National Paediatric Hospital Development Board: Financial Statements 2018
Contributions 261–522 of 1,051. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
How many hospitals have I built? I have built no hospitals on a greenfield basis. I have worked on hospitals but I have never built any stand-alone hospitals.
Comment on this
No, I am not talking about working or being part of working. Mr. Gunning has said that he has never done either. He has not been involved in the construction of a-----
Comment on this
Sorry, just to answer that a little further. Given my position as Chair of the board, I have been on boards of companies that have been building hospitals. Lots of them.
Comment on this
Who, on the board, is experienced in leading a hospital project of this scale?
Comment on this
We were furnished with a list that contained everybody's details and I did not see any board member who had managed or led a project of this scale before.
Comment on this
Sure. Well, I have certainly managed lots of projects of this scale before.
Comment on this
No. I asked who has led a project.
Comment on this
I have led. I have been project manager, project director on projects of this scale-----
Comment on this
I am talking about a hospital-----
Comment on this
-----because we are talking about something specialised.
Comment on this
So Mr. Barry has not. I ask because of what is stated at the bottom of page 70 of the PwC report regarding controllable risks and please note that the contractors are BAM. It reads: "Contract management. The Contractors understand the contractual relationships better than the NPHDB, allowing them to exploit opportunities to increase prices." Is that not more or less saying they can make buck eejits out of the entire board? Have they made fools of the board? I have cited what the report refers to as one of the controllable risks.
Comment on this
Thank you. I just point to our record during the course of this year where we have dealt with a very large number of contractor claims and we have come out of this fairly well.
Comment on this
Right. I have quoted what is written in black and white in the PwC report.
Comment on this
Black and white is the actual result on the ground.
Comment on this
The report highlights my point about the lack of experience allowing contractors, and the contractor in this case, to play the board for fools as there is no expertise. Let us take, for example, specialised lighting in a hospital setting. The PwC report states that the board will be exploited because of a lack of specialised experience.
Comment on this
Mr. Barry can be gobsmacked but we are talking about public funding and public moneys. It is not the first time that the board was appointed lacking in experience. It is the second time that nobody has specialised experience and nobody has led a project of this nature before. It is a case of déjà vu and we have a board with no experience, a fact that is clearly stated in black and white in the report.
Comment on this
I would say that I am fairly experienced in the management of very large complex projects, including projects very similar in nature to the ones we are dealing with in the hospital. I accept that there may be others much better than me at the job but I was asked to do it. I am not really here to interview for the job.
Comment on this
No but the PwC report highlights the lack of experience on the board and the fact that its members could be exploited, and not for the first time as this is the second board. Hence, the overrun and why we are here in the first instance.
Comment on this
Go raibh maith agat. Before I put questions to our witnesses I want to make the following clear. I do not like witnesses taking a casual approach to the Committee of Public Accounts and getting irritated when questions are put. I very much hope that there will be a step change as the meeting progresses because we can stay here and ask a second, third and fourth round of questions, if needs be.
I am also disappointed that we have not got additional information on what we received last year, which is a point that the Chairman made at the start of the meeting. We are here to hold the witnesses to account in terms of governance, accountability and spend, and the control mechanisms that are in place. I will concentrate on all of that. I will go under the bonnet to see what is actually happening and, hopefully, get responses to my questions. If I do not get responses then we will stay for a second and third round of questions because this is a very important issue. We are here to do a job and we must do it.
I shall start with the guaranteed maximum price. Mr. Barry said, in response to Deputy Munster, that the price of €1.433 billion is guaranteed in the context of the agreed framework and contract and there are residual risks that are outside of that. The €1.433 billion that is guaranteed is only what is guaranteed in terms of what is within the framework of the contract. Is that correct?
Comment on this
In a sense then it is a qualified guarantee. What the public expect and hear when one says there is a "guaranteed maximum price" is that not a cent more above the €1.433 billion will be spent because we have a guaranteed maximum price. When most lay people hear the words "guaranteed" and "maximum" they will think that is the price and the amount will not go beyond that but that is not the case. Can we at least accept as a start that the guaranteed maximum price is a qualified maximum price and that it is possible if not likely that the price will be higher than €1.433 billion?
Comment on this
Residual risks have been mentioned. What are the residual risks and in what areas will there be possible risk? Residual risks were talked about. Are they the areas for additional claims? Additional cost claims that can be made by the developer were mentioned. A developer may make a claim but it does not necessarily mean they will be paid so one has to go into a negotiation, there will be a barter and they may or may not be paid. I assume that is what Mr. Barry was talking about. There are residual risks and because of them there may well be additional cost claims. If that is the case, if Mr. Barry agrees with that, can he outline the areas in which there is the possibility of a risk in terms of additional costs?
Comment on this
Certainly, I will do that. I would just add to it because the contractor's claims are not restricted to what we would call residual risks. The contractor can legitimately claim that we, on our side, have been late in providing access to something or late in providing information, or have mis-described something, and that might lead to an additional-----
Comment on this
That makes the guaranteed maximum price even less guaranteed.
Comment on this
My point is that the claims can be for matters that are, in our view, perhaps contained within the guaranteed-----
Comment on this
Okay. There are two distinctions.
Comment on this
There are possible mistakes that the board may have made and I am not saying it did.
Comment on this
And then there are the residual risks.
Comment on this
And then there are residual risks. Yes, indeed.
Comment on this
I get the first part. I would like a breakdown of the possible residual risks.
Comment on this
Among the residual risks are client changes, changes to the design. They might arise, perhaps, with the medical practitioners. Practices have changed over the years while the project was being built and some change was asked to be made to the building. That would be, and I think appropriately, not something that the contractor would have included for in the original price.
If we, on our side of the State, were to introduce changes to the design-----
Comment on this
Design changes are one potential.
Comment on this
We have talked about inflation. If inflation is over 4%, that cost will fall.
Comment on this
Is that one of the residual risks?
Comment on this
I will get to that in a moment and I have questions on it. What else is there?
Comment on this
If there any regulatory changes that lead to an increase in costs, that is, changes in legislation or regulations from any of the many bodies that have regulatory control over the operating of hospitals, which could manifest themselves as design changes-----
Comment on this
When Mr. Barry referred to design changes, changes in regulations and so on, are they ones for which a claim could be made, although that does not necessarily mean that the claim will be paid? If, for example, the developer submitted a claim as a consequence of one of the residual risks relating to design changes or the regulations he outlined, I imagine there would be negotiation. Is that how it would work?
Comment on this
Indeed. If there were a change for one of those reasons, the contractor would be entitled to be paid.
Comment on this
There is no guarantee the contractor would be paid. There would have to be a negotiation between the board and the company.
Comment on this
There would have to be, but the contractor would be entitled to be paid for those changes and would be paid for them.
Comment on this
There were already some cost controls. Mr. Barry stated the board manages the claims that are received. A range of claims could be received and there may well be pushback from the board on some of them to protect the taxpayer, as he noted.
Comment on this
That can happen in certain circumstances where it is not guaranteed that simply because a developer makes a claim, he or she will be paid.
Comment on this
Inflation is not one such circumstance.
Comment on this
To clarify, the entitlement to payment through inflation is not one of the circumstances the Deputy outlined. There will be issues around when particular costs fall and there may be some arguments over the calculation of the amount to be paid-----
Comment on this
Mr. Barry might confirm my understanding or, if I am wrong, correct me. My understanding is that inflation of 4% is built into the contract. Is that correct?
Comment on this
If inflation is less than 4%, will there be clawback for the State?
Comment on this
I regret to say that is an academic point because I think inflation is running at about 7% this year.
Comment on this
That was not the question I asked, because I know that. If it was less than 4%, would we get money back?
Comment on this
We get no money back if it is less than 4%, but if it is above 4%, we will have to pay the difference.
Comment on this
The risk, in terms of inflation, will be carried by the State. Why is that? I ask Mr. Barry because he is leading the project-----
Comment on this
I am leading the project but did not have anything to do with the negotiations of the contract. I am implementing the contract as agreed. I did not have a role in the negotiations.
Comment on this
We have to examine where mistakes may have been made. Could that have been one such mistake, where better controls should have been put in place?
Comment on this
To go back to my earlier point, it is most unlikely that one would get any substantial contractor to agree to carry inflation risk on a contract of six or seven years. Contractors will not accept the risk, and that is a matter beyond the children's hospital, or us, or -----
Comment on this
Why include the rate of 4% in that case? If it was included, one would expect that some attempt must have been made to mitigate the risk. In fact, there was none, given that if it is less than 4%, we will get nothing back, while it is more than 4%, the State will have to pay more.
Comment on this
My point is that irrespective of that, we can all accept that at the end of the year, inflation will be above 4% and there will be an additional cost. Is that fair to say?
Comment on this
That additional cost will be on top of the €1.433 billion. At least in this area, therefore, there will be an additional cost for the taxpayer.
Comment on this
It goes back to the set of minutes that Deputy Munster mentioned earlier. It was redacted where the board discussed the risks associated with inflation. Mr. Barry stated the discussion was probably about what the board would have to pay in "certain circumstances" - those were the words he used - if inflation were to go above 4%.
Comment on this
There was a discussion at the board. If the cost will have to be paid, it is not commercially sensitive.
Comment on this
The fact of having to pay is not commercially sensitive-----
Comment on this
In that case, why not give us the information? We should have the information. I do not see any issue with it. If there is to be an additional cost, my estimate is it will be approximately €40 million. I am not an expert but it is my estimate in light of what inflation will be.
I will ask a question rather than giving my view, which Mr. Barry might consider unfair. Is it the case that the minutes were redacted and he does want to give us the information because he does not want a headline to result from a meeting of the committee to the effect that the cost will higher than €1.433 billion? It goes back to the issue the Chairman raised earlier, namely, that we are not getting any additional information because there is a preciousness over the cost. For understandable reasons, the costs have escalated and the board discussed the matter. We have a responsibility to probe the information. We have a version of the minutes that has been redacted in respect of what is clearly either another cost overrun or an additional cost, yet Mr. Barry is not in a position to tell us the figure. I do not know why and I can only surmise. Is it because he does not want, at this point, the public and the committee to know there could be an additional cost of at least €40 million for construction inflation?
Comment on this
There were a number of questions. First, it is already in the public domain, and we referenced the figures in the PwC report, that if inflation is over 4%, there will be extra costs over the €1.433 billion. I reiterate that inflation this year is running at about 7%. It is an absolute certainty that we will pay extra money on foot of that inflation. If inflation runs at 7% for the life of the project, the total additional cost from inflation will be in the order of €50 million. If it is higher, it will be more, while if it is less, it will be less. There is no suggestion on our part that there is not going to be an additional cost from inflation over the €1.433 billion. If I have given the impression that we think there will not be a cost through inflation, I did not mean to give that impression.
Comment on this
Is that €50 million over the entire period of seven years?
Comment on this
When something like that is redacted-----
Comment on this
-----we are left to guess because we are not in the know. When we do not know, it naturally raises people's curiosity.
Comment on this
When a section of the minutes stating there was a discussion on the risks associated with inflation is redacted, it will obviously pique our interest-----
Comment on this
-----and still I have not heard a satisfactory response as to why the section was redacted. Mr. Barry stated an officer made the decision. Who makes such a decision?
Comment on this
Does that information officer work for the board?
Comment on this
Mr. Barry cannot tell us why the information officer made the decision but only who made it. Will he provide a reason?
Comment on this
I can give a little colour without infringing on anything. Part of our considerations at the moment are around how much we will pay for this year. We have a pretty good idea in that regard but there will be some negotiations around it. For the committee's interest, assuming inflation stays at 7% this year, depending on how much is paid in invoices at the end of the year and the exact figure, the additional cost for 2019 will be in the order of €2 million or €2.2 million. We will not have the exact figures until we get the indices, which will come out-----
Comment on this
That is helpful. Perhaps if that information had been given at the start, I would have avoided having to spend five minutes trying to get it. Will Mr. Barry expand on his point that there will be a level of negotiation? I do not want to be unfair to the board. My understanding was that once inflation exceeded 4%, the additional cost would have to be paid, whatever it was. If there is to be a bartering on the matter-----
Comment on this
It is not quite so much bartering but there may be an issue as to when certain costs land and, consequently-----
Comment on this
Is Mr. Barry saying the 7% is year by year based on the cost landing on the invoice when paid?
Comment on this
Per annum. If for two years of the project, inflation runs at 7%, we pay the balance. If in three years, inflation is 2%, we will save nothing.
Comment on this
Certainly. If inflation runs at 7% this year and 7% next year-----
Comment on this
Three percent this year, and we are caught for 6% next year if there has been inflation of 14% and only 8% covered in the contract.
Comment on this
If the inflation runs cumulatively at 7%, at 30% over and the contract only covers-----
Comment on this
It is estimated that construction inflation is softening a little. It may well be 6% to 7% this year but it may well be less next year and the year after.
Comment on this
It may well be less, in which case we benefit.
Comment on this
Is the board doing that type of analysis now? Where does Mr. Barry get his information from? I would imagine that if he were trying to control costs, he would be looking at the bodies that do the work in regard to construction inflation and looking ahead to what the costs will be. He said it is cumulative.
Comment on this
If we had to bet money on it, we would take it as about 7% running through but a lot depends on how much the State is going to spend in the period. There will be changes in the economy, and Government spending is going to change. Private sector spending is going to change. That can move up or down. This goes back to debates I have had with various representatives. When we look forward and ask what the level of inflation is going to be in the sector in a couple of years, we look at what the CSO and all the forecasters state but there is no absolute consensus.
Comment on this
At least, however, there is acceptance that there will be an additional cost. Mr. Barry also said this at a meeting of the Joint Committee on Health. It is almost certain there will be additional costs associated with inflation. With regard to the other residual risks or other claims that may be made by the developer, is it his view that there will be additional costs associated with other elements or elements other than inflation? He mentioned earlier that it is almost certain that-----
Comment on this
It is. Regarding the issue of design change, it is very usual in long-running projects for the end-users' requirements to change a little as the project goes along. I certainly see that in the private sector all the time. Consequently, based on my experience, I expect that some changes will be introduced into the project at the back end.
Comment on this
Does the board, or Mr. Barry as its chairman, have meetings with the Minister?
Comment on this
I was not at last week's meeting but I am here now and I am asking the question.
Comment on this
Indeed. I do not take minutes of those meetings. The records that are kept of those meetings are kept by the civil servants supporting the Minister. Whether he has minutes produced or whether file notes are kept is a matter-----
Comment on this
Are there records of the meetings? Surely from a good governance perspective, there will be somebody present to take minutes of the meetings. At the meetings, does Mr. Barry discuss the potential of increased costs in terms of some of the residual risks or reasons there may be additional costs? Does this come up in any of the discussions with the Minister?
Comment on this
What comes up with the Minister generally are issues around progress on the project, where we stand on the cost-----
Comment on this
I did not ask that. I am sure all those issues arise but I am asking whether Mr. Barry has ever had a discussion with the Minister at any of the meetings about the possibility of additional costs and the fact that there are risks. Has he said to the Minister that, while he is on target, there may well be additional costs?
Comment on this
And that is not minuted on Mr. Barry's part?
Comment on this
I can talk about attendance at those meetings. The question arose last week about the recent meeting in November. There is a record of that meeting. It is on the file. We record the meeting. There was toing and froing as to whether the record was a minute. A minute is usually signed off at a subsequent meeting and everybody agrees on it. We do not do that at all the meetings where Ministers meet people. We take our own record. We place it on the file and that suffices for-----
Comment on this
I accept that. That is a credible answer. I have no difficulty with the answer but the difficulty concerns where there are additional costs. We should remember the history of this project. There were additional costs, and questions were asked about when Ministers knew or did not. There was no suggestion that the Ministers had done anything wrong. Let me outline what creates suspicion and difficulties. Let us just say there are additional costs, that they have been discussed at meetings with the Minister and that a future Committee of Public Accounts is looking for notes of minutes and is told there were none, or that there was a note that was not a minute-----
Comment on this
I know Mr. Breslin has confirmed that but I suggest that if there are meetings taking place between the chairman of the board and the Minister and discussions on additional costs, bearing in mind the importance of this issue and the significant cost overrun, there should be proper record-keeping to allow us and members of a future Committee of Public Accounts to do our job. It would be better for the Minister. How many times has the HSE found itself in a position where there were difficulties over record-keeping and minutes, and what was in them and what was not? If clear minutes are taken, there is no issue.
Comment on this
I am in agreement. The Deputy will have seen over the course of this project that there has been no lack of record-keeping. We published all of that. It went to PwC. It showed the timeline of all the escalations and the information. There is a record of the most recent meeting too.
Comment on this
I have one final question and I will move on then. It relates to what Deputy Munster said earlier. The BAM report is in some respects quite damning regarding the board. I do not refer to Mr. Barry; I refer to the previous incarnation of the board. I acknowledge he said there have been a number of changes. It is stated that the contractors - in this case, BAM - understand the contractual relationships better than the development board, allowing them to exploit opportunities to increase prices. It is quite incredible that this is what PwC arrived at. I would like Mr. Barry's or Mr. Breslin's understanding of it. My layman's reading of it is that there may have been a lack of expertise in regard to how the contract works and cost controls. If there are many potential additional claims, people are needed who have the experience and knowledge to address them. PwC's view is that the contractors understand the contractual relationships better than the development board.
Comment on this
I think PwC identified this as a risk rather than a fact of the case. I think it was put by them-----
Comment on this
Notwithstanding that, it is still damning.
Comment on this
The context within which PwC framed some of this was that it considered that some of the expertise was in the design team rather than in the development board itself, and some of the integration within the design team and between the design team and the executive in the development board needed to be strengthened. I know that the development board has substantially enhanced its claims-management process and has brought expertise into the board to support it in that regard. It has stronger control systems in place post-PwC than would have been in place at the time.
Comment on this
The witnesses are welcome. I have one or two questions arising from the opening statement. One of the things we do is try to decode language or spot things that may imply something that one expects to mean something different. I have two questions in that regard. The first is on the Blanchardstown facility. It was handed over to CHI. Since we last met, services have commenced there. When will they be fully operational? Knowing that will give us some sort of an idea as to how the children's hospital will work when fully operational.
Comment on this
I will take that. I thank the Deputy. This is the first time representatives of CHI have been before the committee.
Children's Health Ireland is a State body established under the Children's Health Act 2018 and a section 38 organisation under the health Act, which means it is commissioned to provide services under the HSE via an annual service arrangement. Children's Health Ireland commenced operation in January 2019. Our main role is to provide services to approximately 336,000 children who turn up to our paediatric services at Crumlin Hospital, Temple Street hospital, Tallaght Hospital and the new facility at Connolly Hospital Blanchardstown which opened in July. These four services operate as one organisation, led by one board and one management team. We provide services through 4,000 staff, working through 39 different clinical specialties, to the sickest children of 25% of the population and all of the children in the greater Dublin area.
Comment on this
As I have limited time, I would like a response to my question.
Comment on this
The facility at Connolly Hospital was handed over on 31 July. There are two major elements to it, namely, outpatients and urgent care. Outpatients is fully operational, Monday to Friday, 9.a.m. to 6 p.m, providing general paediatric services. It is building up its services incrementally and it is working very well. In regard to urgent care, we have had challenges in recruiting emergency medicine consultants. When the facility opened, we had seven new emergency medicine consultants, which is a great increase, but due to unplanned leave and an inability to find locums, we could not expand the opening hours beyond Monday to Friday, 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. The facility closes at 8 p.m. but it takes approximately three hours to clear the department of patients.
Comment on this
When will the facility be fully operational?
Comment on this
It is dependent on our recruitment strategy. We have a pipeline of consultants coming in over 2020. When they come on board, we will be able to expand the service. Between now and then, what we are trying to do is increase the hours-----
Comment on this
When it is expected to be fully operational?
Comment on this
It is dependent on getting these consultants in 2020.
Comment on this
So, Ms Hardiman cannot be sure it will be fully operational in 2020.
Comment on this
We have a good idea of a pipeline of consultants that we need to address to this area. Paediatric radiologists are one of the areas where there is a challenge. We have identified consultants, who we appoint proleptically, which means they get a position but they may be finishing off their training before they start.
Comment on this
I am trying to get an idea of the challenges of operating this small facility.
Comment on this
This is about a model of care. Children's Health Ireland is trying to change how we deliver services. The model of care is very much around-----
Comment on this
I am sorry but I must move on. Many of the issues in regard to this facility are matters for the Joint Committee on Health. I am trying to deal with matters relevant to this committee. We are building a hospital that is to be completed on a particular date from the point of view of BAM and other contractors walking off the site and the hospital being handed over. The operation of this facility gives us some idea of the likely challenges of getting that hospital fully operational. I will move on.
The second issue arising from the opening statement is the updates on all aspects of project delivery. Controlling costs is critically important. A lengthy list of technicians is involved in the project, including quantity surveyors, architectural technicians, valuation officers and portfolio planners. I would like Mr. Gunning to elaborate on the role of each of these professionals and if that role changes over time. We are all interested in containing cost overruns or even reducing some costs. What are the prospects of that happening?
Comment on this
I will ask my colleague, Mr. Phelim Devine, to follow up in case I miss any particular points. The Chairman made an interesting point about the National Paediatric Hospital Development Board when he said, "They go way when the development is over." The organisation has been set up for a specific purpose and it is staffed by a wide range of contractors and consultants on a particular basis, including a design team of over 200 from whom we purchase services. We have people closer to the organisation who are part of the national paediatric hospital organisation. These are known as constructive management services and they provide an array of different services on site. We also buy in specialist services from others. Deputy Murphy is correct that there is a lengthy list of urban planners, healthcare planners, architects, building engineers, civil and structural engineers and so on.
In the design team we have, predominantly, a large number of architects. BDP is the lead architectural firm. It also provides what is know as the employers' representative function. We have quantity surveyors from Linesight, who measure costs and do various other activities. The ARUP company provides mechanical and electrical, primarily design verification, services and supervises implementation of that on site. We then have an organisation called OCSE Civil and Structural Work looking at all the structural design, the concrete, the steel and the pulling together of the whole thing. They are the range of services within the project.
Comment on this
Mr. Gunning might provide a follow-up note to the committee on how that has changed over time.
Comment on this
The architectural side will probably reduce and other specialties will probably increase so Mr. Gunning might provide a note outlining how that has changed.
Comment on this
How does this project compare with a private sector build or other public sector build in terms of the level of administration? Is there any variation in that regard, or is it pretty similar?
Comment on this
I came to this project around two months ago. It is well staffed but it is pretty lean. We do not have any surplus staff. In terms of administration, there is administration in all of the key areas but it is around contract administration and claims administration. As we are engaged in processes that are legal or quasi-legal in terms of conciliation and arbitration, it is really important that there is excellent record keeping and we are in a position to find information. We have strengthened the team and our software support and so on to enable that.
Comment on this
I do not mean to diminish the role of administration because it is critically important, but I wanted to know how it compared. Following a lengthy discussion on this issue last year, the committee published a particular page in its periodic report which contained a table of the various components.
Comment on this
It is page 88 of the committee's periodic report. Leaving aside building inflation and other issues arising from design changes, the project is on course to complete at a cost of €1.43 billion. In terms of this table, are there variations from what was presented last year? If the witnesses do not have that information to hand, they might provide the committee with an updated table of the profile of changes at a later date.
Comment on this
Yes, we can provide the Deputy with an updated table. I could not give the individual accounts off the cuff but we will do that.
Comment on this
It would be useful if we had a similar initiative on a constant basis. We could then see where changes are taking place. In respect of our periodic report, there were 11 recommendations from the PwC report. Have they all been implemented at this stage?
Comment on this
We and the board have implemented them as they refer to ourselves and the board. Some of the recommendations are broader and perhaps the Secretary General might want to speak to those. The development board has implemented all the recommendations made that are addressed to us.
Comment on this
I mentioned at the outset that the development board and ourselves have led on the implementation of a range of the recommendations, including the splitting of the role between the chief officer and project director, as the Deputy sees today. Approvals were given for those and recruitment done. The two recommendations that relate to major capital projects in general, not specifically the national children's hospital, are relevant to the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform, which is on the record as saying it is taking them into account in how it is going to revise the public spending code. I think the Chairman referenced the fact that they have updated the committee on that and expect to conclude it shortly. As an addendum to that, I also identified earlier that as soon as we have that, at the same time as the public spending code concludes, we would intend to revise our overarching governance structures to make sure we are fully in line with the public spending code. That will streamline the bit above the development board in Children's Health Ireland, which people have commented on. I think they are fair comments.
Comment on this
If changes have taken place in structures, other than the outline we had, it would be useful to see a map of those.
Comment on this
As soon as we make that decision, and we will have to go back to Government with it because Government approved the original structures, we will write to the committee and advise it.
Comment on this
I want to go back to Children's Health Ireland. It engaged external expertise and technical support, according to today's briefing paper, and €35.1 million has been invested across the workstreams. There is long-term investment there. That was between 2016 and 2019. Given that Children's Health Ireland has not employed many of the people who will run the services in Blanchardstown, is this work concluded? Is it delayed by virtue of the fact that Children's Health Ireland does not have the staffing fully in place?
Comment on this
Again to give the context for that, I outlined what we do on a day-to-day basis, which is delivering services across four sites in Dublin. In addition to that, we are actually client to the project. For the last six years, we have been working with the development board inputting into the design of the hospital. We have inputted into the business cases and the ICT that is required to deliver this hospital. When the business case was approved by Government in 2017, we clearly indicated that we had to bring on expertise to take on the client role to support the design and development of the hospital. What I have included in those costs are, for example, we have set up a new entity, Children's Health Ireland. We have had to dissolve the boards of two other voluntary hospitals and dissolve those organisations. All of the legal work and what we call the pre-commencement assessment and review process make up some of those costs. That is expertise in mergers, for example, and legal expertise that we would not have in Children's Health Ireland. Like the development board, these are short-term initiatives that we had to do. Besides providing the services to children - I appreciate that the work we are doing is challenging and we badly need this hospital because of that - we have to integrate the three children's hospitals. When we looked at major projects like this, there are not many in the world that merge three hospitals and then move them into a new hospital. If we do not get the integration correct, there will be challenges around that. We are working with the staff to get our clinical and corporate processes aligned and to align how we actually operate. This investment has been around standardising our models of care and a significant amount of it has been around ICT. That is the other remit we have. We are implementing projects now in the children's hospitals as single instances that we move into the children's hospital. It is investment that we need to make now to make it happen.
Comment on this
I understand that it is necessary to get that integration correct. The vast majority of people will understand that money needs to be spent on that side and on the physical side. The greatest disappointment is the delay in the facility becoming fully operational. What work is Children's Health Ireland doing to minimise the delay in opening the new national children's hospital or can that even be done at this stage? I know it is a few years away but clearly there is a learning curve here in respect of this delay. What is Children's Health Ireland doing and what can be done?
Comment on this
Maybe if I can clarify, this is not just around investing to open up the new services in Connolly, although that is a really important part. This integration is about merging hospitals and we know from national and international experiences that this can be a challenge. Something like 75% of mergers do not achieve success. Very early on, we were working on the process to be commenced as a single organisation, which we have just done this year. A significant amount of investment was to make that happen. When we opened up Connolly it afforded us an opportunity to have, for example, a single, unique identifier for all of the patients in Children's Health Ireland. That means that the patients can go to any of our facilities and the staff can see their records. It is a really important safety issue and also it is a really important matter when we are under pressure. We are now actually moving the patients and the staff around to where the resources are. We have invested-----
Comment on this
I am sorry but I have limited time. We have very deficient services at the moment.
Comment on this
We are seeing serious problems with delays in children receiving care, even down to queues and pain management. We have a facility here that has been opened, yet the accident and emergency department-----
Comment on this
Urgent care is operating from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., Monday to Friday. The service is not fully operational and may not be fully operational next year. There is a serious concern about the investment actually delivering the outcomes that would have been expected from it.
Comment on this
We have delivered and I want to demonstrate that to the Deputy. It has already been demonstrated by our waiting lists. The Deputy is right that we have long waiting lists. For example, general paediatrics is one of the services in which we have invested. They have developed new ways of working and are now using an automated system to look at their patients. In the last six months, we have reduced our general paediatrics waiting list by 35%. That has been done because the paediatricians are working across the cities and we are managing-----
Comment on this
Crumlin, Temple Street, Tallaght and Connolly. The most important part of it, I would say, is that we have some long waiters and we started with them first. Our long waiting lists, meaning anything over 12 months, which is the target set by the HSE and which should be shorter, we have managed to reduce that by 65% in five months. The reason we have done it is that we have new ways of working and new facilities open.
That is really important because these new ways of working are-----
Comment on this
Is the urgent care situation better or worse?
Comment on this
We have had horrendous pressures across all our hospitals. I acknowledge the experience of Deputy O'Connell and other families, for which we apologise. We are dealing with a significant pressure arising from the flu and respiratory illness winter season. Without the unit at Connolly hospital, it would have been an awful lot worse. That facility has allowed us to decompress some of the other emergency departments and move patients to wherever there are better facilities. We have also been able to move staff. That was possible because we have the same systems in place across the hospitals, so the staff are familiar with the set-up. In addition, we have an IT system which shows where all the beds are in each hospital. Our staff are now working in an integrated way. The important point to emphasise is that it takes a lot of time to plan and put things in place, but it means we will be ready to get working when we move to the new hospital.
Comment on this
Finally, will Ms Hardiman provide us with a note on the outstanding areas in which Children's Health Ireland has not fully recruited and what the profile is likely to be so that we have some understanding of how this investment will deliver better services?
Comment on this
I am happy to do so. We are working on a workforce plan. We acknowledge that there are challenges and that we need to start planning now for what we will be delivering in a few years' time.
Comment on this
Ms Hardiman should submit the information Deputy Murphy requested to the committee secretariat.
Comment on this
I am looking forward to the day when we have equal gender representation among witnesses, particularly in respect of the children's hospital. I preface every contribution I make at the committee with that comment. It is no reflection on the witnesses, but I am sometimes dismayed by the systems that allow inequality to persist.
I did not welcome the pictures the witnesses from the hospital development board showed us. They seem to have been misadvised on that point. The witnesses are here for the purposes of accountability. We do not need to see photographs of a construction site. What we do need to see is that the right processes are in place, there is proper accountability, we are not wasting any more money and, in particular, that other projects are not affected.
Were the witnesses from the hospital development board advised by a public relations company in respect of their attendance at today's meeting?
Comment on this
As the Deputy may be aware, Q4PR is an adviser to us on press, public and community affairs and a range of other issues. We take its advice on a regular basis.
Comment on this
Were the witnesses advised in regard to their attendance at this meeting?
Comment on this
Did the witnesses have what might be called a pre-meeting about how they would answer questions and present themselves today?
Comment on this
I do not know exactly but we certainly talked though some of the topics and issues.
Comment on this
Why was that necessary?
Comment on this
We want to make sure the answers we provide are as complete as possible and that we meet members' particular needs and requirements.
Comment on this
How much did the advice cost?
Comment on this
The Deputy will be aware that we have a multi-year agreement in place-----
Comment on this
Will Mr. Gunning remind me of the financial details? I have it in my head that the cost is something like €200,000 per year?
Comment on this
The cost of communications in 2018, including VAT, was €338,000. The figure for this year, up to October 2019, is €285,000.
Comment on this
Does that include training for the witnesses to appear before this committee, the health committee or any other committee?
Comment on this
Might we be given a copy of that scope of work?
Comment on this
I am happy to provide it. It is more about community and stakeholder engagement than Oireachtas committee meetings.
Comment on this
On page 21 of the accounts I see a reference to communications and community engagement. "Engagement" is a lovely word. How much of the total cost went into communications in terms of communicating press releases and training, as opposed to community engagement? The total figure for 2018 is €338,451, which is extraordinary.
Comment on this
Will Mr. Gunning provide that information to the Chairman?
Comment on this
I am happy to provide a breakdown of the effort involved.
Comment on this
We all want to see the hospital up and running and I wish the witnesses all the best in that regard. We want moneys to be used efficiently so that so everyone can access a public health service. That is why we are here. The background to this is before my time but I understand the previous Committee of Public Accounts was assured that what happened before would never happen again. Not alone has it happened again but it is just as bad as the first time. I understand €30 million or €35 million was written off on the previous occasion and now we are dealing with the same issue again. I do not need photographs of construction sites but I do need to know the cost of the overall project and when mistakes are made and that the witnesses are learning from those mistakes. It is totally unacceptable to have that level of spending on the services of a public relations company. It is an absolute waste of taxpayers' money. The witnesses are here for the purposes of accountability. Our work should be done in a polite way and none of our questions should be put in a personalised fashion. However, the witnesses must be held to account at this committee and every committee before which they appear. They do not need to consult a public relations company for that purpose. There is something seriously wrong if they are resorting to that and, in this instance, they were ill advised on the question of producing photographs.
Mr. Gunning has undertaken to provide the committee with a breakdown of spending under the heading of communications and community engagement. Spending on other professional fees was €793,000 in 2018, which is a huge jump as far as I can see. What does that expenditure include? Does it include fees for external bodies?
Comment on this
The overall figure of €793,000 for professional fees is made up of a range of costs, including those relating to the adjudication and standing conciliator services associated with the project. These are professionals who are supporting the project-----
Comment on this
I have no problem with professionals being paid. I would just like a list of them to see where the moneys went. If Mr. Farragher does not have the information to hand, he might send it to the Chairman in due course.
Comment on this
We have that information and will send it to the committee.
Comment on this
On page 4 of the financial statement, we are told that the board set up a committee to consider and address the recommendations of the internal audit that was done by Mazars. Who is on that committee, how often does it meet, how is its work proceeding and is there a plan of implementation for the recommendations in the Mazars report?
Comment on this
A sub-committee of the board was set up to address the implementation of the Mazars and the PwC recommendations.
Comment on this
I understand the PwC report cost almost €500,000. What was the cost of the audit by Mazars?
Comment on this
There was a payment of €180,000 to Mazars in 2018, which includes its internal audit as well as other work it did.
Comment on this
The PwC report was the larger cost.
Comment on this
Yes, but it is not in our accounts because it was commissioned by the HSE.
Comment on this
I will come back to the HSE witnesses on that point. Will Mr. Barry indicate the membership of the committee, how often it meets and the implementation plan for the recommendations?
Comment on this
The committee was chaired by me and included other members of the board, with members of the executive reporting into it. We are finished as a committee because we have implemented all of the recommendations as they applied to the hospital board.
Comment on this
How often did the committee meet?
Comment on this
How many recommendations were there?
Comment on this
There were six or seven PwC recommendations referred to us directly and they have all been implemented.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Barry. There is a reference on page 4 to ongoing monitoring and review.
Formal procedures are in place. All of that is welcome. Mention is made of key risks and related controls being identified and processes being in place. What are the key risks and controls?
Comment on this
Where we used to have an audit committee, we now have an audit and risk committee with a specific responsibility for monitoring risk management within the organisation. We have appointed an individual within the organisation as the risk officer to help identify and channel our responses to various risks. We are reviewing risk at the board meeting as a specific agenda item every month.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Barry in a position to say what risks have been identified?
Comment on this
I will give the broad categories. The main risks and challenges facing the project relate to the commissioning, startup and certification of facilities where third party certification and validation are required, and the transfer of those facilities from us as a developer to Children's Health Ireland as their manager.
Comment on this
What does that mean in plain English?
Comment on this
We are the developers, which means we are building the hospital and taking it through construction startup. We have to transfer everything over to Children's Health Ireland, which will be operating the hospital. The handing over and transition from the construction startup to operations poses a significant challenge for us all. Failing to get that right is a key risk.
Comment on this
The risks are of things not working properly.
Comment on this
Why would they not work properly? What would not work properly? The development board has been appointed to build, design and furnish.
Comment on this
What are the risks?
Comment on this
The risks are around the transfer of a built facility that meets the requirements we have set over to an operating entity that is expected to operate and manage this enormous, new and highly sophisticated building. I am not saying that there will be problems. Rather, I am saying that one of the risks we need to address is to ensure that we manage that properly.
Comment on this
Mr. Barry is saying that there is a process in place, including a risk and audit committee and a risk officer, to identify risks on an ongoing basis and to deal with them.
Comment on this
We will not be taken by surprise in the future if a risk emerges that the board has not identified or dealt with.
Comment on this
I sincerely hope not.
Comment on this
I am sorry, but I missed the first part of the Deputy's statement. She said: "We will not-----
Comment on this
"We will not be taken by surprise in the future".
Comment on this
I thank the Chairman, who tried to clarify the issue of the overall structures at the beginning. We have the Department of Health, the HSE, CHI, which is a new statutory entity, and the witnesses' board. What is it called?
Comment on this
The National Paediatric Hospital Development Board.
Comment on this
Is there also a children's hospital group board?
Comment on this
No. That was us. We were part of the hospital groups' establishment in 2013 as part of the HSE. Under our legislation, which commenced in January, the then Children's Hospital group, as well as the three hospitals of Our Lady's Children's Hospital, Crumlin, the Temple Street Children's University Hospital and the paediatric services at Tallaght Hospital, all moved into CHI.
Comment on this
CHI is the equivalent of the Saolta University Health Care Group in the west.