National Paediatric Hospital Development Board: Financial Statements 2018
Contributions 523–786 of 1,051. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
It is the entity over a group of hospitals.
Comment on this
Then there are the various structures. What happened to the group on the ground that had the philanthropic role and was trying to get extra money from McDonald's? I cannot remember the charity's exact name. The group was looking at ways of providing rooms for parents and research.
Comment on this
CHI has the statutory mandate for philanthropy.
Comment on this
Where did the other group go? There was another committee.
Comment on this
I might be able to help. I am not entirely sure but I will try to clarify. Is the Deputy referring to the charity for family accommodation?
Comment on this
That is the charity, but I understand that a group or committee was set up whose function was to raise funds from charities for research and development.
Comment on this
The charity for family accommodation is one group. Each of the three children's hospitals had its own foundation. Crumlin had its own foundation. Temple Street had its own-----
Comment on this
I am not interested in the foundations at the moment. Under these structures, I understood that there was another committee. I cannot remember its name. When the witnesses appeared before us previously, it was called the "Children's Project Group" or something. It sought out funds. Is there any group like that currently?
Comment on this
All I can say is that, in the statute setting up Children's Health Ireland, there is a specific function around philanthropy. It includes research and fundraising from philanthropy.
Comment on this
Maybe I am making a mistake, but the witnesses cannot clarify what the group was. They are saying that there is no group currently other than CHI, which has this function under statute. There is the NPHDB and the board of CHI. Is the chair of the latter the former president of NUI Galway?
Comment on this
Is there gender equality on the board?
Comment on this
Yes. Of the board, 42% of members are female. Of my executive, 60% are female.
Comment on this
Lovely. Where are we with the philanthropy role? To preface my remarks, I have a major difficulty with the use of charity and philanthropy in a public hospital.
Comment on this
I am sorry, but what is the Deputy's question?
Comment on this
Tell me about the philanthropy role.
Comment on this
I will start with some of the history, which the Deputy seems to understand. Each of the three children's hospitals, as independent voluntary hospitals up until December of this year, had its own associated foundation. As part of our merger and integration of the three hospitals, the foundations have agreed to merge into one foundation. Speaking personally, I was delighted with that because I was the chief executive of a hospital - Tallaght Hospital - with three foundations. That was a positive change. The foundations were independent charities, but they were affiliated. The new foundation's sole purpose is to raise funds for us. Internationally, children's hospitals have a good reputation in that regard.
Comment on this
There is one foundation now, the role of which is to raise funds.
Comment on this
Correct, and the purpose of the funds is solely for Children's Health Ireland and to support research. Those are the primary reasons for raising funds.
Comment on this
Will the foundation be consolidated within CHI's accounts?
Comment on this
No. It is not a part of our organisation.
Comment on this
Will it appear before our committee?
Comment on this
There will be no scrutiny of that foundation.
Comment on this
The Charities Regulator regulates charities. It is through that process that accountability, oversight and scrutiny of those-----
Comment on this
I have heard that said before, but speaking as a member of this committee, I am not happy. Foundations have been set up within universities. Lately, Trinity College Dublin has "consolidated", I think is the word-----
Comment on this
It had a separate foundation. When it appeared before us to go through its accounts, it had consolidated the foundation's accounts, meaning that we had "scrutiny" of same. Trinity has led the way. I do not believe that Maynooth University has a foundation. Did it consolidate? I cannot recall. The other universities have not done it yet. CHI is following a pattern of having a foundation that is not open to scrutiny by the Committee of Public Accounts.
Comment on this
I am happy to consider the emerging precedents in other sectors. One of our objectives was to have charitable status so that someone could give to the entity. If we can preserve the charitable status and consider the precedents that are emerging, we will look at the issue and revert to the committee.
Comment on this
It is important. In a hospital of this nature, the foundation's uses should be open to maximum scrutiny, particularly in respect of research and development.
Has it been confirmed how many rooms will be available for families? Are we still waiting on the never-never for that?
Comment on this
Within the base build of the hospital, there are 30 dedicated rooms for families, particularly pertaining to critical care. External to the hospital, which is not part of the NPHDB's remit, is the 53-bed family accommodation unit, which is to be built by the charity.
Comment on this
Just to clarify, it made sense to agree that we build the foundations and the basement for that building but above basement level will be built by the charity.
Comment on this
Has that been agreed and the charity identified? Has a time been given for the building?
Comment on this
Negotiations are under way on the arrangements, costs and financing of that. We have asked the HSE to look at it in further detail and have not yet reached a conclusion. The Deputy knows from our previous discussions that the charity that is currently on the Crumlin site has put forward a proposal to run that accommodation.
Comment on this
What is the charity?
Comment on this
It is Ronald McDonald House Charities Ireland.
Comment on this
Let me go back to the fact that there are 30 rooms.
Comment on this
I will add that all of the individual bedrooms are single bedrooms with a patient bed. There is accommodation in all of the inpatient bedrooms for a parent.
Comment on this
Very good. Separately, there are 30 rooms.
Comment on this
That is right. There are not bedrooms or beds for parents in intensive care because of the nature of that care. There is extra accommodation, should it be required.
Comment on this
What was the number of rooms required for parents or families in the design? What is the required number of rooms?
Comment on this
What was the plan? What is the required complement?
Comment on this
We have planned for a parent bed in every individual bedroom. There will be a comfortable lounger-type armchair in intensive care so that parent who want to stay with their child can do so comfortably. It will not be an upright chair but one in which a parent can rest within the intensive care rooms. There are 30 extra rooms should it not suit a parent to stay in a child or young person's bedroom, or if the child is intensive care.
Comment on this
Why are the extra 53 rooms to be built by the charity needed?
Comment on this
I will answer that. We already have this facility in Crumlin Hospital. We have a 20-bed unit that has been run for the past 15 years and is a critical part of services for a children's hospital. We also have another facility near Temple Street. The charity is a part of a global network of charities that support family accommodation in children's hospitals. We mapped out how many beds we required and the charity has identified the increased requirements. There is a waiting list of families at the moment. We cannot accommodate the families.
Comment on this
I understand that, but-----
Comment on this
I am more interested in the model of public medicine and what is required. I will come back, when asking my final questions, to ask about private rooms and the overall cost of the hospital. However, given the amount of public money involved, one would imagine that having enough rooms without relying on a charity would have been the kernel, central to the matter. Even if we are relying on the charity, I would have expected the charity to make arrangements according to what we want.
Comment on this
I need to be crystal clear. These rooms are to accommodate families, usually including siblings and others, who come to the hospital because a child is sick.
Comment on this
Hospitals are not funded to provide that type of accommodation but, because these are really sick children who come from all 32 counties and these families need to be together, this facility is provided by a charity in most children's hospitals.
Comment on this
It is additional accommodation, and that is very welcome in a sense as long as the charity comes under public scrutiny.
Comment on this
The State has not provided that service but it is integral. We had to build this in when designing the children's hospital. It has been included in the design and planning permission and the arrangement that is in place is that a charity provides it.
Comment on this
What will be the final cost of the hospital? I ask also, as I did on the previous occasion, about the number of private rooms for consultants to do private medicine. Those are my final two questions. The figure of €2 billion has been used. I do not want headlines, I want clarity. What do our guests think will be the final figure for the building costs when the hospital is handed over to Children's Health Ireland?
Comment on this
The exact final cost of the hospital will depend on how events unfold in relation to residual risks where the State bears responsibility for the costs.
Comment on this
I agree, and Mr. Barry has been clear on that, but he must have some figure in his head. There must be a plan to cover those residual risks.
Comment on this
The arrangement, if I can call it that, is that, if and when these residual risks unfold, we will turn to the Department and the Government for additional funding to go with them. That will happen if and when or as those risks arise.
Comment on this
Could it cost €2 billion?
Comment on this
Theoretically, things could cost anything but that seems highly improbable.
Comment on this
It is highly improbable that it will cost €2 billion?
Comment on this
What about the number of private rooms?
Comment on this
There are no private designations to any of the 473 inpatient or day patient beds.
Comment on this
Will Ms Hardiman take this slowly, please?
Comment on this
There are no private designations to any of the 473 inpatient or day care beds in the new children's hospital. We have 119 clinical examination rooms in outpatients and, because of the legal obligations of our HR contracts with our consultants who have a B-type contract, those consultants are entitled to do 20% of their outpatient work on site. One suite, containing eight rooms, has been designated as private for us to honour that legal obligation. If there is any change on the policy, as we have said before, we are willing to implement it.
Comment on this
There is a legal obligation.
Comment on this
Are the consultants being charged for the suites?
Comment on this
The fee has not yet been agreed but the model has been agreed. There will be an operational fee for access to the rooms and other elements of the hospital, such as imaging and laboratories.
Comment on this
Will those consultants be charged market value for those facilities?
Comment on this
Yes. We have not actually gone into the cost but I am sure that will be the case. It is part of the commissioning phase.
Comment on this
There are 119 clinical examination rooms in outpatients.
Comment on this
The total is 473 for inpatient and day cases.
Comment on this
None of the beds is. They are all single rooms so there is no differentiation.
Comment on this
Does that mean there will be no payment from any of the private health insurers in respect of those rooms if none of them is designated as private?
Comment on this
We are into the area of national policy so I might come in here.
Comment on this
I just want to know about money. Will money be paid in respect of those rooms by private health insurers?
Comment on this
As of today, money would be paid because the ability to charge the insurer is not linked to the room being private. We removed that about four years ago. If one is a private patient in a public hospital, even if one is not in a single room, it is a chargeable event and one can be charged for that. That is the position as of today.
Members of the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Health know that policy will change, going forward. Sláintecare has said we should remove private practice from public hospitals. We have commissioned a group, led by Donal de Buitléir, that has issued and published its report which is under consideration. The Minister has talked of his interest in taking an initiative, with consultants, to try to address the de Buitléir recommendations. That is likely to change the mix of private practice in our public hospitals, if not entirely eliminate it. The important thing is that the outpatient rooms that are being talked about as potentially available for private work are absolutely the same as all the other outpatient rooms. If they are not needed for private work, they will be used for public patients.
Comment on this
I welcome our guests back. Deputy O'Connell and I had a slight feeling of déjà vu. We went around the houses last week but there are many more players today. To be fair to Mr. Gunning and Mr. Barry, they have taken on a poisoned chalice, in a way.
Some of the questions at the Joint Committee on Health, especially to Mr. Gunning about his history and where he was before this, were probably a tad unfair. I will not go anywhere near that. Sometimes the most obvious question is that one that needs to be asked, so my first question is not to Mr. Barry or Mr. Gunning, but to Dr. Curtis, Mr. Devine, Mr. Breslin, Mr. McGreal, Mr. Farragher, Mr. Morris, Mr. Sullivan and Ms Hardiman. "Reeling in the Years" is my favourite programme on television because it is a quick snapshot of a year in 25 minutes, with good music, usually, though not all the time. I am showing my age but someone here is older than me. We all know that the big issue here is the overrun in the costs of the hospital. All of the people I have named are here to do a job. Today is 5 December 2019, and could be played out on "Reeling in the Years" in the future, hence the link. Is there anything that any of the witnesses want to say to us and to the public watching? Are there any concerns that they would like to put on the record of the committee or to present to the public? Is there anything at all in what they know at this point regarding concerns about the spend on or timelines for this hospital? Do any of the witnesses have anything they would like to share with us? Now is the time to say so. If they do not say so, it is date-stamped. If anyone I have referred to would like to share anything, please tell us now.
Comment on this
I will speak for myself. The position is properly reflected in the PwC report and the chair's opening statement.
Comment on this
I have read this report inside-out. I have approximately 20 pages of notes from it as the people who attended the committee last week know. I have gone through it in depth. Not enough people have read it. I do not want a status report. I am asking if there is anybody here with any concerns extra and above what we know publicly.
Comment on this
Not extra and above. The concerns relate to the residual risks identified in the report. We have talked about family accommodation and finishing out those issues, philanthropy and so on. They are well-flagged at this stage.
Comment on this
For the record, everybody at the committee has no concerns outside of what is identified in this report or is public at present. Is that fair enough to say?
Comment on this
Some risks are touched on in that report. We have talked about the risks that are flagged about capital costs.
Comment on this
Is there anything new relating to time? Does anybody have concerns that they know about which they need to air now? Everything will be known in the future anyway so I am asking if there is anything that we need to know about now.
Comment on this
We have talked about some of the risks today. We talked about capital costs. We touched on the timeline for the three sides.
Comment on this
There are two more that we have come across. It would be wrong, in a project and programme of this scale, to indicate or give assurance that there are no other risks.
Comment on this
I did not say the Deputy is. I am trying to get there now.
Comment on this
There are two more specific things. The establishment of a new electronic health record arrangement that CHI is taking forward is undoubtedly a risk.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Connell and I have gone through this at the Joint Committee on Health.
Comment on this
There is not just the challenge of procuring that but the challenge of getting it on the ground and working. The other risk I flagged up, which was picked up in response to some of the questions from Deputy Catherine Murphy, relates to the staffing of the existing site. That is small in comparison to the staffing of the new hospital. We are seeking to mitigate all of those risks but those are the risks I would put on the table.
Comment on this
We know about those two risks. We have talked about them at the Joint Committee on Health and it has been publicly aired. I will open this up to Mr. Barry and Mr. Gunning but, pardon the pun, they have probably been interrogated on this enough. Does anybody else want to say anything publicly to Ireland that is not known, that people are not aware of, or any concerns that they need to air?
Comment on this
We see the major strategic risks as being around the digitisation of healthcare, including electronic healthcare records and other elements, because this is a digital hospital. The other element is staffing. I would never underestimate the challenges of integrating and merging hospitals. Those are our big risks.
Comment on this
I am sorry for interrupting but I am caught for time. We know all of that. It has been aired publicly. Does anyone have anything else? No. That is fine.
I asked at last week's health committee meeting about additional claims for the project, so I presume Mr. Gunning or Mr. Barry will have an answer today. They outlined how just over €1 million to date has been paid in extra charges. Correct me if I am wrong because this is from memory since the Official Report of that meeting is not up yet. That was approximately 50% of overall claims. The witnesses acknowledged that smaller claims are quicker than larger claims, which is obvious to most people. I asked how much of the claims were based on the Connolly site rather than the main site and the witnesses were to come back to me but they have not yet. Presumably they have the answer to that.
Comment on this
Virtually all of it related to the main site.
Comment on this
That is fair enough. I went into detail at the last meeting about the real issue, which is the design of the hospital and moving goalposts. That is where the costs are coming in. Anyone who really interrogates this document, particularly the most revealing pages - 26, 27 and 28 - which are about design, will see that. On the previous occasion, Mr. Barry and Mr. Gunning told me that the design of the hospital was more or less complete when the GMP was signed off.
Comment on this
Mr. Barry made a comment which I will have to follow up on. I did not on that day because I thought I would research it a bit more, which is the appropriate thing to do. He said that the design was almost agreed for the GMP but there were a few small things relating to the IFC. He might explain what the IFC is and the difference between that and the GMP.
Comment on this
IFC is short for issued for construction. When one comes to the actual construction for the project, one issues a very large number of very detailed drawings and specifications, often integrating specific products that are being provided by the builder.
Comment on this
In layman's terms, is this a more detailed GMP?
Comment on this
It is detailing of the design that is included within the GMP. A source of claims is a contractor submitting that the details differ significantly from, and are inconsistent with, the design.
Comment on this
That is very well explained. When the GMP was signed off, the IFC was, give or take-----
Comment on this
I know. Did the IFC in any way retrospectively affect the GMP?
Comment on this
If ever a question is going to be asked about this hospital, I believe that one is critical. It is the nub of this issue.
Comment on this
Many of the claims have been submitted on the basis that the IFC documents differ from the design as agreed within the GMP.
Comment on this
There is a big difference between the IFC and GMP.
Comment on this
Many claims are based on there being a difference. We have been arguing against them.
Comment on this
The contractors have an opinion that there is a big difference between the IFC and GMP.
Comment on this
This brings us back to the employer's determination of those arguments.
Comment on this
Okay. Mr. Barry does not agree with it.
Comment on this
So far, the determination has been largely that the issue for construction design is within the design-----
Comment on this
Okay, fair enough. On behalf of the taxpayer I hope Mr. Barry is right.
Comment on this
I keep cautioning there is a long way to go on this.
Comment on this
On behalf of the taxpayer, I hope Mr. Barry is right but there is a credibility issue here. If it ends up being determined that the IFC cost was considerably away from the GMC, we will incur serious costs. In any project that would be correct, would it not?
Comment on this
I cannot correlate how, then, we ended up with a 63% uplift in payments to the design companies. According to this report, €27 million extra was paid to design companies, which is 63% more than what was agreed. In any correlation if we go from the GMP to the IFC cost - and I am sorry for all of the jargon but people who know this know what I am talking about and there are arguments with regard to a significant change that would have a massive impact on the costs - a key signal is the fact that 63% more than what was expected had to be paid for the design consultants who have designed the hospital to date in the first place. The correlation indicates that the IFC cost is way off. If there is a 63% differential, it would in indicate that we are heading for a big problem here.
Comment on this
I might come in and answer this. Deputy Kelly is probably referring to the settlement agreement that happened with the design team at the end of 2018, which is also-----
Comment on this
Can I ask a question though? Is it way out?
Comment on this
I am sorry. Tone is an issue here. Is it way out or not?
Comment on this
GMP to IFC cost has nothing to do with the settlement agreed with the design team back in 2018. They are not related issues.
Comment on this
Can we move on? At the end of 2018, the design team submitted claims to us in terms of additional services it felt it undertook, or was about to undertake, associated with the project when compared to when it tendered for the job back in 2014. The design team tendered for the job in 2014 and, through its lifescale, the job was supposed to finish in 2020 to 2021. There are entitlements for the design team on prolongation in accordance with the standard contract. We entered into a conciliation with the design team at the end of 2018. We appointed a conciliator. We stated our position and it stated its position and an agreement was made. In terms of what was agreed, the design team recovered €24.5 million, including VAT, or €19.9 million, excluding VAT. There were two categories in this. One category was variations it was entitled to as set out in the contract. These were prolongation of stages 2C and 3 up to the time of GMP and stage 4 because of the construction programme-----
Comment on this
It is all in the report, in fairness.
Comment on this
-----scope changes, proposed client changes undertaken and alternate contractual design proposals submitted. That came to approximately €15 million of the €24.5 million. The team is entitled to that under contract.
Comment on this
Scope changes and prolongation of the programme.
Comment on this
Mr. Devine is going to take up all of my time, I am afraid. That is the only reason I am-----
Comment on this
The second part of this was additional services that we decided to buy as a development board. They were about strengthening the employer's representative team and strengthening the design team leadership team. Some of this came out of what we experienced through the GMP process. We brought in many additional resident architects, engineers, quantity surveyors and inspectors to ensure we had the right quality in the project. We bought €9.5 million of additional services.
Comment on this
Effectively, it is what I said. It is an increase of 63% in the design costs. Is that accurate?
Comment on this
That is just fact and it is what it is.
Comment on this
I believe the correlation I outlined is accurate. I asked my next question last week and I hope Mr. Barry has had a week to reflect on it because transparency is an issue. The board is changing and that is fair enough. Fair play to anybody who is volunteering for this job, as I said on the that occasion. I thank them because it is not an easy role to jump into. In fairness to Mr. Barry jumping into this role, when he got the phone call, he had to think about it for a while. This is a very important question and that is the reason he sat down with Q4 PR but I will get on to that in a while. Is the board strengthened or weakened by the fact the head of procurement in Ireland is no longer on it? I am not asking about the person but the role. Is the board strengthened or weakened by the fact the head of procurement in the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform, who is the most senior person in Ireland when it comes to procurement, is no longer on it? On the previous occasion we were told much of the procurement is out of the way and while I am not sure whether I accept it, I accept it as an answer. I am not going to dwell on this. Is the board strengthened or weakened by the fact the role is no longer part of it?
Comment on this
Could I reference what we are seeking in the replacement board members? Perhaps that is the way to address the question without making comments about any individual.
Comment on this
I am not asking Mr. Barry to making a comment about any individual.
Comment on this
I am asking him a very simple question. Is the board strengthened or weakened? Mr. Barry is a skilled person who has been in front of committees for years. He is one of the best people I have ever seen for coming in front of committees and answering questions, to be fair to him. This is a very specific question that I am asking and the country is watching. Is the board strengthened or weakened by the fact the role is no longer on it?
Comment on this
By the way, the Government said publicly in the past that the reason the role was on the board was specifically because it needed to be and it was a good idea.
Comment on this
I have no doubt it was a good idea but I do not want to compare the qualities of one individual leaving the board with the person who might come onto the board.
Comment on this
This is about the seventh or eighth time. I am not asking Mr. Barry to do that. It is a very simple question. If he does not want to answer, that is fine. Well, it is not fine but I will accept Mr. Barry does not want to answer it. Is the board strengthened or weakened by the fact the role is no longer part of it? It is a pretty basic question.
Comment on this
If the Deputy can accept I do not want to answer the question, perhaps that is the best way to proceed.
Comment on this
I do not know what to say to that, to be honest.
Comment on this
Mr. Barry obviously has a view but he is not going to share it. Does he have a view on it privately that he will not share? He has made it clear he will not share it.
Comment on this
I have a view that I am quite willing to give publicly on the skill set we need from the incoming board members but I do not want to say anything in the context of offering a critique, good or bad, of an individual who has left. I am quite happy to say what I think the appropriate skill sets are for those we are seeking to bring onto the board at the moment.
Comment on this
Mr. Barry is not answering the question and we will move on.
Comment on this
In fairness to Mr. Barry, and it is my first time to be fair to him today on this one-----
Comment on this
The Chairman is always fair to him.
Comment on this
We did say at the beginning that Mr. Barry should not criticise or make charges against anyone-----
Comment on this
I am not asking him to make any comment. In fairness, the Government made a decision that this specific role should be part of the board and it is no longer part of the board. Is the board weakened or strengthened by this? It is a pretty basic question. It is not being answered. We will move on.
Comment on this
As far as I know, I am not allowed to make a comment on Government policy.
Comment on this
I will move on because, in fairness, we have washed that. With regard to the hospital, the services being brought in and the cabling and mechanical works, has there been any change in the design of the corridors or rooms in the very recent past with regard to mechanical or electrical works?
Comment on this
I am finishing up. I have a few quick questions.
Comment on this
The Deputy should put the questions so that Deputy O'Connell can get in.
I have a question for Mr. Sullivan. He is the deputy director general and head of strategy and planning. Future capital investment is generally planned five years ahead. This year a three-year plan has been released ten months late. Can Mr. Sullivan say on the record whether the delivery time of any capital project related to the HSE anywhere in Ireland been impacted by the spend on the hospital? That is my second last question.
My last question is for the chairman of the board. I asked this at our last meeting but I wish to put it on the record. The minutes of a meeting on 3 April state that a presentation was made by the design team to the finance and construction committee. It was reported that provisional findings had identified additional monetary risk. I asked for the presentation and for the minutes of the procurement subcommittee on 29 April. Mr. Barry said he would not supply us with the complete report but he would redact it and supply the minutes. They have not yet been received. Can he please provide them? Those two questions were directed to Mr. Sullivan.
In response to Deputy Connolly the witnesses said they would outline the scope of the work of Q4 Public Relations. I wish to echo that request. The documents the witnesses supply must predate today. They cannot be written up now.
Comment on this
I will take the first question. There have been no changes to the corridors or rooms within the hospital since the guaranteed maximum price, GMP, was agreed. There have been no impacts associated with mechanical and electrical works.
Comment on this
In response to the Deputy's second question, I note that additional funding was provided by the Government for 2019 and 2020 to mitigate the risk he has flagged.
Comment on this
In Mr. Sullivan's opinion there will not be a single capital project in the whole of Ireland in the next five years whose timeline will be impacted in any way by the national children's hospital. Is that correct?
Comment on this
That will depend on funding in future years.
Comment on this
At this point in time, funding has been provided for 2019 and 2020-----
Comment on this
Nothing has reached Mr. Sullivan's desk to indicate that a project will have to be pushed back. There has been nothing like that.
Comment on this
There has been nothing as black and white as that.
Comment on this
At the outset I wish to state that I have been a long-term supporter of the children's hospital and of locating it on the St. James's Hospital site. My support has been based on the recommendation of a tri-located model with the capacity to include a maternity hospital and an adult hospital on the site. This will mean children can be born and transferred while women who have babies do not have to be separated from them. All the evidence that has been presented to me, mostly through Professor Hardiman-----
Comment on this
After this it definitely will be. We will give Ms Hardiman an honorary title. Once I committed myself to studying all the information I was convinced that this was the right place to put the hospital. I was given a document at the Oireachtas Committee on Health about four years ago. It stated that about 75% of the patient cohort came from the greater Dublin area. I do not care what trouble I get into. I cannot get into any more trouble than last week. Anyone who tries to reverse out of the hospital's current position is really doing a disservice to the children of Ireland. Despite some media reports, I have been a user of Our Lady's Children's Hospital, Crumlin for ten years. I have been an inpatient and a day patient. I have used the cardiac facilities in the medical tower, the accident and emergency department and everything bar the oncology unit, touch wood. I am fully aware of the challenges children are facing. This is about children. I do not see this as a poisoned chalice but as a wonderful opportunity to deliver something that successive Governments, boards and groups have failed to deliver. I recognise the huge challenges. I have sat in so many meetings about the children's hospital. I understand that we need to get value for taxpayers' money and we need the best possible hospital for our children, but the constant pushback against providing this only serves to damage outcomes for the children of Ireland. While our role is to interrogate this process, when any of us criticise the progress of the hospital we have to be very conscious of how much we needed it when it was first mooted. Perhaps Ms Hardiman could outline this. Consider the changes that have taken place at Temple Street Children's University Hospital and Crumlin. We still have not delivered. I remember seeing surgical pods being installed at Crumlin ten years ago and thinking it was a waste as we were going to build a hospital. Ten years later we do not have that hospital. For the record, I would like to encourage the board to keep going to get this delivered. However everyone should consider the children who have missed out due to the persistent delays that have plagued this project.
Turning to the Children's Health Ireland, CHI, it is very positive that there has been a 35% reduction in general paediatric waiting lasts in the last six months. Can we replicate that over the next six months or is that just a push to the start line? Similarly, there has been a reduction of 65% in the 12-month waiting list. Can we keep pushing in that direction or have we reached a saturation point?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for the opportunity to elaborate on that. Our board has taken this very seriously. With due credit to the previous hospitals, we tend to stay within our limits financially. We do our best around safety issues, which are really important. Access is one area in which we must make improvements. Our overall waiting list for outpatients has reduced by 8% this year. The biggest reduction has been in the number waiting for longer than 12 months. That has decreased by 12%. This does not just apply to general paediatrics.
As I was saying, general paediatrics is the one specialty to be based at Connolly Hospital Blanchardstown in which we have made early investment into new ways of working. Staff there work virtually. There are virtual triage clinics and patients are moved to the next available slot. There is central referral so a patient is not referred to a particular doctor. Whoever has the shortest list gets the next patient. It is a much more efficient way of working. Clinics have now been set up at Connolly that do not need paper. If the patient has been in another hospital, his or her records are scanned and sent over. We do not have vans of paper going from place to place. This new way of working needed investment.
I can assure the committee that we have been successful in reducing our waiting lists through initiatives with the HSE. We are definitely starting to make an impact. The facility in Tallaght will be opening next year. To be quite honest, our biggest issue is the constraints of the facilities. We are trying to implement some strategic initiatives between now and 2023 so that we do not come into this hospital with long waiting lists. We want to start successfully and be able to implement the services that the children and families of Ireland deserve, as Deputy O'Connell says. Our staff deserve to be working in those facilities as well.
Comment on this
To summarise Ms Hardiman's answers, staff in various sites are operating according to different protocols, with different ways of getting paid, different time schedules and different levels of management. CHI is streamlining practices so that staff can be transferred to the new hospital without a fuss about name tags, pay packets or practices.
Comment on this
This is absolutely necessary in order to integrate the services. The issue of parents' rooms constantly comes up. All rooms outside of the intensive care unit and the high dependency unit have facilities for parents. On the Crumlin road there is a charitable organisation providing facilities where parents or other children can stay. For the benefit of people who have never been in that situation, parents need to wash clothes, feed their children and feed themselves. I have never used Ronald McDonald House because I am based in Dublin, but the facilities there are absolutely essential to supporting families who come from further away so they can live their lives without incurring huge hotel expenses.
This might be a question for the Department but is there any issue with Children's Health Ireland being a section 38 organisation in terms of the committee's access to its accounts in the future?
Comment on this
I will be the auditor of Children's Health Ireland and reporting to the committee.
Comment on this
That is fine. I wanted to clarify that in light of other questions that have been put.
Comment on this
That is a development on the constituent hospitals. We have moved from Crumlin Hospital, Temple Street hospital and the paediatric part of Tallaght Hospital being voluntary hospitals, with their full participation, into something that is a public body. That is quite a step to have made.
Comment on this
As of now, I audit five of the section 38 hospitals. I do not audit the rest of them.
Comment on this
On the ICT and the single unique identifier for children, would it be true to say this is a template for the future for adult healthcare? Are we trying to get it right with the children's identifier first or are both happening in tandem in the Department?
Comment on this
This is instead of doing a big bang. There was an option at one stage of purchasing a single electronic health record, EHR, for the whole country. The children's hospital, as we all know, has many unique features. Children's Health Ireland will procure an EHR for the children's hospital but we will build linkages to the national project and how that gets rolled out so that there is compatibility. For example, the individual identifiers will be the same and they will use the same standards and so on, but the purchase and deployment will be separate from the children's hospital deployment.
Comment on this
Again, I would not like the wrong message to go out from the committee on the 63% increase in design costs. My understanding from what Mr. Devine said is that the increase was to get more design because it precedes the GMP and the detailed drawings for where the plugs and cables go. It is not really the case that it was a pure increase but the costs increased by 63% to get more design. There was almost an impression given that it was a waste or nothing was got in return for the increase. Perhaps that could be clarified so that an incorrect headline does not go out from here.
Comment on this
There were two aspects to it. The first aspect was that a large part of the €15 million cost I talked about was for the prolongation. We have our design team for an extra two years. The numbers were mentioned and we are talking about 100 to 200 people. Those prolongation periods happened during the intense period between going to tender and then finalising the GMP. They had 200 people working on the job for an extra six months. When we get to this stage, which is all about the construction and implementation, there are probably over 100 people working for another year or year and a half on that. That is where most of the cost was generated. The timeline of the project has extended out for different reasons.
The second aspect was the €9.5 million cost. As a development board, taking our experience of the GMP and what is in the PricewaterhouseCoopers report, we strengthened certain aspects of the design team and the capability within that team. We decided, after looking at other large-scale projects internationally, that we needed additional people from the design team checking quality on site, more than we had allowed for in 2014. There was an impact there in that the building control regulations were only in their infancy in 2014 when we tendered the job. This is a highly complex project. There are 6,000 rooms, every one of which has medical services in it. We need to do a huge amount of assurance and checking to ensure our contractors complete the job and commission the hospital to the right standards so we hand over a fit-for-purpose hospital to Children's Health Ireland.
Comment on this
We brought in extra people to give us better assurance on the end product.
Comment on this
The consequences of it not being right are extremely serious-----
Comment on this
-----for the outcomes for children. The importance of having the right pipe attached to the right gas line, for example, is crucial.
Comment on this
On dealing with the period between now and when we have the new hospital, I welcome the reduction in the fee for the urgent care centres, which has gone from €100 to €75 to make the service more affordable. We need to focus on expanding the services at Connolly Hospital in the short-term because the reality is that if we have some kind of serious outbreak in the coming months or even next winter before the hospital is ready, we will have challenging outcomes for children.
Comment on this
We have not completed our work at this stage. Deputies must go to vote. We will resume at 2.15 p.m. and I expect we will be out of here by 3 p.m. We thought we might have finished by now but not all the questions have been asked. We will have a good half hour of discussion after the voting session. We had hoped to be finished by lunchtime but, as with projects, they do not always finish on time. We will inform the guests who are due in at 2.30 p.m. that we now expect to begin our discussion with them at 3 p.m.
Comment on this
We resume our discussion in respect of the National Paediatric Hospital Development Board and other groups associated with the hospital. A number of members spoke earlier. As Chairman, I normally wait and allow the other members to ask their questions before I do. Some members then add further questions while I am asking mine. I have a number of questions before I get into the specifics of the accounts. Can someone call out the list of directors of the National Paediatric Hospital Development Board?
Comment on this
There is myself, Tim Bouchier Hayes, Anne Butler, Karl Kent, John Cole, Liam Woods and Lorcan Birthistle.
Comment on this
We are kept busy. The quorum for a meeting is five members.
Comment on this
Yes, we have managed it so far but it is tight.
Comment on this
-----responsible for the largest capital construction project in the State. The State has set up a body to manage that project and we find that there are currently only seven out of 13 directors on the board. That says a great deal. I will put a question to Mr. Breslin in a moment because it is not Mr. Barry's fault that there are not enough members on the board. When did these members join the board? I do not need the date. The approximate month will do.
Comment on this
Other than myself, as far as I know, all of the other board members have been there for a fairly long time.
Comment on this
If we turn to the financial statements on page 8, four members were appointed on 2 August 2013. Liam Woods became an ordinary member on 4 March 2015 and, for completeness, Mr. Birthistle on 2 February 2016. Then there was Mr. Barry's appointment, which was this year.
Comment on this
The of directors are the people who are ultimately responsible. We will go down through this list, which has been presented in the context of the 2018 financial statements. Tom Costello, the former chairperson, has gone.