We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Chapter 18 - Tax relief on film production

Contributions 1–193 of 594. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

This morning we are joined from the Revenue Commissioners by Mr Niall Cody, chairperson, Ms Kathleen Redmond, principal officer, Padraigh Donnelly, assistant principal, and Angela O'Gorman, principal officer. We are also joined this morning from the Department of Finance by Ms Deirdre Donaghy, principal officer, who may have to leave early in the course of the meeting to go to the Seanad, and Ms Anne Marie Walshe, principal officer. We are also joined from the Department of Culture, Heritage and Gaeltacht by Mr Conor Falvey and Ms Mary Nash, who are here with particular reference to the discussion on the tax relief on film production in case anything arises whereby we have to call on their expertise during the course of the meeting.

I remind members, witnesses and all those in the Public Gallery that all mobile phones must be switched off or put into airplane mode, as merely putting them on silent mode does not prevent interference with the recording system.

By virtue of section 17(2)(l) of the Defamation Act 2009, witnesses are protected by absolute privilege in respect of their evidence to the committee. If they are directed by it to cease giving evidence on a particular matter and they continue to do so, they are entitled thereafter only to qualified privilege in respect of their evidence. They are directed that only evidence connected with the subject matter of these proceedings is to be given. They are asked to respect the parliamentary practice to the effect that, where possible, they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable.

Members are reminded that under Standing Order 186, the committee shall refrain from inquiring into the merits of a policy or policies of the Government or a Minister of the Government, or the merits of the objectives of such policies.

While we expect witnesses to answer questions asked by the committee clearly and with candour, they can, and should, expect to be treated fairly and with respect and consideration at all times in accordance with the witness protocol. I invite the Comptroller and Auditor General to make his opening statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

The 2018 account of the receipt of revenue of the State collected by the Revenue Commissioners was certified by me on 18 April 2019 and received a clear audit opinion. The account records receipts of taxes and duties remitted by Revenue to the Exchequer, and receipts collected by Revenue on behalf of other agencies. In 2018, the net receipts of taxes and duties amounted to a total of €54.6 billion, an increase of €4 billion or 8% when compared to 2017. At the level of tax headings, the most significant change related to corporation tax receipts, which increased by €2.2 billion, or 27% year-on-year. Receipts related to VAT, income tax and corporation tax together accounted for 84% of net tax receipts. Net receipts collected by Revenue on behalf of other agencies increased by 14.6% year-on-year, from €12.3 billion in 2017 to €14.1 billion in 2018. Pay related social insurance contributions continue to account for the majority, nearly 80%, of such receipts.

Members may wish to note that there was a change in the treatment of local property tax receipts in 2018. Up to 2017, such receipts were treated as an Exchequer receipt but since 1 January 2018, local property tax receipts are remitted by Revenue directly to the Local Government Fund. The amount received in 2018 was €488 million, up marginally from the €482 million received in 2017.

Revenue's administration and operational expenses are charged to Vote 9 - Revenue Commissioners, rather than the Revenue account. The appropriation account shows that the total spent by Revenue in 2018 was €425 million. This was up 3.4% from €411 million in 2017. Taking account of appropriations-in-aid of €72 million, net expenditure under the Vote amounted to €353 million. The surrender for the year was €3.7 million. In my report on the appropriation account, I draw attention to instances of non-compliance by Revenue with procurement rules. The nature of this and how it is being addressed is disclosed by the Accounting Officer in the statement on internal financial control.

I will turn now to chapter 17, which is on tax compliance interventions. Chapter 17 outlines Revenue's approach to monitoring and managing taxpayer compliance. The report reviews controls over compliance interventions and the agreement and collection of tax settlements. The examination found that Revenue's compliance work is well-targeted. Just over 460,000 specific interventions were recorded as completed in 2018. These ranged from low-intensity interventions such as customs checks, checks of information available to Revenue and inquiries with taxpayers, to more intensive on-site audits and investigations. These can result in identification of a yield amount, that is, additional tax, interest and in some cases, penalties due. Out of 456,000 non-audit interventions completed in 2018, one in four resulted in identification of yield, amounting to €316 million. A total of 4,700 audit interventions were also completed in 2018, with almost two thirds of those resulting in a yield. The average yield per case for completed audits was approximately €84,500.

The review also examined 50 settlement cases closed formally by Revenue in 2018, with a combined yield of €92.7 million. For most of the cases reviewed, the examination found that the liability had been calculated by Revenue as required under its procedures, or Revenue had validated calculations by a taxpayer's agent, and interest and penalties had been applied in accordance with legislation. A number of the settlement cases examined have been outlined in the chapter, and illustrate the protracted nature of many compliance and settlement cases.

Case study A involved liabilities of a taxpayer under four aspects of PAYE and PRSI. While Revenue had issued a notice of estimation of amounts due in one of those areas in 2015 in the amount of €205 million, a settlement offer of €29.1 million was accepted in August 2018. The reasons for the change in Revenue's view on the liability are documented in the case file and appear reasonable.

In case study B, Revenue accepted a settlement just days before a Tax Appeals Commissioner hearing was due in April 2017. While Revenue had assessed the tax due at €113 million, it ultimately accepted a settlement offer of €10 million on foot of legal advice to settle, among other reasons, due to the passage of time in the case.

The chapter also looked at the collection of settlements agreed with taxpayers. In general, Revenue does not pursue intervention yield amounts which it deems uneconomic to pursue. There is no set threshold for non-pursuit: each amount is judged on a case-by-case basis. Revenue published information about a total of 554 settlements with taxpayers in quarterly listings in 2017 and 2018, with a combined value totalling €97 million. Of this amount, 59% had been collected by Revenue by the end of May 2019. The rate of outstanding liabilities varied, with the highest percentages of yield outstanding for quarter 2 and quarter 3 of 2017.

The chapter made two recommendations around the area of data recording and performance measurement. The first suggests that Revenue should distinguish in its performance information between interventions prompted by taxpayers and those commenced by Revenue as a result of its own planning or systems. The second recommendation is that Revenue should consider reporting the differences between the amount of tax assessed as due from compliance activity, the tax settlement amount and the tax actually collected, and the reasons for any variances.

I will turn now to chapter 18, which deals with tax relief on film production. Tax relief for investment in films, generally referred to as film relief, was first introduced in Ireland in the 1980s. The administration of film relief involves both the Department of Culture, Heritage and the Gaeltacht and the Revenue Commissioners. The regulations underpinning the scheme were revised in 2015. In order for a film production company to qualify for film relief, the project proposal must be authorised by the Department as a qualifying audiovisual project, based on satisfying certain criteria. A special-purpose production company must be set up for each project. The company may claim corporation tax relief in advance, based on the projected expenditure on a qualifying project, through the mechanism of a payable tax credit. This typically results in a payment to the company and does not depend on the amount of tax previously paid. This is effectively a grant scheme operated through the taxation system. Under the 2015 scheme, 337 projects were granted a total of €273 million of film relief in the period 2015 to 2018, which is an average of approximately €810,000 per project.

The examination reviewed a sample of 35 film relief applications submitted to the Department between 2015 and 2018. Three applications were refused on the basis that they were for categories of film not eligible for certification. All of the remaining 32 projects were approved on the basis that they passed the Department's cultural test. This means that they met at least three of eight broadly-defined cultural criteria as assessed by the Department.

While seven of the eight criteria are amenable to quantification or objective testing, one is very broadly stated. It was noted that almost all of the approved projects were deemed to have met this criterion.

The Department also operates an alternative employment test for projects that are proposed for film relief. To qualify under this test, the Minister must be satisfied that the project can act as a stimulus to the making of audiovisual projects in Ireland through the provision of quality employment, training and skills development opportunities. However, there is no definition of what constitutes quality employment. The chapter recommends that the Department establish criteria to establish the employment aspects of proposals for film relief.

Under the 2015 scheme, Revenue was responsible for approving the value of the film relief. A sample of 15 Revenue files processed under the scheme was examined to check that the prescribed pre-production and post-production checks were undertaken on the projects. These included checks on the legal structure of the production companies, the budget for the project and the expenditure outturn. The examination identified no issues of concern from those reviews.

Revised regulations for film relief were implemented with effect from March 2019. This included moving the relief to a self-assessment basis, similar to that used for most other tax reliefs. When the chapter was being finalised, Revenue was still in public consultation with the film sector on draft guidelines on the operation of the credit under the new system. Revenue stated that planning was underway for an appropriate compliance testing regime for film relief. The recommendations in the chapter were addressed to the Department, rather than to Revenue.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I understand that today’s meeting is to focus on the Revenue Vote, the account of the receipt of Revenue for 2018 and two chapters of the 2018 Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General published in September. Those are chapter 17 - tax compliance interventions, and chapter 18 - tax relief on film production.

I am accompanied today by Ms Kathleen Redmond and Mr. Padraigh Donnelly, compliance policy, planning division and Ms Angela O’Gorman, Comptroller and Auditor General and committee liaison.

In the context of today’s discussions, I draw the committee’s attention to section 851A of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 and my obligation to uphold taxpayer confidentiality.

Revenue's role is to serve the community by fairly and efficiently collecting taxes and duties and implementing customs controls. Our aim is to protect Exchequer funds by ensuring that there is compliance with the various tax and duty obligations set down in the laws enacted by the Oireachtas. We support voluntary compliance by making it as easy as possible for taxpayers to understand and meet their tax and duty obligations and we prioritise the protection of Exchequer funds and support to compliant taxpayers by identifying, targeting and tackling non-compliance on a risk basis. Revenue responds to non-compliance in all its forms, from non-filing of tax returns to complex tax-avoidance schemes, criminal tax evasion and excise fraud. Our response is risk-based, proportionate and responsive to taxpayer behaviour.

In 2018, Revenue collected total gross Exchequer receipts of €77.27 billion, including €14.1 billion in non-Exchequer receipts collected on behalf of other Government Departments and agencies. The net Exchequer receipts were €54.6 billion which was an increase of €4.04 billion, or 8%, over 2017 figures. The net Exchequer receipts for corporation tax were €11.4 billion, up 26.7%, income tax receipts were €23.5 billion, up 6.6%, and VAT receipts were €19.3 billion, up 7%. To the end of October this year, the net Exchequer receipts were over €44 billion, some €3 billion more than the same period last year.

In chapter 17, the Comptroller and Auditor General reviews tax compliance interventions. Under Ireland’s self-assessment tax system, returns filed by taxpayers are the basis for calculating tax liabilities and Revenue promotes voluntary tax compliance by making it as easy as possible to file those returns and pay the right amount of tax at the right time. Our success in this regard is clearly evidenced by the consistently high timely compliance rates being achieved year on year. For example, the timely compliance rates in 2018 were above 90% across all taxes, with the majority of taxpayers paying the right amount on time. These compliance rates were, a month after the timely deadline, 99% and 98% for our largest and medium-sized cases, respectively.

Revenue compliance interventions are designed to protect the Exchequer, to assure ourselves as to the accuracy of self-assessment returns, to influence compliance behaviour and to provide a level playing field for all taxpayers. We have a clear risk focus to our compliance intervention approach. In 2018, we completed over 580,000 risk-based interventions which yielded €572 million. To the end of October 2019, we have completed almost 388,000 interventions yielding almost €409 million. These interventions include almost 2,600 audits and investigations.

The examination of tax compliance interventions in chapter 17 is a follow-on from chapter 27 on tax settlements in the 2012 Comptroller and Auditor General annual report. The chapter, in 2012, contained six recommendations, all of which have been implemented. The findings and the recommendations in that report informed improvements in how we manage, record and report our compliance interventions. Some of the actions taken include ICT developments, such as the introduction of our real-time case working system, revenue case management, RCM, in 2015. The introduction of RCM delivered improvements in the quality and effectiveness of interventions through more targeted case selection and case management.

As part of the Comptroller and Auditor General’s 2018 report, 50 cases were reviewed. These included five assurance checks and 45 cases with tax settlements that were achieved through Revenue interventions. The 45 interventions included aspect queries, profile interviews, audits and investigations with a total yield of €97.2 million. The examination covers the timeliness and classification of interventions, calculation of the tax liability, application of interest and penalties, authorisation and approval of settlements and collection. The report sets out four case studies in detail. In three of the case studies, the intervention followed contact from the taxpayer and, in two cases, that contact dates back to before the 2012 Comptroller and Auditor General examination took place. This leads to the first recommendation on recording and analysing the origin of interventions. The second recommendation relates to reporting the differences between tax assessed, tax settled and tax collected and both recommendations are agreed by Revenue.

Revenue’s statement of strategy 2020-2022 and our corporate priorities for next year were finalised recently. Our priorities include enhancing our risk-focused approach to compliance activity and we will consider how best to implement the recommendations in this context. We have prioritised a review of our current compliance intervention models to ensure our continued effectiveness in improving voluntary compliance. We will also explore options for closer integration of collection and debt management with other compliance activity.

Chapter 18 of the Comptroller and Auditor General's report deals with tax relief on film production and examines the administration of the scheme between 2015 and 2018. During this period, 337 projects were approved by Revenue, granting a total €273 million in corporation tax relief. There are no recommendations in the chapter for Revenue.

This relief is administered by the Department of Culture, Heritage and the Gaeltacht on the cultural and employment aspects, and by Revenue in relation to the value of credit available.

The Comptroller and Auditor General's examination coincided with a significant change in Revenue's administration of the relief. Following commencement of section 26 of the Finance Act 2018, on 27 March 2019, applications for relief were moved to full self-assessment, bringing the administration of the scheme in line with the rest of the tax code and operating on the same basis as other tax reliefs. Film relief is now managed through Revenue’s suite of risk-based compliance interventions in the same manner as other reliefs and, as already mentioned, the type of intervention deployed is determined by taxpayer behaviour.

Revenue’s guidelines on film relief were issued in October 2019 following an intensive consultation process and provide comprehensive information on the operation of the relief. A link to the published guidelines was included in the briefing provided to the committee secretariat.

Our effectiveness in all our activities depends on our people and continued investment in the ICT systems to support our work.

Pay and associated costs accounted for €303 million of the total €425.4 million expenditure in 2018. There were approximately 6,250 staff serving at the end of 2018. This figure included 145 temporary staff. The committee might be interested to note that the full-time equivalent figure at 31 October was 6,752, which included 103 temporary clerical officers. ICT was the second largest item of expenditure at €56.8 million.

I note that the committee is currently reviewing non-compliance with public procurement guidelines. In this context, we included a note in the briefing document that we sent to the committee secretariat last Friday setting out details in respect of expenditure of €4.4 million in 2018 that was non-compliant with the guidelines. Some €1.2 million of that related to issues with the unavailability of contracts under the Office of Government Procurement frameworks. Contracts in compliance with the guidelines are now in place for all of those contracts.

Given the inclusion in chapter 17 of some case studies involving interventions that we carried out on taxpayers, I will again draw the committee's attention to section 851A of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 and my obligation to uphold taxpayer confidentiality. Subject to this constraint, I will answer questions from the committee.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Cody. The first member to indicate was Deputy Burke, who will have 20 minutes. After him will be Deputy Connolly with 15 minutes. Members have indicated in the following sequence: Deputies Cullinane, Murphy, MacSharry, Cassells and O'Connell. We are also joined by two officials from the Department of Culture, Heritage and the Gaeltacht in respect of film relief. If any member has a question on that particular aspect, we will try to get to it before the break instead of making the officials sit here for the afternoon as well.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Cody and his team for appearing before the committee. I compliment them on the transparent way in which they give us information, which allows us to do our duty as Members of the Oireachtas. That information is helpful. By and large, Revenue does its job well and effectively.

Christmas is approaching and flat rate expenses are being debated in the media. Depending on who one listens to, this matter could affect anywhere between 80,000 and 600,000 employees, including 75,000 shop assistants and 8,000 journalists. These are not highly paid individuals. It is published and stated policy that, in theory, flat rate expenses could be withdrawn from 1 January 2020. We are effectively moments away from the first or second week in January when people will be getting amended tax credit certificates through the post. What is the state of play currently? I do not want to accuse Mr. Cody of being the Christmas Grinch who stole these expenses.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I thank the Deputy. As he knows, we discussed this matter when I was before the committee this time last year. We are carrying out a comprehensive review of the range of flat rate expenses in order to ensure that they are in accordance with legislation and changes in employment practices. This time last year, we had planned to amend flat rate expenses as we carried out our reviews across particular categories. In the context of last year's budget and Finance Bill discussions, though, we recognised that there were concerns. We are proposing a postponement of the implementation of the review for any sector until we have completed the review of all sectors. The subject has been under discussion on Committee Stage of the Finance Bill. The Minister wrote to me two or so weeks ago to ask for a full report of where we were with our review. The review is nearly complete, but there are a number of categories where we still have to complete our communications. Last Friday, I sent a reply to the Minister's request. He has that reply. I am aware that he has been away this week. I am awaiting his reply. Yesterday, a parliamentary question was answered in which the Minister outlined that his officials were studying my reply. I expect that he will-----

Comment on this

I am clear about Mr. Cody's independence in the performance of his duties. It is an issue for Revenue to enforce the legislation. Will there be a change on 1 January?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

We are in correspondence with the Minister, so I must wait to see what his reply will be. I will consider his reply and we will publish the correspondence. We will be clear about what we will be doing before tax credit certificates issue in early December.

Comment on this

Has Revenue made a determination on its review? Has the review been completed?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

No. As I mentioned, there are a small number of categories that we have not finalised our correspondence on yet. Last year, we stated that we would not implement for anyone until we were in a position to do so for everyone.

Comment on this

Revenue undertook public consultation with-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

We have engaged with-----

Comment on this

-----union officials representing those who work in these industries.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Absolutely. From representations made in the past while, I can see that a number of unions have published some of that correspondence among their members. I am sure that a number of committee members have submitted parliamentary questions.

Comment on this

I sit on the Committee on Finance, Public Expenditure and Reform, and Taoiseach. This matter and public representatives' concerns about it were raised during the debate on the Finance Bill. As a legislator, I am conscious that budget 2020 was an income tax neutral budget. Some of these flat rate expenses date back a significant period, but a massive cost does not attach to them by and large. They give lower paid workers a break and are in most cases wholly and exclusively for the purpose of those workers' employment. We know from advertisements this week that many reliefs go unclaimed. We are trying to increase that. If people are to get small and reasonable amounts, I would not like to see the online process that will be embarked upon next year being made too difficult.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Some of the flat rate expenses date back to the 1950s and 1960s. When we commenced our review, it was clear to us that, due to the passage of time, changes in employment law and the introduction of health and safety legislation, some of them were not being incurred anymore and were out of date. I reviewed some of this recently. In 2015, there was a series of parliamentary questions about the differences in flat rate expenses. Some were provided on a gender basis. For example, a male in one category of worker had a higher flat rate expense than the female. One of the Deputy's colleagues asked a parliamentary question and I remember seeing the answer and thinking that what it described looked odd and did not reflect a modern economy. It is also the case that flat rate expenses apply to sectors that are well represented, but a whole range of people have not had that facility to negotiate such expenses.

We have comprehensively reviewed the basis and the submissions. We will have a detailed report, which we will publish, but as regards-----

Comment on this

Is there a date for its publication?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

No. It is not completed yet, but it will be published. The one thing that will be in place is a very simple scheme through which people can claim their entitlements. I presume at some stage today we will talk about the modernisation of the PAYE system and the massive change that will be in place in January, through which there will be a simple online review mechanism to claim any health expense, flat rate expense or other expense.

Comment on this

I will revert to the online side in a moment, but I want to be clear about this matter.

There are anomalies. Mr. Cody referred to gender-based anomalies. I am fully aware that these must be tidied up, but my basic concern is for ordinary employees. I do not want to see them losing out come 1 January because of a decision that makes it too difficult to embark on a process whereby they can claim expenses. I hope I am making that point well to Mr. Cody.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Absolutely. I assure the committee that I expect to get a reply from the Minister, probably early next week.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

What the Minister undertook to do on Committee Stage of the Finance Bill was to make the correspondence available. We will publish that. We will publish the reply and it will be clear what will happen at that stage.

Comment on this

When Mr. Cody was before the committee on 1 June 2017, I raised concerns in relation to MyEnquiries and how it was operating. At that stage, Mr. Cody stated: "Our statistics do not bear out that the process has slowed down, but there are varying degrees of complexity in requests for correspondence, and it depends on what the issue is." In the next response, Mr. Cody stated that it was timely that I asked the question because Revenue - the Collector General - was conducting a review or talking about MyEnquiries in terms of Revenue's internal procedures. I will take it back to where I come from.

If one looks at relevant contracts tax, RCT, section 530P governs the fact that if a subcontractor has tax deducted the surplus becomes available for offset against other liabilities. As I mentioned in 2017, once, all it took was a five-minute phone call whereby someone could contact their local district tax office and state that his or her client had a surplus in RCT and that he or she wanted to offset it against another tax head. I will provide an example from earlier this year. Mr. Cody will bear in mind that my initial inquiry was in 2017. An individual practitioner had a query from a client who had €5,000 of RCT and wanted to allocate €1,000 against his PAYE return. The person had a liability with the Revenue for €1,000 and he also has €5,000 on account with the Revenue under RCT. It was a quarterly P30. It could be a VAT3 or anything in any event because P30s are gone now. It was a quarterly P30 or a quarterly VAT3. Be that as it may, it was due on 23 May last. It was due after the period end, on 23 April. There is nothing new there. Essentially, on 12 April, the practitioner logged on to MyEnquiries. He submitted a request to have €1,000 taken from the RCT and allocated against his VAT in order to discharge that liability. This was on 12 April and it was not due until 23 April. On 22 May, the Revenue issued a demand to that client for collection and payment. The client knew that he had €5,000 on account with Revenue. The first thing he did was to contact the practitioner and ask, "Are you doing your job at all, lads?". He was extremely frustrated. The practitioner had to provide him with a paper trail in terms of what had been done on his behalf. Next, the practitioner went back to MyEnquiries - bear in mind, one is talking about 20 or 25 days of a turnaround - to try and sort out the matters relating to the demand. The demand was reissued.

Let us return to the point where the frustrated practitioner called the Collector General. He picked up the phone to the Collector General and the member of staff of the Collector General's office stated that she could see on the screen in front of her that the €5,000 was there and that €1,000 needed to be allocated but that she could do it. That is what the practitioner was told. Bear in mind where we live. In terms of the advances in the IT available to the Revenue Commissioners, I would have thought this is a basic enough matter. The lady in the Collector-General's office stated that she could not put a stop on the demand going out. The practitioner went back to the RCT section, which was dealing with the inquiries. The official stated, "Yes, I understand where you are coming from". The practitioner asked, "Can I put a complaint in in relation to it?". The practitioner asked if the official point him to where he could submit a complaint on the website. It was not possible to get a complaint through in connection with it. Ultimately, the individual said that maybe the practitioner should talk to his local Deputy in connection with the matter. That is the process as people are experiencing it on MyEnquiries. All it used to take was a five-minute phone call whereby a person could contact someone in the local tax office and ask if he or she would not mind doing what I have outlined. This is not a complex issue but we are turning it into a 25 or 50-day process. The accountant in question asked me to imagine what will happen when the next quarterly P30 or VAT3 return is due. The process will start all over again. I would be grateful if Mr. Cody could comment on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It is difficult to comment on an individual case.

Comment on this

This is global. MyEnquiries is a global issue. It is something I get correspondence from practitioners on regularly. It is the same with tax clearance that we had previously. In a case where a company could require tax clearance for doing a job urgently, there was a time where one could ring up the office stated there is an instalment arrangement here, one will have it in place by X date and the Revenue, based on heads of agreement, would issue the tax clearance. MyEnquiries lengths that process. Specifically, on my P30 and VAT3 query, how do we deal with that delay?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

in 2018, we dealt with 2.1 million cases through MyEnquiries. Generally, the system works.

Comment on this

Would Mr. Cody clarify that? Is he talking about members of the public or practitioners?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

A significant level of the inquiries through MyEnquiries are from practitioners.

Comment on this

Do the practitioner and the public go through the same route?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Yes. I remember our previous discussion. What we have done in the meantime is we set up a tax administration liaison committee with the Consultative Committee of Accounting Bodies in Ireland, the Irish Tax Institute and the Law Society about looking at particular problems and aspects. Actually, there was a meeting of the sub-committee this week at which the areas of concern were identified.

What we try and do with our systems is to provide for as much as possible but it takes an IT development for automatic off-set of withholding taxes, such as RCT, against declared liabilities. Recently, we launched a facility for VAT repayments where one could automatically do it oneself because we would like to provide the facility for the practitioner to be able to do it.

Comment on this

Of course, it is common sense.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

But any change like that requires an IT development and takes a period of time. RCT is an interesting-----

Comment on this

Can Mr. Cody see how frustrating that can be?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Absolutely. It is frustrating for our staff who have to deal with things that do not work perfectly and we are working on making it seamless.

I want to talk a little about tax clearance. Tax clearance is available automatically online without any intervention. We also held a recent experiment around the use of robotics to automatically deal with the tax clearance query because most of it is a step-by-step process. We are constantly trying to innovate to improve the service provision.

The Deputy talked about what we would do before when one could ring up if a company had some temporary difficulty, and which would stop the issue of the tax clearance which would stop them getting the contract which would lead to a spiral of issues. In the introduction of our new debt management system which was launched at the end of last year, there is an online system to enter into an instalment arrangement. Once it fits the criteria, we automatically allow the instalment arrangement which would free-up the tax clearance certificate. These initiatives come from that engagement with the practitioners.

Comment on this

Will it take long to address that issue I detailed?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

When the meeting is finished, I would like the Deputy to give me the details of the case. What I find useful-----

Comment on this

Mr. Cody already has it.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It sounded familiar to me.

Comment on this

It is not an isolated case.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Absolutely.

Comment on this

I am merely making the point that there are numerous such incidents.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

To be fair to our people and systems, we respond to examples and we try to fix them. The Deputy can see from our figures that we have ongoing information technology development, maintenance and enhancement. There is a very complex and complicated information technology framework. Changes take planning and implementation. When I was before this committee on one occasion the Chairman was surprised that I knew about one of the parliamentary questions he submitted on a case. I pay much attention to issues of that nature. This is how we learn about real world matters. We also carry out regular surveys of both businesses and agents of their experience of interaction with us. The results of those are very positive. Helping people to comply is a core pillar of how we work.

Comment on this

I can guarantee that there is frustration at the agent level on that issue. It is significant. When the next period comes around, they will have to face into this process and they know that their client will potentially get a demand. The client will then complain.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The agent representatives bodies are not slow to point out matters to us and we work with them to fix that.

Comment on this

I hope it is cleared up. Will Mr. Cody speak about Revenue Online Service, ROS, and what happened coming up to the deadline? It was extended to 6 p.m. on 13 November but there were further technical issues and it was down on the Wednesday morning. The next extension brought the deadline to midnight on 17 November. The Revenue Commissioners were very clear that a surcharge would not apply to any returns filed in that week. What happened? Were the Revenue Commissioners initially slow to extend the deadline? Was extending it to the following day a case of not seeing the bigger picture in trying to respond to the issue?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The ROS difficulties on 12 November were one of the first instances of us having those issues. It happened on 12 November, which was the extended deadline for pay and file processes. We were very sorry as we knew the impact it had. It is a big day in the agents' world. Many people were very frustrated that afternoon. We had difficulties on 12 November because of a database server problem that happened at 11.50 a.m. It was identified very quickly and various people worked on solving that problem. Like with every information technology system, people tried what had been done before to fix the problem and the expectation was that it would be fully operational in an hour. Unfortunately, previously tried approaches did not work and the system was effectively operating at partial capacity until approximately 5 p.m. From 9 a.m. to noon on 12 November, 11,000 returns were filed, whereas from noon until 5 p.m., only 2,500 returns were filed. At all times there was a trickle of returns. The system returned to being fully operational at 5 p.m. and from then until midnight, there were 33,000 returns filed.

When we identified the problem and knew we had the solution, we extended the deadline until 6 p.m. or the end of the following working day, which should have been adequate to deal with the expected 60,000 or so returns. Unfortunately, on the morning of 13 November, it transpired that we had missed one element of the non-application of the surcharge to a small category of cases that came through a particular challenge, with 300 of those cases getting notification of a surcharge. We were monitoring what agents were saying and we said there was a problem on one particular "pipe". It was purely human error and it had been missed in the extension of the deadline. We fixed that in what would have been a normal process - we would not have seen it as a big fix - but because it happened when the returns were coming in, it slowed the overall process. One can imagine our response. We said we would just extend the deadline until midnight on the Sunday.

I realise this is not in the chapter but I expected us to be discussing the issue. On the Wednesday we got 17,500 returns and by the end of the week we had 536,769 income tax returns filed through ROS, which is an increase of 6.1% on last year's filing deadline. On the Sunday, there were 4,692 returns filed. I know people pay attention to what I say here and we are really sorry about the disruption we caused people. We had a board meeting on the Thursday to review what happened and although we cannot ever say for definite that we will not have problems in future, we will not have these problems in future.

Comment on this

Everybody learns from this. I know all this is not specifically within the chapter but I hope it is relevant to what is a very big Vote. I thank the witnesses for responding in the way they have.

I have two very quick questions. I am coming from the position of small businesses and their use of the PAYE any time application. A small farmer may have one employee and the accounts cost €1,000 if they are done by an agent. With the PAYE process, he or she must input a weekly payment. It could be another small business, such as a shop. No matter who the accountant is, he or she could charge €20 per week for this. That means it costs €1,000 for this individual with one employee, meaning accountancy fees have doubled. If a business only has two employees, could this be done monthly? It would save inputting for very small businesses. I know the Revenue Commissioners are trying to get real-time and live information but how is this affecting the small guy?

I have a more global question on corporation tax and the mood music from the OECD, including proposals on treatment of multinational digital companies and how they are taxed. This is the minimum effective rate of corporation tax on all companies in all jurisdictions. Have the Revenue Commissioners carried out any calculations on how that would affect the corporation tax yield?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I am smiling as the Deputy said he had two quick questions but the last question could be the subject of a committee meeting all on its own.

The Deputy spoke about PAYE modernisation and the requirement to provide real-time information. The positive reaction to this has been really interesting. Small businesses have moved to payroll software and this is a really competitive sector. Some of the providers do this for free. I know one that does it if there are fewer than two employees in a company, for example.

We have also provided a facility for the really small companies which do not use any payroll software to enter the amounts themselves through the ROS system. The costs that people anticipated this time last year have not really been borne out. I am aware that some agents have got out of that work because of the burden it imposes, while others have decided to get more into it. When we looked at PAYE modernisation one of the aspects that is often neglected in the debate is that there are obligations on employers with regard to payslips under employment law. All we have done is to capture the submission of that detail. Sometimes I have seen representations being made by various bodies and commentators who seem to ignore the fact that an employee has entitlements and rights. All we are doing is capturing the reporting of that.

This time last year one of my big worries was how PAYE modernisation would have worked, but it has been a phenomenal success. It has provided a basis for improved policy making. We will publish a detailed report next April on what we have learned. I am aware that the Central Statistics Office is quite excited about what it can do with it. I believe it has been a hugely positive development for employees. Reference was made to trying to ensure people get the right credits. The facility people will have in January to review their tax affairs with no need to ring us or contact us will be one of the transformational change programmes.

On the corporation tax-----

Comment on this

Will we get an insight into the reports?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It will be very easy for a person to claim expenses that he or she is entitled to. It also opens up all sorts of opportunities, in time, for us to review in-year claims, such as health expenses, and how we integrate real-time claims. This may require some legislative change. My Department of Finance colleagues might be saying "He should stop talking about things like that", but it does open up opportunities.

On corporation tax, proposals are under way at OECD level. Pilar 1 is around the nature of where the taxation applied. Pillar 2 is around a potential minimum effective rate. These proposals are at varying degrees of development. The OECD has just recently completed a consultation on Pillar 1, and a consultation on Pillar 2 is ongoing. At the finance committee we have highlighted potential range with some elements of it, but it is very hard, or nearly impossible, to have estimates on Pillar 2 because nobody knows yet what policy decisions will be taken or the timing of that. When we do know this I am sure the finance committee will be talking to us and we will talk about it again at this committee also.

Comment on this

I appreciate Mr. Cody's response, and I am aware that everything is not contained in the reports. I thank the team and the Chairman's office for responding back to parliamentary colleagues; it is a very effective and efficient service.

Comment on this

I let that session run a little bit longer because Mr. Cody was giving information the public would welcome by hearing the various issues. I let it run on on that basis.

Comment on this

Cuirim fáilte roimh na finnéithe agus roimh an gcothromaíocht inscne, atá ag feabhsú an t-am go léir. Mr. Cody has a voice that lulls silence. I thank him for all of his work, and all of the documentation, which I welcome and which I have read. I welcome the gender equality, but it is not reflected in top management. I see we have three wise men in charge. The management is still predominantly male. I make this comment on every organisation. Revenue's number is way up in terms of the percentage, which is interesting. I believe that 62% of staff is female, but this figure is not reflected in management. These are my preliminary comments.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The Deputy has spoken to me previously about this. Revenue has an interesting story to tell around the progression of that percentage, and I always preface this remark by saying that my predecessor was Ms Josephine Feehily, so we were-----

Comment on this

Very good, and maybe we will get the story in a written form through the Chairman so I can ask my questions. I would appreciate the story.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

We are now at 50/50 at principal officer level. That figure was 23% female in 2013.

Comment on this

I saw that, but I looked at the annual report for 2018 and certainly at assistant secretary level it is not.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It is now at 33%.

Comment on this

The photo does not do the figures justice. The men jump out. In any event-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Next year's photo will show a lot more colour.

Comment on this

I also welcome that the day started positively with Revenue asking to help us to get money back, which was very nice. It was a touch of class this morning to wake up and hear that interview. Well done on that, and well done on the audit. Revenue has got a clean audit. There are, however, just a number of issues around procurement. Of course, Revenue is sorting that out, but does this mean that this time next year there will be no issues around procurement at the scale they are?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

At any particular time-----

Comment on this

There are various faults-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

We are sometimes dependent on frameworks. We are also dependent on the State warehouse, which had to be re-tendered.

Comment on this

Why was that? Revenue then did the re-tendering process itself and was successful. What was the difference?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

We are dealing with a very specialised contract in which, with the benefit of hindsight, we probably should have done-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The State warehouse is where we store seized product, be it cigarettes, drugs or vehicles.

Comment on this

These are seized products, not documents.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

No. During our previous attendance at the committee we spoke about tobacco. If we seize 40,000 cigarettes, for example, that seizure is stored in the State warehouse pending court action. We must retain it.

Comment on this

It is very important that it is stored properly.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It is also a highly secure operation.

Comment on this

Why did Revenue not do this in the first place?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

With policy on public procurement, the Office of Government Procurement, OGP, was set up for a reason across the Civil Service. At the time, it was probably the first renewal of the warehouse contract. The OGP generally runs the public procurement process. In hindsight, Revenue probably should have run it at the start,

Comment on this

In the chapter that applies to Revenue and the recommendations, there are a number of very helpful case studies in the Comptroller and Auditor General's report. Case study B looks at the "delay in case due to complex issue". I believe it was an inordinate delay, and it is set out on page 283. While there were no specific recommendations in the conclusion relating to that case, issues were highlighted in the chapter on that case. A significant sum of money is involved - €113 million as the assessment and €10 million was the settlement. The case went from 2009 to 2018. In February 2012 "Revenue wrote to the company", and again in April 2012, which was not too long of a delay. The next letters, however, were in October 2012 and June 2014. There is a huge gap there. I am not cribbing over a month or two but the correspondence gap then goes from October 2012 to June 2014. There was also a change of case worker. I read the chapter. What processes has Revenue put in place to ensure this will not happen or how will it be minimised?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

In my opening remarks I said that this case started back before our Revenue case-management system was developed.

The process will be supported by the Revenue case management system far more. That has all the documentation in it. In that period when the delay took place, there was significant engagement with counsel to seek a legal opinion. This was a highly technical issue.

Comment on this

I saw all of that. I do not mean to be unfair to Mr. Cody but I have read it and looked at it. What processes are now in place to ensure that does not happen or that if it does happen it is reasonable?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The recommendations of the 2012 report in chapter 27 dealt with some of these issues. There is a series of six multistage recommendations in chapter 27 of the 2012 report-----

Comment on this

They have all been implemented.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

-----and they have all been implemented. One of the big areas is to have a quality assurance process. That process is multilayered under the management of the team. That is why I have my colleagues from the planning division here. We have a centralised review of the quality assurance process.

Comment on this

Let me relate that to this. With the new system in place, it would not happen that we would jump from October 2012 to June 2014 without somebody checking back.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Absolutely.

Comment on this

That type of gap and approach is not happening now.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I would be disappointed if such a gap could manifest itself. I would not be surprised if we had cases in which there were compliance interventions that will be long but that gap would not be there.

Comment on this

I understand that, given the complexity. I want to see a process that looks at that complexity and does not see gaps. I was tempted to start by asking if there is anything we should know, given the occurrence of printer gate. I am being smart, but are there any issues with storage or anything?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

If the Deputy wants me to talk about printers, I will.

Comment on this

No Christmas cards.

Comment on this

On that matter, the process is now in place, Revenue has looked at that and Mr. Cody would not expect there would ever be a gap again because there were gaps in the documentation on Revenue's interaction with the agent. Although Revenue had told the Comptroller and Auditor General that conversations were had, there was no documentation.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Yes. The 2012 report highlighted a number of these recommendations and we have improved it. One of the positive things from the review by the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General that I found reassuring is that most of the cases would have been reviewed in the last three to four years and the report was clear about the cases that were reviewed and about the documentation involved in the process. We were reassured by that because the Comptroller and Auditor General has full access to all our material-----

Comment on this

I will stop Mr. Cody there. I heard what he told me and I accept it. That leads into the recommendations as well because that was a case of self-disclosure. The Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General brought the concern to Revenue's attention in case B.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

In the expression of doubt process. It is a legal provision.

Comment on this

It leads into one of the conclusions where the analysis of companies or people bringing concerns, doubts or worries to the attention of Revenue and Revenue doing a risk analysis. There were two recommendations. One recommendation was to break that down. Is Revenue doing that?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

As I said in my opening statement, we have accepted both recommendations-----

Comment on this

But where is Revenue with those recommendations?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

In our case management system, we recognise whether the source of the disclosure-----

Comment on this

Is the individual or company.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

When we come to our annual report next year and when we publish our summary documentation on our results, that is where-----

Comment on this

Is that data not vital to help Revenue determine its risk assessment and where it goes?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

We have it in our systems.

Comment on this

But not in Revenue's reporting.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

When we publish the total numbers of our interventions, we will look at breaking that down.

Comment on this

To find the source of where it started?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Yes, but from the point of view of reviewing our risk analysis systems, we will respond. If there is a voluntary disclosure that suggests this might arise in other cases, we build that into our risk analysis system.

Comment on this

Revenue is accepting that recommendation and we will see progress next year on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Yes.

Comment on this

The second recommendation is interesting as well. It is on the tax, penalties and interest assessed and the liability, the settlement and the money received. Is that happening?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Yes. We have all that information and we publish it.

Comment on this

I understand that but it should be made available.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

In the current publication list the Deputy will see we show tax that is collected and tax that is not collected. We have no problem with that recommendation whatsoever.

Comment on this

It recommends specifically to report the difference between the tax assessed and the tax settled for and collected.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

That is not a problem.

Comment on this

I have a few more practical questions. Table 13 in the annual report on page 88 is interesting. It is entitled: "Audit and Compliance Intervention Activity". It details that the number of interventions are down but the yield is up. Talk me through that.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

This goes to the heart of what we are trying to do. Our systems are based on risk so we are constantly evolving our risk analysis system, our risk evaluation analysis and profiling, REAP, system and the various other subsets of REAP. We are trying to identify cases where there are errors, mistakes and evasion so that we target our resources on those cases. It is interesting that our overall numbers are down, as the Deputy rightly says, and the average yield is up, which we find reassuring in that it suggests our targeting is improving. The last time I was here we were talking about the realignment of the organisation and we talked about high wealth individuals. We are trying to realign the organisation to increase the resources dedicated to dealing with larger, more complex and wealthier cases, which take a lot longer to settle and deal with because they are more complicated. Last Friday, there was an article in the Irish Independent reporting on a Tax Appeals Commission determination of a case that was essentially ongoing since 2005. The determination by the Tax Appeals Commission was published on its website. It is 95 pages long. We have spoken before about the Tax Appeals Commission and the information covered in the Tax Appeals Commission determinations involve some of the most positive and important developments in tax administration. It would be positive if people could read and try to understand the complexity of some of the stuff we are dealing with. As we go on, the numbers of interventions will probably continue to go down. We would like to get to a stage, although we never will get there, that the yield would start to go down as well because that would suggest voluntary compliance is correct but I am not naïve enough to think we will ever get to that stage.

Comment on this

It is fair to say the vast majority of people are tax compliant.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I say that every time I come here.

Comment on this

That jumps off the pages. The work of Revenue is in a small area with a high yield, therefore. The vast majority of people pay their taxes and have no difficulty in doing so.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I said in my opening statement and we say it every time that we have high rates of timely compliance. There is another part of tax compliance as tax can be complicated and errors are made. Not all our recoveries happen because somebody has set out not to comply.

Comment on this

On that matter, how much money is due back to people?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

People are entitled to claim repayments and credits under the law-----

Comment on this

It is a detailed report. I reviewed it but did not see a figure for what has been given back. There are timelines for dealing with the case or applications but I did not see a figure for the sum. Whoever did the interview earlier mentioned a high figure for one of the years.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

On the issue this morning, we were talking about an initiative we first did in-----

Comment on this

What is due back? The figure was mentioned but I have forgotten it.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The figure mentioned this morning was about €27 million-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

For a particular year for a category of taxpayers. We try to make it as easy as possible for people to claim their entitlements-----

Comment on this

The €27 million was paid back in the year mentioned.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Absolutely, but there are repayments and they are outlined in the accounts. We repay something like €10 billion per year in the various taxes, although that sum is off the top of my head and cannot be confirmed until the figures come up for the Revenue accounts.

Comment on this

€10 billion.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Yes, including VAT refunds, corporation tax and income tax. We try to ensure that people can claim it as quickly as possible. If we know they are entitled to it, we automatically provide it, but we cannot know if someone is entitled to tax back on health expenses because we will not know if he or she has health expenses until he or she claims it.

Comment on this

On the changes, Revenue took on board our recommendation that the threshold reduce to €20 million. Mr. Cody pointed out in his opening statement that it led to an additional 446 cases under that reduction. What is the status of that?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It is implemented. Since I was here last, we carried out a subsequent review of the case base, because we always try to ensure that the right cases are in the right place. Our high-wealth individuals division, HWID, is in place and the case base is subject to review by the people in that division. We increased our resources to deal with that division and it is an ongoing process.

Comment on this

The figure I mentioned was actually in Mr. Cody's briefing document. He referred to an additional 475 cases as a result of the change. What yield does Mr. Cody expect from that? It might be the wrong question to ask.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It is an impossible question to answer because most of the people dealt with by the HWID are tax compliant and pay the correct taxes. Their affairs are much more complicated than the Deputy's or mine. We want to ensure there are appropriate assurance programmes to ensure that timely compliance. It is a managed-----

Comment on this

The worry for the ordinary person is the perception that the wealthier a person is, the more he or she will get away with it.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It is important to state there is no evidence to suggest that any category of taxpayer is more susceptible to non-paying. In the case of people dealt with by our HWID, their compliance and the levels of money they pay are positive.

Comment on this

My final question concerns Airbnb and the related, rental sector. I have re-examined Revenue's annual report. On page 89 of the report, various sectoral intervention results are outlined. In the rental category, the number of audits or investigations was 326, yielding €12.83 million. Did that cover Airbnb?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Airbnb is an interesting area. The interventions covered on page 89 are general rental income. That covers the broad rental sector, and every year we will have audit and risk interventions in the rental sector. In respect of short-term letting and so on, it is not any individual company. Over the past few years, we have written to all the people in receipt of short-term rental income-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Yes. First, we did a risk assessment of the categories and identified individual cases with income in excess of €30,000 where it did not appear that the amounts had been returned.

Comment on this

In the rental sector generally in 2018.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

In the short-term rental sector.

Comment on this

Revenue wrote to 12,000 people.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Yes, but first we looked at it and identified those cases that had rental income in excess of €30,000. We are reviewing them and they are subject to interventions. For the 12,000 other people, we wrote to them and said we understood they were in receipt of rental income, and outlined the rules and how the money could be returned. That project will be evaluated as the returns are filed, and we will report on it.

Comment on this

Is there a closing date or deadline?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It ties in with the filing date on the returns. I was talking to Deputy Burke about filing on ROS two weeks ago.

Comment on this

I welcome Mr. Cody and his team, and thank them for their professionalism and the work they do, which is always to a first-class standard, as I have previously noted. I have some questions on corporation tax receipts. I am sure Mr. Cody noted the report of the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council published earlier. Before I turn to that, I wish to re-examine chapter 17 of the Comptroller and Auditor General's special report that dealt with tax compliance interventions. It refers to an overview of compliance interventions, an effective compliance regime and how that is essential to the integrity of the tax system, which is based on the principle of "Trust but test". It outlines self-assessment compliance in some areas and what that regime involves. How important is compliance to the tax system?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The tax system is strongly based on a system of voluntary compliance. That is the structure of a self-assessment system, with an obligation on taxpayers to file and pay their returns on time. There is a great onus on us to make it as simple as possible, provide as much information as possible and build in safeguards to ensure that the right tax is paid at the right time. We have two pillars, namely, a service to support compliance and another to deal with non-compliance. We make it as easy as possible to pay and we have a risk-based system to review what is paid. We have a suite of interventions to review and try to ensure that taxpayers pay the right tax at the right time.

Comment on this

How seriously does Revenue take non-compliance with tax rules?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It is our bread and butter-----

Comment on this

It is serious. Revenue has a sharp focus on and keen interest in non-compliance.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Yes, and we pay close attention to everything that goes on across the community and to any evidence of non-compliance discussed by the committee. We tackle non-compliance to the best of our ability and hope we achieve that. We take a range of interventions and action.

Comment on this

My point is that non-compliance with tax rules is serious and it is a serious part of Revenue's work.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Absolutely.

Comment on this

I turn to page 8 of the appropriation accounts for 2018. What is the first subhead on the page?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The non-compliance with procurement rules.

Comment on this

Why is there non-compliance with procurement? Mr. Cody stated compliance with tax rules is important, but compliance with procurement rules is equally important.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Absolutely.

Comment on this

What does it mean if the Office of the Revenue Commissioners, in particular, is non-compliant with procurement rules?

We are shining a spotlight on it because it is important. It is part of our work to do so. As I understand it from the accounts presented, there are four contracts. I ask Mr. Cody to elaborate on each contract and the reason for the non-compliance, starting with the contract of €2.141 million relating to security. What is the context in that regard?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

We had a range of contracts on security across various buildings and areas across the organisation. We wanted to review all our security contracts and pull them together into one contract to cover the organisation as a whole. Unfortunately, the review and the delay in finalising our requirement took longer than we would have liked. This meant there was a delay which led to-----

Comment on this

Was that delay as a consequence of a lack of planning on the part of the office? In other words, was the non-compliance based on the rules being too rigid, the framework not being as clear as it needed to be or simply because not enough attention was paid to the timeframe?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The review took longer than we anticipated.

Comment on this

So it was a mistake.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Yes, it was a mistake. I would much prefer that we had not been found to be non-compliant with any provision.

Comment on this

The next contract was for €1.037 million relating to warehousing contracts. What was the reason for non-compliance in regard to this contract?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

We discussed the State warehouse review already with Deputy Connolly. State warehousing is not normal warehousing. The original tender was run through the Office of Government Procurement, OGP. That tender was unsuccessful. We then had to run the tender and review ourselves, which accounts for the delay. It was better that we stopped the process and started it again and got the proper contract in place.

Comment on this

The next contract is for €765,000 relating to various services, including mobile telephone and fuel cards. When outlining the reason for the non-compliance in this instance, Mr. Cody might elaborate on the fuel cards and to whom they are given.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The fuel cards are issued in respect of official vehicles.

Comment on this

Do staff members have fuel cards?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

No. They are issued in respect of customs enforcement vehicles. No individual has a personal fuel card to cover their-----

Comment on this

I am not suggesting any person would have one for personal use. Obviously, it would be for work purposes.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Yes.

Comment on this

These are fuel cards for employees-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I would rather it be recorded that they are fuel cards for our official vehicles.

Comment on this

I have no problem with that. What was the reason for the non-compliance?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I have a detailed note on this matter. I do not want to blame the OGP for not having a framework in place if it did for this contract. The framework expired on 31 January 2018. The contract went to tender in November 2017. There was a delay in the OGP framework being put in place. We could not pull down the contract because there was no contract in place. This accounted for some of the delay. When the OGP framework is put in place, we draw down from it. I am aware of recent commentary on this issue. In some cases, the OGP framework is not in place such that a temporary interim measure has to be put in place to deal with that.

Comment on this

That information is helpful. What we are hearing today is that in some cases where there is non-compliance it is because the OGP does not have the frameworks in place in time for Revenue to be able to avail of them. In other instances, mistakes are made or there is a lack of planning on behalf of, say, Revenue, or a particular Department. This is not a huge issue. In the context of Revenue's overall spend, by and large, its compliance with public procurement rules is strong. That said-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

We are serious about it.

Comment on this

That is my point. Of all of the Departments, the Office of the Revenue Commissioners is the most important in terms of full compliance with procurement rules. If there are issues with the frameworks, that is a separate matter beyond Mr. Cody's control. In matters that are within his control, we would want to see compliance tightened up.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I knew the committee was interested in this area so in the briefing material provided last Friday, we set out details on the particulars. I have even more information that we have no difficulty making available to the committee.

Comment on this

That would be helpful. We are doing a piece of work in respect of which it would be important.

On the corporation tax receipts, am I correct in my reading of the Revenue receipts for 2018 that corporation tax receipts was €11.442 billion?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It is €11.442 billion gross. There is a net figure also. Approximately €1 billion is repaid such that the net figure is-----

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

It is €10.38 billion.

Comment on this

That is the net figure.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Yes.

Comment on this

How many companies pay corporation tax in this State? Does Mr. Cody that have information to hand?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Last April, in conjunction with our annual report, we published a report on corporation tax, CT, in detail, inclusive of corporation tax 2018 payments and 2017 returns. In 2018, 55,400 companies paid CT.

Comment on this

What percentage of the overall net corporation tax receipt were paid by the top ten or top 20 companies?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The ten largest payers paid 45% of CT in 2018.

Comment on this

Revenue has a role in regard to the collection of taxes. Mistakes were made in the past leading up to the collapse of the economy and during the Celtic tiger era. There were also problems in the banking system that led to fiscal problems, in response to which adjustments had to be made. Another one of the ingredients of the collapse was an overdependence on consumption taxes. There were a number of different factors to it. We hope that lessons were learned. The Irish Fiscal Advisory Council has raised the concern that much of the spending now is based on unsustainable corporation tax receipts and that we are essentially exposed in some respects, in that a small number of companies pay almost half of the corporation taxes. Does Revenue have a role in terms of having an eye to the sustainability of tax or is that a matter for others? One of the critiques of the State organisations as a consequence of the crash, be that the Department of Finance, economists or watchdogs, as well as Revenue or the Central Bank of Ireland, was that organisations were asleep at the wheel. I am assuming that Revenue is not asleep at the wheel and that it has an eye to this issue but does it have a remit in this area or is a matter for others? Does Revenue review the overall tax receipts from a sustainability perspective?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

In the context of tax receipts and forecasts, Revenue supports the Department of Finance. We provide our detailed knowledge of company level developments. In the context of the budget estimates and forecasting, we engage with the large multinationals and large Irish companies on what they anticipate will be the position for the following year.

Since 2015, we have been publishing an annual report on corporation tax receipts to provide as much information as possible to facilitate the discussions about which the Deputy is talking. The aggregate data underlying all of our information is available to the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council. It has access to our figures and if-----

Comment on this

To give some context, Mr. Coffey, head of the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council, was saying that there were warnings that the Government should not be over-reliant on corporation tax and that receipts were as likely to go up as to go down. He said that the top ten contributors were paying 45% to 55% of overall tax receipts and that the money is spent almost as soon as it comes in. He said there is a difficulty in basing spending on unreliable corporation tax receipts. That is the council's analysis. Does Revenue share that analysis? Will Mr. Cody offer an opinion on that analysis?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Our role is to collect taxes and duties.

Comment on this