioned State-funded childcare. With regard to preschool children, the early childhood care and education, ECCE, scheme and so forth, do childcare providers operating under charitable status receive ECCE payments?

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

Yes.

Comment on this

Must these have 100% State-funded ECCE payments with no private element?

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

There could be fees paid, but in all those schemes there is a payment made by the Department for children-----

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

-----but the individual parent also pays some money as well.

Comment on this

Sometimes it is a top-up.

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

They would have a mix.

Comment on this

Is the top-up income tax exempt?

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

I do not know. That is a matter for the Revenue Commissioners.

Comment on this

I have to go to the House for a division, but perhaps I could submit a question afterwards. If it is, it is definitely an example of an uneven playing field if a private operator is operating the ECCE scheme and it is paying full tax on any income. If the operator has charitable status and is receiving ECCE payments or whatever it is called now - there is a new name for it-----

Comment on this

The national childcare scheme.

Comment on this

We can put that to the Revenue Commissioners next week.

Comment on this

Are they tax exempt on all the income they get in addition to the three hours of the ECCE scheme per child per day? It could be from 9 a.m. to 12 noon or whatever. If I put my child into the facility for three hours and I decide to pay for another six hours in the day in one of these State-funded charitable places versus a private operator, is one getting preferential tax treatment over another?

Comment on this
Mr. Eamon O'Halloran

That is a tax matter-----

Comment on this

I understand that, but it is important to know who is giving them charitable exemption. We will ask the Revenue Commissioners next week.

Comment on this

The charitable exemption does not mean they necessarily get the tax exemption.

Comment on this

Charitable does not mean tax.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

They do not get it automatically.

Comment on this

We will raise that with the Revenue Commissioners when they are here in the next week or so.

Comment on this

I thank the Chairman.

Comment on this

I have some brief questions on page 9 of the financial statement. The CRA spent a great deal on legal fees. Why was it so much? Given the size of the organisation, €213,000 is a lot.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We only have one in-house legal adviser. Almost all the charity tests we do are legal tests so a large volume of legal advice is required in that area. We have a requirement for three legal advisers, but we only have one at present so we are reliant on using some of our funds to get external legal advice.

Comment on this

Page 8 refers to consultancy costs. Consultancy costs include the cost of external advice to management and exclude outsourced business as usual functions. Can you differentiate between paying somebody on a consultancy basis and an outsourced function? What is the difference?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

They are both consultants, but the outsourced was identified as a position on our organisational chart some years ago for the preferred operating model. That is where we identified that we needed in-house financial support in terms of having an accountant. It was decided at that time to do it by way of outsourcing, that is, to get somebody in as a consultant to do it for us.

Comment on this

How many whole-time equivalent posts are outsourced?

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

There was one. It was not full-time, but a certain number of days.

Comment on this

Okay. I was worried that it might be a large number. The CRA has consultancy costs of €388,000. The digital platform, which was mentioned earlier, is €218,000. Page 22 refers to consultancy costs of €333,000. The digital platform is a significant element of that cost. According to page 8, the authority capitalised €212,000 of it and only charged €126,000 of it to its revenue account. How does authority decide what is capitalised and what is charged to the revenue account?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Scanlon

It is a matter of accountancy policy. The capitalised element is any of the expenditure directly related to the platform and the project management fees associated with the platform. Of the €218,000 for the digital platform, we capitalised €212,000 of that. Some €6,000 of that related to training, which was put directly to the income statement.

Comment on this

Okay. I see that the authority brought €298,902 into its capital account. I presume the €212,000 is part of that. I am looking at page 23.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Scanlon

Yes.

Comment on this

What else has been capitalised other than the expenditure on the digital platform?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Scanlon

Just general IT equipment. It could be anything from monitors to personal computers, PCs, that were outside of the new digital platform.

Comment on this

Will Ms Martin send us a note on it? There is quite an amount capitalised out of what the organisation is spending. I realise that if the organisation is building up the system it will want to do that, and some of it is then charged to revenue. I will be happy if she sends a note on that.

Comment on this
Ms Helen Martin

We will.

Comment on this

We have concluded our work and a division has been called in the Chamber. I thank the witnesses from the CRA and the Department of Rural and Community Development for their attendance and for the information provided as well as for the information they will forward to the secretariat in writing in due course in respect of information sought at the meeting.

We will suspend the meeting until 2.30 p.m. when we will deal with carbon taxation with representatives of the Department of Communications, Climate Action and Environment.

Comment on this

We will go into private session.

Comment on this