We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Pobal: Financial Statements 2018

Contributions 1–202 of 618. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

This morning we are dealing with Pobal and its financial statements for 2018. We are joined this morning by Ms Anna Shakespeare, chief executive officer. She is new to the position having joined in August. You are very welcome to your first meeting of the Committee of Public Accounts. Ms Shakespeare is joined by Mr. Jerry Murphy, deputy chief executive, and Mr. Brian Lehane, chief financial officer. They are also joined by Richard Deane and Gerard Sellars. We are also joined by Mr. Paul Geraghty, principal officer, Department of Rural and Community Development, and Mr. Gordon Gaffney, principal officer, Department of Children and Youth Affairs.

I wish to advise members, witnesses and everyone in the Public Gallery that all mobile telephones must be switched off in their entirety or put in airplane mode, as merely setting them to silent mode can still cause interference with the recording system. I advise witnesses that by virtue of section 17(2)(l) of the Defamation Act 2009, they are protected by absolute privilege in respect of their evidence to the committee.

If they are directed by the committee to cease giving evidence on a particular matter and continue to so do, they are entitled thereafter only to qualified privilege in respect of their evidence. They are directed that only evidence connected with the subject matter of these proceedings is to be given and are asked to respect the parliamentary practice to the effect that, where possible, they should not criticise or make charges against any person, persons or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable. Members are reminded of the provisions of Standing Order 186 to the effect that they shall refrain from inquiring into the merits of a policy or policies of the Government or a Minister of the Government or the merits of the objectives of such policies. While we expect witnesses to answer questions asked by the committee clearly and with candour, they can and should expect to be treated fairly and with respect and consideration at all times in accordance with the witness protocol. We will begin by inviting Mr. McCarthy to make his opening statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

Thank you Chairman. Pobal is a State-owned not-for-profit company limited by guarantee. The company was originally established in 1992 by agreement with the European Commission to manage an EU grant scheme to support local development. Over time, the functions of Pobal have expanded significantly. It now functions as an agent for a number of Government Departments and EU bodies providing administration, management and support services for around 25 programmes in the areas of social inclusion and equality, inclusive employment and enterprise and early years education and childcare. In 2018, Pobal issued grants totalling around €695 million. As indicated in the figures now on screen, almost 70% of the payments were in relation to childcare programmes funded by the Vote for the Department of Children and Youth Affairs. Other significant areas of grant payment related to community employment schemes funded by the Department of Employment Affairs and Social Protection and community services grants funded by the Department of Rural and Community Development. Pobal recoups its administration costs under the terms of service agreements with the funding Departments. In 2018, Pobal spent a total of €35.1 million in administration costs and other programme supports. This comprised €21.7 million in respect of payroll and €13.4 million in non-pay costs.

My audit report on the financial statements drew attention to the statement on internal control which disclosed that in 2018 Pobal incurred expenditure to the value of €1.15 million on goods and services, the procurement of which was not compliant with the relevant procedures. This mainly related to ICT and project management services required to deliver the national childcare scheme. I also drew attention in the audit report to Chapter 16 of the Report on the Accounts of the Public Services 2018, which examines the delivery of early learning and childcare funding programmes. This deals with Pobal’s role in administering the schemes and in ensuring compliance with scheme conditions. The statement on internal control summarises Pobal’s compliance activity in that regard.

Comment on this

Thank you. I now invite Ms Shakespeare to make her opening statement.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

I thank the Chairman and committee members for their invitation to attend this meeting. I am accompanied by Mr. Jerry Murphy, our deputy chief executive who has been with the organisation since 2005, and Mr. Brian Lehane, our chief financial officer who joined Pobal in July 2018. I was appointed as chief executive of Pobal in August this year. I joined Pobal from St.Michael’s House where I was chief executive since 2015.

Pobal values the role of this committee and we are here to account for and apply the lessons of this process. Pobal is a not-for-profit, registered charity and a company limited by guarantee without share capital. Pobal’s board is appointed by the Government under the aegis of the Department of Rural and Community Development. Established in 1992, Pobal has developed in response to Government priorities over 27 years. On behalf of Government, our work supports valuable services in marginalised communities. Our core role is to deliver an effective programme and grant management service in order to create an inclusive society where Government and communities work together.

In 2018, Pobal managed 25 programmes, primarily for four Government Departments. The areas, groups and communities we support are outlined in the briefing document we submitted to the committee. In managing these programmes in 2018 Pobal disbursed €694.7 million, an increase in expenditure of €79.7 million over 2017. We supported 2,500 community groups and almost 32,000 individuals through the Social Inclusion and Community Activation Programme, SICAP. We channelled funding to 4,832 early learning and care services, supporting approximately 81,899 families with reduced fees through the community subvention programme. We also approved 19,000 participants for the seniors alert scheme.

In 2018 Pobal employed 442 staff in 2018, with 46% based outside Dublin. We operate our programmes efficiently. Our administration spend for 2018 was €29.94 million or 4.10% of budget. Pobal’s budget has evolved to deliver programmes of work in line with Government policy and requirements which make a difference to people’s lives. Funds disbursed moved from €257 million in 2011 to €695 million in 2018. This reflects changes in Irish society and the Government’s commitment to supporting civil society with these changes.

As CEO, my vision for Pobal is to deliver a value for money service for Government and to make a difference for people and communities. The landscape of Irish society has altered significantly, redefining who we are and how we live. Working with community and voluntary organisations, Pobal aims to build capacity locally and to support sustainable, resilient communities. In a world increasingly fraught with social challenges, the importance of a strong network of natural community supports is a critical component of individual and collective well-being. It enables us to meet the challenges of the future.

Pobal is committed to ensuring our processes deliver verifiable management of taxpayer’s money, while offering user friendly and effective support to all stakeholders. Our supports assist community organisations to meet their legislative, governance and financial management requirements. We also provide practical help such as helping hands workshops and managing better guides. Where possible we utilise information technology to reduce the administrative burden on community organisations. We have seen remarkable changes across the early learning and care and the school age childcare sector in Ireland in recent years, including the development of the First 5 strategy and the national childcare scheme, of which Pobal is scheme administrator.

We are proud of our work but we know we do not always get things right. We welcome the oversight of the Comptroller and Auditor General and this committee. This process is important in reminding us of our purpose and in identifying areas for improvement and learning. The committee is aware the Comptroller and Auditor General highlighted two issues in our 2018 annual financial statements. I accept that there is a need for improvement in our procurement processes, with non-compliance on a proportion of expenditure on goods and services in 2018. I take this matter extremely seriously, as does the organisation. A corrective action plan is in place with targets and timelines for completion.

The second note to the accounts relates to Chapter 16 of the 2018 Annual Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General, which examined the administration by Pobal of early learning and childcare funding programmes. Two of the recommendations in the chapter were directed to Pobal. However, we understand this chapter will be considered in greater detail at a future meeting of this committee.

Looking ahead, in 2020 the Department of Rural and Community Development will undertake a periodic critical review of Pobal under the code of practice for the governance of State bodies. This is the first such review under the 2016 code. The Department of Children and Youth Affairs has also indicated it will undertake a major operational review of all its early years programmes and the operating model in the early learning and care sector. We look forward to both reviews and implementing any recommendations for change and improvement. The entire team at Pobal works hard to deliver for the communities from which we come and where we live. It is an important part of our organisational culture that we exist for families and communities who not only need the services and programmes we administer but who also, in real terms, pay for these services. I thank the committee for the opportunity to appear today and my colleagues and I are happy to take any questions members may have.

Comment on this

Thank you Ms Shakespeare. The first speaker today is Deputy Shane Cassells who has 20 minutes. All other speakers will have ten minutes. I remind everyone that the weekly voting slot in the Dáil is scheduled for 1.45 p.m. This meeting will finish at 1.45 p.m. at the latest, if not before then. We will be dealing with other business in the afternoon so we must finish by 1.45 p.m. at the very latest.

Comment on this

I welcome Ms Shakespeare and her team to this meeting. I wish her well in her new role and thank her for the comprehensive briefing documents that were provided to the committee prior to this meeting. The total amount of money going through Pobal is substantial, amounting to €695 million in 2018. The largest element comprises grants from the Department of Children and Youth Affairs, totalling €506 million.

Are all of those moneys distributed to programme supports or do some administration and salary costs come out of them? Ms Shakespeare mentioned the administration cost of €29.4 million.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

We extract some of our costs from that €506 million.

Comment on this

Is that done on a proportional basis in terms of the staff assigned to the early years sector within Pobal or across the board?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

We agree a programme of work in the context of our performance delivery agreement and the number of full-time equivalents associated with that programme under the governance of the service level agreement between ourselves and the Department. Indeed our other programmes are delivered in that way. I refer the Deputy to my colleague, Brian Lehane, who might be in a position to provide further detail.

Comment on this

I want to get an understanding of Pobal's work because many people may not be aware of it, despite its significant budget. Until 2006 the funding for childcare infrastructure came from the EU under the equal opportunities childcare programme, EOCP. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Yes.

Comment on this

That would have been focussed on training, education, employment and assisting people in coming back into the workforce. That changed to the national childcare investment programme around 2006. Is that right?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

That is my understanding, yes.

Comment on this

Then it moved to Exchequer-based funding. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

That is my understanding.

Comment on this

At the time there was a rationale for Pobal when it was run under the previous model. Can Ms Shakespeare explain to me the need for Pobal now as the middleman, considering that change in 2006? Could the Department not do this work? We needed the middleman to draw down the EU funding but then we moved to Exchequer-based funding.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

I will refer the Deputy to my colleague, Jerry Murphy, who worked in the organisation at that time.

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

The Deputy is absolutely right to refer back to the long history of our involvement in early years care. Pobal was party to the original investigations around the needs for childcare and much of that started with particular needs in disadvantaged communities but as we moved through that cycle there was a tendency to divide responsibilities so that the more administrative elements of the role came to Pobal. These include significant elements of policy making, design, standard setting and oversight that traditionally lie with the Department but because of the intricacies of managing these flows of moneys to so many individual groups the decision was made that there were advantages in having a specialist organisation with the knowledge and infrastructure to do that. Over many years we have developed staff teams with the experience of the local bodies and how things work, with experience in financial management, compliance and people who are available to interact directly with groups whether in a support role or dealing with issues such as financial compliance. We also developed a series of expertise around matters such as monitoring and reporting to the Department. We feel we have developed a set of skills distinct from what would normally be within a Department.

Comment on this

There is a representative from the Department of Children and Youth Affairs but there is also one from the Department of Rural and Community Development. Am I correct in saying it was the original parent body in 1992? I am trying to understand why Pobal, which was established to manage EU grants, is administering childcare grants now. It had a different sphere. Is that why the Department of Rural and Community Development is here today too?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

The Department of Rural and Community Development is our lead Department.

Comment on this

That Department is the lead, not the Department of Children and Youth Affairs.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

That is correct. In any programme activity with another Department we write to our lead Department for the authority to proceed.

Comment on this

On that point, what is the Department of Children and Youth Affairs' interpretation of its relationship with Pobal and the fact that this middleman is implementing the grants for the Department?

Comment on this
Mr. Gordon Gaffney

The Department's relationship is on a customer-type basis. There is a strong governance methodology with a service level agreement and an annual programme of works. Pobal is better suited to undertake the type of work because it has an in-depth knowledge of the early years sector. It has strong relationships. We believe there is strong governance in place between us and Pobal. It is fair to say, however, that it has grown out of EU schemes into Exchequer schemes and over the past five years there has been a 141% increase in funding in the scale of the schemes under administration by Pobal. Our Minister is about to undertake a review of systems and structures to consider Pobal and the city and county childcare committees to see if there are improvements that can be made to the system.

Comment on this

Is there a review under way?

Comment on this
Mr. Gordon Gaffney

A review is about to commence on this very matter.

Comment on this

In her briefing document Ms Shakespeare noted that Pobal received over 36,000 queries in 2018, 78% of those are related to the early years and childcare, so that accounts for most of its work. She cites the early childhood care and education, ECCE, scheme, the higher capitation applications.

I note the high profile launch of the new national childcare scheme this week but a woman contacted my office who, during the soft launch, was twice provided with an invalid Chick code. She eventually got the correct code yesterday but here's the rub: she was a mum returning to the workforce, she had applied on 7 November and was commencing work shortly after that but due to the glitch in the system her application was processed only yesterday, 10 December. She now owes her childcare provider a substantial sum for that period but she has been told the payments cannot be backdated. They are in place only from yesterday and she is out of pocket. Can Ms Shakespeare enlighten me please on that?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

First, it is unfortunate that an incorrect childcare identifier number was allocated. We express our gratitude to that individual for joining us at the soft launch because that was part of individuals like her assisting us in ironing the glitches out of the system.

Comment on this

I know that but unfortunately she is out of pocket for a substantial amount of money through being part of that guinea pig programme. She had a very bad experience as part of it. She is now collateral damage.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

As I said, I thank the Deputy's constituent and I understand the very difficult situation she now finds herself in. The income assessment is the foundation of the national childcare scheme.

Comment on this

She was told that it would be turned around in ten days. That was on 7 November; 10 December was yesterday.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

That is correct. As part of our verification process to ensure proper oversight of the financial controls and that the system was working correctly we have had to do some manual exercises around identifying individuals going through the income assessment. That means we need to connect with the data from the Department of Employment Affairs and Social Protection and from the Revenue Commissioners to calculate the income assessed value of the subsidy that will be awarded to an individual such as the Deputy's constituent. It is regrettable that it has taken a little time to get through that.

However, we needed to balance the piece of making sure that, on the one hand, when an individual gets his or her income assessed value, the payment he or she is going to get is absolutely correct because an individual might make, as the Deputy's constituent obviously did, life-changing decisions to go back into the workforce or into education and, on the other hand, it is about balancing the approach to ensure probity in Exchequer spend of money.

Comment on this

On the higher capitation whereby the payment per child varies depending of the qualification of the room leader, am I correct that a room leader with a level 5 or 6 qualification would result in a payment of €69 per child?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

I will have to confirm that.

Comment on this

Where it is a room leader with a degree qualification it would be €80.25 per child. It should be noted, and the Comptroller and Auditor General noted it in his report, that in 2010 just 11% of ECCE room leaders had a degree qualification and the figures available for 2018 show that this has risen to over 50%. That is very positive. Will Ms Shakespeare explain the problems with the payment of higher capitation since September? My office has been contacted by providers since then and the verification process by Pobal in many cases is still ongoing, meaning that the higher capitation is not paid and the providers are out of pocket. They have higher qualified room leaders who must be paid and who command a higher wage. The verification process is still ongoing for many of the people who contacted me. Can Ms Shakespeare explain why the delays are occurring? If there is a change in the opposite direction and the provider goes down from a room leader who has a degree qualification, I presume the provider will owe a refund of moneys. Will she discuss that?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

It was agreed between Pobal and the Department of Children and Youth Affairs that an appraisal of the higher capitation applications would commence in early October. The application process opened in August to allow service providers ample time to submit applications. It involves the Pobal employees verifying the qualifications and verification of the qualifications of all those individuals. What happened is that when we went to seek the verification of the qualifications of some of the individuals and when the qualification confirmation and verification came back, they went back to the end of the queue so we had to revise our process. I again acknowledge that was a learning point for us. Those individuals subsequently have been moved further up the queue. In some respects that has contributed to the delay in that regard.

Comment on this

I appreciate that Ms Shakespeare is new to the post. She referred to that as a learning point but this organisation has been on the go since 1992. We are dealing with a very fragile industry. I attended a briefing with providers last month and many of them have become exasperated as to whether they would even continue in the profession. There are major pressures in counties such as Meath, Kildare and Dublin with even attaining places for children, such is the dearth of places in urban areas, yet providers are at the end of their tether. Despite people's perception of this being an industry flush with cash because of the high fees that are charged, many providers are on the breadline and the delay in the processing of payments, where Ms Shakespeare said people go to the end of the queue, is causing many of them to be on that line. It is coming up to Christmas and it is still not resolved. Will the situation be remedied or will we see it continue in 2020?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Absolutely. I should add that by agreement with the Department of Children and Youth Affairs, an initial preliminary payment was made and a second preliminary payment has been made while we work our way through the higher capitation application verification exercises. My colleague, Mr. Murphy, might wish to add to that.

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

We are conscious of the fact that, particularly in this instance with early years, we are working with a sector that is always close to the limit. What that means for us is that often we intentionally manage our processes in a way that gives us very little time for things like turnarounds, to ensure that payments are done as quickly as possible. It puts a significant amount of pressure on our side but it is in recognition of the fact that moneys need to flow. While we have been involved in this for a long time, it is reasonably recently that the higher capitation grants were transferred to us. We opened the process early to allow people to make submissions early, but it was always flagged by us that the assessment process would not start until significantly later than that. We are conscious that this was translated by the sector as an expectation that the assessments would begin shortly after the applications were sent in. I know learning points are not as important as delivery, but that was equally a lesson for us.

Comment on this

I appreciate that. I have cited two examples - a parent who is out of pocket because of the glitches in the system and, second, the industry providers who are facing financial hardships as well. Both the administration of the scheme by Pobal and the glitches in the system are causing these pressures on a very fragile industry.

Childcare in the early years has been hitting the headlines for all the wrong reasons this year, unfortunately. The Department has to develop a quality service. As part of that, in the annual report the Department outlines its better start programme, which is a national early years quality development service for the early learning and care providers working with children from birth to six years of age. When the controversy with the Hyde & Seek crèches in Dublin was uncovered by RTÉ, I tabled a parliamentary question to the Minister to ask if the early year specialists under the better start programme had visited this crèche. I was told in the reply that the better start programme visited the crèche and that the quality development service assigned an early years specialist to work with this service from November 2015 to September 2016. The early years specialist visited the Hyde & Seek crèche on 13 occasions during this time and made recommendations to the service on ways to improve quality. There were 13 visits to this service, which was exposed on RTÉ, on ways to improve quality. Was none of the shortcomings that were subsequently exposed by RTÉ highlighted by the early years specialist, who visited it on 13 occasions, to Pobal and what actions were taken?

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

Our staff were not aware of the issues that were highlighted in the "RTÉ Investigates" programme and did not see any evidence of the child protection issues. Any time our staff are in a situation where they are aware of any such issue, there is an immediate process for passing on that information to Tusla, which is the regulatory agency there. Our supports through the better start programme are related to the learning environment, the mechanisms that are used by individual staff members to ensure they are carrying out their roles properly and the standard of their care service. It is an unfortunate reality that one can work successfully with a series of individuals but there is still the wider context of the management system of a crèche, which was uncovered there.

Comment on this

Mr. Murphy's comment goes to the nub of the issue. Pobal had people going in but they were dealing with the learning environment. There is a plethora of people involved in early years childcare. As Mr. Murphy mentioned, there is Tusla, which has its sphere of work to do. There is Pobal, which has its sphere of work and then there is the Department of Children and Youth Affairs as the overarching body. The Department of Rural and Community Development is involved. The Comptroller and Auditor General when doing reports on local government will say it is complex, but the area of childcare is even more complex in terms of the plethora of people involved, including the Health Service Executive, the Department of Children and Youth Affairs and the Department of Rural and Community Development. There are so many that things fall between the cracks. There were 13 visits to this crèche, but Mr. Murphy said Pobal's sphere was to deal with the learning environment. A significant amount of money is being spent on the better start early years specialist programme. It is €7.9 million this year.

Next year that will rise to €9.7 million, an increase of nearly €2 million. Did no one look at the broader picture rather than looking at the learning environment only and leaving everything else to Tusla? Tusla also looks at certain aspects only. It defies belief. Things get missed when everyone works in silos.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

To answer the Deputy's question, he is right in that the focus of the Better Start programme is supporting the implementation of the national curriculum and Aistear and Síolta in early learning and childcare environments. Better Start staff are clearly instructed to report any child protection or welfare issues they notice. No child welfare or protection issues were identified in their visits to those crèches and locations.

Comment on this

Has Pobal re-examined these published reports in respect of anything that could have been looked at during that period?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

I am satisfied that no child protection or welfare concerns existed at that time. We will take the point on the organisation retrospectively going over the reports with a fine-tooth comb.

Comment on this

On the matter of different stands of funding coming from different agencies, if Pobal is auditing a community childcare centre and looking at money coming from the Department of Children and Youth Affairs, how does it deal with money coming from, for example, the Department of Rural and Community Development for a transport programme? Is everything looked at in silos or in its entirety?

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

First of all, I will distinguish between the issue of audit versus the issue of verification and compliance visits.

Comment on this

Pobal carried out 3,500 such visits last year, as opposed to 17 audits. Am I correct in that? Is that considered a low number of audits? What sparks an actual audit?

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

The majority of these audits were sparked, to use the Deputy's term, by a contractual commitment of ours under the community services programme. We contract with the Department of Rural and Community Development to conduct audit visits on a set percentage of programmes.

Comment on this

In that case, they are not sparked by anything. They are carried out on percentage basis.

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

Absolutely. The small number which remain - I believe it is seven but I may call on my colleagues in that regard - were conducted because of information given to us which suggested the need for an audit.

Comment on this

I will refer to those inspections because there was a significant issue in respect of non-compliance. Am I correct in saying that there was non-compliance in 50% of cases?

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

To start with, I would clearly distinguish between compliance visits and audits. The compliance visits which happen under the early years programmes consist of Pobal staff looking at record-keeping within each childcare centre to see whether it complies with the rules that are in place for early years education. The main issue found with regard to what the Deputy raised was around attendance records. Under the subsidised schemes, the Department of Children and Youth Affairs pays money based on the attendance of a child at a service. The services charge Pobal for those schemes. Our compliance team checks records to ensure the child's attendance matches what we are being charged for.

Comment on this

To return to my original question, if Pobal is looking at a service which receives funding from a number of different strands or Departments, how is that examined?

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

With regard to that massive work, we look at that small element of records. We do not look at a service's broad financial books.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

To go back to the Deputy's earlier question, he has correctly identified the number of interactions between Tusla, Pobal and others. At the heart of this is the major operational review being completed by the Department of Children and Youth Affairs. I understand that part of the drive behind that review is to bring some rationalisation to these interactions.

Comment on this

I will ask the witness from the Department of Children and Youth Affairs about the term "rationalisation". Does that mean the Department is moving towards a more streamlined provision? What does that mean?

Comment on this
Mr. Gordon Gaffney

We are not going to pre-empt the findings of that review but certainly-----

Comment on this

Is the review being carried out internally by staff or is a consultancy involved?

Comment on this
Mr. Gordon Gaffney

We are proposing to set up an interdepartmental group with the involvement of staff and a consultant. It has not been formally published yet. We are still working through the planning phase. We hope to see that completed over the coming year.

Comment on this

The report will be finished by the end of next year.

Comment on this
Mr. Gordon Gaffney

I am sorry. We hope to see it commenced and the bulk of the work completed next year. I cannot say that the report will be finalised by the end of next year.

Comment on this

Will the report then go to the Minister, whoever that might be, for a review of the findings?

Comment on this
Mr. Gordon Gaffney

We expect it to go to the Minister for review and decision.

Comment on this

I also want to raise the issue of delays in the higher capitation payments. I am aware that an apology was issued but no reason or rationale was provided for the delays. I am glad that has been somewhat clarified today. Ms Shakespeare said an appraisal was carried out in October. Did that relate to the delays? How soon can we expect to see an improvement given the problems this issue causes for people?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

If I can be of assistance, there may be two issues at play here. The first is that we did, unfortunately, have a financial failure. Some €11.5 million of payments did not issue as a result of an ICT failure. That is one part. The second part relates to the higher capitation payments. I can absolutely confirm that much has been learned from this in respect of timing and the amount of work entailed in verifying the qualifications of providers seeking that additional funding. We have put in place two interim payment plans to ensure the sustainability of those organisations in the interim.

Comment on this

How soon can we expect to see improvement in the overall system? It is fair enough that interim payment systems are in place, but when will the overall system be improved so that we can rest assured that this will not happen again?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

I expect that there will be further improvements with effect from this month. The implementation platform or payment platform is to be replaced with the national childcare scheme in 2020. We expect to see improvements as that early years platform is implemented further.

Comment on this

There is no question of administration resources being insufficient. That does not come into play at all, does it?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Is the Deputy referring to Pobal's resources?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

I am not aware of that issue being brought to our attention.

Comment on this

With regard to compliance visits, I was going to ask what exactly is checked but Mr. Murphy said that it is record-keeping and so on. Some figures were given to us in the briefing note. It states that "19 % were deemed major

non-compliant". That is a significant and worrying figure. Will Ms Shakespeare provide some detail in that regard?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

As Mr. Murphy has identified, that 19% figure relates to child attendance. The child's registration is linked to his or her attendance at the early learning and care centre.

Comment on this

It is strictly down to child attendance, there is nothing else.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Yes. It is in accordance with the registration.

Comment on this

Was that introduced on foot of the issue in Galway in 2014 when children were registered as attending a crèche which they did not attend? To the best of my recollection, I believe an overpayment to the tune of €100,000 was made but I stand to be corrected. Were these compliance visits put in place since that case arose or were they carried out prior to that?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

These compliance visits relate directly to the programme rules and guidelines published by the Department. These have been refined over time to provide further clarity. Our most recent compliance visits have related to the refined programme rules and guidance

Comment on this

Those came in after the issue arose in Galway.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Yes.

Comment on this

How are the services to undergo audit chosen? What is the rationale?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

It is agreed as part of the programme of work with the Department of Children and Youth Affairs. It is also based on a review of the monetary value and risk profile associated with that spend.

There are a number of drivers behind it, if that makes sense.

Comment on this

How many on average are carried out each year?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

There were 3,400 compliance visits completed in 2018.

Comment on this

Okay. Seventeen audits were carried out in 2018. Were there any instances of misuse of public funding that came up in any of those audits?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

There were 17 audits. Seven of them were childcare related and were related to non-capital spend, and ten were related to the community services programme, with one of those also relating to dormant accounts funding. I am not aware of any actual or suspected misappropriation. We work alongside providers in improving their governance and their systems. As Deputy Cassells has referenced, it is a developing sector and we would see a part of our role in supporting agencies, improving their governance and improving their compliance over time.

Comment on this

Will Ms Shakespeare explain the increase in consultancy costs between 2017 and 2018?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

There was an increase of €226,000 in consultancy between 2017 and 2018 and we have done a detailed review of that internally. I will pass that question over to Mr. Lehane, our chief financial officer.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

There was a big increase, which was related to various projects. A strategic review was undertaken, there was a review in regard to ISO 27001, and a review of the early years procedures. An employee survey is also part of that figure, and the HP deprivation index was also undertaken in 2018, as well as the charity review. There are various elements making up that figure of €226,000.

Comment on this

What were the specific requirements for all of those reviews?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

One was in regard to the leadership review of Pobal overall, given the growth of the organisation. There was a review of the contracts we have regarding procedures for the early years policies, particularly around compliance. With regard to ISO 27001, we have started a process around getting alignment with ISO 27001 and what we need to do around that aspect. The charity review was around the charity standing of Pobal. As for the employee survey, given the fact that Pobal has grown, we took a review of employees and their views of Pobal.

Comment on this

Will Mr. Lehane expand on that last point?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

What we are trying to do is get the employee excellence through people award, so our first step was to survey the employees of Pobal to get their views on Pobal and how they feel about working with Pobal. We will then move it on to get the excellence through people award.

Comment on this

Cuirim fáilte roimh na finnéithe.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Go raibh maith ag an Teachta.

Comment on this

Is dea-scéal é go bhfuil an méid seo airgid ag Pobal le leithdháileadh ar thograí suntasacha agus tábhachtacha.

I welcome the witnesses. It is a positive story to have this money, so there is a particularly high onus on Pobal to be accountable for itself as an organisation and then to ensure accountability on the ground. My questions come within that. With regard to the bike to work scheme, how many people availed of that?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Within Pobal?

Comment on this

Yes. It is in the accounts and it jumped out at me.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

We will have to come back to the Deputy on that as I do not know the number.

Comment on this

It is just out of interest. A bugbear of mine is property being leased continuously. Page 116 of the Pobal accounts gives a list of its offices. Pobal owns no land or buildings and, therefore, it provides the services through a number of rented premises. Is that right?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

That is correct.

Comment on this

The accounts deal with total leasing commitments. I will first take the list of properties, which are located throughout the country. Are there two in Galway - one in Clifden and one in Galway city?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

That is correct.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Yes.

Comment on this

Some leases have expired.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

They have been renewed. That information is out of date. The date for Adelaide Road, which had expired, has gone to 2024, the one for Monaghan has gone to 2028, and Limerick has gone to 2020.

Comment on this

Limerick has gone to 2020 and Adelaide Road has gone to 2024. What are the details? Has the rent increased or decreased?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

Overall, rent has increased. From 2017 to 2018, there was an increase in rent because, in 2017, we moved into Ormond Quay, so there is a full year's rent in 2018, and 2018 was the first year we moved into Adelaide Road, so our rent overall has increased.

Comment on this

What is the total amount going out on rent every year?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

The total amount in rent for 2018 was approximately €1.7 million and the balance is made up of service charges of €300,000.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

It is basically the service charge we pay to the landlord for the upkeep and maintenance.

Comment on this

Would that be €2 million per year?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

It was €2 million for 2018.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

It should be a similar figure for 2019.

Comment on this

Under the heading "Break Clause", it states "None", and there were no break clauses in any of Pobal's leases.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

No.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

At the time, they were not included. When they were negotiated, maybe it was felt we did not need a break clause. I do not know the answer as they were negotiated before I joined.

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

I was there at the time. At the time some of them were negotiated, it was simply not possible to get a break clause, particularly from a Dublin landlord. They had queues of customers and they were not willing to offer that kind of arrangement.

Comment on this

Really? They had queues of customers. In regard to Galway, Letterkenny, Limerick and all of those, had they queues of customers?

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

The Deputy is right. It is a very different situation there.

Comment on this

It is not, because there is no break clause in any of them.

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

No.

Comment on this

Maybe it is better or cheaper when there is no break clause. I do not know and I am no expert.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

It usually does have a cost effect. It may be cheaper. That is obviously something one would want to look at in regard to a lease. It strikes me that the note that is presented here would be improved if the duration of the lease was given as well because, obviously, if it is a short-term lease, such as a five-year lease, one would not be looking at a break clause. The extension on Adelaide Road is to 2024, so that is five years, and one would not expect a break clause on such a short lease.

Comment on this

Perhaps the witnesses could come back, through the Chair, to clarify when the leases started. I think of Galway, where we became very aware of the number of rented buildings. I think of one HSE building which was almost €1 million per year. I do not need to exaggerate because it was so high - more than €800,000 or almost €1 million per year for 25 or 30 years, and when they broke it, there was a penalty of €1 million. I am very conscious of rented buildings. Has there ever been a discussion at board level in regard to a permanent building or the purchase or construction of a building?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

I am not aware there has been. The nature of Pobal is that we are dependent on programmes of work that are finite of duration and nature and related to a performance delivery agreement and a service arrangement. Therefore, the continuance of Pobal into the future is something the board would definitely be mindful of when investing heavily in assets. It is certainly something we can take back to the board from this committee.

Comment on this

In relation to debts outstanding, I forget which page it was on. I was running in and out. Usually, I have it marked.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

Is it the grants repayable?

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

It is on page 115. It is at the top of that page.

Comment on this

Pobal estimates that €1.7 million of this closing balance is irrecoverable and the remaining balance then is set out. Is the €1.7 million written off? Are these grants given out that were not used?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

That is correct. The majority of those grants of €1.7 million go back quite a period of time to the early opportunities childcare programme and the national childcare investment programme. They have not been written off yet but we are liaising with the Department of Children and Youth Affairs regarding those debts.

Comment on this

It looks like they will be written off.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

Potentially.

Comment on this

Up to one year, there is a debt of €1.3 million that is outstanding for one year. Is that right?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

That is correct.

Comment on this

More than one year and up to five years, there is €1 million and more than five years, €2.1 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

Correct.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

In our view, it has gone through our recovery process. A lot of those amounts relate to companies that either have been dissolved or are in liquidation, and I would suspect that the majority, if not all, of that could potentially be deemed irrecoverable.

Comment on this

Where does the fault or the gap lie that such an amount of debt is irrecoverable?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

I suppose it needs to be looked at in the context of the total funding over the period since 2000 of approximately €2.4 billion. There are various reasons that would happen. Given funding commitments, organisations, as I said, have gone into liquidation. They have been dissolved. We go through a process in Pobal to seek recovery of those funds and at times we are successful in getting them, and at other times we are not.

Comment on this

Are there repayment plans in place for some of those?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

For some of those, there would be repayment plans in place.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

I do not have the full figures in front of me but I can certainly get that. However, there would be repayment plans in place.

Comment on this

Maybe Mr. Lehane could come back with that.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Lehane

Yes.

Comment on this

In relation to chapter 16 of the Comptroller and Auditor General's report, there were a number of recommendations. I refer to delivery of the early learning and childcare programmes. I am focusing on the two recommendations that are directed to Pobal. Has Ms Shakespeare looked at those? Will she tell me where Pobal is with them? I refer to recommendation 16.2, that, in conjunction with the Department, "Pobal should implement a formal risk rating model ...". Recommendation 16.4 is also directly related to Pobal.

Recommendation 16.2 is serious enough, is it not? It refers to a formal risk-rating model, which was not in operation. It states that "Pobal should implement a formal risk rating model and use it to calculate the required level of compliance activity...".

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Apologies, I am trying to find it in my folder.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

There were two recommendations that specifically related to Pobal.

Comment on this

Recommendations 16.2 and 16.4. One is the risk and the other is in relation to a "reliable methodology".

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

We have commenced that work with the Department. There is a compliance working group in place.

Comment on this

Since when has it been in place?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

That is in place since September.

The second question related to the further works that we have agreed as part of our programme of work. We have commenced a pilot of governance audits relating to an agreed programme of work with the Department of Children and Youth Affairs.

Comment on this

Let me go through those a little. In relation to a risk-rating model, Pobal carries out compliance visits. Is it based on risk assessment? It is good that the compliance is happening but it is not done in a methodical manner. The recommendation is that "Pobal should implement a formal risk rating model and use it to calculate the...compliance activity...". In regard to that relatively recent chapter, is Ms Shakespeare saying one step has been taken and a compliance working group has been set up?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Absolutely.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

In September.

Comment on this
Mr. Gordon Gaffney

If I could intervene on that, the Department in conjunction with Pobal takes cognisance of risk. Non-compliance is a big problem in the sector. In 2018-2019, we concentrated on those schemes with the highest risk of over-claims and focused their attention on those in order to minimise the level of over-claims that would be occurring had we not undertaken compliance activities in those areas.

Comment on this

I suppose at this point I am only focusing in on the two recommendations, specifically to see where we are with them. Returning to the committee that was set up in September, it is now December. What would have happened in the meantime?

Comment on this
Mr. Gordon Gaffney

The base of the national childcare scheme, NCS, has far stronger governance built in from the word go. The scheme has been designed to address weaknesses in previous schemes. Looking at working towards a formal risk-rating methodology is a difficult task and it will take time. With the introduction of NCS, it affords us the opportunity to do that on a proper basis.

In the meantime, compliance visits and compliance activities are targeted towards the areas of the highest risk. Under our formal risk-rated model, it has recognised that those schemes where we are targeting or focusing attention are the ones with the highest level of over claims.

Comment on this

I understand and welcome that. However, it is a specific recommendation. Pobal has accepted the recommendation. What has happened as a result? A committee has been set up with a view to setting up a formal risk-rating model. That will take time.

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

It is a joint working group with the Department.

Comment on this

How many times have they met?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

My understanding is the group has met on two occasions, if not three.

Comment on this

I take it there are minutes of those meetings. At what stage does Ms Shakespeare envisage that the risk-rating model will be set up?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

I will have to confirm that to the committee, but at the earliest possible time.

Comment on this
Mr. Gordon Gaffney

I presume it would be for the next programme year. That is the most likely time at this stage, but as soon as possible.

Comment on this

What of recommendation 16.4, on the methodology?

Comment on this

Will Pobal send the committee a note on a possible timescale for that?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

I will, indeed.

Under recommendation 16.4, in practical terms, the report states that it was expected to result in audit checks that focus on verifying and improving governance standards. In November this year, the Department of Children and Youth Affairs agreed with Pobal that we would engage with governance reviews or governance audits of some early learning and care providers. It is a pilot programme of governance checks to a sample of a number of community-based services. That has commenced.

Comment on this

That is a good start and there is a pilot project. However, Pobal accepted the recommendation that "Pobal should develop a reliable methodology to enable it to estimate and monitor the underlying level of over-claims...". When will that methodology be in place?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

What we have done in response to the early years chapter from the Comptroller and Auditor General's report is we have completed an entire assessment of the potential over-claims and reached a figure where the over-payments number has been clarified. We are in the process of recouping a total value of €1.1 million on behalf of the Exchequer that resulted from those over-payments. We have €690,000 still outstanding as part of an agreed repayment process with providers and €400,000 has been received back on behalf of the Exchequer.

Comment on this

That is all very positive but there is an absence of methodology. There is a recommendation that Pobal has it. When will it be in place?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

My understanding is that we have a methodology and an approach in integrating and working with providers in an integrated case management system to ensure the sustainability of a provider while understanding that there will be a repayment piece.

Comment on this

Can I cut through this for a moment?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

Sorry, Deputy.

Comment on this

Maybe I am being unfair and maybe Mr. Gaffney or Mr. Geraghty will help me. I am looking at the chapter and at two specific recommendations, the first of which is that "Pobal should develop a reliable methodology ...". Is it perfectly reasonable to ask when that reliable methodology will be in place in relation to the over-payments?

Comment on this
Mr. Gordon Gaffney

We are working towards that.

Comment on this
Mr. Gordon Gaffney

I will have to get back to the Deputy on that. We take this report very seriously. We are working through since we received this report.

As pointed out, the initial pilot phase has happened and we will work through.

Comment on this

When will the pilot phase be completed?

Comment on this
Mr. Gordon Gaffney

I understand that it should be completed by the end of the year-----

Comment on this
Mr. Gordon Gaffney

-----but I would need to check and see exactly where we are on that.

Comment on this

We cannot examine the minutiae but only governance and accountability. If recommendations were made and the Department accepts them, that is great and the job is done, but they have not yet been done and there is a little vagueness. I understand that it takes time and that the recommendations were made only recently but there is a certain vagueness in the response on when the items will be dealt with.

Comment on this

The Department might get the detail of the Vote for us or of where the Vote stands and send it to the committee. It might help us determine the timescale.

Comment on this
Mr. Gordon Gaffney

Certainly.

Comment on this

Pobal maps are a wonderful resource, but something has come to my attention and perhaps our guests can clarify it for me. I have asked the school whether I can use its name, and while I am not especially interested in doing so, it does not mind. A school in Galway cannot secure DEIS status, even though on every level it should have it. That is a matter for the Department of Education and Skills, but the decision is made based on Pobal maps, and the level of deprivation in the area and various other criteria. As a result, the school cannot secure DEIS status. Does Pobal just take raw data from the CSO or does it conduct its own analysis on the ground?

Comment on this
Ms Anna Shakespeare

I ask Mr. Murphy to answer this question.

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

Pobal maps and the underlying deprivation index are based on CSO data but there is significant work in identifying the key criteria within those data, which need to be amalgamated into the deprivation index. That identifies a series of the key components that, as a total, point to the reality of the life of an individual community. The schools issue is separate and distinct from us.

Comment on this

I understand that. I have that much information and have not much time but have raised the matter to make a point. The school has written to Pobal on the matter and I can give our guests the details later if they wish.

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

Yes, please.

Comment on this

The school highlighted, according to its analysis, the level of deprivation, the substantial number of non-national pupils and the language barriers, as well as other barriers. The great weakness for the school is that the Pobal map has put it in a place where it should not be.

Comment on this
Mr. Jerry Murphy

What we would always point out, which is central to this, is that Pobal maps define the community who live in an area. A service such as a school can be located outside a disadvantaged area but still serve the community. There are instances where advantaged schools are stuck in the middle of disadvantaged communities. There is a distinction between the kids in a school and the community we map. We would like to talk to the school the Deputy mentioned.

Comment on this