Chapter 18 - Tax relief on film production
Contributions 194–393 of 594. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
That is what I asked at the start. I asked if Revenue had a role in this respect and Mr. Cody said that Revenue does give advice to the Department of Finance.
Comment on this
We support the Department in the preparation of the Estimates. I spoke about this last year. What we have tried to do is put as much information as possible into the public domain to enable people, including the fiscal council, the ESRI and this committee, to analyse the data. We do not, however, have a role in determining what corporation tax receipts are likely to be in three or four years' time.
Comment on this
I am not trying to get Mr. Cody to say something he does not want to say. That is not my purpose in asking this question. The report the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council has published is very important. It is one of the main news items today because it is something on which people now put more focus because of what happened in the crash. All I am saying is that, if the council is warning that there is a danger in basing spending on tax receipts which may be unsustainable, surely Revenue has to have some view on whether this revenue is sustainable or not. That is what I am asking. We do not want to see something, either foreseen or unforeseen depending on how one looks at it, happening, such as some of these corporations leaving for whatever reason, resulting in reduced corporation tax receipts and adjustments having to be made. We do not want it to be the case that nobody is to blame because nobody had a role. Surely Revenue has to have some opinion as to whether these receipts are sustainable.
Comment on this
I cannot say whether they are sustainable. We have put out specific information about what the top ten pay. We have put this information out for the last four or five years. We have provided the analysis. A really concentrated level of corporation tax is paid by a small number of companies. Some 77% of corporation tax receipts were paid by foreign-owned multinationals. It is concentrated and, as we discussed earlier, there are significant international developments with regard to multinational tax. That will play out over the coming years. There have been significant changes with regard to base erosion and profit shifting. It is a volatile figure. I would certainly be very careful if I was in a position different from my own.
Comment on this
My time is nearly up but I have just one more question. I thank Mr. Cody for his response. With regard to corporation tax receipts he is essentially saying that, when Revenue puts out this information, it shows that tax received is concentrated in a small number of companies. That speaks for itself. It speaks volumes. With regard to companies which do not pay corporation tax, how many companies pay zero corporation tax? If he has the figures, could Mr. Cody provide the committee with a breakdown of the total number of companies that are eligible to pay corporation tax and how much they pay, perhaps divided into bands from €1 million upwards? That has already been-----
Comment on this
It is published. Okay. How many do not pay any tax? In what document are these figures found?
Comment on this
It is titled "Corporation Tax 2018 Payments and 2017 Returns". The link to the document was provided to the committee secretariat last Friday along with------
Comment on this
That is perfect. Does it cover the number of companies that do not pay corporation tax or which have 0% liability?
Comment on this
No. Most of the companies who do not pay tax do not have a tax liability because they have not made a profit.
Comment on this
Do we know how many such companies there are?
Comment on this
If the Deputy will give me a few moments to find the table-----
Comment on this
Mr. Cody can come back to us on it because I know other Deputies want to get in.
Comment on this
We will move on. Perhaps somebody can get that figure. I want to let Deputy Catherine Murphy in.
Comment on this
It is in the documentation. The documentation also includes, very importantly, the detail of how much is paid by these companies in payroll taxes. That is often overlooked. A significant amount of payroll taxes are paid by those companies because, by and large, their employees are better paid than employees of small indigenous Irish companies.
Comment on this
That was as a result of a long discussion with me.
Comment on this
The average pay of an employee with a multinational was close to €80,000. It is much lower in Irish businesses.
Comment on this
Correspondingly, the level of PAYE paid in multinational companies was very high. We will get the link to that document. I thank Mr. Cody. Will he come back with that information? He can give it now if he has it. I will then call on Deputy Catherine Murphy.
Comment on this
With regard to the tax returns for 2017, there were 164,000 companies. Some 101,000 of those had no liability for that year. Most of these are small Irish indigenous companies. Some are only starting up. There were 124 companies with corporation tax liabilities of more than €8 million. We use ranges including nil, €1,000 to €20,000, and €5 million to €8 million. It is all on page 23 of the report.
Comment on this
Out of curiosity, does the book cover the total number of individual taxpayers in the system and the number of them who have zero liability for tax, perhaps also divided into bands? This report deals only with corporation tax but is it covered in other annual reports?
Comment on this
When we published our annual report last April, we published six detailed supplementary reports. Earlier I spoke about what we are going to publish with regard to the information we have got from PAYE modernisation. When we publish our annual report, we will publish a detailed analysis of wages, pay, taxes and pensions across the country.
Comment on this
I have just worked out the percentages in my head and 62% of companies have no liability for corporation tax. Does the report tell us why? Can Mr. Cody furnish the committee with that information?
Comment on this
The data may be there but I am seeking the rationale and the reason.
Comment on this
Absolutely, but the data will show, for example, the number of companies carrying losses forward or which did not have an income. If there is-----
Comment on this
We should have read the report. Is that what Mr. Cody is saying?
Comment on this
There is probably more in that report than-----
Comment on this
I will have a look before the day is out.
Comment on this
I wish everyone a good afternoon. A bugbear of mine was mentioned. I know that these companies provide employment but it is the employees who pay the-----
Comment on this
I am very conscious that it is the employees. That is one of the reasons we were so keen to modernise the PAYE system. Employees are entitled to know that tax has been paid on their behalf. That has often been missed in the debate.
Comment on this
I may come back to corporation tax in a few minutes but I want to ask a few quick general questions on Revenue's accounts. In 2018 there were three cases of misappropriation of tax by employees of the Revenue Commissioners. How was the discovered? Was it referred to the Garda? Perhaps Mr. Cody will outline the details of that case. What was the outcome? Was any of the money recovered?
Comment on this
If the Deputy will bear with me for a moment, I have a note on this matter.
Misappropriation was identified in three cases. This is something we take very seriously. It is a rare occurrence because Revenue staff are very serious about what they do. Unfortunately, in any organisation people sometimes do things they should not, for various and sometimes sad reasons. We have audit systems in place all our internal IT systems, including monitoring and review and audit controls. As one can imagine, any organisation-----
Comment on this
Is that how this was-----
Comment on this
That is how it is detected. Three cases led to people leaving Revenue, all of which were referred to the Garda. We are very serious and have zero tolerance for any abuse of public money.
Comment on this
Was any of the money recovered?
Comment on this
Some was recovered and some is being recovered on an ongoing basis.
Comment on this
I am very conscious that Revenue staff pay attention to what goes on at this committee, just as the public does. One must consider the level of cases Revenue staff deal with. I cannot speak strongly enough of how positively I view our staff.
Comment on this
The fact that this is included in these accounts and is in the public domain identifies and acknowledges that Revenue takes this very seriously.
Corporation taxes, CTs, are up by 22%. An official from the Department of Finance was before this committee a few years ago when there was a very large increase in corporation taxes. In that case, it was to do with the onshoring of some of the-----
Comment on this
Yes. That official was not sure why the amount had increased by so much. An increase of 22% appears to be very high. Does that consist of additional companies, increased profits, or something else? Can Mr. Cody identify one or more big ticket items which would explain that increase?
Comment on this
The original big spike of 26% occurred in 2015. In November 2015 I wrote to the Minister to highlight our analysis of the situation at that stage. We followed that up with the first of our reviews of corporation tax receipts for 2015, which we published in April 2016. We have continued to publish such reports. That is this report Deputy Cullinane and I discussed, which tries to analyse the figures. The challenge is that the corporation tax returns for 2018 are filed in 2019. The payments we receive in 2018 mostly relate to preliminary tax, and until we get the returns we cannot do the detailed analysis. This report profiles CT payments in 2018. The main feature of CT payments in 2018 was that CT receipts from large corporates increased by €1.9 billion.
Comment on this
That would have been the bulk of it.
Comment on this
The big chunk related to companies dealt with by our large corporate division. This is why we have a large corporate division.
Comment on this
Did those companies have a particular profile?
Comment on this
Foreign-owned multinationals paid 77% of the CT.
Comment on this
Were they within a certain sector, such as ICT or pharmaceuticals?
Comment on this
The largest sector in payment terms was manufacturing, which accounted for 31% of the net receipts. Receipts from financial and insurance services, which was the largest sector in 2017, fell during 2018 despite the overall increase in receipts. Over 55,000 companies paid CT in 2018 and the number of net payers increased by 5,000. The total trading profits in 2017 were €159 billion, which was an increase of €238 million on the previous year. Around 25,000 companies used losses in 2017. A certain amount of companies which have used up their losses and did not pay the previous year are paying now. The report is on the screen and the detail is in that report. On 30 April next year we will be publishing the updated report on those figures as well as any other reports we have ready. Over the last four years, we have tried to make as much information available as is possible while having regard to taxpayer confidentiality.
Comment on this
I will move on to a few other issues. While the representatives from the Department are here, I wish to ask them about the film industry. The alternative employment test is one of the tests that satisfies whether or not there is a qualification. I appreciate that the film industry brings other benefits besides employment, such as showcasing the country and encouraging spending in the country. If that is one of the criteria, how can one apply that test if there is no definition of what constitutes quality employment? Is the Department fully taking on board such a definition is required and, if so, when will it be in place?
Comment on this
The Department welcomes the report by the Comptroller and Auditor General and has accepted its recommendations. Substantial changes have been made to the regulations in 2019 in the context of quality employment. Members are probably aware of discussions taking place in the Oireachtas more generally. We have set a standard around compliance with all employment legislation. We have also significantly upgraded the training regime to a skills development and training regime. For larger projects, that is done in consultation with Screen Skills Ireland, which is the skills development branch of Screen Ireland. There have been significant changes.
Comment on this
Presumably the longevity of projects is set out and included in that.
Comment on this
Absolutely. We capture data at the application stage on each role, the number of days and so on. All that information is gathered. The issue was raised by the Comptroller and Auditor General in relation to data generally. In the first quarter of next year the European Audiovisual Observatory will hold a workshop on these matters at a European level, in which we intend to participate. Similar challenges around capturing good data on the audiovisual and film sectors are being faced in other jurisdictions. We want to participate in that process and ensure Irish practices reflect best practice.
Comment on this
Employment can be very tenuous in this area. We want to ensure we get quality projects which will deliver good employment.
Comment on this
Ensuring a strategic approach has been a significant focus of our efforts over the past 12 months, in partnership with the Department of Finance and the Revenue Commissioners and in the context of the Government's audiovisual action plan. Quality employment and compliance with the employment legislation must be at the heart of everything we do. We also want to ensure our training and skills development regime is of very good, high-end quality.
Comment on this
What about the timelines?
Comment on this
The requirement for data compliance is in the new regulations. Participation in data-related activity will take place in the first quarter of 2020. We will see what emerges from that.
Comment on this
We might look at that again next year. I will return to Mr. Cody on ICT, which was the second-largest item. We are probably more acutely aware of what that might contain following our own experience with a printer here. I note that €56.8 million is an awful lot of money. I know Revenue is a very big organisation and it is highly regarded for its efficiency. I can see how ICT would help Revenue in targeting. What is the breakdown of the spend? Is it human resources, is it one-off or ongoing maintenance? What is the profile?
Comment on this
Our organisation is dependent on two main planks, our people and our ICT systems. Everything is computerised. We have ongoing expenditure on computer development, maintenance and enhancement year on year. Our ICT division has about 350 or 360 people working on ICT developments and there are external companies which work with us in partnership.
Comment on this
Does the €56 million include payroll for ICT?
Comment on this
No. It does not include payroll for our staff, but it does for our external partners.
Comment on this
What kind of component was the external side?
Comment on this
In 2018, about €35 million was spend on external ICT resources and about €16 million related to licensing and maintenance costs to cover software.
Comment on this
Was there a change in the licensing regime? Was there an upgrade?
Comment on this
We have a whole layer of different software products. Some require licensing and some do not. All the external ICT resources are run through proper compliance with procurement. There is a multi-vendor strategy which was enacted.
Comment on this
Was there anything unusual in the €56 million in a big spend during the year?
Comment on this
We have this level of expenditure every year. It is ongoing. I spoke about PAYE modernisation. That started work in 2016 and went live in January 2019. The overall investment to develop our PAYE modernisation system was just under €29 million to date.
Comment on this
On non-audit interventions, Revenue uses its ICT section in addition to its human resources to identify areas that are possibly non-compliant. Were there particular sectors that were targeted in that year? Are they the usual suspects or was there anything different?
Comment on this
We report on the basic trade sectors or sectors in which we have our audit settlements. I spoke to Deputy Connolly about the rental piece. We have an ongoing risk profile system where there is a reoccurrence of, say, cash-type businesses, as well as the construction sector. Every year, we may have special projects. For instance, I was here some years ago when we discussed medical consultants.
Comment on this
Was there anything in this year like that?
Comment on this
There was the continuation of the medical consultants. There is a project under way around locum doctors. We are constantly engaged in the construction sector, and that is something every year. A specific project that is very timely and topical is our focus on gaming and amusement machines, which is a kind of multi-intervention as some of it relates to licensing of gaming machines but also audit yield for non-compliance with tax and employee liability.
Comment on this
The ratio of payout would be known there.
Comment on this
There is a real challenge. I know legislation is before the Houses on the whole gaming and gambling sector. Unfortunately, it is an area that, because legislation has not been updated and modernised, people seem to think that Revenue is the sole regulator of the sector but we have a limited role in relation to licensing. We are very conscious that we have that role. I would be very happy if legislation was enacted to modernise the whole area and we could concentrate on the elements of the sector for which we are responsible.
Comment on this
We are on the cusp of the voting block in the Dáil so I will cut to the main topic I wish to discuss and try to finish before the division bells ring. I welcome the Chairman, as always. Earlier, he stated on flat rate allowances that because the Minister had written to Mr. Cody and Mr. Cody responded, and that the Revenue was leaving the matter awaiting a further response. The Minister put on the record of the Dáil that he had written to Revenue during questions to the Minister for Finance two weeks ago. He went further by stating why he had done so. He said he was simply seeking first, the number of employees impacted, second, the cost to Revenue and third, the benefit to each employee group so that he could have "a clearer understanding of the scale of [the] change that may ensue". He did not have to go to that bother as the Irish Independent had published a two-page special this time last year, breaking down exactly the number of employees by sector, using colourful graphs and the costs involved. This made me wonder why the Minister, who was at pains to say it was done at his arm's length and was purely Revenue's baby, is simultaneously writing to Revenue seeking information that the Irish Independent has published in graphic form. From a political perspective, I would suggest the Minister is trying to look as though he is concerned so he wrote to Mr. Cody. I cannot expect Mr. Cody to comment on the inference I have drawn from what I perceive to be a charade, I can ask him to comment on the Taoiseach's position, who was surprisingly blunt in his view when I questioned him in the Dáil on 17 September. I put it to him that there had been a backing away from the issue this time last year because of the intense media coverage. The Taoiseach responded:
This is a matter for the Revenue Commissioners, not the Government. However, I would be very happy if the [Revenue] just left matters as they stand.
That is some statement from the Head of Government saying that he would like the Revenue Commissioners to leave things as they are, while at the same time saying that he has nothing to do with it. Will the Chairman comment?
Comment on this
I pay close attention to what the Chairman says at the beginning of the committee's meetings each week because I pay attention to what goes on. Some of my colleagues wonder do I work on Thursday mornings at all. The Chairman talks about the things on which the witnesses are not supposed to comment.
I regularly watch, and everybody seems to forget this happens at the start. What I said earlier is that I have replied to the Minister and set out the details. The Deputy spoke about independently provided data. That was data provided in replies to parliamentary questions via the Minister. It does not have the full breakdown because we do not have the full breakdown of each category. What is on the public record for 2017 is that the estimated number of taxpayers who availed of flat rate allowances was just over 606,000. There were gross claims in the region of €160 million, equating to a tax cost of somewhere around €48 million. It is dependent on whether people are taxable or not and whether they are taxable at 20% or 40%. Part of the reason the Minister has written to us is that we have tried to improve the information we will capture from tax returns for 2018. That will not be available until we process those returns next year. We will have more granular detail.
There are a number of items in the review. Some categories will get an increase, admittedly a smaller number than those that will get a reduction. In some cases it would seem to us that sectors are no longer entitled to a flat rate expense. We have identified a number of areas. A number of issues were the subject of discussion on Committee Stage of the Finance Bill, for example, relief on trade union expenses, which was in place until 2010, and relief on professional fees, which was restricted in 2010. Many tax credits were reduced in 2010.
I have written back providing more comprehensive data to the Minister. It is now part of a correspondence and it would be wrong of me to discuss it as it is now the Minister's letter. I expect I will receive a reply early next week and I will then review where we are with it. We will then be very clear.
One thing we said this time last year is that we do not operate in a vacuum. Revenue operates within the community. We live within the community. We are very conscious of how to operate a system based on voluntary compliance and self assessment. Some people are probably entitled to more than the flat rate expense because they have probably spent more. A global figure is always difficult because sometimes it involves averaging. It is very important. Sometimes when I am before this committee I think about the fact that if people do not have the expenditure and do not spend money we cannot allow a credit. They may be engaged in some type of work where they would have had to incur that expenditure previously. If the Comptroller and Auditor General decided this was an area worth examining I would imagine, as accounting officer, that if credit was being given where it should not I would be dealing with a different issue. What we did undertake publicly was not to implement the change until we finalised the review of everybody. We did this for reasons of fairness. What we will do, as we always do, is reflect on what we receive from the Minister. We will make our decision and we will publish it and make it available.
Comment on this
The point on quantifying is interesting. It was analysed by Dr. Brian Keegan in The Sunday Business Post on 3 November under the headline "Taxing times ahead at TDs' clinics". I am sure Mr. Cody read it. On the point of quantifying the figure, again on the record, in response to a parliamentary question, the Minister said it is not possible to quantify accurately the anticipated increase in tax revenue arising out of any abolition or reduction.
I will skip to an individual issue pertaining to this because of how it is being addressed. Revenue is looking at a broad range of sectors that are impacted and I have read through the list of items being taken into consideration for flat rate allowances. I am interested in a particular sector, which is the mining sector. Only one mine is impacted by this, which is Tara Mines in my home town of Navan. It the largest zinc mine in Europe and employs 620 people. It is a primary industry. On the list, the mining industry has the second-highest allowance, second only to the RTÉ orchestras. It has been in operation for more than 40 years.
In his earlier statement, Mr. Cody said these allowances have been in place for a number of years. I have copies of correspondence going back to 1990 on all of the reviews that have taken place. The frustration is that going back over these 30 years the allowance was increased through engagement with Revenue and the mines but now there is genuine fear it could possibly be gone. I was interested to hear Mr. Cody say there could be increases within the review. As was raised earlier, I know the workers are due a wage increase in 2020 but this would be eroded if the allowance goes. The allowance for the mining industry is €1,312. Will Mr. Cody comment on this?
What is the process of the review? Mr Cody said the report to be published will be comprehensive. Earlier, he touched on the public consultation. I want to ask about this engagement with the unions. Mr. Cody and Mr. Tom Kiely in particular were very kind when I raised this matter last year. I have a letter from the Revenue to SIPTU pertaining to the miners. It is dated 26 January 2018 and sets out the nature of the allowance. Was anything beyond a desktop study done in respect of the review?
Comment on this
How a flat rate expense arises in the first place is that a representative body or trade union makes representations and provides detail of the expenses incurred to support the claim. We then review it. The Deputy is right that over a period of time various reviews led to increases in particular sectors. This time last year, we spoke about the mining allowance. The initial stage of the review, as we would expect in tax administration, was based on the higher amounts. This is the normal approach we take to a review of any sector. The representative body provides the documentation to support the claim and we review it, having regard to the legislation and subject to discussions and meetings with the various bodies. Changes would probably have been effected with regard to mining if we had proceeded last year because it was in one of the earlier reviews but no change will commence until it applies to everybody.
An issue that the Department and the Minister may wish to consider is that there are particular sectors in which the nature of the employment may be such that it is a policy determination whether a specific sector should be entitled to a particular credit, having regard to the nature of the activity it is engaged in. I am sure the Minister will reflect on this as a policy matter.
Comment on this
I would like to follow up on the interesting point that Mr. Cody has made. During my interaction with the Minister on Question Time in the Dáil Chamber two weeks ago, I asked about the desktop study for a very specific reason. Obviously, it is a very hot topic. The largest zinc mine in Europe, which employs 620 people, is in my home town. I told the Minister that I had travelled to the bottom of the mine to better inform myself and to be able to appreciate the concerns that are being raised. I was not being facetious in any respect when I invited the Minister to visit the mine. I extended the same invitation to Mr. Cody.
Comment on this
I did not feel I might get out of the mine that handy.
Comment on this
I ask Mr. Cody to trust me when I say that if I made it out, he would make it out. It is okay. I issued that invitation to the Minister and to Mr. Cody in the context of my query about whether this was a desktop study or whether those involved had actually been to this location. When a person who is doing a desktop study sees the list of allowances that are being claimed for, he or she might ask whether the conditions being faced by the workers warrant these types of claims. I am 41 years of age. I grew up right beside the mine. Until I went down into the mine, I had no appreciation of what the workers face and how it equates to what they are looking for. It takes an hour to go down to the deepest part of the mine, which is 900 m under the surface. It is the deepest underground spot in Ireland. The guys who are on shift work do not see daylight at this time of year. They go in when it is dark and they come out when it is dark. They have allowable claims for vitamin tablets, etc. They work in extremely hazardous conditions. There are escape pods at every point. If there is a collapse or a fire, the workers sit in the escape pods in the dark for 12 hours until someone comes to rescue them. The air down there is very thin. I knew when I came out of the mine that I had been through a harrowing experience. If there was something wrong with the mine from an employment perspective, there would be a line of politicians outside the gates speaking to the RTÉ cameras. It is quite proper from my point of view for me to pose an invitation to the Minister and to Mr. Cody. I make no apology for it. If the allowances available to the workers in the largest zinc mine in Europe are going to be changed, those involved in making that change should go to see the mine.
Comment on this
I am aware of the interaction between the Deputy and the Minister because I looked up the debate in question. We have to look at matters like this from the perspective of what is provided for in legislation. The legislation provides that employees may claim expenses where they are wholly, necessarily and exclusively incurred in the fulfilment of their duties. There is a significant body of case law. The question of hazardous conditions may well form the basis for a policy review of this issue. The case law under the "wholly, necessarily and exclusively" provision is very clear.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Cody intimating that that is where this should go? If so, it worries me. Potentially, there is a change coming. Is Mr. Cody intimating that the Minister should interject on a policy basis to protect the income of the workers? Am I able to draw that inference?
Comment on this
I did not intend to imply such an inference.
Comment on this
The issue is that we have to review on the basis of the legislation. I am not indicating what the outcome of any of the reviews will be. We look at expenses that are "wholly, necessarily and exclusively" incurred. We review them on that basis. I imagine that the conditions in the workplace about which the Deputy is speaking are very different from the normal conditions in which the vast majority of people work.
Comment on this
They are not comparable to the conditions in any of the other sectors out there.
Comment on this
Absolutely. I recognise that. In no way do I want to downplay the nature of the employment. We have to operate the tax code as provided by the Oireachtas. If we were to imply subjectivity in how we apply the tax code, it would be a very worrying development.
Comment on this
As a Member of the Oireachtas, I was not saying to the chairman of Revenue that it should be done subjectively. I was asking about the study that was being done to assess the tax code. I was looking at the application of the interpretation of the list I have in front of me. The Minister has said that it is a question of interpretation. That is why the invitation was extended. It was done on a genuine basis.
Comment on this
I invited the Minister and Mr. Cody to see the facility at first hand. Any review of any subject matter should involve looking at it at first hand to experience it.
Comment on this
We engage fully with the trade union involved. We implement the law as provided for, having regard to the tax code. That is what we are trying to achieve here. There are rafts of people in employment who have no flat-rate expenses because nobody ever made a representation. As part of the process of PAYE modernisation, from January 2020 our online system will be really effective in cases of people who incur allowable expenditure. If somebody feels that we are wrong in our interpretation of the tax code, it is open to him or her to appeal our determination of non-entitlement.
Comment on this
As some votes are about to be called in the Chamber, I propose that we suspend until 2.30 p.m. We are nearly there. The officials from the Department of Culture, Heritage and the Gaeltacht are free to go. If anything comes up, we will send a letter to them. If we need an answer to a query that arises, we can send on a letter.
Comment on this
We will continue our meeting with the Revenue Commissioners on the appropriation accounts for 2018, chapters 17 and 18 of the Comptroller and Auditor General's annual report.
Comment on this
I will try to be as brief as possible. We had the Charities Regulator in here last week and I wish to ask Mr. Cody about its relationship with Revenue, insofar as that is possible. We heard evidence last week that Revenue removed 579 people from the register of charities because they were inactive. Could he explain "inactive"? Is the removal from the register due to there being no activity on the account or is there any inference that there was anything untoward about their activities?
We heard evidence that a number of charities or groups have money in a Davy investment account, but some of the entities within the group no longer have charitable status. The fund is a historic one that pays a twice yearly dividend. I wonder about the tax status. Is there any way of retrospectively changing the status of groups in the fund? The understanding is that money was collected by a charity and the fact is that a dividend is paid. If charitable status no longer applies then perhaps there should be some change. Could Mr. Cody speak to that and inform me of the position?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. We are aware of the issues that arose as the secretariat sent us the transcript of the meeting. If we had a little bit more time we would have sent the committee a briefing on it. We will be able to send the notes we have but I do not have a note on the last piece about the dividend.
In the years 2015 to 2018, 295, 323, 610 and 583 exemptions, respectively, were withdrawn. Many of those charities advised Revenue that they were no longer active or had merged with other bodies. In such cases, we would withdraw their charitable tax exemptions. I believe the Charities Regulator set out how the process worked. The entities that had charitable tax exemption when the Charities Regulator was established were moved across.
Comment on this
The term "deemed" is always concerning because I would argue that it does not necessarily mean "definite".
Comment on this
I referenced gambling. The appointment of the Charities Regulator was long overdue and important. We have an excellent relationship with the regulator. I would like to check into the issue of the dividend. If an entity was inactive and we cancelled its exemption, and it then got-----
Comment on this
No. Perhaps I have misled Mr. Cody. These are two separate issues.
Comment on this
It could be that, although the charity was no longer active, the dividend was still payable because the charity was an original member. Whether the payment of the dividend is enough to exercise the entity's activity is the question.
Comment on this
I will. It is a well-performing fund and seems to have a great deal of money, although I cannot remember how much exactly.
Comment on this
I think it made €10 million. It is being managed very well.
Comment on this
Generally, that income would not be taxable because charities are tax exempt.
Comment on this
Mr. Cody gets where I am coming from.
Comment on this
There is money but an entity no longer has charitable status. If dividends are being paid, is tax being paid on them and what is Revenue's role in gathering that tax?
Comment on this
Generally, dividend withholding tax is payable on the payment of dividends. That is offset against income tax liability or corporation tax liability. It could be the case that the dividend withholding tax is paid but no body is claiming the credit for it.
Comment on this
That is possible, but it is also possible that a body is claiming the credit.
Comment on this
Absolutely. If the body is no longer a charity and, therefore, no longer exempt-----
Comment on this
-----it should not be entitled to claim it back.
Comment on this
Mr. Cody might supply a detailed note on that.
Comment on this
I raised a different issue last week. If a charity's turnover is over €100,000, Revenue requires it to undergo an audit. Am I correct in saying that?
Comment on this
Is there any evidence of deliberate attempts being made to keep turnovers under €100,000 in order to avoid audits?
Comment on this
Where a charity with an annual income of less than €100,000 applies for tax exemption, its latest financial accounts must be submitted with the application and signed by two trustees. Where a charity with a turnover in excess of €100,000 applies for charitable tax exemption, the financial accounts submitted to Revenue must be audited accounts and signed by an auditor.
Comment on this
In terms of the former, are there many with turnovers of €97,000, €98,000 or €99,000?
Comment on this
No, and they would still be subject to examination by us anyway. Something that we are fairly used to is examining accounts. There are all sorts of rules for companies and obligations to have auditors. Given how audited accounts progression is going for companies, €100,000 is in some ways a low turnover figure.
Comment on this
I referenced a particular charity last week, that of Gianna Care. It is not actually registered as a charity. A formal complaint has been made to the Charities Regulator. I was caught by something last week. If an organisation is purporting to be a charity and collecting money under that heading but it is not a registered charity, the Charities Regulator does not seem to be able to do anything. What is Revenue's role in that regard? If there is a rogue charity, for want of a better term, I assume that Revenue's role in terms of tax exemption is the same. It does not just assume that a body is a charity. Would the body be dealt with in the same way as an ordinary company?
Comment on this
Yes. One cannot get charitable tax exemption now unless one is registered as a charity. That was the fundamental change with the introduction of the Charities Regulator. Since it regulates the sector, a charity must first register with it and then apply to us for a tax exemption. In the question put by the Deputy, the entity could not avail of the exemption. It would then be down to the nature of the body. For example, is it a company or a person portraying himself or herself in a certain way? The entity would have tax liabilities like anyone else. If someone has an income from criminal activity, he or she is liable to tax. The challenge is knowing who he or she is. It is a risk-based system and we are always interested in information about entities, for example, which the underlying person or company operating it is.
Comment on this
We would be interested in that person's own tax liability. We do not have a role-----
Comment on this
If there is a rogue agency and it is not registered with the Charities Regulator, is Revenue's role just to ensure that it gathers the appropriate taxes from it, to put it in the nicest way possible? Has Revenue any role in tackling fraud, given that the agency would be purporting to be something that it was not, or would that be someone else's job?
Comment on this
That would be a matter for the Charities Regulator. It may well be a matter for the Garda.
Comment on this
I am paraphrasing, but the Charities Regulator told me that it was not its job because the agency was not registered.
Comment on this
Then it is a matter for the Garda. If a body is engaged in fraudulent activity or-----
Comment on this
If it is purporting to be something it is not.
Comment on this
Deception. It comes down to whether there is a criminal offence. If a body is raising money under false pretences, it is a question for the Garda. We would have an interest to the extent that there were tax offences. I will not refer to any individual case or taxpayer, given that I cannot, but the chances are that, if someone is engaged in defrauding members of the public, the likelihood is that he or she is hardly very tax compliant unless we make him or her.
Comment on this
Perhaps my next point does not fall in Revenue's area, but I was concerned last week by some of the reasons for which someone could get charitable status, including the advancement of religion and the advancement of education. Deputy Burke spoke about historical allowances and tax credits. With a view to tidying up the system, has Revenue considered moving the goalposts in terms of what is advancement of religion or education? If there are organisations whose reason for having a tax exemption is the advancement of religion, how much of that is interrogated? Some religions are very wealthy. Surely there is a great deal of revenue that could be gathered.
Comment on this
The regulation of the charity sector and the policy decisions about what is regarded as a charity are not matters for ourselves. Those are policy matters. The idea that Revenue, as a tax administration, would get involved in subjective judgments is something that would be a negative development. That is why we were very pleased as an organisation when the Charities Regulator-----
Comment on this
-----was established. I have seen parliamentary questions asking what is the promotion of religion. We can all have our individual opinions on this, but as an organisation we do not have an opinion. In the self-interest of the organisation, we believed it was important that-----
Comment on this
Mr. Cody is saying it is the Charities Regulator's job to decide the parameters under which an organisation gets status.
Comment on this
-----in the first place and then the Charities Regulator regulates the sector. A tax exemption flows from that once they apply for it.
Comment on this
Am I correct that some childcare facilities have charitable status?
Comment on this
It applies to community crèches. I suppose it depends on the area of the country. Must all of the income stream of a community crèche come from the early childhood scheme? Is it all State money that is paid? A child aged between three and five may be on the early childhood care and education, ECCE, scheme for three hours in the morning. If the parents or guardians decide to pay for another five hours, is that amount, which is paid from their pocket, tax exempt?
Comment on this
It might be helpful if I read out the note on the area.
Comment on this
The first question I have is: what is the tax treatment of the income of childcare providers with charitable exemption and are these affecting competition in the market?
Comment on this
That is essentially what I am getting at.
Comment on this
A body can be granted tax exemption once it has a charitable purpose and the funds are applied to that charitable purpose. In the childcare sector some crèches are established under community schemes for charitable purposes and in general if they apply, they will be granted tax exemption. These bodies will be in receipt of the early childhood and care scheme for the children being cared for and this does not impact the charitable status in any way. Other crèches are established for non-charitable purposes and are actually trading entities which have been established for profit. These would not be eligible for charitable tax exemption because there is no charitable purpose and funds are not applied to any charitable purpose. These bodies too could be, and most likely are, in receipt of ECCE.
The next question that I think the Deputy was asking last week is: is the tax exemption for charities affecting businesses providing similar services?
Comment on this
My question is as follows. Let us say I have a crèche and Deputy Aylward has a crèche next door. Deputy Aylward is operating a completely private crèche. Mine is a community crèche and I have tax exemption. In the mornings, I operate ECCE for the three hours but I also take cheques from parents for later in the day. Is the income over and above the State payments exempt from tax?
Comment on this
The answer I have here is that childcare providers that have been granted charitable status are not-for-profit bodies and all funds must be applied to the charitable purpose as a condition of the tax exemption. Essentially, if they were getting income in addition to the ECCE and that is used for the crèche-----
Comment on this
I know that. I am just saying-----
Comment on this
While the tax exemption applies to the income of charity, it does not apply to the salaries of the-----
Comment on this
The issue is that if a charity gets public funds and also raises subscriptions or sells some product or service, the tax exemption covers the full income once it is used for the charity. That is the scheme.
Comment on this
Could Deputy Aylward's private crèche apply for advancement of education as a reason to get tax exemption if he operates the Montessori method?
Comment on this
He would first have to apply for the charity, so-----
Comment on this
Deputy Aylward would be perfectly entitled to apply.
Comment on this
We might go into business together.
Comment on this
One never knows. I did not realise this was an issue. It is an issue if-----
Comment on this
There are grey areas around the boundaries between the charitable sector and business. An area that this would have arisen in a good number of years ago, and in which I was personally involved, was the whole area of charitable sporting bodies and private members' clubs. Particularly when golf took off, there was a lot of development of private courses. It was a sport and was primarily members only, but then there had to be provisions brought in under VAT legislation to allow income from some elements of the members' club to be taxable because of the competitive process.
Where one has a sector where the funding model is partially State, partially public and partially private, certainly it is a policy area that covers the Department of Children and Youth Affairs, the Minister for Children and Youth Affairs, a whole range of areas-----
Comment on this
-----that I am certainly not qualified to talk about.
Comment on this
It is important to highlight this issue. If there is charitable status for whatever reason in one childcare facility and another person up the road is operating a legitimate business and it is pretty much accepted that there is not that much margin in childcare - obviously big companies seem to be making a margin, but smaller providers-----
Comment on this
Of course, the tax would follow if the margins were-----
Comment on this
Yes absolutely, the Revenue Commissioners would be coming in too.
Comment on this
They would be among some of those companies we talked about earlier with no liability.
Comment on this
These people are providing a legitimate and needed support service for families. Perhaps a lad down the road has a community crèche but has a body of income coming from the private sector and that exemption covers that income. I know that it obviously needs to be used, but I find one will always find a way to spend money if one needs to. Perhaps this committee will have a look at it. I remember we had Tusla or Pobal in-----
Comment on this
Just before Christmas. I will look forward to that.
Comment on this
I welcome the witnesses, particularly my fellow Kilkenny man. I always welcome a Kilkenny man to Dublin.
I wish to ask about discrepancies in value added tax, VAT. I was approached by an individual whom I will not name. He said there are discrepancies in how VAT is being applied, particularly in co-operatives. He brought his case to Europe about three or four years ago. Mr. Cody might know the case. I think he won his case in the European Court of Justice and was referred back to the Revenue but nothing has happened since.
Regarding the farmer co-operative arrangements, are they an advantage to co-ops when it comes to VAT refund? I am talking about a level playing field or equal treatment. This man seems to think that he was unfairly treated and he lost his business. He was trying to compete against people who had an advantage. I just want a general opinion. I am not talking about an individual case. I want to ask generally about the way VAT is being applied. Are there discrepancies in the system?
Comment on this
I understand what the Deputy is talking about is the interaction of what is called the flat rate credit-----
Comment on this
-----for unregistered farmers and the pricing structure that is used within some of the co-operative frameworks for dealing with particular agricultural activity.
Comment on this
There were representations made about whether there is an abuse of the flat rate system. The sector was the poultry sector.
Comment on this
We conducted a study of the pricing mechanism. The EU VAT rules provide that one can have a flat rate scheme to compensate unregistered farmers for their VAT inputs.
One of the conditions laid down in the VAT directives is that the sector cannot overcompensate.
What we did is we did a study and then the Minister for Finance brought in a provision in the Finance Act - it might be two years ago - to provide a mechanism to exclude a sector or a subsector of the unregistered farmers sector from the flat-rate edition, subject to an analysis by Revenue and the establishment of the fact that there was overcompensation. That provision was brought in and-----
Comment on this
Did that rectify things if there were discrepancies?
Comment on this
There is another bit to go on the tale. Once the legislation was brought in, we did a detailed analysis of the sector to see and establish if there was overcompensation in the sector. We have sent our report to the Minister for Finance. It is now with the Minister and he has to consider. I am not 100% certain of this but I think it would have come up in the context of the Finance Bill, and he acknowledged that he had received the report from us. Again, his office and officials are considering it. There will need to be a specific provision for the sector, namely, unregistered farmers in the poultry industry. The poultry industry is interesting in that day-old chicks are hired out, nearly-----