National Paediatric Hospital Development Board: Financial Statements 2018
Contributions 1–260 of 1,051. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
We have two sessions today. This afternoon, we will meet representatives of the HSE to discuss primary care centres and other matters. This morning, we are dealing with 2018 financial statements of the National Paediatric Hospital Development Board. As we last met representatives of the board on 16 May 2019, it is timely that we are engaging with them again on the management of the children's hospital project and the associated costs of this key capital project for the State. In the committee's sixth periodic report, we made a number of recommendations relating to and arising from our previous meetings on the 2017 accounts. Today's meeting gives us an opportunity to review the progress that has been made in addressing these issues.
We are joined this morning by Mr. David Gunning, who is the chief executive officer of the National Paediatric Hospital Development Board. I think this is the first time he has attended a meeting of the Committee of Public Accounts. He is welcome. Mr. Gunning is accompanied by Mr. Fred Barry, who is the chairperson of the board; Mr. Jim Farragher, who is the board's finance officer; Mr. Phelim Devine, who is the board's project director; and Dr. Emma Curtis, who is the board's medical director. We are also joined this morning by Mr. Jim Breslin, who is the Secretary General of the Department of Health. He is accompanied by Mr. Barry McGreal, who is a principal officer in the new children's hospital unit of the Department, and Mr. Liam Morris of the Department's acute hospitals division. Ms Pamela Carter, who is a principal officer in the Department, and Ms Anna Wallace, who is an assistant principal in the Department, are also in attendance. We are also joined this morning by Mr. Dean Sullivan of the HSE chief strategy office and by Mr. Jim Curran, who is the head of estates with the HSE. Mr. Paul de Freine, who is the HSE's chief architectural adviser, is also in attendance. We are also joined this morning by Ms Eilísh Hardiman, who is the chief executive of Children's Health Ireland. All of the witnesses are very welcome.
I remind members, witnesses and those in the Gallery to turn all mobile phones off. That means putting them into airplane mode. Merely putting them on silent can still interfere with the recording system. I wish to advise all witnesses that by virtue of section 17(2)(l) of the Defamation Act 2009, witnesses are protected by absolute privilege in respect of their evidence to this committee. If they are directed by the committee to cease giving evidence in relation to a particular matter and they continue to so do, they are entitled thereafter only to a qualified privilege in respect of their evidence. They are directed that only evidence connected with the subject matter of these proceedings is to be given. They are asked to respect the parliamentary practice to the effect that, where possible, they should not criticise or make charges against any person, persons or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable. Members of the committee are reminded of the provisions within Standing Order 186 that the committee shall also refrain from inquiring into the merits of a policy or policies of the Government or a Minister of the Government, or the merits of the objectives of such policies. While we expect witnesses to answer questions asked by the committee clearly and with candour, witnesses can and should expect to be treated fairly and with respect and consideration at all times, in accordance with the witness protocol.
I invite the Comptroller and Auditor General to make his opening statement.
Comment on this
As Deputies will be aware, the National Paediatric Hospital Development Board exists to procure the planning, design, construction and fit-out of the new national children's hospital at the St. James's campus in Dublin and of two satellite paediatric outpatient and urgent care centres at Tallaght and Connolly hospitals, respectively. When they have been commissioned, all three facilities will be operated by Children's Health Ireland, which was formally established with effect from 1 January 2019. To date, the development board has been funded fully by State grants provided by the HSE. In 2018, the board's expenditure amounted to €127.6 million, representing an addition to the value of fixed assets recorded in the financial statements. Total accumulated project capital costs to the end of 2018 amounted to just under €260 million, inclusive of VAT.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for inviting us here this morning to discuss the National Paediatric Hospital Development Board, NPHDB, financial statements 2018. I am joined here today by Mr. David Gunning, chief officer, Mr. Jim Farragher, finance officer, Dr. Emma Curtis, medical director, and Mr. Phelim Devine, project director.
The National Paediatric Hospital Development Board was appointed in 2013 to design, build and equip the new children’s hospital. A planning application was lodged in 2015 and An Bord Pleanála granted planning permission in 2016 for the new children’s hospital, and the two paediatric outpatients and urgent care centres - one already complete and operational at Connolly Hospital in Blanchardstown and a second under construction at Tallaght University Hospital.
Following the approval of a guaranteed maximum price in December 2018, the NPHDB provided the Committee of Public Accounts in January 2019 with a breakdown of costs approved by Government for the design, build and equipping of the new children’s hospital. The agreed investment decision is €1.433 billion. The investment decision approved at the time was exclusive of residual risks as was communicated at the time of approval. These exceptions were also set out within the PwC report published in April. As pointed out by PwC, some of these risks are under our control and some are not. We are actively managing those under our control while monitoring those that are not.
The 2018 accounts were audited and approved by the Comptroller and Auditor General on 24 October 2019. The expenditure as at 31 December 2018 for that year on the design and build of the hospital was €127,603,801. An analysis of expenditure to 31 December 2017 and 2018 is included in the opening statement submitted to the committee.
I would like to take this opportunity to give members an update on the construction progress; those of you who have had the opportunity to visit the site of the new children’s hospital – or indeed any of you that have passed by the site recently - will have seen the progress that has been achieved. Across the 12 acre site the excavation, piling, and the structural frame to the underground basement for campus-wide facilities management, energy centre, and the 1,000 space underground carpark are nearing completion and the first window has actually been installed in the hospital. Well over 1 million sq. ft. of slabs have been poured. Mr. Gunning will give the committee some further detail on the construction shortly. The outpatient and urgent care centre at Connolly Hospital in Blanchardstown was handed over to our colleagues in Children’s Health Ireland for operational commissioning earlier this year, and since we last met services have commenced there.
Since I appeared before the committee in May, there have been a number of changes in leadership, and in relation to project governance. Following a competitive process overseen by the Public Appointments Service, Mr. David Gunning was appointed as chief officer in September and Mr. Phelim Devine was appointed project director in October. We have additionally added to the capabilities of the project team by engaging expertise in a number of areas. We have reorganised the board committee structure to focus our attention on what will be our critical challenges over the coming years. As a result of the resignation of a number of board members this year, there are vacancies on the board. These positions were advertised via the Public Appointments Service, and we understand that a shortlist of potential candidates will be submitted to the Minister in December.
We report to the children’s hospital project and programme, CHP&P, steering group on a monthly basis, providing comprehensive updates on all aspects of the project, and we also report to the CHP&P board.
Comment on this
Can Mr. Barry explain who or what those groups are as the public would have no concept? We thought Mr. Barry was over the children’s hospital project and programme steering group and now he tells us otherwise.
Comment on this
The development board is over the day-to-day running of construction, building, equipping activities. There are quite a few different strands in the development of the hospital, including our colleagues in Children's Health Ireland who will operate the hospital; there is input on the ICT side from other parties and there are many issues around staffing and so on. There is a very broad array of interests and stakeholders in the project. There is considerable interest in the project on all fronts from the Department of Health and the HSE and that reports right up to the Minister. There is a steering group which meets monthly to track and co-ordinate progress from all the different parties including ourselves but going far beyond ourselves and a board oversees that.
Comment on this
They both have rather long titles of the children's hospital project and programme with one, the steering group and the other, the board.
Comment on this
We report to the board but the steering group is a function of the ongoing -----
Comment on this
That is for the Department of Health to answer.
Comment on this
I am sorry to interrupt but the public are totally confused about all these different titles when there are so many groups involved.
Comment on this
I chair the programme board. Its constituent elements are myself, the CEO of the HSE and Dean Sullivan, as chair of the steering group. We invite in CHI and the national paediatric development board to update us at those meetings. Mr. Sullivan chairs on a monthly basis -----
Comment on this
There are four permanent members and others are in attendance.
Comment on this
They are brought in. Sorry about this but we will be lost if we do not get this right. Who are the four again?
Comment on this
He is deputy CEO in the HSE but he also chairs the steering group underneath it. The assistant secretary, acute hospitals division, in the Department is also on it.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Breslin telling me that Children's Health Ireland is not on the programme board for the national children's hospital?
Comment on this
So they are not members of the board. I just want to understand this. The national children's hospital, Children's Health Ireland are not on the board that is over the programme board.
Comment on this
This is an oversight mechanism, not the delivery of the project. Those delivering the project, both the CEO of Children's Health Ireland and the CEO of the National Paediatric Hospital Development Board, account to those structures for where they are at in relation to delivery. It is separate from delivery and is to oversee and ensure that it is up to date on any issues and we are fully advised on what is happening on the project.
Comment on this
But Children's Health Ireland is ultimately going to run the hospital and Mr. Breslin is telling me it has no role, it does not have a member on the board overseeing it.
Comment on this
No, because then it would be accountable to itself. It is responsible to the Department, as the sponsor of the project and the HSE as its funder. They account on the programme that they are delivering. They are not accountable to themselves and are not members of the group.
Comment on this
But they will run the hospital at the end of the day. Should it not be running this project? Should it not be the key group on the board if it is going to run the children's hospital? Forgive me for asking what might seem like a strange question to Mr. Breslin.
Comment on this
Children's Health Ireland and the paediatric hospital development board have statutory responsibilities.
Comment on this
The development board goes away and CHI stays there forevermore running the hospital.
Comment on this
Yes. They have that statutory responsibility but the HSE, as funder, and the Department, with the responsibility it enjoys, need to oversee that and make sure it is being performed correctly. We have put a structure in place to make sure that is happening. Otherwise we would be having ad hoc meetings, calling people in, not having a proper structure to it. This is the structure that we use. We minute the meetings. We do a full review of the programme as it is when we meet and we look at issues that are coming up or on the horizon.
Comment on this
When the hospital is functioning, because people want to know, will CHI report to the programme board in the long term?
Comment on this
CHI, just like Beaumont Hospital and St. James's Hospital, has its own.
Comment on this
And so will CHI be. It will be a statutory body.
Comment on this
It is a statutory hospital. It is a public body funded by the HSE under section 39 of the Health Act.
Comment on this
It is closest to St. James's or Beaumont Hospital, which is, a public body put there by statute of the Oireachtas, with appointees made by the Minister and which receives its funding from the HSE, because the HSE has overall responsibility for the entire health service.
Comment on this
Children's Health Ireland will be a section 38 organisation, not run by the Department of Health. It will have its own board-----
Comment on this
It will be audited by the Comptroller and Auditor General. It will report here as an accountable body to the Committee of Public Accounts.
Comment on this
I was merely clarifying that. I do not know whether that is good or bad. It is merely information I want to put out there for people because we get lost with these long titles.
Comment on this
We probably will come into it in the meeting, but I might just note that we will revise those structures. We have already looked at those structures. We will look at the work that is being done by the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform on the public spending code. When that is completed, we are likely to streamline those top-level governance structures, not the CHI or the development board but how we oversee it. We will take account of any learning.
Comment on this
We just had a note from Mr. Robert Watt of the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform, DPER, on the new spending code pending approval. We have to cover that on another topic.
I apologise to Mr. Barry for the interruption.
Comment on this
That is my habit. If there is something that I do not understand, I will try and add a bit of clarity. It is important so that we understand the structure.
Comment on this
I had come to the end of my little spiel anyway. I would now like to introduce our recently appointed chief officer, David Gunning, who will introduce himself a little further and provide more detail on the construction update.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Barry. I thank the Chairman for his welcome.
I thought, building on what Mr. Barry has pointed out here, that I would show some photographic evidence, if that can be put up on the slides here. It is there. We sent it in in advance just to show here. I have a number of photographs and I would just like to talk the members of the committee through the work that is going on.
For an orientation point of view, the first photograph is taken from the north end, looking south towards the Dublin mountains. One can see in this photograph, starting on the right-hand side, this U-shaped road which comes in from South Circular Road, comes all around the perimeter of the children's hospital site and eventually appears over on the left-hand side into St. James's. That is the new access road, into the hospital and into the St. James's campus.
Comment on this
There is a pedestrian footpath. This is access for the emergency services, in and out, and all traffic, in and out.
This is a view of the 12-acre site. One does not get to see a lot on this and I guess the access road is the key point.
I would like to move on to the next slide. This is taken, again, looking in that same direction, but the key point here is we are starting to see a hospital emerging from the building site. To talk about some of the areas here, one will see the area, "Concourse", that is labelled there in the centre of the photograph. That will be, if you like, the main street up through the hospital. One may remember that from previous presentations or models. Again, to emphasise, that street is the length of Grafton Street, as a reference point. Off that street, there is a multi-storey on each side. We see on the left, going from bottom to top, we have the decontamination unit, radiology above that, critical care and then the various therapy rooms along that. On the right, these are the fingers that one will notice if one drives by the South Circular Road. They will be the outpatient departments. Above that, we have cardiology, a surgical ward or other therapies, and the haematology and oncology ward on the top, and others will go on top of that. Down on the bottom left, one will see a plant room is being constructed. That is the location of the former access road, which has now been practically fully excavated. That is a recent milestone that we have passed. That plant room there will provide energy and various other services to the building. Again, to emphasise, we are starting to see a hospital emerge from the building site.
If I could have the next one, please. It is hard to see some of this in red. Again, to show the scale, one will see the workers in the foreground there laying out reinforcing bar, rebar, in advance of a concrete pour. Right above them, one sees B2, which is basement 2, basement 1 above that. There is lower-ground floor, ground floor, levels 1, 2, 3 and 4. Just beside the "L" on level 4, one starts to see some columns emerging that are the start of the supports for levels 5, 6 and 7. An enormous amount of work has been achieved. I will say probably the progress is not as much as we would like but we are making quite considerable progress. That gives the scale from basement 2 all the way up to what has been done.
The next slide shows the view if one drives along South Circular Road. The old entrance is where that traffic warden is on the left-hand side at the break in the timber there. Again, one can see these three different figures that stick out. What one cannot see because of the scaffolding is that we now have facade going up on these particular buildings. Mr. Barry mentioned there is one window in. Now tens of windows have gone in, even in the past week. There is quite a lot of progress. The outpatients are over on this side. Gardens will be on top of this to provide a healing environment for the children and their families. I mentioned previously the haematology and oncology there on the left, as that will go three more storeys on top of those fingers for the wards and other locations.
The next slide gives another view. There is a lot of scaffolding there which is paving the way for facade, insulation, etc., that get affixed to the structure along with the windows. That is the north block, which is probably the slower part of the build but is moving along now at a fair degree of pace.
The next slide shows the view from close to the offices that we occupy in Herberton, beside Fatima Luas stop. The Luas runs along there from left to right and the other side of the fence is our view of the building. To the left of that will be where the helipad is located and in there we see a so-called "linear park", which is a development along the Luas which provides a nice environment there for the local community.
On the next slide, just going into some of the mechanical and electrical detail, a lot of work has been done in this particular area and it is not all just concrete and steel. On the left-hand side, one can see lagged pipes up towards the top with the silver coating on them. Those are all for steam and hot water. On the fire protection in the centre, the red pipes are the already-installed sprinkler system for the areas that have been developed.
A large number of air handling units have been installed in the level two basement, which will provide ventilation and various other services related to air quality in the entire hospital. Basement level one is a car park and is practically complete, only requiring some lining up and finishing. The final slide shows the orientation of the hospital from a height. As one looks through the main street of the hospital, one can see in the distance, if one's eyesight is very good, a couple on the roof of the Royal Hospital in Kilmainham. This will all be enclosed eventually. These photographs are two weeks old. We had a presentation from the design team on Tuesday that showed even more progress than we are showing here today. I wanted to share those photographs with the committee to give an indication of the progress made to date.
As I went through the slides, I spoke about insulation. The sustainability of the hospital has been raised in the past. I wish to emphasise that the hospital is being built to the highest standard set out by the Building Research Establishment, BRE. It will reach the "excellent" rating for energy performance and sustainability or the building energy rating, BER, A-3 standard. This means that there will be a 60% to 70% reduction in the energy costs of this hospital in comparison to the existing hospitals being operated by CHI, which is significant.
Mr. Barry mentioned the outpatient and urgent care centre at Connolly Hospital and construction is also ongoing at Tallaght University Hospital. The CHI unit at Connolly is open and is delivering services. Almost 2,000 children have attended urgent care clinics and 1,000 outpatient appointments have taken place since the opening.
The images do not convey the full reality of what is going on and the scale of it. In that context, we would be delighted to host a visit from the committee as a group or as individuals. That invitation stands and we would welcome such a visit.
Comment on this
The first speaker to indicate was Deputy Imelda Munster, who has 20 minutes. We will have a second session in the afternoon and will have a different opening speaker for that session. Before I go to the Deputy, I wish to make one observation. This is the Committee of Public Accounts. The witnesses have told us that the agreed investment decision or agreed maximum price of €1.433 billion was approved last December.
Comment on this
Here we are, 12 months on. We have had the opening statements from our witnesses but not a solitary figure has been presented other than the one presented here 12 months ago. That is all I am saying and we will come back to that during the meeting.
Mr. Fred Barry: I would be happy to respond to that now.
Comment on this
I would be quite happy to respond to that now.
Comment on this
Please do because it just struck me that we received no up-to-date information, other than the photographs.
Comment on this
Okay. Perhaps that was an oversight on my part. I had understood that because we were looking at the 2018 accounts, the figures included should only be for that year. I can tell the committee-----
Comment on this
We are here, one year later and we are still within the €1.433 billion budget as set for us last year.
Comment on this
Yes. I am saying we are still within it. The budget was set last year and the Chairman has asked for an update as to where we are now. I am saying that we are still within the budget as set for us last year.
Comment on this
What about the issues referred to? Mr. Barry said that some risks are under the board's control and some are not. We are interested in the items that are not in the €1.433 billion budget, which will ultimately be a cost to the taxpayer. There seems to be a suggestion that these items are separate from the €1.433 billion budget but these are the items with which we are concerned. We want to know about the issues that are not in the budget.
Comment on this
Mr. Barry has said that there is a budget and so far, the project is within that budget. However, that budget is not the full budget at all because there are lots of issues outside of the board's control. He has not said a single syllable about them. That is important in the context of our role. I am just making that point because I want the other members to come in. I do not want to take over the meeting but I hope Mr. Barry understands the point I am making about the opening statements.
Comment on this
I wish to echo the Chairman's comments. I have a concern as well because what we got was a presentation on the build which is nothing to do with our job. That is for the health committee. The witnesses are before the Committee of Public Accounts and what we expect is up-to-date information on costs, with proper breakdowns. We have many questions and I hope we will get the answers. If we do not get those answers today, then I do not know why Mr. Barry has come in. He and his team should have been aware of what this committee does and what it expects of witnesses who come before it. Given what I have just heard and the questions put by the Chairman, I have concerns but I will reserve judgment until I put my questions. I hope that when I do so, I will get an adequate response.
Comment on this
Given that the Chairman has opened the meeting up to comments-----
Comment on this
Yes, but I ask the Deputy to be brief. I apologise to Deputy Munster, who is the main speaker. This is not normal procedure.
Comment on this
I am delighted to hear that windows are being opened and a hospital is emerging. That is what we all want. However, what we are here today to do is determine if accountability is emerging. I would appreciate the witnesses bearing in mind when they are answering questions that we are interested in the process of accountability in the context of the overspend. I hope they can zoom in on that rather than just showing us lovely pictures.
Comment on this
What we are referring to is under the 2018 accounts. Note No.11 in the 2018 accounts on page 27 refers to contingent liabilities. Those liabilities are not quantified. Liabilities have been incurred, the value of which has yet to be determined. This is referenced in the 2018 accounts. We need details, fleshed out, on what those contingent liabilities are in respect of accounts signed off 11 months ago. They are relevant to the 2018 accounts and we need to know more about them. I am sure the witnesses can see where we are coming from. Deputy Munster has the floor now, with my apologies.
Comment on this
I thank the Chairman. The witnesses are all very welcome. I will start with Mr. Barry if I may. Has there been any revision of the projected final cost since the figures were published in the PwC report last April?
Comment on this
No. There are residual risks which are outside of the approved budget. We have said previously and I repeat that it is very likely that some of those risks will come to pass but they have not hit us as yet during this year. We have, therefore, not gone back to the Government and said that some of the residual risks retained by the State have occurred and we need more money against those. That has not happened, at least as yet.
Comment on this
The board has not revised the-----
Comment on this
We are still within the €1.433 billion authorisation.
Comment on this
Can Mr. Barry explain how he can say that the GMP for construction is €1.433 billion or that the entire cost is €1.7 billion when we know that contractors' claims are being submitted on an ongoing basis?
Comment on this
The contractors' claims are going in on an ongoing basis and a number of those claims have been through the process. The process with contractors' claims is that if they are not agreed, they are referred to the employers' representative for determination.
Comment on this
I know that and I know that there is a process of 20 days-----
Comment on this
What I am saying is that those contractors' claims are being submitted on an ongoing basis. Mr. Barry said that currently approximately 50% of those claims have been processed. Most of them were the smaller claims. The other 50% of claims are outstanding and further claims will be submitted over the next three years and beyond. In that context, how can he say that there is a GMP when contractors' claims are being submitted on an ongoing basis and will be for years to come? He said recently it could be 2024 or later before the final accounts are ready and we know what is what.
Comment on this
Where does the GMP come in? The process makes a nonsense of that, does it not?
Comment on this
I suppose. The GMP arrangement with the contractor is a price from him for work as described in the contract at that time.
It does not preclude the contractor for submitting claims based on anything that the contractor may feel is outside of that price.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Barry expect further overruns?
Comment on this
So far, we have been able to combat and resist all of the claims. We are representing the public interest in doing this, but we have been able to resist them and make the case that the guaranteed maximum price is already included for the items claimed by the contractor. Whether or not we will succeed in that for the next three years with all of them, I really cannot say. I know we are going to keep arguing, keep making the case and keep fighting them as resolutely as we can.
Comment on this
I think what Mr. Barry is saying is that he cannot guarantee that there will be no further overruns, even with the guaranteed maximum price in place? Is Mr. Barry telling this committee that he cannot guarantee-----
Comment on this
I am certainly saying to the committee that I almost expect that on some of the residual risks - the ones retained by the State - there will be costs involved against them. For example, the State has retained risk on inflation over the 4% level.
Comment on this
It is a virtual certainty that there will be additional costs associated with that.
Comment on this
At the health committee last week, Mr. Barry put forward the argument that no one can predict and that it was impossible to know what way inflation would go. One of the members speaking to Mr. Barry was aghast that he did not have some business case or a model to determine it, but he made reference to the fact that the PwC report gave a range for inflation and that was all the board had done. Mr. Barry made reference that the PwC had given a range for inflation, but in the minutes of the most recent meeting of the board, which is online, it says the board discussed the risks associated with inflation.
Comment on this
The next two paragraphs are redacted. I am wondering is the redaction in relation to the discussion around the risks associated with inflation. The headline is the board discussed the risks associated with inflation, and then there are two paragraphs redacted. Was that the case?
Comment on this
Is the redaction in relation to the discussion around the risks associated with inflation?
Comment on this
With respect, something has been redacted by the information officer and I am not really going to say what it was. I do not think that would be appropriate.
Comment on this
I am asking because every other headline includes the discussion that took place, except for the redaction under the headline, the board discussed the risks associated with inflation. Every other headline-----
Comment on this
-----includes the discussion. Was the redaction in relation to the discussion around inflation?
Comment on this
If the matter was redacted, and the information officer redacts items for reasons of confidentiality or commercial sensitivity-----
Comment on this
Okay. Mr. Barry is presuming it is around commercial sensitivity, that that would be the only logical reason for the board to redact it.
Comment on this
It would be a confidentiality or a commercial sensitivity issue.
Comment on this
Commercial sensitivity.
Could I just have clarification around construction inflation and whether or not it is deemed commercially sensitive? Could I ask through the Comptroller and Auditor General to confirm if construction inflation - one is talking about the general industry as such - would be deemed commercially sensitive?
Comment on this
My understanding would be that indices of construction costs would be in the public domain.
Comment on this
It would not be deemed commercially sensitive at all.
Comment on this
Mr. Barry has just said it was commercially sensitive.
Comment on this
No, Mr. Barry said there were two reasons, confidentiality or commercial sensitivity. The Comptroller and Auditor General has just ruled out commercial sensitivity as a reason, so what is the reason? Why is there a redaction?
Comment on this
With respect, the Comptroller and Auditor General said, and I fully agree, that public indices and indices that are in the public domain around inflation are not confidential, and I am not suggesting that they are.
Comment on this
Mr. Barry referred to commercial sensitivity. Can the Comptroller and Auditor General confirm that again, because there seems to be a little bit of confusion? Is there any train of thought or any aspect where construction inflation could be deemed commercially sensitive in the wider sphere of things?
Comment on this
Publicly available information is obviously not commercially sensitive, and there would not be a need to redact that. I do not know what is in the paragraphs.
Comment on this
None of us does, because they are redacted.
Comment on this
Why would this information be redacted? Is it to save blushes?
Comment on this
There are no blushes on our part over construction inflation.
Comment on this
Why would we be blushing over construction inflation?
Comment on this
It was the fact that it was redacted, and Mr. Barry said a moment ago there were two reasons for it being redacted, and one of them was because it was commercially sensitive. Now that has been rubbished.
Comment on this
What was the other excuse Mr. Barry gave?
Comment on this
Deputy Munster is making the assumption that what was being discussed was the publicly available indices. That assumption is mistaken.
Comment on this
I have asked Mr. Barry if the redaction was in relation to the board discussing the risks associated with inflation. That is a "Yes" or "No" answer.
Comment on this
The redaction was in relation to our discussions and considerations around how much the board might be paying in certain circumstances arising from inflation.
Comment on this
It was in relation to how much the board might be paying in certain circumstances arising from inflation.
Comment on this
Okay. Mr. Barry made reference to the fact the PwC report had estimated inflation at that time at 4%. Why would that be so sensitive that it be redacted from the minutes?
Comment on this
Deputy Munster is really asking me what has been redacted, and I am afraid we are not going to get anywhere with that.
Comment on this
I asked Mr. Barry, in particular, because the public need is not really served by him not disclosing the discussion. That is what this committee is about.
Comment on this
The public need is well-served by us negotiating our best with those with whom we negotiate to minimise State expenditure. If that means we do not show our hand in any particular issue, that is in the public interest and not against it.
Comment on this
Prior to that, Mr. Barry had not done anything in relation to inflation. It was the PwC report that had given the rate of inflation at the time. When Mr. Barry was questioned at the health committee last week, that was very evident. The public need is not served by Mr. Barry redacting the information and the two reasons he gave have amounted to nothing. Anyway, people can see that for themselves.
Comment on this
As I often say here, that is your view. That is not necessarily the view of the committee. During the course of this meeting, people will express their own views. They are not the formal views of the committee until we make a report in due course. You are entitled to make-----
Comment on this
Okay. Thank you. If inflation rises above 4%, can the construction company claim that back?
Comment on this
-----one could be looking at an additional cost of €166 million. Would that be right?
Comment on this
I think if it was 7% across the life of the project, the additional cost would be in or about €50 million.
Comment on this
Okay. Is the clause in the contract around inflation increases standard for contracts of this type?
Comment on this
I am not sure about the specific wording of the clause, but I would say that in the industry generally, contractors will willingly enough give fixed price without inflationary increase for up to three years. If one gets to four years, it is difficult. I know certainly in the private sector, in which I am very involved at the moment, nobody will give fixed price contracts for large amounts for such a long-term contract as this one.
Comment on this
Off-hand, would Mr. Barry know of any other public builds of this nature with clauses like that?
Comment on this
I do. For example, a lot of the long-term road contracts had price inflationary clauses in them.
Comment on this
That would be for longer-term costs. One will get fixed prices readily enough for two or three years. With inflation rising, getting out to four years is very difficult and certainly, one will not get bigger contractors to give fixed prices for anything going beyond that without an inflationary adjustment for a project lasting seven or eight years. I do not think one would get that in a public or private project.
Comment on this
On the contractor claims, is there any way of estimating the value of the claims between now and then? From what Mr. Barry said earlier I believe there is pretty much no way, but is there none whatsoever?
Comment on this
We have no idea, and this comes back again to the guaranteed maximum price. We have no idea whatsoever what the final cost will be.
Comment on this
The guaranteed maximum price does cover the vast bulk of the construction and associated risks.
Comment on this
No. If we have no idea of estimating what the costs will be in those-----
Comment on this
Sorry, just let me explain. Those contractor claims are ongoing and will be for the foreseeable future, possibly for four or five years.
Comment on this
Mr. Barry has just answered me. We have no idea of what they would be. How could he then-----
Comment on this
It is like pretty well every other project out there. Construction claims come in on every project the State is doing.
Comment on this
I know that, but it would stand to reason that we have no idea whatsoever of what the final cost will be. Is that a "Yes" or a "No"?
Comment on this
It is a silly answer to say "It is not a "Yes" or a "No"". It is a yes-no answer. Do we have any idea of what the final costs will be? That is a yes-no answer, in fairness.
Comment on this
When the Deputy words it in that fashion, she is trying to get me to say that it is completely open ended what the costs might be.
Comment on this
No I am not. I am asking Mr. Barry a question. We have said that we have no way of estimating what the claims will be between now and the end of the build. Mr. Barry agreed that there was no way of estimating those claims.
Comment on this
The question is, if we have no way of estimating what the claims will be then how can we possibly have any idea what the final costs will be? Is that a "Yes" or a "No" to my question?
Comment on this
To say that we cannot have any possible sense of what the costs will be is not really a proper reflection. The contractor can put in endless claims. There is no restriction on the amount a contractor can actually come looking for. If one has a contract in place, as we have, which covers the vast majority of the costs out there, then it is not as though the guaranteed maximum price bears no relationship to the end costs or that billions of euro of extra costs can arise; they cannot. As I have said before, the contractor will make claims, we will resist them and it will be a surprise if some of those claims do not stick before the jobs is over.
Comment on this
This is the same as every single other large project going on around the city, be it public sector or private sector. On every one of these projects, the contractors are entitled to put in their claims and they get worked out. It is true to say that we cannot say exactly where it is going to end up but one cannot say-----
Comment on this
Mr. Barry cannot say what the final cost will be. It stands to reason.
Comment on this
We cannot say exactly where it is going to end up-----
Comment on this
So Mr. Barry has no idea what the final cost will be. If the witness has, then he should say it. This is why I ask the question. Unless he tells us otherwise we can presume that he has no idea what the final cost will be.
Comment on this
Deputy, we are going around in circles on this.
Comment on this
No. Does Mr. Barry have any idea what the final cost will be?
Comment on this
Indeed. The final cost will be the guaranteed maximum price, plus whatever residual risks-----
Comment on this
Whatever you are having on top. With that response, it is fair to say that the €1.7 billion is aspirational rather than a reality.
At the committee last week, Mr. Barry said that some contractors tend to approach claims differently. Some make claims that can be managed and substantiated, hence 50% of claims are done while another 50% are not done. Mr. Barry said that other contractors would make more inflated claims. This is what Mr. Barry said at the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Health. What record has the contractor BAM in this regard? Given the use of this particular procurement model for the first time ever in a public build, I assume that the board would have examined this at an early stage.
Comment on this
I am not quite sure what examination was done on the pre-qualification of the tenderers because I was not the chairman at the time.
Comment on this
Is there anyone here from board who was there at the time?
Comment on this
Those who were involved in that aspect are not. Some people here were on the executive team at the time.
Comment on this
Perhaps they may be able to answer. It is no secret that BAM has a history of overspend in other countries and not just in this country. Given the type of procurement and it being the first time it was used, I assumed this would have been looked into and researched in the context of cost control and overruns.
Comment on this
I was not there at the time but I will observe for the committee, because it is of broader interest than just for this project, there is a real-----
Comment on this
For the members of the committee who were there at that time there was the infamous Ballyfermot leisure centre and the Port of Cork project. It would have been pretty obvious. I wonder what oversight was given to that?
Comment on this
There are real difficulties in the State sector in referencing previous performance when awarding new contracts. This is not just a children's hospital matter, it is a more general matter. I am aware that some of the relevant Departments are working on this issue currently and may come up with an approach that will allow the purchasing agencies to reflect and include consideration of past performance a little better than can be done at the moment. Right now, under the rules that are there, essentially if contractors meet the pre-qualification criteria, one cannot stop them tendering. If they tender and their tender is the most economically advantageous, then they have to be awarded the contract. There is a challenge there, certainly.
Comment on this
Given what he has said, and that this procurement model had never been used before, would Mr. Barry have imagined that this sort of history - which was out there in the public domain - would have been taken into account given the scale of the project, the costs involved and what we have seen to date?
Comment on this
In more recent procurements using that type of approach it has become usual at the pre-qualification phase to examine the different contractors and their key personnel for their ability to work within the co-operative shared risk-type environment and-----
Comment on this
Would there ever have been a prevention from doing that?
Comment on this
I do not know. I do not know if that would ever have been prevented. I just know that is being done more widely now in Ireland and in other countries.
Comment on this
It was not done anyway. Maybe it was a bit slack.
Comment on this
I do not know whether it was or was not done in this case.
Comment on this
That is why we are where we are, I suppose.
Comment on this
I was involved in the executive when we pre-qualified the contractors. This was done in 2015 and they were pre-qualified around the end of 2015. We tendered the project in 2016. On the criteria against which they were assessed, past performance was not one of the criteria. Obviously, financial capability, record and experience were some of the criteria. My understanding of public procurement, which complied with EU rules at that stage in 2015, is that one cannot preclude a contractor from tendering for a project based on their past performance in the context of relationship or claims history, as Mr. Barry has already outlined
Comment on this
I do not believe so. As I recall, it was based on their financial capability, on their experience of building similar large-scale acute hospital projects and on their people.
Comment on this
If it was not the formal case then, when did the new process commence of looking at a contractor's past history?
Comment on this
I am not sure. I know it did not exist back in 2015.
Comment on this
If I may clarify, the process of looking at a contractor's past history has not commenced. In some cases there is a degree of psychological testing of the key individuals to judge how they would perform in a co-operative environment.
Comment on this
Would Mr. Barry consider it good practice to do this before engaging somebody? Should one speak to somebody who had engaged the contractors before?
Comment on this
In the private sector past experience is looked at all the time.
Comment on this
Certainly, in my time in the public sector I would very much like to have been able to look at past performance.
Comment on this
I refer to what the Chairman said about the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform and looking at the capital procurement framework to see the extent to which this could be done. There are definitely restrictions on this. I am not here to advocate for contractors, but if somebody under a previous contract put in a claim and validly got the claim through the dispute resolution process, up to and including the High Court, and then it was subsequently said, "Because you took that other person to court-----
Comment on this
I am just saying it would have to be crafted very carefully and one would need to make sure it would stand up to challenge.
Comment on this
When the Department of Education and Skills tenders for schools, whether today, last year or the year before, it seeks references from organisations that have previously worked on building schools. Different parishes or locations around the country or different ETBs could be involved. Deputy Catherine Murphy will be aware of one project in my constituency and in her county in respect of which references were granted and a person who was not short-listed was not given an opportunity to comment on the adverse reference they were given. They took the case to court and, because they were not given an opportunity to comment on what they felt was not a good recommendation from a previous employer, the tendering had to start again. What this demonstrates to me is that, as far as the public sector is concerned, the Department of Education and Skills has a budget, builds €600 million or €700 million worth of schools and has a practice of getting references from previous employers that engaged those contracts. I am now surprised to hear that while that happens on school projects, the Department of Health does not seem to know anything about it when it comes to the children's hospital or does not even know whether that practice exists in the public sector. It is happening, though.
Comment on this
Indeed. The Chairman did mention that that case ended up in the High Court and the State lost.
Comment on this
There was a good practice in place but it was not followed through on or completed fully.
Comment on this
I am just saying that this idea of getting references from people who employed the contractor previously is normal. Perhaps that Department was caught out in that it did not follow the process through, but this had been a standard feature to allow people through the pre-qualification process. We did not seem to get an accurate understanding of that practice. Does the Comptroller and Auditor General wish to comment? I know the case I am talking about.
Comment on this
I do not know the case and have not come across it but the expectation, as I understand it, with public procurement is that each of the parties entering into a contract is responsible for its own activities, oversight, management and so on. If there are weaknesses on the State side, it is not the fault of the contractor that puts in for tender. If it wins in conciliation or in a court case, it is legally entitled to that and cannot be prevented from future work. It has done everything, as it sees it, legally and properly. The onus then is on public bodies contracting to make sure that their systems are tight and close, that decisions are made in a timely way and that processes are followed. That is the side we really need to focus on.
Comment on this
Mr. Curran, who has responsibility for the overall health capital programme, might be able to make a more general comment.
Comment on this
Regarding the short-listing of contractors, they submit a pre-qualification questionnaire, part of which relates to reference projects in respect of which they supply certificates of satisfactory completion from whoever they were contracted to. The contractors supply certificates of satisfactory service for those reference projects.
Comment on this
We can go back and check them. That is what I have been talking about. Did that happen here, though?
Comment on this
It did, but that still does not give the committee access to the claim history on those projects.
Comment on this
No, but this is broader than just claim history; it is a matter of quality of work and timeliness.
Comment on this
Indeed. Also, and I say this from my experience in bidding for contracts, if one were bidding for a job, naturally enough, the projects one would put forward as references would be those in respect of which one is pretty well-off. One might not bother including those that ran into some difficulties.
Comment on this
Mr. Devine was involved at that stage. Irrespective of what has been said in the past few minutes, was he aware of BAM's record in respect of overruns?
Comment on this
I was aware of some projects BAM had executed that overran.
Comment on this
Was the rest of the board aware of that? Did Mr. Devine inform the board?
Comment on this
I am not sure if the rest of the board were aware. They may have been. I need to go back and clarify that as part of the pre-qualfication process Mr. Curran talked about, that cannot be taken into account. We have just had that discussion. The other bit of information I would like to add is that the process we undertook through pre-qualification and the tender process was fully compliant with both public rules and European rules on procurement. We independently audited that to that effect as well.
Comment on this
Is this not amazing, though? I refer to what was said about past performance in the private sector. Whoever said it laughed straight away. Of course past performance comes into it, but not in the public sector.
My next question is about delays. Last week in the health committee Mr. Barry gave the impression that there were fairly minor delays with the build, but when he was pressed later on he mentioned there was a deadline to remove and replace a road that was causing a delay. Can he give us a bit of information about that and any other delays?
Comment on this
Certainly. When I was first before this committee and indeed the health committee, around May or so of last year, the main contractor was behind schedule by weeks. I said at the time that it was well within the contractor's compass to make up that time. I said last week and I will say again to this committee that it is unfortunately the case that the contractor has not made up that time - not only that, but it has slipped further weeks. As an example of where this would show up on a milestone in work to date, the removal of the old road that crossed the centre of the site was a milestone in the ongoing activity. Its removal took place a couple of months later than it would have taken place had it been done per the contracted programme. The work going on at the moment is primarily the pouring of concrete: the concrete frame, the columns, the slabs and so on. There is other work going on around the site as well.
Comment on this
When Mr. Barry refers to the delays and the setback in time, what kind of delay is he talking about?
Comment on this
Is it probably six weeks or a couple of months behind programme at this stage.
Comment on this
If there were further delays, that would set it back further and further. I was curious because what Mr. Barry said at the health committee about minor delays did not tally with what Mr. Reid, I think, from the HSE said. There were media reports going back to last September that an internal memo in the HSE had stated that capital project for the new children's hospital is facing delays to the construction programme which could impact critical timelines if mitigation measures are not taken. I presume the NPHDB has taken those stringent mitigation measures. I ask Mr. Barry to outline to the committee what they are.
Comment on this
Sorry, I am missing something. What did Mr. Reid say?
Comment on this
Mr. Reid said that "capital project for the new children's hospital is facing delays to the construction programme which could impact critical timelines if mitigation measures are not taken".
I would presume that the board would have seen to it that stringent mitigating measures were taken to ensure that there are no further delays and timelines are not set back. Please outline what steps or measures have been taken.
Comment on this
Sure. What we are doing about that is we are working very closely with the contractor on the details of the programme. Just to step back a little bit, at the time of contract the contractor puts forward a programme scheduling the works as to how he is going to get from the start of the construction to the end within the timeline set out in the contract. As the work unfolds there are normally changes to that programme. Some things get ahead and some things get behind but in everything things are rarely done exactly in accordance with that programme. The contractor comes up with new programmes and rescheduling of the work. The contractor is developing new programmes at the moment and we are working very closely with him to ensure that those programmes are consistent with the contract.
Comment on this
Has nothing been pinned down? Can Mr. Barry show us a document today that lists the mitigating measures that have been put in place?
Comment on this
Fair enough. I want to ask about the experience of the board. There was a lack of experience on the first board. How many hospitals has Mr. Barry built?