We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

National Paediatric Hospital Development Board: Financial Statements 2018

Contributions 787–1,051 of 1,051. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.

Mr. Fred Barry

She was replaced by a-----

Comment on this

No, she has left according to the list I am looking at in the board's annual financial statements. She has gone. Liam Woods is there.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

He is there.

Comment on this

What about Lorcan Birthistle?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

He is there.

Comment on this

What about Jonathan Hourihane?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

He has gone.

Comment on this

Out of the 13 that were there, seven have gone and one has been replaced. What is the Department of Health's position on this? Mr. Breslin will mention the Public Appointments Service process but a board of directors for the national children's hospital construction project is a matter of urgency. Every week that passes, costs are being incurred. How is the Department of Health allowing this to continue?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

Over the course of the year, there has been significant changeover in the board, with the new chair and the previous chair resigning, etc.. We have concluded the period for expressions of interest and will be submitting names to the Minister this month in to fill out the rest of the board. It was important to work for the new chair to identify the competencies which he wants to see on the board and which, on the basis of the PwC report, are required. We have done that and gone through the State boards process which is almost concluded.

Comment on this

We have gone through the State boards Public Appointments Service process.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

This is where the Public Appointment Service advertises.

Comment on this

Did many people apply?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

I am told that there is a good level of interest. I have not seen the quality because I am not part of the nominations process and have not seen the applications. The number is good.

Comment on this

When did that process start?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

The closing date was 15 November, so probably in October.

Comment on this

Some of these people have been gone since last February.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

Yes, some have been gone since last February.

Comment on this

Why did it take nine months to start filling the vacancies?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

Tom Costello went in February and has been replaced by-----

Comment on this

Mr. Barry.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

There were people who went at the end of May, people who went over the summer and people who left in October.

Comment on this

Right.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

I have been before this committee and the health committee previously and I was asked how I was going to address the PwC report and strengthen the board. There was an entire board there and the Minister had no flexibility to make new appointments beyond what was in place. We might not have planned it this way but-----

Comment on this

Mr. Breslin is telling me that it is a good thing that they have all left. He is the master here.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

It allows us to stand back at this period in the development, which is a different one to when we started, in looking at what are the remaining competencies and skills that we might want. Hopefully, through the expressions of interest process, we will get a very good set of additions to the board.

Comment on this

I am aware that Mr. Barry probably did not get an opportunity to answer the question or may not have wanted to answer it, but the skills that were necessary at the earliest stage of the project, in terms of procurement, etc., might not be as critical now because it is a question of seeing the project to completion.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

That is correct. In the early stages of the project, the conceptual design, development, planning, getting the statutory approval to build and procurement would have been very much in the board's considerations. Now we are moving more into the supervision of construction, construction safety and quality, validation and so on, together with start-up and transfer.

There is a body of procurement of medical equipment and so on yet to be undertaken

Comment on this

We will come to future procurement.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

There is expertise available to us from the HSE and CHI in respect of that equipment.

Comment on this

The HSE is expert at not complying with procurement rules. Between 25% and 40% of its procurement is non-compliant. The committee deals with its procurement every year. It tops the list in terms of non-compliance with procurement rules, as the Comptroller and Auditor General will confirm. Some 24% of procurement within a sample he took last year was non-compliant. I say that as a warning that Mr. Barry should not rely on the HSE in respect of compliance. If he, as chairman of the board, is looking for people to advise on complying with procurement rules, the HSE is not necessarily the right choice.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

We do not look to the HSE for procurement administration, which is within our competence. Rather, we will seek its technical input on appropriate equipment.

Comment on this

I will turn to my next question. The board signed off on the accounts on 9 October.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

We did.

Comment on this

As Chairman of the Committee of Public Accounts, I note it is important that this committee receive information on this critical project in a more timely fashion. It is unacceptable for the committee to have to wait nine or ten months after year end before it can see the financial statements for last year of an organisation as sensitive as this. I ask that the accounts for 2019 be submitted to the Comptroller and Auditor General by the end of February and that the Comptroller and Auditor General give them priority. I cannot dictate the workload of the Comptroller and Auditor General and I acknowledge that the appropriation accounts must be done but the HSE and the NTMA are given priority. Similar priority should be given to the largest capital project in the State. I do not know who will be here this time next year, but the Oireachtas should not have to wait until October of next year to see the financial statements for the period that will conclude in three weeks' time. Mr. Barry gets my point. There should be more urgency. It is possible that the change of directors or another matter was the reason for the delay. Many organisations appear before the committee. I consider this to be a critical organisation in which there is a significant amount of public interest. It is good for the reputation of the project if information is provided in a timely manner but it damages its reputation if information must be dragged out. I am making that point in a positive way. I ask Mr. Barry to try to get ahead of the curve on these matters.

This is the first time Ms Hardiman has appeared before the committee. Children's Health Ireland, CHI, deals with the hospitals in Crumlin, Temple Street, Tallaght and Blanchardstown. What about children who live outside Dublin and those who are sick in hospitals elsewhere in the country? Do they fall under the umbrella of CHI?

Comment on this
Ms Eilísh Hardiman

No. We cover local services with local secondary hospitals for the greater Dublin area, including counties Meath, Dublin, Kildare and Wicklow.

Comment on this

CHI covers Dublin and some eastern counties.

Comment on this
Ms Eilísh Hardiman

Yes. We cover local services along the eastern seaboard and in the greater Dublin area. Patients in Cork would go to Cork University Hospital, which has a children's unit, while those in the west would go to a hospital in Galway or Limerick, for example. Those regional hospitals have paediatric units and there are smaller paediatric units in the remainder of the system. That is one part of our job. The other part-----

Comment on this

It is not part of the job of CHI. Those hospitals fall outside its remit.

Comment on this
Ms Eilísh Hardiman

That is correct. However, there is a plan to take a network approach to the delivery of services. What is part of our job is all of the national services. We are the only hospital in the system that has all of the national services in one organisation. The sickest children, who comprise 25%, are all in our group. A very sick baby in Cork who needs intensive care will come to us. Children with complex and chronic illnesses or a rare disease come to us. We deal with all of the national services, as well as some for Northern Ireland. In addition, we provide secondary care in the greater Dublin area.

Comment on this

Ms Hardiman referred to Ireland east. The impression was given earlier in the meeting that files and patient records have been integrated such that there are no paper records but people from outside the greater Dublin area will not be part of the patient integrated system and as such, will have paper files. Ms Hardiman gave an impression that everything goes on electronically but everyone from outside the eastern region will only have a paper file, as their records have not been not integrated.

Comment on this
Ms Eilísh Hardiman

I thank the Chairman for giving me an opportunity to clarify this issue. We have put in a patient administration system such that all of our 1.2 million records are on one administration system.

Comment on this

Are there 1.2 million children or records?

Comment on this
Ms Eilísh Hardiman

Records.

Comment on this

How many children does that cover?

Comment on this
Ms Eilísh Hardiman

Most of them relate to children. They are our historical records. They are held on an administrative system. We are going to purchase a clinical system to maintain clinical records, including medications and so on. As Mr. Breslin outlined, there initially was a plan for a national electronic healthcare record but it was agreed for us to proceed with our system. Interoperability is very important for us. The records of many children born in four of the maternity hospitals are stored on an electronic system. We must have a process whereby files can be transferred to ensure a continuity of care. Our preference would be for all of the hospitals to be able to link up-----

Comment on this

That will not happen between now and the opening of the new children's hospital. It is further down the road.

Comment on this
Ms Eilísh Hardiman

There is a separate process to progress the national electronic healthcare record.

Comment on this

For children.

Comment on this
Ms Eilísh Hardiman

No. For outside-----

Comment on this

That is a long time away. It is being done in parts. It has been indicated that it is not being done in one job. It could take a decade for it to be completed.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

The regional paediatric units would be in scope for deployment of the children's hospital solution.

Comment on this

I ask Mr. Breslin to repeat that in English.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

That means that we will have to make a decision on the matter but when the children's hospital procures and develops its electronic health record, which will be specific to children and will have non-standard features, the regional units outside CHI also will be able to deploy that. We will not go about reinventing the wheel.

Comment on this

Consequently, in due course but not yet, the records held by a hospital in Portlaoise on a child who then comes up to Dublin will be compatible.

Reference was made to 4,000 staff being under CHI. Whose staff are they?

Comment on this
Ms Eilísh Hardiman

The board of Children's Health Ireland is the employing authority of those staff.

Comment on this

Were they HSE employees?

Comment on this
Ms Eilísh Hardiman

No.

Comment on this

Where did they come from?

Comment on this
Ms Eilísh Hardiman

The three children's hospitals. The boards of Our Lady's Children's Hospital, Crumlin, Temple Street and Tallaght employed staff. Under the legislation governing CHI, the assets and liabilities of those voluntary hospitals, including staff, legally transferred to us as a State body.

Comment on this

CHI pays them now.

Comment on this
Ms Eilísh Hardiman

They are all on our payroll and all report to one board and one executive.

Comment on this

Where is CHI based?

Comment on this
Ms Eilísh Hardiman

We are based beside the new children's hospital, in the same building as our colleagues on the National Paediatric Hospital Development Board. While we occupy half of the building, we spend much of our time out in the hospitals.

Comment on this

Is payroll and so on centralised through CHI?

Comment on this
Ms Eilísh Hardiman

It is still run through the three hospitals. That is part of our merger and we now are starting to move to a single payroll. When I talk about integration, that is what I mean.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Hardiman. I wanted to clarify that.

What happens when the children become adults? Where do their records go?

Comment on this
Ms Eilísh Hardiman

We have transition services. If they are local, they will transition to the local services. That means they will go to any of the hospitals in the greater Dublin area. For those in receipt of specialist care, we have transition arrangements with some of the adult hospitals that have specialists for rare diseases, for example. We have a lot of connections with St. James's Hospital around cancer and haematology because it has the national adult services in those areas. That is how we work.

Comment on this

The next question is directed to Mr. Barry or whoever wants to deal with it. On the financial statements, I wish to deal with capital commitments, which appear on page 25. In January of this year, the witnesses' predecessors appeared before the committee and on that day, we were given the famous figure of €1.433 billion, which was put together over the lunch break and revealed when the committee reconvened.

I have quite a few questions in this area. The central paragraph on page 35 of the report states: "Up to the end of 2017, the Phase A of the construction contract was awarded which primarily supported the site enabling works of the project." We understand that. It refers to the ground works, underground work, a car park. It is not all overground. Is phase A complete?

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

It is. It is part of the instruction for phase B, which is the GMP phase.

Comment on this

I am focusing on phase A first.

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

Phase A is complete.

Comment on this

What was the total cost of phase A?

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

I will have to come back to the Chairman with an exact figure but it was approximately-----

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

-----€82 million excluding VAT. I do not have the actual cost.

Comment on this

I am reading the information we got from the board and from our periodic report No. 6. Paragraph H.10 of our report says:

Members questioned the cost of Phase A, the substructure, in relation to the overall project. The NPHDB stated that Phase A works were approximately €100m, including VAT, of all project costs. This represents approximately 7% of the current construction cost estimate of €1.4 billion.

That was several months ago. The board was able to give us that cost after the main meeting. It was an approximate figure at that time. There are several obvious questions. These are the financial statements. There is a reference to phase A having been completed. My question is simple. What was the final cost for phase A?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

We will get the exact cost for the Chairman.

Comment on this

It is going to make the rest of my questioning difficult if I cannot get the cost of what has already been completed, never mind-----

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

We have no intention of not giving the Chairman that cost.

Comment on this

I would have thought that somebody would know the cost. We have this in our report. The board has not told us that it had any problem with its figures. We got these figures from the board; we did not make them up. It says that costs for phase A were approximately €100 million, including VAT. That would be equal to €85 million, €86 million or €87 million plus VAT.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

I have just confirmed that the approximate figure Mr. Devine gave the Chairman excluded VAT. If one adds the VAT, it is very close to the figure the committee previously had.

Comment on this

What does Mr. Barry believe the full figure is including VAT?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

As I have said-----

Comment on this

I am not tying him to that €100 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

The €82 million plus VAT is approximately-----

Comment on this

That is €100 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

It is close to €100 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

The approximate figure of €82 million excluding VAT would be €100.86 million including VAT. It is pretty much the same figure.

Comment on this

We will say it is €109 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

No, it is €100.86 million.

Comment on this

It is €100 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

It is effectively the same figure. We will come back with the exact amount.

Comment on this

The figure we had in our periodic report some time ago stands.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Yes.

Comment on this

That is okay. Given that this phase has been completed, can the board give us the breakdown of that figure between the main contractor and other contractors? Do the witnesses have a breakdown of that €100 million?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

We can get a breakdown for the Chairman.

Comment on this

We want to get it.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

The committee will get it.

Comment on this

I have a difficulty as Chairman of the Committee of Public Accounts. We are looking at the board's 2018 accounts. We have done a periodic report and the board has been in here twice. This is its third time before the committee this year. It was here at the beginning of January and in May. We did a periodic report based on figures provided in respect of the board. I asked a basic question. We spent some time this morning talking about the estimates for the future. I am asking about the part of the project that has been completed. I am sitting here as Chairman looking at the board's accounts in respect of the completed works and I am being told that I cannot be given a breakdown of the €100 million. That is not a good place for us to be in. Does Mr. Barry understand my point?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

I am not in any way saying that we will not give the Chairman a breakdown.

Comment on this

I know that.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

We absolutely will.

Comment on this

I would have thought that somebody coming in with the 2018 financial statements that have been signed off by the board, audited, approved by Cabinet, lodged with the Oireachtas, noted and presented at the committee would be able to give us information on any figure within those accounts. That is what the Committee of Public Accounts is about. Getting a set of accounts is just the start of the meeting. We give our thanks and note that we have them on file and then delve into and analyse the accounts. The first question I asked referred to the board's note which said that phase A, which related to the substructure, had been completed. I asked whether we could have a breakdown of the costs now that it has been completed. That is what this committee is for. We are here to ask those questions. The Committee of Public Accounts expects answers to such questions today, not in ten days' time. Doe the witnesses get my point? They might not like that point but I am making it to everyone collectively. I will come to Mr. Breslin because he is the chairman of the children's hospital project programme board. Does he know the cost of phase A or can he give me a breakdown?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

I know the cost of phase A but I do not know the broken-down figures the Chairman has asked for. It is something we could come up with pretty quickly. We will seek to get it before the committee finishes this evening.

Comment on this

Whatever. We might not be here for too much longer. I am expressing the frustration of all members here today. We were here last January and we extracted the figure of €1.433 billion at that meeting. We have not been given one single new figure today, 11 months on. There is a bit of frustration on this side of the table. We have a set of audited accounts and when I asked my first question about them, I expected a breakdown to be available today. It is going to come and that is fine but I believe Mr. Breslin sees my point.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

This may be because the Chairman is asking about phase A, which does not relate to a particular year or to the current figures. It is part of the project. If the Chairman asked a question about expenditure on the project to date, including how much has been paid to the contractor, I believe people would be able to answer that.

Comment on this

Believe it or not, I am going there. I am starting from the board's financial statements, which include a reference to phase A. I am not inventing a question. I am asking for details on matters the board refers to in paragraph 7, page 35 of its financial statements. It is fine. I will take the figure of €100 million for now. We will get the breakdown. Can anyone indicate how much of this figure was paid to BAM? Was it 70% or 80%?

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

BAM was paid all of it. Phase A was all carried out under a single contract with BAM.

Comment on this

That is nice to know. That is the breakdown. Mr. Devine has answered that question. I will take that as an answer.

I am now moving on to phase B. I am reading on in the same paragraph: "In 2018, having agreed the GMP [guaranteed maximum price] for the project, the contract for the main works [which was held by BAM, if I am correct] was awarded for €887.7m (ex vat)". VAT came to €120 million so the contract comes to €1.007 billion, including VAT. I am reading the board's figures. Am I right in my figures? I believe I am.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Farragher

That is the figure plus VAT, yes.

Comment on this

So that is €1.007 billion plus the €100 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

I believe that figure includes the €100 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Farragher

We merged phase A into the main contract.

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

To clarify, phase A is part of the overall contract. When we tendered the job, it was for phase A with a following instruction for phase B but, at the end of the day, it is all one contract. The €887 million includes the €100 million spent on phase A.

Comment on this

That is fine. I am just trying to get information. Phase A is part of the overall thing. It had been referred to separately and I wondered whether it was a separate issue. I will now refer to the chart which provides the breakdown of the figure of €1.433 billion, which is on page 88 of our periodic report No.6. Do the witnesses have this chart in front of them?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Yes.

Comment on this

Okay. It is just not up on the screen. There is a row titled "Net Main NCH Construction".

Does the big figure of €890 million refer to the BAM element?

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

Yes, that is correct.

Comment on this

Does the VAT come in under it?

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

Yes.

Comment on this

In that case, BAM is in line to get approximately €1 billion.

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

Yes.

Comment on this

I am just trying to get a breakdown of the figures. Page 26 of the financial statements refers to total capital commitments for contracts not provided in the financial statements. These are contracts that have been entered into but have not come up yet and are not in the financial statements. The total amount, including VAT, is €997 million. The sum of €260 million has already been incurred on the balance sheet. The two figures on the balance sheet of €260 million and €997 million bring the contracts that have been signed to date to €1.257 billion. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

That is correct.

Comment on this

Mr. Gunning said the total project cost is €1.433 billion between now and 2022 or 2023.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

That is correct.

Comment on this

The difference between the two is €176 million.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

That is correct.

Comment on this

At this stage, Mr. Gunning is saying the contract has been signed for 88% of the costs, namely, €1.433 billion?

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

That is correct.

Comment on this

Has the board entered into any new contractual arrangements that were not in place at the end of December last year?

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

Yes, we have. The amount committed to 31 November 2019 is an additional €18 million on top of that.

Comment on this

Mr. Gunning mentioned that additional procurement will be needed for equipment for the project. Can everything for the period from 1 January 2019 to the hand-over of the hospital be completed for €176 million to give the figure of €1.433 billion? We are not talking about inflation. Does Mr. Gunning have an estimate of what further costs will be incurred to complete the project? Does he follow me? It am trying to get the big picture.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

I understand that. I would just like to underline the difference between capital commitments, which is the promise to pay under contracts, and what has already been paid.

Comment on this

Yes, I have said that.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

I am just making sure. Some of these capital commitments, for example, the €997 million, will materialise right up to the end of the contract.

Comment on this

Of course. I am looking at the full length of the contract.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

The amount remaining to be committed is about €155 million, if we take out the commitments we have made this year - equipping and the other things the Chairman mentioned.

Comment on this

Does that €155 million cover everything the board will expect up to the end of 2023?

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

Yes, it is within the scope of the budget and all the items we have identified. As the Chairman correctly said, it does not include reserves and various other items.

Comment on this

We dealt with those issues in our periodic report so we understand that. We had a brief discussion on that. The board is operating on a very tight amount. A total of 88% of the costs of completion to 2023 has already been committed. That leaves very little. Is Mr. Gunning satisfied that the small amount of €155 million will see out the remaining life of the project?

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

We are. It is back to the payments-----

Comment on this

We know that tenders are subject to inflation and other elements such as new design and whatever else.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

If the contractor in the claims process can establish that there is work that we, on the State side, thought was included in the GMP of the contract but was not, that would be an exposure.

Comment on this

Mr. Barry is a very experienced man. What would be the industry norm for claims submitted by experienced contractors versus what they end up getting? Would they normally end up getting 60% or 70% of the claim?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

No, they would not. There is not a single norm. Some contractors put in extremely high claims and they come down an awful lot. Some put in more measured, considered ones and they still come down. One cannot really benchmark claims on the basis of the amount claimed and say that, therefore, there would be so much to pay. However, one can say that, over the life of a construction project, it would be most unusual if a contractor could not find some things that were additional to the original.

Comment on this

I will direct some questions to Mr. Breslin. I am still on the same topic but I want some information from him. There was talk about the HSE's capital plan and whether it would impact on other projects. I do not have the figures in front of me so I will be guided by Mr. Breslin's figures. What are the global figures for the HSE capital plan for the years 2019, 2020 and 2021?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

Over the three years?

Comment on this

No, per annum. They were quite late coming out. What is the approximate global figure per annum?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

It is about €650 million, growing to approximately €750 million.

Comment on this

This year, it is about €650 million and next year, it will be approximately €700 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

I have a note saying it is about €744 million for next year.

Comment on this

What will it be in 2021?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

We have not broken that out yet. I have a total for the entire health service, including for the Department's ICT, of €880 million. That is an increase of €35 million on the previous year.

Comment on this

What is €880 million?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

The figures I gave earlier were for construction. We also have an ICT programme. Our total figure is going up by approximately €35 million.

Comment on this

Could Mr. Breslin give me the total amount for the capital plan?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

What I was going to do was just add the increase of €35 million, which will predominantly go to construction. That would bring the figure up to about €770 million or €780 million.

Comment on this

Mr. Breslin is adding figures up in his head and I am not with him. To come back to the figures for 2019, 2020 and 2021, what is the total in the capital plan?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

It is €642 million in 2019 for HSE construction. It is €744 million in 2020. We do not have a published figure for 2021 but I estimate that it will be in the range of €775 million.

Comment on this

The figure for this year is €642 million. What was the Department's payment to the National Paediatric Hospital Development Board this year? The Oireachtas grant was €128 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

For which year?

Comment on this

For 2018. What has the Department allocated to the NPHDB for construction for this year?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

It was €200 million.

Comment on this

It is obviously more than last year. The amount is cranking up and I can understand that.

Page 26 refers to total capital commitments in the future. The money for 2018 has been paid. Mr. Gunning stated the board's balance sheet at the end of December last year showed contracted capital commitments to be paid within one year, which means in 2019, of €265 million. They are not in the financial statements because they have not occurred yet. Am I reading that right?

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

Yes.

Comment on this

Based on how the board is phasing the works, Mr. Gunning is saying that in 2019 when he finished the audited accounts, which were only signed off a few weeks ago, contracts had been entered into that he expected to be paid in 2019 of €265 million. Is that a correct reading of the position? It might not turn out exactly that way.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

Yes.

Comment on this

I am taking the figures from the audited financial statement.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

I understand.

Comment on this

There might be a slight difference.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

The point is these were the figures as of 31 December 2018. These figures would not have been updated, as the Chairman might have suggested-----

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

-----when the audit was signed off in October.

Comment on this

It was a couple of weeks ago. Fine.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

This was the position as of 31 December 2018.

Comment on this

Starting into 2019, it was expected that €265 million would be paid in respect of contracts entered into-----

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

Correct.

Comment on this

-----as part of the project. That money would come from the board. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Farragher

It would be via the HSE.

Comment on this

Okay. We are agreed. It would be something close to €265 million. I now move to the period "between one and two years". This refers to figures for after the end of 2019 but before the end of 2020. The accounts were finished at the end of 2018. Year one would have been 2019. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

Correct.

Comment on this

The period between one and two years would be 2020. That is what the document indicates. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

This includes 2020 and 2021.

Comment on this

That is not what the document indicates.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

That is what is in it.

Comment on this

This is meant to be "between one and two years".

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

I am just telling the Chairman exactly what numbers are there.

Comment on this

Fine. The witnesses can see why the figure is alarming me. The published audited accounts indicate, in layman's language, that these payments are to be made in 2020 but Mr. Gunning is now telling me this should be 2020 and 2021. It should cover between one and three years.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

Correct.

Comment on this

We are taking the figure as wrong. It is between one and two years. Mr. Gunning is saying it is between one and three years.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

It refers to payments after year one and at the end of year two. The numbers in it-----

Comment on this

I am coming to that. We have covered year one.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

Correct.

Comment on this

The next line refers to payments between year one and year two.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Farragher

It is two years. It is not singular. It is "between one and two years". The first year refers to payments of €265 million, which we have just discussed. There is then a reference to "between one and two years"-----

Comment on this

That is after year one.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Farragher

Correct.

Comment on this

That is not stated.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Farragher

Yes. It is very simplified.

Comment on this

The reference is to the two years after year one.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Farragher

Correct.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

Correct.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Farragher

It is 2020 and 2021.

Comment on this

It does not state that. I am putting it on the record that the accounts do not indicate that. We will stick with that. The witnesses are stating that in 2020 and 2021, the national children's hospital will require €653 million from the capital budget. We are dead right on that. Mr. Devine is nodding so my figures are dead right. A sum of almost €654 million will have to be paid in respect of the children's hospital in the years 2020 and 2021. It is what the document states.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

It states it was the position as of end of the December.

Comment on this

Fine. Mr. Breslin has told me the total capital construction budget for the HSE is €744 million for 2020 and €775 million for 2021.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

Without wishing to complicate the Chairman's life, I have an additional comment. We will do a capital carryover from this year to next year of €30 million, which will be added to the €744 million.

Comment on this

It appears that meeting the commitments for work already contracted and under way means the board will have to come up with €654 million between 2020 and 2021. It is stated in the accounts when that is expected to be paid. That is from a total capital construction budget of approximately €1.5 billion.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

Yes.

Comment on this

I want those figures on record. What percentage is that?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

It is approximately 40%.

Comment on this

In that case, 40% of the capital budget for 2020 and 2021 will go straight to the children's hospital. I want to put that on the public record. It is what the figures indicate. The job of the Committee of Public Accounts is to look at these annual accounts and that is the implication of the figures. It is for another forum to say the children's hospital would not have an impact on the capital budget for any other project. We are putting it on record that it is taking 40% of the entire budget.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

That has been our planning on this project for some time. It will be the big signature project of the health capital programme.

Comment on this

We know it is the biggest single project. It is why we would like to see accounts early in the year.

Comment on this

With respect, does the Chairman have any suggestion as to what capital budget it should come from? Where would he expect it to come from if not from health?

Comment on this

I am not suggesting anything. I am just putting the fact on the table that it is 40% of the capital budget. I am not suggesting anything. The Deputy can see the way the figures were presented and they did not tally when I first read them. It read as if those payments would come from next year's budget. The witnesses have said it refers to the two years after year one, which I accept. I am just putting the facts out there. I am not suggesting the funding will come from anywhere else.

The capital commitments of €997 million already incurred as per the note and the €260 million included in the previous year's accounts bring a total of approximately €1.25 billion. I do not expect the witnesses to have a breakdown now but can they provide it for the €1.257 billion, including contractual commitments entered into?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Yes.

Comment on this

Do the witnesses understand what I am seeking?

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

We have a table.

Comment on this

If it is not a big table, it can be read into the record. I am happy for it come in writing.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

We will provide it.

Comment on this

It might be neater. Things can get lost when they are read out loud.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

Of course.

Comment on this

There is approximately €1.257 billion committed to date and the witnesses will send a detailed breakdown of it.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

It will cover what makes up that figure. That is fine.

Comment on this

The job of the Committee of Public Accounts is to get to the bottom of the financial statements.

Comment on this
Mr. David Gunning

Absolutely.

Comment on this

It was one of the main issues I wanted to raise. This concerns capital commitments and the project moving on for the next few years. The breakdown of phase A is to be provided, although the witnesses have said it was part of the main contract at the end of the day. I will have to go to the chairman of the children's hospital project programme board for the next answer. Mr. Barry is only handling the €1.433 billion. Am I correct in saying that?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Yes.

Comment on this

He said that is the budget agreed and it is hoped to come in on budget, subject to what we have discussed. I will not rehash that. It will be subject to assumptions. There is a clear implication that there are other costs associated with the children's hospital not in the construction contract. Will Mr. Breslin start telling us what else will be in there to get this children's hospital up and running? Children's Health Ireland will have significant costs and other costs may not be met directly by that organisation. What will be the costs of getting the hospital open? He is chairman of the project programme board, which comprises two people from the Department and two from the HSE. The members of the programme board are the people with the global picture of how this hospital will work.

We will start with the figure of €1.433 billion, which is fine. Let us hope it is as close to that as possible. Mr. Barry referred to issues in his opening statement that are not in that guaranteed maximum price. What are those elements not included in what we have been talking about today?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

There are probably two categories. There is what has been discussed in the meeting around residual risks relating to the paediatric hospital development board's costs and there are some costs outside the paediatric hospital development board. I can go into either of those if the Chairman so wishes.

The residual risks are a challenge to the development board at bringing this in at €1.433 billion. We have spoken about inflation and so on. The Government has clearly stated the budget is €1.433 billion. Outside this are elements not in the budget for the construction of the hospital. These lie primarily with Children's Health Ireland, and they include ICT, the electronic health record and integration of services. They all form into the total figure seen before of €1.7 billion.

Comment on this

Okay. The €1.433 billion figure has been subject to quite a bit of interrogation. Mr. Barry is smiling as I say that.

The other costs have not been subject to any interrogation here at all. Today, we have dealt with the €1.7 billion. In meeting members of the board, we have only focused on the bare costs. This committee has never had a discussion on the €293 million in other costs. What information can Mr. Breslin give us on that? We have not really had any discussion on those extra costs.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

One of the biggest items is the electronic health record. That will go through a peer review process under the office of the chief information officer. The procurement process and the project have already been looked at. We would hope to go to tender shortly and, on receipt of the tenders, CHI will contract with a provider to deliver an electronic health record. The budget that is provided for this has been looked at on a number of occasions, most recently in the request to the peer review process for permission to go to tender, and it seems to be within the norms that might be expected for a project of this nature.

Comment on this

Who makes up the peer review group?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

They are independent people who are not part of the delivery process. They are nominated by the chief information officer for the Government. They invigilate this to ensure that we have proper costing, a proper programme and proper governance in place.

Comment on this

Ms Hardiman stated that the records of 1.2 million children would be on the system.

Comment on this
Ms Eilísh Hardiman

I want to be absolutely crystal clear. What we have at the moment is a patient administration system. That is a basic foundation system with the patients' data and information on it. What we are going out to procure is an electronic healthcare record. That is a different system that has all of the clinical notes. It also has all of the medications. It can combine their X-rays and all of their lab feedback. It also allows the clinicians to order electronically their diagnosis of the investigations. It is a very different system.

As the Secretary General outlined, we have developed a business case. So it has been through the HSE. As with any major ICT project in health, the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform has a peer review process. We have been before this peer review independent group three times this year. It interrogates the business case, the costs, independent of the Department or the HSE and reports back up to the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform. We have been through those three meetings. The final one was only last week and we hope to get a positive indication to go out to procure after that.

Comment on this

I ask Ms Hardiman to send us a detailed briefing on that, rather than taking up the time of the meeting at this hour in the afternoon. It is the one issue that we have not discussed as a committee, other than those quick figures we got the last time. Representatives from the HSE will appear before the committee in a few minutes.

Comment on this

Will the electronic health record contain any genetic data relating to children? I ask this because of how powerful that the genetic data of a population would be to a corporate entity. Do we have sufficient protections for our genetic data?

Comment on this
Ms Eilísh Hardiman

Electronic healthcare records do not tend to hold genetic data - all of the ones that are out there. There tends to be a separate system that holds the genetic data electronically.

Comment on this

Either Mr. Barry or Mr. Gunning stated that there might be claims in addition to the €1.433 billion for items they thought were not included. Have they had a meeting on what these might be? I am thinking that it might relate to ground works or whatever. This would lead to an argument between the quantity surveyors on both sides. Has the NPHDB looked into what these potential big claims might be that they might not have considered?

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Yes. We are reviewing them all the time and we are reviewing the responses being prepared by the design teams or the quality surveyors and inputting into all of that. It is in respect of these that we have had most of the disputes with the contractor during past year and, indeed, they will continue into next year and beyond. It is for these that the total additional cost to date has been certified at well under the €1 million.

Comment on this

We have discussed that. Mr. Barry believes it is 50% of the claims.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Of those that have been determined.

Comment on this

Mr. Barry also said it was of those that had been submitted.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Of the ones submitted.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Just so that there is no doubt on the record, when the ER determines the claim, the contractor still has the facility to take further action against them up to the High Court, but we are not in the High Court on anything yet, I am pleased to say.

Comment on this

Good. I thank Mr. Barry.

Comment on this

While it may be rumour, is there any truth to the suggestion that the ducting for cabling, toilet piping, etc., is too small? I only heard recently that it is not wide enough to carry all the necessary facilities going through these corridors, ducts, ducting or whatever one wants to call them to carry the electric cables, toilet pipes and all that. I have heard that the ducts are not wide or big enough to take them and that is causing a problem. My second question is about rumours relating to steel beams. I do not actually know what kind of beams were involved. When they were brought in from abroad, they were too big to fit and had to be cut or adapted to fit. This resulted in a major cost. Is there any truth to these rumours?

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

We are not aware of any corridors not being large enough to cater for the designed M and E services as set out in the GMP. Just to say on that, we have brought the design of this building to a very high level in terms of building information modelling. We have a 3D representation of every single service in the building. That was done for GMP. We are very confident that all of the services fitted within the corridors. I can also confirm that I am not aware of any claim that has come in to say that the services are not fitting in the corridors. I am not aware of any steelwork that came in that had to be cut or altered. If such a thing should happen, it would be the contractor's responsibility and not that of the employer.

Comment on this

I am asking because there was a bit of ruction here last week regarding a printer that was bought and did not fit. I was told that the same thing could have happened in the building of the children's hospital. I am just clarifying if this happened.

Who makes up the design team for the building? Are they Irish or are they foreign?

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

We have a mixture. The lead architect is BDP, which is a UK firm. Its partner is an Irish firm, O'Connell Mahon Architects. The quantity surveyor is Linesight, which is an indigenous Irish firm, but it is also global. The M and E design engineer is Arup, which is again a global firm but it has been established in Ireland since 1946 with about 500 people. It is an Irish firm, one could say. O'Connor Sutton Cronin is the civil and structural engineer, and that is an indigenous Irish firm.

Comment on this

If there were an issue such as I described, who would carry the can? Would it be BAM, the contractors or the design team that would incur the costs if something in the design were wrong? Who would have responsibility and who would carry the costs if something like fittings were wrong?

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

Let us take the steelwork. If the steelwork came to site and it was the wrong length or something of that nature, that would generally be the contractor's responsibility.

Comment on this

That would be BAM in this case.

Comment on this
Mr. Fred Barry

Or its subcontractor.

Comment on this

If there was anything wrong with the design of the building, who would take responsibility?

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

If the design of the steelwork were incorrect and it had to be changed, that would be an employer responsibility through the design team.

Comment on this

The taxpayer would not be caught for any of those costs.

Comment on this
Mr. Phelim Devine

If the design of the steel beam were incorrect and it was a design team mistake, the taxpayer would be responsible, the employer would be.

Comment on this

That is why I am asking. It could fall back on the taxpayer again.

Comment on this

We will conclude this session because some of the HSE people are waiting outside. I know we ran a bit longer, but it was an issue people wanted to talk about. I thank our guests from NPHDB, the Department of Health, the HSE, and CHI for their attendance. Further information is to come through.

Comment on this