We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Chapter 18 - Tax relief on film production

Contributions 394–594 of 594. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

That is right.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

-----the farmer feeds them, and grows them, and then they go back to the company where they are killed and end up packaged as chicken. That is with the Minister to determine whether he will bring forward a provision to remove the flat-rate status from the poultry sector, which will mean the farmers in that sector will have to register for VAT and then they will be in the normal system.

Comment on this

Were there directives from the European Court of Justice on that case for Revenue to take on? Is it that there were no recommendations or directives from the court? The case did not direct Revenue to do anything in particular.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

No. A number of the Deputy's colleagues have made representations and met some of our officials about the case. The issue and the concern are, again, practices in the poultry sector and if they are brought into some of the other sectors. Now we have this provision, which will allow us do that study of other sectors. The challenge is for us to know what is going on because this has all to do with the pricing models, the price of food, the feedstuffs and all of the rest of it. It is not really in the tax system. It is in the commercial contract relationships between the parties.

Comment on this

There could be an advantage to people within that system, we will say, through feedstuffs and all that.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

There is no doubt that, within the poultry sector, the pricing structure allowed for an overcompensation of the VAT for some people who are in that trade.

Comment on this

Does Revenue know how many farmers, in general, besides poultry, are registered and not registered for VAT? Is that something Revenue would know offhand?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I would know it offhand if I had a little bit of time. There are about 110,000 farmers. Most of them are part-time at this stage. There is a very small number of farmers registered for VAT.

Comment on this

I was thinking that.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It is probably less then 10,000.

Comment on this

Mr. Cody can send on the notes.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I will. I spent a lot of time in my career in VAT and I used to know these figures off the top of my head. Again, we publish a really interesting report on the farming sector and tax, and we updated it there recently. If the committee likes, we will send on the link to that report.

Comment on this

Okay. Another reason I am asking this is because of the present situation with beef and the feedlots. We have been talking about poultry up to now, but the feedlots, which are mostly owned by factory owners and processors, have an advantage in that they buy off the farmer and can upset the market by having all these cattle in reserve, which they can use to fix prices if they want to because they have the cattle to do it and can supply their own beef. Would this VAT thing that we are talking about have an implication for that sector, if it is not changed, by giving an advantage to processors, in particular? That is really what I want to get at, that this could be giving beef processors an advantage against an ordinary farmer who is trying to fatten cattle, like I do myself, and trying to supply from hoof to factory. These processors could have an advantage through this VAT thing. That is what I want to ask the witnesses. Are these processors at an advantage there, and should the loophole be closed if they are?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

There was a recent parliamentary question about the feedlots in the beef sector. So far, we have not seen evidence. The process is different in that a lot of the overcompensation on the poultry was because they were supplying the feestuffs-----

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

-----to the chicken rearer.

Comment on this

They are all tied in, yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The feedlot stuff is a different model. We are very open to information on practices in the sector because, ultimately, we find out things that are happening after the event because that is the way the tax system works. Tax returns follow the activity, the period for things to be returned. Often the earliest we will be aware of something could well be when it is two years in place. What we have said in reply to parliamentary questions is that we have no evidence to date. I hope that we are not stupid and that if we know it is happening in a sector, we will be keeping an eye on it.

Comment on this

That is what I am going to say. Now that Revenue is aware of this, will it scrutinise it more and ensure that no advantage is being taken by processors and factory owners, in particular?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

We are aware of the practices that took place in one sector and we will be actively looking to see if it is taking place in other sectors. We are also open to information.

Comment on this

In terms of Revenue reporting to the Minister, and I know that Revenue does not set policy, which is the Minister's problem, what way could the policy be scrutinised? If the Minister had to come up with means and ways to fix the problem, would it be to force farmers to register for VAT?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It would be to remove the flat-rate compensation for the sector.

Comment on this

I am a farmer so I know that would not be a good thing, and I might not look for that.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I was going to explain how the flat-rate system works, but then the Deputy probably knows how it works as well as I do. Basically, the flat-rate system works by an addition of a percentage to the price paid by the registered purchaser, which is 5.8%. So, if an unregistered farmer sells his cattle, he gets an additional 5.8% on the price. What that is meant to do is to compensate the farmer for the VAT on the inputs-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

-----whether it is on running the farm, running the tractor and keeping the thing going.

Comment on this

Feed and all of that.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Yes, feed and feedstuffs where it is not zero rated. It is calculated based on macroeconomic data across the sector in its entirety. That is why some farmers register. A tillage farmer probably has more inputs. Mostly, the registered farmers are tillage farmers-----

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

-----because they have higher income subject to VAT.

Comment on this

Fertilisers and all that.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Yes.

Comment on this

Are feedstuffs zero rated for VAT?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Most of it is zero rated.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Livestock feedstuffs are zero rated for VAT.

Comment on this

That is great and good to hear. I am glad that Mr. Cody gave me those few answers. Mr. Cody spoke about corporation tax this morning. I refer to the €10 billion that was brought in and then €6 billion from ten companies. Is he worried that this is a temporary tax? A sum of €6 billion is a lot of money. Could it disappear next year? Could the figure reduce to €2 billion next year and zero the year after? Is he worried because this is a lot of money and could upset our tax returns for any given year over the next five or six years? When we are speaking about billions, it is serious stuff.

Is Mr. Cody, as chairman of Revenue, worried? Does he expect the income to be temporary or will we continue to receive, say, €6 billion from the large companies? They are probably foreign direct investment companies based here. Is Mr. Cody of the view we will become, or are, dependent on them in the same way we became dependent on the construction industry before we went bust? I acknowledge he has commented on it but I would like to hear more.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

As the Minister said, there will always be a concern around any sector dependent on a small number of large payers. There will also be concern around the idea of international tax, given that that debate has been of significance for the past five years, and many developments are taking place internationally. There is no doubt that over the past couple of years, some of the changes in international tax have been to the benefit of Ireland's corporation tax receipts. The Minister stated he will be careful and cautious. There is a great deal of interest in the matter. Certainly, the figures so far this year suggest we will be ahead of target again. As a country, we have to be careful about it.

Comment on this

Is Mr. Cody afraid that due to the changes in international tax law, not least in Europe, the companies in question will just become tax compliant and prepare for what will come down the line, but that the money could evaporate to €1 billion or €2 billion per year instead of €10 billion?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I certainly would be worried that it will reduce to €1 billion or €2 billion. Who knows where it will be in three years? The figures we have published over the past number of years show that the top ten have paid between 37% and 45% of the total corporation tax every year, and that has been fairly consistent for a long time. Many of the companies have deep roots in Ireland and employ many people. Some of the challenges over the next number of years may well have an impact on attracting new companies, and the challenge will always be there.

I have figures on farmers, although the figures are a bit wider than just farmers because they are dependent on NACE codes. The figure for VAT registration by the agri, forestry and fishery sector in 2018 was 12,078. That figure has been fairly consistent, going back to when I was dealing with VAT full time.

Comment on this

That is approximately 10% of farmers.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

In addition to the flat rate VAT, unregistered farmers are entitled to claim back VAT on farm buildings. They had 20,000 claims, totalling €59 million in VAT on capital development for slatted sheds and so on. The Deputy has probably claimed a number of them.

Comment on this

I am due to submit another claim.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I cannot deal with that without talking about taxpayer details.

Comment on this

Mr. Cody stated the report is with the Minister. Will the change require a statutory instrument?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Yes, it will.

Comment on this

Mr. Cody stated that two years ago, there was an amendment enabling-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Yes, it was enabling legislation.

Comment on this

A statutory instrument will be required. The change to the flat rate VAT for the poultry sector will not come into effect until such time as a statutory instrument is signed. It is a matter for the Minister. Mr. Cody hinted that if it was to become necessary in another sector, the template is now in place to allow it to be extended.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It was a difficult situation for people in the sector. It was a challenge for us to get to the bottom of the model. It was not taxed in its normal way but had to do with commercial pricing and contracts. We now have enabling legislation. VAT has been in place since 1972, while the flat rate system has been an important and sensible way of administering VAT for unregistered farmers.

Comment on this

For the benefit of people watching the meeting, will Mr. Cody explain what he meant when he stated that when a farmer sells cattle, he or she will get an additional 5.8%? Who pays the 5.8%?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The registered purchaser-----

Comment on this

That is a mart or factory.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

We might leave out marts for a moment. If a farmer is selling to a factory, the factory will pay the 5.8% and claim it back in its VAT return. It is an input credit. The Exchequer pays it.

Comment on this

What about sales through a mart?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It is essentially paid by the purchaser. The 5.8% is added at the mart.

Comment on this

For the benefit of people who are not familiar with marts, when a farmer buys an animal at a mart, he or she knows that the VAT will be 5.8%.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Yes, the farmer will get 5.8% from the mart.

Comment on this

If one farmer sells a yearling to another, unregistered farmer, what happens?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

If it goes through a mart, the flat rate system operates. If two unregistered farmers sold to each other-----

Comment on this

A total of 90% of farmers are unregistered, as Mr. Cody stated.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Yes. The flat rate addition will not apply. The claim in respect of some of the lots is that the final person in the chain receives the full value of the flat rate, and that is the issue we are looking at-----

Comment on this

If a farmer sells a weanling at a mart, he gets an additional 5.8%, whereas to another, unregistered farmer, he will not get the additional 5.8%-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The Chairman is challenging my recollection of the flat rate system and marts. If he would like, I will revert with a clear, rather than detailed, note.

Comment on this

Please do. I had not intended to broach this area.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I had not intended to talk about it either.

Comment on this

I guarantee Mr. Cody that such a farmer will pay the same amount because the buying farmer will get the same price, irrespective of whether it is at a mart. The same amount will be paid in any event. The VAT would be included in the price if the sale was from farmer to farmer.

Comment on this

Mr. Cody might send us a note on the various scenarios.

Last Friday, I was listening to "Liveline" while driving. A caller complained about the cost of calling Revenue. If I type "Revenue phone number" into my iPhone, as Mr. Cody will be aware, the results include the Revenue phone number and a number for help information. When I select the latter result, it states that to contact Revenue, it costs €2.95 per minute from an Eir landline. It states a 1590 number for the revenue collector division and numbers for general inquiries in the Dublin region, the western region, the east, the Border and the midlands. The lady on the radio the other day said she was in new employment and could not get her tax credits. She went straight to Google and found the Revenue phone number, which she called, but after ten minutes the line cut off, as is noted on the website. When she received her phone bill, it stated that two phone calls, of €28 a piece, cost her €56, which was probably more than she earned from her part-time job at the weekend. What will Revenue do about that? I now know that it is not Revenue's website but people listening to the radio programme may have a different impression. The lady called what she thought was the Revenue phone number. When I google the number, the first result claims to be the Revenue phone number. Revenue has to do something about that because it is bad for its business.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

As one can imagine, just as we pay attention to what happens in committee meetings, we pay attention to what happens on the radio.

Comment on this

Revenue has a great army of people watching what is going on. I would not like to be on the wrong side of Mr. Cody.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I generally listen to the 1 o'clock news and the start of "Liveline" or the advertisement for it, to find I am not on it and then I stop listening to it. On the issue around the phoneline, the challenge is that commercial operations pay for their location on search engines to be the first item that shows.

If anybody looked up the Revenue website, he or she would find a lo-call number. We used to have an 1890 number but, because of concerns around the bundles offered by telecoms companies, we reintroduced an 01 number last year as most people can call such numbers for free within their bundles. We issued a press release and publicised this number. When the promo for "Liveline" came on last week, we sent the producers a copy of that press release. I believe some of it was read out on the programme. It is a real concern. One can ring Revenue for nothing but commercial companies, some of whom are not even established in Ireland, have put themselves into this space. When we had our 1890 number, which was a lo-call number - we were probably among the first in the country to use one - the mobile companies did not include calls to lo-call numbers in their bundles. We made representations to ComReg, which carried out a consultation on the issue. I know it has taken a long time for changes to come about in that sector but we moved to an 01 number ourselves.

Comment on this

Why does Revenue not use a public service 076 number?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It is not like when I was young and one was charged long distance rates. The 01 number is generally free under people's phone packages. We publicised the number as much as we could but we do not have any role in the process by which commercial companies can become the first result on a search engine. I saw a complaint yesterday from somebody whose son got caught in the same way. It tends to be youngish people in their first job-----

Comment on this

Using smartphones.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

-----using smartphone browsers rather than accessing the website on a computer. In a way the advantage of the "Liveline" programme is that it gives us an opportunity to have this discussion today and to advertise again. We will be issuing our bulk issue in the coming weeks. For the first time in more than ten years, we are going to issue a letter to everyone who is registered for PAYE because of the fact that there will be no P60s under the new PAYE system. We are going to write to everybody. It will be done electronically for those who have myAccount but we will also be issuing more than 1 million ordinary letters, for the first time in a long time, in order to explain the new provisions and that the easiest way to do things online. It is terrible. It is a matter of entities taking advantage of people. We are not, however, the regulator for the telecommunications sector.

Comment on this

For the record, I am referring to a company called TryWeb which is registered in Old Gloucester Street, London. Mr. Cody knows all this. Can Revenue not contact Google? It deals with the entire population of Ireland. This can happen to other Government agencies. Is this a problem internationally? Does it happen in every country?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

This is international. No company such as this sets up to make its money from Ireland. Our population is not large enough to allow that. This is international. It is a challenge for us. We hope that people will not have to ring us at all. That is our aim.

Comment on this

Will there be a phone number on the letter the Revenue is issuing to 1 million people or will they be directed to a website?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

No, there will be a phone number.

Comment on this

Grand. It will be a busy one.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I was going to say that if it is not on it now, it will be by the time I get back but I know there is phone number because I was looking at the draft letter.

Comment on this

Mr. Cody will understand why I asked. I listened to that and it took a long time before what this was all about eventually came out. In my head, I was giving out about Mr. Cody saying that he will see me next week. I say that flippantly, as Mr. Cody understands.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The reality is that we are not often the subject of "Liveline" but every so often we are. It is probably fair to say that a long explanation from Revenue will not be the first thing read out on the programme. It does not tend to make a programme.

Comment on this

Mr. Cody should do a short explanation.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

That would certainly not make a programme.

Comment on this

I know. I have covered that point because it is a concern to the hundreds of thousands of people who heard this. Is there an international group of revenue chairmen at EU level? Surely there is some international group that can talk to Google. As Mr. Cody has said, this is probably happening in every country. I am only making a suggestion and putting the thought in Mr. Cody's mind. That is the first thing people hit when they search for Revenue's phone number on Google.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The reality is that if-----

Comment on this

It is a very clever company. It is making a fortune. Does it pay tax here or in England?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

If it is not established here it will not be paying tax here. This sector is regulated in all countries. There are various different models and 1590 numbers are run by legitimate businesses.

Comment on this

I know that.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It is similar to the matter we discussed with Deputy O'Connell. People portray themselves in a certain way. For all intents and purposes, one would think one was on to the Revenue number when one is not.

Comment on this

The company does not have any access to people's personal tax affairs. They can only have general information.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

That number just routes to Revenue. The call is put through to our number.

Comment on this

This is worse, it is a redial. I thought one rang the number and someone would give one some general advice.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

No.

Comment on this

People ring this number, which comes from England, at €2.90 a minute or €28 for ten minutes and they are connected to Revenue. The company gets the €2.90.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

We do not even know it is happening.

Comment on this

Revenue does not even know the call is coming through this intermediary.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

No. We have no way of knowing.

Comment on this

Surely Revenue's telephone system has some way to recognise these numbers so that the person can be asked if they know that they have called through an intermediary that is charging €2.90.

Comment on this

Is it not fraud?

Comment on this

Revenue will have to implement a system to recognise incoming phone numbers. If it comes from a 1590 number the people should be told the minute they get through. Does Mr. Cody get my point?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I will check to see what shows up on our system if a call comes in through that system. I will find out what technology we could employ.

Comment on this

The people do get through to a Revenue official at the end of the day.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Absolutely.

Comment on this

They are being charged €2.80 a minute or €28 for ten minutes, however.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

If they go through to-----

Comment on this

I hope the Revenue will fix that.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Our friends in Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs are probably getting a few bob out of it.

Comment on this

Is it not fraud?

Comment on this

It is not because it is advertised as a contact number.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The terms and conditions, if one gets to the end of them, are very clear.

Comment on this

I am looking at them. It says that one should call the landline number directly if one has a complicated query. The company has an out in the small print of the advertisement.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It does not tell people how to get out of emergency tax. It is a matter of routing.

Comment on this

Revenue is doing all the work and TryWeb is getting all of the money for the phone call.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

We are used to that.

Comment on this

Mr. Cody can understand why I am asking. It was highlighted. There is a real issue in this regard. People do not know about it until they get their phone bill or until they run out of credit halfway through a call.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Absolutely. In the case yesterday to which I referred the person was letting us know that their son had got caught. This person was just glad he had not been caught as badly as that other lady.

Comment on this

Okay. I have aired that point. It is important because we are all talking about contacting Revenue and there is a scam going on in that regard. The poor person making the phone call is the one who pays for it.

Paragraph 6.3, at the bottom of page 18, has a small but interesting point in regard to compensation and legal costs. Under the heading "Claims by members of the public", there have been 25 claims and Revenue's legal costs were €33,000, which is an average of €1,320. The legal costs awarded, presumably from the other side, were €166,000, giving an average of €6,640. The amount of compensation awarded was €86,000 in the 25 cases, an average of €3,440. Therefore, the legal costs averaged €7,960 and the compensation awards were €3,440. This means 30% of the total cost of €285,000 was compensation and 70% was legal costs. We know who is the winner there, simple as that, although somebody must have had some sort of fall or slip. What is the nature of this? It really puts this into focus that, in the entire year, out of the total payments in respect of compensation and legal costs, 70% was legal costs and only 30% compensation, although I am not blaming Revenue's solicitor. It would almost pay Revenue to tell them to go away when they send in a letter, although I say that flippantly, and I know it has to fight the case.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I know this is a topic the committee has been interested in. Our claims are handled by the State Claims Agency. We are very fortunate that the claims are small in number and they tend to be small. They often involve somebody having an accident coming into one of our premises, for example, slips and so on. I spoke to Deputy Cullinane earlier about fuel cards. A small number of cases are traffic accidents involving Revenue vehicles. The figures speak for themselves. There are a couple of bigger cases that did not happen to get paid out in the year that are being dealt with.

Comment on this

We have made the point and it is one we all have to watch. I want to move to page 78 of the accounts, where I find one set of figures interesting, although we are not talking about billions. It is in regard to non-Exchequer receipts collected on the behalf of other Departments, agencies or EU member states. I found a few figures of interest. I have three questions. Revenue collected €2.6 million on the health levy, which was abolished in 2011. Seven years on, how is it that money is still being collected? I know the money is due but how is it out there for seven years without being collected? I presume Revenue collected some money on it this year as well.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I presume it is the winding up of this. Again, I will get a note on the health levy but I believe it is a legacy issue.

Comment on this

I know it is legacy.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Where we are collecting PRSI, and we have talked before about debt-----

Comment on this

Could this be from estates?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It could be arrears of PRSI going back a number of years.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

I think it is the health levy.

Comment on this

I am talking specifically about the health levy.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

I think it is the health levy, which is collected through companies.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It is pay related. There could be arrears of pay being paid.

Comment on this

Mr. Cody might send us a note.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I will send a note on the breakdown of the €2.6 million.

Comment on this

And a note on why, eight years later, the money has not been collected.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

In our overall debt figures, we are lucky that the figures over eight years old are quite low. However, there is money we collect from companies every year that relates to aged debt. For example, it could come out at the end of a liquidation.

Comment on this

Mr. Cody can send us a note. I have several questions in a similar vein. Under note 3, the local property tax, LPT, collection figure of €488 million is broken down. For example, there is €25 million for the household charge, which was €100 and which is from seven years ago, and the LPT arrears for 2012 to 2017. Why, six years later, are we collecting LPT that was not collected in 2012? How was it left outstanding for six years? Mr. Cody is going to give us a breakdown in writing of the €25 million between arrears of local property tax for each of the years, and I do not expect him to have the detail now. I want to know how much of that €25 million was for the household charge. What I do know is that when people come to sell their property, there is a letter asking whether they have paid their household charge, and I believe €7,000 is the figure they have to cough up if they never paid it. Mr. Cody might send us a note. I have heard of people being caught for a figure like €7,000. Mr. Cody might remember there was a big rush and there were major penalties if people did not pay it. Revenue is probably just collecting it on the basis of property being sold where there is a query from the solicitor as to whether the household charge was paid, and it can be up to €7,000. Am I right in that?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

There are three things covered under the whole area of houses. The non-principal private residence, the second home, aspect was run by the local authorities and never had anything to do with us, and the penalties in regard to the non-principal private residence were-----

Comment on this

That is the €7,000.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The household charge was the €100, and when property tax was introduced in May 2013, the household charge came across as an LPT charge. We took responsibility for collecting uncollected household charges for the two years that the household charge was in place and, to date, we have collected just over €71 million in household charge arrears. We picked it up sometimes when houses were sold and sometimes when we tidied up the register, given there was no household register. There is a small percentage of houses to be sorted in the register and there were also all sorts of exemptions for unfinished estates. When LPT came in, the unfinished estates were a smaller footprint. People decided they had the household charge exemption because they had not been liable to LPT but they did not have that exemption. Therefore, every year, we collect a small element of arrears. If we are collecting arrears of LPT, what tends to happen is that we are collecting it from the start.

The other piece is that there are a whole range of deferrals, and there are people who have opted for the deferral, and they then decide they are in a better position - perhaps they have a new job - and they pay the arrears of the deferral. When we took on the job of LPT, we anticipated that we would have got €60 million in the household charge to bring it up to date, but we have actually got €71 million. There was a provision, in whatever year it was, in which we said that if the household charge was not paid by the date, it doubled. We took a lot of innovative approaches to ensure people paid their LPT.

Comment on this

That is fine. Mr. Cody can send us a note because we have touched on a couple of different issues. It is historic but it is interesting that it is still rolling through. A final question is on tobacco excise receipts of €167 million. Will Mr. Cody explain what that is for? I understand it goes directly to the Department of Health.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Although I forget what year it was introduced, this applies to an element of the tobacco excise receipts. It has to do with some of the changes around health funding, whereby a small element of the excise receipts goes directly to the Department of Health.

Comment on this

Revenue collects it and forwards it on.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Yes, but we collect it within the total excise figure and that is only a very small proportion.

Comment on this

It is €167,000.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

No, it is €167 million.

Comment on this

It is the same figure for both years.

I ask Mr. Cody to send the committee a note on the origins of that figure. I raise these issues because the general position is that all moneys collected must go to the Exchequer, other than those which go to-----

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

The Revenue fund is provided for by law.

Comment on this

I am highlighting these because-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Hypothecation.

Comment on this

Yes, hypothecated tax. Some people claim it does not exist. That is an example of an existing hypothecated tax. That is the only point I am making. The chart which has been provided probably shows a hypothecated tax.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

It is received as an appropriation-in-aid into the Department of Health Vote.

Comment on this

I refer to the list of defaulters and so on which is published by Revenue. I will not go through the figures which were presented. Up to 55% is collected after two years. Some of the defaulters cannot afford to pay the debt but the Revenue still goes through the process. The committee has been provided with figures for what has been collected up to two years after the event. Are payment arrangements in place for many defaulters? Mr. Cody did not state whether there are payment arrangements in place in addition to the collections that have been made. He is indicating there are no payment arrangements with defaulters.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

If one enters into a settlement with the Revenue which is publishable because the tax, interest and penalty thresholds are met and one enters into an instalment arrangement to clear the debt, we do not record that as an uncollected debt. Rather, it is treated as payable. We discussed this two years ago. Prior to the Finance Act 2010, the name of a defaulter could not be published if he or she did not pay. For the name of a defaulter to be published, it was required that there be a settlement with tax, interest and penalties above 15% and that the amount had been paid. That was fine while the economy was going well as we generally got our money. After the economic crash, a number of people met the tax, interest and penalty thresholds but were unable to pay any of the debt. Their names could not be published but those of persons who paid their debts could. The Finance Act 2010 changed that. Thereafter, we published the names of defaulters who could not pay. The process was further changed in 2016 such that we now identify within the list those who did not pay. From 2010 until 2016, the names of defaulters were published and everybody thought all debts were paid.

Comment on this

Including the committee. This was discussed some time ago.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The committee should not have thought that because-----

Comment on this

We passed the legislation.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

-----the Oireachtas passed the legislation updating the process.

Comment on this

The committee has been told off by Mr. Cody.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The Finance Act 2016 provided that we would highlight unpaid debts. The Revenue does not categorise the debts of defaulters who have entered a payment agreement as being unpaid. If one engages properly with the Revenue, enters an instalment arrangement and commits to continue to pay one's taxes, we do not publish one's name within the category of unpaid debts. If subsequent-----

Comment on this

Where are the names of those who have not paid published? The committee is familiar with the list of defaulters.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

They are published within the list of defaulters. There is a column noting whether the debt has been paid. Newspapers do not always include that information. We publish the list in Iris Oifigiúil and on our website. The list on the website shows whether the debt has been paid.

Comment on this

I ask Mr. Cody to send the committee a note on the number of defaulters whose names have been published by the Revenue and for whom a payment arrangement is in place. On the total amount outstanding from defaulters-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The Chair is seeking a note on the defaulters for whom a phased payment arrangement is in place.

Comment on this

Yes. That was not mentioned in the notes. We have not previously addressed that topic.

Page 34 of the annual report contains reference to e-audit. I am sure Mr. Cody will tell me this paragraph is included every year, but I have only just noticed it. The report states:

During 2018, we collected almost €69 million in yield from e-audits. This represents almost 28% of yield collected through our audit programmes. In 2018, the average audit yield from e-audits was €65,816, higher than the average audit yield of €49,896 when traditional auditing methods are used.

I ask Mr. Cody to outline the e-audit process. How may e-audits were carried out? Is the number increasing? Obviously, a desktop approach is taken. Would it be possible to do more e-audits? If Revenue officials can collect more money through e-audits while sitting at their desk, so much the better.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

That paragraph has been in each of our annual reports for the past ten years.

Comment on this

I thought that might be the case. I do not get to ask Mr. Cody about each paragraph each year. We would be here until next week if I did so. I ask him to discuss e-audits. I do not remember them being addressed previously at the committee.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

E-audits involve an interrogation of a feed of electronic records. As the committee is aware, most businesses of scale now keep electronic records. We use IDEA software which comprises a commercial e-audit package which is also used by the Comptroller and Auditor General. An e-audit does not take place solely in our office; it also involves an interview. The opening interview with the taxpayer and his or her agent, if applicable, and the opportunity to make disclosures and so on are a core part of the audit process. If one is a retailer with electronic records of purchases, sales and cash, we will download those records and apply our audit techniques and software to that process. An e-audit is not appropriate in cases such as those involving complex accounts. If the business in question is a multiple, e-audit may encounter difficulty regarding its VAT system and the proper rates being charged on products. The e-audit process allows us to carry out 100% analysis of the data as compared with traditional paper-based auditing which involves taking representative samples and extrapolating from them. We have engaged in e-audit to varying extents for 20 years. It has been introduced through various processes. Its usage is far more routine than was previously the case. Our annual report in a couple of years' time may not contain a paragraph explaining e-audit because we will use e-audit techniques for appropriate cases. It is becoming more the norm. The cases will tend to be bigger. It could have been noted in the paragraph in question that the audit yield was higher because e-audit tends to involve bigger cases.

Comment on this

It is not that it is a better system.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It is like an annual report from the days when I was carrying out audits including a paragraph on audits using a calculator. We now do not identify e-audits within our statistics. The numbers are a bit more problematic. We will look at it further for the committee.

Comment on this

I ask Mr. Cody to so do, although he has explained it fairly well.

On page 35 there is reference to third-party information and data analytics. Mr. Cody mentioned this in passing. The report states:

...in 2018, matched third-party data was used to drive a wide range of ongoing projects including work on medical locums, providers of short-term accommodation, and Irish residents in receipt of income from foreign assets. In addition, we began a review of unmatched data to identify possible evidence of shadow economy activity.

Mr. Cody referred to medical locums. Providers of short-term accommodation include AirBnB hosts.

The next paragraph states that the data gathered in third-party returns is used to "support voluntary compliance, for example, information on agricultural subsidy payments provided by the Department of Agriculture, Food, and the Marine was used to prepopulate 78,000 income-tax returns."

That is interesting. Anyone using ROS knows now is the time one gets the pre-populated tax return. Mr. Cody is telling me Revenue has information from the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine and not just from the employers to pre-populate part of the form. It would be great if Revenue could get that information from the Department of Employment Affairs and Social Protection in due course. I know I am probably disturbing a hornet's nest here but we have all encountered several cases in the past of, for example, somebody in receipt of a social welfare payment who might have taken up employment again or who might have been overpaid in social welfare. It takes a minimum of two years before the Department of Employment Affairs and Social Protection tells Revenue and then the person either gets a tax bill because he or she had not declared a social welfare payment or as the case may be, the person might owe money to the Department because he or she got a job. One would have hoped the lines of communication between Revenue and the Department of Employment Affairs and Social Protection would be closely aligned because it is the biggest Department in the country for payments, such that if somebody on a social welfare payment takes up employment it is immediately matched. It takes years for that to happen in some cases and vice versa, if somebody in employment gets a social welfare payment for some other reason, it is taxable. Sometimes it takes two years for that to happen and then people are upset that they are getting this bill afterwards. They wonder why somebody did not tell them at the time. We know people should know themselves but it causes a lot of upset. That is down to what I would call the delay in transferring information between Revenue and the Department of Employment Affairs and Social Protection. It causes a lot of hardship for a lot of people. I would have said the exact same thing to the Accounting Officer from the Department of Employment Affairs and Social Protection here a few weeks ago.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Revenue and the Department have extensive exchange of information between us. Within the self-assessed income tax form 12, we pre-populate it. When we see the figures in the new year, the form 12 is pre-populated with some of the data for some of the schemes. With others, the information is dependent on how the feed comes across so in some of the fields for some of the smaller schemes, we give a pop-up information box to say how much people are in receipt of. I do not want to name a scheme because if I do it off the top of my head I will probably name the wrong one. This year's form 12 for next year will have pre-population of the Department of Employment Affairs and Social Protection information. We pre-populate the form 12 for most of the schemes now. Where we cannot put in the figure but we know people are in receipt of funds, we give them a reminder. When we redesigned our PAYE services and the jobs and pension process, we pulled in as much of the information as possible, including the information on where we have it and where we have matched it. The good thing about the information we get from the Department is it is matched because the PPS number drives the whole process. Most of what the Chairman would like us to do, we are doing already.

Comment on this

It will happen on 1 January. I was not aware of that and the public are probably not aware.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It is already being done.

Comment on this

It is in the system.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Yes.

Comment on this

In other words, Revenue is already on top of the work I was suggesting it carries out.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It is a bit different when we exchange information. The Department of Employment Affairs and Social Protection's receipt of information from us tends to be more around the issue of whether people are entitled to means testing, etc.

Comment on this

Or DIRT payments. The Department often picks up bank accounts through information on DIRT from Revenue.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

We are trying to improve in the area where people take on jobs and start again. A few months ago in our PAYE services, we also provided a facility for unemployment repayments because one of the ways we get repayments of tax is through unemployment. People have been able to do that online in recent months, whereas before they had to-----

Comment on this

It is important to do an information campaign on that so people will know their Department of Employment Affairs and Social Protection information will be linked in to their Revenue information. It is good, it is the right way and it is the up-to-date way to operate. People will think that because I raised it I am the reason for it happening but Revenue was doing it anyway.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

We are doing it anyway. One of the challenges and complications is that when we issue our tax credit certificates next month, they will show the amount of Department of Employment Affairs and Social Protection income we know people are in receipt of. The long-term schemes or long-term pensions are clear but unemployment payments-----

Comment on this

Come and go. Some people will get a shock when they realise some of the social welfare payments might be taxable. They might not have had to pay tax on them before but they will be surprised to see this.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

One of the things that also happened in the context of PAYE modernisation is there was a range of short-term payments across the public sector, wider than the Department of Employment Affairs and Social Protection, which were legally taxable but not practically taxable. As part of the preparation for PAYE modernisation, the Department of Finance carried out a review and in the Finance Bill, there are a number of specific short-term schemes that were made exempt from tax.

Comment on this

Where do the likes of the community employment schemes and Tús workers come in? That is income and there could be other income in such a household.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

They were all subject to a review and it was determined from a policy perspective which of them should be exempt.

Comment on this

Mr. Cody might send us a note on which ones were exempt.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

Yes, that will be in the Finance Bill process.

Comment on this

I know Mr. Cody is going to tell me I should know because we approved it.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

I would not dream of saying that to the Chairman.

Comment on this

We can only follow so much from this side but it would be useful to give information on it because people will be surprised when they find out about this.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The complication around how Department of Employment Affairs and Social Protection payments are taxed is confusing in how it is coded into the process. I would hope it would be clear to people when they see it.

Comment on this

What is the VAT rate on food supplements?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

The Bill is going through the Oireachtas and subject to it passing all Stages and the Bill being signed by the President, it will be 13.5% from 1 January.

Comment on this

That is what is in the Finance Bill. Perhaps Ms Walshe from the Department of Finance can help.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Marie Walshe

It is 13.5% and it does not apply to certain supplements such as folic acid.

Comment on this

Does the Department have an information note it could send us, pending the passage of the Bill?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Marie Walshe

Yes.

Comment on this

In a practical sense, what was the VAT rate in 2018 on food supplements or is this new VAT rate just coming into place from 1 January next year?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

It has been well-----

Comment on this

I know but let us wrap it up now.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Cody

-----rehearsed and thrashed out through the process. Some of them were attracting a zero rate and it evolved over time. Our view was some food supplements and various other types of products were liable for 23% VAT. There was a consultation process and a tax strategy group and then the Minister brought forward the proposal to put them at 13.5%, apart from those that actually qualify for 0% VAT as they are approved by the Health Products Regulatory Authority, HPRA.

Comment on this

Can the Department of Finance send us a note on that? I know we are at the end of the road on that matter, it has been running a while and we are all familiar with it. I have covered all the ground the members did not cover earlier.

I thank everybody from the Revenue Commissioners, the Department of Finance and the Department of Culture, Heritage and the Gaeltacht, who were here earlier, for their attendance and for the information provided. I also thank the Comptroller and Auditor General and his staff. It is agreed the clerk will seek any follow-up information and carry out any agreed action from the meeting.

Our next public meeting is next Thursday, 5 December. There will be two sessions. The first session in the morning will be with the National Paediatric Hospital Development Board, the Department of Health, the HSE and Children's Health Ireland and the meeting will be on the 2018 financial statements for the National Paediatric Hospital Development Board.

In the second session we will meet with the HSE and the Department of Health to deal with its accounts for the public services for 2018 and chapter 15 from the Comptroller and Auditor's report, dealing with primary care centres and specific topics we have already indicated we will deal with on the day, such as an update on measures to reduce incidents of clinical negligence that may lead to claims against the State. We covered that in our periodic report this week. We will also have an update on matters related to the oversight of sections 38 and 39 organisations and the practice of issuing advance funding to such organisations. We will also discuss private ambulance contracts and home support services. That is in addition to everything else.

Comment on this